The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, met on January 16, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Acting Chair Joanna Taft presided over the meeting with members Roger Bohannon and Rayanna Bender. Due to having only three members present, all votes required unanimity; indecisive votes (2-1) automatically resulted in continuances to the next meeting. The board addressed continuances, withdrawals, expedited cases, and three non-expedited variance petitions. Consent Calendar - Expedited Cases: After a waiver of rules of procedure, the board voted on three expedited petitions collectively. All were approved unanimously: - 2023 DV 2037: Variance of development standards at 8120 Sycamore Road (Town of Williams Creek) for a building addition with reduced front yard setback and open space. - 2023 UV 2017: Variance of use at 1701 West 18th Street for a daycare facility for children up to 12 years old (limited to under 6). - 2023 DV 3053: Variance of development standards at 1711 Ringold Avenue for construction of a single-family dwelling with reduced side yard setbacks. Public Comments & Testimony - Procedural Inquiry: Robert McIntyre, petitioner for 2023 UV 3026 (4328 East Michigan Street), questioned the continuance process, noting he believed five days' notice was required. Staff clarified that the continuance was granted as a "for cause" request (not automatic) after the deadline, and no opposition was voiced. The board acknowledged the continuance. Discussion Items - 2023 UV 1023 – Enterprise Car Rental at 7217 Whitland Drive: Petitioner Joseph Calderon requested a variance of use to operate a car and truck rental facility in a C4 zone. He argued the use is less intense than permitted uses, has support from Pike Township Residents Association and Park 100 South Owners Association, and repurposes a vacant Hardee's building. Staff recommended denial, stating the use is a C7 use not permitted in C4, and no practical difficulty prevents redevelopment with a C4 use. The board voted 2-1 in favor (Taft and Bohannon yes, Bender no), resulting in an indecisive vote and continuance to February 20, 2024. - 2023 DV 3050 – Fence Height at 805/825 South Kitley Avenue: Petitioner Murray Clark, on behalf of KK Fence, sought a variance to allow an 8-foot tall fence in the front yard (ordinance max 6 feet). The fence had already been installed. The petitioner cited security concerns, community support from Councillor Hart, Warren Township Development Association, and neighbors. Staff recommended denial, noting a 6-foot fence would serve the same purpose and the front yard did not store dangerous materials. The board voted 2-1 in favor (Bender and Taft yes, Bohannon no), resulting in an indecisive vote and continuance to February 20, 2024. - 2023 DV 3051 – Side Setbacks at 3449 North Kenwood Avenue: Petitioner Tony Hurt initially requested a variance for both a 27-foot front building line and 3-foot side yard setbacks. After staff clarified that the front setback could be reduced to comply with ordinance (19.9 feet max), the petitioner withdrew the front setback request. Staff recommended approval of the side yard variances. The board voted unanimously to approve the side setback variances. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: - 2023 UV 3022 (8345 Bash Street) – continued to February 20, 2024, without notice. - 2023 SE 3005 (6179 East 26th Street) – continued to February 20, 2024, with additional notice. - 2023 SE 3006 (1140 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street) – continued to February 20, 2024. - 2023 UV 3024 (2745/2815 Curry Road) – automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2023 UV 3026 (4328 East Michigan Street) – continued to February 20, 2024 (for cause). - Withdrawals: - 2023 DV 3046 (6415 East 82nd Street) – withdrawn, acknowledged. - 2023 UV 3027 (350 South Midhoffer Road) – withdrawn; refund of $982.75 approved. - Approvals: All three expedited cases approved unanimously. 2023 DV 3051 (side setbacks only) approved unanimously. - Indecisive Votes (Continued to Feb 20, 2024): 2023 UV 1023 (Enterprise rental) and 2023 DV 3050 (fence height).
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Board of Zoning Appeals No. 2 convened on January 9, 2024, at 6:00 PM. Due to an insufficient number of board members present to form a quorum, the board could not hear its regular docket of cases. Instead, Acting Chair James Duke acknowledged automatic continuances, withdrawals, and exercised discretion to transfer several cases to other board divisions or future dates. No public comments or testimony were received. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments or testimony were provided during the meeting. Discussion Items - 2023 SC2-02 (3210 Chief Lane): Petitioner submitted an automatic continuance to the February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. Acknowledged. - 2023 DV2 036 (7508 Central Avenue): Registered neighborhood organization filed an automatic continuance to February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. Acknowledged. - 2023 DV2 038 (8245 Allisonville Road): City-County Councillor Boots filed an automatic continuance to February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. Acknowledged. - 2023 UV 2015 (7069 Riverfront Avenue): Petitioner filed a written request for withdrawal. Acknowledged. - 2023 DV2037 (8120 Sycamore Road): Petitioner (Joe Calderon) requested transfer to BZA 3 on January 16, 2024. Staff had no objection. Transfer acknowledged. - 2023 UV 1023 (7217 Woodland Drive): Petitioner (Joe Calderon) requested transfer to BZA 3 on January 16, 2024. Staff had no objection. Transfer acknowledged. - 2023 UV 2014 (35 East Morris Street): Staff originally requested a continuance; petitioner changed direction to a rezoning. The board continued this case to the February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. - 2023 UV 2017 (1701 West 18th Street): Petitioner Jamaica Cooper requested transfer to BZA 3 on January 16, 2024. Staff had no objection. Transfer acknowledged. - 2023 SE2001A (2400 Roosevelt Avenue): The petitioner requested transfer to Division 1 on February 6, 2024. The remonstrators (represented by Pat Andrews) requested February 13, 2024. After discussion, the board decided to transfer to BZA 1 on February 6, 2024, with the understanding that remonstrators could request a continuance if unable to attend. - 2023 UV 1024 (6524 Dover Road): City-County Councillor Boots, representing remonstrators, requested continuation to February 13, 2024. Staff had no objection. Acknowledged. - 2023 DB2034 (1949 Alvard Street): Neighbor John Parlberg was present; the petitioner was absent. The case was automatically continued to February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. - 2023 DV2 035 (5602 North Keystone Avenue): Attorney Tim Oakes, for the petitioner, agreed to continue to February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing. Staff had no objection. Acknowledged. - 2023 SE2002: Previously acknowledged as part of automatic continuances. Key Outcomes - All cases were either continued to February 13, 2024, BZA 2 hearing, transferred to other BZA divisions on earlier dates, or withdrawn as noted. - No votes were taken due to lack of quorum; all actions were acknowledgments or administrative transfers by the chair.
The Metropolitan Development Commission of Indianapolis convened on January 3, 2024, at 18:00 UTC. The meeting focused on administrative approvals, continuances, and a consent docket of no-appeal petitions. All motions passed unanimously (6-0). Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the November 15, 2023 meeting (4-0). - Approved the minutes of the December 20, 2023 meeting (voice vote, all in favor). Discussion Items - Continuances Requested by Staff Due to Lack of Commitments: - 2023 ZON101 (3905 East Draymond Street and 3810/3912 Bethel Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2024. Staff cited pending receipt of commitments; petitioner's attorney indicated commitments were received but legal description issues remained. - 2023 ZON072 (2143 and 2145 South Emerson Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2024. Staff cited lack of submitted commitments. - 2023 CZN803 (3601 North Kidley Avenue and 6535 Massachusetts Avenue): Continued to January 17, 2024. Attorney Joe Calder (11 South Meridian) acknowledged commitments were signed but had not yet been notarized, assured completion by the next hearing. - No-Appeal Docket (8 Petitions) Approved as a Whole: - 2023 MOD 018 (4411 Wild Pheasant Lane, Franklin Twp, Council Dist. 25) - 2023 ZON 100 (4509/4585 Allisonville Rd & 2828 E 45th St, Washington Twp, Council Dist. 9) - 2023 ZON 104 (2920/2990 N Arlington Ave, Warren Twp, Council Dist. 13) - 2023 ZON 107 (2831 E 38th St, Center Twp, Council Dist. 9) - 2023 ZON 108 (1102 E Stop 11 Rd, Perry Twp, Council Dist. 24) - 2023 ZON 110 (2837 E New York St & 253 N Rural St, Center Twp, Council Dist. 17) - 2023 REG 092 (126 W Georgia St, Center Twp, Council Dist. 16) - 2023 REG 095 (838 Greer St, Center Twp, Council Dist. 16) Key Outcomes - Motion to appoint Michael James as acting secretary passed without objection. - All three continuances (2023 ZON101, 2023 ZON072, 2023 CZN803) were moved to the January 17, 2024 hearing; each passed 6-0. - All eight no-appeal petitions were approved as a whole by a vote of 6-0. - Meeting adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 held a public hearing on January 2, 2024. Acting Chairperson Andrew Catona presided, joined by board members Jennifer Witt and Patrice Ducket Brown, with Chris Steinmetz serving as legal counsel. The board reviewed expedited petitions, continuances, and two fully contested cases. Consent Calendar - The board unanimously approved a waiver of rules to vote on the expedited docket without individual testimony. - Continuances: Automatic continuances were acknowledged for petitions 2023 UV 1027 (7425 Westfield Blvd) and 2023 UV 1028 (7429 Westfield Blvd) to the February 6, 2024 hearing, filed by a registered neighborhood organization. The board acknowledged amended commitments for 2023 DB 1056 (3777 West 69th St), with staff continuing to recommend approval. - Expedited Docket (Approved 3-0): - 2023 DV 1056: Variance for a detached garage (7 ft west side yard vs. 15 ft required) and a free standing shed (4.5 ft east side yard) at 3777 West 69th St. - 2023 DV 1059: Variance for 7% facade transparency on a proposed convenience market at 3835 East 96th St (40% required). - 2023 DB 1060: Variance for setbacks and main floor square footage for single-family dwellings at 1202-1244 Hartford St (1 ft front yard setback vs. 10 ft required, 3 ft rear yard vs. 20 ft required, 634/660 sq ft main floor vs. 720 sq ft required). Discussion Item: Petition to Terminate Commitment (2023 AP 1002 - 1001 North Rural Street) Proposal: The petitioner requested the termination of Commitment No. 10, a condition of a 2008 variance (2008 DV 1058) for the gas station at 1001 North Rural Street, which prohibited the sale of cigarette or tobacco rolling papers. Petitioner Position: Miranda Steele, on behalf of Harsh Pre Inc., argued the commitment creates a competitive disadvantage compared to nearby gas stations that sell rolling papers, which is a use permitted by right in the C3 district. She stated the restriction diverts customers and revenue to other stations. Remonstrator Position: Chris Staub, President of the Near Eastside Community Organization (NESCO), opposed the termination. He reported that the Brookside Neighborhood Association, Rivelee Park Neighborhood, and the NESCO Board of Directors had all voted against termination. He cited the historical need for the commitment due to public safety concerns at the former business on the site and noted prior code enforcement violations. Staff Position: Staff provided no recommendation, noting they were not party to the original commitment and that the sale of rolling papers is a permitted use by right. Key Outcome: The board voted 3-0 to deny the petition (2023 AP 1002). Members Catona, Witt, and Ducket Brown all voted no, citing a lack of neighborhood support for the request. Discussion Item: Variance for Carriage House (2023 DV 1054 - 530 West 44th Street) Proposal: Petitioner James Hall requested variances to construct a carriage house with a secondary dwelling unit. The variances sought were for a 754 sq ft structure (720 sq ft max), a 5-foot corner side yard setback from Sunset Avenue (10 ft required), and a 2.5-foot rear yard setback (5 ft required). Petitioner Position: Mr. Hall stated the design was necessary to accommodate a functional two-car garage, storage, mechanicals, and an interior stairwell, which he argued was safer and provided better tenant privacy than an exterior staircase. He confirmed the primary residence would remain owner-occupied. No remonstrators appeared in opposition. Staff Position: Staff recommended denial, arguing the practical difficulty was self-imposed because the structure could be redesigned (e.g., reducing the living space or placing stairs outside) to meet code standards. Staff believed the deviations should relate to the site, not the owner's preferences. Key Outcome: The board voted 3-0 to approve the variances (2023 DV 1054). Members Ducket Brown, Catona, and Witt all voted yes, rejecting the staff's recommendation of denial.
The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held a public meeting on December 20, 2023, at 6:00 PM EST. The meeting included approval of multiple resolutions, a TIFF presentation, and three public hearings. Notable actions included approval of a rezoning for a 208-unit multifamily development on Westfield Boulevard, a hotel height modification, and a gas station convenience store redevelopment. The meeting also featured an announcement about the takeover of Circle Centre Mall by Hendricks Group and a farewell to outgoing Executive Director Rusty Carr. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from December 6, 2023, were approved unanimously. - Group of 11 Resolutions (Non-Public Hearing): The following resolutions were approved 8-0: 2023 R037 (contract with Kinmar LLC for Union Station management), 2023 R038, 2023 E041 (Fall Creek HOTIF funds for alley/sidewalk improvements), 2023 E047 (South Post Road economic development area), 2023 E048 (Irvington TIFF amendment), 2023 E049 (grant funds for greenway trail system), 2023 E050, 2023 E051 (Augusta Heights HOTIF area), 2023 E054 (Alabama Street bond pledge for TWG/Old City Hall project), 2023 BB010 (authorizing public hearing officers), and 2023 P019 (agreement with hearing examiner Judy Wurzhall). - Petitions of No Appeal: Four zoning petitions were approved 7-0: 2023 ZON 068, 2023 ZON 095, 2023 ZON 099, and 2023 ZON 103. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023 E052 – Professional Sports Development Area (Indy 11 Park): Eunice Trotter, representing the Indiana Remembrance Coalition and Indiana Landmarks Black Heritage Preservation Program, spoke about the need to protect Green Lawn Cemetery, where an estimated 1,323 African Americans were interred. She urged the city to conduct discovery processes and follow DNR guidelines, stating that failure to do so could be a Level 6 felony. Her comments were entered into the record. - 2023 ZON 094 – 6729 Westfield Boulevard Rezoning: - Remonstrators: John Coutzman (resident of 6375 Oxbow Way), Lindsay Scott (vice president of Marot Island Community Association), and Melina Kennedy presented opposition on behalf of hundreds of residents. They argued the 208-unit proposal violates the comprehensive plan on density (25.1 units/acre vs. allowed 1–5), height (59 ft vs. max 42 ft per adjacent buildings), and road access (Westfield Boulevard is a two-lane road, not three lanes as required). They offered to support up to 107 units. They also claimed the developer is double‑counting the lake density and that 2003 commitments to Spirit Lake should be honored. - Supporters: Misha Rabinowich and John Hart (JC Hart Company) argued the project was redesigned to comply with the comprehensive plan and pattern book, including reduced density (208 units from original 256), lower building height (59 ft from 75 ft), and environmental enhancements. They noted a traffic study approved by DPW showed no significant impact, and that the project includes a sidewalk and crosswalk improvements. They cited a letter of support from sitting Councilor Keith Potts. - City-County Councilor: John Barth (District 7) expressed support for the remonstrators, stating the community wants responsible development and urging the commission to reject the current proposal. - 2023 MOD 019 – Southport Road Hotel Height Modification: - Remonstrator: Michael Carroll (resident at 5621 Woodworth Way) objected to a three-foot height increase, arguing commitments from 2001 should be upheld. He also contended that an extended-stay hotel is akin to multifamily residential, which was prohibited, and that previous landscaping/berm commitments were not fulfilled. - Petitioner: Russell Brown (attorney) and Al Hill (HDI Hotels) stated the only change is a 3-foot parapet for architectural interest and to screen rooftop equipment. They offered to eliminate illuminated signage on north and east facades as a concession. - 2023 MOD 020 – Shadeland Avenue Gas Station Redevelopment: - Petitioner: Pat Rooney (attorney) and Mike Singh (property owner) argued that the required crosswalk across Shadeland Avenue is unsafe and unnecessary, as the west side has no sidewalks, only a drainage ditch and car dealership. They presented support letters from Warren Township Development Association, Blossom Chevrolet (the dealership across the street), and neighbors. Estimated cost of the crosswalk was $600,000+, which the owner said would put him out of business. They proposed an alternative crosswalk across Pleasant Run Parkway. - Staff/DPW: DPW’s Jill Palmer testified that the alternative crosswalk is not up to code (stop sign precedence). Staff recommended denial, citing safety concerns on the six-lane road and a history of pedestrian crashes. DPW estimated construction costs at $102,000. Discussion Items - TIFF Annual Presentation: Megan Bukasich (Deputy Director of DMD) and Lucas Anderson (OFM) presented the state-required TIFF policy overview and fiscal year 2022 financials. Total TIFF revenues were $159.5 million, expenses $110 million (75.5% debt service). The hypothetical maximum impact on local taxing units if all TIFF increment were released to base units was $76.7 million ($32.4 million to city-county). The presentation was for informational purposes; no vote taken. - 2023 ZON 094 – Detailed Debate: Over two hours of testimony focused on density calculation (whether to count the 13-acre lake as part of the 21.44-acre parcel), comprehensive plan compliance, traffic safety, and the “double dip” density claim. Staff affirmed that density is calculated on the entire legal boundary and that the pattern book guidelines are not hard rules. Commissioner Ash questioned comparables; petitioner cited Shore Acres (24 units/acre) and The Reserve (17.45 units/acre). - 2023 MOD 020 – Crosswalk Dispute: Staff and DPW defended the requirement, noting the area has high pedestrian activity and that informal routes (parking lots, shoulders) are unsafe. The petitioner countered that local residents and businesses oppose the crossing and that DPW had no master plan for the west side. Key Outcomes - 2023 E052 – Professional Sports Development Area: Approved 7-0 (Commissioner Schumacher recused). The confirmatory resolution creates the area for Indy 11 Park, subject to further state and financing steps. - 2023 E053 – Alabama Street Redevelopment Project Area: Approved 8-0. Creates a TIF allocation area for Old City Hall redevelopment by TWG. - 2023 A041 – Tax Abatement for 22nd and Monon Multifamily: Approved 8-0. 10-year real property tax abatement for a 192-apartment and 16-townhome project. - 2023 A042 – Tax Abatement for Patch Washington Street Industrial: Approved 8-0. 7-year abatement with an amended inclusivity plan directing donation to the Area 31 program (housing/job training) and landscaping improvements on a nearby roundabout. - Walk-On Resolution 2023 P021 – Technical Correction: Approved 8-0. Corrects the contract amount with Elizabeth K. Williams landscape architects for Indiana Avenue planning. - 2023 ZON 094 – 6729 Westfield Boulevard Rezoning: Approved 8-0 after ballot vote. The rezoning from SU 434 and DPFF to DPFF allows 208 residential units (192 apartments, 16 townhomes) and modification of 2003 commitments. Conditions include DP statement, site plan, landscape plan, elevations, pedestrian plan, and commitments. - 2023 MOD 019 – Southport Road Hotel Height Modification: Approved 8-0. Allows a 38-foot-tall hotel (from 35-foot limit) with the petitioner’s commitment to eliminate illuminated signage on north/east facades. - 2023 MOD 020 – Shadeland Avenue Gas Station Modification: Approved 5-3. Modifies commitments to allow redevelopment with updated site plan and crosswalk across Pleasant Run Parkway instead of Shadeland Avenue. Other Business - Announcement: President Dillon announced that Circle Centre Mall will be taken over by Hendricks Group, describing it as a “game changer” for downtown Indianapolis after 18 months of negotiations. - Farewell: Rusty Carr, retiring Executive Director of DMD, was recognized for his service and wished well as he moves to the Parks Foundation.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on December 19, 2023, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Joanna Taft, with members Percy Bland, Andrew Cantona (alternate), Roger Pohanon, and Rihanna Binder. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board heard requests for continuances, an expedited docket of five petitions, and three full hearings on variances and special exceptions. The meeting began with a waiver of rules to allow expedited votes and consideration of special requests. Consent Calendar - 2023 SE3-008 (1102 Miley Ave): Special exception for religious uses including a food pantry; variance for a 15.5 ft tall, 1,600 sq ft pole barn with greater floor area and height than the primary dwelling and vehicular access from 11th Street. Approved unanimously (5-0). - 2023 DV3-040 (8850 E 21st St): Variance of development standards to convert an existing motel into a multifamily dwelling with perimeter yards ranging from 0 to 5.5 ft (20 ft required). Approved unanimously. - 2023 DV3-047 (2831 Kristen Dr W): Variance for a detached garage with a 5 ft south side yard setback and a concrete pad with a 2.5 ft setback (15 ft required). Approved unanimously. - 2023 UV3-025 (809 Noble St): Variance of use and development standards to operate a community center and eating establishment with zero off-street parking spaces. Approved unanimously. - 2023 DV3-045 (215 & 217 Dixon St): Variance of development standards for renovation and addition to an existing duplex, resulting in 33% open space (60% required), 2.7 ft north side yard setback (5 ft required), 0 ft south side yard setback, and 6.5 ft front yard setback (10 ft required). Originally a special request, moved to expedited after agreement with neighbors, then approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023 SE3-007 (Reagan Outdoor billboard at 1841 Ludlow Ave): Multiple remonstrators spoke in opposition. Pat Andrews (Decatur Township Civic Council and Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations) led the opposition, joined by Chris Staub (Near East Side Community Organization), Jacqueline Gunn, Marjorie Kenley (Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis), Calvin Gwynn (Indiana Landmarks), and others. They argued that approving the billboard would set a dangerous precedent, reversing a 50-year ban on billboards inside I-465, harm historic neighborhoods (including properties on the National Register), and that the petitioner had not demonstrated a good faith effort to relocate to commercial zones. They contested the legal interpretation of state statute, asserting that the city would not be liable for eminent domain costs because the property was sold before the law changed and the one-year filing window had expired. - 2023 DV3-028 (SRMK Realty fence at 405 S Short Ridge Rd): No remonstrators present. - 2023 UV3-023 (Quak Bowen second dwelling at 3319 Burkett St): No remonstrators present. Discussion Items Case 2023 SE3-007: Reagan Outdoor Advertising billboard relocation - Petitioner Michelle Knoppenberger and Daniel McClendon (Reagan Outdoor corporate counsel) requested a special exception to relocate an off-premise advertising sign due to the I-69/I-465 interchange project (I-69 Finish Line). They also sought variances: increase sign height from 40 ft to 60 ft (amended from 70 ft), reduce setback from I-70 from 60 ft to 5 ft, and reduce radial spacing from other signs from 1,000 ft to 761 ft and 630 ft. They argued that state statute (Ind. Code 8-23-20-25.6) allows relocation within the county, and that denial would shift over $1 million in eminent domain costs to the city. They cited prior approvals for similar relocations. - Staff recommended approval of the special exception but denial of all variances, citing lack of practical difficulty, safety concerns (distraction to motorists), and negative aesthetic impacts on protected districts. - Board vote: Part A (special exception) approved 4-1 (Bohannon dissenting). Part B (variances) denied 0-5. Case continued for adoption of findings of fact. Case 2023 DV3-028: SRMK Realty fence height and electric fence - Petitioner Jamila Mintz (In & Out Unlimited) requested a variance of development standards for a 6 ft tall metal perimeter fence (3.5 ft max in front yards) and a variance of use and development standards for a 10 ft tall electrified fence with warning signs (electric fences and barbed wire not permitted). The property is used for commercial vehicle and RV storage. The petitioner argued the metal fence is for privacy and the electrified fence (described as a pulsating security measure, not lethal) deters theft. A letter of support from the Warren Township Development Association was read. - Staff recommended denial of both, citing excessive height, use of barbed wire (disputed by petitioner), unverified amperage of the electrified fence, and potential dangerous precedent. The petitioner clarified the inner fence uses smooth wire, not barbed wire, and that the owner had been shocked without harm. - Board vote: Part A (6 ft metal fence) approved 4-1 (Taft dissenting). Part B (10 ft electrified fence) denied 0-5. Case continued for findings. Case 2023 UV3-023: Quak Bowen second dwelling at 3319 Burkett St - Petitioner Quak Bowen requested a variance of use to allow a second primary dwelling on a single lot (existing structure built in 1980s, 1,386 sq ft, larger than the 720 sq ft maximum for a secondary unit). He stated he bought the property in 2001 with existing structures, paid fines and back taxes, and now wants to renovate the rear building for rental. The lot is zoned DA (Dwelling Agricultural) and is in a floodplain. - Staff recommended denial, citing the ordinance allowing only one primary dwelling per lot to prevent overdevelopment, and noting the structure exceeds the allowable size for an accessory dwelling. No remonstrators appeared. - Board vote: Approved 3-2 (Bohannon, Catona, Bland in favor; Binder, Taft opposed). Case continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - Expedited docket: All five petitions approved unanimously. - 2023 SE3-007: Special exception approved; all variances denied. Case continued for findings. - 2023 DV3-028: 6 ft metal fence approved; 10 ft electrified fence denied. Case continued. - 2023 UV3-023: Variance approved (3-2). Case continued. - The board also adopted revised findings of fact for 2023 UV3-020 and negative findings of fact for 2023 DV3-041.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division II held a public hearing on December 12, 2023, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Patrice Duckett Brown and Tom Barnes. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz was present. Because only three members were present, three affirmative votes were required to take action on any request. The board considered continuances, an expedited docket, and three contested petitions. Consent Calendar - Adopted a waiver of procedural rules to allow expedited petitions to be voted on without additional testimony. - Granted continuances: 2023 DV2-035 (5602 North Keystone Ave.) to January 9, 2024, without notice; 2023 DV2-030 (3833 East 56th St.) to February 13, 2024, without notice; 2023 SC2002 (3210 Chief Lane) to January 9, 2024; 2023 DV2-032 (911 Sanders St.) to February 13, 2024, without notice, with staff noting this would be the last continuance staff would support; 2023 UV2-015 (listed as 769 Riverfront Ave., later as 7069 Riverfront Ave.) to January 9, 2024, with notice. A three-day waiver of mailed notice was granted for 2023 DV2-034 (1949 Alvord/Alvard St.). Petition 2023 DB2027 (4110 North Illinois) was withdrawn. - Expedited petitions 2023 UV2012 (6328 Sherab Road) and 2023 UV2016 (37 West St. Clair St.) were approved unanimously with three yes votes. Public Comments & Testimony - Patrick Milligan, a neighbor, did not object to the continuance for 2023 DV2-035. - John Parlberg, a neighbor at 1955 Alvord Street, initially expressed uncertainty about the three-day notice waiver but did not object. Later he remonstrated against the side-yard variance, citing drainage, shading, and loss of green space. Vernon Compton (Martindale Brightwood) also opposed the variance. - For the billboard petition (2023 SE2001), multiple remonstrators testified in opposition: Pat Andrews (Decatur Township Civic Council and Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations) argued the billboard would violate the ban on signs inside I-465 and cited impacts on property values and the applicable state law timing; Vernon Compton (Martindale Brightwood One Voice) opposed any changes near I-70; Chris Staub (Near Eastside Community Organization) and David Scott (Spades Park Neighborhood Association) said the billboard would not improve residents' quality of life and could create a harmful precedent; Marjorie Kinley (Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis) noted the sign ordinance was a two-year compromise and that no new billboards inside I-465 was sacred. Discussion Items - Enterprise Rent-A-Car (2023 UV1-023, 7217 Woodland Drive): Attorney Joe Calderan and Jeff Gowdy sought a use variance to convert a vacant former Hardee's restaurant into a car and truck rental facility in a C4 zone. They argued the use is less intense than permitted uses like McDonald's, noted support from the Pike Township Residents Association and Park 100 owners association, and listed commitments (no damaged vehicles, no repair work, trucks stored on the east side, flooding issue on Greenleaf fixed). Staff opposed, stating that intensity is measured by more than traffic, that auto rental is restricted to C5 and large-truck rental to C7/industrial zones, and that commitments do not address staff's concerns. Board members asked about the largest truck (26-foot box truck) and employee numbers. The vote was 2 yes (Duckett Brown, Von Dalen) and 1 no (Barnes), which failed to reach the required three votes; the petition was automatically continued to January 9, 2024. - Reagan Outdoor Advertising sign (2023 SE2001, 2400 Roosevelt Avenue): Petitioner sought a special exception and variances to relocate a billboard taken by INDOT for the I-69 finish line project. The requested variances included a 60-foot height (reduced from 70 feet), a 220-foot separation from an exit roadway center line (500 required), a 6-foot front setback (60 required), and a 130-foot separation from a protected district (300 required). Property owner John Campbell and petitioner Michelle Knoppenberger testified about the property investment, tenant SEAL's support, and the financial burden to Marion County if not approved. Staff supported the special exception and the amended height due to the I-70 road deck, but recommended denial of the other variances, noting the sign could be relocated on the site to meet standards. The board split its ballot: on Part A (special exception and reduced height), votes were 1 yes (Barnes) and 2 no (Von Dalen, Duckett Brown), an indecisive vote, so Part A was automatically continued to January 9, 2024. On Part B (remaining development standards), all three members voted no, so those variances were denied. - Catherine Ramsire / Melissa Ianucci (2023 DV2-034, 1949 Alvord Street): The petitioner requested variances for a 26-foot front building line (19.9 feet max) and four-foot side yard setbacks for a detached garage (five feet required). Staff corrected the zoning to D8, and recommended approval of the front setback due to ambiguity in measurement, but denial of the side setbacks because a 30-foot garage could satisfy the five-foot requirement. The petitioner requested a continuance to discuss with neighbors; the remonstrator opposed because he would be unavailable in January. The board granted a continuance to the next regular hearing (January 9, 2024) without notice. Key Outcomes - All requested continuances and the expedited approvals were granted unanimously. - Enterprise Rent-A-Car petition received 2 yes and 1 no, failing to obtain the necessary three votes; automatically continued to January 9, 2024. - Reagan Outdoor Advertising special exception (with 60-foot height) received 1 yes and 2 no and was automatically continued to January 9, 2024; the associated development-standard variances were denied 3-0. - The Alvord Street petition was continued to January 9, 2024, without a vote on the merits. - The board adopted findings of fact for expedited petition 2023 UV2-012 and negative findings for 2023 DV2-017 (from a September 12 denial).
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on December 6, 2023, to consider several resolutions, including tax abatements, bond issuances, and continuances. The meeting began with a tribute to Deputy Mayor Scarlett Andrew, who is leaving the city on December 15. Minutes from November 15 were approved unanimously. The commission approved multiple resolutions and heard public testimony regarding the Broad Ripple Park Family Center bond. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from November 15, 2023 (7-0). - Resolutions 2023 R036, 2023 E046, 2023 BB007, and 2023 P018 approved (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Michael McKillop, representing Midtown Indy and other community organizations, spoke against the use of Midtown TIF funds for the Broad Ripple Park Family Center purchase. He argued that the proposal violated the intentionality of the TIF district, was rushed without community review, and would concentrate 95% of TIF funds in Broad Ripple, draining equity from the last 11 years. He requested the commission honor the community's long-standing process and not oppose the purchase but seek alternative funding. The commission acknowledged his concerns but noted the City Council's unanimous 24-0 vote in favor. Discussion Items - Resolution 2023 A042 (Patch Washington Street LLC): Continued to December 20, 2023, due to councilor concerns. - Resolution 2023 A041 (DJ BCG Monon 22 LLC): Continued to December 20, 2023, because principals were unavailable. - Resolution 2023 A043 (CTC02 LLC at 910 South Post Road): Approved for up to 7 years of real property tax abatement. The project involves a 69,000-square-foot industrial building, a minimum of 14 jobs at $18/hour, and a partnership with Warren Central's apprenticeship program. The applicant noted it is a speculative project but with strong clawback protections. - Resolution 2023 A044 (Garage Door Doctor LLC and Five-Star Property LLC at 808 South Post Road): Approved for 5 years of real property tax abatement. The tenant (Garage Door Doctor) will occupy the building, moving 48 existing jobs and creating 30 new jobs. The project is not speculative. - Resolution 2023 BB008 (Broad Ripple Park Family Center bond): Approved (7-0) after extensive discussion. Joe Glass (Indianapolis Bond Bank) explained that the $26 million bond is needed to purchase the facility by year-end to avoid escalating costs (purchase price increases $1 million annually and rent of $958,000 would be due in 2024). The bonds will be paid by Midtown TIF revenues and other park revenues. Despite opposition from community representatives, the commission passed the resolution, noting the City Council's unanimous support. - Resolution 2023 BB009 (Near East Side infrastructure bonds): Approved (7-0) for $19 million in bonds to improve infrastructure at 10th Street and Rural Street, including stormwater, pedestrian, and traffic safety improvements. - Continuances: - 2023 APP030 (Haven Health Management): Continued to March 6, 2024, to allow the petitioner to file a new rezoning petition to clarify permitted uses. - 2023 CAP856 and 2023 CVR856 (Thompson Road properties): Continued to January 17, 2024, to allow additional information requested by staff. - 2023 ZON08 (Archdiocese of Indianapolis, Haverstick Road): Continued to January 17, 2024 (vote 6-1, with Commissioner Garver dissenting). The petitioner requested additional time due to a delayed closing caused by the Archbishop's father's death. The commission warned that if not ready on January 17, the petition would be pulled. - No Appeal Docket: 2023 ZON055 (8550 East 21st Street) approved (7-0). Key Outcomes - All resolutions were approved as noted, with majorities of 7-0 except one continuance (6-1). - Continuances were granted as requested, with explicit warnings about readiness for future hearings. - The commission emphasized accountability for tax abatement clawbacks, particularly for speculative projects. - The Broad Ripple Park Family Center bond received strong community opposition but passed due to city council support and financial urgency.
This public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, was called to order by Chairperson Peter Nelson. The board addressed several continuances, transfers, and expedited petitions, along with a contested appeal regarding the legal non-conforming status of a waste processing facility. The meeting included public testimony, staff presentations, and a vote on the appeal. Continuances and Transfers - 2023 DV1 56 (3777 West 69th Street): Continued to January 2, 2024, without additional notice, to allow the petitioner to present to the Pike Township Residents Association. - 2023 UV1 026 (6524 Dover Road): Transferred to Division 2’s January 9, 2024 hearing with new mailed notice, due to petitioner’s travel conflict. - 2023 UV1 021 (7040 Rockville Road): Continued to February 6, 2024, with new notice, to allow research and possible amended petition. - 2023 DV1 058 (7215 East Thompson Road): Continued to January 2, 2024, with notice, at staff’s request for an additional variance. - 2023 UV1 018 (5524 Georgetown Road): Moved to the expedited docket per agreement with staff and no opposition, with the understanding that the grant would not be subject to a site plan review. - 2023 DB 104/59 (3835 East 96th Street): Automatic continuance to January 2, 2024, acknowledged due to a timely filing by an auto-registered neighborhood organization. - 2023 AP 1002 (1001 North Rural Street): Automatic continuance acknowledged. Fee Waiver Request - Petitioner Cameron Parasuti requested a waiver of filing fees for petition 2023 AP 1001. Staff recommended against the waiver, noting fees had already been paid and the request was for a refund. The board took no action after hearing no motion. Expedited Docket – Unopposed Petitions - 2023 DV1 048 (1305 South Biltmore Avenue): Variance for a masonry fence encroaching into a clear site triangle. - 2023 DV1 055 (5326 Riverview Drive): Variance for a detached garage and secondary dwelling unit in the front yard. - 2023 UV1 018 (5524 Georgetown Road): Variance of use for a liquor store. All were approved unanimously by ballot (no opposition noted). Contested Appeal – 2023 AP 1001 (1511–1555 De Loss Street) Cameron Parasuti appealed the administrator’s determination that the waste processing facility operated by Scott Isaacs (Kurt and Jerry Sewer Service/Commercial Grease Trap) is a legally established non-conforming use. The board heard extensive testimony. Petitioner’s Position (Cameron Parasuti, supported by community members and elected officials): - The facility processes grease trap waste and septage in a three-walled structure, causing odor, health impacts, and violations (four IDEM violations in April–May 2023, waste leakage beyond lot lines, and building condition violations). - The property was vacant from 1984 to 1991, so the use was not continuous. Under the 1996 ordinance, a legal non-conforming use must have existed prior to 1969 and continued uninterrupted – which the site does not meet. - The use should be classified as a solid waste facility, requiring a special exception in I4U district, not permitted in I2U. - Performance standards (odor, waste discharge) were violated, and the facility is incompatible with the adjacent residential neighborhood. - Elected officials (Councilor Zach Adamson, Councilor Kristen Jones, Representative Blake Johnson, Senator Andrea Hunley) submitted letters or spoke in support of the appeal, citing health and quality-of-life concerns. Remonstrator’s Position (David Rutherford, attorney for property owner): - The business is properly permitted under IDEM and handles only commercial grease trap waste (no human waste). The dewatering process is an accessory use to the primary plumbing business, established in 1992. - The use was permitted by right in 1992 under the I2U district; 1996 changes do not retroactively affect it. There has been no abandonment – the use has continued since 1992. - Violations have been cured; the business has made operational improvements. The owner is willing to adopt new technology (fractal tank) to further reduce odors, but the neighborhood’s enforcement demands are better handled by IDEM and health departments, not this board. - Staff’s determination that the use is legally non-conforming is correct and should be upheld. Staff Presentation: - Principal Planner Eddie O’Neill and Planning Administrator Matt Pleasant explained that the I2U district allowed the use by right in 1992, prior to 1996 amendments. The use is legally non‑conforming based on 1992 establishment and continuous operation. Staff cited case law supporting that permit issuance history can factor into legal non-conforming status. - Staff clarified that this appeal is about the administrator’s interpretation, not enforcement. A “yes” vote would overturn the administrator’s determination (favoring the petitioner); a “no” vote would uphold it (favoring the property owner). Board Deliberation: - Board members questioned the continuity of use, the relevance of the 1969 date, and the distinction between primary and accessory use. Staff confirmed that the 1992 establishment was as of right, and no abandonment was found. The board also discussed the burden of proof and that the appeal is a fact-finding question. Key Outcomes - Continuances and transfers were approved as outlined above. - Expedited petitions were approved unanimously. - Fee waiver request was denied (no motion made). - Appeal 2023 AP 1001 was denied by a vote of 4–1 (Duncan, Catona, Duke, Nelson voted no; Witt voted yes). The board upheld the administrator’s determination that the facility is a legally established non-conforming use. The case will be continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Revised findings of fact for a prior case (2023 UV1 102) were adopted.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division III, chaired by Joanna Taft, held a public hearing on November 28, 2023, to consider petitions for variances of development standards and a use variance. The board acted on proposals involving fencing, residential setbacks, commercial signage, and a Dollar General Market in a transit-oriented development overlay district. Consent Calendar (Special Requests, Continuances & Expedited Actions) - The board unanimously approved a waiver of its rules to allow consolidated voting on expedited petitions. - Continuances Granted: Petitions 2023 DV3040 (8850 E. 21st St.), 2023 SE3006 (1140 Dr. MLK Jr. St.), 2023 SE3005 (6179 E. 26th St.), and 2023 SE3007 (1841 Ludlow Ave.) were continued to the board's December 19, 2023 hearing. - Other Administrative Items: A two-day notice waiver was granted for 2023 UV3021 (1838 E. Upler Ave.). An additional commitment limiting a proposed freestanding sign to 8 feet was accepted for 2023 DV3042 (6830 Lake Plaza Dr.). - Expedited Approvals (Unanimous): - 2023 DV3042 (6830 Lake Plaza Dr.): Approved 5-0 for a third freestanding sign, subject to the 8-foot height limit. - 2023 UV3017 (5420-5418 McFarland Rd.): Approved 5-0 to legally establish a 19,966 sq. ft. parcel and allow a dwelling with reduced street frontage and side yard setbacks. Public Comments & Testimony Members of the public provided testimony on several agenda items, supporting or opposing specific variance requests: - 2023 DV3039 (Fall Creek Rd. Setback): Neighbors Kenneth Beach, Fiona Devon, and Leno Puente opposed the request, arguing it violated the zoning code they complied with, degraded their viewshed, and raised traffic safety concerns on a road with a documented history of accidents. - 2023 DV3041 (Roosevelt Ave. Skyline Sign): Vernon Compton of Brightwood Concerned Citizens spoke in opposition to prevent sign proliferation and protect community sightlines. - 2023 DV3043 (38th St. TOD Variances): James Kane of the 38th & Franklin Road Neighborhood Association opposed variances, citing traffic safety risks and the need for the developer to adhere to established codes. - 2023 UV3021 (Epler Ave. Commercial Vehicle Storage): Richard Oldham, representing Edgewood United Methodist Church, opposed the use variance, citing concerns over a commercial business operating in a newly rezoned residential area. Discussion Items 2023 DV3035 (2305 N. Leland Ave.) – Fence Height Variance - Proposal: A variance to permit a wooden privacy fence ranging from 8.5 to 9.5 feet tall within the front yards and a clear sight triangle. The maximum permitted fence height in this I-2 industrial zone is 3.5 feet, and encroachment into the sight triangle is not allowed. - Petitioner Position (Philip Chambers / Pat Rooney): The fence is critical for security in a high-crime neighborhood (46218 zip code). Petitioner stated he was initially told a 10-foot fence was allowed. The petition included letters of support from 90% of neighbors and the Warren Township Development Association. - Staff Position: Recommended denial. The fence is over twice the permitted height, creating blind spots and safety hazards. - Outcome: Approved 4-1. (Taft, Bland, Binder, Bohannon voted yes; Rivera voted no). 2023 DV3039 (6422 Fall Creek Rd.) – Front Yard Setback Variance - Proposal: A variance to reduce the required 84-foot front yard setback to 36.17 feet for a single-family dwelling, necessary due to severe topography (floodplain, steep slopes) on a vacant lot. - Petitioner Position (Drees Homes for Sean Clausen): The site constraints make building with the standard setback impractical. Petitioner offered a heritage tree preservation plan. - Remonstrator Position: Neighbors strongly opposed, stating they met the code at great expense and the variance would degrade their viewshed, reduce property values, and create a safety hazard. - Staff Position: Recommended approval, noting the site's practical difficulties and a preference for the proposed side-yard garage configuration. - Outcome: Denied 2-3. (Taft and Binder voted yes; Rivera, Bland, and Bohannon voted no). 2023 DV3041 (1409-1411 Roosevelt Ave.) – Skyline Sign Variance - Proposal: A variance to allow a second skyline sign on the northwestern elevation of a building, where one skyline sign per elevation is permitted. - Petitioner Position (Tim Oakes / Early Learning Indiana): The building’s location abutting a railroad makes other elevations invisible. The petitioner offered commitments to limit skyline signs to two total and prohibit them on the south facade. - Remonstrator Position (Vernon Compton, Brightwood Concerned Citizens): Opposed, stating it would open a “Pandora’s box” for sign proliferation. - Staff Position: Recommended denial, citing a lack of practical difficulty (modern wayfinding tools exist) and the risk of setting a precedent for sign proliferation on large buildings. - Outcome: Denied 1-4. (Bohannon voted yes). 2023 DV3043 (7801 E. 38th St.) – Multiple TOD Variances - Proposal: Five variances for a Dollar General Market in a Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) overlay district, involving building entrance spacing, lot occupancy, front building line, parking location, and driveway width. - Petitioner Position (Misha Rabinowich / Joe Leonard): Strict TOD standards are incompatible with the site’s narrow configuration and location 300 feet from the transit line. The project, in a designated food desert, includes concessions such as narrowed driveways and a crosswalk commitment. Supported by the Warren Township Development Association. - Remonstrator Position (James Kane, 38th & Franklin Road Neighborhood Association): Opposed the three principal variances, citing traffic concerns and code adherence. - Staff Position: Split recommendation. Supported variances for lot occupancy and driveway width (reduced to 30 ft). Opposed variances for the 10-foot front building line (63 ft requested), parking in the front yard, and the remaining driveway width. - Outcome (Split Vote): - Part A (Entry & Lot Width): Approved 4-1. (Taft, Bland, Binder, Bohannon yes; Rivera no). - Part B (Setback, Front Parking & Driveway): Denied 1-4. (Bohannon yes; Taft, Bland, Rivera, Binder no). 2023 DV3044 (2440 W. County Line Rd.) – Pylon Sign Height Variance - Proposal: A variance to increase the height of a pylon sign from the 25-foot maximum to 35 feet for Norma’s Fine Wines and Spirits. - Petitioner Position (John Reader / Brian Toy): The business was forced to relocate by the I-69 expansion. The new site is 25-30 feet below the highway grade with severely reduced visibility. Petitioner committed to no additional primary freestanding signs. No remonstrators were present. - Staff Position: Recommended denial. The sign is intended for interstate visibility, beyond the street-level wayfinding purpose of such signage. - Outcome: Approved 3-2. (Rivera, Binder, Bohannon voted yes; Taft and Bland voted no). 2023 UV3021 (1838 E. Upler Ave.) – Commercial Vehicle Storage Use Variance - Proposal: A use variance to permit the outdoor storage of four commercial utility trailers with 14-foot cargo beds (exceeding the 12-foot limit) in a D3 residential district. - Petitioner Position (Griselda Delgado / Jim Brown): The trailers are needed for a family roofing business. Parking at home provides security against theft. Petitioner offered commitments including a privacy fence, limiting the use to specific trailers, and tying the variance to the current owner. - Remonstrator Position (Richard Oldham, Edgewood United Methodist Church): Opposed. The church rezoned the property for residential use before selling. Concerns included the nature of commercial vehicles and potential business expansion. - Staff Position: Recommended denial. The use is inappropriate for a residential district. The claimed hardship is purely financial. - Outcome: Approved 4-1, subject to the offered commitments. (Rivera, Bland, Binder, Bohannon voted yes; Taft voted no). Key Outcomes - Next Meeting: The board will reconvene on December 19, 2023. - Continuances Granted: Four petitions were continued to the next hearing. - Expedited Approvals: Two petitions were approved unanimously (5-0). - Variances Approved: 2023 DV3035 (4-1), 2023 DV3044 (3-2), 2023 UV3021 (4-1), and 2023 DV3043 Part A (4-1). - Variances Denied: 2023 DV3039 (2-3), 2023 DV3041 (1-4), and 2023 DV3043 Part B (1-4). - The board acknowledged the service of departing member Paula Angarita Rivera.