Public Meetings - Cleveland, Ohio

The Cleveland City Council convened on December 1, 2025, for a lengthy session covering routine capital and property matters followed by urgent deliberations on the settlement agreement regarding the relocation of the Cleveland Browns. Former Cleveland Mayor and Congressman Dennis Kucinich provided testimony urging the Council to reject the settlement, maintain legal leverage, and negotiate a significantly higher return for taxpayers. The Administration and Council leadership presented a revised settlement term sheet, which included amendments to increase community benefits and allocate funds specifically to neighborhood improvements. Despite strong opposition from some Council members and Kucinich regarding the lack of transparency during negotiations and the perceived inadequacy of the financial exit package, the Council proceeded to vote on the measures. Consent Calendar - Ordinance 1082-2023: Fully supported by Council members; approved to authorize state funding applications for State Route 283 improvements (pavement, sidewalks, water main). - Resolution 1407-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate a portion of Mount Carmel Road in the Woodland Hills neighborhood to facilitate the Woodhill Choice Project development. - Ordinance 1471-2025: Fully supported; approved to modify the non-compliant sidewalk repair program (formerly 5050), allowing contracts up to $300,000 to support small business growth. - Ordinance 1472-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate a "paper street" portion of East 73rd Street for economic development land assembly. - Ordinance 1470-2025: Fully supported; approved for City consent to resurface Nottingham Road using county motor vehicle license tax funds. - Ordinance 1481-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate a "paper street" portion of East 70th Street. - Ordinance 1486-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate a "paper street" portion of East 71st Place. - Ordinance 1487-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate a portion of Redmond Avenue Southwest to facilitate ODOT property transfer. - Ordinance 1488-2025: Fully supported; approved to vacate the old alignment of West Boulevard to establish a permanent easement for the Timere Rice Memorial. - Ordinance 1496-2025: Fully supported; approved to authorize an encroachment permit for Cleveland Clinic Foundation to install a driveway and erosion control barrier along Alley in Court. - Ordinance 1508-2025: Fully supported; approved to appropriate $1.2 million to the streets division for employee personnel and benefits related to resurfacing work. - Ordinance 1509-2025: Fully supported; approved to provide temporary appropriations for city payrolls and expenses from January 1 through the effective date of the annual budget. - Ordinance 1510-2025: Fully supported; approved to transfer and amend general fund appropriations totaling approximately $19.6 million to balance year-end budget variances, specifically addressing savings due to vacancies in Urban Forestry and Police, and overages in Fire and EMS. Public Comments & Testimony - Cleveland Mayor Dennis Kucinich (Former): Expressed strong opposition to the proposed Brown's settlement, characterizing it as a "fraud upon the city." He argued the administration deceived the Council for three years, that the City is waiving a lawsuit worth over $200 million, and that the $100 million deal undervalues the stadium (which has 24 years of life left). He proposed charging the owners $100 million annually for rent until 2031 and advocated for the community to buy the team under the Modell Law. - Councilman Mike Polonski: Expressed significant concern regarding the lack of communication from the administration. He argued the $100 million figure was known two years ago and questioned why the City is accepting a deal that does not fund neighborhood improvements, noting that taxpayers have subsidized the stadium for $700 million with nothing to show for it. - Councilman Richard Harsh: Expressed disappointment and skepticism, stating the administration has "resigned" to losing the team. He argued that if the administration is not fighting to keep the team, the Council cannot win alone. He emphasized the risk of taxpayers being left with a demolition bill and the loss of the City's status as a major league city. - Councilwoman Deborah Gray: Expressed deep concern about the lack of transparency, stating she has not made a final decision. She emphasized that the Modell Law was created in 1996 to protect the City's investment and questioned why the Haslums were never required to negotiate with the City under that law. - Councilwoman Rebecca Jones: Expressed frustration regarding the lack of inclusion in the negotiation process, stating the City was "blindsided" by a press conference. She argued that while the Administration claims to have listened, the lack of direct engagement with Council members before the deal was finalized created a trust deficit. - Councilman Brian Casey: Expressed hesitation and partial opposition, citing two main concerns: the risk of the lawsuit being dismissed before the new stadium in Brook Park is built ("shovels in the ground"), and the lack of commitments regarding unionized service workers who would be moving to the new facility. Discussion Items - Browns Settlement Settlement (Ordinance 1325-2025): The Council debated a settlement to vacate the City's current stadium and exit the lease. Key points of contention included: - Financial Value: Kucinich and Councilman Polonski argued the $100 million exit fee is insufficient compared to the potential damages of the lawsuit. The Administration countered that litigation carries significant risks, legal fees (over $1.5 million already spent), and no guarantee of retaining the team. - Neighborhood Benefits: Councilman Slife proposed and supported an amendment to redirect $5 million of the community benefit package from lakefront development to direct neighborhood improvements, creating a $25 million total fund for residents. - Communication: Councilman Casey and Councilwoman Jones criticized the Administration for negotiating secretly and presenting a "take it or leave it" deal with a deadline. The Administration defended the process, citing the need for confidentiality during mediation. - Stadium Demolition & Repurposing: Councilman Harrison and others questioned the necessity of demolition, asking if an engineering report confirmed the stadium could not be repurposed. Administration officials confirmed that developers and engineers believe the stadium is too large for other uses and requires significant investment to retrofit, necessitating demolition. - Service Workers: Councilwoman Jones expressed concern that the settlement did not include guarantees for unionized service workers to retain their jobs at the new Brook Park stadium, which the Administration said was outside their jurisdiction. - Ordinance 1461-2025 (Urban Forestry): Council members discussed expanding the tree assistance program for seniors. Councilman Casey requested clarification on whether the program covers trees on private property, which the Director confirmed as "99% sure" it does. Council member Belichick supported the program and suggested exploring tree farms to improve canopy cover. Councilman Palonski questioned the 26-year cycle for tree trimming. - Ordinance 1492-2025 (Luke Easter Skate Park): Council members fully supported the authorization to apply for a Land and Water Conservation Fund grant to build a 10,000 square foot skate park, with matching funds from the MGK Foundation and The Skate Park Project. Key Outcomes - Amendments Approved: The Council unanimously agreed to five amendments to the settlement term sheet (Ordinance 1325-2025-A1). Key changes include: - Increasing the total community benefits funding to $103 million (with $25 million allocated specifically for neighborhood improvements, $25 million of which is directed to neighborhoods rather than the lakefront). - Clarifying that any lease extension options will require additional payments for community benefits. - Mandating that 30% of demolition contracts go to Cleveland businesses (20% small businesses/MBEs) and requiring prevailing wage compliance. - Ensuring Council has approval authority over the 20 million dollar community benefits fund. - Ordinance 1325-2025 Vote: The amended ordinance was put to a roll call vote. The vote tally was 11 in favor and 3 in opposition (Councilman Casey, Councilman Polonski, and Councilwoman Jones). The ordinance passed, authorizing the Mayor and Directors to enter into the settlement with Haslam Sports Group. - Next Steps: The Council adjourned the consensus calendar and scheduled a brief meeting for the following day (7:00 PM) to address remaining diversity and equity items. The Administration is expected to finalize the legal documentation for the settlement based on the amended term sheet.

On December 1, 2025, the Cleveland City Council convened a Committee of the Whole meeting to review and approve a series of emergency ordinances and legislative motions. Key agenda items included financing for the Erie View Tower hotel redevelopment, funding increases for the Greater Cleveland Film Commission, lease amendments for Lakefront Parks and Public Square, and the restructuring of the Department of Economic Development into the Department of Development. The meeting featured significant discussion regarding the implementation of Community Benefits Agreements, the balance of funding between downtown and neighborhood parks, and strategies for improving the efficiency of city operations. Consent Calendar - Ordinance 1440-2025: Adopted, authorizing a PACE financing deal of up to $43.88 million for the hotel component of the Erie View Tower redevelopment to fund clean energy improvements. - Ordinance 1454-2025: Approved, authorizing a grant to the Greater Cleveland Film Commission with an additional $50,000 for operating expenses due to inflation and competition. - Ordinance 1512-2025: Approved, adding the North Coast Inner Harbor and Marina to the existing 99-year lease with Cleveland Metropolitan Park District, removing it from private management (previously OASIS/GIT). - Ordinance 1316-2025: Approved, granting a fire lane easement for the CEDAR redevelopment Phase 4 residential project adjacent to the Central Recreation Center. - Ordinances 1397-2025 & 1399-2025: Approved, authorizing the city to acquire and reconvey properties at 2230 and 2202 Superior Avenue to establish chain of title for future Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for the Heller and Keller Cone building redevelopment. - Ordinance 1456-2025: Approved, providing an $500,000 restricted contribution match to Downtown Cleveland Inc. (DCI) for the maintenance and programming of Public Square. - Ordinance 1460-2025: Approved, terminating the Port Authority lease for the original Rock & Roll Hall of Fame site and consolidating it into a direct city-to-museum lease. - Ordinance 1514-2025: Approved, authorizing contracts for common-use self-service kiosks at the Cleveland Hopkins International Airport via Amadeus. - Ordinance 1452-2025: Approved, contracting with Esperanza Inc. for $100,000 to provide outreach and programming for high-risk youth in Wards 7, 11, and 14 under the Safe Streets Safe Schools project. - Ordinance 1403-2025: Approved, accepting a $105,000 grant from the Office of Criminal Justice Services to operate the Cartel Gang Narcotics Laundering Task Force. - Ordinance 1411-2025: Approved, authorizing the acquisition and reconveyance of 1200 West 58th Street (Westinghouse plant) for chain of title for future TIF. - Ordinance 1464-2025: Approved, contracting with five organizations to provide "Moms First" home visitation and support services for at-risk pregnant women. Public Comments & Testimony - Councilman Brian Casey: Expressed strong concern that the project team for the Erie View Tower had not moved forward with the Cleveland Public Power (CPP) conversion as stipulated in the Community Benefits Agreement (CBA). He stated, "we haven't moved one iota on on that community benefits agreement" and argued that without fulfilling these commitments, the project team had failed to provide a reason for the council's support. He threatened to bring CPP officials into the meeting if the issue was not resolved. - Councilman Michael Pelancy: Expressed full support for the Erie View project as critical for job creation but echoed concerns regarding the delay in the CPP agreement. - Councilman Brian Casey (Film Commission): Stated wholehearted support for the Film Commission but noted that the organization failed to publicly thank City Council for its longstanding support. - Councilman Brian Casey (Public Square): Expressed opposition to the $500,000 match for Public Square, stating, "this one's gonna be for me" and drawing a line in the sand regarding the disparity in funding between downtown and neighborhood parks, which received significantly fewer resources. - Councilwoman Rebecca Moore: Stated support for downtown but expressed concern that resources were not being distributed equitably to neighborhood playgrounds and facilities, citing specific lack of action on Coit Playground. - Councilman Anthony Hairston: Emphasized the need for seamless operations and safety in neighborhoods, stating that children in the Glenville and Collinwood communities "need to know that you care about them." - Councilman Polencick: Expressed frustration with the city's inefficiency, comparing a delay in opening a candy store to the difficulty of getting large development projects through the system. He demanded proactive strategies for business retention and investment in underserved neighborhoods like the East Side. - Councilwoman Trudy Andrews (Chief Assistant Director of Law/Transition): Thanked colleagues for their support during her tenure and acknowledged the upcoming transition. Discussion Items - Erie View Tower CBA (CPP): Project team confirmed the CPP conversion was part of the CBA but deferred explaining delays, citing low current demand due to demolition and a 1.5-year construction timeline. They committed to the agreement will be completed by the time the building is operational (Certificate of Occupancy). - Public Square Funding: Councilman Polencick challenged the necessity of the $500,000 DCI match, citing high costs in neighborhood parks. Director DeRose noted the funds come from Economic Development, not Parks & Recreation, and that DCI had exceeded a 1:1 match ratio in 2025. - Neighborhood Park Equity: Multiple council members (Moore, Hairston, Polencick) pressed Director DeRose on the disparity in resources between downtown and neighborhoods like Coit Playground and Glenville, urging the administration to prioritize preventative maintenance and specific improvements in those areas. - Department Restructuring (Ordinance 1226-2025): Councilman Polencick and Conwell pushed heavily for a timeline and outcome measures for the reorganization of Economic Development into the Department of Development. They demanded proof that the new structure would improve efficiency, reduce delays (e.g., the candy store issue), and include proactive risk management for business closures. They also asked for clarification on the remaining functions of the Department of Community Development and the status of CDBG fund usage. - Amendments to Renewable Power Ordinance: Councilman Casey moved to amend Ordinance 1494-2025, changing the expiration date for implementation contracts from December 31, 2030, to December 31, 2027, to ensure accountability and faster results on renewable power projects. - Utility Disconnections: Council members requested updates on utility disconnection processes following the loss of CHN funding. Director DeRose confirmed that while a moratorium was in place, the department would reinstitute severance processes once CHN transitions were complete and encouraged residents to contact them directly for flexible payment arrangements. - Lighting Repairs: Councilwoman Moore requested an update on lighting repairs at 55th and Broadway due to theft. Director DeRose explained crews were re-pulling cable and anticipated repairs before the end of the month, pending the implementation of a solution to secure the underground cabling. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 1440-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1454-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1512-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1316-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinances 1397 & 1399-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1456-2025: Approved unanimously despite Councilman Casey's opposition. - Ordinance 1460-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1514-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1452-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1494-2025: Approved unanimously as amended (deadline changed to 12/31/2027). - Ordinance 1464-2025: Approved unanimously. - Ordinance 1226-2025 (as amended): Approved unanimously, renaming the Department of Economic Development to the Department of Development and transferring 18 staff positions from Community Development to the new department. - Meeting Adjournment: The meeting was suspended to reconvene at 1:00 PM for further legislative items.

This meeting featured the presentation and approval of three key emergency ordinances: a PACE financing agreement for the Erie View Tower Hotel, the designation of the Old John Marshall High School as a Cleveland landmark, and a significant departmental reorganization renaming the Department of Economic Development to the Department of Development. Council members expressed strong commitment to collaborating with the administration on future policy development and metrics, despite concerns regarding the lack of a current Director for Community Development and the timeline for performance evaluation implementation. Consent Calendar - No items were listed on the consent calendar in this transcript. Public Comments & Testimony - Jessica Beam, Cleveland Landmarks Commission: Presented the history of the Old John Marshall High School (built 1899), arguing it represents the heritage of West Park and Cleveland. She noted the building has been in use for over 40 years as a furniture store and later a cafe. - West Park Historical Society Representative: Spoke in support of the landmark designation, emphasizing the building's significance to the neighborhood's history. - Property Owner and Representative: Expressed opposition to the landmark designation, citing concerns that the designation would create a financial or regulatory burden on the property. - Councilwoman House Jones (Public Comment/Questioning Context): While not formal public testimony, she provided extensive input regarding the administration's history of failing to prioritize the nighttime economy and the lack of stress management practices for staff in Community Development, characterizing these as failures from her perspective. Discussion Items - Ordinance 1440-2025 (Erie View Tower PACE Financing): - Project Sponsor/Presenter: City staff presented a PACE financing agreement for the hotel component (floors 4-12) of the Erie View Tower redevelopment, totaling $43,881,864 over 28 years (ending 2055). The financing covers energy-efficient upgrades like HVAC, windows, and roofing. - Councilmember Moorehouse: Inquired why hotel rooms were placed on lower floors rather than higher view levels. Staff explained that transient hotel use is considered an "inferior use" and that higher floors are better utilized for offices and apartments seeking long-term value from views. - Amendment: Councilman Moorehouse proposed an amendment to strike specific language and replace it with "maximum" and "schedule" to clarify assessment collection limits. The amendment passed unanimously. - Ordinance 1321-2025 (Old John Marshall High School Landmark Designation): - Presenter: Jessica Beam detailed the building's history from its 1899 construction to its current state as the Wash House and Cafe, noting it is one of the last remaining pre-annexation municipal/educational buildings in the area. - Councilman Slife: Expressed full support for the designation, noting there are only two landmarks in Ward 17. He highlighted the value of historic tax credits and clarified that the designation does not compel property owners to change the building, but rather serves as an alternate design review district that recognizes neighborhood history. - Councilman Harris: Clarified architectural details regarding the original 1899 facade facing Lorraine Avenue versus later additions. - Ordinance 1226-2025 (Departmental Reorganization): - Chief Director & Team: Presented a plan to rename the Department of Economic Development to the "Department of Development" by consolidating real estate functions (housing development, land bank, asset redevelopment) from the Department of Community Development. The reorg aims to streamline decision-making, create a "single front door" for development, and improve efficiency. - Key Proposals: Creation of a new Deputy Director of Land Strategy, 4 other new general fund positions (accounting, GIS, real estate analyst), and integration of the land bank office with economic development functions. - Councilwoman House Jones: Expressed significant concern regarding the timeline for implementing work performance standards (KPIs), noting the current reliance on spreadsheets and the delay until 2027. She also criticized the administration for not addressing the nighttime economy proactively and questioned the support given to staff in Community Development during the transition. - Councilman Harsh: Questioned the separation of land bank revenues into a special fund (SF 964) versus the general fund, arguing it limits oversight. He also raised concerns about the lack of a Director for Community Development, describing the situation as "raiding the pantry" while the department is leaderless. He noted the department is currently funded largely by CDBG, which recently faced funding delays. - Councilman Slife: Questioned the long-term vision for the Department of Community Development if legislation 854-2025 (CDBG reform) does not pass, and sought clarification on the number of layoffs, confirming there will be none. He also questioned the departmental structure regarding Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) restrictions. - Law Department: Clarified that Ohio Revised Code requires land bank proceeds to be held in a separate special revenue fund to avoid compliance issues with HUD, explaining the legal necessity behind the fund separation. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 1440-2025: Approved as amended. The PACE financing for the Erie View Tower Hotel is authorized. - Ordinance 1321-2025: Approved. The Old John Marshall High School is designated as a Cleveland Landmark. - Ordinance 1226-2025: Approved with amendments. The Department of Economic Development is renamed the Department of Development. The ordinance creates a new Special Revenue Fund 17 SF 964 for residential land bank proceeds and transfers appropriate funds from the general fund (SF 469) and the commercial land bank fund to facilitate the new structure. - Commitment: The Chief Director and Department Director committed to working jointly with City Council to co-develop policy and metrics for the new department structure. - Next Steps: The approved ordinances will be sent to the Finance Committee for final consideration.

The Cleveland City Council convened for a public session characterized by extensive public commentary on civil rights, surveillance technology, and wrongful convictions, alongside the unanimous approval of over twenty emergency ordinances and resolutions. Council members engaged in standard administrative procedures, including recognition of community leaders and condolences, while public speakers utilized the platform to urge the council on immediate policy reversals and ethical considerations regarding city spending and justice system integrity. Consent Calendar - The Council reviewed and transmitted standard communications, including reports from the Fair Employment Wage Board, the Ohio Division of Liquor Control, and sustainability updates. - Condolence resolutions were adopted for Salima Moya Smith, Ernestine Welch Baker, Kenneth L. Zoller, and Richard Michael St. Clair. - Recognition resolutions were passed honoring the 82nd Lebanese Independence Day, various community award recipients (including Dr. Nasib Fawaz, Edward C. Banks, and Zoe Wolf), and Ingreta Ublis and Earl B. Turner. Public Comments & Testimony - Terry Wong (Ward 3): Spoke against "flock-ups" (systemic failures) regarding the city's surveillance technology. She expressed strong opposition to the purchase of shot spotter and Flock gunshot detection technology, characterizing it as a misallocation of public funds and a legal liability. She criticized Councilmember McCormack for leaving to work for a lobbying firm (Flock) and advocated for deep soul-searching among council members regarding their service to the community. She opposed the proposed move of the Browns to Brook Park, calling it the "biggest mistake in Cleveland history." She expressed a position that current elected officials are "complicit" and do not deserve their paychecks. She stated she will be back after the holidays to discuss "real issues." - Dean Van Farrell (Ward 7): Expressed gratitude and appreciation for outgoing Councilwoman Jenny Spencer, stating he values her passion for public participation and her ability to engage with those who disagree with her. - Norman Edwards (Ward 3): Representing the Black Contractors Group, he stated he is present to discuss the lack of diversity and inclusion in the city, though he was noted as not being physically present during the roll call. - Fauzi Badour (Ward 11): Expressed strong opposition to a gas station zoning appeal at 100 Madison Avenue. He stated that the court, Planning Commission, and border zoning decisions rejected the appeal, and he argued that reintroducing legislation for a gas station would look "bad" for the council. He asserted that the neighborhoods (Kuduell, West Boulevard, Euclid) voted "clear and loud" against the gas station. - Josiah Quarrells (Shaker Heights, representing Northeast Ohio Coalition for the Homeless): Called on the council to pass "Tanisha's Law." He expressed support for the law as a necessary runway for community engagement and workforce recruitment. He requested confirmation that the safety committee hearing is scheduled for December 4th at 1 p.m. - Evangelist Darlene (Ward 4): Representing Anthony Connor, she urged the council to use their platform to call for DNA testing ordered by the Court of Appeals and to encourage the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office to review Connor's case. She described the evidence against Connor as non-existent and the identification methods as unduly suggestive. - Vivian Connor (Ward 6, mother of Anthony Cobb): Expressed a desperate need for justice for her son, Anthony Cobb, who has spent over 13 years in prison for a crime he did not commit. She asked the council to use their platform to help free her innocent son. - Alexis Mason (Garfield Heights): Reiterated the call for the council to use their platform to demand DNA testing for Anthony Cobb and urged the Prosecutor's Office to review the case with "fresh eyes" in the interest of truth and fairness. Discussion Items - Emergency Ordinances: The Council considered a large batch of emergency ordinances (1507–1545) related to: - Credit card regulations and appropriations. - Transfers of liquor license ownership and location. - Leases for parks, marinas, and airport kiosks. - Contracts for water treatment chemicals, polymer, and hauling residuals. - Collective bargaining agreements for the Firefighters, Electrical Workers, Plumbers, and Painters Local unions. - Tax incentive reviews and the Waterloo Art District project. - Redevelopment of the Warner Swayze building and the Village of Joy birthing center. - Design Review Districts: Discussion on establishing the Lorraine Antiques Design Review District (Ordinance 1520) and expanding the West 117th Street Design Review District (Ordinance 1521). - Infrastructure and Public Works: Approval of contracts and grants for the Euclid Avenue Pedestrian Improvement Project, Euclid Beach Trail Connector, signal support polls, and active transportation programs. - Court Services: Authorization for contracts with Court Community Service, Oriana House, and the Cuyahoga County Public Defender Commission for the Cleveland Municipal Court. - Street Vacations: Ordinances to vacate portions of West Third Street (Ordinances 1490 and 1492). Key Outcomes - Unanimous Passage of Emergency Ordinances: With Councilmember Starr recusing himself on Ordinance 1416-2025, the Council voted 14-0-1 (for 1416) and 15-0 for all other emergency ordinances and resolutions listed on the second reading and first reading, placing them on final passage immediately. - Specific Vote on Ordinance 1416: The vote on Ordinance 1416-2025 (Euclid Beach Trail Connector) resulted in 14 Yeas, 0 Nays, and 1 Recusal (Starr). - All Others: All other emergency ordinances passed on final passage with a 15-0 vote tally. - Scheduling Confirmation: Councilwoman House Jones confirmed via announcement that the first hearing for "Tanisha's Law" will be held on Thursday, December 4, 2025, at 1:00 p.m. - Acknowledgments: Council members recognized community figures including Stephanie Morrison Herbeck, her husband George Herbeck, and local business owner Solomon. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned to the call of the chair, with the next meeting scheduled for Monday, December 1, 2025. - Recusal Note: Councilmember Starr recused himself from the vote on Ordinance 1416-2025.

On November 24, 2025, the Cleveland City Council's Committee on Finance, Development, Equity, and Inclusion convened to consider a wide-ranging agenda involving significant real estate redevelopment, municipal contracts, public safety initiatives, and infrastructure improvements. The committee addressed ten ordinances and multiple emergency measures, including amendments to loan agreements for the redevelopment of the Warner and Swayze building and a new birthing center, contract renewals for the Cleveland Municipal Court, and various public works projects ranging from ATM installations to street resurfacing and pedestrian enhancements. The meeting concluded with the ratification of the final collective bargaining agreements for the city, bringing the total ratified contracts for the fiscal year to 25 out of 33. Consent Calendar Ordinance 1448-2025: Authorizes the Director of Finance to contract with Court Community Service for community service placement and Cleveland Work Crew program placement. Council members expressed full support and high praise for the organization's decade-long service and effectiveness. Ordinance 1449-2025: Authorizes the Director of Finance to contract with Oriana House, Inc. for pretrial release supervision services. Council members fully supported the piece, with Councilwoman Santana noting strong support for the program as data shows a decrease in failure-to-appear rates from 42% in 2018 to 24% in 2024. Ordinance 1453-2025: Authorizes the Director of Finance to contract with the Cuyahoga County Public Defender Commission for legal services. Council members fully supported the measure, with Councilman Pelesi offering wholehearted support and thanking the department for its critical work. Ordinance 1418-2025: Authorizes the Director of Aging to accept grants from the Western Reserve Area Agency on Aging. Councilman Conwell fully supported the request, citing the Department of Aging's consistent excellence and reliability. Ordinance 1522-2025: Authorizes a $750,000 loan to Village of Joy Corporation (Birth & Beautiful Communities) for a birthing center. Council members strongly supported the project, with Councilman Casey thanking the administration and expressing personal connection to the program, while Council President emphasized support for the "triple bottom line" of economic, social, and environmental impact. Ordinance 1396-2025: Authorizes the installation of an ATM at City Hall with Key Bank. While Councilman Bishop supported the passage, he expressed concern regarding the potential loss of revenue for the city from such machines and requested further investigation into revenue sharing. Councilman Palency expressed concern about the technological currency of the ATM, noting personal issues with fraud flags. Ordinance 1404-2025: Authorizes contracts for active transportation and traffic calming improvements. Council members expressed concern regarding the visibility and maintenance of speed tables and delineator posts during winter snow plowing. Councilman Palency expressed strong dissatisfaction with current paint quality and visibility, demanding better materials and snow-clearing capabilities. The committee reaffirmed support for the project contingent on addressing these specific safety and maintenance issues. Ordinance 1446-2025: Authorizes contracts for replacing mast arm signal supports. Councilman Bishop fully supported the ordinance, noting the necessity of repairing rotted or damaged poles. Ordinance 1295-2025: Extends an MOU with the RTA for West 117th Street improvements. Councilman Bishop fully supported the extension and the additional payment for extra concrete work. Ordinance 1400-2025: Authorizes state funding applications for the rehabilitation of Wade Park Avenue. Council members fully supported the project, with Councilman Conwell emphasizing strong resident support ("100% support") and praising the administration for listening to community input. Ordinance 1402-2025: Authorizes consultants for pedestrian enhancements on Euclid Avenue. Council members fully supported the measure, with Councilman Hairston expressing hope that this is not the only phase and urging future funding for additional improvements. Ordinance 1416-2025: Amends the Euclid Beach Trail Connector agreement to make easements perpetual and adds submerged land leases. Council members fully supported the changes to ensure long-term trail viability and praised the project for providing greater lakefront access. Ordinances 1489, 1490, and 1491-2025: Vacate portions of West Third Street to facilitate development and create a river walk/kayak launch. Council members fully supported the vacations. Councilman Pelesi expressed concern regarding the lack of bollards to prevent vehicles from entering the river, requesting confirmation that the design team will address this safety issue. Ordinance 1511-2025: Approves the Tax Incentive Review Council's 2024 recommendations. Councilman Harrison fully supported the committee's recommendation to continue agreements, noting that entities were close to compliance and making significant investments. Ordinance 1516-2025: Ratifies the collective bargaining agreement with Local 93 AFSCME (firefighters at the airport). The ordinance was approved, though Councilman Bishop requested more transparency regarding budget impacts and retroactive costs in future negotiations. Ordinance 1517-2025: Ratifies the collective bargaining agreement with IBEW Local 38. The ordinance was approved following no objections. Ordinance 1518-2025: Ratifies the collective bargaining agreement with Plumbers Local 55. The ordinance was approved with no objections. Ordinance 1545-2025: Ratifies the collective bargaining agreement with IBPAT Local 639. The ordinance was approved, marking the ratification of the 25th of 33 city contracts. Public Comments & Testimony Court Community Service Representatives: Michelle Kenney and Stephanie Pope Early testified on the effectiveness of the program, providing statistics on community service hours (78,000 hours) and collections. Oriana House Representatives: Ron Hampton and city pretrial staff testified on the success of the pretrial services program, highlighting the reduction in failure to appear rates and low rates of new criminal activity. Village of Joy Corporation Representatives: Jasmine Long (CEO), Chris Shefton (Chief of Growth), and Robin Brown (Project Manager) testified on the birthing center project, highlighting the $13.9 million raised and the imminent construction start. Key Bank Representative: A representative was present to discuss the ATM agreement, though specific remarks were not transcribed in detail. Cuyahoga County Public Defender Representative: Attorney Sweeney testified on the 20-year partnership with the city and the critical importance of representing indigent defendants. Discussion Items Warner and Swayze Redevelopment (Ordinances 1458 & 1519): The committee discussed the amendment to allow multiple separate loans for different housing components (senior vs. family units). Councilman Casey pressed on the city's total investment ($10.6 million) and the percentage of forgivable loans (the $2.8 million ED portion). Director Rose clarified the city's position as subordinate (third position) to senior lenders. Councilman Starr expressed full support, calling it a "great opportunity" nearing the finish line after 2.5 years of work. Birthing Center Project (Ordinance 1522): The committee reviewed the $750,000 loan and the $1.75 million total city contribution. Councilman Casey critiqued the presentation of the "capital stack," urging future meetings to provide detailed financial breakdowns upfront to track spending across different city neighborhoods. Speed Tables and Visibility (Ordinance 1404): A significant portion of the discussion focused on the visibility of speed tables. Councilman Palency stated clearly that current paint quality is insufficient and demanded an explanation of the plan to upgrade to high-visibility materials (like day-glow paint) and ensure snow plow crews can clear delineators. Councilman Bishop confirmed he had personally hit unpainted speed tables, agreeing that some need repainting. ATM Revenue (Ordinance 1396): Councilman Bishop voiced concern that the city receives no revenue from the private sector's ATM usage. He proposed a more aggressive stance on negotiating a small portion of the transaction revenue for city funds to support other needs. Snow Removal and Delineators (Ordinance 1404): Councilman Palency expressed dissatisfaction regarding the ability to plow streets with installed delineators in the Northeast side. The Commissioner confirmed the city has the equipment and a group dedicated to this, but Palency urged the committee not to install delineators in such areas unless plowing is guaranteed. Key Outcomes Ordinances 1458-2025 (amended) and 1519-2025: Approved to allow multiple loan agreements for the Warner and Swayze redevelopment, pending full body consideration. The total city investment was confirmed at $10.6 million, with $2.8 million of the ED loans being forgivable contingent on meeting specific conditions. The city holds a third position in the loan hierarchy. Ordinances 1448, 1449, 1453, 1418, 1522, 1396, 1404, 1446, 1295, 1400, 1402, 1416, 1489, 1490, 1491, 1511, 1516, 1517, 1518, and 1545: All passed with no objections or with unanimous support, pending full body consideration where noted. Budget Impact Request: Councilman Bishop secured an agreement from the Director of Finance to explicitly detail budget impacts (specifically retroactive costs) for all future collective bargained agreements. Safety Improvements Mandate: The committee agreed to address the specific visibility issues of speed tables and delineators raised by Councilman Palency and Councilman Bishop, with a request to provide exact addresses for inspection. River Walk Safety: The committee agreed to have the design team and developer discuss the installation of bollards for the West Third Street river walk vacation to prevent vehicles from entering the river. Contract Ratification Status: The committee successfully ratified 25 out of 33 collective bargaining agreements, reaching approximately 76% completion for the fiscal year.

On November 24, 2025, the Cleveland City Council convened to review subject matter expertise regarding the $100 million settlement agreement between the City of Cleveland and the Haslam Sports Group (HSG) regarding the departure of the Cleveland Browns to a new stadium in Brook Park. Council President Griffin emphasized that the hearing was a strategic business discussion focused on ensuring the City of Cleveland is "made whole" financially and physically, rather than a sentimental debate. The session featured testimony from four external experts regarding the economic implications, infrastructure risks, and the feasibility of the settlement, followed by extensive debate among council members regarding the city's leverage, the usage of settlement funds, and the administration's negotiation strategy. Consent Calendar - No routine consent calendar items were included in this specific hearing transcript; the session was dedicated entirely to discretionary discussion and expert testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Ken Silliman (Retired City Law Department Veteran): Stated he has no financial stake in the outcome but expressed a position of strong concern. He described the Brook Park project as the "single worst development deal" for the region in 38 years based on the city's economic study, which predicts $11 million in annual tax revenue loss. He expressed support for the $100 million settlement amount and its timing but strongly opposed the "best efforts" language in Sections 2E and 2F of the term sheet, arguing it could inadvertently prioritize Brook Park infrastructure over Cleveland neighborhood projects. He recommended deleting Section F entirely and amending Section E to clarify that city support does not override other city infrastructure priorities. - Michael Deemer (President/CEO, Downtown Cleveland Inc.): Expressed "heavy-hearted" support for the $100 million settlement. His position is that the "die was cast" when the State of Ohio provided the $600 million, shifting the focus to making the best of a difficult situation. He argued the settlement provides the necessary clarity and funding to strengthen the downtown core and mitigate the negative economic impacts of the stadium's departure. - David Ebersall (Vice President, Greater Cleveland Partnership): Expressed strong support for the settlement. His position was that the agreement allows for the development of a domed stadium that will benefit the region (citing peer cities like Detroit and Indianapolis for added events) and secures critical investment for the downtown lakefront. He argued that rejecting the deal would result in the city getting "nothing" and losing the opportunity to catalyze $5 billion in regional investment. - Scott Skinner (President/ED, North Coast Waterfront Development Corp): Expressed support for the settlement as a necessary step to provide certainty for the downtown lakefront development. He argued that the $50 million specifically earmarked for the lakefront and stadium demolition is critical to initiating the $150 million land bridge project and attracting private investment, which would not happen without the certainty of the stadium's removal. - Councilman Joseph Slifer: Raised concerns about the potential for unfunded mandates and prioritization of Brook Park infrastructure over city-of-Cleveland needs (specifically Miles Road, Lee Road, and Rocky River Road projects). He stated he would not support an agreement that locks the city into prioritizing suburban projects over neighborhood infrastructure needs. - Councilman Michael Palency: Expressed strong opposition to the deal as currently structured, stating he "cannot support" it without further amendments. His position includes concerns that the stadium has not been independently inspected to confirm demolition is necessary, that the $100 million settlement is insufficient given existing city debts and capital repair obligations, and that the administration failed to leverage a "full court press" against the state of Ohio or the NFL. - Councilman Brian Casey: Expressed a determination to "die in the alley" and oppose the settlement, arguing the city could have secured more and that the deal favors outside interests over local residents. He highlighted the disparity between the support provided to billionaires versus everyday working people in neighborhoods facing school closures and disinvestment. He questioned the shift in position by the Downtown Cleveland Alliance and Greater Cleveland Partnership, accusing them of failing to lobby in Columbus against the $600 million state grant. - Councilwoman House Jones: Questioned the relevance of the settlement to single mothers and seasonal workers in neighborhoods facing immediate hardships like school closures. She argued that the projected economic benefits are distant and that the deal essentially transfers tax revenue (currently $11 million annually) to Brook Park and the State, leaving the city with "nothing" but a liability for the stadium demolition. She urged voters to hold the state accountable for valuing billionaires over working people. - Councilman Anthony Harrison: Defended the administration, stating they had genuine conversations and plans to keep the Browns and that the 600 million state grant was an insurmountable obstacle. He argued the council must accept the reality of the situation and work to make the best of it rather than creating division. Discussion Items - Infrastructure Leverage and Term Sheet Language: A primary discussion focused on Ken Silliman's testimony regarding Sections 2E and 2F of the term sheet. Councilman Slife, Councilwoman Moore, and others pressed the administration and legal team on whether "best efforts" language could legally force the city to prioritize Brook Park infrastructure over city neighborhood projects. Council President Griffin and Chief Treasurer expressed that the intent was never to prioritize Brook Park and committed to amending the language to protect city flexibility for projects like Miles Road and the West Park Rapid Station. - Revenue Loss and Economic Impact: Multiple council members (Palency, Jones, Slifer) argued that the move represents a net loss, citing a projected $11 million annual loss in city tax revenue and a $30 million hit to economic development. They questioned the validity of the "multiplier" effects promised by the stadium proponents and the lack of tangible benefits for neighborhoods. - Negotiation Strategy and Leverage: A significant portion of the debate centered on whether the administration could have secured more leverage. Councilman Palency and Councilwoman Jones argued there should have been a more aggressive legal and political battle, including a "full court press" in Columbus and a refusal to settle while lawsuits were pending. Councilman Harrison countered that the Art Modell law was effectively gutted by the state, leaving the city with no legal leverage to keep the team and that delaying the move further would cost the city more. - Usage of Settlement Funds: Council members debated how the $100 million settlement should be allocated. Council President Griffin and Councilman Slifer emphasized the need to ensure funds are used to replace lost revenue and invest in neighborhoods (e.g., Gen Academy, John Hay, Sheridan Hotel, housing repair). Councilman Palency expressed skepticism that any funds would reach the East Side neighborhoods. - Stadium Demolition and Lease Extension: Councilman Palency questioned the necessity of demolishing the existing stadium without an independent structural study. The discussion clarified that the stadium must be demolished under the term sheet. The lease extension provision (two one-year options) was discussed, with councilmembers noting the low rental fee ($250,000/year) during the extension period is inconceivable compared to market rates. - Role of Business Organizations: Councilman Casey challenged the positions of the Greater Cleveland Partnership and Downtown Cleveland Alliance, noting their executive committees supported the move while their full boards had previously voted against relocation plans. He accused them of failing to mobilize against the state's $600 million grant. Key Outcomes - No Final Vote: The council did not cast a final vote on the settlement during this hearing; the session was strictly for expert testimony and information gathering. - Commitment to Amend Language: The administration explicitly committed to addressing the "best efforts" language in Sections 2E and 2F of the term sheet to ensure it does not prioritize Brook Park infrastructure over Cleveland neighborhood projects. Council President Griffin pledged to work on these amendments. - Strategic Pivot Confirmed: While passionate debate occurred, the council's leadership (Council President Griffin and Council member Harrison) concluded that the city's leverage is limited to delaying the move rather than preventing it, and the immediate strategy is to secure the $100 million settlement to make the city "whole" and protect taxpayers from future demolition liabilities. - Directives for Staff: The Council President directed policy and research staff to gather recommendations on amendments to the term sheet and lease, focusing on infrastructure priorities and the use of settlement funds for neighborhood revitalization projects."}

The Municipal Services and Properties Committee convened for its final official meeting of the year to consider and approve several emergency ordinances related to public works, safety improvements, and property management. The committee focused on funding for roadway projects, the installation of an Automated Teller Machine (ATM) for vital statistics, active transportation infrastructure, and the vacation of specific right-of-way portions to facilitate the Bedrock development project. Multiple ordinances were subject to amendments proposed by Councilman Casey and Councilman Starr regarding notification protocols and funding sources. Consent Calendar - [None; all items were addressed as Discussion Items or required specific action/votes] Public Comments & Testimony - [No formal public comments or testimony were recorded in the transcript; all discourse was limited to committee members and city staff.] Discussion Items - Ordinance 396-2025 (Amended): Authorized a license agreement with Key Bank for an ATM at Vital Statistics. Staff stated that two RFPs yielded no responses, leaving Key Bank as the sole willing partner. Director noted that while Key Bank has committed to Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) rules, the $4 transaction fee (applicable to non-account holders) was not negotiated as part of the original RFP but represents the standard fee Key Bank charges. - Positions: Councilman Starr and Councilman Casey expressed concern regarding the lack of competitive bidding and the specific $4 fee structure, questioning if costs could have been negotiated. Director clarified that while they requested cost negotiation in the RFP, no other bank responded. - Ordinance 1404-2025: Authorized contracts for the "Active Transportation Program" (Vision Zero/Cleveland Moves) to retrofit safety improvements like signage and pavement markings. Commissioner Mavic explained the program aims to retrofit existing roadways (like Huron/Prospect) rather than new capital projects. - Positions: Councilman Starr raised concerns about business access and safety issues at the Huron/Prospect project, citing business owner complaints about delivery bottlenecks and parking changes, though Commissioner Mavic defended the safety improvements and reduced traffic control needs for events. Councilman Maher noted confusion regarding the reversal of one-way traffic for Rockets games. - Amendment: Councilman Casey and Councilman Starr proposed an amendment requiring written notice to the clerk for cooperative purchases. The amendment was passed unanimously to ensure council awareness of cooperative agreement usage without requiring prior approval for every minor project. - Ordinance 1446-2025: Authorized contracts to purchase and install traffic signal support poles where existing ones were damaged or compromised. - Positions: Councilman Casey clarified the scope is limited to repairing compromised uprights, not installing new mast arms on existing wire-hung signals unless part of a capital project. Data was requested regarding the total number of signals and the percentage of mast arm vs. wire-hung systems. - Ordinance 1316-2025: Authorized a deed of easement selling rights for a fire lane and pedestrian access to Cedar Redevelopment Phase 4 for $14,000 (fair market value). The city retains fee ownership of the land. - Positions: Councilman Harrison and Councilman Casey sought clarification that the city retains land ownership (fee interest) while granting only usage rights. Councilman Starr expressed full support, aligning the easement with the broader Central Recreation Center and neighborhood upgrade initiatives. - Ordinance 1416-2025: Amended previous agreements for the Euclid Beach Tri-Trail Connector to change trail easements from 50 years to perpetual terms and added a submerged land lease piece for the sewer district. - Positions: Councilman Harrison questioned the shift to perpetual easements, fearing future renewal issues with multiple property owners. Staff explained that perpetual terms prevent property owners from denying easements during renewal, ensuring long-term trail stability. Commissioner De Janeiro clarified that the submerged land lease remains limited to 50 years due to Ohio Department of Natural Resources regulations. - Ordinance 1082-2023: Authorized application for DOPWIC state funding for roadway improvements on State Route 283 (55th St to St. Clair). The project scope expanded from $8.5M to $13M to include safety enhancements. - Positions: Councilman Harrison expressed initial frustration that funding was prioritized over worse-condition sections of St. Clair Avenue but noted that a phased plan for the remaining sections was developed to his satisfaction. Councilman Casey inquired about private entity donations, which staff clarified are typically limited to enhancements within the public right-of-way adjacent to private developments. - Ordinance 1295-2025: Amended an agreement with GCRTA for the West 117th Street station to extend the term and cover a $29,600 cost overrun. - Positions: Councilman Starr proposed an amendment to strike the vague language "and other funds as approved by the director of finance," insisting that funding sources be explicitly listed in the legislation. The amendment passed unanimously. - Ordinance 1400-2025: Authorized funding applications for rehabilitating Wade Park Avenue (66th to 118th) and connecting it to the 66th Street transformation project. - Positions: Director noted the project is critical for bike infrastructure connectivity but clarified that the $164,000 listed for 2026 bonds is an estimate and requires future explicit authorization from Council. - Ordinance 1402-2025: Authorized consultants for pedestrian enhancements on Euclid Avenue (Upper Valley to Ivanhoe), utilizing TLCI grant funding. - Positions: Councilman Harrison expressed full support but noted the project is dangerous for students and emphasized the need for future funding (bonds or discretionary) to fully realize the scope. - Amendment: Councilman Starr moved to add a requirement for written notice to the clerk for cooperative purchases, which passed unanimously. - Ordinances 1489, 1490, & 1491-2025: Authorized the vacation of portions of West Third Street right-of-way to facilitate the Bedrock development project, transferring the land to adjacent property owners. - Positions: Councilman Casey questioned why the city does not sell the land or issue easements instead of vaccating. Staff explained that upon vacation of a right-of-way, the land reverts to the adjacent owner by legal right, not via sale. Key Outcomes - Ordinance 396-2025: Approved as amended (Key Bank agreement, 2-year term with 3-year option). - Ordinance 1404-2025: Approved as amended (Amendment regarding cooperative purchase notification passed; Vote: Ayes: 14, Nays: 0). - Ordinance 1446-2025: Approved. - Ordinance 1316-2025: Approved. - Ordinance 1416-2025: Approved as amended (Easements made perpetual; Submerged land lease term noted as 50 years). - Ordinance 1082-2023: Approved. - Ordinance 1295-2025: Approved as amended (Struck vague funding language; Vote: Ayes: 14, Nays: 0). - Ordinance 1400-2025: Approved. - Ordinance 1402-2025: Approved as amended (Amendment regarding cooperative purchase notification passed; Vote: Ayes: 14, Nays: 0). - Ordinances 1489, 1490, 1491-2025: Approved (Vacation of West Third Street portions). - Next Steps: Staff to provide data on traffic signal inventory and Huron/Prospect traffic counts to Council members. Staff to finalize design for Euclid Avenue as funding is confirmed. Next meeting scheduled as called by the Chair.

The Cleveland City Council convened on November 17, 2025, to address urgent community safety and infrastructure issues, honor the Transgender Day of Remembrance, and advance numerous legislative actions. The meeting was marked by significant public testimony regarding Tanisha's Law, systemic failures in the school system, and frustrations with the administration's responsiveness and funding allocation for lead remediation and crime prevention tools. Consent Calendar - Routine Approvals: The council unanimously approved several items including a $10,000 donation for adult changing tables at Cleveland Hopkins Airport, oath of office certifications for Planning Commission members (Anthony Whitfield, August Flucher) and Public Safety Directors (John Lair, Phil Jubert, Sydney Johnson), the dedication plat for Woodhill Homes, multiple liquor license applications, and various street vacatures (East 73rd, East 70th, East 71st, Ridman Avenue, West Third Street). - Resolutions of Condolence: Adopted condolence resolutions for JC Boyland, John Patrick Lennihan, and Nellie Grace Glasgow. - Resolutions of Congratulations/Recognition: Adopted resolutions honoring the 100 Black Men of Greater Cleveland, Cameo (Lebanese Independence Day), and recipients of the Reading Ram Academy Youth Renaissance Empowerment Award (Karen Howard and Terrence Lewis). Public Comments & Testimony - Michael Anderson (Tanisha's Uncle): Expressed deep respect for the democracy and the city of Cleveland while advocating for the passage of Tanisha's Law. He described the night Tanisha died (32 degrees, handcuffed, stark-necked) and noted she was honored internationally (Time Magazine, Beyoncé concert), contrasting this with the city's lack of action. He expressed hope for a successful meeting next month. - Daryl Houston (Bedford Heights): Expressed strong frustration regarding the lack of cooperation between the Mayor and City Council, stating they represent taxpayers. He demanded the City "eradicate the lead in the city of Cleveland" for the sake of his granddaughter. He criticized the Kinsman Bridge operations as "terrible" and "not doing a good job." He directed severe criticism at Councilors Polenzic and Conwell, stating they "have done nothing for Glenville" and "Collinwood" regarding dilapidated schools and asserting they are "well beyond retirement." He expressed opposition to the Cleveland Browns' future on the land, suggesting manufacturing businesses should be used instead. He called for the return of the Fire Chief to work and criticized the use of tax dollars on a "six-figure salary with a guy sitting at home." - Brenda Bickerstaff (Citizens for Safe Cleveland): Expressed disagreement with state laws enacted by Governor Mike DeWine (Stand Your Ground, Open Carry). She stated these laws have made crime worse and set people up for death, particularly those with felony convictions who cannot legally carry without a court order. She asserted that Councilmembers Griffin and House Jones should have opposed or vetted these laws but instead passed them. She demanded the Consent Decree be retained until full compliance with police reforms is achieved, stating, "We want compliance before it leave." - Pete Van Lear (Ward 3): Cited models from Durham and Albuquerque to express full support for Tanisha's Law. He argued that integrating crisis response into 911 calls is more effective than the current pilot program limited to 988 calls. He proposed a specific financial directive: redirecting the over $900,000 spent annually on ShotSpotter to fund Tanisha's Law. He advocated for institutionalizing community safety departments with cabinet-level status. - Terry Wang (Ward 3): Expressed strong opposition to ShotSpotter and proposed replacement with Flock's "Raven" technology. He stated that nearly 30 years of research shows "up to 90% of shot spotter alerts yielded no evidence of a gun related crime." He argued these tools do not reduce gun violence and that the city lacks evidence that Flock performs better. He asserted that socioeconomic stability, not surveillance, makes communities safer. He noted that the city appears to have violated the consent decree and charter section 1155 regarding automatic license plate readers. - Jake Taylor (Ward 15): Described a two-year delay in receiving grant funds for lead remediation for his duplex. He expressed that as an educator, he cannot afford the high cost of replacing windows and remediation himself. He stated he has checked in every 90 days for over a year without resolution. He expressed a strong desire to fix the units for his tenants but feels unable to do so without funds. Discussion Items - Tanisha's Law & Crisis Response: Councilwoman House Jones expressed extreme frustration regarding the 371-day delay in receiving a formal response from the administration to a bill introduced on November 4, 2024. She stated, "I am so frustrated in this building... I am tired of fighting with y'all just to acknowledge basic humanity." She criticized the administration for not centering underserved people despite using those slogans to secure grants. Pete Van Lear supported the bill as a way to modernize the 911 system using proven models from other cities. - School System & East Side Stability: Councilman Joe Jones and Councilwoman Brenda Bickerstaff discussed systemic issues in the Cleveland Municipal School District (CMSD). Councilman Jones stated the school board has squandered ARPA funds and closed 28 schools on the East Side, leading to a population exodus. He argued that families are fleeing due to the lack of schools and the stripping of programs (e.g., at Collinwood). Councilman Conwell expressed concern that if the administration continues to close schools (specifically mentioning plans to close four more), the city will "lose two more wards" due to redistricting. He stated, "Families talk with their feet," and warned that an exodus will destabilize the city. Councilman Polenzik emphasized that while Council controls no budget for schools, the political will must exist to reverse these decisions to prevent further loss of families. - Lead Remediation Funding: Issues regarding the stagnation of lead remediation funds were raised by public testimony (Jake Taylor) and the frustration of Councilmembers who feel the administration is not moving quickly enough. - Crime and Safety Tools: A debate emerged regarding ShotSpotter versus Flock. Terry Wang presented data showing ShotSpotter's low efficacy (90% no evidence) and raised concerns about Flock's implementation. Councilwoman Bickerstaff highlighted the negative impact of state legislation on local crime rates. Key Outcomes - Ordinances Passed: Passed 16 ordinances (Emergency and Regular) without objection or with 15 Yes/1 Nay votes (Ordinance 1304-2025). Key items included: - Parking charge subfunds creation. - Contracts for Municipal Court community service programs (Community Service, Cleveland Work Crew, Oriana House). - Designation of the Cam's Corner Bank Building as a Cleveland Landmark. - Grants for Greater Cleveland Media Development Corporation. - Retrofit of a Division of Police command bus. - Consolidation of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame lease. - Urban forestry service contracts. - Vacature approvals for multiple streets. - Luke Easter Skate Park grant applications and development authorization. - Airport system funding and maintenance contracts. - Economic development grants for Warehouse District, Memphis/Pearl, Dales Barber Arbor Park, and Fairfax Neighborhood Technology Training Center. - Resolutions Passed: - Resolution 1469-2025: Recognized Transgender Day of Remembrance on November 20, 2025, reaffirming commitment to transgender equality and anti-discrimination protections. Passed 16-0 with additions by Councilmember Gray. - Several resolutions of condolence and recognition passed unanimously. - Directives/Next Steps: - Councilwoman House Jones vowed to continue fighting for Tanisha's Law in 2026, promising not to be silent regarding the administration's lack of responsiveness. - Councilman Polenzik and Councilwoman House Jones called for the administration to provide a clear "game plan" for closing school buildings and integrating Glenville and Collinwood to prevent neighborhood destabilization. - Councilman Jones urged the Council and Mayor to work together to secure adequate funding and leadership to transform the city's education and safety systems, likening the city's potential economic value to a "financial gold mine." - Procedural Notes: Council was adjourned with the next meeting scheduled for November 24, 2025.

The Finance, Diversity, and Inclusion Committee convened on November 17, 2025, to review and approve a series of emergency ordinances focusing on public health initiatives, green space expansion, housing advocacy, technology upgrades, and extensive airport development projects under the Department of Port Control. The meeting featured presentations from community organizations regarding infant mortality rates and tree canopy management, alongside updates on terminal modernization, wetland mitigation, and airport debt financing. All proposed ordinances were reviewed thoroughly, with specific attention given to budget allocations, inter-organizational partnerships, and operational logistics before being approved unanimously. Consent Calendar - Ordinance 1322-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Public Health to enter a two-year agreement with First Year Cleveland to support infant health programming. - Ordinance 1431-2025: Approved authorizing an agreement with Western Reserve Land Conservancy (Thriving Communities Institute) for professional services regarding green space planning, vacant land restoration, and reforestation, with a budget not exceeding $150,000. - Ordinance 1421-2025: Approved authorizing an agreement with the Fair Housing Center for Rights and Research to manage the Vacant and Abandoned Property Action Council (VAPAC), transferring the function from Western Reserve Land Conservancy. - Ordinance 1445-2025: Approved authorizing an agreement with On-Tech Partners for professional computer technology services for Council operations. - Ordinance 1086-2025: Approved authorizing the Department of Port Control to enter requirement contracts for industrial and building supplies for facility maintenance. - Ordinance 1251-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Port Control to employ an insurance brokerage firm for a seven-year Owner-Controlled Insurance Program (OCIP) for the terminal modernization development program. - Ordinance 1252-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Port Control to employ consultants for wayfinding services to improve ticketing lobby operations at Cleveland Hopkins International Airport. - Ordinance 1253-2025: Approved authorizing the Department of Port Control to contract for concrete services and structure maintenance for airport roadways, runways, and taxiways. - Ordinance 1304-2025: Approved authorizing an agreement with West Creek Conservancy for the design and implementation of wetland mitigation projects to relocate wetlands off the airfield to a site in Grafton, Ohio. - Ordinance 1317-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Port Control to employ financial and accounting consultants for one year to assist with terminal modernization and airline negotiations. - Ordinance 1318-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Port Control to employ consultants for on-call asset management services for one year. - Ordinance 1401-2025: Approved authorizing the Director of Finance to employ consultants for Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) implementation and advisory services with a cap of $50,000. - Ordinance 1408-2025: Approved amending the 2024 revolving line of credit and authorizing additional airport system indebtedness up to $476 million to fund terminal, parking garage, and RTA station improvements. Public Comments & Testimony - Councilman Palencik: Expressed concern regarding the lack of neighborhood connectivity for infant health outreach and questioned why resources were not utilized at existing community centers like the Collinwood Rec Center. He also expressed skepticism about the high infant mortality rates compared to birth rates and requested data by ward. He later expressed deep frustration regarding Port Control's failure to purchase 170 acres of land adjacent to the airport for future expansion, calling it a "major misstep" and a "lack of vision." - Councilman Bishop: Questioned the trend of city birth rates and requested data on infant mortality by ward to better understand community-specific impacts. He praised targeted work in the Lee-Harvest community that reduced local mortality rates. - Councilwoman Spencer: Expressed strong support for the Western Reserve Land Conservancy's "nimble" approach, highlighting the successful resolution of the Hermit Park Trail project which had been stalled for over a decade. She credited the organization's creativity and flexibility for achieving results that the city and other entities could not. - Councilman Casey: Expressed gratitude for the Port Control team's role in facilitating the installation of adult changing stations at the airport, a key feature for the Special Olympics. He requested clarification on the status of FAA and TSA operations following the federal government shutdown. - Western Reserve Land Conservancy (Matt): Clarified that the organization nurtures trees for five years post-planting, provided detailed statistics on tree planting numbers (over 1,000 in 2025 vs. 64 by the city), and outlined a framework for partnering with CMSD to manage school district tree inventory and maintenance. - Port Control (Director/Dennis Kramer): Explained that the new RTA station is a replacement for the existing station which is beneath the future terminal, not a new addition to the network outside the airport. He confirmed the airport is operating normally following the government shutdown and that FAA restrictions have been lifted. Discussion Items - First Year Cleveland & Infant Mortality: Director Angela White Newton and Public Health Director Francis Frank presented the organization's 10-year history and a $7 million investment strategy. Data was shared showing the 2024 preliminary infant mortality rate is 13.6 (African American: 19.7, Hispanic: 9.1, White: 5.8), significantly above the Healthy People 2030 goal of 5.0. While birth rates are declining, the mortality rate is rising. Council debated outreach strategies, with First Year Cleveland noting their "One Community" framework and resource app (First Year Connects) designed to reach families in specific zip codes through neighborhood centers. - Green Space & Vacant Land: Councilman Griffin introduced the Western Reserve Land Conservancy contract, highlighting a $30 million leveraged investment resulting in 2,500 trees planted over five years. The discussion included plans for the Store Avenue transformation, the Euclid Beach Transformation Project, and a new Thurgood Marshall Green Park. Councilmen expressed interest in expanding tree stewardship training and addressing dead trees on CMSD properties. - VAPAC Transition: Councilman Griffin clarified the transfer of VAPAC management from Western Reserve to the Fair Housing Center. Frank Ford confirmed VAPAC's role in leveraging county lawsuits and monitoring land transfers via the Northern Ohio Information Data System. - Airport Terminal Modernization: Director of Port Control presented a comprehensive package for airport improvements, including a new parking garage, RTA station replacement, and ground transportation center funded by a $476 million line of credit increase approved by airlines. Councilman Palencik questioned the lack of land acquisition plans next to the airport, citing the missed opportunity with the Browns' proposed site. Councilmen also sought clarity on the RTA station location, confirming it is a replacement on the existing footprint. - Wetland Mitigation: Assistant Director Dennis Kramer detailed the necessity of moving 8 acres of wetlands off the airfield to a site in Grafton, Ohio, to comply with EPA regulations and reduce wildlife hazards. The site in Grafton was identified as unique for satisfying mitigation requirements within the same watershed. - Ordinances 1489, 1490, 1491 (Street Vacations): These ordinances to vacate portions of Western Street were held for review. No committee members present in Finance were aware of the details, and no representatives from Planning Commission or the councilmembers who sponsored them (Welsh, Bishop, Harrison) were present to advocate for the measures. Key Outcomes - Unanimous Approval: All presented ordinances were approved by voice vote and instructed to be signed. - Budget Allocations Confirmed: - $500,000 for First Year Cleveland over two years (general funds). - $150,000 maximum for Western Reserve Land Conservancy professional services (2026 scope). - $150,000 maximum for VAPAC professional services. - $300,000 annually for Port Control industrial supplies. - $300,000 annually for Port Control concrete services. - Five-year budget for Port Control insurance brokerage (OCIP). - Strategic Directives: The Committee acknowledged the need to rework the Statement of Work (SOW) to potentially increase tree planting budgets and requested specific data on infant mortality and birth rates by ward from the Public Health department. - Next Steps: The Committee will revisit the street vacation ordinances (1489-1491) once Planning Commission details and sponsor advocacy are provided. Port Control is scheduled to proceed with the wetland mitigation project in Grafton and the terminal modernization financing.