Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 711–720 ENTRIES
711
SEP 19, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Division 3 Meeting – September 19, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 3, met on September 19, 2023, at 6:00 PM under Chairperson Joanna Taft, with members Paula Rivera, Rayana Binder, Aaron McBride (alternate), legal counsel Chris Steinmetz, and planning staff. The board addressed multiple variance requests, continuances, and waiver petitions. Key actions included approval of a sign variance for a community health center and a tie vote on a landscaping business variance, resulting in an automatic continuance. Consent Calendar - 2023 UV3020 (Tom Loudermilk): Two-day waiver of notice granted (4-0). - 2023 DV3032 (David Kingan): Three-day waiver of mailed notice granted (4-0). - 2023 DV1034 (Mark Crouch): 12-day waiver of notice for amended petition granted (4-0). - 2023 UV3017 (5420 McFarland Road): One-month continuance to October 17, 2023, without additional notice, granted (4-0). - 2023 DV3028 (405 South Short Ridge Road): One-month continuance for further staff review granted (4-0). - 2023 UV3013 (5437 Greenfield Avenue): Withdrawal of petition acknowledged. Discussion Items - 2023 DV3033 – Jane Pauley Community Health Center sign at 537th Street (Warren Township): Petitioner Tammy Ortman requested a variance to legally establish an existing monument sign with a 0.5-foot setback from Downey Avenue and encroaching within the clear sight triangle of East 16th Street and Downey Avenue. The sign has existed since 1965 and was previously determined by court order to be a non-conforming use. Staff noted the sign is in the clear sight triangle, no permit was ever issued for a monument sign, and a prior LNCU petition was denied. Staff made no recommendation. Board members expressed that the sign did not pose a safety hazard or substantial impact on neighboring property values and that the health center needed signage for public access. The variance was approved in a 4-0 vote, with findings of fact to be adopted later. - 2023 UV3020 – Tom Loudermilk landscaping business at 3465 West New Heart Street and 5200 Sandhurst Drive (Perry Township): Petitioner requested a use variance to operate a landscaping business with outdoor storage of trucks, equipment, and materials on a property zoned DA (dwelling/agriculture). Loudermilk stated he used the equipment for both his agricultural pumpkin farm and his landscaping contractor work, and presented 113 signatures of support from neighbors. Staff recommended denial, stating landscaping business use is not permitted in the zone and incompatible with the comprehensive plan. During questioning, board members explored possible compromises such as removing commercial signage and limiting the variance to the petitioner’s ownership. The vote resulted in a 2-2 tie (Rivera yes, Taft no, Binder no, McBride yes), automatically continuing the petition to the October 17, 2023, hearing with a full five-member board. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2023 DV3033 (Jane Pauley sign variance) – unanimous approval (4-0), with findings of fact to be drafted and adopted subsequently. - Continued / Tied: 2023 UV3020 (Loudermilk landscaping business) – tie vote (2-2) automatically continues to October 17, 2023, hearing. - All consent calendar items were granted as listed. - Board reminded petitioners that a four-member board could lead to ties, and offered continuances; none were requested for the two regular cases.

PROCEDURAL 29% · ZONING AND LAND USE 28% · AGRICULTURE 21% · SIGN REGULATION 11%
712
SEP 12, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two - September 12, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two held a public hearing on September 12, 2023, beginning at 6:00 PM. The board considered a special request to waive the 12-month refiling rule, several continuances and withdrawals, expedited docket cases, and five regular docket petitions. Key actions included approval of Butler University's revised variance request, denial of a multi-unit house in a historic neighborhood, and approval of a transitional living facility for at-risk youth. Special Requests & Continuances - Butler University Special Request (DV2010): The board granted a unanimous request to allow Butler University to file a new rezoning petition and companion variance within 12 months of a prior denial. The new proposal removes the height variance (building now under 35 ft), and a rezoning to University Quarter District is planned. Staff supported the request due to substantial differences. - Continuances without notice to October 10, 2023 were granted for: Cecina High School parking variance (2023 DV2-022), monument sign variance (2023 DV2-021), and fence variance (2023 DV2-024). All unopposed. - Withdrawal of case 2023 UV2-004 (2029 Massachusetts Ave) was accepted, with fees transferred to a new case. - Waivers of notice were granted for: 5-day waiver for 2023 DV2-026 (5515 Guilford Ave); 2-day waiver for 2023 DV2-017 amended (717 E 27th St); 3-day waiver for 2023 UV2-008 (1718 SE St); 1-day waiver for 2023 DV2-025 (1449 Olive St). Staff had no objections. Expedited Docket - Four petitions were approved unanimously by voice vote: 2023 DV2-020 (3 ft side yard setback), 2023 DV2-023 (5 ft rear setback), 2023 DV2-025 (single-family dwelling setbacks), and 2023 UV2-009 amended (tattoo parlor separation variance, subject to plan of operation commitment). - Petition 2023 UV2-010 (transitional living) was pulled from the expedited docket after an audience member expressed opposition and was heard in the regular docket. Regular Docket Cases 2023 DV2-015: 1133 S Illinois St (Denied) - Petitioner (Hoosier Renovators LLC, by Mark and Kim Crouch): Requested variances to construct a three-unit multi-unit house on a 30-ft wide lot (35 ft required), with a 3-ft front setback (10 ft required) and zero-ft side setback (2 ft required). Owner Ryan Moeller stated intent to live on site. - Remonstrators (Jim Dewis, Donald and Melissa Dyer): Opposed citing inadequate lot width, damage to adjacent properties during demolition, privacy concerns from balconies, and skepticism about owner occupancy. A letter from Center Township Trustee LaDonna Freeman (not received by staff) was referenced. - Staff: Recommended approval, noting the front setback is consistent with the block and the building meets all other standards. - Vote: 4 no (Ducett Brown, Von Dalen, Barnes, Duke), 1 yes (Brandon) — Denied. 2023 DV2-017 amended: 717 E 27th St (Denied) - Petitioner (Lamon J. Henderson by Myron Cheeks): Requested variances for a three-story duplex on a 3,250 sq ft lot (7,200 sq ft required), reduced main floor area (360 sq ft vs 660 sq ft), 5-ft rear setback (20 ft required), and 44% open space (60% required). Parking garages included due to lack of on-street parking. - Remonstrance: None. - Staff: Recommended denial due to the number and severity of variances; noted the site could be developed with fewer units or single-family. - Vote: 5-0 Unanimous Denial. 2023 DV2-026: 5515 Guilford Ave (Approved) - Petitioner (Anthony and Julia Nicholson by Jerry Myers): Requested a 2-ft north side yard setback for a replacement carriage house (same footprint as original destroyed by tree). Structure not for dwelling, only storage. - Remonstrance: None. Staff and Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association supported. - Staff: Recommended approval; the reduced setback matches historic placement. - Vote: 5-0 Unanimous Approval. 2023 UV2-008: 1718 SE St (Denied) - Petitioner (Captain Mike's Holding Court by Mark and Kim Crouch): Requested variance to operate a bar within 68 ft of a protected district (100 ft required) and a deck encroaching into the right-of-way (originally 2.3 ft, later revised to 6.5 inches). Petitioner argued the establishment is a restaurant-bar; a zoning violation triggered the petition. - Remonstrators (Gina Christopharo and James Bulow of Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association): Opposed due to noise complaints, loitering, and lack of proper permits. They stated they do not oppose a restaurant but oppose a bar. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing self-imposed hardship, insufficient parking, potential noise impact, and retroactive correction of violations. Staff clarified a restaurant is permitted without a variance. - Vote: 5-0 Unanimous Denial. 2023 UV2-010: 4002 Broadway St (Approved) - Petitioner (Eclectic Soul Voices Corporation by Russell Brown): Requested variance to operate a transitional living quarter for up to seven males aged 14–17. The facility, Blossom House, will have 24/7 staff, no external changes, and no on-site visits. A three-year lease exists. Meridian Kessler Neighborhood Association supported. - Remonstrator (Ben Brockman, neighbor): Initially concerned about safety and property values, but after hearing details expressed support for the program. - Staff: Recommended approval; the use is small-scale and fits the residential character. - Vote: 5-0 Unanimous Approval. Key Outcomes - Butler University granted permission to refile a variance petition (height removed, rezoning planned). - Expedited approvals: Four variances approved unanimously (DV2-020, DV2-023, DV2-025, UV2-009 amended). - Denials: Three petitions denied — DV2-015 (4-1), DV2-017 (5-0), UV2-008 (5-0). - Approvals: DV2-026 (5-0) and UV2-010 (5-0). - Other actions: Revised findings of fact adopted for 2022 DV2009; negative findings adopted for two prior petitions.

ZONING AND LAND USE 72% · PROCEDURAL 18% · YOUTH PROGRAMS 5% · ALCOHOL BEVERAGE REGULATION 3%
713
SEP 6, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting - September 6, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission met on September 6, 2023, to consider several resolutions, petitions, and public hearings. The meeting was led by President Dillon, with a special guest leading the Pledge of Allegiance. Key actions included approval of minutes, numerous economic development resolutions, continuances, and two public hearings on rezoning and variance requests. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes from August 16, 2023, with Commissioner Robinson recused. - Approved seven resolutions as a whole (2023 E029, E035, E036, A034, E038, C007, and C008) by a vote of 8-0, with Commissioner Robinson recused on resolution 2023 A034. - Approved continuance of petition 2023 ZON 055 to December 6, 2023, by vote of 8-0. - Approved continuance of petition 2023 ZON 026 to September 20, 2023, by vote of 8-0. - Acknowledged withdrawal of appeal 2023 APP 025. - Approved six petitions of no appeal as a whole by vote of 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made by attendees during the public hearing sections. Only staff and petitioners testified. Discussion Items - 2023 E031 & E032 – County Line Road Economic Development Area: Staff (Ryan Hunt) presented on designating approximately 200 acres as an economic development area to support an industrial park, with infrastructure improvements financed by bonds. Approved 7-1 for E031 and 7-1 for E032. - 2023 E033, E034, E036 – Ingram and Penn Electric Allocation Areas: Staff presented on creating the North Mass Economic Development Area (E033) and two single-site TIF allocation areas for Ingram (E034) and Penn Electric (E036), each supporting separate bonds. All approved 8-0. - 2023 ZON 053 – 2500 Lafayette Road Rezoning: Petitioner Don Fisher (Insight Engineering) requested rezoning 0.762 acres from C4 to C5 to allow vehicle sales at an existing auto repair. Staff recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan, nearby multifamily investments (e.g., Herman & Kittle development at 2300 Lafayette Road with $900,000 in city funds), and the potential for outdoor display adjacent to residential uses. Commissioner Murphy moved to approve with two commitments (preserve rear buffer and maintain site cleanliness). Passed 6-2 after a previous 4-4 tie in the hearing examiner. - 2023 BAR 001 amended – 2802 South Holt Road Variances: Petitioner Amr Preet Carr requested variances for a six-foot chain-link fence, outdoor storage of vehicles awaiting repair (up to 72 hours), a temporary portable storage structure, and two sliding gates encroaching on clear sight triangles, all for a planned auto repair shop on a site rezoned to C4. Staff recommended denial, noting that only heavy industrial districts (I-3, I-4) allow six-foot front yard fences and that the requests were self-imposed. After discussion, the petitioner agreed to a continuance to October 4, 2023, to clarify commitments with staff. Motion to continue passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Approved all economic development resolutions as noted. - Approved rezoning at 2500 Lafayette Road (C4 to C5) with two commitments, vote 6-2. - Continued the variance petition for 2802 South Holt Road to October 4, 2023, for further staff discussions. - Continued petition 2023 ZON 055 to December 6, 2023. - Continued petition 2023 ZON 026 to September 20, 2023. - Withdrawal of appeal 2023 APP 025 acknowledged. - Commissioner Robinson recused on resolution 2023 A034.

ZONING AND LAND USE 66% · PROCEDURAL 15% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 14% · FENCE REGULATION 3%
714
SEP 5, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division One Public Hearing - September 5, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division One held a public hearing on September 5, 2023, at 6:15 PM in Indianapolis, Indiana. Chairperson Peter Nelson presided, with board members David Duncan, Andrew Catona, Tom Barnes, and Jennifer Witt (alternate). Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz, and staff from the Division of Planning included Eddie O'Neilla, Jeff York, Alison Richardson, Noah Stern, and Heather Stefan. The meeting covered expedited petitions, continuances, and two contested variance cases. Consent Calendar - The board approved a motion to waive rules of procedure to vote on all expedited petitions without additional testimony. The following seven petitions were approved unanimously (5-0) via ballot: - 2023 DV 1032: Variance for vehicular access from Warsaw Street. - 2023 DV 1037: Variance for a detached garage with reduced rear yard setback. - 2023 DV 1038 (amended): Variance for a projecting blade sign. - 2023 DV 1040 (amended): Variance for a detached garage and secondary dwelling unit with reduced side yard setbacks. - 2023 DV 1041: Variance for parking area expansion. - 2023 DV 1042: Variance for an attached garage with reduced side yard setback. - 2023 DV 1039: Variance for duplex construction with reduced lot width and open space. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022 UV 1009 (rehearing): Petitioner Sylvia Miller (representing S&S Center LLC) argued for a permanent variance to continue automobile and motorcycle sales at 8930 West Washington Street, citing existing use, lack of neighborhood impact, and detrimental reliance on a prior temporary variance. Support was voiced by Charles Hunt, an adjacent property owner. Remonstrator Brian Twee (representing the Indianapolis Airport Authority) opposed, citing comprehensive plan incompatibility, environmental sensitivity (floodway), prior violations, and lack of hardship. Staff recommended denial. - 2023 UV 1014: Petitioner Anna Crohn (representing The Auto Center) requested a use variance for a personal motor vehicle repair shop at 7006 Southeastern Avenue, highlighting the building's 140-year history of similar use and community support. Greg Earl, the business owner, provided details on operations. No opposition was present. Staff recommended denial due to concerns about outdoor storage and comprehensive plan consistency. Discussion Items - 2022 UV 1009: The board deliberated on the petitioner's compliance with prior commitments, support from the dissolved Bridgeport Neighborhood Alliance, and the lack of evidence of hardship. Staff noted that the comprehensive plan recommended community commercial use, not outdoor auto sales, and that the property was in a floodway and environmentally sensitive area. The board voted 5-0 to deny the variance. - 2023 UV 1014: The board questioned the petitioner about outdoor storage, overnight parking, and paving. The petitioner agreed to commitments: (1) limit outdoor storage during the day to 25% of the gross floor area of the auto repair operations, (2) no overnight outdoor storage of vehicles, and (3) hard-stripe all parking spaces within 12 months. The board approved the variance 5-0. Key Outcomes - 2022 UV 1009: Denied (5-0). The board will adopt findings of fact in support of the denial. - 2023 UV 1014: Approved (5-0) with the three commitments listed above. - Continuances and Withdrawals: - 2023 UV 1018 (5524 Georgetown Road) continued to October 3, 2023, without additional notice. - 2023 UB 1017 (2352 Burke Street) continued automatically to the next meeting. - 2023 DV 1043 (1710 West Morey Street) withdrawn by the petitioner. - The board also acknowledged receipt of findings for previously approved petitions.

ZONING AND LAND USE 69% · PROCEDURAL 13% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 7% · TRANSPORTATION 5%
715
AUG 16, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting - August 16, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) convened on Wednesday, August 16, 2023, at 6:00 p.m. to address nine resolutions, multiple zoning petitions, and public hearings. Key actions included approval of tax abatements for a truck company expansion, adoption of the 2023 Indy Parks Comprehensive Master Plan, and a contentious rezoning for a mixed-use development near 86th Street and I-465. The meeting also featured several continuance requests and a final approval of a workforce housing project on the Monon Trail. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: Minutes from the August 2, 2023, meeting were approved 7-1 after correcting two votes (2023 A029 and A030) to 7-1. - Resolutions Without Public Hearing (approved 8-0): - 2023 R023: Authorize DMD to contract with N XG Youth Mortar Sport for property acquisition at 50 North Tibbs. - 2023 R031: Authorize DMD to pay up to $725,000 for acquisition of former John Marshall High School. - 2023 E028: Interlocal agreement with Wayne Township for employee training program (Area 31 Project), up to $100,000. - 2023 A033: Final ERA resolution for Truck Country of Indiana (Stoops Freightliner Western Star) – real property tax abatement, 7 years. - 2023 C005: DMD contract for community engagement services. - 2023 C006: DMD contract for community engagement services (second resolution). - No-Appeal Docket (16 petitions) approved 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023 P015 – Indy Parks Comprehensive Master Plan: - Jeff Stanth, Executive Director of Indiana Forest Alliance (IFA), expressed support for the plan, specifically endorsing the full circle Indy Greenways plan, acquisition of East Side Flatwoods Forest, and importance of Upper Eagle Creek Park. He noted that the consultation phase lacked engagement from local conservation groups like IFA and urged future inclusion. - 2023 CZN 814 / CVR 814 – Large Mixed-Use Rezoning (Cornerstone/GCG): - Remonstrators (opposing): - Susan Blair, President of Pike Township Residents Association (PTRA), stated PTRA unanimously opposed rezoning due to deviations from the comprehensive plan, traffic, drainage, and environmental concerns. She noted the site is zoned for low-density residential with an environmentally sensitive overlay and argued that market conditions do not justify the change. - Martin Rich, hydrologist and chair of Eagle Creek Park Advisory Committee, detailed environmental risks: increased stormwater runoff, flooding impacts on Hopewell Creek and Eagle Creek, potential contamination from former Ropke Tank and Airplane Museum, and questions about tree replacement and endangered species. - Steve Jones, West 86 subdivision representative, opposed the retail and hotel elements due to light, noise, and traffic impacts on surrounding homes. - Brad Yarger, traffic engineer, identified issues with the traffic study, including the need for a second left-turn lane at 86th Street eastbound to I-465 northbound, which may require costly interchange redesign. - Barry Stern, real estate broker and resident, argued the site could be developed with custom homes and that rezoning would reduce property values. - Sally Endow expressed concern about toxic runoff into Eagle Creek Park and reservoir. - Petitioners (supporting): - J. Murray Clark, attorney for Cornerstone Companies and GCG Investments, presented a revised plan with a 48.6-acre preservation area (increased from earlier), a four-story height limit, and 33 commitments including no distribution centers, limited hotel hours (3-diamond AAA), and restrictions on fast-food drive-throughs. He highlighted the need for CS zoning to enable a high-end mixed-use and life science campus. - 2023 ZON 049 – Monon Trail Multifamily: - Jacqueline McMillan Gunn, resident of Martindale Brightwood, spoke in full support. Discussion Items - 2023 A031 and A032 – Truck Country Tax Abatements: Staff (Ryan Hunt, DMD) supported both real and personal property abatements for a truck company expansion on Thompson Road. Approved 7-1 and 7-1 respectively. - 2023 P015 – Comprehensive Plan Amendment (Indy Parks Master Plan): Staff (Carmen Leffig, DMD) supported adoption, praising the robust planning and engagement. Approved 8-0. - Continuance Requests: - 2023 CZN 814 / CVR 814 (large rezoning): Remonstrator attorney Russ Sipes requested continuance due to insufficient notice to clients, new site plan and staff report, and need for more review. The request was denied 8-0 after petitioner Murray Clark objected and staff stated notice was proper. - 2023 CZN 830 / CVR 830 (Martin Petroleum): Continuance to October 4, 2023, granted 8-0. - 2023 DAR001 (2802 South Holt Road): Continuance to September 6, 2023, granted 8-0. - 2023 ZON 026 and CAP 822: Staff requested continuances to September 6, 2023; both approved 8-0. - 2023 ZON 064 (40 West 40th Street): Automatic continuance to September 20, 2023, acknowledged. - 2023 CZN 814 / CVR 814 – Large Rezoning Deliberation: - Petitioner detailed commitments: 48.6-acre preservation area, maximum 4 stories, tree and wetland assessments, community review (7 days) before DMD administrator approvals, and prohibition on certain uses. Remonstrators emphasized deviation from comprehensive plan, traffic, drainage, and property value concerns. - Staff (Kathleen) reiterated support, noting the comprehensive plan is flexible and that CS zoning allows future public review. Commissioner questions focused on drainage, traffic impact study (accepted by DPW and INDOT), and notification to PTRA of future admin approvals. - Vote: 6 approval, 1 denial, 1 recusal for both resolutions. Approved. - 2023 ZON 049 – Multifamily at 1011 East 22nd Street: - Petitioner Misha Rabinowich presented a 111-unit, 51% workforce housing project (80% AMI) on 2.3 acres with 106 on-site and 11 off-site parking spaces. Design includes three-story walk-ups, modular construction, and engagement with the Monon Trail. City-County Councillor Zach Adamson spoke in favor. Staff expressed concerns about site design (surface parking along alley, pedestrian safety) and preferred a taller building with parking underneath. Petitioner argued cost and feasibility constraints. - Vote: Approved 8-0. Key Outcomes - Minutes Corrected: August 2 minutes approved 7-1 after updating vote counts on two items. - Tax Abatements Approved: 7-year real and personal property abatements for Truck Country (Stoops Freightliner) on Thompson Road (7-1 each). - Indy Parks Master Plan Adopted: 2023 Indy Parks Comprehensive Master Plan (P015) approved 8-0 as an amendment to the Marion County Comprehensive Plan. - Consent Resolutions Approved: Six resolutions (R023, R031, E028, A033, C005, C006) passed 8-0. - No-Appeal Docket: 16 zoning petitions approved 8-0. - Continuances: - Large rezoning (CZN 814/CVR 814) continuance denied; hearing proceeded. - Martin Petroleum (CZN 830/CVR 830) continued to October 4, 2023. - DAR001 continued to September 6, 2023. - ZON 026 and CAP 822 continued to September 6, 2023. - ZON 064 continued to September 20, 2023 (automatic). - Large Mixed-Use Rezoning Approved: 2023 CZN 814 and 2023 CVR 814 for a 200-acre mixed-use development (Cornerstone/GCG) at 6419 West 86th Street area. Vote: 6-1-1 on each. Conditions include 48.6-acre preservation area, maximum 4 stories (buildings east of internal road), and commitments for environmental assessments, community review, and notification to neighborhood associations. - Workforce Housing Approved: 2023 ZON 049 for 111-unit multifamily (51% affordable at 80% AMI) at 1011 East 22nd Street, approved 8-0. Developer given directive to ensure quality.

ZONING AND LAND USE 30% · PROCEDURAL 11% · LAND USE REGULATION 11% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 11%
716
AUG 15, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Public Hearing - August 15, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened on August 15, 2023, at 6:15 PM with Chairperson Joanna Taft presiding. Board members present were Percy Bland, David Duncan (alternate from Division 1), and Rianda Binder. Only four board members were present, which the Chair noted could affect outcomes if a split vote occurred. The board heard special requests, an expedited docket, and several regular petitions, issuing decisions including approvals, dismissals, and denials. No agenda or minutes were independently available; this summary is based solely on the transcript. Special Requests & Continuances - One-day waiver for expedited petition 2023 DV3025 (Iona Road): Petitioner David Gilman requested a one-day waiver of the second notice requirement for an amended petition. Staff had no objection. Board granted the waiver unanimously. - Withdrawal and fee transfer for 2023 DV3022 (Castleton Road): Alan Townsend requested withdrawal of the petition and transfer of fees to the expedited case 2023 SE3004 (same address). Staff had no objection; no remonstrators appeared. Board approved the withdrawal and fee transfer unanimously. - Withdrawal of 2023 UV3012 (1735 West Edgewood Ave): Staff noted the petitioner requested withdrawal; the board acknowledged the withdrawal. - Continuance for 2023 DV1034 (517 Prospect Street): Staff requested a continuance to September 19, 2023, due to a late amended site plan, with additional notice if needed. No opposition appeared. Board approved the continuance unanimously. - Expediting 2023 DV1033 (337 Sanders Street): The petitioner requested to be moved to the expedited docket. Staff recommended approval but noted a sidewalk setback issue not included in the variance. Board approved expediting unanimously. Expedited Docket All four expedited petitions were approved unanimously (4-0 votes) without further testimony, as per the adopted waiver of rules. - 2023 SE3004 (7930 Castleton Road): Outfront Media LLC sought variances for relocating a 40-foot advertising sign due to I-465/I-69 highway widening, including reduced separation distances and setback. Approved. - 2023 DV1036 (914 Harland Street): 3 Amigos Estate LLC sought variances for a dwelling addition with reduced front and side setbacks. Approved. - 2023 DV3025 (6248 Iona Road): Maxwell Fall sought variances for a 20-foot-tall pole barn (2,592 sq ft) taller than the primary dwelling and located in the front yard. Approved. - 2023 DV1033 (337 Sanders Street): 3 Amigos Estate LLC sought variances for a building addition with reduced front and side setbacks. Approved. Regular Hearings & Public Testimony - 2023 UV1016 (2909 South Meridian Street): Mars Realty Trust LLC sought a variance of use for outdoor auto sales (up to 40 vehicles). The petitioner was absent. Laura Piercefield, representing the South Village Neighborhood Association, stated they had 120 signatures from three neighborhoods opposed, and that petitioners had indicated they would withdraw but didn't. Staff confirmed no withdrawal was filed and recommended the case be heard or dismissed. Remonstrators requested dismissal. Board voted to dismiss 3-1 (Bland, Bender, Taft yes; Duncan no). - 2023 DV3019 (2059 North Pasadena Street): Gregory Gordon and Kyle Stewart sought variances for a 3,002 sq ft pole barn. Petitioner absent. Remonstrator Stanley Schill, a nearby property owner, opposed the structure in a residential area. Staff noted the petitioner had already received one continuance and had no contact since. Schill requested dismissal. Board voted to dismiss 3-1 (Bland, Bender, Taft yes; Duncan no). - 2023 UV3015 (3545 North Shadeland Avenue): Hobby Shop Paint and Collision, LLC sought variances for an outdoor storage trailer, a 6-foot-tall fence in the front yard, and a dumpster in the front yard. Petitioner Andy Wirt (land use professional) presented the case, emphasizing the need for security against catalytic converter theft. Remonstrator (name unclear from transcript, owner of adjacent business) strongly opposed, describing the site as a junkyard, citing illegal structures, paint fumes, and noise affecting nearby hotel guests. Staff recommended denial on all three variance requests, stating the hardships were self-imposed. The petitioner offered a commitment to hours of operation Monday–Saturday 9 AM–6 PM. The board voted separately on each item: A (storage trailer) denied 4-0, B (fence) denied 4-0, C (dumpster) denied 4-0. The case was continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2023 UV3017 (5420 McFarland Road): David Smithmeyer (by Jerry Hornbeck) sought variances for two parcels, including two primary dwellings on one parcel, an accessory structure without a primary dwelling, and substandard street frontage/width. Petitioner Hornbeck stated his intent to fix up and sell the property. Staff explained complexities: parcel two actually had a dwelling, and the living spaces might qualify as accessory dwelling units if under 720 sq ft. The petitioner initially withdrew some requests but then rescinded the withdrawals and requested a continuance to clarify issues. Board approved the continuance unanimously to the September 19, 2023 hearing. Key Outcomes - Approved all four expedited petitions unanimously. - Granted a one-day notice waiver and a fee transfer for specific petitions. - Dismissed two petitions (2023 UV1016 and 2023 DV3019) due to petitioner absence, both by 3-1 votes with David Duncan dissenting. - Denied all three variance requests in 2023 UV3015 (unanimous 4-0) and continued for findings. - Continued 2023 UV3017 to September 19, 2023, for further clarification.

ZONING AND LAND USE 82% · PROCEDURAL 14% · CODE ENFORCEMENT 2% · SIGN REGULATION 1%
717
AUG 8, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Meeting - August 8, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 convened on August 8, 2023, at 10:30 AM to consider several variance requests and continuances. The meeting was chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members James Duke, Beth Brandon, and Tom Barnes present. The board heard a mix of continuances, expedited approvals, and contested variances, resulting in two denials and two approvals. Consent Calendar - Expedited Docket (Unanimous Approval): Three petitions were approved without opposition: - 2023 DV 1031: 1409 Fletcher Avenue – variance for detached garage with 3-foot side yard setbacks (5 feet required). - 2023 DV 1035: 1310 West 26th Street – variance for single-family dwelling and secondary dwelling unit with 3-foot side yard setbacks. - 2023 DV 2014: 28 East 40th Street – variance for detached garage with 3-foot rear and side yard setbacks. A two-day waiver of notice was granted for this petition due to a posting deficiency; all board members affirmed their votes. Public Comments & Testimony - Butler University President’s House (2023 DV 2010): Four remonstrators spoke in opposition: - Kevin Sindelar (524 Buckingham Drive) objected to the height (43 feet 10 inches vs. 35 feet maximum) and called the house a “monstrosity” out of scale with the neighborhood. - Mary Claire Chapman (501 Blue Ridge Road) requested a design tweak to keep the structure to scale, noting Butler’s encroachment into the residential neighborhood. - Evelyn Ridley Turner (507 Buckingham Drive) asked for a height reduction to match other homes and noted the historical significance of the existing house. - Richard Turner (507 Buckingham Drive) stressed the sheer size of the house and its encroachment on the lot, expressing skepticism that the existing house could not be remodeled. Discussion Items - Continuances: Several cases were continued to September 12, 2023: - 2023 UV 2-009 (1540 South East Street): Granted over objection from the Bates Hendricks neighborhood association, which opposed the underlying petition but did not object to the continuance. - 2023 DV 2-017 (717 East 27th Street): Staff requested a continuance for cause to review an amended site plan; no objection from the audience. - 2023 DV 2-015 (1133 South Illinois Street): Remonstrator Shannon Dugan requested a continuance; petitioner did not object; granted without additional notice. - 2023 DV 1022 (2247 Broadway Street): Petitioner Peter Meehan sought a variance to build a 1,085-square-foot carriage house (720 square feet maximum). Staff recommended denial, citing the accessory dwelling size and self-imposed practical difficulty. The board questioned the floor area calculation and considered the height and design self-imposed. The petition was denied 4-0. - 2023 DV 2010 (526 Blue Ridge Road): Butler University, through Andrew Wirt, requested variances for a 43-foot-10-inch tall president’s house (35 feet max), a 10-foot rear setback (20 feet required), and a front entrance not on the front facade. Staff supported the request, noting the context of a four-story university building nearby and the residential use. Remonstrators opposed the height and scale. The board questioned the 12-foot ceiling height and 12/12 roof pitch as self-imposed hardship. The petition was denied 4-0. - 2023 DV 2013 (4809 East 70th Street): Petitioner Abraham Jordan sought a variance to retain a 6-foot privacy fence in the front yard (3.5-foot limit). Staff recommended denial, citing fence height regulations and suggesting alternatives like trees. The petitioner argued safety, privacy, and neighborhood precedent. The board approved the variance 4-0. - 2023 DV 2018 (2050 Carrollton Avenue): Petitioner Jimmy Lamentz requested a variance for an 8-foot fence in the rear yard (6-foot max) to provide privacy for a pool and basketball court. Staff recommended denial but noted approval limited to the rear fence. The board approved 4-0, and findings of fact were adopted. Key Outcomes - Continuances Granted: Three cases were continued to September 12, 2023 (2023 UV 2-009, 2023 DV 2-017, 2023 DV 2-015). - Denials: - 2023 DV 1022 (carriage house): Denied 4-0; continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2023 DV 2010 (Butler president’s house): Denied 4-0; continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Approvals: - 2023 DV 2013 (fence height): Approved 4-0. - 2023 DV 2018 (fence height): Approved 4-0; findings of fact adopted. - Expedited Docket: Three petitions approved unanimously with no testimony. - Next Meeting: The board’s next regularly scheduled hearing is September 12, 2023.

ZONING AND LAND USE 56% · PROCEDURAL 25% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7% · PUBLIC SAFETY 4%
718
AUG 2, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting – August 2, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission met on August 2, 2023, at 6:00 PM to consider resolutions, continuances, petitions, and public hearings. Key agenda items included approval of six administrative resolutions, several continuance requests, a contested rezoning for a plastics recycling facility, a tied vote on a vehicle sales rezoning, and approval of a senior living facility. The meeting involved extensive public testimony, commissioner debate, and last-minute commitments to address neighborhood concerns. Consent Calendar - Minutes of July 19, 2023: Approved with a vote of 8–0. Commissioners Garver and Robinson recused themselves. - Six Resolutions (2023 R030, R032, A030): Passed as a group 8–0, except Resolution 2023 A30 (real property tax abatement) which passed 7–1, with Commissioner Moriarity voting no. - Continuances: - 2023 CZN 823 and CVC 823 (Van Buren Street) continued to September 20, 2023, on petitioner's request without notice; approved 8–0. - 2023 ZON 050 (McFarland Boulevard) granted a one-day notice waiver due to a 22-day notice (instead of required 23 days) after staff support; approved 8–0. - 2023 ZON 026 (Brookville Road) and 2023 CAP 822 (Nolan Avenue and Windsor Street) continued to August 16, 2023, pending receipt of commitments; each approved 8–0. - Petitions of No Appeal (2023 MOD 012, ZON 031, ZON 047, CZN 876): Approved as a group 8–0. Public Comments & Testimony - Rezoning for Plastics Recycling Facility (2023 ZON 025, VAR 002): Multiple remonstrators spoke in opposition: - Tom Lorenz (Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association) stated the neighborhood voted overwhelmingly to oppose the petition. He cited concerns about noise, air quality, plastic dust, fire risk, and the petitioner's refusal to put verbal promises into writing. He argued that an I3 (heavy industrial) use is inappropriate near homes, a church, and a park. - Vicky Winning (area resident) presented a petition with signatures from neighbors. She highlighted fire incidents at similar facilities (citing Richmond, Indiana and New Palestine), noise levels (reported 90 dBA at a similar Brazil plant), and diesel emissions. She noted the company's low Better Business Bureau rating and environmental violations. - Pat Andrews (Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations – MCANNA) emphasized that the upzoning would put pressure on a " ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​" and that the absence of written commitments left neighbors vulnerable. - Other Petitions: No public testimony was given for the assessment of benefits hearing (CVC 829), the Lafayette Road vehicle sales (ZON 053), or the senior living facility (ZON 050). Discussion Items - Plastics Recycling Facility (2023 ZON 025/VAR 002): - Petitioner Brian Tewey (counsel for Loth Group and Republic Services) presented a $110 million, 286,000-square-foot indoor plastics recycling facility on 23 acres at 1002 West Hannah Avenue. The site is zoned I2 and surrounded by industrial uses and railroad lines. Tewey highlighted commitments: redirecting truck traffic to the west, installing two 10-foot sound walls, using electric yard dogs, quieter backup alarms, and enhanced landscaping. A sound study showed existing ambient noise exceeds expected operations. Staff recommended approval, noting the site's industrial context and the buffer provided by railroad right-of-way. - Remonstrators argued that promised measures (e.g., 12-inch grinder room walls, closed loading dock doors, truck idling limits, air quality testing, no melting of plastic) were not put into written commitments. - During rebuttal, President Dillon asked the petitioner to agree to semi-annual air quality testing; Tewey accepted. Additional commitments were made: an 8- to 12-inch concrete wall around the grinder, office space on the north side of the north building, and electric forklifts. - The petition was approved 8–0, subject to all agreed commitments. - Vehicle Sales Rezoning (2023 ZON 053): Petitioner Don Fisher sought to rezone 0.762 acres at 1200 Lafayette Road from C4 to C5 to allow car sales. He argued the area is auto-centric, with 13 sales lots and many repair shops. The owners agreed to exclude additional C5 uses and to keep sales in the front portion. Staff recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan (community commercial) and concerns about outdoor display near residences. After debate, the vote was tied 4–4, resulting in a continuation to September 6, 2023. - Senior Living Facility (2023 ZON 050): Petitioner Joe Calder presented a DP rezoning for 6.43 acres at 7525 McFarland Boulevard. The project is a 135-unit senior independent living facility (one building, three stories) on excess land from Southport Presbyterian Church. The project eliminated a previously contentious traditional multifamily component. Staff supported the rezoning as consistent with the comprehensive plan and current Emerson Avenue improvements. Councilor Dilk supported it. The petition was approved 8–0. Key Outcomes - Six resolutions approved; one tax abatement passed 7–1. - All requested continuances were granted. - The plastics recycling facility (2023 ZON 025/VAR 002) was approved 8–0 with added commitments (air quality testing, reinforced grinder room, office placement, electric forklifts). - The vehicle sales rezoning (2023 ZON 053) ended in a 4–4 tie and was continued to September 6, 2023. - The senior living facility (2023 ZON 050) was approved 8–0. - Negative findings of fact for a variance denied on July 19, 2023 (2022 CVR 862) were acknowledged for signature.

ZONING AND LAND USE 41% · PROCEDURAL 14% · ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION 14% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 10%
719
AUG 1, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 Hearing - August 1, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 hearing on August 1, 2023, convened with only two board members present (Chairperson Peter Nelson and Andrew Catona), lacking a quorum. As a result, no votes or substantive actions could be taken on any petition. All petitions on the agenda were continued to future hearing dates, either transferred to other divisions or continued to the next Division 1 meeting on September 5, 2023. Several petitions were withdrawn by petitioners and acknowledged by the board. Public Comments & Testimony - Clark Harris, homeowner at 521 Prospect Street, submitted a letter of opposition from a neighbor regarding petition 2023 DV1034 (517 Prospect Street) and requested it be filed. He also expressed concern about scheduling, noting the August 15 date would work. - Laura Piercefield, representing the South Village Neighborhood Association, stated the community collected over 120 signatures opposing petition 2023 UV1016 (2909 South Meridian Street) and argued there was no need for a continuance given the area's existing used car lots. She noted the petitioner owns other land that suits their needs. The board explained that without a quorum, a continuance was required, and the petition was transferred to August 15, 2023. Discussion Items No substantive discussion on the merits of any petition occurred due to lack of quorum. All discussion centered on scheduling continuances and acknowledging withdrawals. Key Outcomes - 2023 DV1036 (914 Harlan Street): Continued and transferred to Division 3 hearing on August 15, 2023 (petitioner preference). - 2023 DV1022 (2247 Broadway Street): Continued and transferred to Division 2 hearing on August 8, 2023 (petitioner preference). - 2023 DV1021 (1931 Lake of the Pines Drive / 8535, 8515 West 21st Street): Withdrawn by petitioner; board acknowledged. - 2023 DV1025 (5010 East 16th Street): Withdrawn; board acknowledged. - 2023 UV1010 (1946 North Euclid Avenue): Withdrawn; board acknowledged. - 2023 UV1013 (5320 West Vermont Street): Withdrawn; board acknowledged. - 2023 UV1014 (7006 Southeastern Avenue): Continued to Division 1 hearing on September 5, 2023 (staff had no objection). - 2023 DV1031 (1409 Fletcher Avenue): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on August 8, 2023. Petitioner also requested expedited docketing for that date. - 2023 DV1032 (515 Southeast Street): Continued to Division 1 on September 5, 2023, with notice (public hearing sign had not been posted for the required 23 days). - 2023 DV1033 (337 Sanders Street): Continued and transferred to Division 3 on August 15, 2023. Petitioner had submitted revised site plans reducing a sidewalk setback, with staff concurring. - 2023 DV1034 (517 Prospect Street): Continued and transferred to Division 3 on August 15, 2023. Petitioner indicated changes would reduce the proposal; staff noted additional notice might be required if plans changed. - 2023 DV1035 (1310 West 26th Street): Continued and transferred to Division 2 on August 8, 2023. Petitioner requested expedited treatment. - 2022 UV1009 (8930 West Washington Street): Automatic continuance acknowledged; continued to Division 1 on September 5, 2023. - 2023 UV1016 (2909 South Meridian Street): Continued and transferred to Division 3 on August 15, 2023. Petitioner and remonstrator (Laura Piercefield) agreed on that date.

ZONING AND LAND USE 90% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 6% · PROCEDURAL 4%
720
JUL 19, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting - July 19, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission met on July 19, 2023, at 1:00 PM at the City-County Building. The meeting included approval of minutes, several resolutions, continuances, and three public hearings on rezoning and variance petitions. Key actions included approval of a mixed-use development near Martin University, approval of a self-storage facility on Ditch Road, and denial of a proposed Quick Trip travel center on South Harding Street. Consent Calendar - Minutes: The minutes from the July 5, 2023 meeting were approved unanimously by voice vote. - Resolutions 2023-R027 and 2023-E026: Approved together 7-0. Resolution 2023-R027 authorizes DMD to deed property to reflect use and tax status; Resolution 2023-E026 enters a local agreement to support an automotive training center. - No Appeals Docket: Six petitions (2023 ZON 021, 027, 038, 046, 051, and 2023 CAP 819) were approved as a block 7-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Quick Trip Travel Center (2022 CZN 862 & 2022 C VR 862): Remonstrators led by Greg DeZula (5221 South Harding Street) opposed the rezoning, presenting photographs of tractor-trailer accidents, environmental and health concerns, and arguing that a 24/7 truck stop is incompatible with residential DA district. They cited the recent ordinance restricting truck stops within 500 feet of protected districts. One neighbor, Kim Martin DeZula, also spoke against the proposal, citing increased crime and decreased property values. - Crossroads Development (2023 ZON 048): Latia Tunsto (2321 Station Street) spoke in support of the mixed-use project, noting it would complement her own plans for a disability-focused development and benefit the neighborhood. Discussion Items - Resolution 2023-E025 (City Market Improvement): Public hearing. Staff urged approval as the next step in the transformative City Market campus project. No public comment. Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023-BB004 (Pan Am Plaza Hotel Revenue Bonds): Public hearing. Staff described this as a confirmatory resolution for the transformative project on the south side of Indianapolis. No public comment. Approved 6-0-1 (Commissioner Dylan recused). - Quick Trip Corporation (2022 CZN 862 & 2022 C VR 862): Petitioner Murray Clark (attorney) presented a plan for a Quick Trip travel center at 5204-5216 South Harding Street, rezoning from CS to C7 with variances for a dumpster enclosure, pole sign height, landscaping, and incidental sign. He emphasized Quick Trip's corporate reputation, commitments to prohibit right turns by trucks, and support from Councilor Josh Bain. Staff (Keith Holdsworth) recommended denial, citing C7's incompatibility with adjacent residential, the recent ordinance against truck stops near protected districts, and the variances being unjustified. After a 15-minute presentation and 5-minute rebuttal, the Commission voted 6-1 to deny both petitions. Commissioner Ash expressed concern about truck traffic and enforcement of the no-right-turn commitment. - Adams French Property LLC (2023 ZON 023 & 2023 VAR 003): Petitioner Brian Toy (50 South Meridian) requested rezoning from C1/C4 to CS and a variance for a 30-foot landscape buffer (instead of 50 feet) for a three-story self-storage facility at 8480-8510 Ditch Road. The site, vacant for 20 years, was a former gas station with environmental contamination. Toy noted support from the NORA community council, adjacent property owners, and Washington Township Trustee. Staff recommended denial, arguing the use is industrial (C7) and incompatible with the comprehensive plan, and the buffer reduction represents overdevelopment. After rebuttal, the Commission voted 7-0 to approve, with conditions that the site be maintained orderly and landscaping maximized. - Crossroads Development (2023 ZON 048): Petitioner David Gilman (211 South Ritter Avenue) requested rezoning from D5/C7 to DP for a mixed-use development at 2214-2320 Station Street, 3619-3631 Massachusetts Avenue, and 2219-2233 Avondale Place. The project includes 40 apartment homes (two buildings), 13 units above daycare and commercial space, 4,625 sq ft of commercial, and a daycare with covered play area. Staff recommended approval, noting the two-story height is a good transition and the rezoning from C7 to residential is appropriate. The Commission voted 7-0 to approve. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved: 7-0. - Resolutions 2023-R027 and 2023-E026: Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023-E025 (City Market): Approved 7-0. - Resolution 2023-BB004 (Pan Am Plaza bonds): Approved 6-0-1 (Dylan recused). - Quick Trip petitions (2022 CZN 862 & 2022 C VR 862): Denied 6-1. - Self-storage facility (2023 ZON 023 & 2023 VAR 003): Approved 7-0. - Mixed-use development (2023 ZON 048): Approved 7-0. - Continuances: Several petitions were continued to August 2, 2023 (2023 ZON 025, 2023 VAR 002, 2023 MOD 012, 2023 ZON 031, 2022 CZN 876, 2023 CVC 829) and to August 16, 2023 (2023 ZON 049, 2023 CZN 830, 2023 CVR 830), all unanimously approved. Commissioner Ash noted that the commission expects all business to be completed by the next hearing date.

ZONING AND LAND USE 44% · LAND USE REGULATION 18% · PROCEDURAL 8% · PUBLIC SAFETY 7%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com