Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 721–730 ENTRIES
721
JUL 18, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Meeting – July 18, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on July 18, 2023, at 6:15 PM, chaired by Joanna Taft. Board members present: Roderick Bohanan, Rihanna Bender, Percy Bland Jr., and Paula Rivera. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and staff from the Division of Planning attended. The meeting included waivers of notice, continuances, an expedited docket of five petitions approved unanimously, and one regular docket petition that was denied. Consent Calendar - Waiver of Board Rules: Approved unanimously (5-0) to allow voting on all expedited petitions together and adopt findings of fact without additional testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023 UV3-015 (3545 North Shadeland Avenue): A business owner (Motel 6/former Shadeland Inn) opposed a continuance requested by the petitioner who was out of town. The remonstrator expressed frustration about traveling from Nashville and raised concerns about the property’s impact. The board granted the continuance to August 15, 2023, over the remonstrator’s objection. - 2023 UV3-003 (Arbor Street): Thomas Lorenz, leader of the Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association, opposed the petition. He described the property as an eyesore, raised safety concerns about truck traffic near school children, storage in floodway fringe, and road damage. He argued the use was inappropriate for a residential suburban neighborhood. Discussion Items - Special Requests for Waivers and Continuances: - 2023 MO3001 (720 Eskenazi Avenue): Petitioner Eskenazi Health requested one-day waiver of notice due to late receipt of signs; granted 5-0. - 2023 DV3-024 (7745 Surrey Drive): Petitioner Shannon Reedy requested one-day waiver for same reason; granted 5-0. - 2023 DV3-027 (3719 Southeast Street): Attorney John Cross requested one-day waiver; granted 5-0. - 2023 UV3-008 (5718 Roxbury Court): Staff requested five-day waiver on petitioner’s behalf; granted 5-0. - 2023 DB3-025 (6248 Iona Road): Petitioner not present; staff requested continuance to August 15 for amendment; granted 5-0. - 2023 UV3-015 (3545 North Shadeland Avenue): Petitioner out of town; staff requested continuance to August 15; remonstrator opposed; board granted 5-0. - Expedited Petitions (All Approved Unanimously): - 2023 MO3001: Modification of commitment for permanent sign location on Sky Bridge above Dr. Harvey Middleton Way. - 2023 DV3-024: Variance for 8-10 foot privacy fence in rear yard (max 6 feet permitted). - 2023 DV3-027: Variance for 40-foot building addition (max 25 feet in transitional yards). - 2023 UV3-008: Variance for use to allow transitional housing expansion with counseling services. - 2023 UV3-016: Variance of use for building expansion of existing transitional house. - Regular Docket – 2023 UV3-003 (Arbor Street): - Petitioner: Daughter of owner Jose Arisa spoke in support. She stated the property is used for storage, no complaints from neighbors, and attended neighborhood association meeting where only request was to route traffic from Troy side. She acknowledged landscaping improvements were ongoing. - Staff Recommendation: Denial. Staff argued the site is zoned residential D4, commercial use is inappropriate, storage in floodway fringe is prohibited, detached garage without primary structure is not permitted, and the use would harm neighborhood character. Clear site triangle encroachment and fence heights were also issues. Staff stated no practical difficulty exists because the site can be developed residentially. - Board Deliberation: No questions from board. Petitioner and remonstrator gave brief rebuttals. Key Outcomes - 2023 MO3001: Approved 5-0 subject to staff conditions. - 2023 DV3-024: Approved 5-0. - 2023 DV3-027: Approved 5-0. - 2023 UV3-008: Approved 5-0. - 2023 UV3-016: Approved 5-0. - 2023 UV3-003 (Arbor Street): Denied 5-0 (Bohannon, Rivera, Taft, Bender, Bland all voted no). Continued for adoption of findings of fact. - Findings of Fact from Previous Hearing: Continued for adoption of revised findings of fact for cases 2023 DV3-023, 2023 DV3-021A and B, and 2023 DV3-011 (from June 20, 2023 meeting).

ZONING AND LAND USE 70% · PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 6%
722
JUL 11, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II Meeting - July 11, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II convened on July 11, 2023, at 6:15 PM. Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen presided, with members James Duke, Beth Brandon, Tom Barnes, and alternate David Duncan present. Legal Counsel Chris Steinman and several Division of Planning staff members attended. The board heard three continuance requests, one expedited docket, and five non-expedited variance petitions, concluding with votes on each. Continuances and Special Requests - 2023 DV2-010 (526 Blue Ridge Road): Petitioner Dana Kevin Sindelar requested a continuance because half the neighborhood was on vacation. Remonstrator Andy Wirt (representing Butler University) preferred to proceed, but neighbors Evelyn and Richard Turner had no objection. Staff had no objection. The board voted unanimously to continue to August 8, 2023, without additional notice. - 2023 UV2-004 (2029 Massachusetts Avenue): Staff requested a continuance on behalf of the petitioner to September 12, 2023, with additional notice, due to an error in the staff report. No audience interest. The board voted unanimously to continue. - 2023 DV2-013 (4809 East 70th Street): Staff requested a continuance on behalf of the petitioner to August 8, 2023, without additional notice. No audience interest. The board voted unanimously to continue. Expedited/Consent Docket - 2023 DV2-011 (multiple addresses in Pike Township): Arbor Homes and Apex Realty Group requested a variance of development standards for single-family dwellings with reduced front yard setback, main floor area, and open space. No opposition was voiced. The board voted unanimously to approve via the previously adopted waiver of rules. Petition 2023 DV2-005: 4540 Park Avenue – Carriage House Variances - Petitioners: Thomas and Kelly Creveling, represented by Mark Demerley. Requested variances for a detached carriage house with secondary dwelling: reduced open space (72% vs. 75% required) and increased square footage (850 sq. ft. vs. 720 sq. ft. max). - Public Comments: No remonstrators appeared. The petitioner noted support from the Meridian Kessler neighborhood and neighbors. - Staff Recommendation: Split – opposed to the square footage overage due to the incidental and subordinate use requirement, but not opposed to the open space reduction given the lot's below-minimum area. - Discussion: The board debated the calculation of floor area, particularly whether the staircase should be counted, and the petitioner argued the stairway should not be counted on the second floor. The board split the vote into two ballots. - Key Outcomes: Ballot A (open space): 5-0 approval. Ballot B (square footage): 5-0 approval. Both variances granted. Petition 2023 DV2-008: 3802 East 10th Street – Fueling Station and Laundromat - Petitioner: Jabo Investments LLC, represented by Joseph D. Calderon. Requested a variance to allow 0% building transparency on the south facade (40% required) and a canopy light level waiver (withdrawn). - Public Comments: Chris Staub, president of the Near East Side Community Organization (NESCO), spoke in opposition only because the petitioners had not yet shared signage and canopy designs. He acknowledged the petitioners had agreed to community commitments and that the only remaining variance concerned the windows. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing the importance of transparency for crime prevention and the availability of design alternatives. - Discussion: The board noted the 19-foot separation from the sidewalk and the security concerns of placing a cashier with a back to glass. The petitioner committed to install window boxes for public art, share sign plans, and add landscaping. - Key Outcomes: Vote: 4-1 approval (Barnes no). Variance granted. Petition 2023 DV2-009: 6151 North Keystone Avenue – Panda Express Drive-Through - Petitioner: Kite Realty Group, represented by Henry Clover and Joseph D. Calderon. Requested variances for a restaurant with drive-through: stacking in the front yard, no screening, 24 parking spaces (23 max), and 0% transparency on the north facade. - Public Comments: No remonstrators appeared. The Greater Allisonville Community Council submitted a letter of support. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, stating that a compliant site plan was possible and that the requested variances were self-imposed due to the lot's geometry. - Discussion: The petitioner argued the preferred plan improved stacking and safety, and that the building orientation was constrained by access easements. The board questioned the percentage of drive-through business (about 50-60%) and pedestrian access. - Key Outcomes: Vote: 4-1 approval (Barnes no). Variance granted. Petition 2023 DV2-012: 3777 North Meridian Street – Perimeter Fence - Petitioner: The Enclave at Meridian LP, represented by Joseph D. Calderon and Raymond Williams. Requested a variance for a six- to eight-foot decorative fence in the front yard (four-foot limit) and side/rear yards (six-foot limit) for security. - Public Comments: No remonstrators appeared. The petitioner noted that residents were excited about the fence and that Mapleton Fall Creek had initially supported then opposed, but no one testified in opposition. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing the fence's aggressive design ("Enforcer" style) and the availability of other security measures like cameras and guards. - Discussion: The board expressed concerns about the fence's aggressive design and height. The petitioner committed to lowering the front yard fence to five feet, using a standard pinch-point fence, and keeping side/rear at six feet. - Key Outcomes: Vote: 5-0 approval. Variance granted as modified by the commitments. Petition 2023 UV2-007: 128 North Traub Avenue – Multi-Unit Use Variance - Petitioner: CK Rents LLC, represented by KW Martinez. Requested a variance of use to allow a four-unit multi-unit house and a detached accessory dwelling (total five units) in a D5 zone, plus a three-foot side setback. The property currently operates as a legally non-conforming five-unit use. - Public Comments: No one appeared in person. A letter of remonstrance from an adjoining neighbor was received. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, stating the request was for insurance/financing purposes, that the difficulty was self-imposed, and that the proposed density (36 units per acre) far exceeded the comprehensive plan's recommendation. - Discussion: The petitioner argued the variance would protect affordable housing and allow refinancing. The board noted that the property could continue as is under the LNCU, and that granting the variance would allow a future rebuild at higher intensity, potentially harming neighbors. - Key Outcomes: Vote: 5-0 denial. The board will adopt findings of fact at a later meeting. Key Outcomes - Three continuances granted (2023 DV2-010, UV2-004, DV2-013). - Expedited docket approved unanimously. - Carriage house variances (DV2-005) approved 5-0 on both ballots. - Fueling station variance (DV2-008) approved 4-1. - Panda Express variances (DV2-009) approved 4-1. - Fence variance (DV2-012) approved 5-0 with modified commitments. - Multi-unit use variance (UV2-007) denied 5-0.

ZONING AND LAND USE 47% · LAND USE REGULATION 13% · PROCEDURAL 9% · PUBLIC SAFETY 9%
723
JUL 6, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 1 - Public Hearing July 6, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 1 met on July 6, 2023, in the afternoon to hear zoning variance petitions. Chairperson Peter Nelson presided, with members David Duncan, Andrew Cotona, and Aaron McBride; legal counsel Chris Steinmetz; and planning staff. The board handled continuances, expedited approvals, and contested cases. Consent Calendar - Approved the waiver of procedural rules to allow expedited petitions to be voted on without additional testimony (motion Duncan, second Catona, 4-0). - Granted a three-day notice waiver for the amended petition 2023 DV1022 at 5335 Windtorf Avenue, upon request of Peter Meehan (4-0). - Continued 2023 UV1014 (7006 Southeastern Avenue) to the August 1, 2023, hearing at petitioner's request (4-0). - Continued 2023 UV1013 (5320 West Vermont Street) to the September 5, 2023, hearing at petitioner's request (4-0). - Acknowledged automatic continuances to August 1, 2023, for 2023 DV1021 (1931 Lake of Pines Drive) and 2023 DV1025 (510 East 16th Street). Note: The transcript initially misstates the latter as "2023-DV1-021" before correcting to "2023 DV1025." - Moved 2023 UV1015 (3449 Broadway Street) to the expedited docket after no opposition was voiced (4-0). - Continued 2023 UV1010 (1946 North Euclid Avenue) to August 1, 2023, because the petitioner was not present and no affidavit of notice had been filed; the remonstrator did not oppose (4-0). Expedited Petitions (all approved 4-0) - 2023 DV1028 – 7417 Glenview Drive East: variance to allow a detached pool shed with a four-foot south side yard setback (seven feet required). - 2023 UV1011 – 6809 West Washington Street: variance of use and development standards for a fleet terminal facility and building addition, resulting in a five-foot-wide parking aisle for four stalls (23 feet required). - 2023 UV1012 – 5301 West 10th Street: variance for a use not permitted and prohibited within 500 feet of a protected district. - 2023 UV1015 – 3449 Broadway Street: variance to allow an attached garage and secondary dwelling unit with a five-foot rear yard setback (20 feet required), 52% open space (60% required), and future conversion to a two-family dwelling. Public Comments & Testimony - 2023 DV1029 (8349 Acton Road): Remonstrator Max Martin of 8401 Acton Road opposed the requested four-foot side yard setback for a detached garage. He stated the property has a history of flooding, that the garage was built without permits, sits two and a half feet (not four) from the property line, has no sill plate or concrete foundation, and that a sump pump and the impermeable structure displace water onto his property, including toward his well field. He also said city inspectors measured the setback at two and a half feet on April 6, and that even if granted the variance, the structure would have to be moved. He referenced a text where owners acknowledged and promised to fix the problem. - 2023 DV1022 (5335 Windtorf Avenue): The petitioners' representative noted five support letters from neighboring properties. No remonstrators spoke. - 2023 DV1027 (8136 East Southport Road): No opposition testimony; petitioners spoke in favor. Discussion Items - 2023 DV1022 (Carriage House at 5335 Windtorf Avenue): Petitioner's representative Peter Mean (on behalf of Ruben and Katie Moust) requested approval to build a carriage house to be used as a personal workshop and in-law guest suite. Staff recommended denial, stating the secondary dwelling exceeded the maximum permitted size for accessory dwellings and that the petitioner did not demonstrate the required practical difficulty. The board split 2-2 (Cotona and Duncan in favor; Nelson and McBride against), which is an indecisive vote. The petition was automatically continued to the August 1, 2023, hearing. (The address is also transcribed as Winthrop Avenue.) - 2023 DV1027 (Fourth Freestanding Sign at 8136 East Southport Road): Petitioner Brent Bennett and representative Taryn Bonhoff sought a variance for a fourth freestanding monument sign along Southport Road, 295 feet from another sign (300 feet required). They argued the sign would serve two outlots (a dentist's office and a Dunkin' Donuts), that a third sign had already been approved for an adjacent property, and that facade signage would be less visible because of 90-foot building setbacks. Staff recommended denial, citing that the sign could be located 10 feet to the west to meet the separation requirement, making the hardship self-imposed, and that the integrated center's existing pylon sign had available space. The board approved the variance 4-0 and continued the case for revision of findings of fact. - 2023 DV1029 (Detached Garage at 8349 Acton Road): Petitioner Carrie Gano and representative Stephen Brown requested a four-foot side yard setback for a detached metal carport/garage, saying the location was the only practical one and that the structure would not worsen drainage. Staff recommended approval, noting the setback aligned with other accessory structures and that drainage and permitting issues are separate from the zoning variance. The board approved the variance 4-0. Key Outcomes - All expedited petitions (DV1028, UV1011, UV1012, UV1015) were approved unanimously (4-0). - 2023 DV1027 (monument sign) was approved 4-0, with findings of fact to be revised. - 2023 DV1029 (detached garage) was approved 4-0. - 2023 DV1022 (carriage house) resulted in a 2-2 tie and was automatically continued to August 1, 2023. - Several continuances were granted, as listed under Consent Calendar. - The meeting adjourned after all business was completed.

ZONING AND LAND USE 68% · PROCEDURAL 19% · DRAINAGE 13%
724
JUL 5, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting – July 5, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) convened on July 5, 2023, at 1:00 PM with a quorum present. The agenda included seven resolutions (consent calendar), one public hearing on a final tax abatement, two companion public hearings on rezoning and variances, continuance requests, and a no‑appeals docket. Key decisions included approval of a seven‑year property tax abatement for a 170‑acre industrial park, rezoning for a mixed‑use development on West Washington Street, and rezoning for an affordable housing project on College Avenue. Consent Calendar The commission considered six items as a group (Resolutions 1–5 and 7). All passed except Resolution 2023‑E020 (declaratory resolution for the County Line Road Economic Development Area), which passed 6‑1 with Commissioner Morerity voting no. The approved items were: - 2023‑R026: Authorizing DMD to amend an existing legal services contract. - 2023‑E020: Declaratory resolution and redevelopment area plan for the County Line Road economic development area and allocation area (approved 6‑1). - Three declaratory resolutions: Near North Mass Economic Development Area, Ingram Allocation Area, and Penn Electric Allocation Area. - 2023‑P014: Authorizing a professional services agreement with Town Planning and Urban Design Collaborative LLC for an assessment and update of the Regional Center Design Guidelines (not to exceed $400,000, funded from downtown consolidated allocation area fund). Public Comments & Testimony - Robin Heldman (resident of 8824 Combs Road, Franklin Township) spoke on Resolution 2023‑A026. She stated she was not opposed to growth but raised concerns about the lack of public transparency during the preliminary hearing on June 21, 2023; the reduction in site size from 208 to 170 acres and from six to five buildings; the timing of abatement benefits relative to job creation; the cost per job; the relationship between the abatement and the proposed TIF district; and traffic improvements (questioning the need for a roundabout based on the existing traffic study). She urged the commission to consider her comments before voting. - Talesa Lloyd (Near West Community Builder) spoke on the West Washington Street rezoning (2022‑CZN‑847 and 2022‑CVR‑847). She supported the removal of the liquor store component but remained concerned that a future restaurant tenant could seek a liquor license. She noted that the project’s supporters from the WeCare neighborhood no longer live in the area and requested that commitments prohibiting alcohol sales be strictly enforced. Discussion Items - 2023‑A026 – Final Economic Revitalization Area Resolution for GPCM County Line Partners LLC: Staff (Ryan Hunt) presented the 170‑acre industrial park project, which includes five buildings and a retail site, projected to create over 360 jobs. The applicant committed $450,000 for inclusive‑incentive requirements (sidewalk extensions and pedestrian crossings on Arlington Avenue). The abatement would be up to seven years, with buildings coming online between 2024 and 2030. Executive Director Rusty Carr clarified that the TIF district (not the abatement) would require additional public hearings, including a future MDC hearing. Commissioner Blackburn asked about greenspace; developer Matt Carlstead noted a 10‑acre wetland area and screening commitments. Commissioner Blackburn also asked about monitoring job creation; staff confirmed clawback provisions in project agreements. - 2022‑CZN‑847 and 2022‑CVR‑847 – Rezoning and Variances for 2619–2627 West Washington Street: Petitioner David Kingan requested rezoning from C4‑TOD to MU2‑TOD to allow mixed‑use development (four residential units above ground‑floor retail). The original proposal included a liquor store, which was removed after community opposition. The hearing examiner had recommended denial. The petitioner amended commitments: no alcohol sales or liquor license requests; a high‑intensity crosswalk (HAWK crossing); and withdrawal of a variance for parking lot access from Holmes Avenue, instead agreeing to access from the alley (West Maryland Street). Remonstrator Talesa Lloyd voiced ongoing concern about future restaurant alcohol sales. Staff supported the rezoning but preferred alley access for pedestrian safety. The commission discussed the site plan and the number of parking spaces. - 2023‑CZN‑831 and 2023‑CVR‑831 – Rezoning for 4185–4201 College Avenue: Staff (Kathleen Blackham) presented a city‑owned parcel being rezoned from SU9‑TOD to MU1‑TOD for a mixed‑use affordable housing development. The plan includes 75–90 two‑ and three‑bedroom units (no studios or one‑bedrooms) targeting 30%–120% AMI, plus ground‑floor retail and community space. Two variances were requested: building height up to 70 feet (including elevator shafts/parapets) and a zero‑foot transitional side setback (using an alley as separation). Petitioner Michael McKillop (Midtown Indy) described extensive community outreach and a commitment to an administrative approval process with design review. No remonstrators appeared. The project is expected to apply for 9% Low‑Income Housing Tax Credits. The city will transfer the land via a qualifying corporation transfer to Midtown Indy. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar items (resolutions 1–5 and 7) were approved 7‑0 (with Commissioner Morerity noted as voting no on E020, making that resolution pass 6‑1). - Resolution 2023‑A026 (final tax abatement for County Line Road industrial park) was approved 7‑1. - Petitions 2022‑CZN‑847 and 2022‑CVR‑847 (West Washington Street rezoning and variances) were approved 7‑1 after the petitioner withdrew variance 1 (alley access) and confirmed no alcohol sales. - Petitions 2023‑CZN‑831 and 2023‑CVR‑831 (College Avenue rezoning and variances) were approved 8‑0. - Continuances: Two petitions (2023‑ZON‑021 and 2023‑ZON‑027) were continued to July 19, 2023 (approved 8‑0). An automatic continuance for petitions 2023‑CZN‑823 and 2023‑CVR‑823 was granted to August 2, 2023. - No‑appeals docket: 16 items (including park improvements and zoning adjustments) were approved 8‑0. The meeting adjourned after the final votes.

ZONING AND LAND USE 21% · TRANSPORTATION 19% · PROCEDURAL 15% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 15%
725
JUN 21, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission Meeting - June 21, 2023

The Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held its regular meeting on June 21, 2023, at approximately 6:00 PM. The meeting covered election of officers, approval of consent agenda resolutions, continuances, and public hearings for two major development petitions. All actions were taken via roll call votes. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes of the June 7, 2023 meeting were approved unanimously by voice vote. - Officer Election: The commission elected the 2023 slate of officers: John Dillon (President), Megan Garber (Vice President), Vincent Ash (Secretary), and Brian Murphy (Acting Secretary). The vote was 7-0. - Resolutions: Eleven resolutions (2023-R018, 2023-R024, 2023-R025, 2023-R028, 2023-R029, 2023-E019, 2023-A022, 2023-C003, 2023-C004, 2023-P013, 2023-BB003) were read into the record and approved unanimously (7-0). These included authorizations for DMD agreements, tax abatements, supportive services contracts, and infrastructure reimbursements. Continuances & Special Requests - 2023 ZON 023 / VAR 003 (Ditch Road): Requested by petitioner Brian Tuey; continued to July 19, 2023. Vote 6-0. - 2022 CZN 862 / CVR 862: Requested by attorney Murray Clark; continued to July 19, 2023. Vote 6-0. Remonstrators were present and encouraged to return. - 2023 CAP 829 / CVR 829 / CVC 829 (Eugene Street / West 30th Street): Waiver of notice (8-day waiver) granted. Vote 5-0 with Commissioner Murphy recused. - 2023 ZON 027 (1130 & 1134 East 19th Street): Continued to July 5, 2023. Vote 6-0. - 2023 CZN & CBR 831 (College Avenue): Continued to July 5, 2023. Vote 6-0. - Case Number Correction: Case 2023 CZN 848 corrected to 2022 CZN 848. Petitions of No Appeal Six petitions were considered and approved unanimously (6-0): 2023 APP 014, 2023 ZON 013, 2023 ZON 015, 2023 ZON 020, 2022 CZN 848, and 2023 CZN 817. Public Hearing: 2023 CVR 817B (Horizon Bank) - Petitioner: Horizon Bank (represented by Joseph D. Cauldron) seeking two variances related to a mixed-use development at 5959 East 38th Street and surrounding properties. The project includes a bank branch and 164 affordable rental housing units (50-60% AMI). The variances appeal a denial for improvements in the 60-foot stream protection corridor and deficient interior parking lot landscaping. - Remonstrator: Catherine Ping (adjacent homeowner) expressed safety concerns about children accessing Pogue Run creek and requested a protective barrier. She urged the commission to require a fence and maintenance. - Staff: Supported approval of variances with conditions, including substantial landscaping along the stream corridor and around dumpsters, and a commitment to share the final site plan with neighbors for review. - Outcome: Approved 6-0 with commitments, including substantial landscaping and fence design coordination with the remonstrator. Public Hearing: 2023 CAP 829 / CVR 829 / CVC 829 (NRP Group / Flanner House) - Petitioner: NRP Group (represented by Will Gooden) seeking modifications to a plan of operation, a use variance, and alley vacations to develop two multifamily residential projects (mixed-income affordability), a community grocery store, and a workforce training center. The project includes 122 multifamily units and 12,160 square feet of food supply. - Staff: Recommended approval with commitments, including livability space ratio standards. The petitioner agreed to most commitments but objected to the livability space ratio; they withdrew the request for a fourth alley vacation and the waiver of assessments for certain alleys. - Commission Discussion: Concerns raised about livability space and family unit sizes. Petitioner's representative confirmed compliance with state minimums, including a 1,075 sq. ft. three-bedroom unit requirement. - Outcome: Approved 5-0 with Commissioner Murphy recused. The alley vacation motion passed 5-0. Key Outcomes - All votes passed with majorities; no opposition votes on any item. - Continuances granted to July 5 and July 19, 2023. - Horizon Bank variances approved with added conditions. - NRP Group project approved with commitments, including a reduction in alley vacations and waiver withdrawal. - Next meeting scheduled for July 5, 2023.

ZONING AND LAND USE 53% · PROCEDURAL 27% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 13% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 2%
726
JUN 20, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III Public Hearing - June 20, 2023

This public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, convened on June 20, 2023, at approximately 6:00 PM, chaired by Joanna Taft. Board members present included Rihanna Binder, Paul and Roderick Bohannon, Percy Bland, and Paula Aguirita Rivera. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz. The board addressed procedural requests, unanimously approved five expedited petitions, and deliberated on three variance cases involving signs and a fence. All votes were recorded by roll call. Consent Calendar - Fee transfer and continuance (2023 UV 3013): Petitioner Brian Twee requested transfer of filing fees from a variance petition to a rezoning petition at staff's suggestion, and a continuance. The board approved the fee transfer unanimously and continued the case to the September 19 hearing, despite an audience member's request for an earlier date. - Continuance (2023 UV 3012): Approved unanimously to the August 15 hearing for additional development standards review. - Waiver (2023 DV3023): A two-day waiver of the sign notice was granted unanimously. - Continuance (2023 DV3019): Approved unanimously to the August 15 hearing. - Waiver (2023 UV3014): A four-day waiver of the legal notice was granted unanimously. - Continuance (2023 DV3022): Approved unanimously to the August 15 hearing for refiling as a special exception. - Waiver (2023 DV3021): A two-day waiver of the legal notice was granted unanimously. - Expedited petitions: The board voted unanimously to approve five petitions without additional testimony: 2023 DV3017 (two illuminated pylon signs within 600 feet of a protected district for Kindred Hospital), 2023 DV3020 (parking expansion, resulting in 812 total spaces vs. 717 permitted for Costco), 2023 UV3009 (freestanding building with deficient setbacks and landscaping for FFFW Callaway Group), 2023 UV3014 (variance of use for up to 50 multifamily units and independent social services for BWI LLC), and 2023 UV3011 (manufacturing materials associated with a commercial contractor for City Site LLC). Discussion Items Case: Sign Height Variance (case number unclear; referred to as "2023 DB 301" or "2023 D V 3011") - The petitioner, an owner of a property with an existing 21-foot sign, requested a variance to keep the sign at 21 feet rather than the 20-foot maximum. The petitioner argued that the sign cabinet is damaged and poses a safety risk, and that neighboring property is zoned mixed-use commercial, not strictly residential. The petitioner also cited a need to advertise competitive gas prices. - Staff recommended denial, stating the sign could be reduced to 20 feet or replaced with a conforming sign, and that the property could be used without the variance. - The board voted 4-1 to approve the variance (Rivera, Bland, Taft, and Bohannon yes; Bender no), subject to revised findings of fact. Case: 2023 DV3021 – Fence Variance, 1690 South Spencer Avenue - Petitioner Laisha Coons and her husband Charles Jackson testified regarding two fences: a 6-foot fence on Minnesota Street (17 years old, 30 feet from street edge, below grade) and a 5-foot fence on Spencer Avenue. They argued the fences were necessary for safety (cars and trespassers) and that the grade made the Spencer fence less visible. They requested to keep the Spencer fence at 5 feet from the south building line to Minnesota, reducing to conforming height in front of the dwelling. - Staff gave a split recommendation: approval for the Minnesota Street fence (including encroachments into the clear site triangle and right-of-way) and denial for the Spencer Avenue portion, though staff acknowledged the grade argument. - The board approved both parts unanimously (5-0). Ballot A (Minnesota Street) and Ballot B (Spencer Avenue from the south building line to Minnesota Street) were approved, with a condition allowing increased height based on elevation subject to administrative approval. The case was continued for revised findings. Case: 2023 DV3023 – Pylon Sign with Digital Display, 6160 East 38th Street - Petitioner Brent Bennett and Michael McFarland (representing Indy Fresh Market) requested a variance for a pylon sign with a 28.2-square-foot digital display located 218 feet from a protected district (400 feet required). They argued the sign is vital for the grocery store in a food desert, would be used for community announcements, and that the protected area is undeveloped. They also noted the building is under construction and the sign would be visually obstructed. - Staff recommended denial, stating the digital display is not permitted that close to a protected district, the food desert would be served without the display, and a wall sign could be used. Staff also noted the property has high visibility from the future Purple Line. - The board voted 3-2 to approve the variance, with Bland, Binder, and Bohannon voting yes; Rivera and Taft voting no. Key Outcomes - All procedural motions (fee transfer, continuances, waivers) were passed unanimously. - All five expedited petitions were approved unanimously. - The uncertain sign height variance was approved 4-1, with continued findings. - The fence variance (2023 DV3021) was fully approved 5-0, with conditional grade-related height and continued findings. - The Indy Fresh Market digital sign variance (2023 DV3023) was approved 3-2. - The board acknowledged the withdrawal of 2023 DV3016. The meeting was adjourned after the final votes and the signing of findings.

PROCEDURAL 26% · SIGN REGULATION 25% · FENCE REGULATION 25% · ZONING AND LAND USE 21%
727
JUN 13, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS II
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 Public Hearing - June 13, 2023

The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 2, chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members Beth Brandon and Tom Barnes, held a public hearing on June 13, 2023. The board heard continuances, one expedited petition, and two regular docket petitions. All decisions required a unanimous vote due to the three-member panel. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Staub, owner of 936 North Oakland Avenue and president of the Near East Side Community Organization (NESCO), testified in support of petition 2023 UV2053 (3721 East 10th Street) for an automobile repair shop. He requested three commitments: a scissor gate on the north overhead door to prevent drive-through access, no use of the alley behind the building, and no outdoor storage of vehicles or parts. The community supported the variance subject to these commitments. Discussion Items - Continuances: Several cases were continued to the July 11, 2023 hearing: - 2023-DV2-011 (Pike Township): Automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2023 DB 2008 (3802 East 10th Street): Automatic continuance acknowledged. - 2023 DB 2009 (6151 North Keystone Avenue): Continued with additional notice due to amendment and requests from neighborhood organization and city-county councillor. Motion carried unanimously. - Expedited Petition 2023 UV 2002 (6627 Man Road, Decatur Township): Request for variance of use to construct five secondary dwellings with entries not visible from the right-of-way, only one secondary dwelling permitted, and other restrictions. No opposition. Approved unanimously (3-0). - Regular Petition 2023 DV2-005 (4540 North Park Avenue, Washington Township): Request for variance to construct a detached carriage house with a secondary dwelling of 850 square feet (720 max permitted) and 72% open space (75% required). Petitioner Mark Demerley requested a continuance to July 11, 2023, due to concerns about calculation of square footage and the board's three-member panel. No opposition. Continued without additional notice (unanimous). - Regular Petition 2023 UV2053 (3721 East 10th Street, Center Township): Request for variance of use and development standards to operate an automobile repair shop in an existing building zoned MU1 (mixed-use), which does not permit auto repair. The business would have 11 parking spaces (20 required). Petitioner Jacob Bratton and owner Jose Calderon explained the business model: scheduled repairs, no overnight storage, minimal customer parking. Staff recommended approval, noting the property was mis-zoned and the use is consistent with the comprehensive plan (light industrial). The community (NESCO) supported with three commitments. The petitioner agreed to the scissor gate and no outdoor storage (as per plan of operation) but could not commit to never using the front door for vehicle entry or restricting alley use. After discussion, the board clarified that the plan of operation already prohibits outdoor storage. The variance was approved subject to staff recommendations and the commitment to install a gate. Unanimous vote (3-0). Key Outcomes - Approved: - 2023 UV 2002 (expedited) – variance approved (3-0). - 2023 UV2053 – variance approved with conditions: compliance with site plan and plan of operation, and installation of a scissor gate on the north overhead door (3-0). - Continued: - 2023 DV2-005 – continued to July 11, 2023, without additional notice. - 2023 DB 2009 – continued to July 11, 2023, with additional notice. - Acknowledged: Automatic continuances for 2023-DV2-011 and 2023 DB 2008. - Additional Business: The board addressed signing of findings from previous months. Beth Brandon was to sign as acting secretary for commitments from May 16, 2023, and Chair Von Dalen signed findings for petitions 2022 DV2042 and 2022 DV2048.

ZONING AND LAND USE 55% · PROCEDURAL 19% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 11% · TOW REGULATION 8%
728
JUN 7, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
Metropolitan Development Commission Public Meeting - June 7, 2023

The Metropolitan Development Commission held its public meeting on June 7, 2023, at 6:00 PM. The meeting included approval of previous minutes, a block of six resolutions, four public hearings on tax abatement matters, two continuances, and an eight-item no-appeals docket. All votes were unanimous 7-0. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes from the May 17, 2023 meeting with minor typographical corrections. - Approved six resolutions (including 2023 R019 and 2023 R020) as a block, covering continued work on the South Downtown Connectivity Plan, design services for downtown public spaces, an agency-wide cost allocation plan, and a tax abatement compliance determination for Polaris Laboratories. (Vote: 7-0) - Approved the no-appeals docket consisting of eight petitions (2023 APP 013, 2023 MOD 007, 2022 ZON 102 amended, 2022 ZON 133, 2023 ZON 028 amended, 2023 ZON 029, 2023 CZN 812, 2023 CZN 816) as recommended for approval. (Vote: 7-0) Public Comments & Testimony No public comments were offered during the public hearing portions or the continuance requests. Public Hearings Four public hearings were held on tax abatement matters, each presented by DMD staff and approved unanimously: - 2023 A016 (Messer): Amendment to reduce job positions, increase wages, and extend the real property ERA for a 2019 tax abatement at 1045 Harding Court. Approved 7-0. - 2023 A023 (Century Ventures LLC / Century Bio Pharma Services Inc.): Final economic revitalization area resolution for a five-year real property tax abatement at 4605 Decatur Boulevard and 4410 Coleman Road. Approved 7-0. - 2023 A024 (Marquee): Waiver of the 2022 pay/2023 deduction application filing deadline for a tax abatement at 2365 Enterprise Park Place. Approved 7-0. - 2023 A025 (Polaris Laboratories): Determination of compliance with tax abatement terms, requiring payment of $6,325.59 due to non-compliance with new job positions. Approved 7-0. Continuances - 2022 CZN/C VR 847 (2619-2627 West Washington Street): Petitioner David King requested a continuance to the July 5, 2023 meeting, stating that the project had removed a liquor store component and now proposed a mixed-use development with five apartments and retail space. The commission granted the continuance, emphasizing it was the final opportunity, after a commissioner noted the site's poor condition. Approved 7-0. - 2023 ZON 020 (25 South Tuxedo Street) and 2023 ZON 027 (1130 and 1134 East 19th Street): Both continued to the June 21, 2023 meeting pending receipt of commitments. Approved 7-0. Key Outcomes - All votes were unanimous (7-0) throughout the meeting. - The election of officers was postponed to the July 5, 2023 meeting. - Resolution 2023 R023 was withdrawn. - The commission welcomed new member Dan Morerity. - The meeting adjourned.

ZONING AND LAND USE 29% · TAXATION 26% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 18% · PROCEDURAL 15%
729
JUN 6, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS I
Indianapolis BZA Division 1 Hearing - June 6, 2023

The Indianapolis Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division 1 held a public hearing on June 6, 2023, starting at 6:15 PM. Chairman Peter Nelson presided, with board members David Duncan, Renee Napoleon (alternate), and Aaron McBride (alternate) present. Legal counsel was Chris Steinmetz. The board heard requests for variances of development standards and use, expedited petitions, and administrative items. The meeting included withdrawals, continuances, and votes on several petitions. Due to only four members present, any split vote would cause the petition to be continued to the next available hearing on July 6, 2023. Consent Calendar - The board unanimously approved a waiver of rules of procedure to vote on all expedited petitions without additional testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Councillor Kristen Jones (District 16) spoke in support of the fence variance for the Eritrean Orthodox Tewahdo Cathedral, citing safety concerns for children and noting no opposition from neighbors. - Bobby Gutierrez, a resident at 1741 Lafayette Road, opposed the pylon sign for the Lafayette Rooms event center, stating it would be intrusive in the residential neighborhood. He did not oppose the wall sign or the event center itself. Discussion Items Withdrawals and Continuances - Petition 2023-UV-1006 (Martin Petroleum Inc.) was withdrawn after staff recommended rezoning instead of a variance. The board approved transferring applicable fees to the companion rezoning petition 2023-CZN-830/C-VR-830. - Petition 2023-UV-1011 (6809 West Washington Street) was continued to July 6, 2023, without additional notice at the request of Councillor Evans for further neighborhood discussions. - Petition 2023-UV-1010 (1946 North Euclid Avenue) was automatically continued to July 6, 2023, due to a timely request from a registered neighborhood organization. - Petition 2023-DV-1022 (2247 Broadway Street) was continued to July 6, 2023, with additional notice to allow for an amendment. Expedited Docket - Petition 2023-DV-1023 (4511 Central Avenue) was approved unanimously. It allowed a detached garage with a 5-foot north side yard setback (7 feet required). - Petition 2023-UV-1008 (545 Southeast Street) was approved unanimously. It permitted building additions, making the residential component of a live-work unit the dominant use. - Petition 2023-UV-1009 (Two jets LLC) was approved unanimously. It allowed an addition to an existing single-family dwelling with a 2-foot west transitional side yard (10 feet required). - Petition 2023-UV-2006 (2320 Duke Street) was approved unanimously. It permitted a rubber press (heavy manufacturing) use. Petition 2023-DV-2004: Fence Variance (849 South Belmont Avenue) - The Eritrean Orthodox Tewahdo Cathedral requested a 54-inch decorative fence in the front yard and clear sight triangle. Maximum fence height is 42 inches, and encroachments in clear sight triangles are prohibited. Attorney Adam Lenkowski presented the petitioner's case. Remonstrators were not present, but Councillor Jones spoke in support. Staff recommended denial, noting the fence height may obstruct sight lines and pedestrian safety. The petitioner had moved the fence from the clear sight triangle, but staff could not verify exact measurements. The board approved the variance, subject to the commitment that the relocation be per the site plan. Petition 2023-DV-1024: Sign Variances (1718 Lafayette Road) - Lafayette Rooms LLC requested a 12.5-foot tall, 11.25-square-foot pylon sign and a 40-square-foot wall sign (max 6 square feet) for an event center. Attorney David Deering argued the variances were necessary because the property remains zoned residential despite years of commercial use. Staff recommended denial, citing procedural issues and lack of demonstrated hardship. The board split the vote. The pylon sign was denied (0-4), while the wall sign was approved (3-1, Nelson dissenting). Both petitions were continued for adoption of findings of fact. Key Outcomes - All expedited petitions (2023-UV-1008, 2023-UV-1009, 2023-UV-2006) were approved unanimously (4-0). - Petition 2023-DV-2004 was approved unanimously (4-0), with a commitment to adhere to the site plan for the fence relocation. - Petition 2023-DV-1024 A (pylon sign) was denied (0-4); Part B (wall sign) was approved (3-1). Both remained continued for adoption of findings. - Petition 2022-DV-2045 (amended findings of fact) was adopted, marking the first opportunity to obtain the third required signature (Renee Napoleon). - The hearing adjourned after all business was completed. Note: No agenda or minutes were available; this summary is based solely on the raw transcript.

ZONING AND LAND USE 56% · SIGN REGULATION 15% · PROCEDURAL 13% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 12%
730
MAY 24, 2023 · INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA · BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS III
Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals Hearing - May 24, 2023

The Indianapolis Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) convened on May 24, 2023, with three members present (Chairperson Bohannon, Binder, and Barnes) to hear requests for continuances, waivers, and variances. The board addressed expedited and non-expedited dockets, making decisions on residential, commercial, and industrial property matters. The meeting included public testimony, staff recommendations, and votes on each petition. Several cases were continued to future hearings due to indecisive votes. Continuances and Waivers - Arbor Street (2023 UV 3003): Granted a two-month continuance to July 18, 2023, at the petitioner's request, with staff support. Final continuance allowed. - 2023 DV 2006 (231 Hendricks Place): Granted a 13-day waiver of mailing notice due to a typo in the original address; staff confirmed the public was aware. - 2023 UV 3009 (1330 Sadlier Circle West Drive): Acknowledged withdrawal of the use portion of the variance; development standard request remained on the expedited docket. - 2023 DV 3018 (1223 Lexington Avenue): Granted a two-day waiver of legal notice; staff had no objection. - 2023 DV 2007 (1502 West 25th Street): Speaker initially requested a two-day waiver but determined it was not needed; remained on expedited docket. - 2023 DV 3016 (1616 Marlowe Avenue): Granted a one-day waiver of notice; staff had no objection. - 2023 UV 3-004 (349 North Post Road): Withdrawal of petition acknowledged. - 2023 UV 3-006 (3650 and 3652 South Meridian Street): Withdrawal of petition acknowledged. - 2023 UV 3-010 (1041 South East Street): Granted a one-day waiver of notice for the expedited docket. - 2023 DV 3017 (1700 West 10th Street): Granted a continuance to June 20, 2023, without additional notice; first request by petitioner. Expedited Docket All expedited cases were read, and the board voted separately on each. The following petitions were approved unanimously (3-0): - 2023 DV 2006 (231 Hendricks Place): Variance for a single-family dwelling with a 5.5-foot rear yard setback (15 feet required). - 2023 DV 2007 (1502 West 25th Street): Variance for a 5-foot corner side setback (8 feet required). - 2023 DV 3014 (5464 East 18th Street): Variance for a covered addition resulting in a 3.5-foot side yard setback (5 feet required). - 2023 UV 3010 (1041 South East Street): Variance to legally establish residential uses and reduce setbacks (10-foot front and side, 15-foot rear required). - 2023 DV 3018 (1223 Lexington Avenue): Variance for a 5-foot side yard setback and 37% open space (40% required). 2023 UV 3009 (1330 Sadlier Circle West Drive) received 2 yes and 1 no votes, resulting in an indecisive vote and automatic continuance to the June 20 hearing. The petitioner requested transfer to another board, but the chair noted rules require a second attempt before transfer. Non-Expedited Cases 2023 DV 1016 (2701 Wheeler Street) - Approved - Petitioner: Georgia May Craig, represented by Gary Cole, requested a variance to allow vehicular access from 27th Street instead of the improved alley. They cited safety concerns, poor alley conditions, and adjacency to neighboring properties already using 27th Street. A supporter, Vernon Compton (President of Brightwood Concerned Citizens), spoke in favor. - Staff: Opposed, citing the 2016 ordinance requiring alley access for lots under 200 feet, safety benefits of reducing curb cuts, and the alley being in good condition. They noted the driveway would be 30 feet from the intersection. - Vote: 3-0 in favor. The board approved the variance. 2023 DV 3011 (1855 North Shadeland Avenue) - Continued (Indecisive) - Petitioner: MG Oil Inc., represented by Cindy Thrasher, requested a 23-foot-tall illuminated sign (max 20 feet, illumination prohibited within 50 feet of protected district). The petitioner withdrew the illumination and LED portions, leaving only the height variance. - Staff: Opposed, recommending a sign face change or alternative location, but the petitioner argued the existing sign cabinet needed replacement. - Vote: 1 yes (Bohannon), 2 no (Binder, Barnes) – indecisive, continued to June 20 without additional notice. 2023 DV 3015 (2300 North Sherman Drive) - Denied - Petitioner: CR Commercial Parking LLC, represented by John Cross, requested a variance for an unmarked, unpaved gravel parking area for truck/trailer storage. They cited financial hardship (paving estimates of $384,000 for asphalt, $1 million for concrete) and the site's existing use. - Remonstrator: Vernon Compton (Brightwood Concerned Citizens) opposed, citing dust, runoff, and proximity to Pogue's Run, and demanded paving. - Staff: Opposed, noting the site was vacant until 2018, had standing water, no striping, and could accommodate 200+ trucks; staff argued the owner could afford paving after purchasing the property for $2.225 million. - Vote: 0-3, denied. The petition was continued for adoption of findings of fact. 2023 DV 3016 (1616 Marlowe Avenue) - Continued (Indecisive) - Petitioner: James A. Allen, represented by David Deering, requested a variance for a 6-foot front yard fence (max 3.5 feet). Allen testified about safety concerns due to a nearby drug house and prior intrusions. Deering noted several existing 6-foot fences in the area, arguing no adverse effect. - Staff: Opposed, citing safety and visibility concerns, suggesting cameras or shrubs as alternatives. Staff noted three letters of opposition and two letters of support. - Vote: 1 yes (Binder), 2 no (Barnes, Bohannon) – indecisive, continued to June 20 without additional notice. Key Outcomes - Approvals: 5 expedited cases (2023 DV 2006, 2007, 3014, 3018, and UV 3010) and 1 non-expedited case (2023 DV 1016) were approved. - Denials: 1 case (2023 DV 3015) was denied. - Continuations: 3 cases (2023 UV 3009, 2023 DV 3011, 2023 DV 3016) were continued to June 20, 2023 due to indecisive votes. Additional continuances were granted for other cases. - Waivers: Several notice waivers (ranging from 1 to 13 days) were granted. - Withdrawals: Acknowledged withdrawals for 2023 UV 3009 (partial), 2023 UV 3-004, and 2023 UV 3-006. The board adjourned after completing the docket, with no further business.

ZONING AND LAND USE 42% · PROCEDURAL 18% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · FENCE REGULATION 9%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com