The Board of Zoning Appeals Division One held an electronic meeting on May 12, 2020, due to COVID-19 restrictions. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided over a board of four members initially (McKay, Robinson, O'Hannon, Hanscom), later joined by a fifth member (McKay). Staff included Mr. Simetz, Allison Richardson, Matt Pleasant, Mr. Callaway, and Jeff York. The meeting addressed minutes approval, withdrawals, continuances, expedited petitions, and public hearings on variance requests. Consent Calendar - Minutes: Approved the April 7, 2020, meeting minutes by roll call (McKay aye, Robinson aye, O'Hannon aye, Taft aye, Hanscom aye). - Withdrawals: Petition numbers 2020 UV101 and 2020 UV1002 were withdrawn at the petitioner's request; fees transferred to a new petition. Approved unanimously. - Continuances: - 2020 DV109: Continued to June 4, 2020, without additional notice (McKay moved, Hanscom second, all ayes). - 2020 DV1018: Continued to June 4, 2020, with additional notice (motion, second by Robinson, all ayes). - 2020 DV1021: Continued to June 4, 2020, with additional notice (motion, second by Hanscom, all ayes). - 2020 DV1019: Continued and transferred to the May 26, 2020, hearing of Board Three without additional notice (all ayes). - 2020 UV1003: Automatic continuance acknowledged (timely filed by registered neighborhood organization, continued to June 4, 2020). - 2019 DV1034: Continued to July 7, 2020, without additional notice (motion, second by Hanscom, all ayes). - 2020 DB1008: Moved to expedited docket after no opposition was expressed (motion, all ayes). - Expedited Petitions: Approved as a block, with one abstention: - 2020 DB1014 (1315 & 1317 Spann Avenue): Variances for two single-family dwellings. - 2020 DB1017 (515 Cottage Avenue): Variance for single-family dwelling and deck. - 2020 VV1020 (1620 & 1622 Carroll Avenue): Variances for single-family and two-family dwellings. - 2020 DB1022 (1220 Waterway Boulevard & 1510 Indiana Avenue): Variance for two temporary parking lots (Robinson abstained). - 2020 UVE3001 (1651 Cornell Avenue): Variance for addition to single-family dwelling. - 2020 DV1008 (945 East Morris Street): Variance for single-family dwelling. - Roll call: McKay aye, Robinson aye (except abstention on 1022), O'Hannon aye, Hanscom aye, Taft aye. Public Comments & Testimony - Remonstrator for 2020 DB1012 (226 Sanders Street): No remonstrators present. - Support for 2020 DB1013 (Chick-fil-A signage): Councilor Paul Anne (Indianapolis City-County Council, District 23) expressed support, stating the location is unique due to its border with Johnson County and multiple access points, and that the sign requests are reasonable for business success. - Remonstrator for 2020 DB1013: A call-in user initially signed on but later disconnected; no testimony given. - Neighbor concern for 2020 DB1012 (1157 Laurel Street): Staff noted a neighbor sent a letter opposing the reduced separation, but the petitioner addressed concerns by agreeing not to install a privacy fence. Discussion Items - 2020 DB1012 (226 Sanders Street): Petitioner Jeffrey Willis sought variances for a carport, stairs, and open space. Staff recommended denial, arguing permits could have avoided violations and the garage was oversized. Petitioner argued practical difficulties due to prior construction without permits. The board denied the petition. - 2020 DB1012 (1157 Laurel Street): Petitioner Mark Crouch sought variances for reduced separation (5 feet vs. 10 feet) and open space (54% vs. 60%). Staff recommended approval, noting the lot is only 31 feet wide and the garage size was reduced. A commitment to maintain a heritage tree was required. Approved. - 2020 DB1013 (2020 East County Line Road): Petitioner Tracy Deal (Chick-fil-A) requested variances for two 40-foot pole signs and 6.5-foot drive-through menu boards. Staff recommended denial, proposing one 20-foot pole sign and the menu boards. The petitioner initially argued necessity due to surrounding signs and multiple frontages but later amended to staff's proposal. Councilor Paul Anne spoke in support. Approved as amended. - 2020 DB1015 (227 Dixon Street): Petitioner Mark Crouch sought variances for reduced separation (4 feet) and open space (40%). Staff recommended approval after petitioner agreed to reduce garage size and delete a breezeway. Approved. Key Outcomes - Denied: 2020 DB1012 (226 Sanders Street) – all board members voted no (McKay no, O'Hannon no, Hanscom no, Robinson no, Taft no). Findings of fact will be prepared. - Approved: 2020 DB1012 (1157 Laurel Street) – subject to commitment to maintain heritage tree. Vote: Robinson aye, Hanscom aye, Taft aye (other members not called; presumably all ayes). - Approved as Amended: 2020 DB1013 (Chick-fil-A signage) – amended to one 20-foot internally illuminated pole sign (150 sq. ft.) and two 6.5-foot menu boards. Roll call: McKay aye, Robinson aye, and others (presumably all ayes). - Approved: 2020 DB1015 (227 Dixon Street) – unanimous: McKay aye, O'Hannon aye, Hanscom aye, Robinson aye, Taft aye. - Continuances and Expedited: All continuances and expedited petitions approved as noted above. - Next Steps: Petitions continued to future hearings as scheduled (June 4, May 26, July 7, 2020). Denied petition requires revised findings of fact. Approved petitions move forward subject to conditions.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III held a public hearing electronically on April 21, 2020, at 1:00 p.m. Due to COVID-19 executive orders and technical issues with the meeting platform, the board addressed procedural matters and continued nearly all petitions. The only expedited petition was transferred to another division, and temporary rule suspensions were adopted to ease filing requirements. Discussion Items - Continuance of Non‑Expedited Petitions: The board heard that four non‑expedited petitions (2019‑DV3‑044, 2020‑DV3‑001, 2020‑DV3‑003, and 2020‑SE3‑001) could not be heard due to lack of quorum and platform limitations. A motion was made and seconded to continue them to the May 26, 2020 meeting without additional notice. The motion passed unanimously. - Transfer of Expedited Petition: The only expedited petition, 2020‑UV3‑001 (1651 Cornell Avenue), was identified by staff as having incorrect WebEx information published for the hearing. Staff requested its transfer to the BZA Division I hearing on May 12, 2020 without additional notice. The board approved the transfer unanimously. - Suspension of Notarization Requirement: The board approved a motion to temporarily suspend the rule requiring notarization of affidavits of notice for new petitions until June 16, 2020. - Suspension of Posting Requirement: A motion to temporarily suspend the rule requiring posting of notices on subject properties until June 16, 2020 was also approved. Key Outcomes - All four non‑expedited petitions were continued to the May 26, 2020 BZA Division III meeting without further notice. - Petition 2020‑UV3‑001 was transferred to the BZA Division I meeting on May 12, 2020 without additional notice. - The board suspended the notarization rule for affidavits of notice and the rule for posting notices on properties until June 16, 2020. - No public testimony or substantive discussion of individual petitions occurred. The meeting was adjourned after the procedural votes.
This was an electronic public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, chaired by Mark Young, held remotely due to COVID-19 executive orders. The board addressed procedural continuations, fee transfers, temporary rule suspensions, and approved expedited petitions. Discussion Items - Continuation of Non‑Expedited Petitions: The board voted to move all non‑expedited petitions (2019 DV2035, 2020 DV2010, 2020 DV2011, 2020 DV2012, 2020 UB2003, and 2019 UV2009) to the May 19, 2020 meeting without additional notice. Motion by James Duke, seconded by Alicia Reuter. Unanimous vote (4‑0). - Additional Continuation with Notice: Petition 2020 DV2008 (6750 East 82nd Street) was continued to May 19, 2020, but required additional notice because the legal notice was not sent. Motion by Mary Kelly, seconded by James Duke. Unanimous vote (4‑0). - Withdrawal and Fee Transfer: Petition 2019 UV2009 (6401 Zionsville Road) was withdrawn; the board voted to transfer the filing fees to a new petition for a different site (5339 West 71st Street). Motion by Mary Kelly, seconded by Alicia Reuter. Unanimous vote (4‑0). - Temporary Suspension of Notarization Requirement: The board voted to suspend the requirement for notarized affidavits of notice until June 9, 2020. Motion by James Duke, seconded by Mary Kelly. Unanimous vote (4‑0). - Temporary Suspension of Posting on Property Requirement: The board voted to suspend the requirement to post notice on the subject property until June 9, 2020. Motion by Mary Kelly, seconded by Alicia Reuter. Unanimous vote (4‑0). - Approval of Expedited Petitions: The board approved all four expedited petitions as a block: 2020 SE2001 (religious use special exception), 2020 DB2007 (variance for detached garage setbacks), 2020 DB2009 (variance for garage setbacks and open space), and 2020 UV2002 (variance of use and development standards for a four‑unit building). Motion by James Duke, seconded by Mary Kelly. Unanimous vote (4‑0). Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous (4‑0) in favor of each motion. - Non‑expedited petitions were continued to May 19, 2020, without additional notice (except 2020 DV2008 which required additional notice). - Filing fees from the withdrawn petition were transferred to a new petition for 5339 West 71st Street. - Two temporary rule suspensions (notarization and property posting) were approved through June 9, 2020. - All four expedited petitions were granted as approved.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, held an electronic public hearing on April 7, 2020, at 6:00 PM ET, due to COVID-19 executive orders. Chairperson Joanna Taft led the meeting, which covered procedural adjustments, continuances, and approval of expedited petitions. Consent Calendar - All non-expedited petitions on the agenda were moved to the May 12, 2020 meeting without additional notice (motion by Peter Hanscom, second by Roderick Bohan, approved unanimously). - Petition 2020 DB1013 (2020 East County Line Road) was continued to the May 12, 2020 hearing with new notice (motion by Roderick Bohan, second by Brian Robinson, approved unanimously). Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made during the meeting. Discussion Items - The board temporarily suspended the rule requiring notarized affidavits of notice for new petitions until June 4, 2020 (motion by Clint McKay, second by Peter Hanscom, approved unanimously). - The board also temporarily suspended the rule requiring additional notice posting on a property subject to a petition until June 4, 2020 (motion by Roderick Bohan, second by Peter Hanscom, approved unanimously). Key Outcomes - All non-expedited petitions (listed: 2020 DB109, 9510 Arris and Aronson Drive; 2020 DB1011, 226 Sanders Street; 2020 DV1012, 1157 Laurel Street; 2020 DV1014, 1315 and 1317 Span Avenue; 2020 DB1015, 227 Dixon Street) were rescheduled to May 12, 2020 without additional notice. - Petition 2020 DB1013 was continued to May 12, 2020 with new notice because new variances will be required. - All expedited petitions (2020 DB1007, 2020 DB1010, 2020 DB1016, 2020 DB3005, 2020 DB306, 2020 UV3002) were approved by unanimous roll call vote. - The meeting was adjourned with no additional business.
The Board of Zoning Appeals convened on March 17, 2020, at 6:00 PM. Because board members necessary to take action were not present, every petition on the agenda was required to be continued to a future hearing date. The board acknowledged continuance requests for six petitions, transferring them to April 2020 hearing dates in three different divisions. No other business was conducted. Petitions Continued - 2020 UV 3005 (1519 [address]) – Continued to Division 1, April 7, 2020, at the petitioner’s request. - 2019 DD 3044 (6139 West 79th Street, Pike Township, Council District 1) – Continued to Division 3, April 21, 2020, at the petitioner’s request. - 2020 DV301 (2050 Carrollton Avenue, Center Township, Council District 17) – Continued to Division 3, April 21, 2020, based on an email request from the petitioner. - 2020 DV3003 (325 West Morris Street / 350 Kansas Street, Center Township, Council District 16) – Continued to Division 3, April 21, 2020, at the petitioner’s request. - 2020 SE3001 (3410 McLaughlin Street, Perry Township, Council District 24) – Continued to Division 3, April 21, 2020, at the petitioner’s request. - 2020 UV 3001 (1651 Cornell Avenue, Center Township, Council District 11) – Continued to Division 3, April 21, 2020, at the petitioner’s request. Key Outcomes - All six petitions on the March 17, 2020 agenda were continued to future hearing dates due to the absence of board members required for action. - Petitioners were offered three continuance options: 3‑week continuance to Division 1 (April 7), 4‑week to Division 2 (April 14), or 5‑week to Division 3 (April 21). Most petitions were transferred to the April 21 hearing. - The meeting was adjourned without any additional business.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two held a public hearing on March 10, 2020, chaired by Mark Young. Board members present included Alicia Ruder, Beth Whitaker, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. The meeting addressed continuances, withdrawals, and three variance petitions. Continuances and Withdrawals - 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Road) – Attorney Kyle Russeteris requested a continuance for ATT Mobility to finalize a lease for a new location. Granted without additional notice to the April 14, 2020 hearing. - 2019 DV 2035 (222 Bluff Road & 357 West Raymond Street) – Petitioner Jonathan Imperial requested a one-month continuance to continue discussions with neighborhood associations. Staff expressed concern over multiple continuances (filed October 2019, continued twice before) but did not object, warning that no future continuances would be supported. Continued to April 14, 2020. - 2020 DV 2005 (1321 Spruce Street) – Fond Square Neighborhood Association Land Use Committee requested a continuance for cause. Petitioner Ronnie Cameron opposed, wishing to proceed for the spring market. The board did not grant a continuance and proceeded with the hearing. - 2020 DV 2006 (3232 Harper Road) – Withdrawn by petitioner’s representative; acknowledged by the board. Public Comments & Testimony - Micah Hill (remonstrator for 1208 Windsor Street, speaking for the neighborhood land use committee) raised three concerns: (1) procedural – the petitioner did not adequately engage with the neighborhood after an initial meeting and declined further meetings; (2) open space – the requested 45%–46% is a nearly 20% reduction from the required 55%, and the lot, while unique, is not unusually small; (3) the revised setback of 4 feet from the alley (down from 8 feet) creates access issues for trash trucks and emergency vehicles. He stated the neighborhood generally supports development but opposes this specific plan. - Martha Latta (neighbor at 1236 Windsor Street) expressed concerns about alley access, noting a concrete block wall and a hard right turn at the proposed garage location. - Jen Ayman (neighborhood association member) clarified that the neighborhood remains open to working with the petitioner and emphasized the need for right-sized development due to aging infrastructure and stormwater issues. Discussion Items - 2020 DV 2004 (6112 Primrose Avenue) – Petitioner Adam Hart and homeowner Alex Fertle sought a variance to rebuild a fire-damaged garage in the same location with a 1.5-foot side setback (3 feet required). The project would move the garage 2 feet closer to the street to save a large maple tree. Broad Ripple Homeowners Association provided a letter of support. Staff had no comments. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. - 2020 DV 2005 (1321 Spruce Street) – Petitioner Ronnie Cameron requested variances for a single-family addition: 3 feet between dwellings, a 5-foot front setback, and 43% open space (18-foot front setback or average, 10 feet between dwellings, and 60% open space required). On the record, he amended the open space to 50% as recommended by staff. Staff recommended approval at the amended 50%. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. - 2019 DV 2041 (1208 Windsor Street) – Petitioner Mark Crouch requested variances for a new single-family dwelling with attached garage: a 5-foot front setback (18 feet or average required), a 10-foot rear setback (15 feet required), and 45% open space (55% required). During the hearing, petitioner acknowledged a revised site plan showing 46% open space and a 4-foot side setback from the alley (originally 8 feet) due to a survey error showing the adjacent garage’s actual setback of 1 foot 6 inches. Staff recommended approval, noting the lot’s irregular shape and reduced size, and that the reduced setbacks match neighborhood patterns. Remonstrators opposed the open space reduction and the alley setback, citing access concerns. Petitioner stated the home would be built for sale, possibly two stories without a basement. After discussion, the board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. Key Outcomes - Approvals (all 5-0): - 2020 DV 2004 (6112 Primrose Avenue) – variance granted. - 2020 DV 2005 (1321 Spruce Street) – variance granted as amended to 50% open space. - 2019 DV 2041 (1208 Windsor Street) – variance granted with 46% open space and revised setbacks. - Continuances granted: 2019 UV 2009 and 2019 DV 2035 to April 14, 2020. - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2020 DV 2006. - Board declined continuance for 2020 DV 2005; hearing proceeded.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, convened on March 3, 2020, at 6:15 PM UTC. Chair Joanna Taft presided over the meeting with board members Clint McKay, Roderick Bohanan, Peter Hanscom, and Brian Robinson. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board heard several variance petitions, including expedited and regular cases, and conducted officer elections. Public Comments & Testimony - For 2020 DV1005 (1901 East 46th Street), remonstrator Emily DeRosa spoke on behalf of property owner Mr. Rose, expressing concern about potential parking overflow onto adjacent vacant lots. She requested conditions to prevent tenants and customers from parking on those lots. - For 2019 DV1069, petitioner Christy Krieg presented reasons for a solar pergola location, including light exposure, septic fields, and a fill dirt contract with a development project. Discussion Items - 2019 DV1049 (4301 and 4325 Westington Street): Petitioner Theodore Minch appeared but had not provided required legal description and affidavit of notice. Staff requested dismissal. The board voted to dismiss the case due to incomplete filings. - 2020 DV1003 (Rusty and Marisa Dobbs): Expedited case for variance to legalize existing pole barns and construct a garage. Staff recommended approval. Board approved unanimously (5-0). - 2020 HOV002 (1528 Woodlawn Avenue): Expedited case for variance to legalize a covered deck and separation between dwellings. Originally had a remonstrator but none appeared. Staff recommended approval. Board approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019 DV1069 (4734 Muller Road): Petitioner Christy Krieg and David Spoonmore (Jefferson Electric) sought variance to allow a pergola with solar panels in the front yard. Two board members recused themselves due to conflicts. Board proceeded with three members. Staff recommended denial, citing lack of practical difficulty and existence of other options. Board approved the variance (3-0) with a condition to install screening shrubs. - 2020 DV1005 (1901 East 46th Street): Petitioner Jeffrey Bellamy sought variances for parking reduction (9 spaces vs 22 required) and clear sight triangle encroachment for a brew pub, cafe, and beauty supply store. The petition was modified to include an ADA space. Remonstrator Emily DeRosa raised concerns about parking on adjacent lots. Board imposed a condition requiring lease clauses prohibiting tenant parking on adjacent property unless mutually agreed. Board approved (5-0). - 2020 DV1006 (3529 Central Avenue): Petitioner Denise Garcia requested a variance for a 6-foot iron and wood fence in front yards and clear sight triangles, near schools. Staff recommended denial, citing safety concerns. Board approved the variance (3-2). Key Outcomes - 2019 DV1049: Dismissed. - 2020 DV1003: Approved (5-0). - 2020 HOV002: Approved (5-0). - 2019 DV1069: Approved (3-0) with condition of landscaping screening. - 2020 DV1005: Approved (5-0) with condition regarding lease language. - 2020 DV1006: Approved (3-2). - Officer Elections: Joanna Taft re-elected as President, Clint McKay as Vice Chair, Peter Hanscom as Secretary. - Meeting adjourned at 2:51 PM (local time). Note: The given meeting start time is 6:15 PM UTC, suggesting a possible discrepancy in time reporting.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III held a public hearing on February 18, 2020, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen. Board members present included Marisal Govea, Anatoly Tony Boschenko, Janice Golson Dunlap, and Beth Whitaker. Legal Counsel Chris Steinmetz and Division of Planning staff, including Senior Specialist Heather Stevens and Principal Planner Larry Callaway, supported the proceedings. The board heard two continuance requests, one automatic continuance, two expedited cases, and four variance petitions, approving all but one with conditions. Consent Calendar - 2020 DV 3003 (325 West Morris Street and 350 Kansas Street): An automatic continuance to the March 17, 2020 hearing was acknowledged by the board without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Fountain Square Neighborhood Association (Josh Martin, 1229 Spruce Street): Expressed support for residential development on the Calvary Street properties but requested a covenant requiring adherence to D5, D52, or D8 residential standards, citing concerns about open space and stormwater mitigation. Martin noted drainage issues in the neighborhood, including water reaching the top of the sidewalk at Orange and Spruce during rain. - Councillor Kristen Jones (District 16, 714 Shepherd Street): Stated support for the Fountain Square Neighborhood Association's position and their due diligence process on both Calvary Street petitions. - Natalie Records (CEO, Collaborative Behavior Solutions): Expressed that the Arlington Avenue facility provides applied behavior analysis services to 23 children with autism and supports nearly 40 staff. She described CBS as a neighbor that enhances the area and warned that denial would remove unique opportunities for children with autism. - David Rutherford (property owner and attorney, 8801 Southeastern Avenue): Expressed appreciation for staff and community support on the Southeastern Avenue sign variance, noting the project took four and a half years and involved door-to-door collection of signatures. Discussion Items - Continuance Requests: Joe Calderon (11 South Meridian) requested a continuance for 2019 DV 3044 (6139 West 79th Street) to March 17, 2020, citing ongoing negotiations with the Pike Township Residents Association and a neighboring property owner; Murray Clark (300 North Meridian Street) supported the request. Justin Kingan (618 East Market Street) requested a one-month continuance for 2020 DV 3001 (2050 Carrollton Avenue) to allow more time to meet with neighborhood groups and staff. Both continuances were approved without additional notice. - 2019 DV 3004 (8602–9010 Southeastern Avenue): David Rutherford sought a variance to legally establish and replace existing wall, pole, monument, and pylon signs within the 15-foot setback and right-of-way, with a 10-foot setback from the back of the curb. The property, in Franklin Township, is zoned D3, C4, C4, Flood Fringe, C5, SU1, and SU10. Rutherford explained that the historic village of Wanamaker was built along former State Highway 421 with a 100-foot right-of-way, leaving most signage nonconforming. Staff recommended approval with four conditions, which the petitioner accepted. The board approved the variance unanimously. - 2020 DV 3004 (759 and 761 South Sherman Drive): Andrew D. Baroker represented Geiger and Peters, an I-4 industrial steel manufacturer operating since 1954. The petition sought to expand an industrial building with a 30-foot north side transitional yard and legally establish an existing nine-foot yard, versus the required 50-foot side transitional yards. Baroker noted 97 notices were sent to neighbors with no objections, and four neighbors called in support. Staff had no additional comments, and the board approved unanimously. - 2019 UV 3010 (2630 South Arlington Avenue): Justin Kingan and Natalie Records represented Collaborative Behavior Solutions, seeking a variance for a behavioral analysis facility for autistic children, a trash container in the front yard, and a sign (sign request withdrawn). The use is not permitted in the D3 zone. CBS provides in-home and wraparound applied behavior analysis, with up to 40 hours per week per child. Staff recommended denial, citing the intensity of the use (up to 25 children and staff in summer), parking concerns, and inconsistency with the comprehensive plan's suburban neighborhood typology. The petitioner rebutted that peak on-site children number only 7–10 at a time on a six-acre site, and offered a commitment to return the property to residential use if CBS vacates. The board approved 4–1, with Marisal Govea dissenting, and directed that the commitment be memorialized in revised findings. - 2019 UV 3016 (1024 Calvary Street): Mark Crouch sought a variance for a two-family dwelling with a five-foot front setback and three- and five-foot side setbacks (30-foot front and 20-foot side setbacks required) on an I-4-zoned property. The Fountain Square Neighborhood Association and Councillor Jones requested a covenant to meet D5/D52/D8 standards. Staff noted the surrounding area is D8-zoned and recommended approval, but suggested D8 standards would be more appropriate than D5. The board approved unanimously. - 2019 UV 3017 (1018 Calvary Street): Adjacent to the previous petition, this sought a two-family dwelling with a five-foot front setback, four-foot side setbacks, and detached garages with three-foot side and five- and eleven-foot rear setbacks. The neighborhood raised stormwater concerns, noting limited green space and tree planting opportunities. Staff recommended approval, noting 47% open space if D8 standards applied. The board approved unanimously. - 2020 DV 3002 (1431 Lexington Avenue): Mark Crouch and Joe Belaski sought a variance for an 816-square-foot secondary dwelling over a three-car garage, exceeding the 720-square-foot maximum. The property is zoned D5 and located in a transit-oriented development area. Staff recommended denial, arguing the size could be reduced to 714 square feet without a variance and that the large garage conflicts with the comprehensive plan. The petitioner argued that the design, including the stairwell placement, justified the size and that the carriage house would serve visiting family. The board approved unanimously, overruling the staff recommendation. Key Outcomes - 2019 DV 3044: Continued to March 17, 2020, without additional notice. - 2020 DV 3001: Continued to March 17, 2020, without additional notice. - 2020 DV 3003: Automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2019 DV 3004: Approved 5–0 with four conditions. - 2020 DV 3004: Approved 5–0 with no additional conditions. - 2019 UV 3010: Approved 4–1 (Govea dissenting), with a commitment that the variance applies only to Collaborative Behavior Solutions and the property reverts to residential use upon their departure; revised findings to be adopted. - 2019 UV 3016: Approved 5–0. - 2019 UV 3017: Approved 5–0. - 2020 DV 3002: Approved 5–0, despite staff recommendation for denial. The meeting adjourned with a note from staff expressing hope that all five appointed members of Division III would be present at the March hearing to elect new officers.
Date: February 11, 2020 Time: 1:00 PM (adjourned at 1:20 PM) Location: Indianapolis, Indiana Chairperson: Mark Young This was a public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division II, to consider multiple variance petitions and continuances. The board voted unanimously to approve all four petitions heard, and granted two continuances to the March 10, 2020 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Katie Alford (Co-chair, Windsor Park Land Use Committee) requested a continuance for cause on case 2019 DB 2041 (1208 Windsor Street). She stated the committee had supported the petitioner's variance based on assurances that were not reflected in the updated plans provided only one day before the hearing. She noted this was the second time the petitioner had altered plans after obtaining neighborhood support. The board granted the continuance without objection. - Kyle Russet Territz (Attorney, Den's Bingham Greenbaum, on behalf of ATT Mobility) requested a 30-day continuance for case 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Road), stating his client was days away from signing a new lease on an alternative site and would withdraw the petition upon completion. The board granted the continuance to March 10, 2020, without additional notice. Discussion Items - 2019 UV 2009 – 6401 Zionsville Road (ATT Mobility): The petitioner sought a continuance to finalize a lease for a different site. No opposition was raised. Staff had no objection. The board approved the continuance unanimously. - 2019 DB 2041 – 1208 Windsor Street: The Windsor Park Land Use Committee requested a continuance for cause due to last-minute plan changes without proper notice. Staff had no objection. The board approved the continuance unanimously. - 2020 DB 2001 – 5715 West Southport Road (Jim and Angela Walsh): Variance to legally establish a lot with 31 feet of frontage (required 125 feet) and permit rehabilitation of an accessory pole barn with 5-foot side setbacks (required 30 feet). The petitioner requested approval. Staff had no additional comments. The board voted 5-0 to approve. - 2020 DB 2002 – 2102 North Meridian Street (St. James Apartments, LLC): Variance to install two 36-square-foot projecting signs (maximum permitted 18 square feet) at a historic apartment building. Petitioner David Kingan stated the signs would enhance the building and the North Meridian Corridor. Staff had no additional comments. The board voted 5-0 to approve. - 2020 DB 2003 – 7440 Woodland Drive (ARHC HRININ 001 LLC): Variance to allow 8.5-foot by 18-foot parking spaces for 75% of total spaces (minimum 9 feet wide and 100 square feet per space). Petitioner Ross Nixon explained the tenant needed to expand operations and add 200 additional parking spaces to meet capacity. Staff recommended approval subject to two commitments (including meeting the green factor requirement). The board voted 5-0 to approve with commitments. - 2020 UV 2001 – 6901 East 38th Street (Suite Realty Group 5 LLC): Variance of use to permit a rug cleaning service and water/microbial remediation (fire damage restoration), not permitted in C5 zone. Petitioner Mark Valencourt stated the building was vacant and a tenant operated in part of it. Staff recommended approval subject to three commitments. The board voted 5-0 to approve. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: - 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Road) – continued to March 10, 2020, without additional notice. - 2019 DB 2041 (1208 Windsor Street) – continued to March 10, 2020, without additional notice. - Variances Approved (all 5-0 votes): - 2020 DB 2001 (5715 West Southport Road) – approved. - 2020 DB 2002 (2102 North Meridian Street) – approved. - 2020 DB 2003 (7440 Woodland Drive) – approved with two commitments. - 2020 UV 2001 (6901 East 38th Street) – approved with three commitments. The meeting adjourned at 1:20 PM.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on February 4, 2020, at 6:00 PM in a public hearing. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Roderick Bohanan and Peter Hanscom. The board considered special requests, continuances, and three expedited variance petitions. All three petitions were approved unanimously. Special Requests & Continuances - 2019 DV 1049 (continued from prior hearings): Staff recommended dismissal due to lack of prosecution and failure to submit required affidavit of notice and legal description over four months. Petitioner's attorney Theodore Minch appeared and requested a final continuance, stating he was obtaining signatures. The board granted a continuance to the March 2020 hearing with new notice. - 2019 UV 1027: Petitioner Sarah Walters requested placement on the expedited docket. Staff had no objection; it became the third expedited case. - 2019-DV1-070 and 2019-DV1-069: Automatic continuances filed by registered neighborhood organizations were acknowledged, continuing both petitions to March 3, 2020. Discussion Items & Expedited Petitions 2020 DV 1001 – 1715 White Avenue (RCA Properties LLC, rep. Sarah Walters): Variance to construct a single-family dwelling with 8–9 ft between dwellings and 51% open space (60% required). Staff had no objections. Unanimously approved (3-0). 2020 DV 1002 – 405 Rawls Court (Hangar LLC, rep. Justin Kingan): Variance for industrial development with reduced yards and outdoor storage up to 148% of gross floor area (25% allowed). Petitioner concurred with staff commitments, added additional wording, and noted support from Warren Township Development Association. Staff recommended approval with amended commitment. Unanimously approved (3-0). 2019 UV 1027 – 1919 South Post Road (CIL Incorporated, rep. Sarah Walters): Variance of use to legally establish an existing commercial office building in a DA district. Commitment to obtain building permits before improvement location permit. Staff had no additional comment. Unanimously approved (3-0). Key Outcomes - All three variance petitions were approved by a 3-0 vote. - Petition 2019 DV 1049 was continued to March 2020 with new notice. - Two automatic continuances were acknowledged for March 3, 2020. - No public comments were made, and no consent calendar was presented.