The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division II met on November 15, 2022, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building to hear and decide on multiple variance petitions. The board consisted of Chairperson Craig E. Von Dalen, Members James Duke, Patrice Ducett Brown, and Kirk Farmer. The meeting covered expedited petitions, transferred petitions, and new petitions, with a focus on variances for fences, signs, residential conversions, and commercial uses. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions (Approved Unanimously): - 2022-DV1-049: Variance for lot line adjustment and barn legalization at 5720/5724 East Southport Road. Approved subject to conditions. - 2022-DV2-040: Variance for three-foot side setbacks for a detached garage at 1517 Ringgold Avenue. Approved. - 2022-DV2-041: Variance for three-foot side setback for a detached garage at 5939 Winthrop Avenue. Approved. - 2022-UV1-039: Variance of use for a jewelry store or yoga studio at 6331 Carrollton Avenue. Approved. - 2022-UV2-021 (Amended): Variance for duplex construction on each of two parcels at 5822/5824 Norcroft Drive. Approved with conditions. - 2022-UV2-025: Variance for addition to existing dwelling with a 3.1-foot side setback at 1129 Worcester Avenue. Approved. - 2022-UV2-026 (Amended): Variance for addition to existing dwelling with reduced side setbacks at 1603/1605 Bates Street. Approved. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022-DV1-036 (Meridian Hills Fence): Petitioner Jacob Cox argued for a five-foot wrought iron fence in the front yard along Meridian Street for child and pet safety due to high-speed traffic and a steep hill. The Town of Meridian Hills approved a variance and supported the request. Remonstrance: None present. - 2022-DV1-048 (Lutheran High School Sign): Petitioner Zach Akers (school senior and then Zach Akers) presented the need for a digital electronic variable message sign to replace an aging monument sign, citing improved safety, reduced illumination, and community support from the Franklin Township Civic League and Councilor Brian Mowry. No public opposition. - 2022-UV1-014, 015, 016 (Reagan Outdoor Advertising Digital Billboards): Petitioners Michelle Noppenberger and John Campbell argued for converting three existing static billboards to digital displays, emphasizing public service features (Amber Alerts), safety studies, and economic necessity. Remonstrators included Pat Andrews (Marion County Alliance for Neighborhood Associations), Gary Chaluffo (Historic Urban Neighborhoods), Councilor Dan Boots (District 3), Jordan Dillon (Broad Ripple Village Association), Paula Brooks (Hoosier Environmental Council), and others. They cited staff recommendations, the city's ban on digital billboards, potential driver distraction, light pollution, and negative precedent. Councilor Keith Potts (District 2) opposed the Broad Ripple petition. Multiple neighborhood organizations submitted opposition letters. - 2022-UV1-037 (977 Roache Street Apartments): Petitioners Joseph Cirillo and Anthony Mormon sought a variance to convert a former commercial building into a four-unit apartment, highlighting the property's deteriorated condition and similar multi-unit properties nearby. Remonstrators Mauna Wadud and Hadiah Wadud Amit (Northwest Landing Neighborhood Association) opposed, citing concerns about parking, traffic, safety, incompatibility with the neighborhood's revitalization plan, and distrust of the petitioner's background. Discussion Items - 2022-DV1-048 (School Sign): Staff classified the proposed sign as a pylon sign (not monument) due to structural interpretation, but the board and petitioner argued it fell under monument sign definitions. Staff opposed the digital display due to proximity to protected districts and lack of practical difficulty. The petitioner emphasized the sign's low height (5 feet), decreased illumination, and support from local officials. - 2022-UV1-014, 015, 016 (Digital Billboards): Staff detailed that the requested variances violated the 2019 sign ordinance (ban on off-premise digital billboards) and failed to meet statutory requirements for practical difficulty, self-created injury, and feasible alternatives. Petitioners provided traffic accident data from Fall Creek Parkway and I-465 locations, showing no increase in accidents after digital installations. Remonstrators pointed to studies indicating increased driver distraction and the city council's unanimous decision to ban such signs. - 2022-UV1-037 (Roache Street Apartments): Staff recommended approval, noting the adaptive reuse of a structure with residential character and consistency with nearby D-5 zoning that permits multi-unit houses. The board questioned apartment sizes (studio/one-bedroom) and potential for low-income tenants. The petitioner stated rents would follow HUD guidelines ($900-1200 per month). Remonstrators argued the building should remain commercial or serve as a community center. Key Outcomes - 2022-DV1-036 (Meridian Hills Fence): Approved 4-0. Variance granted for a five-foot wrought iron fence in the front yard. - 2022-DV1-048 (Lutheran High School Sign): Approved 3-1 (Member Farmer dissenting). Variance granted for a 58.2-square foot sign with a 23.14-square foot digital component, located 80 feet from a protected district. - 2022-UV1-014 (I-465 Billboard): Denied 4-0. Petition continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2022-UV1-015 (Sam Jones Expressway Billboard): Denied 4-0. Continued for adoption of findings. - 2022-UV1-016 (Broad Ripple Billboard): Denied 4-0. Continued for adoption of findings. - 2022-UV1-037 (Roache Street Apartments): Denied 3-1 (Member Farmer in favor). Petition denied. - 2022-UV2-024 (Minnesota Street – Indecisive): Continued to January 10, 2023, without additional notice. - 2022-UV3-022 (River Avenue – Transferred): Continued to January 10, 2023, without additional notice. - 2022-UV3-025 (Sherman Drive Daycare): Continued to December 13, 2022, without additional notice. - 2022-DV2-039 (Keystone Avenue Sign): Transferred to Division III hearing on November 22, 2022. - 2022-DV2-042 (Chester Avenue Third Story): Continued to December 13, 2022, without additional notice. - 2022-DV2-043 (81st Street – Automatic Continuance): Acknowledged continuance to December 13, 2022.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held a public meeting on November 2, 2022, at 6:15 PM (18:15). The meeting included approval of minutes from October 19, 2022, reading of 16 resolutions, a public hearing on amendments to the commission's rules of procedure, approval of 15 resolutions, continuance requests, action on petitions of no appeals, and a contested rezoning hearing. All votes were unanimous (8-0) unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the October 19, 2022 meeting were approved by a unanimous vote (8-0) with no additions or deletions. - Bulk Approval of 15 Resolutions: After the public hearing on the rules of procedure, the remaining 15 resolutions (numbers 2022 R039 through R044, 2022 E041 through E044, 2022 FS003, 2022 P017 through P020) were approved unanimously (8-0). These resolutions covered a range of administrative actions, including contract amendments, property transfers, loan authorizations, and professional service agreements. Specific items include: - Adding $23,282 to a contract with STR Grants LLC for land bank property portfolio management. - Adding $50,000 to a contract with Allied Logistical Services for property preservation. - Transfer of property at 2434 Winthrop Avenue to INHP for $25,000 for affordable housing. - A loan for the same property with funds revolving back to the DMD Brownfield Program. - Amendment to maintenance agreement with Indianapolis Marion County Building Authority (increase of $150,000). - Professional services agreement with Urban Land Institute for Market East District planning (up to $30,000). - Declaratory resolutions for redevelopment areas including Coal Motor Allocation Area and City Market Redevelopment Area. - Contract amendments for CAT Consulting ($50,000), Story Board LLC ($15,000), History Concierge LLC ($20,000), and James Holland for hearing examiner services ($2,000). - Professional services agreements for Marion County Land Use Plan Assessment ($50,000), West Washington Street Corridor economic impact study ($280,000 with $240,000 from Airport Authority), and Regional Center Design Guidelines update ($400,000). Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made during the public hearing on the rules of procedure or during other agenda items, except for the contested rezoning hearing (see Discussion Items). Discussion Items - Rules of Procedure Amendments (Resolution 2022 P016): Shannon (DMD staff) presented a comprehensive update to the MDC, Plat Committee, and Hearing Officer rules of procedure. Key changes included: - Adherence to Indiana Code and state law regarding time computation (excluding holidays/weekends instead of business/calendar days). - Allowing electronic filing of applications. - Adding minimum filing time for Plat Committee. - Correcting citations to Indy Rezone and state code. - Removing references to Speedway hearing examiner (no longer under MDC jurisdiction). - Clarifying complete applications and docketing. - Updating automatic continuance rules per council advice. - Allowing recused commissioners to remain in the room (no longer required to leave). - Notifying city-county counselors of administrative approval of final plans. - The last comprehensive update was in 2013, with minor changes in 2014, 2017, and 2019. The resolution passed unanimously (8-0) and became effective immediately. - Continuance Requests: - Case 2022 ZON 051 and companion 2022 VAR003 (Buck Creek matter, 11811 & 1194 Southeastern and 700 S. Carroll Road): Petitioner Joe Calderon requested continuance to January 18, 2023, due to ongoing negotiations that may require an amendment triggering notice. Staff supported. Unanimously approved (8-0). - Case 2022 CAP 858 / 2022 CVR 858 (3820 N. Keystone Avenue): Petitioner Calderon requested a two-week continuance to November 16, 2022, as he was recently retained. Staff supported without additional notice. Unanimously approved (8-0). - Case 2022 CZN 833 / 2022 CVR 833 (2425 W. Michigan Street, Indianapolis Public Transportation Corporation): Petitioner Howard Stevenson requested continuance to December 7, 2022, at the request of Councillor Vop Osley. Staff supported. Unanimously approved (8-0). President Dillon noted a preference for trash cans to be hidden behind buildings. - Case 2022 ZON 115 (1255 & 1351 Roosevelt Avenue): Staff requested continuance to November 16, 2022, pending receipt and review of commitments. Unanimously approved (8-0). - Petitions of No Appeals: Five petitions recommended for approval were approved unanimously (8-0): - 2022 ZON 101 (1067 W. 29th St., Center Twp., Dist. 11) - 2022 ZON 105 (2340 & 2344 Shelby St., Center Twp., Dist. 21) - 2022 ZON 107 (11517 E. 38th St., Warren Twp., Dist. 14) - 2022 ZON 114 (1657 & 1661 N. Arsenal Ave., Center Twp., Dist. 17) - 2022 CZN 850 (700 N. High School Rd., Wayne Twp., Dist. 15) - One petition recommended for denial (2022 ZON 077, 3653 Carson Ave., Perry Twp., Dist. 21) was confirmed for denial unanimously (8-0). - Contested Rezoning Hearing – 2022 ZON 096 (1401 S. Talbot St., approximate, Center Twp., Dist. 16): Petitioner BDD LLC (Marcus Crouch, Surfreek Companies) requested a rezoning from D5 to D8 on a 0.10-acre corner lot (35 ft x 130 ft). The hearing examiner recommended denial; the petitioner appealed. The petitioner argued that the lot only conforms to multi-unit house standards under D5 due to width, and that an exemption allowing single-family construction is contradicted by the use chart. He contended that D8 would allow flexibility and that the neighborhood's existing context (25% multi-family, industrial uses nearby) supports D8. The remonstrators (Old Southside Neighborhood Association, represented by Judith Essex, Melissa Brown, Matt Swickheimer, Heather Gallagher, and Jed Fuller) opposed the rezoning, stating they prefer single-family or duplex development and that the petitioner did not present specific plans. Staff (Kathleen) recommended denial, citing density concerns (duplex would yield 20 units/acre, four units 40 units/acre, exceeding the 5-15 units/acre for traditional neighborhoods), that the lot is on local streets not collector streets (per pattern book), and that the existing D5 zoning allows single-family, duplex, or up to four units via an exemption, though variances might be needed for setbacks. The petitioner rebutted that the exemption does not authorize use, and that the lot does not conform to D5 standards. After deliberation, the commission voted 8-0 to deny the rezoning, upholding the hearing examiner's denial. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2022 P016 (Rules of Procedure): Approved 8-0, effective immediately. - 15 Administrative Resolutions: Approved 8-0 en bloc. - Continuances: All four continuance requests approved unanimously. - Petitions of No Appeals: Five approved, one denial confirmed. - 2022 ZON 096 (rezoning): Denied 8-0, affirming the hearing examiner's recommendation. - Next Steps: The next meeting is scheduled for November 16, 2022, with several continued cases to be heard.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division I convened on November 1, 2022, at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. Only two board members were present (Matt Boone, acting chair, and David Duncan), which fell short of the three-member quorum required to take action. Consequently, all petitions on the agenda were continued to future hearing dates, primarily transferred to Division 2 on November 15, 2022, or other specified dates. Staff recommended denial on several petitions, but no votes were taken. Public Comments & Testimony - Brent Lyle (Flanner House, 2424 Dr. MLK Street) spoke on behalf of community members regarding Petition 2022-UV1-037 (977 Roache Street) and expressed no objection to the continuance. - Carol Barker (6334 Walton Street, representing RHGNA neighborhood association) requested that Petition 2022-UV1-020 (6805 Jackson Street) be transferred to November 15 rather than continued to January 2023, citing ongoing illegal parking of a commercial vehicle in a residential area. Her request was noted, but the board acknowledged the continuance to January 3, 2023. - Edwin Lock (Township Resident Association, 5318 Shadow Accord) stated no objection to the continuance of Petition 2022-UV1-016 (1060 Broad Ripple Avenue). Discussion Items - Lack of Quorum: Chair Matt Boone explained that only two board members were present, so every petition must be continued. All dismissals, withdrawals, and timely automatic continuance requests were acknowledged. - Continuance and Transfer Requests: Nearly all petitioners or their representatives requested transfers to Division 2 on November 15, 2022. Staff had no objections, and the board acknowledged these transfers. Only a few petitions were continued to different dates: - 2022-DV1-047 (409 East Morris Street) continued to December 6, 2022. - 2022-UV1-020 (6805 Jackson Street) continued to January 3, 2023 (petitioner requested; neighborhood association objecting requested November 15). - 2022-UV1-025 (3920 South Post Road) withdrawn at petitioner's request. - 2022-DV1-052 (358 East Terrace Avenue) continued to December 6, 2022 with additional notice. - 2022-UV1-035 (6234 East Hanna Avenue) continued to December 6, 2022. - 2022-UV1-036 (2711, 2715, 2719 Madison Avenue) continued to December 6, 2022 without additional notice. - 2022-UV1-038 (4010 West 86th Street) automatically continued to December 6, 2022 due to a timely automatic continuance request from a registered neighborhood organization. - Staff Recommendations: Staff reports for several petitions recommended denial, including those for a digital off-premise sign near I-465 (2022-UV1-014), a digital sign near I-70 (2022-UV1-015), a digital sign in Broad Ripple (2022-UV1-016), a commercial vehicle parking variance (2022-UV1-020), a semi-truck driver training school (2022-UV1-025), a self-storage facility with outdoor storage (2022-UV1-036), and a methadone clinic (2022-UV1-038). No decisions were made due to lack of quorum. Key Outcomes - All petitions continued or transferred: No actions were taken on the merits. The board acknowledged continuances and transfers as requested by petitioners or automatically. - Continuance with notice: Petition 2022-DV1-052 (358 East Terrace Avenue) was continued to December 6, 2022 with additional notice required. - Withdrawal: Petition 2022-UV1-025 (3920 South Post Road) was withdrawn. - Next hearing dates: Most petitions were transferred to Division 2 on November 15, 2022. Remaining petitions were scheduled for December 6, 2022 or January 3, 2023. - Staff to enforce notice: For continuances without additional notice, staff will enforce notice if required.
The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on October 19, 2022, to consider resolutions, continuances, no-appeal petitions, a contested rezoning and variance for a large industrial park on the south side, and a plat for the Elanco headquarters. All votes were unanimous except where recusals applied. Resolutions (Consent Calendar) - Five resolutions were approved unanimously (6-0 with one recusal on three, 7-0 on the remaining two): - 2022 R 037: Authorizing conveyance of two properties to Intend Indiana Inc. for neighborhood redevelopment. - 2022 R 038: Authorizing renovation of the Greyhound bus station restrooms at Union Station. - 2022 E 040: Authorizing $350,000 from the 96th Street Castleton Allocation Fund to reimburse the city for improvements at Keystone Avenue and Woodfield Crossing Boulevard. - 2022 A 024 & 2022 A 025: Preliminary economic revitalization areas for Raiz Bio Inc. (later corrected to Raised Bio Inc.) at 5850 West 88th Street and 5850 West 80th Street, recommending four-year real and personal property tax abatements. Commissioner Ash recused from these three. The presentation noted Raised Bio is developing targeted radiopharmaceuticals for pancreatic and lung cancer, investing $45 million in a 10-year lease with ProLogis. Continuances and Special Requests - 2022 ZON 083 (1751 South Laundale Avenue): Continued to December 21, 2022, with a "do or die" condition – approval 7-0. - 2022 ZON 101 (1067 West 29th Street): Continued to November 2, 2022 – 7-0. - 2022 ZON 107 (11517 East 38th Street): Continued to November 2, 2022 – 7-0. - 2022 VAC 002 (Massachusetts Avenue properties): Continued to November 16, 2022, after petitioner Murray Clark reported ongoing negotiations with stakeholders and Councilor Adamson, with assurances of resolution – 7-0. - 2022 UV 2021 (5822 & 5824 Nordcroft Drive): Waiver of the one-year refiling rule granted, allowing a rezoning petition previously denied on December 1, 2021, to be heard on November 15, 2022. The Decatur Township Civic Council and land use group now support – 7-0. Petitions of No Appeals - Approved (5 petitions): - 2022 MOD 014 (Mossy Creek Lane/Court, Franklin Twp) - 2022 ZON 074 amended (1305 West Troy Ave, Perry Twp) - 2022 CZN 812 amended (3544 & 3602 South Harding St, Perry Twp) - 2022 CZN 830 & 2022 CAP 830 (companion petitions, 7320 East Hannah Ave, Franklin Twp) - 2022 REG 061 (1840 North Meridian St, Center Twp) All approved 7-0. - Denied (1 petition): - 2022 ZON 062 (6900 East 21st Street, Warren Twp): Recommended for denial by staff and hearing examiner for a truck parking facility adjacent to homes and institutions. Commission affirmed denial 7-0. Contested Hearing: County Line Partners Rezoning and Variance - Petitions: 2022 ZON 060 and 2022 VAR 006 – GPCM County Line Partners, LLC, sought rezoning of 208.24 acres from CSC4 and DA to CS (commercial/industrial) and a variance for loading areas. The site at County Line Road and I-65 would become an industrial park (seven buildings up to 500,000 sq ft each, plus 6 acres of commercial) with 21 commitments. - Petitioner's Position (Brian Tuey): The project follows the strategic plan for the interchange area, provides substantial buffering (50-foot landscape buffer, 6-foot berm, evergreen trees, and a 6-foot concrete wall near residences), and will generate $131 million in assessed value and jobs. Staff and the hearing examiner recommended approval. Traffic improvements will maintain acceptable levels of service. The nearest residential neighbor (Robin Heldman) has a 564-foot setback with intensive screening. - Remonstrator Position: - Robin Heldman (8824 Combs Road): Opposed the orientation of Building 7 (dock doors, trailer parking, dumpsters facing her property). Requested a reorientation of the building, an additional 100 feet of green space, and that her property not be used as a buffer. She noted other residents were under contract to sell, but she was not offered compensation. She also raised concerns about potential well damage and flooding. - Susie McGovern (Hoosier Environmental Council): Expressed concerns about loss of woodlands and wetlands (approximately 50 acres on site), noting Indiana has lost over 85% of its original wetlands. She urged protection of headwater wetlands near Pleasant Run Creek. - Rebuttal: Petitioner clarified that Building 7 is 564 feet from Heldman's home, with a berm, double row of evergreens, and a masonry wall. They promised to repair any well damage. Staff noted commitments for wetland delineation and tree preservation. - Decision: The commission approved both petitions 8-0 (Commissioner Ash recused). The chair urged the developer to pay attention to Heldman's concerns. Plat Petition: 2022 PLT 069 – Elanco Replat - Petitioner: Indiana Economic Redevelopment Corporation (Andy Metzel) sought approval of a replat of Lot 10B at the former GM Stamping Plant (430 S. White River Parkway West Drive) to divide 31.536 acres into four lots for Elanco Animal Health's global headquarters. The plat committee lacked a quorum, so it was transferred to this meeting. - Staff recommended approval with 12 conditions. No remonstrators. The replat is for financing and phasing purposes. - Decision: Approved 7-0 (Commissioner Ash recused). Key Outcomes - All five resolutions passed unanimously. - All continuances and the waiver of refiling rule were granted unanimously. - Five no-appeal petitions were approved; one was denied (truck parking facility). - The County Line Partners rezoning and variance were approved 8-0, subject to 21 commitments including extensive buffering. - The Elanco replat was approved 7-0. - Meeting adjourned after the plat vote.
October 18, 2022 – The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III convened at 1:00 PM in the Public Assembly Room of the City-County Building. The board heard fourteen petitions, including expedited, indecisive, transferred, and continued cases, and made decisions on seven. Votes were cast by Chairperson Joanna Taft and members Percy Bland Jr., Cameron Bradford, Bart Brown, and Rodrigue Bohannon until Bland’s departure at 4:00 PM, after which four members remained. Consent Calendar (Expedited Petitions) - 2022‑DV3‑040 (2802 Newton Avenue) – Approved unanimously (5‑0) to allow a 22.39‑sq‑ft externally illuminated wall sign for a microbrewery in a D‑5/I‑3 district. Staff recommended approval, noting the gooseneck lighting would not face surrounding dwellings. - 2022‑DV3‑041 (2350 Barnor Drive) – Approved unanimously (5‑0) to reconstruct a deck with an 8‑ft front setback (20‑ft required). Staff found the reduced setback matched a previously nonconforming porch and would not impact the streetscape. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022‑UV3‑019 (Digital Billboard) – Alan Townsend (Lamar Advertising) argued the sign conversion met all variance criteria and that digital billboards are not banned in Marion County. Remonstrators Gary Chalufo (Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis), Thomas Lorenz (Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association), Edwin Locke, and city‑county councillor Josh Bain testified against, citing safety hazards, aesthetic impacts, and the council’s 2019 decision to prohibit off‑premise digital signs. Two emails from councillors Maori and Anna were read in support. - 2022‑UV1‑021 (Commercial Vehicle Parking) – Petitioner Judy Poling and neighbor Ernest McFadden spoke in favor, noting 26 years of operation without complaints. Remonstrator Doug Morgan and others raised concerns about property maintenance, manure, and dust. - 2022‑UV1‑026 (Personal Livestock) – Petitioner Alex Intermill presented support letters from neighbors, a city‑county councillor, and three neighborhood associations. Remonstrators Doug Morgan (neighbor), Kelly Smith, and others alleged fence line disputes, manure burning, and past neglect. - 2022‑DV3‑034 (Tacoma Avenue House) – Petitioner Mark Crouch submitted a revised site plan reducing variance requests. Remonstrators Troy Wilsie, Kayla Silverman, Andrea Howard (Springdale Neighborhood Association), and Lori Klinger opposed, citing safety, foundation risks, and the developer’s alleged pattern of violations. - 2022‑DV3‑035 (Fence Height) – Petitioner Brandon Brown and supporters (Nancy Fair, David Boykie, Russell Kish) described the wrought‑iron fence as historic, safe, and beneficial. Staff opposed, saying the fence (57 in) exceeds the 42‑in limit and creates sight‑line problems. - 2022‑UV3‑028 (Second Dwelling) – Petitioner Andrew Wert explained plans for a carriage house for an elderly relative. Staff opposed, calling it overdevelopment of a D‑S district. Discussion Items - 2022‑UV3‑019 (1245 Harding Court) – Lamar requested to convert an existing 672‑sq‑ft off‑premise billboard to digital with a 50‑ft height and 10‑second message dwell. Staff recommended denial, arguing self‑created injury, feasible alternative locations, and safety risks from driver distraction on I‑465. The board denied the petition (4‑1, with Bohannon dissenting). - 2022‑UV1‑021 (7619 Acton Road) – Request to legally park five commercial dump trucks on a D‑4 lot. Staff cited incompatibility with the residential area and self‑imposed hardship. The board approved with three yes votes (Bland, Bradford, Bohannon) and two no (Taft, Brown). - 2022‑UV1‑026 (4200 East Raymond Street) – Request to keep four horses and a shelter on a D‑3 lot without a primary dwelling. Staff recommended denial but offered conditions (permits, max 4 horses, regular waste removal). Approved 4‑1 (Bradford opposed). - 2022‑DV3‑034 (1324 North Tacoma Avenue) – Revised request reduced variances to alley access and landscaping (37% living material vs. 50% required). Staff now supported; remonstrators raised safety and pattern concerns. Denied 2‑3 (Taft and Bohannon yes; Bland, Brown, Bradford no). - 2022‑DV3‑035 (3225 South Meridian Street) – Request to keep a 5‑ft wrought‑iron fence in front yard. Staff argued the 2007 ordinance limits fences to 42–48 in for safety. The board approved 3‑1 (Bohannon opposed) after Bland left. - 2022‑UV3‑028 (6150 Iona Road) – Request for a second single‑family dwelling above a garage (1,568 sq ft, zero ground floor area). Staff said it exceeds the 720‑sq‑ft accessory limit and would double density. Denied unanimously (4‑0). Continuances & Transfers - 2022‑UV3‑031 (Valvoline) – Continued to December 20, 2022, with additional notice. - 2022‑DV3‑042 (Pole sign) – Continued to November 22, 2022. - 2022‑UV3‑025 (Childcare facility) – Transferred and continued to Board II on November 15, 2022. - 2022‑UV3‑026 (Daycare/educational facility) – Withdrawn; $2,057 fee transferred to a rezoning petition. - 2022‑UV3‑030 (Digital billboard) – Continued to November 22, 2022 (acknowledged). - 2022‑UV3‑029 (Storage units) – Automatically continued to November 22, 2022 (acknowledged). - 2022‑UV3‑022 (Duplex development) – Transferred and continued to Board II on November 15, 2022. - 2022‑UV3‑027 (Single‑family dwelling) – Use variance withdrawn; $579 fee transferred to companion rezoning. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2022‑DV3‑040, 2022‑DV3‑041, 2022‑UV1‑021, 2022‑UV1‑026 (with conditions), 2022‑DV3‑035. - Denied: 2022‑UV3‑019, 2022‑DV3‑034, 2022‑UV3‑028. - Continued/Transferred: 2022‑UV3‑031, 2022‑DV3‑042, 2022‑UV3‑025, 2022‑UV3‑030, 2022‑UV3‑029, 2022‑UV3‑022, 2022‑UV3‑027 (use withdrawn). - Board member Percy Bland recused after 4:00 PM, reducing the voting panel to four members for the final two petitions.
On October 11, 2022, the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division Two held a public hearing to consider multiple variance petitions. The board consisted of three members: Vice Chair James Duke, Patrice Ducket Brown, and Beth Brandon. Due to the limited membership, unanimous votes were required for action. The meeting included expedited cases, continuances, withdrawals, and contested petitions. Consent Calendar - Four expedited petitions (2022 DV 2037, 2022 DV 2038, 2022 UV 2022, 2022 UV 2023) were approved unanimously by three yes votes each. These included variances for a building addition, fencing, a triplex, and a single-family dwelling. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022 UV 1034 (Lafayette Road community center): Supporters from the West Side Neighborhood Association and nearby residents spoke in favor, citing commitments for tree planting and limited use. No remonstrators appeared. - 2022 DV 2031 (Regent Street three-story house): The petitioner, Walter Rosinos, presented his case. No remonstrators were present. - 2022 DV 2033 (Union Street setback): The petitioner, Indianapolis Neighborhood Housing Partnership (INHP), explained the survey error. No remonstrators appeared. A letter of support from the Old South Side Neighborhood Association was submitted. - 2022 DV 2035 (Crown Point Road addition): The petitioner and a neighbor spoke in support. No remonstrators. - 2022 UV 2013 (digital billboard): Petitioner Regan Outdoor Advertising argued for the conversion. Remonstrators representing the Decatur Township Civic Council, Councilor Zach Adamson, and several neighborhood groups spoke in opposition, citing safety concerns and the city's ban on digital billboards. - 2022 UV 2020 (transitional living quarters): Supporters, including Holly Brook Lester and Jared Loper, argued for the need for sober living facilities. Remonstrators included Councilor Zach Adamson and neighbors Janine Lowe and Julie Smith, who raised concerns about density, lack of transparency, and the for-profit model. - 2022 UV 2024 (commercial vehicle storage): Petitioner David Kingan presented the case for a small landscaping business. No remonstrators appeared, but staff opposed. Discussion Items - 2022 UV 1034 – 1718 Lafayette Road: The petitioner sought a variance of use to operate a community and event center in a D5 zone. Staff recommended denial, arguing that rezoning to C4 was more appropriate. The board approved with three yes votes, subject to commitments including tree planting, limiting use to the current owner, and a right of first refusal for the neighborhood. - 2022 DV 2031 – 61 East Regent Street: Request for a variance to allow a three-story house (exceeding the 2.5-story limit) and a deficient lot size. Staff recommended approval for the lot size but denial for the three stories. The board approved the entire petition with three yes votes, overriding staff's recommendation. - 2022 DV 2033 – 1922 Union Street: Variance for a reduced south side setback (1.5 feet instead of 5 feet) due to a staking error. Staff opposed, citing overdevelopment and fire separation concerns. The board approved with three yes votes, noting the installation of a one-hour firewall and commitments to work with BNS. - 2022 DV 2035 – 8551 Crown Point Road: Variance for a garage addition with reduced side setback (11 inches and 1 foot 11 inches) and open space of 82% (vs. 85% required). Staff recommended denial, but the board approved unanimously, finding no adverse impact. - 2022 UV 2013 – 6111 West Hannon Avenue: Petition for a digital billboard conversion with height increase and reduced separation distances. Staff and multiple remonstrators opposed, citing safety and the city's ban. The board voted unanimously to deny (3 no votes), continuing for adoption of findings of fact. - 2022 UV 2020 – 805 North Hamilton Avenue: Variance to operate a transitional living quarters for up to 19 women. Staff and neighbors opposed, citing overintensity, lack of hardship, and the for-profit model. The board denied unanimously (3 no votes), continuing for findings of fact. - 2022 UV 2024 – 3916 East Minnesota Street: Variance to store commercial vehicles and equipment for a landscaping business. Staff opposed, citing commercial use in a residential zone. The board vote was split (Brandon yes, Duke yes, Ducket Brown no), resulting in an indecisive vote. The petition was automatically continued to November 15, 2022. Key Outcomes - Approved petitions: 2022 UV 1034, 2022 DV 2031, 2022 DV 2033, and 2022 DV 2035 (all with 3-0 votes). - Denied petitions: 2022 UV 2013 and 2022 UV 2020 (both 0-3 votes, continued for findings of fact). - Continued petition: 2022 UV 2024 (indecisive vote, automatically continued to November 15, 2022). - Continuances granted: 2022 UV 2021 (Norcroft Drive) continued to November 15, 2022; a two-day notice waiver was granted for 2022 DV 2033. - Withdrawals acknowledged: 2022 DV 2024 (Broadway Street) and 2022 UV 2019 (Glenn Cairn Lane) were withdrawn.
The Metropolitan Development Commission held a public meeting on October 5, 2022, to consider a consent calendar, continuances, a special request, petitions of no appeals, and a contested hearing on a modification petition. The meeting included votes on seven resolutions, several continuances, and a final vote on a request to modify commitments to allow an automobile fueling station at 4001 South Keystone Avenue. Consent Calendar - Seven resolutions (2022 R035, 2022 E035, 2022 E036, 2022 E037, 2022 E038, 2022 E039, 2022 C010, 2022 P015) were read into the record by the secretary. Commissioner Blackburn moved to approve, seconded by Commissioner Bruns. The roll call vote was 8–0 in favor, with all commissioners voting aye (Ash, Blackburn, Bruns, Garver, Robinson, Schumacher, Selm, Westrick, and President Dillon). - Resolution 2022 E036 (confirmatory resolution for Domino and Monon 32 projects) was separately approved 8–0 after a brief comment from Deputy Director Rusty Carr, who stated the resolution would enable two housing projects with over 200 total units. Public Comments & Testimony - Councilman Frank Muscari spoke in support of the 2022 MOD 010 petition (gas station), stating he had heard no opposition from remonstrators and that the property has been an eyesore for years. He noted that Councilman Dick also supported the petition. - Remonstrators (represented by attorney Greg Zubek) testified against the gas station petition. They included owners of nearby fueling stations and the McCanna neighborhood association. Key points: the property was purchased in February 2022 for $199,999 with full knowledge of the existing commitments; the comprehensive plan designates the area as village mixed use, which excludes automobile uses; there are already five fueling stations within 0.7 miles; and the 2016 commitments were a condition of the C4 zoning. A petition with 92 signatures and letters from two other gas station owners were entered into the record. Discussion Items - 2022 MOD 010 – Modification of Commitments for 4001 South Keystone Avenue - Petitioner (Greg Hahn, representing Amon LLC) argued that the property has been abandoned since 2017, is blighted with trash and graffiti, and that the owner (Suquender Singh) is a reputable businessman who owns 40 gas stations and convenience stores. The petitioner requested removal of the commitment prohibiting an automobile fueling station (the car wash request was withdrawn earlier). They offered to reduce access drives from five to three, invest $2.5 million, and commit to daily cleanup and routine inspections. They noted that Councilmen Muscari and Dick supported the project. - Staff (Kathleen and others) recommended denial, citing the comprehensive plan’s village mixed use designation, which excludes automobile uses. Staff noted that C4 zoning currently allows at least 40 permitted uses beyond the 18 excluded by commitments, and that a fueling station would be inconsistent with the plan. Staff also expressed concern about safety with five access drives and the property’s condition. - Commission questions included whether the owner had underground tanks (petitioner said no), and the feasibility of other uses. Commissioner Ash noted that while a liquor store is permitted, it may not be desirable. Key Outcomes - 2022 MOD 010 was denied by a vote of 5–4 (4 in favor, 5 against). The petitioner was informed that they must wait one year before refiling, unless a waiver is obtained. - Continuances were granted for several petitions due to lack of commitments: - 2022 CZN 830 and 2022 CAP 830 (7320 East Hannah Avenue) continued to October 19, 2022 (8–0). - 2022 ZON 083 (1751 South Lawdale Avenue) continued to October 19, 2022 (9–0). - 2022 ZON 101 (1067 West 29th Street) continued to October 19, 2022 (9–0). - 2022 ZON 107 (11517 East 38th Street) continued to October 19, 2022 (9–0). - Special request for a waiver of the one-year refiling rule (for properties at 5822/5824 Norcroft) was withdrawn by staff after the commission requested a formal letter of support from the Decatur Township Civic Council, which had not yet been provided. - Petitions of no appeals (seven petitions) were approved 9–0 as a group. - Consent calendar resolutions and the confirmatory resolution were approved 8–0. Note on vote discrepancies: The transcript shows an 8–0 vote for the consent calendar but later 9–0 votes for continuances, possibly due to a commissioner arriving late or a recording error. The numbers are reported as stated.
Date: October 4, 2022 (1:00 PM - approximately 5:20 PM) The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division I held a public hearing to consider numerous variance petitions, including expedited items, several continued cases, and a notable set of four related petitions from Reagan Outdoor Advertising seeking to convert static billboards to digital displays along I-465. The board also handled procedural requests, withdrawals, and continuances. Due to a reduced board (three members present at the end), decisions required unanimity. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions (approved unanimously without testimony): - 2022-DV1-046 (4235 N Pennsylvania St): Variance for a covered structure over an outdoor kitchen with a 4-foot side setback (7 required). Approved subject to elevations. - 2022-DV1-050 (4504 E 17th St): Variance to construct a duplex on a lot 39 feet wide and 6,046 sq ft (60 ft and 7,200 sq ft required), with a 5-foot east side setback. Approved. - 2022-UV1-033 (amended) (3032 E Michigan St): Variance to legally establish an existing single-family dwelling and allow an expansion with a 4-foot front setback (12 required). Approved. Public Comments & Testimony - Reagan Outdoor Advertising Petitions (2022-UV3-009, 010, 011, 014): Numerous remonstrators spoke in opposition, representing multiple neighborhood associations, including Warren Township Development Association, Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis, Decatur Township Civic Council, Pike Township Residents Association, Nora Northside Community Council, Martindale Brightwood, Valley Neighborhood, Woodruff Place Civic League, Health by Design, and others. Key arguments: - The City-County Council in 2019 explicitly rejected amendments to allow digital billboards; the BZA should not reverse that legislative decision. - Digital billboards are a safety hazard due to driver distraction, especially near interchanges and residential areas. - They reduce property values and create visual blight. - Petitioners seek a competitive advantage by circumventing the ordinance. - Mapleton Fall Creek Neighborhood Association (2022-UV1-027): Rachel Lau, representing herself and a neighbor, opposed a storage garage and six-foot fence, stating the project would harm neighborhood character and property values. She noted the petitioner did not contact her or her neighbor. - Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association (2022-UV3-011): A representative opposed the digital sign, citing safety, property values, and deviation from code standards. Discussion Items - Reagan Outdoor Advertising Petitions (2022-UV3-009, 010, 011, 014): The board heard consolidated testimony after initially rejecting petitioner's objection to a combined hearing. Petitioners argued that the conversions were not new signs, that digital technology is safer and provides public service (Amber Alerts, public safety messages), and that the variance process is appropriate. Staff recommended denial on all four, citing: - Failure to meet statutory "practical difficulties" test under Indiana law (Caddyshack Looper factors). - Self-created injury (petitioner chose to acquire nonconforming sites). - Feasible alternatives exist (static vinyl faces). - Signs would be injurious to public safety due to driver distraction near interchanges. - Signs would negatively impact protected residential districts. - City-County Council has consistently rejected digital billboard expansion. - Continued Cases: Several petitions were continued or transferred: - 2022-DV1-036 (6761 & 6767 N Meridian St): Continued to November 1, 2022, after Meridian Hills town indicated support with conditions. - 2022-DV1-045 (2003 N College Ave): Continued to November 1, 2022, to address staff concerns. - 2022-DV1-047 (409 E Morris St): Continued to November 1, 2022, for design modifications with Bates Hendricks Land Use Association. - 2022-UV1-021 (7619 Acton Rd): Transferred to October 18, 2022 (Division III) to allow for a full board after earlier continuance. - 2022-UV1-026 (4200 E Raymond St): Transferred to October 18, 2022 (Division III) to allow a full board. - 2022-UV1-027 (2803 N New Jersey St): Continued to December 6, 2022, to explore an alternative location for the storage garage. - 2022-UV1-028 (1354 Shelby St): Withdrawn by petitioner. - 2022-UV1-034 (1718 Lafayette Rd): Transferred to October 11, 2022 (Division II) per petitioner request. - 2022-DV1-048 (5555 S Arlington Ave): Continued to November 1, 2022. - 2022-MO1-002 (114 E 49th St): Withdrawn and allowed to refile within three months; partial refund approved. - 2022-UV1-024 (1601 S High School Rd): Withdrawn by petitioner. - 2022-UV1-025 (3920 S Post Rd): Automatically continued to November 1, 2022 (registered neighborhood organization request). - 2022-UV1-030 (8401 & 8415 Central Ave): Variance to merge two lots with two primary dwellings. Petitioner requested to build connecting outdoor space and remodel one dwelling into garage/in-law quarters. Staff opposed, citing lack of hardship and availability of alternatives. Neighborhood support and no remonstrators. Board approved unanimously (3-0). Key Outcomes - Denied (all four Reagan Outdoor Advertising petitions): - 2022-UV3-009 (2650 N Franklin Rd): Denied 4-0. - 2022-UV3-010 (7500 E 30th St): Denied 4-0. - 2022-UV3-011 (175 Southern Plaza Dr): Denied 4-0. - 2022-UV3-014 (7715 E 42nd St): Denied 4-0. - Approved: 2022-UV1-030 (8401 & 8415 Central Ave): Approved 3-0. - Expedited petitions approved (3 items – see Consent Calendar). - Continuances and transfers granted (see Discussion Items for details). - Withdrawals acknowledged: 2022-UV1-028, 2022-UV1-024, 2022-MO1-002, and 2022-DV1-026 (717 Shelby St). - Other: A request to allow future refiling of a case at 10859 E Washington St before Division III was granted. A one-day waiver of notice for 2022-UV1-033 was approved.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on September 21, 2022, to receive the annual Tax Increment Financing (TIF) presentation, approve a resolution for property conveyance, act on several continuance requests, and hear two rezoning petitions. The meeting included public testimony from remonstrators and city councilors. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (September 7, 2022): Motion to approve passed. Commissioner Ash recused herself as she was not present at the prior meeting. - Resolution 2022 R034 (Property Conveyance to Intend Indiana Inc.): Authorized the conveyance of two properties. Passed 6-0 with one recusal (Commissioner Ash recused? The record shows six votes and one recusal, but roll call includes Ash voting on later items; likely another commissioner recused. The transcript states "you'll need to recuse yourself from this vote" but does not identify the recused commissioner.) - No Appeals Docket: Eleven petitions recommended for approval were read into the record and approved unanimously (7-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Brian Zeller (attorney and adjoining landowner) opposed the continuance of 2022 ZON 051 and 2022 VARO 3, arguing that the developer had not negotiated in good faith and that many remonstrators had taken time off work to attend. He requested the commission acknowledge the large turnout. - City Councilor Zach Adamson (District 17) supported the remonstrators, expressing concern that the developer was not negotiating in good faith and noting the burden on residents who had attended multiple hearings. - Vernon Compton (remonstrator, Martindale Brightwood) testified against the Arsenal Avenue development, citing excessive density, safety issues in a school zone, and violations of development standards. Discussion Items - Annual TIF Presentation: Rusty Carr (Deputy Director, Department of Metropolitan Development) and Lucas Anderson (Office of Finance and Management) presented the required annual update on TIF districts. They explained the purpose of TIF, highlighted fiscal year 2021 financial activity (revenues of $130.7 million, expenses of $152.6 million), and noted that expenditures require commission approval. The presentation concluded with no questions from the commission. - Continuance Requests: - 2022 ZON 051 & 2022 VARO 3 (11 South Meridian): Petitioner Joe Calder requested a continuance to November 2, 2022, at the request of the district councilor and to facilitate further negotiations. Remonstrator's attorney Brian Zeller objected, citing late notice and lack of good faith. The commission granted the continuance (6-1). - 2022 VAC 002 (Marie Clark): Granted to October 19, 2022, to allow ongoing discussions between the petitioner and Indianapolis Cultural Trail (7-0). - 2022 CZN 830 & 2022 CAP 830 (7320 East Hand Avenue): Granted to October 5, 2022, pending receipt of executed commitments (7-0). - 2022 ZON 083 (1754 South Lawndale Avenue): Granted to October 5, 2022, due to lack of commitments (7-0). - Hearing on 2022 CZN 837 & 2022 CVR 837 (1450 East 16th Street / 1607 North Arsenal Avenue): Petitioner Brian Birch (Neon Architecture) sought rezoning from C5 to D8 and variances to develop eight townhomes on a vacant 0.31-acre site. Remonstrator Vernon Compton opposed, citing excess density, safety in a school zone, and seven code violations. Staff recommended approval with conditions (including a sidewalk and tree retention). The commission approved the petition 7-0. - Hearing on 2022 ZON 082 (8018 West Washington Street): Petitioner Will Gooden (High Spirits Development LLC) requested a PUD rezoning of 13.7 acres for a mixed-use development with 227 multifamily units, 30 townhomes, and 6,000 sq ft of commercial space. No remonstrators appeared. Staff recommended approval, noting the site's location and the project's environmental sensitivity. The commission approved 6-0 (Commissioner Schumacher had left). Key Outcomes - Minutes approved with one recusal. - Resolution 2022 R034 passed 6-0 (one recusal). - Continuances granted: - 2022 ZON 051 & 2022 VARO 3 → November 2, 2022 (6-1). - 2022 VAC 002 → October 19, 2022 (7-0). - 2022 CZN 830 & 2022 CAP 830 → October 5, 2022 (7-0). - 2022 ZON 083 → October 5, 2022 (7-0). - No appeals docket approved (11 petitions, 7-0). - 2022 CZN 837 & 2022 CVR 837 approved with staff conditions (7-0). - 2022 ZON 082 approved (6-0).
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) Division Three held a public hearing on September 20, 2022, starting at 6:00 PM. Chairperson Joanna Taft presided, with board members Bart Brown, Roderick Bohannon, Percy Bland, and Cameron Radford present. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff participated. The board heard a variety of variance requests, including expedited petitions, continuances, and contested cases. Several decisions were made, with some approvals, denials, and continuances. The meeting extended past 5:00 PM, and due to board members leaving, only three members remained for the final votes on the Lamar Advertising petitions. Consent Calendar - Expedited petitions approved unanimously (5-0): 2022 DV3037 (variance for building addition at 2521 Plains Drive), 2022 DV3038 (health center facility at 6002-6106 E. 38th Street), 2022 DV3039 (building addition at 1215 Marlowe Avenue), and 2022 DV302 (retail store at 7801 E. 38th Street). All received 5 yes votes. - Continuances granted to October 18, 2022 hearing: 2022 UV3025 (3335 N. Sherman Drive), 2022 UV3026 (940 W. Banta Road), 2022 UV3022 (830 River Avenue), 2022 DV3035 (case number unclear), and 2022 DV3022 (case moved to expedited docket). All were continued without objection. - Motion to consolidate three Lamar Advertising petitions (2022 UV2017, UV3018, UV3019) was approved unanimously to be heard together with adjusted time limits. Public Comments & Testimony - 2022 UV3024 (3415 English Ave – methadone clinic): Remonstrators including Edgar Wadrama (retired paramedic), Jude O'Dell (Twin Air resident), Rachel Cooper (Southeast Community Organization president), and RJ Pollock (property owner) opposed the clinic, citing concerns about crime, property values, proximity to homes and a park, and strain on police resources. They presented a petition with over 124 signatures from Twin Air residents and letters from real estate experts. Supporters included Dr. Ashley Overly (CEO, Sandra Eskenazi Mental Health Center), Doug Hunsinger (Executive Director of Drug Prevention, Treatment and Enforcement), and petitioner attorney Joseph Calderon, who argued the clinic would provide life-saving services and is needed in a high-overdose area. Community members also voiced concerns about the clinic's proximity to LaSalle Park and schools. - 2022 DV3031 (6619 E. 43rd Place – carport): Petitioner Alfred Popper requested a variance for a 12-foot front setback (required 25 feet). Remonstrators were not present, but staff noted the carport was built without permits and was a violation. Popper stated he would remove the carport if the tenant moved out, which led to a debate about adding that as a condition. - 2022 UV3020 (4840 S. Meridian St – auto sales): Petitioner Daniel Russello and Brian Collins (co-owner of Ideal Auto Sales) sought a variance to operate an auto sales lot. No remonstrators appeared, but staff opposed the request. The petitioner argued the existing mechanic shop was rundown and the auto sales would improve the site. Staff argued the use is not permitted in C3 and would overintensify the site. - 2022 UV3021 (4301 W. Southport Rd – truck storage): Petitioner Jason Lucking represented Lawler Trucking, seeking a variance for truck storage and service in a floodway fringe. No remonstrators appeared. Staff opposed, citing floodway safety and non-compliance with the comprehensive plan. The petitioner argued the site is already used for similar purposes and would be safe. - 2022 DV1040 (2801 W. 86th St – Brebeuf Jesuit sign): Petitioner Murray Clark (attorney) requested a variance for a digital component on a monument sign. No remonstrators present, but staff recommended denial because the sign is within 300 feet of a protected district and digital displays are not permitted in SU2 districts. Support letters from Pike Township Residents Association and neighboring commercial properties were noted. - 2022 DV1044 (1206 St. Paul St – front-load garage): Petitioner Paul Lambey (land use consultant) represented RCA Properties, requesting a variance for a front-loaded garage. No remonstrators, but staff opposed, citing the ordinance's prohibition and the availability of alternatives. The petitioner argued the shallow lot and lack of alley access create a practical difficulty. - 2022 DV2027 (3048 S. McClure St – side setbacks): Petitioner Sarah Walters requested a variance for reduced side setbacks. She withdrew the south side setback request and agreed to commitments with Decatur Township Civic Council. No remonstrators present. Staff still opposed, but the board approved. - 2022 DV2032 (8335 Keystone Ave – skyline signs): Petitioner Timothy Oakes (attorney) requested a variance for two skyline signs on the western elevation. No remonstrators, but staff recommended denial. The petitioner argued the building is oriented toward Keystone and the east side faces a cemetery, making the second sign necessary. The board approved. - Lamar Advertising consolidated petitions (2022 UV2017, UV3018, UV3019): These three petitions sought to convert existing static billboards to digital displays along I-465. Public opposition included Pat Andrews (Decatur Township Civic Council and Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations), Susan Blair (Pike Township Residents Association), Edwin Locke (PTRA), Ron Phillips (Warren Township Development Association), and Tom Lorenz (Northwest Perry Neighborhood Association). They argued digital billboards are banned, pose safety risks, create light pollution, and would set a precedent for proliferation. Petitioner Alan Townsend (counsel for Lamar) argued digital signs are safe, allowed in many locations, and would modernize existing signs. Staff recommended denial, citing the 2019 City-County Council decision and failure to meet practical difficulty standards. Discussion Items - 2022 UV3024 (Methadone clinic): The petition requested a variance of use to allow a methadone clinic within 345 feet of a dwelling district (500 feet required). The clinic would be operated by Eskenazi Health. Staff recommended approval subject to a plan of operation and commitments. Remonstrators raised concerns about property values, safety, and proximity to a park. The board voted 3-2 to approve (Taft, Radford, Brown yes; Bland, Bohannon no). - 2022 DV3031 (Carport): The petition sought to legalize an existing carport with a 12-foot front setback (25 feet required). Staff opposed, citing the lack of permits and available alternatives. The board added a condition that the carport must be removed if the current tenant moves out. The vote was 3-2 to approve (Radford, Bohannon, Brown yes; Bland, Taft no). - 2022 UV3020 (Auto sales): The petition requested a variance for auto sales and reduced setbacks on a C3-zoned property. Staff opposed, arguing the use is not permitted and would overintensify the site. The board voted 2-3 to deny (Radford, Bohannon yes; Bland, Taft, Brown no). The denial was continued for adoption of findings of fact. - 2022 UV3021 (Truck storage): The petition sought a variance for truck storage and service in a floodway fringe. Staff opposed, citing flood safety and inconsistency with the comprehensive plan. The board voted 3-2 to approve (Bland, Bohannon, Brown yes; Radford, Taft no). - 2022 DV1040 (Brebeuf Jesuit sign): The petition sought a variance for a digital display on a monument sign. Staff opposed, but the board voted 4-1 to approve (all except Taft). - 2022 DV1044 (Front-load garage): The petition sought a variance for a front-loaded garage. Staff opposed, but the board voted 4-1 to approve (all except Bland). - 2022 DV2027 (Side setbacks): The petition sought variances for reduced side setbacks. The petitioner withdrew the south side request and agreed to commitments. Staff still opposed, but the board voted 5-0 to approve. - 2022 DV2032 (Skyline signs): The petition sought a variance for an additional skyline sign. Staff opposed, but the board voted 4-1 to approve (all except Taft). - Lamar Advertising petitions (2022 UV2017, UV3018, UV3019): The board considered these together. After hearing testimony and staff reports, the board voted on each petition with three members present (Bohannon, Brown, Radford) due to earlier departures. 2022 UV2017 was denied 0-3, 2022 UV3018 was denied 0-3, and 2022 UV3019 resulted in an indecisive vote (1 yes, 2 no), leading to an automatic continuance to the October 18, 2022 hearing. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2022 UV3024 (methadone clinic) – 3-2; 2022 DV3031 (carport) – 3-2 with condition; 2022 UV3021 (truck storage) – 3-2; 2022 DV1040 (Brebeuf sign) – 4-1; 2022 DV1044 (front-load garage) – 4-1; 2022 DV2027 (side setbacks) – 5-0; 2022 DV2032 (skyline signs) – 4-1. - Denied: 2022 UV3020 (auto sales) – 2-3; 2022 UV2017 (Lamar sign) – 0-3; 2022 UV3018 (Lamar sign) – 0-3. - Continued: 2022 UV3019 (Lamar sign) – indecisive vote, automatically continued to October 18, 2022. - Expedited petitions: All four approved unanimously (5-0). - Continuances: Six petitions continued to October 18, 2022. - Staff announcement: Staff announced a potential swing hearing in November or December, with details to follow. The meeting adjourned after the final votes.