The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on June 18, 2019, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Marisel Glovea, Anatoly Boshenko, Matthew Draven, and Clint McKay (alternate) present. The board heard petitions for variances, modifications, and continuances. Key decisions included approval of a variance for a real estate office (3-2) and denial of a modification to extend a commitment for a gas station (0-5). Continuances and Withdrawals - 2019 MO3-001 (264 North Rural St): Continued to July 16, 2019, without additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV3-061 (8800 Keystone Crossing): Continued to August 20, 2019, with additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2019 UV3-008 (2942–2954 MacPherson St): Continued to July 16, 2019, with notice. (Unanimous) - 2019 UV2-006 (3380 North Sherman Dr): Continued to July 16, 2019, without additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2019 DV3-016 (2707 East 79th St): Continued to July 16, 2019, without additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2019 DV3-018 (1330 East Market St): Continued to July 16, 2019, without additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2019 UV3-007 (5143–5145 East 65th St): Withdrawal acknowledged by board. (Unanimous) - 2019 HOV-021 (692 Ellsworth St): Automatic continuance to July 16, 2019, due to timely remonstrator filing. Expedited Cases (Approved Unanimously) - 2018 DV3-056 (3615 White Cedar Ct): Variance for front porch addition with zero-foot side setback. Approved 5-0. - 2019 DV3-025 (720 Eskenazi Bolt Ave): Variance for temporary banner sign on sky bridge. Approved 5-0. - 2019 DV3-015 (49 West Maryland St): Moved to expedited docket; variance for temporary changeable signs in sky bridge. Approved 5-0. - 2019 UV3-004 (1007 East 86th St): Variance for outdoor walk-in freezer at Wendy's restaurant. Approved 5-0. Discussion Items 2019 DV1-022 (9600 Southeastern Ave) – Approved 5-0 - Petitioner: Joe Calderon for Premier Land Company. Requested variance to allow two-family dwellings on any lot (not just corners) and reduce open space from 70% to 63% in a D3 district. - Support: Greg West, trustee of New Bethel Baptist Church, supported the development because the petitioner promised to donate 8.2 acres to the church for cemetery expansion. The Franklin Township Civic League voted unanimously to support. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing that two-family dwellings are only permitted on corner lots per ordinance and that the open space reduction would over-intensify the site. - Board Vote: Approved 5-0 despite staff opposition. 2019 DV3-010 (1301 East Market St) – Continued to July 9, 2019 - Petitioner: Mark Crouch for property owner. Requested variance for a renovation/addition to a single-family dwelling, requiring reduced setbacks and open space. Initially proposed 36.5% open space; later amended to 48% open space. Staff recommended denial; petitioner requested continuance to meet with staff. Continued to Division II hearing on July 9, 2019, without additional notice. 2019 MO3-002 (2711 Madison Ave) – Denied 0-5 - Petitioner: Kevin Buckheit for Global Indy 2 LLC. Sought to modify commitment from 2016 UV-3017 to extend time from April 1, 2019 to April 1, 2020, to find a gas station operator or remove underground tanks. - Remonstrators: Michelle Straw Salinas (South Indy Quality of Life Plan), Roy Gabriel (Madison Avenue Action Team), Cheryl Dillamack (Garfield Park Neighbors Association) opposed the extension, arguing the gas station is unsightly, redundant (two nearby stations), and an environmental risk. Councilor Jefferson Shreve also opposed, stating the commitment was made in good faith and should be enforced. - Staff: No recommendation (commitments resulted from neighborhood negotiation, not staff). - Board Vote: Denied unanimously (0-5). 2019 DV3-024 (1628 South East St) – Approved 3-2 - Petitioner: Rebecca Casper for Two Chicks and a Hammer. Requested variance for a real estate office with accessory storage, allowing five parking spaces (nine required) and maneuvering in the rear transitional yard. Proposed a 3,364 sq ft building on a lot previously occupied by a 1,128 sq ft doctor's office. - Support: James Bulow (Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association) and Paul Smith (Southeast Neighborhood Development) endorsed the project as consistent with neighborhood plans and beneficial for economic development. Councilors Jefferson Shreve and Frank Mascari submitted letters of support. - Remonstrator: Charles Rogers, adjacent property owner at 1624 South East St, objected to the building's size, potential parking spillover, snow load, and loss of light. He noted the previous office had parking issues and doubted five spaces sufficed. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing overdevelopment, inadequate parking, and that practical difficulty was self-imposed by the large building size. - Board Vote: Approved 3-2 (Von Dalen, Draven, McKay in favor; Boshenko, Glovea opposed). Key Outcomes - Approved: Expedited cases (4) and variance for 9600 Southeastern Ave (5-0). - Denied: Modification for 2711 Madison Ave (0-5). - Approved by split vote: Variance for 1628 South East St (3-2). - Continued/Withdrawn: Seven cases continued or withdrawn as noted above. - All votes were recorded, and the board adjourned after completing the docket.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Board of Zoning and Appeals Division 2 convened on June 11, 2019 at 6:15 PM under Chairperson Mark Young. Board members present included Margaret Bannon, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning were present. The agenda consisted of continuances, withdrawals, and multiple variance and special exception petitions. Several petitions were continued to future dates, some were withdrawn, and decisions were made on development standard and use variances. Consent Calendar - 2019 SE 2002 & 2019 UV 2008 (2110 Bloyd Ave): Continued to July 9, 2019 without additional notice at the petitioner’s request due to concerns from the Marion County Department of Health. - 2019 DV 2011 (9445 N Meridian St): Continued to August 6, 2019 with transfer to BZA1 and additional notice, requested by petitioner to allow time for community engagement and amendment for an eight-foot fence. - 2019 DV 2006 (619 E Minnesota St): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2019 UV 2010 (1501 Leslie Ave): Automatically continued to July 9, 2019 via timely filing by registered neighborhood organization. - 2019 DV 2013 (1431 N Colorado Ave): Continued to July 9, 2019 without additional notice per staff/petitioner agreement. - 2019 UV 2001 (1151 W Thompson Rd): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2019 UV 2009 (6401 Zionsville Rd): Automatically continued to July 9, 2019 via timely filing. - 2019 DV 2010 (429 Parkway Ave): Continued to July 9, 2019 without additional notice at petitioner’s request. Public Comments & Testimony - 2019 SE 2001 (Sunrise Missionary Church parking lots): Lucia Voshel (1906 Cornell Ave) expressed concerns about a proposed retention pond (health/safety) and requested signage, fence extension, and evergreen trees. Cynthia Hooks (Kennedy King Neighborhood Association president) supported the church’s plan unanimously with conditions: a six-foot privacy fence, proper drainage, and signage indicating overflow parking only. Pastor James Johnson and contractor James Long testified in favor, noting the church’s 50-year community service and million-dollar addition. - 2019 DV 3013 (pole barn, 7645 W 96th St): Jim Calhoun (neighbor to the north) supported locating the pole barn in front of the house to preserve his property view and privacy. - 2019 DV 2014 (dog daycare, 11 W Stop 11 Rd): Mark Stalitz (120 W Stop 11 Rd) outlined five stipulations as conditions for support: signage size/placement, privacy fence locations, setback of dog area 100 ft from rear garage, keeping front garage door closed, and daily cleanliness. He and his wife emphasized maintaining a residential appearance. Ned Raddock (Meridian Church of God) asked for ongoing dialogue if concerns arise. Discussion Items Continuances and Procedural Matters - The board handled multiple continuances and withdrawals without objection, as noted in the Consent Calendar. 2019 DV 2008 (5325 Searley Rd) – Tractor trailer parking with transitional yard variances - Petitioner Joseph DeCauldron noted support from Decatur Township Civic Council and tendered requested commitments. Staff recommended approval with two commitments. Vote: 4-0 approved. 2019 DV 2012 (4624 W 38th St) – Standalone ATM variance - Petitioner Timothy Oaks noted support from Pike Township Residents Association and agreement with staff. Staff recommended approval with commitment (no signage on south facade). Vote: 4-0 approved. 2019 DV 1019 (5208 E 62nd St) – Lot width variance to remedy encroachment - Petitioner Paul Carroll explained a surveying error caused a house to be built 4 ft over the property line. The variance would transfer 13 ft (amended from 11 ft) of the subject lot to the adjacent lot, leaving a 57-ft-wide lot (80 ft required). Staff recommended denial, citing alternatives like absorbing the lot into adjacent properties and concerns about future variances. The petitioner offered a commitment not to seek additional variances. Vote: 4-0 approved. 2019 DV 1026 (8320 U.S. 31 S) – Electronic variable message sign within 250 ft of protected district - Petitioner Joseph DeCauldron proposed replacing three manual sign panels (81 sq ft) with one digital panel (54.10 sq ft). Commitments included no blinking/scrolling, 30-second static messages, dimming, and sign turned off 10 p.m. – 6 a.m. Staff recommended denial, citing potential glare, impact on six dwellings, and lack of practical difficulty. Vote: 3-1 approved (Bannon dissenting). 2019 DV 1027 (6221 N Keystone Ave) – Electronic variable message sign within 320 ft of protected district - Similar proposal at a different Crew Car Wash location. Petitioner argued sign would be lowered 4 ft and screened by existing landscaping. Staff recommended denial, citing unobstructed views for multiple homes and no practical difficulty. Vote: 3-1 approved (Bannon dissenting). 2019 DV 3013 (7645 W 96th St) – Pole barn in front yard, taller than 24 ft, built before dwelling - Petitioners Ronald and Marcia Streets sought to build a 25.5-ft-tall pole barn in the front yard (300 ft from road) to store construction equipment before building a new home. Staff split recommendation: deny front-yard placement but approve other aspects if barn moved to rear. Neighbor Jim Calhoun supported front placement to protect his view. Vote: The board voted on the petition as submitted. Kelly no, Duke yes, Young yes, Bannon no – a 2-2 tie, resulting in denial (motion not carried). 2019 SE 2001 (916 & 926 E 19th St, 1901 Cornell Ave) – Special exception for church overflow parking lots - Sunrise Missionary Baptist Church requested 12 additional parking spaces (6 on each lot) as part of a million-dollar expansion. Petitioner Lester Carver presented landscaping plans. Neighbors and Kennedy King Neighborhood Association supported with conditions: six-foot privacy fence, proper drainage, and signage. The church agreed to extend the existing fence at its cost and work with neighbors on drainage. Vote: 4-0 approved with commitment to provide signage and adhere to staff recommendations. 2019 DV 2014 (11 W Stop 11 Rd) – Outdoor dog run and training area for dog daycare - The Alex and Alley Foundation proposed a boutique dog daycare employing young adults with intellectual disabilities. The outdoor area would be within 0 ft of a protected district (100 ft required). Nearby residents expressed concerns about noise, odor, and property values but offered stipulations. Staff recommended denial, citing noise and potential commercial impacts. The board continued the case to July 9, 2019 to allow the petitioner to work with neighbors and staff on an amended plan of operation and commitments. 2019 DV 2015 (9860 E McGregor Rd) – Pole barn with 12-ft east side setback (30 ft required) - Petitioner Barbara Quinn requested a reduced setback to avoid floodplains and preserve neighbor’s view. Staff recommended denial, citing ability to move the barn 18 ft west without encroachment. Vote: 3-1 approved (Duke dissenting). Key Outcomes - Votes by case: - 2019 DV 2008: Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 2012: Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 1019: Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 1026: Approved 3-1 (Bannon no). - 2019 DV 1027: Approved 3-1 (Bannon no). - 2019 DV 3013: Denied (tie vote 2-2). - 2019 SE 2001: Approved 4-0. - 2019 DV 2015: Approved 3-1 (Duke no). - Continuances: Several cases continued to July 9 or August 6, 2019, as noted. - Commitments: In multiple approvals, commitments were made part of the decision (e.g., sign operational limits, no additional variances, fence upgrades). - Administrative: Negative findings of fact adopted for 2018 DV 2047 and 2019 UV 2007.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, met on June 4, 2019, at 6:15 PM. Chair Joanna Taft presided with board members Clint McKay, Peter Hanscom, and Rob Robinson. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz was present. The board heard several petitions including continuances, expedited cases, and contested variance requests involving a cell tower, a detached garage, an auto sales lot expansion, a fence in the right-of-way, and two Northern Tool retail stores. Consent Calendar - 2019 DV1015 (225 McKim Ave): Approved unanimously (4-0) for a single-family dwelling variance. - 2019 UV1008 (4905 Kentucky Ave): Approved unanimously (4-0) for outdoor storage and trash container variance, subject to commitments from staff and Decatur Township. - 2019 UV1010 (1731 N College Ave): Approved unanimously (4-0) for residential use variance. - 2019 DV3005, 3006, 3007 (Ringgold Ave): All three approved unanimously (4-0 each) for single-family dwelling variances after amendments removing existing foundation requirement. - 2019 UV1003 (2750 S Meridian St): Approved unanimously (4-0) with revised findings of fact for a beauty salon and barber shop in accessory building. - 2019 DV1018 (357 Parkway Ave): Approved unanimously (4-0) for open space variance after amendment to 49% open space. Discussion Items - 2019 DV1013 (3702 Ferguson Rd): Petitioner Joe Calderon (Vertical Bridge REIT) requested a variance to allow a 120-foot monopole cell tower (max 60 feet within 500 feet of protected district). He argued that the site is zoned C7 (high-intensity commercial), the tower is needed to fill FCC coverage gaps, and the nearest residential district is over 400 feet away. Staff recommended denial, stating the variance is self-imposed and the comp plan discourages such uses. The board voted 3-1 to approve (Hanscom yes, Robinson yes, Taft yes, McKay no). - 2019 DV1017 (340 S Fenton St): Petitioner Christine Cote sought a variance for a 22-foot tall detached garage (taller than the primary dwelling) to include a playroom for grandchildren. Staff recommended denial, citing no practical difficulty and noting a shorter structure could be built. Warren Township requested three commitments. After testimony from the builder and homeowner, the board voted 1-3 to deny (Hanscom no, Robinson yes, Taft no, McKay no). - 2019 UV1007 (3217 S Lyons Ave): Petitioner David Deering, on behalf of Gary Clark (Decatur Auto Sales), requested a use and development variance to expand an existing auto sales lot onto an adjoining residential-zoned lot. Staff recommended denial, citing potential impact on residential properties and self-imposed hardship. The petitioner argued that the lot has been used for parking for years and that the expansion would bring compliance. The board approved 4-0 with a commitment to submit a revised site plan and landscape plan along western and southern boundaries. - 2019 DV1021 (corner of McCarty and Greer St): Petitioner Thomas and Cynthia Uriga requested a variance to replace an existing fence with a 4-foot metal fence in the right-of-way. Staff recommended denial due to lack of practical difficulty, but noted a pattern of fences in the area. The board approved 4-0 (unanimous) citing the existing fence and neighborhood character. - 2019 DV1023 and 2019 DV1024 (Victory Drive and Waldemar Road): Petitioner Joe Calderon (Northern Tool and Equipment) requested a variance from window transparency requirements for two new retail stores. Staff recommended denial, citing safety and ordinance compliance. The board split 2-2 on each (Hanscom yes, McKay yes; Robinson no, Taft no), resulting in automatic continuance to July 2, 2019. Key Outcomes - Approved petitions: 2019 DV1015, UV1008, UV1010, DV3005/3006/3007, UV1003, DV1018, DV1013 (cell tower), UV1007 (auto sales), DV1021 (fence) — all with votes or commitments as noted. - Denied petition: 2019 DV1017 (garage) — denied 1-3. - Continued petitions: 2019 DV1023 and DV1024 (tied vote, continued automatically to July 2, 2019). Also, 2019 UV102 (9600 Southeastern Ave) was continued and transferred to Board 3 on June 18, 2019. 2019 UV100 (5908 Broadway St) was continued to July 2, 2019. Additionally, two late petitions (DV1026 and DV1027) were continued and transferred to Board 2 on June 11, 2019. - Findings of fact: Revised findings were adopted for 2019 UV1003 and 2019 UV1007 (development standards findings submitted later).
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III convened at 6:15 PM on May 28, 2019, with Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presiding. Members present included Maris Algovea, Anatoly "Tony" Boschenko, Matthew Draving, and alternate Margaret Banning. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff provided support. The board considered variance requests, continuances, withdrawals, and a dismissal. Eight variances were approved, nine cases were continued to future hearings, one petition was dismissed, and one case was transferred to another board. Decisions were based on evidence presented and staff recommendations. Continuances, Withdrawals, and Special Requests - 2019 DV 3015 (49 West Maryland Street): Continued to June 18, 2019, without additional notice at the petitioner's request for additional staff discussions. Staff had no objection. - 2018 DV 1044 (2729 Madison Avenue): The petitioner withdrew portions of the variance request concerning storage of operable vehicles exceeding 25% of gross floor area, the handicapped space, and the front yard setback. The remaining request to legally establish zero-foot side and rear setbacks was moved to the expedited docket. - 2019 MO 3001 (264 North Rural Street): Continued to June 18, 2019, without additional notice to allow the petitioner to appear before the neighborhood organization. - 2018 DV 3055 (245 North Delaware Street): Continued to the Board's July 16, 2019 hearing without additional notice. Staff noted a conflicting email request to transfer the case to Board 2 on July 9, but the board accepted the petitioner's oral request for July 16. - 2019 DV 3013 (7645 West 96th Street): Continued and transferred to the June 11, 2019 hearing of BZA Board 2, without additional notice. - 2019 DV 3010 (1301 East Market Street): Continued to June 18, 2019, without additional notice to work with staff. - 2019 DV 3019 (1048 St. Peter's Street): After staff recommended the open space be reduced to 50%, the petitioner agreed and the case was moved to the expedited docket. - 2019 UV 3006 (6780 West Washington Street): With staff recommending approval and McDonald's Corporation resolving its concerns, the petitioner requested expedited review, and the board moved it to the expedited docket. - 2019 DV 3016 (2707 East 79th Street): A registered neighborhood organization filed a timely automatic continuance; the board acknowledged the continuance to June 18, 2019. - 2018 DV 3056 (3615 White Cedar Court): Continued to June 18, 2019, without additional notice at the petitioner's request due to complications with an adjoining property owner. - 2017 UV 3024 (7960 West Washington Street): Dismissed by a unanimous board vote because the petitioner indicated they would not proceed and did not submit a formal withdrawal letter. Expedited Cases Approved - 2019 DV 3020 (4500 Kessler Boulevard East Drive): Approved 5-0 to legally establish accessory structures (pool, pergola, fire pit, outdoor kitchen) in the front yard. The petitioner agreed with the staff report. - 2019 DV 3021 (837 North Temple Avenue): Approved 5-0 for a front porch with a 5.5-foot front setback and reduced separation between dwellings. The petitioner stated the porch would not protrude beyond the southern neighbor's structure. - 2019 DV 3022 (223 and 227 West 28th Street): Approved 5-0 for two single-family dwellings with 10-foot front setbacks and zero off-street parking spaces. Habitat for Humanity's representative cited the very small lots (2,800 square feet) and available on-street parking. Staff recommended approval subject to site plans filed April 18, 2019. - 2019 DV 3023 (7474 Central Avenue): Approved 5-0 for a garage addition with two-foot overhangs, 6-foot side setback, and 8-foot aggregate side setback. The petitioners stated neighbors and the Town of Meridian Hills supported the request. - 2018 DV 1044 (2729 Madison Avenue) as amended: Approved 5-0 to legally establish an automobile repair shop with zero-foot side and rear setbacks. The building has existed at the location for over 50 years, verified by aerial photographs. - 2019 DV 3019 (1048 St. Peter's Street): Approved 5-0 for a detached garage creating 50% open space (60% required). - 2019 UV 3006 (6780 West Washington Street): Approved 5-0 to allow outdoor sales, display, storage, and repair of construction equipment on the former Target property, expanding McAllister Machinery. Staff recommended approval. Public Hearing and Testimony: 2019 DV 3017 (Tattoo Parlor) - 2019 DV 3017 (2627 Shelby Street): The petitioner, John DeWez, sought a variance to operate a tattoo parlor within 70 feet of a protected district (1,000-foot separation required). He testified he had invested over $13,000 of his own money and would be forced to move or close if denied. He had not operated the business yet and was three days from opening when the violation was flagged. Supporters included Cheryl Dillenback, president of the Garfield Park Neighbors Association, who reported unanimous board and neighborhood support; and Ed Mahorn, speaking for Big Car and the Garfield Park land use committee, who described the area's revitalization and noted commitments by the petitioner to restrict hours from noon to 10 p.m. and limit signage to the front window. No remonstrators appeared. Staff recommended denial, stating that lack of ability to find another location or financial hardship did not constitute a practical difficulty under the zoning ordinance. After discussion, the board voted 5-0 to approve the variance with the two commitments made binding by legal counsel. Discussion and Continuance: 2019 DV 3018 (1330 East Market Street) - 2019 DV 3018 (1330 East Market Street): The petitioners, Rachel McIntosh and David Chesnik, sought variances for an addition to an existing single-family dwelling (13.5-foot front setback, 1-foot side setback, 7 feet between dwellings) and a detached garage with a secondary dwelling unit (3-foot side setback, 42% open space). They cited medical needs, aging in place, and historic preservation. Staff recommended denial, primarily due to the reduction in open space (55% required) and the absence of a practical difficulty because the site meets zoning standards. During the hearing, staff noted the garage could be reduced and reconsidered. The board suggested the petitioners work with staff and continue the case. The board voted to continue to June 18, 2019, without additional notice. Key Outcomes - Variances approved (5-0): 2019 DV 3020, 2019 DV 3021, 2019 DV 3022, 2019 DV 3023, 2018 DV 1044 (amended), 2019 DV 3019, 2019 UV 3006, 2019 DV 3017. - Cases continued: 2019 DV 3015, 2019 MO 3001, 2018 DV 3055, 2019 DV 3013 (transferred to Board 2), 2019 DV 3010, 2019 UV 3004 (to June 18 with notice), 2018 DV 3056, 2019 DV 3018, and 2019 DV 3016 (automatic continuance). - Petition dismissed: 2017 UV 3024. - Commitments imposed: For 2019 DV 3017, the tattoo parlor must operate only from noon to 10 p.m. and have signage only on the front-facing window.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division II met on May 21, 2019, beginning at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building, Indianapolis, Indiana. Chair Mark Young presided with board members Alicia Reuter, Mary Kelly, James Duke, and Margaret Banning present. The board heard eight petitions, approved seven, denied one, and continued six docket items to later June 2019 hearings. Continuances and Procedural Actions - 2019-DV2-010 (429 Parkway Avenue) – continued to June 11, 2019, without additional notice at the petitioner's request; staff had no objection. - 2019-DV2-008 (5325 Seerley Road) – continued to June 11, 2019, without additional notice; attorney Joe Calderon requested time for revised plans and review by the Decatur Township Civic Council. - 2019-UV2-001 (1151 West Thompson Road) – continued to June 11, 2019, without additional notice; attorney John Cross cited a pending HOA and city-county councilor review. - 2019-UV2-006 (3380 North Sherman Drive) – continued and transferred to the June 18, 2019 BZA III hearing without additional notice so the petitioner could provide additional information. - 2019-SE2-001 (916 and 926 East 19th Street / 1901 Cornell Avenue) – automatically continued to June 11, 2019; the automatic continuance was acknowledged. - 2019-DV2-006 (619 East Minnesota Street) – continued to June 11, 2019, without additional notice; staff noted the petitioner planned to amend the request. Discussion Items / Petitions Heard 2019-DV2-003 – 1140 Ohio Street (Approved 5-0) - Petitioner Mark Crouch sought a variance of development standards to convert a two-family dwelling into single-family attached dwellings and legally establish a zero-foot west side yard, a 2.5-foot east side yard, 2.5 feet between dwellings, and 39.5% open space (four-foot side yards, 10 feet between dwellings, and 55% open space required). - Staff recommended approval subject to the site plan dated April 1, 2019; a discrepancy between the referenced site plan and the one included in the staff report was clarified. - The board voted 5-0 to approve. 2019-DV2-004 – 232 North Oriental Street (Approved 5-0) - Petitioner Josh Hreha requested variances for a garage addition, reduced setbacks, porch steps encroaching 5.5 feet into the right-of-way, access to Oriental Street, and 26% open space (15-foot rear setback, four-foot side setback, 18-foot front or average setback, and 55% open space required). - Hreha stated the proposed configuration mirrors a home across the street and had neighborhood association support. - Staff had no additional comments; the board voted 5-0 to approve. 2019-DV2-007 – 1440 Hoyt Avenue (Approved 5-0) - Mark Crouch, for Goris Homes LLC, requested a variance to construct a detached garage creating 41% open space (60% required) and to legalize an existing 13-foot front setback, zero-foot side setbacks, and zero-foot separation from adjoining dwellings (18-foot front or average, three-foot side setback, and 10-foot separation required). - Staff recommended approval subject to a commitment that the grant remains valid only while the existing structure is retained; if the structure is torn down or expanded, the grant is invalid. - The board voted 5-0 to approve with that commitment. 2019-DV2-009 – 421 East Morris Street (Approved 5-0) - The petition sought to legally establish an existing single-family dwelling and garage with a 10-foot front setback, two-foot side setbacks, a two-foot separation from a primary dwelling, and 51% open space (18-foot front or average, three-foot side setbacks, 10 feet between dwellings, and 60% open space required). - Staff had no additional comments; the board voted 5-0 to approve. 2019-UV2-005 (Amended) – 6158 West 10th Street (Approved 5-0) - Homes in Motion LLC requested a variance of use for a real estate office in a residential structure, plus one 24-square-foot ground sign; the original request for two 15-square-foot wall signs was removed by amendment. - Attorney John Cross said the neighborhood supported the petition subject to commitments preventing the variance from running with the land. Staff recommended approval subject to those commitments. - The board voted 5-0 to approve, subject to the submitted site plan and the commitments. 2019-DV3-008 (Amended) – 7307 Holliday Drive West (Setback Approved 4-1; Fence Approved 5-0) - Andrew Thompson requested a variance for an addition with an eight-foot north side setback and a 20-foot aggregate side setback (12-foot side and 30-foot aggregate required) and a six-foot-tall privacy fence along the east side lot line within the front yard of 73rd Street (maximum four feet with 30% opacity or less). - Staff had a split recommendation: denial of the reduced setback and approval of the fence as amended. - The board voted on Part A (the setback) 4-1 to approve, with Alicia Reuter dissenting, and Part B (the fence) 5-0 to approve. The case was continued for updated findings of fact. 2019-DV2-005 – 3820 South Sherman Drive (Approved 3-2) - Amanda Faux-Smith, for Amandeep Singh, requested variances to legalize a rebuilt porch with a two-foot side setback and a 20-foot front setback from the proposed right-of-way of Sherman Drive, and to legalize a storage barn with a one-foot south side setback (three-foot side setback and 35-foot front setback from the proposed right-of-way required). - Faux-Smith withdrew the request related to the barn's side setback, stating the barn would be moved to comply. - Staff recommended denial, arguing the work was done without proper permits and the deficient setbacks created maintenance and trespass concerns. - The board approved the petition 3-2; it was continued for revised findings. 2019-UV2-007 (Amended) – 1027 Sears Street (Denied 5-0) - Ana Lopez, through Amanda Faux-Smith, requested a variance of use to store multiple commercial vehicles in a proposed garage and to legally establish a shed with a five-foot north side setback (seven-foot side and 19-foot aggregate side setback required). - Staff recommended denial, stating contractor vehicle storage is not permitted in residential districts, no peculiar hardship existed, and the use would extend commercial activity into a residential neighborhood. - The board voted 5-0 to deny and continued the case for adoption of findings of fact; staff said it would clarify whether the existing shed must be brought into compliance. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2019-DV2-003, 2019-DV2-004, 2019-DV2-007, 2019-DV2-009, 2019-UV2-005, 2019-DV3-008 (both parts), and 2019-DV2-005. - Denied: 2019-UV2-007. - Continued: 2019-DV2-010, 2019-DV2-008, 2019-UV2-001, 2019-UV2-006, 2019-SE2-001, and 2019-DV2-006 to later June 2019 hearings. - Several approvals were conditioned on site plans, commitments not to let variances run with the land, or commitments to retain existing structures; certain cases were continued to adopt or revise findings of fact.
On May 14, 2019, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened at 6:15 PM under Chairperson Joanna Taft. Board members Clint McKay, Roderick Bohanan, and Peter Hanscom were present, with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning. The meeting addressed continuances, an expedited docket, and several variance and use petitions, with multiple votes and procedural notes about board member departures later in the session. Continuances - 2019-DV1-017 (4320 North 550 West Fairland): Continued to June 4, 2019 without additional notice, per petitioner request and staff no objection. - 2018-UV1-025 (802 & 808 South State Avenue): Continued to June 4, 2019 without notice. - 2019-DV1-019 (5208 East 62nd Street): Continued and transferred to Division 2 for June 11, 2019 hearing with additional notice, due to scheduling conflicts. - 2019-DV1-013 (3702 Ferguson): Continued to June 4, 2019 without notice. - 2019-DV3-005, 2019-DB3-006, 2019-DV3-007 (Ringgold Avenue properties): All three continued separately to June 4, 2019 without notice at staff request for additional review. - 2019-DV1-015 (225 McKim Avenue): Continued to June 4, 2019 without notice for continued staff discussions. - 2019-DV1-018 (357 Parkway Avenue): Continued to June 4, 2019 without notice. - 2019-UV1-008 (4905 Kentucky Avenue): Acknowledged automatic continuance to June 4, 2019. - 2019-DV1-010 (2212 Woodlawn Avenue) and 2019-UV1-006: Withdrawn by petitioners, acknowledged. - 2019-UV1-007 (3217 South Lines Avenue): Acknowledged automatic continuance to June 4, 2019. Expedited Docket (Approved Unanimously) - 2019-DV1-014 (8815 Matthews Road): Variance to reduce lot width, side setbacks, and aggregate side setback for a garage. Approved 5-0. - 2019-DV1-016 (118 & 124 Pleasant Run Parkway North Drive): Variance to construct detached garages with reduced rear setbacks and open space. Approved 5-0. - 2019-DV3-011 (1230 Hoyt Avenue): Variance for single-family dwelling with reduced front setback, reduced spacing between dwellings, and detached garage creating 52% open space. Approved 5-0. - 2019-DV3-012 (915 Dawson Street): Variance for additions to existing single-family dwelling and legalization of existing garage with reduced setbacks. Approved 5-0. - 2019-DV3-014 (1211-1215 East 16th Street): Variance to allow parking lot in front yard setback for a hair salon reuse project. Approved 5-0. - 2019-UV1-004 (amended petition): Variance of use and development standards for single-family dwelling with detached garage. Approved 5-0; findings of fact to be adopted. - 2019-UV3-001 (5900-5954 West Minnesota Street): Variance for fleet terminal with reduced setbacks, subject to three commitments. Approved 5-0. - 2019-UV3-005 (8902 South Meridian Street): Variance for outdoor storage with eight-foot fence in front yard for ACE Hardware, subject to commitments. Approved 5-0. Notable Discussion Items & Votes - 2018-DV1-055 (6113 Bluff Crest Court): Variance for 24-foot tall pole barn with reduced side setback. Petitioner amended to reduce height and attached garage. Staff opposed citing no practical difficulty. Board approved 4-1 (McKay dissenting); continued for revised findings. - 2019-UV3-003 (1813 Morris Street): Variance to allow 8-bed group home for recovering addicts (amended from 12 beds). Petitioner Philip Anderson expressed support; remonstrators Margaret Harvey and Karen Young opposed, citing lack of regulation and neighborhood concerns. Staff recommended approval after amended plan of operation. Board approved 5-0; continued for findings. - 2018-DV1-047 (4565 North Park Avenue): Variance to legally establish fences in front yard and clear sight triangles. Petitioner sought to retain six-foot wood fence and four-foot wrought iron fence; staff recommended denial for the wrought iron fence due to safety. Board approved 3-2 (McKay and Bohanan dissenting). - 2018-UV1-045 (5101 West 38th Street): Temporary use variance for school bus parking (up to 130 buses) for Miller Transportation. Petitioner argued parking lot use permitted, but classified as fleet terminal. Remonstrator Catherine Bean (Eagledale Neighborhood Association) opposed citing noise, particulates, and property values. Staff recommended approval subject to commitments. Board approved 4-0 (one member absent); continued for findings. - 2019-UV1-003 (2750 South Meridian Street): Variance for beauty salon/barbershop in accessory building. Petitioner reduced employees to two. Staff noted if use space is under 600 sq ft it would comply with home occupation rules. Board continued to June 4, 2019 to allow petitioner to provide floor plan showing salon area under 600 sq ft. - 2019-SE1-005 (2805 South Lynnhurst Drive): Special exception for 155-foot monopole wireless communications tower on school campus. Petitioner Joe Calderon cited coverage gaps; remonstrator Carrie Moretti (SWAN) raised health concerns and property value decline. Staff recommended approval. Board approved 4-0. Key Outcomes - 17 cases granted continuances or withdrawals. - 8 expedited variances approved unanimously. - 4 regular variances approved: one with dissenting vote (2018-DV1-055), one with partial dissent (2018-DV1-047), two without dissent (2019-UV3-003, 2018-UV1-045). - 1 special exception approved (2019-SE1-005). - 1 case continued for compliance (2019-UV1-003). - Note: Board member departures after 3:00 PM reduced voting quorum to four members for later cases.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 3, convened on April 16, 2019, at 6:00 PM. Only two board members were present (Matthew Draving, acting chair, and Tony Boshinko), lacking the required quorum of three members to take action. As a result, all petitions on the agenda were continued to future hearing dates. The meeting consisted entirely of acknowledgments of continuances, transfers, and withdrawals. Administrative Continuances and Transfers - All petitions were continued to various future dates in May or June 2019, as requested by petitioners or staff, with no objections from staff. Specific continuances included: - 2019 DV 3011 (1230 Hoyt Ave): Continued to May 14, 2019 (Board 1). - 2019 DV 3012 (915 Dawson St): Continued to May 14, 2019 (Board 1). - 2019 DV 3014 (1211 & 1215 E 16th St): Transferred to Board 1 on May 14, 2019. - 2019 UV 3001 (5900-5954 W Minnesota St): Transferred to Board 1 on May 14, 2019. - 2019 UV 3004 (1007 E 86th St): Continued to May 28, 2019 (Division 3). - 2019 UV 3005 (8902 S Meridian St): Transferred to Division 1 on May 14, 2019. - 2018 DV 1044 (2729 Madison Ave): Continued to May 28, 2019 (Division 3). - 2018 DV 3056 (3615 White Cedar Ct): Continued to May 28, 2019 (Division 3). - 2019 DV 3005, 3006, 3007 (1538, 1540, 1544 Ringgold Ave): Transferred to Board 1 on May 14, 2019. - 2019 DV 3008 (7307 Holiday Dr W): Transferred to Board 2 on May 21, 2019. - 2019 MO3001 (264 N Rural St): Automatic continuance acknowledged to May 28, 2019. - 2019 DV 3009 (429 E Morris St): Withdrawn by petitioner; continued to May 14, 2019, for consideration of a fee refund. - 2019 DV 3010 (1301 E Market St): Automatic continuance to May 28, 2019. - 2019 DV 3013 (7645 W 96th St): Continued to May 28, 2019. - 2019 UV 3003 (1813 W Morris St): Continued to May 14, 2019. Key Outcomes - No decisions or votes were made on the merits of any petition due to the lack of a quorum. - All petitions were either continued, transferred to other divisions, or withdrawn (with one withdrawal pending a fee refund hearing). - The meeting was adjourned after all continuances were acknowledged.
The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two convened on April 9, 2019, with Chairperson Mark Young presiding and board members Alicia Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke present. The board addressed a withdrawal, two continuances, and an automatic continuance acknowledgment. No public testimony was offered. All actions passed without opposition. Consent Calendar / Administrative Actions - Case 2018 UV 2025 (2940 Cold Spring Road): Marion University, through representative Roger Kilmer of Ice Miller, requested withdrawal of its variance petition because the university now intends to pursue a rezoning. The board approved the withdrawal and authorized transfer of the already-paid variance filing fee to apply to the future rezoning filing fee. Staff supported the request. - Case 2019 UV 2005 (6158 West 10th Street): The board continued this petition to the May 21, 2019 hearing to allow time for proper notice. The motion included additional notice. - Case 2019 UV 2001 (1151 West Thompson Road): At the petitioner's request, the board continued this case to the May 21, 2019 hearing without additional notice. - Case 2019 DV 2003 (1140 Ohio Street): The board acknowledged a timely automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood association. Other Business - Board members were reminded to update and submit their ethics disclosure slips by May 1, 2019. Public Comments - No members of the public provided testimony or expressed interest in the cases heard.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1, chaired by Joanna Taft, convened on April 2, 2019, at 6:15 PM to hear multiple petitions for variances and special exceptions. The meeting covered continuances, expedited approvals, and contested hearings, resulting in several approvals, one denial, and multiple continuances. Consent Calendar - 2019 SE 1004 (813 & 819 West 27th St) – Special exception for parking lot for existing religious use. Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019 DV 1009 (8855 South Emerson Ave) – Variance for drive-through service unit. Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019 DV 1012 (717 Orange St) – Variance for single-family dwelling addition. Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 UV 1024 (amended) (810, 814, 818 South State Ave) – Variance for three single-family dwellings. Approved unanimously (5-0); continued for revised findings. - 2019 SE 1003 (4040 East Thompson Rd) – Special exception for wireless communication facility. Approved unanimously (5-0) with commitment to remain outside stream protection corridor. - 2019 DV 1008 (714 & 718 Cottage Ave) – As amended to 54% open space, variance approved unanimously (5-0). - 2019 UV 1005 (2903 Kentucky Ave) – Variance for outdoor freezer storage. Approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Janice McCartney (2122 De Bello Court) – Remonstrator against 2019 SE 1002 (parking lot for Blended Church at 8240 West 21st St). Raised concerns about drainage, traffic safety, prior code violations, noise, and privacy. Argued that the church has available parking and alternative options (e.g., satellite location). - Melissa Green (2927 South Rowena St) – Spoke in support of 2019 SE 1002, noting overcrowding on Sundays and need for overflow parking. - Scott and Helen Middleton (1530 West Roach St) – Petitioners for 2019 DV 1011 (deck addition). Explained deck was built without permit due to ignorance, and they are willing to modify it. Submitted letters of support from neighbors. - Delva Rodriguez (2750 South Meridian St) – Petitioner for 2019 UV 1003 (beauty salon in accessory building). Her daughter translated; proposed limited hours and appointments. Staff recommended denial due to commercial intensity in residential zone. - Kenneth Majors – Petitioner for 2019 DV 1010 (2212 Woodlawn Ave, additions to dwelling). Explained need for master suite for disabled veteran. Staff split recommendation: approve setbacks but deny open space reduction. Discussion Items - 2019 SE 1002 (8240 West 21st St, church parking lot) – Petitioner David King presented site plan for 76-space lot with landscaping, low-level lighting, and pathway to church. Pastor Daner Moyer testified to need (average attendance 900-1,000). Remonstrator Janice McCartney objected on drainage, traffic, and prior violations. Staff recommended approval subject to two commitments (site plan and trail easement). Petitioner offered three additional commitments: lot used only for parking, gate on 21st St (open Sundays only), and removal of parking if church vacates. After debate about gate compatibility with trail, board voted 3-2 to approve (Von Dalen, Bohannon, Hanscom yes; Taft, Robinson no). Continued for findings. - 2019 DV 1011 (1530 West Roach St, deck addition) – Extensive discussion on feasibility of compliance via lowering deck to under 18 inches and raising retaining wall. Staff maintained that setbacks still require variance. Petitioner did not withdraw. Motion to vote on original request passed; board denied unanimously (0-5), making petitioner ineligible to reapply for one year unless design changes materially. Continued for findings. - 2019 DV 1010 (2212 Woodlawn Ave) – Petitioner Kenneth Majors proposed expansion to 51% open space. Staff recommended approval of setbacks but denial of open space reduction, citing alternative design possibilities. Board suggested continuance to allow petitioner to work with staff. Continued to May 14, 2019. - 2019 UV 1003 (2750 South Meridian St, beauty salon) – Staff recommended denial due to commercial nature in residential zone, but petitioner offered to reduce to one employee (owner). Board continued to May 14, 2019, to explore options with staff. - Various continuances and transfers: - 2018 UV 1025 continued to May 14. - 2018 UV 1045 continued to May 14. - 2018 DV 1044 continued and transferred to Board 3 on April 16. - 2018 DV 1055 continued to May 14. - 2019 UV 1004 continued to May 14 with new notice. - 2019 UV 1006 automatically continued to May 14. - 2019 UV 2003 withdrawn. Key Outcomes - Approved (5-0): 2019 SE 1004, 2019 DV 1009, 2019 DV 1012, 2018 UV 1024, 2019 SE 1003, 2019 DV 1008, 2019 UV 1005. - Approved (3-2): 2019 SE 1002 (church parking lot) with five commitments. - Denied (0-5): 2019 DV 1011 (deck at 1530 West Roach St). - Continued to May 14, 2019: 2018 UV 1025, 2018 UV 1045, 2018 DV 1055, 2019 UV 1004, 2019 UV 1006, 2019 DV 1010, 2019 UV 1003. - Continued and transferred: 2018 DV 1044 to Board 3 on April 16, 2019. - Withdrawn: 2019 UV 2003.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on March 19, 2019 at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The board heard several continuance requests, one expedited petition, a corrected petition, and multiple variance petitions. Key actions included approving a waiver of the refiling rule for a hardware store in a shopping center, approving a banner signage variance for the Old Southside neighborhood, approving a church sign variance with a condition, and approving a residential fence variance with a condition to move the fence. Several petitions were continued to future hearing dates. Continuances - 2018-DV3-055 (245 North Delaware Street, Wheeler Mission Ministries): Continued to May 28, 2019 hearing without notice, pending receipt of revised elevations from the architect. - 2019-UV3-001 (5900-5954 West Minnesota Street, Indianapolis Airport Authority): Continued to April 16, 2019 hearing without notice, upon request of Councilor Jarrett Evans due to ongoing discussions. The petitioner expressed disappointment but did not object. - 2018-DV3-056 (3615 White Cedar Court, Irma Hernandez): Continued to April 16, 2019 hearing without notice, to allow additional time to amend the petition and contact an out-of-state adjacent property owner. - 2019-DV3-008 (7307 Holliday Drive West, Andrew Thompson): Continued to April 16, 2019 hearing without notice, to allow submission of revised fence drawings addressing clear sight triangle concerns. - 2019-DV3-005, 2019-DV3-006, 2019-DV3-007 (1538, 1540, 1544 Ringgold Avenue, Sahar Montalvo et al.): Automatically continued to April 16, 2019 hearing due to a timely continuance filed by a registered neighborhood organization. Public Comments & Testimony - Amber Cleveland (8821 Classic View Drive): Questioned the address on the notice for petition 2019-AP3-001, noting a discrepancy between 8902 South Meridian Street (tax parcel) and 8914 (mailing address). Petitioner clarified they are the same parcel. She expressed support for the petition. - Tara Sumner (petitioner for 5402 Lobo Drive): Gave emotional testimony about needing a six-foot fence to contain her dog, which could climb the existing 3.5-foot fence. She stated she had tried various containment methods and that moving the fence would be costly and result in having to rehome the dog. - Tina Sumner (3322 Tupelo Drive, mother of petitioner): Commented that many other fences in the neighborhood are similar to the subject fence, but only this one was reported. - Bobby Winter (petitioner for 4103 South Lynhurst Drive): Argued that the sign is needed to identify the church and advertise activities, and that the community approved it. He committed to not lighting the sign. Discussion Items Expedited Petition: 2019-AP3-001 – Waiver of Refiling Rule (8902 South Meridian Street) - Petitioner: Adam Law, on behalf of Village Plaza Properties LLC, requested a waiver to allow a variance of use and development standards for an Ace Hardware with outdoor storage, after a prior variance for a catering business with smokers was denied in 2018. The proposed use is in a different building on the same parcel. - Staff: Recommended approval, noting the prior petition was for a different use and building. - Action: The board unanimously approved the waiver (5-0). The board also granted a separate waiver of the 35-day filing rule to allow the underlying variance to be heard at the April 16, 2019 hearing. Corrected Petition: 2018-DV2-052 – 1230 South Talbot Street - Petitioner: Austin Aynes requested a variance to correct open space and setback issues for a rear addition and detached garage. - Staff: No additional comments. - Action: Approved unanimously (5-0). Variance: 2019-UV3-002 – Old Southside Neighborhood Banners - Petitioner: Jedadiah Fuller, Vice President of the Old Southside Neighborhood Association, requested a variance to install 30x46-inch banners on utility poles as public signs in protected districts, to increase neighborhood visibility. - Staff: Recommended approval, noting that signs are pedestrian-friendly and similar to those in other neighborhoods. - Action: Approved unanimously (5-0). Variance: 2018-DV3-057 – 4103 South Lynhurst Drive Church Sign - Petitioner: Bobby and Renata Winter requested a variance for a 7.5-foot tall, 32-square foot pole sign with reduced setbacks, clearance, and proximity to a protected district. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing commercialization of a residential area and availability of alternative signage (e.g., ground sign). - Petitioner: Argued the sign was already purchased and needed for visibility; committed to not illuminating the sign and provided letters of support from the Decatur Civic Council. - Action: Approved 4-1 (Board member Govea voted no) with a condition that the petitioner file a written commitment not to light the sign, to be recorded with the Marion County Recorder's Office. Variance: 2019-DV3-003 – 5402 Lobo Drive Fence - Petitioner: Tara Sumner requested a variance to legalize a six-foot tall privacy fence in the front yard on a corner lot. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing safety concerns for pedestrians, inconsistency with residential character, and availability of alternative containment for the dog. - Petitioner: Argued necessity to contain a dog that climbs the existing fence, and that the fence is high quality and consistent with other fences in the neighborhood. Neighbor testimony noted other similar fences were not cited. - Action: Approved unanimously (5-0) with a condition that the petitioner move the fence along Straw Hat Drive back 15 feet from the edge of the sidewalk, to be memorialized in a recorded commitment. Key Outcomes - Approved waiver of refiling rule and 35-day filing rule for 2019-AP3-001 (Ace Hardware at 8902 South Meridian Street). - Approved corrected petition 2018-DV2-052 (1230 South Talbot Street). - Approved banner variance 2019-UV3-002 (Old Southside Neighborhood Association). - Approved church sign variance 2018-DV3-057 (4103 South Lynhurst Drive) with commitment not to light. - Approved fence variance 2019-DV3-003 (5402 Lobo Drive) with condition to move fence 15 feet from sidewalk. - Several petitions continued to April 16, 2019 or May 28, 2019 hearings. - Board adopted revised findings of fact for 2019-DV3-001 and negative findings of fact for 2018-DV3-002.