Public Meetings - Honolulu, Hawaii

On Thursday, September 25, 2025, at 11:06 AM, the Committee on Government Efficiency and Community Services convened to receive an informational briefing on the implementation of the HL Build permitting platform. The meeting was chaired by Committee Chair Dosantis and attended by Vice Chair Wire, Councilmember Nishimoto, and Councilmember Cordero. Mayor Rick Blangiardi and Department of Planning and Permitting (DPP) Director Dawn Apuna presented on the system's goals, challenges, and progress since its August 4, 2025 go-live. The meeting concluded at 12:25 PM. Public Comments & Testimony - Greg Masekian (testifying as an individual) raised concerns about a roof project at his condominium, alleging fraud, improper work, and potential pay-to-play issues. He requested assistance from the council and mayor. - Raquel Achu expressed support for Director Apuna and DPP, acknowledging the difficulty of modernizing a decades-old system and urging patience and accountability from all stakeholders. - Angela Melody Young offered positive remarks about DPP's technological transition, supporting affordable housing, transit-oriented development, and the use of social media to promote positive community engagement. Discussion Items - Mayor Rick Blangiardi opened with a passionate defense of the HL Build project, emphasizing the historic challenge of replacing the 28-year-old Posse system. He noted that the administration had been transparent and that vendor Sporidian had extended the hypercare phase at no additional cost to address issues. He criticized recent negative media coverage and called for council support. - Director Dawn Apuna presented a detailed overview: - Purpose: Replace the outdated Posse system (1998) with a cloud-based platform to improve efficiency, transparency, and customer service. - Vendor Selection: A rigorous process beginning in December 2022, including a tiger team, RFI, competitive solicitation, and final selection of Clarity/Sporidian in February 2024. The contract was 18 months from kickoff to go-live. - Development: 17 two-week sprints, user acceptance testing, and a steering committee that gave green lights before launch. - Go-Live (August 4, 2025): Anticipated bumps; hypercare phase initially through September 2025 but extended indefinitely. - Challenges: Data migration errors (90% resolved), account setup difficulties, and new process questions. Staff handled thousands of inquiries. - Statistics Since Launch: 3,716 permits processed (1,539 building permits, 301 multi-apps, 77 grading, 16 minor SMAs, 1,154 quick permits); 3,495 account registrants. Noted that comparison with pre-launch periods is not apples-to-apples due to registration and front-end requirements. - Costs: $5.4 million for first three years (federal FRF funds); future maintenance costs to be presented to council during budget. - Councilmember Questions: - Councilmember Cordero inquired about stakeholder feedback incorporation, application changes, testing, go-live decision factors, data migration verification, and staff workload. Director Apuna acknowledged that stakeholder input came from general DPP discussions and that the application now requires more upfront information to reduce backlogs. Staff have been heavily involved in testing and training, impacting normal duties. - Vice Chair Wire asked about public notice for discretionary permits. Director Apuna confirmed that HL Build can generate reports by council district, and the department will work to provide regular updates to the council and potentially allow public search. - Chair Dosantis raised concerns about contract timing, data remapping, inspection system integration, and the departure of a key Sporidian business process manager just before go-live. Director Apuna noted that the loss has been a challenge but that Sporidian has provided replacement staff. The chair requested copies of contracts and invoices. Key Outcomes - No votes were taken; the briefing was informational. - The committee received the presentation and public testimony. - Director Apuna agreed to provide additional data on inspections (NOVs and NOOs) and to follow up on the feasibility of public access to discretionary permit reports. - The committee will continue to monitor the HL Build implementation and requested documentation of contracts and invoices.

Note on date discrepancy: The meeting took place on September 25, 2025 per the provided timestamp, but the raw transcript states the meeting was held on Wednesday, September 24, 2025 at 2:32 p.m. The Committee on Housing, Homelessness, and Parks convened to consider several resolutions, a bill, and two informational briefings. Key actions included confirming a parks board appointee, accepting gifts, advancing a bill on fire-resistant construction for affordable rental housing, receiving a presentation on a three-year child care action plan, and discussing the ongoing effort to inventory city-owned properties. Consent Calendar - Resolution 25-241 (confirming Charles Mitsui to the Board of Parks and Recreation) was reported out for adoption without objection. Mr. Mitsui testified about his background developing skate parks and expressed interest in creating a committee to facilitate community park projects. - Resolutions 25-250, 25-251, 25-252, and 25-255 (accepting gifts) were all reported out for adoption without objection. These accepted: - A cook pine tree valued at $3,000 for the 2025 Honolulu City Lights event (25-250) - A $4,000 monetary gift from HMSA for the 2025 Mayor's Craft and Country Fair (25-251) - An ice maker valued at $3,000 for Muanaluo Community Park (25-252, adopted as CD1) - A cook pine tree valued at $3,000 for the 2025 Kapolei City Lights event (25-255) Public Comments & Testimony - Bill 39 (2025): Gina Thielen testified online in support of the bill, standing on written testimony and offering to answer questions. - No public testimony was offered on any other agenda item. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-241 – Appointment of Charles Mitsui: Mr. Mitsui answered questions about his background, noting that he started the Association of Skateboarders in Hawaii in 1996 and helped develop nine skate parks. He hoped to return to a committee structure to facilitate new parks. - Bill 39 (2025) – Fire-Resistant Construction for Affordable Housing: Councilmember Wire introduced a CD1 amendment. Deputy Director Brian Gallagher of the Department of Planning and Permitting stated the department had no comments and was okay with the version. The bill was amended to CD1 and reported out. - Informational Briefing – Child Care Action Plan: Jordana Ferrero, from the Department of Community Services, presented the city’s three-year action plan (2025-2028). Key statistics shared: 50% of children under age 5 lack access to child care, and 90% of children under age 3 have no access. The plan has four goals: bolstering the workforce, expanding affordable options, empowering families, and building city infrastructure. Councilmembers discussed the need to align with city ordinances (Chapter 11), improve data collection, and streamline permitting. Councilmember Tupola emphasized focusing on one or two high-impact initiatives rather than spreading too thin. - Informational Briefing – Inventory of Vacant County-Owned Properties: Kevin Ajay (Director Designate, Department of Housing and Land Management) and Chief Data Officer Kara Chichum presented. They described efforts to centralize property data from multiple departments, with a target go-live date of May 2026. Council Chair Waters noted that previous charter mandates had not been fulfilled. Eleven properties suitable for affordable housing development were identified (listed in the summary). Eight RFQs had been issued, with contracts to be negotiated. Councilmember Tupola urged earlier community input and expressed interest in seeing an interim list rather than waiting until 2026. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-241 reported out for adoption (unanimous without objection). - Resolutions 25-250, 25-251, 25-252 (as CD1), and 25-255 reported out for adoption (unanimous without objection). - Bill 39 (2025) amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption (unanimous without objection). - The committee received the informational briefings. Councilmembers requested interim updates on the property inventory and continued collaboration with council districts on site selection for affordable housing.

The committee on International Legal Affairs was called to order at 23:01:56 UTC on September 24, 2025. All members were present (Representatives Talba, Okimoto Cordero, Kia Aina, Dos Santos TAM, Tupola, and Chair Waters). The meeting was conducted remotely pursuant to Section 92-3.7 HRS. Procedures for public testimony in English and Hawaiian were outlined. The committee consulted an executive session with its attorneys regarding legal matters. No objections or reservations were raised. No other agenda items or discussions are captured in the available transcript.

The Committee on Infrastructure, Transportation, and Technology met on September 24, 2025, at 9:02 a.m. via remote and in-person interactive conference technology. Chair Cordero presided with members Dosantos Tam, Wire, Okimoto, and Tupola (joining later). The meeting covered land conveyances, bills on HART planning, fare box recovery ratio repeal, library vending machines at Skyline stations, taxi regulations, and informational briefings on bus/rail integration and Biki bike share operations. Public testimony was heard on multiple agenda items. Consent Calendar - Communication D671 2025: Approved the deed conveying roadway lot 53 and grants of flowage easements 10 and 11 for public use in Eva. Unanimous without discussion. - Communication D698 2025: Approved the deed conveying roadway lots 19886 and 19887, grant of flowage easement 11180, and temporary road turnaround easements 11178 and 11179 for public use in Eva. Unanimous without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - On Bill 60 (HART planning expansion): - Donald Sakamoto (President, Citizens for Affirmative Action on Disability) advocated for including people with disabilities in rail planning studies, citing accessibility concerns at Dillingham Boulevard. He urged dialogue on Section 2.2 of the bill. - Jacob Winsack (transit rider) testified in strong support, stating that "prior preparation prevents poor performance" and that Bill 60 would help avoid past delays and cost overruns. - Mark Anthony Clemente (Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters) supported, citing a 2024 Hawaii Perspectives poll showing 74% of Oahu residents support rail expansion to Ala Moana and 77% support to UH Manoa. - Andrew Pereira (Director of Public Affairs, Pacific Resource Partnership) supported, arguing the bill is a "common sense solution" and that incomplete rail (like a half-built H3) is unusable. - On Resolution 25-262 (fare box recovery ratio repeal): - Ross Isukane supported repeal, stating public transportation should be heavily subsidized and that the fare box ratio is a "misguided concept" compared to road subsidies. - Donald Sakamoto recommended leaving the policy as is until the next rail segment opens, noting the impact of COVID on ridership. - On Informational Briefing (bus/rail integration): - Michael De Leon opposed elimination of Route 20, arguing it would disrupt elderly and disabled riders in Chinatown. - Ross Isukane opposed, stating the new W line (via Nimitz) is not a replacement for Route 20 (via Beretania) and serves tourism over locals. - Luka Cuniberti (North Shore resident, Hawaii Youth Transportation Council) supported rail but expressed frustration that no reasonable connections from North Shore to Skyline are included in the route changes. - On Resolution 25-263 (library vending machines): - Donald Sakamoto supported the pilot program but requested audible books for blind individuals. - On Bill 42 (taxi cabs): - Ryan Naka (taxi industry representative) supported, stating the bill restores fairness and allows the taxi industry to thrive. Discussion Items - Bill 52 2025 (Maintenance of trees and bodies of water): Chair Cordero noted it was the second committee hearing. No testimony or discussion; director absent. The bill was reported out for third reading unanimously. Councilmember Dosantos Tam referred to it as his "nerdy bill." - Bill 60 2025 (Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation): Introduced by Councilmember Dosantos Tam and co-introduced by Chair Cordero. The bill directs HART to plan for extensions beyond current statutory limits (Ala Moana and West Kapolei). A CD1 (OCS 2025-0749) was posted removing geographic specificity. HART Executive Director Dori Kahikina requested deferral because the HART Board had not discussed it; the next board meeting to consider the bill is October 24, 2025. Despite the request, the committee voted to amend to CD1 and report out for second reading and public hearing. Councilmember Wire asked DTS Director Roger Morton about ADA considerations at rail stations and restroom access policies ("urgent need" policy; restrooms at Kalihi Transit Center and airport). - Resolution 25-262 (Repeal of fare box recovery ratio policy): Councilmember Dosantos Tam explained the policy (25-30% goal) has not been met since 2016 and is non-binding. DTS Director Morton agreed, noting rising costs and post-COVID ridership decline. He said if enforced, it would force cuts to unproductive routes or fare increases. The resolution was referred to the Budget Committee for further consideration. - Resolution 25-263 (Library vending machine pilot at Skyline stations): Co-introduced by Councilmember Tupola and Chair Cordero. State Librarian representative Malory Fujitani expressed support for an 18-month pilot. No opposition. Adopted unanimously. - Bill 42 2025 (Taxicab regulations): Councilmember Tupola presented a CD1 with amendments agreed with CSD: removal of digital dispatch definitions, revision of fare charges (permitted when hired, not just occupied), exemption of CSD fare charges for taxicab drivers, and removal of baggage charges reference for jitneys. Director Hashiro of CSD submitted a late recommendation (DC 731) adding a five-year sunset with DCS evaluation. The committee verbally amended to include that sunset. Bill 42 as amended was reported out for second reading and public hearing. - Informational Briefing: Bus operations and rail integration (DTS): Deputy Director John Noichi presented changes accompanying the October 2025 opening of Skyline Segment 2 (four new stations to Kalihi Transit Center). Key changes: extended Skyline hours (4 a.m.–10:30 p.m. daily); new rapid bus lines: A Line (Ahua Lagoon to UH Manoa), U Line (Ahua Lagoon express to UH Manoa and East Honolulu), W Line (airport to Waikiki via Nimitz, reducing stops from 50 to 15). Route adjustments included Route 51 linking Central Oahu to Waiawa Skyline station, Route 331 for Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam, and frequency reductions on Route 46. Testimony raised concerns about elimination of Route 20 and lack of North Shore connections. Dep. Director Noichi noted workforce constraints but committed to quality service improvements. The committee discussed outreach, queue management at Lagoon Drive, and future North Shore connectivity. - Update on Biki bike share operations (DTS): Director Morton reported Biki has over 1,200 bikes, 132 stations, 5+ million rides since 2017, but faces financial challenges with negative margins. The city is stepping in with $800,000/year for integration with HOLO card (free 15-minute rides for monthly transit pass holders) and a federal fleet refurbishment program. The city owns about one-third of the fleet. Vandalism by one individual has caused significant damage. Councilmember Dosantos Tam asked about taking over the entire fleet; Morton said it could be explored. Concerns about federal funding for bike programs were noted. The committee discussed public-private partnerships and governance. Key Outcomes - Approved Communication D671 and D698 (land conveyances) unanimously. - Reported out Bill 52 2025 for third reading. - Amended and reported out Bill 60 2025 (CD1) for second reading and public hearing. - Referred Resolution 25-262 to the Budget Committee. - Adopted Resolution 25-263. - Amended and reported out Bill 42 2025 (CD1 as further verbally amended) for second reading and public hearing. - Noted the informational briefings; no formal action taken. - Next steps: HART to discuss Bill 60 at its October 24, 2025 board meeting; public hearing to be scheduled. DTS to continue integration of Biki with HOLO card by early 2027 and refurbish fleet by FY 2027.

The Committee on Zoning and Planning met on Tuesday, September 23, 2025, at 1:02 PM to consider several resolutions, bills, and discussion items related to historic preservation appointments, special management area permits, a special improvement district, and potential changes to permit notification requirements. The meeting was chaired by Chair Kia Aina, with Vice Chair Waters and members Councilmembers Tupola, Okimoto, Cordero, and Wara (also referred to as Councilmember Wire) in attendance. Public Comments & Testimony - Edward Jones (on behalf of Costro) testified in opposition to Bill 62 unless short-term rental allowance on same residential lot is clarified, citing the mayor's direction and urging a separate bill. Chair did not commit to introducing such a bill at that hearing. - Margaret Oronde testified that the $1,000 re-registration fee for changes in operator is excessive and that current restrictions are unconstitutional, warning of potential regulatory takings claims. - Cole McLullan (American Town Lodging Association/Hawaii Hotel Alliance) offered comments in support of Bill 62, noting it cleans up enforcement needs. - Angela Melody Young (CARES) testified neutral on Bill 62, commenting on insurance and HOA requirements. - Kelly Lee (Oahu Short-Term Rental Alliance) strongly supported Bill 62 but requested amendment to remove the $1,000 re-registration trigger for operator changes. - Bradley Ramos (Captain Cook Resorts/Oahu Short-Term Rental Alliance) echoed Kelly Lee's concerns on re-registration fees. - Kikoa McClellan (Roman Catholic Diocese of Honolulu) testified in support of Bill 51 (SID expansion) and thanked the chair for the exemption amendment. - Raquel Achu (North Shore resident) testified in support of Bill 56 and Resolution 25-228, stating that developers are abusing SMA minors and CUPs (e.g., gondola project) and that communities need notification at application stage. - Kathleen Pahinui (Chair, North Shore Neighborhood Board) asked for a heads-up on SMA minors/notifications at application stage, not after decision. - Jim Hayes (as citizen and developer representative) opposed Bill 56 but supported adding agribusiness to CUP notification requirements, noting that agribusiness developers often bend rules. Discussion Items - Appointments to Oahu Historic Preservation Commission: Resolutions 25-238 (Mahilani Seifer) and 25-237 (Catherine Stevens) were both amended to CD1 with technical corrections and reported out for adoption. Both appointees spoke about their experience and desire to complete rulemaking and educate the public. DPP (Michael Catt) supported both nominees. - Bill 62 (2025) – Bed and Breakfast/Transient Vacation Unit Amendments: The bill corrects inadvertent omissions from Ordinance 25-2, primarily registration requirements. The chair proposed a verbal amendment (CD1) to replace four black-and-white figures with high-resolution color versions from Ordinance 25-2. DPP’s Elizabeth Krieger supported the CD1 and agreed to discuss with the director a separate remedy for the $1,000 re-registration fee trigger for operator changes. The bill was amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading with a public hearing. - Resolution 25-229 – SMA Major Permit (Sea Turtles Estates): For demolition/construction on a 1.36-acre shoreline lot in Malai Kahana. The chair proposed a verbal amendment to remove condition C1 (requiring a revised cultural impact assessment) because SHPD does not accept such assessments. The agent, Mark Howland, confirmed project plans were revised by a new architect without removing the initial stamp; DPP recommended transparency. Resolution amended to CD1 as further amended and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-230 – SMA Major Permit (Sippen): For a new dwelling on a 29,976 sq ft lot in Kahalu. Conditions included floodway permit, flood insurance, and acknowledgment of sea level rise risk. Agent Mark Holland presented. Resolution amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-245 – SMA Major Permit (Remington): For additions and a new dwelling on a 31,480 sq ft lot in Malai Kahana. Agent Mark Holland noted an archaeological inventory survey (AIS) has already started. Resolution amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-246 – SMA Major Permit (AJ Beach LLC): For a new dwelling on a 13,724 sq ft lot in Wailupe. Issues included seawall encroachment into state submerged lands and 3.2 ft sea level rise exposure. Agent Jim Hayes explained BLNR granted a right-of-entry; certified shoreline survey pending. Resolution amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Bill 51 (2025) – Fort Street Mall Special Improvement District Expansion: The bill expands the district to cover more of downtown and renames it Downtown Honolulu SID No. 2. A hand-carried CD2 (OCS 2025-0776) was distributed, adding an exemption for parcels exempt from real property taxes under ROH 810.9B3. Agent Chris Fong (Trade Wind Capital) presented the need for safety and cleanliness. Managing Director Mike For me testified administration supports the bill and will not reduce city services. Bill amended to CD2 and reported out for third reading. - Bill 56 (2025) – SMA Minor Permit Notification (Discussion Only): The bill would require neighborhood board presentations for SMA minor permits. DPP’s Elizabeth Krieger opposed, citing that minors are by definition of no substantial adverse effect, and adding a 60-day board notice would extend the 55-day timeline. She noted DPP can already deny minors and elevate to major permits. Councilmember Wara (introducer) suggested electronic posting of applications as an alternative. Public testimony raised concerns about abuse of minors (e.g., gondola project). No vote; discussion only. - Resolution 25-228 – CUP Minor Permit Notification (Discussion Only): The resolution would direct DPP to amend the LUO to require neighborhood board presentations for all minor CUPs. DPP recommended focusing only on specific uses like agribusiness and agritourism (currently not on the list requiring board notice) rather than across the board. Councilmember Wara indicated openness to narrower amendments. Public testimony highlighted the gondola project as an example of CUP minor abuse. No vote; discussion only. Key Outcomes - Resolutions 25-238 and 25-237: Both amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption (unanimous). - Bill 62 (2025): Amended to CD1 (figure replacements) and reported out for second reading and public hearing (unanimous). Chair noted commitment to pursue a separate remedy for the re-registration fee trigger with DPP. - Resolutions 25-229, 25-230, 25-245, 25-246: All amended to CD1 (with verbal amendment to 25-230 removing condition C1) and reported out for adoption (unanimous). - Bill 51 (2025): Amended to hand-carried CD2 and reported out for third reading (unanimous). - Bill 56 and Resolution 25-228: Discussion only; no action taken. Committee members and administration agreed to explore more targeted notification approaches (e.g., online posting or adding specific uses like agribusiness to CUP notification list). North Shore Neighborhood Board will provide feedback at their October meeting.

The Committee on Budget, chaired by Councilmember Okimoto, convened on Tuesday, September 23, 2025, at 9:03 AM. The meeting covered nine agenda items, including audits, fund transfers, fare adjustments, tax exemptions, and fee waivers. Key discussions centered on the Fire Plans Review Revolving Fund audit, transit fare restructuring, and property tax relief for homeowners and veterans. Public Comments & Testimony - Arnold Wong (Honolulu Fire Commission) expressed support for the fire department and disagreed with the auditor's findings, stating that contract workers are necessary to prevent backlogs in planning and permitting. - Donald Sakamoto supported the audit of the fire fund, calling it fair, and also supported the Transportation Demand Management (TDM) program and the Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization work program. - Brian Mick (Disability and Communication Access Board) opposed Bill 54 CD1 and the proposed CD2, citing concerns about elimination of fare waivers for personal care attendants (PCAs) and insufficient accommodations for disabled riders. - Gregory Masekian (Kakua Council President) expressed concerns about consultant costs for transit projects and the weakening of language in Bill 59, and supported the veteran fee waiver with caution about revenue loss. - Ben Satoshi (Unite Here Local 5) opposed bus fare increases, advocating for public transportation as a public service. - Myung O (Honolulu Board of Realtors) supported Bill 34 (property tax threshold update). - Linda Howe supported the property tax threshold update but urged automatic adjustments to prevent future cycles of steep tax increases. Discussion Items 1. Audit of the Fire Plans Review Revolving Fund (Resolution 25-4) - Auditor Troy Shimasaki presented findings: the fund’s administrative structure is inconsistent with ordinance requirements, lacks transparency, and bypasses council oversight. Expenditures generally complied with law, but 46% of sampled transactions (31 of 67) were not clearly justified as fire prevention activities. The auditor recommended establishing the revolving fund, removing the “appropriated upon receipt” clause, or adding controls and reporting requirements. - Fire Chief Kalani Howe acknowledged areas for improvement but disagreed with some findings, arguing that operational expenses (e.g., solid waste, drinking water) are necessary for fire prevention, and that the fund allows flexibility to respond to urgent needs like wildfire prevention and permit processing. He noted that contract positions are reported quarterly to the council. - Budget Director Andy Kawano confirmed the fund balance is $790,683, and agreed to improve transparency through annual reporting. - Councilmember Waters clarified that the audit found no violations, and the department acted properly within existing rules. 2. Tax Compromise for Eugenia Postnecker (Resolution 25-239) - Director Kawano explained that a widow lost her home exemption and tax credit due to a city recording error from decades ago. The city requested a compromise to restore the credit, resulting in a reduced tax liability of $1,891.02. - Councilmember Waters questioned how to prevent similar errors, and Kawano suggested a permitted interaction group to discuss systemic changes. The resolution was passed unanimously. 3. Transportation Demand Management Program (Resolution 25-258) - DTS Director Roger Morton and Max Calhammer presented the HNL Connect program, funded by a $190,687 local match (20%) for a federal grant. The program aims to reduce single-occupancy vehicle trips through incentives, marketing, and a restricted parking zone. The return on investment is measured in congestion reduction. - Councilmember Waters asked about sustainability; Morton noted that the subsidy for transit is about $350 million annually, with farebox revenue at $42 million. The resolution passed. 4. Vision Zero Safety Planning (Resolution 25-259) - Director Morton and Jermaine Salim described a $160,000 local match for an $800,000 federal planning grant to update crash data, high-injury locations, and lighting needs. The entire contract goes to a single consultant. - Councilmember Waters questioned the consultant cost; Morton confirmed it is planning money. The resolution passed. 5. Transit Fare Restructuring (Bill 54 2025 CD1) - The committee considered two proposed CD2 amendments. Councilmember Dosantos Tam proposed expanding the low-income fare threshold from 30% to 50% of area median income (AMI), which could cost $6-10 million in lost revenue. Director Morton noted the current low-income program is underutilized (only 4,500 certifications out of 110,000 eligible), and expanding eligibility might not improve usage without reducing barriers. - Chair’s CD2 restored the senior rate and limited the director’s authority to set special event fares. The committee adopted the Chair’s CD2 and postponed further action to allow review of Dosantos Tam’s proposal. - Public testimony highlighted concerns about PCA fare waivers, cash surcharges, and the need for better outreach. 6. Industrial Wastewater Surcharge Repeal (Bill 59 2025) - Director Babcock explained the bill is a housekeeping measure to remove references to a surcharge that was never implemented. The city regulates industrial users through a pretreatment permitting program. Councilmember Waters questioned the language change from “shall not” to “may not,” calling it weaker. The bill passed to second reading. 7. Real Property Tax Exemptions Correction (Bill 61 2025) - Director Kawano supported the bill to fix a discrepancy in HCDA rules but requested an amendment to restrict the expanded FAR to renewing taxpayers to avoid a flood of requests. Councilmember Nishimoto agreed to work on the amendment and passed the bill to second reading without it, with the intention to add it later. 8. Residential A Property Tax Threshold Update (Bill 34 2024 CD1) - Director Kawano outlined the three-tier structure: Residential A threshold raised from $1 million to $1.3 million, and TVU threshold from $900,000. The goal is revenue neutrality through rate adjustments at upper tiers. Councilmember Kiaina introduced Bill 63 2025 to provide a dedication option for affordable rental housing. The committee passed Bill 34 to third reading. - Councilmember Waters praised the bill as a long-awaited relief for homeowners. 9. Motor Vehicle Registration Fee Waiver for Veteran Kupuna (Bill 62 2024 CD1) - Director Hashiro reported that the waiver would affect up to 13,849 veterans aged 65+ and result in a maximum revenue loss of $276,980. She requested six months to implement programming changes. Councilmember Toba expressed support. The bill was amended to a CD2 with an effective date of July 1, 2026, and passed. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-4: The committee will meet with BFS and HFD to draft legislation incorporating the auditor’s recommendations, including possibly removing the “appropriated upon receipt” clause. - Resolution 25-239: Approved for adoption (unanimous). - Resolution 25-258: Approved for adoption (unanimous). - Resolution 25-259: Approved for adoption (unanimous). - Bill 54 2025: Amended to CD2 (Chair’s version) and postponed to a future date determined by the chair. - Bill 59 2025: Reported out for second reading and public hearing (unanimous). - Bill 61 2025: Reported out for second reading and public hearing (unanimous), with intention to add an amendment. - Bill 34 2024 CD1: Reported out for passage on third reading (unanimous). - Bill 62 2024 CD1: Amended to CD2 with effective date July 1, 2026, and reported out for second reading (unanimous).

The Honolulu City Council convened at 2:05 PM and adjourned at 3:05 PM on September 4, 2025, to consider a range of resolutions including budget transfers, acceptance of gifts, zoning permits, and policy directives. Discussions centered on climate resiliency fund allocations, affordable housing projects, and police chief selection process. Public Comments & Testimony - Natalie Wasser testified in support of Resolution 25-217 (peer review gift) and raised questions about Resolution 25-209 (reimbursement for workshops), citing a two-year delay and lack of prior discussion. - Robert Santelon and Shelby Billionaire were registered but not present for Resolution 25-208. - Mark Anthony Clemente (Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters) testified in support of Resolution 25-207 (Cove project) and Resolution 25-236 (Lau Lima housing). - Panamantomi III testified in support of Resolution 25-207. - Matt Cares (James Campbell Company) testified in support of Resolution 25-207 on behalf of the applicant. - Mike Golo Jr. (Pride Work Hawaii) testified in support of Resolution 25-222 but urged amendments to include overpoliced populations and transparency on MOUs. - Kikuko Reese and Larry Verray were registered for Resolution 25-205 but not logged on. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-204 CD1 (Climate Resiliency Fund transfers): Councilmember Okimoto introduced an FD1 amendment to add a $175,000 transfer for the Office of Climate Change administrative expenses and clarify allocations for climate adaptation strategies. Councilmember Tupola supported the targeted approach, referencing long-standing drainage issues in her community. DDC Director Hakumelas expressed concerns that $700,000 for Kulao Puni street water quality improvements is insufficient, citing a prior $3 million estimate and acceptance issues. Director Ben Sullivan (Resiliency) stated intent to pursue projects aggressively, noting funds roll back if not used. Councilmember Kia Aina emphasized mangrove removal funds are supplemental to DLNR efforts. Councilmember Tolba voted no, preferring to prioritize cesspool upgrades. - Resolution 25-233 (Vehicle purchase for DTS): Councilmember Okimoto questioned if the purchase was included in the FY26 budget; DTS representative Tony Valdez confirmed it was. Resolution adopted. - Resolution 25-185 CD1 (Relocation program for city-funded housing): Councilmember Tupola urged development of a program and a dedicated position. Councilmember Okimoto registered a no vote. Adopted. - Resolution 25-207 CD1 (SMA permit for Cove project in Ko Olina): Councilmember Tupola expressed support, acknowledging community concerns about noise, parking, and traffic, and noted developer commitments for bathrooms, parking, and construction impact fees. Roll call: 9 ayes. Adopted. - Resolution 25-236 CD1 (Lau Lima affordable housing exemptions): Councilmember Tupola supported, noting community input and need for traffic improvements. Councilmember Kia Aina raised concerns about double dipping under the unilateral agreement and questioned the applicability of Act 294 constraints. Adopted with 9 ayes (Councilmember Cordero had reservations). - Resolution 25-222 CD1 (Police chief selection process): Councilmember Tupola highlighted survey results from rank-and-file officers and civilian employees, urging transparency and inclusion. Testifier Mike Golo Jr. called for broader transparency across all HPD operations. Adopted. - Resolution 25-109 CD1 (Audit of CORE/EMS): Councilmember Tupola discussed the need to align with proven crisis response models like CAHOOTS in Oregon. Adopted. Key Outcomes - Adopted resolutions: 25-204 CD1 as amended (Councilmember Tolba voted no on amendment and final passage); 25-208; 25-217; 25-231; 25-233; 25-185 CD1 (Councilmember Okimoto voted no); 25-205; 25-211 through 25-216, 25-220, 25-225; 25-209; 25-109 CD1; 25-242; 25-243; 25-207 CD1 (9 ayes); 25-236 CD1 (9 ayes, Councilmember Cordero reservations); 25-222 CD1; 25-234; 25-232; balance of committee reports (settlements); new business items 25-235, 25-247, 25-248, 25-249. - Laid over: Resolution 25-223 (eminent domain for wastewater pump stations) ordered published. - Next meeting: Adjourned until Wednesday, October 1, 2025, at 10:00 AM.

The Honolulu City Council held a regular meeting on September 3, 2025, beginning at approximately 9:00 AM and continuing into the afternoon with a recess at 2:00 PM. The meeting included a message of aloha, procedural announcements, approval of minutes, and action on numerous resolutions and bills covering appointments, tax policy, transit fares, housing, and downtown revitalization. Key decisions included the referral of Kevin Alger's nomination for housing director, passage of first reading for several bills, second reading for transit fare increases and a downtown business improvement district, and third reading for property tax exemptions. Public Comments & Testimony - Message of Aloha: Mikiala Lidstone, introduced by Councilmember Tupola, spoke about the importance of caring for sacred sites like Pu‘u Kapole as an act of aloha and stewardship, highlighting challenges and community dedication. - On Kevin Alger Nomination (Resolution 25-206): Perry Arrow-Smith (Housing Hawaii’s Future) supported Alger, citing his outreach and vision. Kai Lee Swan and Donald Sakamoto also voiced support, with Sakamoto emphasizing housing for the disabled. Pikachu Shelby Billionaire testified with reservations, urging better council communication. - On Bill 56 (SMA minors): Raquel Achu (North Shore Neighborhood Board) testified that small SMA applications are often used to avoid major review, undermining environmental and cultural review. - On Bill 60 (HART planning): Andrew Pereira (Pacific Resource Partnership) supported, saying planning prevents brain drain. Donald Sakamoto opposed, citing ADA access issues. Kylie Swan requested more accessible bathrooms on Skyline. - On Bill 62 (STR corrections): Multiple testifiers including Tara Gregory and Jeanette Fukuzawa supported with requests to protect small owner-occupiers. Ed Jones (Costro) requested narrow tailoring. - On Bill 54 (transit fares): Brian Mick (Disability and Communication Access Board), Kaili Swan, and Don Sakamoto opposed due to impacts on personal care attendants and Medicare cardholders, and lack of smartphone loading. - On Bill 51 (Downtown BID): Supporters included Sandra Pohl (Downtown Arts Center), Ed Keripsky (Fort Street Mall BID), and Robbie Kelly (Avalon Development). Opponents included Kevin Crummy (Douglas Emmett) who argued the current BID hasn't proven effective and that the process was rushed. Several testifiers urged inclusion of Chinatown. Discussion Items - Kevin Alger Nomination (Resolution 25-206): Councilmembers Cordero, Tupola, Okimoto, and Kia Aina expressed concerns about lack of communication, lack of a detailed plan, and a combative communication style. Alger defended his direct approach, cited the strategic plan, and noted progress on RFQs and financing. The nomination was referred to committee; Councilmember Cordero stated she would vote no. - First Reading Bills (56-62): Bills 56 (SMA), 57 (dumpsters), 58 (property tax exemption), 59 (sewer charges), 60 (HART), 61 (real property tax), 62 (STR amendments) passed without objection. Councilmember Kia Aina expressed concerns about Bill 56 burdening homeowners; Councilmember Wire noted reservations on Bills 58 and 53. - Bill 34 CD1 (Real property tax tiers): Created three-tier Residential A and TVU tax brackets. Supporters (including Councilmember Kia Aina) said it provides relief for modest homes caught in high valuations. Councilmember Dos Santos Tam requested more data on thresholds and inflation adjustment. - Bill 54 CD1 (Public transit fares): Proposed fare increases for bus and rail. Councilmembers Cordero, Dos Santos Tam, Tolba, and Wire expressed opposition or strong concerns about burden on youth, seniors, and disabled. Dos Santos Tam noted the increase is only 1.5% of subsidy but affects vulnerable riders. Passed second reading with objections from Dos Santos Tam and Tolba, and reservations from Cordero, Waters, and Wire. - Bill 51 CD1 (Downtown Business Improvement District): Expanded Fort Street Mall BID to cover a larger downtown area. Extensive testimony. Councilmember Kia Aina clarified the process was not rushed and announced a September 23 committee hearing. Passed second reading 9-0. - Bill 49 and 50 (Property tax exemptions for seniors): Increased exemptions for homeowners 65+. Concerns about $5.6M and $5M revenue losses. Passed third reading despite reservations from Tolba and Wire on Bill 49, and Tolba and Wire on Bill 50. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved without objection. - Resolutions 25-224 and 25-218 adopted (Cynthia L. McMillan reappointed to Rate Commission; Larry Veray reappointed to Neighborhood Board Commission). - Resolution 25-206 (Kevin Alger nomination) referred to committee. - Resolutions 25-237, 25-238, 25-241 referred to committees (Historic Preservation Commission appointments and Parks Board appointment). - First reading bills (56-62) passed. - Second reading bills passed: Bill 34 CD1 (real property tax tiers), Bill 62 CD1 (motor vehicle registration), Bill 54 CD1 (transit fares – with objections/reservations), Bill 20 (first-time homebuyer loan assistance), Bill 39 (affordable rental housing), Bill 52 (improvement districts), Bill 51 CD1 (Downtown BID – 9-0), Bill 5 CD1 (animal recovery – 9-0). - Third reading bills passed: Bill 41 CD1 (permit fees – 9-0), Bill 49 (senior property tax exemption – passed with reservations), Bill 50 (increased exemption – passed with reservations), Bill 33 CD2 (administrative enforcement – 9-0). - Referred items: Permitted interaction group report on tax increment financing (Council Communication 221) deferred to the next scheduled council meeting on October 1, 2025, per HRS 92-2.5B1.

On September 3, 2025, the Honolulu City Council convened to present honorary certificates recognizing outstanding individuals, youth sports teams, and community programs for their achievements and contributions. The meeting featured multiple presentations honoring athletic excellence, educational leadership, and community service. Manoa Ten and Under All-Star Baseball Team - Councilmember Nishimoto presented a certificate to the Manoa 10U All-Star Baseball team for winning the 2025 Hawaii State Championship and the 2025 Pacific Southwest Regional Championship, representing Hawaii at the Cal Ripken World Series. Hawaii Kai Elite Baseball Team - Council Chair Waters presented a certificate to the Hawaii Kai Elite Baseball team for capturing the 10U Cal Ripken World Series Championship in August 2025. The team won the championship game 10-0, allowing only 4 runs in 8 games while scoring 69 runs. The team was founded in 2023 and has won multiple regional and tournament championships. Whissawahoo 12U Boys Soccer Team - Councilmember Dos Santos Temp presented a certificate to the Whissawahoo 12U boys soccer team (Whissawahoo Hammers) for winning the 2025 National AYSO Games Championship in their division. The competition featured 348 teams and 4,800 players. The team went undefeated in five pool play games and won the semifinal and final. Team Oahu Junior Life Guards - Councilmembers Wire and Tolpa presented a certificate to Team Oahu Junior Life Guards for winning the overall championship at the 2025 Junior Life Guard State Championships held at Kaanapali Beach, Maui. The team earned 203 total points, the highest score ever recorded in the championship's history, competing in high surf conditions. Dr. Genevieve Le Aken - Councilmember Tupolo presented a solo honorary certificate to Dr. Genevieve Le Aken for her extraordinary service as an educator, leader, and visionary in the Wainae Coast community. She established Wainae High School's first certified organic farm, co-founded the Ho'ma Huaka Foundation and Lei Kaulu internship program, and helped create higher education pathways. She served for over 30 years at Wainae High School. Mililani High School Girls Varsity Softball Team - Councilmember Okimoto presented a certificate to the Mililani High School Girls Varsity Softball Team for winning the 2025 Data House HHSAA Division One Championship, their second consecutive state title. They defeated Mariano 10-7 in the championship game on May 9, 2025, and earlier beat Punahou 19-5 after overcoming a five-run deficit with home runs from five players. The team also won the OIA division one crown. Hawaii Job Corps - Councilmember Kia Aina presented a certificate to the Hawaii Job Corps Center in Waimanalo for its commitment to youth education, vocational training, and workforce development. Established in 1966 at Coco Head and relocated in 1995, the center serves over 200 students on Oahu and 128 on Maui. The program ranks in the top five percent nationally for performance and job placement. Honolulu Recreational Community Gardening Program - Councilmembers Kia Aina, Nishimoto, Tupola, and Chair Waters presented a certificate to the Honolulu Recreational Community Gardening Program on its 50th anniversary. The program began in 1975 under Mayor Frank Fasi and now operates 11 active community gardens across Oahu with more than 2,000 participants. It is recognized as critical public infrastructure, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic.