The Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations (MCANA) held its regular meeting on Saturday, March 17, 2024, at North United Methodist Church. President Kathy Burton welcomed attendees and outlined the purpose of MCANA. The meeting featured two main presentations: a solar eclipse safety briefing by the Marion County Public Health Department and a disaster preparedness talk by the Mesh Coalition. Additionally, updates were provided on the ongoing digital billboard battle and concerning state legislation (HEA 1338) that weakens public access laws. Public Comments & Testimony - Several neighborhood representatives announced upcoming community cleanups: Franklin Township (May 11, 8 a.m.), Keystone Millennium (May 18, 9 a.m.–1 p.m. at Avondale Meadows YMCA), and Ohio and Sandy Neighborhood (last Saturday of April, 9 a.m. at 29th and Capitol). - Members expressed interest in having Mesh provide naloxone training at a future MCANA meeting. Discussion Items Solar Eclipse Preparedness (Marion County Public Health Department) - Cassandra Jompe (Emergency Preparedness Director) and Courtney Gordon (Deputy Director) presented a detailed overview of the April 8, 2024 total solar eclipse. Key points: - The path of totality will pass over Indianapolis, with totality from 3:06 p.m. to 3:09 p.m. (3 minutes 49 seconds). - Up to 500,000 visitors expected, causing major traffic disruptions and strain on emergency services. - Free eclipse glasses will be distributed at three drive-through events: April 2 (Lafayette Square, 10 a.m.–2 p.m.), April 4 (Washington Square, 2–6 p.m.), and April 6 (Health Department open house, 3838 N. Rural, 10 a.m.–2 p.m.). - Primary public health threat is ocular injury; viewers must use certified glasses except during the brief totality. - Safety recommendations: full gas tank, food/water, charged phone, and a go-kit. Schools in Marion County will either close or use e-learning; charter/private schools remain open. - A question about using parks/greenways for eclipse viewing was raised; health department encouraged checking Indy Parks for events. Mesh Coalition (Managed Emergency Surge for Healthcare) - Jim Floyd, Administrator of the Mesh Coalition, described the organization's role in managing healthcare surge during disasters. Mesh, a 501(c)(3) formed in 2008, focuses on whole community support, operational support, education/training, and planning. - Statistics shared: - 80% of socioeconomically disadvantaged individuals perceive disaster risk, but only 41% are prepared; 21% have essential documentation/insurance. - June 2023 saw 5,621 severe weather reports (1,095 above the 2013–2022 average). - In Marion County, 135,340 residents have a disability; life expectancy varies by 20 years between some census tracts. - Mesh offers an Emergency Preparedness and Resilience Coach (EPRC) training (12 hours over 4 weeks) covering psychological first aid, practical preparedness, and community coaching. The next sessions are in April. - Free naloxone training is provided every two months; the next is May 30 (about one hour). - Floyd emphasized meeting people where they are, addressing barriers like lack of emergency savings (average $400, but real expenses $1,400; evacuation costs $1,200–$5,000). - Questions addressed coordination with DPW sustainability, mental health crisis response (MCAT teams with IMPD), long-term recovery support, shelter and family assistance center planning, and donation management. Floyd stressed the need for neighborhood-level relationships and a buddy system for vulnerable residents. Digital Billboard Update (Ed Locke) - Ed Locke reported on the ongoing effort to maintain Marion County’s ban on new billboards inside I-465 (in place since 1971) and digital billboards (since early 1990s). - In 2013 and 2019, city council unanimously reaffirmed the ban. However, a Texas company (Reagan) is exploiting loopholes from I-69 construction displacements and state law changes. - Recent Board of Zoning Appeals hearings have resulted in split votes (2-2) on special exceptions; variances have been rejected. The latest hearing (March 12) ended in a tie, requiring a re-hearing in May. - A legislative amendment in January 2024 aimed to further undermine the ordinance; the fight continues. Locke called for neighborhood support and contacting state legislators. Public Access Legislation (Clark Cowell) - Clark Cowell discussed HEA 1338, now on Governor Holcomb’s desk. The bill alters the state public access counselor’s term to at-will employment and restricts the counselor to only using the public access law and court rulings (no dictionary or context). - Cowell read excerpts from an Indianapolis Capital Chronicle editorial by Nikki Kelly (March 8) criticizing the process: the language was inserted late without public hearings or vetting. - Cowell urged attendees to email Governor Holcomb (govholcomb@gov.in.gov) and ask him to veto the bill, emphasizing that it weakens transparency and civic engagement. Key Outcomes - Solar Eclipse Preparedness: Free glasses distribution events announced; residents encouraged to plan ahead for traffic and safety. - Mesh Coalition: Will arrange naloxone training at a future MCANA meeting; EPRC training in April is open to all. Neighborhood associations are urged to build connections and use Mesh’s resources. - Digital Billboards: The fight continues; neighborhoods are encouraged to attend BZA hearings and contact legislators. - HEA 1338: A call to action to email Governor Holcomb requesting a veto of the bill. - Next Meeting: April 20, 2024, will include board elections (dues must be paid to vote) and a speaker from the Indianapolis Recorder.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaOn March 12, 2024, at 6:00 PM, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II held a public hearing chaired by Acting Chairperson James Duke, with board members Beth Brandon, Patrice Deckett Brown, and Tom Barnes. Staff from the Division of Planning and legal counsel were present. The board considered continuances, notice waivers, expedited items, and several contested variance and special exception requests. Consent Calendar - The board unanimously approved a waiver of procedural rules to expedite voting on the expedited docket. - Expedited Docket (Item 3): A variance of development standards for a single-family dwelling with 66.9% open space at 529 East 57th Street (Washington Township) was approved unanimously. - Continuance: Cindy Thrasher’s request to continue case 2024 DV2‑002 to May 21, 2024, was granted without opposition. - Notice Waiver: A three‑day mailing waiver and five‑day posting waiver for case 2024 DV2‑006 (1212 East 25th Street) were approved by a 3‑1 vote (Barnes dissenting). Public Comments & Testimony Case 2023 UV1023 – Enterprise Leasing (7217 Woodland Drive): - Ed Locke, representing the Pike Township Residents Association (PTRA), stated the PTRA supports the petition with the proposed covenants. Case 2023 SC2002 – Reagan Outdoor Advertising (3210 Chief Lane): - Pat Andrews, representing the Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations and Decatur Township Civic Council, opposed the petition, arguing that the billboard does not exist to relocate, that city ordinance prohibits signs inside I‑465, and that the requested variances are unnecessary because the site can accommodate standard setbacks. - Tom O’Beal, president of Historic Urban Neighborhoods (HUNY), urged the board to uphold the city’s sign ordinance and vote no. Case 2024 DV2008 – Broadway Street Fence: - No remonstrators appeared. Petitioners Maureen Borto, Lauren Gillot, and Timothy Smith testified in support of their request for an 8‑foot‑tall rear yard fence. Discussion Items Special Requests and Continuances: - The board considered a continuance and notice waivers as noted in the Consent Calendar. Staff also acknowledged an automatic continuance for 2024 UV2‑002 to April 9, 2024, and a housekeeping correction for 2023 SC2002. Case 2023 UV1023 – Enterprise Leasing (Car/Truck Rental Facility): - Petitioner Joe Calderon and Jeff Gowdy (Enterprise Mobility) presented the proposal to convert a vacant former Hardee’s into a car and truck rental facility. They argued the triangular site and vacancy create a peculiar hardship, and that the use would be less intense than permitted C4 uses (e.g., 20 transactions per day). They noted support from the Park 100 Owners Association and the north‑adjoining day‑care center. - Staff opposed, stating the site can be redeveloped as a permitted restaurant, that vacancy is not a peculiar condition, and that the hardship is self‑created. - Board vote: Brown yes, Barnes no, Duke yes, Brandon yes – passes 3‑1. Case 2023 SC2002 – Reagan Outdoor Advertising (Billboard Relocation): - Petitioner John Campbell and counsel Dana McClendon requested a special exception and variances to relocate an outdoor advertising sign displaced by the I‑69 widening. They presented letters of support from City‑County Councillors Jared Evans and Joshua Bain. - Remonstrators opposed, citing the city’s ban on signs inside I‑465, the lack of an actual sign to relocate (the land was sold to INDOT), and safety concerns. - Staff supported the special exception (state law supersedes local ordinance) but did not recommend the variances, citing potential driver distraction and inadequate separation from protected districts. - The board split the vote: Part A (special exception) received a 2‑2 tie (Barnes no, Duke yes, Brown no, Brandon yes), resulting in an automatic continuance to May 21, 2024. Part B (development standards variances) was denied unanimously. Case 2023 DV2038 – Raising Cane’s Restaurant (8245 Allisonville Road): - Petitioner Joe Calderon, Gene Byerman (Kite Realty), and Felicia Bivens presented plans for a double drive‑through restaurant on a triangular out‑lot in Castleton Crossing. They requested variances for the drive‑through in the front yard (9.2‑foot setback instead of 10 feet) and for a second drive‑through lane without a bypass aisle. They highlighted a landscaping plan with 838 plantings, 17 trees, and 224 shrubs at 30‑inch height, and noted support from the Greater Allisonville Community Council. - Staff objected, asserting that headlight glare from westbound traffic on I‑465 would distract drivers, that deciduous landscaping provides inadequate year‑round screening, and that the lack of a bypass aisle poses safety risks. - Board vote: Brown yes, Brandon yes, Barnes no, Duke yes – passes 3‑1. Case 2024 DV2006 – OmniSource Sign (1212 East 25th Street): - The petitioner initially sought a variance for a 20‑foot‑tall internally illuminated pole sign. Staff recommended denial. - After staff explained that a pylon sign without illumination is permitted by right, the petitioner withdrew the variance request. The board acknowledged the withdrawal. Case 2024 DV2008 – Broadway Street Fence (5669‑5677 Broadway Street): - Petitioners Maureen Borto, Lauren Gillot, and Timothy Smith requested variances to maintain an 8‑foot‑tall fence in the rear yard (and originally along the side and front, but they committed to reducing the side/front portions to 6 feet). They cited noise, light pollution, and safety concerns from a neighboring property used as a short‑term rental (Airbnb) that can accommodate up to 21 guests. They noted unique lot conditions: their garages face Broadway, not the alley, and they lack the buffering that other neighbors have. - Staff recommended denial, stating that noise and light are not sufficient grounds for a variance and that 8‑foot fences are atypical for residential areas. - Board vote: All yes – passes unanimously. Petitioners agreed to reduce side and front fence heights to 6 feet. Key Outcomes - 2023 UV1023 (Enterprise Leasing): Approved 3‑1. - 2023 SC2002 (Reagan Outdoor Advertising): Part A (special exception) continued to May 21, 2024, due to indecisive vote; Part B (variances) denied. - 2023 DV2038 (Raising Cane’s): Approved 3‑1. - 2024 DV2006 (OmniSource Sign): Withdrawn after amendment to conform to ordinance. - 2024 DV2008 (Broadway Street Fence): Approved unanimously with commitment to reduce side/front fence heights. - Expedited Item 3 (529 E 57th St): Approved unanimously. - Continuances: Case 2024 DV2‑002 continued to May 21, 2024; case 2024 UV2‑002 automatically continued to April 9, 2024.
The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on March 6, 2024, to consider tax abatement resolutions, zoning appeals, a flood control ordinance amendment, and a Butler University rezoning and variance request. The meeting began with approval of consent items and included multiple public hearings and votes throughout the session. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved the minutes from the February 21 meeting. - Approved six policy resolutions (2024 A001, A002, A012–A015) for tax abatements on a 7–0 vote. These included preliminary and final economic revitalization area resolutions for e-solutions LLC, Edwards Electrical and Mechanical Incorporated, Republic Polymers 2 LLC, and Blue Polymers LLC. Public Comments & Testimony - Republic Polymers and Blue Polymers Tax Abatements (Resolutions A012–A015): - Thomas Lorenz (leader of Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association) and Ann Schott testified in opposition. Lorenz argued that the company had not fulfilled promises made during the rezoning process (e.g., improvements to Bluff Park, road repairs) and that the tax abatement would not benefit the neighborhood. He noted that the area lacks adequate infrastructure, such as sidewalks and public transit. Schott added that the company’s failure to meet the tax abatement application deadline suggested the project could proceed without the incentive. - Jake German (attorney for Republic Services and Blue Polymers) and Ginger Richardson (senior public affairs manager) spoke in favor, committing to continue discussions with the neighborhood and to be good partners. Commissioner Dillon urged good faith efforts to address neighbor concerns. - Butler University Rezoning and Variance (Resolutions CZN 801 and CVR 801): - Petitioners Brian Towey and Michael Lofton presented plans to rezone 0.32 acres at 526 Blue Ridge Road from D5 to UQ2 to build a new university president’s residence. They cited a $4–6 million donor-funded project, a four-million-dollar gift, and the need for variances (10-foot rear setback vs. required 20-foot, and front entrance facing Sunset Avenue). - Remonstrators Peter Berger, Evelyn Ridley Turner, John Richard Turner, and Kevin Sindelar opposed the rezoning. They argued the existing D5 zoning already permits a residence, the proposed house is out of scale with the neighborhood, and UQ2 could allow future uses without neighbor notification. Berger noted the house is 93 years old and that variances would enable demolition. - Staff (Marlene) recommended approval, stating that UQ2 limits uses to D5 and aligns with the comprehensive plan’s institution-oriented mixed-use designation. Discussion Items - Continuance Request for 2023 APP 30 (Haven Health Management): Attorney Murray Clark requested a 60–90 day continuance to May 1, 2024, pending a new rezoning case to resolve a zoning dispute. Staff preferred dismissal, but the commission approved the continuance on a 6–2 vote (Commissioner Schumacher voted no). - Three Zoning Petition Continuances (CZN 858, 868, 803): Staff requested continuances to March 20, 2024, for finalization of commitments. All three were approved 7–0. - Flood Control Ordinance Amendment (2024 A001): Planner Shannon Norman presented amendments to Chapter 742-203 to comply with FEMA requirements for the National Flood Insurance Program. The ordinance was approved 7–0. Key Outcomes - Tax Abatements for Republic Polymers and Blue Polymers (A012–A015): All four resolutions were approved 6–1 (Commissioner James voted no). Each granted a 10-year tax abatement (real and personal property) for facilities at 1002 and 1010 West Hannah Avenue. - Continuance for Haven Health Management Appeal: Approved to May 1, 2024, by a 6–2 vote. - Zoning Continuances: Three petitions continued to March 20, 2024, all 7–0. - Petitions of No Appeal: Two items approved 7–0. - Flood Control Ordinance: Passed 7–0. - Butler University Rezoning (CZN 801): Approved 5–2 (Commissioners Garver and Blackburn dissenting). - Butler University Variance (CVR 801): Approved 7–0. Commissioner Dillon noted that the new president’s house is a significant investment that will likely increase property values.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 held a public hearing on March 5, 2024, chaired by David Duncan with members Jennifer Witt and Andrew Catona. The board considered several petitions including continuances, waiver requests, and variance applications. Procedural Matters - The board approved a one-day notice waiver for case 2024 M0102 (3527 N College Avenue) and a two-day waiver for case 2024 UV3-001 (1615 W Edgewood Avenue). - Case 2023 UV306 (4328 E Michigan Street) was placed on the expedited docket. - Case 2023 UV1027 (7425 Westfield Boulevard) was withdrawn. - Case 2024 M01001/2024 DV1007 (7530 Allisonville Road) was continued to March 19, 2024, BZA3 due to jurisdictional issues. - Case 2024 DV1006 (5565 Bertha Street) was continued to April 2, 2024, to allow for an amendment. Expedited Docket - All three expedited cases were approved unanimously (3-0): - 2024 DV1003 (7219 92nd St): pole barn variance. - 2024 DV3002 (6161 E 82nd St): drive-through and stacking space variance. - 2023 UV306 (4328 E Michigan St): conversion to duplex with front yard setback. Case 2023 UV3022: 345 Bash Street – Auto Sales Variance - Petitioner David Gilman (for CF Lockner Associates) sought a use variance to allow automobile sales as an accessory to auto repair in C4 zoning. - Public testimony: Councilor Dan Boots opposed (District 4), citing the Castleton Revitalization Plan and opposition from GACC and Benford community groups. - Staff recommended denial, stating the use would be primary rather than accessory and counter to the comprehensive plan. - Petitioner offered commitments including limiting sales vehicles to seven and enhanced landscaping. - Board voted 3-0 to approve with conditions, including the seven-vehicle cap and site plan commitments. Case 2023 UV1021: 7040 Rockville Road – Secondary Dwelling Unit - Petitioner David Gilman (for Donald Quas) sought variances for a zero-foot west side yard setback (Part A) and to allow a secondary dwelling unit without owner occupancy (Part B). - Public testimony: Karen Farmer and Carol Barker of RHGNA opposed Part B, arguing absentee ownership would harm neighborhood stability. - Staff supported Part A (setback) due to legal nonconforming status, but opposed Part B because the 2016 ordinance requires owner occupancy. - Board voted: Part A passed 3-0; Part B was denied 3-0. Case 2024 M01002: 3527 N College Avenue – Modification of Commitments - Petitioner John Cross (for Walvin Investments) requested termination of 2018 commitments requiring owner-occupancy and prohibiting rentals, replacing them with five new commitments (including a ban on rentals under one month). - No remonstrators appeared; staff had no objection. - Board voted 3-0 to approve the modification. Case 2024 DV1005: 1639 Lafayette Road – Gravel Parking and Buffer Variance - Petitioner Randall Parsons (Gardner Glass Products) sought variance for gravel parking encroaching into protected zones and right-of-way. - Public testimony: William Gerlough opposed, citing safety hazards, obstruction of sidewalk, and aesthetic concerns. - Discussion: Board suggested potential paving and reconfiguration; staff recommended continuance for further analysis. - Petitioner requested a continuance to April 2, 2024, which was granted 3-0 over the remonstrator's objection. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2023 UV3022 (auto sales) with conditions; 2024 M01002 (commitment modification); Part A of 2023 UV1021 (setback). - Denied: Part B of 2023 UV1021 (secondary dwelling without owner occupancy). - Continued: 2024 DV1005 to April 2, 2024; other cases continued or withdrawn as noted. - All expedited cases approved.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on February 21, 2024, at 6:00 PM. The meeting covered routine approvals, public hearings, and discussion of several development proposals. All votes were unanimous (8-0) except where noted. Key actions included approval of tax abatements for Republic Polymers and Blue Polymers, a modified commitment for a painting business, and rezoning for a new subdivision by Arbor Homes. Consent Calendar - The commission approved the minutes from the February 7, 2024 meeting. - Approved five policy resolutions (2024 R004, 2024 R005, 2024 E011, 2024 A003, 2024 A004, 2024 A005, 2024 A006) in a single vote. These included an intergovernmental transfer of property, cooperation with the Indianapolis Fire Department for a fire station site, a contract for data tracking software, and preliminary economic revitalization area resolutions with tax abatements for Republic Polymers 2 LLC and Blue Polymers LLC. - Approved a waiver of the 2023 pay 2024 deduction application filing deadline for IMH Products Inc. (2024 A008) after a public hearing. The waiver was granted because the company missed the deadline but was in compliance. Vote: 8-0. - Approved seven petitions on the no-appeal docket (2023 MOD 002, 2023 ZON 105, 2023 ZON 122, 2023 CZN 863, 2023 CAP 863, 2023 CZN 865, 2023 REG 106) as recommended by the hearing examiner. Vote: 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - IMH Products Waiver (2024 A008): Letitia Ramsey, DMD compliance manager, presented the waiver request. No public comment. Approved. - Republic Polymers & Blue Polymers Tax Abatements (2024 A003-A006): Attorney Josh Minkler (Barnes & Thornburg) appeared on behalf of the companies. He confirmed that a prior stop work order had been resolved, all permits are now in compliance, and foundation construction is underway. He committed to reporting back before the full building permit is issued in April. Commissioner Blackburn asked about recycling of electronics; Alex from Blue Polymers explained that the facility handles only plastics (2-7), and electronics should go to authorized recyclers like Technology Recyclers, Recycle Force, or ERI. The commission approved the four abatements. Vote: 8-0. - Modified Commitment for Decatur Township (2023 CAP 856): Attorney Bill Nemeyer requested withdrawal of the companion petition (2023 CVR 856) and narrowed the request to modify commitment two at 6345 West Thompson Road. The change allows an office for a painting business with up to four business vehicles, two of which may park overnight (previously one). Pat Andrews, representing the Decatur Township Civic Council, stated the civic council now supports the modified commitment. Staff also recommended approval. No remonstrators. Vote: 8-0. Discussion Items - Republic Polymers Compliance: President Dillon raised concerns about a stop work order. Attorney Minkler explained that the issue was with the developer, not Republic, and has been resolved. The commission will receive a report in April. - Arbor Homes Rezoning (2023 ZON 117): Caitlin Dofer, Director of Entitlement for Arbor Homes, presented a proposal for a 244-lot subdivision called Middleton at 11015 and 11127 East 46th Street (Lawrence Township). The project includes two products: traditional Arbor Homes (single-family homes from 1,200 to 3,200 sq. ft.) and a new Genesis product (attainable homes in the mid- to high-$200,000s, 1,100 to 1,900 sq. ft., with no shared walls). The Genesis homes are designed to be more affordable by using smaller lots, efficient construction, and prototypes currently being built in Pike Township. Density is 3.29 units per acre. Traffic study and commitments have been addressed. Staff recommended approval. Commissioners discussed lot sizes, parking, and the potential for converting the Genesis product to traditional homes if needed. The commission approved the rezoning. Vote: 8-0. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous (8-0). - Approved tax abatements for Republic Polymers and Blue Polymers, contingent on continued compliance and a progress report in April. - Approved a modified commitment for the painting business at 6345 West Thompson Road, with the civic council’s support. - Rezoned 75.5 acres for the Middleton subdivision, with a mix of single-family homes and an affordable Genesis product. - Granted continuances for two petitions: 2023 ZON 101 (to March 20, 2024) and 2023 CZN 858 (to March 6, 2024), due to pending commitments. - Withdrawn petition: 2023 ZON 114 (2307 Post Drive) at the petitioner’s request. - The commission expressed interest in touring the Genesis prototype homes in Pike Township.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 convened on February 20, 2024, at 18:15. Only two board members were present (Joanna Taft, acting chairperson, and Ray Anna Bender), resulting in a lack of quorum. As a result, no official votes could be taken on any petitions. The meeting was used to process continuances and transfers for all scheduled cases. Each petitioner or their representative came forward to select a new hearing date: either March 5, 2024 (Board 1), March 12, 2024 (Board 2), or March 19, 2024 (Division 3). One case was continued to April 16, 2024 (Division 3). Staff had no objection to any continuance request. The meeting adjourned after all cases were handled. Discussion Items The chair explained that due to lack of quorum, all items would need to be continued. Each case was called individually, and the petitioner or representative stated their preferred new date. The following continuances were granted: - 2023 UV 3022 (8345 Bash Street): Continued and transferred to Board 1 on March 5, 2024. (Represented by David Gilman) - 2024 DB 3001 (6027 Castle Bar Circle): Continued to Division 3 on March 19, 2024. (Represented by Russell Brown) - 2023 SE 3005 (6179 East 26th Street): Continued to Division 3 on March 19, 2024. (Represented by Marco) - 2024 DB 3002 (6161 East 82nd Street): Continued and transferred to Board 1 on March 5, 2024. (Represented by Jason Lucas) - 2023 UV 3026 (4328 East Michigan Street): Continued and transferred to Board 1 on March 5, 2024. (Represented by Robert Macintar) - 2024 UV 3001 (1615 West Edgewood Avenue): Continued and transferred to Board 1 on March 5, 2024. - 2023 DB 3050 (805 and 825 South Kitley Avenue): Continued to Division 3 on April 16, 2024. (Represented by Murray Clark; requested later date due to conflict) - 2023 UV 1023 (7217 Woodland Drive): Continued and transferred to Board 2 on March 12, 2024. (Represented by Joe Calderon) - 2023 SE 3006 (1140 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street): Continued to Division 3 on March 19, 2024. (Represented by Aaron Adelman) - 2023 UV 3024 (2745 and 2815 Curry Road): Continued to Division 3 on March 19, 2024. (Represented by Joe Calderon) - 2024 DV 303 (3308 North Mitthoeffer Road): Continued to Division 3 on March 19, 2024. (Represented by Joe Calderon) Staff confirmed no objection to each continuance. Key Outcomes - No petitions were heard or decided due to lack of quorum. - All 11 scheduled cases were continued to future dates as listed above. - The meeting was adjourned after all continuances were processed.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 2 convened on February 13, 2024, at 6:00 PM. The board unanimously elected officers for 2024, addressed procedural requests, and decided several variance and special exception petitions. Notable cases included a fence height variance, a billboard relocation, and an oil change facility, each involving detailed testimony and board deliberation.
The Metropolitan Development Commission of Marion County convened on Wednesday, February 7, 2024, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The meeting covered downtown placemaking contracts, economic development area expansions, tax abatements, and decisions on two contested zoning appeals, including a denial of a food truck rezoning and approval of a Habitat for Humanity subdivision. Consent Calendar - Meeting Minutes: Approved the minutes from the January 17, 2024 meeting. - Policy Resolutions (8 items): The commission voted 7-0 to approve a block of items without public hearing: - 2024-R-002: Downtown Indy Inc placemaking agreement amendment for Georgia St. and Monument Circle (additional $300,000, total cap $1,000,000). - 2024-R-003: Indianapolis Cultural Trail, Inc. placemaking agreement amendment for Lugar Plaza, Downtown Canal, and Georgia St. (additional $200,000, total cap $1,475,000). - 2024-E-005: Declaratory Resolution to create the Allison Pointe Economic Development Area and Allocation Area (Council District 3, Washington Township). - 2024-E-008: Extension of the maturity date of a loan to the Indianapolis Housing Agency through December 31, 2025. - 2024-E-009: Legal services contract with Taft Stettinius & Hollister, LLP for the acquisition of the John Marshall School (not to exceed $40,000). - 2024-E-010: CMT contract amendment for the 10th and Rural infrastructure project (not to exceed $2,738,094.25) and authorization to use excess TIF revenue. - 2024-A-007: Preliminary Economic Revitalization Area Resolution for Calumet Specialty Products Partners, L.P. (4 years personal property tax abatement). - 2024-P-003: Appointment of Anne-Marie Taylor as backup Hearing Examiner for 2024 ($5,000). - Zoning Petitions of No Appeal (3 items): Approved without public testimony: - 2023-MOD-021 (10 S. Mickley Ave): Modification of commitments to allow a gas station. - 2023-ZON-120 (9501 36th Place): Rezoning by Indianapolis Public Schools for a non-profit center. - 2023-CZN-867 (2233 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. St): Rezoning for an existing two-family dwelling. - Continuances: The E Solutions, LLC and Edwards Electrical & Mechanical real and personal property tax abatement requests (2024-A-001 and 2024-A-002) were continued to the March 6, 2024 meeting. A scrivener's error in the Calumet resolution packet was corrected to reflect the final hearing date of April 17, 2024. Public Comments & Testimony Public Hearings on Policy Items - 2024-E-006 (Brookville Road/Irvington Plaza EDA Expansion): Emily Scott of DMD presented the confirmatory resolution, stating staff support for the expansion to include additional industrial sites to generate positive TIF increment for infrastructure investment. No remonstrators spoke. - 2024-P-002 (Chapel Hill Park Master Plan): Carmen Lethig of DMD presented the comprehensive plan amendment, stating staff support to allow the construction of new park amenities per the plan. No remonstrators spoke. Contested Zoning Appeal: 2023-ZON-116 (2002 N. Tibbs Ave) - Petitioner Hugo Rubin de Celis: Appealed the hearing examiner's denial of a rezoning from D-5 to C-3 to operate a lot for 8-10 food trucks. He stated he surveyed neighbors who were receptive and submitted a petition in support. Upon questioning by Commissioner Murphy, he proposed hours of 6 AM to 10 PM Monday through Thursday and 6 AM to midnight Friday and Saturday. He argued the development would improve safety through lighting and cameras. - Staff: Recommended denial, stating the C-3 commercial district would be an "undue intrusion into a long-established residential area," negatively impacting quality of life with increased traffic, noise, and lighting demands. Staff noted the lack of a plan of operation. Contested Zoning Appeal: Habitat for Humanity (3838 E. 46th St) A set of companion petitions from Habitat for Humanity of Greater Indianapolis for the "Devon Creek" subdivision, rezoning 4.22 acres from SU-1 to D-5, a variance for a stream corridor access drive, and a subdivision plat. - Petitioners Chris Barnett and CEO Jim Morris: Presented the project, highlighting Habitat's 37-year history of providing affordable homeownership (833 homes built, zero-interest mortgages). They argued the development is consistent with the Millersville-Fall Creek Village and Corridor Plan (3.5-5 units per acre proposed as 3 units per acre), and committed to restrictions against multi-family, brick facades, and landscaping requested by Councilor Gibson. They noted the current SU-1 zoning allowed a large religious building (512 seats, 128 parking spaces) which was never built. - Remonstrator Russ Sipes and Traffic Engineer Brad Yarger: Representing neighbor Michael Chenoweth, they argued the D-5 district is inappropriate for this suburban area and would endanger residents. Mr. Yarger presented speed data showing 46th Street has a 45 mph limit but an 85th percentile speed of 56 mph, with vehicles clocked over 70 mph. He cited a pedestrian fatality in April 2023 on the same street and a lack of pedestrian facilities, making the area unwalkable. - Staff: Recommended approval. Staff stated the project meets the density recommendations of the area plan, the D-5 design objectives, and could act as a traffic calming measure on 46th Street. Staff supported the right-of-way vacation and sidewalk waiver due to topography constraints. Discussion Items - E-Solutions Abatement Continuance: Staff requested the real and personal property tax abatements for Edwards Electrical & Mechanical and E Solutions be continued as the company was not prepared to present to the committee. The commission voted 7-0 to continue the items to March 6, 2024. - Habitat for Humanity Board Deliberation: Commissioner Murphy recused herself from the vote on the subdivision plat (2023-CPL-859). The remaining commissioners discussed the commitments and conditions provided by the petitioner before voting. Key Outcomes - Approved: Brookville Road/Irvington Plaza EDA Expansion (7-0). - Approved: Chapel Hill Park Master Plan amendment (7-0). - Approved: 8 policy resolutions, 3 no-appeal zoning petitions, and meeting minutes on consent calendar. - Denied: 2023-ZON-116 (Tibbs Avenue food truck rezoning) – 7-0 vote. - Approved: Habitat for Humanity Devon Creek Subdivision: - Rezoning (2023-CZN-859): Approved 7-0. - Variance of Development Standards (2023-CVR-859): Approved 6-1. - Subdivision Plat (2023-CPL-859): Approved 6-0-1 (Commissioner Murphy recused). - Continued: E-Solutions tax abatements to March 6, 2024.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 met on February 6, 2024, at 1:00 PM (local time) under Chairperson Peter Nelson. Board members present included David Duncan, Jennifer Witt, and Natalia Rodriguez Hilt. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz. Staff from the Division of Planning presented reports. The meeting handled special requests, continuances, an expedited docket, and two contested regular petitions. Key outcomes included approval of three expedited variances, denial of a special exception for a billboard relocation inside I-465, and approval of a variance for outdoor operations at a fitness center subject to commitments. Special Requests and Continuances - 2024 DV1001 (4120 North Illinois Street): Moved to expedited docket by motion (vote: 4-0). - 2024 DV1002 (5449 North Pennsylvania Street): Moved to expedited docket (vote: 4-0). - 2024 PTN014: Filing fee reduced from $1,970 to $550 per staff recommendation (vote: 4-0). - 2023 UV1021 (7040 Rockville Road): Continued to March 5, 2024, as a final continuance (vote: 4-0). - 2023 UV1027 (7425 Westfield Boulevard): Continued to March 6, 2024, with $579 fees transferred to a new rezoning petition (vote: 4-0). - 2023 UV1028 (Westfield Boulevard): Withdrawn with board acknowledgement. - 2024 DV1003 (7219 92nd Street): Automatically continued to March 5, 2024, due to a timely continuance request from Pike Township Residence Association. Expedited Docket - 2024 DV1001 – Variance for building additions (4-foot side yard vs. 7-foot required): Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2024 DV1002 – Variance for building additions (9-foot rear yard vs. 20-foot required): Approved unanimously (4-0). - 2024 DV1004 – Variance for carriage house construction (8-foot rear yard and encroachment in clear site triangle): Approved unanimously (4-0). Public Comments & Testimony - On 2023 SE2001A (billboard relocation): Multiple remonstrators spoke. Pat Andrews represented Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations and Decatur Township Civic Council, reading a list of 12 opposing organizations. Vernon Compton (Martindale Brightwood) stated the neighborhood opposes the billboard inside I-465. Chris Staub (Near Eastside Community Organization) cited Municipal Code 74491 and prior denials of similar petitions. Tom O’Beale (Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis) emphasized the 1971 ban on billboards inside I-465. Councillor Jesse Brown (District 13) argued that billboards correlate with economic devastation and urged upholding the ban. Gary Chuluthov asked whether the petitioner had exhausted permitted locations outside I-465. - On 2024 UV101 (outdoor fitness center): Staff noted that three residents along Adell Drive submitted letters opposing the variance due to noise concerns. The Franklin Township Civic League also expressed opposition despite discussions on mitigation. Discussion Items - 2023 SE2001A – Reagan Outdoor Advertising: Petitioner Michelle Knoppenberger sought a special exception and height variance to relocate a billboard from 1720 West Thompson Road to 2400 Roosevelt Avenue inside I-465 due to the I-69/State Road 37 expansion. Staff recommended approval of the special exception only, but the board had to determine whether the height variance (60 feet vs. 40-foot limit) was already denied by Division 2 in December 2023. Board counsel confirmed the height variance was part of a prior vote and could not be reconsidered. The board voted solely on the special exception. On roll call, Rodriguez Hilt voted no, Duncan yes, Witt no, Nelson no – resulting in denial (3-1). - 2024 UV101 – MEI Fitness: Petitioner Andy Wirt requested a variance for outdoor operations (fitness area) at 5914/5920 East Stop 11 Road. The fitness center, owned by Mel Rivera, proposed a 48'x75' fenced area with shade structures, accessible only through the building. Staff recommended denial, citing lack of hardship, incompatibility with C-3 zoning, and negative externalities. The petitioner offered four commitments: no loudspeakers, vinyl fencing, landscaping, and the variance being tied to the current tenant. The board approved the variance unanimously (4-0) with those commitments made binding. Key Outcomes - 2023 SE2001A (special exception) – Denied (3-1). The board determined the height variance had already been voted on by Division 2; only the special exception was before them. Negative findings of fact will include the height variance. - 2024 UV101 (variance of use) – Approved (4-0) with commitments: no outdoor loudspeakers, vinyl fencing, landscaping substantially similar to the site plan, and the approval is personal to the petitioner. The case will be continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Continuances and expedited approvals – All moved as noted above. - Next hearing – March 5, 2024 (Division 1) for continued cases.
The Metropolitan Development Commission convened on January 17, 2024, at 6:00 PM to consider resolutions, continuances, and two public hearings. All votes were unanimous 7-0. The main agenda item was a rezoning petition for a proposed housing hub for people experiencing homelessness. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the January 3, 2024 meeting were approved. - Six policy resolutions were approved en bloc: 2024 R001 (authorizing DMD to dispose of property at 1322 Columbia Avenue), 2024 E001 (authorizing up to $1 million for financial services to support businesses owned by disproportionately impacted classes), 2024 E003 (amending a services agreement with CAT Consulting LLC and assigning rights to the CAC), 2024 E004 (declaratory resolution for expanding a consolidated redevelopment area as a housing hub allocation area), 2024 E007 (granting $300,000 in 2024 for City Market maintenance and operation), and 2024 P001 (appointing a backup hearing examiner and plan commission member). All passed 7-0. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were offered on the consent calendar items. - For the rezoning petition 2023 ZON 121, three remonstrators spoke in opposition: John Maveris (958 East Georgia Street), Thomas Gormley (963 East Georgia Street), and Daniel Paul Graff (1110 Bait Street). They expressed concerns about lack of prior community engagement, potential negative impacts on property values and neighborhood safety, security arrangements, and the “low barrier” model. John Maveris noted that he had invested in the area for a decade and is now considering moving. Daniel Graff stated that despite promises, petitioner representatives never visited their homes. - David Kingan (618 East Market) spoke in support, emphasizing that the final site plan would address many concerns. Discussion Items - Continuances and Withdrawals: - 2023 CAP/CVR 856 (requested by Bill Nemeyer) was continued to February 21 with new notice, as required by staff. - 2023 ZON 055 (approved in December) was formally withdrawn after financing fell through; the withdrawal was acknowledged before City-County Council action. - 2023 ZON 101 and 2023 CZN 863 were continued to February 21 without notice at the request of staff. - No Appeals Docket: Four petitions (2023 ZON 072, 088, 113, and 2023 CZN 803) were approved without appeal. - Plat Petition 2023 PLT 101: A subdivision plat for Mount Perrin Hope Subdivision (19.464 acres into two lots) was approved 7-0, subject to ten conditions from the staff report. The petition had been transferred from the Plat Committee due to a tie vote. - Rezoning Petition 2023 ZON 121: The petitioner, RHC Shelby Street LLC (an affiliate of RDOR/Merchants Affordable Housing), requested rezoning from I-4 (industrial) to CS-TOG (commercial specific) to develop a “housing hub” at 1007–1030 Shelby and Bait Streets. The proposed facility would include day services, emergency shelter, master-leased apartments, a health center, and supportive services for up to 150–200 residents. Petitioner Brian Twee, along with Andrew Merkley (City Division of Homelessness) and developer Brian Kahn, argued the site is well-served by transit (Blue and Red lines) and consistent with the comprehensive plan’s pattern book and transit-oriented plans. Staff (Kathleen) recommended approval, noting the area is transitioning from industrial to residential. Three remonstrators raised concerns about insufficient community input, security, funding uncertainty, and potential harm to nearby home values. Petitioner rebutted with examples of successful supportive housing near high-value properties (e.g., Wheeler Mission area). The commission approved the petition 7-0 with three commitments, including an amended right-of-way dedication (unless DPW waives or adjusts). Key Outcomes - All six policy resolutions passed 7-0. - Three continuances and one withdrawal were granted as requested. - The “no appeals” docket (four petitions) passed 7-0. - Plat petition 2023 PLT 101 was approved 7-0 with conditions. - Rezoning petition 2023 ZON 121 was approved 7-0 with three commitments, including the amended right-of-way language.