The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on April 9, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of prior minutes, general public comment, a report from the Chief Diversity Officer on racial equity initiatives, discussion and approval of the consent calendar, and several regular agenda items including updates to the Water System Improvement Program, water and wastewater fee schedules, an easement acquisition, modifications to the Green Infrastructure Grant Program, and a discussion on recruiting a new Commission Secretary. The meeting also included a closed session on litigation and settlement matters. Consent Calendar - The commission approved the consent calendar (items 6A through 6J) unanimously with a roll call vote of 3-0. - Prior to the vote, Commissioner Maxwell questioned the difference between items 6D (water main replacement with earthquake-resistant ductile iron pipe, manufactured in Japan by Kubota) and 6E (standard ductile iron pipe). Staff explained that item 6D is part of a pilot project to install seismic backbone pipes to San Francisco General Hospital, while item 6E uses standard pipe but with upgraded joints. The earthquake-resistant pipe is about twice as expensive but proven for large earthquakes. Staff noted that the cost of such pipe may decrease as more U.S. manufacturers develop seismic joints. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Two speakers addressed the commission. The first speaker, an environmentalist, urged the SFPUC to use the underutilized contracting center to connect elder wisdom and resources, and requested commission approval. The second speaker, Jacob Evans, organizer with Chair California, commented on the SFPUC’s lawsuit against the State Water Board over freshwater flows to the Bay-Delta. He urged the commission to accept the recent court ruling rather than appeal, stating that appealing would waste ratepayer dollars and harm vulnerable Delta communities. He asked that future conversations on this matter be made public. - Public Comment on Item 7 (Water System Improvement Program): Nicole from the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) spoke in support of the staff recommendation, noting BAWSCA staff had met with SFPUC and appreciated the proposed changes. - Public Comment on Item 5A (Chief Diversity Officer Report): One speaker commented on the need for good leadership and kindness in the workplace, referencing the HR system and temporary workers hired during the pandemic. - No public comments were made on items 6, 8-9, 10, 11, 12, or 14. Discussion Items - Item 5A – Report of the General Manager: Chief Diversity Officer Update – Chris Bijou, Chief Diversity Officer, presented an oral update on racial equity and inclusion initiatives over the past nine months. He emphasized three focus areas: relationships (building trust with staff and community), professional development (creating a sustainable, internal curriculum rooted in equity), and rethinking data use (moving beyond quantitative metrics to qualitative measures). He noted that the agency’s Racial Equity Action Plan has many action items, but the team is prioritizing four pillars: hiring/recruiting, retention/promotion, mobility/professional development, and organizational culture. Commissioners praised the approach and asked for more concrete examples in future reports. Commissioner Rivera asked about recurring themes from staff feedback; Bijou cited a convoluted hiring process and a need for improved management skills. - Item 7 – Water System Improvement Program (WSIP) Proposed Revised Scope, Schedule, and Budget – Katie Miller, Director of Water Capital Programs, presented the March 2024 proposed revised WSIP. The program is 99% complete; only three active projects remain. Key changes: the Alameda Creek Recapture Project will have a schedule extension to June 30, 2032, and a $5 million budget increase for planning and redesign. Staff noted that further budget increases are likely as costs become better understood. The commission approved the item unanimously. - Items 8 & 9 – Water and Wastewater Miscellaneous Fee Schedules – Christina Venice, Rates Analyst, presented the proposed updates. The changes result from a 2025 fee study that evaluated existing fees using a bottom-up cost methodology. Key proposals: new fees for backflow inspection and after-hours temporary service shutdown; elimination of the flow restricting installations fee, pending shutoff notice fee, and others. The fee schedules also include CPI escalations, no changes, and structural updates (e.g., tiered meter test fees). The commission approved both items separately, each by a 3-0 vote. - Item 10 – Easement Acquisition for Pipeline Crossing – Staff presented a purchase and sale agreement for a 1,386-square-foot easement from the San Mateo County Flood and Sea Level Rise Resiliency District (One Shoreline) for $70,000, to allow an aerial pipeline crossing over Colma Creek for the Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Project. A correction was noted: the pipeline is 8-inch, not 12-inch. The commission approved the item with the correction. - Item 11 – Green Infrastructure Grant Program Guidelines Modification – Sarah Bloom, Senior Watershed Planner, presented proposed modifications including increasing the maximum cost per acre of impervious surface managed from $930,000 to $1,035,000, raising the maximum grant award from $2 million to $2.5 million, expanding eligibility to include projects in the public right-of-way, and revising disbursement for city departments. The commission approved the modifications unanimously. - Item 12 – Process to Recruit and Select a New Commission Secretary – President Paulson proposed that the President serve on the interview committee and that the final candidate be presented to the full commission. The commission agreed without objection. The position is posted and will remain open for at least two weeks. - Item 14 – Items Initiated by Commissioners – Commissioner Maxwell announced that the next meeting (April 23, 2024) would be her last as a commissioner. Commissioners expressed gratitude and surprise. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Items 6A-J): Approved unanimously (3-0). - Item 7 – Water System Improvement Program Changes: Approved unanimously. Staff directed to send a notice of change report to the State Water Resources Control Board and the Alfred E. Alquist Seismic Safety Commission. - Item 8 – Water Miscellaneous Fee Schedule: Approved unanimously, effective July 1, 2024. - Item 9 – Wastewater Miscellaneous Fee Schedule: Approved unanimously, effective July 1, 2024. - Item 10 – Easement Acquisition: Approved unanimously, with the corrected resolution referencing an 8-inch pipeline. - Item 11 – Green Infrastructure Grant Program Guidelines: Approved unanimously. Staff will submit revised guidelines to the Board of Supervisors and request a two-year extension of delegated authority through June 2026. - Item 12 – Commission Secretary Recruitment: The commission approved the proposed process: President Paulson will serve on the interview committee, and the selected candidate will be presented to the full commission. - Closed Session: The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege. Staff recommended approval of settlements in items 17, 18, and 19 (personal injury and property damage claims). No action was taken on items 20 and 21 (litigation updates). The commission adjourned without further action.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, April 4, 2024, at approximately 1:00 PM (local time) to consider a full agenda including continuances, consent calendar items, a major discussion on the city's housing element rezoning, approval of amendments to the Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island project, an informational update on the 3501 Cesar Chavez medical office building, a conditional use authorization for 600 20th Street, and a contentious discretionary review and variance for an unpermitted rear addition at 820 Laguna Honda Boulevard. The meeting lasted several hours and included public testimony on multiple items. Consent Calendar - Items 4, 5, and 6 were approved unanimously (6-0) without discussion: 254 Jules Avenue (conditional use for five+ bedrooms), 680 Folsom Street (conversion of retail to office), and 410 Jessie Street (Intermediate Length Occupancy unit). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed the commission on the housing element rezoning. Catherine Petrin (Neighborhoods United San Francisco) welcomed the mayor's call for a revised plan but noted the April 4 date was originally scheduled for upzoning discussion. Marie Joyce (Outer Richmond homeowner) opposed the upzoning, citing concerns about displacement, traffic, and loss of neighborhood character. A resident of the Masonic/Geary area requested mailed updates for elderly neighbors and expressed fear that the rezoning would "gut" the neighborhood. A speaker from the public also discussed unpermitted alterations and demolition controls, referencing a property at 1363 Sanchez. - Treasure Island Project: Supportive testimony came from Mauricio Chavez and Pedro Mendez (NorCal Carpenters Union), Sherry Williams and Nella Gonzales (One Treasure Island), Elizabeth Kawada (Mercy Housing), and others, emphasizing job creation, affordable housing, and community benefits. Jeff Klein, a 25-year resident, opposed the project, citing risks from forever chemicals, earthquake hazards, sea level rise, and flood risks from megastorms. - 3501 Cesar Chavez (Medical Office Building): Robert Coleman raised concerns about the unfinished Guerrero Plaza park, part of the CPMC development agreement. - 820 Laguna Honda Boulevard: Numerous public speakers testified on both sides. Supporters of the variance (including friends and family of the owner) argued the addition was built with neighbor's knowledge and that the dispute was personal. Opponents (including the DR requester Tony Hall, Karen Tarantola of the Greater West Portal Neighborhood Association, former Supervisor M. Gonzalez, and others) stressed the illegal nature of the construction, the lack of permits, and the precedent of allowing code violations. Some speakers questioned the role of political connections. Discussion Items Commission Matters: Housing Element Rezoning - The commission discussed the mayor's April 3 letter calling for a revised rezoning plan. Director Hillis outlined a memo with topics for additional hearings: state density bonus, feasibility analysis, historic preservation, infrastructure, objective design standards, and equity. Commissioners expressed support for a more deliberative process, with Commissioner Moore emphasizing the importance of neighborhood-focused planning and defending the planning department from criticism. Commissioner Williams stressed that equity provisions of the housing element must remain central. The commission agreed to hold a series of topic-specific hearings in the coming months. Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island Project (Items 12a-c) - Staff and the project sponsor presented a package of amendments to the planning code, zoning map, design for development (D4D), and development agreement. Key changes include a five-foot height increase for certain zones, floor plate adjustments, and a new financing plan using $115 million in city general fund certificates of participation (COPs) to fund stage two infrastructure. The COPs would be repaid over 20 years (estimated $233 million principal and interest) from future tax revenues generated by the project. The project is on track to deliver nearly 2,000 homes in stage one, with 27.2% affordable. Stage two will add 1,300 units, including 250 affordable units and a 240-bed behavioral health facility. Commissioner Diamond added a finding noting the unique scale of infrastructure investment. Vice President Moore added a reference to LEED Platinum certification. The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to approve the three items with those findings. 3501 Cesar Chavez (Medical Office Building) – Informational - The project sponsor presented final designs for the 129,000-square-foot medical office building at the Mission Bernal Care Complex. The design uses GFRC panels to complement the existing hospital. Commissioners raised concerns about the delayed Guerrero Plaza park (part of the CPMC development agreement). Staff confirmed that a final design has been submitted and construction is expected to begin in 2024. The item was informational only, with no vote. 600 20th Street (Conditional Use Authorization) - The project seeks to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit and construct a five-story mixed-use building with lab, office, arts activity, and one residential unit. The design draws inspiration from the adjacent American Industrial Center. The project sponsor confirmed the building is being built for a specific user. The commission approved the CUA unanimously (6-0) with conditions added by staff, including bicycle parking refinements. 820 Laguna Honda Boulevard – Discretionary Review and Variance - This item involved legalizing a 10-foot-by-25-foot three-story rear extension built without permits approximately 20 years ago. The DR requesters (Tony Hall and the Greater West Portal Neighborhood Association) opposed legalization, citing privacy, noise, and the lack of permits. The project sponsor argued the owner believed permits were obtained and that the addition meets variance criteria. Staff recommended taking DR and imposing a condition requiring neighborhood notification for any future alterations. After extensive debate, the commission voted 4-2 (Commissioners Williams and Coppel dissenting) to take DR and impose a condition that any future building expansion or construction at the rear must provide neighborhood notification, and urged the zoning administrator to require staff-initiated discretionary review for any rear work. The zoning administrator indicated he will grant the variance with that condition, but will also consider whether to require removal of the third-floor portion. Key Outcomes - Continuances: All items (1153 Guerrero Street, 638 Rhode Island Street, 619 Marina Boulevard) continued to May 2 or May 9, 2024, unanimously (6-0). - Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously (6-0). - Minutes: Approved unanimously (6-0). - Treasure Island Project (Items 12a-c): Approved unanimously (6-0) with additional findings on infrastructure scale and LEED Platinum. - 600 20th Street: Approved unanimously (6-0) with staff conditions. - 820 Laguna Honda Boulevard: Discretionary review taken and conditions imposed (4-2 vote); zoning administrator to grant variance with conditions, including future commission review of any rear work.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 4, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston and joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan, considered three main agenda items: an umbrella memorandum of understanding for green infrastructure between the SFPUC and SFUSD, an amendment to the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act (COPA), and annual reports from three Community Benefit Districts (CBDs). All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Green Infrastructure MOU): A retired teacher (H. Brown) spoke about using school grounds for homeless shelters, tangentially related to the item. The speaker was redirected to stay on topic. - Item 2 (COPA Amendment): A public speaker opposed the ordinance, arguing that requiring private property owners to notify nonprofits of foreclosure proceedings is unnecessary because the information is already public. The speaker also warned of potential costs and market distortions. - Items 3-5 (CBD Annual Reports): No public comment was offered. Discussion Items - Item 1: Umbrella MOU between SFPUC and SFUSD – Sarah Bloom (SFPUC) and Kate Levitt (SFUSD) presented the resolution approving a 40-year framework (June 1, 2024 – June 30, 2064) for installing and maintaining green infrastructure on SFUSD properties. The MOU does not commit to specific projects; individual site agreements (e.g., Giannini Middle School) will be approved separately by the SFPUC Commission and Board of Education. The SFPUC will handle procurement and maintenance. Supervisor Chan asked about procurement alignment, and the presenters explained that projects will go through standard city bidding with additional school district requirements. The committee discussed coordination with SFUSD’s resource alignment plan, noting that project lists will be developed in tandem. - Item 2: Administrative Code Amendment – COPA – Supervisor Preston (co-sponsor, on behalf of absent Supervisor Peskin) described the ordinance as closing a loophole: requiring multifamily property owners to notify the Mayor’s Office of Housing and qualified nonprofits when transferring property through deeds in lieu of foreclosure. This aligns with COPA’s existing notice requirements for traditional sales. Preston and Chan emphasized the need for city funding to act on COPA opportunities. Preston criticized the current administration for underfunding the program and obstructing acquisitions, citing examples (400 Divisadero, 708 Divisadero). Vice Chair Stefani countered with a successful COPA acquisition in her district (Russian Hill, 2022) and urged recognition of collaborative work. Chan noted unequal distribution of resources across districts. - Items 3-5: Annual Reports of Noe Valley, Castro, and Discover Polk CBDs – Jackie Hazelwood (OEWD) presented a benchmarking analysis. Noe Valley CBD met three of four benchmarks (missed benchmark 4 by not identifying carry-forward funds in the report, but corrected in subsequent reports). Castro CBD met all four benchmarks. Discover Polk CBD met three of four (missed benchmark 3 due to intentional underspending during COVID uncertainty; reserves are now being spent down). Directors Deborah Neiman (Noe Valley), Andrea Aiello (Castro), and Ben Bleiman (Discover Polk) presented their districts’ activities: cleaning, graffiti removal, community events, homeless outreach (Castro CARES), and beautification. Statistics from Castro CBD for FY2021-22: 109,260 pounds of trash removed, 11,845 incidents of human feces cleaned, and community ambassadors conducted 904 unhoused engagements and 602 wellness checks. Discover Polk emphasized its cleaning team and annual music festival. Supervisor Mandelman’s office expressed support for the Noe Valley and Castro CBDs. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to send the resolution to the full Board with positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Stefani, Chan). - Item 2: Motion to send the ordinance to the full Board with positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Stefani, Chan). - Items 3-5: Motion to forward the three annual reports to the full Board with positive recommendation passed 3-0 (Preston, Stefani, Chan). - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on April 16, 2024. Note - The committee clerk announced that public comment can be submitted via email or mail, and items acted upon are expected before the full Board on April 16.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 3, 2024, at 6:15 PM under the chairmanship of Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar. The committee considered seven agenda items, including amendments to water supply agreements, retroactive grant acceptances, a Community Stabilization Fund expenditure, a lease continuation for an observation wheel, a Union Square revitalization grant, and a rent relief amendment for duty-free concessions at San Francisco International Airport. Public comment was called on each item but no speakers appeared. With the exception of item number five (SkyStar Wheel lease), which was continued to the call of the chair, all items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Santa Clara Valley Water District Intertie Facility Agreement – The committee heard from Angela Chung of the SFPUC, who explained that the second amendment designates the Santa Clara Valley Water District as the operation and maintenance party for the intertie facility in Milpitas from July 1, 2024, through June 30, 2029. The arrangement is more efficient due to the district’s proximity and will have little financial impact (shared O&M costs about $50,000–$60,000 annually per party). The committee voted unanimously to forward with recommendation. - Items 2 & 3 – Retroactive Grant Acceptances (Mental Health and Tobacco Prevention) – Angelica Jernigan (ZSFG) and Jen Kallaward (DPH) presented two grants: approximately $909,095 from the San Francisco General Hospital Foundation for the Transform Mental and Behavioral Health program, and approximately $2,888,144 from the California Department of Justice for the Youth Tobacco Sales Prevention Grant. Both grants required retroactive authorization due to timing of award notices. Supervisor Mandelman and Melgar added themselves as co-sponsors. The committee forwarded both resolutions unanimously. - Item 4 – SoMa Community Stabilization Fund Expenditure ($890,000) – Grace Lee of MOHCD presented the expenditure resolution for eight grants to community-based organizations serving SoMa, recommended by the Community Advisory Committee. The BLA reported that the amounts are continuations of this fiscal year’s funding. The committee forwarded unanimously. - Item 5 – SkyStar Wheel Lease (Continued) – The Port requested a continuance to the call of the chair. The committee voted unanimously to continue the item. No public comment was heard. - Item 6 – Union Square Park Revitalization Grant ($2,000,000) – Neil Patel (Rec & Park) and Jacob Bintliff (OEWD) presented a retroactive grant from the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development to modernize cafe spaces in Union Square. Discussion focused on a prior $444,000 activation grant to the tenant (The Greater Organization / Tyler Florence) and the scope of capital improvements. The grant term ends December 31, 2026. Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor. The committee forwarded unanimously. - Item 7 – DFS Group Lease Amendment (SFO Duty-Free) – Airport staff presented the fourth amendment to extend a reduced percentage rent structure (36% of gross revenues, down from 45.8%) and set a reduced minimum annual guarantee of $30 million through 2026. The BLA estimated $10 million annual rent relief, with a $1.5 million annual impact on the General Fund. Supervisors Chan and Melgar questioned long-term strategy and diversification of retail offerings, noting shifts in luxury shopping trends and the need to attract tourists from Latin America. The committee forwarded unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 2 & 3: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5: Continued to call of the chair (3-0). - Item 6: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 7: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - The committee noted that the afternoon Budget and Appropriation Committee meeting was cancelled and that the next regular meeting would be on April 16, 2024, after the legislative spring recess.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on April 2, 2024, at 10:15 AM. The meeting covered a wide range of items including consent calendar approvals, a public hearing on an appeal for a conditional use authorization at 2351 Mission Street, resolutions on affordable housing, early childhood education, equal pay, and an imperative item opposing the renaming of Oakland International Airport. Key decisions included approving amendments to the Casements bar patio hours with sound mitigation requirements, adopting a resolution for the Faircloth-to-RAD program, and recognizing the Week of the Young Child. Consent Calendar - Approved routine items 1 through 19, including settlements, fee waivers, and street acceptance. Specific settlements included: Mitzey Davis and Leslie Lankster ($100,000), Jocelyn Li ($45,000), Ibrahim Nimer Shiheiber ($50,000), Charles Heard ($900,000), Kirstin Johnson et al. ($75,000), Yes in My Back Yard and Sonja Trauss ($32,000), Danielle Dillard and Kim Lee ($2,800,000), and various unlitigated claims and grievances. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Speakers addressed multiple topics. One speaker expressed concern about AT&T eliminating copper landlines, citing disability and electromagnetic sensitivity. Another speaker called for an audit of a low-income housing manager. A speaker urged support for item 49 (Faircloth-to-RAD) to create deeply affordable housing. A speaker highlighted the need for organ donation, noting 20,000 Californians on the transplant waitlist. A speaker sang about fentanyl and drug use. A speaker criticized the HSA Sherlock system, claiming it increases surveillance and overdoses. A speaker praised the board for passing item 32 on sea level rise. - Public Comment on Casements Appeal (2351 Mission Street): Many speakers in support of the appeal (extending patio hours) emphasized the business's community role, LGBTQ+ inclusion, and economic contribution. They cited a 30.6% reduction in sales after 10 PM curfew and a 18.9% drop in tips. Opponents, including nearby residents, cited noise disturbances, patron shouting, and the need for a 10 PM compromise. One neighbor noted 29 signatures in opposition. A sound engineer testified that Casements' noise was within Entertainment Commission limits and recommended mitigation measures. Discussion Items - Appeal of Conditional Use Authorization – 2351 Mission Street (Casements): The appellant, Casements, sought to extend outdoor patio hours from 10 PM to 11 PM weeknights and midnight weekends, citing financial hardship. The Planning Commission had approved a 10 PM curfew. After hearing public testimony, Supervisor Ronan moved to amend the motion to approve the appeal with conditions: hours of 9 AM to 11 PM Sunday–Thursday, 9 AM to midnight Friday–Saturday, and requiring installation of three sound mitigation measures (wall height increase, sound dampening, system adjustments) by January 1, 2025. The amendment passed, and the board approved the amended motion, tabling the alternative motion to uphold the commission's decision. - Item 49 – Faircloth-to-RAD Program: Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution calling on the Housing Authority to leverage the Faircloth-to-RAD program to create up to 3,668 new deeply affordable rental units. He noted that the rent augmentation flexibility expires September 30, 2024, and that the Housing Authority had agreed to conduct feasibility analysis this year. A technical amendment was made and adopted. The resolution passed. - Item 52 – Week of the Young Child: Supervisor Melgar introduced a resolution celebrating April 6–12, 2024, as the Week of the Young Child. Multiple speakers advocated for early childhood educators, noting that 44% of Black children entering SFUSD are kindergarten-ready and that Black children with a Black teacher are 13% more likely to graduate. The resolution passed unanimously. - Item 54 – AANHPI Equal Pay Day: Supervisor Chan introduced a resolution declaring April 3, 2024, as Asian American, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander Equal Pay Day, noting that AANHPI women earn 80 cents per dollar compared to 84 cents for all women. The resolution passed. - Imperative Agenda – Oakland Airport Renaming: Supervisor Peskin introduced a resolution opposing the proposed renaming of Metropolitan Oakland International Airport to “San Francisco Bay Oakland International Airport,” citing potential financial harm to SFO and passenger confusion. The board found serious injury to public interest and approved the resolution without objection. Key Outcomes - Casements Appeal (2351 Mission Street): Approved as amended (Supervisor Ronan’s motion). Motion to disapprove the Planning Commission’s decision (Item 44) passed with conditions: extended hours (11 PM weeknights, midnight weekends) and mandatory sound mitigation by January 1, 2025. Item 43 (approve commission decision) was tabled. Item 45 (findings) was approved. - Item 49 (Faircloth-to-RAD): Resolution adopted as amended. - Item 52 (Week of the Young Child): Resolution adopted. - Item 54 (AANHPI Equal Pay Day): Resolution adopted. - Imperative Agenda (Oakland Airport): Resolution adopted without objection. - Consent Calendar: Items 1–19 approved as routine. - In Memoriam: Meeting adjourned in memory of Fred Martin, Eddie O., and Jean Pitt Fong Li Yuen.
The San Francisco Rules Committee met on April 1, 2024 at 6:15 PM UTC (11:15 AM PT) under Chair Supervisor Hillary Ronan, Vice Chair Shamann Walton, and Supervisor Ahsha Safai. The committee considered mayoral reappointments to the Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) Board of Directors, a treasurer's appointment to the Treasury Oversight Committee, and an ordinance to allow a parklet at 1429 Mendell Street. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony Item 2: Janet Tarlov Reappointment – Four speakers expressed strong support: - Renee Richards, an attorney and small textile arts business owner, praised Tarlov's long commitment to San Francisco, her experience as a cyclist and parent, and her attunement to senior transportation challenges. - Mike Zweifelhoffer, president of the North Beach Business Association and Council of District Merchants (CDMA) member, highlighted Tarlov's patience during contentious bylaw negotiations and her willingness to listen to small business frustrations. - Mark Abus (President of Staff of Mark Abus Association and co-chair of SFPD Small Business Advisory Forum) called Tarlov a "superstar" who listens and works effectively with city departments. - Another speaker recounted Tarlov's care for an assaulted merchant, visiting and checking in weekly after the incident. No public speakers were present for Items 1 (Fiona Hinze), 3 (Kevin Kone), or 4 (Parklet Ordinance). Discussion Items 1. Mayoral Reappointment of Fiona Hinze to SFMTA Board (Term ending March 1, 2028) Hinze, director of public policy at Independent Living Resource Center, outlined her goals for a second term: strengthening Vision Zero through interdepartmental collaboration, completing the biking and rolling plan (formerly active communities plan), implementing the agency's first accessibility strategy, and advocating for sustainable state funding for transit. She noted her background as a disability advocate. Supervisors Ronan, Walton, and Safai thanked her for her service and expressed support. 2. Mayoral Reappointment of Janet Tarlov to SFMTA Board (Term ending March 1, 2028) Tarlov, a former small business owner and advocate, described her intensive learning process since her initial appointment a few months prior. She emphasized listening to advocacy groups, helping them advocate effectively, and finding solutions for vulnerable communities (seniors, disabled, unhoused, families in poverty). She rejected a narrative of winners vs. losers, calling for collaboration. A lengthy discussion ensued about homelessness and vehicle dwellers, triggered by Supervisor Safai and Walton's concerns about recent RV removal from Bernal Heights. Tarlov acknowledged the need for interagency collaboration. She also shared a success story about helping a merchant by moving a bus shelter. Supervisor Ronan expressed disagreement with the mayor's removal of 15 RVs from Bernal Heights, noting that wealthier neighborhoods receive attention while working-class neighborhoods like the Mission bear the burden. Supervisors praised Tarlov's responsiveness and commitment. 3. Appointment of Kevin Kone to Treasury Oversight Committee (Term ending June 17, 2026) Kevin Kone, assistant CFO at San Francisco International Airport, noted his prior service on the committee and his expertise in capital markets and bond financing. No questions were asked. 4. Ordinance – Shared Space at 1429 Mendell Street Parklet Supervisor Walton introduced the item, explaining that Old School Cafe installed a parklet on a street segment closed to traffic. Because the parklet is not in the curbside lane, it does not qualify as curbside shared space under current law. The ordinance waives that requirement, conditional on compliance with public health, safety, and design regulations, and requires physical modifications to bring it up to code. No public testimony was given. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Hinze): Motion to amend to remove "rejecting" from the legislation and send to full board with positive recommendation. Passed unanimously (Walton aye, Safai aye, Ronan aye). - Item 2 (Tarlov): Motion to amend similarly. Passed unanimously. - Item 3 (Kone): Motion to amend to remove "rejecting" and add a residency waiver. Passed unanimously (Walton aye, Safai absent? Chair notes Safai absent but then later 'Safayi aye' – transcript unclear, but motion passes without objection). - Item 4 (Parklet): Motion to send to full board with recommendation. Passed unanimously. All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on April 16, 2024, unless otherwise stated.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on April 1, 2024, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Marina Melgar, with Vice Chair Dean Preston. Supervisor Peskin was excused. The sole agenda item was a resolution authorizing the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) to apply for the state's Prohousing Designation Program, which would make San Francisco more competitive for state housing and infrastructure grants. The committee heard presentations, public comment, and voted to send the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - John Avalos (Council of Community Housing Organizations) urged support for the resolution, noting that many community housing organizations would benefit from the designation. However, he highlighted a contradiction: a resolve clause in the resolution that could tie the city's hands by discouraging additional legislation that might jeopardize the designation, potentially limiting innovative approaches to protect neighborhoods against displacement. Discussion Items - MOHCD Presentation: Sheila Nicolopoulos, Director of Policy and Legislative Affairs, presented the resolution. She explained that the state's Prohousing Designation Program, updated in 2024, requires threshold requirements (e.g., compliant housing element, annual progress report, compliance with state housing laws, and an executed resolution). San Francisco's application highlights 14 existing prohousing policies, including local density programs, ADU allowances, no parking requirements, mixed-use zoning, a one-stop permit center, priority processing for 100% affordable projects, impact fee waivers, and local funding sources. The resolution does not commit the city to new policies. The state review is expected by May 17, 2024. She noted that two-thirds of affordable housing funding comes from state or federal sources, and the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities (AHSC) and Infill Infrastructure Grant programs have awarded over $309 million to 18 San Francisco projects since 2018. - Supervisor Dean Preston expressed support for the resolution but criticized the state's "prohousing" terminology as a euphemism that conflates market-rate and affordable housing, arguing it primarily benefits luxury housing and conditions affordable housing funds on incentivizing unaffordable market-rate development. He listed several instances where the mayor's office has obstructed or defunded affordable housing initiatives approved by the Board, including refusal to budget Proposition I revenue, defunding the Housing Stability Fund by $20 million, delaying Parcel K development, and blocking affordable housing at 400 Divisadero. He warned that continued obstruction could compromise the prohousing designation. - Chair Marina Melgar supported the resolution and agreed with the need for more robust affordable housing investment, capacity, and funding. She noted that her district (District 7, West Side) has historically low density and zoning that limits housing (e.g., West Portal Avenue zoned for 27 feet height). She emphasized the need to operationalize the Housing Element equitably across all districts, including the West Side, to allow future generations to afford living in San Francisco. She disagreed with Supervisor Preston's characterization of the state's approach, arguing that the city's past decisions concentrated development in certain areas while neglecting others. - Supervisor Preston responded that his objection is not to West Side development but to the state's system of conditioning affordable housing funds on market-rate housing incentives, which he called "completely upside down" and harmful to low-income San Franciscans. Key Outcomes - Motion to excuse President Peskin passed unanimously (2 ayes: Melgar, Preston). - Motion to send the resolution (Item 1) to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Preston aye, Chair Melgar aye). The item will appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of April 16, 2024. - The committee did not take any other actions.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 28, 2024, to consider two liquor license applications, hold a hearing on the impacts of permanent supportive housing (PSH) facilities, and receive an update on the implementation of the "A Place for All" ordinance. The meeting featured extensive public testimony and debate on the operation and community effects of PSH. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (240185): Liquor license issuance for Kim Huong Cafe at 325 Leavenworth Street. The SFPD recommended approval with conditions (monitor loitering, maintain litter-free area). No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send a positive recommendation to the full Board. - Item 2 (240186): Liquor license issuance for Origin Boutique Nightclub at 1538 Fillmore Street. The applicant explained the need for a Type 90 license to operate without a kitchen. SFPD recommended conditions including noise control and security. No public comment. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward with positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (PSH hearing): Many residents and advocates spoke. Niki Amadi (West Soma resident) presented a petition with 1,300 signatures, expressing concerns about overconcentration of supportive housing in District 6 and lack of community engagement. She cited the closure threat to Bay of Burma restaurant and argued that the city has ignored resident safety concerns. - Deanna Terzian (Mission Bay resident) detailed that a HomeRise PSH facility at 1538 Fillmore (opened Oct 2022) generated 1,166 calls for service (656 police) in 18 months, including 159 priority A calls. She requested 24/7 security, better screening, and relocation of repeat offenders. - Other Mission Bay and West Soma residents recounted drug dealing, violence, public masturbation, and screaming incidents near PSH sites. They claimed HomeRise was unresponsive for nine months and that promises made during planning were not kept. - Supportive housing providers (e.g., Lauren Hall, SHPN) and tenants defended PSH, noting 97% of residents are not disruptive. They called for increased funding for clinical services, mental health support, and community ambassadors rather than private security. Several PSH residents, including a woman who was formerly homeless, shared their success stories and urged patience. - Supervisor Dorsey emphasized that the hearing was not about undermining PSH but about improving operations to maintain public confidence. He noted that the city must address legitimate concerns from residents. Discussion Items - Item 3 (24118): Hearing on Impacts of Permanent Supportive Housing Facilities. Emily Cohen (HSH) presented an overview: SF has over 13,000 PSH units (70% site-based). She discussed the "Good Neighbor Policy," community working groups, and the cost of 24/7 private security ($60-70M annually). She advocated for community ambassadors and increased social services, noting that the budget for such investments is limited. Supervisor Dorsey questioned the crime data, arguing that many incidents are underreported and that the current approach is reactive and expensive. He pushed for more proactive security measures. Supervisor Mandelman raised concerns about 100% PSH buildings and the need for a higher level of care for the most acute 5% of residents. He suggested that geographical deconcentration and mixed-income buildings could reduce problems. - Marcel Davis (HomeRise) reported that 3% of residents at the Mission Bay site cause the majority of issues. He detailed steps taken (no-loitering signs, 24-hour response to complaints, de-escalation) but acknowledged that progress is slow due to fair housing laws and eviction timelines. He emphasized that 97% of residents thrive and that the building is a success story. - Deanna Terzian (Mission Bay) presented slides showing fights, drug deals, and public indecency. She argued that HSH broke screening promises and that 24/7 security is necessary. She called for an urgent relocation policy for repeat offenders. - Item 4 (24242): Hearing on A Place for All Implementation Update. Supervisor Mandelman noted that unsheltered homelessness remains at about 4,200 people, unchanged from 2022. He criticized HSH's initial plan as unrealistic and urged a more focused approach. Emily Cohen presented HSH's progress: 3,400 shelter slots (93% occupancy), 400 new beds needed to reach 50% reduction, and the "Street to Home" program (60 placements). She cited funding and siting as key barriers. Sam Dodge (DEM) stated that with 1,000 additional shelter beds and current resources, encampments could be resolved within 24 hours. He also stressed the need for SB 43 (civil commitment) and more appropriate placement for people with severe mental illness. Public comment included criticism of shelter conditions and calls for more housing-first solutions. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing on permanent supportive housing (Item 3) to the call of the chair to allow for further progress assessment. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to file the hearing on A Place for All implementation (Item 4). - Both liquor license items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations (3-0 votes each). Note on date discrepancy: The transcript incorrectly begins with "March 27, 2024" but the agenda and official scheduling indicate the meeting occurred on March 28, 2024. This summary uses the official date.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, met on Wednesday, March 27, 2024, to consider ten agenda items. The committee approved all items, forwarding them to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, after adopting minor amendments to three resolutions. Consent Calendar - No separate consent calendar was used. All items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided oral testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (240200): Resolution retroactively authorizing the Department of Adult Probation to accept and expend a $300,000 grant ($100,000/year for three years) from the California Office of Emergency Services for the Probation Specialized Units Program, funded through the Violence Against Women Act. The department explained it was retroactive to correct a prior resolution. Approved unanimously. - Item 2 (240235): Resolution retroactively authorizing the Department of Public Health to accept a $32,265,440 grant from Advocates for Human Potential, Inc., for the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing Program to provide housing for homeless individuals with serious behavioral health conditions. The grant is retroactive to July 1, 2023, and funds 10 projects adding 113 new beds and enhancing 67 existing beds. Approved unanimously. - Item 3 (240192): Resolution authorizing a repayment agreement with Baker Places, Inc., requiring repayment of $7,669,814 over 23 years, plus a purchase agreement for 333-7th Street for $3,000,000 (plus $8,200 closing costs) to reduce the debt. The item generated extensive discussion. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended approval but also urged the city to develop a plan to take ownership of two other properties (214 Dolores and 2153-2157 Grove) to protect city investments. Chair Chan and Supervisor Melgar expressed cautious optimism but emphasized the need for ongoing fiscal oversight. Vice Chair Mandelman opposed the BLA’s recommendation to transfer property ownership, arguing it could destabilize services. The committee voted to amend the resolution to correct language, and then forwarded it with the amendment. Chair Chan noted she would send a separate letter requesting assessments of collateral properties. - Items 4 & 5 (240049, 240051): Items 4 and 5 were considered together. - Item 4: Resolution approving a COVID-19 lease extension program for up to 88 eligible airport concessions, offering extensions of up to 3.5 years to help recoup losses from the pandemic period (March 2020 – August 2023). BLA reported the minimum annual guaranteed rent for all leases would be $49.3 million. - Item 5: Resolution approving an $20.4 million increase (to a new not-to-exceed $45.4 million) and a two-year term extension (through January 2027) for a contract with PGH Wong & Partners JV for project management services on the Courtyard 3 Connector Project at SFO. The airport noted the contractor met or exceeded expectations in all 31 performance measures. The committee amended Item 5 to correct the term extension in the resolution, then forwarded both items. - Item 6 (240234): Resolution approving a $13,000,000 loan to 249 Pennsylvania Associates L.P. (a partnership of Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation and Young Community Developers) to acquire and pre-develop a 100% affordable family housing project at 249 and 201 Pennsylvania Avenue and 935 Mariposa Street (approx. 120 units). The committee amended the resolution to correct the split between acquisition and pre-development funding and forwarded it. - Items 7-10 (240230-240233): Four resolutions approving senior operating subsidy grant agreements for four affordable housing projects: - 1296 Shotwell Housing L.P.: $4,820,042 for 11 years - Transbay 2 Senior, L.P.: $18,290,441 for 15 years and 3 months - 4200 Geary Associates, L.P.: $7,795,022 for 15 years - Chinatown SRO’s, LLC: $6,209,204 for 15 years and 6 months All funded by state Permanent Local Housing Allocation program funds to keep rents affordable for extremely low-income seniors (≤30% AMI). The committee forwarded all four without amendment. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (3-0) and forwarded to full board. - Item 2: Approved (3-0) and forwarded to full board. - Item 3: Amended (3-0) to correct language on page 1 and page 5; then approved as amended (3-0) and forwarded to full board. Chair Chan will send a separate letter requesting property value assessments by December 2024. - Item 4: Approved (3-0) and forwarded to full board without amendment. - Item 5: Amended (3-0) to correct the term extension in the resolution; then approved as amended (3-0) and forwarded to full board. - Item 6: Amended (3-0) to correct funding split; then approved as amended (3-0) and forwarded to full board. - Items 7-10: Approved as a block (3-0) and forwarded to full board. - All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda on April 2, 2024, unless otherwise stated.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee convened on March 27, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Supervisors Myrna Melgar, Shamann Walton, and Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman (arriving later) present. President Peskin was excused. The committee took up two agenda items: an appropriation for independent analysis at Hunters Point Shipyard and a hearing on the Youth Commission's budget priorities. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Appropriation for SFPUC): Multiple speakers testified in support. Key points: urged a 100% cleanup of radioactive/toxic waste at Hunters Point Naval Shipyard with community oversight; criticized the Navy's plan to cap contamination; highlighted health disparities in Bayview Hunters Point; called for the city to hire expert scientists as recommended by the 2021-2022 Civil Grand Jury; and expressed frustration with the mayor's office and the Navy's lack of transparency. - Item 2 (Youth Commission Priorities): No public speakers. Discussion Items - Item 1: Appropriation – General Reserve – SFPUC – $500,000 (FY2023-2024) Supervisor Walton explained the need for independent research on sea level rise and groundwater impacts at Hunters Point Shipyard, noting the SFPUC general manager confirmed ratepayer restrictions prevented using SFPUC funds. The item was continued from a prior meeting to adjust the fiscal year and funding source; the committee moved to forward it with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Hearing – Youth Commission Budget Priorities (FY2024-2025 and FY2025-2026) Youth Commission Chair Ewan Barker Plummer and Vice Chair Gabby Listana, joined by Commissioners Jason Fong and Alistair Adair, presented a comprehensive report covering 16 budget and policy priorities across three committees: - Civic Engagement & Education: Lowering the voting age to 16 via a ballot measure (cost-free), improving school safety (infrastructure, emergency training, mental health), addressing sexual assault and harassment, and expanding voter preregistration. - Housing, Recreation & Transit: Making free Muni for youth permanent, improving transit safety and frequency, expanding youth-centered recreational spaces (parks, library hours, slow streets), advancing Vision Zero (new action plan, no-turn-on-red, congestion pricing), increasing housing stock (annual building targets, zoning amendments, limiting discretionary review), supporting homeless transitional-age youth (navigation centers, LGBTQ+ support), and improving climate resiliency (sea level rise preparation, tree maintenance). - Transformative Justice: Reducing youth weapon access (community violence prevention, gun buybacks, mental health services), combating fentanyl overdoses (school curriculum, Narcan access), improving language access (funding ESL programs, supporting Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs, translation for emerging languages), accelerating cleanup of Bayview Hunters Point environmental contamination, and addressing food insecurity (supporting community initiatives, school meals, neighborhood investment). Commissioners emphasized realistic priorities within budget constraints, highlighting vote 16, free Muni, school safety, and language access as top items. Supervisors asked about school consolidation, food insecurity overlap with schools, and transit delays. Vice Chair Mandelman noted the transportation authority’s focus on transit issues. Chair Chan encouraged youth commissioners to continue direct engagement during the budget process. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230314): Motion by Supervisor Walton, seconded by Chair Chan, to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Approved unanimously (4-0, with Peskin excused). - Item 2 (240278): Motion by Chair Chan, seconded by Vice Chair Mandelman, to hear and file the report. Approved unanimously (4-0).