Public Meetings - Honolulu, Hawaii

The meeting was called to order at 1:05 p.m. on August 22, 2025 (the council's specified date, though the transcript recorded a date of August 21). Chair Maho presided. The committee considered one resolution on flood monitoring, one resolution on the police chief selection process, and received an informational briefing from the Honolulu Police Department on media relations. Councilmembers present included Anjotopola (likely Tupola), Okimoto, Nishimoto, Kia Aina, Wire, and Kudero. Discussion Items Resolution 25-234: Flood Inundation Zone Monitoring Devices - Deputy Director Jennifer Walter of the Department of Emergency Management expressed support for additional monitoring capability, noting the importance of broad language to allow use of traffic cameras with sensors or AI. She mentioned potential grant funding for AI hazard detection in the next year. Councilmember Wire, the sponsor, explained the resolution stemmed from the recent tsunami warning and the community's desire for real-time situational awareness. The resolution passed without objection. Resolution 25-22: Police Chief Selection Process - Lori Foster, Vice Chair of the Police Commission, reported on the commission's efforts to improve the selection process, including consulting five national search firms and deciding to hire a search firm. She outlined a timeline: RFP release within a week, contract by November, and a comprehensive discovery/engagement phase ending around March 2026. Foster noted the commission seeks a chief who combines strong leadership with collaboration and communication. - Councilmember Tupola offered a verbal amendment to add "and civilian employees" to the title and throughout the resolution, seconded and adopted unanimously. The amended resolution (CD1) was reported out for adoption. Informational Briefing: HPD Media Relations and Public Access - Acting Chief Roddy Vadik presented HPD's digital initiatives, including a new unified media landing page (expected by end of August), a 24-hour incident log, and a CAD text alert system for media (modeled after HFD). He emphasized the department's commitment to transparency while balancing officer safety and privacy. - Councilmembers discussed the need for written internal communications, the role of new Communications Director Claudette Springer, and ongoing coordination with media outlets. Chief Vadik noted a media roundtable scheduled for August 26, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony On Resolution 25-22: - Nicholas Schaupak (SHOPO State Board Treasurer, 17-year HPD veteran) expressed strong support, saying the resolution gives frontline officers a real voice for the first time. He cited a member survey showing officers want to be heard. - Jonathan Fry (SHOPO Honolulu Chapter Chair, 15-year HPD veteran) urged passage, criticizing the prior process for lacking transparency and meaningful input. He stated the resolution would define good leadership, require thorough vetting, and integrate the staffing and retention task force findings. - Austin Salcido (remote) testified in support, emphasizing the need for collaboration between the chief, union, and community, and warning against misuse of authority. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-234 was reported out for adoption unanimously. - Resolution 25-22 was amended to include civilian employees (CD1) and reported out for adoption unanimously. - Informational briefing was accepted; HPD committed to sharing the media roundtable outcomes and continuing to work with the council and media. - Councilmember Kia Aina voiced disappointment that the DEM Director did not attend a requested briefing on tsunami evacuation lessons learned, urging better responsiveness.

This informational briefing before the Honolulu City Council’s Committee on Zoning and Planning provided an update on the Clean Water and Natural Lands (CWNL) Fund program. Presentations were made by Catherine Tatchner, Deputy Director of the Department of Housing and Land Management (DHLM), and Olu Campbell, President and CEO of the Hawaii Land Trust (HLT). The briefing covered the program’s history, current portfolio, financial status, application process, stewardship efforts, and challenges. Council members raised questions about equitable distribution, the due diligence sequence, and process improvements. Public Comments & Testimony - Elizabeth Riley (Livable Maunalua): Expressed strong appreciation for the CWNL Fund, noting that without it her community would not have been able to protect nearly 600 acres of important land. She highlighted the effective partnership with DHLM on the Pyko Ridge transaction and commended the department’s thorough preparation while awaiting land court action. She offered to serve as a resource for other community organizations. - Angela Melody Young: Unable to be heard due to technical issues; no testimony was captured. - No other in-person or online testifiers were present at the time of public comment (two online participants were identified, but only one was heard). Discussion Items - Program Overview and History (Catherine Tatchner): - CWNL Fund created by voter charter amendment in 2006, program started in 2007, first acquisition in 2010. - In 2016, voters approved an advisory commission; in 2022, a stewardship fund was added for operations and management of acquired lands. - The fund can be used for agriculture, open space, cultural/historic sites, watershed land, coastal areas, etc. - Application process: landowner/applicant submits to DHLM, initial review, qualification, advisory commission evaluation, council funding approval, then negotiation and closing (which can take years). - A seven-member volunteer advisory commission is appointed (3 by mayor, 3 by council, 1 by majority vote). - Portfolio and Financial Status (Kevin Auger, DHLM Director Designate): - From 2010–2020: 12 transactions, $35 million, 1,340 acres protected (avg. 1 transaction/year, 112 acres, $3M). - DHLM assumed responsibility July 2023; there were 5 pending transactions (2019–2022) totaling $14M and 196 acres. - Since July 2023, DHLM originated 2 new transactions: 172 acres, $16.7M (avg. 1/year, 80 acres, $8.4M). - Current fund balance: $35 million. Annual revenue from 0.5% of real property tax: $8–9M. - CIP balances: FY25 $25M, FY26 $29M. Total availability after pending projects: $37M. - Program Improvements and Stewardship (Catherine Tatchner): - Prior to Blangiardi administration, no formal CWNL program staff or stewardship; now a conservation office has been created. - Hired first program managers; instituted annual monitoring of all 12 previously acquired sites. - Stewardship funding was approved by voters in 2022; new projects include fencing, signage, and training at Kahuku Golf Course for Uokani shorebirds. - Streamlined application process: replaced a 9-page form with a simple inquiry form (QR code provided). Since 2023, received over 20 inquiries and 2 formal applications; pre-acquisition studies can be funded by the program. - Upcoming closures: Pyko Ridge, Palawai, Makalii (Monawili area). New application expected from Puhunua Owailupe later in August. - Olu Campbell (Hawaii Land Trust): - Emphasized the scarcity of land acquisition programs: only a few at county, state, and federal levels; private philanthropy is limited. - CWNL Fund is essential for large landscape-scale projects on Oahu. - Challenges: projects require more than acquisition funding (staff capacity, due diligence, closing costs); limited number of organizations with dedicated transactional staff; need for quick capital to meet landowner timelines; flexibility for complex multi-year projects. - Stewardship is a perpetual responsibility; the stewardship component of the fund is critical but should be balanced with acquisition needs. - Suggested opportunities: using contracts instead of grants, collaborative capacity strategies (e.g., pilot project with city for contract stewardship monitoring), and expanding fund purposes to include fire mitigation and climate adaptation. - Councilmember Questions and Comments: - Chair Kia Aina noted the geographic concentration of projects in districts of Councilmembers Waters and herself, and asked about efforts to engage underserved communities on the Waianae Coast and elsewhere. Olu Campbell responded that HLT has worked with groups like Mao Farms and Cahumana Farms in Waianae, but land availability and landowner willingness are key factors. - Councilmember Cordero asked about advice for organizations just starting. Olu Campbell encouraged early conversations with HLT, case-by-case approach. - Councilmember Tupola expressed frustration that her district (west side) had no dots on the map despite repeated outreach to DHLM about specific projects (e.g., Eton family in Eva, Makaha Heyao). She asked for clarification on where the process gets stuck. Deputy Tatchner suggested that inquiries should be submitted via the new online form and committed to following up. - Councilmember Waters raised a procedural concern: the current practice of conducting due diligence after council approval does not match the charter’s sequence (Section 9-204), which she reads as requiring due diligence before the advisory commission and council approval. She argued that this leads to delays (sometimes years) and asks for a “blank check.” She suggested an ordinance to require deals to be fully packaged before coming to council. Director Auger responded that DHLM has only had jurisdiction for two years and that issues like land court delays are outside their control; he argued that doing full due diligence up front would be costly and could chill conservation transactions. Chair Kia Aina noted that the Charter Commission is accepting comments on such issues. Key Outcomes - No formal votes or resolutions were taken; the session was an informational briefing. - Chair Kia Aina directed DHLM to meet individually with council members to help disseminate program information to constituents. - Councilmember Waters indicated intent to work on an ordinance to align the due diligence process with her interpretation of the charter (due diligence before council approval). - The committee acknowledged the need for better geographic equity and encouraged outreach to underserved communities. - The meeting was adjourned at approximately 12:30 p.m. (note: the transcript ends with adjournment).

The Committee on Zoning and Planning met on August 22, 2025, at 9:01 a.m. to consider four agenda items: Bill 33 (administrative enforcement of land use violations), Bill 51 (Fort Street Mall Special Improvement District), Resolution 25-207 (Special Management Area permit for the Cove redevelopment), and Resolution 25-236 (Lau Lima Affordable Rental Housing project). The meeting was chaired by Councilmember Kiaaina, with Vice Chair Waters and members Topola, Dos Santos Tam, Cordero, and Okimoto present. Public Comments & Testimony - Bill 33 (CD2): No public testimony was offered in person or remotely. - Bill 51 (CD1): Seven testifiers spoke in support. Warren Wong (property manager, Caris organization, and current Fort Street Mall SID director) supported expanding the district to improve safety, cleanliness, and economic vitality. Ed Karipsky (executive director, Fort Street Mall BID) endorsed the bill for residential transition. Jason Regal (general manager, Executive Center) cited benefits for safety and cleanliness. Jamie Barboza (resident) described safety concerns and supported the bill. Mark Anthony Clemente (Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters) strongly supported. Ben Duke Cheetra (Avalon Group) noted the assessment would be fully borne by commercial property owners with no cost to residents and a five-year term. Perry Arassmith (director of policy, Housing Hawaii East Future) supported for activating downtown. Additional remote testimony: Kendrick Chang (small landowner) supported, noting expansion would lower his fee. Tony Longcamp (business owner, Yifang Fruit Tea) supported, citing increased foot traffic. Angela Young (via CARES) expressed support but questioned whether businesses would be forced to pay; she attended a community event and found goals achievable. - Resolution 25-207 (Cove SMA Permit): Five testifiers supported. Peter Ganabon (business manager, Laborers' Union Local 368) cited 870 construction jobs and 500 permanent jobs. Justin Tanoy (executive director, Operating Engineers) emphasized local jobs and economic impact. Trisha Taketa (carpenter) highlighted 800+ construction jobs. Mark Anthony Clemente (carpenters) reiterated jobs and $150 million in economic activity. Pane Meatoga (deputy political director, Operating Engineers Local 3) spoke of bringing locals back to Ko Olina and noted landowner’s transition support for current employees. Anna Tuyasu Sopo (operating engineers) supported, noting 70% of members live on the West Side. Remote testimony: Angela Young (via CARES) supported as long as SMA guidelines are followed. - Resolution 25-236 (Lau Lima Affordable Housing): Three testifiers supported. Peter Ganabon (Laborers' Union) noted 750 units address housing shortage for workers. Mark Anthony Clemente (carpenters) supported. Anna Tuyasu Sopo (operating engineers) supported, noting union jobs will help local workers afford to stay. Remote testimony: Angela Young (via CARES) questioned developer rationale for higher AMI rents but supported the project. Discussion Items - Bill 33 (CD2) – Administrative Enforcement of LUO Violations: Chair Kiaaina introduced the CD2 version (OCS 2025-676) which deletes a requirement that the notice of violation include corrective actions and adds conforming amendments. Director of Planning and Permitting Don Takiuchi Apuna proposed a verbal amendment to add “or upon receipt of the notice of violation” to allow correction upon physical notice. No objections. The bill was amended to CD2 and recommended for third reading without opposition. - Bill 51 (CD1) – Fort Street Mall Special Improvement District 2: Councilmember Dos Santos Tam explained the CD1 included community comments. Chris Fong (senior investment associate, Tradewin Capital) presented updates: two town halls held (August 12 and 14) with 25–40 attendees; no opposition was raised. He noted the timeline for implementation by July 2026 tax year. Councilmember Okimoto asked about attendance and demographics; Fong said a mix of businesses and residents. Councilmember Waters asked about increasing board size from 17 to 20 and including a first-year budget; Fong and Tam considered it reasonable. Waters also asked about bylaws and exempt parcels; Fong committed to follow-up. Managing Director Michael Formby stated the city supports the community-driven initiative and that Budget and Fiscal Services can collect assessments. The average assessment rate is $0.75 per $1,000 of property value, down from $0.95 for current members. The bill was amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading and public hearing. - Resolution 25-207 (CD1) – Cove SMA Major Permit (Paradise Cove Redevelopment): Chair Kiaaina described the project: demolition of 23 buildings, retention of two chapels, construction of 11 buildings and four structures including an amphitheater, restaurants, retail, and cultural spaces. The hand-carried CD1 (OCS 2025-661) deletes conditions F1, F2, F4 from the posted CD1, replacing them with requirements for an archaeological monitoring plan and stop-work protocols. Matt Cares (James Campbell Company) presented: the project aims to create a Hawaiian gathering place with 500+ permanent jobs, $2 million in annual tax revenue, 85% open space, improved beach access, and free parking. Councilmember Topola inquired about outreach to Kailani (six meetings), Ko Olina Community Association (ongoing contribution), and job transition for current 210 employees (commitment to assist). Councilmember Okimoto asked about beach access and parking; Cares confirmed maintaining the public easement and 15 free stalls. Councilmember Waters asked about the comfort station (restrooms with showers). Director Takiuchi Apuna supported the CD1. The resolution was amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-236 (CD1) – Lau Lima Affordable Rental Housing Project: Chair Kiaaina explained the project is 750 affordable rental units (250 at 60% AMI, 500 at 120% AMI) on 17.3 acres in Kapolei West. She noted the controversy over Act 294 (2025) which limits council’s ability to modify exemptions, and that the hand-carried CD1 (OCS 2025-666) deletes a waiver of park dedication fees (exemption 12). Kip Shepherd (CEO, Lau Lima Affordable Housing) presented: the project is the first phase of a larger 2,370-unit master plan, will use union labor, and has secured $97 million in private equity. Councilmember Waters questioned rents: at 120% AMI, a three-bedroom could be up to $3,900; Shepherd acknowledged market rates are lower (90–105% AMI). Councilmember Topola noted the parcel’s lack of infrastructure and history of failed development, and offered to help apply for DERF grants to lower costs. Councilmember Dos Santos Tam asked about market rents; Jackson Shepherd (president) stated the project will charge 90–95% of AMI to lease up. Director of HHFDC Demon Akami Minakami explained that rents include utilities and are set by HUD; he confirmed the project received LIHTEC financing for the 70-unit senior phase (30–60% AMI). Councilmember Waters asked DPP and HHFDC about the 50% affordability requirement; both clarified that the 750 units are a separate increment from the larger master plan, and that the project meets the requirement since all units are affordable. Councilmember Cordero expressed reservations. The resolution was amended to CD1 and reported out for adoption with Councilmember Cordero’s reservations noted. Key Outcomes - Bill 33 (CD2) – Amended to CD2 with a verbal amendment; reported out for passage on third reading. - Bill 51 (CD1) – Amended to CD1; reported out for second reading and scheduling of a public hearing. - Resolution 25-207 (CD1) – Amended to CD1; reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-236 (CD1) – Amended to CD1 deleting exemption 12; reported out for adoption with Councilmember Cordero’s reservations.

The committee met on August 21, 2025, to consider four agenda items: the reappointment of Cynthia L. McMillan to the Rate Commission, acceptance of a gift from the Hawaii Council of Engineering Societies, acquisition of wastewater pump stations by eminent domain, and a bill to expand stream maintenance definitions. All items were advanced with unanimous support. Public Comments & Testimony - Angela Young testified via videoconference in support of Bill 52, stating it would help clean up streams and activate environmental restoration. No other public testimony was offered on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-224 – Reappointment of Cynthia L. McMillan to the Rate Commission: McMillan described her experience on the commission, noting the challenge of balancing public testimony with the city's fiscal needs. She highlighted that some riders would pay more for cleaner, safer bus stops and that the low-income relief process is too cumbersome. Councilmembers DeSantos Tam, Okimoto, and Wire questioned her on fare policies, the Fairbox recovery ratio, youth fares, and the demographic of riders. McMillan expressed a desire for greater public participation. The resolution was reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-209 – Acceptance of Gift from Hawaii Council of Engineering Societies: The resolution accepts $57,268.70 to reimburse the city for registration fees from the 2023 stormwater quality workshops. No questions or testimony. Reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-223 – Acquisition of Wastewater Pump Stations by Eminent Domain: Aaron Sakamoto of the Department of Design and Construction explained that the city has operated two pump stations in Aliamanu since the 1950s but never acquired fee ownership. The current owner is defunct, necessitating eminent domain. The parcels include a roadway. Councilmember DeSantos Tam asked about potential impacts on neighbors; none are anticipated. No testimony. The resolution was reported out to be laid over and published. - Bill 52 (2025) – Stream Maintenance: Adding Endorheic Lakes: Introduced by Chair Cordero, the bill adds endorheic lakes (e.g., Salt Lake, Enchanted Lakes) to the definition of streams for maintenance enforcement. Deputy Director Warren Mamizuka of the Department of Facility Maintenance expressed support. Councilmember Okimoto noted there are about three such lakes on Oahu, mostly privately owned. Chair Cordero inquired about the enforcement process. Angela Young testified in support. The bill was reported out for second reading and public hearing. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-224 (McMillan reappointment) reported out for adoption (unanimous). - Resolution 25-209 (gift acceptance) reported out for adoption (unanimous). - Resolution 25-223 (eminent domain acquisition) reported out to be laid over and published for subsequent adoption (unanimous). - Bill 52 (2025) reported out for passage on second reading and scheduling of a public hearing (unanimous).

The Committee on International and Legal Affairs met remotely on August 20, 2025, to deliberate on several agenda items including resolutions, a bill, and executive session matters. The meeting addressed the reappointment of a neighborhood board member, an audit of the CORE program, and proposed legislation on intergovernmental agreements. Consent Calendar - Resolution 25-218: Reported out for adoption without objection. The resolution concerns the reappointment of Larry Vere to the Pearl City Neighborhood Board. Councilmembers expressed strong support for Mr. Vere, citing his community advocacy and previous service. Managing Director Mike Formby noted Mr. Vere was absent due to illness. Public Comments & Testimony - Resolution 25-109 (CORE Audit): Liam Ching, representing the Reimagining Public Safety in Hawaii Coalition, testified in support of the audit but warned it should not be used to eliminate or reduce funding for CORE. He urged that the audit serve strictly to improve the program and align it with proven models like CAHOOTS. Angela Melody Young testified in support of CORE's work, emphasizing partnerships with Christian networks and state-level coordination. - Executive Session – 525 Avocado Street: Eric Bartolome, owner of Maverick Muay Thai Academy located adjacent to the property proposed for demolition, testified in support of the demolition. He described ongoing safety issues including drug use, homeless activity, and violence affecting his business and students. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-109: Chair Nishimoto presented a proposed CD1 with amendments, submitted by Councilmember Tupola. Managing Director Formby expressed support after the removal of the 5th and 6th whereas clauses, which the administration had concerns about. City Auditor Troy Shimasaki confirmed the office could complete the audit as prescribed. Councilmember Tupola moved to amend the CD1 by removing the 5th and 6th whereas clauses; the motion passed without objection. The amended CD1 was then adopted. - Bill 47: Managing Director Formby testified in strong opposition, stating the bill would impose a 15-day hold on intergovernmental agreements (IGAs) valued at $30 million or less, burdening daily operations. He noted that many IGAs are oral and later memorialized, and that voiding agreements not approved by council would hinder emergency actions. Councilmember Okamoto questioned the scope and suggested limiting to federal agreements, but Formby argued that would still cover many routine actions. Councilmember Kobayashi expressed support for notification but acknowledged concerns about flexibility. Councilmember Tupola opposed the bill, emphasizing the need for rapid municipal responses. Chair Nishimoto recommended deferral to work with the author and administration. The bill was deferred to a date and time to be determined by the chair. Key Outcomes - Resolution 25-218: Approved for adoption with no objections. - Resolution 25-109: Adopted as amended (CD1 with removal of 5th and 6th whereas clauses). - Bill 47: Deferred for further discussion. - Executive Session: The committee convened into a closed meeting to discuss legal matters (Brune, Kramer, Mao, Winona Lee claim, Ally Financial claim, and demolition at 525 Avocado Street), with no objections.

The Committee on Housing, Homelessness and Parks (HH&P) of the Honolulu City Council met on August 20, 2025, at 2:31 p.m. under Chair Tupola. The agenda included numerous gift acceptances for park benches, resolutions on relocation assistance and down payment loan programs, bills on fire safety and affordable housing zoning, and informational briefings on the Maili wildfire response and the interim dirt track at Kaliloa Park. Consent Calendar The committee unanimously approved the following routine resolutions reporting them out for adoption: - Resolution 25-205: Rename Pearl City District Park Pool to Ken Suenaga Pearl City District Park Pool. - Resolution 25-211: Accept a traditional bench donation (valued at $2,521.67) from Bruce Tartileschi for Makapu Beach Park. - Resolution 25-212: Accept a bench donation (valued at $2,849.51) from Linda Clark for Leahi Beach Park. - Resolution 25-213: Accept a bench donation (valued at $3,669.51) from Alina Gryger Bell for Sandy Beach Park, as amended by CD1. - Resolution 25-214: Accept a bench donation (valued at $3,119.51) from Marie Mirror (Girl Scout Troop 873) for Makalai Beach Park. - Resolution 25-215: Accept a bench donation (valued at $2,621.67) from Michael Rollins for Sandy Beach Park. - Resolution 25-216: Accept a bench donation (valued at $2,621.67) from William Byrley for Kapiolani Regional Park, as amended by CD1. - Resolution 25-220: Accept a bench donation (valued at $2,819.51) from Martin Esposito for Kailua Beach Park. - Resolution 25-225: Accept a cash gift of $3,000 from Friends of Honolulu Parks and Recreation for DPR programs and events. Public Comments & Testimony - Bill 20 (Down Payment Loan Assistance Fund): Suzanne Young of the Honolulu Board of Realtors testified in strong support, stating down payment assistance is a critical barrier to homeownership. - Bill 39 (Fire Safety for Affordable Housing): Gina Thielen testified in support, noting the department’s work with stakeholders. - Bill 53 (Affordable Rental Housing Requirements): A large number of testifiers were heard. In opposition: Gina Thielen (developer, stating Bill 53 would kill Bill 7 projects); Justin Manina (neighborhood board treasurer, concerned about parking costs); Matt Pearlberg (Holomua Collaborative, citing survey that 70% of local workers may leave); Michael Munikata (Ulupono Initiative, noting parking costs of $22,500-$42,000 per space); Roseanne Freitas (BIA Hawaii, stating it adds costs); Susan Lee (Hawaii Appleseed, citing $68,000 per parking stall and a 25,000-unit housing shortage). In support: Michelle Luke (arguing Bill 7 fails community); Ann Smoke (stressing need for community oversight and parking); Claire Santos (Punchbowl resident, requesting special district protections and neighborhood assessments). - Maili Wildfire Briefing: Representative Maroca highlighted unsung heroes from the community. Angelita requested information on financial assistance and canine accelerant detection. Representative Kila asked about coordination on emergency access routes. - Kaliloa Park Dirt Track Briefing: Representative Maroca spoke in favor as a family sport. John Rogers (Eva Neighborhood Board) expressed concerns about lack of an operational plan. Daniel Benz (Electric Vehicles Auto Sport Association) supported. Dr. Kione Dudley (neighborhood board member) opposed, stating the Eva board voted against it and that the location is inappropriate. Discussion Items Resolution 25-185 (Relocation Assistance Program): Director Kevin Auger (Housing and Land Management) generally supported but suggested the program be placed in his department. Councilmember Wire moved to strike the last whereas clause and modify the second be it further resolved to allow the mayor to choose the department. The amendment was seconded by Councilmember Cordero and adopted. Bill 20 (Down Payment Loan Assistance Revolving Fund): Deputy Director Edward Los Banos (Community Services) noted existing federal programs serving up to 80% AMI and that HFDC plans a $30 million program launching November 2025 reaching up to 120% AMI. Gavin Thornton (Housing Policy Director) requested deferral, arguing the bill would not create new homes and may duplicate efforts. Chair Tupola and Councilmember Cordero questioned the department's written comments and suggested using existing funds. The chair recommended reporting the bill for second reading and referral to the Budget Committee for further consideration between hearings. Bill 39 (Fire Safety for Affordable Housing): Deputy Director Brian Gallagher (Planning and Permitting) requested a minor language change regarding combustible piping and noted future working group sessions to improve the affordable rental program. The chair recommended reporting the bill as originally introduced for second reading, allowing further refinements in a future CD. Bill 53 (Affordable Rental Housing Amendments): Gavin Thornton opposed the bill, stating it would roll back key provisions of Bill 7 (2019) that streamlined approvals and eliminated parking mandates, effectively halting development. Department of Planning and Permitting Director noted that to date 58 total projects have been proposed under Bill 7, with 15 permits issued and 4 certificates of occupancy. Chair Tupola suggested holding the bill to work on a comprehensive CD addressing community concerns (neighborhood board involvement, resident managers, parking solutions) while preserving the program’s intent. The committee held Bill 53. Maili Wildfire Response and Recovery (Informational Briefing): Presentations from DEM Director Collins, HFD Chief Howe, HPD Captain Han, Hawaiian Electric, DOE, and Hawaii Wildfire Management Organization. The briefing covered the July 6, 2025 fire (55 acres, one fatality, two residential structures destroyed, 34 units deployed). Improvements identified: 24/7 DEM watch office, streamlined alerting, use of drones, improved community recovery support. The chair deferred detailed questions for written responses due to an active incident. Kaliloa Park Lands – Interim Dirt Track (Informational Briefing): DPR presented the master plan process for the 400-acre former Navy property, funded for FY26, including environmental assessment and community advisory group. The National Park Service approved interim use of Lot 13060 (23 acres) for a temporary dirt motorsports facility for up to 4 years. Lee Cobian (Oahu Motorsports Association) described the plan, noting noise levels comparable to the adjacent helicopter base. The chair emphasized the need for a written operational plan and community outreach on hours and management. Key Outcomes - All consent items (Resolutions 25-205 through 25-225) were unanimously reported out for adoption. - Resolution 25-185 was amended by verbal amendment (striking last whereas and modifying placement language) and reported out as CD1 for adoption. - Bill 20 was reported out for second reading and referred to the Budget Committee; further amendments to be developed. - Bill 39 was reported out for second reading as originally introduced; department to refine language for a future CD. - Bill 53 was held in committee; Chair Tupola will work with Councilmember Nishimoto on a CD addressing community input, neighborhood board involvement, resident managers, and parking solutions. - The Maili Wildfire briefing concluded with a commitment to provide written answers to outstanding questions; the committee acknowledged the community’s role and ongoing improvement efforts. - The Kaliloa Park interim dirt track briefing concluded; DPR will require the user group to present a detailed operational plan and conduct community outreach before proceeding.

On August 20, 2025, the Committee on Energy, Environment and Sustainability, chaired by Councilmember Wire, convened to receive an informational briefing from Genshu Price, founder of Bottles for College, on the Recycling and Schools Initiative. The meeting was conducted remotely and in-person, with Vice Chair Los Santos Tem and Councilmember Cordero present (Councilmembers Tolba and Tupola excused; Councilmember Cordero designated as temporary voting member). No formal action was taken. Public Comments & Testimony - Angela Young (in person) testified in support of Bottles for College, noting her volunteer work and partnership with the organization for the Hawaii Children and Youth event. She mentioned that a previous resolution to place recycling bins at parks, proposed by the Youth Commission, was denied by the council, and encouraged collaboration on existing initiatives. Discussion Items - Presentation by Genshu Price: Mr. Price, a 17-year-old Marian B. Thompson Academy graduate and incoming freshman at UH Manoa, presented the Bottles for College nonprofit, which collects recyclable cans and bottles to fund college scholarships for local students. He highlighted the Bottles for College for Schools program, launched in 2025 with two pilot schools (Kapalay High School and Kailu High School), which recycled 30,000 cans and bottles in the pilot year. He stated that over 900 million cans and bottles are sold in Hawaii annually, with a 55% redemption rate in 2023, representing lost resources. The organization has recycled over 2 million cans (150,000 pounds diverted from landfills), supported 16 students with scholarships, and granted over $70,000. He requested city and county support to expand the program, including providing bins and storage, and to help schools overcome barriers such as lack of resources and logistical challenges. - Councilmember Questions: - Councilmember Wire asked about removing the 68-fluid-ounce size limit on bottle deposits; Mr. Price explained that the current limit excludes larger containers, discouraging recycling. - Councilmember Cordero inquired about how Bottles for College coordinates with schools and existing recycling clubs, the process for collecting and depositing recyclables, and how scholarship recipients are selected. Mr. Price clarified that schools retain autonomy in selecting students, and his board of directors handles statewide scholarships to avoid bias. - Vice Chair Los Santos Tem asked about reducing single-use bottles; Mr. Price emphasized that recycling is an immediate action and that Bottles for College has helped businesses increase environmental impact by up to 400%, while acknowledging the need for eventual reduction. - Mr. Price identified the biggest barrier to youth recycling as lack of environmental education in classrooms and insufficient resources, but noted growing interest and support from schools when given the opportunity. Key Outcomes - No votes or formal decisions were taken; the briefing was informational only. - Councilmembers expressed appreciation for the presentation and indicated possible consideration of related legislation (e.g., removing bottle size limits) as part of the HSAC package. - The committee closed the meeting with no further business.

The Committee on Budget, chaired by Councilmember Okimoto, met on August 20, 2025, at 8:19 a.m. to consider ten agenda items, including resolutions for fund transfers, bills on property tax exemptions, transit fare adjustments, and motor vehicle registration fees. The meeting featured testimony from the public and discussions among council members, with several items advanced to full council or public hearings. Public Comments & Testimony - Donald Sakamoto (Kaneohe resident) testified in support of Resolutions 25-208, 25-217, 25-231, 25-233, and Bill 34, and expressed support for Bill 49 with a suggestion for a Permitted Interaction Group (PIG). He also raised concerns about Bill 54 regarding accessibility for seniors and people with disabilities, opposing the cash surcharge on buses. - Kim West (unrelated testimony) spoke about a personal court matter not pertaining to the agenda items; council staff offered to connect her with appropriate assistance. - Suzanne Young (Honolulu Board of Realtors) testified in support of Bill 34, stating that current residential A thresholds unintentionally hit everyday homeowners and supported the proposed tier adjustments. - Angela Young (CARES) testified in support of Bill 62, suggested the council consider higher transportation fees for higher-income groups, and supported Bill 54’s process. She also called for a PIG on property tax issues. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-208 (Transfer $400,000 for HPD community policing equipment): Major Elgin R. Carroll (HPD District 5) explained the funds would purchase seven vans and one truck for all eight districts to support community policing teams. Councilmember Nishimoto confirmed the transfer aligns with budget provisos. Unanimously adopted. - Resolution 25-217 (Accept $4,500 gift for city auditor travel): Acting City Auditor Troy Shimasaki supported the resolution for a peer review trip to Seattle. Unanimously adopted. - Resolution 25-231 (Transfer $50,000 within DTS for covering receivables): Deputy Director John Noichi (DTS) explained the transfer repays internal accounts for federal funds that did not materialize. Unanimously adopted. - Resolution 25-233 (Transfer $42,630.94 for DTS passenger vehicle): Noichi stated the vehicle would support the Transportation Performance and Development Division. Unanimously adopted. - Bill 41 (2025) (Repealing outdated permit fee provisions): Councilmember DeSantos Tam introduced a CD1 to fix a fee discrepancy for large soil grading. DPP Director Don Takeuchi Apuna expressed support. Amended and passed for third reading. - Bill 49 (2025) (Real property tax home exemption increase for 65+): Director Andy Kawano (BFS) estimated a $5.6 million revenue loss and recommended a PIG instead. Council Chair Waters supported the bill as a cost-of-living relief. Councilmember Tupola noted reservations. Adopted for third reading with reservations. - Bill 50 (2025) (Amending home exemption): Kawano reiterated BFS concerns. Testifiers Sakamoto and Young suggested a PIG. Adopted for third reading with reservations. - Bill 34 (2024) (Real property tax rates for residential A and TVU tiers): Councilmember Kiaina presented a CD1 raising residential A thresholds to $1.3M and $3.5M, and TVU tiers to $900K and $2M, to help homeowners inadvertently classified as non-owner-occupied. Kawano noted the changes would reduce residential A tax keys from 30,000 to under 12,000. Testimony supported the bill. Adopted for second reading and public hearing. - Bill 54 (2025) (Transit fare structure update): Deputy Director Noichi and Rate Commission Chair Dre Khalili detailed a 4.1% overall fare increase, simplified categories, and a $25 surcharge for cash riders to cover $4 million annual cash-handling costs. Councilmember DeSantos Tam expressed concern about annual pass increases ($880 to $990). Councilmember Tupola supported but requested a CD2 to address Medicare concerns. Amended to CD1 and passed for second reading and public hearing, with a CD2 promised. - Bill 62 (2024) (Motor vehicle registration fee exemption for veterans 65+): Director Kim Hashiro (Customer Services) estimated a potential revenue loss of $926,000 based on 46,326 veterans. Councilmember Tupola contested the number, citing approximately 12,000 veterans on Oahu, and requested data on driver’s license holders. Councilmember Kiaina raised fairness concerns and suggested expanding the exemption to all seniors. Amended to CD1 and passed for second reading and public hearing. Key Outcomes - Unanimous adoptions: Resolutions 25-208, 25-217, 25-231, and 25-233 were all reported out for adoption without objection. - Bill 41: Amended to CD1 and reported out for passage on third reading. - Bill 49: Reported out for passage on third reading with reservations from Councilmember Tupola. - Bill 50: Reported out for passage on third reading with reservations from Councilmember Tupola. - Bill 34: Amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading and scheduling of a public hearing. - Bill 54: Amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading and scheduling of a public hearing, with a CD2 to address Medicare concerns. - Bill 62: Amended to CD1 and reported out for second reading and scheduling of a public hearing. The Department of Customer Services will provide additional data on veteran and senior driver populations.

The Honolulu City Council convened on August 7, 2025, to address a range of issues including appointments to city boards and commissions, the first reading of several bills, and a contentious third reading of a land use boundary amendment for Haleiwa (Bill 37). The meeting featured extensive public testimony, particularly on Bill 37 (over 800 written testimonies and 1,300 petition signatures in opposition) and Bill 46 (police information release). The council also debated the confirmation of a new police commissioner and heard updates on the Fire Commission and Ocean Safety Commission. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The minutes of the 11th session were approved without objection or reservation. - Resolution 25-191 (Neighborhood Board Commission Appointments): Adopted without objection, confirming Christian De Quevedo, Angela Knight, and Harris Nakamoto. - Resolution 25-179 CD1 (Ocean Safety Commission Appointments): Adopted without objection, confirming the mayor's appointees to the newly established commission. Councilmember Tupolo highlighted the commission's role in supporting the Ocean Safety Department and selecting a chief. Public Comments & Testimony - Ocean Safety Commission: Testifiers expressed strong support for the lifeguards and the new commission, emphasizing the need for timely action and community representation. - Fire Commission Review: Testifier Shelby Billionaire raised concerns about fire investigations, while Fire Commission Chair Dave Matlin provided an update on station visits and a new online document portal. - Police Commission (Christopher Magnus): No public testimony was given, but council members questioned Magnus on his background, independence, and commitment to understanding local culture. He was referred to the Public Safety and Economy Committee. - First Reading Bills (Bills 52-55): Testifiers commented on Bill 53 (affordable housing) and Bill 54 (public transit). Richard Ching supported Bill 53 but expressed concerns about affordability and parking. Harrison Nakamoto raised concerns about a project at 1427 Ernest Street, citing crime and lack of a resident manager. Don Sakamoto supported Bill 54's fare adjustments. - Bill 49 and Bill 50 (Real Property Tax Exemptions): Cody Sula of the Hawaii Iron Workers Stabilization Fund testified in support, calling the exemptions a small step to help seniors and homeowners remain in Hawaii. - Bill 46 (HPD Information Release): Multiple media representatives (Brenda Salgado, Katie Pickman, Christina Lockwood) testified in support, citing the need for real-time dispatch access during emergencies like the July 29 tsunami warning. They emphasized their commitment to responsible reporting. Opposition came from Brent Colbus (26-year Navy veteran) who cited operational security risks, and from Tim Geary who supported the chief's position. The Hawaii Association of Broadcasters president Chris Leonard urged a middle ground. Interim Police Chief Vanek and Managing Director Formby expressed legal concerns, including potential violation of FBI CJIS security policy. - Bill 37 CD1 (Haleiwa Land Use Boundary Amendment): Overwhelming opposition from the community. Testifiers included: - Senator Brent Awa (opposed, citing land flipping and generational wealth for investors) - Denise Antolini (Ole Backyards Coalition) – warned of irreversible change and referenced past council reversals - Cheryl Matsumoto – highlighted the need for agricultural land to meet school food sourcing mandates (Act 175) - Chris Hagan – described severe traffic congestion and tsunami evacuation risks - Linda Molina – pleaded for protection of agricultural land and community safety - Raquel Acheu, Yvonne Yoro, and others – emphasized infrastructure strain and loss of rural character - Supporters including Travis Murakami (Carpenters Union) and Juan Parastal argued that the bill only changes the boundary and allows further planning, and that workforce housing is needed. Discussion Items - Resolution 25-200 (Police Commission Appointment): Christopher Magnus, former police chief in three mainland departments, answered questions about his nomination. He stated he originally contacted the mayor to offer ideas and was subsequently asked to serve. Councilmembers questioned his familiarity with local culture and the current search for a permanent HPD chief. The resolution was referred to the Public Safety and Economy Committee. - First Reading Bills (Bills 52-55): Councilmember Dosantos Tam expressed reservations on Bill 53, noting the tone of some testimonies that seemed to exclude low-income residents, and raised technical concerns about parking requirements in TOD areas. Councilmember Wire also noted reservations. The bills passed first reading. - Bill 46 (HPD Information Release): Extensive debate. Chief Vanek explained that the analog system allowed media access, but digital encryption is now required by the FBI to protect personally identifiable information (PII) and criminal justice information (CJI). He noted that all patrol communications go on one frequency, making it impossible to separate tactical from non-tactical calls. He also stated that the FBI is preparing a national position against the bill. Councilmember Kia Aina expressed reservations, citing potential criminal access to police communications. Councilmember Okimoto voted no, concerned about the uniqueness of Honolulu's system. Chair Waters noted ongoing efforts to find a middle ground. Bill 46 passed second reading with reservations from Tupola and Kia Aina, and a no vote from Okimoto. - Bill 37 CD1 (Haleiwa Land Use Boundary Amendment): After extensive testimony, Councilmember Kia Aina moved to recommit the bill to the Zoning and Planning Committee. He cited the need for further discussion on potential city acquisition of the property, community garden, or transportation hub. Councilmember Wire supported the motion, noting public safety concerns highlighted by the recent tsunami warning and the lack of a second access point. Councilmember Tupola emphasized the contradiction between the community growth boundary and the community's opposition to the proposed project. The motion passed unanimously without objection. Key Outcomes - Adopted: Resolutions 25-191 and 25-179 CD1; Committee Report 161 (Fire Commission review). - Referred: Resolution 25-200 (Police Commission) to Public Safety and Economy Committee. - Passed First Reading: Bills 52, 53, 54, and 55 (with reservations on Bill 53). - Passed Second Reading: Bill 49 (senior property tax exemption) and Bill 50 (home exemption) unanimously; Bill 46 (HPD information release) with reservations and one no vote. - Recommitted: Bill 37 CD1 (Haleiwa land use) to Zoning and Planning Committee for further discussion. - Meeting recessed at 12:00 PM to reconvene at 2:00 PM.