The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened on October 1, 2019, at 6:00 PM under Chairperson Joanna Tapp, with board members Roderick Rohannon and Peter Hanscom. The meeting addressed multiple continuance requests, expedited variance petitions, and one contested use variance that resulted in a split vote and automatic continuance. Continuances - 2019 DV1049 (4301-4325 West Washington Street): Petitioner Theodore Minch requested a continuance to November 7, 2019, due to trial scheduling. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - 2019 DV1050 (401 North Walcott): Petitioner requested a continuance to November 7, 2019. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. Petitioner also inquired about posting new signs; staff advised that signs should remain with case number only (no date change) until board decision. - 2019 UV1013 (30 West Adler Street): Petitioner Jonathan Imperial requested a continuance to November 7, 2019 without additional notice. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - 2019 DV1052: Petitioner Ricardo Trula requested transfer to October 8, 2019 Board 2 hearing without additional notice. Staff had no objection. Motion carried unanimously. - 2019 DV1036 (8185 Sigamore Road): Staff drew attention to the petition, which was requesting a continuance to November 7, 2019 with notice as amended. Motion carried unanimously. - 2018 DV1037 (1007 Lexington Avenue): Automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood group, continuing to November 7, 2019. Board acknowledged. Expedited Cases (Variances Approved) - 2019 DV1048 (515 Orange Street): Petitioner Paul Carroll requested a variance of development standards for a garage and front porch addition to an existing single-family dwelling. Staff recommended approval, no remonstrance. Board voted 3-0 to approve. - 2019 DV1051 (245 Dixon Street): Petitioner John Dearwester requested a variance to legally establish a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and a detached garage. Staff recommended approval. Board voted 3-0 to approve. - 2019 UV1016 (7405 Westfield Boulevard): Petitioner Michael Rabinowich requested a use variance for behavioral therapy services. Staff and Nora Community Council recommended approval subject to three commitments. Board voted 3-0 to approve. Discussion Item: 2019 UV1017 (3015 South Harding Street) - Petitioner: David Owens requested a use variance to permit storage of equipment and gravel on a residentially zoned (D4) lot. He argued the lot is used as a turnaround for trucks, reducing traffic on residential streets, and that the site had been used similarly for years. He noted planned landscaping (apple trees) and that nearby properties are already commercial or gravel. - Staff Position (Larry Callaway): Recommended denial. Staff argued the use would be inconsistent with the comprehensive plan, detrimental to surrounding residential neighborhoods, and would lead to further non-residential encroachment. Concerns included dust, runoff, aesthetic impacts, and that any practical difficulty was self-imposed since the site could be used for permitted residential uses. - Board Vote: Peter Hanscom voted yes; Joanna Tapp and Roderick Rohannon voted no. With one yes and two no votes, the petition was automatically continued to November 7, 2019, for a new hearing before a full board. Other Business - The board adopted negative findings of fact for petition 2019 DV1025. The meeting was adjourned after all business. No public comments from non-petitioners were received.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III met on September 17, 2019, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The board considered four continuances, one expedited petition, two contested variance petitions, and one variance of use petition. Key outcomes included approval of a multi-family affordable housing project in Mapleton-Fall Creek, a controversial self-storage facility on East Washington Street, and a single-family dwelling on Edgewater Drive. Consent Calendar - 2019-DV1-040 (7505 Edgewater Dr): Variance of development standards for a single-family dwelling. The petitioner withdrew the height variance request. Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2019-DV3-034 (2905-2927 N Central Ave & 508 E 29th St): Variance for a 4-story, 47-foot tall multi-family building with reduced parking, setbacks, and landscaping. The petitioner withdrew the request for unscreened trash enclosure. Approved unanimously (4-0). Public Comments & Testimony - 2019-DV1-040: Petitioner David Rutherford (representing Laura Rector) stated the lot is small and along the White River, necessitating reduced open space and a garage in front of the primary dwelling. He noted agreement with the Nora Community Council on a commitment prohibiting rental activity in the garage. No public opposition voiced. - 2019-DV3-034: Petitioner Joe Calderon (attorney) and Lee Riley Evans (Mapleton-Fall Creek Development Corporation) presented the project as the first phase of a master plan providing 48 affordable rental units, with support from the neighborhood association and Councilor Oliver. Remonstrators (Norm Mahmood, Elaine Hawkins Morgan, Scott Gill, Arizona Fox) raised concerns about parking reduction (from 36 to 25 spaces), unscreened dumpster, clear sight triangle hazards, building height overshadowing adjacent homes, and density exceeding the neighborhood plan's 8-15 units per acre. Staff clarified the dumpster would be enclosed per ordinance. - 2019-UV3-009 (10901 E Washington St): Petitioner Russell Brown (attorney) and Trent Overhue (affordable family storage) argued for a variance to convert a vacant former Marsh grocery store into a climate-controlled self-storage facility. They cited a permit issued in error, $1.5 million already invested, and support from the Warren Township Development Association (WTDA) subject to conditions. Remonstrator Michelle Sig presented photographs of incomplete site work, argued the area already has sufficient self-storage, and noted the WTDA had reversed its support. Staff recommended denial, citing inconsistency with the comprehensive plan (recommends regional commercial) and the Blue Line BRT corridor (which discourages auto-oriented uses like self-storage). Discussion Items - Continuances: Four petitions were continued: 2019-MO3-001 (264 N Rural St) to November 19 without notice; 2018-DV3-055 (245 N Delaware St) to November 19 without notice; 2019-DV3-032 (1202 S Meridian St, etc.) to October 15 with notice; 2019-UV3-010 (2630 S Arlington Ave) to October 15 with notice. Staff expressed concern about repeated continuances for 2019-MO3-001 but recommended one more continuance. All were approved. - 2019-DV1-040: The board heard that the requested height variance was withdrawn. The remaining variances (10-ft rear setback, 5-ft between dwellings, garage in front of building line, 55% open space) were supported by staff as minor deviations consistent with neighborhood patterns. The building must comply with floodplain regulations. Approved with a commitment of no rental activity in the garage. - 2019-DV3-034: The board debated the building's 47-foot height (35-ft max) and reduced parking. Staff supported the height due to proximity to the Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Red Line and the Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) overlay. Reduced parking (25 vs. 36 required) was deemed acceptable given transit access. Remonstrators worried about density and shadow impacts. The board approved with the commitment to screen the dumpster per ordinance. - 2019-UV3-009: The petitioner offered multiple commitments to address neighborhood concerns: no billboards or digital signs, property maintenance, well-lit parking, 50% of parking for free park-and-ride for the Blue Line, access drive maintenance, and allowance for the Pennsy Trail. Staff maintained denial recommendation. The board engaged in extensive discussion about due diligence, zoning errors, and the need for adaptive reuse. Three members voted to approve with the eight commitments; one member voted against. Key Outcomes - 2019-DV1-040: Approved (4-0). - 2019-DV3-034: Approved (4-0) with commitment to enclose dumpster. - 2019-UV3-009: Approved (3-1; Gulson Dunlap, Draving, Von Dalen in favor; Gouvea opposed) with eight commitments: 1. No billboards or digital signs. 2. Exterior property maintained and clean of trash. 3. Lighting maintained and well-lit. 4. 50% of parking dedicated for free park-and-ride for Blue Line BRT. 5. Allow continuation of Pennsy Trail (width to be determined with parks department). 6. Maintain access drive. 7. Subject to plan of operation. 8. (Additional from Mr. Pace's letter) - Not explicitly read but referenced. - Continuances: All four approved as requested. Additional Business - The board noted adoption of negative findings of fact for a prior petition (2019-DV3-033) and adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two held a public hearing on September 10, 2019, chaired by Mark Young, with members Mary Kelly and James Duke present, later joined by member Reuter. The board considered continuances for two petitions and ruled on two variance requests. Staff from the Division of Planning provided comments. Continuances - 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Road): The petitioner (AT&T) requested a 30-day continuance to continue working with the Pike Township Residents Association on a potential alternative site. Staff had no objection. The board unanimously approved the continuance to the October 8, 2019 hearing without additional notice. - 2019 UV 2014 (4831 Oaknoll Drive): Petitioner Justin King requested a 30-day continuance to allow more time to meet with the city-county counselor. Staff had no objection. The board unanimously approved the continuance to the October 8, 2019 hearing without additional notice. Variance Requests - 2019 DV2025 (6462 Avocado Drive, Perry Township): Petitioner Elizabeth Vence Williams (land use planner) requested a variance to allow a 4-foot-tall subdivision identification sign on a 3.5-foot-tall fence with a zero-foot setback from the right-of-way, where a 15-foot front setback and restrictions on signs in the right-of-way normally apply. Staff noted agreement with an addendum in their report. The board voted 3-0 (Kelly, Duke, Young) to approve the variance. - 2019 DV2026 (8641 Rawls Avenue, Warren Township; address corrected to 1104 South Post Road): Petitioner Joshua H. Kriblar requested a variance to allow more than five double-loaded rows of parking in the front yard, where only one double-loaded row is permitted. The additional rows were needed to separate passenger vehicle parking from truck lanes. Staff noted a condition that landscape requirements must be met. The board voted 4-0 (Kelly, Duke, Young, Reuter) to approve the variance. Other Business - The board acknowledged amended findings for case 2019 DV3008, passed along by Board Member Duke, with no further discussion. Key Outcomes - Both continuances (2019 UV 2009 and 2019 UV 2014) were granted to the October 8, 2019 hearing without additional notice. - Variance 2019 DV2025 was approved (3-0). - Variance 2019 DV2026 was approved (4-0). - Amended findings for 2019 DV3008 were accepted.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on September 3, 2019, at 6:15 PM to hear several petitions for variances of development standards. The board granted continuances, expedited multiple cases, and approved all variances heard, including a contested case involving a garage and secondary dwelling on North Park Avenue. All votes were unanimous (4-0). Public Comments & Testimony - John Prosser (5873 Greenfield Avenue) approached the board after the vote on 2019 DV1047 to inquire about a shared driveway arrangement. He was directed to discuss the matter with the petitioner in the hallway. - Chelsea Marberger, Executive Director of the Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association, spoke in support of the petition for 4456 North Park Avenue (2019 DV1046). She noted that the association's land use committee and full board voted to support the variance, and that surrounding neighbors had submitted letters of support. Discussion Items - 2019 DV1046 (4456 North Park Avenue): Petitioner Todd Tatro and property owner Adam Horst requested variances to construct a detached garage with a secondary dwelling. The existing garage was unsafe and located near property lines. The petitioners argued for a three-car garage with a one-foot side and rear setback and a garage door on the north side for safety (to avoid children crossing the driveway), and to accommodate turning radius for a minivan. Staff recommended approval but with conditions: reducing the garage size to 34 feet wide and 20 feet deep to meet seven-foot side and five-foot rear setbacks, and providing a visible entrance from the public right-of-way for emergency access. The petitioner withdrew the variance request for the secondary dwelling's square footage after reducing it to 685 square feet (below the 720 sq ft threshold). The Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association supported the petition. The board approved the variance as amended. Key Outcomes - Continuances: - 2019 DV1034 (5720 & 5724 East Southport Road) continued to November 7, 2019, at the petitioner's request to modify plans. - 2019 DV1036 (8185 Sycamore Road) automatically continued to October 1, 2019, due to a registered neighborhood group filing. - 2019 UV1016 (7405 Westfield Boulevard) automatically continued to October 1, 2019. - Withdrawal: 2019 UV1015 (947 South Illinois Street) withdrawn by the petitioner. - Expedited Docket (all approved 4-0): - 2019 DV1038 (4520 Broadway Street): variance for a 700 sq ft garage with reduced side setbacks. - 2019 DV1047 (5877 Greenfield Avenue): variance for a single-family dwelling on an existing foundation (amended to require an updated site plan including the existing sidewalk). - 2019 HOV022 (1106-1107 Span Avenue): variance for single-family residential development, subject to two commitments. - 2019 DV2017 (1401 Leonard Street): variance for a detached garage in front of the primary dwelling. - 2019 DV1037 (1401 Charles Street): variance for a two-family dwelling on a 2,610 sq ft lot (7200 sq ft required), with reduced setbacks and 43% open space. - 2019 DV1043 (1722 Laurel Street): variance for a single-family dwelling with a one-foot rear setback, eight feet between dwellings, and 46% open space (amended to 50% open space by removing a breezeway). - 2019 DV1046 (4456 North Park Avenue): variance approved as amended (4-0) for a detached garage with a secondary dwelling, with reduced side and rear setbacks and a visible entrance requirement waived by the board's approval. - The board adopted findings of fact for 2019 DV1017, 2019 UV1013, and 2019 DV1031.
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting - August 20, 2019\n\nThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on August 20, 2019, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building, Indianapolis, Indiana. Board members present were Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen, Marisol Govea, Anatoly Tony Boschenko, Matthew Driving, and Janice Golson Dunlop. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz. Staff from the Division of Planning included Heather Stevens, Larry Callaway, Robert Eulen Hake, Marlene Arahada, Keith Holdsworth, and others. The meeting addressed several variance petitions, including continuances, expedited items, and new cases.\n\n Continuances and Procedural Matters\n- 2019-DV3-032 (1202 South Meridian Street / West Morris Street): Continued to September 17, 2019, without additional notice at the petitioner's request.\n- 2019-UV3-010 (2630 South Arlington Avenue): Continued to September 17, 2019, without additional notice at the petitioner's request.\n- 2019-UV3-009 (10901 East Washington Street): Continued to September 17, 2019, without additional notice after a request by remonstrator Norman Pace (Warren Township Development Association), who was hospitalized. The petitioner objected but the board granted the continuance.\n- 2019-DV3-034 (2905-2927 North Central Avenue / 508 East 29th Street): Continued to September 17, 2019, with additional notice to allow time for revised plans.\n- 2019-DV3-030 (Amended) (719 Lincoln Street): A five-day waiver of legal notice for the amended petition was granted, as the second notice was deficient.\n\n Petition 2019-DV3-016: 2707 East 79th Street\n- Request: Variance to construct a garage with a zero-foot front setback from Temple Avenue (25 feet required). The previous garage burned down.\n- Staff Recommendation: Approval subject to substantial compliance with the August 19, 2019 site plan (reduced garage size compared to original).\n- Outcome: Unanimously approved (5-0).\n\n Petition 2019-DV3-030 (Amended): 719 Lincoln Street\n- Request: Variance to build a single-family dwelling with attached garage: 5-foot front setback, 4- and 6-foot separations between dwellings, and 51% open space (18-foot front setback, 10 feet between dwellings, 60% open space required). The small lot (4,031 sq. ft.) created practical difficulties.\n- Staff Recommendation: Approval.\n- Outcome: Unanimously approved (5-0).\n\n Petition 2019-UV3-011: 1045 Harding Court\n- Request: Variance of use and development standards to legally establish a lot with 52 feet of frontage (75 required), expand a cryogenic air separation facility, and allow reduced side setbacks (25 ft south, 9 ft west; 30 ft required). The use existed since 1975.\n- Staff Recommendation: Approval, finding no detrimental impact.\n- Outcome: Unanimously approved (5-0).\n\n Petition 2019-DV1-029: 1306 Olive Street\n- Request: Variance to permit additions to a single-family dwelling with a 1-foot north side setback, 5-foot front setback, and 3 feet between dwellings (3-foot side, 10-foot separation, 18-foot front required). The property had a stop-work order for exceeding a remodel permit.\n- Staff Recommendation: Initially denial; after a commitment ensuring the adjacent property (1304 Olive Street) would develop with a 10-foot separation from the shared property line, staff supported approval.\n- Outcome: Approved (5-0).\n\n Petition 2018-DV3-061 (Amended): 8800 Keystone Crossing\n- Request: Variance to allow a 15x60 ft (900 sq. ft.) banner sign as an off-premise advertising sign on a parking garage, within 150 ft of a protected district and 25 ft of an entrance roadway, for a temporary period until January 31, 2020. Maximum billboard size is 672 sq. ft.; off-premise signs are not permitted on buildings. The petitioner argued the sign frame had a valid on-premise permit since 2012 and the temporary use was for Indiana State University.\n- Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing size (40% larger than maximum), potential driver distraction near the Keystone Avenue/I-465 interchange, and lack of practical difficulty.\n- Board Discussion: The board considered the temporary nature and the petitioner's agreement to remove the sign. The neighborhood organization (Nora Northside Community Council) did not object.\n- Outcome: Approved (5-0).\n\n Petition 2019-DV3-033: 2936 South Kenyon Drive\n- Request: Variance to construct a detached garage with a 2.5-foot north side setback and located in front of the established front building line (7-foot side setback required; accessory structures not permitted in front of the building line). The petitioner stated neighbors had no objection and the location was convenient.\n- Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing adequate room in the rear yard, potential impact on a drainage swale, and no demonstrated practical difficulty.\n- Outcome: Denied (2-3). Voting yes: Govaia and Boschenko. Voting no: Golson Dunlop, Driving, and Von Dalen. The case was continued for adoption of findings of fact.\n\n Key Outcomes\n- Five petitions were approved, one was denied.\n- Continuances were granted for four petitions to the September 17, 2019 hearing.\n- A five-day waiver of notice was granted for the amended petition at 719 Lincoln Street.\n- The board recorded a total of 28 votes (23 in favor, 3 opposed) across all decided cases.
The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals met on August 13, 2019, at 18:00 to hear requests for variances of use and development standards. The meeting included continuances, transfers to the expedited docket, and a contested variance for a dog daycare and training facility. Board members present were Leisha Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, James Duke, and Chairman Young. Legal counsel was Chris Steinz, and staff from the Division of Planning provided comments. Continuances & Transfers to Expedited Docket - 2019 DV2017 (1401 Leonard Street): Continued to September 3, 2019, without additional notice. - 2019 DV2025 (6462 Avocado Drive): Continued to September 10, 2019, without additional notice. - 2019 DV2022 (3500 Lafayette Road): Transferred to the expedited docket. - 2019 UV2014 (4831 Oaknot Drive): Continued to September 10, 2019, without additional notice. - 2019 DV2020 (1555 English Avenue): Transferred to the expedited docket. - 2019 DV2021 (409 East Minnesota Street): Transferred to the expedited docket. - 2019 DV2024 (623 East Minnesota Street): Transferred to the expedited docket at the request of staff after revised site plan was submitted. Expedited Cases – Unanimous Approvals All of the following petitions were approved unanimously (5–0) with no remonstrators or staff objections: - 2019 DV2013 (1431 North Colorado Avenue): Variance for deck addition, fence, and garage (zero-foot setbacks, clear site triangle). - 2019 DV2023 (826 East Minnesota Street): Variance for single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space. - 2019 UV2012 (1040 East 75th Street): Variance to legally establish a single-family dwelling encroaching 15 feet into right-of-way. - 2019 UV2015 (2319 Distributors Drive): Variance to board and train service dogs, subject to two commitments (site plan/plan of operation dated June 1, 2019; remove barbed wire within 60 days). - 2019 UV2016 (5740 West Minnesota Street): Variance for limousine service, subject to four revised commitments (site plan, trail easement, paving, barbed wire removal). - 2019 UV2017 (953 & 1005 Harrison Street): Variance for remodeling dwellings and constructing garage with various setbacks. - 2019 DV2022 (3500 Lafayette Road): Variance for floodplain compensatory storage at off-site location. - 2019 DV2020 (1555 English Avenue): Variance to legally establish existing dwelling (zero-foot side setback) and construct detached garage; commitment that if demolished, rebuilt to current code. - 2019 DV2021 (409 East Minnesota Street): Variance for room additions and detached garage; same demolition commitment. - 2019 DV2024 (623 East Minnesota Street): Variance for single-family dwelling and detached garage with reduced setbacks and open space; site plan revised to meet staff recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Mark Stalitz (120 West Stop 11 Road) and his wife spoke in opposition to 2019 DV2014 (111 West Stop 11 Road). They built their home across the street two years ago. They provided a list of eight stipulations to the petitioner the day after the initial hearing, but only four were addressed. They expressed disappointment that communication was poor and that the revised plan of operation was not provided until the day before the meeting. They were not in favor of the variance, citing concerns about noise, number of dogs (30 outside), lack of privacy fence, and signage. - Jennifer Parker (president of Alex and Alley Foundation) and Victor Pear (representative) spoke in support. They apologized for communication issues and stated their intent to be good neighbors. They emphasized the mission of employing young adults with developmental disabilities and argued the dog daycare would be a high-end, neighborhood-friendly use. They offered to pave the driveway and install privacy fencing, but were reluctant to limit total dogs on site, preferring a limit on dogs outside (20 at a time). Discussion Items – Contested Variance (2019 DV2014) - Petition: Alex and Alley Foundation requested a variance to operate an outdoor dog run and training area at 111 West Stop 11 Road (zoned C3). The use required a variance because outdoor dog activities are not permitted within 100 feet of protected districts (residential). The property is adjacent to two single-family dwellings to the west; the petitioner’s plan placed the outdoor area zero feet from the nearest protected district. - Staff Report: Staff recommended denial, citing concerns about noise, odor, traffic (10–30 customers daily on gravel driveway), dust, and the incompatibility of outdoor kennel operations adjacent to residential properties. Staff noted that the site could be used for indoor commercial uses without a variance, and that the practical difficulty was self-imposed. - Petitioner’s Argument: The outdoor area is essential for exercise and training. The foundation plans to employ adults with disabilities. They agreed to pave the driveway, install privacy fencing, and limit total dogs to 50 (20 outside at any time). They argued the use is more compatible than a strip mall, which was previously approved for the site. - Remonstrators’ Argument: The Stalitzes insisted on all eight stipulations, including a total dog limit of 20 and a privacy fence on the entire west side. They felt the petitioner’s response was insufficient and that outdoor operations would disrupt the neighborhood. - Board Deliberation: Board members discussed the need for enforceable commitments. Counsel suggested tying commitments to the plan of operation, an amended site plan showing paved areas and privacy fencing, and limits on dog numbers. The board voted on the variance subject to three conditions: (1) plan of operation dated July 2, 2019; (2) amended site plan (subject to administrator approval) showing paved maneuvering areas and upgraded privacy fencing; (3) maximum 50 dogs total on property and 20 dogs outside at any time. Key Outcomes - All expedited cases (listed above) were approved unanimously (5–0). - 2019 DV2014 (111 West Stop 11 Road) was approved on a 3–2 vote (Duke, Kelly, Young: yes; Reuter, Banning: no). The variance was granted subject to the three commitments described above. - No further business was conducted; the meeting adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 held a public hearing on August 6, 2019, at 6:15 PM (EST) in Indianapolis, Indiana. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided over the meeting with Board Members Brian Robinson, Peter Hanscom, and Roderick Bulhannon present. The board heard continuances, expedited cases, and full hearings on variance and modification petitions, including two cases with remonstrance and one denial. Continuances - 2019 DV 1036 (8185 Sycamore Rd): Continued to September 3, 2019, without additional notice, first continuance requested by petitioner. - 2019 DV 1040 (7505 Edgewater Dr): Continued and transferred to September 17, 2019, Board 3 hearing without additional notice, to allow further discussions with neighborhood association. - 2019 DV 1038 (4520 N Broadway St): Continued to September 3, 2019, with additional notice, due to amended site plan. - 2019 DV 1037 (1401 Charles St): Continued to September 3, 2019, without additional notice, awaiting feedback on revised site plan. - 2019 UV 1013 (30 W Adler St): Continued to October 1, 2019, with additional notice (possibly), to modify petition. - 2019 DV 1034 (5720 & 5724 E Southport Rd): Continued to September 3, 2019, without additional notice, to obtain renderings for a neighbor. - 2019 DV 1029 (1306 Olive St): Continued and transferred to August 20, 2019, to allow the petitioner to work with staff on commitments regarding fire separation and adjacent property. Expedited Cases (Approved Unanimously) - 2019 DV 1039 (3402 S Rural St): Variance for attached garage setbacks and detached garage in front yard. Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 1044 (9202 E Raymond St): Variance for 6.4 ft side setback. Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 2010 (429 Parkway Ave): Variance for single-family dwelling in clear side triangle and open space. Approved 4-0 after amendment to 52% open space. - 2019 UV 1014 (827 Coolidge St): Variance of use and development standards for single-family residential use. Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 1041 (1230 Pleasant St): Variance for 9 ft between dwellings and garage with secondary dwelling. Amended to reduce secondary unit to 720 sq ft and make entrance visible from public street. Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 1042 (2020 E County Line Rd): Variance for 75 parking spaces for a fast-food restaurant (Chick-fil-A, 50 max). Approved 4-0. Public Comments & Testimony - 2019 HOV 022 (1106 & 1107 Spann Ave): Anson Keller, representing the Fountain Square Neighborhood Association and Southeast Neighborhood Land Use Task Force, spoke in remonstrance. He argued the petition set a dangerous precedent for overdevelopment, citing 33% open space and potential for 10,000 sq ft of livable area without proper design. He noted that the C5 zoning should be rezoned to D5 and that the requested height variance lacked elevations. He referenced a prior problematic project at 1108 Lexington as a cautionary example. - 2019 DV 2011 (Dogtopia, 9445 N Meridian St): No remonstrators present. Staff recommended denial, but petitioner and landlord provided extensive testimony and a noise impact study, and the Nora Northside Community Council voted not to oppose. - 2019 DV 1045 (902 E Hannah Ave): Councillor Jefferson Shreve (District 16) spoke in support, emphasizing the need to retain a pharmacy presence in the area and the impracticality of relying on adjacent parking. Discussion Items - 2019 HOV 022 – Variance of use and development standards for five single-family homes on C5-zoned lots in Fountain Square. Petitioner Luke Borough argued the lots have historically been residential and that staff recommended approval. Staff noted the properties were platted for residential use and that the requested variances are similar to adjacent approved variances. The board voted 2-2 (Robinson no, Hanscom yes, Taft no, Bohannon yes), resulting in an indecisive vote, and the petition was automatically continued to September 3, 2019. - 2019 DV 2011 – Dogtopia requested a variance for an outdoor dog run (not permitted in C3) and an 8-ft fence (6-ft max). Petitioner Murray Clark presented evidence of the area's transformation to regional commercial, a noise impact study, and commitments (1,000 sq ft max outdoor area, 8-ft fence, supervised use, no additional lighting). Staff argued no practical difficulty existed and that the outdoor run was self-created. The board voted 4-0 to approve the variance. - 2019 MO1001 (1807 Bade Rd) – Modification to remove condition requiring paved driveway from a 2005 variance. Petitioner Chris DeFour cited financial hardship and the commonality of gravel driveways in the area. Staff initially recommended denial but offered a compromise to pave only the portion serving multiple parcels. The petitioner clarified that the driveway serves only two residences. The board voted 4-0 to approve the modification, to be continued for adoption of findings. - 2019 DV 1030 (8889 Heg Rd) – Variance for outdoor storage (86% of building footprint, exceeding 25% max) and reduced setbacks for a landscape supply business. Petitioner David King argued the lot is small and the use is characteristic of the area, with letters of support from neighbors and Councillor McQuillen. Staff noted the 217% increase over allowed storage and that the use would be primary rather than accessory. The board voted 3-0 to deny the petition. - 2019 DV 1043 (1722 Laurel St) – Variance for a rebuilt garage with 46% open space (60% required) and reduced setbacks. Petitioner Sarah Walters requested to reuse the existing foundation for financial reasons. Staff recommended denial unless open space was increased to 50% to mitigate stormwater runoff. The board voted 2-1 (Hanscom yes, Taft no, Bohannon yes), an indecisive vote, continuing the case to September 3, 2019. - 2019 DV 1045 (902 E Hannah Ave) – Variance for 20 parking spaces (12 max) for a drugstore. Petitioner Michael Rabinovich argued the site has been vacant 17 years, and the extra spaces are needed for customers, especially elderly or infirm. A Walgreens representative explained the smaller store concept and customer needs. Councillor Shreve supported the variance. Staff recommended denial, citing no practical difficulty and the availability of adjacent parking. The board voted 3-0 to approve the variance. Key Outcomes - Approved variances: 2019 DV 1039, 2019 DV 1044, 2019 DV 2010, 2019 UV 1014, 2019 DV 1041, 2019 DV 1042, 2019 DV 2011 (Dogtopia), 2019 DV 1045 (Walgreens). - Approved modification: 2019 MO1001 (driveway paving condition removed). - Denied petition: 2019 DV 1030 (outdoor storage at 8889 Heg Rd) – vote 3-0. - Continued (indecisive votes): 2019 HOV 022 (continued to Sept 3, 2019); 2019 DV 1043 (continued to Sept 3, 2019). - Continued (other): 2019 DV 1029 (continued to Aug 20, 2019 transfer). - All continuances from the beginning of the hearing: 2019 DV 1036, 2019 DV 1040, 2019 DV 1038, 2019 DV 1037, 2019 UV 1013, 2019 DV 1034 all granted as requested. - The board noted that after 3:00 PM, one member left, leaving a three-member panel for the final cases. Cases requiring a unanimous vote or indecisive resulted in continuances or denials.
On July 16, 2019, the Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 convened with four members present (Chairman Craig E. Von Dalen, Marisla Govea, Anatoli Bush/Anthony Boshenko, and Matthew Draving) to hear requests for variances and use approvals. The meeting covered continuances, expedited dockets, and regular hearings. All cases that went to a vote were approved unanimously (4-0), including one over staff's recommendation. Continuances and Special Requests - 2019 UV3-009 (10901 E. Washington St.): Continued to the August 20 hearing without additional notice, at the request of Norman Pace, representing the Warren Township Development Association. Later, property owner Trent Overhew objected, but the board declined to revisit the continuance. - 2019 MO3-001 (264 N. Rural St.): Continued to the September 17 hearing without additional notice (initially misstated as September 19, then corrected) at the request of attorney David Kingan, who cited anticipated significant changes after meeting with the neighborhood association. - 2018 DV3-055 (245 N. Delaware St.): Continued to the September 17 hearing without additional notice at the request of David Kingan, representing Goodwill Industries, due to architect changes. - 2019 DV3-032 (1202 S. Meridian St.): Continued to the August 20 hearing. Staff (Paige Story) requested no sooner, stating the site plan had just been received and needed full review. The petitioner's request for an August 6 continuation for a tax credit project time line was denied. - 2019 DV3-030 (719 Lincoln St.): Continued to the August 20 hearing, with new notice required if the petition is amended. The petitioner, Epifanio Carvajal, agreed. - 2019 DV3-016 (2707 E. 79th St.): Initially moved to the expedited docket, but the petitioner never appeared. It was later continued to the August 20 hearing without additional notice. Expedited Docket - 2019 HOV-021 (692 Ellsworth St.): Approved 4-0. The Watermark HOA received a variance to construct a metal fence, brick screen wall, wood screen, access gate, sliding gate, and masonry columns in the Walnut Street right-of-way. Staff noted support from the City Architect and no remonstrance. - 2019 UV3-008 (2942-2954 McPherson St.): Amended petition approved 4-0. Jane Singh sought a use variance for four two-family dwellings on undersized lots. Staff noted the condition adding 24x24-foot detached garages. - 2019 DV3-028 (1206 Fletcher Ave.): Approved 4-0 after remonstrator William Coss withdrew his objection when the petitioner agreed to a four-foot setback. Epifanio Carvajal represented the petitioner. - 2019 DV3-018 (1330 E. Market St.): Approved 4-0. Rachel Macintosh received a variance for a residential addition, with increased open space to 50%. Staff noted the revised site plan met open space requirements. - 2019 DV3-029 (1546 Hoyt Ave.): Approved 4-0. Epifanio Carvajal obtained a variance for a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space, subject to a commitment to maintain the existing house. - 2019 UV2-006 (3380 N. Sherman Dr.): Approved 4-0. Ramsey Belfira received a use variance for window tinting, tire repair/sales, car wash/detailing, and car audio sales/installation, subject to six commitments listed in the staff report. Regular Docket - 2019 DV3-031 (7811 Lantern Rd.): The board split the ballot and approved both requested variances 4-0. Attorney Russell Brown represented homeowners Jeffrey and Christine Ballock. The first variance allowed an accessory structure (22x22-foot detached garage) in front of the primary dwelling; the second reduced the north side setback from 15 feet to four feet. Staff (Paige Story) recommended approval of the front location but denial of the setback, arguing the 15-foot setback could be met and trees would be affected either way. The petitioner argued the reduced setback preserved heritage trees and had support from 11 neighbors. The board also received a commitment that the garage would be one story. Key Outcomes - All seven cases that received final votes were approved unanimously (4-0). - One remonstrance (DV3-028) was resolved and withdrawn. - Staff's denial recommendation on DV3-031's setback was overruled by the board. - The board acknowledged a legal advertisement issue: petition 2019 DV3-027 was removed from this docket and reassigned as 2019 DV1041, to be heard by Division 1 on August 6, 2019. - The board adopted revised findings of fact for 2019 DV3056 and negative findings of fact for 2019 MO302.
This was a regular public hearing of the Metropon Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, held on July 9, 2019, at 6:00 PM. The board considered multiple petitions for variances, special exceptions, and continuances. All decisions were unanimous, with several items continued to the August 13, 2019 meeting. Consent Calendar - 2019 D V two 017 (1401 Leonard Street): Continuance to August 13, 2019, without additional notice. Motion passed unanimously. - 2019 UV two zero zero eight (2110 Blood Avenue): Moved to expedited docket. Motion passed unanimously. - 2019 D V two 013 (1431 North Colorado Avenue): Continued to August 13, 2019, without additional notice. Motion passed unanimously. - 2019 UV two-012 (1040 East 75th Street): Automatic continuance to August 13, 2019, acknowledged without objection. - 2019 UV two zero one four (4831 Oakno Drive): Continuance to August 13, 2019, without additional notice. Motion passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Petitioner (unidentified name) for 2019 DB two-014 (111 West Stop 11 Road): Expressed desire to proceed on the current date rather than continue, arguing that a month's delay would cause inconvenience and that preparation was done overnight without communication. However, the board decided to continue the case to August 13, 2019, as published. - Christina Bruno (attorney for Lutheran Child and Family Services): Presented Petition 2019 UV 2010 for a variance of use to allow a group home emergency shelter for up to 10 children (ages 8-13). Noted no remonstrators, neighborhood support, and staff support. The variance was approved. - James R. Cotterall (property owner): Presented Petition 2019 UV two zero one one for a variance to create a parking lot at 237 and 241 West 38th Street for an existing ministry. Asked to proceed that day despite a requested continuance; the board voted to decide immediately with added commitments. The variance was approved. - Justin Kingan (petitioner for 2019 DV2019, 1147 Span Avenue): Presented a variance of development standards for a single-family dwelling and detached garage. A remonstrator, Jackie (surname not provided), voiced opposition. The variance was approved. Discussion Items - 2019 D V two zero one nine (1147 Span Avenue): Originally on expedited docket but moved to full hearing due to a remonstrance. After testimony, the board voted to approve the variance. - 2019 SE 2002: Special exception for a community room use. Staff requested four commitments: limit on number of ovens, landscaping plan, community room for dinner events, and approval of items. The board voted to approve with those commitments. - Commitments for 2019 UV two zero one one: Staff recommended three commitments (including landscaping plan submission); the board added a fourth (community room for dinners). All approved. Key Outcomes - All continuance requests were granted, moving cases to the August 13, 2019 hearing date. - 2019 D V three zero one zero: Variance approved. Vote: 5-0. - 2019 UV 2010 (1501 Leslie Avenue): Variance of use for group home emergency shelter approved. Vote: 5-0. - 2019 UV two zero one one (237 & 241 West 38th Street): Variance of use and development standards for parking lot approved with four commitments. Vote: 5-0. - 2019 SE 2002: Special exception approved with four commitments. Vote: 5-0. - 2019 DV2019 (1147 Span Avenue): Variance of development standards approved. Vote: 5-0.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met in public hearing on July 2, 2019, to consider petitions for variances and continuances. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided with board members Clint McKay, Roderick Bohanan, and Peter Hanscom; Brian Robinson was expected but absent. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. All votes were cast by four board members. Continuances and Procedural Matters - Six petitions were continued to the August 6, 2019 hearing: - 2019 DV 1030 (8889 Haig Road) – continued without additional notice at the petitioner's request to work with nearby property owners. - 2019 UV 1013 – continued without additional notice after Tom Dill, president of the Stadium Village Business Association, stated the petitioner had not responded to contact attempts for three weeks. - 2019 DV 1029 (1306 Olive Street) – continued without additional notice at the petitioner's request for more information. - 2019 DV 1034 (5720 and 5724 East Southport Road) – continued without additional notice to allow discussions with neighbors and the Civic League. - 2019 M01-001 – continued without additional notice to allow staff to review additional submitted information. - 2019 HOV 022 (1106 and 1107 Spanish Avenue) – continued with additional notice, which had already been sent. - 2019 DV 1031 (306 Sanders Street) was moved to the expedited docket after the petitioner agreed to a 50% open space commitment. Expedited Docket The board approved the following expedited cases unanimously (4-0) based on staff recommendations and no remonstrators: - 2019 DV 1028 (1259 South High School Road) – variance for a 13-foot front setback and zero-foot side setback for a freestanding sign; approved. - 2019 DV 1032 (9701 East Washington Street) – variance to add sign paddle panels to an existing non-conforming sign; approved. - 2019 DV 1035 (1132 Fletcher Avenue) – variance for a single-family dwelling with an attached garage, 6-foot separation between dwellings, and 55% open space; approved. - 2019 UV 1012 (7201 Pendleton Pike) – variance of use to provide a standalone ATM; approved with commitments. - 2019 DV 1031 (306 Sanders Street) – variance for an 11-foot front setback, 5 feet between dwellings, 2.2-foot side setbacks, and 45% open space (increased to 50% as a commitment); approved. The case was continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. Discussion Items - 2019 DV 1023 and 2019 DV 1024 (Northern Tool & Equipment, 5236/5302 Victory Drive and 9345 Waldemar Road): The board allowed the two related cases to be heard together. Petitioners Jay Moore and Duane Boris sought variances to reduce window transparency below the required 40%, arguing the windows are not functional for the retail layout, that the required glass was installed only to obtain permits, and that filling them in would improve the building's appearance and reduce break-in risk. Staff recommended denial, stating that transparency standards promote safety and pedestrian activity, that blocking windows with fixtures would still violate the code, and that the buildings could be built with windows. The board approved both variances by 3-1 (Hanscom, Taft, McKay yes; Bohanan no). - 2019 DV 1025 (5908 Broadway Street): Attorney John Cross, for petitioner Nathaniel Ward, requested a variance to allow a 7-foot-4-inch side yard separation (10 feet required) for a new dwelling, arguing the need applies to only a 12-foot strip of the adjacent home. He noted support letters from adjacent property owners. Staff recommended denial, citing an ordinance requiring vehicle access from the abutting improved alley and noting that moving the house one foot would eliminate the need. The board denied the petition 4-0 and continued it for findings of fact. - 2018 UV 1025 (802 and 808 South State Street): Attorneys Paul Carroll and Michael Delp requested a variance of use and development standards to allow three live/work units with three garage spaces and zero-foot setbacks. They argued the existing building is abandoned, the live/work use is appropriate in the C3 district, and the proposal is supported by the Fountain Square Neighborhood Association, Southeast Neighborhood Development, and Councilor Adamson. Staff recommended denial, saying the project is not a reuse of the existing structure and the design is out of scale with the neighborhood. The board approved the variance 3-1 (Hanscom, Bohanan, McKay yes; Taft no). - 2019 DV 1033 (358 Terrace Avenue): Attorney Chad Rollins, for petitioner Matthew A. Griffith, accepted staff's condition to move the proposed detached garage two feet west out of the clear site triangle. Approved 4-0. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2019 DV 1028, DV 1032, DV 1035, UV 1012, DV 1031, DV 1023, DV 1024, UV 1025, and DV 1033. Conditions and commitments attached where noted. - Denied: 2019 DV 1025 (4-0) and continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Continued to August 6, 2019: DV 1030, UV 1013, DV 1029, DV 1034, M01-001, and HOV 022. DV 1031 also continued for revised findings of fact. - No petitions were remonstrated by public testimony; the board acted with four members because Brian Robinson was absent.