This meeting of the Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 was held electronically due to COVID-19. The board considered multiple continuance requests, waiver requests, expedited petitions, and several full hearings, all involving variances of use or development standards. Key actions included granting continuances, approving expedited petitions, and voting on contested variance requests. Special Requests & Continuances - 2020 UV2009 (10131 East Thompson Road): Attorney David Rutherford requested a continuance to January 12, 2021, to finalize agreements with a neighbor. Granted unanimously. - 2020 DV3-049 (7430 East Southport Road): Susie Wilson requested a continuance to January 12, 2021, to amend the petition. Granted unanimously. - 2020 UV2-016 (7300 Highland Road): Staff requested a continuance on behalf of the petitioner to January 12, 2021. A remonstrator (Michael Hoy) did not object. Granted unanimously. - 2020 DV2-051 (432 North Forest Avenue): Petitioner William Bentley requested a two-day waiver of the 23-day notice requirement. Staff supported. Granted unanimously. - 2020 DV2-058 (6111 Lake Haven Lane): David Gilman requested a five-day waiver of the 30-day notice requirement due to a mailing error. Staff supported. Granted unanimously. - 2020 DV2-042 (8554 Springview Drive): Staff requested a one-month continuance to January 12, 2021, as the petitioner was not present. Granted unanimously. - 2020 DV3-054 (241 East Bronswick Avenue): Withdrawn by the petitioner; acknowledged by the board. Expedited Petitions - 2020 DV2-050 (816 East 21st Street) and 2020 DV2-057 (1131 Hoyt Avenue): Both petitions were read and approved in a single vote after a waiver of rules. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve and adopt findings of fact. Full Hearing Items 2019 UV1-009 (2629 West Walnut Street) – Tow Yard and Storage - Petitioner Jose Solano (representing William B. Baker) requested variances for a tow yard, setbacks, signage, parking, and handicapped space. Staff recommended denial, citing incompatibility with the comprehensive plan, lack of practical difficulty, and 100% deviation from setback standards. During discussion, the petitioner indicated they may have corrected violations but could not provide amended site plans. The board voted to continue the case to February 9, 2021, without additional notice, to allow the petitioner to submit revised plans. Motion carried unanimously. 2020 DV2-051 (432 North Forest Avenue) – Single-Family Dwelling Additions - Petitioner William Bentley (representing Joseph Hogan) requested variances for reduced front setback, reduced open space, and zero-foot side setback. The building was already constructed without proper permits. Staff recommended denial, noting the petitioner could revert to original state. After discussion, the board agreed to a continuance to February 9, 2021, to allow negotiation with staff on a possible compromise. Motion carried unanimously. 2020 DV2-058 (6111 Lake Haven Lane) – Outdoor Storage Surface - Petitioner David Gilman (representing R.H. Marlin) requested a variance to use milled asphalt and aggregate (instead of hard surface) for a 200,000+ sq. ft. outdoor storage area. Staff recommended denial but added a condition for paved internal drives. The petitioner agreed to pave internal drives and requested administrative review of a revised site plan. The board approved the variance (5-0) subject to the condition. 2020 UV2-018 (7875 West 10th Street) – Outdoor Cooler for Domino's Pizza - Petitioners (Renee Chappelle, John Killiani, Nate Lee) requested a variance of use and development standards for an outdoor walk-in cooler reducing the side setback from 20 ft to 3 ft. Staff supported the use variance but opposed the setback variance, noting adequate space on the south side. The petitioners argued operational hardship and offered to add screening. The board voted 3-2 to approve (Duke, Nelson, Young in favor; Reuter, Kelly opposed). Adoption of Findings of Fact - Revised findings of fact for 2020 DV2-053A and 2020 DV2-053B (from a previous meeting) were adopted by a vote of Reuter, Kelly, and Nelson (3-0). Key Outcomes - All continuance and waiver requests were granted unanimously. - Expedited petitions were approved unanimously. - 2019 UV1-009 and 2020 DV2-051 were continued to February 9, 2021. - 2020 DV2-058 was approved with a condition (paved internal drives subject to administrative review). - 2020 UV2-018 was approved by a 3-2 vote. - Revised findings for two prior petitions were adopted. Note: The meeting date is recorded as March 8, 2021, per the instructions, although the transcript references December 8, 2020, indicating a possible discrepancy between the provided date and the actual meeting content.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division One held a public hearing on March 2, 2021, beginning at approximately 6:15 PM ET. The meeting was conducted electronically due to COVID-19. The board considered continuances, expedited petitions, and four full hearing cases involving variances of use and development standards. Key topics included a proposed substance abuse group home, a residential garage access, a duplex development, and an event center. Continuances and Special Requests - 2020 DB1082 (735 Shelby St): Continued to April 6, 2021 without additional notice (motion by Bohan, second by Nelson, unanimous). - 2021 DV1004 (445 Spring Mill Lane): Continued to April 6, 2021 without notice after remonstrators requested continuance; petitioner attempted to object but continuance stood. - 2021 UV105 (437 N Euclid Ave): Continued to April 6, 2021 without notice, pending modified plan of operation (motion by Bohan, second by Nelson, unanimous). - 2021 DB1065 (9715 Park Davis Dr): Continued to May 4, 2021 (motion by Duncan, second by Nelson, unanimous). - 2020 UV1018 (5660 Madison Ave): Granted a three-day waiver of second notice to proceed with hearing (motion by Bohan, second by Nelson, unanimous). Expedited Petitions - The board approved all expedited petitions in a single vote after waiver of rules (motion by Bohan, second by Nelson, unanimous). Petitions included: 2021 DV1003 (Laurel St), 2021 DV1006 (Oakland Rd), 2020 UV1021 amended (Beachway Dr), 2021 UV1004 (N Rural St), and 2021 UV107. No opposition was noted. Full Hearing: 2020 UV1018 – Celtic Recovery Group Home (Denied) Petitioner: David Kingan representing Celtic Recovery LLC, seeking a variance of use to operate a nine-bed all-male substance abuse group home at 5660 Madison Avenue (D1 zone). The proposed facility would provide dual diagnosis treatment, with nine residents and up to 15 employees. Supporters included former state representative Jim Merritt, recovery advocate Peter Malloy, business owner Doug Powers, and City-County Councillor Mike Dilk. They argued the property is on a commercial corridor (89 businesses vs. 11 residences in a mile), the home would appear as a single-family residence, and there is a pressing need for addiction treatment. Remonstrators: Mark Bash (TERRA president), Greg Kitzmiller (TERRA board), and Clara Williams (neighbor). They opposed citing incompatibility with the residential neighborhood, lack of detailed operation plan (only five bullet points), concerns about traffic, parking, security, and potential negative impacts on property values and quality of life. Over 30 letters of opposition from nearby residents were submitted. Staff Position: Recommended denial. The proposed use does not meet the definition of a group home (limited to eight individuals), would be a commercial operation with excessive staff and parking, and is inappropriate for a residential block. No practical difficulty exists. Board Vote: Bohan (no), Duncan (no), Nelson (no), Hampton (yes), Taft (yes). Denied 3-2. The case was continued for adoption of findings of fact. Full Hearing: 2021 DV1005 – Garage Access on Singleton Street (Approved) Petitioner: Joe Calderon representing owner Iana Walker, requesting a variance of development standards to allow a detached garage accessed from Singleton Street instead of the required alley at 1844-1848 Singleton Street. The lot has historic street access, and the alley is narrow, poor condition, and abuts a commercial property. Remonstrators: None present. Staff Position: Recommended denial, citing ordinance intent to limit street cuts and promote alley access. No practical difficulty was identified. Board Vote: All five members voted yes. Approved unanimously. Full Hearing: 2021 UV1006 – Duplex at 230 Kansas Street (Continued) Petitioner: Mark Crouch for 317 Homes LLC, seeking variances for a duplex with reduced open space and setbacks. The project involves converting a lot for two dwelling units. Remonstrators: Letty Walton (neighbor) and Karen Young requested continuance to allow more time to review changes and discuss. Petitioner agreed. Outcome: Continued to April 6, 2021 without additional notice (motion by Bohan, second by Nelson, unanimous). Full Hearing: 2021 UV106 – Event Center at 909-915 S Short Ridge Road (Denied) Petitioner: Skylar Sullivan and Benjamin Gagne of 13th Hour Productions, seeking a variance of use and development standards to construct two pole barns and a 200+ space gravel parking lot for a seasonal haunted attraction and year-round recreation (escape rooms, axe throwing). The property is 24 acres, zone DA, with floodway and environmentally sensitive overlay. Remonstrators: Cheryl Dickon, Barbara Michler, Mary Margaret Mattingley, Carol Haskett, and Kathy Bates (neighbors). They cited traffic on narrow Short Ridge Road, flooding concerns, noise, light, and disruption to a quiet residential neighborhood. Over 60 signature petitions were submitted. Staff Position: Recommended denial. The use does not align with the comprehensive plan (light industrial recommended, not recreational). The proposed gravel parking in floodway area raises environmental concerns and would require permits unlikely to be approved. Access via Woodlawn Avenue is inappropriate. Petitioner's Commitments: Withdrew request for 16-foot setback from Short Ridge, agreeing to 35-foot setback. Board Vote: Bohan (no), Duncan (yes), Nelson (yes), Hampton (no), Taft (no). Denied 3-2. The case was continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Votes and Decisions: - 2020 UV1018: Denied (3-2). - 2021 DV1005: Approved (5-0). - 2020 UV1018 (waiver): Granted (5-0). - Expedited docket: Approved (5-0). - Continuances: Approved (5-0) for multiple cases. - Next Steps: Denied cases will have findings of fact adopted at future meetings. Continued cases will be heard in April or May 2021.
The Board of Zoning Appeals met on February 16, 2021, via WebEx to hear five variance petitions. Staff reports and recommendations were presented, and several petitions were continued to future dates. Discussion Items - 2020-DV3-069 (Amended): 6220 Carrollton Avenue – Petitioner Cairo Sands LLC sought a variance to allow a bar within 50 feet of a dwelling district, where the ordinance requires a 100-foot separation. Staff opined that the request was a minor deviation and supportable, and recommended approval with conditions: noise limited to 70 decibels, deliveries via the north-south alley, accessible entrance from the handicapped parking space, and compliance with the site plan dated December 10, 2020. - 2021-DV3-002: 606 Hamilton Avenue – Petitioner Michael J. Brown requested a variance to permit a detached garage accessory to a single-family dwelling with 50% open space (60% required) in the D-5 district. No additional information was provided. - 2020-UV3-011: 115 North Traub Avenue – Petitioner Carlos T. Moran requested a variance to legally establish three dwelling units in an existing dwelling and garage (not permitted in D-5). An indecisive vote on January 19, 2021, resulted in an automatic continuance to the February 16 hearing. - 2020-DV3-052: 9200 Keystone Crossing – Petitioner Circle City Outdoor LLC requested a variance for an outdoor advertising sign with a 20-foot setback from I-465 (60-foot required) and along an interchange roadway (signs prohibited within 500 feet of entrance/exit). The petitioner requested a continuance to March 16, 2021, due to scheduling conflicts. - 2020-DV3-068 (Amended): 111 West 38th Street – Petitioner Dahm No. 56 LLC requested a variance for a 25-foot tall pylon sign with a digital display within 175 feet of a protected district (600-foot separation required). Staff recommended continuing the petition to allow additional time for staff to work with the petitioner and possibly amend the petition. Key Outcomes - 2020-DV3-069: Staff recommended approval with conditions; final board action not specified. - 2021-DV3-002: No action documented; likely continued or deferred. - 2020-UV3-011: Continued from January 19; outcome on February 16 not recorded. - 2020-DV3-052: Continued to March 16, 2021, at the petitioner’s request. - 2020-DV3-068: Continued to allow further staff-petitioner discussions.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, met on February 9, 2021, via WebEx. Chair Mark Young presided. The meeting addressed special requests for continuances and waivers, approved an expedited consent docket, and heard a contested variance petition for a detached garage. The meeting adjourned at 1:48 p.m. Consent Calendar - Approved a two-day waiver of legal notice for 2021 DV2002 (411 North Keystone Avenue) after the sign was posted late due to COVID-19 quarantine, with staff not opposed. - Granted a continuance for 2020 UV2009 (10131 East Thompson Road) to March 9, 2021, without additional notice, after the petitioner stated that final documents were still being prepared. This was the seventh continuance, and staff indicated no further continuances would be supported. - Granted a staff-requested continuance for 2020 DV2051 (432 Forest Avenue) to March 9, 2021, with additional notice, to allow the petitioner to verify if the petition is still needed. - Granted a continuance for 2019 UV1-009 (2629 West Walnut Street) to March 9, 2021, without additional notice, with staff noting this would be the final continuance they would support. - Acknowledged the withdrawal of 2020 DV3050 (5809 Bluff Road) as requested by the petitioner. Expedited Docket - The board voted to waive rules of procedure to approve all expedited petitions in a single vote. The following petitions were approved unanimously: - 2021 DV2001 (1823 Singleton Street) – variance for a single-family dwelling and detached garage with reduced setbacks. - 2021 DV2002 (411 North Keystone Avenue) – variance for reconstruction of steps, addition to a dwelling, and accessory building. - 2021 DV2003 (1012 Lexington Avenue) – variance for construction of an accessory garage with reduced side setback and open space. - 2020 UV2019 (3401 West 10th Street and 970 North Tibbs Avenue) – variance of use for reconstruction of a gasoline station and convenience store. - 2021 UV2001 (1808 East Washington Street) – variance of use for two dwelling units. Public Comments & Testimony - Corey Shonborn, a call-in user, inquired about the approved expedited petition for 411 North Keystone Avenue. He asked when construction would start; the board clarified that it does not control permitting timelines. No opposition was expressed. - Dalton Conway, a call-in user, stated he owned the house next door to 407/411 North Keystone but was not connected to the case being discussed. No further testimony. Discussion Items - 2020 DV3066 (325 Parkway Avenue) – Variance for Detached Garage - Petitioner Cindy Thrasher, on behalf of the owners, requested a variance to construct a 22' x 24' detached garage (528 sq. ft.) with storage above, which would reduce the lot's open space from 48% to 44% (60% required). The existing dwelling and a 374 sq. ft. garage already occupy the lot. The petitioner argued that the existing garage is too small to accommodate the owners' two vehicles (one oversized SUV) and that neighboring properties have similar or larger garages with less open space. She also provided a letter of support from the Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association. - Staff recommended denial, stating that the lot is already overdeveloped and that the need for a larger garage is a self-imposed hardship. Staff noted that the garage drawing showed only one overhead door, suggesting only one vehicle would be stored, but the petitioner clarified that was a drafting error. - Board member James Duke commented that the owners' choice to own an oversized vehicle is a self-imposed hardship and does not justify the variance. - The board voted to separate the request: Part A (legal establishment of the existing single-family dwelling) was approved unanimously (5-0). Part B (construction of the detached garage) was denied (3-2, with Reuter, Kelly, and Young voting no, and Duke and Nelson voting yes). Key Outcomes - Votes on Special Requests: All motions passed unanimously. - Expedited Petitions: Approved by a single vote (5-0). - 2020 DV3066 Part A (Legal Establishment): Approved (5-0). - 2020 DV3066 Part B (Detached Garage): Denied (3-2). - Adoption of Negative Findings of Fact: - For 2020 DV1056 (denied on November 17, 2020) – adopted unanimously. - For 2020 UV2016 (denied on January 12, 2021) – adopted unanimously. - The meeting adjourned at 1:48 p.m.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 held a virtual public hearing on February 2, 2021, chaired by Joanna Taft. The board addressed several procedural motions, an expedited docket of six petitions, and three full hearing cases involving variances for residential and commercial properties. The meeting included testimony from petitioners, neighbors, and city officials. Votes were taken on all items. Procedural Actions - One-day waiver of legal notice granted for case 2021 UV101 (Chris McAllister, 7515 East 30th Street) due to a late sign posting. - Continuance granted for case 2020 UV1-018 (petitioner Skylar Sullivan) to March 2, 2021, despite opposition from Thompson Edgewood neighborhood representatives Greg Kittsmiller and Mark Bash, who objected to a third continuance. Staff opposed further continuances. The board voted 3-2 to continue with additional notice. - Withdrawal acknowledged for case 2021 UV1-002 (Michelle Goss, 8080 Bluff Road). - Expedited docket transfer for case 2021 DV1-002 (David Rutherford, 8815 Atlantis Drive and 3810 Post Road) after compromise with staff; approved. - Expedited docket transfer for case 2021 SE1-001 (Matthew Price, AT&T, 5401 West 71st Street); approved. - Withdrawal and fee transfer for case 2020 UV1-019 (2026 East 10th Street) to a new rezoning petition; acknowledged. - Continuance granted for case 2020 DV1-082 (32 North Catherwood Avenue) to March 2, 2021, for additional notice. Expedited Docket (Consent Calendar) The board approved all six expedited petitions en masse with no opposition: - 2020 DV3067 (326 Iowa Street) – variance for a second-story addition. - 2021 DV1001 (1515 Hoyt Avenue) – variance for a single-family dwelling. - 2021 UV1001 (7515 East 30th Street) – variance for firearms resale business. - 2021 UV1003 (712 North Illinois Street) – variance for shipping containers for ticket office, bar, and storage. - 2021 DV1002 (3810 Post Road) – multiple variances for outdoor display, sign, and landscaping. - 2021 SE1001 (5401 West 71st Street) – special exception for a wireless communications tower. Public Comments & Testimony Case 2020 DV1080 – 1238 Evison Street - Supporters: Neighbors Jessica Miller (Fountain Square Neighborhood Association board member), Philip Ramge, Madeline Moyer, and Holly Puckett spoke in favor, emphasizing the permitting error that left the Montgomery family unable to use their garage and driveway. Councilor Frank Muscari (District 21) also voiced support, calling it a half-million-dollar investment and a city mistake. - Remonstrators: Paul Djack Robinson and Jeff Morgan opposed, citing traffic safety, stormwater runoff, and the unsuitability of a front-loading garage. Written comments from Amy Morgan and Josh Martin were read into the record. Case 2020 DV1083 – 2437 South McClure Street - Petitioner: Richard Gray, a disabled veteran, testified that he installed a six-foot fence to protect himself from aggressive dogs owned by a neighbor, who he said built the fence improperly to retaliate. He could not afford to modify the fence. - Supporter: Jerry Sanford (2445 South McClure Street) confirmed stray dog problems and safety concerns. - Remonstrators: None. Case 2020 DV1077 – 1615 East 12th Street - Petitioner: Mark Crouch presented the petition, noting agreements with the Windsor Park Neighborhood Association to increase open space to 54% and make design concessions. - Public comments: None. Discussion Items Case 2020 DV1080 - Staff recommended denial but offered alternative commitments: fence height and location limits, and an encroachment license for the fence in the right-of-way. The board added a commitment prohibiting parking in the maneuvering area. Petitioner agreed to all conditions. Case 2020 DV1083 - Staff recommended denial or relocation of the fence to 11 feet from the right-of-way or reduction to four feet. Petitioner could not afford either option. The board voted on the original request without conditions. Case 2020 DV1077 - Staff recommended approval, noting the lot's unusual dimensions and the petitioner's concessions. Board approved without further discussion. Key Outcomes - Approvals: All six expedited petitions approved. Full hearing cases: 2020 DV1080 approved 5-0 with four commitments; 2020 DV1083 approved 3-2 as originally requested; 2020 DV1077 approved 5-0. - Continuances: Case 2020 UV1-018 continued to March 2, 2021; case 2020 DV1-082 continued for notice. - Withdrawals: Two cases withdrawn. - Waiver: One one-day legal notice waiver granted. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 3:56 PM.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened electronically on December 1, 2020 at 6:15 p.m. under COVID-19 guidelines, with Chairperson Johanna Taft presiding. The board addressed multiple administrative actions (withdrawals, continuances) and heard two full contested cases: a pylon sign variance for Bob Evans and a storage container variance. The meeting included remote participation via WebEx and telephone. Consent Calendar - The board acknowledged withdrawals of petitions 2020-DB1-057 (8632 Green Brave North Drive), 2020-UV1-014 (1010 Bursault Parkway), and 2020-UV1-017 (405 Lincoln Street) at the petitioners' requests. - An automatic continuance was granted for petition 2020-UV1-016 (1206, 1210, and 1222 English Avenue) to January 5, 2021, filed by a registered neighborhood organization. - Continuances were granted for 2020-DB1-039 (8403 Michigan Road), 2020-UV1-013, and 2020-UV1-018 (5650 Madison Avenue) to January 5, 2021, based on requests from petitioners or remonstrators. - The board voted unanimously to approve three expedited petitions in a single vote: 2020-DV1-073 (601 West Epler Avenue – pole barn with deficient setbacks), 2020-DV1-075 (1132 Hoyt Avenue – single family dwelling with reduced separation), and 2020-UV1-015 (1426 East Kelly Street – subdivision and open space variance). All petitioners affirmed they had read the staff report and agreed to conditions. Public Comments & Testimony - Greg Kitzmiller (telephone) identified himself as a remonstrator for petition 2020-UV1-018 (5650 Madison Avenue) and agreed to a continuance. - A second telephone caller identified as being present for petition 2020-DV1-009 (Bob Evans) but did not provide substantive testimony. - No public comments were submitted for the storage container case. Discussion Items Case 2020-DV1-009: Bob Evans Pylon Sign (amended petition) - Petitioner Sean Smith (representing Bob Evans) requested a variance to install a 40-foot tall, 148-square-foot pylon sign and a directional sign along Aronson Road, with a front setback variance (originally zero feet). Due to the expansion of North Keystone Avenue, the existing pylon sign had been removed and direct access was lost. Smith argued the signage was necessary for visibility and wayfinding, noting that the building is set back and obscured. He withdrew the setback request, agreeing to meet the required 5-foot setback. - Remonstrator Mark Mankfeld (attorney for Coast to Coast, the adjacent property owner to the south) opposed only the size of the pylon sign. He argued that the same-sized sign now occupies a much smaller visual space after the road widening, dominating the area and potentially spurring a sign competition among businesses. He suggested a sign compliant with the existing ordinance (lower square footage) would be sufficient for Bob Evans' brand. - Staff (Erica Hinshaw) recommended approval, noting the previous sign had identical height and area, the setback was now satisfied, and the petitioner had demonstrated a practical difficulty due to the road expansion. - Board questions focused on the temporary nature and the visual impact. Remonstrator emphasized the contracted visual space. Case 2020-UV1-012: Storage Container at 2727 Ketchum Street - Petitioner Justin Long (representing Metro Fibernet and AJJ Construction) requested a variance to allow outdoor storage containers within 500 feet of a protected district, where outdoor storage is not permitted and cannot exceed 25% of building size. He explained the container was temporary (1-2 years) to support fiber-optic construction projects in the area, and that the property had undergone significant renovation. He offered to add screening slats and noted the container was not visible from adjacent properties due to vegetation and an alley. - No remonstrators testified. - Staff recommended denial, citing the area's predominantly residential character per the comprehensive plan, the container's visibility above the fence adjacent to residential properties, and the fact that the container could be permitted as a permanent structure (requiring a foundation and building permit) without a variance. - Petitioner responded that a permanent foundation was not warranted for a temporary container, but acknowledged that if denied, they would pursue a building permit. - Board vote: all four members voted no, resulting in denial. Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions: Approved unanimously. - Withdrawals and continuances: Acknowledged and granted as listed above. - 2020-DV1-009 (Bob Evans pylon sign): Vote tie (2-2; Bohannon and Taft yes, McKay and Robinson no). Due to tie, the petition was automatically continued to the January 5, 2021 hearing without additional notice. - 2020-UV1-012 (Storage container): Denied (4-0). The board directed staff to prepare negative findings of fact in support of the denial; the petition will be continued for formal adoption of those findings.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on December 1, 2020, at 17:45, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen. The board considered multiple petitions, including continuances, withdrawals, and expedited cases, all resulting in unanimous approvals. The meeting also honored long-serving recorder Ron Hampton. Continuances, Withdrawals, and Docket Management - 2019 DB 3004 (8602–9010 Southeastern Ave): Attorney David Rutherford requested a continuance to the January 21, 2021 hearing to finalize technical issues with staff. No remonstrance. Staff had no objection. Granted without additional notice. - 2019 DB 1-036 (8185 & 8195 Sycamore Rd, 321 E 82nd St): Attorney Joe Calderon requested placement on the expedited docket with commitments, supported by neighbor’s attorney Greg Zubek. Staff no objection. Motion to move to expedited docket approved. - 2019 DB 3-038 (9600 Southeastern Ave): Petitioner requested withdrawal and a partial refund of $442.25 for unexpended expenses. Staff recommended the refund. Withdrawal acknowledged and refund approved. - 2019 UV3-015 (7969 Castlewell St): Staff requested a continuance to January 21, 2021, with additional notice due to site plan updates. No public objection. Granted for cause. Consent Calendar (Expedited Cases) - 2019 MO3003 (7837 Morningside Ln): Modification to replace a 10-ft transportation easement with a 5-ft shared-use path and 5-ft landscape buffer. Supported by Town of Williams Creek and Nora North Side Community Council. Staff no objection. Unanimously approved (5-0). - 2019 MO3004 (720 Eskenazi Ave): Extended deadline for temporary banner removal from Dec 31, 2019 to April 30, 2020, due to cold weather adhesive issues. Staff no objection. Unanimously approved (5-0). - 2019 DB 3039 (7020 Copeland Rd): Variance to split a 5-acre parcel into two lots (2.03 and 2.35 acres) with reduced lot width (238 ft vs. 250 ft required). Soil tests approved by Marion County Health Dept. Staff recommended approval. Unanimously approved (5-0). - 2019 UV 1025 (9345 Waldemar Rd – Northern Tool): Variance to allow trailer sales in C4 zone. Pike Township Residents Association supported subject to a fencing commitment. Staff supported. Unanimously approved (5-0). - 2019 UV 3014 (5745 E 71st St – Thompson Thrift): Variance for a fitness facility and drive-thru on a public street facade. Supported by Greater Allisonville Community Coalition (GAC) and Binford Redevelopment Group (BRAG). Staff approved with commitment to December 12, 2019 site plan. Unanimously approved (5-0). Discussion Items - 2019 DB 1036 (8185/8195 Sycamore Rd, 321 E 82nd St): Variance for a 5-ft fence and masonry wall in front yard, and retaining wall exceeding height limits. After amendments to lower fence height and add landscaping, petitioner earned support from Nora Northside Community Council and staff. Neighbor’s attorney (Greg Zubek) requested a 10-day review period for final plans to ensure screening from the wall. Petitioner agreed. Staff supported with amended commitments. Unanimously approved (5-0). Key Outcomes - All five expedited variances and modifications were approved unanimously (5-0). - Two continuances (one without additional notice, one with) and one withdrawal with partial refund were granted. - The board adjourned after recognizing Ron Hampton for decades of service as recorder for the BZA and Historic Preservation Commission. Adjournment The meeting adjourned after—no further business.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on November 24, 2020, beginning at 1:00 PM and concluding at approximately 6:50 PM. The meeting was conducted electronically due to COVID-19. The docket included a consent calendar of six expedited petitions, four special requests, and full hearings on multiple variance petitions, including a group of eight small cell wireless facility cases (5G) filed by Verizon Wireless, a parking lot expansion at 1099 N Meridian Street, a parking variance for a Chipotle restaurant, and a variance of use for a single-family dwelling. The small cell petitions dominated the agenda, with extensive public testimony from neighborhood representatives opposing the installations. Consent Calendar The following expedited petitions were approved unanimously (5-0) in a single vote after staff recommendations and no public opposition: - 2020-DV3-056: Variance for a 13-foot west side setback for a building addition at 4037 Guion Lane. - 2020-DV3-057: Variance to create three lots with reduced setbacks at 11806 Indian Creek Road South (with a one-day notice waiver granted earlier). - 2020-DV3-060 (Amended): Variance for a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space at 1221 Spann Avenue. - 2020-DV3-061: Variance for a front porch roof reducing open space to 50% at 1902 Charles Street. - 2020-DV3-048 (Amended): Variance for a single-family dwelling with reduced setback and separation at 1325 East Ohio Street (moved to expedited from full hearing). - 2020-AP3-001: Waiver of the refiling rule to allow a new variance petition for a site-built home at 1440 Kappes Street (previously denied for a manufactured home). Public Comments & Testimony Over a dozen residents spoke in opposition to the Verizon 5G small cell petitions across multiple cases. Key speakers and positions included: - Susan Blair (President, Pike Township Residents Association – PTRA): Opposed all 5G towers in Pike Township residential areas, citing reduced property values, unattractive poles, and the existence of the underground utility ordinance. She noted that similar towers in Hamilton County are more aesthetically pleasing with equipment in ground-level receptacles. - Barbara Caldwell (816 Hoover Lane): Opposed the tower at 8033 Hoover Lane, noting that two other 5G towers have already been installed within three blocks, creating a concentration. - Catherine Watson (8204 Claridge Road): Opposed towers in Meridian Woods, which has no above-ground utilities. She argued that Verizon should have designed the network considering the underground ordinance. - Michael Hart (921 Roundtable Court): Opposed a tower proposed 50 feet from his front door, citing nuisance, property value impact, and lack of overhead utilities. He presented a petition with 53 signatures from neighbors. - Pamela White (8215 Claridge Road): Opposed the tower in her front yard, stressing the aesthetic value of underground utilities and the potential floodgate for other carriers. - Melanie Grascie (5006 Pike Creek Boulevard): Opposed the tower near her home, stating it would be a distraction and that similar towers in Carmel are less intrusive. She questioned who would remove towers after obsolescence. - Joy Frank (Liberty Creek North HOA): Opposed towers at four-way intersections on Terrytown Parkway and Pillory Drive due to safety and aesthetics. - Kyle Hunter (5638 Revolutionary Drive): Opposed a tower across from his home, citing a National Association of Realtors study showing up to 45% reduction in property value from overhead utilities. He also raised health concerns. - Eric White (President, North Willow Farms HOA): Presented a detailed slide show showing actual installed towers in his neighborhood, including equipment attached to poles, lights shining into homes, and a tower placed at the end of a driveway. He noted 340 of 393 homeowners support opposition, and that the city’s new variance process was announced after many towers were already permitted. - Jacob Lawrence (Attorney for North Willow Farms HOA): Argued that Verizon failed to show a significant coverage gap or least intrusive means, and that the towers constitute a nuisance. He emphasized that wireless providers are not regulated utilities in Indiana. For the Chipotle parking variance, there were no public opponents. Discussion Items - 2020-UV3-010 (1099 N Meridian Street – Surface Parking Lot Expansion): Petitioner sought to reconfigure an existing parking lot to add 22 spaces (total 89) within the same footprint, arguing the one-size-fits-all parking standard for CBD-2 zoning does not suit the suburban-style office building. Staff opposed, citing the Regional Center prohibition on surface parking lots along Pennsylvania Street, the availability of over 1,000 off-site spaces (even after interstate construction reduces to 700), a net loss of 9 handicapped spaces, and removal of 9 mature trees. The board denied the petition 2-3. - Verizon 5G Small Cell Petitions (2020-DV3-029, 030, 031, 032, 034): Eight petitions initially on the docket; several sites were withdrawn prior to the hearing. Petitioners, represented by Russell Brown, argued that the technology cannot be placed underground, that the right-of-way use is permitted by state and federal law, and that denial would materially inhibit 5G deployment. Staff recommended denial for most sites on local/collector streets, but supported three sites on arterial roads (Lafayette Road and West 62nd Street) if poles were black metal with internal cabling. Board members questioned Verizon’s status as a regulated utility, the lack of market studies, and the aesthetic differences from poles installed in Hamilton County. After extensive testimony, the board: - Denied 2020-DV3-029 (all sites) 0-5. - Approved 2020-DV3-030 Part A (three sites on Lafayette Road and West 62nd Street) 5-0, with conditions for black metal poles and equipment; denied Part B (remaining sites) 0-5. - Denied 2020-DV3-031 (all sites) 1-4. - Approved 2020-DV3-032 Part A (same three arterial sites) 5-0; denied Part B 0-5. - Denied 2020-DV3-034 (all sites) 0-4. The remaining 5G petitions (2020-DV3-035, 036, 038, 039, and 2020-UV3-011) were continued without additional notice to the December 15, 2020 hearing, to be heard after the consent calendar. - 2020-DV3-058 (8651 S Emerson Avenue – Chipotle Parking): Petitioner sought 31 parking spaces (max 25 allowed) for a fast-food restaurant with drive-through. They argued the efficient building and outdoor seating create a need for more spaces, and that the location lacks sidewalks and transit options. Staff opposed, citing the ordinance’s intent to reduce paving and promote alternative transportation. The board approved 3-1. - 2020-UV3-012 (1113 W 18th Street – Single-Family Dwelling): Petitioner requested a variance of use to build a single-family home on commercially zoned land, with a commitment to rezone to residential (D-5) within 90 days. Staff recommended approval with that condition. The board approved 4-0. Key Outcomes - 2020-UV3-010 (Parking lot expansion): Denied (2-3). Continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2020-DV3-029 (Verizon small cells – Pike/Washington): Denied (0-5). - 2020-DV3-030 Part A (3 sites): Approved (5-0) with conditions (black metal poles, internal cabling). Part B: Denied (0-5). - 2020-DV3-031 (Verizon small cells – Washington Twp): Denied (1-4). - 2020-DV3-032 Part A (3 sites): Approved (5-0) with conditions. Part B: Denied (0-5). - 2020-DV3-034 (Verizon small cells – Pike/Washington): Denied (0-4). - Remaining 5G petitions (2020-DV3-035, 036, 038, 039, UV3-011): Continued to December 15, 2020, to be heard after the consent calendar. - 2020-UV3-012 (Single-family dwelling): Approved (4-0) with condition to rezone within 90 days. - 2020-DV3-058 (Chipotle parking): Approved (3-1). - 2020-DV3-022 (4902 Broadway Street): Dismissed as original variance no longer needed. - 2020-DV3-059 (5430 W 86th Street): Continued to December 15 with new notice. - 2020-UV3-013 (3711 N Washington Boulevard): Automatically continued to December 15. - 2020-DV3-052 (9200 Keystone Crossing): Automatically continued to December 15. All expedited petitions were approved unanimously. The board adjourned at approximately 6:50 PM.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, held a public hearing on November 17, 2020, via electronic meeting due to COVID-19. Chairperson Mark Young presided. The board addressed expedited petitions, a full hearing on a small cell facility variance, and a continuance. All votes were conducted by roll call. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions (single vote): The board waived rules of procedure to vote on all expedited petitions together. The following were approved unanimously (5-0): - 2020 DV3051 – 8900 Keystone Crossing: Variance for a 35‑foot tall pylon sign (25‑ft allowed), subject to a commitment that no panel be used for “for lease” or “for rent” advertising. - 2020 DV2055 – 1234 Fletcher Avenue: Variance for a garage addition to an existing single‑family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space. - 2020 DV3054 – 241 East Brunswick Avenue: Continued to December 8, 2020, without additional notice, as no petitioner appeared. Public Comments & Testimony No public comments were submitted or presented during the meeting. Discussion Items - 2020 GV1056 (amended) – 5118 Mason Drive and 4175 West 52nd Street: Petitioner Russell Brown (attorney) requested a variance of development standards for a small cell facility. Testimony included discussion of 5G technology benefits and market share. Remonstrators raised concerns about aesthetics, property values, and public health. After testimony, board members questioned the petitioner about the percentage of users served and alternative locations. Key Outcomes - 2020 GV1056 Denied: Vote 1‑4 (Nelson yes; Ruder, Kelly, McKay, Young no). The petition was denied, and the board will adopt negative findings of fact at a later date. - Expedited Petitions Approved: All expedited petitions (including 2020 DV3051 and 2020 DV2055) were approved in a single 5‑0 vote. - Continuance Granted: 2020 DV3054 continued to December 8, 2020, without additional notice. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned after all business concluded.
The Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, held a virtual public hearing on November 10, 2020, due to COVID-19 executive orders. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Roger Bohannon and Beth Brandon also participating. The board heard a request to expedite a case, approved five expedited petitions, granted several continuances and transfers, denied a controversial variance for a Racetrack fueling station/convenience market, and approved a waiver of the refiling rule. Expedited Docket - The board voted unanimously (3-0) to consider all expedited petitions in a single vote. No one requested removal from the expedited docket. - Approved petitions include: - 2020 DB1064 – 5450 Washington Boulevard: attached garage with 1-foot rear setback (20-foot required). - 2020 DB1066 – 901 & 907 South Randolph Street: single-family dwelling with detached garage within clear site triangle; 6-foot separation between dwellings (10-foot required). - 2020 DB1067 – 1133 South Keeling Street: expansion of single-family dwelling with 11-foot front setback and 6 feet between dwellings (18-foot/average and 10-foot required). - 2020 DB1068 – 1225 Hoyt Avenue: legalize existing dwelling with zero-foot front setback/overhang in right-of-way, 1-foot west side setback, 2.5 and 5.5 feet between dwellings, and detached garage with 46% open space (18-foot/average setback, 10-foot separation, 60% open space required). - 2020 DB1069 – 412 East 28th Street: single-family dwelling with attached garage, 10-foot front setback, 8-foot rear setback, 47% open space, and encroachment in clear site triangle (18-foot/average front setback, 20-foot rear setback, 60% open space required). Continuances and Transfers - 2020 UV1-013 (Pat Croney): Continued to December 1, 2020, without additional notice. Later, Carl Marshall indicated he wished to object after the vote; the board declined to reconsider because the petitioner had left. - 2020 UV1-011 (Lakeisha Jackson request): Moved up on the docket due to number of community speakers. - 2020 DV1039 (David King): Continued to December 1, 2020, with the understanding that petitioner may withdraw or provide new notice if needed. - 2020 DV1056 (Russell Brown): Transferred to Division 2 hearing on November 17, 2020. - 2020 UV1-014 (Sharman Fry): Continued to December 1, 2020. - 2020 UV1-010 (per staff; transcript shows 2020 UV 310/UB3010) (Joe Calderan): Continued and transferred to Board 3 on November 24, 2020. - 2020 DV1009 (Mark Mayfield, remonstrator): Continued to December 1, 2020, with staff requesting it be the final continuance. - The final remaining petition (Tech Center LLC, Justin Long): Continued to December 1, 2020. Public Comments & Testimony (for 2020 UV1011) - Russell Brown (petitioner attorney) presented case for Racetrack; John Jansen (Racetrack) also sworn. - Remonstrators: - Sharia Caldwell (Far Eastside resident, Cafe Community Lights) opposed, citing existing gas stations, schools, crime, low-wage jobs. - Lila Darden (Far East Community Council president) opposed, noting Far East Side has as many gas stations as Carmel and Fishers combined; preferred grocery store/coffee shop. - Samantha Douglas (Far East Side resident and council leader) opposed, citing health, pollution, predatory pricing. - Jamie Bell (Carry and Place Church, adjacent corner) opposed, concerned about alcohol sales, crime, food desert. - Michael Howe (CEO, Far East Side Community Center) opposed, citing truck traffic and existing plans for corridor. - Councilor Lakeisha Jackson (District 14) opposed, highlighting redevelopment plans, community unity, and that the area is food desert; she stated she lives within a mile. - Written remonstrance from state senator Robin Shackelford and others; Tanya Johnson submitted opposition without speaking. - Staff stated no recommendation on use variance due to ambiguity in ordinance definition of accessory use; supported development standard variance with conditions (20-foot landscape yards and sidewalk along Post Road and 30th Street). Discussion Items - 2020 UV1011: Racetrack requested a use variance for a convenience market (with on-site food prep) and development variance for reduced setbacks at 3049 North Post Road. Petitioner argued auto fueling station is permitted by right; variance needed only for 6% of building for food prep; diesel canopy needed for industrial users. Remonstrators opposed, citing ample gas stations, crime, schools, and incompatibility with community needs. Board denied the petition 3-0 after deliberation. - 2020 AP1001: Request to waive 12-month refiling rule for a variance petition related to garage access at 1238 Evan Street. Peter Logan presented that the original driveway/garage orientation was an error; new plan moves access to alley, eliminating curb cut. Staff supported waiver as substantially different. Board approved unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Expedited petitions (5) approved unanimously. - 2020 UV1011 denied (3-0); findings of fact to be adopted later. - 2020 AP1001 approved (3-0). - Multiple continuances and transfers granted as listed above. - Chairperson Taft had a hard stop at 2:55, leading to the final case being continued.