The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 held a public hearing on September 13, 2022, beginning at approximately 2:00 PM and continuing until after 5:30 PM. The board, chaired by Acting Chairperson Patrice Ducket Brown, included members Beth Brandon, Kirk Farmer, Bart Brown, and David Duncan. The hearing addressed over 20 petitions for variances of use and development standards, including expedited approvals, continuances, and contested cases. Key decisions included approval of a front-yard garage variance on Wheeler Street, denial of a digital billboard on 82nd Street, and a split vote on a front-yard solar array that was continued to a future hearing. Consent Calendar - Expedited Petitions (8 approved as a group): 2022 DV1038, 2022 DV1039, 2022 DV1043, 2022 UV1010, 2022 UV1032, 2022 DV3025, 2022 UV1031, and 2022 DV2029. All were approved unanimously after a motion to waive individual testimony. - Continuances and Withdrawals: - 2022 DV23 (1922 Union Street) – continued to October 11, 2022 with new notice. - 2022 UV2016 (2505 North Sherman Drive) – withdrawn. - 2022 DB2035 (8551 Crown Point Road) – continued to October 11, 2022. - 2022 DB1043 (5243 East Edgewood Avenue) – remonstrator present; petitioner and remonstrator went out to negotiate (outcome not recorded). - 2022 DV2031 – continued to October 11, 2022. - 2022 UV2017 (3912 Glen Arm Road) – transferred to Division 3 on September 20, 2022. - 2022 DV2032 (8335 Keystone Crossing) – transferred to Division 3 on September 20, 2022. - Four Reagan Outdoor Advertising petitions (2022 UV2009, UV2010, UV2011, UV2012) – continued to December 13, 2022 due to late hour and quorum concerns. Public Comments & Testimony - Digital Billboards (2022 UV1012): Multiple remonstrators, including representatives from Historic Urban Neighborhoods of Indianapolis, City-County Councilors Zach Adamson and Dan Boots, and residents Jessica Ware and others, opposed the digital billboard, citing safety concerns, visual pollution, property value impacts, and the city's 2019 sign ordinance ban. They argued that granting the variance would set a dangerous precedent and undermine extensive community-led zoning efforts. - Solar Array (2022 UV2019): Neighbors Carol Lynn Myers, January Cattells, and others testified against the front-yard solar array, describing it as an eyesore, a safety hazard (blocking sightlines), and a detriment to property values. They noted the homeowners had not consulted them beforehand and had a history of yard neglect. The homeowners and their installers (GRNE Solar) argued that the array was the only viable location due to shade, that permits were issued and then revoked after installation, and that they planned landscaping to screen it. - Wheeler Street Duplex (2022 DV1034): Petitioner Sheila and James Wright argued for front garage access, citing poor alley condition and safety. Remonstrator Vernon Compton (Brightwood Concerned Citizens) opposed, stating the alley is viable and that the proposal would block sidewalks. He also noted the councilor for District 17 disapproved. - Gale Street Deck (2022 DV1041): Remonstrator Vernon Compton questioned the dimensions and safety of the deck, and noted prior stop-work orders. Petitioner Josh Mullins (N10) explained the deck was rebuilt to existing dimensions and that permits were amended. Discussion Items - 2022 DV1025 (16 West Morris Street / 1150 South Meridian Street): Petitioner David Kingan requested variances to redevelop a liquor store site into a new commercial building. After discussion, the petitioner agreed to add a commitment excluding vape shops. Staff recommended approval subject to site plan approval. The board approved 5-0. - 2022 DV1034 (2727 Wheeler Street): Petitioners sought a variance to allow front garage access instead of alley access for a new duplex/townhouse. Staff recommended denial, citing the ordinance requiring alley access and the infill housing guidelines. The board voted 3-2 to approve, with members Duncan, Ducket Brown, and Brown in favor, and Brandon and Farmer opposed. - 2022 DV1041 (2633 North Gale Street): Petitioner requested a variance for a 1.9-foot setback for a deck. Staff recommended approval as the deck was existing. The board approved 5-0. - 2022 UV1012 (5531 East 82nd Street): Reagan Outdoor Advertising sought variances for a digital billboard (height, size, separation, display time). The petitioner withdrew the request for 8-second display, committing to 10 seconds. Staff recommended denial, citing the 2019 sign ordinance, safety concerns, and lack of practical difficulty. The board voted 0-4 to deny. - 2022 DV2023 (1509 Prospect Street): Petitioner Donald Packwood (APWU) requested a variance for a digital component on an existing pole sign. Staff recommended denial, noting the sign code prohibits digital displays on pole signs. The board voted 1-3 to deny. - 2022 UV2019 (4305 Glen Cairn Lane): Petitioners Amanda and Brian Shepherd requested a variance for a front-yard solar array, arguing that the city issued permits and then revoked them after installation. Staff recommended denial, stating that the ordinance requires solar arrays in side/rear yards and that rooftop options exist. The board voted 2-2 (Duncan and Brown yes; Brandon and Ducket Brown no), resulting in an automatic continuance to October 11, 2022. - 2022 DV2034 (5210 Broadway Street): Petitioner Steve Horman requested a variance for a taller detached garage with a carriage house. Staff recommended approval, citing consistency with neighborhood plans. The board approved 3-0. Key Outcomes - 2022 DV1025 – Approved 5-0, subject to commitment excluding vape shop. - 2022 DV1034 – Approved 3-2 (Duncan, Ducket Brown, Brown yes; Brandon, Farmer no). - 2022 DV1041 – Approved 5-0. - 2022 UV1012 – Denied 0-4 (Duncan, Brandon, Ducket Brown, Farmer no; Brown recused). - 2022 DV2023 – Denied 1-3 (Brown yes; Duncan, Brandon, Ducket Brown no). - 2022 UV2019 – Vote 2-2, continued to October 11, 2022. - 2022 DV2034 – Approved 3-0. - Expedited Petitions (8) – Approved as a group. - Continuances/Transfers: Multiple cases continued or transferred to future dates (see Consent Calendar). - Reagan Outdoor Advertising cases – Continued to December 13, 2022.
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, Indiana
Public Meetings - Indianapolis, IndianaThe Metropolitan Development Commission met on September 8, 2022 (the transcript opens with September 7, 2022, creating a date discrepancy). The meeting included a public hearing on a tax abatement waiver, approval of 10 routine resolutions, continuances of two zoning petitions, and approval of four unopposed petitions. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the August 17, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously without changes. - Ten resolutions (2022 R028, R030, R031, R032, R033, C009, P011, P012, P013, P014) were read and approved as a block by a vote of 8–0. These resolutions authorize various property conveyances, TIF fund reimbursements, contract amendments, and professional services agreements for City Market planning and improvements. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made by citizens. The only testimony came from the applicant on the public hearing item. Discussion Items - Public Hearing – Tax Abatement Waiver (Resolution 2022 A023): TWG Development Incorporated and TWG Polk LLC requested a waiver of the 2022 tax abatement application filing deadline for property at 1515 Lewis Street. Commissioner Bruns moved approval, seconded by Commissioner Garver. The resolution passed 8–0. The applicant expressed support and noted this was a one-time request. - Continuance Requests: - Staff requested a continuance of petitions 2022 CZN 830 and 2022 CAP 830 (7320 East Hannah Avenue) to the September 21, 2022 hearing because commitments were still being negotiated and not yet signed. The continuance was approved 8–0. - Staff requested a continuance of petition 2022 ZON 083 (1751 South Laudale Avenue) to September 21, 2022 in order to receive executed commitments. The continuance was approved 8–0. - Petitions of No Appeals: Four petitions were recommended for approval without opposition: 2022 ZON 086 (8135 Brookville Road), 2022 ZON 087 (15 and 25 North Highland Avenue), 2022 CZN 836 (4800 East Raymond Street), and 2022 CZN 844 (2545 East Pleasant Run Parkway North Drive). Commissioner Westrick moved to approve them as a group, seconded by Commissioner Selm. They passed 8–0. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2022 A023 (Tax abatement waiver): Approved 8–0. - Consent calendar (10 resolutions): Approved 8–0. - Continuances: Two zoning petitions continued to September 21, 2022, both by 8–0 votes. - Petitions of no appeals: Four petitions approved 8–0. - Meeting adjourned without further business.
Due to the absence of a third board member, the hearing lacked a quorum. All petitions on the agenda were continued to future dates. The meeting was chaired by Peter Nelson with David Duncan as alternate board member. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. Public Comments & Testimony - Councilor Dan Boots (District 3) requested that petition 2022 UV1012 (5531 East 82nd Street) be accelerated to the September 13 hearing of Division 2, noting that the petition had already been continued once due to a non-conclusive vote and that citizens were present. - Pat Andrews (Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations) expressed appreciation for the board's volunteer service and acknowledged that while some remonstrators could not attend the September 13 hearing, substitutes would be arranged to accommodate the councilor's request. - Mr. Richardson (regarding 2363 North Parker, petition 2022 HOV 044) addressed the board about a refund request after the petitioner withdrew the variance petition. He noted that a motion at the August 2 hearing resulted in a 2-1 vote and that, despite staff's recommendation against a refund, the petitioner wished to proceed. He was advised to present the refund request at the September 13 hearing of Division 2 during additional business. Discussion Items - All petitions were read in order by staff. Attorneys and petitioners requested continuances to various dates. Staff expressed no objection to each request. The board acknowledged automatic continuances filed by registered neighborhood organizations for three petitions. - For 2022 UV1012, Councilor Boots and Pat Andrews both spoke in support of transferring to the September 13 hearing. The attorney for the petitioner concurred, noting the previous indecisive vote. - For 2022 SE1001 (cell tower relocation), the petitioner requested a three-month continuance to December 6, 2022, with additional notice, to allow time for a potential alternative solution. - For 2022 UV1014, 1015, 1016 (High School Road, Sam Jones Expressway, Broaderville Avenue), the petitioner and remonstrators agreed to continue all three to November 1, 2022. - For 2022 UV1024 (1601 South High School Road), the petitioner requested a continuance to October 4 with additional notice to amend the request for two additional variances; the Indianapolis Airport Authority had no objection. Key Outcomes - All petitions were continued or transferred as follows: - September 13, 2022 (Division 2): 2022 DV1038, DV1039, UV1010, UV1032, UV1012, DV1025, DV1034, UV1031 (all without additional notice). - September 13, 2022 (Division 3): 2022 DV1043 (without additional notice). - September 20, 2022 (Division 3): 2022 DV2027, DV1040, DV1044 (all without additional notice). - October 4, 2022 (Division 1): 2022 UV1021, UV1025, DV1045 (without additional notice); UV1024 (with additional notice); UV1026, UV1028, UV1030 (automatic continuances by neighborhood organizations, no additional notice). - November 1, 2022 (Division 1): 2022 UV1014, UV1015, UV1016, UV1020 (all without additional notice). - December 6, 2022 (Division 1): 2022 SE1001 (with additional notice). - Withdrawn: 2022 DV1011 (acknowledged). - The board acknowledged that no quorum was present, preventing any substantive decisions or votes on the merits. All matters were continued administratively.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on August 17, 2022, to consider several resolutions, continuances, and a public hearing. Key actions included approval of a $1 million grant for the Indianapolis Housing Agency (IHA), two tax abatement extensions for Rolls-Royce Corporation, and denial of a variance for a shipping container and carport in a floodway fringe. Consent Calendar - Minutes of the August 3, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously. Resolutions - Resolution 2022 E034 (walk-on): Authorized an additional $1 million grant to IHA for operational stabilization and tenant recertifications. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 2022 C018: Approved amendment to the Indianapolis Housing Trust Fund Agreement with CHIP to include all persons with lived experience. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 2022 A019: Authorized amendment to real property tax abatement for Rolls-Royce Corporation with extension of economic revitalization area designation. Passed 7-0. - Resolution 2022 A020: Authorized amendment to personal property tax abatement for Rolls-Royce Corporation with similar extension. Passed 7-0. Withdrawals, Continuances, and Dismissals - 2022 ZON 076 (640 South Carroll Road): Withdrawn by petitioner; partial refund of $1,492 approved 6-1. - 2022 ZON 028: Continuance requested for sixth time; denied (7-0) and case dismissed for lack of prosecution. - 2022 CZN 830 & CAP 830 (7320 East Hannah Avenue): Continued to September 7, 2022 without notice pending commitments. - 2022 CZN 836 (4800 East Raymond Street): Continued to September 7, 2022 without notice. - 2022 VAC 002 (836 and 875 Massachusetts Avenue): Continued to September 21, 2022 without notice to continue discussions. - 2022 ZON 082: Automatic continuance acknowledged to September 21, 2022. - 2022 ZON 083 (1751 South Lawndale Avenue): Continued to September 7, 2022 to allow for commitments. Petitions of No Appeals - Four petitions (2022 APP 009, 2022 ZON 081, 2022 CAP 827 amended, 2022 CAP 841) approved 7-0. Public Hearing: Variance Petition 2022 UV 1002 - Petitioner: William M. Gammon Jr. and Beth L. Gammon, represented by Garrett Lawton, seeking variance for a shipping container and carport at 2535 East 79th Street (in a floodway fringe). - Arguments for: Storage container has been present for 30+ years; property is fixed income; removal would cause hardship; neighborhood support (30+ signatures, River Park Neighborhood Association letter). Petitioner offered commitments to remove structures upon property transfer. - Arguments against: City code enforcement case since December 2018; structure is an illegal permanent storage container/commercial vehicle in a residential district; floodplain concerns (FEMA compliance, risk to federal flood insurance and disaster assistance); three letters of opposition from Councillor Boots, Greater Allisonville Community Council, and Nora North Sign Community Council. Floodplain administrator noted that the container could become debris in a flood and that FEMA may place the community on probation if variances are improperly granted. - Vote: 5-2 against (denied). Motion to uphold the variance failed; petition denied. Key Outcomes - All four resolutions approved unanimously. - Majority of continuances granted as requested, except for 2022 ZON 028 which was dismissed. - Variance petition denied after detailed testimony. - Meeting adjourned.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division III held a public hearing on August 16, 2022 at 6:15 PM, chaired by Joanna Taft, with board members Bart Brown, Rodrigue Bohanan, and Percy Bland Jr. present. The hearing addressed continuances, expedited petitions, and non-expedited cases involving variances for land use and development standards. Key decisions included the approval of one petition and several continuances due to indecisive votes or requests for additional time. Continuances and Transfers - 2022 DV3025 (4639 Myrtle Lane): Continued and transferred to September 13, 2022 (Division 2) to allow petitioner to prepare an amended site plan. Staff had no objection. - 2022 UV3018 (7801 East 38th Street): Continued to September 20, 2022 (Division 3) after petitioner requested more time and remonstrators (Mayor James Cooney of Southport) expressed opposition but staff had no objection. - 2022 UV3019 (1245 Harding Court): Continued to September 20, 2022 without objection. - 2022 UV3024 (3415 English Avenue): Continued to September 20, 2022 to allow further neighborhood discussions. - 2022 DV3034 (1316 North Tacoma Avenue area): Continued to October 18, 2022 per agreement between petitioner and remonstrator. - 2022 DB3035 (3225 South Meridian Street): Acknowledged automatic continuance to September 20, 2022. - 2022 DV3018 (24 East Street, Southport): Continued to September 20, 2022 as final continuance staff would support, pending revised elevation and site plans due by September 6. - 2022 UV3015 (511 Madison Avenue): Petition withdrawn, acknowledged by board. - 2022 UV3022 (830 River Avenue): Automatic continuance acknowledged to September 20, 2022. Expedited Petitions (Approved Unanimously) - 2022 DV3026 (1815-1835 North Meridian Street): Variance for six-story mixed-use building height and setbacks. Approved (4-0). - 2022 DV3032 (140 East Southport Road): Variance for pole barn height exceeding primary structure. Approved (4-0). - 2022 DV3033 (5970 South Belmont Avenue): Variance for off-premise advertising sign height and spacing. Approved (4-0) after Board Member Brown corrected his ballot to 'yes'. Discussion Items and Votes 2022 UV3020 (4840 South Meridian Street) - Ideal Auto Sales LLC - Request: Variance of use (C3 to C5) for automobile sales, with setback and landscaping variances. - Petitioner (Daniel Rosello and Brian Collins): Argued the site cannot be used for residential (underground fuel tanks), auto sales would improve the property, and they offer low-cost vehicles to the community. Committed to a maximum of four inoperable vehicles on site and that the variance would apply only to Ideal Auto Sales. - Staff: Recommended denial, citing incompatibility with surrounding single-family homes, lack of due diligence, and that the variance would outlast the current tenant. Staff noted the site could be used for other allowed C3 uses. - Vote: 2 yes (Bland, Taft) - 2 no (Brown, Bohanan). Indecisive; petition continued to September 20, 2022. 2022 DV3031 (6619 East 43rd Place) - Alfred and Louise Popper - Request: Variance for a carport front setback of 12 feet (25 ft required). The carport was built without a permit. - Petitioner (Alfred Popper): Stated he built it for his disabled tenant and was unaware of permit requirements; willing to pay penalties. - Staff: Recommended denial, noting no practical difficulty and the carport is unique in the neighborhood. - Vote: 2 yes (Brown, Bohanan) - 2 no (Bland, Taft). Indecisive; continued to September 20, 2022. 2022 UV3021 (4301 West Southport Road) - Lawler Trucking LLC - Request: Variance for indoor/outdoor truck storage and maintenance in a DA district and floodway fringe. - Petitioner (Jason Lucking): Argued use is mobile and can be moved in a flood; barbed wire fencing will be removed; no hazardous materials. - Staff: Recommended denial because the use is prohibited in floodway fringe and incompatible with comprehensive plan; potential environmental harm. - Vote: 2 yes (Brown, Bohanan) - 2 no (Bland, Taft). Indecisive; continued to September 20, 2022. 2022 UV3023 (4071 South Keystone Avenue) - Downey Home Association (Knights of Columbus) - Request: Variance for an event center as ancillary use to a fraternal lodge in C3 district. - Petitioner (Pat Rooney): Presented commitments: event center only ancillary to Knights of Columbus, redevelopment per site plan (closing drive-thru, adding parking), and preserving landscaping. Maximum occupancy reduced to 76. - Support: Letters from State Senator Jack Sandlin, Councilor Michael Dilk, neighbors; testimony from Councilor Paul Anne. - Staff: Recommended denial based on original submission (no hardship, potential noise/traffic). Noted staff had not reviewed amended documents. - Vote: 4 yes (Taft, Bland, Brown, Bohanan). Approved, subject to written commitments to be recorded. Key Outcomes - Approved: 2022 DV3026, DV3032, DV3033 (expedited), and 2022 UV3023 (Knights of Columbus event center). - Continued to September 20, 2022: 2022 UV3020, DV3031, UV3021 (indecisive votes); also continuances granted for UV3018, UV3019, UV3024, DV3018. - Continued to October 18, 2022: 2022 DV3034. - Transferred to September 13, 2022: 2022 DV3025. - Withdrawn: 2022 UV3015. - Board acknowledged automatic continuance for 2022 DB3035 and 2022 UV3022. - Reagan Outdoor Advertising petitions (UV3009, UV3010, UV3011, UV3014): Transferred to Division 1 on October 4, 2022 due to board member conflicts and heavy docket. - Procedure: Board adopted waiver of rules for expedited petitions. Board also approved a waiver to allow a modification of commitments (2009 UV1025) to be heard by Divisions 1 or 2 due to township representation changes. Note: Meeting adjourned after approval of findings for 2022 UV3023.
The Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals Division 2 met on August 9, 2022, at 6:00 PM to hear a variety of variance petitions, including requests for development standard variances, use variances, and digital sign conversions. The board was chaired by Craig E. Von Dalen, with members James Duke, Patrice Ducett Brown, Beth Brandon, and Kirk Farmer present. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff also attended. The meeting included continuances, expedited petitions, and five contested cases, with public testimony and staff recommendations presented for each. Public Comments & Testimony - Mauna Wadood (Northwest Landing Neighborhood Association) opposed the use variance for auto repair at 1259 West 29th Street, stating that an auto body shop does not fit neighborhood revitalization aspirations and that 30 members signed a letter of opposition. - Tom Hanley (CEO of 913 Inc., a tenant at 1271 West 29th Street) urged denial of the same petition, citing four years of nuisance issues, safety concerns (including a homicide, theft ring, explosion, and threats with guns), and improper disposal of hazardous materials. He stated that the property has operated outside zoning for years. - Pat Andrews (representing Decatur Township Civic Council and Marion County Alliance of Neighborhood Associations) spoke against the digital billboard petitions (2022 UV2-023 and 2022 UV2-018), arguing that the city’s ban on digital off-premise signs reflects community standards and that granting variances would set a dangerous precedent. She also cited safety studies indicating driver distraction. - Edwin Locke (representing Pike Township Residence Association) opposed the digital billboard at 4900 Robison Road, stating that the area already has a clutter of signs and that the sign does not create a hardship. He also noted that the city council unanimously upheld the digital ban in 2019. - Lafayette Williams (petitioner for 1259 West 29th Street) briefly rebutted allegations, calling them untrue, and stated he has owned the property for two years. Discussion Items - 2022 DV2-009 (1635 South Sherman Drive) – Petitioner Will Gooden requested variances to allow a 3,200 sq ft detached accessory structure and a roofing business with commercial vehicle storage. The existing single-family home is on a one-acre lot in a D3 district. The petitioner argued the structure would be at the rear, not visible from the street, and that the commercial vehicles would be stored inside or out of view. Staff recommended denial, citing the structure’s excessive size, height, and commercial nature that would be injurious to the residential character. The board approved the petition 4-1 (Farmer dissenting) after the petitioner committed to removing two small sheds. - 2022 UV2-007 (1259 West 29th Street) – Petitioner David Kingan sought a use variance to allow auto repair in an I2 zone. The petitioner proposed an indoor operation with limited hours, letters of support from 23 neighbors, and a plan of operation with commitments including a non-transferable variance. Staff recommended denial, noting the property had been in violation since 2019 and that auto repair is a high-intensity use incompatible with nearby residential uses. The board denied the petition 3-1 (Duke supporting) after hearing testimony from the remonstrators. - 2022 UV2-023 (5430 Victory Drive) – Lamar Advertising requested multiple variances to convert an existing static billboard to a digital 40-foot tall, 14x48 foot double-faced sign along I-465. The petition sought relief from separation requirements, a front setback, and the digital display ban. The petitioner argued the sign is safe, NDOT permits digital signs, and the conversion would allow Amber Alerts and community messages. Staff and multiple neighborhood groups opposed, citing the 2019 ordinance that bans digital off-premise signs and the lack of a practical difficulty. The board denied the petition 3-2 (Von Dalen and Duke supporting, Brandon, Ducett Brown, Farmer opposing). - 2022 DV2-022 (1342 Southeast Street) – Petitioner Mark Crouch requested variances to legally establish an existing commercial building within the clear site triangle, provide a second-story addition, reduce parking to 6 spaces, and allow a balcony/awning into the right-of-way. Staff supported the existing building and parking but opposed the balcony due to right-of-way encroachment and proximity to power lines. The board split the vote: Part A (legal establishment and parking) was approved 5-0; Part B (balcony extension) was approved 3-2 (Duke and Farmer opposing). - 2022 UV2-018 (4900 Robison Road) – Lamar Advertising again sought variances to convert a 38-year-old static billboard to digital along I-465 in Pike Township. The petitioner noted the sign is in an I4 industrial area and that the conversion would allow safety upgrades and community alerts. Staff and remonstrators (including Pike Township Residents Association) opposed, citing the 2019 ordinance, self-created injury, and safety concerns. The board denied the petition 4-1 (Von Dalen supporting). Key Outcomes - 2022 DV2-030 (8040-8042 Westfield Blvd) – Moved to expedited docket and approved without testimony (5-0 vote via ballot). - 2022 DV2-020 (1603 Hoyt Avenue) – Moved to expedited docket and approved (5-0 vote). - 2022 DV2-009 (1635 Sherman Drive) – Approved 4-1 (Farmer dissenting). - 2022 UV2-007 (1259 West 29th Street) – Denied 3-1 (Duke supporting). - 2022 UV2-023 (5430 Victory Drive) – Denied 3-2 (Von Dalen and Duke supporting). - 2022 DV2-022 (1342 Southeast Street) – Part A (existing building and parking) approved 5-0; Part B (balcony) approved 3-2. - 2022 UV2-018 (4900 Robison Road) – Denied 4-1 (Von Dalen supporting). - Continuances: Several petitions were continued to future dates without additional notice: 2022 UV2-009 through 013 (September 13), 2022 UV2-013 (October 11), 2022 DV2-027 (September 6, transferred to Division 1), 2022 DV2-024 (September 13), 2022 DV2-023 (September 13), 2022 UV2-017 (September 13 with additional notice). - Expedited petitions: 2022 DV2-030 and 2022 DV2-020 were moved to the expedited docket and approved. - The board also acknowledged a timely automatic continuance for 2022 DV2-029.
The Metropolitan Development Commission (MDC) held a public meeting on August 3, 2022, beginning at 6:00 PM. The meeting covered a variety of land use and development items, including the approval of four resolutions, continuances, a withdrawal, seven no-appeal petitions, and three major public hearings. Key decisions involved rezoning a unique property on Kessler Boulevard for a 10-unit multifamily development, approving a mixed-use office and retail project in Broad Ripple Village, and a plat approval for a property on East 23rd Street despite title challenges. Consent Calendar - Minutes: Approved unanimously (6-0) for the July 20, 2022 meeting. - Resolutions: Four resolutions were approved together (6-0): - Resolution 2022 R026: Authorizes conveyance of four properties to Indypendence Indiana Incorporated for neighborhood redevelopment. - Resolution 2022 R027: Authorizes an interlocal agreement with IHA for up to $175,000 for housing rehabilitation using Meridian Redevelopment Area TIF funds. - Resolution 2022 E032: Authorizes up to $9,240,000 from unobligated funds for local public improvement projects. - Resolution 2022 E033: Authorizes pledge of TIF revenues for refunding bonds (series 2022) not to exceed $88 million. The Bond Bank and financial advisor Crow testified that the refunding would aim for lower interest rates (current bonds at 5%, target savings in the 3-4% range). - No-Appeals Docket: Seven petitions recommended for approval were approved together (6-0): - 2022 APP 008 (2001 W 86th St) - 2022 ZON 030 (11700 & 11850 E 38th St, 4002 N Carroll Rd) - 2022 ZON 059 (1902 Alvard St) - 2022 ZON 065 (3450 W 62nd St) - 2022 ZON 075 (95-975 Bertzel Pkwy) - 2022 ZON 079 (2018-2030 Rembrandt St) - 2022 CZN 834 (2143 Columbia Ave) Withdrawals & Continuances - Withdrawal: Petition 2021 ZON 125 and companion 2022 V AR001 (East Edgewood and South Emerson Avenue) were withdrawn by counsel Joseph Calderon to allow further work on a new site plan and community consensus. - Continuances: - 2022 VAC 002 (863 & 875 Massachusetts Ave) continued to August 17, 2022, without notice, with no objection from remonstrators or staff. - 2022 CZN 830 and 2022 CAP 830 (7320 E Hana Ave) continued to August 17, 2022, awaiting executed commitments. Public Hearing: 2022 ZON 034 – 4915 Kessler Boulevard East Drive - Petitioner: Misha Rabinovich representing Eric Armstrong (Spam Alexander REIG) sought rezoning from D2 to DP for a 10-unit luxury apartment development on a 1.66-acre property known as the "Dolphin House." - Supporting Testimony: - Neighbor Jordan Steinmetz (4903 Kessler Blvd East Dr) expressed support, citing the developer's responsiveness and the property's current blight. - Councilor Boots (Councillor for the area) testified in favor, emphasizing the developer's extensive concessions, including indemnification for neighboring wells, a development statement with 26 parking spaces, and a commitment to address code violations. He argued the unique property warranted a DP designation and that the 10-unit density was necessary for financial feasibility. - Opposing Testimony: - Laura Servas (4897 Kessler Blvd) objected on behalf of the Kessler View Neighborhood Association, citing density (three times the plan recommendation of 1.9 units/acre), parking concerns, the precedent of legitimizing past violations, and lack of enforcement. She noted the property had been a source of neighborhood problems. - Calvin Johnson (5730 Emerson Way) did not object to the zoning change but asked for strong city oversight during construction. - Melinda Hall (4711 Kessler View Dr) highlighted the property's history of non-compliance and expressed concern that the DP would not ensure future adherence. - Karen Friss (5204 Green Willow Ct) opposed due to traffic and safety issues at the curved intersection. - Staff Recommendation: Denial, citing inconsistency with the neighborhood plan (recommended 0-1.75 units/acre; proposal 6 units/acre), concerns about parking (26 spaces vs. code minimum of 10), and the legalization of unpermitted structures. Staff stated redevelopment should be compatible with the surrounding low-density character. - Key Outcomes: Motion to approve subject to the DP statement (dated August 3, 2022), site plan (May 23, 2022), and floor plans (June 23, 2022) passed 6-0. Commission President Dillon committed to monitoring the project alongside Councilor Boots. Public Hearing: 2022 CZN 821, CVR 81, CVC A21, CPL 821 – Cornell Avenue & Ferguson Street (Broad Ripple) - Petitioner: Misha Rabinovich representing Avenue Development sought approvals to redevelop four parcels into a mixed-use building with ground-floor restaurant (Ambrosia-affiliated) and three floors of office, along with a surface parking lot, alley vacation, and subdivision plat. The project would bring 80-100 daytime jobs to Broad Ripple. - Supporting Testimony: - Jordan Dillon, Executive Director of Broad Ripple Village Association (BRVA), testified in support, stating the project would bring needed daytime traffic to sustain businesses and improve public safety. She noted the developer had made three presentations to the land use committee and adjusted the building design. - The petitioner highlighted a $16-18 million investment, 2.5 million in property tax revenue over 10 years, and a parking agreement with Veritas Realty for 10 spaces. - Opposing Testimony: - Denny O'Clack (930 E 66th St) objected, arguing the project would harm the village character, increase congestion on Cornell Avenue, and set a precedent that undermines the Envision Broad Ripple Plan. - Staff Recommendation: Split – recommended approval of the rezoning (CZN) and variance for medium mixed-use building type and reduced parking (51 spaces vs. 75 required), but recommended denial of the alley vacation (CVC) and the surface parking lot on Ferguson Street, citing the Transit Oriented Development (TOD) overlay that prohibits surface parking within 1,000 feet of the Red Line. Staff suggested underground parking as an alternative. The hearing examiner had recommended denial of the entire project. - Key Outcomes: The commission approved all four petitions (each 4-0, with President Dillon recusing): - 2022 CZN 821 (rezoning) approved. - 2022 CVR 81 (variance of use and development standards) approved. - 2022 CVC A21 (alley vacation) approved, subject to public utility rights and a final assessment of $200 plus $750 appraiser fee. - 2022 CPL 821 (plat) approved, subject to 10 conditions in the staff report. Public Hearing: 2022 PLT 032 – 502 East 23rd Street - Petitioner: Attorney John Cross representing Jem Holmes LLC sought approval of a subdivision plat to re-plat three lots into four lots (0.69 acre, zoned D8). The property had a contested title history. - Remonstrator: Kenneth Kadir (P.O. Box 55227, Indianapolis) argued that the property was rightfully his through inheritance and that his mother's will and subsequent deeds were forged. He stated he had filed a new lawsuit and forensic evidence of forgery. He also argued the proposed development (condos/townhomes) would create parking issues and was inconsistent with the neighborhood's preference for single-family homes. - Petitioner's Response: Provided a detailed title history showing that Mr. Kadir's previous legal challenges had been dismissed with prejudice, and that the property was legally sold to the current owner. The plat met all subdivision ordinance requirements. - Staff Recommendation: Approval, noting the plat committee's function is ministerial; the plat complies with the subdivision control ordinance. - Key Outcomes: Motion to approve passed 4-1 (Commissioner Blackburn voted no). The commission noted the title dispute is a matter for the courts and did not affect the plat's compliance. Key Outcomes Summary - Approved 4 resolutions, 7 no-appeal petitions, and 3 major public hearing requests (with conditions). - Denied none; all votes on contested items had sufficient support. - The next MDC meeting is scheduled for August 17, 2022, with several items continued to that date. - President Dillon and Councilor Boots pledged to monitor the Kessler Boulevard project for compliance.
This meeting of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division 1, was held on August 2, 2022, beginning at approximately 6:15 PM. Acting Chairperson Matt Boone presided, joined by board members Eduardo Luna and David Duncan. Legal counsel Chris Steinmetz and planning staff were present. The board considered multiple requests for continuances, withdrawals, and variance petitions, with votes on several key items. Due to the departure of a board member, a quorum was lost before all agenda items could be heard, resulting in automatic continuations of the remaining petitions. Consent Calendar - The board approved a waiver of rules of procedure to vote on all expedited petitions without additional testimony (motion by Duncan, second by Luna, unanimous). - Petition 2022-DV1-037 (5943 Leicester Lane) was withdrawn as the proposed setback now complies with the ordinance. The board acknowledged the withdrawal and approved a full refund of the filing fee ($580) (motion by Duncan, second, unanimous). - Petition 2022-DV1-038 (7525 Edgewater Drive) received a timely automatic continuance filed by a registered neighborhood organization to September 6, 2022; the board acknowledged. Later, staff noted a publication error required additional notice, and the board re-acknowledged the continuance with that condition. - Several petitions were continued due to publication errors: 2022-UV1-010 (Prospect Street), 2022-DV1-039 (Ferguson Street), 2022-UV1-024 (South High School Road), 2022 SE1001 (Michigan Road), 2022 DV1034 (Wheeler Street), 2022 DV1040 (West 86th Street), 2022 DB 1041 (North Gale Street) — all continued to September 6, 2022 with additional notice. The board voted unanimously on each. - Petition 2022 UV1020 (Jackson Street) had a timely automatic continuance filed by the petitioner; acknowledged. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made during the opening procedures. Discussion Items - Continuance Requests - Petition 2022-DV1-036 (Meridian Hills): Petitioner Jacob Cox requested a continuance to October 4, 2022, to allow the Meridian Hills town council to vote on the variance request. Staff had no objection. The board granted the continuance (unanimous). - Petition 2022 UV 1009 (8930 West Washington Street): Petitioner Sylvia Miller requested a continuance due to only three board members present. Remonstrator Brian Tui (Indianapolis Airport Authority) opposed, noting the petition had been filed in February and already continued twice. Staff indicated they had previously stated no further continuances but had no objection given the partial board. The vote resulted in a 2-1 split (Luna no, Duncan yes, Boone yes), which is indecisive under board rules, so the petition proceeded to hearing. - Petition 2022 DB 1026 (717 Shelby Street): Petitioner Paul Lambey requested a continuance to October 4, 2022, to meet with the Fountain Square Neighborhood Association and allow the petitioner to reassess economic conditions. Staff had no objection, and the continuance was granted unanimously. - Petition 2022 HOV 004 (2363 North Parker Avenue): Petitioner, representing owner Jean Camara, sought a variance for a zero-foot corner side setback to build a shipping container home. During testimony, the petitioner requested withdrawal of the petition and a full refund, citing the desire to avoid a decision with only three board members and recent site plan updates that may eliminate the need for a variance. Staff recommended denial of the refund because the case had proceeded through multiple hearings. The board acknowledged the withdrawal but split on the refund: Luna voted yes, Duncan no, Boone yes — an indecisive vote, meaning no refund was granted. - Petition 2022 UV1-002 (2535 East 79th Street): Petitioner Garrett Lawton represented William and Beth Gammon, seeking a variance of use and development standards to retain a shipping container and carport on their lot (in a floodway fringe, with deficient setbacks). The container has existed for about 40 years, the carport for a decade. The petitioners argued hardship due to disability, limited income, and the loss of a garage from a fire. Neighbors testified in support, noting the lot is well-maintained and the structures are not visible. Staff opposed, citing ongoing violations, floodplain concerns, and the ability to develop the lot residentially. The board voted 3-0 to approve, subject to commitments that the improvements be removed upon transfer of the property and that the container remain uninhabitable. - Petition 2022 DV 1025 (16 West Morris Street & 1150 South Meridian Street): The petitioner did not appear when called. Staff noted a revised site plan was submitted late. The board moved the petition to the end of the docket. Later, David Kingan arrived and requested a continuance to September 6, 2022, with additional notice. Staff expressed concern about repeated continuances but agreed. The board granted the continuance (unanimous). - Petition 2022 UV 1009 (8930 West Washington Street, continued from earlier): Petitioner Anjali Sang sought a permanent variance for continued automobile and motorcycle sales (a use granted as a temporary variance in 2017). The petitioner argued compliance with commitments, support from neighbors, and a small business investment. Remonstrators (Indianapolis Airport Authority, City-County Councillor Jared Evans, and Indy Gateway) opposed, citing violations of commitments (e.g., landscaping, age of vehicles), negative impact on the airport entrance, and inconsistency with the comprehensive plan. Staff recommended denial. After hearing rebuttals, the board voted 3-0 to deny the petition. - Petition 2022 UV 1012 (5531 East 82nd Street): Reagan Outdoor Advertising sought variances to convert a static billboard to digital (42 feet tall, 672 sq ft, eight-second message duration, within 415 feet of a protected district). Remonstrators, including neighborhood associations and nearby residents, opposed, citing traffic safety, light pollution, inconsistency with the sign ordinance, and precedent. Staff recommended denial. The vote was 2-1 (Boone and Duncan no, Luna yes), an indecisive result, so the petition was automatically continued to September 6, 2022. - Petition 2022 UV 1013 (4015 East 82nd Street): Essentially the same request as UV 1012 but at a different location. The board incorporated the staff report and prior testimony by reference. After testimony, the board voted 3-0 to deny the petition. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted: 2022-DV1-036 to Oct 4, 2022; 2022 DB 1026 to Oct 4, 2022; 2022 DV 1025 to Sep 6, 2022; 2022 UV 1012 auto-continued to Sep 6, 2022. - Withdrawal acknowledged: 2022-DV1-037 (with refund approved); 2022 HOV 004 (withdrawal acknowledged, refund request indecisive – denied). - Variance approved: 2022 UV1-002 (2535 E 79th St) with commitments (3-0). - Variance denied: 2022 UV 1009 (8930 W Washington St) (3-0); 2022 UV 1013 (4015 E 82nd St) (3-0). - Loss of quorum: After board member Luna left, the remaining petitions (2022 UV 1014, 1015, 1016, 1021, 1023) were continued to September 6, 2022, or transferred to Division 2 on August 9, 2022, as agreed by the petitioners and without objection from the audience. - Adoption of findings: For denied petitions, the board continued the cases for adoption of negative findings of fact at a later hearing.
The Metropolitan Development Commission met on July 20, 2022, to consider resolutions, zoning petitions, and a major public hearing for a new recreation center. The meeting opened with recognition of Commissioner Alpha Blackburn as a "living legend" and a farewell to long-time staff member Lena Hackett, who is resigning. The commission approved two resolutions, handled several continuances, denied a request for a waiver of appeal rules, and unanimously approved a slate of no-appeal petitions. The highlight was a public hearing for the Frederick Douglass Family Community Center, which was approved unanimously. Consent Calendar - Minutes Approval: The minutes from the July 6, 2022 meeting were approved unanimously. Commissioner Robinson recused herself. - Resolution 2022 R025: Authorized the transfer of property at 3949 Metals Drive for a business expansion. Passed 8-0. - Resolution 2022 BB 002: Authorized the expenditure of up to $40,000 from allocation funds to reimburse the bond bank for prior expenditures. Passed 8-0. - No-Appeal Petitions: After voting separately on 2022 ZON 037 (1212 Castillana Drive), the commission approved the remaining 12 petitions recommended for approval by the hearing examiner as a block. All passed 8-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Luke Burrow (representing LP2LC) requested a waiver of rules to appeal a variance denial for 1105 and 1107 English Avenue, citing a missed deadline. Commission denied the request 7-1. - Caitlin Levesque (attorney for BRHQ Real Estate) requested a continuance for petitions related to 6548-6556 Cornell Avenue and 6535 Ferguson Street to August 3, 2022. No objections; granted. - Tim Oaks (attorney for M Development Company) requested a continuance for 2022 ZON 037 (1212 Castillana Drive) due to a late appeal from Senator Taylor's office. The commission ruled the appeal out of order and proceeded to vote on the petition, which was approved 8-0. - During the public hearing for the Frederick Douglass Park recreation center, two community members spoke in support: - Jacqueline McMillan Gunn (resident of Martindale Brightwood) expressed support for the project. - Burning Compton (president of Brightwood Conserved Citizens) expressed support on behalf of the community. Discussion Items - Special Request – Waiver of Rules: Luke Burrow requested a waiver of the five-business-day appeal period for a variance denial. Staff recommended denial, noting the deadline was announced and he was reminded. The commission denied the request 7-1. - Continuances: The commission approved continuances for several petitions to the August 3, 2022 meeting: - 2022 CZN 821, C VR 821, CVC 821, CPL 821 (Broad Ripple area) – granted. - 2022 ZON 030 (East 38th Street and Carroll Road) – continued due to pending commitments. - 2022 CZN 830 and CAP 830 (7320 East Hannah Avenue) – continued for commitment review. - 2022 ZON 037 (1212 Castillana Drive): Despite a late appeal filed by Greg Taylor representing Senator Vanessa Summers, the commission ruled the appeal out of order and proceeded to approve the zoning petition individually 8-0. The petitioner expressed willingness to meet with opponents. - Public Hearing – Frederick Douglass Family Community Center: - Petitioner: Indy Parks and Recreation (Phyllis Boyd, Director; Don Colvin, Deputy Director) presented plans for a 45,000-square-foot recreation center at 1616 East 25th Street, funded by Circle City Forward bonds. The project includes a parking lot, playground, picnic shelter, sidewalks, and landscaping. A variance was requested to allow sidewalks only adjacent to the building along 25th Street and Ralston Avenue, with additional sidewalks to be extended to 27th Street per staff recommendation. Commitments included $20,000 for XBE engagement, a playground fence, and security measures. - Staff: Supported both the rezoning and variance, noting the project is well-designed. - Sarah Reardon (Director of the Indianapolis Local Public Bond Bank) confirmed that $110 million in bonds were issued for Circle City Forward projects, with this project moving fastest. The bond repayment is secured by an unlimited pledge of local income tax through a lease financing structure. - Commissioners: Expressed strong support, commending the inclusive design and community engagement. Key Outcomes - Waiver of Rules Denied: Luke Burrow's request to waive appeal rules was denied 7-1. - Continuances Granted: All requested continuances to August 3, 2022 were approved 8-0. - 2022 ZON 037 Approved: The zoning petition for 1212 Castillana Drive was approved 8-0, with the late appeal not recognized. - No-Appeal Petitions Approved: 12 petitions were approved as a block 8-0. - Frederick Douglass Park Recreation Center Approved: Both the park district designation (2022 CAP 831) and the variance of development standards (2022 C VR 831) were approved 8-0. Construction is targeted for completion by September 2023. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned following a motion by Commissioner Hackett, who was recognized for her 10 years of service.
This was a public hearing of the Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division III, held on July 19, 2022, chaired by Joanna Taft, with members Bart Brown, Cameron Radford, and Roderick Bohannan. The board processed multiple continuances, two expedited petitions, and two non-expedited variance petitions. Continuances and Special Requests - The board approved numerous continuances to the August 16, 2022 hearing, including for cases 2022-DV3-022 (convenience centers), 2022-DV3-018 (24 East Street), 2022-UV3-010, 2022-UV3-014, 2022-UV3-018, 2022-UV3-009, 2022-UV3-011, 2022-UV3-015, 2022-DV3-026, and others. Some continuances were without additional notice, others with. - A request for continuance for 2022-DV3-028 (fence variance) was denied; the case proceeded. - Withdrawals were acknowledged for 2022-UV3-005, 2022-UV3-017, and 2022-DV3-009B. - Timely automatic continuances were acknowledged for 2022-UV3-019 and 2022-DV3-025. Expedited Cases - Two petitions were moved to expedited and approved by unanimous vote (4-0): - 2022-DV3-024: 6832 East 82nd Street – variance for a 25-foot pylon sign (staff recommended approval). - 2022-DV3-027: 1609 Oliver Avenue – variance for a building addition with reduced front setback (staff recommended approval). Public Comments & Testimony (Non-Expedited Case: 2022-DV3-014 – 337 Parkway Avenue) - Petitioner Paul Carroll (representing the developer) requested variances to construct a duplex on a substandard lot. He argued the lot historically had two houses, and the duplex is the highest and best use, consistent with new D5 zoning and TOD overlay. He noted cooperation with the Bates Hendricks Neighborhood Association and staff, reducing the open space variance from 47% to 55% (required 60%). - Remonstrator Jean Salzman (homeowner at 330 Parkway for 24 years) opposed, stating a previous variance for two houses was denied in 2019. She argued the lot can only support one dwelling, and the duplex would overcrowd, detract from property values, and be inconsistent with the streetscape. She presented seven letters of opposition. - Staff recommended approval, noting the lot is substandard regardless of use, the front setback is consistent with neighbors, and the duplex fits the D5 district character. Public Comments & Testimony (Non-Expedited Case: 2022-DV3-028 – 4017 South State Avenue) - Petitioner Uche Anagu (property owner) requested a variance to add a 4-foot privacy screen atop a 6-foot fence, creating a 10-foot fence. He testified that the neighbor, Wanda Ladd, has engaged in ongoing harassment, including peering over the fence, using a ladder to watch, installing cameras, and making animal sounds at his children. He presented photos, videos, and police reports, and letters of support from neighbors and the University of Indianapolis president. - Remonstrator Wanda Ladd (neighbor) denied the allegations, accusing Anagu of lying and exaggerating. She claimed Anagu’s fence is ugly, that he has multiple Airbnb units, and that he is trying to block city inspectors from viewing his property. She stated Anagu’s second story sees into their yard, and they have no privacy. She also claimed Anagu did not provide proper notice to neighbors. - Staff recommended denial, citing the zoning ordinance that fences shall not exceed six feet to maintain residential character. Key Outcomes - 2022-DV3-014 (337 Parkway Avenue): Approved by a vote of 3-1 (Bohannan opposed). The variance allows construction of a duplex with an 8-foot front setback and 55% open space (reduced from 60%). - 2022-DV3-028 (4017 South State Avenue): Approved by a vote of 3-1 (Brown opposed). The variance allows a 10-foot fence (6-foot fence plus 4-foot screen) along the north property line. - The board also adopted revised findings of fact for previously continued cases (2022-DV3-098, 2022-DV3-017, 2022-DV3-019). - Meeting adjourned.