Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 911–920 ENTRIES
911
MAR 12, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Indianapolis BZA Division 2 Hearing March 12, 2019: Continuances and Variance Approval

On March 12, 2019, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 convened a public hearing at 6:00 PM to consider zoning variance petitions. The board, chaired by Mark Young, addressed continuances for several cases and approved one variance. The hearing was recorded by Ron Hampton, with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz present. Continuances and Special Requests - 2019-UV2-001 (1151 West Thompson Road): Petitioner's attorney Paul Carroll requested a 30-day continuance to address staff concerns regarding floodplain and improvement locations. No objections were raised, and the board moved the petition to the April 9, 2019 hearing date without additional notice. - 2019-UV2-003 (552 Jefferson Street): Petitioner's attorney Christopher McAwee, newly retained, requested a continuance to April 2, 2019 (BZA Division 1), citing scheduling conflicts. Remonstrator Leona Kruska opposed, noting work had already commenced and expressing readiness to oppose. Staff noted potential inadequate time for new information but did not object. The board granted the continuance without additional notice. - 2018-DV2-052 (1230 South Talbot Street): No petitioner representative appeared. Staff recommended a one-month continuance for lack of prosecution. The board moved the case to the BZA Division 3 hearing on March 19, 2019, without additional notice. Discussion Items - 2019-UV2-004 (6173 North College Avenue): Mark and Kristen Dutton requested a variance of use and development standards to convert a 1,000-square-foot bungalow into a law office for Dutton Legal Group. The property required three off-street parking spaces, which were deemed deficient. Staff had no objections. The board approved the variance unanimously. Key Outcomes - Approved variance 2019-UV2-004 with five yes votes and zero no votes. - Granted continuances for 2019-UV2-001, 2019-UV2-003, and 2018-DV2-052 to specified future dates. - Directed that all continuances be without additional notice. Meeting adjourned after addressing these items.

ZONING AND LAND USE 56% · PROCEDURAL 44%
912
MAR 5, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - March 5, 2019

The Board of Zoning Appeals Division I met on March 5, 2019, at 6:15 PM with Chair Joanna Taft and members Roderick Bohanan, Peter Hanscom, and Brian Robinson (four members present). Legal counsel Leonette Pierce and staff from the Division of Planning were in attendance. The board heard several special requests, expedited cases, and regular docket items, including variances for a cell tower, a tattoo parlor, a duplex, and a garage. Consent Calendar - Withdrawals: Petition 2018-DV1-058 (withdrawn by petitioner); Petition 2019-DV1-001 (withdrawn). - Continuances: - 2019-SE-1001 (cell tower) – petitioner requested continuance due to new material; denied, case heard (see below). - 2018-UV-1024 – continued to April 2, 2019, without notice (staff no objection). - 2018-DV-1044 – continued to April 2, 2019, with new notice. - 2018-DV-1047 – continued to May 14, 2019, without notice (staff noted only one more continuance allowed). - 2018-UV-1045 – continued to April 2, 2019, due to lack of full board and remonstrator opposition. - 2019-SE-1002 – continued to April 2, 2019. - 2019-SE-1003 – continued to April 2, 2019. - 2018-DV-1055 – continued to April 2, 2019, without notice. - Waivers of Notice: - 2018-DV-1056 – six-day waiver granted. - 2018-DV-1061 – one-day waiver granted. Public Comments & Testimony - 2019-SE-1001 (cell tower): Richard Clayton (2416 E. Edgewood Ave) objected, arguing the Perry Township Multi-School Building Corporation lacked authority to lease land, that Verizon’s own insurance excludes radiofrequency pollution, and that alternative sites exist. Michael Thomas (2746 E. Edgewood Ave) raised property value concerns, citing a certified appraisal predicting 5–20% depreciation. - 2019-DV-1006 (tattoo parlor): Eric Hoagland (6202 Sheridan Ave) opposed, claiming he received no hearing notice, that the statute strictly requires 1,000-foot separation from residential districts, and that the proposed use would lower property values. He noted a prior attempt to place a tattoo parlor nearby and that he had vocally objected. - 2019-DV-1007 (fire-damage rebuild): Jen (2027 Wellcock St) opposed reconstruction, citing a fire in April 2018 that damaged over 20 homes because fire trucks could not navigate the narrow streets. She argued rebuilding would perpetuate fire risk. Discussion Items - 2019-SE-1001 – Verizon Wireless 130-foot monopole tower at 2215 Country Club Road (Perry Township school property): Petitioner David Pike presented expert reports on structural safety, radio frequency need (capacity overload in the area), and property valuation. Staff recommended approval, noting all local requirements met. Remonstrators challenged authority and need. Board approved 4-0. - 2018-UV-1045 – Bus company variance: Petitioner requested continuance due to only four board members and split neighborhood support. Remonstrators (Eagledale Neighborhood Association) objected, stating they had taken time off work. Board granted continuance to April 2, 2019. - 2018-DV-1061 – Garage variance at 606 Weghurst St: Petitioner Bob Abbott explained the garage was built inadvertently too close (1.5 ft side setback vs. 3 ft required). Neighbor Robert Roller and Bates Hendrix Neighborhood Association supported after agreement. Staff recommended denial citing drainage and maintenance concerns. Board approved 4-0. - 2018-UV-1048 – Duplex at 5670 N. College Ave: Petitioner Mark Demerley argued the lot (40 ft wide, 9,670 sq ft) is similar to nearby duplex lots and has neighborhood and councilwoman support. Staff recommended denial, citing lot width deficiency and open space reduction (65% vs. 70% required), and that a single-family dwelling could be built without variance. Board approved 3-1 (Bohanan dissented). - 2019-DV-1006 – Tattoo parlor at 6127 E. Washington St: Petitioner Brent Schlemmer described a private, appointment-only studio with low walk-in traffic, noting 20+ supporter signatures from within 1,000 ft. Staff recommended denial because lack of a tenant is not a practical difficulty. Board denied 1-3 (Bohanan voted yes; Hanscom, Robinson, Taft no). - 2019-DV-1007 – Rebuild of fire-damaged home at 2023 Wellcock St: Petitioner Amanda Fow Smith requested variance to rebuild on existing foundation with reduced side setbacks (6 ft and 7.5 ft vs. 10 ft required). Remonstrator Jen opposed due to fire safety and narrow streets. Staff recommended approval, noting the new footprint is smaller. Board approved 4-0 with condition of fire-rated walls. - Expedited Cases (approved unanimously): - 2018-DV-1056 (sunroom replacement with easement encroachment) – approved. - 2019-DV-1004 (signs for warehouse) – approved. - 2019-DV-1005 (432 sq ft dwelling with reduced setbacks) – approved. - 2018-DV-1057 (window signs and dumpster enclosure – withdrawn window sign portion) – approved. Key Outcomes - 2019-SE-1001 – Approved (4-0) for wireless communications tower with conditions. - 2018-DV-1061 – Approved (4-0) for garage setback variance. - 2018-UV-1048 – Approved (3-1) for duplex with reduced open space; board to adopt findings of fact. - 2019-DV-1006 – Denied (1-3) for tattoo parlor; board to adopt findings of fact. - 2019-DV-1007 – Approved (4-0) for fire-damage home rebuild with fire-rated wall condition. - All expedited cases approved as noted. - Several continuances granted as detailed above. - Board adjourned after approving findings of fact for previously continued cases.

ZONING AND LAND USE 33% · PROCEDURAL 22% · CELL TOWER REGULATION 16% · CANNABIS REGULATION 5%
913
FEB 19, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Public Hearing - February 19, 2019

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on February 19, 2019, at 6:15 PM. The meeting covered several continuances, expedited cases, and regular docket items. The board voted on multiple variance requests, with decisions ranging from approval to denial. Continuances - 2018 DV3061 (8800 Keystone Crossing): Petitioner requested a 60-day continuance to April 16, 2019, without additional notice unless needed due to amendments. Staff had no objection. The board granted the continuance. - 2018 DV3056 (3615 White Cedar Court): Petitioner requested a continuance to March 19, 2019, to amend the petition and obtain additional consent. Staff had no objection. The board granted the continuance with additional notice only if needed. - 2018 DV3055 (245 North Delaware Street): Petitioner requested a continuance to March 19, 2019, without notice. Staff had no objection. The board granted the continuance. - 2018 DV3057 (4103 South Land Hurst Drive): Petitioner requested a continuance to March 19, 2019, due to new information about sign height. Staff had no objection with additional notice. The board granted the continuance. Expedited Cases - 2019 SE3001 (3033 Station Street): Petitioner Dean Rayner requested a special exception for a manufactured home with a two-car garage and front porch in a D5 zone. Staff had no comments. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. - 2019 DV3002 (5640 Cooper Road): Petitioner Covenant Community Church requested a variance for two freestanding signs. The petition was amended to reduce the second sign to three feet tall with a ten-foot setback. Staff recommended approval. The board voted unanimously (5-0) to approve. Regular Docket - 2018 DV302 (337 Parkway Avenue): Petitioner Rhonda Tucker by Mark and Kim Crouch requested a variance to split a 45-foot-wide lot (4,950 square feet) into two lots (22.5 feet wide, 2,475 square feet each) and construct a second dwelling. Staff recommended denial, citing the lot's existing nonconformity (50-foot width and 5,000 square feet required) and the availability of a secondary dwelling under the ordinance. Remonstrators, including Jean Salzman (330 Parkway Avenue) and seven other homeowners, opposed the petition, arguing it would not fit the neighborhood character, create safety hazards, and encourage overdevelopment. The petitioner argued the new house would be similar to existing tight quarters and the owner would occupy it. The board voted 4-1 to deny the petition (McKay voted yes, Draving, Von Dalen, Govaia, Boshenko voted no). - 2019 DV301 (3977 West 10th Street): Petitioner Joseph P. Long by Amanda Fo Smith requested a variance for a freestanding sign with an electronic variable message component (EVMS) within 100 feet of a protected district (600 feet required). Staff recommended denial, stating the sign would negatively impact nearby residential areas due to brightness and scrolling displays. The petitioner argued the sign was needed to recruit truck drivers, citing a record shortage. Bob Hickman, owner of the adjacent church (3903 West 10th Street), spoke in support, welcoming the business. The petitioner offered to add plantings and commit to obtaining a permit for a temporary trailer. The board voted 4-1 to approve the variance (Boshenko voted no, McKay, Draving, Von Dalen, Govaia voted yes), with a condition to obtain a trailer permit prior to the sign permit. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: Four cases continued to future dates. - Expedited approvals: Two cases approved unanimously. - Denial: 2018 DV302 (337 Parkway Avenue) denied 4-1. - Approval with condition: 2019 DV301 (3977 West 10th Street) approved 4-1 with a condition to obtain a trailer permit. - The board also adopted findings of fact for cases 2018 UV1043, 2018 UV3026, and 2018 DV3049 (signatures obtained).

ZONING AND LAND USE 50% · SIGN REGULATION 19% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 15% · PROCEDURAL 9%
914
FEB 12, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Meeting – February 12, 2019

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing on February 12, 2019, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The board considered seven petitions: two continuances, two expedited petitions, and three new petitions involving variances of use and development standards. Key actions included approvals for a trucking company, a car dealership addition without sidewalks, and a contractor’s office, while a petition to park commercial vehicles in a residential zone was denied. Continuances - 2018-UV2-025 (2940 Cold Spring Road): Marian University requested a temporary gravel parking lot. The board granted a continuance to the April 9, 2019 hearing date with additional notice, at the petitioner’s request to meet with the property owner. - 2019-UV2-001 (1151 West Thompson Road): David Allison sought a variance of use for heavy vehicle sales, rental, and repair. The board granted a first continuance to the March 12, 2019 hearing without additional notice, to allow the petitioner to meet with neighbors. Public Comments & Testimony - Terry Porter (230 Allison Court, representing Shelton Heights Neighborhood Association) opposed petition 2018-UV2-027 (4035 Rockville Avenue), stating that more than three commercial vehicles were present, along with trailers and wood piles, and that the neighborhood had worked to clean up the area. He acknowledged the petitioner was a good neighbor but noted the business activity had increased. - Gregory Arthur (1318 Cliffridge Lane) briefly addressed the board regarding the continuance of 2019-UV2-001, expressing no objection to the continuance. Discussion Items - 2018-DV2-041 (755 Terrace Avenue) – Corrected Petition: Benchmark Design Homes LLC requested a variance for an 8-foot front setback, 7.5-foot side setback, and 49% open space (required: 18-foot front, 10 feet between dwellings, 60% open space). The petition was previously approved but remanded due to a staff calculation error. The board approved the waiver of the four-day notice and then approved the variance 5-0. - 2018-DV2-050 (1509 South Post Road): James and Jeanne Hulett sought a variance to operate a trucking company with zero-foot side setback and zero feet of frontage. Staff revised their recommendation to approve after a site plan amendment increased setbacks to 30 feet. The board approved the variance 5-0, subject to the amended site plan (filed January 24, 2019), four commitments from the Warren Township Development Association, and a landscaping plan to be approved by staff. - 2019-DV2-001 (1605 Fletcher Avenue) – Amended Petition: KDK Group LLC requested a variance for a single-family dwelling and detached garage with a 10.5-foot front setback and 5/7-foot separations (required: 18-foot front, 10 feet apart). Staff noted a typo in the case number but recommended approval. The board approved the variance 5-0. - 2018-DV2-048 (4405 and 4505 West 96th Street): Falcon Realty LLC requested a variance to build a 14,629-square-foot addition to an auto dealership without installing sidewalks, citing safety concerns and lack of pedestrian activity on the heavily industrial corridor. Petitioner Fernando Falcon and attorney Andy Baroker argued the area is not pedestrian-friendly and that sidewalks would be impractical and dangerous. Staff recommended denial, stating the site has no extreme difficulty for sidewalk installation and that sidewalks would provide safe pedestrian access for workers and future commercial uses. The board voted 5-0 to approve the variance after questioning staff about the payment-in-lieu amount ($63/linear foot, totaling $45,000) and noting the unique location. - 2018-UV2-027 (4035 Rockville Avenue): Maribel Ramon and Miguel Sanchez requested a variance to park three commercial vehicles in a residential zone. The petitioner, speaking through a translator, explained he has a small tree service business and cannot afford other parking due to theft. A remonstrator (Terry Porter) opposed, citing more vehicles and equipment visible. Staff explained that commercial vehicles over 10,000 lbs. GVWR are not permitted in residential districts. The board denied the variance 0-5 and continued the case for adoption of findings of fact. - 2019-UV2-002 (640 North Tibbs Avenue): CC Assets LLC requested a variance of use to operate a general contractor’s office in an existing non-residential building, plus a freestanding sign. Petitioner Joseph Calderon presented a detailed plan of operation, letters of support from the Near West Collaborative and neighbors, and argued the property was historically used as a commercial building and that the city’s online comprehensive plan showed light industrial. Staff recommended denial, citing concerns about expansion of commercial use in a transitional area. The board approved the variance 5-0 after the petitioner agreed to add a commitment for a six-foot privacy fence along the west and south property lines, subject to staff approval of a fencing plan. Key Outcomes - Approved: 5 petitions (2018-DV2-041, 2018-DV2-050, 2019-DV2-001, 2018-DV2-048, 2019-UV2-002) – all by unanimous votes (5-0). - Denied: 1 petition (2018-UV2-027) unanimously (0-5), with continued adoption of findings of fact. - Continued: 2 petitions (2018-UV2-025 to April 9, 2019 with additional notice; 2019-UV2-001 to March 12, 2019 without additional notice). - Commitments Added: For 2018-DV2-050, the variance is subject to the amended site plan and four commitments (including landscaping); for 2019-UV2-002, a six-foot privacy fence commitment was added.

ZONING AND LAND USE 60% · PROCEDURAL 11% · VEHICLE REGULATION 8% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7%
915
FEB 5, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Board of Zoning Appeals I - February 5, 2019: Multiple Variance Decisions and Continuances

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, met on February 5, 2019, at 1:00 PM to hear requests for variance of development standards, continuances, and a fee waiver request. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided with board members Clint McKay, Peter Hanscom, and Brian Robinson. The board voted on several expedited cases and deliberated on contested petitions, resulting in approvals, denials, and continuances. Consent Calendar - Automatic Continuances Acknowledged: 2019 DV 1001 (Bluff Road) and 2019 SE 1001 were automatically continued to the March 5, 2019 hearing by neighborhood organizations; the board acknowledged these continuances. Public Comments & Testimony - Judith Essex (1133 Church Street), representing the Old South Side Neighborhood, requested a waiver of the variance fee for neighborhood banners that were not in compliance with ordinances. Staff recommended reducing the fee to $279. The board approved the fee reduction. Discussion Items - Continuances Granted (with notice or without): - 2018 UV 1045 (5101 W 38th St): Continued to March 5, 2019, to allow time for neighborhood association review of commitments. - 2018 DV 1044 (2729 Madison Ave): Continued to March 5, 2019, with additional notice for amended petition. - 2018 DV 1047 (4565 N Park St): Continued to March 5, 2019, without additional notice, to meet with neighborhood land use committee. - 2018 UV 1025 (802 & 808 S State Ave): Continued to April 2, 2019, with new notice, to amend petition from townhouses to live-work units. - 2018 UV 1024 (810, 814, 818 S State Ave): Continued to March 5, 2019, without notice, to reduce density from four townhouses to three detached units. - 2018 DV 1056 (8304 N College Ave): Continued to March 5, 2019, without notice, to obtain approval letters from citizens and IPL. - 2018 DV 1057 (2536 E 10th St): Continued to March 5, 2019, without notice, to resolve issues with dental office. - 2018 DV 1058 (435-55 Earlham Dr): Continued to March 5, 2019, without notice, to explore alternatives with neighbors. - 2018 DV 1061 (606 Wegwurst): Continued to March 5, 2019, to allow staff and petitioner to clarify submission items. - 2018 UV 1048 (5670 N College Ave): Continued to March 5, 2019, after petitioner requested continuance due to missing findings of fact. - Expedited Cases (Approved Unanimously): - 2018 DV 1062 (4321 N Pennsylvania St): Approved 4-0 for a 22'x28.5' carport with reduced side setback. - 2018 DV 1064 (1146 S Randolph St): Approved 4-0 for a single-family dwelling with front, side, and open space variances. - 2019 DV 1002 (1506 SE St): Approved 4-0 for a two-story single-family dwelling with revised setbacks; a letter of support from Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association was filed. - 2018 DV 1054 (969 Elm St): Approved 4-0 for a single-family dwelling with front, side, and open space variances; staff initially anticipated a remonstrator but none appeared. - Contested Case – 2018 DV 1055 (6113 Bluff Crest Ct): Petitioner Susan Easter Day requested a variance for a 24' tall, 1,500 sq ft pole barn with a 10' north side setback (15' required). The petitioner withdrew requests for height and size to attach the barn, but staff still recommended denial of the setback. The board voted 2-2 (Robinson yes, Hanscom no, Taft yes, McKay no), resulting in a tie. The petition was automatically continued to the March 5, 2019 hearing without additional notice. - Contested Case – 2018 DV 1060 (356 Thorncrest Dr): Petitioner Pam Burton requested a variance for a zero-foot north side setback (7' required) for an existing carport. Staff recommended denial, citing ordinance purposes. The board voted 3-1 (McKay, Robinson, Hanscom yes; Taft no) to approve the variance, but continued the case to adopt revised findings of fact supporting the decision. - Contested Case – 2018 DV 1063 (1140 & 1142 S Randolph St): Petitioner Robert Citron requested a lot split and variances to construct a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks and open space on two narrow lots. Staff recommended approval for the existing dwelling (1142) but denial of the lot split and new construction. The board voted 3-1 (Robinson, Hanscom, Taft yes; McKay no) to approve the entire petition, finding the rhythm of the neighborhood supportive. Key Outcomes - Fee Waiver: Approved reduction to $279 for Old South Side Neighborhood banners. - Continuances: Multiple petitions continued to March 5, 2019 or April 2, 2019, with or without additional notice as noted. - Expedited Approvals: Four variances approved unanimously without objection. - Tie Vote: 2018 DV 1055 continued automatically due to 2-2 split. - Conditional Approval: 2018 DV 1060 approved 3-1, but continued for revised findings. - Approval Over Staff Recommendation: 2018 DV 1063 approved 3-1, allowing lot split and new construction on narrow lots. All decisions are subject to compliance with conditions and commitments as outlined in the board's procedures.

ZONING AND LAND USE 72% · PROCEDURAL 22% · SEPTIC SYSTEMS 2% · LAND USE REGULATION 2%
916
JAN 15, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Hearing - January 15, 2019

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III met on January 15, 2019, at 6:15 PM to hear variance requests, grant continuances, and conduct board business. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided over the hearing, with board members Tony Antoli Bochenko, Kim Boyd, Marisol Govea, and Matthew Draving present. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were also in attendance. The board heard three expedited variance petitions, unanimously approving the first two and approving the third by a 4-1 vote. The board also continued one petition, acknowledged a withdrawal, and elected officers. Consent Calendar - Withdrawal: 2018 UV 1042 – Petition withdrawn by the petitioner, acknowledged by the board. - Automatic continuances: 2018 DV 3-057 and 2018 DV 3-061 were continued to the February 19, 2019 hearing after timely automatic continuances were filed by registered neighborhood associations. - Officer elections: Craig Von Dalen re-elected Chairperson, Marisol Govea elected Vice Chair, and Matthew Draving elected Secretary (all by voice vote). Public Comments & Testimony - 2018 UV 3-030 (1306 North Pennsylvania Street): Dan Mullendore, chairman of the Old North Side Land Use Committee, representing the Old North Side Neighborhood Association, opposed the parking lot variance. He argued that a parking lot would make Pennsylvania Street an “alley for Meridian Street” and urged the board to require a 40-foot green buffer with landscaping to preserve future development potential. He cited a recent SPEA study indicating downtown parking is oversupplied by about 30 percent. Tim Gray, owner of a commercial building across the street, also opposed the variance, requesting a condition for landscaping along Pennsylvania Street to restore trees and a green strip. He noted recent renovations in the area and suggested the property could support higher uses. Discussion Items - 2018 DV 3-060 (6251 East Southport Road): Petitioner Ryan Brymeyer requested a variance to build a 17.5-foot-tall detached garage with a 10-foot rear setback, exceeding the primary dwelling height and the required 15-foot rear setback. No remonstrators appeared, and staff had no additional comments. The board voted unanimously to approve. - 2018 UV 3-031 (6345 Rockville Road): Petitioner Hamish Brims requested a variance of use to allow a security, courier, and delivery business with up to five company vehicles on the property, which is zoned C4 and does not permit fleet terminals. Staff recommended approval subject to a plan of operation dated December 10, 2018, and with support from the Rockville High School Girls School Roads Neighborhood Association. The following three commitments were imposed: (1) outdoor lighting must be deflected away from residences to the south, (2) no hotel, motel, or apartments may be constructed on the property, and (3) the commitments may be enforced by the neighborhood association. The petitioner agreed, and the board approved unanimously. - 2018 UV 3-030 (1306 North Pennsylvania Street): Petitioner Michael Rabinowich, representing LOA Properties LLC, requested a variance to expand an existing L-shaped parking lot into an adjacent vacant lot, adding 17 parking spaces for two apartment buildings (the Winter House at 1321 N Meridian and the Raleigh at 108 E 13th St). The expansion area has been vacant since the early 1970s. The petitioner argued the lot would provide 118 spaces for 206 units, still short of the 155 required by ordinance, but a significant improvement. Staff explained that the regional center approval previously granted was erroneous and that the variance would correct the oversight, allowing for improved landscaping, fencing, lighting, and a safer lot layout. Remonstrators opposed the surface parking use, preferring a larger setback or future redevelopment. During discussion, board members questioned ADA parking adequacy and the impact on future development. Staff responded that ADA spaces are located elsewhere in the existing lot and that the variance does not preclude future redevelopment. The board vote was 4-1 in favor, with Kim Boyd voting no. Key Outcomes - 2018 DV 3-060: Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2018 UV 3-031: Approved unanimously (5-0) with three commitments. - 2018 UV 3-030: Approved 4-1 (Boyd dissenting). - Continuance: 2018 DV 3-056 continued to February 19, 2019 due to need for additional property owner consent. - Findings of fact: The board adopted revised findings for 2018 UV 3026 and negative findings for 2018 DV 3049, noting that one of the required deciding votes came from board member Lethig, who resigned after the prior hearing where the petition was denied. - Officers elected: Von Dalen (Chair), Govea (Vice Chair), Draving (Secretary). The board welcomed new member Tony Antoli Bochenko. The hearing adjourned after all business was completed.

PARKING MANAGEMENT 46% · ZONING AND LAND USE 30% · PROCEDURAL 16% · PUBLIC SAFETY 3%
917
JAN 8, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting - January 8, 2019

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 (BZA2) met on January 8, 2019, to consider several variance petitions, continuances, and elect officers. Chairperson Mark Young presided, with board members Alicia Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke present. Staff from the Division of Planning presented recommendations. The board heard testimony from petitioners and one member of the public. Consent Calendar - Continuances and Procedural Motions: - Petition 2018 UV 2025 (2940 Cold Spring Road) was continued to February 12, 2019, without additional notice, with staff support. - Petition 2018 UV 2026 (2508 West Michigan Street) was moved to the expedited docket, with staff no objection. - Petition 2018 DV 2050 (1509 South Post Road) was continued to February 12, 2019, without additional notice, with staff support. - Petition 2018 DV 2048 (4405-4505 West 96th Street) automatic continuance to February 12, 2019, was acknowledged. Public Comments & Testimony - Lori Klinger (2326 Noland Avenue) testified in opposition to Petition 2018 DV 2047 (2305 Noland Avenue) regarding garage access from Nolan Avenue. She stated that parking on the block is already an issue and that the curb cut would remove on-street parking. She disputed the petitioner’s claim of neighborhood support, noting most signatories were not on her block. Discussion Items - Petition 2018 DV 2051 (1521 Kennington Street): Petitioner Austin Aynes requested a variance for a single-family dwelling with an attached garage and 55% open space (60% required). Staff recommended approval with an amended site plan commitment after neighborhood feedback. The board approved unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2018 DV 2052 (1230 South Talbot Street): Petitioner Austin Aynes requested a variance for a rear addition and legalizing existing setbacks for a single-family dwelling and detached garage. Staff had no additional comments. The board approved unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2018 UV 2026 (2508 West Michigan Street): Brian Fonseca, producing director of Fonseca Theater Company, requested a variance for a theater use with deficient parking. He described the theater as a professional company focusing on stories of people of color, LGBTQ, and disabled communities, with plans for community programming and economic development. Patricia Castaneda, board president, supported the project, emphasizing its potential to bring arts and economic growth to the near west side. Staff recommended approval subject to a parking agreement. The board approved unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2018 DV 2026B (3155 Bonham Drive): Petitioner Antonio Lisenby sought a variance for a detached garage with a three-foot rear setback (five-foot required) and two-foot encroachment into a utility easement. The garage had been built without permits. IPL provided an email stating the garage was clear of safety codes, but a fence needed modification. Staff recommended denial, arguing no practical difficulty existed. The board approved 4-1 (Margaret Banning opposed), subject to obtaining an encroachment permit from DBNS. - Petition 2018 DV 2047 (2305 Noland Avenue): The board considered two requests: separation reduction (Part A) and garage access from Nolan Avenue (Part B). Petitioner AJ Robertson argued that unusual grade and desire for green space justified a front curb cut, citing neighborhood support. Lori Klinger remonstrated, citing parking concerns. Staff split recommendation: approve Part A, deny Part B. The board approved Part A (building separation) 5-0 and denied Part B (curb cut) 0-5. - Petition 2018 DV 2049 (2649 South Pennsylvania Street): Petitioner Justin King requested a variance for an 8,000-square-foot addition to a fabrication building and parking setbacks. He withdrew the parking setback request. Staff recommended approval with commitment for administrative approval. The board approved unanimously (5-0). - Petition 2018 UV 2027 (4035 Rockville Avenue): Petitioner Miguel Sanchez requested a variance to park three commercial vehicles. Due to language comprehension concerns, the board offered a continuance. A remonstrator representing the neighborhood agreed to wait. The board continued the petition to February 12, 2019, without additional notice, and staff committed to sending a multilingual notice to the petitioner. Key Outcomes - Approvals (all unanimous except where noted): - 2018 DV 2051: Approved 5-0, subject to amended site plan. - 2018 DV 2052: Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV 2026: Approved 5-0, subject to parking agreement. - 2018 DV 2026B: Approved 4-1 (Banning no), subject to encroachment permit. - 2018 DV 2047 Part A: Approved 5-0. - 2018 DV 2047 Part B: Denied 0-5. - 2018 DV 2049: Approved 5-0. - Continuances: - 2018 UV 2025, 2018 DV 2050, 2018 UV 2027 continued to February 12, 2019. - 2018 DV 2048 automatic continuance acknowledged. - Election of Officers: - Mark Young re-elected as Chair. - Alicia Ruder re-elected as Vice Chair. - Mary Kelly re-elected as Secretary.

ZONING AND LAND USE 58% · PROCEDURAL 14% · ARTS AND CULTURE 6% · UTILITY REGULATION 6%
918
JAN 3, 2019 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Meeting - January 3, 2019

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on January 3, 2019 at 6:15 PM to hear requests for variances of use and development standards. The board addressed multiple continuances, an expedited case, and four regular petitions, with votes on each. Continuances - Several petitions were continued to the February 5, 2019 hearing, including: 2018-UV1-039 (to allow rezoning filing), 2018-UV1-045 (to meet with staff and neighbors), 2018-DV1-057 (petitioner unavailable), 2018-DV1-055 (more time to work with staff), 2018-UV1-044 (second continuance for parking agreement), 2018-DV1-047 (fence relocation and land use committee), 2018-DV1-054, 2018-DV1-056, and 2018-DV1-058. Staff had no objections, though for 2018-UV1-044 staff noted this was the second continuance and may object to future requests. - Petition 2018-UV1-041 was withdrawn and acknowledged. Expedited Case - 2018-UV1-047 (9546 Allisonville Road): Request by LOR Corporation for a variance to allow indoor recreation and entertainment (escape game room and axe throwing) in a C3 zone. Staff had approved with commitments. The board voted unanimously (4-0) to approve the variance, subject to a plan of operation dated December 21, 2018. Discussion Items - 2018-DV1-045 (724 & 728 E 21st Street): Petitioner Luke Burrow requested variances for two single-family dwellings with reduced setbacks and open space. Staff recommended approval of most variances but denial of reduced open space at 724 (from 55% to 46%). The board split the vote: Part A (setbacks and open space for 728) approved 4-0; Part B (open space reduction at 724) approved 3-1 (Taft, Hanscom, Von Dalen in favor; Reuter opposed). The variances were approved. - 2018-UV1-043 (5326/5328 W 79th Street): Petitioner Wabash Brewing requested a variance to add artisan food and beverage, restaurant with alcohol sales, and outdoor seating in an I-1 industrial zone. Staff recommended denial, citing the introduction of commercial uses in an industrial area, parking concerns, and the lack of practical difficulty. The board denied the petition by a vote of 1-3 (Hanscom in favor; Taft, Von Dalen, Reuter opposed). - 2018-UV1-044 (11832 E McGregor Road): Petitioner Christy Keo requested a variance for an existing second dwelling unit (mother-in-law quarters) built in 2002, and for a lot without frontage. Staff recommended denial due to the number of dwellings on a single access drive and the size of the unit. The board voted 4-0 to approve the variance, allowing the dwelling to remain and facilitating refinancing. - 2018-UV1-046 (1510 Southeast Street): Petitioner Marcus Crouch requested variances to legally establish an existing single-family dwelling and to split the lot for construction of a second dwelling. Staff recommended approval for the existing structure but denial for the lot split. The board split the vote: Part A (existing dwelling) approved 4-0; Part B (lot split) approved 4-0. Both variances were granted. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2018-UV1-047 (indoor recreation), 2018-DV1-045 (two dwellings with open space reduction), 2018-UV1-044 (mother-in-law quarters), 2018-UV1-046 (lot split). - Denied: 2018-UV1-043 (restaurant/brewery expansion in industrial zone). - Continued: All continuances to February 5, 2019. - Withdrawn: 2018-UV1-041. - The board also adopted findings of fact for a previously denied case (2018-DV1-051).

ZONING AND LAND USE 67% · PROCEDURAL 16% · TRANSPORTATION 10% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 3%
919
DEC 18, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Board of Zoning Appeals III Meeting – December 18, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, met on December 18, 2018 at 6:15 PM to hear a range of requests including continuances, expedited cases, and contested variances. The board granted six expedited variances unanimously, denied two petitions (a lot split and a gas station expansion), and approved one contested variance for a unique infill home. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided, with members Carmen Lethig, Maris Algavea, and Matthew Draving present; Kim Boyd arrived later. Procedural Motions & Continuances - Case 2017-UV-3-024 (7960 W Washington St): Petitioner Walid Beg requested a continuance to May 28, 2019 after a garage was built without a permit and a right-of-way dedication was still pending. Staff recommended continuation with the condition that the right-of-way be completed or the case dismissed. Motion passed unanimously. - Case 2018-UV-2-024 (507-509 N Bradley Ave/3836 E Michigan St): Petitioner David Kingan requested this variance be moved to the expedited docket. No remonstrance; staff agreed. Motion passed unanimously. - Case 2018-DV-3-055 (245 N Delaware St): Petitioner requested a continuance to February 19, 2019 with notice to allow for petition amendment. Staff had no objection. Motion passed unanimously. - Case 2018-DV-3-056 (3615 White Cedar Ct): Staff requested a continuance to January 15, 2019 with notice for amendment. Motion passed unanimously. - Case 2018-UV-3-025 and 2018-UV-3-030 (1306 N Pennsylvania St): Automatic continuances to January 15, 2019 were acknowledged by the board. - Case 2018-DV-2-004 (1335 Marlowe Ave): Request to withdraw the petition was acknowledged. - Case 2018-DV-3-002 (337 Parkway Ave): Petitioner requested a continuance to February 19, 2019 with notice for amendment. Motion passed unanimously. Expedited Docket (Unanimously Approved) - 2018-DV-3-059 (8325 Norfolk St, Park 100): Variance of development standards to allow a loading area in front of a 500,000 sq ft industrial building, with a zero-foot front setback and reduced side setback. Staff recommended approval with a commitment. All five board members voted yes. - 2018-UV-3-026 (227 W 38th St): Variance of use to allow an auto repair facility in a D5 zone. Petitioner worked with the neighborhood and agreed to administrative landscaping approval. Unanimous approval. - 2018-UV-3-027 (1551 E Stop 12 Rd): Variance of use to permit a painting class with retail sale of beer and wine. Staff recommended a commitment limiting the use to a specific tenant bay. Unanimous approval. - 2018-UV-3-028 (2490 N Graham Rd): Variance of use to allow storage of semi-trucks, trailers, boats, and RVs inside a building. No staff objection. Unanimous approval. - 2018-UV-2-024 (507-509 N Bradley Ave/3836 E Michigan St): Variance of use and development standards to legally establish an existing two-family dwelling and single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks. No remonstrance; staff had no comment. Unanimous approval. Discussion & Decision Items - 2018-DV-3-049 (6116 Guilford Ave) – Denied: Petitioner David Kingan sought to split an 89-foot-wide lot into two lots (49 ft and 40 ft widths; 50 ft required). He argued that 83% of lots in the area are smaller, the Broad Ripple Village Association supported the split after three meetings, and the property is near the future Red Line transit corridor. Staff opposed, citing consistency with the comprehensive plan (density of 5.5 dwelling units/acre vs. plan’s 3.5–5), concerns over impacts on property values, and seven letters of opposition still on file. Staff also noted that the existing lot is legal non‑conforming and that splitting would encourage further overdevelopment. The board voted 2–3 to deny (Chair Von Dalen and Mr. Draving in favor; Ms. Algavea, Ms. Lethig, and Ms. Boyd against). - 2018-DV-3-058 (1127 E 17th St) – Approved: Petitioner Joshua Duba requested variances to allow a single-family home on a narrow 25.5-foot-wide lot with garage access from 17th Street (no alley access), a 3.5-foot west side setback (4 ft required), and 290 sq ft of main floor living area (660 sq ft required). The home was redesigned with a flat roof to manage drainage. Staff recommended approval for the garage access and living area, but denial of the reduced side setback due to maintenance and drainage concerns. The petitioner argued the reduction was necessary to create a marketable home and that historical homes on the block had zero setbacks. No remonstrators were present. The board voted unanimously to approve all three variances, noting the creative design for a difficult lot. - 2018-UV-3-029 (5060 Southeastern Ave) – Denied: Petitioner Ray Basile sought a variance of use to expand an existing gas station/convenience store and modify a prior commitment (from 2013) to close a driveway on Southeastern Avenue instead of the southernmost Emerson Avenue entrance. The proposed expansion would add storage inside and remove outdoor storage. The adjacent property owner (Wayne Weimer, 5030 Southeastern Ave) testified in support. Staff recommended denial, citing a higher parking requirement (at least 40 spaces vs. the 30 proposed), the unresolved prior commitment (five years overdue), and the risk of hardship on the adjacent property if it had to comply with current parking standards. The board voted 2–3 to deny (Chair Von Dalen and Mr. Draving in favor; Ms. Algavea, Ms. Lethig, and Ms. Boyd against). Key Outcomes - Approved: Six expedited variances (all unanimous); one contested variance (2018-DV-3-058) for a narrow lot infill home. - Denied: Two petitions—lot split at 6116 Guilford Ave (2–3) and gas station expansion at 5060 Southeastern Ave (2–3). - Continued or Withdrawn: Seven cases were continued, one withdrawn, and two automatic continuances acknowledged. - Farewell: The board recognized outgoing member Carmen Lethig, thanking her for her service. - Next Steps: The denied cases will be continued for adoption of findings of fact; approved cases require compliance with stated commitments.

ZONING AND LAND USE 70% · PROCEDURAL 8% · PARKING MANAGEMENT 8% · TRANSPORTATION 4%
920
DEC 11, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Meeting - December 11, 2018

This meeting of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division II, chaired by Mark Young, considered several variance petitions, including requests for continuances, expedited docket transfers, and approvals. The board heard testimony from petitioners, remonstrators, and staff, and voted on each case. All votes were unanimous (5-0) unless otherwise noted. Public Comments & Testimony - Case 2018 DV2034 (1102 & 1108 Fletcher Avenue): Remonstrator Isla Haas (1111 Span Avenue) opposed the variance for a bar addition, citing existing parking overflow onto adjacent vacant lots, property damage, trash, and lack of communication from the petitioner. She requested denial or further negotiation. Petitioner David Kingan (618 East Market Street) argued that on-street parking is available, commitments (including public art, trash pickup, and signage) mitigate concerns, and the addition is for restrooms only. Staff recommended approval with seven commitments, including excluding the second floor from patron use. - Case 2018 DV2044 (1221 North Bevel Avenue): Remonstrator Lori Klinger (2326 Noland Avenue) and Victor Hill (1225 North Bevel Avenue) opposed the variance for a reduced building separation of 5.5 feet. They cited a previous variance violation, lack of notification, and impacts on light and privacy. Petitioner Anton Zensarski and architect Brent Mather argued that the separation aligns with neighborhood fabric, fire safety measures are in place, and the lot is narrow (40 feet vs. required 50 feet). Staff recommended approval. - Case 2018 DV2026B (3155 Bonham Drive): Remonstrator David Legg (3218 North Centennial) objected to a continuance, noting drainage issues and lack of progress from petitioner Antonio Lisenby after two months. Discussion Items - 2018 DV2034 (Fletcher Avenue): Three variances were requested: exemption from 40% transparency requirement (due to restroom wall), expansion of a bar within 100 feet of a protected district (owned by petitioner), and reduction of parking from 22 to 15 spaces (based on first-floor use only). Staff clarified that the second floor is not used for patrons, and the petitioner agreed to a commitment prohibiting its use as a tavern. The board discussed adding a commitment to contact property owners of adjacent lots to request no-parking signs and a barrier. The petitioner agreed to pay for signs and contact owners. The board amended the commitment to extend trash pickup to 75 feet. The variance was approved unanimously. - 2018 DV2044 (Bevel Avenue): The petitioner requested a reduction in building separation from 10 feet to 5.5 feet on both sides. Staff noted that the lot width is 40 feet (required 50 feet), creating a practical difficulty. The petitioner presented fire-rated materials and centered the house to minimize impact. Remonstrators argued that the process was flawed and that the structure would block light. The board approved the variance. - 2018 DV2026B (Bonham Drive): Petitioner Antonio Lisenby requested a second continuance to consult with building services. Staff recommended continuance to January 8, 2019, but warned of dismissal if no new information is provided. The remonstrator opposed further delay. The board granted the continuance without additional notice. Key Outcomes - 2018 UV2024 (507-509 North Bradley & 3836 East Michigan Street): Continued to December 18, 2018, without additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV2028 (2019-2029 North College Avenue): Moved to the expedited docket. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV2043 (1329 Marlowe Avenue): Moved to the expedited docket due to amended petition. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV2047 (2305 Nolan Avenue): Continued to January 8, 2019, with additional notice. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV20242 (401 Parkway Avenue): Variance approved (5-0). - 2018 DV2046 (627 Lincoln Street): Variance approved (5-0). - 2018 DV2028 (2019-2029 North College Avenue): Variance approved (5-0). - 2018 DV2043 (1329 Marlowe Avenue): Variance approved, but continued for adoption of findings of fact (5-0). - 2018 DV1050 (701 Parkway Avenue): Variance approved (5-0). - 2018 DV2026B (3155 Bonham Drive): Continued to January 8, 2019, without additional notice; staff to recommend dismissal if no new information provided. (Unanimous) - 2018 DV2034 (1102 & 1108 Fletcher Avenue): Variance approved with seven commitments, including amended trash pickup to 75 feet, and additional commitments to contact property owners for no-parking signs and barriers. (5-0) - 2018 DV2044 (1221 North Bevel Avenue): Variance approved (5-0). - Additional Business: Negative findings of fact adopted for petition 2018 UV2017.

ZONING AND LAND USE 60% · PARKING MANAGEMENT 13% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 11% · PROCEDURAL 4%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com