The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on December 4, 2024, to consider policy resolutions, zoning petitions, and a public hearing on a modification of commitments. The meeting included approvals of routine items, a contentious amendment to a tax abatement resolution, and a compromise on a commercial space requirement for a self-storage facility. Consent Calendar - Approved the November 20, 2024 draft minutes without changes. - Approved eight policy resolutions (2024 R033, R034, E040, E044, E046, C006, C007) with a vote of 6-0, except for 2024 E044 which passed 5-1. - Approved eight petitions of no appeal (2024 APP 020, 021, ZON 087, 113, 121, 129, CAP 840, REG 055) by a vote of 7-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Jen Higginbotham (Principal Planner, Indianapolis Metropolitan Planning Organization) opposed the modification of commitments for 25 McLean Place, arguing that retaining 10,000 square feet of commercial space is critical to support the transit-oriented development (TOD) overlay and the Red Line BRT system. She emphasized the long-term vision for walkable urbanism and the substantial public investment in transit. - Phil Votar (Interim Director, Near North Development Corporation) expressed support for the petitioner's request, noting the soft retail market in the area and the quality of the existing self-storage facility. - City Council President Vop Osley supported the petitioner's request, citing the lack of leasing interest over seven years and the need for practicality, while reaffirming his support for the TOD overlay. Discussion Items - 2024 R033 and R034 (Sherman Park property transfer): Deputy Director Jenny Foltz and Piers Kirby explained that 7.5 acres of Sherman Park would be transferred to the state of Indiana in exchange for city-owned property at 401 North Randolph Street. The current zoning is CS, and the state will determine future use. The commission approved these resolutions. - 2024 A041 (Peregrine Energy Solutions tax abatement): The petitioner sought a five-year personal property tax abatement for a $144 million battery energy storage facility at 4025 West 86th Street. Staff recommended approval. President Dillon expressed frustration that the resolution came before the commission before regulatory approvals from MISO and the IURC were secured. He moved to amend the resolution to make approval contingent on those regulatory approvals. The amendment passed 7-0, and the amended resolution was approved 7-0. Dillon warned that if commitments are not met, the project would be dead. - 2024 ZON 112 (continuance): Petitioner David Gilman requested a continuance to revise the site plan and zoning class. Staff recommended continuing to January 15, 2025. The motion passed 7-0. - 2024 ZON 099 (continuance): Staff requested a continuance to December 18, 2024, to finalize commitments. The motion passed 7-0. - 2024 MOD 017 (modification of commitments for 25 McLean Place): The petitioner, Illinois Street Self-Storage LLC (owner Greg O'Harron), requested termination of commitments requiring 10,000 square feet of commercial space, citing seven years of unsuccessful marketing. Staff recommended denial, offering a compromise of 4,000 square feet. The petitioner proposed 2,000 square feet. After testimony from the remonstrator, City Council President, and staff, Commissioner Murphy moved to approve the modification but with the condition that 2,000 square feet remain reserved for commercial uses. The motion passed 7-0. Key Outcomes - 2024 R033 and R034: Approved 6-0 (property exchanges). - 2024 A041: Amended to require regulatory approvals from MISO, IURC, and AES, then approved 7-0. - 2024 ZON 112: Continued to January 15, 2025, by a 7-0 vote. - 2024 ZON 099: Continued to December 18, 2024, by a 7-0 vote. - 2024 MOD 017: Approved as amended, reducing the commercial space requirement from 10,000 to 2,000 square feet, with the remaining 8,000 square feet allowed for self-storage. Vote: 7-0.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1, chaired by Peter Nelson, convened on December 3, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The board heard multiple continuance and waiver requests, five expedited petitions, and four regular variance cases. Decisions included approvals, denials, one indecisive vote leading to a continuation, and a transfer to another division. Public testimony was heard on several cases, with community organizations and residents expressing opposition or support. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: Unanimously approved the minutes from the November 7, 2024 meeting. - Waiver of Rules for Expedited Petitions: Unanimously approved to allow the board to vote on all expedited petitions without additional testimony. - Automatic Continuance Acknowledged: Case 2024-UV1-027 (7720 West New York Street) was continued to January 7, 2025, by a registered neighborhood organization. - Withdrawal Acknowledged: Case 2024-DV1-040 (3033 Sutherland Avenue) was withdrawn by the petitioner. - Commitment Acknowledged: For case 2024-DV1-039 (5402 East Thompson Street), the board acknowledged a commitment associated with the staff's approval recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Case 2024-UV1-028 (O'Reilly Auto Parts): Bob Polk, representing the Southport Green HOA, opposed the variance, citing a restrictive covenant prohibiting auto-related businesses and arguing the notice sign was poorly placed. He expressed concern about toxic chemicals and setting a precedent for more intense uses. - Case 2024-UV1-014 (Child Care Facility): Susan Blair, president of the Pike Township Residence Association (PTRA), opposed the petition, citing safety concerns over parking, maneuverability, and traffic at the intersection of Lafayette and Shanghai Roads. She noted a unanimous vote against the petition by PTRA's board. - Case 2024-UV1-023 (Grocery/Event Center): Susan Blair (PTRA) and Kerry Manders (Crooked Creek Community Land Use Committee) opposed the petition, arguing the uses are too intense for the C1 zoning, would increase traffic on Michigan Road, and violate the long-standing Michigan Road Corridor Plan. They noted the intersection at 79th and Michigan was selected for a crash study due to high accident rates. - Case 2024-UV1-022 (Contractor Business): Bob Lutz, attorney for the Town of Claremont, expressed conditional support for the petition with three conditions (personal to petitioners, no outside storage, shed design) but noted the petitioner's absence. - Case 2024-DV1-031 (Pylon Sign): Elizabeth Bence Williams, land use planner for the petitioner, presented the need for a fifth freestanding sign due to the private street status of Harrington Place. No remonstrators spoke. - Case 2024-DV1-030 (Garage Height): James Mack, architect for the petitioner, explained the need for extra height to store equipment. He noted support from the Pike Township Residence Association with commitments. Discussion Items - Continuances and Waivers: Several continuances were granted: - Case 2024-UV1-024 (4723 South Emerson) continued to January 7, 2025, without additional notice. - Case 2024-DV1-041 (2844 Ruckle Street) granted a 10-day waiver for mailed notice. - Case 2024-DV1-039 (5402 East Thompson) granted a 9-day waiver for mailing and 5-day for sign posting. - Case 2024-UV1-028 (6855 East Southport) granted a 5-day waiver for sign posting and 9-day for mailing. - Case 2024-DV1-042 (8002 North Pennsylvania) granted an 8-day waiver for both sign and mailing. - Case 2024-DV1-033 (7401 Holiday Drive West) continued to January 7, 2025, to allow the Town of Meridian Hills to vote on the matter. - Case 2024-UV1-029 (1629 North Rural Street) granted an 11-day waiver for both sign and mailing. - Case 2024-DV1-037 amended (2402 East 38th Street) continued to January 7, 2025, with additional notice due to a deficient variance request. - Case 2024-UV1-017 (1016 Tecumseh Street) continued to January 7, 2025, noted as the third and final continuance supported by staff. - Case 2024-DV1-043 (1221 West 33rd Street) granted a 9-day waiver for both sign and mailing. - Case 2024-DV1-038 (2511 Columbia Avenue) continued to January 7, 2025, with additional notice. - Expedited Petitions: Five cases were voted on under the waiver of rules. All were granted unanimously (4-0): - 2024-DV1-039: Variance for two pump island canopy signs at 5402 East Thompson Street. - 2024-DV1-041: Variance for a duplex at 2844 Ruckle Street. - 2024-DV1-042: Variance for a covered rear porch at 8002 North Pennsylvania Street. - 2024-DV1-043: Variance for a single-family dwelling side yard setback at 1221 West 33rd Street. - 2024-UV1-029: Variance of use to convert a detached garage into a dwelling at 1629 North Rural Street. - Case 2024-DV1-031 (Pylon Sign, 5402 East Thompson): Petitioner argued the sign is needed for businesses west of Harrington Place, a private street. Staff recommended denial, citing the ordinance limits two freestanding signs for an integrated center and noting building signage and GPS as alternatives. The board granted the variance 3-1 (Rodriguez Hilt dissenting) with commitments including no additional pylon signs and non-illumination. - Case 2024-DV1-030 (Garage Height, 8002 North Pennsylvania): Petitioner sought a 2-foot height increase for a detached garage to store equipment. Staff recommended denial, citing unwanted precedent and lack of practical difficulty. The board granted the variance 4-0 with commitments (no living space, no active business operation). - Case 2024-UV1-014 (Child Care, 6301 Lafayette Road): Petitioner proposed a child care facility with reduced parking and enrollment. Staff and PTRA opposed due to safety concerns over limited parking, maneuverability, and traffic at the intersection. The board denied the variance 4-0. - Case 2024-UV1-022 (Contractor Business, 911 Crawfordsville Road): The petitioner was absent. The Town of Claremont offered conditional support. The board continued the case and transferred it to Division 3 on December 17, 2024, to allow the petitioner to appear. - Case 2024-UV1-023 (Grocery/Event Center, 7780 Michigan Road): Petitioner proposed a grocery store, eating establishment, and event center in a C1 zone. Staff, PTRA, and Crooked Creek community opposed, citing intensity, traffic, and violation of the Michigan Road Corridor Plan. The board voted 2-2 (Rodriguez Hilt and Catona in favor, Duncan and Nelson opposed), resulting in an indecisive vote and continuation to January 7, 2025. - Case 2024-UV1-028 (O'Reilly Auto Parts, 6855 East Southport): Petitioner sought a variance to operate an auto parts store in a C3 zone. Staff recommended denial, citing the use as automobile repair under the ordinance. A remonstrator cited a restrictive covenant. The board denied the variance 3-1 (Rodriguez Hilt dissenting). Key Outcomes - Expedited Cases: All five granted unanimously. - Case 2024-DV1-031: Granted (3-1) with commitments. - Case 2024-DV1-030: Granted (4-0) with commitments. - Case 2024-UV1-014: Denied (4-0). - Case 2024-UV1-022: Continued to December 17, 2024, and transferred to Division 3. - Case 2024-UV1-023: Indecisive vote (2-2), continued to January 7, 2025. - Case 2024-UV1-028: Denied (3-1). - All Continuance and Waiver Requests: Approved as noted above.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on November 20, 2024, at 6:00 PM. The meeting included continuance requests, approvals of multiple tax abatements and policy resolutions, and a docket of non-appeal petitions. A special presentation on a proposed Wawa convenience store was also heard. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes of the November 6, 2024 meeting were approved unanimously (voice vote). - Six Policy Resolutions (no public hearing): 2024 R028, 2024 E037, 2024 E041, 2024 E042, 2024 E043, and 2024 P010 were grouped and approved 7–0. Discussion Items - Continuance Requests: - 2024 A037 (raised bio Inc., 5850 West 80th Street) continued to December 18, 2024, upon staff request; passed 7–0. - 2024 A038 (Georgia’s Concrete, continued to December 18, 2024) due to higher‑than‑expected project costs; passed 7–0. - Public Hearing – 2024 A034 (130 East Worcester Street): 10‑year real property tax abatement for Holiday Property Services. Project: 22 units at 60% AMI for 15 years, two full‑time jobs at $55,000/year, and a mural commitment or $15,000 donation to public art. Staff recommended approval. Approved 7–0. - Public Hearing – 2024 A039 (351 West 10th Street): Termination of personal property tax abatement for Life of Mike Inc., which never utilized it. Staff concurred. Approved 7–0. - Public Hearing – 2024 A040 (4825 West 79th Street): Five‑year personal property tax abatement for Olson Custom Designs LLC. Expansion with $5 million investment, retention of 56 jobs ($28/hr average), creation of 30 new jobs ($28/hr minimum), and a 5% tax savings donation to the Indy Achieves completion grant. Approved 7–0. - Petitions of No Appeal: Nine items were read into the record. One continuance was granted for 2024 MOD 017 to December 4, 2024 (7–0). Special guest Joe Calderan (counsel for petitioner) presented on 2024 ZON 111 (4900 & 4952 Kentucky Avenue) – a rezoning for a Wawa convenience store with fuel. He noted unanimous support from Decatur Township Civic Council and staff, a 5.5‑acre site with 2.5 acres developed, and C4 zoning consistent with the comp plan. The Commission approved all nine petitions: Commissioner Morerity was recused on 2024 ZON 082 and voted no on 2024 CAP 832; all others passed (6–0 on most, 6–1 on 2024 CAP 832). Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes, continuances, six policy resolutions, three public‑hearing tax abatements (2024 A034, A039, A040 – all 7–0). - Approved: Nine non‑appeal petitions (2024 APP 018, 2024 MOD 009, 2023 MOD 015, 2024 ZON 082, 2024 ZON 111, 2024 ZON 116, 2024 ZON 117, 2024 CAP 832, 2024 CZN 837) with one recusal and one dissenting vote noted. - Continued: 2024 A037 to December 18, 2024; 2024 MOD 017 to December 4, 2024. - No public comments were received from the audience.
The Marion County Commissioners met on November 19, 2024, at approximately 2:05 PM in Room 260 of the City-County Building. President Joseph O'Connor presided, with Auditor Milo Eldridge serving as secretary; Treasurer Barbara Lawrence was absent but a quorum was present. The only substantive agenda item was the transfer of a delinquent-tax parcel to the abutting landowner program. Consent Calendar - The minutes of the September 17, 2024 meeting were approved by voice vote with a motion and second. Discussion Items - Abutting Landowner Program – Parcel 7029586 (Tudor Park Drive): Staff presented a parcel comprising the length of Tudor Park Drive, the main thoroughfare of the Tudor Park condominium development. The parcel had delinquent taxes dating back to 2003 and went to tax sales around 2005‑2006. It was not originally platted as common property. On April 26, 2024, the Peter Boa (likely a board or committee) unanimously approved an exemption on the assessed value, bringing it below the $50,000 threshold for the abutting landowner program. Staff recommended declaring the property surplus and transferring it to the highest bidder among eligible abutters. Commissioner O'Connor noted that the deed would be restricted to use only as common property, making it non‑taxable. It was clarified that only Tudor Park HOA members could bid because they are the only parties who could use the property in good faith, though parcels to the south technically also abut the land. The commissioners asked no further questions. Key Outcomes - Vote: The commissioners unanimously approved a motion to transfer Parcel 7029586 to the abutting landowner program. The motion carried by voice vote (two ayes, no nays). The next meeting was scheduled for December 17, 2024 at 2:00 PM in the same room. Adjournment The meeting adjourned immediately following the vote.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III, chaired by Joanna Taft, held a public hearing on November 19, 2024, to consider several variance petitions, continuances, and expedited matters. The board heard testimony on proposals including a Dutch Bros coffee shop with drive-thru at a transit-oriented development site, a residential pole barn, and a school digital sign. Key decisions included denial of the Dutch Bros variances, approval of the pole barn, and denial of the digital sign. Consent Calendar - The board approved meeting minutes from July 16, August 20, September 17, and October 15, 2024, by unanimous vote. - The board voted unanimously to waive rules of procedure to allow expedited petitions to be voted on without additional testimony. Special Requests and Continuances - 2024-DV3-031 (Whitehead Signs): Granted continuance to January 21, 2025, with a four-day waiver of notice. - 2024-UV3-016 (425-435 South Gibson): Granted continuance to January 21, 2025, with no objection from staff. - 2024-DB3-032 (10410 East 79th Street): Granted four-day waiver of notice to be heard on expedited docket. - 2024-DV3-030 (8600 Madison Avenue): Granted four-day waiver of notice to be heard on expedited docket. The petitioner withdrew a variance for reduced transparency. - 2024-DB3-033 (2731 Columbia): Continued to December 17, 2024, for staff review of affidavit. - 2024-DB3-034 (2739 Columbia): Continued to December 17, 2024, with correction of agenda typo acknowledged. - 2024-UV3-015 (1313-1315 Standish): Continued to December 17, 2024, for intended filing of new petition. - 2024-UV3-017 (8949 East Washington): Automatic continuance to December 17, 2024, requested by registered neighborhood organization, acknowledged. - 2024-DV3-029 (405 FinTail Drive): Continued to December 17, 2024, at staff's request for additional filings. - Item number 7: Withdrawn by petitioner, acknowledged. Expedited Petitions - 2024-DV3-030 (8600 Madison Avenue): Variance granted unanimously for commercial building with 15% front building line width (40% required). All board members voted yes. - 2024-DV3-032 (10410 East 79th Street): Variance granted unanimously for detached garage in front yard with 10-foot east side yard setback (15 feet required). All board members voted yes. Discussion Items Case 2024-DV3-024: 1022 East Washington Street – Dutch Bros Coffee Shop Petitioner: Joseph D. Calderon representing NDWS 40 LLC. Proposal for a drive-thru without exclusive bypass aisle, reduced front building line setback (33 feet vs. 20 feet maximum), deficient front building line width (33.5% vs. 46% required), and deficient first-story transparency (22% vs. 60% required). The site is zoned C4 TOD (Transit-Oriented Development) and is located near a proposed Blue Line BRT stop. Testimony in Support: - Petitioner argued the site is currently vacant with an eyesore, and the revised site plan (Tab 5) addresses concerns by flipping the building, adding a walk-up window, and moving the drive-thru to the rear. They noted support from Warren Township Development Association and Councillor Hart (letter provided). The use is permitted in TOD, and 34,000 cars pass daily. Testimony in Opposition: - Ryan Hunt (Indigo): Appeared in remonstrance. Argued the TOD overlay was designed to leverage the $389 million BRT investment and promote denser, transit-oriented development. Despite plan improvements, the drive-thru remains car-centric and contradicts TOD goals. Prior variances from 2023 already provided relief; the new drive-thru intensifies non-compliance. - Andrea Miller (Indianapolis Metropolitan Planning Organization): Opposed the variance, stating the TOD overlay was created to prevent such development patterns and that the BRT opportunity is limited. Decisions will last generations. Staff Recommendation: Denial. Staff cited inconsistency with TOD goals, high paved vehicle area (59% of lot), insufficient transparency, and lack of site-specific practical difficulty. The 2023 approved plan showed feasible compliant development. Board Vote: Motion to deny passed 4-1 (Bohannon voted yes, others no). The variance was not granted. Case 2024-DV3-027: 9621 East 96th Street – Pole Barn Petitioner: Chris Schupter. Request to build a 27-foot-tall, 3,200 sq. ft. pole barn (larger and taller than the 23-foot primary building) on a 2.76-acre lot zoned DA. Petitioner stated it is for storage of vehicles and trailers, and neighbors have no objections. Testimony in Support: Neighbor Don Gardner (9611 East 96th) confirmed no issue and praised petitioner as a good neighbor. Staff Recommendation: No explicit opposition stated; staff noted the property size and existing structures. Board Vote: Variance granted 4-1 (Taft voted no, others yes). Case 2024-UV3-014: 454 East Stop 11 Road – School Digital Sign Petitioner: Thomas Hopkins (Sign Solutions) representing Perry Township Schools. Request for a monument sign with digital display (prohibited in SU2 zoning), located 0 feet from protected district (600 feet required), and encroaching within right-of-way (5-foot setback required). Petitioner offered four commitments: no blinking/scrolling, 30-second static messages, auto-dimming, and sign off between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. Testimony in Opposition: None from public, but staff opposed. Staff noted digital signs are inappropriate in residential-context SU2 zoning, the sign would be too large and close to homes, and encroachment on right-of-way creates safety issues. Alternate methods for advertising school events exist. Board Vote: Variance denied 3-2 (Bohannon and Bland voted yes, others no). Key Outcomes - Decisions: - Denied: Dutch Bros variances for 1022 E Washington St (4-1). - Granted: Pole barn variance for 9621 E 96th St (4-1). - Denied: Digital sign variance for 454 E Stop 11 Rd (3-2). - Granted: Two expedited variances (unanimous). - Multiple continuances to December 17, 2024, or January 21, 2025, as listed. - Withdrawal: Case 2024-DV3-026 (7140-7142 E Washington) was withdrawn. - Next Steps: The board will adopt findings from previous hearings at a later date. The meeting adjourned.
The Information Technology Board of Indianapolis and Marion County met on November 19, 2024, at 9:35 a.m. in Room 260 of the City-County Building. Chairman Joseph O'Connor presided. The board approved minutes from the October 29, 2024 meeting, heard reports from the Information Services Agency (ISA), and voted on six resolutions and two recognitions. All items passed unanimously. ISA Board Report - Enterprise Projects: The Unified Communications project is transitioning to Webex Calling, with a new timeline expected in January 2025. The CCB Restack Phase 2 is ongoing, with Parks moving into permanent homes by December 11, 2024. The Storage Modernization project (previously on hold) has a path forward with the vendor. The Property Tax Management RFP was released publicly on November 8, 2024. The JMS Relaunch has no significant updates. The Enterprise GIS Upgrade (ArcGIS) is testing applications, targeting completion by the end of March 2025. Chairman O'Connor asked about benefits; Colin Hill (CIO) explained it provides more flexibility for internal staff and public-facing data. Terry Morris inquired about organizational change management (OCM); Hill noted the vendor includes training and communication. - Vendor Service Level Agreements: Bell Tech Logics and Daniels and Associates met all SLAs in October. - Customer Satisfaction Survey: October score was 99 out of 100. ISA Financial Report - Kai Davis (CFO): Budget trending as expected. A large remaining balance in category 3 due to pending contracts. Internal chargebacks (77% collected). External chargebacks billed at 141% of budget due to conservative budgeting allowed by OFM (only reliable revenues were budgeted). Davis aims to improve chargeback accuracy by 2026, with quarterly billing beginning in December. Resolutions Approved - Resolution 24-63 – Flock Group (IMPDR): Approved a four-year contract not to exceed $6,000,000 for license plate reader technology (annual spend $1M budgeted). Kevin Weddington (Deputy Chief, IMPD) presented. The contract covers 400 cameras by Q1 2025 (up from 301), with expansion possible through council district funds. Features include traffic pattern analysis, B-Link integration, and potential drone-first-responder trials. Cost: $3,000 per camera per year. All cameras are solar-powered with cellular backhaul. - Resolution 24-64 – CDW Government (MESA): Approved $900,000 not to exceed (actual proposal $830,000) for a new video wall at the Emergency Operations Center (EOC). Candace Harris (CFO, MESA) explained the wall will be 13 screens wide by 2 tall, replacing an obsolete system. Funded partly by a $750,000 UASI grant. Includes a five-year warranty. - Resolution 24-65 – New Era Technology (Sheriff’s Office): Approved $376,195 for on-site AV and IPTV support. presented by Kenley Webber (Director of Information Services, Marion County Sheriff’s Office).<|eotid| - Resolution 24-66 – BizStream Inc. (Municipal Court): Approved an amendment adding $565,000 (total not to exceed $1,481,763) for a new youth intake and case management system at the Youth Services Center, replacing the obsolete Quest system. presented by Amitha Thamba (Court Administration). - Resolution 24-67 – MTS Integra Track (ISA): Approved a $50,000 amendment (total $269,012.40) for call record processing. presented by David Williams (Unified Communications Manager, ISA). - Resolution 24-68 – ISA Access Control Policy: Approved a policy update for access control and remote access, with changes including session lockout after 5 attempts (down from 10) to comply with CJIS standards. presented by Nicole Heatley Holmes. Recognitions - Resolution 24-69 – Judge Mark Rothenberg: Recognized for his service on the board from January 1, 2021, to December 31, 2024. Approved unanimously (Judge Rothenberg abstained). - Resolution 24-70 – Terry Morris: Recognized for his service on the board from May 12, 2022, to December 31, 2024. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All six resolutions and two recognitions were approved by voice vote with no opposition. - The next meeting is scheduled for January 28, 2025, at 9:30 a.m. in Room 260. - The meeting adjourned after recognizing departing board members.
On November 18, 2024, at 11:35 AM, the Marion County Election Board convened with Vice Chair Jennifer Ping presiding. The meeting focused on certifying the official results of the 2024 general election and recognizing staff members for their contributions. Director of Elections Patrick Becker reported that a final provisional ballot was tabulated on Friday, bringing the total provisional ballots counted to approximately 429 (out of an initially prepared 428 plus one late arrival). The board reviewed and signed the required state certification forms (CEB-9, CEB-10, CEB-11, CEB-12, CEB-13, and CEB-25) to make the election results official. Election Certification - Director Patrick Becker presented the final results summary and a series of CEB forms for board signatures. The CEB-9 is a county election report to the state covering registration, turnout, absentee and provisional voting, budget, and equipment. CEB-10 covers governor/lieutenant governor results; CEB-11 covers county offices (treasurer, coroner, surveyor, township offices); CEB-12 covers the statewide public question, Supreme Court and Court of Appeals judicial retention; CEB-13 covers president/vice president, U.S. Senate, Congress, state Senate, and state representatives; and CEB-25 covers nonpartisan school board races. Corporation counsel advised that board member signatures on the documents are sufficient for certification. The board signed all documents. Champion of Democracy Awards - Marion County Clerk Kate Sweeney Bell presented
This meeting of the Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations (MCANNA) was held on November 16, 2024, from 9:00 to 11:00 a.m. at North United Methodist Church (38th and Meridian). President Kathy Burton welcomed members and the public, noting that the next meeting will be on January 18, 2025 (no meeting in December). The meeting featured two planned presentations: one on winter storm preparedness by Candace Tony (American Red Cross/Edna Martin Christian Center) and one on the mayor's neighborhood liaison program by Brittany Crone (mayor's office), who did not attend. The group then discussed several neighborhood issues, including billboard ordinance changes, city street/ally conditions, and the health department's role. Public Comments & Testimony - Several attendees asked questions during the Red Cross presentation, including: how to obtain extra medication for emergency kits (insurance limitations noted), outreach to homeless populations, availability of resources for generators or heating fuel, and the role of 211 (United Way) for shelter and warming center information. One member suggested neighbors check on elderly or disabled residents during winter weather. - During the discussion period, members raised concerns about: the condition of the alley behind the Martindale Post Office (Brightwood area), lack of city maintenance on streets and sidewalks, insufficient warning for street closures, confusing Indigo bus line routes, and the need for a central calendar of city projects. Discussion Items - Winter Storm Preparedness (Candace Tony): Tony presented Red Cross guidelines for winter storms, including definitions of advisories, watches, and warnings; tips for staying safe at home, in vehicles, and outdoors; frostbite/hypothermia recognition; and importance of emergency kits. She distributed checklists and highlighted the Red Cross Emergency app and 211 for shelter information. Q&A covered pet safety, space heater dangers, and generator use. - Washington Square Mall Update: Kathy Burton reported that the health department and code enforcement conducted inspections and issued multiple citations for health/safety violations (trash, mold, debris). A second set of warnings was issued after no correction in 30 days. The property has multiple owners, complicating enforcement. - Billboard Ordinance Changes (Pat): The city has proposed changes to the sign ordinance, including raising allowable height from 40 to 60 feet and reducing the required distance between billboards on the same side of a freeway from 1,500 to 1,000 feet. The ordinance passed the Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) and is scheduled for a hearing before the Metropolitan and Economic Development Committee on Monday, November 18, 2024, at 5:30 p.m. Pat noted that the changes are a compromise to preempt state legislation. Only about 12-20 new billboard locations are expected to be opened. - Mayor's Neighborhood Liaisons: Members shared mixed experiences. Some praised the liaison (e.g., Susan Martinez, Delia) while others reported high turnover and lack of effectiveness. The group noted that these positions have evolved from the Goldsmith-era township administrators with more clout and budgets. - Health Department Update (Jane): Jane highlighted the Health First Indiana funding applications, efforts to reduce maternal mortality (especially among women of color), and ongoing issues with the Meadows apartment complex (repeated sewage/trash violations). She confirmed that restaurant inspection reports are available online and that the health department handles bed bugs and roach complaints. - Street Closures and Lack of Warning: Members complained about abrupt street closures for tree removal, construction, and events (e.g., Monumental Marathon) without adequate notice or detour signage. They called for a centralized calendar of city projects. - Indigo Bus Line Issues: Several members reported confusion about route changes, discontinuation of lines on Capitol Avenue, and the difficulty for seniors and disabled persons to access the Red Line and Purple Line stops. The group agreed to invite Indigo representatives to a future meeting. Key Outcomes - The group will continue to monitor the Washington Square Mall situation and support enforcement actions. - Members will attend the billboard ordinance hearing on November 18 to express support or concerns. - The group plans to invite the city controller, Indigo transit representatives, and the health department director (Dr. Kane) to future meetings. - MCANNA will follow up on the alley behind the Martindale Post Office by contacting the city councilor (Ron Gibson) and the MAC Center. - No formal votes were taken; decisions were made to schedule future speakers and continue advocacy on identified issues.
The Marion County Election Board met on November 15, 2024, at 2:06 PM to finalize voting from the previous week. Chair proxy Paul Babcock called the meeting to order with Vice Chair General Keene and Secretary Kate Squinny Bell present. Staff presented recommendations on absentee ballot issues and provisional ballots, and the board voted unanimously on all agenda items. Public Comments & Testimony - There were no public comments submitted online. One attendee approached staff during a pause to inquire about their ballot; the issue was addressed confidentially. Discussion Items - Absentee Ballot Review: Director Becker presented several categories: - 300 blank ExpressVote ballot cards (voters exited without completing voting). Staff recommended counting these as the voters had checked in. - 5 in-person early voting ballots with missing labels later reprinted. - 9 military/overseas ballots received after Election Day but before the noon November 15 deadline. - 1 traveling board application processed incorrectly as a mail ballot; the voter returned the ballot with a disability marking. Staff recommended accepting all these. - Provisional Ballots: Over 2,000 provisional ballots were reviewed with bipartisan staff recommendations. The board considered them in groups: - Ballots 1–151: Absentee mail signature issues where curing documents were returned (missing signature or mismatched). Counted. - Ballots 152–167: Missing signatures with no curing document returned. Not counted. - Ballots 168–206: Mismatched signatures, no curing document, but a third bipartisan review deemed 39 of 47 should count. Counted; ballots 207–214 remained mismatched and were not counted. - Ballots 215–242: Challenge based on ID requirements. Board authorized counting if proper ID or affidavit is provided by the noon November 15 deadline. - Ballots 243–276: Voters not on poll book but later found eligible for fail-safe voting. Counted. - Ballots 277–300: Voters on poll book but not initially entitled to fail-safe; staff found eligibility. Counted. - Ballots 301–302: Inactive voters flagged to affirm residency; poll workers mistakenly used provisional process. Counted. - Ballots 303–480: Various categories including address changes, certificates of error, and poll worker errors. Counted. - Ballots 481–2056: Staff recommended not counting, but the board reserved the right to revisit if voters provide additional information before the deadline. - Write-In Canvas: Staff reported that one vote center required pulling ballots to examine write-in images; the canvas will continue. Key Outcomes - All votes on staff recommendations passed unanimously. - The board approved counting 300 blank ExpressVote cards, 5 reprinted ballots, 9 military/overseas ballots, and one misclassified mail ballot. - 151 signature-cured absentee ballots were counted; 16 were not counted (no curing document). - 39 mismatched-signature ballots without curing documents were counted after a third review; 8 were not. - ID-challenged ballots (215–242) may be counted if cured by noon November 15. - Provisional ballots 243–480 were counted; ballots 481–2056 were not counted pending possible voter contact. - The provisional ballot log included three empty envelopes and one blank ballot; the total tabulated will not exactly match the vote counts. - The meeting was recessed until Monday, November 18, 2024, at 11:30 AM to allow for any additional adjudications and completion of the write-in canvas.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing on Tuesday, November 12, 2024, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room, City-County Building. The meeting was chaired by Acting Chairperson Patrice Ducket Brown with members Natalia Rodriguez Hilt, Tom Burns, Beth Brandon, and James Duke. The board considered petitions for continuances, expedited items, and full hearings on variances for signage, parking, and development standards. Several petitions were approved, often with conditions, and staff recommendations were overruled in multiple instances. Consent Calendar - Adoption of minutes and withdrawal of petition 2024-UV2-026 (2355 North Meridian Street) for an automobile service facility were acknowledged without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Jolena Moore (2452 Sheldon Street) expressed no objection to petition 2024-DV2-041 for 2461 Sheldon Street, requesting that the front porch remain open. She noted a discrepancy in the clear sight triangle measurement but was satisfied with the open‑porch condition. - Denise Henderson (2625 North College Avenue) asked for confirmation of commitments for petition 2024-DV2-031: no curb cut and first‑come‑first‑served parking. - David Ojo and Jennifer Ojo (petitioners for 2010 Mansfield Street) testified that they inherited an existing driveway from a previous owner, were unaware of the need for variances, and faced financial hardship if required to relocate the parking area. They presented 14 signed neighbor support forms. - Dolores (neighbor, address not fully captured) spoke on behalf of elderly residents of the Marion Park Black Club, urging the board to consider the positive contributions of new homeowners and the uniqueness of the neighborhood. - Jesse Brown, City-County Councilor for District 13, spoke in support of the Ojos, noting the broader alley‑access issue and the Ojos’ good citizenship. Discussion Items - 2024-DV2-034 (McDonald’s, 9521 Haver Way): Variance to allow internal illumination of a 25‑foot tall pylon sign (prohibited in C3 zoning). Petitioner argued the unique intersection (Keystone and 96th Street roundabout) created a practical difficulty; all other sign dimensions comply. Staff recommended denial, stating the hardship was self‑imposed by choosing C3 zoning and that external illumination was available. A commitment to prohibit off‑premise signage was offered. The variance was granted 5‑0. - 2024-DV2-041 (Intend Indiana, 2461 Sheldon Street): Variance for a single‑family dwelling encroaching into the clear sight triangle and a zero‑foot walkway side setback. Neighbor Jolena Moore agreed to approval with the condition that the front porch remain open. Staff noted a practical difficulty due to competing ordinance standards. The board imposed a commitment for an open porch. Variance granted 5‑0. - 2024-UV2-013 (MSD Pike Township, 5455 West 56th Street): Variance for a digital display pylon sign located 70 feet from a protected district (600 feet required). Petitioner offered seven commitments, including operation off between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m., static display for at least 30 seconds, and no red, yellow, or green messages. Staff recommended denial, citing the ordinance’s intent, proximity to homes, and risk of distracted driving. Councilor Carlos Perkins spoke in support. Variance granted 5‑0. - 2024-UV2-022A, B, C (MSD Pike Township: 6701 Zionsville Road, 7001 Zionsville Road, 2811 Barnard Street): Three similar petitions for digital display signs at schools, located 85, 288, and 50 feet from protected districts (600 required). The same seven commitments were proffered. Staff argued lack of buffering, risk to motorists, and unenforceability of nighttime curfew. Member Tom Burns recused himself because his daughter teaches at one of the schools. Each variance was granted 4‑0. - 2024-DV2-040 (David & Jennifer Ojo, 2010 Mansfield Street): Variance to legalize an existing front parking area without alley access and a zero‑foot side setback. The driveway was installed by a previous owner in 2023; petitioners claimed financial hardship if forced to relocate. Staff recommended denial, stating the alley is accessible and the hardship is not from the ordinance but from the prior owner. Variance granted 5‑0 (one vote in opposition). Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: Items 1 (2024-DV2-036, 2526‑28 Harding Street), 2 (2024-DV2-037, 3265 Ruckle Street), and 3 (2024-DV2-038, 2959‑53 Ruckle Street) all continued to December 10, 2024, without objection. - Waivers of notice granted: For petitions 2024-DV2-034 (McDonald’s, 4‑day waiver), 2024-DV2-041 (Sheldon, 6‑day waiver), 2024-DV2-042 (Panda Express, 10‑day waiver), and 2024-DV2-040 (Mansfield, 5‑day waiver) due to late provision of notice materials by staff. - Expedited petitions approved (no testimony): - 2024-DV2-031 (2701 North College Avenue) – variance to allow 8 parking spaces where 11 are required (amended from original parking‑lot proposal). Granted 5‑0. - 2024-DV2-035 (2161 Gent Avenue) – variance for a walkway side setback. Granted 5‑0. - 2024-DV2-042 (2419 East 62nd Street) – variance for an additional 10‑foot tall drive‑thru sign. Granted 5‑0. - All full‑hearing variances granted: McDonald’s illumination (034), Sheldon house (041), Pike Township digital signs (013, 022A, 022B, 022C), and Mansfield parking (040). Most were approved over staff’s recommendation of denial. - Commitments: The McDonald’s petition included a commitment prohibiting off‑premise signage. The Sheldon petition included a condition that the front porch remain open. Pike Township petitions included seven operational commitments (timing, brightness, content restrictions).