Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 931–940 ENTRIES
931
AUG 21, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals III – August 21, 2018

Meeting called to order at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided over the Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III. Members present: Carmen Lethig, Kim Boyd, Mary Sol Govea, and Matthew Dar Draving. Legal Counsel: Chris Steinmetz. Staff from the Division of Planning presented reports. The meeting lasted approximately 1 hour and 7 minutes. Consent Calendar / Continuances & Withdrawals - 2018 AP 3-001 (1628 Southeast Street): Continued to September 18 without notice. - 2018 UV 3-017 (625 South Meridian Street): Withdrawn; partial refund of $909 granted. - 2018 DV 2-004 (1335 Marlowe Avenue): Continued to September 18 without notice. - 2018 DV 3-038 (702 Sanders Street): Continued to September 18 without notice. - 2018 DV 3-033 (509–535 East Warsaw Street): Continued to September 18 with notice due to improper notice. - 2018 MO 3-001 (2230 East Washington Street): Continued to September 18 without notice. - 2018 HOV 079 (1532 South Alabama Street): Continued to September 18 over petitioner's objection; Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association requested further discussion. - 2018 DB 3-039, 2018 DV 3-034, 2018 DV 3-007: Automatic continuances acknowledged (registered neighborhood organizations filed continuances to September 18). - 2017 UV 3-024 (7960 West Washington Street): Continued to September 18 without notice for right‑of‑way commitments. - 2018 DV 3-031 (318 North Illinois Street): Continued to September 18 with notice for amended request. Expedited Docket 2018 DV 3-035 (4820 Washington Boulevard) – Approved Petitioner Jennifer Eger sought a variance for a detached garage with a 1‑foot rear setback (5 feet required). No remonstrators appeared; a letter of opposition was noted but not pursued. Staff recommended approval. Vote: 5–0 in favor. 2018 DV 3-040 (8711 River Crossing Boulevard) – Approved Petitioner PK Duke Development (represented by Gene Valenzano) requested a variance for 210 small vehicle parking spaces (30% max permitted). No opposition; staff supported. Vote: 5–0 in favor. 2018 DV 3-036 (1529 & 1531 Woodlawn Avenue) – Continued Petitioner did not appear (car trouble). Case continued to September 18 without notice. Regular Docket 2018 DV 3-041 (1423–1425 English Avenue) – Denied Petitioner Jonathan Maddox requested a variance to allow a duplex on a 5,000‑square‑foot, 40‑foot‑wide lot (minimum 7,200 sq ft, 70‑foot width) with 48% open space (60% required). Staff recommended denial, stating the lot is suitable for single‑family use. Vote: 2–3 to deny. (Yes: Draving, Von Dalen? Actually 2 yes: Draving and presumably Von Dalen? Transcript shows 2 yes, 3 no – denied.) 2018 DV 3-042 (3835 Bluff Road) – Denied Petitioner Diane Collins sought a variance for a 1,800‑square‑foot accessory structure with 3‑foot side and rear setbacks (15 feet required) and 77% open space (85% required). Staff recommended denial, citing design choices and no practical difficulty. Vote: 0–5 to deny. 2018 UV 3-016 (8902 South Meridian Street) – Vote taken, result unclear in transcript Petitioner Village Plaza Properties (represented by Adam Law) requested a permanent variance to allow a tattoo parlor without a special exception and within 500 feet of a protected district. The business had operated five years under a temporary variance. Petitioners argued no complaints, rising societal acceptance, and positive economic impact. Staff recommended denial, classifying tattoo parlors as adult businesses incompatible with the comprehensive plan. The board cast ballots but the transcript does not record the final tally. The meeting adjourned immediately after this case. Key Outcomes - Three variances were approved (two expedited, one permanent? Actually DV3-035 and DV3-040 approved; UV3-016 outcome not recorded). - Two variances were denied (DV3-041 and DV3-042). - Multiple cases continued to the September 18, 2018 meeting. - A partial refund of $909 was authorized for the withdrawn petition. - The board will adopt findings of fact for the denied petitions at a later date.

ZONING AND LAND USE 72% · PROCEDURAL 19% · RETAIL REGULATION 9%
932
AUG 14, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Public Hearing – August 14, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division II, convened a public hearing on August 14, 2018, at 6:00 PM. Chairperson Mark Young presided, with board members Lee Sha Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke present. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and the proceedings were recorded by Ron Hampton. Staff from the Division of Planning included Heather Stephens, Larry Callaway, Robert Eulenh, Christopher Myers, and Paige Story. The hearing addressed multiple petitions for variances, including continuances, expedited approvals, and two contested denials. Special Requests & Continuances - 2018 DV2024 (4217 Graceland Avenue): Continued to September 11, 2018, without additional notice, at the petitioner's request to address staff concerns. - 2018 DV2021 (3924 & 4002 West Washington Street): Continued to September 11, 2018, without additional notice, at the petitioner's request to finalize neighbor commitments. - 2018 DV2020 (1810 Barth Avenue): Amended to revert to a five-foot front setback from Pleasant Run Parkway; moved to the expedited docket with staff support and no neighborhood opposition. - 2018 DV2028 (2019-2029 North College): Continued to September 11, 2018, without additional notice. - 2018 DV2026 (3155 Bonham Drive): Continued to September 11, 2018, with additional notice, to allow the petitioner to satisfy legal notice requirements. - 2018 UV2020 (433 North Bradley Avenue): Continued to September 11, 2018, with additional notice. - 2018 DV2013 (907 South State Avenue): Withdrawn; acknowledged by the board. - 2018 UV2017 and UV2018: Automatic continuances filed by registered neighborhood organizations to September 11, 2018; acknowledged. - 2018 DV2022 (525 North Temple Avenue): Continued to September 11, 2018, without additional notice, to accommodate an interpreter. Expedited Docket Approvals Three petitions were approved unanimously (5-0) on the expedited docket: - 2018 DV2025 (4635 East 75th Street): Variance to allow an in-ground pool and spa in the front yard due to the orientation of the house. Approved. - 2018 UV2012 (1323-1329 Southeast Street): Variance of use and development standards to legally establish a two-family dwelling and detached garage. Approved. - 2018 UV2019 (1917-1921 Prospect Street): Variance of use to construct three townhome units with detached garages in a commercially zoned area. Approved. - 2018 DV2020 (1810 Barth Avenue): Variance for a garage addition with a five-foot front setback from Pleasant Run Parkway. Approved after amendment. Public Comments & Testimony 2018 UV2004 (1302 East Stop 11 Road, Nail Salon): - David Rutherford (petitioner's attorney): Argued that the proposed nail salon would improve a deteriorating residential property, provide on-site parking to eliminate dangerous street parking, and that the business owner would live on site. He emphasized the property's proximity to commercial zoning and the need for a variance to allow a viable use. - James Fisher (neighbor, 7916 South Oak Drive): Opposed the petition, citing traffic safety concerns on Stop 11 Road and Oak Drive, including a recent pedestrian fatality and motorcyclist accident. He stated that adding a business would worsen conditions and that the neighborhood has historically opposed commercial encroachment. - Councilor John Westler (District 24): Opposed the petition, reporting that after door-to-door conversations, residents feared that approval would lead to further commercial development. He noted the area is designated residential and that the existing buffer (fence) should be maintained. Discussion Items 2018 UV2004 (1302 East Stop 11 Road) – Denied: The petitioner requested a variance of use and development standards to operate a nail/pedicure salon in the garage and breezeway with a future expansion and parking lot. Staff recommended denial, citing inconsistency with the US 31 South Madison Corridor Plan (recommending single-family residential), failure to meet home-occupation requirements (owner not living on site, excessive square footage), and potential precedent for commercial encroachment. The petitioner offered commitments (owner majority-owner resident, removal of sign request) but the board voted 5-0 to deny after hearing testimony from neighbors and the councilor. 2018 DV2027 (7931 West 10th Street) – Denied: The petitioner sought a variance to reduce the landscape front yard from 10 feet to 5 feet for a 10,000-square-foot retail store. Staff recommended denial, stating the reduction would not allow adequate landscaping and that the site could function with the required setback. The petitioner argued operational needs and noted a neighboring gas station had similar variance. The board voted 5-0 to deny. Key Outcomes - Approvals: Three expedited petitions approved unanimously (5-0). - Denials: Two contested petitions denied unanimously (5-0): 2018 UV2004 (nail salon) and 2018 DV2027 (landscape setback). - Continuances: Multiple petitions continued to September 11, 2018, with or without additional notice. - Findings of Fact: The board adopted findings of fact for previously denied petitions 2018 UV1013 and 2018 UV3015 (from June 12 hearing), with board member James Duke dissenting on those decisions.

ZONING AND LAND USE 68% · PROCEDURAL 16% · TRAFFIC SAFETY 9% · LANDSCAPE REGULATION 3%
933
AUG 7, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Meeting – August 7, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, convened on August 7, 2018, at 18:00 UTC (2:00 PM local) in Indianapolis, Indiana, with Chairperson Joanna Taft and members Clint McKay, Roderick Bohannon, and Peter Hanscom. The board addressed 14 variance petitions, granted nine continuances, and adopted findings of fact for prior cases. The chair warned that one board member would depart at 3 PM and quorum would be lost at 3:45 PM, prompting parties to consider continuances. Continuances and Special Requests - 2018-UV1-024 and 2018-UV1-025 – Continued to September 4, 2018, at the petitioner's request without additional notice. - 2018-UV2-013 – Two-day notice waiver granted; case later heard and approved. - 2018-UV1-012 – Continued to September 4, 2018, due to petitioner's attorney being in mediation. - 2018-HOV-080 – Continued to October 2, 2018, over the petitioner's objection, after remonstrators reported lack of communication. - 2018-DV1-015 – Continued to September 4, 2018, due to potential board scheduling conflicts. - 2017-SE-2002 – Continued to September 4, 2018, to allow negotiations with a condo association. - 2018-UV1-006 – Continued to September 4, 2018, with support of the Watson Park Neighborhood Association. - 2018-UV1-023 – Continued to September 4, 2018, pending health department feedback. - 2018-UV1-019B – Continued to September 4, 2018, to satisfy legal notice requirements. Cases moved to the expedited docket: 2018-DV1-014, 2018-UV1-020, 2018-DV1-025, and 2018-DV3-032. Expedited Docket (Consent Calendar) All expedited cases were approved unanimously (4-0) unless otherwise noted. - 2018-DV1-023 (515 East Market St.): Front yard fence height variance – Approved. - 2018-DV1-024 (601 West Epler Ave.): Side and rear setbacks for garage and greenhouse – Approved. - 2018-DV1-026 (2170 East 75th St.): Garage side setback and accessory structures in front yard – Approved. - 2018-UV1-027 (5565 North Keystone Ave.): Roof signs and pylon sign with reduced front setback – Approved subject to one commitment. - 2018-UV1-028 (370 South Franklin Rd.): Expansion of maintenance/storage building – Approved after amendment. - 2018-UV2-013 (1164 Birdsell Pkwy.): Lot width and front setback variances – Approved; continued for adoption of revised findings. - 2018-DV1-014 (329 Lincoln St.): Dwelling and garage setbacks/open space – Approved. - 2018-UV1-020 (334 Lincoln St.): Residential use variance – Approved. - 2018-DV1-025 (1531 Southeast St.): Retail building parking and transitional yard – Approved as amended. - 2018-DV3-032 (963 Hosbrook St.): Dwelling addition setbacks and open space – Approved subject to commitments. Regular Hearings - 2018-DV1-022 (3902 North Illinois St.): Variance for building in clear side triangle, setbacks, sign, sidewalk cafe, and fencing. The petitioner withdrew the sidewalk cafe request; staff recommended approval; the variance was approved 4-0. - 2018-DV1-027 (1266 Lawrence Ave.): Variance for a 7-foot fence (6 feet maximum). The petitioner, Joseph Bishop, cited burglaries and the need to contain his dogs. Staff recommended denial, but the board voted 3-1 to approve (Hanscom, McKay, Bohannon yes; Taft no). - 2018-DV1-028 (5883 North Victoria Dr.): Variance for a detached garage with a 22-foot front setback (25 feet required) in the established front yard. The petitioner cited mature trees and existing paving. Staff recommended denial, noting adequate rear yard space; the board voted 0-4 to deny. - 2018-UV1-026 (1236 English Ave.): Variance of use to permit three single-family dwellings and a secondary dwelling on commercially zoned property. The petitioner argued rezoning would cause undue hardship; staff recommended denial and suggested rezoning. The board voted 3-1 to approve (Hanscom, Taft, McKay yes; Bohannon no). Key Outcomes - Approved (13 petitions): All expedited cases and three regular cases (2018-DV1-022, 2018-DV1-027, 2018-UV1-026). - Denied (1 petition): 2018-DV1-028 (0-4). - Continued (9 cases): Listed above; all to September 4, 2018, except 2018-HOV-080 to October 2, 2018. - Findings adopted: Revised findings for 2018-UV2-013; negative findings for 2018-DV1-019, 2018-UV1-005, and 2017-DV1-078. - Adjournment: The board adjourned after completing all business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 67% · PROCEDURAL 20% · FENCE REGULATION 7% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 3%
934
JUL 17, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting - July 17, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, held a public hearing on July 17, 2018, at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided over a four-member panel. The board heard several continuance requests, expedited petitions, and two regular docket cases involving variances of development standards. Key decisions included approval of four variances, denial of one, and multiple continuances. Continuances and Administrative Actions - 2017 DV3044 (2659 Shelby St): Continued to September 18, 2018, without new notice, pending an IDEM investigation. - 2018 DV3032 (963 Hosbrook St): Continued and transferred to BZA Division 1 for August 7, 2018, hearing without notice. - 2018 HOV079 (1532 S. Alabama St): Automatic continuance acknowledged to August 21, 2018. - 2018 HOV080 (5653 Brendan Way W. Dr): Continued and transferred to Division 1 for August 7, 2018, without notice. - 2018 UV3013 (220 Virginia Ave): Withdrawn per written request. - 2018 DV3033 (509-535 E. Warsaw St): Automatic continuance acknowledged to August 21, 2018. - 2018 MO3001 (2230 E. Washington St): Continued to August 21, 2018, without notice, to allow review of a legal nonconforming use certificate. - 2018 DV3002 (337 Parkway Ave): Continued to September 18, 2018, without notice unless site plan modifications require notice. - 2017 UV3024 (7960 W. Washington St): Continued to August 21, 2018, without notice, to finalize right-of-way commitments. - 2018 AP3001 (1628 S. East St): Continued to August 21, 2018, without notice, to allow neighborhood organization discussion. - 2018 DV3031 (3018 N. Illinois St): Continued to August 21, 2018, without notice, to allow project changes. Public Comments and Testimony - Chelsea Marburger (Executive Director, Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association) spoke in support of petition 2018 DV3024 (5857 Winthrop Ave), noting the petitioner's transparency and that the project would improve livability and protect a large tree. The association's board voted unanimously to support the variance. - Thomas Taylor (5865 Winthrop Ave, neighbor) remonstrated against 2018 DV3024, arguing that a two-foot side setback (versus the required four feet) would hinder maintenance, create safety issues, and lock in an undesirable condition for future property owners. Discussion Items - 2018 DV3024 (5857 Winthrop Ave): Kelly and Gavin McNamara requested a variance to allow a detached garage with a two-foot north side setback (four feet required). They argued the reduced setback would minimize impervious area, maximize usable yard space, protect a tree, and improve access to the garage. Staff recommended denial, citing lack of practical difficulty. After rebuttal, the board voted 1-3 to deny the petition. - 2018 DV3027 (2464 Broadway St): Luke Burrow requested variances for a single-family dwelling with an 8-foot front setback, 3-foot side setbacks, and 48% open space (660 sq ft minimum main floor, 55% open space required). The initial staff commitment to narrow the driveway from 20 to 10-12 feet was removed after discussion. The petitioner cited ease of access and consistency with the original variance. The board voted 4-0 to approve. - 2018 DV3028 (5831 Harveston Dr): Eddie Smith, representing Michael Walton, sought a variance to locate a detached garage in front of the front building line on Greta Drive (accessory buildings are not permitted in front of the established building line). Staff recommended approval with an amended site plan removing the request for a reduced front setback (from 25 to 20 feet). The petitioner noted the garage would be used for antique car storage and no driveway would be added. A remonstrance letter concerning potential vehicle storage was deemed a code enforcement issue. The board voted 4-0 to approve. Key Outcomes - All continuance requests were granted as moved. - Expedited cases approved: - 2018 SE3002 (parking lot for religious use) – 4-0. - 2018 DV3029 (detached garage, 832 Eastern Ave) – 4-0. - 2018 DV3030 (in-ground pool and deck, 7801 New Hallway) – 4-0. - 2018 DV3024 denied (1-3), with findings of fact to be adopted. - 2018 DV3027 approved (4-0). - 2018 DV3028 approved (4-0) with amended variance request. - The board also adopted negative findings of fact for several previously heard cases (2018 UV1013, 2017 UV1026, 2018 DV3009).

ZONING AND LAND USE 73% · PROCEDURAL 21% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2% · HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION REGULATIONS 2%
935
JUL 10, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Public Hearing - July 10, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 convened on July 10, 2018, at 6:00 PM under Chairperson Mark Young to hear requests for variances, special exceptions, and modifications of conditions. Board members Alicia Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke were present. The meeting addressed multiple petitions, including continuances, withdrawals, and expedited cases, as well as contested applications for outdoor storage, snow removal operations, and a residential fence. Decisions were made on all items, with most approvals being unanimous. Procedural Actions - Continuances and Withdrawals: Several petitions were continued to future hearings with or without additional notice: 2018 UV2-013 (continued to August 7), 2018 DV2-022 (continued to August 14 without notice), 2018 UV2012 (continued to August 14 with new notice), 2018 DV2020 (continued to August 14 with new notice), 2018 DV2013 (continued to August 14 without notice). Petition 2018 DV3-020 was withdrawn; a partial refund request was deferred to staff. - Expedited Transfers: Cases 2018 HOV 076, 2018 SE3-004, and 2018 MO2001 were moved to the expedited list and subsequently approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Cheryl Factor (5750 West 80th Street) expressed concerns about existing flooding on the property west of 8020 Zionsville Road, stating that annual flooding affects her outbuilding and that additional paving could exacerbate the issue. She did not formally oppose the variance but urged a comprehensive drainage study. The petitioner’s engineer testified that the addition of less than 0.5% impervious surface would not materially worsen drainage, and that a drainage permit would be required. Discussion Items 2018 HOV 016 – 8020 Zionsville Road (Pike Township, Zone I2) - Petitioner (Tim Oaks, BHZ LLC): Requested variances to expand a parking lot south of the building and to legally establish a 29.7-foot west side setback (30 feet required). Argued the setback deviation was minor (0.3 feet) and that additional parking was needed for the building’s new use. Presented engineering reports showing no flooding issues after record rainfall in April 2018 and committed to ditch improvements already completed. - Staff: Recommended approval, noting the practical difficulty of adding parking on a site built under older ordinances and that the drainage concerns would be addressed at the improvement location permit stage. - Board Decision: Approved unanimously (5-0). 2018 UV 3015 – 4140 West Washington Street (Wayne Township, Zones C5/C7) - Petitioner (Paul Lamby, Tovar Snow Professionals): Sought variances to allow a snow removal contractor (use not permitted in C5), outdoor salt storage exceeding 10 feet in height (proposed 23-foot peak salt bin), and a zero-foot rear transitional yard. Argued the site historically was used for heavy commercial operations, that screening walls and landscaping mitigated impacts, and that relocation to the C7 portion of the lot would be infeasible. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan’s preference for low-intensity commercial uses, the ordinance’s restrictions on outdoor storage near protected districts, and the availability of alternative compliant options. Staff noted that adjacent approved variances had commitments prohibiting outdoor storage. - Board Decision: Denied (4-1, with Duke voting yes) after a motion to approve subject to petitioner’s commitments failed. The board adopted findings of fact supporting denial. 2018 UV 2005 – 6155 Guion Road (Pike Township, Zone I2) - Petitioner (Ray Basile, Frase Investments): Requested variances to permit outdoor storage and heavy outdoor storage exceeding the 25% floor area ratio (requested 125%) and within 35 feet of a protected district (500 feet required). The owner had used the property for 20 years without complaints; an auto repair use was withdrawn after enforcement. Sixteen commitments included screening, limited hours, and no increase in intensity. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan’s call for light industrial uses with limited outdoor storage, but acknowledged the petitioner’s commitments and letters of support from neighbors and the Pike Township Residents Association. - Board Decision: Approved (3-2, with Banning and Reuter voting no) subject to the commitments filed July 9, 2018. The board ordered revised findings of fact. 2018 DV2023 – 5209 Papas Drive (Franklin Township, Zone D4) - Petitioner (Terry Thomas): Requested a variance to keep a 6-foot privacy fence in the front yard (maximum 42 inches). She explained security concerns, dog harassment by pedestrians, and plans for a pool. A petition from 12 neighbors supported the fence. - Staff: Recommended denial, stating that the fence creates a compound aesthetic and that alternative locations (e.g., moving it 24 feet back) or reducing height to 42 inches would comply. No practical difficulty justified the variance. - Board Decision: Denied (3-2, with Young and Duke voting in favor, Kelly, Reuter, Banning opposed). The board adopted findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Approved unanimously (5-0): - 2018 SE2-001 (religious use special exception, 3440 North Hovey Street) - 2018 UV2-014 and 2018 UV2-015 (Lexington Avenue residential variances) - 2018 UV2-016 (Shelby Street commercial variance) - 2018 HOV 076 (Lexington Avenue single-family dwelling with multiple setbacks) - 2018 SE3-004 (Linden Street shelter special exception) - 2018 MO2-001 (modification of conditions for auto sales) - 2018 HOV 016 (Zionsville Road parking and setback variances) - Approved with conditions (3-2): 2018 UV2-005 (outdoor storage on Guion Road) - Denied (4-1): 2018 UV3-015 (Tovar snow removal use and storage) - Denied (3-2): 2018 DV2-023 (front yard privacy fence) - Continued: Several petitions as noted above. - Next Steps: Petitioners for approved variances must comply with conditions (e.g., drainage permits, landscaping plans) and submit an affidavit of compliance within 30 days of completion. The board adjourned with a reminder of a training session later in July.

ZONING AND LAND USE 59% · PROCEDURAL 13% · DRAINAGE 10% · SNOW REMOVAL 5%
936
JUL 3, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I Meeting - July 3, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on July 3, 2018, at 1:00 p.m. in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building, Indianapolis, Indiana. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided. The board heard a series of variance and special exception petitions, with 30+ items on the agenda. Due to a lack of quorum at prior meetings, many petitions were transferred to this hearing. The board also noted that two members would leave at 4:30 p.m., potentially affecting quorum. Consent Calendar (Expedited Petitions) - 2018-SE3-003 (6337 Hanna Ave): Special exception for a religious use in an existing building. Approved unanimously. - 2018-DV3-022 (4560 E 62nd St): Variance to allow a 6.2-ft tall freestanding sign for a day care. Approved unanimously. - 2018-UV3-008 (5820 W 56th St): Variance to legally establish a gasoline service station. Approved with commitments from the Pike Township Resident Association. - 2018-DV1-016 (449 Parkway Ave): Variance to legally establish a 6-ft tall fence in the front yard. Staff corrected setback measurement; approved unanimously. - 2018-DV1-020 (270 N Reisner St): Variance to allow a single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks. Approved unanimously. - 2018-DV3-004 (1017 St. Paul St): After amendment, variance to legally establish an existing two-family dwelling with a garage. Approved unanimously. - 2018-DV1-017 (2054 W 65th St): Variance to create two lots of 11,399 sq ft each for Habitat for Humanity. Approved unanimously. - 2018-DV3-023 (109 Walleye Ct): Variance to add a three-season porch with reduced side setback. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - 2018-UV1-005 (3320 N Arlington Ave): Petitioner argued for a home care office, citing no structural changes and neighbor support. Staff opposed, citing commercial intrusion into a residential area. No remonstrators. Denied. - 2018-UV3-001 (828 Shelby St): Petitioner presented letters of support from neighborhood associations and councilman for two townhomes and a commercial space. Staff argued over-intensification. Denied. - 2018-UV3-012 (3615 S Rural St): Petitioner (Hotel Tango Farms) requested a roof sign and whiskey barrel storage. Petitioner argued the use is agricultural and the sign is artistic. Staff opposed, citing incompatibility with residential area. Approved. - 2018-UV3-014 (6566 Carrollton Ave): Petitioner requested a Pilates studio. A remonstrator raised parking concerns. Staff recommended approval with commitments. Approved. - 2018-UV1-010 (4600 & 4620 W Southport Rd): Petitioner proposed a camping, fishing, and recreation site. The Decatur Township Civic Council and Councilor Holiday opposed, citing safety and lack of attendant. Staff recommended approval. Approved with conditions. - 2018-UV1-019A (1620 S East St): Petitioner requested three residential units in an existing building. Remonstrator from HBHW neighborhood opposed intensification. Staff recommended denial. Denied. - 2018-DV1-019 (6919 Wildridge Dr): Petitioner requested a lot split to create a 0.18-acre lot. Remonstrators opposed due to lot size, sewer concerns, and plat restrictions. Staff recommended denial. Denied. - 2018-DV1-021 (4030 N Illinois St): Petitioner requested a 7-ft tall fence for security. No remonstrators. Staff opposed, citing CPTED principles. Petitioners described a crime incident. Approved. Discussion Items - 2018-UV1-012 (3760 Cold Spring Rd): Continued to August 7, 2018, for revised plans. - 2018-UV1-023 (5651 S Harding St): Continued to August 7, 2018, to add a variance for a gravel parking lot. - 2017-SE2-002 (5532 N High School Rd): Continued to August 7, 2018, for further discussions. - 2018-DV1-015 (7073 W Washington St): Automatic continuance to August 7, 2018. - 2018-DV1-018 (749 Parkway Ave): Withdrawn. - 2018-UV1-024 (810, 814, 818 S State Ave): Continued to August 7, 2018. - 2018-UV1-025 (802 & 808 S State Ave): Continued to August 7, 2018. - 2018-UV1-019B (1620 S East St): Split from A; continued to August 7, 2018, for new notice. Key Outcomes - Approved (8 petitions): 2018-SE3-003, 2018-DV3-022, 2018-UV3-008, 2018-DV1-016, 2018-DV1-020, 2018-DV3-004, 2018-DV1-017, 2018-DV3-023, and additionally 2018-UV3-012, 2018-UV3-014, 2018-UV1-010, 2018-DV1-021. - Denied (4 petitions): 2018-DV3-015, 2018-UV1-005, 2018-UV3-001, 2018-UV1-019A, 2018-DV1-019. - Continued (7 petitions): 2018-UV1-012, 2018-UV1-023, 2017-SE2-002, 2018-UV1-024, 2018-UV1-025, 2018-UV1-019B, 2018-DV1-015. - Withdrawn: 2018-DV1-018. - The board adopted negative findings for several previously denied petitions.

ZONING AND LAND USE 69% · PUBLIC SAFETY 8% · WATER AND WASTEWATER MANAGEMENT 4% · PROCEDURAL 3%
937
JUN 19, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Board of Zoning Appeals III Meeting – June 19, 2018: All Cases Continued or Withdrawn Due to Lack of Quorum

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, convened on June 19, 2018, at 18:15 UTC (2:15 PM EDT) with only two members present: Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen and Member Kim Boyd. Because three board members are required for action, every petition on the agenda was continued, transferred, or withdrawn. The meeting lasted approximately 23 minutes and consisted primarily of acknowledging continuance requests and staff recommendations. Discussion Items - Lack of Quorum: Chairperson Von Dalen announced that with only two members present, no votes could be taken. All petitions scheduled for June 19, 2018, were required to be continued. - Continuance Options: Petitioners were offered continuances to: July 3, 2018 (Division 1), July 10, 2018 (Division 2), or July 17, 2018 (next Division 3 hearing). Staff had no objections to any request. Key Outcomes - 18 petitions continued or transferred to future hearings as follows: - To July 3, 2018 (Division 1): 2018 DV 1014 (329 Lincoln St), 2018 DV 3022 (4560 E 62nd St), 2018 UV 1020 (334 Lincoln St), 2018 UV 3008 (5820 W 56th St), 2018 DV 3002 (337 Parkway Ave) – note: staff corrected to July 17th – 2018 DV 3004 (1017 St. Paul St), 2018 DV 3015 (969 Elms St), 2018 UV 3001 (828 Shelby St), 2018 SE 3003 (6337 E Hauna Ave), 2018 DV 3023 (109 E Walleye Ct), 2018 UV 3012 (3615 S Rural St), 2018 UV 3014 (6566 Carrollton Ave), 2018 DV 3004 (337 Parkway Ave actually continued to July 17th). - To July 10, 2018 (Division 2): 2018 HOV 016 (820 Zionsville Rd), 2018 SE 3004 (1223-1237 Linden St), 2018 UV 3015 (4140 W Washington St). - To July 17, 2018 (Division 3): 2018 MO 3001 (2230 E Washington St), 2018 SE 3002 (1213-1217 Eugene St), 2017 DV 3044 (2659 Shelby St), 2018 DV 3002 (337 Parkway Ave) – per staff correction, 2017 UV 3024 (7960 W Washington St). - Withdrawals Acknowledged: - 2017 UV 3021 (1859 West View Drive) – withdrawn by petitioner. - 2018 DV 3025 (2306 & 2310 Woodlawn Ave) – withdrawn prior to meeting; noted for the record. - Automatic Continuances Acknowledged: - 2018 DV 3024 (5857 Winthrop Ave) – automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2018 UV 3013 (220 Virginia Ave) – automatic continuance acknowledged. - No Public Comments: No members of the public spoke in support or opposition to any petition.

PROCEDURAL 80% · ZONING AND LAND USE 20%
938
JUN 12, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting - June 12, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, convened on June 12, 2018, at 6:00 PM, chaired by Mark Young, with members Leisha Ruder, Margaret Banning, Mary Kelly, and James Duke. The board heard numerous variance petitions, including continuances, an expedited docket, and several contested cases. The meeting lasted several hours and covered a wide range of requests. Continuances and Administrative Matters - 2018 DV3020 (3500 Lafayette Road): Continued to July 10 without additional notice at petitioner's request. - 2018 DV2013 (907 State Avenue): Continued to July 10 without additional notice. - 2018 UV1005 (3320 N. Arlington Avenue): Continued and transferred to Board 1 for July 3 hearing without additional notice. - 2018 DV2016 (2037 Bellefontaine Street): Petition withdrawn, acknowledged by board. - 2018 UV2012 (1329 Southeast Street): Continued to July 10 with new notice to amend petition. - 2018 UV2005 (6155 Guyan Road): Continued to July 10 with new notice. - A typographical error was corrected for the address of 2018 HOV052 (5106 Carrollton Avenue). Consent Calendar / Expedited Docket The following petitions were approved unanimously (5-0) with little or no discussion: - 2018 DV1011 (8451 S. Emerson Avenue): Variance for 4-foot tall vehicle entry point signs (max 2.5 ft permitted). Approved. - 2018 DV1012 (2205 S. Holt Road): Variance for accessory solar array in front yard. Approved. - 2018 DV2012 (822 Olive Street): Variance for front setback, open space, and dwelling separation. Approved. - 2018 DV2014 (602 Terrace Avenue): Variance to legally establish single-family dwelling with reduced setbacks. Approved. - 2018 DV2015 (1517 Leonard Street): Variance to legally establish existing dwelling and addition with reduced setbacks. Approved. - 2018 DV2018 (7420 Shadeland Station Way): Variance for two ground signs on 545 ft frontage (600 ft required). Initially moved to regular docket due to a remonstrator, but the remonstrator was found to be referring to a different property, so it was returned to expedited and approved 5-0. - 2018 UV1018 (6050 E. 10th Street): Variance of use to allow second floor residences for students. Approved subject to commitments (no more than three students at a time). Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV1021 (1411 & 1413 S. Alabama Street): Variance to legally establish two duplexes with reduced lot width, setbacks, and open space. Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV1022 (2936 E. Washington Street): Variance to provide porch additions to multifamily dwelling. Approved 5-0, but continued for adoption of findings of fact. Regular Discussion Items 2018 HOV052 (5106 Carrollton Avenue) – Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Petitioner: Canary Construction LLC, represented by Paul J. Lamby, seeking a variance of development standards to allow a single-family dwelling with 7 feet between primary dwellings (10 ft required). The house was rebuilt down to the foundation after mold and rot were discovered, triggering new construction standards. Remonstrators: Multiple speakers opposed, including Robert Weiss (30-year resident, architect), Mary Owens (land use committee), Chelsea Marburg (executive director of Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association), Eileen Hack (land use committee chair), and Councilman Joe Simpson. They argued that the petitioner violated building codes and permits, that the structure does not conform to the neighborhood plan, and that granting the variance would reward irresponsible behavior and set a bad precedent. They noted the house was built without proper permits and that the same builder had a similar issue at 5715 Washington Boulevard. Staff: Recommended approval, stating that the variance is only for the 10-foot separation requirement, which staff considers unrealistic in older urban neighborhoods. Staff acknowledged structural concerns but said those are handled by the Department of Business and Neighborhood Services. Petitioner’s Rebuttal: The builder, Bobby Jennings, explained that the wall studs deteriorated and were removed for safety, and they believed they could amend permits. They offered that the new house is safe and the neighbors to the north and south support the project. Board Vote: Approved 5-0 (Duke, Kelly, Young, Banning, Reuter all yes). 2018 DV1010 (2218-2234 Central Avenue) – Fall Creek Place Area Petitioner: Joe Smoker for Commodore Davis, seeking variances for three two-unit townhomes with zero-foot side setbacks, reduced lot widths, reduced front setbacks, and reduced open space. The proposal featured offset units to provide wider living spaces. Staff: Recommended denial for most variances except the front setback. Staff argued that the proposed lot configuration does not follow historic patterns, would create hardships for future development, and that practical difficulties were not demonstrated since the site is undeveloped and could be developed with a traditional side-by-side layout. Board Vote: Denied 1-4 (only Kelly voted yes; Duke, Young, Reuter, Banning voted no). The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. 2018 UV1003 (2245 W. 62nd Street) – Crooked Creek Area Petitioner: David Miller for Tomas Eduardo Meta Revolorio, seeking a variance of use and development standards to store commercial vehicles and building materials on a residential lot, with a gravel storage area, reduced setbacks. Petitioner later amended to remove material storage and request only three commercial trailers on an 8,000 sq ft gravel area. Remonstrators: Carmen Bailey (neighbor and Crooked Creek Community Organization land use chair) opposed, citing traffic safety, incompatibility with the residential character, potential runoff issues, and concerns about property values. She noted the property is near a library and a school, and that the alley is already used by commercial vehicles. Staff: Recommended denial, stating the use is inappropriate for a residential zone, would set a precedent, and does not meet the comprehensive plan. Staff also noted that the neighbor’s similar trailers may themselves be violations. Board Vote: Initially tallied as Young yes, others no (1-4), but the chair corrected the tally to 0-5 (all no) after clarifying that Young intended to vote no. Petition denied and continued for findings of fact. 2018 DV2008 (2317 S. Garfield Drive) – Garfield Park Petitioner: Martin Kuntz, seeking a variance for a second-story addition to an existing detached garage to create an art studio, with a zero-foot south side setback for an exterior stairway. The stairway was proposed on the south side to meet visibility requirements for secondary dwelling units. Staff: Recommended denial, suggesting the stairway could be placed on the north side to avoid the setback variance. Petitioner argued the north side has an existing door and window, and moving the stairway would require widening the driveway, creating more impervious surface. Board Vote: Approved 5-0 (Kelly, Duke, Young, Reuter, Banning all yes). 2018 DV2010 (6320 N. College Avenue) – Broad Ripple Petitioner: F. Douglas Staley Jr., seeking a variance for a 45.3 sq ft wall sign (6.5% of facade) for a St. Vincent immediate care center (zoned D7, max 3% allowed). Petitioner revised the design to 45.3 sq ft, flush-mounted, and committed to no ground sign, after discussions with Broad Ripple Village Association. Staff: Recommended denial, citing potential traffic safety concerns and that the site can be identified with a smaller sign or an existing allowed ground sign. Board Vote: Approved 4-1 (Kelly, Young, Reuter, Banning yes; Duke no), subject to the revised plan (45.3 sq ft, no raceways, no ground sign). 2018 DV2011 (1323 W. 32nd Street) – Center Township Petitioner: Kevin P. Horn, seeking a variance to build a new 24x24 garage accessed from 32nd Street instead of the existing alley, which is in poor condition. He stated the alley is not maintained, the existing garage has been broken into, and he wants better visibility and safety. Staff: Recommended denial, citing safety concerns with additional curb cuts on 32nd Street and that the alley is still usable for trash collection. Board Vote: Approved 4-1 (Reuter, Duke, Kelly, Young yes; Banning no), with a commitment that the existing garage will be removed within one year of the grant. 2018 DB2017 (1815 Bade Road) – Warren Township Petitioner: DJ Davis for Dwight and Janet Pertlebaugh, seeking variances to divide a 2.43-acre parcel into a 1.5-acre lot (with house) and a 1-acre lot (to be sold to a neighbor for a new home). The new lot would lack direct street access and have insufficient lot width (165 ft vs 250 ft required) and area (1 acre vs 3 acres minimum). Remonstrators: None present. Petitioner noted the neighbor at 1807 Bade Road received a similar variance in 2005 and that the area has many substandard lots. Staff: Recommended denial, stating the proposed lots do not meet the DA district’s requirements, would set a precedent, and that the strict application does not create a practical difficulty since the existing house can continue as is. Board Vote: Approved 5-0 (Kelly, Duke, Young, Reuter, Banning all yes), with commitments that the access drive easement be paved and maintained within one year, and that an address sign be posted at the intersection with Bade Road. Key Outcomes - Approved variances: - 2018 DV1011, DV1012, DV2012, DV2014, DV2015, DV2018, UV1018, UV1021, UV1022 (all 5-0, UV1022 continued for findings). - 2018 HOV052 (5-0 over strong opposition). - 2018 DV2008 (5-0). - 2018 DV2010 (4-1 with conditions). - 2018 DV2011 (4-1 with commitment). - 2018 DB2017 (5-0 with commitments). - Denied variances: - 2018 DV1010 (Central Avenue) – 1-4 (only Kelly yes). - 2018 UV1003 (W. 62nd Street) – initially 1-4 but corrected to 0-5 (unanimous denial after chair corrected vote). - Continued/Administrative: Several cases continued to July 10, 2018, with or without new notice; one withdrawn; one transferred to another board.

ZONING AND LAND USE 47% · PROCEDURAL 17% · LAND USE REGULATION 8% · SIGN REGULATION 8%
939
JUN 5, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Hearing - June 5, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, convened on June 5, 2018, at 18:15. Due to a lack of quorum (only the secretary and counsel were present), no official actions could be taken on the agenda. All petitions were either continued to future dates, transferred to other divisions, or withdrawn as requested. The meeting was conducted by Secretary Peter Hanscom with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz. Continuances, Transfers, and Withdrawals - 2018-DV1011 (8451 South Emerson Avenue): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-DV1012 (2205 South Holt Road): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-UV1018 (6050 East 10th Street): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-UV1021 (1411 South Alabama): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-UV1022 (2936 East Washington Street): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2017-SE2002 (5532 North High School Road): Continued to the July 3, 2018 meeting of Division 1. - 2018-DV1010 (2218 Central Avenue): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-UV1005 (3320 North Arlington Avenue): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on June 12, 2018. - 2018-UV1010 (4600 West Southport Road): Continued to the July 3, 2018 meeting of Division 1. - 2018-UV1012 (no address given): Recognized as continued to July 3, 2018, per automatic continuance policy. - 2018-UV1015 (1336 East Washington Street): Withdrawn by the petitioner; board acknowledged. - 2018-DV1013 (11415 Noll Ridge Lane): Withdrawn by the petitioner; board acknowledged. - 2018-UV1019 (1620 Southeast Street): Continued to July 3, 2018, per timely automatic continuance filed by registered neighborhood organization. - 2018-UV1020 (334 Lincoln Street): Continued and transferred to Division 3 meeting on June 19, 2018. Key Outcomes - No votes or decisions were made due to the absence of board members. - All petitions were either continued, transferred, or withdrawn as noted. - The meeting concluded with no further business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 70% · PROCEDURAL 30%
940
MAY 1, 2018 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Meeting - May 1, 2018

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 convened on May 1, 2018, at 6:00 PM UTC (2:00 PM EDT) in Indianapolis, Indiana, with Vice Chairperson Clint McKay presiding. Board members Roderick Bohanen, Carmen Leffig, Peter Hanscom, and Renee Napoleon were present, along with legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff. The meeting, lasting approximately 2 hours and 32 minutes, handled continuances, expedited petitions, public hearings, and administrative findings. Continuances and Transfers - 2018 UV 1006 (2870-2890-2975 S. Capitol Ave / 2856 S. Meridian St): Continued to August 7, 2018, at the petitioner's request to redesign the project with fewer units and possibly convert apartments to condominiums. Staff had no objection. - 2018 DV 1007: Transferred to Board 3 on May 22, 2018, without additional notice. - 2018 UV 1010 (4600-4620 W. Southport Rd): Continued to June 5, 2018, at the petitioner's request. - 2018 DV 2004 (1335 Marlowe Ave): Transferred to May 22, 2018, without additional notice. - 2018 UV 3005 (928 Spruce St): Transferred to May 22, 2018, without additional notice. - 2018 UV 1015 (1336 E. Washington St): Acknowledged automatic continuance to June 5, 2018. - 2018 DV 1010 (2218 Central Ave): Continued to June 5, 2018, with new notice due to updated site plans requiring new variances. - 2017 SE 2002 (5532 N. High School Rd): Transferred to June 5, 2018, after ongoing discussions between the petitioner and Hidden Bay Condominium Association; no objection. - 2018 UV 1005 (3320 N. Arlington Ave): Continued to June 5, 2018, after the petitioner agreed; staff required any new information by May 22. Expedited Cases - 2018 AP 1001 (7073 W. Washington St): Family Express Corporation sought a waiver of the refiling rule for an electronic variable message sign, proposing a wall sign instead of the previously denied freestanding sign. Approved 5-0. - 2018 DV 1008 (7336 Trotter Rd): Michael Ells requested a variance for a detached garage with an 18-foot front setback (25 feet required). Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV 1017 (1529 Southeast St): Stephen R. Hawk requested a use variance for primary and accessory residential uses, including a single-family dwelling and detached garage. Approved 5-0. Public Hearings - 2018 HOV 041 (734 Orange St): Leonard J. Fernandez requested a variance for a detached garage creating 55% open space (60% minimum). Remonstrator Nick Zimmerman, an adjacent neighbor, opposed, citing a year of construction noise, property damage, and unqualified workers. The petitioner said he would use licensed contractors and finish the garage in 90 days. Staff recommended approval, noting the deviation was modest. Approved 5-0. - 2017 UV 1026 (2462 N. College Ave / 665 E. 25th St): TGI LLC requested a variance for a dwelling unit above a detached garage accessory to a two-family dwelling. Petitioner Sarah Walters argued the use intensity would be similar to a single-family home. Staff recommended denial, citing overdevelopment and incompatibility. Denied 0-5. - 2018 UV 1011 (2860 S. Capitol Ave): CICF Holdings LLC requested a variance for an in-residence comprehensive mental health facility housing up to 20 residents, with farming therapy and produce sales. Attorney Tim Oakes reported agreements with several neighborhood groups; Ed Mayhern of Garfield Park Neighbors spoke in support. Staff required a new plan of operation. Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV 1013 (3300 Prospect St): William Shank requested variances to legalize automobile salvage and existing office trailers. Rachel Cooper (Southeast Community Organization) spoke in support, citing the business's 40-year history. Opponents Steve Bailey and Jess Ray raised environmental and blight concerns, with one asking for additional community notice. Staff recommended denial. Denied 1-4, with Bohanen voting yes. - 2018 UV 1014 (2525 E. 56th St): Pete's Classic Car Storage and Restoration requested variances for vehicle repair and indoor/outdoor recreation for classic car shows. Attorney Joseph Calderon detailed the low-intensity, indoor nature of the business and proposed commitments. Staff recommended denial but the board adopted staff and petitioner commitments. Approved 5-0. - 2018 UV 1016 (2535 Country Club Rd): Jacob Vanderbilt requested a variance for automobile sales. After an expedited request and a brief removal due to a remonstrator, the petition was re-expedited. City-County Councillor Janice McKinnery supported the request with a tenant-limited commitment. Staff recommended approval with two commitments plus the tenant condition. Approved 5-0. Administrative Actions - The board adopted negative findings of fact for petitions 2018 DV 1003 and 2018 DV 1005, and revised findings for 2017 DV 1078. Key Outcomes - Approvals (7): AP 1001, DV 1008, UV 1017, HOV 041, UV 1011, UV 1014, UV 1016. - Denials (2): UV 1026 (0-5), UV 1013 (1-4). - Continuances/Transfers (9): UV 1006, DV 1007, UV 1010, DV 2004, UV 3005, UV 1015, DV 1010, SE 2002, and UV 1005. - Several approvals carried commitments, including tenant-limited operation for UV 1016 and a revised plan of operation for UV 1011.

ZONING AND LAND USE 61% · PROCEDURAL 13% · LEGAL AND LIABILITY 10% · TRANSPORTATION 4%
← PREVIOUS
01…9394
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com