Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 921–930 ENTRIES
921
DEC 4, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - December 4, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on December 4, 2018, to hear and decide on several petitions for variances of development standards and use. The Board acted on five petitions, including three expedited matters approved unanimously, and two new petitions that involved public testimony and split votes. One petition was continued to a future hearing. All decisions were based on staff recommendations, petitioner presentations, and public input. Consent Calendar - 2018-DV1-048 – 925 East Pleasant Run Parkway, South Drive: Approved unanimously (5-0) to provide for an accessory garage with a one-foot rear setback and 37% open space (required: five-foot rear, 60% open space). Staff recommended approval. - 2018-DV1-049 – 7202 North Keystone Avenue: Approved unanimously (5-0) to replace an existing freestanding sign with a four-foot tall ground sign encroaching approximately eight feet into the right-of-way, being within 115 and 215 feet of two existing signs, and being the third sign on a 270-foot frontage. Staff recommended approval. - 2018-DV1-052 – 7151 Marsh Road: Approved unanimously (5-0) for a 195-foot front setback (maximum 85 feet permitted), subject to a commitment to connect the proposed sidewalk to an off-site sidewalk to the north. Staff recommended approval; a neighborhood representative voiced concerns about tree line and mounding but withdrew after discussion with the petitioner. Public Comments & Testimony - Lori Clark (6311 Yearling Run, 46278) – Expressed concern that the proposed development for 2018-DV1-052 would affect trees and a mound on the north property line. After a hallway discussion with the petitioner, she stated she was satisfied as long as the trees and mound were not disturbed. - Kylie Hofsteder (1906 Commerce Avenue) – Remonstrated against 2018-DV1-051. She stated that while she liked her neighbors, the carport construction had started without prior consultation, removed a section of privacy fencing, lacked a gutter (causing water runoff onto her property), and was painted a different color from the garage. She requested that the carport be moved inward, a gutter installed, the structure painted to match, and confirmation that her property’s future use would not be affected. - Robert Oliver (828 East Minnesota Street) – Remonstrated briefly for 2018-DV1-053, initially concerned about a half-foot east setback affecting his property. After clarification that the setback referenced the existing house and not the garage, he stated he had no problem with the garage. Discussion Items - 2018-DV1-050 – 701 Parkway Avenue: The petitioner, through representative Jason Burke, agreed to staff’s conditional recommendation to reduce the garage to 20×20 feet, remove the breezeway, and meet detached garage setbacks, but disputed the staff-calculated open space percentage (37% vs. petitioner’s 32%). Staff requested a continuance to review the math. The Board granted a continuance to the next hearing. - 2018-DV1-051 – 1910 Commerce Avenue: Petitioner Anthony Jones argued that a zero-foot side setback for a carport was necessary to allow vehicle access from the alley. Staff recommended approval of the dwelling’s two-foot west side setback but denial of the carport, citing the need for trespass onto the adjacent property to maintain the structure, potential stormwater issues, and the existence of a two-car garage. The remonstrator detailed her concerns. The Board voted 4-1 to deny the carport variance (one member voted in favor) and continued the case for adoption of findings. - 2018-DV1-053 – 824 East Minnesota Street: Petitioner’s representative Jason Burke argued that the garage was an existing structure (dating to at least 1956) that had been repaired, not rebuilt, and should be treated as legal non-conforming. Staff countered that the removal of walls constituted new construction requiring compliance with current setbacks and clear sight triangle standards. The Board split the vote: Part A (legally establish the dwelling with 3.5-foot front, 2-foot west, 0.5-foot east setbacks) was approved 5-0. Part B (the garage with 0.4-foot west and north rear setbacks, 2-foot east setback, 31% open space, encroaching into the clear sight triangle) was also approved 5-0, overruling staff’s denial recommendation. Key Outcomes - Approved (unanimous): 2018-DV1-048, 2018-DV1-049, 2018-DV1-052 (all expedited). - Denied and continued for findings: 2018-DV1-051 (carport variance denied 4-1; dwelling setback approved). - Approved (split vote): 2018-DV1-053 – Part A (dwelling) approved 5-0; Part B (garage) approved 5-0. - Continued to next hearing: 2018-DV1-050, to allow staff to review open space calculations and for the petitioner to submit an updated site plan. - The Board also noted that the two-thirds rule for demolition (per Chapter 740, Article 6) applies when a structure is voluntarily removed; natural disaster may allow rebuild to original dimensions. Staff advised that the demolition rule is enforced by the Bureau of Neighborhood Services.

ZONING AND LAND USE 42% · LAND USE REGULATION 22% · PROCEDURAL 11% · CODE ENFORCEMENT 9%
923
NOV 13, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two – November 13, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division Two, met on November 13, 2018, at 18:00 local time, chaired by Mark Young. The board heard several petitions for variances, special exceptions, and continuances. Key decisions included approval of a special exception for a crematorium, approval of multiple development standard variances, and a contentious denial of a use variance for a church’s housing ministry. Consent Calendar - 2018 SE 2002: Special exception for a crematorium at 2020 Montcalm Street (Washington Park Cemetery Association). Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2 036: Variance for commercial building at 1105 English Avenue (Lexington Place LLC). Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2 037: Variance for signs at multiple addresses (Buckingham Properties). Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2 045: Variance for single-family dwelling at 2314 Woodlawn Avenue (Randall Hubble). Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2 041: Variance for single-family dwelling at 755 Terrace Avenue (Benchmark Design Homes LLC). Approved unanimously (5-0). - Continuances: Several petitions were continued to December 11, 2018, or February 12, 2019, without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - 2018 UV 2017 (10th Street Baptist Church): David Hittle (NESCO Land Use Committee) opposed the expansion, citing poor living conditions, safety hazards, and violation history. James Taylor (John Bonner Neighborhood Center) described appalling conditions during a tour, including missing smoke detectors and blocked stairwells. Joe Bowling (Inglewood CDC) questioned the claim that commercial space was unviable without adequate marketing. Tim Harmon (business owner) testified about unsanitary conditions inside the 970 Olney house. Chris Staub (Rivley Park Neighborhood) detailed the initial complaint and noted 17 police calls to one address. Natalie Waite (Near East Side Association of Tenants) opposed the use but supported decent housing. Remonstrators urged denial of the expansion. Discussion Items - 2018 UV 2017: Petitioner David Rutherford argued that the variance was necessary to legally establish housing for men in a ministry, emphasizing that the properties were previously vacant and that the ministry had improved them. He noted that staff recommended approval with conditions, including caps on residents. The board debated the living conditions and the petitioner’s history of violations. Ultimately, the board voted 2-3 to deny the variance. - 2018 UV 2023 (Hector Lozano): Petitioner Jason Burke presented a case for adding a second-floor residence and expanding storage at a contractor’s site. He argued that the business had grown and that the expansion would not negatively impact neighbors. Staff recommended denial, citing conflict with the comprehensive plan and potential impacts on property values. The board approved the variance 4-1, with one member dissenting due to concerns about the modern design and storage. Key Outcomes - 2018 UV 2017 (10th Street Baptist Church): Denied (2-3). Votes: Duke (yes), Kelly (no), Young (yes), Reuter (no), Banning (no). The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2018 UV 2023 (Hector Lozano): Approved (4-1). Votes: Banning (no), Duke (yes), Kelly (yes), Young (yes), Reuter (yes). - Other variances: All unanimously approved. - Continuances: 2018 DV2 028 (North College Ave) continued to Dec 11; 2018 DV2 044 (1221 N Bevel Ave) continued to Dec 11; 2018 DV2 045 (2314 Woodlawn) waiver of notice granted; 2018 DV2 042 (401 Parkway Ave) continued to Dec 11 with notice; 2018 DV2 034 (1102 & 1108 Fletcher Ave) continued to Dec 11 without notice; 2018 DV2 043 (1329 Marlowe Ave) continued to Dec 11 without notice; 2018 DV2 026B (3155 Bonham Dr) continued to Feb 12, 2019, month-to-month without notice. - Withdrawal: The development standards variance (sign) portion of 2018 UV 2017 was formally withdrawn.

ZONING AND LAND USE 54% · PROCEDURAL 12% · HOMELESSNESS 9% · LAND USE REGULATION 8%
924
NOV 8, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - November 8, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on November 8, 2018, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Acting Chair Craig E. Von Dalen presided over a four-member board (Roderick Bohanan, Matthew Draving, Rahani Napoleon) with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz. Due to the four-member panel, a majority of three votes was required for approval. The board heard a mix of expedited and regular petitions, granted multiple continuances, approved several variance requests, denied one, and saw one petition automatically continued due to a tie vote. Consent Calendar - Continuances Granted: - 2017-SE2-002 (5532 N. High School Road): Petitioner requested continuance to meet with remonstrators; continued to December 4, 2018, with notice. - 2018-DV1-044 (2729 Madison Avenue): Continued to December 4, 2018, without notice, to revise site plan. - 2018-DV1-047 (4565 N. Park Avenue): Continued to December 4, 2018, without notice, to meet with neighborhood land use committee. - 2018-UV1-024 (810-818 S. State Avenue) and 2018-UV1-025 (802-808 S. State Avenue): Continued to December 4, 2018, without notice, pending verification of commercial building vacancy. - Withdrawal Acknowledged: 2018-DV1-035 (220 S. Girls School Road) was withdrawn by the petitioner. - Automatic Continuance: 2018-UV1-039 (1436-1442 E. 10th Street) was continued to December 4, 2018, due to a timely automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood organization. - Expedited Docket Transfer: 2018-DV1-040 (612-616 Stevens Street) was moved to the expedited docket at the petitioner's request, with staff recommending approval. Public Comments & Testimony - 2018-UV1-038 (6629 Massachusetts Avenue): Several remonstrators (Jeanette Craney, Juka, Angela Mendenhall, Wyona Zetterberg, Nathan Byrd, Alison Minton Hall) testified in opposition. They expressed concerns about noise from heavy equipment, loss of trees and privacy, water runoff changes, safety hazards from commercial trucks entering/exiting a busy road, potential for future commercial intensification, and the presence of gravel and lights indicating intended commercial use. They also noted that the property had been a wooded buffer and that the petitioner's cleanup claims conflicted with observed activities. A petition with signatures from nearby residents was submitted. - 2018-UV1-035 (7129 E. Thompson Road): No remonstrators appeared. The petitioner, Donald Pulley, testified in favor, stating the pest control business is home-based, chemicals are stored securely, and the sign and fence are intended to be landscaped and unobtrusive. - 2018-DV1-045 (724-728 E. 21st Street): No remonstrators appeared. Petitioner Luke Burrow argued for the need to maintain a functional family home size, noting that adjacent properties have similar open space percentages. - 2018-UV1-040 (6525 Ferguson Street): No remonstrators appeared. Petitioner Stacy Boggs testified in support, noting that nearby properties have front-yard parking and that the area is increasingly commercial. Sid Blazik, a real estate developer, also spoke in favor. Discussion Items - Expedited Petitions (Unanimously Approved): - 2018-AP1-002 (969 Elm Street): Waiver of refiling rule to allow a new development standards petition after a prior denial. Staff noted substantial changes to the site plan (50% open space, 5-foot side setbacks). Approved 4-0. - 2018-DV1-036 (1409 Orange Street): Variance to legalize and add to an existing dwelling with reduced setbacks. Staff noted consistency with neighborhood character. Approved 4-0. - 2018-DV1-042 (314 N. State Avenue): Variance for a single-family dwelling with a secondary dwelling unit and reduced front setback. Staff noted alignment with adjacent dwellings. Approved 4-0. - 2018-DV1-046 (5325 N. Delaware Street): Variance to replace an existing detached garage with a slightly larger one, with reduced side and rear setbacks. Staff noted the garage had existed since at least 1915. Approved 4-0. - 2018-UV1-034 (48 Palmer Street): Variance to legally establish single-family attached dwellings and add steps/landing to a multi-family building. Staff recommended approval with a commitment for concrete construction. Approved 4-0. - 2018-DV1-040 (612-616 Stevens Street): Variance for two single-family dwellings with reduced setbacks and open space. The petitioner amended the plan to 55% open space, 4-foot side setbacks, and 8-foot front setbacks, meeting staff conditions. Approved 4-0. - Regular Petitions: - 2018-UV1-035 (7129 E. Thompson Road): Request for a pest control business (use variance), illuminated sign, and 7-foot fence/piers. Staff recommended approval of the brick piers but denial of the use variance and sign/fence variances, citing concerns about chemical storage and commercial character. The board voted 3-1 to approve the entire request (Von Dalen dissenting). The petitioner agreed to reduce the fence to 6 feet. - 2018-DV1-045 (724-728 E. 21st Street): Variance for two dwellings with reduced open space (40% for 724) and side setback. Staff recommended approval of most items but denial of the 3-foot side setback and 40% open space, suggesting a reduction to 50% open space and a 4-foot side setback. The board split 2-2 (Von Dalen and Bohanan in favor; Draving and Napoleon opposed), resulting in an automatic continuance to December 4, 2018. - 2018-UV1-038 (6629 Massachusetts Avenue): Variance for outdoor storage of portable containers and commercial vehicles related to site cleanup. Staff recommended denial, citing the intense commercial nature, lack of appropriate setbacks, inconsistency with the comprehensive plan, and potential for permanent commercial use. The board voted unanimously (0-4) to deny. - 2018-UV1-040 (6525 Ferguson Street): Variance for a hair salon (use variance) and front-yard parking with reduced setbacks. The petitioner withdrew requests for variances related to handicapped and bicycle parking after providing a site plan showing compliance. Staff recommended denial of front-yard parking, citing the Broad Ripple plan's pedestrian-oriented goals and safety concerns. The board voted to approve (vote tally unclear from transcript, but meeting adjourned after approval). Key Outcomes - Approved (Expedited): 2018-AP1-002, 2018-DV1-036, 2018-DV1-042, 2018-DV1-046, 2018-UV1-034, 2018-DV1-040 – all granted 4-0. - Approved (Regular): 2018-UV1-035 (3-1), 2018-UV1-040 (majority vote, exact tally not recorded). - Denied: 2018-UV1-038 (0-4). - Continued: 2018-DV1-045 (2-2 tie, automatically continued to December 4, 2018); multiple other petitions continued as noted above. - Withdrawn: 2018-DV1-035. - Next Steps: Petitioners for approved variances must comply with any conditions and submit affidavits of compliance. The board will adopt findings of fact for the denial of 2018-UV1-038 at a future meeting.

ZONING AND LAND USE 59% · PROCEDURAL 13% · PARKING MANAGEMENT 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 5%
925
OCT 16, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Board of Zoning Appeals III Meeting – October 16, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, held a public hearing on October 16, 2018, to consider variance requests, continuances, and procedural waivers. Chair Craig E. Von Dalen presided with board members Matthew Draving, Carmen Leffig, and Kim Boyd. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board heard multiple expedited petitions, one contested variance request, and acted on several continuances to the November 20, 2018 hearing. Procedural Actions and Continuances - 2018-HOV-080 (5653 Brennan Way West Drive): Continued to November 20, 2018, after remonstrator Jacob Cox requested a continuance for cause, stating that the petitioner’s engineer report was dated September 26 and had just been received; petitioner’s counsel Alan Townsend opposed, but staff did not object. - 2018 UV 3023 (6654 West Washington Street): Removed a requested variance for zero bike parking spaces; the remaining petition moved to the expedited docket with staff support. - 2018 UV 3022 (2441 Production Drive): Moved to the expedited docket after an amended plan of operation was submitted and staff withdrew opposition. - 2018 DV 3049 (6116 Guilford Avenue): Continued to November 20 without additional notice at petitioner’s request. - 2018 DV 2-004 (1335 Marlowe Avenue): Continued to November 20 without notice. - 2018 DV 3-038 (702 Sanders Street): Continued to November 20 with notice if needed for a petition amendment. - 2018 UV 3-024 (5201 South Harding Street): Granted a three-day waiver of the legal notice requirement; adjacent neighbor Bill Runyon raised no objection. - 2018 UV 3019 (726 East McCarty Street): Continued to November 20 without notice at staff’s request. - 2017 UV 3024 (7960 West Washington Street): Continued to November 20 without notice. - 2018 DV 3-047 (7947 Elm Street): Acknowledged automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood association. Expedited Petitions - 2018 DV 3-048 (915 Jefferson Avenue): Approved 4–0. Variance of development standards to allow a 22-by-22 detached garage, 50% open space (60% required), and a 15-foot front setback (18 feet required), and to legally establish a single-family dwelling. - 2018 UV 3020 (1129 East 16th Street): Approved 3–0 after a board member recused. Variance of use to allow office uses not permitted in an I-3 industrial zone as the first phase of redeveloping an IPS building maintenance facility. - 2018 UV 3021 (2425 East New York Street): Approved 4–0. Variance of use to allow a coffee shop and grocery store in a former church building for Outreach Inc., which serves homeless youth and plans to create employment opportunities. The NESCO land use committee was supportive. - 2018 UV 3023 (6654 West Washington Street): Approved 4–0 as amended. Variance of use and development standards for a commercial battery center with retail, wholesale, and delivery center, including reduced setbacks and parking in the front yard, subject to staff report commitments. Petitioner said it would consolidate locations from Plainfield and Greenwood and bring jobs to Marion County; Councillor Jarrett Evans supported. - 2018 UV 3022 (2441 Production Drive): Approved 4–0. Variance of use for an accessory apartment for the business owner and variance of development standards for a warehouse addition with an 11-foot side setback (30 feet required), subject to an amended plan of operation filed October 16 and a recorded access easement. Contested Case - 2018 UV 3024 (5201 South Harding Street): Denied 0–4 and continued for findings of fact. The petitioner sought variances to operate a transport company office and to park tractor trailers with reduced setbacks and no transitional yard. Remonstrators Bill Runyon and Floyd Burdone cited safety hazards, nighttime truck idling, diesel fumes, and a fence struck by trucks; staff recommended denial, finding the proposed use conflicted with the comprehensive plan and would harm the protected DA district. The petitioner disputed claims about the fence and trucks. Key Outcomes - 5 variances approved (four by unanimous vote; one 3–0 after recusal). - 1 variance denied (2018 UV 3024) with negative findings to be adopted. - 9 continuances granted, mostly to the November 20, 2018 hearing. - The board noted only four members were present, so a majority of three votes was required for approval. - At the conclusion of the hearing, staff presented negative findings for adoption; the transcript labels the petition as 2018 UV 3018, which may be a transcription error for the denied case 2018 UV 3024.

ZONING AND LAND USE 77% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC SAFETY 3% · HOMELESSNESS 2%
926
OCT 9, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two Meeting - October 9, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two, chaired by Mark Young, held a public hearing on October 9, 2018, to consider several variance requests and continuances. The board voted on multiple petitions, including approvals and denials, and continued several cases to future dates. Continuances and Procedural Motions - 2018 DV2028 (2019-2029 N College Ave) continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing without additional notice. - 2018 DV2034 (1102-1108 Fletcher Ave) continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing without additional notice. - 2018 DV2036 (1105 English Ave) continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing with additional notice due to amendments. - 2018 DV2037 (231 Virginia Ave, 336 S Delaware St, 302-322 E Louisiana St, 230 S Alabama St, 237 S Delaware St) continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing without additional notice. - 2018 UV2023 (8438 Crawfordsville Rd) continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing with additional notice. - 2018 UV2021 (1318 N Capitol Ave) was moved to the expedited docket and later heard. - The garage portion of 2018 DV2026 (3155 Bonham Dr) was continued to the November 13, 2018 hearing without additional notice to allow the petitioner to seek an encroachment permit from the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services. Public Comments & Testimony - Glenda Arieta (petitioner, resident of 525 N Temple Ave) spoke in favor of retaining a 47-inch tall opaque fence in the front yard and a 10-foot tall fence in the side and rear yards, citing the need to safeguard her 16 dogs, neighbors, and herself. She stated that animals had jumped over the fence in the past and that Animal Care Control had no issues with her current setup. - David Legg (remonstrator, resident of 3172 N Centennial Ave) opposed the variances at 3155 Bonham Dr, raising concerns about stormwater runoff from proposed paving that could flood neighboring properties, the fence enclosing a utility pole (hindering access for repairs), and the garage being constructed without proper permits. He also disputed the petitioner's claim that he lived directly behind the property. - Jacob Nelson (petitioner, resident of 2222 N Delaware St) presented his case for additions at 2230 N Delaware St, emphasizing that the current 1,500 sq ft, two-bedroom home is one of the last on the block unrenovated. He argued that building to the front and south side was the only viable option due to roof lines, interior space constraints, and the need for a usable backyard. He provided letters of support from all surrounding neighbors and the Fall Creek Place HOA, and cited two prior variances (2002 DV3029 and 2006 CVR 814) that granted similar setbacks in the neighborhood. Discussion Items - 2018 UV2022 (2240 N Meridian St): David Kingan represented the petitioner (AEP Charter Meridian LLC) for a variance of use to convert a recently constructed charter school building into office use for a nonprofit. No initial building changes were planned, and the petitioner agreed to file a regional center petition for any exterior improvements. Staff had no additional comments. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2022 (525 N Temple Ave): Glenda Arieta requested variances to keep a 47-inch opaque brick fence in the front yard and a 10-foot tall fence in the side and rear yards. Staff recommended denial, stating that the fence height violated ordinance standards and that no practical difficulty existed; suggested alternatives like landscape plantings or electric fencing. The board split the request: Part A (front yard fence) was approved 5-0, and Part B (side/rear fence) was denied 0-5. Findings of fact will be adopted. - 2018 UV2021 (1318 N Capitol Ave): Jeff Cowser and Andy Bulla of Indy Brew Bus LLC requested a variance of use to allow a bar/tasting room in an existing automotive garage. Staff had recommended commitments, including submission of a regional center petition for a dumpster enclosure within 60 days. The petitioner agreed to all commitments. The board approved the variance unanimously (5-0). - 2018 DV2026 (3155 Bonham Dr): Antonio Lisenby requested variances for a detached garage with a three-foot rear setback (five feet required) and two-foot encroachment into a utility easement, plus an eight-foot fence in the utility easement and a seven-foot side yard fence (six feet maximum). Staff recommended denial, citing the lack of permits, utility access issues, and the compound aesthetic of tall fences. Neighbor David Legg remonstrated against the drainage and utility pole concerns. The board continued the garage portion to November 13 for an encroachment permit review, then voted on the fence portion separately. The fence variance was denied 0-5. Findings of fact will be adopted. - 2018 DV2033 (2230 N Delaware St): Jacob Nelson requested variances for additions to a single-family home: a 10-foot front setback (18 feet required), a six-foot south side building separation (10 feet required), and to legally establish an existing two-foot north side setback and nine-foot building separation. Staff recommended approval for the existing north side deficiencies (pre-dating zoning) but denial for the new construction variances, arguing that the front setback reduction was a 44% deviation from the average block setback and that the south side separation would negatively impact adjacent properties. The board voted 3-2 (Young, Reuter, Banning in favor; Duke, Kelly opposed) to approve the entire petition, including the new construction variances. Key Outcomes - Approved: - 2018 UV2022 (2240 N Meridian St): Variance of use for office, approved 5-0. - 2018 DV2022 Part A (525 N Temple Ave): 47-inch front fence, approved 5-0. - 2018 UV2021 (1318 N Capitol Ave): Variance of use for bar/tasting room, approved 5-0. - 2018 DV2033 (2230 N Delaware St): Variances for additions including reduced front setback and south side building separation, approved 3-2. - Denied: - 2018 DV2022 Part B (525 N Temple Ave): 10-foot side/rear fence, denied 0-5. - 2018 DV2026 fence portion (3155 Bonham Dr): Fence variance, denied 0-5. - Continued: - Multiple cases continued to November 13, 2018 (see Continuances section). The garage portion of 2018 DV2026 continued to November 13 without additional notice. - Next Steps: Petitioners for denied cases may submit revised proposals; findings of fact will be adopted for 2018 DV2022, 2018 DV2026, and others as noted. The board also acknowledged negative findings of fact for petition 2018 DV2024, but no further action was taken.

ZONING AND LAND USE 50% · PROCEDURAL 28% · FENCE REGULATION 17% · UTILITY REGULATION 3%
927
OCT 2, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - October 2, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I met on October 2, 2018, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Peter Hanscom, Brian Robinson (first meeting), and alternate Brittany Solis. The board heard a mix of expedited, continued, and new petitions, addressing variances for residential additions, signs, commercial uses, and telecom facilities. Several petitions were continued due to lack of quorum late in the meeting. Votes and decisions are summarized below. Public Comments & Testimony - Susan Blair, President of the Pike Township Residents Association (PTRA), spoke in opposition to petition 2018-UV1-031 (tire store at 9150 N. Michigan Road). She argued that the area already has a high concentration of tire retailers (10 within 1.7 miles), that the Michigan Road Corridor Plan of 1998 discourages tire stores in that area, and that a restaurant would be a better use given the planned 180-room hotel nearby. She noted that the comprehensive plan update continues to recommend against auto-related uses in this corridor. - John Winter, representing the Bates-Hendricks Neighborhood Association land use task force, spoke in support of petition 2018-UV1-019B (garage in clear sight triangle), stating that the proposed garage is typical for the neighborhood and that shifting it would lose yard space without improving safety. Discussion Items Continuances and Transfers (all granted without objection unless noted) - 2018-UV1-024 (810-818 S. State Ave.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, to wait for IPL confirmation on a neighboring vacant parcel. - 2018-UV1-025 (802-808 S. State Ave.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, same reason. - 2018-UV1-034 (48 Palmer St.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, while petitioner works with staff. - 2017-SE2-002 (5532 N. High School Rd.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, at petitioner’s request for ongoing discussions with remonstrators. - 2018-DV1-036 (1409 Orange St.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, to allow time for proper notice. - 2018-DV1-040 (612-616 Stevens St.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, at remonstrators’ request (agreed by petitioner). - 2018-HOV-080 (5653 Brendon Way W. Dr.) – Transferred to Board 3 on October 16, 2018, by petitioner’s request. Expedited Petitions (all approved unanimously 4-0) - 2018-DV1-037 (1007 Lexington Ave.) – Variance for additions to existing dwelling and detached garage with reduced setbacks and 40% open space. Staff recommended approval; no remonstrators. - 2018-DV1-038 (1152 Hoyt Ave.) – Variance to legalize 8-foot front setback, 3-foot building separation, and 54% open space for a 1900-era dwelling. Supported by Fountain Square Neighborhood Association. - 2018-DV1-039 (3827 N. Mitthoefer Rd.) – Variance for a second freestanding sign within 110 feet of an existing sign. Updated elevations and findings addressed staff concerns. - 2018-DV1-041 (1719 Woodlawn Ave.) – Variance to build a new single-family home with 5-foot separation between dwellings (10 required). Condition: meet fire code. - 2018-UV1-036 (1414 Sadlier Cir. W. Dr.) – Variance of use for a fitness center in an I-1 district. Subject to site plan and plan of operation commitments. Supported by Warren Township Neighborhood Association. Other Petitions Heard - 2018-UV1-006 (3527 N. College Ave.) – Petitioner amended from 8 to 6 units; remonstrators absent after compromise. Board approved 4-0 with commitments that units be sold only to owner-occupants and that subsequent purchasers also cannot rent. The Mapleton Fall Creek CDC initially opposed but later supported the compromise. - 2018-UV1-019B (1620 S. East St.) – Variance for a three-car garage within the clear sight triangle of two alleys. Staff recommended denial, citing safety hazards. Petitioner argued the garage is typical for the neighborhood and the adjacent triplex (approved by MDC) needs parking. Board rejected staff’s position and approved 4-0. - 2018-UV1-031 (9150 N. Michigan Rd.) – Request for a tire store (use variance) and a building height variance. Petitioner withdrew the height variance. Staff supported the use variance. PTRA opposed based on over‑saturation and the 1998 corridor plan. Board approved 4-0, subject to the plan of operation without outside storage. - 2018-UV1-023 (5651 S. Harding St.) – Split into two votes: - Part A (use variance for auto body shop): Approved 4-0, subject to the plan of operation. Staff had recommended denial, citing intensity incompatibility with I-2 district, but board accepted petitioner’s arguments about contained operations and landscaping buffers. - Part B (development standards variance for gravel parking lot): Denied 1-3 (only Solis voted yes). Staff argued owner-created hardship; petitioner cited cost. - 2018-UV1-032 (1040 N. Post Rd.) – Variance for a 90-foot monopole wireless tower. Staff recommended denial, citing no camouflage and previous denials. Petitioner noted 124 signatures of support and no remonstrators. Board approved 3-0 with commitments to expand landscaping (from 16 to 32 plantings and 10-foot wide yard). - 2018-DV1-035 (220 S. Girls School Rd.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, after losing quorum. Petitioner expressed frustration but agreed to the continuance. - 2018-UV1-035 (7129 E. Thompson Rd.) – Continued to November 8, 2018, also due to lost quorum. Key Outcomes - Approved (4-0): 2018-DV1-037, 2018-DV1-038, 2018-DV1-039, 2018-DV1-041, 2018-UV1-036, 2018-UV1-006 (with owner-occupancy commitments), 2018-UV1-019B, 2018-UV1-031 (with plan of operation), 2018-UV1-023 Part A. - Approved (3-0): 2018-UV1-032 (with landscaping commitments). - Denied (1-3): 2018-UV1-023 Part B (gravel parking lot). - Continued to November 8, 2018: 2018-UV1-024, -025, -034, 2017-SE2-002, 2018-DV1-035, -036, -040, 2018-UV1-035. - Transferred to Board 3: 2018-HOV-080. - Meeting adjourned early due to loss of quorum after 3:48 p.m. when board members left.

ZONING AND LAND USE 49% · PROCEDURAL 15% · LAND USE REGULATION 9% · CELL TOWER REGULATION 7%
928
SEP 18, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Board of Zoning Appeals III Meeting Summary - September 18, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III convened on September 18, 2018, at 6:15 PM to hear zoning variance requests, use variances, and other petitions. The board approved several variance requests, denied one use variance, and continued or withdrew others. Public testimony was heard on several cases, including concerns from neighborhood associations and adjacent property owners.

ZONING AND LAND USE 65% · PROCEDURAL 14% · FIRE SAFETY 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 4%
929
SEP 11, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting - September 11, 2018

This is a summary of the Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals meeting held on September 11, 2018. The meeting covered various zoning variance petitions, including continuances, expedited cases, and public hearings. Key actions included approving several variances, denying a duplex proposal, and continuing others for procedural reasons.

ZONING AND LAND USE 33% · SIGN REGULATION 29% · PROCEDURAL 15% · PUBLIC SAFETY 10%
930
SEP 4, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - September 4, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on September 4, 2018, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided with board members Clint McKay, Roderick Rohanan, Peter Hanscom, and Brian Robinson (joining late). The board heard several expedited and non-expedited petitions, addressing variances for residential development, signage, and use changes. Due to only four board members present for most of the meeting, tied votes resulted in automatic continuances. Expedited Petitions (Consent Calendar) - 2018-HOV-083: Approved unanimously (4-0). Variance for a single-family dwelling and detached garage at 1139 Fletcher Avenue with reduced separation (8 feet vs. 10 required) and front setback (10 feet vs. 18 required). Staff recommended approval. - 2018-DV1-032: Approved unanimously (4-0). Variance for a detached garage at 3116 North Park Avenue creating 45% open space (60% required). Staff recommended approval. - 2018-DV1-034: Approved unanimously (4-0). Variance for a pool, retaining wall, and structures at 3820 Nesbitt Road including reduced rear setback (10 ft vs. 25 ft), stream corridor encroachment (16 ft vs. 50 ft), and reduced side setback (13 ft vs. 15 ft). A letter of support from the Greater Allisonville Community Council was noted. Staff recommended approval. - 2018-UV1-030: Approved unanimously (4-0). Variance of use and development standards at 2018 Yandes Street to legally establish a single-family dwelling and garage in an I-3 district with deficient transitional setbacks. Staff recommended approval. Public Comments & Testimony - 2018-UV1-006 (3527 N College Ave): Remonstrators Nathan Abbott (3536 Carrollton Ave), Logan Wector (3556 Carrollton Ave), and Gil Amram (3548 Carrollton Ave) opposed the variance for an eight-unit condo building, citing concerns about overdevelopment, precedent, neighborhood character, and enforcement issues. The Mapleton Fall Creek Community Development Corporation submitted a letter of opposition. Petitioner David Dearing argued the building historically had eight units and that the condo project would be a quality restoration. - 2018-UV1-012 (3760 Cold Spring Rd): No remonstrators appeared. Petitioner Tim Ochs (Marian University) argued the site's unique location as an island near I-65 made it unsuitable for permitted uses; the proposed off-premise stone sign would serve as a campus front door. - 2018-UV1-019B (1620 S East St): No remonstrators. Petitioner Jason Wolfe argued the garage placement in the alley clear sight triangle matched existing patterns and preserved a mature tree. Discussion Items - 2018-DV1-015 (7073 W Washington St): Petitioner Family Express sought a variance for an electronic variable message wall sign (33.88 sq ft, 100% EVMS) within 330 feet of a protected district (600 ft required). Petitioner argued the sign was reduced from a previous denied proposal, included commitments (no blinking/ flashing, hours of operation), and was visually obstructed from most homes. Staff countered that the sign would be visible to several residences, enforcement of commitments was difficult, and no practical difficulty existed. No remonstrators appeared. - 2018-UV1-006 (3527 N College Ave): Continued from prior hearings. Petitioner Wallvan Investments sought a use variance for eight residential units in a D-5 district where only single- and two-family dwellings are permitted. Staff recommended approval citing historic eight-unit use since at least 1961, though currently vacant. Remonstrators opposed, arguing density (32 units per acre vs. plan recommendation of 8-15) and precedent for nearby illegal operations. - 2018-UV1-012 (3760 Cold Spring Rd): Marian University requested a use variance for two 10-foot tall, 196 sq ft off-premise signs on a 1.19-acre vacant MU-1-zoned property. Staff recommended denial because the signs would be within 135 feet of a protected district (300 ft required), the property could be developed for permitted office use, and directional signage from INDOT was possible. Petitioner emphasized the site's unique odd shape and lack of frontage, and that the sign would be a campus landmark. - 2018-UV1-019B (1620 S East St): Petitioner Arthur Haan sought a variance to build a three-car detached garage within the clear sight triangle of two alleys. Staff recommended denial, citing safety hazards and that the need arose from the self-imposed desire to convert the property to multifamily use. Petitioner argued the garage was consistent with neighborhood patterns and that moving it would require removing a large tree. - 2018-DV1-030 (11650 Fox Rd) and 2018-DV1-033 (7250 E 75th St): Both petitions (Lawrence Township Schools seeking EVMS signs near protected districts) were transferred at petitioner's request to Board Two for hearing on September 11, 2018. No objections. Key Outcomes - Approvals: 2018-HOV-083, 2018-DV1-032, 2018-DV1-034, and 2018-UV1-030 were approved via expedited consent (all 4-0). - Denial: 2018-DV1-015 (Family Express EVMS sign) was denied by a vote of 1-3 (Hanscom yes; Taft, McKay, Bohannon no). The board will adopt findings of fact supporting denial. - Approved: 2018-UV1-012 (Marian University off-premise sign) was approved by a vote of 3-1 (Taft, Hanscom, Hannahan yes; McKay no). - Automatic Continuances: 2018-UV1-006 and 2018-UV1-019B each resulted in a 2-2 tie vote, continuing them to the October 2, 2018 hearing. - Transfers/Continuances: Several petitions were continued or transferred without objection: 2018-UV1-023 (to Oct 2), 2018-UV1-024 and 2018-UV1-025 (to Oct 2), 2017-SE2-002 (to Oct 2), 2018-UV1-033 (transferred to Division III for Sept 18), 2018-DV1-029 (withdrawn, fees transferred to a new petition), and 2018-UV1-031 and 2018-UV1-032 (acknowledged automatic continuances to Oct 2). - Waiver: A four-day waiver of legal notice was granted for 2018-UV1-019B.

ZONING AND LAND USE 38% · SIGN REGULATION 33% · PROCEDURAL 14% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 4%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com