The Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations (MCANNA) held its monthly general membership meeting on Saturday, April 22, 2024, at North United Methodist Church. President Kathy Burton opened the meeting, outlining MCANNA's mission to connect neighborhoods across Marion County. The meeting featured presentations from the office of Congressman Andre Carson, the Indianapolis Public Library, and the Indianapolis Recorder, along with community discussion, board elections, and announcements for upcoming events. Guest Presentation: Congressman Andre Carson's Office - Andrew Baknica, field representative, provided updates on district boundary changes (now northern border at 96th Street, southern at Troy Avenue, excluding three southern townships) and constituent services. He noted that the office secured over $10 billion for the community in the FY2024 budget, focusing on youth services, crime prevention, infrastructure, public transportation, and housing. - Baknica announced a youth opportunities fair held in March with 72 organizations, and an upcoming job fair in August for individuals 24 and older. He also highlighted the congressional art competition (deadline April 26) and the Congressional App Challenge (launching May 1). - He emphasized casework assistance, noting that over $1.5 million was returned to constituents last year, with current trends in passport delays and food stamp theft. Presentation: Indianapolis Public Library Strategic Plan - McKenzie (representative, last name not given) presented the library's "Now and Next" strategic planning process for 2025–2027. She reported that the library system has 25 branches, with a new Glendale branch opened March 30, 2024. Approximately 300,000 of Marion County's 850,000 residents hold library cards, and 55–65% of cardholders are active borrowers. In 2023, physical circulation exceeded 5 million items, with digital circulation nearly doubling that figure. - The library is seeking community input through surveys (available in English, Spanish, Arabic, Burmese, Farsi, French, and Punjabi), virtual focus groups, and in-person "connection tables." Key areas of focus include literacy (broadly defined), racial equity, and fostering a sense of belonging. The library also added a social worker at Central Library to connect patrons with housing, employment, and transportation resources. Presentation: Indianapolis Recorder - Tamika Jones, editor-in-chief, discussed the Recorder's 129-year history (founded in 1895), making it the fourth oldest surviving African American-owned newspaper in the U.S. She emphasized the Recorder's mission to be a voice for the voiceless and to educate, empower, and engage the community. Coverage includes hometown heroes, health equity, environmental justice, and minority business. The Recorder Media Group also publishes the Indiana Minority Business Magazine and the Minority Business Review. - Jones shared that about 40% of readers are Caucasian, and the audience is primarily aged 35 and older. She invited community members to submit story ideas to newsroom@indyrecorder.com and noted partnerships with Martin University and the Hoosier State Press Association on health equity reporting. Community Discussion & Q&A - Attendees raised concerns about illegal dumping, potholes, and the responsiveness of the Mayor's Action Center. Several speakers noted that code enforcement and the health department often provide faster responses. Clark Collow advocated for climate resiliency and land use issues, urging the Recorder to cover variance board and Metropolitan Development Commission decisions. - Ellen Antonitas discussed the need for affordable, quality housing and the lack of tenant protection laws in Indiana. Susie Stam mentioned a North District IMPD crime watch meeting on May 6 at 7 p.m. at Knights of Columbus. Alma Trawick and others shared upcoming neighborhood meetings and resources. - Kathy Burton emphasized the importance of bridging gaps between downtown and suburban neighborhoods, and the Recorder's potential role in fostering unity. Board Elections - Kathy Burton read the proposed slate of board members: herself (president, Franklin Township), Pat Andrews (secretary, Decatur Township), Anthony Burke (Washington Township), Ed Locke (Pike Township), Jim Spoholski (Center Township), Jackie McMillan Dunn (Center Township), Jim Floyd (Warren Township), Alma Trewick (Washington Township), and Ellen Antonitas (Washington Township). The slate was approved by acclamation with no additional nominations from the floor. Key Outcomes - The board slate was elected unanimously. - Upcoming MCANNA meetings: May 18 (speakers Laura O'Brien from Citizens Energy and Juliana Kennedy from Marion County Health Department) and June 15 (naloxone training provided by Jim Floyd of MESH). - The library will continue collecting community input through April and May; paper surveys are available at branches. - The Indianapolis Recorder encouraged submissions of neighborhood events and story ideas to newsroom@indyrecorder.com.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) met on April 17, 2024, to consider a range of zoning, plat, and historic preservation matters. The most prominent item was a public hearing on the proposed Church of the Holy Cross Historic Area Plan (2024 HP001), which sparked extensive debate between the Archdiocese of Indianapolis and neighborhood preservation advocates. The commission also approved several consent items, granted continuances, and voted on no-appeal petitions and a subdivision plat. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the March 20 and April 3, 2024 meetings were adopted unanimously (7-0). Commissioner Garber recused on the April 3 minutes. - Resolution 2024 R006, authorizing a lease at 39 West Jackson Place, was approved (7-0). - Three public hearing items were continued to the May 1, 2024 meeting without additional notice: 2024 A016 (Bella Solar), 2024 A017, and 2024 A018 (Novartis tax abatements). Staff requested the continuance for Novartis items because the applicant submitted reduced committed jobs requiring review. Public Comments & Testimony Public testimony was heard exclusively on the Holy Cross Historic Area Plan. Both sides were sworn in and given 10 minutes each. - Archdiocese of Indianapolis (opposition): Attorney Paul Carroll argued that the historic designation violates the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) by imposing a substantial burden on the owner (St. Philip Neri Parish). Father Joseph Newton explained canonical law: a church must be relegated to profane (non-sordid) use before demolition, and the property cannot be sold for for-profit use if the building remains. Father Jeffrey Dufrein, pastor of St. Philip Neri, stated the parish cannot afford repairs, and the plan would divert resources from serving an immigrant community and maintaining its historic Rural Street campus. The Archdiocese stated there is no middle ground, as no non-sordid use could be guaranteed in perpetuity. - Holy Cross Community & Indiana Landmarks (support): Mark DeLassus (Indiana Landmarks) refuted the RLUIPA claim, citing U.S. Supreme Court precedent (Penn Central v. New York) upholding landmarking. He noted other Catholic churches in the archdiocese have been reused for events or retail. Tim O'Sullivan (Holy Cross Land Use Committee chair) argued the buildings can be adapted (e.g., art gallery, theater) and that there are interested developers. Councilor Jesse Brown (District 13) stated canon law is not relevant civil law, and the community overwhelmingly supports preservation. He challenged the Archdiocese to present a unified plan with the neighborhood. - IHPC Staff: Meg Bush, IHPC administrator, presented the plan as a tool to review exterior work under Secretary of the Interior standards. She noted over 200 public supporters and a 597-signature petition. An emergency designation was issued on March 27, 2024, due to imminent demolition threat. IHPC Chairman Bill Brown confirmed the building is structurally sound and can be economically restored, citing historic grants and development interest. Discussion Items Church of the Holy Cross Historic Area Plan (2024 HP001) - The plan would add the parcel at 125 North Oriental Street to the comprehensive plan, providing preservation guidelines based on historic and architectural significance. - Commissioners questioned both sides about feasibility, potential reuse, and whether a meeting had occurred. The Archdiocese acknowledged no joint meeting had taken place. IHPC staff clarified the emergency designation has a 90-day window from March 27 (ending June 25) unless the MDC acts. - Motion to adopt the resolution was made; roll call vote: 6 yes, 1 no. The plan was approved, meaning the IHPC’s designation is upheld. Petition Withdrawals and Continuances - Staff acknowledged withdrawal of 2024 ZON008 (8560 North College Ave) per petitioner request. - Withdrawal of 2023 APP030 (5510 South Emerson Ave) was acknowledged, as its companion zoning petition had already been approved by council. - A continuance was granted for 2024 ZON012 (1170 Kentucky Ave) to May 15, 2024, after petitioner Jonathan Howe stated the neighborhood meeting could not accommodate an earlier date. The petitioner (Shuck Corporation) did not object but expressed frustration over lack of in-person dialogue. No‑Appeal Docket - Seven petitions recommended for approval were read and passed 7-0: 2023 ZON125, 2024 ZON010, 2024 ZON019, 2024 ZON020, 2024 ZON024, 2024 CZN806, 2024 CZN810. - One petition recommended for denial (2024 ZON007 at 3000 North German Church Road) was moved to “pass” (i.e., deny the recommendation) by a commissioner, but the motion failed; a second motion to deny (agree with staff) passed 7-0, confirming denial. Caldwell Farms Subdivision (2024 CZN808 and 2024 CPL808) - A companion rezoning and plat at 11329 Mays Road, Franklin Township, to create three single-family lots on 8.18 acres (well/septic). No remonstrators. Staff recommended approval. The plat was approved 7-0, and the rezoning was approved 7-0. Key Outcomes - Holy Cross Historic Area Plan adopted (6-1). The plan is now part of the comprehensive plan; any future exterior work or demolition will require IHPC review. - Continuances granted: 2024 A016, A017, A018 to May 1; 2024 ZON012 to May 15. - No‑appeal items: Seven approvals passed; one denial (2024 ZON007) upheld by vote. - Caldwell Farms subdivision and rezoning approved (7-0 each). - Negative findings of fact for previously denied variance petition 2023 UV302 were made available for commissioner signature.
The Marion County Commissioners met on April 16, 2024, at 2:05 PM in Room 260 of the City-County Building. President Joseph O'Connor presided, with Commissioners Milo Eldridge and Barbara Lawrence present. The meeting focused on approving prior minutes and receiving updates from two appointed board members: Carl Drummer (Health and Hospital Corporation) and Patricia Payne and Ray Biederman (Indianapolis Public Library Board). Consent Calendar - Approved the January 16, 2024 meeting minutes unanimously via voice vote. Discussion Items - Carl Drummer – Health and Hospital Board Update - Drummer reported making nearly 100% of board meetings and highlighted the new Eskenazi Health campus at 38th and Arlington. He noted the hospital’s commitment to diversity: city goals are 15% MBE, 8% WBE, and 3% VBE; current performance was approximately 17% MBE, with VBE at 4.8% and disabled-owned at about 1%. He expressed a desire to reach 25-30% diversity participation. - He addressed the ongoing nursing shortage and a new program to recruit and train nurses. Drummer also chairs the public health committee and praised Eskenazi’s leadership under Dr. Harris and Dr. Kane. - Commissioners thanked him for his service and noted the positive impact of the new facility on the neighborhood. - Patricia Payne – Indianapolis Public Library Board Update - Payne has served on the library board since 2014, currently as chair of the finance committee, board secretary, and a member of the executive committee. She reported that staff have completed a two-day racial equity training provided by Indianapolis Public Schools. - She advocated for higher salaries for library staff and encouraged commissioners to donate to the Lillian Childress Hall Scholarship Endowment, which supports employees earning a master’s degree in library science. Payne personally donated $100. - Commissioner Eldridge asked about stability after recent challenges; Payne acknowledged ongoing efforts to unify the board but said she is not completely satisfied. - Ray Biederman – Indianapolis Public Library Board Update - Biederman has served since January 2020 and is vice president of the board, chair of the diversity, policy, and HR committee, and liaison to the library foundation. He reported that a new CEO has been hired and a strategic plan is underway. - The board is conducting a wholesale review of policies, including removing outdated gender pronouns. Two new branches opened in the past 12 months: the Lawrence branch (with facilities for autistic children) and the Glendale branch. - He discussed staffing challenges and the need for increased operational funding from the city-county council. He noted that the library has taken a strong stance on intellectual freedom in response to external pressures and is actively working on literacy initiatives. - Commissioner Lawrence praised the autism-friendly design, and Commissioner Eldridge commended the board for surviving the CEO search. Key Outcomes - The meeting minutes from January 16, 2024, were approved unanimously. - The next Marion County Commissioners meeting is scheduled for May 21, 2024, at 2:00 PM in Room 260 of the City-County Building. - No votes or formal actions were taken on the updates; the presentations were for informational purposes only.
Date: April 16, 2024 | Time: 1:00 PM (called to order at approximately 1:00 PM, adjourned after votes and elections) | Location: Public Assembly Room, 2nd Floor, City-County Building, Indianapolis The board convened under Acting Chair Joanna Taft with members Roderick Bohanan, Ryanna Bender, Percy Bland, and Brian Hannon. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The meeting covered special requests, continuances, expedited petitions, and four full public hearings, culminating in board officer elections. Consent Calendar & Special Requests - 2024-DV3-005 (2360 Prospect Street): Dismissed due to lack of payment after repeated attempts to contact the petitioner. Staff recommended dismissal; board voted unanimously to dismiss. - 2024-DV3-011 (6243 Hillcrest Lane): Petitioner withdrew the request after determining the variance was not needed (structure within 5-foot setback exception). Staff had no objection. Board voted unanimously to approve withdrawal and refund of filing fees. - 2024-DV3-013 (10220 East Washington Street): Granted a one-day notice waiver for sign posting (posted on a Sunday). No opposition; staff had no objection. Board voted unanimously to approve. - 2024-DV3-003 (3308 North Mitthoefer Road): Continued to May 28, 2024, at petitioner’s request to allow corporate leadership to decide on options discussed with staff. No opposition; staff not opposed. Board voted unanimously to continue. - 2024-DV3-009 (801 North Layman Avenue): Moved to the expedited docket after no remonstrators appeared and staff recommended moving it. Board voted unanimously. - 2024-UV3-005 (6901 East 38th Street): Automatic continuance acknowledged; continued to May 28, 2024, per petitioner’s timely filing. - 2024-UV3-004 (2308 Shelby Street): Continued to May 28, 2024, for unpaid filing fees. Staff noted if unpaid at next hearing, dismissal would be recommended. No opposition; board voted unanimously. - 2024-DV3-010 (1635 West Michigan Street): Continued to May 28, 2024, because a new variance required amended notice. No opposition; board voted unanimously. - 2024-DV3-012 (2916 West Banta Road): Continued to May 28, 2024, to allow a sound study at lot lines and further discussion. No opposition; board voted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made outside of the specific petitions. Several speakers appeared in support of or in opposition to particular agenda items as noted below. Discussion Items 1. 2024-DV3-008 (8155 Talliho Drive) – Expedited - Variance to construct an enclosed addition with a 3.13-foot north side yard setback (15 feet required). Approved unanimously as part of the expedited docket. 2. 2024-DV3-013 (10220 East Washington Street) – Expedited - Variance to construct a bank with one primary entry (two required). Approved unanimously. 3. 2023-UV3-024 (2745 and 2815 Curry Road) – Expedited - Variance of use to operate a landscaping contractor with indoor/outdoor storage of commercial vehicles, equipment, and materials (not permitted). Approved unanimously. 4. 2024-DV3-009 (801 North Layman Avenue) – Expedited (moved from special requests) - Variance for building expansion including driveway accessing St. Clair Street, resulting in 65.82% open space and a 4-foot north side yard setback (65% open space, 5-foot side yard required). Approved unanimously. 5. 2023-DV3-050 (805 & 825 South Kitley Avenue) – Full Hearing - Petitioner (Murray Clark, representing Kitley Avenue Properties LLC): Requested a variance to allow an 8-foot-tall fence in the front yard (6-foot maximum). Argued the fence is decorative, provides security for the do-it-yourself center, and is consistent with surrounding 8-foot fencing. Presented letters of support from Councillor Michael Hart, Warren Township Development Association, neighboring business owner Charles Mong, and the adjacent Kitley Inn Bar & Grill. Emphasized the fence’s aesthetic and practical benefits. - Staff (Michael Weigel): Recommended denial, stating the practical difficulties are not clearly solved by an 8-foot fence vs. a compliant 6-foot fence. Noted that the front yard is used only for parking, with dangerous materials stored in the rear where taller fences are already allowed. Six feet is already generous for front yards in I-4/C-7 zoning. - Board Vote: 5-0 in favor of the petitioner. All members voted yes. 6. 2024-MO1-001 / 2024-DV1-007 (7530 Allisonville Road) – Full Hearing - Petitioner (Ashlyn Carter, representing the Rushton Trust): Requested a modification of commitments and a variance to create a separate parcel for a cell tower to allow the sale of the family home while retaining the tower lease. The tower’s lean-to shelter was built in the wrong location due to a contractor error, and the property owner previously sold off rear land, creating non-compliance. Petitioner argued that the neighbors (Johnson and Knoll families) support the plan, as does the Greater Allisonville Community Council (GACC). The cell tower company indicated moving the shelter would cost over $100,000 and cause months of service disruption. - Staff (Nova Stern): Recommended denial of the variance, stating that the practical difficulties are self-imposed (contractor error and voluntary land sale). The site could be split to create a buildable lot without the requested variances. Staff noted the neighbors’ original agreement was based on all commitments being included. The cell tower is a private, for-profit enterprise, not a utility. - Councillor Dan Boots (District 3): Spoke in favor, noting the tower is critical for the area and that the requested variances would maintain the status quo. He argued that splitting the lot to create a buildable lot would contradict the low-density DA zoning. - Board Vote: 2-3 against the petitioner. Yes: Taft, Hannon. No: Bland, Bender, Bohanan. Motion failed. 7. 2024-SE3-002 (6760 Dalton Street) – Full Hearing - Petitioner (Michelle Noppenberger, representing Reagan Outdoor Advertising): Requested a special exception and variances to relocate a billboard due to the INDOT ClearPath 465 project. The original sign (14x48 ft, 50 ft tall) was removed. The proposed location is 187 feet from the original site, requiring a 65-foot height (40 ft max), 30-foot V separation (15 degrees/42 inches max), reduced setbacks, and reduced spacing from other signs and interstate ramps. Petitioner argued the height is needed to be visible over a 52-foot hotel and trees, and that the state code allows relocation. Provided letters of support from Binford Redevelopment and Growth (BRAG) and the Greater Allisonville Community Council (GACC). - Councillor Nick Roberts (District 4) and Councillor Dan Boots (District 3, former district) spoke in support. - Staff (Robert Ewalt): Recommended approval of the special exception and five of the six variances, but made no recommendation on the height variance (65 ft). Staff noted that a 50-foot height would match the original sign and be a one-for-one replacement, but the petitioner did not agree. Staff acknowledged the state code and practical difficulty of the highway project. - Public Speaker (Tom O’Beal, representing Pat Andrews of MCANOA): Expressed support for the neighborhood’s decision to support the petition. - Board Vote: 5-0 in favor of all requested relief, including the 65-foot height. All members voted yes. 8. 2024-DV3-006 (3805 South East Street) – Full Hearing - Petitioner (Joe Calderon, representing S&L Properties Indianapolis East LLC): Requested a variance for a proposed Culver’s restaurant, originally including drive-through location, stacking spaces, parking, bicycle parking, and landscaping. After negotiations with staff, all variances except drive-through location and landscaping were resolved. The remaining variance involved the drive-through within the front yard of National Avenue and deficient frontage tree planting. Petitioner presented a revised landscaping plan with 37 trees (17 along frontage, 20 interior), 211 shrubs, and a green factor of 0.26 (requirement 0.22). Staff noted that the plan still lacks 6-7 trees along the frontage to meet the 23-tree requirement (based on 825 feet of frontage at 1 tree per 35 feet). Petitioner agreed to add 7 trees to meet the requirement. - Staff (Noah Stern): Initially recommended denial of the landscaping variance, but after the petitioner’s commitment to add 7 trees, staff withdrew objection and recommended approval of the entire petition with the additional trees as a condition. Staff noted that the site is a significant improvement over current conditions, but the area is severely deficient in landscaping and the ordinance standards should be met. - Board Vote: 5-0 in favor, with the condition that the landscaping plan include the additional 7 frontage trees. All members voted yes. Key Outcomes - Dismissed: 2024-DV3-005 (2360 Prospect Street) – dismissed for lack of payment. - Withdrawn with refund: 2024-DV3-011 (6243 Hillcrest Lane). - Continued to May 28, 2024: 2024-DV3-003, 2024-UV3-005, 2024-UV3-004, 2024-DV3-010, 2024-DV3-012. - Expedited petitions approved unanimously: 2024-DV3-008, 2024-DV3-013, 2023-UV3-024, 2024-DV3-009. - Approved: 2023-DV3-050 (fence variance) – 5-0. - Denied: 2024-MO1-001 / 2024-DV1-007 (cell tower lot) – 2-3. - Approved: 2024-SE3-002 (billboard relocation) – 5-0. - Approved with conditions: 2024-DV3-006 (Culver’s restaurant) – 5-0, with commitment to add 7 frontage trees. - Board Officer Elections: Joanna Taft re-elected as Chair; Roderick Bohanan elected as Vice Chair; Percy Bland elected as Secretary. All elections were unanimous. - Adoption of Negative Findings of Fact: The board adopted negative findings of fact for petition 2023-BD3-030 (as corrected by staff) to be included in the record.
Date: April 9, 2024, at 6:00 PM (ET) — The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II convened under Acting Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Tom Barnes, Patrice Ducket Brown, and Beth Brandon present. Legal Counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff provided support. The board heard special requests, continuances, and voted on an expedited docket of four petitions. Unanimous votes were recorded on all actions. Special Requests and Continuances - 1402 Shelby Street (2024 UV 2-003): Petitioner requested a continuance to allow revised parking plans after DPW concerns. The board granted a transfer to the Division 1 hearing on May 14, 2024, with additional public notice. - 4117 East New York Street (2024 UV 2-004): Granted a two-day waiver of notice with no objection from staff. - 1613 East 20th Street (2024 DV 2-012): Granted a three-day waiver of notice after staff noted the request required three days for mailers and two for signs. - 411 and 4117 East Washington Street (2024 UV 2-006): Revised commitments, including a change to allow parcels to be “either combined or platted” and a timeline adjustment, were read into the record and accepted by staff. No board action required. - 911 Sanders Street (2023 DV 2-032): Continued to May 21, 2024, due to missing orange public hearing signs on site. - 4925 West Southport Road (2024 UV 2-005): Continued to May 21, 2024, to allow the petitioner to mail legal notices in compliance. - 1105 Self Harding (2024 DV 2-010): Automatic continuance acknowledged to May 21, 2024. - Various addresses off U65th Street (2024 UV 2-002): Automatic continuance acknowledged to May 21, 2024. - 4233, 4235, 4237 Evanson Avenue (2024 DV 2-001): Transferred to Division 1 hearing on May 14, 2024, after the petitioner worked with staff on an amended site plan. Expedited Docket - Item 5 – 5000 Nolan Avenue (2024 DV 2-009): Variance for wall signs on two freestanding buildings with sign areas exceeding maximums (11.95% and 19.5% of elevation) and not facing a public street. Approved unanimously. - Item 6 – 1613 East 20th Street (2024 DV 2-012): Variance to construct a single-family dwelling with reduced corner side yard (4.5 ft) and front yard (27.4 ft vs. 19.9 ft maximum). Approved unanimously. - Item 7 – 4117 East New York Street (2024 UV 2-004): Variance to legally establish an existing duplex with a zero-foot front yard setback from New York Street. Approved unanimously. - Item 8 – 411 and 4117 East Washington Street (2024 UV 2-006): Variance to construct a duplex as a third primary building on a two-parcel lot with an 89-foot front yard setback from Washington Street and primary entry not on the front facade. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - All four expedited petitions (items 5–8) passed unanimously (5-0). - Nine continuances or transfers were granted, all either by unanimous vote or acknowledgement. - The board waived the rules of procedure to allow expedited voting on the docket without individual testimony. - No remonstrators appeared for any petition on the docket. - The meeting was adjourned after the final vote.
The Marion County Election Board met on April 6, 2024, to conduct public testing of voting machines, approve contracts, address a voter registration clarification from IPS, hold hearings on campaign finance fines, adopt a new campaign finance policy, and approve a rental agreement for tabulators. The meeting also included updates on upcoming elections and poll worker training. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: Minutes from January 29, February 23, and March 8, 2024, were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Nick Roberts (candidate): Filed report 3 minutes late at 12:03 p.m. instead of 12:00 p.m. on deadline. The board waived the $50 fine unanimously. - Mya Castillo (Lawrence candidate): First-time candidate with a zero-balance committee; did not file annual report. The board reduced the $1,000 fine to $259.90 (maximum reduction for first offense) unanimously. Staff offered assistance to close the committee. - John Fencil (Pike Township Constable): Filed annual report more than 20 days late due to caregiving duties and business; first offense. The board reduced the $1,000 fine to $259.90 unanimously. - Angela Moore (candidate): Treasurer failed to file annual report; report later filed. The board reduced the $1,000 fine to $259.90 unanimously. Others with 2023 annual fines who did not appear: fines remain in effect, but committees remain eligible for settlement under the prior policy. Discussion Items - Contract Approvals: - Elect Staffing Logistics: Not-to-exceed $172,000 for delivery/pickup of voting equipment through Dec 31, 2024. Approved. - Elect Staffing Mechanics: Not-to-exceed $96,680 for on‑election‑day support and key pickup through Dec 31, 2024. Approved. - Dentons Bingham Greenbaum LLP: Not-to-exceed $50,000 for legal representation on IPS redistricting matter (due to conflict of interest with current counsel). Approved. - IPS Voter Registration Clarification: The Marion County Board of Voter Registration sought the election board’s interpretation of whether state law allows technical corrections to the IPS redistricting plan certified in December 2022. Discussion identified 103 parcels with agreed‑upon errors. The board concluded that VR may proceed with these technical corrections; more complex disputes (unclaimed or double‑claimed parcels) require court action. Motion passed unanimously to allow VR to update the precinct key for technical corrections. - Campaign Finance Policy Update: Approved a new policy effective April 6, 2024, removing the automatic settlement structure and requiring unpaid fines to be referred to the city’s Revenue Recovery Unit after 60 days. All open committees will be notified. - Rental Agreement for DS 850 Tabulators: Approved $81,600 to rent two high‑speed tabulators for the primary and general elections, due to expected high turnout and limited availability of equipment. Key Outcomes - All three contract approvals passed unanimously. - Resolution allowing VR to implement technical corrections to IPS redistricting plan passed unanimously. - Campaign finance fines were waived or reduced as noted; new policy adopted unanimously. - DS 850 rental agreement approved unanimously. - The CAN‑9 notice of primary election was presented as filed. Updates & Next Steps - Early in‑person absentee voting begins April 9, 2024, at the clerk’s office and eight satellite locations. - Voter registration deadline: April 8, 2024 (online by midnight; paper applications accepted until noon April 9 due to Eclipse Day closure). - Inspector training set for April 21–22, 2024, offering free CLE credits. - Poll worker safety emphasized; a new state law effective July 1, 2024, makes poll worker intimidation a felony.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on April 3, 2024, with a quorum of six commissioners. The meeting addressed minutes from the previous meeting, two resolutions, several continuances, and a no appeals docket. All actions were approved unanimously by a 6-0 vote. Consent Calendar - The no appeals docket, consisting of 14 petitions (listed as 2024 APP 002, 003, 004; 2023 ZON 086, 101, 118; 2024 ZON 005, 011, 013, 016, 017, 018; 2023 CZN 869 and 2023 CAP 869 amended), was approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - None. Discussion Items - The minutes of the March 20, 2024 meeting were deferred to the April 17, 2024 meeting due to needed edits. (Motion carried 6-0) - Resolution 2024 E013 authorized the Department of Metropolitan Development (DMD) to expend $50,000 for services to stabilize the powerhouse building on the Central State campus, to be paid from the Central State allocation fund. (Approved 6-0) - Resolution 2024 P006 authorized the director of DMD to accept funds from Reclaim Indiana Avenue, not to exceed $15,000, to support the creation of the Indiana Avenue certified strategic plan. (Approved 6-0) - Item 2024 ZON 008 was continued to the April 17, 2024 meeting due to lack of commitments. (Approved 6-0) - Item 2023 UV 3022 (a variance petition for 8345 Bass Street) was continued to the April 17, 2024 meeting. (Approved 6-0) - The adoption of negative findings of fact for variance petitions from the March 20, 2024 meeting was also continued to the April 17, 2024 meeting. (Approved 6-0) Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous (6-0). The next meeting is scheduled for April 17, 2024, which the chair noted would be significantly longer.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One held a public hearing on April 2, 2024, at 6:00 PM, chaired by Acting Chairperson Peter Nelson with members Jennifer Witt and Andrew Cotona. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and staff from the Division of Planning were present. The hearing addressed several variance petitions, including expedited cases, continuances, and non-expedited cases. Below is a summary of each agenda item as they were heard. 2024-DV1-011 – Minor Waiver of Notice (Southeast Neighborhood Development) - Petitioner: Kelly Mergot, president of Southeast Neighborhood Development (SEND), requested a minor waiver of notice for case 2024-DV1-011 (105 East Moore Street). Notice was mailed four days late; signs were posted 19 days prior. - Public Testimony: No opposition to the waiver was voiced. - Staff Position: Not opposed to the four-day waiver. - Board Vote: Unanimously approved the waiver. (Motion by Witt, second by Cotona, all yes.) 2024-DV108545 – Automatic Continuance (545 Southeast Street) - Staff noted a request for automatic continuance by a registered neighborhood organization; the board acknowledged the continuance to May 14, 2024. 2024-DV-1005 – Withdrawal (1639 Lafayette Road) - Petitioner: Requested withdrawal of the petition, which was acknowledged by the board. 2024-UV-1002 – Expedited Petition (1125 Worcestershire Avenue) - Property: 1125 Worcestershire Avenue, Center Township, zoned I2. Request for variance to establish a single-family dwelling with a zero-foot south side yard setback (10 feet required). - Public Testimony: No one from the audience expressed interest. - Board Vote: Unanimously approved (all three members voted yes). 2024-DV3001 – Variance for Fence and Driveway (6027 Castle Bar Circle) - Petitioners: Audrey Dressel (owner) represented by attorney Russell Brown. Requested variances to legalize a 6-foot-tall fence in the front yard (maximum 3.5 feet) and an 88-foot-wide parking area in the front yard (maximum 30 feet). The driveway had been replaced with concrete in the same location as the original asphalt, and the fence replaced a 4-foot fence. Dressel’s parents built the home in 1963. - Public Testimony in Support: Brown argued the property is unique (corner lot with primary orientation toward cul-de-sac), that improvements were substantially the same as historic conditions, and that 105 residents signed a letter of support. - Public Testimony in Opposition: Blair Austin (president of Devonshire Five Civic Association) submitted a letter of opposition, stating the fence is out of place and the parking area expanded. Tom Dempsey (neighbor) cited safety concerns (blocked sight lines) and called the fence an eyesore. Beth Austin (neighbor) submitted two letters of opposition, raising public safety and visual impacts, and noted rumors of a planned bed-and-breakfast. - City-County Counselor Dan Boots (District 3) spoke in opposition, emphasizing that retroactive requests are problematic and that the self-imposed hardship should not burden neighbors. - Staff Position: Opposed to both variances. Staff stated the fence does not match development patterns, the driveway width violates code, and no practical difficulty exists. - Board Vote: The variance was split into two parts: - Part A (fence): Cotona (no), Witt (yes), Nelson (no) – split vote, continued to next hearing. - Part B (parking area): Cotona (yes), Witt (yes), Nelson initially said yes then corrected to no – split vote, continued to next hearing. 2024-DV1006 – Variance for Detached Garage (5565 Bertha Street) - Petitioners: Juan Carlos Lopez Cortez and Sylvia Canchola Medina (owners). Requested variance to allow a detached garage within an electrical utility easement with a 4.5-foot rear setback and 2-foot east side yard setback (5 feet required). Garage built without permits; petitioners are low-income and built the garage themselves. - Public Testimony: No remonstrators appeared. - Staff Position: Recommended denial due to encroachment into utility easement (by about 0.5 feet), lack of permits, and no practical difficulty. - Board Vote: Witt (yes), Nelson (no), Cotona (yes) – split vote, continued to May 14, 2024. 2024-DV1009 – Variance for Pole Barn (774 36 West Henry Street) - Petitioner: Ryan Freeman (general contractor) for Charles and Claire Powell. Requested variance to construct a 1,728 sq. ft. pole barn (larger than the 1,208 sq. ft. primary residence, which is not permitted). The property is in a floodplain; structure would be 143% the size of the house. - Public Testimony: No remonstrators appeared. - Staff Position: Recommended denial; no practical difficulty; multiple smaller buildings could meet ordinance. - Board Questions: Concerns about the size and potential commercial use (vehicles visible on Google Earth), but petitioner stated personal use only. - Board Vote: Nelson (no), Cotona (no), Witt (yes) – split vote, continued to May 14, 2024. 2024-DV1010 – Variance for Fourth Freestanding Sign (5435 East Thompson Road) - Petitioner: Jason Lucas (Farnsworth Group) for GOC Realco LLC. Requested variance for a fourth primary freestanding sign along Thompson Road (maximum two allowed), with a 1-foot front setback (5 feet required) and separation of 40 feet (required 245 feet). The site is in a C4 zone. - Public Testimony: No remonstrators appeared. - Staff Position: Strongly opposed, stating the request would create visual clutter and oversaturation of signage, contrary to ordinance rules designed for integrated commercial centers. Alternative signage (wall signs, multi-tenant sign 40 feet away) is available. - Board Vote: Unanimously denied (Nelson no, Cotona no, Witt no). 2024-DV1-011 – Variance for Four-Unit Townhouse (105 East Moore Street) - Petitioners: Kelly Mergot (SEND) and Scott Perkins (architect, Black Line Studios). Requested multiple variances to construct a four-unit affordable rental townhouse on a 4,196 sq. ft. lot (minimum 5,000 sq. ft. required), with reduced setbacks, zero off-street parking (three on-street spaces counted per ordinance), and encroachment into the clear site triangle. The project received City of Indianapolis Vacant to Vibrant funding and design approval from the city architect. - Public Testimony in Support: Petitioner argued the project addresses affordable housing needs, received neighborhood association approval, and is consistent with missing middle housing goals. - Public Testimony in Opposition: DiMario Vitalis (owner of adjacent properties) raised concerns about lot size non-compliance, insufficient side yard setback (3 feet next to his property), lack of parking, traffic safety, utility access, trash, and property values. Greg Clausen (neighbor and retired architect) emphasized safety hazards (fire access, sight lines), zero usable open space, and poor design for the site. - Staff Position: Recommended approval. Staff clarified that per ordinance, on-street parking counts reduce the parking variance to one space. The D5 zone permits up to four units on lots as small as 3,500 sq. ft. The proposed setbacks are greater than the previous development on the site. The clear site triangle encroachment is not unique in the neighborhood, and no objections from the Department of Public Works were raised. - Board Vote: Chairperson Nelson voted yes. The petition passed (specific tallies of other members not fully recorded, but the chair declared approval). However, due to issues with the proposed findings of fact, the case was continued to the next meeting for adoption of clean findings. Key Outcomes - Approved (with cleanup): Variance for 105 East Moore Street (four-unit townhouse). - Denied: Variance for fourth sign at 5435 East Thompson Road. - Continued (split votes): - Fence and parking variance for 6027 Castle Bar Circle (both parts continued). - Garage variance for 5565 Bertha Street. - Pole barn variance for 774 36 West Henry Street. - Other: Minor waiver of notice granted; automatic continuance acknowledged; withdrawal accepted; expedited petition approved.
The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) of Marion County, Indiana, met on March 20, 2024, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The Commission considered routine approvals, tax abatements, and multiple zoning petitions, including public hearings on a proposed girls' STEM school, a used car sales variance, and a mental health treatment facility expansion. All votes were 6-0 unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the March 6, 2024 meeting (Commissioner Robinson recused). - Approved Resolution 2024-R-007, authorizing a contract with Green Earth Lawn Services, Inc. for mowing services on DMD-owned properties through 2025, not to exceed $400,000. - Approved Resolution 2024-C-001, authorizing a consulting services contract with Shrewsberry & Associates LLC, not to exceed $255,000. Tax Abatement Resolutions - 2024-A-010 (Real Property Tax Abatement): Approved as amended to expand the leasable square footage from 82,744 to 86,000 square feet to include a proposed mezzanine. The five-year abatement for E Solutions, LLC and Edwards Electrical & Mechanical, Inc. at 3233 North Post Road passed 6-0. - 2024-A-011 (Personal Property Tax Abatement): Companion resolution for the same entities and property. Approved 6-0 as published. Continuances - 2023-ZON-086 (6185-6531 East 34th Street) – Continued to April 3, 2024, for lack of commitments. - 2023-ZON-101 (3905 East Raymond Street) – Continued to April 3, 2024, for lack of commitments. - 2024-ZON-005 (977 Roache Street) – Continued to April 3, 2024, for lack of commitments. - 2024-ZON-008 (8560 North College Avenue) – Continued to April 3, 2024, for finalization of commitments. - 2024-CZN-808/2024-CPL-808 (11329 Maze Road) – Acknowledged automatic continuance to April 17, 2024, filed by a registered neighborhood organization. Petitions of No Appeal (Recommended for Approval) Seven petitions were approved 6-0: 2023-ZON-119, 2024-ZON-001, 2024-ZON-006, 2023-CZN-858, 2023-CZN-868, 2024-CZN-803, and 2024-CAP-805. Petition of No Appeal (Recommended for Denial) - 2023-ZON-102 (117 North Sherman Drive): The Commission voted 6-0 to uphold the hearing examiner's denial of the rezoning. Public Hearing: 2023-ZON-109 – Paramount Schools of Excellence (5136 Michigan Road) This 10.13-acre rezoning from SU-1 to SU-2 for an all-girls STEM school (K-8, phasing in K-6 initially) drew extensive testimony. Petitioner's Position (Paramount Schools): - Attorney Brian Tuohy presented the case, highlighting the adaptive reuse of a historic church (formerly Witherspoon Presbyterian Church) and the school's benefit to black and brown girls. He noted the site had housed a church for 50 years, and the school would have similar traffic impacts. - Principal Crystal Westerhouse cited that Paramount's network is 80% diverse, 13% English language learners, and 18% special needs. The school would grow from 125 to 300 students over five years. - Pastor Winterborne Harrison Jones testified that education aligns with the church's legacy. - Traffic engineer Steve Fairbach stated the proposed turn lanes and queuing improvements would mitigate traffic (estimated $600,000-$700,000 investment). - The petitioner agreed to commitments, including installing turn lanes, improving the driveway, a traffic control/queuing plan, municipal sewer connection, and a new commitment: no high school at the site. Remonstrators' Position (Washington Township Schools, Highland Kessler Civic League, and others): - Attorney Jonathan Hughes argued the project violates the comprehensive plan (rural/estate neighborhood) and would be a large-scale school in a typology that does not recommend schools. He cited existing school saturation (seven schools within 3.5 miles) and questioned the petitioner's transparency. - Raymond Baker (Highland Kessler) said the community strongly opposed (85+ residents at a January meeting, 500 opposition letters) and expressed skepticism that commitments are enforceable without neighborhood authority. - Councillor Dan Boots and Councillor Leroy Robinson spoke; Robinson supported the school, while Boots opposed it, calling the site a "bad use." Staff Position: Recommended approval, noting the comprehensive plan is a guideline, and traffic and sewer concerns are addressed. Decision: The petition was approved 5-1. Public Hearing: 2023-UV3-022 – Used Car Sales Variance (8345 Bash Street) This was an appeal of a BZA decision to grant a variance for automobile sales (primarily as an accessory to a repair shop). The Commission considered the appeal filed by city-county councilors. Petitioner's Position (David Gilman): - Argued the variance would allow a small auto repair business with up to 16 cars, only seven for sale, and that the design meets the Castleton revitalization plan's vision for the Nickel Plate Trail. Appellants' Position (Councillors, Bragg, GACC, Senator): - Opposed the variance as inconsistent with the Castleton Plan and the Nickel Plate Trail's potential. - DMD staff recommended denial. Decision: The Commission voted 5-1 to overturn the BZA's approval (four no votes were needed; five were cast). Public Hearing: 2023-ZON-127 – Haven Health Management (5448 & 5510 South Emerson Avenue) Rezoning 1.82 acres from D-P and D-A to D-P to allow a mental health and addiction residential treatment facility (up to 24 residents). Petitioner's Position: - Proposed a clarification of the code, adding a northern parcel for parking and a recreational building, and committed to a six-foot privacy fence around patient areas. Remonstrators' Position: - Neighbors Adam Zico and Adam Gutter expressed concerns about lighting, noise, traffic, and building proximity. - They were satisfied with the clarified fence commitment but remained opposed. Staff Position: Recommended approval, noting expansion of critical services and that lighting would meet code. Decision: Approved unanimously 6-0. Key Outcomes - Approved routine resolutions and tax abatements. - Continued five zoning petitions to April 3 or April 17, 2024. - Approved seven no-appeal rezoning petitions and denied one no-appeal petition. - Approved the Paramount Schools rezoning (5-1) with added commitments. - Overturned BZA's approval of used car sales variance (5-1). - Approved Haven Health rezoning (6-0) with fence commitment. Note: The meeting agenda listed a 1:00 PM start, but the transcript indicates the meeting was also called for 6:00 PM (per source metadata). No discrepancy was noted in the agenda.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on March 19, 2024, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room, City-County Building. Acting Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with members Percy Bland and Rihanna Bender present. Only three members were available, requiring a unanimous vote for any action to pass; split decisions resulted in continuances. The docket included continuances, withdrawals, expedited petitions, and contested cases. Continuances and Special Requests - 2024-SE3-002 (6760 Dalton Street): Requested by Reagan Outdoor Advertising to continue to April 16, 2024, for the Greater Allisonville Community Council to gather more information. No opposition. Staff had no objection. Unanimously approved. - 2024-DV3-001 (6027 Castlebar Circle): Petitioner requested transfer to Division I (April 2) due to only three board members. A remonstrator (Devonshire Civic Association president) opposed the continuance but the board voted to transfer. Unanimously approved. - 2024-DV3-003 (3308 North Mitthoefer Road): Petitioner requested continuance to April 16 to consider changes. No opposition. Staff had no objection. Unanimously approved. - 2024-DV3-006 (3805 South East Street): Petitioner requested continuance to April 16 to revise site plan. No opposition. Staff had no objection. Unanimously approved. - 2023-UV3-024 (2745 & 2815 Curry Road): Petitioner requested continuance to April 16 due to lack of agreement with staff and desire for a full board. No opposition. Staff had no objection but noted if continued again, transfer to different board. Unanimously approved. - 2024-DV3-005 (2360 Prospect Street): Staff requested continuance to April 16 on petitioner's behalf. No opposition. Unanimously approved. - 2024-DV3-004 (1328 Lawrence Avenue): Staff requested continuance to May 28, 2024, because petitioner could not attend April 16. No opposition. Unanimously approved. - 2024-UV3-002 (5312 South Emerson Avenue): Petitioner withdrew the variance of use petition to file a rezoning. Fee transfer requested. Staff supported transfer. Unanimously approved withdrawal and fee transfer. Expedited Petitions - 2023-SE3-005 (Amended) (6179 East 26th Street): Special exception for religious uses with a monument sign and variance for parking width. No remonstrators. Approved unanimously. - 2024-SE3-001 (8550 East 30th Street): Special exception for religious uses and variance for rear yard setback. No remonstrators. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - For 2024-MO1-001/2024-DV1-007 (7530 Allisonville Road): Rebecca Patton (executor of estate) stated the cell tower income supports her mother’s care; neighbors support the variance. Gregory Cagnassola (attorney) and Ashlyn Carter (attorney) represented the trust. A neighbor (Mr. Lu Boots) testified the condition has existed for 15 years with no complaints and that strict compliance would cause hardship. - For 2023-SE3-006 (1140 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street): Superintendent Alicia Johnson (IPS) and student Taro Johnson spoke in favor of relocating the cell tower to allow athletic field renovations. Petitioner Aaron Adelman (SMJ International) described the need for the tower to maintain coverage, including 911 calls. Attorney Larry Opelski (American Tower) cited Federal Telecommunications Act requirements. - Against 2023-SE3-006: Paula Brooks (Hoosier Environmental Council, resident, and community leader) argued that the tower would harm health, that IPS failed to meaningfully engage the community, and that the location impedes future development. She urged denial to allow wider community input. - For 2024-UV3-003 (8540 US 31): Damon Cox (facilities coordinator, Christ Indianapolis United Methodist Church) explained the church’s desire to install an electronic messaging display to share hope and community announcements (e.g., suicide awareness, food pantry). Scott Hudson (Board of Trustees chair) supported the request. They committed to removing two existing signs if the EVMS is approved. Discussion Items - 2024-MO1-001/2024-DV1-007 (7530 Allisonville Road): Petitioner sought modification of two commitments from a 2009 variance (requiring DA district setbacks and antenna type) and a variance of development standards for reduced setbacks (south side 7 ft, north side 0.5 ft, rear 2.5 ft, aggregate 7.5 ft; required 30 ft side, 75 ft aggregate, 75 ft rear) and creation of a 0.606-acre lot with 40-ft frontage (minimum 3 acres and 125 ft). Staff recommended denial, asserting that the difficulty was self-imposed (cell provider’s construction error and sale of rear land) and that the tower could be relocated to comply. The board split 2-1 on both the modification and variance, resulting in a continuance to April 16, 2024. - 2023-SE3-006 (1140 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street): Petitioner sought a special exception for a 120-ft monopole tower (plus 4-ft lightning rod) and a variance for landscape screening. After neighborhood opposition, the site was moved further from residences. Petitioner withdrew the landscape variance because the revised plan included a 10-ft landscape strip. Staff recommended approval. The board voted 3-0 to approve the special exception as amended (with landscaping). - 2024-UV3-003 (8540 US 31): Petitioner requested a variance to install an electronic message display (37.28 sq ft digital component on existing pylon sign) and to legally establish two existing signs (one pole sign, one monument sign). Staff recommended denial, citing sign clutter and proliferation of EVMS signs in the corridor. The board separated the request: Part A (EVMS with commitment to remove other signs within 60 days of installation) passed 3-0. Part B (legalization of existing signs) was withdrawn by the petitioner after Part A passed. Key Outcomes - Continuances approved: 2024-SE3-002, 2024-DV3-001 (transferred to Division I), 2024-DV3-003, 2024-DV3-006, 2023-UV3-024, 2024-DV3-005, 2024-DV3-004, and 2024-MO1-001/2024-DV1-007 (due to split vote) were all continued to future dates as specified. - Withdrawal: 2024-UV3-002 was withdrawn; filing fees transferred. - Expedited petitions (2023-SE3-005 amended, 2024-SE3-001): Approved unanimously. - Contested case 2023-SE3-006: Approved unanimously with the landscape variance withdrawn. - Contested case 2024-UV3-003: Part A (EVMS sign) approved unanimously; Part B (legalization of existing signs) withdrawn. Commitment to remove two signs within 60 days of EVMS installation. - All decisions are binding pending adoption of findings of fact at a subsequent hearing.