The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II convened on November 21, 2023 at 6:00 PM with Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen, and board members Patrice Duckett Brown and Tom Barnes present. Staff included Senior Planner O'Neill, Senior Specialist Heather Stevens, and Planning Administrator Matt Pleasant. The board heard four variance cases, several continuances, and withdrawals. Three votes were required for action due to the reduced panel. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were offered from the audience at the start of the meeting. Discussion Items - Continuances and Withdrawals: - 2023 DV2-032 (911 Sanders Street): Continued to December 12, 2023 without additional notice per petitioner’s request; staff noted that new notice was not required if variances are reduced. - 2022 SC2001 (2400 Roosevelt Avenue): Acknowledged automatic continuance to December 12, 2023. - 2023 DV2-031 (8419 North Pennsylvania Street): Withdrawal acknowledged. - 2023 UV2012: Automatic continuance to December 12, 2023 acknowledged. - 2023 UV2-013 (6008 North Keystone Avenue): Withdrawal requested and fees transferred to a new rezoning petition; board voted unanimously to approve transfer. - 2023 UV2-014 (35 East Morris Street): Continued to January 9, 2024 with additional notice, pending modifications and refiling as rezoning. - 2023 UV2-015 (769 Riverfront Avenue): Continued to December 12, 2023 with additional notice for site plan modifications. - 2023 DV2-021 – 5000 Noland Avenue (Scecina Memorial High School): - Petitioner Joe Thurber and David Smith requested a variance for an 8.08-foot monument sign with digital display (max 5 feet, no digital display). The original plan for a two-sided sign was modified to a one-sided sign oriented 45 degrees to the street, with messaging on one side only. Petitioner offered to reduce sign height to 60 inches (including base) and turn off the display at 9:00 PM daily. Staff recommended denial due to the digital display being prohibited within 400 feet of a protected district (100 feet away) and because the height exceeded the limit. The petitioner noted support from the Little Flower Neighborhood Association and several neighbors. The board approved the variance unanimously (3-0) with conditions for reduced height and nighttime shutoff. - 2023 DV2-027 – 4110 North Illinois Street: - Petitioner Michael Brannan requested an 8-foot privacy fence (max 6 feet) to accommodate a raised deck around a swim spa. A neighbor provided a letter of support. Staff recommended denial, citing that the fence would exceed the six-foot limit and that privacy could be achieved with landscaping. The petitioner argued that a similar seven-foot fence was previously approved nearby and that the fence does not abut the alley. The vote was 1-2 (Duckett Brown yes, Von Dalen no, Barnes no), resulting in an automatic continuance to December 12, 2023. - 2023 DV2-029 – 6151 North Keystone Avenue (Kite Realty Group): - Petitioner Gene Beerman sought a variance for an 88.16-foot front yard setback (max 65 feet) and one stacking space in the front yard for a proposed Starbucks at Glendale Town Center. The site is in the compact context zone and includes a roadside ditch and existing monument sign. Petitioner noted support from the Greater Allisonville Community Council. Staff recommended denial, stating the site could be designed closer to the street and that the stacking area and parking dominated the frontage. The board approved the variance unanimously (3-0), but the decision was continued for the submittal and adoption of revised findings of fact. - 2023 DV2-030 – 3833 East 56th Street: - Petitioner Race Dorsey requested a variance to retain a six-foot vinyl privacy fence in the front yard (max 3.5 feet). The fence was installed without a permit by a contractor who assured compliance. The property is between two apartment complexes and a busy road, and the fence encloses 0.23 acres. Petitioner cited safety for dogs (some can jump 4-foot fences), privacy, gardening, and use by a rescue organization (FIDO) rehabilitating dogs. Neighbor Ed Spangerman spoke in support. Staff recommended denial, citing safety hazards from restricted visibility and deviation from neighborhood character. The board cast three votes: Duckett Brown voted yes, Barnes voted no. The outcome of the third vote (Chair Von Dalen) was not recorded in the transcript; the meeting adjourned immediately after. The result is ambiguous. Key Outcomes - Approved: - 2023 DV2-021 (Scecina Memorial High School sign) – Approved 3-0 with conditions (height lowered to 60 inches, digital display off by 9 PM). - 2023 UV2-013 (fee transfer) – Approved unanimously. - Continued/Deferred: - 2023 DV2-032 – Continued to December 12, 2023. - 2023 UV2012 – Continued to December 12, 2023 (automatic). - 2023 UV2-014 – Continued to January 9, 2024 with additional notice. - 2023 UV2-015 – Continued to December 12, 2023 with additional notice. - 2023 DV2-027 – Automatically continued to December 12, 2023 due to indecisive vote (1-2). - 2023 DV2-029 – Approved but continued for submission of revised findings of fact. - Withdrawn: - 2023 DV2-031 (withdrawal acknowledged). - 2023 UV2-013 (withdrawal acknowledged, fees transferred). - Outcome unclear: - 2023 DV2-030 – Three votes cast; Duckett Brown yes, Barnes no; the third vote and final decision are not clear from the transcript.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission convened on Wednesday, November 15, 2023, to act on a consent agenda of eight economic development resolutions, a public hearing for a rezoning petition, and multiple administrative items. The commission approved all consent resolutions except one bond issuance, which drew a single dissenting vote. Commissioner Bruce Schumacher, despite being unwell, served as acting pro tem secretary to ensure a quorum. The minutes from the November 1, 2023 meeting were also approved. Consent Calendar - Minutes: The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the November 1, 2023 meeting. - Economic Development Resolutions: Eight resolutions were read into the record and approved by a single roll call vote. All passed 5-0 with the exception of 2023 BB006, which passed 4-1 (Commissioner Schumacher dissenting). - 2023 E045 – Amends 2023 E029 to approve a funding agreement for acquisition and improvement of real property within a consolidated allocation area. - 2023 A027 – Preliminary Economic Revitalization Area (ERA) for CTCO2 LLC at 910 South Post Road (Council District 18, Warren Township), recommending up to 7 years of real property tax abatement. - 2023 A028 – Preliminary ERA for Barrage Door Doctor LLC and Five Star Property LLC at 808 South Post Road (Council District 18, Warren Township), recommending 5 years of abatement. - 2023 A039 – Preliminary ERA for DJ BCG Monon 22 LLC at 929 East 21st Street / 1011 East 22nd Street (Council District 17, Center Township), recommending 10 years of abatement. - 2023 A040 – Preliminary ERA for Patch Washington Street LLC at 8501–8609 West Washington Street (Council District 22, Wayne Township), recommending up to 7 years of abatement. - 2023 P017 – Authorizes a professional services agreement with Mojo Up LLC for a marketing/communications/public education blueprint for the planning process, not to exceed $200,000. - 2023 BB005 – Preliminary determination to issue economic development tax increment revenue bonds up to $19 million for the 10th and Rural infrastructure project. - 2023 BB006 – Preliminary determination to issue economic development special benefits tax bonds up to $26 million to purchase the Broad Ripple Park Family Center and approve the real estate purchase. - Petitions of No Appeal: Nine petitions (2023 APP 029; 2023 ZON 004, 078, 082, 096, 097; 2023 CZN 848, 852, 857) were read into the record and approved 5-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Rezoning Hearing – 2023 ZON 084 (amended): This public hearing was scheduled because an error had been made in the calculated acreage of the original filing. The request concerns 5640 East 38th Street. (Note: The transcript also references 5540 East 38th Street and the 3800 block of Ottoman Road in the earlier waiver discussion, while the hearing itself identifies the 3800 block of Audubon Road.) Jeff Hasser of the Indianapolis Neighborhood Housing Partnership testified in support of the petition, explaining that the project is part of the East 38th Street Corridor Lift Indy project in partnership with United Northeast Community Development Corporation. He stated that the homes would be approximately 1,700 square feet and affordable at 80% area median income (AMI). No remonstrators spoke. Staff affirmed support for the rezoning of 0.598 acres from SU1 TOD to D5 TOD for single-family detached dwellings. The commission voted 5-0 to approve. Discussion Items - Continuance – 2023 APP 030: Attorney Cheyenne Riker, on behalf of Haven Health Management, requested a continuance of the petition at 5510 South Emerson Avenue to the December 6, 2023 hearing. Riker initially misidentified the petition number (saying 2023-ADM-158) and the agenda item number; staff corrected the record to 2023 APP 030 and agenda item 20. Staff had no objection. The commission approved the continuance 5-0. - Waiver of Notice – 2023 ZON 084: Jeff Hasser requested a waiver of the required 11-day written notice for the amended petition. Staff confirmed awareness of the notice requirement and had no objection. The request was approved 5-0. - Staff Special Requests: Kathleen (planning staff) presented three items: (1) A request to continue 2023 ZON 088 at 8815 and 8817 Haverstick Road to December 6, 2023 pending receipt of executed commitments – approved 5-0; (2) an acknowledgement that companion petitions 2023 CZN and CBC 823 (involving Van Buren and Draper streets) were withdrawn via a September 25, 2023 letter – acknowledged; and (3) an acknowledgement of an automatic continuance for 2023 ZON 094 at 6729 Westfield Boulevard to December 20, 2023 – acknowledged. Key Outcomes - All eight economic development resolutions were approved; 2023 BB006 passed 4-1, with Commissioner Schumacher voting no. - The rezoning for 5640 East 38th Street (2023 ZON 084 amended) was approved 5-0. - The continuance to December 6, 2023 for 2023 APP 030 was approved 5-0. - The waiver of notice for 2023 ZON 084 was approved 5-0. - The continuance for 2023 ZON 088 was approved 5-0. - The withdrawal of petitions 2023 CZN/CBC 823 and the automatic continuance of 2023 ZON 094 to December 20 were acknowledged. - Next commission hearing is scheduled for December 6, 2023.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I held a public hearing on November 14, 2023, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Chairperson Peter Nelson presided, with board members David Duncan, Andrew Cotona, Patrice Ducket Brown, and Jennifer Witt. The board considered multiple variance petitions, including continuances, expedited cases, and public hearings. Decisions were made on automobile sales/repair, construction contractor storage, and residential development projects. Special Requests & Continuances - Six petitions were continued: 2023-UV1-023 (Enterprise Leasing) transferred to Division II on December 12; 2023-AP1-001 (Deloss Street) automatic continuance acknowledged; 2023-UV1-021 (Rockville Road) continued to December 5 with notice; 2023-DV1-048 (Biltmore Avenue) continued to December 5 without notice; 2023-DV1-054 (44th Street) continued to January 2, 2024 without notice. 2023-UV1-024 (Sherman Drive) was moved to the expedited docket upon petitioner request and staff support. Public Comments & Testimony - Tabitha Grab (4613 West Naomi Street) spoke regarding expedited case 2023-DV1-020 (Caven Street), conditionally withdrawing opposition pending relocation of a gas meter and bollards to the rear of 4622 West Caven Street. The petitioner agreed. - Carol Barker (representing Rockville High School Girls School Neighborhood Association) spoke during continuance of 2023-UV1-021, expressing concern that the petitioner intended to lease the entire property without owner occupancy, which would violate zoning rules for secondary dwelling units. - Over 96 letters of support from neighbors, along with letters from State Senator Aaron Freeman and State Representative Mike Speedy, were submitted for 2023-UV1-025 (Maze Road). Discussion Items - 2023-UV1-019 (Roys Towing) – 2994 North Arlington Avenue: Petitioner David Dearing requested variances for auto sales/repair and a six-foot chain link fence in front yards. Staff recommended approval of the use but denial of the fence variance, citing safety and zoning compliance. Petitioner argued the fence is needed for security and has existed for 30 years. The board approved the full request. - 2023-UV1-025 (Michael & Nicole Cole) – 11150 Maze Road: Petitioner requested a use variance to park up to 11 commercial vehicles (dump trucks, trailers, pickups) for a concrete contracting business. Staff recommended denial, citing incompatibility with the D-A rural residential zoning and comprehensive plan. Petitioner presented extensive community support and commitments: no other business operations on site, termination upon sale, and hours of operation (pickup 7–8 AM, drop-off by 7–8 PM or one hour before dusk, Monday–Friday, with a winter shutdown). The board approved with these commitments. Key Outcomes - Approved – 2023-DV1-020 (Project 65 LLC): Variance for 11 single-family lots with reduced setbacks and garage width limits. Approved unanimously (5-0) as part of expedited docket with commitment to move gas meter to rear of 4622 West Caven Street. - Approved – 2023-UV1-022 (Adriano Montas): Variance to legalize existing residential use and detached garage in C-3/SU-9 district. Approved unanimously (5-0) on expedited docket; continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. - Approved – 2023-UV1-024 (Vivian Randolph): Variance for commercial garden, food processing center, and eating establishment at 3348 North Sherman Drive. Approved unanimously (5-0) on expedited docket; continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. - Approved – 2023-UV1-019 (Roys Towing): Variance for auto sales/repair and six-foot fence. Approved unanimously (5-0) after rebuttal; continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. - Approved – 2023-UV1-025 (Michael & Nicole Cole): Variance for parking 11 commercial vehicles with commitments including vehicle type, hours, and termination upon sale. Approved unanimously (5-0); continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. - Adoption of Findings: The board adopted revised findings of fact for petition 2023-DV1-024B (from October hearing) and negative findings for 2022-UV1-007.
The Metropolitan Development Commission of Indianapolis-Marion County met on Wednesday, November 1, 2023, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The meeting included adoption of minutes, a bid opening, consideration of ten resolutions (including three public hearings), a plat appeal, a variance appeal, and two zoning appeals. Key votes included approval of a new professional sports development area for the Indy Eleven stadium, termination of a FedEx tax abatement with repayment of $223,563.94, and a $1.25 million grant for homeless support services. Consent Calendar - Minutes: Approved as submitted from October 18, 2023. - Bid Opening: Sealed bids received for RFP-13DMD-2023-6 (The Drake Apartments) from Our Door Housing Corporation, Near North Side Development, and Flannery and Collins Properties. Bids will be reviewed by staff. - Resolutions (approved en bloc): - 2023-R-034: Authorized a technology contract with Tolemi (OpportunitySpace) for land bank operations, initial cost $98,600, with optional three-year extension at $95,000/year. (Passed 9-0.) - 2023-R-035: Authorized a stewardship agreement with ROKH LLC for Old Fire Station 18 at Central State campus, including community engagement for adaptive reuse. (Passed 9-0.) - 2023-E-042: Authorized reimbursement of $9,240,000 from allocation areas for DPW capital improvements. (Passed 9-0.) - 2023-E-043: Authorized reimbursement of $25,867,450 from allocation areas for economic development infrastructure. (Passed 9-0.) - 2023-E-044: Declaratory resolution creating an Additional Professional Sports Development Area (PSDA) for the Indy Eleven stadium project (“Eleven Park”), covering up to $9.5 million/year in state revenue for 32 years. The plan includes a multipurpose stadium, approximately 600 apartments, 205,000 sq ft office, 197,000 sq ft retail, hotel, and public plazas. Commissioner Schumacher recused himself; passed 8-0-1. - 2023-C-010: Authorized grant of up to $1,250,000 from the Indianapolis Housing Trust Fund to the Indianapolis Foundation’s Housing to Recovery Fund for homelessness support services. (Passed 9-0.) - 2023-FS-002: Increased professional services agreement with Resultant, LLC by $1,000 (new total $81,000) for leadership development. (Passed 9-0.) Public Comments & Testimony 2023-A-036 – FedEx Supply Chain Tax Abatement Termination Ryan Hunt (DMD staff) explained that FedEx Supply Chain, Inc. ceased operations at 5425 Exploration Drive, triggering termination of a 5-year personal property tax abatement. The company agreed to repay $223,563.94 in tax savings received. No public comments or commissioner questions. The resolution passed 9-0. 2023-A-037 – MiraVista Diagnostics/Mirabella Technologies Amendment and Waiver Ryan Hunt stated that the applicant missed the 2023 deduction filing deadline and was behind on job creation commitments. The resolution waives the filing deadline and amends the MOA: reduces job creation from 22 to 16 new positions (at $32.58/hr), increases retained positions from 53 to 63 (at $41.97/hr), and extends the deadline to December 31, 2026. No public comments. Passed 9-0. 2023-A-038 – OnPoint Fort Ben, LLC Final ERA Resolution Ryan Hunt introduced the 5-year real property tax abatement for redevelopment of the historic PX building at Fort Benjamin Harrison. Dan Connors (Meyer Najem) confirmed interior work to be completed by January 2024. The project will retain 21 jobs (avg $44/hr) and create 11 new jobs ($35/hr). No public comments. Passed 9-0. 2023-PLT-064 – Irvington Plaza Plat Appeal - Petitioner (Joe Calderon, Talon Capital): Sought approval of a subdivision plat dividing 15.75 acres into six lots and one block at 6243 East Washington Street. The plat was approved by the Plat Committee on October 11, 2023, but appealed by the Historic Irvington Community Council. Petitioner argued the plat meets subdivision standards and agreed to commitments restricting uses (e.g., no drive-throughs on frontage). - Remonstrator (Sue Beecher, HICC President): Initially opposed due to lack of a master plan and fear of suburban strip mall development. After negotiations, HICC supported the plat subject to agreed commitments. Over 200 residents attended a community meeting; 51% of 2,000 survey respondents supported housing on the site. - Remonstrator (Blade Houth, architect): Argued the plat failed to show all existing buildings and lacked dedicated parking easements for Lots 2 and 6, creating potential zoning noncompliance. He urged denial. - Staff (Matt Pleasant): Recommended approval of the plat (dated October 31, 2023) as meeting subdivision ordinance requirements. Parking compliance is not a plat requirement and will be addressed at the improvement location permit stage. - Vote: Approved 9-0 subject to 10 standard conditions. 2023-VAR-001 – Maninder Singh Variance (2802 South Holt Road) - Petitioner (Amar Preeth): Requested six variances to operate an auto body repair shop, including a 6-ft chain-link fence, outdoor storage (72-hour limit), temporary portable storage (until building is built), reduced setbacks, and zero transitional yards. After staff collaboration, an amended site plan was filed September 30, 2023. - Staff: Recommended approval of all six variances with conditions: variances A, C, D void after two years or upon construction of a freestanding building; outdoor storage limited to 72 hours; building to have reduced setbacks from Farnsworth Street and Holt Road, and zero south/west transitional yards. - Public Comment: No remonstrators. - Vote: Passed 8-1 (Commissioner Blackburn voted no). 2023-CZN-830 / 2023-CVR-830 – Martin Petroleum Rezoning and Variance (201 West 38th Street) - Petitioner (Alan Townsend): Represented Martin Petroleum (owned by Sarbjeet Singh). Requested rezoning of 0.44 acre from D-5 and C-4 to C-4 (staff recommended approval) and a variance of use and development standards to build a 3,200-sq-ft convenience store on a D-5 lot (south of existing station) with a zero-foot south transitional yard. The project also includes replacing underground tanks, new canopy, landscaping, and enhanced security (off-duty IMPD officer, no-trespass agreement, B-link). Six nearby property owners and the Crown Hill Neighborhood Association (Denita Hoskin) wrote letters of support. - Staff (Kristen?): Recommended approval of rezoning but denial of the variance, stating the commercial encroachment into a residential district is inappropriate and the site should instead be used for housing to increase stock. Noted lack of written commitments from petitioner. - Crown Hill Representative (Denita Hoskin): Stated strong support for the revitalization of the 38th Street corridor; the association’s letter confirmed support. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Murphy asked about lot width (40 ft) and building dimensions (32 x 100 ft). Commissioner Robinson emphasized security improvements and the need for cooperation with IMPD. - Vote: Rezoning and variance approved 7-1 (one no vote noted). Discussion Items Special Requests - Continuance – 2023-ZON-088 (Our Lady of Peace Cemetery): Continued to November 15, 2023 pending receipt of executed commitments. Passed 9-0. - Move to No Appeals – 2023-ZON-091 (Callaway Group, Zionsville Road): Petitioner Bob Samuels agreed to dedicate a 63-ft half right-of-way along Zionsville Road to allow rezoning from SU-39 to I-4 (heavy industrial). Staff confirmed commitments received. Moved to the consent (no appeals) docket. Passed 9-0. Key Outcomes - Resolutions (R034, R035, E042, E043, E044, C010, FS002): All approved – E044 with one recusal, others 9-0. - FedEx Tax Abatement Termination (A036): Approved 9-0; $223,563.94 repayment required within 60 days. - MiraVista/Mirabella Amendments (A037): Approved 9-0; job creation target reduced, deadline extended to 2026. - OnPoint Fort Ben Tax Abatement (A038): Approved 9-0; 5-year real property abatement with phased schedule (75% to 35%). - Irvington Plaza Plat (PLT-064): Approved 9-0 subject to conditions and commitments with HICC. - Singh Variance (VAR-001): Approved 8-1 with conditions. - Martin Petroleum Rezoning & Variance (CZN-830/CVR-830): Approved 7-1. Next Steps: Staff will review bids for The Drake Apartments. The commission will meet next on November 15, 2023, to consider the continued cemetery petition.
The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held a public meeting on October 18, 2023, at 6:00 PM. The meeting covered administrative approvals, one resolution, several continuances/withdrawals, and three public hearings. Key actions included approval of a resolution for IMPD facilities, denial of a commitment extension for a gas station, approval of a Dollar General rezoning, and denial of a food pantry rezoning. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the October 4, 2023 meeting were approved unanimously by voice vote. - Resolution 2023 R033: Authorized the Department of Metropolitan Development to enter into agreements with the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department for K-9 and horse patrol facilities on the grounds of the former Central State Hospital. Staff noted the land is owned by DMD and this formalizes the arrangement. Vote: 8-0 (Commissioner Dillon also voted yes). Passed. - Continuance – 2023 ZON 078: Petitioner Rebecca Phillips requested a continuance to November 15, 2023 for the property at 4021 West 71st Street, because the petitioner is purchasing the property and closing on October 27th. The hearing examiner had recommended approval with no appeal. Staff had no objection. Vote: 7-0 (Commissioner Murphy recused). Approved. - Withdrawals – 2023 CZN and CBR 814: Staff announced that the “CornerStorm” project petitions (mixed-use at 86th Street west of I-465) have been withdrawn. The petitions are removed from the docket. - Petitions of No Appeal: Six petitions were read and taken together for approval: 2023 ZON084, 2023 CZN839, 2023 CAP850, 2023 CZN851, 2023 REG064, and 2023 REG070. All were approved by a vote of 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Pat Andrews (Decatur Township Civic Council) testified on multiple petitions: - For the Kentucky Avenue gas station (2023 MOD 009), she opposed the extension, detailing a 21-year history of non-compliance with commitments. She stated the community will have to restart enforcement if the extension is granted. - For the Dollar General proposal (2023 ZON 073), she opposed unless the petitioner agrees to connect to IMPD’s B-link security system, citing safety concerns and a national pattern of crime at Dollar General stores. - Bruce Meadows (neighbor at 4365 Kentucky Avenue) described hardships from the lack of water line extension, including his wife's paralysis and two summers with a dry well. He asked the commission to deny the extension. - Denise Casarati (2933 Mertz Drive) opposed the food pantry rezoning (2023 ZON 083), citing narrow streets, inadequate lighting, parking spillover, traffic, safety, and property value concerns. She presented a petition with over 100 signatures against the project. - Diana Craig (2943 Mertz Drive) questioned the commitment language about equal opportunity housing and expressed fear of homeless individuals living on site. Staff clarified there is no housing component. - Regina Wilson (2954 South Parker) spoke about the neighborhood’s historic family character and stated the petitioner told her he had “nowhere else to move.” She urged denial. Discussion Items - Resolution 2023 R033: Staff explained the formal action to give IMPD land for horse and canine patrols at Central State. No public hearing was held; it was introduced and passed. - 2023 MOD 009 Amended – Extension Request (4375 Kentucky Avenue): - Petitioner Garrett Lawton (McNeely Law) represented owner Mike Badisha (Five Star Oil Inc.). He explained the request to extend the deadline for completing all commitments from September 2023 to March 31, 2024, citing a larger-than-expected water line project ($250,000–$450,000 budget), engineering delays, and a change in representation. He provided exhibits showing signed engineering contracts, purchased shoebox lights, landscaping progress, and permit filings for an unpermitted structure. - Remonstrator Pat Andrews presented a detailed timeline of non-compliance since 2002, including past code enforcement citations, an agreed judgment in court (Nov 2022), and minimal progress until court involvement. She argued that granting the extension would “start the clock over” for community enforcement. - Staff recommended approval, stating that denial would “kick the can down the road” and the court’s involvement (compliance hearing scheduled December) provided assurance. Commissioners questioned the efficacy of an extension; staff could not answer what happens if the extension is denied (case in court). - Petitioner rebuttal: argued that the client purchased the property in 2013, did not build the original structures, and has since spent $40,000 on engineering. He stated all five open commitments (water line, landscape, permit for building addition, shielded lights, amended site plan) are achievable by March 2024. - Remonstrator rebuttal: argued the only movement has been under court supervision; the fine was only $125; the neighborhood has waited 11 years. - Vote: 3 yes, 5 no. Denied. - 2023 ZON 073 – Rezoning to C3 (8300 Camby Road): - Petitioner Misha Rabinowich (representing Second Circle Investments LLC, developer for Dollar General) presented plans for a 1.5-acre Dollar General store on a 2.67-acre site. Thirteen commitments were agreed with the Decatur Township Civic Council, including restrictions on uses, lighting, fencing, signage, and a fire access easement. The only remaining dispute was the B-link system; Dollar General refused due to privacy and national system concerns. - Remonstrator Pat Andrews opposed without B-link, presenting data on robberies, killings, and OSHA violations at Dollar General stores nationally. She argued the B-link system (cost: $20/month per camera) would improve safety for a store near the county’s edge with long police response times. - Staff recommended approval, noting consistency with the comprehensive plan. Commissioners asked about B-link; staff and Matt (from DMD) thought it would be beneficial but is voluntary. - Petitioner rebuttal: developer Joe Leonard stated Dollar General will not agree to B-link, but they have met all other neighborhood requests. The president of MDC expressed disappointment, saying they “will be following up on commitments.” - Vote: 5 yes, 3 no. Approved. - 2023 ZON 083 – Rezoning to SU7 (2991 East Troy Avenue): - Petitioner Greg Ilko (Crossroad Engineers) represented Servants Heart of Indy, a food pantry ministry. He described operations: two distribution days per week (Thursday 6:30-9 PM, Saturday 9 AM-2 PM), serving 60-150 families per day, 10-20 volunteers, no meal preparation, no housing. The site is adjacent to a church (owner), and 2.3 acres would be rezoned. Commitments include a tree preservation plan and an operational plan. - Remonstrators Denise Casarati, Diana Craig, and Regina Wilson opposed, citing narrow streets (Mertz Drive), lack of lighting, traffic congestion, safety concerns, property value loss, and the impact on a multigenerational family neighborhood. They noted other food pantries exist within a mile and the church is selling the land only if rezoned. - Staff recommended approval, noting the use is compatible with the comprehensive plan and that the church could have operated the food pantry itself as a permitted use. Staff clarified that Mertz Drive is public right-of-way and meets width requirements; no traffic study was required. - Petitioner rebuttal: clarified classrooms are only for volunteer training, no housing, and the site will have lighting. They could not move the entrance to Troy Avenue because of church improvements. - Vote: 1 yes, 6 no. Denied. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2023 R033: Approved (8-0). - Continuance 2023 ZON 078: Approved (7-0) to November 15, 2023. - Petitions of No Appeal: All six approved (8-0). - 2023 MOD 009 (Kentucky Avenue extension): Denied (3-5). The property remains in court jurisdiction with compliance hearing in December. - 2023 ZON 073 (Dollar General rezoning): Approved (5-3) subject to the previously agreed commitments (including fence, lighting, emergency access, sign restrictions). B-link system was not required. - 2023 ZON 083 (Servants Heart food pantry): Denied (1-6). The zoning remains D5; the proposal does not move forward. The meeting adjourned after the final vote.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on October 17, 2023, at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided over the meeting with members Percy Bland Jr., Roderick Bohanan, and a fourth member (Rivera) present. The board heard special requests, expedited petitions, and one contested variance of use petition. The board voted on expedited items without testimony and approved a variance of use for Thomas Loudermilk with conditions. Special Requests & Continuances - Three-day waiver (2023 DV3038): Granting a three-day waiver from the legal notice requirement for petition 2023 DV3038 (2434-2444 Winthrop Avenue). Staff had no objections. The board voted unanimously to approve the waiver. - Continuance (2023 UV3017): The petitioner requested a continuance to November 28, 2023, due to new findings from the tax assessor's office and a disparity between site plans. Staff supported the continuance. The board voted unanimously to continue to November 28, 2023, with additional notice if needed. - Continuance (2023 DV3028): The petitioner requested a continuance to November 28, 2023. Staff had no objections. The board voted unanimously to continue. - Continuance (2023 DV3035): Staff noted that the petitioner did not meet the notice deadline and requested a continuance to November 28, 2023. No audience opposition. The board voted unanimously to continue. Expedited Docket - 2023 DV3037 (2519 Guilford Avenue): Request for variance of development standards to construct a duplex on a 40-foot wide lot (60-foot lot width required). No opposition. The board voted to approve the petition based on staff reports, without additional testimony. - 2023 DV3038 (2434-2444 Winthrop Avenue): Request for variance of development standards to construct a townhome community with reduced rear yard setbacks and livability space ratio. No opposition. The board voted to approve the petition based on staff reports, without additional testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Petitioner Thomas Loudermilk (2023 UV3020): Through representative Tabitha Ayers, Loudermilk described his 44-year farming operation, the need for dump trucks, flatbed trucks, and trailers exceeding 12 feet for farming and excavation work. He stated that his vehicles are plated as farm vehicles, he does not operate excavation from his residence, and he rents heavy equipment only for off-site jobs. He emphasized that the variance is needed to continue his livelihood and care for his son. He expressed willingness to limit the scope of the business and to have the variance tied to him personally. - Supporters: Nicole Woods, Ben Adams, and Gary Vandever spoke in support of Loudermilk, citing his community contributions, neighborly assistance, and the compatibility of his operation with the surrounding area. Discussion Items - 2023 UV3020 – Thomas Loudermilk: The board considered a variance of use to operate a landscape/excavation business with outdoor storage of trucks, equipment, and materials in a DA (dwelling agriculture) zone. Staff recommended denial, citing that the excavation business is not permitted by right, the plan of operation was ambiguous, and such uses tend to grow beyond approved scope. Staff noted that the property was zoned for farming, but the excavation component required a variance. The petitioner clarified that he does not store heavy excavation equipment on site and that his vehicles are registered as farm vehicles. The board discussed potential conditions, including a revised plan of operation limiting the number of employees and vehicles, restricting commercial signage, and making the variance personal to the petitioner. The petitioner requested removal of the signage condition, which the board accepted. Key Outcomes - Vote on 2023 UV3020: The board voted 4-0 to approve the variance of use with two commitments: (1) the petitioner must submit a revised plan of operation to staff that limits the scope of the excavation business, including number of employees and vehicles; (2) the variance is personal to Thomas Loudermilk and does not run with the property. The petition was continued for adoption of revised findings of fact. - Adoption of Findings of Fact: The board adopted revised findings of fact for petition 2023 DV3033 (from the September 19, 2023 hearing) and negative findings of fact for petition 2023 UV3003. The board also approved the minutes from the September 19, 2023 hearing.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II convened on October 10, 2023, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen. The board addressed procedural matters, a continuance request, an amended petition, and approved four expedited variance petitions. All votes were unanimous. Procedural Matters - The board unanimously approved a waiver of rules to vote on all expedited petitions without additional testimony from individual petitioners. - Staff confirmed no objections to the continuance request for petition 2023-DV2-021. Continuance Request - Petition 2023-DV2-021 (5000 Noland Avenue): Ben Hoole requested a continuance without notice to confer with the neighborhood. The board continued the petition to the next scheduled hearing on November 21, 2023, without additional notice. Motion passed 5-0. Amendment to Petition - Petition 2023-DV2-024 (2507 Willowbrook Parkway): The request was amended to seek a variance for a six- to eight-foot decorative perimeter fence, exceeding the maximum of 3.5 feet in front yards and six feet in side and rear yards. Expedited Docket Four petitions were considered under the expedited docket with no opposition present. All received five affirmative votes and were approved: - 2023-DV2-022: Variance of development standards to expand an existing parking lot to 220 spaces (197 permitted) in a SU2 and D5 zone. - 2023-DV2-024 (amended): Variance for a decorative perimeter fence at 2507 Willowbrook Parkway in C3, W1F zone. - 2023-DV2-028: Variance for a detached garage with a 5.5-foot west side yard setback (15-foot minimum, 30-foot aggregate required) at 8635 West 96th Street. - 2023-UV2-011: Variance of use and development standards to legally establish single-family dwellings at 818 and 822 Union Street with reduced side yard setbacks (2.5 feet south at 818, 1.3 feet north at 822; zero or 10 feet required). Key Outcomes - Approved: All four expedited petitions unanimously. - Continued: Petition 2023-DV2-021 to November 21, 2023, without additional notice. - Adopted: Negative findings of fact for petition 2023-DV2-015. - Adjourned: The meeting concluded after adoption of findings.
The Metropolitan Development Commission convened on October 4, 2023, at 6:00 PM. The meeting included approval of previous minutes, adoption of resolutions, several continuances, a dismissal, and rulings on petitions of no appeal. All votes were unanimous except where noted. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the September 20, 2023 meeting were approved (moved by Commissioner Schumacher, seconded by Commissioner Blackburn; all aye). - Resolutions 2023 E039 (Harding Street redevelopment), 2023 E040 (interlocal agreement with Health and Hospital Corporation for Flanner House Partnership), and 2023 C009 were adopted. Roll call passed 9-0 (President Dylan recused himself on C009). - Eight petitions of no appeal recommended for approval (listed below) were approved 9-0. Discussion Items - Continuance Request – 2023 ZON 075 (Appeal Deadline Waiver): James R. Martin (516 South Rural Street) requested a waiver of the rules of procedure to appeal a hearing examiner’s recommendation, stating he missed the September 21 filing deadline due to personal conflicts. Staff objected, noting they provided the necessary information on time. The commission voted 9-0 to deny the waiver, upholding the deadline. - Continuance Request – 2023 VAR001 (2802 South Hulthod): Petitioner Amir Pritkar requested a continuance to November 1, 2023, to finalize an updated site plan. Staff supported the request, noting a variance may be added. Approved 9-0. - Continuance Request – 2023 CZN 830 & 2023 CVR 830 (Martin Petroleum Inc.): Attorney Alan Townsend (11 Monument Circle) requested a continuance to November 1 for newly retained client Martin Petroleum Inc. (item 16). Commissioner Blackburn commented on the site’s condition, suggesting a check with IMPD and cleanup. Approved 9-0. - Dismissal – 2023 ZON 026: Staff requested dismissal because commitments required for the petition had not been submitted; the petitioner’s representative was aware and did not appear. Dismissed 9-0. - Continuance – 2023 CAP 850 (4545 South Emerson Avenue): Staff requested a continuance to October 18 without notice due to missing commitments. Approved 9-0. - Continuance – 2023 REG 070 (addresses on 14th, 15th, 16th Streets, Senate and Capitol Avenues): Staff requested a continuance to October 18 without notice because regional center commitments were not yet received. Approved 9-0. - Petition of No Appeal Recommended for Denial – 2023 ZON 075: This was the same petition for which the waiver was denied earlier. The commission voted 9-0 to uphold the recommendation for denial, effectively rejecting the appeal. Key Outcomes - All motions and votes were unanimous (9-0) with the only recusal being President Dylan on resolution C009. - Waiver request for late appeal (2023 ZON 075) was denied. - Two petitions were continued to November 1, 2023 (2023 VAR001, 2023 CZN/CVR 830). - Two petitions were continued to October 18, 2023 (2023 CAP 850, 2023 REG 070). - One petition (2023 ZON 026) was dismissed. - Eight petitions of no appeal were approved: 2023 APP 06026, 2023 ZON 043, 2023 ZON 063 (second amended), 2023 ZON 077, 2023 ZON 081, 2023 CZN 843, 2023 CAP 845, and 2023 CZN/CAP 846. - The denial of the appeal for 2023 ZON 075 was upheld.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I held a public hearing on October 3, 2023, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room, City-County Building. Chairperson Peter Nelson presided, with board members David Duncan, Jennifer Witt, and Andrew Catona. Legal Counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The meeting covered continuances, waivers, expedited petitions, and seven public hearings on variance requests. Consent Calendar - The board voted unanimously (4-0) to waive rules of procedure to allow voting on all expedited petitions without additional testimony. The three expedited petitions (2023-DV1-046, 2023-DV1-047, 2023-DV1-049) were approved as a block with votes of 4-0, subject to conditions in staff reports. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023-DV1-020 (West Caven Street): A resident, Taoitha Grab, spoke about incomplete homeowner notifications but supported the continuance to allow all homeowners to be notified. - 2023-UV1-017 (Burke Street towing): No opposition testimony was presented. - 2023-DV1-045 (Manhattan Avenue fence): No opposition testimony was presented. - 2023-DV1-048 (Biltmore Avenue fence): An email from a neighbor opposed the fence due to obstructed views; no other opposition spoke. - 2023-DV1-050 (Chick-fil-A parking): No opposition testimony was presented. - 2023-DV1-051 (Rolls Royce signs): No opposition testimony was presented. - 2023-DV1-052 (IPS fence): Two remonstrators, Kelly Don Jones and Donald Jones, spoke in opposition, citing concerns about blocked access, increased traffic, litter, and safety. Discussion Items - 2023-UV1-017 (Ferguson towing, 2352 Burke Street): The petitioner requested a variance to operate a towing business with outdoor storage. After testimony that the business moved most operations to a new location, the plan was amended to limit use to maintenance of four tow trucks, with no storage of towed vehicles. The petitioner committed to removing barbed wire and the dumpster. Staff recommended denial, but the board approved 4-0, subject to the plan of operation and findings of fact. - 2023-DV1-045 (Manhattan Avenue fence, 2236 Manhattan Avenue): Petitioner sought a 6-foot perimeter fence in the front yard (max 3.5 feet). After discussion, the petitioner committed to: (1) converting the entire front fence to chain link, (2) limiting the variance to the current owner (not running with the land), and (3) a sunset clause expiring upon construction of a building or within three years. The board approved 4-0 with these conditions. - 2023-DV1-048 (Biltmore Avenue fence, 1305 South Biltmore Avenue): The petitioner requested a masonry fence up to 6.2 feet tall with 6.5-foot columns in front yards, encroaching into sight triangles and right-of-way. Staff recommended denial, suggesting modifications. The petitioner agreed to lower the fence, move it out of the right-of-way, and modify the corner. The board granted a continuance to November 14, 2023, without additional notice, to allow a revised site plan. - 2023-DV1-050 (Chick-fil-A accessory parking, 5240/5310 East Southport Road): The petitioner requested a variance to build an accessory parking lot on a separate parcel, resulting in 108 total parking spaces (max 48). Staff opposed due to pedestrian safety and self-created parking shortage. The petitioner argued the store predated parking maximums and that the lot would eliminate employee street parking. The board approved 4-0. - 2023-DV1-051 (Rolls Royce signs, 2355/2001 South Tibbs Avenue): The petitioner sought eight 12-foot-tall incidental signs (max 8 feet). Staff recommended denial, citing the ability to use primary signs or relocate signs. The petitioner cited safety and visibility for large trucks on a 300-acre campus. The board approved 4-0. - 2023-DV1-052 (IPS fence, 2251 Sloan Avenue): Indianapolis Public Schools requested a 6-foot chain link fence in front yards of an elementary school converted to a maintenance facility and adult education center. Staff recommended denial, favoring decorative fencing. Remonstrators opposed the fence and traffic changes. The board denied the petition 1-3 (Duncan yes, Catona no, Witt no, Nelson no). Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: - 2023-DV1-020 (West Caven Street) continued to November 14, 2023, with additional notice (4-0). - 2023-UV1-018 (Georgetown Road liquor store) continued to December 5, 2023, without additional notice (4-0). - 2023-DV1-048 (Biltmore Avenue fence) continued to November 14, 2023, without additional notice (4-0). - Waivers of notice granted: - 2023-DV1-052 (IPS fence): Two-day waiver (4-0). - 2023-DV1-051 (Rolls Royce signs): One-day waiver (4-0). - 2023-DV1-048 (Biltmore fence): Nine-day waiver (3-1, Witt dissenting). - Automatic continuance acknowledged: 2023-UV1-019 (Arlington Avenue towing) automatically continued due to a timely filed request. - Expedited petitions approved: 2023-DV1-046, 2023-DV1-047, 2023-DV1-049 (all 4-0). - Public hearing votes: - 2023-UV1-017 (Ferguson towing): Approved 4-0. - 2023-DV1-045 (Manhattan fence): Approved 4-0 with conditions. - 2023-DV1-050 (Chick-fil-A parking): Approved 4-0. - 2023-DV1-051 (Rolls Royce signs): Approved 4-0. - 2023-DV1-052 (IPS fence): Denied 1-3. - Findings of fact adopted: Negative findings of fact for petition 2022-UV1-009 from a previous hearing were adopted.
This was the regular meeting of the Metropolitan Development Commission of Indianapolis, held on Wednesday, September 20, 2023, beginning at approximately 6:00 PM. The meeting opened with a special recognition of Keith Holdsworth, a DMD planner retiring after 36 years of service. The commission addressed a number of zoning and economic development items, including continuances, a rezoning petition, and routine approvals. Several items sparked public testimony and debate, particularly around neighborhood engagement. Consent Calendar - Meeting minutes from the previous session were approved unanimously. - The following eight "petitions of no appeal" were approved without opposition (roll call 7-0): - 2023 APP 020 (8260 NAB Row) - 2023 APP 021 (8091 Township Line Road) - 2023 APP 023 amended (310 West 42nd Street) - 2023 MOD 014 (6011 Copeland Mills Drive) - 2023 CZN 834 (4202 East 10th Street and 1009 Gladstone Avenue) - 2023 CZN 835 (1100–1122 English Avenue) - 2023 CZN 842 (2601 East New York Street and 239 North Temple Avenue) - 2023 REG 059 (260 South Illinois Street / 101 West Georgia Street / 201 South Cabanol Avenue) - Resolution 2023 P016, authorizing acceptance of funds from the Mellon Foundation and Purdue University to prepare a certified strategic plan for Indiana Avenue with EKLA Studio LLC, was approved with a 7-0 vote. (Staff co-lead Carmen Lethig expressed full support.) Public Comments & Testimony - Jess Darling, representing the Fountain Square Alliance, and Elizabeth Sif (a community member) opposed a 60-day continuance for property at 1545 Van Buren Street (case 2023 CZN 823). They stated the developer had not meaningfully engaged, had provided delayed responses, and had presented no modified plans. They asked the commission to deny the continuance and proceed with the remonstration. - Rose Gilmore, a remonstrator for case 2022 CZN 867 (5400 Greenfield Avenue), urged the commission to deny the petitioner’s appeal because it was filed late and continued a pattern of mishandling responsibilities. Laura Purdue (Indiana Forest Alliance) echoed that request. - Peggy Powers (Tarkington Tower resident) testified in support of the MLK Center rezoning (2023 ZON 064), stating the organization has a history of transparency and good faith engagement with neighbors. - Several remonstrators spoke against the MLK Center rezoning, including Keith Micels (adjacent neighbor) and Morton Marcus (economist), who expressed concerns about "project creep," lack of a final development plan, and potential future uses not constrained by current leadership's intentions. Discussion Items - Vila Solar Inc. Economic Revitalization Area Resolution (2023 A035): Staff (Ryan Hunt) requested a continuance from the public hearing to allow the petitioner more time to understand Indiana’s classification of personal vs. real property for tax abatement commitments. The commission continued the item to December 20, 2023, with the possibility of a further update if needed. No public comment was heard. Vote: 7-0. - 1545 Van Buren Street Continuance (2023 CZN 823): Attorney Mary Soliday requested a 60-day continuance, citing ongoing discussions. Neighbors opposed, arguing the developer had not budged despite a year and a half of engagement. Commissioner Dillon expressed sympathy and voted to continue, noting the property is important to the neighborhood and urging progress. The continuance was granted to November 15, 2023. Vote: 7-0. - 6501 Brookville Road (2023 ZON 026): Staff (Kathleen) reported that commitments had not been submitted after five continuances, and the petitioner had been out of the country. The commission granted one final continuance to October 4, 2023, with Commissioner James voting no. Vote: 6-1. - Appeal Denial for 2022 CZN 867 (5400 Greenfield Avenue): Petitioner Baldi Batham asked for a continuance because remonstrators received late notice. Staff noted the appeal paperwork was incomplete and submitted after the deadline. The commission denied the request to hear the appeal, then proceeded to vote on the underlying petition of no appeal (recommended for denial). The denial of the petition was approved 6-1 (Commissioner Moreity voted no). - MLK Multi-Service Center Rezoning (2023 ZON 064): Petitioner David Kingan and Alison Luthy (MLK Center) requested rezoning from D2 to SU7 to legally establish the community center. They emphasized that no site plan or building permit is attached, and any future expansion would require administrator approval with additional opportunities for neighbor input. Staff (Keith Holdsworth) explained the SU7 district and the added commitment that final site plans be shared with remonstrators. The commission voted 6-1 to approve the rezoning. Key Outcomes - Vila Solar continuance approved to December 20, 2023. - 1545 Van Buren Street continuance approved to November 15, 2023; staff directed to facilitate further discussions with the Fountain Square Alliance. - 6501 Brookville Road continued to October 4, 2023, with a warning that failure to comply will result in dismissal. - 2022 CZN 867 appeal denied and the underlying petition (for denial) was approved 6-1, upholding the hearing examiner’s recommended denial. - MLK Center rezoning (2023 ZON 064) approved 6-1, with a commitment to share future development plans with remonstrators. - All eight petitions of no appeal and Resolution 2023 P016 were approved unanimously. - Meeting adjourned after completing the agenda.