The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division One held a public hearing on October 27, 2020, at approximately 6:15 PM. The meeting was conducted electronically due to COVID-19 restrictions. Key actions included approvals of expedited petitions, decisions on multiple Verizon 5G small cell variance requests, and rulings on use and development variances for commercial properties. Consent Calendar - Granted one-day mailing notice waivers for petitions 2020 DB1-058, 059, 061, 062, 060, 2019 UV1-009, and 2020 UV1-010. - Approved continuation and transfer of 2019 UV1-009 (2629 West Walnut Street) to the December 8, 2020 hearing of Board Two. - Moved 2020 DB1-060 (1513 Churchman Avenue) to the expedited docket with staff recommendation for approval. - Acknowledged automatic continuance of 2020 DV1-057 (8632 Green Braith North Drive) to December 1, 2020. - Granted a three-day mailing notice waiver for 2020 UV101 (3049 North Post Road). - Granted a notarization waiver for 2020 DB1-059 due to applicant being out of the country. - Approved withdrawals of multiple addresses from petitions 2020 DV1-054, 2020 DV1-056, and others. - Modified presentation time for attorney Russell Brown to a 20-minute overview and 5 minutes per petition for two Verizon cases. - Approved a waiver of rules of procedure to vote on all expedited petitions in a single roll call vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Laura Troop (remonstrator, 2020 DV1054B): Expressed support for 5G technology but requested neighborhood input on placement and aesthetics. Concerned about above-ground poles in a 1990s subdivision with underground utilities. - Jessica Darling (written, via QA): Vice President of Falcon Square Alliance. Expressed concern that neighborhood associations did not receive variance paperwork, that proposed locations did not meet city standards, and noted property damage during previous 5G deployment by contractors. Stated support for 5G but opposition to multiple poles. - Adrian Fowler (remonstrator, 2020 UV1010): Raised concerns about potential flooding from increased runoff due to new construction, and about noise from large trucks entering/exiting the site. - John Anderson (remonstrator, 2020 UV1010): Requested a fence and/or pine tree border on the western boundary to shield his property from visibility of equipment and protect resale value. - Sarah Schwomer (staff liaison, reading on behalf of Councilor Jackson, 2020 UV1011): Councilor Jackson opposed the proposed gas station and convenience market due to proximity to a school, existing gas stations in the area, potential alcohol sales leading to crime, and the need for healthier food options in a food desert community. - Written remonstrance letters from Councilor Jackson and others were also entered into the record. Discussion Items - Verizon 5G Small Cell Petitions (2020 DV1054B, 2020 DV1056): Attorney Russell Brown presented the need for 5G technology, described the technical requirements, and argued that variances are necessary due to the underground utilities ordinance and the lack of suitable locations along arterial roads. Staff recommended approval of one location (McFarland Court) but denial of others on local streets, citing negative impact on neighborhoods. Remonstrators raised concerns about aesthetics and property values. For 2020 DV1054B, the board split the vote, approving the McFarland site (3-1) and the remaining four sites with the condition of black metal poles (3-1). For 2020 DV1056, the board deadlocked 2-2, resulting in automatic continuance to November 10, 2020. - 2020 UV1010 (Allini Drill Foundations, 3930 South Post Road): Petitioner sought a use variance for a heavy commercial contractor facility and a development variance for a gravel driveway/parking area. Staff recommended denial due to incompatibility with the area, intensity of use, and concerns about dust and gravel. Remonstrators expressed flooding and noise concerns. The board approved the petition (4-0) with commitments to submit an amended site plan showing fencing along south, west, and north sides, and to adhere to the plan of operation. - 2020 UV1011 (Racetrack, 3049 North Post Road): Petitioner requested a use variance to operate a convenience market as part of an automobile fueling station (with food preparation/reheating) and a development variance for reduced setbacks. Staff had no recommendation on the use variance due to interpretation questions about whether prepared food is allowed under an auto fueling station definition, but recommended approval of the development variance with a 20-foot landscape yard condition. Councilor Jackson and others opposed. The board voted 2-1 (Robinson no, Brandon yes, Bohannon yes), resulting in a indecisive vote and automatic continuance to November 10, 2020. Key Outcomes - 2020 DV1054B (Verizon): Approved. McFarland Court site approved 3-1 (wood pole); remaining four sites (Oak Drive, Stop 10 Road, Todd Road, Remington Drive) approved 3-1 with condition of black metal poles and internal cabling. - 2020 DV1056 (Verizon): Continued to November 10, 2020 due to a 2-2 tie vote (Bohannon no, Robinson yes, Brandon no, Taft yes). - 2020 UV1010 (Allini Drill Foundations): Approved 4-0 with commitments: (1) plan of operation as submitted, (2) amended site plan showing fence along south, west, and north sides. - 2020 UV1011 (Racetrack): Continued to November 10, 2020 due to a 2-1 indecisive vote (Robinson no, Brandon yes, Bohannon yes). - Expedited Petitions: All 2020 GV1-058, DV1-061, DV1-062, DV1-063, and DV1-060 (amended) approved by roll call (unanimous).
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III met on October 20, 2020, at 1:00 PM via WebEx, under COVID-19 guidelines. The agenda included numerous variance petitions, primarily from Verizon Wireless for small cell wireless communications facilities, as well as several other development and use variance requests. The meeting saw multiple withdrawals, continuances, and one expedited approval. Public testimony highlighted concerns about the impact of small cell poles on residential neighborhoods and opposition to transferring cases to other BZA divisions. Public Comments & Testimony - Susan Blair (President, Pike Township Residence Association) opposed transfers of Verizon cases to other boards, stating no justification, but did not object to continuances within Division III. - Eric White (President, North Willow Farms HOA) requested that cases proceed as scheduled or be continued to the board's next hearing, citing the expense and effort of preparation. - Katherine Watson (resident at 8204 Claridge Road) opposed continuances, arguing the neighborhood had made its position clear and no new information justified delay. - Miles Groot (VP, Meridian Woods HOA) seconded Watson's objections to continuances. - Anthony Burke (Secretary, North Side Community Council) reluctantly agreed to continuances but strongly opposed transfers, calling them "unacceptable." - Kyle Hunter (resident at 5638 Revolutionary Drive) opposed continuances due to the burden of taking time off work and the lack of valid reasons beyond counsel's absence. - Rusty Reed (resident at 5769 Wildwood Avenue) opposed continuance and transfer for case 2020-DV3-035, noting the proposed pole was in his front yard. - Emma Clust (Meridian-Kessler Land Use Committee chair) opposed transfer but not continuance for case 2020-DV3-035. - Sarah Crosby (attorney for Bire Sale Neighborhoods Association) objected to both continuance and transfer, asking the panel to hear the case that day. - Lisa Herber (resident at 551 Westfield Boulevard) opposed the continuance for case 2020-DV3-036. Discussion Items - Withdrawals of Verizon Petitions: Prior to regular business, petitioner Matt Bates (Verizon Wireless) withdrew seven petitions (2020-DV3-040 through 2020-DV3-047) without objection from the board. - Continuances and Transfers: The board considered requests from Verizon to continue and transfer multiple small cell facility cases to other divisions. Staff recommended against transfers, noting preparedness. After extensive public comment opposing transfers, the board voted to continue most cases to its next regular hearing on November 24, 2020, without transfer. Specific cases continued included 2020-DV3-029, 2020-DV3-030, 2020-DV3-031, 2020-DV3-032, 2020-DV3-034, 2020-DV3-035, 2020-DV3-036, 2020-DV3-038, 2020-DV3-039, and 2020-DV3-022. A few cases were transferred to other boards: 2020-DV3-051 to November 17 (Division 2), 2020-DV3-049 and 2020-DV3-050 to November 17, 2020-DV3-054 to November 17, and 2020-UV3-010 to November 10 (Division 1). - Expedited Petitions: Three petitions were approved as a block: 2020-DV3-053 (var. front setback, Meridian Hills), 2020-DV3-055 (var. silo height, Pike Township), and 2020-UV3-008 (var. use for online retail vehicle sales). The board voted unanimously to adopt findings of fact for all three. - Case 2020-DV3-042 (Amended): Initially scheduled for continuation, the single remaining location at 3109 East 38th Street was moved to the expedited docket after petitioner agreement. Staff recommended approval with a condition that the pole be black metal and all equipment painted black. Petitioner Matt Bates agreed, and the board approved the variance unanimously. Key Outcomes - Withdrawals Granted: Petitions 2020-DV3-040 through 2020-DV3-047 withdrawn. - Continuances Without Transfer (to November 24, 2020): 2020-DV3-029, 2020-DV3-030, 2020-DV3-031, 2020-DV3-032, 2020-DV3-034, 2020-DV3-035, 2020-DV3-036, 2020-DV3-038, 2020-DV3-039, and 2020-DV3-022. - Transfers to Other Boards: 2020-DV3-051 (to Division 2, Nov 17), 2020-DV3-049 (to Nov 17), 2020-DV3-050 (to Nov 17), 2020-DV3-054 (to Nov 17), 2020-UV3-010 (to Division 1, Nov 10). - Expedited Approvals: 2020-DV3-053, 2020-DV3-055, and 2020-UV3-008 approved unanimously. - Approval with Condition: 2020-DV3-042 (remaining location at 3109 East 38th Street) approved subject to a black metal pole and black equipment. - Automatic Continuances Acknowledged: 2020-DV3-048 (1325 East Ohio Street) and 2020-DV3-052 (9200 Keystone Crossing) continued to November 24, 2020, by neighborhood organization request.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 met electronically on October 13, 2020, at approximately 2:00 p.m., adjourning at 2:04 p.m. The board handled several continuances, withdrawals, a two-day waiver, five expedited petitions, and three full hearings. Votes were taken by roll call. Consent Calendar - Two‑Day Waiver (2020‑DV2‑041) – Approved unanimously (5‑0) for 8221 Sergeant Road. - Expedited Petitions (single vote) – The board approved five petitions en bloc after waiving rules of procedure (vote 5‑0): 2020‑DV2‑040 (933 Olive St), 2020‑DV2‑043 (11315 E Washington St), 2020‑DV2‑046 (514 Spruce St), 2020‑DV2‑047 (531 S Capitol Ave), and 2020‑UV2‑015 (940 S Meridian St, with added commitments). Public Comments & Testimony - Paula Brooks – Spoke during the withdrawal of 2020‑UV2‑013 (2450 & 2458 Arsenal Ave) to confirm the entire petition (use variance and development standards) was being withdrawn. The withdrawal was acknowledged by the board. - No other public testimony was offered on the full‑hearing cases; all attendees either were petitioners or representatives. Discussion Items - 2020‑DV2‑041 (8221 Sergeant Road) – Petitioner Jeff Grummer accepted staff’s amended recommendation (detached garage in front yard with a reduced front setback, but withdrawing the request for a 5‑foot side setback). Staff recommended approval. The board approved unanimously (5‑0). - 2020‑DV2‑044 (2451 North Park Avenue) – Petitioner Joshua Fendler sought a variance to allow a 912‑sq‑ft secondary dwelling (carriage house) above a three‑car garage; the ordinance caps secondary dwellings at 720 sq ft. Staff recommended denial, citing lack of practical difficulty and noting the property is a double lot. After a 3‑2 vote (Duke, Nelson, Young in favor; Reuter, Kelly opposed), the variance was approved. - 2020‑DV2‑048 (5526 Bracken Circle) – Petitioners William Forey and Chloe Whitfield (represented by Cindy Thrasher and Ron Chzinski) requested a zero‑foot side setback and reduced combined side setback for a kitchen/living room addition. Staff recommended denial, arguing the addition could be placed at the rear to meet setbacks. The board voted 4‑1 (Reuter opposed, Kelly, Duke, Nelson, Young in favor) to approve. The property owner confirmed the HOA easement was for pond access, not utility. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted (unanimous): - 2020‑UV2‑009 (10131 E Thompson Rd) – continued to November 17, 2020, without additional notice. - 2020‑DV2‑042 (8554 Springview Dr) – continued to November 17, 2020, without additional notice (petitioner family emergency). - 2020‑DV2‑045 (7020 N Pennsylvania St) – continued to November 17, 2020, with additional notice to amend petition for a secondary dwelling. - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2020‑UV2‑013 (2450 & 2458 Arsenal Ave) was withdrawn by the petitioner, with plans to file new rezoning and variance petitions. - Findings of fact adopted for the three approved full‑hearing cases (2020‑DV2‑041, 2020‑DV2‑044, 2020‑DV2‑048) after a motion and vote (board members who voted against a case did not participate in adopting its findings).
This public hearing, conducted electronically under COVID-19 executive orders, addressed numerous zoning variance petitions, primarily for Verizon Wireless 5G small cell facilities. The three-member board (Chair Joanna Taft, Rob Bohan, and Robinson) heard public testimony, received staff recommendations, and voted on each case. Several petitions were automatically continued, and the board split votes on multiple small cell sites, resulting in automatic continuances to the October 27, 2020 meeting. Consent Calendar - Automatic continuances were acknowledged for the following petitions to the October 27, 2020 hearing: 2020-db3-04A, 2020 DB1-050, 2020-dv1-051, 2020-db1-052, 2020-db1-053, 2020 DB1055, 2020 DV1056. - Continuances to November 10, 2020 were granted for 2020 DB1039 (third continuance, staff noted no further continuances would be supported) and 2020 DB109 (at remonstrator's request). - A continuance request for 2020 DV1049 on behalf of remonstrators was denied after petitioner objected due to the 90-day federal shot clock; legal counsel advised against the continuance. Public Comments & Testimony - Monica Mueller (1129 N. Oxford St.) opposed the 5G poles on her street, citing visual blight, placement in the middle of lots, and potential harm to property values. She urged poles be placed in alleys or on property lines with decorative designs. - Joshua Dubach (1017 E. Michigan St.) objected to a pole proposed within his property boundaries and requested it be moved to the corner or alley. - Robert Deagle (1129 N. Oxford St.) deferred to emailed comments emphasizing aesthetics, tree protection, and requiring companies to share poles. - Marilyn Ray (3316/3314 Robson St.) stated the pole would be in her front yard, less than 10 feet from her porch, and opposed it. - Gary Moody (41 N. Keeling Ave., president of Ropes and Voorhees Neighbors Association) criticized Verizon's approach, noting the pole would be near a vacant lot and that the neighborhood submitted a resolution opposing the site. - Kelly Elmore (representing Park Place Property Owners Association) argued the 47-foot pole at 6627 Carolina Blvd. would be an eyesore in a well-landscaped area and could be relocated. - Harvey Warner (135 E. Brunswick Ave.) cited flooding risks, poor drainage, and heavy school traffic at the proposed locations on Brunswick Ave. - Steve Gentry (215 E. Brunswick Ave., Southern Hills HOA) found it incredible that two poles were proposed 100 feet apart and argued they could be moved to nearby commercial areas. - Brad Lockard (Beechwood Lane) asked that the pole be moved to an existing utility pole across the street, as allowed by state law. - Michelle Troxel (6563 High View Dr.) noted no overhead utilities exist on her street and questioned why a pole was suddenly proposed on the frontage. - Donald Lathrop (6824 Glacier Dr.) raised concerns about property reassessment, safety if the pole fell, and the possibility of multiple carriers adding poles. - Jody Beach (180 E. Vinoy Dr.) argued that 5G would not benefit older residents, that poles should be placed on existing utility easements, and that no power or fiber lines exist at the proposed site. - Savannah Loftus (attorney for Richmond Hill Community Association) opposed the pole at 8341 Field Fairway, citing HOA covenants, aesthetics, and the neighborhood's recent recovery from a 2012 explosion. - Attorney Corey Baldwin (Roach Associates) disputed Verizon's property value arguments and called the company's proprietary approach a "cop out." - Doug Aldridge (19-year Richmond Hill resident) said the subdivision has been rebuilding after the explosion and cannot afford further devaluation. - Helen Upton (19-year resident) echoed concerns about property values and aesthetics. - Kyle Squillis (1721 Southview Dr.) asked that poles be placed on commercial zones like Madison Avenue, not in front of homes. - Beverly Stout (for Frank and Mary Alice Kapler) asked about the exact location of the pole at 2301 Brewer Dr. and whether it would affect the backyard. - Written and QA comments from numerous residents (Bob Wheedy, Rob Deagle, Leah Burns, Bill Weymeyer, Kathy Waycox, Mike Eccles, Richard Fitzgerald, Libby Cruz, Nick Hunter, Ryan Konnecky, Christina Hunter, Heather Cranich, Matt Lennon) all opposed the poles, citing aesthetics, property values, health concerns, and lack of notification. Discussion Items 1. Expedited Petition 2020 DV1045 (11844 E. McGregor Rd.) - Request for a 25.58-foot tall pole barn (larger and taller than the principal dwelling). Staff recommended approval; petitioner agreed. The board voted unanimously to approve. 2. Special Request for Modified Presentation Time - Petitioner Russell Brown (Verizon Wireless) requested 20 minutes for an overview presentation on 5G technology and 5 minutes per case for three small cell petitions. Staff and legal counsel supported the request, with equal time for remonstrators. The board approved. 3. Small Cell Petitions (2020 DV1047, 1049, 1054) - Overview: Verizon Wireless (represented by Russell Brown) argued that the 5G small cell facilities are permitted by state law in rights-of-way, that federal law preempts local aesthetics requirements not in writing, and that the proposed poles would fill coverage gaps. He noted that 950+ small cells are already on air in Indianapolis. The company agreed to use black metal poles (except for mid-span wood poles required by IPL) and to house fiber/electric inside the poles. - Staff Position: Staff recommended approval for sites on arterial streets or alleys with black metal poles, and denial for sites on local streets near residences. Staff upheld the 1973 underground utility ordinance. - Federal Law Limitation: Legal counsel stated that the board cannot consider health effects of radiofrequency emissions per federal regulations. 4. Negative Findings of Fact (2020 DV1042) - The board adopted findings of fact for a previously denied petition, and also adopted findings for the approved expedited petition. Key Outcomes - 2020 DV1045 (Expedited): Approved unanimously (3-0). - 2020 DV1047: - Part A (5 sites with staff recommendation of approval): Vote 2-1 (Bohan no, Robinson yes, Taft yes) – indecisive, continued to Oct. 27. - Part B (5 sites with staff recommendation of denial): Vote 2-1 (Bohan no, Robinson yes, Taft yes) – indecisive, continued to Oct. 27. - 2020 DV1049: - Part A (436 E. Craigmont St.): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Part B (remaining 19 sites): Vote 2-1 (Bohan no, Robinson no, Taft yes) – indecisive, continued to Oct. 27. - 2020 DV1054: - Part A (7425 Madison Ave.): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Part B (remaining 14 sites): Vote 2-1 (Bohan no, Robinson no, Taft yes) – indecisive, continued to Oct. 27. - Negative Findings of Fact: Adopted for 2020 DV1042 and for the expedited petition. - All automatic continuances acknowledged. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 8:30 PM ET.
On September 23, 2020 (though the chairperson opened the meeting referencing September 22, creating a date discrepancy), the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 held a public hearing to consider two variance petitions from Verizon Wireless for small cell wireless communications facilities (5G poles). The board consisted of Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen and members Anatoly Boshenko and Mark Young (Valite absent). Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and multiple planning staff were present. The meeting was conducted electronically due to COVID-19 restrictions. Consent Calendar - The board acknowledged seven automatic continuances (petitions 2020-DB3-038 through 2020-DV3-047) to the next hearing date of October 20, 2020, filed by registered neighborhood organizations or a city-county counselor. Public Comments & Testimony - Kevin Malley (349 West 46th Street): Supported a neighbor's proposal to modify pole placement; urged more consideration of aesthetics and placement near existing utilities. - Jean Robertson (402 Buckingham Drive): Opposed the pole proposed in her front yard on Buckingham and Cornelius, citing reduced property values and health concerns. Requested the pole be placed on the Cornelius side rather than the front yard. - Lori Surrand (401 Buckingham Drive): Opposed the pole, arguing neighborhood beauty (Butler Tarkington) is the primary attraction, not 5G. Questioned why an existing streetlight could not be used or replaced. - Diane Hancock (327 Buckingham Drive): Opposed the pole 4 houses away; noted the area is not underserved and questioned future additional poles. Asked for assurances that more poles would not be needed. - Danielle Havens (237 West 46th Street): Disagreed with using existing wood poles as a design standard; argued Verizon should provide higher-quality installations regardless of existing infrastructure. Noted alley right-of-way behind many houses. - Rose Black (4061 Cornelius Avenue, submitted via text): Opposed placement diagonally from her house; requested pole be on existing electrical grid on 42nd and Cornelius if necessary. - Written comments from others: Danielle urged placing poles in business areas; Martha Riley asked about benefits to non-Verizon customers; Lisa Doby questioned why wireless is considered a utility; Bill Grout wondered why Carmel gets more aesthetic poles. Discussion Items - Procedural Change: The board approved a petitioner request (moved by Mr. Young, seconded by Mr. Boshenko) to modify the hearing format: the petitioner gave a 20-minute general overview of 5G technology, followed by 5 minutes per case, with equal time allotted to remonstrators. - Petitioner Presentation (Russell Brown, attorney): - Described 5G as the fifth generation of wireless technology, enabling faster speeds, lower latency, and supporting smart city, medical, and public safety applications. - Explained small cell facilities are necessary for dense network coverage; poles are typically placed in public rights-of-way and cannot be easily relocated without redesigning the network. - Argued that federal and state regulations limit local zoning reviews; the variance is needed because wireless equipment cannot be installed underground. - Proposed four pole types: wood poles, metal poles without lights, metal poles with lights, and mid-span poles (which become IPL property). - For case 2020 DV3033 (6 locations in Warren/Lawrence Townships), he detailed pole specifications and noted many locations are near above-ground utilities. - For case 2020 DV3037 (11 locations in Washington Township), he noted two mid-span poles (723 W 44th St and 245 W 40th St) must remain wood due to IPL requirements; agreed to paint other metal poles black. - Emphasized that denial would create a digital divide and underserved areas. - Staff Recommendations: - Allison Richardson: Recommended denial for both cases. Main reason: underground utilities have been required since 1973 and petitioner failed to prove practical difficulty. Noted that burying utilities improves safety, aesthetics, and property values. Suggested all metal poles be black if approved. - Robert Ulenhae: For case 2020 DV3037, noted the 723 W 44th St pole is at the rear and could be approved conditionally if black. Otherwise, recommended denial due to impact on residential neighborhoods and potential interference with tree planting on private property. Stated that existing above-ground poles are legally non-conforming and not a valid precedent. - Board Questions & Discussion: - Chairperson Von Dalen questioned whether Verizon is a utility or a luxury, citing billing practices. Brown argued that state/federal law grants right-of-way use and that internet access is now essential (e.g., remote schooling). - Boshenko asked about competition and whether other carriers will need their own poles; Brown confirmed they likely would. - Young asked about design differences between Indianapolis and Carmel; Brown noted Carmel has published aesthetic guidelines, while Indianapolis does not. Staff stated they are working on standards but currently recommend black poles. - Chairperson expressed disappointment that Indianapolis often gets lower-quality installations than suburbs; Brown agreed to black poles. - Brown clarified that pole heights are typically 10 feet higher than surrounding poles; typical utility poles range 35-55 feet. - Regarding co-location, Brown stated poles can structurally accommodate one additional carrier, but multiple carriers would require taller poles and more ground space. Key Outcomes - 2020 DV3033: Three votes cast (Boshenko: no, Young: no, Von Dalen: no). Denied. Continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2020 DV3037: Three votes cast (Boshenko: no, Young: no, Von Dalen: no). Denied. Continued for adoption of findings of fact. - The board did not approve any variances in this hearing. All new 5G small cell poles were rejected.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III held a public hearing on September 15, 2020, at 1:00 PM via WebEx, in compliance with COVID-19 executive orders. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided with board members Guevaya, Janice Golson Dunlap, and Anatoli Bashenko (four members present). The agenda included numerous variance petitions, primarily for small cell wireless facilities (5G) and residential development standards. The board handled continuances, withdrawals, and expedited approvals. Public Comments & Testimony - Kevin Malley (349 West 46th Street) requested that all interested parties be notified of the continuance of petition 2020-DV3-037 to September 22, 2020. - Jean Robertson (402 Buckingham Drive) agreed with the continuance but also requested notification of all interested parties. - No other public comments were made on other petitions. Special Requests & Continuances - Russell Brown (attorney for Verizon Wireless) requested a one-week continuance (to September 22, 2020) for petitions 2020-DV3-033 and 2020-DV3-037, to allow submission of revised findings of fact. The board granted the continuance without additional notice after hearing public comments. - Mark Crouch (petitioner for 2020-UV3-006, 941 Morgan Drive) requested the petition be moved to the expedited docket, agreeing to staff's condition of an eight-foot east side setback. Staff had no objection, and the board approved the expedited placement. - Joe Calderon (attorney for petitioner) withdrew petition 2020-UV3-003 (1718 Lafayette Road and 2438 West 17th Street) at the petitioner's request. The board acknowledged the withdrawal. - Automatic continuances were acknowledged for six Verizon Wireless small cell petitions (2020-DV3-029 through 2020-DV3-036, except 2020-DV3-033 and 2020-DV3-037 which were continued separately) filed by registered neighborhood organizations, continuing them to the October 20, 2020 hearing without additional notice. - 2020-DV3-022 (4902 Broadway Street) was continued to the October 20, 2020 hearing at the petitioner's request, without additional notice, to allow time to amend the petition and obtain permits. The board approved. Discussion Items - Expedited Petitions: Two petitions were heard on the expedited docket. - 2020-DV3-028 (322 North Highland Avenue): Variance to allow a detached garage accessory to a two-family dwelling with 51% open space (55% required). The petitioner confirmed agreement with the staff report and findings of fact. The board approved unanimously. - 2020-UV3-006 (941 Morgan Drive): Variance of use and development standards for a 336-square foot addition and a 1,680-square foot pole barn (height variance). Following staff's amended recommendation, the petitioner agreed to an eight-foot east side setback, and the petition was moved to expedited docket. The board approved the amended request unanimously. Key Outcomes - Approved Expedited Petitions: - 2020-DV3-028: Approved (4-0). - 2020-UV3-006 (as amended): Approved (4-0). - Continued to September 22, 2020 Hearing: - 2020-DV3-033 and 2020-DV3-037 (Verizon small cell petitions) – continued without additional notice. - Continued to October 20, 2020 Hearing: - 2020-DV3-022 (Broadway Street) – continued at petitioner's request. - 2020-DV3-029, 2020-DV3-030, 2020-DV3-031, 2020-DV3-032, 2020-DV3-034, 2020-DV3-035, 2020-DV3-036 (Verizon small cell petitions) – automatically continued by neighborhood organizations. - Withdrawn: - 2020-UV3-003 (Lafayette Road/17th Street – police station) – withdrawn by petitioner. - Next Steps: The board noted that the results of the hearing would be posted on the city's website, and the amended docket for the September 22, 2020 hearing would be updated online.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division One held a public hearing electronically on September 10, 2020, due to COVID-19. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided. The board considered several special requests, approved a consent agenda of expedited petitions, and conducted full hearings on two variance petitions. Consent Calendar (Special Requests and Expedited Petitions) - Waiver of sign placement for 2020 DV1043 (1453 Span Ave) granted unanimously. - Motion to move 2020 UV1-009 (1525 Prospect St) to the expedited docket granted unanimously. - Withdrawal of 2020 DV1-037 (4545 Kentucky Ave) acknowledged. - Continuance of 2020 DV1-039 (8403 Michigan Ave) to October 6, 2020, without additional notice, granted unanimously. - Continuance of 2020 DV1-045 (11844 E McGregor Rd) to October 6, 2020, with additional notice, granted unanimously. - Waiver for hearing sign posting and three-day mailed notice for 2020 UV1-007 (660 E 42nd St) granted unanimously. - Expedited petitions (2020 DV1036, DV1040, DV1041, DV1046, UV1007, UV1008, UV1009) were approved en masse by a single vote, with the board waiving rules of procedure. All passed 5-0. One petition (2020 DV1043) was initially removed due to a remonstrator but later returned to the expedited docket and approved. Public Comments & Testimony - 2020 DV1042 (8341 Bravestone Way): The petitioner, Christopher Isam, and homeowner Chase Belton testified in support of a six-foot privacy fence in a front yard. Remonstrator Jerry Means, representing the Woods at Liberty Park HOA, testified in opposition, citing HOA rules and zoning violations. Staff recommended denial. - 2020 DV1043 (1453 Span Ave): Initially a remonstrator (Erica, neighbor) objected, but after speaking with the petitioner, they reached an agreement and the remonstrator did not return. The petitioner Mark Crouch confirmed the agreement. - 2020 DV1044 (709 N Tremont St): No remonstrators. Petitioner Lester Carver and Pastor Ronald Covington testified in support of an addition to an existing dwelling, emphasizing the pastor's need for a first-floor master suite and community revitalization. Discussion Items - 2020 DV1042 (Bravestone Way): Staff recommended denial based on lack of practical difficulty, noting the fence could be modified to comply with height or moved to a different location. The board heard rebuttal from the petitioner. The board voted 4-1 to deny (McKay in favor, others opposed). - 2020 DV1043 (Span Ave): After the remonstrator left, staff recommended approval, noting that nine of 18 nearby dwellings have six-foot or less setbacks. The board approved unanimously. - 2020 DV1044 (Tremont St): Staff recommended denial due to large addition, insufficient open space, and unresolved separation distance. The petitioner verbally amended to reduce the garage by two feet to meet the 10-foot separation from the south dwelling. The board approved 5-0, subject to a revised site plan approved by staff. Key Outcomes - Denied: 2020 DV1042 (Bravestone Way fence) – 4-1 vote. - Approved (expedited): 2020 DV1036, DV1040, DV1041, DV1046, UV1007, UV1008, UV1009 – all 5-0. - Approved (full hearing): 2020 DV1043 (Span Ave) – 5-0. - Approved (full hearing, with condition): 2020 DV1044 (Tremont St) – 5-0, subject to revised site plan. - Adopted negative findings of fact for petition 2020 UV1-003 (3544 Carrollton Ave) from the previous month, as recommended by the board. The meeting adjourned after all business was completed.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two held a virtual public hearing on September 8, 2020, at 6:00 PM, chaired by Mark Young. The meeting addressed continuances, fee waivers, expedited petitions, and full hearings on variance requests for development standards and use. All votes were conducted by roll call. The meeting was held under COVID-19 guidelines. Consent Calendar - Waiver of Notarizations: Approved unanimously by roll call (Reuters yes, Kelly yes, Duke yes, Nelson yes, Young yes). - Special Requests: - 2020-DV-2033 (Charmin Fry): Request for a six-day waiver for mail-in notice and an eight-day waiver for sign placement. Staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2020-UV-2005 (ATT Mobility, Kyle Russell Terrace): Continuance to November 17, 2020, without additional notice, to work with schools on a new location. Staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2020-UV-2009 (David Rutherford, Thompson Road): Continuance to October 13, 2020, without additional notice, to resolve drainage issues with an abutting neighbor. Staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2020-UV-2013 (automatic continuance): Automatically continued to October 13, 2020, acknowledged by the board. David Kingan noted the rules of procedure were not followed, but staff confirmed compliance. Acknowledged. - 2020-UV-2014 (Indiana Dog Park Company, Erica Ballard): Request for 50% fee waiver ($900). Staff supported. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Richard Roller (2020-DV-2039): Expressed a commitment about the case, later confirmed by the petitioner. - Kevin Labradt (2020-UV-2012): Neighbor at 633 East 38th Street, asked about the tax credit percentage (9% tax credit) and unit mix. Petitioner responded. Discussion Items - 2020-DV-2022 (Major Tool & Machine, 1931 Dr. AJ Brown Ave): Petitioner Tim Oakes requested variances for a 24,000 sq ft manufacturing addition with zero-foot front setback, parking encroachment, 6-foot fence with barbed wire. Staff recommended approval for all except barbed wire, citing agricultural/penal use only. Petitioner argued unique security needs for defense contracts. The board voted 4-1 (Kelly no) to approve all variances including barbed wire. - 2020-DV-2025 (Roger Watson, 3316-3318 St. Paul St): Petitioner requested variance for private wells (public water required). Staff recommended temporary two-year approval only. Petitioner disagreed, stating infrastructure costs too high and other homes have wells. The board voted to remove the staff commitment, approving the variance permanently (5-0). - 2020-UV-2012 (Redline Holdings, 605-625 E. 38th St): Mixed-use development with 40 affordable housing units, 1,600 sq ft retail, variances for height, setbacks, open space, clear site triangles. Staff recommended denial due to insufficient development standards, but petitioner noted a September 18 deadline for tax credit application. The board voted 4-0 (Nelson recused) to approve all variances. Petitioner offered commitments including rezoning to MU1, administrative approval of elevations, and privacy fence. - 2020-UV-2014 (Indiana Dog Park Company, 368-382 Prospect St): Variance for dog park (use) and banner yard signs. Staff recommended approval with commitments, including a 100% opaque north fence. Petitioner and neighbor Donna Gore requested chain link fence for visibility and safety. Board approved with amended commitment allowing chain link fence (4-0). Key Outcomes - Expedited Petitions (2020-DV-2033, 2034, 2035, 2038, 2039): Approved in a single vote (5-0). For 2020-DV-2039, three commitments read into record (sanitary sewer access, tree removal, privacy fence). Also approved subject to staff site plan commitment. - Full Hearing Votes: - 2020-DV-2022: Approved 4-1 (Kelly dissenting). - 2020-DV-2025: Approved 5-0 (without staff's two-year commitment). - 2020-UV-2012: Approved 4-0 (Nelson recused). - 2020-UV-2014: Approved 4-0 (with amended fence commitment). - Findings of Fact Adopted: For 2020-DV-2033, 2034, 2035, 2039, 2022, 2025, and UV-2012 (with Nelson abstaining on UV-2012). - Continuances: Approved for 2020-UV-2005 (to Nov 17), 2020-UV-2009 (to Oct 13), and automatic continuance for 2020-UV-2013 (to Oct 13).
The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 3 held a virtual public hearing on August 18, 2020, starting at 6:15 PM. The board considered several variance requests, including expedited petitions, public hearings, and administrative matters. Key decisions included approvals for a digital sign (with modifications), a manufactured home (with conditions), and a secondary dwelling unit, alongside denials for other projects. The meeting also covered continuances, adoptions of findings, and procedural motions. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The board unanimously approved the meeting minutes for June 16, 2020, and July 21, 2020. - Continuance of 2020-DV3-022 (4902 Broadway Street): Continued to September 15, 2020, without additional notice, at the petitioner's request. - Expedited Petitions: The board approved both expedited petitions in a single vote: 2020-DV3-025 (919 Eastern Avenue) and 2020-DV3-026 (7520 North Pennsylvania Street). - Adoption of Findings: The board adopted findings for several previously heard petitions. Public Comments & Testimony - Jonathan Howe (President, West Indianapolis Neighborhood Congress) testified in opposition to the manufactured home variances, expressing concerns about fire safety, the loss of the 10-foot separation between dwellings, and the historical/cultural impact on the community. - Tamara Gammon (resident at 1432 South Capus Street) opposed the variances, citing fire hazards and the closeness of homes. - City-County Councillor Kristen Jones (District 16) spoke in support of the manufactured home variances, noting the community's historical density and WIDC's willingness to listen to neighbors. Discussion Items - 2020-DV1-034 (4280 Lafayette Road): Joe Calderon represented Crew Car Wash for a digital display sign on an existing pole sign. The petitioner argued it would reduce sign area and meet all operational restrictions. Staff recommended denial, citing the sign's non-conformity and lack of practical difficulty. The board approved the variance with an added 2 condition for a one-hour fire-rated wall system. - 2020-UV3-004 (1440 Capus Street): Joe Calderon represented West Indianapolis Development Corporation (WIDC) for a manufactured home with reduced side setbacks and separation. The petitioner argued the lot's narrowness and affordability requirements necessitated the variance. Staff recommended approval, but remonstrators raised fire safety and community character concerns. The board denied the variance (1-3). - 2020-UV3-005 (1416 Shepherd Street): The petitioner requested a continuance, which was initially opposed by remonstrators. The board denied the continuance, but the petitioner then withdrew the petition. - 2020-DV3-027 (4604 East County Line Road): Carrie Sable represented AutoZone for a second freestanding sign. The petitioner argued AutoZone was at a advertising disadvantage. Staff recommended denial due to lack of practical difficulty and sign clutter. The board denied the variance (1-3). - 2020-UV3-006 (941 Morgan Drive): Mark Crouch represented the property owners for a pole barn with a dwelling unit. The petitioner agreed to reduce the height and side setback. The board continued the case to September 15, 2020, without additional notice. - 2020-UV3-007 (5712 Rake Road): Mark Callaway and Jamie Barnes represented the property owner for a secondary dwelling unit. The petitioner argued the need for a one-level home for aging parents and the property's 10-acre size. Staff recommended denial, citing the prohibition in the metro context area. The board approved the variance (3-1). Key Outcomes - Voted to approve 2020-DV1-034 (digital sign) - motion passed 4-0. - Voted to deny 2020-UV3-004 (manufactured home) - motion failed 1-3. - Voted to deny 2020-DV3-027 (AutoZone sign) - motion failed 1-3. - Granted a continuance for 2020-UV3-006 to September 15, 2020. - Voted to approve 2020-UV3-007 (secondary dwelling) - motion passed 3-1. - Adopted findings for several petitions, including 2020-DV3-016 and the expedited docket. All votes were conducted by roll call. The meeting adjourned after these items.
The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals 2 held a virtual public meeting on August 11, 2020, at 1:00 PM. The board addressed several petitions, including continuance requests, two expedited variance petitions, and a full hearing item. All votes were conducted by roll call and passed unanimously (5-0). Chairperson Mark Young presided. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes (July 14, 2020): The board unanimously approved the minutes from the July 14, 2020 BZA2 meeting. Motion by James Duke, seconded by Barry Kelly. Vote: Ruder yes, Kelly yes, Duke yes, Nelson yes, Young yes. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke during the meeting. For expedited petitions, no attendees indicated interest in the question and answer panel. For the full hearing item (2020 DV2025), no audience members were present. Discussion Items - Continuance Request (2020-205): Matt Price, representing the petitioner at 5339 West 75th Street, requested a continuance to the September 8, 2020 meeting. Price stated ongoing negotiations with the Pike Township Residence Association and Pike High School property owner regarding an alternate location. Staff had no objection. The board approved the continuance without additional notice. Motion by Barry Kelly, seconded by James Duke. Vote: 5-0. - Automatic Continuances Acknowledged: Two petitions were automatically continued to September 8, 2020 due to timely filings by neighborhood organizations: 2020 DV2-022 at 1931 Dr. AJ Brown Avenue, and 2020 UV2-009 at 10131 East Thompson Road. The board acknowledged these continuances. - Expedited Petitions (Approved): - 2020 DV2031 (301 Sanders Street): Request by Robert Ctron (Mark and Kim Crouch) for a variance of development standards to allow a single-family dwelling with a 12-foot front setback, 4 feet between dwellings, 52% open space, and a detached garage within the clear side triangle. Staff conditions and findings of fact were accepted. Motion by Ruder, seconded by Kelly. Vote: 5-0. - 2020 UV2010 (5133 East 65th Street/5127 East 56th Street): Request by Jerome J. Connor for a variance of use to permit alcohol sales by the drink, carry-out sales, and outdoor seating for a microbrewery with a tasting room and retail sales of beer and merchandise. A letter of support from City-County Councillor Dan Boots was received. Motion by James Duke, seconded by Barry Kelly. Vote: 5-0. - Full Hearing Item (2020 DV2025 – 3316 and 3318 St. Paul Street): The petitioner was not reachable by staff prior to the meeting. Staff recommended a continuance. The board voted to continue the petition to September 8, 2020 without additional notice. Motion by Barry Kelly, seconded by James Duke. Vote: 5-0. Key Outcomes - Adoption of Findings of Fact: The board unanimously adopted negative findings of fact for previously denied petition 2020 DV2024 (7030 Emblem Drive) and findings of fact for the two approved expedited petitions (2020 DV2031 and 2020 UV2010). Motion by Ruder, seconded by Kelly. Vote: 5-0. - All matters were concluded; the meeting adjourned with no further business.