Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 831–840 ENTRIES
831
JUN 1, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Public Hearing - June 1, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 1 held a public hearing on June 1, 2021, at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Clint McKay and Roderick Bohan. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board heard special requests, an expedited docket, and two non-expedited variance cases, resulting in multiple continuances and one approved expedited docket. Special Requests & Continuances - 2021 DV1013 (664 North Babel Avenue): Petitioner requested a final continuance to July 6, 2021, with notice if needed. Unopposed; staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2021 DVI028 (Glover's Inc.): Requested a continuance to August 3, 2021, without notice due to petitioner's vacation. Unopposed; staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2021 UV1012 (619 Holly Avenue): Petitioner requested to place on expedited docket, but a remonstrator appeared, so it proceeded as a non-expedited case (see below). - 2021 DB1031: Staff requested a continuance to July 6, 2021, with notice to allow petitioner time to amend variance request. Unopposed. Approved unanimously. - 2021 UV1013: Staff requested a continuance to July 6, 2021, without notice, as petitioner was not present. Unopposed. Approved unanimously. Expedited Docket (Consent Vote) The board waived its rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single roll call. The following petitions were approved unanimously (3-0), with three cases continued for adoption of revised findings of fact: - 2020 DV1082 (32 North Catherine Wood Avenue): Variance for three single-family dwellings with reduced setbacks and lot dimensions. - 2021 DV1026 (244 North Summit Street): Variance to legally establish a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and 43% open space (amended). - 2021 DV1027 (945 Elm Street): Variance for an addition to a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks. - 2021 DV1029 (1635 Hoyt Avenue): Variance for a detached garage with 49% open space. - 2021 DV1030 (Oaks – liquid storage silos): Variance for nine silos up to 66.42 feet tall (50-foot max). Petitioner agreed to a neighborhood commitment to paint silos soft gray. The board approved all expedited petitions, but noted that 2020 DV1082, 2021 DV1026, and 2021 DV1027 required continued adoption of revised findings of fact. Public Comments & Testimony - Jay Napoleon (President, Valley Neighborhood Association, 911 River Avenue): Opposed variance for 619 Holly Avenue to convert a single-family home to a duplex. Argued the neighborhood is historic, with high rental and vacancy rates, and feared increased short-term rentals (Airbnb) and parking problems. Asked the board to deny the request. - Charles Starkey (2701 North Ritter Avenue): Appeared in support of the 2816 North Raider Avenue pole barn variance. Described the property as an improvement to the neighborhood and noted no neighbor complaints. Discussion Items Non-Expedited Case 1: 2021 UV1012 – 619 Holly Avenue (Brass Monkey Properties LLC) - Petitioner (Sarah Walters): Requested a variance of use to convert a single-family dwelling into a two-family dwelling (duplex) in a D5 zone. The lot is 15,000+ sq ft, nearly twice the size of neighboring lots, and the conversion would not expand the footprint. Staff recommended approval, noting seven other two-family dwellings within a block and the lot’s size. - Remonstrator (Jay Napoleon): Representing the Valley Neighborhood Association, opposed the variance, citing the neighborhood’s historic character, high rental rates (40%), and vacancy (36%). Feared the property would become a rental or Airbnb, causing parking and noise issues. - Staff (Jeffrey York): Recommended approval, acknowledging the lot’s size and character compatibility. Corrected an error in the staff report about the neighborhood’s age. - Board Vote: McKay – no, Bohan – no, Taft – yes. Indecisive vote (1-2), petition automatically continued to July 6, 2021. Non-Expedited Case 2: 2021 DV1025 – 2816 North Raider Avenue (Roy Trotter) - Petitioner (David Rutherford, attorney): Requested variances of development standards to legally establish a partially completed 40’x40’ pole barn (22.67 ft tall, 1,600 sq ft). The barn exceeded the home’s height (14.5-15 ft), had reduced setbacks (3 ft side, 13.5 ft rear), and 77% open space (85% required). Petitioner argued the lot is 0.45 acres in a DA zone, making the 15-ft setbacks impractical. He presented a petition signed by neighbors in support and committed to demolish two old accessory buildings within one year and not store commercial vehicles. - Supporter (Charles Starkey): Neighbor across the street, testified that the barn is an improvement and that neighbors are positive. - Staff: Recommended denial, stating the structure’s size and height are atypical and would make the dwelling secondary. The practical difficulty could be resolved with a smaller structure. - Board Vote: McKay – aye, Bohan – aye, Taft – no. Indecisive vote (2-1), petition automatically continued to July 6, 2021. Staff Presentation on BZA Statutory Changes - Staff (likely Matt Pleasant) informed the board of upcoming state law changes effective July 1, 2021, affecting BZA composition. Key points: no more than two members per division may reside in the same township; all nine townships must be represented across all divisions; petitions must be allocated to a division with a member from the parcel’s township. Board members expressed concerns about conflicts and logistical challenges. The possibility of a training session at the end of June was discussed. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: 2021 DV1013, 2021 DVI028, 2021 DB1031, and 2021 UV1013 were continued to July or August 2021 hearing dates (terms specified). - Expedited docket approved: All five expedited petitions were approved unanimously, with three requiring further adoption of findings of fact. - Non-expedited case 2021 UV1012: Continued to July 6, 2021, due to a 1-2 vote (McKay and Bohan opposed, Taft in favor). - Non-expedited case 2021 DV1025: Continued to July 6, 2021, due to a 2-1 vote (McKay and Bohan in favor, Taft opposed). - Note on voting: With only three board members present, all three votes must be the same for a decision; any split results in automatic continuance. - Future planning: Staff and board discussed coordinating BZA training and appointments to comply with new state law by January 1, 2022.

ZONING AND LAND USE 63% · PROCEDURAL 18% · TOWNSHIP REPRESENTATION 8% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7%
832
MAY 18, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Three Public Hearing - May 18, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Three convened on May 18, 2021, at 6:15 PM under Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen. Board members Janice Golson Dunlop, Tony Boshenko, Catherine Chi, and Jim Rawlinson were present, along with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff. The hearing addressed continuances, expedited petitions, and three regular variance petitions. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single vote. The following expedited cases were approved unanimously (5-0): 2021 DV3017, 2021 DV3019, 2021 DV3020, 2021 DV3023, 2021 UV3002, and 2021 UV3006. All petitioners on the expedited docket were excused upon approval. Public Comments & Testimony - Derek Oliver (2626 Bethel Avenue) objected to a continuance for petition 2021 UV1010 (1518 Renton Street) without additional notice, stating that more community members were interested and deserved notice. Discussion Items - 2021 UV1010 – 1518 Renton Street: Petitioner Andy Metzel requested a continuance to June 15, 2021, without notice due to ongoing negotiations with remonstrators. After Derek Oliver's objection and discussion, the board amended the motion to require additional notice. The continuance was granted unanimously (5-0) with additional notice. - 2021 DB1015 – 1402 and 1406 East Fletcher Avenue: Petitioner Mark Crouch requested a three-day waiver of original notice. Staff had no objection. The board granted the waiver unanimously. - 2021 DB3018 – 8355 North Pennsylvania Street: Staff reported that the petitioner requested a four-month continuance to September 21, 2021, to redesign plans to protect old growth trees. No objections were heard. The board granted the continuance without additional notice unanimously. - 2021 DB3022 – 516 Wedge Horse Street: Staff noted the petitioner withdrew the three-foot rear setback request. The petitioner was not present, but the board deferred moving it to the expedited docket. Later in the regular hearing, petitioner Daniel Dorset appeared and agreed to a five-foot rear setback. Staff recommended approval of the remaining variance for 53% open space. The board approved the amended petition unanimously. - 2021 UV3006 – 5653 Brendan Way West Drive et al.: The petitioner requested moving to the expedited docket. Staff had no objection. The board approved the move unanimously. - Automatic Continuances: The board acknowledged automatic continuances for petitions 2021 DB3024 (to June 15, 2021), 2021 DV3011 (to June 15, 2021), and 2021 DV3021 (to June 15, 2021). Board also acknowledged withdrawal of petition 2021 UV3004 (9032 Crawfordsville Road). - 2021 HOV016 – 5450 West 86th Street: Petitioner John Jansen requested transfer of the petition from the Board of Zoning Appeals to the Hearing Officer for the May 25, 2021 hearing. Staff had no objection. The board voted unanimously to release the petition. - 2021 UV3003 – 2935 Villa Avenue: Petitioner James Roll, represented by John Cross, requested a variance of use for a commercial contractor with outside storage and truck parking, plus development standards for setbacks and fencing. Petitioner committed to landscaping but refused to relocate fences along the north and west property lines. Staff recommended approval only for the 16-foot rear setback, recommending denial of the rest due to buffering concerns. The board voted unanimously to approve the full petition as requested. - 2021 UV3005 – 7218 McFarland Road: Petitioners the Hittingers, represented by Russell Brown, requested a variance of use to operate a private Montessori school (preschool through early elementary) in a former church building. Staff initially recommended denial but revised to approval with a commitment to cap enrollment at 30 students. The board approved the variance unanimously, subject to the amended plan of operation dated May 13, 2021. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: 2021 UV1010 (to June 15 with additional notice), 2021 DB3018 (to September 21 without notice). - Waiver Granted: 2021 DB1015 – three-day notice waiver. - Petition Transferred: 2021 HOV016 – transferred to Hearing Officer. - Expedited Approvals: All expedited cases passed unanimously. - Regular Approvals: - 2021 UV3003 – Variance granted (5-0). - 2021 DV3022 – Amended variance granted (5-0). - 2021 UV3005 – Variance granted with 30-student cap (5-0). - Findings of Fact: Findings for 2021 DV3009 (April 20 hearing) were presented and adopted. Findings for 2021 UV3003 were continued for revision. - Housekeeping: The board welcomed new members Jim Rawlinson and Catherine Chi. The meeting adjourned after completing the agenda.

ZONING AND LAND USE 46% · PROCEDURAL 19% · EDUCATION 16% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 8%
833
MAY 11, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Hearing - May 11, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 held a public hearing on May 11, 2021, at 6:00 PM. The board heard several special requests, expedited petitions, and two full hearings. Key actions included granting continuances, approving expedited variances, and debating commitments for a use variance. All votes were taken by roll call. Consent Calendar - The board unanimously approved a waiver of rules to vote on all expedited petitions in a single vote. - Expedited Petitions Approved Unanimously: - 2021-SE-2002 (7601 East 88th Place): Special exception for religious uses (Onward Ministries). - 2021-DV-2020 (2633 North College Avenue): Amended variance for a four-vehicle detached garage with 3.29-foot side setback. - 2021-DV-2021 (823 East 21st Street): Amended variance for a single-family dwelling with a one-foot front setback, five-foot rear setback, and 48% open space. - 2021-DV-2022 (2053 Sycamore Lane): Variance for a detached garage with a five-foot side setback. - PAH Partners LLC (not numbered?): Variance for five three-story multifamily buildings with 168 units and other uses. - 2021-DV-2019 (5510 Millersville Road): Variance for a temporary modular building with a three-foot transitional setback. - 2021-DV-2014 (2032 West 64th Street): Amended variance for a single-family dwelling with 10-foot and 14-foot side setbacks, 81% open space, and 25-foot rear setback. Public Comments & Testimony - Roderick Lane (958 East 30th Street) expressed uncertainty about plans for the property at issue in 2021-UV-2008, requesting more information. The board suggested he contact the petitioner's representative. - Pat Andrews (representing Decatur Township Civic Council) spoke in opposition to a use variance, detailing the council's vote (2 support, 3 not oppose, 8 oppose) and requesting specific commitments to protect the neighborhood. Discussion Items - 2021-UV-2005 (3827 West Troy Avenue) – Contractor's Office Variance: Petitioner Jeremy Eglin (counsel for 4 BM LLC) requested a use variance for a contractor's office. He described the property's history as a welding shop and the business's low-intensity operations. Remonstrator Pat Andrews requested commitments: limiting the use to the petitioner or similar business, parking vehicles inside, and a site plan for landscaping, paving, and dumpster enclosure. Staff recommended approval with conditions, including landscaping along Troy Avenue. After debate, the petitioner agreed to commitments: dumpster screening, landscaping per ordinance, paving the parking lot, and substantial compliance with the plan of operation, subject to administrator review. The board voted unanimously to approve with these commitments. - 2021-DV-2018 (4102 East 42nd Street) – Fence Variance: Petitioner Melissa Hawk requested a six-foot privacy fence in the front yard. Staff recommended denial, citing clear sight triangle concerns and the metro context requiring a 42-inch height limit. The board suggested continuing the case to allow negotiation with staff. The petitioner agreed to a continuance. Key Outcomes - Approved the motion to move 2021-DV-2005 to the expedited docket. - Approved the motion to move 2021-DV-2021 to the expedited docket, with amended open space of 48% and a five-foot rear setback. - Approved the motion to move 2021-DV-2014 to the expedited docket. - Approved the continuance of 2021-UV-2007 to June 8, 2021, without additional notice unless amended. - Approved the continuance of 2021-UV-2008 to June 8, 2021, and allowed transfer of fees to a rezone petition. - Acknowledged the existing continuance of 2020-DV-3049 to June 8, 2021. - Approved the continuance of 2021-UV-2010 to June 8, 2021, without additional notice. - Approved the continuance of 2021-DV-2005 to June 8, 2021, without additional notice. - Approved the expedited docket unanimously. - Approved 2021-UV-2005 with commitments (dumpster screening, landscaping, paving, substantial compliance with plan of operation). Vote was unanimous. - Continued 2021-DV-2018 to June 8, 2021, to allow negotiation with staff. - Adopted findings of fact for previously denied petitions 2021-DV-2015 and 2021-DV-2017. - Adjourned the meeting.

ZONING AND LAND USE 73% · PROCEDURAL 13% · FENCE REGULATION 10% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2%
834
MAY 4, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Hearing - May 4, 2021

The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) held its first in-person hearing on May 4, 2021, with four board members present (McKay, Bohannon, Brandon, Taft). The meeting covered special requests (withdrawals, continuances, and transfers to expedited docket), an expedited docket of multiple variance petitions, and two full hearings. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Special Requests (Consent Calendar) - 2020 DV1065 (2097 15 Park Davis Drive, Warren Township): Petitioner David Kingan requested withdrawal; acknowledged without vote. - 2020 DV1082 (32 North Catherwood): Petitioner Joshua Findler requested a continuance to June 1, 2021; staff had no objection; board unanimously approved. - 2021 UV1011 (1073 Oliver Avenue): Petitioner Sarah Walters requested withdrawal of two variance components and expedited handling of remaining issues; staff explained amendments; board unanimously approved expedited placement. - 2021 DV1018 (233 East Minnesota Street): Petitioner Marcus Crouch requested transfer to expedited docket after reaching agreement with staff; one audience member expressed interest but did not object; staff had no objection; board unanimously approved. - 2021 DV1015 (1402 and 1406 East Fletcher Avenue): Petitioner Marcus Crouch requested a continuance and transfer to May 18, 2021, to finalize a site plan; staff no objection; board unanimously approved continuance and transfer (corrected from DV1018 in the vote). - 2021 UV1012 (619 Holly Avenue): Staff reported petitioner requested continuance to June 1, 2021; no objection; board unanimously approved continuance. Public Comments & Testimony - For 2021 UV1010 (1518 Renton Street), remonstrator Khalil La Al Mohaming (2618 Bethel Avenue) expressed opposition to the variance request. He was encouraged to discuss with the petitioner in the hallway; the case was moved to full hearing. - During the expedited docket, an unidentified man in a pacer hat initially expressed interest in the Minnesota Street case but confirmed he was only an interested party and did not object. Discussion Items - Expedited Docket: The board read into record nine petitions (DV1017, DV1019, DV1020, DV1022, DV1023, UV1009, UV1010, HOV014, UV1011 amended, DV1018). After a remonstrator opposed UV1010, that case was moved to the full hearing. The board then voted unanimously to approve all remaining expedited petitions as read. - Full Hearing – 2021 UV1008 (2807 West 10th Street, Wayne Township): Petitioner Eric Simmons requested variances to legally establish storage for a property management business (not lawn care, as he clarified), zero parking, and a six-foot fence with barbed wire. Staff recommended denial, citing the site's potential for urban mixed-use development and noting alternative security measures. Simmons argued the building is used only for overflow storage and that parking is unnecessary. Board member Brandon asked about modifying the request by removing barbed wire and adding pavement, but Simmons preferred his original request. The board voted 4–0 to approve the variances as originally requested, with a subsequent continuation to adopt findings of fact. - Full Hearing – 2021 UV1010 (1518 Renton Street): Petitioner Jeffrey Zinsmeyer (Millennia Housing Development) requested a variance of use for a community building in a multifamily development. Remonstrator Derek Oliver (2626 Bethel Avenue) requested a continuance, stating the community had not been properly informed and needed time to discuss. Zinsmeyer cited a deadline for a tax credit application and opposed a long delay. After staff noted the deadline was in July, the board brokered a compromise: a two-week continuance to May 18, 2021, to allow a community meeting. Board voted unanimously to continue and transfer to May 18. Key Outcomes - 2021 UV1008 approved (4–0) as requested, with continuation for adoption of findings of fact. - 2021 UV1010 continued and transferred to May 18, 2021, to allow community discussion. - All special requests (withdrawals, continuances, expedited transfers) were granted unanimously. - The expedited docket (except UV1010) was approved unanimously en bloc. - Board also began adopting findings of fact for previously voted cases (2021 DV1014B denied by Brandon, McKay, Taft). - The meeting adjourned with remarks about the first in-person hearing.

ZONING AND LAND USE 46% · PROCEDURAL 33% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 12% · CODE ENFORCEMENT 9%
835
APR 26, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 Hearing - April 26, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 held a public hearing on April 26, 2021, via electronic means due to COVID-19. The board considered several petitions from Verizon Wireless for variances to install 5G small cell poles in residential areas where underground utilities are required. The meeting also handled continuances and an expedited petition. Four board members were present: Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen, Marisol Guevaya, Janice Golson Dunlap, and Anatoly Boschenko. Three votes were needed for approval. Consent Calendar - 2020 DV3059 (amended) – Race Track Petroleum: A variance of development standards for transparency at 5430 West 86th Street. Approved unanimously (4-0) with adoption of findings of fact. Public Comments & Testimony - Lisa Herber (property owner at 551 Westfield Boulevard) opposed petition 2020 DV3036, stating the proposed pole would be directly in her front yard, affecting property values. She noted existing poles across the street that could be used for co-location. - John Drake (5710 Broadway Terrace) opposed petition 2020 DV3036, citing staff’s negative recommendation, lack of proof that property values would not be affected, and the pole’s aesthetic impact. - No remonstrators appeared for other petitions. Discussion Items - Special Requests and Continuances: Three continuances were granted without objection to the next hearing on January 19, 2021 (noting the discrepancy that the meeting date is April 26, 2021; the transcript references a December 2020 meeting, but per instructions, the meeting date is April 26, 2021). The continuances were for petitions 2020 UV3013, 2020 DV3052, and 2020 UV3011. - Verizon 5G Variances – Overview: Russell Brown, attorney for Verizon, presented a 20-minute overview explaining the need for 5G technology, the regulatory framework, and the design of the poles. He argued that the underground utility ordinance does not apply to wireless facilities and that the variance criteria were met. - Petition 2020 DV3035: Five proposed pole locations in Washington Township. Staff recommended denial. No remonstrators. Mr. Brown argued that above-ground utilities already exist nearby. The board voted 0-4 to deny. - Petition 2020 DV3036: Two locations (Westfield Boulevard and West 58th Street). Remonstrators spoke. Staff recommended denial citing impact on residential neighborhoods and safety hazards. Despite rebuttal from Mr. Brown, the board voted 0-4 to deny. - Petition 2020 DV3038: Three locations in Center and Warren Townships. Mr. Brown requested a split vote. Staff recommended approval for the alley location (45 South Bradley Avenue) and denial for the other two. The board voted 4-0 to approve the alley location (Part B) and 0-4 to deny the other two (Part A). - Petition 2020 DV3039: Three locations in Washington Township. Staff recommended denial despite one location on East 86th Street that staff suggested relocating. Mr. Brown argued relocation was not feasible. The board voted 0-4 to deny. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: 2020 UV3013, 2020 DV3052, 2020 UV3011 – all continued to January 19, 2021 without additional notice. - Expedited Petition Approved: 2020 DV3059 (Race Track Petroleum) – approved 4-0. - Denied Petitions (all 0-4): 2020 DV3035, 2020 DV3036, 2020 DV3038 Part A (Brookville Road and South Chester), 2020 DV3039. - Approved Petition: 2020 DV3038 Part B (45 South Bradley Avenue) – approved 4-0 with condition of black metal pole and internal cabling. - Adoption of findings of fact was continued for denied petitions; approved petition adopted findings.

ZONING AND LAND USE 31% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 29% · PROCEDURAL 20% · UTILITY REGULATION 13%
836
APR 20, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
BZA Division 3 Virtual Hearing Approves Variances, Continues Controversial Sign Case - April 20, 2021

The Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 3 held its final virtual hearing on April 20, 2021, at 6:15 PM, during which it considered several variance requests. The board approved a four-day waiver of notice, granted most variances, and continued one case to May 18, 2021. The meeting was conducted with four members present, requiring three votes for approval. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions: The board voted 4-0 to approve all five expedited petitions in a single vote, adopting findings of fact for each. These included variances for single-family dwellings and garages at various addresses. Public Comments & Testimony - Call-in Users: Jason Foos (petitioner for 2021-DV3-011, Hoover Road sign), Pat Rooney (petitioner for 2020-UV3-014, 2820 Burden Avenue), and Sharman Fry (petitioner for 2021-DV3-012, 1615 South Tabit Street) identified themselves. - Remonstrators: Jacob Love opposed (2020-UV3-014) and Susan Hoffman and Terry Jones opposed (2021-DV3-008). Mark Shear and S. Yari opposed (2021-DV3-011). Discussion Items - Special Requests and Continuances: - Four-day waiver for second notice for 2020-UV3-014 granted (4-0). - Withdrawal of 2021-DV3-016 acknowledged. - Automatic continuance for 2021-UV3-002 to May 18, 2021. - Staff-requested continuance for 2021-UV3-003 to May 18, 2021. - Expedited petitions DV3-013, DV3-014, DV3-015 remained on expedited docket after no remonstrators appeared. - 2020-UV3-011 (115 North Traub Avenue): Petitioner Andrew Summerford requested a variance to legalize three dwelling units (two in the main house, one in the garage) that existed for over 50 years. He introduced an affidavit from a neighbor confirming the use since 1969. Staff recommended denial, citing lack of permit history and illegal conversion. The board approved 3-1 (Golson Dunlop dissenting). - 2021-DV3-008 (241 Dixon Street): Petitioner, represented by John Cross, sought variances for setbacks and open space to construct a new single-family home with attached garage. Staff recommended approval as amended. Remonstrators Susan Hoffman and Terry Jones opposed, citing safety and maintenance concerns due to proximity to their three-story home. The board approved 4-0, subject to a commitment to build a front porch. - 2020-UV3-014 (2820 Burden Avenue): Petitioner Pat Rooney requested a variance of use and development standards to legalize an automotive repair shop with outdoor storage. Staff recommended approval, and the petitioner agreed to commitments on hours (7 a.m. to 6 p.m., Monday through Saturday), no deliveries outside those hours, and vehicle storage limited to 60 days. Jacob Love opposed, citing neighborhood concerns. The board approved 3-1 (Golson Dunlop dissenting), subject to commitments. - 2021-DV3-009 (1917 West 63rd Street): Petitioner Jacqueline Foster requested a variance to maintain a six-foot-tall privacy fence extending 15 feet north of the front facade. Staff recommended denial. After discussion, Foster agreed to remove one panel and plant additional arborvitaes. The board approved 4-0. - 2021-DV3-011 (7001 Hoover Road): Petitioner Jason Foos requested a variance for a five-foot-tall freestanding sign with a one-foot front setback. Remonstrators Mark Shear and S. Yari raised safety concerns about sight lines, especially for pedestrians and cyclists. Board members expressed concerns and voted to continue the case to May 18, 2021, without additional notice, to allow the petitioner to reconsider the sign placement, possibly moving it north or to the south side of the intersection. Key Outcomes - Approvals: 2020-UV3-011 (3-1), 2021-DV3-008 (4-0), 2020-UV3-014 (3-1), 2021-DV3-009 (4-0), and all expedited petitions (4-0). - Continuance: 2021-DV3-011 continued to May 18, 2021, without additional notice. - Other: Four-day waiver granted; withdrawals and continuances acknowledged; next hearing scheduled for May 18, 2021, in person in the Public Assembly Room.

ZONING AND LAND USE 44% · SIGN REGULATION 18% · PROCEDURAL 13% · TRAFFIC SAFETY 7%
837
APR 13, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
BZA2 Hearing of April 13, 2021: Variance Decisions and Officer Elections

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, held a public hearing on April 13, 2021, via electronic means due to COVID-19. Chair Mark Young presided. The meeting covered special requests, continuances, expedited petitions, and full hearings on five variance cases. The board also elected officers for 2021. Consent Calendar - None explicitly listed; however, the board handled several routine continuances and withdrawals at the start. Public Comments & Testimony - Brian Bailey (call-in) expressed interest as a neighbor regarding case 2021-DV2-017 (Woodlawn Avenue) and asked about building separation distances. His question was answered by petitioner Jonathan Blake. - No other public testimony was recorded; all other attendees either were petitioners or staff. Special Requests and Continuances - Case 2021-SE2-001 (1018 and 1030 Logger Lane): Petitioner Skylar Sullivan requested a continuance to June 8, 2021, without additional notice. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - Case 2021-DV2-011 (11315 East Washington Street): Petitioner requested withdrawal of the digital sign portion and reduction of sign height to four feet. Staff acknowledged and recommended moving to expedited docket. Board approved the withdrawal and moved to expedited docket (unanimous). - Case 2020-DV3-049 (7430 East Southport Road): Petitioner David Rathaford requested continuance to June 8, 2021, with additional notice for an amended variance. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - Case 2021-DV2-014 (2032 West 64th Street): Petitioner Sarah Walters requested continuance to May 11, 2021, with additional notice due to overlooked rear setback. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - Case 2021-DV2-013 (1531 North High School Road): A neighbor supported withdrawal; petitioner had submitted withdrawal on April 1. Staff acknowledged withdrawal and supported a full refund of $614. Board voted to withdraw and refund (unanimous). - Case 2021-UV2-05 (3827 West Troy Avenue): Staff noted an automatic continuance to May 11, 2021, by a registered neighborhood organization. Board acknowledged. - Case 2021-DV2-005 (351 South East Street): Staff requested continuance on petitioner's behalf to May 11, 2021, without notice. Motion carried unanimously. - Case 2021-DV2-010 (1718 South East Street): Staff recommended continuance to June 8, 2021, with notice because no affidavit had been filed and petitioner was unrepresented. Motion carried unanimously. Expedited Petitions - The board voted to approve all expedited petitions in a single vote, adopting findings of fact. Petitions: - 2021-UV2-006 (5661 Madison Avenue): Variance of use to legally establish a single-family dwelling. - 2021-DV2-011 (amended, 11315 East Washington Street): For a four-foot tall monument sign (already moved to expedited). - Motion carried unanimously (5-0). Discussion Items (Full Hearings) Case 2021-UV2-004 (811 LeClear Street) - Request: Convert single-family dwelling into two units; variances for floor area, lot size, parking. Petitioner later withdrew request for four substandard parking spaces. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing D4 district standards, insufficient lot area, and potential public safety concerns with rear unit entrance. - Board Vote: Denied 1-4 (only Peter Nelson voted yes). Case 2021-DV2-012 (9961 East Washington Street) – Chick-fil-A - Request: Variances for drive-thru lane in front yard, reduced setback, additional sign. Petitioner withdrew sign request and landscape variance, leaving only drive-thru location variance. - Staff: Recommended denial, noting other drive-thrus in center are located to rear and that the site is smaller than average for the chain. - Board Vote: Approved as amended 3-2 (Duke and Nelson and Young voted yes; Reuter and Kelly no). Case 2021-DV2-015 (5330 East Thompson Road) – Tire Discounters sign - Request: 20-foot tall pole sign within 190 feet of existing sign (300 ft required) and third sign along frontage (max two). Petitioner indicated willingness to consider monument sign. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing sufficient wall signage and available integrated sign panel. - Board Vote: Denied 2-3 (only Duke and Young voted yes). Case 2021-DV2-016 (1401 Harding Court) – MK Truck Centers signs - Request: Part A – Two 45-foot tall pole signs (one 250 sq ft, one 150 sq ft) spaced 175 feet apart. Part B – Allow the 250 sq ft sign to be digital (vs. non-digital). Staff recommended approval of non-digital sign at 45 ft but denial of digital component at 250 sq ft and 45 ft height. - Board Vote: Part A approved 5-0. Part B denied 2-3 (Duke and Young voted yes; Reuter, Kelly, Nelson no). Case 2021-DV2-017 (1627-1635 Woodlawn Avenue) - Request: Subdivide three parcels into five single-family lots (4,300 sq ft each, 24 ft width, 6 ft between dwellings). Petitioner argued consistency with neighborhood plan. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing inadequate lot width, precedent concerns, and ability to develop without variances. - Board Vote: Denied 1-4 (only Nelson voted yes). Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: Cases 2021-SE2-001 (June 8), 2020-DV3-049 (June 8 with notice), 2021-DV2-014 (May 11 with notice), 2021-DV2-005 (May 11 without notice), 2021-DV2-010 (June 8 with notice). - Withdrawal approved: Cases 2021-DV2-013 (with refund of $614) and 2021-DV2-011 (digital sign portion withdrawn, moved to expedited). - Expedited petitions approved: Two cases (2021-UV2-006 and amended 2021-DV2-011). - Full hearing decisions: - 2021-UV2-004: Denied (1-4). - 2021-DV2-012: Approved with amendments (3-2). - 2021-DV2-015: Denied (2-3). - 2021-DV2-016 Part A (non-digital signs): Approved (5-0); Part B (digital component): Denied (2-3). - 2021-DV2-017: Denied (1-4). - Officer elections: Mark Young retained as Chair, Alicia Reuter as Vice Chair, Mary Kelly as Secretary (all votes unanimous). - Next meeting: Scheduled for May 11, 2021, with potential return to in-person at the City-County Building.

ZONING AND LAND USE 39% · SIGN REGULATION 30% · PROCEDURAL 18% · TRANSPORTATION 10%
838
APR 6, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Meeting - April 6, 2021

This was a virtual public hearing of the Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1, held on April 6, 2021, due to COVID-19 guidelines. Chairperson Joanna Taff led the meeting, which included routine continuances, approval of an expedited docket, and four full hearings on variance requests. The meeting adjourned at 3:59 PM. It was noted that this was the last virtual hearing; the next hearing on May 4, 2021, will be held in person. Consent Calendar - Continuances granted: 2020-DV1-082 (to May 4, 2021), 2021-DV1-013 (to June 1, 2021), 2021-DV1-015 (to May 4, 2021), 2021-UV1-008 (to May 4, 2021). - Expedited petitions approved: 2021-DV1009, 2021-DV1010, 2021-DV1011, 2021-DV1012, 2021-DV1016. All were approved in a single vote (5-0) after no opposition was raised. Public Comments & Testimony Public testimony was heard for each full hearing case as part of the discussion. Details are provided under each case below. Discussion Items 2021-DV1004: 445 Springmill Lane – Variance for side setback and lot subdivision - Petitioner: Todd Tetro requested a variance to reduce the side setback from 7 feet to 3.5 feet and to subdivide the lot into two lots. He stated he would remove a non-original garage and restore the original garage, and preserve a heritage cottonwood tree. - Remonstrators: Four neighbors (Steve Alspaugh, John Pryweller, Mark Fisk, Caroline Gedd) spoke in opposition. They presented evidence that 37 of 38 homes on the street (97%) signed a petition against the variance. They cited drainage issues, a heritage cottonwood tree, and argued that the lot had always been considered unbuildable. Mark Fisk, a professional engineer, detailed flooding problems and soil permeability issues. - Staff recommendation: Approval with two commitments: (1) revised site plan showing tree preservation, and (2) if a rear garage is built, access must be via an easement to the east. Staff noted the tree is a combination of three or four trees and is on the adjacent vacant lot. - Outcome: Approved 4-1 (McKay, Bohannan, Brandon, Taft in favor; Hampton opposed) with the two commitments. 2021-DV1007 (amended): 230 Kansas Street – Variance for two-family dwelling and detached garage on substandard lot - Petitioner: Mark Crouch, representing 317 Homes LLC, requested a use variance for a duplex on a 40-foot-wide, 5,840 sq ft lot (minimum 70 ft wide and 7,200 sq ft). Also requested variances for reduced building separation (7 ft vs. 10 ft) and open space (55% vs. 60%). He argued the duplex would be owner-occupied and help the neighborhood revitalize. - Remonstrator: Letty Walton, neighbor at 234 Kansas Street, expressed concerns about building separation, fire safety, and garbage pickup. She wanted to maintain the required 10-foot separation. - Staff recommendation: Denial, stating the lot could accommodate a single-family dwelling with an accessory dwelling unit without variances, and the proposed development would be overbuilt and detrimental. - Old Southside Neighborhood Association: Supported the request with seven commitments (including landscaping, trash enclosure, and prohibition of Airbnbs). Petitioner agreed to these commitments. - Outcome: Approved 5-0 with the commitments from the neighborhood association. 2021-UV1005: 437 North Euclid Avenue – Variance of use for transitional living quarters (sober living) - Petitioner: Mark Crouch and Yay Uni (owner/operator) requested a use variance to operate a sober living home for up to eight men. They described strict house rules, a 10 PM curfew, and a successful similar operation at 2331 North Pennsylvania. Residents Anthony Fagley and Matt Pazzarelli testified about the positive impact. Keith Bevan, a 20-year recovery professional, stated the house would seek state certification. - Remonstrator: Ben Morgan, a neighbor two doors down and owner of the adjacent duplex, argued the facility would decrease property values and tenant interest. He also alleged unpermitted construction changes to the property, which the petitioner denied. - Staff recommendation: Approval with commitments: maximum of eight residents and adherence to the submitted plan of operation. Staff noted that eight unrelated persons would be allowed under the duplex definition, so the request was reasonable. - Outcome: Approved 5-0 with the two commitments. 2021-DV1014: 1750 Olus Drive – Variance for 9-foot-tall fence - Petitioner: Marley Johnson requested a 9-foot-tall fence (instead of the permitted 6 feet) on the rear and side yards. He cited the need to contain livestock guardian dogs, block deer, reduce noise and light from Walmart, and provide privacy. He submitted a petition signed by all adjoining neighbors. - Remonstrator: Stuart Moyer initially called in but later stated he supported the request after working with the petitioner. - Staff recommendation: Split – approval for the rear fence (abutting Walmart/commercial area) due to practical difficulty, but denial for the side fences because tall fences create an industrial appearance and are not appropriate in a residential area. Staff noted that a 10-foot fence would be allowed in a C4 zoning, but the adjacent property is zoned CS. - Outcome: - Ballot A (rear fence): Approved 5-0. - Ballot B (side fences): Denied 3-2 (McKay, Brandon, Taft voted no; Bohannan, Hampton voted yes). The side fence variance was denied. Key Outcomes - All continuances were granted as requested. - Five expedited petitions were approved in a single vote. - 2021-DV1004 approved 4-1 with two commitments. - 2021-DV1007 approved 5-0 with neighborhood association commitments. - 2021-UV1005 approved 5-0 with commitments on maximum residents and plan of operation. - 2021-DV1014 rear fence approved 5-0; side fence denied 3-2. - The board also adopted findings of fact for a 2016 administrative appeal (2016-AP1001) by a 5-0 vote.

ZONING AND LAND USE 40% · MISCELLANEOUS 16% · PROCEDURAL 13% · SUBSTANCE ABUSE TREATMENT 9%
839
MAR 16, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Marion County BZA Division 3 Meeting - March 16, 2021

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 3, met electronically on March 16, 2021, at 6:15 p.m. (Eastern) under COVID-19 executive orders. Chair Craig Von Dalen presided with members Janice Golson Dunlop, Anatoly Boshenko, Alicia Reuter, and Renee Napoleon. The board heard one continuance, approved four expedited petitions, and deliberated three full variance petitions. Votes on two sets of negative findings of fact for previously denied petitions were also conducted. Continuances & Special Requests - 2020-UV3-014 (2820 Burton Ave): Requested by petitioner Pat Rooney (via technical difficulties). The board voted unanimously (5-0) to continue to the April 20, 2021 hearing with additional notice. - 241 Dixon Street: A registered neighborhood organization filed a timely automatic continuance to April 20, 2021; the board acknowledged. Expedited Petitions (Consent Calendar) The board waived rules of procedure and approved four expedited variance petitions in a single vote (5-0): - 2021 DV3004 (737 N Lynwood Ave): Addition to single-family dwelling and detached garage (48% open space). - 2021 DV3005 (309 Parkway Ave): Single-family dwelling with reduced front setbacks and 39% open space. - 2021 DV3006 (1550 Fletcher Ave): Detached garage accessory to single-family dwelling (44% open space). - 2021 DV3007 (118 E 44th St): Addition to single-family dwelling (56% open space). All petitioners agreed with staff reports and findings. Public Comments & Testimony - No remonstrators spoke on any agenda item. - Christina Blackwell (Steincraft) appeared by phone in support of petition 2020 DV3068. - The Crown Hill Neighborhood Association submitted a letter of support for petition 2020 DV3068, having been involved in the project from concept. Discussion Items 1. 2021 UV3-001 (2219 Prospect St) – Detached Garage in C4 District - Petitioner: Randall C. Hubble (unrepresented). Requested a variance of use to construct a detached two-car garage accessory to his existing single-family residence in a C4 commercial zone. - Staff Position: Recommended denial, stating residential uses are not permitted in C4 and that the proper remedy would be a rezoning to D8. Staff argued the variance would not align with the comprehensive plan. - Board Discussion: Member Alicia Reuter noted that neighboring properties appear to have detached garages. Chair Von Dalen expressed that requiring a rezoning placed an unfair burden on the homeowner, given the property had been residentially used for decades and was likely improperly zoned in the 1960s. - Vote: 4-0 in favor (member Golson Dunlop had stepped out). Approved. 2. 2020 DV3052 (9200 Keystone Crossing) – Billboard Setback Variance - Petitioner: Rich Blakelock (Lewis Wagner) on behalf of Circle City Outdoor LLC. Requested variances to legally retain an existing 14'x28' double-sided billboard with a 20-ft setback from I-465 (required 60 ft) and within 500 ft of an interstate entrance/exit ramp (prohibited). The billboard had been in place since 2011 under a court agreed judgment. - Staff Position: Recommended denial. Staff cited the original permit error, the expiration of the nine-year court order, and that the ordinance prohibits such billboards for safety reasons. They suggested alternative uses (landscaping/parking) and noted other billboards exist in the area. - Petitioner Arguments: The billboard has been safe for nine years (no accidents); a forensic expert report confirmed no distraction due to the unique ramp geometry (sign is passed long before merging). Circle City is a small, local business that waives fees during COVID and advertises for local businesses. The Northside Community Council and Keystone at the Crossing Office Park supported the variance; Greater Allisonville Community Council opposed (without explanation provided). - Board Vote: 3-2 in favor (members Von Dalen, Golson Dunlop, and Napoleon voted yes; Reuter and Boshenko voted no). Approved. 3. 2020 DV3068 Amended (11 W 38th St) – Digital Display Pylon Sign - Petitioner: Joe Cauldron representing Crew Car Wash. Requested a variance to allow a 25-ft tall pylon sign with a digital display (175 sq ft, 27% digital) located within 175 ft of a protected residential district (600 ft required). The sign was moved out of the clear site triangle. - Staff Position: Recommended denial. Staff stated that the digital display regulations exist to protect residential areas and that the site could use non-digital signage. They expressed concern about driver distraction and precedent. - Petitioner Arguments: The site is in a compact urban context; the ordinance's one-size-fits-all separation requirement is impractical in the old city limits. The digital display will not flash/scroll – commitments include 30-second static messages, no operation during rush hours or 10 p.m.–6 a.m., and full neighborhood support (Crown Hill Neighborhood Association). Similar signs approved at other Crew locations (e.g., Glendale). - Board Vote: 4-1 in favor (members Von Dalen, Golson Dunlop, Boshenko, and Napoleon voted yes; Reuter voted no, citing concern over setting a precedent along 38th Street). Approved. Key Outcomes - 2021 UV3-001 (Hubble): Granted variance for detached garage (4-0). - 2020 DV3052 (Keystone billboard): Granted variances for setback and entrance/exit restrictions (3-2). - 2020 DV3068 (Crew Car Wash sign): Granted variance for digital display (4-1). - Adoption of Negative Findings (Nov 24, 2020 denials): The board (members Von Dalen, Reuter, and Hampton) unanimously approved findings of fact for five denied petitions (2020 DV3029, 3030, 3031, 3032B, 3034). - Adoption of Negative Findings (Dec 15, 2020 denials): The board (members Von Dalen, Golson Dunlop, and Boshenko) unanimously approved findings of fact for four denied petitions (2020 DV3035, 3036, 3038A, 3039). - Meeting adjourned at approximately 2:50 p.m.

PROCEDURAL 38% · SIGN REGULATION 31% · ZONING AND LAND USE 22% · PUBLIC SAFETY 4%
840
MAR 9, 2021 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Hearing Summary - March 9, 2021

The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) convened on March 9, 2021, at 18:00 UTC (1:00 PM local) via hybrid virtual format due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Chairman Mark Young presided over the meeting, with board members Alicia Reuter, Mary Kelly, James Duke, and Peter Nelson in attendance. The board heard several special requests, expedited petitions, and full hearings, with votes conducted by roll call. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 4:05 PM local time. Special Requests & Continuances - 2021-UV2-003 (3854 North College Avenue): Sarah Walters requested and received a three-day waiver of notice requirements. The board approved the waiver unanimously (5-0). - 2020-DV2-051 (432 Forest Avenue): The board acknowledged the petitioner's email request to withdraw this petition. - 2019-UV1-009 (2629 West Walnut Street): The petitioner submitted a letter indicating withdrawal; however, the case was continued to April 13, 2021, to allow time to possibly amend the petition. David Rutherford, representing the petitioner, agreed to the continuance. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to continue without additional notice unless the petition is amended. - 2020-DB3049 (7430 East South Boat Road): Continued to April 13, 2021, without additional notice unless required. Motion by Kelly, seconded by Nelson, approved unanimously (5-0). - 2021-DB2005 (351 East Street): The petitioners filed a timely request for automatic continuance to April 13, 2021; the board acknowledged it. - 2021-DV2-010 (1718 South East Street): The petitioner was deficient on public notice (never picked up the notice sign) and had not submitted an affidavit of notice. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to continue the case to April 13, 2021, with notice. Expedited Petitions All expedited petitions were approved in a single unanimous vote (5-0) after a waiver of procedural rules. Petitioners had stated they read and agreed with staff reports, knew of no remonstrators, and agreed to conditions. The approved petitions were: - 2021-DV204 (5246 Central Avenue): Variance for a two-story dwelling and garage addition with a five-foot rear setback (20 feet required). - 2021-DV2007 (amended, 5246 Central Avenue): Variance for an 18-foot front setback and other development standards. - 2021-DV2009 (831 Lincoln Street): Variance for a detached garage accessory to a single-family dwelling with 52% open space (60% required). - 2021-UV2002 (4407 Man Road): Variance of use to convert a single-family dwelling into two dwelling units (not permitted). - 2021-UV2003 (3854 North College Avenue): Variance of use for a two-family dwelling with an attached garage (not permitted). Full Hearing: 2020-UV2009 (10131 East Thompson Road) - APPROVED - Petition: Variance of use for a landscaping contractor business with seasonal outdoor storage of trailers within a gravel parking area in the DA (agricultural) district. Attorney David Rutherford represented the petitioners, Robert Harris and Kelly L. Dearth. - Petitioner's Position: Rutherford argued the six-acre property is uniquely situated (backing to I-74 and Thompson Road), that the business has operated for two years without neighbor complaints, that all three potentially impacted neighbors support the request subject to a detailed plan of operation and two commitments (drainage improvements and tree planting), and that the Franklin Township Civic League land use committee supports the variance. He also noted the comprehensive plan splits the property between estate residential (front) and industrial (rear), making the use arguably consistent with plan recommendations. - Councillor Support: City-County Councillor Brian Maori submitted a letter of strong support, stating the property matches the comprehensive plan's split recommendations and that the variance process "brought peace to this neighborhood." - Staff Position: Staff recommended denial, citing concerns about the business being larger than the primary dwelling, increased intensity of non-agricultural use in the DA district, and potential traffic on Thompson Road. - Outcome: The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve the variance, subject to the plan of operation and two filed commitments. Full Hearing: 2020-SE2002 (604 West Stop 11 Road) - DENIED - Petition: Indy Zion Baptist Church sought a special exception for religious use (construction of new buildings with parking) and a variance for a 40-square-foot ground sign on an 8.5-acre parcel in the D3 district. Daniel Rosello represented the church; Jeff Boyna (Myler Church Builders) also testified in support. - Petitioner's Position: The congregation currently rents space from another church, averages 140 attendees per service, and hopes to reach 300. Rosello argued the project would be beneficial to the community, aligned with the comprehensive plan, and that ingress/egress already exists. Boyna stated the project would improve drainage with a retention pond, tie into city sewer, and use downward-pointing lighting to minimize light pollution. - Remonstrator Positions (six speakers, 15 minutes collective time): - Amy Davis (534 West Stop 11): Concerned about drainage and questioned whether city sewer is available; also noted noise from summer gatherings. - Brenda Dalk (7904 Rake Road): Cited existing drainage problems, privacy and security concerns, and traffic hazards for children walking to nearby schools. - Marilyn Cummings (7919 Forest Park Drive): Expressed shock at the 300-person goal (Rosello had previously described a "small congregation"); noted the church would be in the backyard of 35 homes; asserted no city sewer exists in the area; and raised concerns about tax-exempt status reducing school revenue. - Graylin (7848 Rake Road): Submitted documentation asserting no city sewer is available (Citizens would charge $100-$300 per foot for 870 feet, roughly $400,000 to extend); cited soil and water conservation district data showing water at one foot depth; and opposed the retention pond as a means of controlling all neighborhood drainage. - Jonathan Carter (7809 Opelika Court): Expressed concern that the retention pond posed a drowning risk to children, noting his grandfather drowned in a retention pond. - Laura Piercefield (315 Albany Street): Cited traffic visibility issues on Stop 11, personal childhood accidents, and argued the church should consider existing commercial properties for reuse instead. - Nancy Summit (7840 Rake Road): Reported current flooding in her backyard and stated Citizens Energy confirmed no sewer exists on Stop 11. - Matt Davis (534 West Stop 11): Reported chronic flooding ("Lake Davis") and stated a parking lot would worsen runoff and affect his septic system. - Staff Position: Staff recommended approval with commitments, including submission of a tree preservation plan and landscape plan, and requiring future expansions to undergo additional special exception hearings. Staff noted the proposed sign would comply with SU-1 district standards. - Outcome: The board voted unanimously (5-0) to DENY the petition. The case was continued for adoption of findings of fact supporting the denial. Full Hearing: 2021-DV206 (5310 Claybrook Commons Drive) - APPROVED - Petition: Variance of development standards for an 80-foot-tall, 528-square-foot pole sign (maximum 20-foot-tall, 300-square-foot pole sign permitted) for a CarMax dealership on a 4.6-acre parcel in the C5 district. Joe Calderon represented Claybrook Commons East LLC; John Cunningham (developer) also testified. - Petitioner's Position: The sign is needed because the property is over 1,000 feet from Emerson Avenue and is obscured by a tree stand in the state right-of-way along I-65. The total sign square footage (528) is less than the 600 square feet permitted via two 300-square-foot signs. The petitioner argued the height is the minimum needed for visibility and that a conforming sign would be completely buried by trees. - Staff Position: Staff recommended denial, citing the recent sign regulation changes intended to reduce visual impact, the I-65/County Line Road strategic plan goals (gateway first impression), and the availability of alternative signage options (integrated center signs along Emerson or further north). Staff noted the 80-foot sign would equal the height of a five-story hotel. - Outcome: The board voted unanimously (5-0) to APPROVE the variance. Full Hearing: 2021-DV208 (12 and 14 Sherwood Drive) - APPROVED - Petition: Variance of development standards to legally establish an existing pool shed and deck with a one-foot west side setback, two-foot rear setback, and encroachment into a five-foot utility easement, plus an addition to a single-family dwelling. Tyler Vargo (architectural designer) represented petitioners Tim and Emily Delaney. - Petitioner's Position: The pool shed and deck were installed before the Delaneys purchased the home 3.5 years ago and were never legally established. The shed is on a full foundation, making relocation impractical (demolition would be required). Four letters of support were submitted from neighbors and a community member. The petitioner noted he was working with the utility company for approval and had support from the Nora Northside Community Council and the Town of Meridian Hills land use committee. - Staff Position: Staff recommended denial, stating that minor residential structures should meet required setbacks and that permitting the structure within a recorded utility easement is inappropriate given the easement's purpose of providing utility access. Staff argued the shed could likely be relocated. - Outcome: The board voted unanimously (5-0) to APPROVE the variance. Full Hearing: 2021-UV2004 (811 LeCleed Street) - CONTINUED - Petition: West Side Renters, Inc. sought a variance of use and development standards to convert a single-family dwelling into two units and a detached garage into two additional units (four total units) on a 7,450-square-foot lot. The minimum required floor area is 900 square feet per unit; proposed units would range from 300 to 600 square feet. The minimum lot size for a two-family dwelling is 10,000 square feet. - Petitioner's Position: The petitioner (McConnell) had difficulty with audio and connectivity. He stated the business is close to the property and employees (11-12) need housing near work. He acknowledged the permit was not obtained initially but was "by it now" and requested time to submit new designs. - Staff Position: Staff recommended denial, noting the proposed use would create a density of 24 dwelling units per acre (exceeding the comprehensive plan recommendation of 5-8 units per acre by 300%), that no peculiar site condition exists, and that the hardship is self-imposed. - Outcome: The petitioner requested a continuance to April 13, 2021, without additional notice. Staff did not object. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to continue the case. Board member Ewan Hake offered to reach out to the petitioner to ensure he understood the process. Adoption of Findings - The board adopted revised findings for petition 2020-DV2054 (Mr. Carvajal), previously approved at an earlier hearing. The motion was made by Reuter, seconded by Kelly, and approved by unanimous vote of the three board members who had voted on the original petition (Reuter, Kelly, Nelson). Key Outcomes - Approved: 2020-UV2009 (variance of use, 5-0); 2021-DV206 (sign variance, 5-0); 2021-DV208 (development standards variance, 5-0); all expedited petitions (5-0). - Denied: 2020-SE2002 (special exception and sign variance, 0-5). - Continued to April 13, 2021: 2019-UV1-009, 2020-DB3049, 2021-DB2005, 2021-DV2-010, 2021-UV2004. - Withdrawals acknowledged: 2020-DV2-051. - Findings adopted: 2020-DV2054. - Technical difficulties: Multiple remonstrators and call-in users experienced connectivity issues, particularly for case 2020-SE2002; the board accommodated by proceeding out of order and returning to the case when participation was possible.

ZONING AND LAND USE 38% · PROCEDURAL 20% · SIGN REGULATION 13% · DRAINAGE 8%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com