Public Meetings - Phoenix, Arizona

The Phoenix City Council convened for a meeting focused on community outreach reports and the adoption of a comprehensive policy framework for the newly established Phoenix Housing Trust Fund. Council members emphasized the critical need for affordable housing amidst rising costs and reduced state and federal funding, highlighting community partnerships for holiday relief efforts. The meeting culminated in the unanimous approval of the Housing Trust Fund policy to accelerate the creation and preservation of affordable housing for households earning 80% of the area median income or below. Consent Calendar - None listed; the meeting proceeded directly to agenda items and housing trust fund discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Craig Tripkin (Housing Advocate): Expressed full support for the staff and council's work on the Housing Trust Fund. Speaker emphasized that housing projects must be accompanied by permanent services and on-site management to ensure community stability. Speaker argued that 24-7 on-site management provides neighborhoods with comfort, transforming housing projects into community assets rather than sources of fear. Discussion Items - Holiday Drive Competition: Councilwoman Stark and Councilman Robinson reported on a fierce competition between District 3 and District 6 to collect turkeys and funds for the Desert Horizon precinct's annual turkey drive. They noted that over $6,000 had been raised by the morning of the meeting, significantly surpassing the $1,700 raised the previous year. The prize for the winning office was a dinner cooked by Commander Warren Brewer, with a humorous concession that the losing office would still attend to eat the food. - Community Outreach Updates: - Councilwoman Guardado (District 5): Reported on a successful Light Rail Community Meeting with 190 residents, the upcoming "El Pavasa" Thanksgiving event distributing nearly 1,000 turkeys, and the return of the "Marybelle" toy distribution event. Speaker expressed gratitude for partnerships with the Firefighter Association and schools, and wished a fond farewell to retiring Parks Department staff member Dave. - Councilwoman Hernandez (District 7): Highlighted district challenges regarding federal administration threats and the potential National Guard invasion. Speaker welcomed City Manager Zirker back, advocated for the freedom of Johnny Reed (wrongfully imprisoned), and called for action regarding the genocide in the Congo. Speaker confirmed the District 7 team's commitment to housing, light rail, and protecting neighborhoods from ICE. - Councilwoman Pastor (District 8): Promoted local events including the CPLC dinner, a new housing tree program, and the "District 8 Express" holiday party. Speaker expressed support for the Guadalatón and Harizona Turkey Drives. - Councilwoman Ketch (District 4): Thanked Creighton School Board for community cleanup participation, celebrated the groundbreaking of the Mary Rose Wilcox Center, and reported on hosting a veterans resource stand-down where a homeless veteran was connected to housing resources. - Housing Trust Fund Policy Presentation: Deputy City Manager Gina Montez, along with Housing Director Titus Matthew and Deputy Housing Director Samantha Keating, presented the policy framework. Staff reported that the city exceeded its 2030 goal of 50,000 units early (reaching 61,000 units by September 2025), with 20% being affordable. However, staff noted a gap of 59,000 affordable rental homes for households at 50% of Area Median Income (AMI) or below. The current trust fund balance is $3.5 million, funded by ARPA interest, GIPLED, and rezoning contributions. - Council Deliberation on Housing: - Councilwoman Stark: Expressed strong support for the policy but raised concerns regarding the enforcement of deed restrictions for affordability and requested the Legal Department analyze potential fee reductions for Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) projects to expedite permitting. - Vice Mayor: Clarified that the 59,000 unit gap refers specifically to rental units. Expressed gratitude for staff work but proposed establishing a permanent funding source by dedicating a percentage of future budget surpluses to the fund. - Councilwoman Hodge Washington: Expressed delight that the trust fund includes homeownership assistance, not just developer funding. Speaker advocated for including eviction protection provisions for residents in funded projects and requested metrics to measure program success. Speaker warned that reliance on fluctuating federal/state funding poses risks, noting that Maricopa County could lose up to $32 million in federal assistance due to new parameters. - Councilman Hernandez: Echoed support for eviction protection and the shift toward homeownership. Discussed the impact of population growth outpacing housing production since the Great Recession. Speaker emphasized the need for consistent annual investment, citing a "magic number" of $20 million annually to make a meaningful impact and suggesting bond proceeds as a potential permanent funding source. - Councilman Robinson: Supported the policy and urged the council to remain open to innovative housing solutions, specifically the conversion of vacant office buildings into affordable single-unit occupancy housing. - Councilwoman Pastor: Thanked the previous council for planting the seeds for this initiative. Speaker reiterated that housing provides a sense of belonging and security, and expressed hope that the fund will provide an economic trajectory for residents. Key Outcomes - Policy Approval: The Council voted 9-0 to approve the Phoenix Housing Trust Fund policy. The policy establishes the trust fund's administration, allowable funding sources (including future general fund contributions and bond proceeds), and permitted uses (homeownership, preservation, gap financing, and revolving loan funds). - Funding Priorities: The policy designates priority for households at or below 80% AMI, with additional consideration for those at 50% AMI. Projects must include affordability terms (ranging from 5 to 40 years) secured via deed restrictions. - Directives: - The Legal Department is requested to analyze the feasibility of fee reductions or exemptions for LIHTC and affordable housing projects. - Staff will return to the Council in the spring to present recommendations on permanent funding sources, potentially including a portion of the 2028 bond election proceeds or general fund allocations. - Future funding distribution plans will be brought back to the Council for approval once the trust fund corpus is built up.

The City of Phoenix Economic Development and the Arts Subcommittee convened on November 12, 2025, to discuss the economic impacts of the light rail system, update on Phoenix Sister Cities activities, and approve new workforce development partnerships. The meeting featured presentations from city departments and Valley Metro, resulting in unanimous votes to approve a new Sister Cities contract and formalize registered apprenticeship programs. No public comment was offered by the scheduled speaker, Jenny Ann Sumner, due to technical difficulties. Consent Calendar - Unanimous approval of the minutes from the October 14, 2025, meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - The scheduled speaker, Jenny Ann Sumner, failed to connect virtually. The meeting proceeded to adjourn on public comment after the chair confirmed no other speakers wished to testify. Discussion Items - Light Rail Economic Impact: Presenters Marcus Coleman (City), Joshua Benerek (Planning), Marty Zeke (Valley Metro), and Eric Johnson (CED) detailed the economic revitalization around the 35.5-mile light rail system. Key data points included over $4 billion in infrastructure investment yielding a 500% return ($20 billion private investment), 50,000+ residential units built (10% affordable), and 286,000 workers now employed in the corridor. Specific projects highlighted included Creighton University at Park Central, the Metro district growth, and the upcoming Central Station development. - Positions: Councilwoman Pastor expressed strong support, stating the investment has exceeded expectations and emphasizing that the light rail provides essential access to underserved areas like South Phoenix that were previously reliant on less efficient bus systems. Councilman Robinson thanked the presenters for demonstrating how the transit infrastructure acts as a critical tool within a larger transit ecosystem. - Phoenix Sister Cities Update: Rita Marco, CEO of Phoenix Sister Cities, and the CED team presented a five-year review and requested approval for a new contract. Highlights included seven outbound delegations (e.g., Prague, Catania), the establishment of a sister city with Suwan, South Korea, and the growth of cultural events like El Grito and Double 10. The presentation emphasized successful business attraction efforts, including semiconductor connections and Taiwanese company growth. - Positions: Councilwoman Stark expressed full support for the program, citing its role in bringing semiconductor investment and business connections to the city, with a specific mention of the Waymo partnership in Prague. Councilman Robinson praised the rigorous business focus of the delegations, noting that every trip resulted in tangible business benefits for Phoenix. Councilwoman Pastor, who shared a personal anecdote about the life-changing impact of the program on a local student (Mondo), voiced complete support and emotional gratitude for Marco's leadership. - Employer Developed Registered Apprenticeships: The committee discussed a new model where the city sponsors employer-developed registered apprenticeships in advanced manufacturing and semiconducting, moving away from standard city-sponsored roles. The program, launched in coordination with TSMC, Northern Arizona University, and Rio Salado Community College, currently includes cohorts for Industrial Maintenance, Manufacturing Technician, and Equipment Tech roles. - Positions: The committee members expressed support for the workforce development strategy. Councilwoman Pastor recused herself due to a potential conflict of interest. The committee noted the program's ability to fill 67,000 skilled worker positions in the valley and its high return on investment for the city through increased tax revenue and workforce resilience. Key Outcomes - Item 3: Motion passed unanimously to recommend approval of a new five-year contract with Phoenix Sister Cities. - Item 4: Motion passed unanimously to approve Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs) with education providers (Northern Arizona University, Mesa Community College, Rio Salado Community College) and authorize the city as the sponsor for employer-developed registered apprenticeship programs. - Item 5: Motion passed unanimously to authorize the city to enter into contracts with employers for registered apprenticeship programs, with a total aggregate funding value not to exceed $650,000. - Recusal: Councilwoman Pastor formally recused herself from voting on Items 4 and 5 due to a conflict of interest.

The Phoenix Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee convened on November 5, 2025, to approve September meeting minutes, interview seven candidates for three vacant Municipal Court judge positions, and receive a report on the Phoenix Fire Department's staffing and TPT tax plan. Following a unanimous vote on the consent calendar and a public comment period supporting judicial candidate Shannon Peters, the Subcommittee deliberated in executive session. The body concluded by recommending two appointments to the full City Council while identifying a vacancy for future filling, and received a detailed update on fire department resource expansion and response time improvements. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved the meeting minutes from September 3, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - John Martinez (Defense Attorney): Expressed full support for judicial candidate Neha Bhatia, describing her as knowledgeable, fair, and willing to consider mitigating factors. - Ed Leiter (Division Chief): Stated strong support for Neha Bhatia, citing her deep understanding of mental health in threat assessment cases and her discretion in deciding not to charge when diversion is appropriate. - Tyler Allen (Employer of Shannon Peters): Expressed full support for candidate Shannon Peters, emphasizing her intelligence, ability to tell an employer "no" when necessary, dedication to hearing every client, and rigorous attention to file details. - David Allen (Mesa City Judge, recused from Peters' cases): Expressed strong support for Shannon Peters, highlighting her professionalism, ethical conduct when evidence is lacking, and respectful treatment of all parties in court. - Speaker identified as Federal Law Enforcement Executive: Expressed support for Shannon Peters, praising her impartiality, integrity, and commitment to equal representation before the law. Discussion Items Judicial Appointments - Process Overview: The Subcommittee interviewed seven candidates for three vacant seats on the Phoenix Municipal Court. Candidates were sequestered during other interviews. Questions focused on sentencing repeat offenders, difficult case types, addressing systemic inequities, and ethical dilemmas. - Candidate Positions and Strategies: - Neha Bhatia: Expressed a position focused on holistic sentencing that considers background causes of recidivism while balancing community safety. She stated difficult cases involve domestic violence due to victim reluctance and cases involving mental illness. She argued the judge must be a role model for diversity to help individuals feel heard. - Pamela Dune: Stated her approach to sentencing is guided by plea agreements, sentencing guidelines, and victim input, weighing mitigation and aggravation. She identified removing life support from a 14-year-old as a difficult case. She affirmed the judge's role in addressing inequities by waiving fees for unhoused residents and providing reasonable accommodations for self-represented litigants. - Brett Hutchinson: Expressed a position holding repeat offenders accountable and ensuring community safety, noting concerns about releases occurring too quickly after arrest. He identified large apartment complex citations as difficult cases requiring community resolution. He opposed the "trial tax" phenomenon, specifically citing a case where a pretrial offer of seven years resulted in a 20-year sentence, labeling it unfair. - Christine Mulano: Stated her approach depends on individual circumstances and recency of offenses. She identified cases involving children, mental illness, and addiction as difficult due to the delicate balance of fairness and accountability. She advocated for judges to be the "face of justice," using plain language and community outreach to address inequities. She supported dismissing cases she deemed ethically insufficient, such as one where the alleged victim instigated the altercation. - Dane Paulson: Expressed a position balancing rehabilitation with the community's interest, emphasizing public safety as a primary responsibility of the court. He identified domestic violence cases as the most difficult due to evidentiary challenges and emotional toll. He affirmed the judge's role in tempering biases and treating all with dignity. - Shannon Peters: Stated she would use a holistic approach, examining rehabilitation participation (e.g., treatment courts) to determine if jail is appropriate. She identified child abuse/neglect cases as the most difficult given her personal experience as a foster parent, though she promised to set aside personal feelings. She advocated using tools like CAP programs to address financial inequities. Fire Department Staffing and TPT Plan - Funding and Capacity: Executive Assistant Fire Chief Tim Christ presented a report on the 2.8% Transaction Privilege Tax (TPT) approved by the Council. The $25 million allocation funds 134 new sworn positions and 19 civilian staff. - New Resources: - Active Units: Battalion 8, Rescue 12, and Ladder 10 have been commissioned. Station 15 resources (Engine and Rescue companies) are planned for doubling upon station construction completion. - Upcoming Units: Medical Response Units 1-4, Engine 71, Rescue 71, Engine 93, and Rescue 93 are funded and in the process of staffing. - New Stations: Construction is underway for Station 71 (District 2) and Station 93 (District 1). Station 74 is anticipated to open by the end of 2025. - Recruitment: Assistant Fire Chief Rita Riddle Bigler reported the department is hiring 65 new recruits starting in February 2026. They transitioned to online testing, resulting in a 5% increase in test-takers and applicants from 24 states. - Response Times Data (Jan-Sept 2025): Citywide critical EMS response is 7 minutes 16 seconds (NFPA standard is 5 minutes). Engine response is 5 minutes 48 seconds. Ladder response is 10 minutes 11 seconds. The report noted that opening Station 62 improved local critical EMS response by 1 minute 38 seconds and ambulance response by 4 minutes 50 seconds in its service area. Rescue 12 has improved ambulance response by 3 minutes 7 seconds in its area. Key Outcomes - Unanimous Approval: September 3, 2025, meeting minutes approved. - Judicial Appointments: - Motion to recommend Brett Hutchinson for a four-year term passed unanimously on aye vote. - Motion to recommend Christine Mulano for a four-year term (expiring November 19, 2029) passed unanimously on aye vote. - Motion to complete the process for the third vacancy within 12 months passed unanimously. - Next Steps: - Recommendations for Hutchinson and Mulano will be forwarded to the full City Council for final appointment. - Subcommittee requested a future presentation on the Phoenix Police Department's "Heat Squad." - Meeting Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 11:50.

The City Council convened for a meeting focused on the transition of City Manager Jeff Barton, extensive discussions on middle housing zoning, executive session pre-authorization, and public comments regarding airport wages and industrial rezoning. The meeting highlighted a significant divide between council members and residents regarding the implementation of state-mandated middle housing laws in historic neighborhoods. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved liquor license items 1 through 17. - Approved Ordinances and Resolutions 18 through 52, with specific exclusions: Items 20, 25, 26, 27, 28, 35, 46 through 49, 51, and 52 were excluded from the blanket motion; Item 44 was withdrawn, Item 49 was revised, and Item 50 was continued. Public Comments & Testimony - Executive Session Authorization (Item 20): - Councilwoman Hernandez expressed strong opposition, arguing that pre-approving a year of executive sessions violates open meeting laws and erodes public trust, stating she would vote "no." - Public speaker Jeremy Thacker, a plaintiff in a pending open meeting law case, urged a "no" vote, citing potential personal liability for council members and noting that legal precedents require executive sessions to be contemporaneous with a specific purpose, not pre-authorized. - Councilwoman Hodge Washington inquired whether legal strategy discussions could occur without executive sessions; City Attorney clarified statutes allow such sessions for legal advice and labor negotiations. - Councilwoman Pastor sought clarification on the purpose of pre-authorization; she was informed it merely establishes calendar holds for future notices. - The item passed 9-0. - Middle Housing Legislation (Items 51 & 52): - Support Positions: - Councilwoman Hodge Washington expressed full support, viewing the projects as critical steps for affordable housing and economic stability. - Councilwoman Guardado expressed support, highlighting the Helen Drake Village project's value to seniors. - Councilwoman Hernandez expressed support, praising developments in the Southwest and the Moreland One project for its affordable units. - Councilwoman Pastor expressed support, emphasizing the city's commitment to honoring President Jimmy Carter and expanding affordable housing. - Councilwoman Stark supported the legislation, praising City Manager Barton's leadership legacy. - Speakers Jacob Armer and Micah Cades expressed full support for citywide middle housing, arguing it is essential for affordability and that historic preservation will not be compromised. - Speakers Evelyn Castillo, Laura Boyajan (initially), and Melissa Boyle expressed support or concern for affordable housing, with some arguing for citywide expansion to prevent gentrification and displacement. - Senator Annalise Ortiz expressed support, sharing her personal struggle to find affordable housing and noting the law was a legislative requirement. - Speakers Andrew Luna, Neil Haddad (via coalition), and Nicole Martinez expressed support, framing middle housing as a necessity for workers, teachers, and community stability. - Speaker Kyle Tash (Mike Yale) expressed support for increasing housing options. - Opposition Positions: - Councilwoman Hernandez (regarding the scope) voiced concern about the process and the specific one-mile radius targeting historic districts, though she noted the state law was a coalition demand. - Speaker Beth Joy Boris expressed strong opposition, arguing the amendment encourages unchecked development without infrastructure safeguards and threatens historic neighborhood character. - Speaker Laura Boyajan expressed strong opposition, stating the bill allows for the rapid demolition of historic homes and lacks local oversight. - Speaker Melissa Boyle expressed opposition, fearing the destruction of neighborhood history and unique architecture. - Speaker Dr. Robert Cannon expressed strong opposition to being labeled a NIMBY, emphasizing the community's long-standing preservation efforts. - Speaker Joanne Kaufman expressed strong opposition, fearing the violation of covenants with historic neighborhoods. - Speaker Arthur Cortez expressed strong opposition to the targeted area, demanding citywide implementation and questioning the planning process. - Speaker Susan Edwards expressed strong opposition, warning of investor exploitation and short-term rentals. - Speaker Kieran Goff expressed support for expansion but concerned about the targeted nature of the current proposal. - Speaker Bill Kubenka expressed opposition to the specific location, arguing the pressure on historic districts is misplaced. - Speaker Jim Huntwork expressed strong opposition to the targeted demolition of properties in historic districts. - Speaker William Kubenka (reiterated) expressed support for citywide application to dilute impact on historic areas. - Speaker Michael Barsinkowitz expressed strong opposition to the one-mile radius, urging citywide application. - Speaker Dustin Moreno expressed strong opposition to the lack of transparency and the targeting of historic districts. - Speaker Sasha Robinson expressed strong opposition to the concentration of burden, advocating for citywide expansion to protect historic districts. - Speaker Jeremy Shachter expressed strong opposition, arguing the measure is not affordable housing and that down payment assistance is a better solution. - Speaker Charles Seavard expressed strong opposition, calling the state law an unconstitutional overreach and urging a legal challenge. - Speaker Sterling Sauer expressed support for middle housing but concerned about the specific zoning application. - Speaker Opal Wagner expressed strong opposition, calling for a delay and an expert study. - Speaker Jason Barr (virtual) expressed strong support for citywide implementation. - Speaker Nicole Sanderson expressed support but urged expansion beyond the one-mile radius. - Speaker Brent Kleinman expressed strong opposition to passing immediately, urging a delay for further study on historic preservation and short-term rental clauses. - Specific Concerns: - Multiple speakers expressed concern that the zoning does not guarantee affordability and fears investor-led short-term rentals (Airbnbs) will dominate. - Speakers expressed fear that historic preservation rules only apply to the home, not the property, allowing for demolition. - Speaker expressed concern regarding infrastructure strain (sewers, traffic) in the Willow and Encanto Palmcroft areas. Discussion Items - Retirement Tribute to City Manager Jeff Barton: - Council members Guardado, Hodge Washington, Hernandez, Pastor, Stark, Waring, and Mayor Gallego praised Barton's fiscal stewardship, integrity, and commitment to working-class families and bond programs. - Mayor Gallego commended Barton's auditor background and problem-solving skills. - City Manager Barton acknowledged his roots, thanked his family, staff, and the council for their partnership in making hard fiscal decisions, and highlighted the work of the Budget and Research Department. - Middle Housing Ordinance (Items 51 & 52): - Staff presented the state-mandated requirement to allow middle housing within one mile of downtown and in 20% of new 10+ acre subdivisions to avoid losing all zoning authority citywide by January 1, 2026. - Councilwoman Pastor moved to continue Items 51 and 52 to November 19, 2025, to allow time for further vetting of legal concerns, infrastructure impacts, and potential amendments. - Councilwoman Stark inquired about the legal requirement to "authorize" the ordinance by the deadline, confirming the January 1, 2026, date for both adoption and authorization. - Councilwoman Stark expressed concern regarding the Minneapolis precedent where duplex construction has been low despite policy changes, suggesting a need for more study on incentives. - Councilman Robinson questioned if the two-week delay would be sufficient for ASU/Morrison Institute analysis. - Councilman Pastor noted that while state law limits local authority, the city would still maintain historic preservation safeguards (one-year demolition stay) if the ordinance passes. - Councilwoman Guardado seconded the motion to continue, emphasizing the need to address poverty wages and ensure community ownership. Key Outcomes - Motion to Continue Items 51 & 52: Passed unanimously 9-0 to continue the middle housing text amendment and rezoning to November 19, 2025, allowing for further legal review and potential study by ASU/Morrison Institute. - Executive Session Authorization: Passed 9-0, establishing the calendar hold for future executive sessions as planned. - Affordable Housing Approvals: Unanimously approved (9-0) several specific affordable housing developments including the 2026 Downtown Enhanced Municipal Services District assessments (Item 25), Moreland One (Item 27), Helen Drake Village (Item 28), and the Jimmy Carter Way street sign dedication (Item 35), as well as Planning Commission recommendations for items 46, 47, 48, and 49. - Public Comments on Airport Wages: Speakers Ezra Davis and Jacqueline Massanabera advocated for a $25/hour living wage for airport service workers and expressed concern over recent layoffs by Sky Harbor contractors; the Council noted these items were discussed but did not vote on specific wage legislation during this session. Other speakers raised concerns regarding the North Park/TSMC industrial rezoning, urging a delay and community meeting before the December vote; the Council did not take immediate action on the rezoning but acknowledged the concerns. - Legislative Strategy: Councilwoman Hernandez clarified that the one-mile radius limitation in HB 2721 was a demand from the Arizona League of Cities and Towns lobbyists, not a decision by the Phoenix Council.

The Phoenix City Council convened on October 29, 2025, to conduct regular business including the approval of board nominations, liquor licenses, and various planning and zoning items. The meeting opened with an invocation by Rabbi Levurtov focusing on compassion and justice, followed by the swearing-in of new members to the Mayor's Commission on Disabilities. The Council proceeded to vote on multiple agenda items with predominantly unanimous support, though a single opposition vote occurred regarding a citizen petition. Consent Calendar - Council unanimously approved Mayor and City Council boards and commission nominations (8-0). - Council unanimously approved liquor license items 2 through 10, with the explicit exception of items 8 and 9, which were scheduled for individual item consideration. This included the approval of the special event liquor license for the Phoenix Public Library Foundation (District 7) and Collective Coffee (District 7), both passing 8-0 following expressions of support from Councilwoman Hernandez regarding community engagement and local business support. - Council unanimously approved new business planning and zoning items 11 through 40, with the specific exclusion of items 13, 26, 28, 31, and 40 to allow for individual discussion. Item 31 was noted as corrected in the record. - Council unanimously approved Item 13, a claim settlement in the Garcia case (8-0), with Councilman Hernandez explicitly offering sincere apologies to the family and emphasizing the city's responsibility to prevent recurrence. - Council unanimously approved Item 28, the FTA low or no emission bus grant program and bus facilities competitive program (8-0), with Councilwoman Hernandez and Councilwoman Pastor expressing strong support for electrifying the bus system to improve air quality and align with the climate action plan, citing the disproportionate impact of pollution on people of color and those with respiratory conditions. - Council unanimously approved Item 31, an ordinance amending local speed limits at nine locations (8-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Jerry Van Gas: Speaker expressed deep praise for the late Councilmember Greta Rogers, describing her as principled and noting her history of holding officials, specifically Phoenix Suns owner Robert Sarver, accountable. He stated Rogers' actions indirectly contributed to the team's competitive success. - Tim Sirikowski: Speaker advocated for a memorial for Greta Rogers, acknowledging her 45 years of unpaid service to the city. He proposed naming a park or placing a plaque in her honor. - Kim: Speaker delivered a confrontation to the council regarding a proclamation previously signed by the Mayor. She expressed that the document was a "shame" and returned it, stating that the Mayor would face divine judgment if not careful. - Maxwell Ulan: Representing Unite Here Local 11, the speaker highlighted a job transition issue at Sky Harbor Airport involving Sky Chefs. While thanking the council for helping secure jobs for 120 workers, the speaker expressed significant concern that 60 workers were facing layoffs due to a lack of cooperation from the new contractor, Sky Cafe. The speaker advocated for a comprehensive worker retention policy to prevent future disruptions. - Tamra: Speaker strongly opposed the rezoning cases (Z-139-24-1 and GPA-NG-1-24-1/NG-2-24-1) for North Park, characterizing the project as "overdevelopment" that would "severely harm" the community. The speaker raised concerns about "outside special interest" lobbying and transparency. Additionally, the speaker petitioned the city to commission a review covering the period from 2019 to assess the effects of special interest involvement, campaign finance, and lawmaker financial activities. Discussion Items - Item 26 (FTA Grant Submittals): Councilwoman Pastor expressed support for federal transit funding, stating it is necessary to keep buses and trains moving. She voted yes, noting the funding ensures the transit system has what it needs to operate. - Item 31 (Speed Limits): The Council reviewed an ordinance amending Chapter 36 of the Phoenix City Code regarding speed limits at nine locations. The discussion was procedural, with no recorded debate before the unanimous vote. - Item 40 (Citizen Petition - Jarrett Maupin): Two speakers, Mr. Maupin and Mrs. Anne Ender, appeared virtually. Mrs. Ender's audio could not be heard by the council due to technical difficulties. The Council discussed a motion to approve the staff recommendation. Key Outcomes - Motion Passed: Approval of Mayor and City Council boards and commission nominations (8-0). - Motion Passed: Approval of liquor licenses for Phoenix Public Library Foundation and Collective Coffee (Item 8 and 9), each passing 8-0. - Motion Passed: Approval of Planning and Zoning items 11-40, excluding items 13, 26, 28, 31, and 40 (8-0). - Motion Passed: Approval of Garcia case claim settlement (8-0). - Motion Passed: Approval of FTA grant submittals (Item 26) with one dissenting vote (7-1). - Motion Passed: Approval of FTA low/no emission bus grant (Item 28) (8-0). - Motion Passed: Approval of speed limit ordinance (Item 31) (8-0). - Motion Passed: Approval of staff recommendation for citizen petition Item 40 (7-1), with Councilman Waring voting against it.

The October 22, 2025 Community Services and Education Subcommittee convened to review routine administrative items, receive detailed presentations on the Phoenix Public Library Foundation's upcoming fundraiser, the city's Head Start program, the second annual evaluation of the Naloxone program, and a refresh of the citywide homelesness action plan. The subcommittee engaged in significant deliberation regarding the governance structure of Head Start, strategic expansion of overdose reversal kit distribution, and the balance between service-first approaches and neighborhood safety regarding homelessness. The meeting concluded with the approval of the planning process for the 2026-2027 HUD Annual Action Plan. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes from the October 2, 2025 meeting via unanimous motion. Public Comments & Testimony - Dr. Michelle Shiota (ASU Professor & Director of Saturn Network): Expressed full support for the breadth and success of the Naloxone program and emphasized the critical need for a comprehensive strategic plan that includes prevention, youth-focused interventions, and expanded harm reduction efforts. She supported the view that the diversion of some opioid settlement funds to the state correction system limited opportunities for city-county partnerships. - Jeff Spellman (Violence Impact Project Coalition): Argued that while leading with services is vital, the subcommittee must acknowledge the deeply embedded criminal elements within some encampments, specifically citing prostitution and drug dealing in the 27th Avenue corridor. He stated a position that community safety requires separating these individuals from criminal networks through enforcement before they can accept services, noting that 100% of residents in his neighborhood associate the perceived danger directly with homelessness-related criminal activity. - Councilman Hernandez: Stated a firm position that criminalization is the wrong response to homelessness, advocating for a holistic approach that prioritizes housing and de-emphasizes police involvement in resolving homelessness. - Councilwoman Stark: Expressed strong support for the Office of Homeless Solutions, particularly the creation of the Community Court. She voiced a position that housing is the primary solution to homelessness and highlighted the severe disparity in Housing Choice Vouchers received by Phoenix compared to the sixth-largest city, urging bold action on city-funded subsidies and volunteer opportunities. Discussion Items - Phoenix Public Library Foundation: The Foundation Executive Director provided an overview of the organization's four key investment areas (early literacy, education access, meaningful spaces, and cultural destination) and detailed the 40th annual "Raise the Stacks" fundraiser scheduled for November 7-14, 2025. - Head Start Program Overview: Human Services officials presented the governance model, noting the City of Phoenix serves 2,209 children with $44 million in annual funding. Councilwoman Hernandez and Councilman Stark inquired about the governance structure, confirming that policy changes flow from staff to a Policy Council before reaching the subcommittee, and that additional meetings separate from the subcommittee are not required. The group discussed eligibility criteria (income at or below 100% of federal poverty guidelines, homelessness, public assistance, or foster care) and the current waiting list status (22% overall). Councilmembers expressed concern regarding the ongoing federal shutdown but confirmed operations remain stable with no changes to services. - Naloxone Program Evaluation: Public Health officials presented data showing a 38% increase in kit distribution in Year 2 (14,660 kits) and a rise in pre-arrival administration of naloxone from 7% (pre-program) to 13% in Year 2. Discussions highlighted the need to improve distribution in Council Districts 2 and 4 where overdose rates are high relative to kit availability. Councilman Hernandez and Dr. Shiota advocated for expanding distribution to community centers, mobile units equipped with motivational interviewing, and greater investment in prevention and treatment initiatives alongside harm reduction. Councilman Hernandez expressed strong support for a public health lens over criminalization, while Councilwoman Stark emphasized the need to see demographic data on who is using the kits to ensure targeted outreach. - Homelessness Plan Refresh: The Office of Homeless Solutions presented the draft refresh of the Strategies to Address Homelessness plan, focusing on five areas: Prevention, Safety, Coordination, Housing, and Accountability. The team clarified the "No Wrong Door" policy and the role of the Community Court. Councilman Hernandez questioned the balance between service provision and police interaction, while Councilwoman Stark emphasized the urgent need for more housing and Housing Choice Vouchers to address the crisis. The subcommittee and staff discussed increasing shelter quality to ensure efficient exits to permanent housing and expanding coordination with behavioral health systems. - HUD Annual Action Plan: Neighborhood Services proposed the planning process for the 2026-2027 Annual Action Plan, outlining community engagement strategies via surveys and public hearings from November to March. Councilman Hernandez inquired about risks from the federal shutdown, with no immediate threats identified for the proposed grants, though LIHEAP remains at risk. Key Outcomes - Motion Carried: Approved the 2026-2027 Annual Action Plan process for HUD entitlement grants (CDBG, HOME, HOPWA, ESG) via unanimous vote. - Strategic Direction (Naloxone): The Office of Public Health committed to conducting a geographic needs assessment in Year 3 to reduce disparities in kit distribution relative to overdose rates, with a specific focus on expanding access in Council Districts 2 and 4. - Strategic Direction (Homelessness): The subcommittee endorsed the "No Wrong Door" policy and the plan refresh's focus on preventing homelessness, improving shelter quality, and linking residents to behavioral health and employment services. Staff agreed to provide the subcommittee with an updated draft plan before seeking full Council approval in January 2026. - Informational Action: Staff agreed to share demographic data on naloxone administration (including age breakdown) with the subcommittee for future review. - Operational Confirmation: Confirmed that Head Start operations will continue unchanged despite the 22nd day of the federal shutdown, with funding receipts current.

On October 15, 2025, the Transportation Infrastructure and Planning Subcommittee convened to review the 2025 Park Summer Program update, debate two design concepts for the Downtown North-South Bikeway Study, and approve the "Preserve Historic Phoenix 2025" plan update. The meeting featured extensive public testimony regarding cyclist safety, traffic impacts on major sports venues, and concerns over BRT community outreach. The subcommittee deferred a final decision on the bikeway study to allow for further traffic analysis and stakeholder negotiation. Consent Calendar - 2024 Minutes: Approved unanimously. - Consent Agenda (Items 2-5): Approved unanimously, including the City Floodplain Management Plan Update. The Chair noted a desire for a future presentation to the subcommittee regarding street flooding complaints in the Levine area. Public Comments & Testimony - Support for Protected Bikeways: - Arja (Raverwall): Expressed that "Concept two, which is mostly paint and signage, isn't adequate protection" and argued that "Concrete curbs work... they physically separate people from traffic." The speaker proposed a hybrid approach using concrete protection along most of Third Street with "flex posts instead of curbs" at the Convention Center. - Will Green: Echoed concerns about removing vertical protection in areas not conflicting with events, stating, "I'm actually good with the um parking protected parts of the lane, but I would like to see the vertical protection remain in place north of Van Buren where there is not those activations." - Patrick McDaniel: As the advocacy director for Phoenix Community Alliance, stated that "more work is needed" to find common ground, emphasizing that the project must be "safe and effective for all" stakeholders. - Mika Cadence: Strongly supported "Concept A with the protected lanes," arguing that "The lack of protected bike lanes pose a serious threat to my safety" and that "the lives of those of us who rely on these micromobility tools... aren't less valuable than a few additional parking spaces." - Sharma: Expressed full support for either concept version due to "safety, and... a quality of life concern," citing a personal tragedy where a friend died in a vehicle collision. - Nicole Sanderson: Speaking for the Downtown Core Community Neighborhood Association, voiced full support for the "protected bike lane version," noting that "severe injuries and deaths fell to zero" after previous vertical protections were installed. - Sterling: Supported "Concepts one, a fully protected bike lane from Jefferson to Lincoln," suggesting flexibility for "plastic um flexible posts" around the Convention Center. - Mike Gio: Endorsed a compromise to keep vertical protections, noting that "Cities have completed similar corridors that have seen 40 to 50 percent fear of crashes" reduced. - Lucas Vargas: Expressed being "extremely concerned" by language suggesting cutting the project's scope, stating, "There is no world in which we can keep our full usage and efficiency of car travel at the same time prioritizing the bike infrastructure." - John Walker: Strongly supported "Concept one," asserting that "Paint is never enough" and that "parking protection... only works when there are cars parked there." - Sean Sharion: Expressed strong support for physically protected bike lanes running "Roosevelt to eventually connect with the Rio Salado," noting a preference for "Concept one" but acknowledging "Concept two" could work if done well. - Nicole Rodriguez: Stated that the goal is not "convenience versus... convenience for cyclists" but safety for vulnerable users like school children. - Concerns Regarding Traffic and Stadium Operations: - Sean King: Representing the Phoenix Symphony, raised concerns about "traffic's impact also to our patrons" and how bike lanes on an alternate route would impact access to the Regency Garage. - Amy Lynn Pierce: Representing the Arizona Diamondbacks, stated the organization is "very, very concerned with this specifically about the safety issue of taking down the car lanes," citing impacts on ingress/egress, Uber/Lyft drop-offs, and garages. The speaker emphasized that "safety is our main concern." - Nick Swaraki: (During public comment) Raised allegations against the BRT project's consultant, claiming they engaged in "corporate counterinsurgency," but was redirected to the end-of-agenda public session as the topic was off-brief for the bikeway study. - David Dickford: Expressed fear that without vertical protection, bike lanes would be "invaded by exactly the type of traffic" mentioned by the Diamondbacks representative (e.g., delivery drivers). - Councilman Warren: Expressed skepticism about the realism of fans biking to games, stating, "This is a different thing" than the short 8-10 football games, noting that "85% of the diamondback fans who go to games are driving." The councilman argued that impeding car access is "not a great idea" and warned of potential tragedies if drivers are "enticed into dangerous situations" by confusing infrastructure. - Councilman Warin: Argued that "You're punishing the people who are going" to the stadiums, not the teams, and that the city is "lured people downtown" only to make it harder for them to leave. - Rocky: (During closed public comment) Expressed that small business owners along 35th Avenue are "devastated" by the BRT project outreach, claiming they have "no clue of what is coming" and that the outreach company has a history of "manipulating the community's voices." Discussion Items - 2025 Park Summer Program Update: - Deputy Director Danielle Povaromo: Reported that the program served over 200 teen volunteers, operated at 26 locations for ages 6-12, and utilized Next Door and social media to generate over 200,000 impressions. The speaker noted that 36% of parents chose the camp for "location," 32% for "price," 17% for "staff," and 12% for "friends." - Becky Kirk (Aquatic Supervisor): Reported that aquatic facilities welcomed over 287,000 visitors (a 5% increase from 2024). The speaker detailed that over 13,200 participants registered for swim lessons (an increase of 1,100 from last year) and that the department hired over 500 staff members. The presentation highlighted the launch of an "accelerated assistant manager training program" for 50 swim instructors and a "two-week aquatic academy" to build a management pipeline. - Councilwoman Hodge Washington: Expressed appreciation for the presentation and the application of lessons learned to expand access. - Councilman Robinson: Noted that these programs are the "first step" in keeping kids engaged and highlighted the long-term impact of exposing youth to the city. - Downtown North-South Bikeway Study Update: - Letitia Vargas & Andy Granger: Presented two concepts: "Concept One" ($17 million) features vertical safety elements (curb medians) and converting Third Street to two-way traffic; "Concept Two" ($2.1 million) utilizes paint/horizontal protection and parking buffers but removes vertical elements. - Director Rionales: Indicated that Concept One's cost and stakeholder concerns regarding vertical elements are major hurdles. Staff recommended modifying the project to end at Jefferson Street to avoid immediate Union Pacific Railroad coordination delays. - Councilwoman Hodge Washington: Asked clarifying questions regarding the timing, noting that projects over $10 million require federal grants which delay implementation, whereas Concept Two could be funded locally. She requested a traffic study and further stakeholder collaboration before a final vote. - Councilman Warren: Warned that the city cannot ignore the reality of "30 or 40 years" of stadiums and warned that the current traffic conditions are already a "traffic hell," making the addition of barriers potentially dangerous. - Preserve Historic Phoenix 2025 Plan Update: - Helena Renner: Presented the update to the 2015 plan, highlighting new strategies such as a "heritage property designation" for non-zoned properties, pre-approved ADU plans for historic districts, and sustainability bonus credits. The speaker noted the office is the only large U.S. city without a city-affiliated HP nonprofit. - Councilwoman Hodge Washington: Expressed support for the plan's focus on expanding preservation to neighborhoods beyond the downtown core, specifically mentioning District 8. - Councilman Robinson: Encouraged the city to revisit the creation of a "city affiliated HP nonprofit" given the high level of community engagement in historic districts like his. - Staff: Recommended council approval of the plan. Key Outcomes - 2025 Park Summer Program: Staff presentation received with high praise from the subcommittee; no action vote required as it was an information-only update. - Downtown North-South Bikeway Study: No final vote taken. The subcommittee directed staff to: - Conduct additional traffic analysis regarding lane removals. - Engage in further collaborative discussions with stakeholders (including the Diamondbacks and Symphony) to refine design elements. - Submit a revised proposal or update regarding the project limits (specifically the Jefferson Street cutoff) after these studies are complete. - Potential next review scheduled possibly "right after summer recess." - Preserve Historic Phoenix 2025 Plan: Approved unanimously by the subcommittee for recommendation to the full City Council. - BRT Public Comment: A request from a small business owner to re-evaluate the BRT community outreach company's transparency and tactics was noted by the Chair for staff follow-up, though not acted upon during the hearing due to jurisdictional limits of the subcommittee.

The Phoenix City Council convened on October 15, 2025, to address a wide-ranging agenda including boards and commissions nominations, liquor licenses, ordinance approvals, and significant public policy discussions regarding police reform and community safety. The meeting featured a swearing-in ceremony for new commissioners, extensive public testimony concerning police accountability and officer-involved shootings, and the approval of the early intervention system contract amidst a 7-1 vote. The session concluded with public comments focused on housing, airport worker wages, and calls for systemic change in policing. Consent Calendar - Unanimous approval of the Mayor and City Council's nomination of new members to various boards and commissions. - Swearing-in ceremony conducted for the newly approved commissioners (including the Phoenix Law Enforcement Association representing line-level officers). - Unanimous approval of liquor license items 2 through 23, with Item 8 handled separately. - Unanimous approval to approve ordinance items 24 through 114, with specific exceptions noted for items requiring public comment or containing corrections (specifically excluding items 30, 31, 33, 37, 39, 42, 45, 51, 56, 67, 70, 85, 99, and 106 from the initial omnibus motion due to specific procedural needs or continuances). Public Comments & Testimony - Daryl Criplin (PLE Charities): Stated that the Phoenix Law Enforcement Association represents line-level officers and detectives. He clarified the special event is closed to former board members celebrating a 50th anniversary, with active officers attending only as board members and off-duty. He confirmed the event serves beer, wine, and spirits with no cap, relying on a professional bartender and board members to monitor consumption and ensure impaired guests are transported, noting the guest average age is 70-75. He detailed charities supported injuries, sickness, community events like "Shop with a Cop," and specific aid like AC units and refrigeration. - Julia Taggart: Expressed full support for the historic preservation overlay on the Sunny Slope Presbyterian Church. She articulated that the building is historically significant as the site of the first world food bank (Desert Mission), served as a community hub from 1949 to 2016, and that current users (Franklin Phonetic School) are grateful for the preservation to maintain community legacy. - Cindy Franklin: Expressed gratitude for the ability to secure financing to preserve the building after the church closed. She articulated support for continuing the legacy of community service and noted that the historic status will allow the school to improve the aging building. - Students (Emma, Selena Montes, Mason): Expressed full support for the historic preservation overlay. They described the overlay as a means of protection for their school as part of local history. Selena Montes articulated that the school is one of the few remaining buildings in Sunny Slope used today, historically a mission church, and that preservation allows for improvements to maintain it for future generations. - Mr. Harris: Expressed strong opposition to the Early Intervention System contract. He argued that the department lacks existing accountability for officers with multiple shootings (specifically naming an officer involved in Jacob Blake's shooting), stating that new software is merely a tool to identify problems already known without actual consequences. He characterized the police department as prioritizing violence over saving lives and requested funds be redirected to the fire department. - Councilwoman Hernandez: Expressed concern regarding the efficacy of the Early Intervention System. She articulated that without addressing accountability after incidents occur, the software cannot truly change behavior. She highlighted a crisis of violence with 10 officer-involved shootings since mid-August and questioned if the system addresses the "culture of violence." - Councilman Hodge Washington: Expressed support for the Early Intervention System, urging the adoption of the tool to identify risk factors. She congratulated the students on their civic engagement and noted the importance of saving history. - Councilwoman Pastor: Expressed support for the historic preservation and the Early Intervention System. She questioned the metrics behind the reported decrease in complaints (48%) and sought clarification on specific risk factors within the predictive model. - Councilman Robinson: Expressed support for the Early Intervention System, citing his 35+ years of law enforcement experience. He characterized the system as a necessary tool to identify officer deficiencies and hold the organization accountable before tragic incidents occur, contrasting it with the punitive nature of previous boards. - Diane Barker: Expressed cautious support for the Sunny Slope project while raising concerns about future traffic and crosswalk violations downtown. Regarding the 35th and Grand Overpass public art project, she questioned the funding source, specifically asking if Prop 400 funds were being used (later clarified as no). - Diane Barker (DPI): Expressed concern regarding safety and chaos in downtown Phoenix (muscle cars, crosswalk violations) despite supporting the Downtown Phoenix Partnership's goals. - Unidentified Female Speaker: Expressed strong opposition to the Public Record Request System RFP. She stated she believed the city was withholding damaging information regarding fire response times and City Manager Barton, alleging records were being "slow-walked" to avoid exposing underfunding. - Letitia Ruiz: Expressed support for the rezoning at Central and Broadway but articulated a position of caution regarding building heights similar to downtown. She requested that the Ed Pasco Center be developed as a cultural center and emphasized the need to serve the neighborhood's housing and community needs. - Councilman Hernandez: Expressed excitement for the Central and Broadway rezoning, stating it delivers on the South Phoenix vision and community input received during the transit-oriented development process. He agreed with the need for small businesses to be front and center. - Jerry Moffin: Expressed support for the Central and Broadway project. He urged the council to engage with historic Black colleges and universities regarding recruitment, stating it would be a cost-free resource for the city. - Janae Vandekirk: Expressed distress regarding the economic status of airport workers. She stated that despite record passenger numbers, workers are struggling to afford basic necessities like air conditioning and are living in shelters. She urged the council to direct an economic impact study to determine needed wages ($25/hour) for a stable workforce. - Diane Barker (Multimodal): Expressed support for Phoenix leading into a good multimodal future but warned that without proper planning, the influx of cars could lead to significant traffic congestion. - Roland Harris: Expresssed strong opposition to the council's current policing strategy and the hiring of Chief Giordano. He characterized the council as the "problem" for not holding their oaths to the community, stating that constituents in other districts do not want more police funding but rather crime prevention through social programs. He highlighted six police shootings in two months and argued that the Early Intervention System fails to provide accountability. Discussion Items - Item 8 (Special Event Liquor License - Phoenix Law Enforcement Association): Councilwoman Hernandez questioned the nature of the event, the alcohol served, and safety measures. Applicant Daryl Criplin clarified the event is for former board members, serves beer/wine/spirits, uses a professional bartender, and relies on board members to transport impaired guests. The event is a closed 50th-anniversary celebration. - Item 30 (Payment Ord Claim): Councilwoman Hernandez raised concerns about a recent officer-involved shooting, stating it was avoidable if officers had taken time to identify the individual. Chief of Police Matt Giordano responded by stating a plan is in place to retrain officers on "time, distance, and cover" by end-of-month and reinstate ICAT (Crisis Intervention Training) by the end of the calendar year. He emphasized communication and less lethal options. - Item 33 (Early Intervention System Contract): - Councilwoman Hernandez questioned the vendor selection, detection indicators, intervention protocols, and data transparency. Commander Will Joe (Police Dept) explained the RFP process favored Benchmark Analytics, which uses 91 variables (including calls for service, arrests, overtime) to predict adverse events with an expected 80% accuracy rate (vs. current <5%). He noted the system is proactive, not punitive, with referrals leading to training or wellness plans. Data will likely be public at a macro level to protect privacy. - Councilman Hodge Washington asked about the budget source (police budget) and the track record of other cities using the system. Commander Joe provided data showing a 33% decrease in use of force and 48% reduction in complaints in other jurisdictions using the system. He clarified implementation will take 12-18 months. - Councilwoman Pastor asked for specifics on risk factors and the data behind complaint reductions, which the vendor provided during the RFP. - Councilman Robinson contextualized the need for the tool given the frequency of officer-involved shootings, citing his own experience recommending firings. He emphasized the value of having data to intervene before tragedy. - Councilwoman Hernandez reiterated her stance that while prevention is good, the lack of accountability post-incident remains a crisis, citing 10 shootings since the new Chief took over. - Item 99 (Sunny Slope Presbyterian Church Preservation Overlay): Introduced by Councilwoman Stark, item included public testimony from residents, educators, and students. The group argued for the overlay to protect the building's history as the Desert Mission site and the current school. The Council expressed strong support, praising the students' civic participation. - Item 106 (Rezoning Central & Broadway): Introduced by Councilwoman Hernandez with support from Councilwoman Pastor. Public comments from Letitia Ruiz and community members expressed general agreement but called for careful consideration of building heights and the inclusion of the Ed Pasco Center to avoid a "downtown scenario." The Council confirmed the project aligns with the South Central Plan and community input. - Item 110 (General Item/Continued): Mentioned in the context of the omnibus and specific continuances. Key Outcomes - Item 8 (Liquor License): Approved 8-0. Approved for Phoenix Law Enforcement Association Charities. - Item 30 (Claim Settlement): Approved 8-0. Subject to Chief's retraining plan for time, distance, and cover. - Item 31 (Rancho Grande Annexation): Public hearing closed; vote deferred to a later date. - Item 33 (Early Intervention System): Approved 7-1 (Councilwoman Hernandez opposed). Contract with Benchmark Analytics approved. - Item 37 (Oracle Contract): Approved 8-0. $23M service contract. - Item 39 (Security Guards): Approved 8-0. Contract includes overnight park security. - Item 42 (Water Easement): Approved 7-0 (Councilwoman Pastor abstained). - Item 45 (Community Engagement): Approved 8-0. Contract for diverse outreach strategies. - Item 51 (Water Protection Grant): Approved 8-0. Funds data collection for river habitat restoration. - Item 56 (Public Art Project): Approved 8-0. Contract for 35th Avenue and Grand Avenue Overpass art. - Item 61 (DPI Budget): Approved 8-0. Downtown Enhanced Municipal Services District budget. - Item 67 (Public Record Request): Approved 8-0. RFP for system to facilitate requests. - Item 70 (Emergency Operations): Approved 8-0. Amendment to Chapter 11 to clarify emergency declarations. - Item 85 (Small Business Enterprise): Approved 8-0. Extension of the Small Business Enterprise program. - Item 99 (Historic Preservation): Approved 8-0. Overlay approved for Sunny Slope Presbyterian Church. - Item 106 (Rezoning): Approved 8-0. Zoning change for Central and Broadway. - Items 109 & 110: Approved 8-0 (after being brought out of order). - Housing: The Housing Director noted the approval of a tri-party deal to purchase land from Isaac School District, adding 160 units (excluding other pending projects like Central and Columbus). Note: Discrepancy identified regarding the voting on Item 33. The transcript indicates a "7-1" vote (Hernandez opposed), whereas the initial roll call summary lists

The Economic Development and Arts Subcommittee of the Phoenix City Council met on Tuesday, October 14, 2025, at 9:00 AM to discuss a range of topics including arts in private development, the Smart City Phoenix initiative, the Phoenix-Hermosillo trade office, and the disposition of city-owned properties. The meeting was called to order by Vice Mayor O'Brien (Chair) and included members Councilwoman Stark, Councilwoman Pastor, and Councilman Robinson. Consent Calendar - The first agenda item (approval of previous meeting minutes) was moved and seconded, and passed unanimously without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - Katrina Kayler (President/CEO of Art Link Inc.; Chair of Phoenix Community Alliance Arts Culture Public Life Committee) spoke in strong support of a citywide art and private development (AIPD) ordinance. She noted that the downtown code was updated in December 2024 to include the word "art" and urged the city to replicate that success citywide. She described the risk as low and the return on investment as high, emphasizing that Phoenix must compete with other cities for residents and businesses. - Patrick McDaniel (Advocacy Director, Phoenix Community Alliance) spoke in support of continued exploration of innovative ways to incentivize art in private development downtown. He described art as a tool to attract people, residents, and businesses, and called art and private development "the path forward" for the evolving urban core. Discussion Items Art and Private Development (AIPD) - Mitch Manchaca (Arts and Culture Director), Carrie Brown (Deputy Arts and Culture Director), and Josh Bedner (Planning and Development Director) presented an overview of public art programs and AIPD models in other cities (Scottsdale, Tempe, Philadelphia, San Diego). They explained that Phoenix does not have a citywide AIPD ordinance but has recently updated the downtown code to allow art to be used as an alternative to frontage standards and for density bonuses (December 2024). - Council members expressed strong interest in pursuing a citywide AIPD ordinance. Councilwoman Stark recalled similar efforts from 2010 and noted that public art can transform neighborhoods (citing the Sunny Slope example). Councilwoman Pastor stressed the importance of art subjectively and the need for maintenance funding for existing and future artwork. Councilman Robinson noted the Shema Art Center in his district and supported expanding art citywide. - Chair O'Brien requested that staff conduct stakeholder meetings with the arts and development communities and return with options for an ordinance. Staff indicated a return in spring 2026. - Chair O'Brien thanked Mitch Manchaca for his service, as this was his final Economic Development and Arts subcommittee meeting before leaving the city. Smart City Phoenix Initiative - Michael Hammett (Office of Innovation Director) and Steen Hambrick (Information Technology Services Director) provided an update on the development of the city's first Smart Cities Roadmap, in partnership with IDC. The roadmap aims to coordinate existing initiatives (130+ identified across departments), leverage data and AI, and improve resident quality of life. - Notable current projects include: smart water meters and leak detection, AI wastewater monitoring (CANDO), 3D augmented reality for affordable housing visualization (In Situ), digital kiosks with ADA features and language translation, and the ARIN pavement assessment tool. - The city has received over 520 community survey responses, with climate and livability as top priorities, and 17% indicating accessibility as important. - AI governance is managed under Administrative Regulation AR-165, with 18 AI tools already approved or under review (including Copilot Chat, Copilot Pro, and WebEx AI assistant). - Councilwoman Stark asked about citywide smart meter installation for water; staff acknowledged the scale challenge but noted progress with remote monitoring. - Councilman Robinson inquired about geofencing technology to warn hikers of extreme heat at trailheads. Steen Hambrick said ITS is evaluating alternatives to address privacy concerns and will report back. - Councilwoman Pastor stressed the need for robust infrastructure and thorough testing of AI before public rollout, citing a frustrating experience with an AI non-emergency number. - Chair O'Brien emphasized the importance of cross-departmental coordination and integration of technology (e.g., cameras, traffic signals) and asked for a briefing on the new portfolio management tool for tracking smart city initiatives. Phoenix-Hermosillo Trade Office Results and Update - Eric Johnson (Acting Community and Economic Development Director), Nathan Wright (Deputy Director), and Juan Batres (Economic Development Program Manager) presented results for FY 2024-2025. The office assisted 290 companies, helped two incorporate in Arizona, and two locate in Phoenix physically. Since 2021, the office has assisted a total of 810 companies, with 24 incorporating and 7 locating in Phoenix. - The office focuses on legacy and emerging industries (aerospace, electronics, pharma, semiconductors) and has signed MOUs with Baja California, Nuevo Leon (Monterrey), and Hermosillo. - Arizona's trade with Mexico totaled $20.6 billion (top partner), with exports of copper, electronics, and aircraft, and imports of produce, electronics, and equipment. - Risks and challenges include economic uncertainty, U.S. immigration policy, potential tariff changes, and the 2026 USMCA review. Opportunities include a second wave of nearshoring and a planned soft-landing program for Mexican companies. - Councilwoman Pastor asked for more details on the soft-landing concept and emphasized the need to provide tools and market analysis to ensure success for incoming businesses. - Chair O'Brien requested a summary of the financial impact and job creation from companies assisted. Disposition of City-Owned Property - Eric Johnson and Zandon Keating (Deputy Community and Economic Development Director) updated on several properties: - Four Corners (24th St & Broadway): Four offers received (deadline September 15); staff evaluating. - Regency Garage: RFP due October 28; under solicitation transparency policy. - 19th Ave & Dunlap (10+ acres): Rezoned to walkable urban code; being prepared for RFP in collaboration with community and Councilwoman Stark. - 19th Ave & Montebello (10+ acres): Rezoning underway; will be prepared for RFP with Councilwoman Pastor's office. - Ed Pastor Transit Center (Central & Broadway): 3.5 acres, subject to federal title ditch abandonment; one RFI response for temporary activation under evaluation. - SE corner Central & Broadway (3.76 acres): Rezoning on City Council agenda for October 15; RFP anticipated in 2026. - 13th St & Washington/Jefferson (two sites, 3.3 acres each): Awaiting master planning. - 7th Ave & Washington (4.63 acres): Rezoning completed; retail study shows strong need for street-level retail. AIA will conduct an ideas competition for the site, with results expected January 2026; RFP to follow. - Councilwoman Pastor asked about the naming of the Ed Pastor Transit Center if it is redeveloped. Staff committed to researching the process and reporting back. Key Outcomes - Art and Private Development: The subcommittee directed staff to conduct stakeholder meetings with the arts and development communities and report back with options for a citywide AIPD ordinance in spring 2026. - Smart City Initiative: Staff will continue developing the roadmap and will report back to the subcommittee. ITS will provide Councilman Robinson with an update on alternatives to geofencing for trailhead heat warnings. - Hiking Safety: ITS is evaluating alternative technologies to geofencing to address privacy concerns and will report back to the subcommittee. - Trade Office: The office will continue its work under the five-year contract (now in year three) and will provide a financial impact summary to the subcommittee. - City-Owned Properties: RFPs for several properties are in various stages; the AIA ideas competition for 7th Ave & Washington is expected to finish in January 2026, with the RFP released shortly after. Staff will research the process for renaming the Ed Pastor Transit Center if it is redeveloped.