The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 18, 2024, at approximately 11:15 AM (PDT) to discuss four major agenda items and approve several settlement agreements. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. Supervisor Shamann Walton participated as a guest for the first item. The meeting lasted over five hours due to extensive public testimony and deliberation. Dreamkeepers Initiative Hearing - Overview: Supervisor Walton introduced a hearing on the Dreamkeepers Initiative (DKI), launched in 2021 with an annual allocation of $60 million to reinvest in San Francisco's Black communities. Since inception, cumulative funding totals $180 million over three fiscal years (FY22–24). - Financial Status (per CFO Samuel Thomas): Over $140 million has been spent or encumbered; $59 million expended on grants; $22 million for homeowner assistance; $3.2 million in mini-grants for basic needs; $3.1 million for entrepreneurs; 52 market-rate homes purchased via down-payment assistance; 196 scholars supported in post-secondary education. - Public Comment: Over 50 speakers expressed strong support for DKI, citing positive impacts on youth, seniors, small businesses, mental health, and cultural preservation. Speakers included representatives from Curry Senior Center, Hope SF, Samoan Community Development Center, and many grantees. - Discussion: Director Dr. Cheryl Davis and Dr. Sai emphasized the initiative's return on investment and community-led model. Supervisor Chan raised concerns about potential budget cuts and rumors of supervisor opposition; Chair Preston and Vice Chair Stefani affirmed their support. Supervisor Walton stressed that DKI represents only 0.0043% of the city's budget. - Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the call of the chair. Delays in Disbursement of Funds to Fix Elevators in Single Room Occupancy Housing - Background: In June 2022, $10 million was allocated for elevator modernization in SROs. Despite repeated promises, the Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) was not issued until February 16, 2024—coinciding with a San Francisco Chronicle investigation. - HSH Presentation: Deputy Director Emily Cohn and Director Salvador Menjivar explained the NOFA process, eligibility (privately owned buildings with master lease, 50% owner match, minimum 5-year lease), and timeline: proposals due May 16, 2024, awards in summer/fall 2024. They cited staffing shortages and competing priorities (acquiring 10 new buildings, wage equity) as reasons for delays. - Public Comment: Tenants and elevator union members described dangerous conditions—trapped residents, fire department rescues, seniors unable to leave apartments. Speakers urged immediate action. - Discussion: Chair Preston criticized the two-year delay and lack of urgency, pressing for expedited timelines. Supervisor Safai noted that the funds were allocated but not prioritized by the administration. The mayor's office representative agreed to explore tightening schedules. - Outcome: The committee voted to continue the item to the call of the chair, with a request for HSH to report back on expedited timelines and a requirement that awarded projects begin work within a set period. SFHA's Housing Choice Voucher Program - Context: Supervisor Safai sponsored a hearing on the Housing Authority's decision to contract out the HCV program after a HUD mandate due to a $20 million shortfall in 2019. The contract with Nan McKay & Associates (worth up to $32 million over three years) led to a breach of contract lawsuit (filed November 2023) for poor performance. - SFHA Presentation: CEO Tanya Ledgister stated that HUD required outsourcing; competitive bidding selected Nan McKay. The authority has since split the program between two contractors: one for tenant-based (8,000 households) and one for project-based (7,500 households) vouchers. No payments have been missed, but litigation will determine damages. - Public Comment: One speaker criticized the lack of due diligence, noting Nan McKay's prior poor performance in Chicago. - Discussion: Supervisor Safai questioned why the authority did not vet Nan McKay's track record (Chicago Housing Authority removed them in 2016). Ledgister replied that procurement rules limited review to submitted proposals. Safai encouraged exploring whether the HUD mandate could be lifted to bring work back in-house. He also emphasized the need for transparency and accountability. - Outcome: The committee continued the item to the call of the chair for follow-up on lessons learned and potential policy changes. Military Equipment Use Policy 2023 Annual Report - Presentation: Captain Alejandro Kabebe presented the Sheriff's Office first annual report under AB 481. The inventory includes drones, mobile command vehicles, breaching shotguns, AR-15 rifles, sniper rifles, MP5s, automatic pistols, flashbangs, chemical launchers, and the Arwen 37mm launcher. Actual deployments in 2023 were minimal: drone used for six days (Bataan memorial, APEC summit, a suicide intervention), rifles used for training and high-risk transport/APEC/Fainstein memorial. No complaints were received. - Request for New Equipment: The department seeks approval to purchase a new ground robot (replacing an obsolete scout robot) and a kinetic breaching tool for the special response team. - Public Comment: None. - Discussion: Chair Preston and Supervisor Chan commended the transparency and community engagement (zero attendees at January 2024 community meeting). The sheriff's legal counsel confirmed the robot is for surveillance only. The MP5 submachine guns are out of service for 10 years and not used. - Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Closed Session Settlements - Items 5–13 comprised eight ordinances and four resolutions authorizing settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims ranging from $36,000 to $800,000. No public comment was offered. Chair Preston noted that his questions had been answered beforehand, making a closed session unnecessary. The committee approved all items to the full board. Key Outcomes: - All four regular agenda items were continued to the call of the chair or forwarded to the full board. - The Dreamkeepers Initiative received strong reaffirmation of support; continued monitoring of budget. - HSH is expected to report back on expediting elevator repair timelines and requiring commencement dates in awards. - The Housing Authority will explore options to possibly lift the HUD mandate and improve contractor vetting. - The Sheriff's Office military equipment report was approved with commendation for transparency.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on April 17, 2024, to consider 13 agenda items including property tax exemptions, contract approvals, leases, and development agreements. The committee approved most items, amended several, and continued one item to a future meeting. Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar were in attendance. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Low-Value Property Tax Exemptions) was passed unanimously with a positive recommendation to the full board. - Items 2 and 3 (Technical Assistance Marketplace and Health Advocates contract) were approved together unanimously. - Item 4 (Airport escalator contract modification) was approved unanimously. - Item 5 (Water recycling engineering contract amendment) was approved unanimously. - Item 10 (Abode Services grant amendment) was approved unanimously. - Item 13 (Transbay Block 2 East housing revenue notes) was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Rudy Gonzalez (Building Trades Council) supported item 4, noting the involvement of elevator constructors. - Anthony (construction superintendent) stated the Jolly Bee restaurant at 934 Market Street is targeting an end-of-year opening. - Brandon Cox (Lighthouse for the Blind) expressed concern about the city ending its partnership at 1155 Market Street, questioning the message to nonprofits investing in mid-Market. - Rudy Gonzalez also supported item 9, praising the Hudson building lease for improving working conditions and emergency capacity. - Mia San Giacomo and Paul Wallace (1145 Market Street stakeholders) supported the lease, noting it would help encourage Whole Foods to reopen. - Van Hart objected to the short notice and timing of the 1145 and 1455 Market leases, advocating for continued use of the Lighthouse building. - Giselle Madrid (Abode Services) supported item 10, sharing a success story of a formerly homeless participant who stabilized through the flexible housing subsidy pool. - Multiple union representatives (Carpenters, Building Trades) supported items 11 and 12, emphasizing job creation and housing benefits on Treasure Island. - Sherry Williams and others (One Treasure Island) urged approval, warning that delay would jeopardize affordable housing units and behavioral health facilities. - Chef Klein opposed the Treasure Island amendments, citing earthquake and megastorm risks not fully addressed. - Other speakers offered brief commentary on various items. Discussion Items Items 7, 8, and 9: Steam Loop Transfer and Market Street Leases - Steam Loop (Item 7): The city will transfer ownership of the 100-year-old steam loop to Energy Center San Francisco (ECSF) for $3.1 million in emergency repairs and a five-year steam purchase commitment. The BLA recommended adding language stating the public interest necessitates the transfer. The committee adopted that amendment. - 1145 Market Street Lease (Item 8): A 10-year lease at $29.95/sq ft for 45,000 sq ft, housing DPH, OCEIA, and DMAC. Estimated savings of $1 million annually. The committee amended the resolution to require the director of property to notify the board before exercising extension options, rather than requiring board approval. - 1455 Market Street Lease (Item 9): A 21-year lease for 157,000 sq ft at $40/sq ft, with options to expand and purchase. Savings of $2.5 million annually. The lease includes tenant improvement allowances and swing space. The committee approved without additional amendments. Items 11 and 12: Treasure Island Development Amendments - The committee considered amendments to the development agreement (DA) and disposition and development agreement (DDA) to accelerate public financing via $115 million in certificates of participation (COPs) for stage two infrastructure. Concerns were raised about COP capacity and impact on the city's capital plan. - Supervisor Dorsey proposed a technical amendment to the DA (striking certain exhibit references). The committee adopted it. - Additional amendments were adopted per OEWD: COPs to be issued in at least three tranches, one per fiscal year, only after the 10-year capital plan demonstrates capacity, and with debt service deferred to FY27/28. - The amendments were approved and forwarded to the full board. Item 6: Honeybee Foods License (Hallidie Plaza) - The resolution originally proposed a $1,200 monthly base fee for an underground electrical utility line. Real Estate Director Gorham requested an amendment to change to an annual fee of $1,200. The committee adopted the amendment but, because it was substantive, voted to continue the item to the April 24 committee meeting. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) to full board. - Items 2 & 3: Approved unanimously to full board. Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor. - Item 4: Approved unanimously to full board. - Item 5: Approved unanimously to full board. - Item 6: Amended (yearly fee) and continued to April 24, 2024 meeting (3-0). - Item 7: Amended per BLA recommendation, then approved unanimously as amended to full board. - Item 8: Amended to add notification requirement, then approved unanimously as amended to full board. - Item 9: Approved unanimously to full board. - Item 10: Approved unanimously to full board. - Items 11 & 12: Amended per Supervisor Dorsey and OEWD, then approved unanimously as amended to full board. - Item 13: Approved unanimously to full board. The meeting adjourned at approximately 2:00 PM.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, April 17, 2024, at 1:45 PM (local time) to discuss a range of public safety and oversight matters. The meeting included the recognition of an officer, a report on crime trends, updates from the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a presentation on the Early Intervention System (EIS), and a discussion on the department’s response to a DPA audit on misconduct handling. The commission also voted on several items, including the adoption of a revised equipment policy and a closed session. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously received and filed the Police Commission Report of Disciplinary Actions for the first quarter of 2024, the Internal Affairs Annual Report for 2023, and the SFPD and DPA SP 1421 monthly report. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Ward Klein urged the commission to refer a criminal complaint to the district attorney’s office regarding alleged illegal issuance of credentials into police and public safety systems, citing California Penal Code sections 502 and 653.2. He also called for a top-to-bottom review of senior officers. - J. Connor B. Ortega expressed strong support for SFPD, congratulated the officer of the month, and praised the passage of Prop E, noting that the downward crime trend proves SFPD can succeed when given the right tools. - A public commenter thanked Chief Scott for the crime reduction report, but raised concerns about a potential hacking incident during a March marine unit rescue, urging an investigation into system access. - Another commenter highlighted issues with plea deals, lengthy hearings, and judicial conduct in the court system. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition: Officer Jeffrey Hospital was honored for his work in the Narcotics Division, particularly for removing fentanyl from the streets. The narcotics team has seized over 70 kilos of fentanyl since May 2023. Lieutenant Kevin Healy described Officer Hospital’s tenacity during a January 10, 2024 arrest in the Tenderloin. - Chief’s Report: Chief Scott reported that overall part one crime is down 30% compared to the same period last year (about 4,400 fewer crimes). Property crimes are down 32% (about 4,200 fewer), violent crime down 14% (about 200 fewer), homicides down 31% (9 vs. 13), and gun violence down 35% (35 victims vs. 54). He highlighted a homicide arrest on April 5, 2024, on the 2300 block of Mission Street, with a suspect arrested within nine hours, and a marine unit rescue of four individuals from a capsized boat on April 14. The chief also noted a protest on the Golden Gate Bridge on April 15 resulting in approximately 30 arrests (by CHP, SFPD provided mutual aid) with zero uses of force, and a small sideshow that was quickly dispersed. - Commission Reports: Commissioner Walker reported on a ride-along in the Tenderloin, noting effective interagency cooperation and the use of private-sector cameras. Commissioner Benedicto reported on the same ride-along and proposed “pieclites” – a community policing concept involving staffed kiosks. He also attended the 20th anniversary remembrance of Officer Isaac Espinoza. Commissioner Yi reported on a merchant walk with the district attorney and chief regarding blessing scams in Chinatown. Commissioner Yanies discussed language access discrepancies in the IA report and the progress on a juvenile pre-booking diversion DGO. - DPA Director’s Report: Executive Director Henderson reported that DPA’s audit division received its third consecutive Knight Award from the Association of Local Government Auditors for the 2023 audit on SFPD’s handling of officer misconduct. He noted a 12% decrease in cases opened compared to 2023, a 4% increase in cases closed, an 18% increase in sustained cases, and that 79% of cases over 270 days are tolled (22 of 28). He also mentioned that 112 cases sustained by DPA are pending with the chief, and 13 are pending with the commission. - Department General Order 10.02 (Equipment): The commission adopted the revised DGO after Chief Scott waived the community engagement process required by Prop E, citing extensive prior feedback. The motion passed unanimously (6-0). - Early Intervention System (EIS) Presentation: Sergeant Darwin Nobal presented Q3 and Q4 2023 data. Use of force indicator points decreased by 75.4% in Q3 and 67.4% in Q4 compared to the previous year. EIS alerts decreased by 59.8% in Q3 and 70.1% in Q4. The department is piloting a new system from Benchmark (First Sign) in July 2024. Director Henderson raised concerns about incorporating implicit bias tracking and abeyance criteria into the system. - Discussion on SFPD’s Response to DPA Audit on Officer Misconduct: Stephen Betts, risk management attorney, presented the department’s response to the 31 audit recommendations. The department plans to implement 27, with 14 already completed. Disagreements remain on two topics: defining and tracking implicit bias (SFPD cites feasibility concerns) and establishing criteria for holding discipline in abeyance (SFPD argues discretion is needed). Commissioner Byrne noted inconsistencies in recommended penalties for similar violations. Key Outcomes - Adopted: Department General Order 10.02 (Equipment) – unanimous vote (6-0). - Pulled: Item 8 (DGO 6.20, Member-Involved Domestic Violence) was rescheduled for a future meeting. - Closed Session: The commission voted (5-0) to hold Item 14 in closed session, asserting attorney-client privilege. After closed session, they voted (5-0) not to disclose any discussion and to maintain the privilege. - Consent Calendar and Minutes: Approved unanimously. - Future Agenda Items: The Internal Affairs Annual Report will be agendized for a future meeting per Director Henderson’s request. The commission also agreed to calendar a discussion on SFPD’s response to sexual assault cases and a presentation on the “pieclites” proposal.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a hearing on the city's continuum of homeless services, supportive housing, and tenant protection services. The meeting also included a motion to continue a hearing on the Five-Year Financial Plan March update. The committee heard presentations from the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD), the Department of Building Inspection (DBI), and a coalition of community-based organizations. Over 50 members of the public provided testimony, overwhelmingly opposing cuts and urging increased investment. Public Comments & Testimony - Jennifer Friedenbach (Coalition on Homelessness) stated that austerity measures would worsen humanitarian crises and called for balancing the budget through revenue from corporations and the wealthy, not cuts to services. - Tabitha Allen (Tenderloin Housing Clinic) emphasized that flat funding is effectively a cut due to rising costs, and that permanent supportive housing providers face over $8 million in rental arrears and $5 million in vacancy losses. - Mayasa Mudio (Housing Rights Committee) warned that a 10% cut to the Code Enforcement Outreach Program (COP) could lead to staff reductions and reduced ability to address habitability issues. - Laura Chiera (Legal Assistance to the Elderly) and Krista Alderson (Eviction Defense Collaborative) noted that 92% of tenants with full-scope representation remain housed, and alerted to a projected 50% cut in Emergency Rental Assistance Program (ERAP) funding, which could result in up to 5,000 individuals losing their homes. - Multiple tenants and family members spoke in support of SRO Families United Collaborative, stressing the importance of language-accessible tenant counseling and code enforcement assistance. - Joel Wilson (Hospitality House) urged the committee to fight for vulnerable residents and suggested a "woodshed conversation" with 84 billionaires to address the deficit. - Hope Kimer (Compass Family Services) highlighted that 442 families are waiting for shelter, including children sleeping outside. - Dozens of other speakers from organizations including Causa Justa, Glide, and the SF Latino Parity and Equity Coalition called for maintaining or increasing funding for housing, prevention, and legal services. Discussion Items - HSH Presentation (Shireen McSpadden and Gigi Whitley): The proposed budget maintains current services and bed capacity through fiscal year 2026 by leveraging state grants and prior year fund balance. It avoids programmatic cuts but defers significant fiscal cliffs. HSH reported helping over 6,700 people exit homelessness in the past two years, and noted a 7% budget decrease overall due to expiring one-time funds. The department identified $4–6 million in general fund reductions through contract efficiencies and capturing underspending. - MOHCD Presentation (Brian Shi): Tenant protection programs (eviction legal defense, ERAP, education, mediation) total about $66.6 million annually. The budget faces a projected reduction in ERAP from $20+ million to roughly $12.5 million from recurring OCO funds, with one-time enhancements expiring. MOHCD provided the mayor's office with options to defer cuts, including using one-time general fund carryover and eliminating a $1 million capital rehab program. - DBI Presentation (Christine Gisperick): DBI's general fund grants for code enforcement outreach (COP) face a 10% reduction (about $500,000), but the department noted that the program has been underspent by a similar amount in prior years. DBI is also implementing fee increases averaging 40% phased in over three years to address revenue shortfalls. - Community Coalition Presentation (Multiple Speakers): The coalition presented a vision for dignified shelter, diverse housing options, and a coordinated by-name system. They opposed cuts to family and youth housing (citing $11 million in Prop C reductions) and called for investment in vehicularly housed populations, better encampment resolution practices, and fully funded contracts for supportive housing providers. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Five-Year Financial Plan Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair on a motion by Chair Chan (seconded by Walton), passed with three ayes (Melgar and Peskin absent). - Item 2 (Homeless Services and Tenant Protections Hearing): After presentations and public comment, the committee filed the hearing on a motion by Chair Chan (seconded by Walton), passed with three ayes. No specific budget decisions were made; the hearing served as an early opportunity for public input and departmental discussion ahead of the mayor's May 31 budget proposal and June budget hearings.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on April 16, 2024, led by President Aaron Peskin. The meeting featured commendations for emergency dispatchers, approval of numerous routine and financial items, introduction of legislation on housing, public safety, and social equity, and extensive public comment focusing on police funding and city response to sexual assault. Consent Calendar (Items 1-13) - All items were approved unanimously. These included routine appropriations, several lawsuit settlements (totaling over $3.9 million, with individual settlements for Mitzey Davis/Leslie Lankster ($100,000), Jocelyn Li ($45,000), Ibrahim Nimer Shiheiber ($50,000), Charles Heard ($900,000), Kirstin Johnson et al. ($75,000), Yes in My Back Yard/Sonja Trauss ($32,000 by appellants), and Danielle Dillard/Kim Lee ($2,800,000)), a retroactive MOU with the Deputy Sheriffs' Association, and amendments to the Building and Planning Codes regarding disability access and commercial uses. Regular Agenda (Items 14-31) These resolutions and ordinances were adopted unanimously on a single vote: - Amendment to DFS Group duty-free lease at the International Terminal. - Agreement with Santa Clara Valley Water District for the Intertie facility. - $890,000 expenditure from the SoMa Community Stabilization Fund. - Acceptance of grants for Union Square Park Revitalization ($2M), Tobacco Grant Award ($2.89M), and Transform Mental and Behavioral Health ($909,095). - Ordinance amending the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA) requiring notice of foreclosure for multifamily buildings. - Annual reports for Noe Valley, Castro, and Discover Polk Community Benefit Districts. - Umbrella MOU with SFUSD for green infrastructure (40-year term). - Authorization to apply for the Prohousing Designation Program. - Liquor license determinations for Kim Huong Cafe and Origin Boutique Nightclub. - Parklet shared space designation at 1429 Mendell Street. - Reappointments to the SFMTA Board (Janet Tarlov, Fiona Hinze) and Treasury Oversight Committee (Kevin Kone). Special Order 2:30 PM - Commendations for Emergency Dispatchers The Board recognized National Public Safety Telecommunications Week. Three awards were presented: Dorian Locke (Tony Hardley Award for Excellence in Supervision), Bill Hackathon (DEM Dispatcher of the Year), and Valerie Tucker (EMS Dispatcher of the Year). DEM Director Mary Ellen Carroll and awardees spoke, honoring the work of dispatchers and remembering deceased colleague Florinda "Flo" Picasso. Legislation Introduced at Roll Call Several key legislative items were introduced by supervisors: - Supervisor Preston Introduced resolutions to retain state funding for the Market Match program (threatened by a $33.2 million proposed cut by Governor Newsom) and support AB 2115 (Methadone access). - Supervisor Ronan Announced a hearing request, co-sponsored by all 11 supervisors, to investigate the city's handling of sexual assault and harassment allegations, specifically evaluating the SHARP office she created in 2018 following an article in the San Francisco Standard. Also introduced resolutions supporting ACA 1 (lowering the voting threshold for housing bonds) and declaring SF SPCA Day. - Supervisor Safai (who was absent during initial roll call but participated later) Introduced a resolution designating Cesar Chavez Day as a paid city holiday. - Supervisor Stefani Introduced a resolution supporting AB 2479 (sober living facilities) and delivered a powerful speech on the systemic failures in addressing sexual violence. - Supervisor Walton Introduced a resolution supporting the California Legislative Black Caucus's 2024 Reparations Priority Bill Package. - Supervisor Mandelman Introduced resolutions supporting AB 2882 (Community Corrections Accountability Act) and recognizing National Independent Bookstore Day. Public Comments & Testimony - Police Budget & Care Not Cops: Over a dozen speakers from Lavender Phoenix, the Anti-Police Terror Project, and allied groups demanded a 50% cut ($400 million) to the SFPD budget, redirecting funds to housing, food banks, and social services. They cited persistent budget overruns (e.g., $25.4M budgeted overtime vs. $80M actual in 2023) and the killing of Binko Brown by a security guard. A healthcare worker coalition requested DPH divestment from policing. - Nonprofit Oversight: Several speakers raised allegations of retaliation, discrimination, and corruption at non-profit organizations receiving city funds, such as the Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation (TNDC) and Centro del Pueblo. They called for a Board investigation into the management and use of taxpayer funds by these entities. - Sexual Assault Response: A speaker stated that sexual assault is a pervasive problem in city politics, noting the article about John Jacobo and alleging a currently serving male supervisor touched them. - Other Comments: Speakers addressed the proposed cuts to the Market Match program, support for the MENA category checkbox (AB 2763), issues at Laguna Honda Hospital, and general critiques of city policies. Key Outcomes - Items Continued: - Item 35 (Supporting SB 1012 on Psychedelic Therapy): Continued one week for further deliberation to secure unanimous support. - Item 37 (Supporting AB 886, the California Journalism Preservation Act): Continued one week pending amendments by the author. - Hearing Ordered: The Board will hold a hearing on the city's response to sexual assault and harassment, examining the SFPD, District Attorney's Office, and the SHARP office. - Adoptions Without Reference: All remaining adoption items (National Donate Life Month, support for SB 1031, etc.) and appointments were approved. - Adjournment in Memory: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Maureen O'Brien Sullivan, Eleanor Coppola, and Raymond Patlan.
On April 15, 2024, the San Francisco Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronan and joined by Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Committee Member Asha Safai, met to consider four agenda items. The meeting began at 6:15 PM (UTC) and covered ordinances related to street vending enforcement, general obligation bond pass-throughs to tenants, emergency repair contract reporting, and updates to conflict-of-interest filing requirements. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 – Vending Requirements and Restrictions: - Jim Swinier, representing Momo's restaurant, reported a 40% decline in merchandise sales since unlicensed vendors began operating near Oracle Park. He urged enforcement against illegal vending, stating that legal businesses were being harmed. - A representative from Gletcha (24 Latino Cultural District) expressed support for the ordinance but requested that changes positively impact legitimate permitted street vendors, noting that the Mission Street vendors are permitted and cooperative. Item 2 – General Obligation Bond Passthroughs: - Numerous tenants and housing advocates spoke in support of the ordinance. Ingrid Heedle, Armando Rodriguez, and others argued that corporate landlords (e.g., Veritas, Mosser) exploit a loophole by passing through property tax increases that have not occurred since 2005. They cited average pass-throughs of $20.66 per month ($250/year) and called the practice "double charging" for a cost not incurred. - Representatives from the Council of Community Housing Organizations, Housing Rights Committee, Tenants Together, and SomCAN urged passage, noting that the city's capital plan has kept GO bond property tax rates flat since 2005-2006. - Salman Sherriott, a small property owner, opposed the legislation, arguing that the current 50-50 split is fair and that tenants can already seek hardship deferrals. He warned that the change could reduce support for future bonds. - Charlie Goss of the San Francisco Apartment Association urged a "no" vote, stating the ordinance would reduce pass-throughs by 80-90% and break the 2003 settlement (Prop H). - Craig Orbelian, a family property manager, suggested a carve-out for small landlords. Item 3 – Emergency Contracts for Repairs: No public comments. Item 4 – Form 700 Filers: No public comments. Discussion Items Item 1 – Public Works Code – Vending Requirements and Restrictions (File 240056) Supervisor Ronan introduced the ordinance to streamline enforcement against illegal fencing operations, which have harmed legitimate vendors. Key provisions: require vendor photos and receipts, limit plot sizes, reduce clearance time to 10 minutes, allow SF Public Works to adjust operating regulations without commission approval, and reiterate existing requirements (e.g., tax registration, no vending in residential zones). A non-substantive amendment restored a sentence urging vendors to remove items. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about the effectiveness of written warnings for repeat offenders, asking whether the first contact itself could serve as a warning. Deputy Director Michael Lennon of DPW explained that enforcement has evolved to a cat-and-mouse game, and that warnings are still given. The committee discussed the need for better guidance from the City Attorney. The item was amended and recommended to the full board. Item 2 – Administrative, Municipal Elections Codes – General Obligation Bond Passthroughs (File 240174) President Peskin presented the ordinance to modify how GO bond pass-throughs are calculated. Since 2005, the city's capital plan has ensured that new GO bonds do not increase the property tax rate, yet landlords pass through costs based on a formula that assumes tax increases. The ordinance would base pass-throughs on the increase in the property tax rate for GO bonds since the tenant's move-in date (or 2005, whichever is later). The Rent Board reported that from 107 hardship applications, 56 were granted (98% rate), with average pass-through of $20.66/month and average deferred amount of $2.12. Controller's Office analyst Jamie Whitaker explained the current math: for FY2023-24, $237 million in debt service yields a pass-through rate of 7.26 cents per $100 assessed value. The proposed change would use the actual rate difference since move-in. Supervisor Chan asked about differences between city, school district, and college district bonds. Peskin noted that only the city has a self-imposed cap, but other entities may adopt similar policies. A minor amendment was added. The item was recommended to the full board. Item 3 – Administrative Code – Emergency Contracts for Repairs (File 240227) Supervisor Chan introduced the ordinance requiring departments to provide estimated costs when seeking Board approval for emergency repair contracts over $250,000, and to file a final cost summary after completion. This is intended to improve budget oversight. No questions or public comments. The item was recommended to the full board. Item 4 – Campaign and Governmental Conduct Code – Form 700 Filers (File 240016) Supervisor Chan presented the annual update from the Ethics Commission, adding required filers (Children and Families First Commission, Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District Authority), streamlining Proposition Q filer designations, and making non-substantive corrections. No questions or public comments. The item was recommended to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Vending): Motion to amend (restore sentence) and recommend to full board passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2 (GO Bond Passthroughs): Motion to amend (add "pursuant to this chapter 37") and recommend to full board passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 3 (Emergency Contracts): Motion to recommend to full board passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 4 (Form 700): Motion to recommend to full board passed unanimously (3-0). All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on April 23, 2024.
This regular meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, focused on two related items concerning the Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island development: a resolution endorsing an aspirational statement for the islands, and an ordinance amending planning and zoning codes to keep the project on track. The meeting began at 9:45 AM and concluded after public testimony and unanimous votes. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - Opposition: One speaker criticized the aspirational statement for lacking a focus on beauty and argued that proposed building heights (up to 240 feet) would waste the sky. The speaker also suggested creating a wildlife refuge staffed by homeless individuals to address homelessness. - Support: - Mauricio Chavez, organizer for the North California Carpenters Union Local 22, spoke in support, noting that Stage 1 has generated nearly 1,000 units (over 250 below-market-rate) and that the project supports 82,000 unit city housing goals. He emphasized the creation of hundreds of union jobs during the economic downturn. - Jay Anthony Manhivar, carpenter and union member, shared personal testimony about how union membership improved his life through fair wages and benefits. - Alex Francois, manager of a construction training program on the island, testified that the project has funded training for people with barriers to employment (e.g., formerly incarcerated, veterans, women) and that a halt would endanger those programs. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Resolution endorsing aspirational statement): Supervisor Matt Dorsey (District 6) introduced the resolution, which endorses a shared vision of inclusion, equity, sustainability, opportunity, and connection developed through a community process involving Treasure Island Development Authority (TIDA), Treasure Island Community Development (TICD), and One Treasure Island. He offered minor technical amendments (striking/clarifying text). - Item 2 (Planning Code & Zoning Map amendments): The ordinance updates the Special Use District for Treasure Island/Yerba Buena Island to: (a) adjust bulk/massing figures (from 10,500 to 10,600 sq ft for buildings 181–240 ft) to recover lost square footage from fire code changes; (b) allow minor modifications if total floor area remains constant; (c) streamline the amendment process for the Design for Development document; and (d) add up to 5 feet in height on several parcels (to 45, 65, 75 ft) to resolve height constraints from seismic and floor assembly requirements. Also corrects a clerical error on height district designation. - Presentations: Anne Marie Rogers (TIDA Deputy Director) highlighted that nearly a thousand homes (991 units) are under construction, that the project is the city's largest underway, and that infrastructure (geotech, sea-level rise adaptation, new ferry, parks) is progressing. Jessica Look (Planning Department) explained the technical amendments, which were approved by the Planning Commission on April 4. Sherry Williams and Nella Gonzalves (One Treasure Island) presented the aspirational statement, developed over six months with community input (127 survey responses), and stated their support for the amendments. Key Outcomes - Motion to amend Item 1: The committee unanimously (3-0) adopted the technical amendments proposed by Supervisor Dorsey. - Motion to forward items to full board: The committee unanimously (3-0) voted to send both Item 1 (as amended) and Item 2 to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The items are expected to appear on the Board's agenda on April 23, 2024.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, April 11, 2024, at 2:15 PM. Commissioners present: Vice President Moore, Commissioners Braun, Imperial, Coppel, Williams, and President Diamond. Commissioner Ruiz was absent. The meeting included continuances, commission matters, department matters, general public comment, and two regular calendar items. Consent Calendar - Items Proposed for Continuance: Item 1a (3225 Fillmore St – Solidcore gym formula retail) continued to May 9, 2024; Item 2a (320-322 Frederick St – Discretionary Review) continued to May 23, 2024; Item 3a (1234 Francisco St – roof decks) was withdrawn. All three continuances approved unanimously (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Two speakers addressed the commission. - Kai Georgia Shootish expressed concerns about demolition calculations and the need to codify the flat policy. She referenced price changes on two Noe Valley projects and questioned whether the drop in 311 notifications was due to the economy or the constraints reduction ordinance. - Hester pleaded for a commission discussion on sea level rise, noting a recent presentation by the Army Corps of Engineers and zoning changes needed along the waterfront, including Hunter’s Point and Ocean Beach. - Item 8 (4000 21st St) Public Comment: - Kai Georgia Shootish criticized the project’s 5% warning letter for demolition values and urged that the ADU be made available per Castro/LGBTQ District guidelines. - Steve Bain, adjacent property owner, expressed no confidence in the project sponsor’s ethics, claiming submitted plans were erroneous and that the project constituted a demolition that could destabilize his foundation. - Ray Willett, architect for neighbors, argued that the structural calculations require full demolition under Section 317 (new plywood shear panels) and asked the commission to enforce that section. - Jeremy Paul noted the large building limitation in the neighborhood was enacted to reduce property value acceleration and increase housing availability for the LGBTQ community, and urged the commission to send the project back. - Item 9 (350 Rhode Island St) Public Comment: No members of the public spoke. Discussion Items - Item 8 – 4000 21st Street (Conditional Use Authorization): The project sought a CUA under Planning Code Sections 249.92 and 303 for a vertical addition to an existing single-family dwelling at 4021st Street (RH-2 zoning, 40-X height district). The original proposal of a 1,128 sq ft addition was revised after the February 22 hearing to add a state-ADU. The revised proposal: 402 sq ft added to the primary unit (total 2,981 sq ft) plus a 1,016 sq ft ADU. The department recommended approval, finding consistency with the General Plan. Discussion centered on the ADU entrance (off Collingwood Street through a rear yard gate) and the risk of future merger with the main unit. Commissioner Moore expressed concern about the ADU bathroom elevation being level with the main unit’s garage entry, creating potential for wall removal. The architect, Ryan Knock, offered to lower the bathroom floor to match the rest of the ADU. Commissioner Braun moved to approve with that voluntary revision; seconded. After debate, the motion passed 4-1 (Moore dissenting). - Item 9 – 350 Rhode Island Street (Office Allocation Amendment): The project sought to modify a previously approved office allocation (motion 1498, year 2000) to remove the exterior sunshade louver system on east and south facades. The Zoning Administrator determined the modification was significant, requiring commission action under Planning Code Section 321 (as amended by Prop E, which eliminated the quality of design finding). Staff recommended approval. The project sponsor (Halfham) cited marketability, tenant desire for outdoor views, and transient safety issues (people taking shelter under louvers in winter). Commissioner Moore raised concerns about loss of architectural character and building energy performance, noting the louvers were integral to the original energy calculations. The architect, Sean Caps, stated that Title 24 compliance would be addressed at building permit stage and interior window film could be added. Commissioner Koppel focused on transient safety; Commissioner Imperial favored retaining louvers for energy efficiency. Commissioner Braun moved to approve; the motion failed 2-4 (Braun and Diamond for; Williams, Imperial, Coppel, Moore against). Vice President Moore then moved to continue to May 23, 2024 with direction to the sponsor to develop a design solution that addresses energy efficiency and external sunshades while mitigating transient concerns, and to bring the ownership team. The motion passed unanimously 6-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1-3 (Continuances): Approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 8 (4000 21st St): Approved 4-1 (Moore dissenting) with the architect’s voluntary commitment to lower the ADU bathroom floor to match the ADU level. The project will proceed with building permits subject to DBI review. - Item 9 (350 Rhode Island St): Motion to approve failed 2-4. Motion to continue to May 23, 2024 with direction approved unanimously (6-0). The project sponsor must present revised architectural and energy performance solutions addressing sunshade removal, building aesthetics, and tenant safety. - Commission Matters: Vice President Moore requested a future agenda item to review the 2017 residential flat policy and its alignment with housing element implementation. Staff agreed to schedule it at the next officers’ meeting. - Department Matters: No director’s announcements. The April 18 meeting was canceled.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 18, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Member Aaron Peskin. The meeting covered six agenda items, including a commemorative street naming, acceptance of public infrastructure for Pier 70, regulations on tobacco paraphernalia establishments, a special use district at 900 Kearney Street, and citywide expansion of allowable commercial uses. Consent Calendar - None (all items were discussed individually and voted on separately). Public Comments & Testimony - Agenda Item 1 (Commemorative Street Naming): Multiple speakers (Nancy Abdul Shakur, Marco, Carlos Molino, Kimberly, Eric) expressed strong support for renaming a portion of Park Street at Holly Park Circle as "Sean Monterosa Boulevard" in memory of Sean Monterosa, a community activist and youth mentor killed by police in 2020. Speakers highlighted his contributions, the family's efforts in community art and libraries, and the need for recognition. - Agenda Items 2 & 3 (Pier 70): No public comments were received. - Agenda Item 4 (Tobacco Paraphernalia Establishments): Several speakers (Prathi Watek, Greg Johnson, Miriam, Chris Schulman, Kathleen Gong, Rosa Alvarado, Areli Hernandez) supported the ordinance and amendments, citing oversaturation, public safety concerns, and negative impacts on residents, especially at night. They urged stronger controls. - Agenda Item 5 (900 Kearney Street SUD): No public comments were received. - Agenda Item 6 (Citywide Commercial Use Expansion): Chris Schulman spoke in support of amendments to the Polk Street NCD, including removing barriers for entertainment and protecting a retail corridor on Hyde Street. Discussion Items - Item 1: Commissioner Melgar introduced the resolution to rename the street. Ashley and Michelle Monterosa, sisters of Sean, presented a slideshow detailing his life and community impact. The committee voted to send the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Items 2 & 3: Cathal Hennessey (Department of Public Works) presented the acceptance of infrastructure for Pier 70 Phase 1, including streets, sidewalks, and utilities, and the associated encroachment permits for custom paving, historical building frames, and conduit. Christine Maher (Port of San Francisco) was also present. The committee voted to send both items to the full Board with positive recommendations. - Item 4: Vice Chair Preston introduced amendments to the ordinance (originally applying to North of Market Special Use District) to also cover the Lower Polk Street NCD, apply a quarter-mile boundary for TPE restrictions, and shorten the abandonment period for non-conforming TPEs from 18 months to 180 days. He noted coordination with community groups. Planning staff Audrey Merlone was acknowledged. The committee voted to adopt the amendments and continue the item to March 25, 2024. - Item 5: President Peskin presented the ordinance to create the 900 Kearney Street Special Use District in Chinatown, allowing non-retail professional services and arts activity uses. He proposed duplicating the file, amending the duplicate to clarify use sizes (requiring re-referral to Planning), and sending the original to the full Board. The committee voted accordingly. - Item 6: Carrie Bernbach (Office of Small Business) presented amendments to the citywide commercial use expansion legislation, reflecting feedback from the committee and community. Changes included adjusting hours and formula retail rules for limited corner commercial uses, modifying use controls in the North Beach NCD, and removing the impact fee exemption. President Peskin proposed additional amendments regarding use restrictions based on nearest NCD or SUD within a quarter mile (rather than half mile) and removing certain use size caps. After discussion with staff (Veronica Flores) and clarification, the committee voted to adopt the amendments and continue the item to March 25, 2024. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to send to full Board with positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Peskin, Melgar). - Items 2 & 3: Motion to send to full Board with positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 4: Motion to adopt amendments (as described) passed 3-0; motion to continue to March 25, 2024 passed 3-0. - Item 5: Motion to amend the duplicate file (regarding use sizes) passed 3-0; motion to continue duplicate to call of chair passed 3-0; motion to send original file to full Board as committee report passed 3-0. - Item 6: Motion to adopt amendments (including quarter-mile radius, removal of use size caps, and all yellow amendments from OSB) passed 3-0; motion to continue to March 25, 2024 passed 3-0.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, April 9, 2024, at 11:15 AM. The meeting covered reports on economic recovery, equity, and key projects; approval of a consent calendar item; authorization of three grants totaling $900,000 for youth internship programs; and an informational presentation and resolution regarding the Mission Rock project's Parcel F. The meeting adjourned at 4:45 PM. Consent Calendar - Item 7A: Resolution 2417 – Authorized advertising for competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2852, Amador Street Infrastructure Improvements. Passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made on any agenda item, either in person or via phone. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A) – Assistant Director Michael Martin presented on behalf of Executive Director Elaine Forbes, who is on leave until later in April. Highlights included: - The 7th annual contract open house at Pier 27 (March 2024) to connect small contractors with resources. - Pop-ups on the Plaza celebrating Black women makers (March 30). - Welcoming USNS Harvey Milk at Piers 30–32 with Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Mayor London Breed. - A temporary mural by Joey Rose at Fisherman’s Wharf (25 x 8 ft) honoring crabbers. - Commercial Dungeness crab season ended early on April 8 due to whale presence; salmon season runs May–October. - Cruise ship Grand Princess to arrive at Pier 80 on April 27 for a 10-hour turnaround with 5,000 passengers. - Dry dock No. 2 RFO received no responses; potential sole source sale of both dry docks. - Heron’s Head Park new bird guide via QR code. - Flood study draft plan public comment period closed March 29 with over 150 comments; outreach to nearly 1,000 people via events, walking tours, webinars, and in-language workshops. - Youth outreach through SF Fellows presentations at John O’Connell and Mission High Schools. - Commissioners praised the report and asked about support for fishermen, the Fisherman’s Wharf redevelopment plan, and the Pier 80 cruise call. Commissioner Harrington suggested seeking federal/state support for the crab season disruption. Commissioner Lee expressed concern for fishermen’s livelihoods. - Item 8A: Grants for Rising Tides Internship Programs (Resolutions 2418, 2419, 2420) – Elizabeth Alexander Toots and Tiffany Tatum presented. Three grants totaling $900,000: - $300,000 to Cal Maritime (7.5-year term) to host up to 12 high school interns for a weeklong summer program. - $300,000 to Enterprise for Youth (2 years) for payroll/administration for Rising Tides Maritime (6-week summer program). - $300,000 to Enterprise for Youth (2 years) for Rising Tides Operations (year-round youth employment, ages 16–24). - Discussion: Commissioner Harrington raised concerns about Cal Maritime’s reported toxic culture; staff assured chaperones would be present and planned to engage Cal Maritime leadership on equity. Commissioner Lee noted difficulty recruiting youth; staff emphasized in-school relationship building. Commissioner Adams highlighted the need for exposure and equity, contrasting Cal Maritime with the Tongue Point Job Corps. The grants were approved unanimously. - Item 9A: Mission Rock Parcel F – Revised Phase 1 Submittal (Resolution 2421) – Josh Keene presented an informational update and resolution. Parcel A (The Canyon) leasing: after 10 months, 156 of 283 units leased (60%), with 90% AMI units fully leased, 120% AMI at 28%, and 150% AMI at only 8%. For Parcel F (The Verde), staff recommended reallocating BMR units: increasing 90% AMI from 13 to 35, decreasing 120% AMI from 55 to 24, and eliminating 150% AMI units. This maintains 30% affordable for Phase 1 (Parcel A 36%, Parcel F 23.2%). The overall project commitment remains 40% affordable. Dan Adams from the Mayor’s Office of Housing supported the modification, noting 150% AMI units are priced above market. Commissioners expressed support, with Commissioner Gilman advocating for deeper affordability (30% AMI) in future phases. Commissioner Harrington asked about Phase 2 timeline (construction targeted 2026). The resolution passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2417 (Consent Calendar) – Passed unanimously. - Resolutions 2418, 2419, 2420 (Grants for Rising Tides internships) – Passed unanimously. - Resolution 2421 (Mission Rock Parcel F amendment) – Passed unanimously. - New Business: Commissioner Harrington requested exploring federal/state support for the crab/salmon fishing industry and periodic commission meetings at community venues (e.g., Southeast Community Center). Commissioner Gilman suggested negotiating a tour of cruise ships at Pier 80 for youth from the Southeast. Staff will follow up on both items.