The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 3, held a public hearing on January 21, 2020, at 6:15 PM. Vice Chairperson Marisol Govai presided with members Anatoly Boshenko, Matthew Draving, and Janice Schoolson Dunlap present. The board heard requests for continuances, expedited docket transfers, and six variance/special exception petitions. All votes were unanimous, with four members voting. Continuances and Procedural Motions - 2019 UV 3010 (2630 South Arlington Avenue): Petitioner Justin King requested a continuance to February 18, 2020, without additional notice, as the petition was recommended for denial and the petitioner was revising the site plan. Staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2019 SE 3002 (11149 Stony Brook Drive): Petitioner Joe Calderon requested moving the case to the expedited docket. Staff agreed. Approved unanimously. - 2019 UV 3017 (1018 Calvary Street): Petitioner Marcus Crouch requested expedited handling, but the Foundation Neighborhood Association had filed a letter requesting a continuance. The board voted to continue to February 18, 2020, without notice. Approved unanimously. - 2019 DV 3004 (8602-9010 Southeastern Avenue): Attorney David Rutherford requested a continuance to February 18, 2020, without notice, citing technical issues with staff. Staff had no objection. Approved unanimously. - 2019 UV 3016 (1024 Calvary Street): Staff reported an automatic continuance filed by a remonstrator to February 18, 2020, with additional notice. The board acknowledged the continuance. Discussion Items 2019 DV 3042 – 5360 East 75th Street - Request: Variance to allow a single-family dwelling with an 80-foot front setback (required: greater of 40 feet or average of 140 feet). - Position: Petitioner Sam Mulligan (Northridge Construction) agreed with the staff report. Staff had no additional comments. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). 2019 DV 3043 – 1238 Tecumseh Street - Request: Variance to construct a single-family dwelling with a 10-foot front setback, 8 feet between dwellings, 3-foot south side setback, and a detached garage with reduced setbacks, including within the clear side triangle. - Position: Petitioner Marcus Crouch stated staff recommended approval. The Windsor Park Neighborhood Association submitted a letter with commitments, but the petitioner disagreed with some requests, particularly the 40% open space minimum. Staff recommended disregarding the 40% open space condition as it was not part of the original petition. The petitioner preferred proceeding as originally proposed. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). 2019 DV 3045 – 621 North Hamilton Avenue - Request: Variance to construct a two-story single-family dwelling with a 2-foot south side yard and a detached garage with 57% open space (required: 3-foot side yard and 60% open space). - Position: Petitioner James Long stated the variance was needed to avoid demolishing an existing foundation. He agreed with the staff report. Staff had no additional comments. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). 2019 UV 3015 – 7969 Caswell Street - Request: Variance to construct a new dwelling unit with an attached garage on a lot with 16 feet of frontage (required 125 feet). - Position: Staff had no additional comments. No remonstrators appeared. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). 2019 SE 3002 – 11149 Stony Brook Drive (Expedited) - Request: Special exception for a wireless communications facility with a 120-foot monopole tower and 10-foot antenna on school district property. - Position: Petitioner Joe Calderon (Vertical Bridge Development) stated the site is well-screened near I-70, and the Warren Township Development Association unanimously approved it. Staff recommended approval with one commitment, which the petitioner accepted. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). 2019 DV 3041 – 1136 and 1138 East 19th Street - Request: Variance to construct a two-family dwelling with 8-foot front and rear setbacks (required: 18-foot front setback or lot average, 15-foot rear setback). - Position: Petitioner Danielle Smith (King Park Development Corporation) argued the practical difficulty was not self-imposed but due to the unique lot configuration and the need to provide affordable housing with attached garages. She stated that any design would require a variance. Staff recommended denial, stating the design could be revised to meet D8 district standards (e.g., by using two single-family attached units) and that the lot width (54 feet) was adequate. The petitioner countered that the existing neighborhood context features reduced setbacks and that redesign would compromise affordability. - Outcome: Approved unanimously (4-0). Key Outcomes - All six variance/special exception petitions were approved with unanimous votes (4-0). - Four continuances were granted to the February 18, 2020, hearing date, with or without notice as specified. - One case (2019 SE 3002) was moved to the expedited docket and heard immediately. - The board noted that with only four members present, a tied vote would result in an automatic continuance.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 met on January 14, 2020 at 6:00 PM to hear several variance petitions. The meeting was chaired by Mark Young with members Alicia Rooter, Peter Hanskin, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. Staff presented recommendations on each case. Public Comments & Testimony - Judith Essex, representing the Old South Side Neighborhood Association, expressed support for Motor Vault LLC's variance of use for automobile display and sales at 520 West McCarty Street, stating it was exactly the type of business the neighborhood seeks. Discussion Items - Continuances: - 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Road): Petitioner requested a 30-day continuance to February 11, 2020. Staff had no objection. All members voted in favor, granted. - 2019 DV2035 (2222 Bluff Road and 357 West Raymond Street): Petitioner requested a two-month continuance to March 10, 2020, after initial confusion about the date. Staff had no objection to transferring to March 10 hearing. All members voted in favor, granted. - Variance of Development Standards: - 2019 DB 2040 (1225 Span Avenue): Jacob Weizen requested variance for a detached garage with 46% open space (required 60%) and a porch with a second-floor balcony with a 6-foot front setback (required 18-foot average). Staff had no additional comments. Approved 5-0. - 2019 UV 2020 (543 East Westfield Boulevard): Chad and Corinna Thompson requested variance of use for a real estate office. The petitioner withdrew the request for a 30-square-foot wall sign. Staff recommended approval if at least one existing residential unit is converted to office use. Approved 5-0. - 2019 DB2036 (8335 Mud Creek Road): John and Emily Perkins and James and Teresa Yaney requested variance to create two 75-foot-wide lots (required 90 feet). Staff recommended approval despite a remonstrator's letter. Approved 5-0. - 2019 DB2037 (1055 South High School Road): Zelda Holloway requested variance for a two-story accessory building taller than the primary dwelling. Construction was about 80% complete without permits. Staff recommended denial citing self-imposed hardship and lot size. Petitioner committed to removing HVAC unit and keeping structure non-residential. Approved 4-1 (Reuter dissenting). - 2019 DB2038 (2001 Alvard Street): Joshua Dubach requested variance for a detached garage in the clear side triangle. Staff recommended denial citing safety concerns. Petitioner argued similar designs exist in area. Approved 3-2 (Hanscom and Kelly dissenting). - 2019 DB2039 (1427 Marlowe Avenue): Joshua Dubach requested variance for a two-family dwelling and garage with 48% open space (required 55%). Staff recommended denial stating property could be developed as single-family without variance. Petitioner noted support from neighborhood and affordability. Approved 5-0. - 2019 DB2042 (2132 Bellefontaine Street): Joseph DeCaudin requested variance for replacement of an outdoor stairway with a 0.5-foot side setback (required 4 feet). Staff recommended denial citing illegal conversion from single-family to duplex. Petitioner argued improvements to existing conditions. Approved 4-1 (Reuter dissenting). - Variance of Use: - 2019 UV2021 (520 West McCarty Street): Jason Lucking requested variance for automobile display and sales in an I-4 zone. Staff recommended denial as auto sales is a suburban use not promoting Regional Center Plan goals. Petitioner described high-end exotic car sales with limited traffic. Neighborhood association and Stadium Village Business Association supported. Petitioner agreed to 15 commitments from the business association. Approved 5-0. Key Outcomes - All continuances and variances were approved except for two dissenting votes on individual items. The board granted all petitions with conditions as noted.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 1 convened on January 7, 2020, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Joanna Taft, with board members Roderick Bohannan, Brian Robinson, and alternate Craig Von Dalen (serving from Division III). Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning were present. The board heard requests for continuances, waivers, expedited variance petitions, and several contested variance cases, voting on each item. Consent Calendar - Expedited docket placements: Petitions 2019 DV1-064 and 2019 DV1066 were placed on the expedited docket with staff agreement. - One-day mailer waivers: Granted for 2019 DV1067 and 2019 DV1068 (both requested by Ron Chazinski/Tresinski, 4320 North 550 West, Fairland, Indiana). - Automatic continuance acknowledged: 2019-UV1-027 (1919 South Coast Road) continued from January 7, 2020, to February 4, 2020, due to a timely automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood organization. - Continuance approved: 2019 DV1034 (5720 and 5724 East Southport Road) continued to May 12, 2020, to allow the petitioner to work on site plan changes related to a remonstrator's request (motion passed unanimously). - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2019 UV1013 (30 West Adler Street) withdrawn by petitioner's representative. - Continuance with dismissal warning: 2019 DV1049 (4301-4325 West Washington Street) continued to February 4, 2020. The petitioner was not present and had not submitted a correct legal description or affidavit of notice. Staff warned that if documents are not received timely or another continuance is requested, the petition will be dismissed for lack of prosecution (originally filed in September 2019). Public Comments & Testimony - Brian James Priest (1318 Olive Street, neighbor): Opposed 2019 HOV053 (1314 Olive Street) but expressed willingness to accept the petitioner's offer of an engineer review. He stated his home, built in 1877 with a lime mortar brick foundation, could be damaged by new foundation digging. He requested a condition survey of his home to establish a baseline for damage. He noted he was unhappy about the tree removal and the new house but said, "If it's gotta be done there, I just want to make sure that I am protected." - Lynn Johnson (826 East 38th Street, adjacent property owner): Opposed 2019 UV1028 (830 East 38th Street) request for a 15-person transitional housing facility. She stated the property has deteriorated since the previous operator left, citing trash, fights on the front porch, and police calls. She said, "There just doesn't need to be more than 10 people. You can have five couples." She expressed concern that 15 people would double the problems, saying, "If you add half as many people, you're going to add half as much problems." She later indicated a preference for 12 people as a compromise and said she had invested $60,000 in improvements to her own property. - Dr. Lionel Thomas Rush: Spoke in support of the transitional housing petitioner, describing his background as a minister and former president of Shepherd of Faith Housing (250 low-to-moderate income houses). He suggested both parties' motivations (financial investment vs. community service) should be part of the conversation. Discussion Items - 2019 HOV053 (1314 Olive Street, New Legacy Homes, LLC): Petitioner Sarah Walters requested a variance for a single family dwelling and detached garage with 58% open space (60% required) and 3-foot and 7-foot separations between primary dwellings (10-foot required). The lot is only 30 feet wide (50 required) and 4,500 square feet (45,000 required). Remonstrator Brian Priest raised foundation concerns. The petitioner agreed to have a licensed Indiana engineer with errors and omissions insurance review and stamp the foundation plans prior to permit issuance, and to discuss covering the cost of a condition inspection of the neighbor's foundation. Board members discussed the condition's enforceability and agreed to require engineer-stamped approval before release of the improvement location permit (ILP). - 2019 UV1028 (830 East 38th Street, Transitional Housing): Petitioner Antonio Lipscomb requested a variance of use to operate a 15-person transitional housing facility for males and females (previous 2010 variance allowed 10 women only). He argued there is a need for couples housing, noting that 60% of Indianapolis's homeless population is African American and that incarceration costs $18,000/year locally and $32,000/year in prison. He stated the facility currently houses 7 people (including 2 couples) and offers supportive services (substance abuse, health, credit repair, homeownership). Property owner John Walthal (Maple Tree Properties, owner since 2009) testified about renovations and a zero-tolerance policy for fighting. Remonstrator Lynn Johnson opposed the increase to 15. Staff recommended approval subject to commitments: a 6-foot privacy fence along the western boundary (and northern boundary fence), and that the variance be subject to the plan of operation and site plan. Staff noted the comprehensive plan recommends village mixed use (6-25 dwelling units per acre) and that 15 unrelated adults would be equivalent to 4 families, consistent with the plan. Board members discussed reducing the limit; petitioner agreed to amend the request to 12 persons. The board approved subject to commitments and the amended limit. Key Outcomes - 2019 DV1063 (1206 South State Avenue): Approved 4-0. Variance for two lots with 33-foot width (50 required) and two single family dwellings with detached garages. - 2019 DV1065 (1631 Hoyt Avenue): Approved 4-0. Variance for single family dwelling with 8.5- and 9-foot separations between dwellings and detached garage with 49% open space. - 2019 DV1067 (7020 Mancor Street): Approved 4-0. Variance for a 960 sq ft pole barn (19'6" tall, amended from 20 ft) with 3-foot south side setback, pool with 3-foot north side setback, 6-foot side setback, and 16-foot aggregate side setback. - 2019 DV1068 (318 Terrace Avenue): Approved 4-0. Variance for detached garage with secondary dwelling and 51% open space (60% required). - 2019 UV1026 (1844 North Rural Street): Approved 4-0. Variance for addition to single family dwelling with 3-foot and 4-foot side setbacks (10-foot required). - 2019 UV1029 (New Fangled Confections, LLC): Approved 4-0. Variance of use for manufacture, packing, storing, and shipping of food-related items. - 2019 DV1064 (1102 Tecumseh Street): Approved 4-0 contingent on condition that the garage be reduced to 20x20 feet, meet 10-foot separation between dwellings, and achieve 38% open space. - 2019 DV1066 (1938 East 11th Street): Approved 4-0 as amended. Amendment eliminated the zero-foot west side setback and included a 20x20 attached garage. - 2019 HOV053 (1314 Olive Street): Approved 4-0 subject to condition that foundation plans be approved and certified by a licensed Indiana engineer with errors and omissions insurance prior to release of the ILP. - 2019 UV1028 (830 East 38th Street): Approved 4-0 subject to commitments (privacy fences, plan of operation, site plan) and the petitioner's amendment limiting the facility to 12 persons. The plan of operation must be revised administratively to reflect 12. - Negative findings of fact: Adopted for petition 2019 DV1050 and revised findings for 2019 UV1023 (2019 UV1019). The meeting adjourned after all business was completed.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing on December 10, 2019, chaired by Mark Young, with board members Alicia Reuter, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke present. The meeting addressed requests for continuances, modifications, and variances of development standards. The board approved all items on the agenda, including one continuance and three variance approvals. Consent Calendar - No items were listed on a consent calendar; all cases were heard individually. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments or remonstrator testimony were presented during the hearing. The petitioner for case 2019 DV2 035 mentioned ongoing contact with the South Village Neighborhood Association but did not testify as a remonstrator. Discussion Items Request for Continuance - Case 2019 DV2 035 - Representative for Safeway Realty LLC requested a continuance for properties at 2222 Bluff Road and 357 West Raymond Street. The request was to allow time to revise the site plan and to meet with the South Village Neighborhood Association in early January 2020. The continuance was granted without additional notice, but staff noted an ongoing violation case and indicated reluctance to grant further continuances beyond the January 14, 2020 hearing date. Case 2019 AP 2001 - Modification of Site and Landscape Plan (1300 North McClee Avenue) - Petitioner's agent David Gilman (address: 211 South Ritter Avenue, Suite H, Indianapolis) requested modification of site/landscape plan and condition 2 of petition 2009 UV 2007. Staff recommended approval subject to two commitments listed in the staff report. The board unanimously approved the modification. Case 2019 DV 2033 - Variance of Development Standards (8160 Lafayette Road) - Petitioner Charlie Swartzel (Eagle Creek Nursery and Landscape) requested variance to allow two freestanding signs measuring 9.1 feet tall and 48 square feet, whereas the maximum permitted is 6 feet tall and 40 square feet. The petitioner had amended the plan after a previous continuance, eliminating a southern entrance sign and relocating the proposed signs 10 feet west of the right-of-way, reducing size from 64 to 48 square feet. Staff recommended approval, and the board unanimously approved. Case 2019 HOV 048 - Variance of Development Standards (1135 Jefferson Avenue) - Petitioner Mark Crouch (representing Jason Blankenship) requested variance for a single-family dwelling with a five-foot rear setback (permitted 20 feet) and 50% open space. The case was originally assigned to a hearing officer but transferred due to remonstrance, which was reportedly resolved. Staff recommended approval, and the board unanimously approved. Key Outcomes - Case 2019 DV2 035: Continuance granted to January 14, 2020, without additional notice; staff cautioned about further continuances. - Case 2019 AP 2001: Approved unanimously (5-0). - Case 2019 DV 2033: Approved unanimously (5-0). - Case 2019 HOV 048: Approved unanimously (5-0). No further business was conducted, and the meeting adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on December 3, 2019, at 18:15, chaired by Joanna Taft, with board members Roderick Bohanan and Brian Robinson. Due to only three members present, unanimous votes were required. The board heard multiple petitions including continuances, transfers, and variances. Continuances and Transfers - 2019 DV 1-036 (masonry wall variance): Continued and transferred to Board 3 hearing on December 17, 2019, with agreement of parties. No opposition. - 2019 UV 1025 (9345 Waltimore Road): Transferred to Board 3 for December 17, 2019 hearing, with proper notice and waiver of rules. No opposition. - 2019 UV 3013 (2548-2556 S Holt Road): Granted a three-day waiver of notice. No opposition. Expedited Cases (Approved Unanimously) - 2019 SE 1006 (8500 Georgetown Road): Special exception for waste transfer facility. Approved 3-0. - 2019 DV 1054 (401 Iowa Street): Variance for single-family dwelling with reduced building separation. Approved 3-0. - 2019 DV 1058 (1111 S Sheffield Avenue): Amended petition for single-family dwelling with reduced open space and building separation. Approved 3-0. - 2019 DV 1061 (8806 Camby Road): Variance for detached garage expansion. Approved 3-0 with commitments: subject to site plan filed November 19, 2019, and no business run from the garage. - 2019 DV 1062 (2627 Broadway Street): Variance for detached garage with reduced side setback and open space. Approved 3-0. - 2019 UV 1022 (4012 & 4014 Boulevard Place): Variance of use for residential uses including porch/deck additions. Approved 3-0. - 2019 UV 1023 (3617 Southeastern Avenue): Variance for outdoor storage of roll-off bins. Approved 3-0, continued for adoption of findings. - 2019 UV 1024 (5850 W 82nd Street): Variance for bulk storage of liquids and barbed wire fencing. Withdrawn setback variance request; approved 3-0 for remaining variance. - 2019 UV 3013 (2548-2556 S Holt Road): Variance for youth recreation center. Approved 3-0 subject to final site and landscape plan. - 2019 UV 1021 (8560 Medicine Avenue): Variance of use for residential use in commercial zone. Expedited and approved 3-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Full Case - 2019 UV 1019 (211 & 213 S Girls School Road): Petitioner Enrique Mauricio Buendia requested a variance to operate a food truck service on his property, operating Thursday-Sunday 7 p.m. to midnight. Remonstrators representing the Rockville Road, High School Road, Girls School Road Neighborhood Association presented a petition with 32 signatures opposing the variance. Concerns included traffic hazards near railroad tracks, noise, litter, attraction of crime, and lack of visibility for business viability. Staff recommended denial, stating the use would be an inappropriate intrusion into the residential neighborhood and that food trucks are not permitted in that zoning district. The board heard testimony from remonstrators Karen Farmer, Teresa Maxon, and Carol Barker. Key Outcomes - Denied: 2019 UV 1019 (food truck service) – denied unanimously (3-0) and continued for adoption of findings. - All other petitions listed above were approved unanimously (3-0), with some subject to conditions. The meeting adjourned after the final vote.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on November 19, 2019, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room, 2nd Floor City-County Building, Indianapolis, Indiana. The board heard and acted on a variety of zoning variance petitions, including expedited petitions, continued cases, and new petitions. The meeting was chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Marisol Gouvey, Anatoly Boshenko, Matthew Draving, and Janet Janice Golson Dunlap present. Legal Counsel was Chris Steinmanz, and staff included Heather Stevens, Senior Board Specialist and Secretary to the Board, and other planning staff. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented. Public Comments & Testimony - Support for 2019-DV3-032 (1202 S. Meridian Street): Several speakers expressed strong support for the proposed mixed-use development, citing its potential to revitalize the Old South Side neighborhood. Speakers included Justin Kingen (petitioner’s representative), Megan Hobbs (BWI), Brian Shapiro (local investor), John Bragg (Stadium Village Business Association), Judith Essex (Old South Side), and Gary Hobbs (BWI). They highlighted the project’s role as a catalyst for future development, the recent LIFT Indy grant, and community backing. - Support for 2019-DV3-036 (Carrollton Avenue): Petitioner’s representative Mark Demerly presented in favor of the variance requests, emphasizing the community’s desire for off-street parking and citing letters of support from the Kennedy King Park Neighborhood Association and adjacent property owners. Discussion Items - 2019-DV3-037 (2490 N. Graham Ave.): Staff recommended approval of a variance to allow outdoor storage equaling 45% of the building (25% permitted) subject to a landscape plan for screening along the eastern and northwestern boundaries. The site is in a high-intensity industrial area, and staff found the request supportable. - 2018-DV3-055 (245 N. Delaware St.): Staff recommended approval after the petitioner (Wheeler Mission Ministries) reduced the number of window signs from six to three on the north façade and two on the west façade. The south façade wall sign was determined to meet ordinance requirements. - 2019-DV1-056 (155 S. Delaware St.): Staff recommended approval for a 13-sq-ft internally illuminated entry sign and a 16-sq-ft electronic variable message sign for a parking garage near Bankers Life Fieldhouse. The signs are within 500 feet of a historic district (600-foot separation required), but staff cited their small size and orientation as mitigating factors. - 2019-MO3-001 (264 N. Rural St.): The petitioner (Joel Russell) requested a three-month continuance to work with neighborhood organizations, but the request had been continued five times over seven months with no new information. Staff recommended denial of further continuances and dismissal for lack of prosecution. The petitioner ultimately withdrew the petition. - 2019-MO3-003 (7837 Morningside Ln.): Staff requested a continuance to December 17, 2019, to allow the Department of Public Works to comment on the proposed modification of a transportation easement. - 2019-DV3-004 (8602-9010 Southeastern Ave.): An automatic continuance was filed by a registered neighborhood organization, moving the case to December 17, 2019. Staff discussed proposed commitments regarding sign permits and removal of illegal signs. - 2019-DV3-032 (1202 S. Meridian St.): The petitioner sought variances for a 65-foot tall mixed-use building (105 units, 2,731 sq ft retail, 69 parking spaces) with reduced setbacks and parking. Staff recommended denial, citing inadequate parking (76 required, 69 proposed) and the availability of a petitioner-owned adjacent lot for parking. The board debated the parking issue and the petitioner argued that the parking deficiency was minimal and that the project had strong community support. - 2019-UV3-010 (2630 S. Arlington Ave.): The petitioner requested a continuance to January 21, 2020, to provide additional information. Staff did not object, and the board granted the continuance. - 2019-DV3-036 (1630 & 1634 Carrollton Ave.): The petitioner sought variances for two two-family dwellings with nine-foot front setbacks (18-foot required) and two-foot side setbacks for garages (four-foot required). Staff recommended approval of the front setback but denial of the side setback, citing no practical difficulty as the lots (41 feet wide) exceed the minimum 30-foot lot width and permits were issued for compliant setbacks. - 2019-UV3-013 (2548-2556 S. Holt Rd.): The petitioner (Mars Hill Youth Center) requested a transfer and continuance to December 3, 2019, due to site plan changes that introduced a clear-sight triangle issue and access from Southern Avenue. Staff did not object, and the board granted the continuance with notice. - 2019-DV3-038 (9600 Southeastern Ave.): The petitioner requested a continuance to December 17, 2019, to meet with city staff (DBNS). Staff did not object, and the board granted the continuance. Key Outcomes - 2019-DV3-037: Approved unanimously (5-0) with landscape plan commitment. - 2018-DV3-055: Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019-DV1-056: Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019-MO3-001: Withdrawn by the petitioner. - 2019-MO3-003: Continued to December 17, 2019, without notice. - 2019-DV3-004: Continued to December 17, 2019, via automatic continuance. - 2019-DV3-032: Approved despite staff recommendation for denial (5-0). The board accepted the parking license agreement and noted the project’s community support. - 2019-UV3-010: Continued to January 21, 2020, without notice. - 2019-DV3-036: Part A (nine-foot front setback) approved unanimously (5-0). Part B (two-foot side setback) approved 3-2 (Boshenko, Draving, Von Dalen in favor; Golson Dunlap, Gouvey against). - 2019-UV3-013: Continued and transferred to December 3, 2019, Division I hearing, with notice. - 2019-DV3-038: Continued to December 17, 2019, without notice.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two convened on November 12, 2019, at 6:00 PM, under the chairmanship of Mark Young. The board considered several petitions for variances of use and development standards, as well as requests for continuances. All votes on the day's petitions were unanimous (5-0). Legal counsel was provided by Chris Steinz, and staff from the Division of Planning supported the proceedings. Continuances - Petition 2019 DV2-033 (8160 Lafayette Road): Continued to December 10, 2019, without additional notice. Staff had no objection. - Petition 2019 UV2-009 (6401 Zionsville Road, AT&T Mobility): Continued to January 14, 2020, without additional notice. Petitioner cited ongoing negotiations with nearby property owners for relocation of a cell tower site; this was the second continuance request. Staff had no objection. - Petition 2019 AP2-001 (1300 North McKinley Avenue): Continued to December 10, 2019, without additional notice, to allow the petitioner to provide additional information requested by staff. Public Comments & Testimony - Christy Agnes, address 1820 Carrollton Avenue, spoke in opposition to Petition 2019 DV2-032 (1819 Carrollton Avenue). She expressed concern that allowing a six-foot building separation between dwellings (rather than the required ten feet) would set a precedent for other new construction in the neighborhood. She noted she had less concern after the petitioner withdrew the request for a variance regarding carriage house size. Discussion Items - Petition 2019 DV2-029 (714 East 20th Street): Petitioner Nick Burrow requested a variance to build a single-family dwelling with a 6-foot front setback, 3-foot rear setback, and main floor under 660 square feet (required: 18-foot front setback average, 15-foot rear setback). Staff had no additional comments. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2019 DV2-030 (7415 West 10th Street): Petitioner Garrett Poorman requested a variance to replace a freestanding pole sign for an Arby’s restaurant with a sign of lesser square footage but exceeding height (31.7 ft vs. 20 ft max) and separation requirements. Staff had no additional comments. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2019 DV2-031 (6360 Guilford Avenue, Broad Ripple): Petitioner Mary E. Soliday, through attorney Kyle Russeter, requested a variance to build a one-story office building with reduced setbacks (5 ft from Main Street, zero-foot steps, etc.) and encroachments into the clear side triangle. The request was similar to a 2018 variance but for a different building design. Staff recommended approval subject to substantial compliance with the submitted site plan and elevations. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2019 UV2-019 (3 Beachway Drive): Petitioner SBP Properties, LLC, through attorney Charles Neblick, requested a variance of use to expand a stock room on the north side and add a freestanding cooler/freezer on the east side of an existing convenience/grocery store. The property previously held a variance for a gas station and convenience store. Staff had no additional comments. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2019 DV2-032 (1819 Carrollton Avenue): Petitioner Eric Stovel, through Joseph Lisi, initially sought variances for a single-family dwelling and detached garage including a six-foot building separation and a carriage house. After discussion with the neighborhood land use committee, the petitioner withdrew the carriage house size variance (reducing it to 720 sq ft to comply). The remaining request was for a six-foot separation between the dwelling and the adjacent building to the south; the required separation is ten feet. Staff noted the neighboring building sits on the property line, and the lot is only 38 feet wide (D8 standard requires 50 feet), creating practical difficulty. Staff recommended approval, citing similar reduced separations in the area. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - All five substantive petitions (2019 DV2-029, DV2-030, DV2-031, UV2-019, DV2-032) were approved by a vote of 5-0. - Three petitions were continued to future hearings without additional notice. - The board adopted negative findings of fact for a previously denied petition (2019 DB1-052) from the October 8, 2019 hearing.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened on November 7, 2019 at 6:15 PM with Chairperson Joanna Taft presiding. Board members present included Clinton McKay, Roderick Bohanan, and alternate Craig Von Dalen (from Division III). The board heard multiple requests for continuances, expedited variances, and regular variance petitions. The board operated with four members, prompting the chair to note that a split 2-2 vote would result in an automatic continuance to the next division. Continuances - 2019 DV 1036 (8185-8195 Sycamore / 321 East 82nd St): Continued to December 3, 2019 without additional notice at petitioner's request. - 2019 UV 1013 (30 West Adler): Continued to January 7, 2020 with notice after petitioner agreed to further continuance. - 2019 DV 1058 (1111 South Sheffield Ave): Continued to December 3, 2019 with additional notice due to amended plans. - 2019 DV 1049 (4301 and 4325 West Washington St): Continued to January 7, 2020; staff indicated no further continuances would be supported. - 2019 UV 1019 (211-213 South Girls School Rd): Automatic continuance to December 3, 2019 acknowledged from registered neighborhood organization. - 2019 DV 1056 (155 South Delaware St): Continued and transferred to Board Division 3 (November 19, 2019) because it was incorrectly docketed for Division 1. - 2019 DV 1054 (address not stated): Continued to December 3, 2019 due to improper notice. - 2019 DV 1034 (5720 and 5724 East Southport Rd): Continued to January 7, 2020 without additional notice. Expedited Cases (all approved) - 2019 DV 1055 (420 East 55th St): Request for detached garage with side setback and open space variances. Amended to 5-foot side setback. Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2019 DV 1057 (5681 Guilford Ave): Detached garage with side setback variance. Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2019 DV 1059 (149 Habig Rd): Secondary dwelling exceeding maximum square footage. Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2019 DV 1060 (2621 Sutherland Ave): Single-family dwelling with front setback variance. Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2019 UV 1018 (824 East County Line Rd): Use variance for pet grooming spa. Approved with commitment for plan of operation (4-0). - 2019 UV 1020 (1652 Spain Ave): Use variance for residential uses with various setback and transitional yard variances. Approved unanimously (4-0). Regular Cases - 2019 UV 1017 (3034 South Chase St / 3015 South Harding St): Petitioner David Owens sought a use variance to store equipment and gravel in a D4 residential zone. Petitioner argued the property is in a flood zone, making residential development impractical, and that the site already had gravel. He emphasized safety concerns about trucks using Chase Street and stated the property is already graveled. Staff recommended denial, citing inconsistency with the comprehensive plan, potential negative impacts on the surrounding residential neighborhood, and that the difficulty was self-imposed. The board approved the variance (4-0), overruling staff's recommendation. - 2018 DV 1037 (1007 Lexington Ave): Petitioner Mead Van Wyke requested variances for a new dwelling and detached garage on a narrow 20-foot-wide lot. The North Square Neighborhood Association submitted a letter opposing the variance. Petitioner presented a revised site plan with increased side setbacks (1.5 feet and 3.83 feet) and 47% open space. Staff recommended approval, noting the amended plan was more supportable. The board approved the variance as amended to reflect the new site plan (4-0). - 2019 DV 1050 (401 North Walcott St): Petitioner Mina Mcouri requested variances for a two-family dwelling with garage access from Vermont Street instead of the abutting alley. Staff opposed, arguing the ordinance requires alley access and that the site could be developed as a single-family dwelling without variances. Petitioner stated that alley access would be impractical due to tight turning radius and that the lot is a corner lot with clearance triangle constraints. The board denied the petition (4-0) after finding no practical difficulty. Key Outcomes - Eight cases were continued to future dates, one with transfer to another division. - All six expedited cases were approved without opposition. - One regular case (UV 1017) was approved over staff's denial recommendation. - One regular case (DV 1037) was approved as amended with revised site plan. - One regular case (DV 1050) was denied.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III held a public hearing on October 15, 2019, at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided, with board members Marisal Gove, Anatoli Boschenko, Matthew Driver Draving, and Janice Golson Dunlop. The meeting addressed continuances, an expedited variance, and a residential fence height variance. Continuances - 2019 DB 3004 (Watermaker village, 8602-9010 Southeastern Avenue): Petitioner's attorney David Rutherford requested a 30-day continuance to November 19, 2019, to finalize conditions with staff. No opposition. Granted without additional notice. - 2019 DV 3032 (South Meridian Place LLC, 1202 South Meridian Street and multiple West Morris Street addresses): Attorney David King requested continuance to November 19, 2019, pending review by the Stadium Village Business Association and a letter of support from Old South Side Neighborhood Association. No opposition. Granted without additional notice. - 2019 UV 3010 (Rob Biswanger, variance of use): Attorney David King requested continuance to November 19, 2019, to appear before Warren Township Development Association and resolve staff commitments. No opposition. Granted without additional notice. - 2019 M03-003 (7837 Morningside Lane): Petitioner filed an automatic continuance to November 19, 2019. Acknowledged by the board. Expedited Cases - 2019 UV 3012 (1440 East 86th Street, Washington Township): Request for variance of use and development standards to permit a liquor store within 50 feet of a protected district (100-foot minimum required). Petitioner Michael Rabinowich presented. No public opposition. Staff had no additional comments. Board voted 5-0 to approve. Discussion Item: Fence Height Variance - 2019 DV3035 (6528 Antry Terrace, Lawrence Township): Petitioner Brandon Lynn requested a variance to legally establish an 8-foot-tall fence where 6 feet is the maximum. Lynn explained that he had HOA approval, a 3.5-foot retaining wall behind his property made the fence appear shorter from neighbors' elevated lots, and he collected 22 letters of support (including from the neighbor who originally complained about drainage). The Greater Allisonville Community Council also voted unanimously in support. Staff recommended denial, arguing the retaining wall does not create a practical difficulty and that screening could be achieved with tall evergreens; they noted the height limits are for consistency and human scale. Board members questioned staff about the purpose of the height limit and noted confusion with fence companies selling illegal heights. Petitioner stated that if denied, he would have to modify the fence at a cost of approximately $2,200 plus $600 petition fee. Board voted 5-0 to approve the variance. Key Outcomes - All four continuances were granted to the November 19, 2019, hearing date without additional notice. - 2019 UV 3012: Variance approved (5-0) for a liquor store at 1440 East 86th Street. - 2019 DV3035: Variance approved (5-0) to allow an 8-foot fence at 6528 Antry Terrace. - Meeting adjourned with no other business.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, convened on October 8, 2019, at 6:00 PM under the chairmanship of Mark Young. Board members present included Alicia Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. Legal counsel was provided by Chris Steinman, and the proceedings were recorded by Ryan Hampton. Staff from the Division of Planning included Heather Steffen, Larry Callaway, Robert Ulanhake, Marlena Aretta, and Keith Holesworth. The hearing considered five petitions: one continuance, two variance of development standards, and two variance of use requests. Public Comments & Testimony - Petition 2019 UV2014 (4831 Oaknoll Drive): Pat Andrews, chair of the Decatur Township Civic Council's Land Use Committee, testified that the council voted 33-0-1 to support the petition after negotiating commitments limiting the use to the petitioner, Matt Thompson. She stated the council was initially skeptical but was convinced by the small scale and commitments. Neighbors provided letters of support. - Petition 2019 UV2018 (4639 Burkett Street): Pat Andrews also testified for this petition, noting the Decatur Township Civic Council voted 21-3-1 to support it, highlighting the family-oriented nature (the petitioner's mother already lives in the main house). Neighbors Ryan Thompson and Eric Tooley spoke in support. Brian Tue, attorney for the petitioner, noted that the city had issued multiple permits before the zoning issue was flagged, and that over $40,000 had been spent. Discussion Items - Continuance - 2019 UV 2-009 (6401 Zionsville Road): Kyle Russell, representing ATT Mobility, requested a continuance to November 12, 2019, without additional notice, citing ongoing negotiations with the Pike Township Residents Association and evaluation of an alternative site. Staff had no objection. The board granted the continuance unanimously. - 2019 DV2028 (401 Parkway Avenue): Petitioner Michelle Raithy requested a variance to build a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks (7-foot front, 1-foot side, 2 feet between dwellings, 46% open space, and a detached garage with 18-foot setback, 3-foot side, 10 feet between dwellings, 60% open space). Staff had no additional comments. The board voted 5-0 to approve. - 2019 DV1052 (1131 Hoyt Avenue): Petitioner Ricardo Turula sought a variance to build a 22x24-foot detached garage (50% open space vs. 60% required) to house two cars, tools, and equipment for an urban garden. Staff recommended denial unless the garage was reduced to 20x20 feet (53% open space). Turula argued that staff's recommendation would barely fit two cars and that he lacked funds for vertical storage. Board members discussed comparisons to prior approved variances. Vote: 2 yes (Young, Banning) and 3 no (Kelly, Duke, Reuter). Denied. The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2019 UV2014 (4831 Oaknoll Drive): Petitioner Matt Thompson, represented by David Kingan, requested a variance of use for machining, fabricating, and welding metal components in a detached garage. The plan included 10 commitments: no customers, no deliveries, limited hours, no expansion, etc. The Decatur Township Civic Council and City-County Councillor Jared Evans supported the petition. Staff opposed, citing the industrial use in a residential zone and the availability of a home occupation exception if the garage were smaller. Thompson demonstrated the equipment's noise level was minimal. Vote: 4 yes (Young, Reuter, Banning, Duke) and 1 no (Kelly). Approved. - 2019 UV2018 (4639 Burkett Street): Petitioner Brad Rugg, represented by Brian Tue, requested a variance to house his elderly father Art Rugg in a 480-square-foot secondary dwelling unit within a new accessory building. The property had been issued permits for the structure before the zoning conflict was identified. The Decatur Township Civic Council and Councillor Jason Holiday supported the request. Staff recommended denial, stating secondary dwellings are not permitted in the metro context area and that an addition to the main house would be more appropriate. Commitments were presented: unit only for Art Rugg, address distinct from main house, stove removal and unit converted to storage after his need ends. Vote: 5-0 in favor. Approved with commitments. Key Outcomes - Continuance granted: 2019 UV 2-009 moved to November 12, 2019, without additional notice (unanimous). - Approved (5-0): 2019 DV2028 (401 Parkway Avenue) - variance of development standards for single-family dwelling and detached garage. - Denied (2-3): 2019 DV1052 (1131 Hoyt Avenue) - variance for 22x24-foot detached garage. Continued for findings of fact. - Approved (4-1): 2019 UV2014 (4831 Oaknoll Drive) - variance of use for machining and fabrication in a detached garage, subject to commitments. - Approved (5-0): 2019 UV2018 (4639 Burkett Street) - variance of use for secondary dwelling unit for Art Rugg, subject to four commitments.