Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1131–1140 ENTRIES
1131
JUL 12, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Regular Meeting - July 12, 2022

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, July 12, 2022, at 10:00 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes and consent items, several major real estate and development discussions, a maritime portfolio update, and a vote to adjust the executive director's salary. Key actions included endorsing a term sheet for the Piers 38 & 40 project, adopting a new broker policy for two properties, and setting the executive director's salary with a catch-up increase. Consent Calendar - Minutes: The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the June 14, 2022 meeting. - Resolution 22‑34: Approved a settlement agreement with Acclama Inc. for past due rent exceeding $1.8 million, including a 14‑month payment plan and a 20% reduction of past due base rent if completed. - Resolution 22‑35: Approved a final settlement agreement to resolve disputed title claims on former Custer Avenue with the Coal Trust, including a purchase and sale agreement, public trust easement, and authority to seek state legislation. - The consent calendar was adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Executive Director's Report: Kathy Q, Commodore of the Bay Area Association of Disabled Sailors (BADS), expressed concern about the Piers 38 & 40 term sheet, noting that BADS currently pays no rent and that the term sheet only promises to honor existing leases "to the extent feasible" without a dedicated space for their workshop or storage. She asked for protection for BADS. - Item 11A (Piers 38 & 40 Term Sheet): Norman Pierce, a 45‑year resident and member of South Beach Yacht Club, spoke in full support of the project, emphasizing the need for visitor docking and the economic benefits of boaters. Drew Harper of Spinnaker Sailing praised the developer's inclusion of maritime tenants and noted that other Bay Area projects are excluding small maritime businesses. Another caller from BADS highlighted the organization's free sailing programs for underserved communities. - No public comments were made on other items. Discussion Items Item 11A – Endorsement of Term Sheet with Pacific Waterfront Partners III, LLC for Piers 38 & 40 - Presentation: David Beaupre (Deputy Director, Planning & Environment) and Josh Keene (Waterfront Development Director) presented the proposed term sheet for the $528 million project. The project includes 215,000 sq ft of office, 21,000 sq ft of market‑rate restaurants, 10,000–20,000 sq ft of affordable restaurant space, and expanded maritime berthing. A key component is resilience improvements (seismic upgrades, sea‑level rise protection) that also benefit the South Beach neighborhood. The capital stack includes $420 million in private equity/developer funds, $65 million in historic tax credits, $19 million in IFD, and a $58 million gap to be secured through grants with port support (no obligation to use port capital). The developer, Simon Snellgrove of Pacific Waterfront Partners, committed to a DEI plan including workforce development (via Cornerstone), affordable rents, and construction assistance for tenants. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Gilman asked about the extension/termination mechanisms, which will be formalized in the Development and Disposition Agreement (DDA). She also noted the high level of public financing (25–30%) and praised the DEI program, stating it sets a new floor for future deals. Vice President Brandon asked about community feedback (reported as generally positive, with ongoing outreach to BADS) and the change in financial terms from the original RFP. Staff explained that the original higher rent with rent credits was replaced by a simpler base rent ($120,000/year escalating 15% every 5 years over 66 years) plus participation rent (0.5–4% on a tiered basis). President Adams expressed support but noted a desire for more public testimony from regular community activists. - Outcome: Resolution 2236 endorsing the term sheet was adopted unanimously. Item 11B – Broker Policy & Multi‑Site Offering (Ferry Plaza East & Pier 33½) - Presentation: Ricky Tijani (Development Project Manager) requested approval to rescind the prohibition on paying broker commissions (Resolution 0729) and adopt a new interim broker policy allowing commissions (4–7% of base rent, paid from rent over time). The policy requires broker registration, port discretion, and that payments come from rent unless an exception is granted. Staff also requested authorization to use a broker‑assisted competitive solicitation for two properties: the Ferry Plaza East building (≈18,000 sq ft, needing reconfiguration) and the Pier 33½ restaurant space (≈4,600 sq ft, more turnkey). The pilot program aims to fill vacancies more efficiently. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Gilman clarified that the detailed selection process in the staff report is a contingency if the broker fails, and she expressed hope that the port will move quickly for ideal applicants. Vice President Brandon asked about how broker fees are negotiated; staff explained that brokers submit fee proposals with their qualifications, and the fee is set before contracting through the Department of Real Estate. The commission confirmed there is no hard cap but an expectation of 4–7%, and that fee details will be brought back when lease terms are presented. - Outcome: Resolutions 2237 (rescinding old prohibition and adopting new broker policy) and 2238 (authorizing the multi‑site offering) were adopted unanimously. Item 11C – Informational Presentation on FY 2022‑23 Parameter Rates - Presentation: Rebecca Benissini (Deputy Director, Real Estate & Development) presented the proposed rate schedule. Of 115 rental rates, roughly half will increase slightly, 40% stay the same, and 10% decrease, reflecting market conditions (high office vacancy, stable industrial demand). New rates were proposed for sidewalk use by port tenants, water‑recreation/maritime uses at Pier 40, airspace rights, and outdoor classes. Leasing tactics include termination rights for 3–4 year leases (with a fee) and sublease profit‑sharing. Special event fees were adjusted with more size categories and discounts for nonprofit and DEI events (up to $7,000 waiver, capped at $60,000/year). No action was taken; staff will return in August for approval. Item 12A – Informational Update on Maritime Portfolio - Presentation: Andre Coleman (Deputy Director, Maritime) reported on cargo, cruise, shipyard, Hyde Street Harbor, and excursion/ferry operations. Cargo at Pier 80 saw a 40% decline due to supply chain issues but is expected to rebound. Cruise is experiencing a record year with 115 vessel calls expected (highest ever). The shipyard is being activated with interim leases and a hydrogen ferry berth. Hyde Street Harbor continues to support 160+ fishing vessels, and the retail fish sales pilot program will return for permanent expansion. Also noted: the French Navy vessel visit, Fleet Week planning, and offshore wind exploration. Commissioners praised the team and the strong recovery. Item 13A – Executive Director Salary Adjustment - Presentation: Katie Petruccioni (Deputy Director, Finance & Administration) presented two options: Option A applied the new MEA MOU increases (5.25% in FY22‑23, 2.5% in FY23‑24, 2.25% on Jan 1, 2024) to the current salary of $318,942. Option B included an additional 7% catch‑up increase (which other MEA employees received but the director did not) followed by the same MEA increases, bringing the salary to approximately $352,000 by Jan 2024. The resolution was left blank for the commission to decide. - Commission Discussion: Commissioner Gilman and Vice President Brandon strongly praised Director Elaine Forbes for her leadership through the pandemic, equity work, and team building. President Adams noted her selflessness. Vice President Brandon moved to adopt Option B, seconded by Commissioner Gilman. - Outcome: Resolution 2239 adopting Option B (7% catch‑up plus MEA increases) was passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2236: Unanimously endorsed the term sheet with Pacific Waterfront Partners III, LLC for the Piers 38 & 40 project, allowing staff to proceed with environmental review and Board of Supervisors approval. - Resolutions 2237 & 2238: Unanimously approved the new interim broker policy and authorized a broker‑assisted solicitation for the Ferry Plaza East building and Pier 33½ restaurant space. - Resolution 2239: Unanimously set the executive director's salary with a 7% catch‑up increase plus the MEA negotiated cost‑of‑living adjustments over the next two fiscal years. New Business - Commissioner Gilman requested updates on wayfinding/signage and the Teatro Zenzani site at a future meeting.

REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 32% · MARITIME OPERATIONS 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PROCEDURAL 9%
1132
JUL 12, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Regular Meeting - July 12, 2022: Drought, PG&E Grid, Surplus Land, and Fishing Program

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held its regular meeting on July 12, 2022, at 1:30 PM in City Hall Room 400. The commission approved the consent calendar, heard a drought update from Assistant General Manager Steve Ritchie, received a report on the PG&E electric grid valuation petition, authorized the sale of a small surplus land parcel to Caltrans, and took a preliminary step toward allowing limited shoreline fishing at Calaveras Reservoir under a court order. Consent Calendar - Adopted Resolution extending the SuperGreen Multi-Year Electricity Service Agreement term limit to up to 10 years (Item 9a). - Approved Contract No. WD‑2887, Harry Tracy Water Treatment Plant Filter Underdrain Replacement, to Anvil Builders Inc. for $9,264,300 (Item 9b). - Accepted work and authorized final payment for Contract WW‑569 (fire alarm upgrades) to L C General Engineering (Item 9c). - Accepted work, approved Modification No. 1 (final), and authorized final payment for Contract WW‑702R (sewer discharge rehabilitation) to Trinet Construction, increasing the contract to $3,967,817 (Item 9d). - Accepted work, approved Modification No. 2 (final), and authorized final payment for Contract WW‑706 (digester liner rehabilitation) to Trinet Construction, increasing the contract to $2,689,318 (Item 9e). Public Comments & Testimony - Dave Warner (Palo Alto) urged the commission to resume regular updates on Bay‑Delta Plan negotiations, noting that demand projections have declined and expressed hope that the SFPUC would take the lead in finding creative solutions. Later, on Item 6G, he praised the General Manager’s letter on water demand projections and requested a third column in the water supply shortfall chart based on finance projections. - Matt Parker (white‑water kayaker) thanked the commission for continued flows on the Tuolumne River, stating that white‑water exposure produces serotonin and helps mental health. - Francisco DeCoston called for a hearing on community benefits, alleging corruption at SFPUC and neglect of Hunters Point residents. He also warned about fire risks at the SFPUC’s 70th‑day area and demanded inclusion of Native Americans in habitat restoration discussions. - Nathan Ringel (President, California Outdoors) thanked the commission for Tuolumne River flows, emphasizing their economic and environmental value to riverside communities. - Nicole Sandkulla (BAWSCA CEO) commented on water demand projections (Item 6G), noting that BAWSCA’s population projections have tracked well but demand and purchase projections have been affected by COVID and drought. She stated that the Urban Water Management Plan may serve as an outer envelope for San Francisco but differs for other agencies. - Jeff Miller (Alameda Creek Alliance) opposed unrestricted fishing at Calaveras Reservoir, citing risks to the genetically valuable landlocked steelhead trout. He urged extremely limited access, a ban on fishing for trout, required presence of SFPUC staff, prohibition of toxic fishing weights, and suggested considering the upper Alameda Creek watershed as a wildlife refuge. - Caller on Item 7B asked about a needs assessment for high‑power lines, maintenance near Hetch Hetchy, fire contingency plans, and undergrounding costs. - Caller on Item 12 questioned the definition of “limited shoreline fishing,” raised security concerns about contamination, and called for an emergency management commander to assess risks. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Hybrid Meeting Findings: Unanimously adopted renewed findings under state urgency legislation to allow hybrid in‑person meetings during the COVID‑19 emergency and directed the Commission Secretary to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. (3‑0 vote) - Item 4 – Minutes of June 28, 2022: Approved without change. (3‑0) - Item 5 – General Public Comment: Four callers spoke (detailed above). - Item 6 – Communications: Included reports on Advance Calendar, Contracts, CleanPowerSF, quarterly status on PG&E disputes, and Water Demand Projections. Public comment heard. - Item 7 – Report of the General Manager: - 7A – Drought Update: AGM Ritchie reported that Hetch Hetchi and Cherry reservoirs are near full, but the water bank is at 40% of capacity. He noted the Upper Tuolumne River Ecosystem Program successfully used excess runoff to flood Pupina Valley ponds, providing habitat for bats and other species. Demand for the last week was 205 MGD, trending toward the target of 210 MGD. The reservoir filled on schedule with minimal spill. - 7B – CPUC Ruling on PG&E Grid Valuation: AGM Hale reported that on June 24, 2022, CPUC Commissioner Reynolds issued a scoping memo setting an 18‑month schedule to value PG&E’s San Francisco electric grid assets. The city’s petition to purchase the grid is moving forward; PG&E’s motion to dismiss is still under review. - Item 8 – New Commission Business: None. - Item 11 – Surplus Land Sale to Caltrans: The commission declared approximately 21,651 sq ft of underused agricultural land (Parcel 57, Alameda County) as surplus and authorized sale to Caltrans for $24,528 for the Alameda Creek Bridge replacement project. Staff noted Caltrans has eminent domain authority, making the sale preferable to litigation. Commissioners questioned the benefit and where proceeds go (they enter the water department fund). (3‑0) - Item 12 – Preliminary Determination on Shoreline Fishing at Calaveras Reservoir: Staff recommended a preliminary finding that limited shoreline fishing (by reservation, no boats, barbless hooks, catch‑and‑release only) could be done without endangering drinking water quality, contingent on amending the Alameda Watershed Management Plan, CEQA review, and a state drinking water permit amendment. Commissioner Paulson asked about ability to add future protections; staff affirmed the process would return to the commission. The item was moved under a court order deadline of September 1, 2022. (3‑0) Key Outcomes - Votes: All items passed unanimously (3‑0, with Vice President Ajami excused). - Directives: The Commission Secretary was directed to agendize a renewed hybrid meeting resolution within 30 days. The General Manager was authorized to develop details for the Calaveras fishing program and pursue CEQA and permit amendments. - Referrals: Staff will return with amendments to the Alameda Watershed Management Plan and a proposed fishing program after environmental review and permit changes. - Next Steps: The commission will not meet on July 26 or August 9, 2022. Item 10 (Master License for wireless pole installations) was removed and rescheduled to August 23, 2022.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 38% · PROCEDURAL 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 8%
1133
JUL 7, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - July 7, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 7, 2022, at 10:00 AM in City Hall, Room 250, in a hybrid format. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, considered eight agenda items including resolutions, ordinances, hearings, and contract approvals. Notable discussions centered on PG&E accountability, veterans' affordable housing priority, and the Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART) implementation. Consent Calendar - Item 7: Resolution retroactively authorizing acceptance of an in-kind gift of internet access services valued at $173,400 from Monkeybrains.net for March 2020 through December 2022, to support COVID-19 response sites. Approved unanimously. - Item 8: Resolution retroactively authorizing acceptance of an in-kind gift of pro bono legal services valued at $250,000 from the University of San Francisco School of Law's Racial Justice Clinic for the District Attorney's Sentencing Review and Wrongful Conviction Units. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (PG&E resolution): Multiple speakers from Reclaim Our Power campaign and community organizations expressed strong support, citing PG&E's negligence, wildfires, and lack of accountability. One speaker suggested transmitting the resolution to state legislators and lobbyists. - Item 2 (Veterans housing priority): Over 30 public speakers, including veterans, commissioners, and service providers, overwhelmingly supported the ordinance. Many shared personal stories of housing insecurity and emphasized the need for priority within existing affordable housing preference categories. Some urged expedited implementation and criticized potential delays. - Item 3 (CART hearing): Approximately 20 public speakers, including advocates, formerly unhoused individuals, and community organization representatives, called for swift implementation of CART as a community-based alternative to police response. Some expressed frustration with the year-long delay and urged immediate action. One caller raised concerns about community input from residents. - Item 4 (Performance audits): One speaker supported the audits and stressed the importance of metrics. - Item 5 (Biosolids contract): One speaker supported the resolution, noting the city's wastewater treatment efforts. - Item 6 (Recology contract): One speaker expressed confusion about the extension and urged transparency but ultimately supported the resolution. Discussion Items - Item 1: Resolution urging Governor Newsom to halt PG&E safety certificate issuance – Vice Chair Chan presented, highlighting PG&E's negligence, wildfire deaths, and cost impacts on San Francisco (nearly 770 city projects delayed, over $10 million annually). Antonio Diaz (PODER) and Jessica Tovar (Local Clean Energy Alliance) detailed PG&E's failures and advocated for a publicly owned energy system (Golden State Energy). Committee members expressed support; Supervisor Preston commented on the need for accountability. The item was moved to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Ordinance adding veterans priority in affordable housing programs – Supervisor Mar presented the Veterans Affordable Housing Access Act, which would prioritize veterans within existing preference categories. Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) Nick Menard estimated implementation costs of $300,000-$400,000 and about 2600 hours of work. Concerns were raised about timeline and funding; Supervisor Preston questioned the necessity of a year-long delay. Commissioner Jason Chittavang (Veterans Affairs Commission) supported the ordinance. After public comment, the committee voted unanimously to send to the full board. - Item 3: Hearing on CART implementation – Supervisor Melgar emphasized the need for a community-based alternative to police for low-priority homelessness-related calls. Director of Emergency Management Mary Carroll outlined a pilot program funded with $3 million, aiming to resolve up to 100 calls per week initially, with an RFP expected in September 2022 and operational start in January 2023. Tim Black (CAHOOTS program, Eugene, OR) described their model: 33 years, 20,000 calls/year, $2.5 million budget, saving $16 million annually. Wes Saver (Glide) and Gwen Westbrook (United Council of Human Services) stressed community trust and lived experience. Deputy Director Robert Smuts (DEM) noted approximately 65,000 C-priority calls related to homelessness annually; the pilot could cover about 5,000-7,500 calls per year. Supervisor Mandelman expressed concerns about neighborhood impacts and adequate response to serious issues. The committee continued the item to the call of the chair. - Item 4: Motion directing BLA to conduct performance audits – Chair Preston proposed two audits: (1) a multi-department audit of street crisis response teams (Fire, HSH, DPH, DEM) and (2) an audit of permanent supportive housing funds administered by HSH. BLA indicated audits would assess response times, service delivery, and funding transparency. The motion passed unanimously. - Item 5: Contract with Lystek International for biosolids management – The item was continued from a previous meeting after technical amendments. Director Carroll clarified transportation costs and fuel use (diesel). The committee approved sending to the full board. - Item 6: Contract modification with Recology for refuse collection – OCA confirmed issuance of a new solicitation. BLA recommended approval as a bridge until a new contract is awarded, noting termination clauses allow the city to exit if a new provider is selected. Committee approved sending to the full board. - Item 7: In-kind gift from Monkeybrains – Policy Analyst Brian Roberts explained the delay in bringing the gift to the board due to oversight; committed to seeking prior approval in the future. Approved. - Item 8: In-kind gift from USF Racial Justice Clinic – Deputy DA Sarcelia Hurtado described the post-conviction unit's work. Committee members expressed hope the new DA would continue the program. Approved. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board; supervisors Preston, Chan, and Mandelman added as co-sponsors. - Item 3: Continued to the call of the chair; DEM committed to issuing RFP by September 2022 for a pilot starting January 2023, with $3 million funding covering 12 months of operation. - Item 4: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board. - Item 5: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board as committee report. - Item 6: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board as committee report. - Item 7: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board. - Item 8: Approved unanimously (3-0) to send to full board.

HOMELESSNESS 21% · VETERANS AFFAIRS 15% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 7% · CRISIS INTERVENTION TEAM 7%
1134
JUL 6, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - July 6, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, July 6, 2022, at 5:30 PM in City Hall Room 400. The meeting included public comment, adoption of minutes, reports from the Chief and DPA Director, commission reports, and a vote to adopt revised Department General Order (DGO) 8.02 on hostage and barricaded suspect procedures. The commission also went into closed session to discuss personnel and disciplinary matters. Key topics included crime trends, pretext stops reform, and community concerns. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Minutes (June 1, 8, and 15, 2022): Unanimously approved (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several callers addressed the commission on items not on the agenda. A caller urged the commission to call a commander involved with emergency services for a needs assessment. Samina Usman (Council on American-Islamic Relations) called for urgency in ending pretext stops, citing racial disparities: 5% of San Francisco's population is African American yet approximately 27% of stops involve African Americans, and she cited the case of Jayland Walker (60 shots). David Aronson (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community) read a statement from founder Felicia Jones calling out anti-blackness in SFPD use of force, arrests, and traffic stops, noting that racial disparities have worsened since 2016 and that routine traffic stops make up about two-thirds of all stops. Rev. Amos Brown (San Francisco NAACP) urged a holistic approach to crime and homelessness, emphasizing working together. Avi Fry (ACLU of Northern California) requested a greater sense of urgency for pretext stop reform, stating empirical science shows no safety justification. Zach Dylan (Public Defender's Office) echoed that call and noted that public comments on the general order had disappeared from the commission website. Wesley Saver (Glide) asked for a clear timeline for working groups on DGO 9.01, referring to a report that San Francisco ranks worst in the state for police-caused hospitalization rates for black residents. A mother (Ms. Brown) pleaded for justice for her son's unsolved 2006 murder. - Public Comment on Chief's Report: A caller urged support for the Walgreens on San Bruno Avenue, saying it serves seniors and needs security to remain open. - Public Comment on DPA Report: None. - Public Comment on Commission Reports: Two callers: Mary Nfami (Council on American-Islamic Relations) emphasized the need to move quickly on pretext stops proposed since February 2022, and another caller spoke in favor of restorative justice, citing its implementation in Bayview Hunters Point. - Public Comment on DGO 8.02: None. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Chief William Scott): Reported weekly crime trends: violent crime up 6%, homicides down 4%, property crime up 7%, burglaries down 25%, auto burglaries up 8% (10,001 compared to 9,264), gun violence down 15% (103 incidents vs. 121), ghost guns constitute 91 of 519 total guns seized (about 18%). Homicide clearance rate is 64% year-to-date. Significant incidents included two homicides (July 1 and 3), a shooting at Ingalls and Underwood on July 4, a stabbing at a Walgreens, and a series of burglaries leading to arrests. A fatal boat collision occurred on June 30. The department seized approximately 40 vehicles as part of stunt driving enforcement. Deployment strategies in Bayview and Ingleside stations were adjusted over the July 4 weekend to address shots-fired incidents; no additional shootings occurred in Bayview that weekend. - DPA Director's Report (Acting Director Sarah Hawkins): Reported 336 cases opened, 362 closed, 237 pending, 38 sustained (vs. 28 last year). 11 cases mediated. 20 cases beyond nine-month investigation period. 12 pending with commission, 1 with chief. Top allegations (past three weeks): 38% failing to take required action (mostly failure to write reports), 14% inappropriate conduct. Mission station had a surge. DPA held a know-your-rights presentation and participated in community meetings. An audit of DGO 8.10 compliance started. Comparison with Internal Affairs numbers still pending. - Commission Reports: Commissioner Benedicto updated on DGO 9.01 (pretext stops): partnering with Human Rights Commission, three outreach methods (community events starting August, listening sessions week of August 22, working groups in August). Specific dates to be provided. He also attended police graduation (15 cadets, 6 bilingual) and DPA mediation conference. Commissioner Byrne reported outreach to Northern Station about defacing and drug dealing on Van Ness, and confirmed increased evening deployment in Tenderloin will continue beyond August. - Discussion and possible action to adopt revised DGO 8.02 "Hostage and Barricaded Suspect": Captain John Jamarena presented the refresh of the 1994 policy, developed with DPA and SMEs. No questions from commissioners. Key Outcomes - Vote on Revised DGO 8.02: Unanimously adopted (5-0). - Vote to Hold Closed Session (Item 9): Unanimously approved (5-0). - Closed Session: The commission entered closed session to discuss personnel exceptions, including evidentiary stipulations, findings of fact in non-disciplinary cases, assignment of commissioners for evidence taking in disciplinary cases (IAD 2022-0074 and IAD 2021-0089), and status of pending cases. - Motion Not to Disclose Closed Session Discussions: Unanimously approved (5-0). - Adjournment: The meeting adjourned without objection at approximately 7:30 PM. Note: The date of the meeting is July 6, 2022, as specified in the agenda and confirmed in the transcript. The transcript includes a long segment after closed session that appears to be from a different event (fire department, art commission, Juneteenth celebration) and is not part of the Police Commission meeting.

AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY 20% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 16% · PUBLIC SAFETY 15%
1135
JUN 28, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - June 28, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on June 28, 2022, at 9:45 AM in San Francisco City Hall Room 400. The meeting included the adoption of hybrid meeting protocols, approval of minutes with a spelling correction, retirement recognitions for two long-serving employees, an update from the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) on drought conditions, a detailed drought update from staff, approval of several real estate easements and large construction contracts, and a public hearing on a temporary ban on irrigation of non-functional turf. The commission also entered closed session to discuss existing litigation and reported no action taken. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Renewed Hybrid Meeting Findings (Item 3): Unanimously approved (4-0) a resolution to continue hybrid in-person meetings under state urgency legislation, directing the secretary to agendize a similar resolution within 30 days. - Approval of Minutes (Item 4): Unanimously approved (4-0) the minutes of June 14, 2022, with a correction to the spelling of a public commenter's first name (from "Aleta" to "Aleta"). - Consent Calendar (Item 11): Unanimously approved (4-0) the consent calendar as presented. Public Comments & Testimony - Alita Dupree urged the commission to prioritize basic water and electricity services for San Francisco residents and noted a broken link in the municipal benchmarking report. - Kevin Delano (commercial raft guide and geologist, speaking as an individual) advocated for legally binding recreational whitewater releases on the Tuolumne River, citing significant economic, recreational, and educational value. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) accused SFPUC staff of being disingenuous about the long-term vulnerability assessment, claiming that key staff are leaving because they were forced to keep quiet on findings showing that instream flow requirements, a 15% demand increase, and a 15% precipitation decrease are equivalent in impact. - Dave Warner (Palo Alto, Tuolumne River Trust) presented analysis indicating a 95% probability that the design drought (at 23% above current demand) has a return period of once in 3,000 years, arguing no justification exists to plan for such a rare event. - David Pilpel (recurring commenter) requested that maps and photos be included as standard attachments in staff reports where appropriate. - Francisco DeCosta criticized the commission for insufficient water releases for salmon, accusing them of ignoring empirical data and wasting water. - Mark Musgrove (whitewater kayaker) attempted to comment on water releases but was redirected as it was not the relevant agenda item. Discussion Items Retirement Recognitions (Item 7) The commission honored two retiring employees with resolutions and tributes: - Alan Joha (Acting Assistant General Manager of Infrastructure, nearly 30 years of service) – Recognized for his leadership on the $4.8 billion Water System Improvement Program and a record of millions of hours without major injury. Public comments praised his professionalism and good humor. - Michael Carlin (Deputy General Manager, nearly 26 years of service) – A certificate of commendation from Senator Dianne Feinstein was presented. Carlin spoke briefly, thanking colleagues. Commissioners, former General Manager Ed Harrington, and BAWSCA CEO Nicole Sandkulla praised his integrity, mentorship, relationship-building, and quiet leadership. A caller from Restore Hetch Hetchy acknowledged him as a respectful adversary. BAWSCA Update (Item 8) Nicole Sandkulla (CEO, BAWSCA) reported on drought impacts across the 26 member agencies. Key points: - Agencies strongly support demand reduction, but alternative supplies are constrained. For example, Alameda County Water District (ACWD) received only a 5% State Water Project allocation (normally 50%) and faces PFOS contamination in its groundwater requiring blending, leading to increased SFPUC purchases. - April 2022 total potable use was 3% lower than April 2015, but SFPUC deliveries were higher, partly because large agencies with alternative supply constraints are buying more water. - She committed to a detailed analysis to help distinguish conservation progress from increased reliance on SFPUC supply. - Commissioner Jamy asked about tracking recycled water projects; Sandkulla said a white paper would be provided. Drought Conditions Update (Item 9a) Steve Ritchie (Assistant General Manager for Water) presented an update. Key points: - Storage: Hetch Hetchy Reservoir is full; Cherry Reservoir is nearly full. The Water Bank is down about 230,000 acre-feet. Overall system storage is at 93% (excluding Water Bank). - Statewide Context: Shasta and Oroville reservoirs are very low. SFPUC reservoirs are relatively full due to system design and October storms that added about 200,000 acre-feet, buying another year of time. - Power Generation: Generation varies due to water availability and curtailment risks. He showed a slide projecting that if curtailment risks persist, generation from the Holm powerhouse could be reduced by about 50 GWh. - Deliveries: After trending upward, the most recent report showed a slight dip. He noted that agencies like ACWD are reducing overall demand but need more SFPUC water due to alternative supply constraints, which may affect the perceived conservation numbers. - PFOS Contamination: Explained that PFOS are ubiquitous, persistent organic chemicals. SFPUC has not found them in its supply. ACWD is blending to manage PFOS while working on permanent treatment. Real Estate Easements (Items 12 & 13) Approved two real estate agreements for the groundwater project: - Item 12: Purchased two small easements (179 sq ft for $7,500 plus $5,000 in lieu of independent appraisal; 1.7 sq ft for $1,000) and granted a 300 sq ft easement to PG&E at no cost for electrical service to a water sampling station. (Vote: 4-0) - Item 13: Purchased a 14,619 sq ft permanent easement and a temporary construction easement from BART for $306,000 to provide access to the Treasure Island Trailer Court Well and Treatment Facility. (Vote: 4-0) Biosolids Digester Facilities Project – Contract Amendments (Items 14 & 15) Approved amendments to two contracts for the Southeast Plant Biosolids Digester Facilities: - Item 14 (Construction): Amendment No. 5 to Contract WW-647R increased the amount by $498,103,597 (total now $1,781,787,283) and extended duration by 621 days (total 3,848 days). The increase reflects construction cost escalation, market conditions, and the added complexity of a phased bidding strategy after a pause in 2021. (Vote: 4-0) - Item 15 (Design): Amendment No. 2 to Contract CS-235 with Brown and Caldwell increased the amount by $55 million (total $208.5 million) and extended duration by 3.5 years to July 2029 to ensure engineering support through construction and commissioning. (Vote: 4-0) - Commissioners discussed lessons learned, risk allocation, and the need for better project assessment and data tracking to avoid future cost escalations. City Distribution Division Campus – Contract Award (Item 16) Approved award of Contract WD-2879R to Clark Construction Group as CM/GC for the new campus at 2000 Marin Street, total amount $260,450,682, duration 2,464 days (7 years). The contract is a not-to-exceed amount for pre-construction and construction services. Clark’s team includes 60% people of color and women, and the company’s Strategic Partnership Program has graduated over 1,250 small businesses, including 61 from San Francisco. (Vote: 4-0) - Commissioner Jamy noted the three bids were close, lending confidence. Commissioner Paulson asked about the SPP program, which was explained as a program for subcontractors, not individuals. Temporary Ban on Non-Functional Turf Irrigation (Item 17) After a public hearing, approved a temporary mandatory prohibition on irrigation of non-functional turf at commercial, industrial, and institutional (CII) sites. The prohibition takes effect immediately and will remain in place until the State Water Board acts or the SFPUC lifts it. Staff stated that parks and sports fields are functional and not targeted. (Vote: 4-0) Transmission Line 7/8 Upgrades – Contract Award (Item 18) Approved plans, specifications, and award of Contract HH-1007 to Wilson Utility Construction Company for reconductoring and upgrading 12.5 miles of transmission lines, amount $23,980,141, duration 668 days. The project resolves 18 hard clearance safety issues and mitigates grid reliability impacts from renewable energy interconnection. Developers are funding the project ($33.3 million total; 85% under agreement). (Vote: 4-0) - Commissioner Paulson raised concerns about the contractor’s track record on training and wage compliance based on correspondence from a fair contracting organization. Walt Posey (Wilson Safety and Training Director) responded that Wilson is an IBEW signatory with a 70-year history, participates in joint apprenticeship programs, has three training facilities, and will sign the project labor agreement. He also noted the bid was independently evaluated and deemed reasonable. Key Outcomes - All votes on items 3, 4, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, and 18 passed unanimously (4-0). - Closed session (Item 21) on litigation (Drummer v. SFPUC) resulted in no action. The commission voted not to disclose discussions (Item 23). - Staff directed to: correct the municipal benchmarking report link; provide a white paper on recycled water projects; continue analysis of alternative supply constraints with BAWSCA; and improve project assessment and data tracking for lessons learned. - The next meeting will include a similar resolution on hybrid meetings within 30 days as required by the adopted findings.

PROCEDURAL 25% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 10%
1136
JUN 27, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - June 27, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, June 27, 2022, starting at 6:15 PM and concluding early on June 28. The committee considered the city's proposed budget for fiscal years 2022-2023 and 2023-2024, along with several related items. The meeting featured a presentation on the cost of a proposed 70-unit cabin project for people experiencing homelessness in the Mission District, and the committee ultimately approved amendments and forwarded the main budget ordinances to the full Board. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comment was taken on Items 1 and 2 (budget and salary ordinances), as public comment had already been held on June 24, 2022. For Items 3, 4, and 5, public comment was opened but no speakers from the public came forward, either in person or by phone. Discussion Items - HSH Cabin Project Estimate: Emily Cohen, Deputy Director of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), presented the cost estimate for a new non-congregate shelter program of 70 cabins in the Mission. The proposed budget included $7 million in one-time capital funds. Two capital scenarios ranged from $5.8 million to $7.4 million, covering construction, possible demolition, and soft costs (design, project management). Each cabin was estimated at roughly $70,000. Operational costs were estimated at $200 per unit per night, including 24/7 staffing, meals, case management, and supplies. In response to questions from Chair Ronan, Ms. Cohen explained that shelter costs are higher than permanent housing on a per-night basis because shelter beds serve multiple people over a year and require more staffing. Chair Ronan expressed support for the project, noting the importance of publicly explaining the high cost. - Technical Adjustments: The budget director, Ms. Graffenberger, indicated that a series of technical adjustments would be emailed to committee members and the clerk. - Final Motions and Votes: After several recesses and late-night deliberations, the committee returned to vote on all agenda items. Consent Calendar - There were no separate consent calendar items; all items were considered individually. Key Outcomes - Items 1 and 2 (Budget and Appropriation Ordinance & Annual Salary Ordinance): Chair Ronan moved to amend the ordinances to reflect the committee's final changes (as outlined in the "Board of Supervisors Budget Spending Plan"), authorize the controller to make necessary adjustments, and forward the items to the full Board of Supervisors for the July 12, 2022 meeting with a positive recommendation. The motion was seconded by President Walton and passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 3 (Appropriation from Fiscal Cliff Reserve for Rent Relief): The committee voted to amend the item per the "Board of Supervisors Budget Spending Plan Housing COPs" and continue it to the July 13, 2022 committee meeting. The amendment included $20 million for site acquisition in higher resource areas, $20 million for affordable housing in District 5, $20 million for public housing repairs, $12 million for educator housing, $10 million for SRO elevator repairs, and $30 million for API community stabilization projects. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 4 (Francisco Park Conservancy Agreement Amendment): The committee voted to continue this item to the call of the chair (no further date set). Motion passed unanimously (5-0). - Item 5 (Certificates of Participation - up to $140 million): The committee voted to forward this ordinance to the full Board on July 12 with a positive recommendation. Motion passed unanimously (5-0). The meeting was adjourned shortly after 1:00 AM on June 28, 2022.

COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 14% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 13% · AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY 10% · LGBTQ+ HISTORY 8%
1137
JUN 24, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Public Hearing on FY 2022-2024 Budget - June 24, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee convened on June 24, 2022, to hear public testimony on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2022-2023 and 2023-2024. The meeting, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen (absent at final vote, Vice Chair Asha Safai presiding), was held in a hybrid format with in-person and remote participation. Over 150 speakers testified, representing diverse communities and coalitions, advocating for funding priorities ranging from affordable housing and food security to immigrant legal services and alternatives to policing. The committee did not debate or vote on the budget; the entire meeting was reserved for public comment. The meeting recessed to forward unfinished items to the June 27, 2022 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony Immigrant and Worker Rights - Multiple speakers, including members of the San Francisco Immigrant Legal Defense Collaborative (SFILDC) and the Immigrant Parent Voting Collaborative (IPVC), urged continued funding for legal representation and civic engagement. The IPVC reported reaching 131,000 people through materials and conducting 282 educational events. Advocates stressed that additional $250,000 for IPVC and $627,000 for SFILDC are needed to sustain services for vulnerable immigrant communities. - Workers' rights organizations called for increased funding for outreach and enforcement, noting that many low-wage workers experience wage theft and lack paid sick leave. The Chinese Progressive Association and others requested resources for the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement. Housing and Homelessness - The Women's Housing Coalition and Community Forward SF requested relocation funding for the only low-barrier 24-hour drop-in center for unhoused women, serving 3,000 women annually. They noted that 35% of homeless population are women and that women are 106 times more likely to be assaulted in co-ed shelters. - Supporters of Cameo House, an alternative sentencing program for justice-involved women with children, urged full funding, highlighting that it serves 11 women and 24 children and prevents homelessness and incarceration. - The SRO Families United Collaborative called for $8.5 million for rental subsidies and $1.5 million for paid job training. Numerous SRO residents testified about overcrowding, lack of space for children, and unsafe conditions. - The HESPA coalition requested hotel vouchers, subsidies for families fleeing domestic violence, and wage equity for frontline workers. They noted that 40% of homeless women experience sexual assault. Community Health and COVID Response - The Latino Task Force and Latinx Equity Coalition asked for restoration of funding for COVID testing and vaccination hubs, food distribution, and employment services. One speaker noted that their hub had vaccinated over 50,000 people and distributed 13,000 pounds of food weekly. Others highlighted that the Latinx community accounted for 80% of COVID cases in 2020. - The Budget Justice Coalition opposed cuts to the Human Services Agency's community food coordination grants, which support 70,000 households. - Supporters of CART (Compassionate Alternative Response Team) urged the board to fund and implement the program as a non-police response to homelessness and mental health crises, noting that $3 million was allocated last year but not yet deployed. Policing and Public Safety - Several speakers, including the Hotel Council of San Francisco and individual residents, supported full funding for SFPD, citing a voter survey where 79% of voters said police presence makes them feel safer and 78% support increasing officer numbers. - Conversely, many activists and community groups opposed the proposed $50 million increase for police, arguing the money should be redirected to housing, mental health services, and CART. They cited police violence and racial disparities in homelessness (38% of unhoused are Black while city is less than 3% Black). Child Care and Education - Parent Voices and the Early Care and Education Advocacy Coalition called for protecting Prop C funds for child care, noting 3,000 children on waitlists and that 25% of children experience food insecurity. They asked for $8 million in additional child care investments and opposed using Prop C funds for family resource centers without sustainable alternatives. - The Family Resource Center Alliance requested $7 million over two years for FRCs but urged finding a source other than Prop C. Senior and Disability Services - Senior and Disability Action requested $4 million for operating subsidies, $10 million for portable rental subsidies, $10 million for SRO elevator repairs, $200,000 for wheelchair repair, and $3.5 million for digital inclusion. Speakers described seniors isolated by broken elevators and unable to access medical care. Public Library Safety - Library workers from multiple branches requested funding for 8207 building and grounds patrol officers at all branches, citing an increase in violent incidents (31 level-one violations since January 2022) and the need for trained de-escalation professionals. Climate and Environment - The San Francisco Climate Emergency Coalition and others urged funding for the Department of Environment's climate action plan, warning that delays will increase costs and exacerbate other crises. Arts and Culture - Organizations such as the Chinese Culture Center (CHAT program), Asian Pacific Islander Cultural Center, and First Voice requested funding for arts education and cultural festivals, emphasizing their role in community identity and economic recovery. Public Defender Funding - Attorneys and staff from the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office called for additional funding to hire more attorneys, social workers, and support staff to manage ballooning caseloads due to pandemic backlogs. They noted that the PD's budget is half that of the DA's office and 15 times less than SFPD. Key Outcomes - The committee took no votes on the budget items. - A motion by Supervisor Walton, seconded by Supervisor Chan, to forward the remaining unfinished agenda items (the budget ordinances and other legislation) to the June 27, 2022 meeting was approved 4-0 (Supervisor Ronen absent). - The meeting recessed to reconvene on Monday, June 27, 2022. - Public comment was closed after extensive testimony; the committee will consider the input during budget deliberations.

PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · PUBLIC SAFETY 8%
1138
JUN 23, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - June 23, 2022

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronin, met on June 23, 2022, to review the Mayor's proposed FY2022-2023 and FY2023-2024 budgets. The committee heard from Budget and Legislative Analysts (BLA) and department heads, approving most departmental budgets with BLA-recommended adjustments. Key debates centered on funding for affordable housing (Prop I), the Tenderloin recovery, alternative street response, park rangers, District Attorney's victim services, and the Police Department's budget. The committee voted to amend and continue the Prop I appropriation, and recessed the Police budget for further negotiation, with a final decision expected on June 27, 2022. Consent Calendar - Adult Probation Department: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $646,010 in FY2022-23 and $138,924 in FY2023-24. - Superior Court: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $100,000 each fiscal year. - Human Rights Commission: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $194,846 in FY2022-23 and $250,527 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $410,000 each fiscal year, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Department of Early Care and Education: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $260,352 in FY2022-23 and $116,352 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Department of Human Resources: Accepted BLA technical recommendations, with reductions of $896,431 in FY2022-23 and $3,765,353 in FY2023-24, but retained three positions (two in government operations recovery initiative, one in external affairs) as agreed. - Department on the Status of Women: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $155,576 in FY2022-23 and $55,576 in FY2023-24. - Asian Art Museum: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $55,644 in FY2022-23 and $59,767 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Fine Arts Museums: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $124,457 in FY2022-23 and $122,964 in FY2023-24. - Arts Commission: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $166,138 in FY2022-23 and $5,000 in FY2023-24. - War Memorial: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $348,698 in FY2022-23 and $203,543 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Fire Department: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $411,040 in FY2022-23 and $241,059 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures; a pending issue on position authority for the stress unit will be addressed on June 27. - Sheriff's Department: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $787,052 in FY2022-23 and $38,660 in FY2023-24, plus prior year encumbrance closures. - Sheriff's Department of Accountability: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $454,810 in FY2022-23 (one-time) and no reductions in FY2023-24. - Department of Police Accountability: Accepted BLA recommendations, with reductions of $30,000 each fiscal year. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were received on the items discussed during this meeting. Public comment on the annual appropriation and salary ordinances was scheduled for June 24, 2022. Public comment was taken on the continuance of the Francisco Park Conservancy resolution, but no speakers were present. Discussion Items - File 211194 – Prop I Affordable Housing Funding: Supervisor Preston proposed amendments to the appropriation ordinance to fund the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board recommendations through long-term debt financing (COPs) totaling $122 million. The amendments included $60 million for land acquisition, $20 million for non-licit social housing, $20 million for public housing life safety, $12 million for educator housing, and $10 million for SRO elevator upgrades. The committee voted unanimously to adopt the amendments and continue the item to June 29, 2022. - Planning Department: Disagreed with BLA policy recommendation to place $4.2 million for Tenderloin community grants on reserve. The department argued the funds were for planned improvements and coordination. Supervisors Walton and Chan expressed concern about equity and lack of detail. The committee accepted BLA technical adjustments but continued discussion on the policy item, requesting a detailed plan. - Department of Emergency Management: Disagreed with BLA policy recommendation to cut $3 million for the CART alternative street response pilot. Chair Ronin reaffirmed commitment to CART's three core aspects. The committee accepted BLA technical recommendations but rejected the policy cut, keeping the $3 million. - Recreation and Park Department: Disagreed with BLA policy recommendation to reduce new park ranger positions from 10 to 5. The department presented a counterproposal with attrition savings. Supervisors debated need vs. other city investments. The committee accepted BLA technical recommendations and continued policy discussion. - District Attorney's Office: Disagreed with BLA policy recommendations related to victim services (Recommendation 8) and vacant positions (Recommendations 9-11). The DA's office argued that cuts would disrupt services to 8,000 victims annually and that attrition rates should account for expected turnover. Chair Ronin expressed intent to cut the victim services program but the committee continued discussion on specific positions and attrition rates. - Public Defender's Office: Disagreed with BLA recommendation to downgrade a confidential secretary position (0922) to a lower classification. The committee accepted the other two BLA recommendations but rejected the downgrade to avoid reducing the current employee's salary. - Police Department: Disagreed with all four BLA recommendations: increasing sworn attrition, reducing two of five analyst positions, deferring $1.5 million for records management system, and deferring facility master planning. Chief Scott argued cuts would harm operations given a 349 officer deficit. Supervisor Walton proposed reducing overtime by 25% and placing four academies (two on reserve) rather than the proposed eight over two years. Chair Ronin expressed frustration that SFPD was the only department not agreeing to any cuts. The committee recessed the item to allow the department to renegotiate with BLA, with final action expected June 27. Key Outcomes - File 211194 (Prop I appropriation) was amended and continued to June 29, 2022. - File 220693 (Francisco Park Conservancy resolution) was continued to the call of the chair. - Most departmental budgets were approved with BLA technical recommendations. - The Police Department budget was recessed for further negotiation; the committee will consider additional cuts (overtime and academies) on June 27. - The committee rescinded earlier votes on Files 211194 and 220693 to re-hear them at a later date.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 49% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 16% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 8% · PUBLIC SAFETY 8%
1139
JUN 22, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting – June 22, 2022

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hilary Ronen, met on June 22, 2022, to consider a lengthy agenda centered on the Mayor’s proposed budget for fiscal years 2022‑2023 and 2023‑2024. The committee heard presentations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) and department heads, accepted most agreed‑upon technical reductions, and debated policy recommendations for several departments. Key votes included forwarding routine items to the full board and continuing certain controversial items for further discussion. The meeting was recessed to June 23 and June 27 for unfinished business. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Racial Equity Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Item 2 (Fiscal Cliff Reserve – Rent Relief): Initially continued to June 23; later a motion to rescind that vote passed unanimously, and it was placed on the June 23 recessed agenda. - Items 3 & 4 (Outreach & Official Advertising): Amended to add Sing Tao Daily; forwarded to the July 12 full board meeting with positive recommendation (5–0). - Item 5 (Dignity Fund Community Needs Assessment): Approved and forwarded to July 12 full board (5–0). - Items 6 & 7 (Administrative Provisions Hearings): Heard and filed (5–0). - Item 10 (Proposition J Contract Certification): Forwarded to July 12 full board (5–0). - Item 11 (Graffiti Clean‑up Fund Ceiling): Forwarded to July 12 full board (5–0). - Item 12 (Access Line Tax CPI Adjustment): Forwarded to July 12 full board (5–0). - Item 13 (Certificates of Participation – up to $140M): Continued to June 27 recessed meeting. - Item 14 (BLA Contract Amendment): Forwarded to July 12 full board (5–0). Public Comments & Testimony - David Pilpel spoke on several items, supporting BLA recommendations and suggesting the addition of Richmond Review/Sunset Beacon as outreach newspapers and noting the importance of administrative provisions. - Paul Ruhlbeck (San Francisco Examiner) testified on Item 4, emphasizing the Examiner’s local printing and 50 jobs, and requesting continued designation as the official newspaper. Discussion Items - Racial Equity Hearing (Item 1): President Walton thanked the BLA for a report on disparities in city hiring and promotions. The hearing was continued to after the budget process to allow full attention. - Outreach Advertising (Items 3‑4): Supervisor Chan moved to add Sing Tao Daily, citing its reach in Chinese‑speaking communities. The amendment passed unanimously. - Dignity Fund Needs Assessment (Item 5): Director Dearman presented findings showing one‑in‑five older adults served, with strengths in serving low‑income populations. Supervisors praised the work and noted the importance of cross‑departmental coordination on housing and technology access. - Administrative Provisions (Items 6‑7): BLA recommended amending the AAO to reflect the new Department of Sanitation and Streets and amending the ASO to require controller certification for temporary‑to‑permanent conversions in subsequent years. The mayor’s budget office agreed. Supervisor Safai raised the possibility of adding a provision to track board‑phase funding; the controller said discussions are ongoing. - Budget Discussion (Items 8‑9): The committee reviewed budgets for over a dozen departments. Most departments reached agreement with the BLA and had their budgets accepted with technical reductions. Notable disagreements and policy decisions included: - Juvenile Probation: BLA recommended cutting two counselor positions. Chief Miller demonstrated that overtime hours increased 167% over two years and that cuts would harm programming and staff. Chair Ronen and President Walton supported retaining the positions, rejecting the policy recommendation, citing the department’s transparency and increased state duties. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing: Technical reductions accepted. A policy recommendation to cut $2M for a Mission district cabin site was deferred to Monday after Director McSpadden could not provide a detailed budget. The committee also noted the department’s $12M wage enhancement plan may need an additional $4.5M to reach desired pay levels. - Public Works: Technical cuts accepted. Policy recommendation to reduce the sidewalk and street enforcement initiative (shared spaces and illegal vending) by 0.79 senior inspector and 0.79 analyst was deferred to Monday. Director Short argued the staffing is needed; supervisors were skeptical about the need for the analyst position given community‑based partner efforts. - Sanitation and Streets: Technical cuts accepted. Policy recommendation to reduce the Tenderloin enhanced cleaning initiative (five to three trucks, two to one steamer, seven to five laborers) was rejected by the committee. Several supervisors stated the Tenderloin requires full investment and that resources were being drawn from other neighborhoods. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): The committee did not accept several BLA recommendations. Disagreements centered on a proposed $4.5M reduction to the mid‑market/Tenderloin ambassador program (the department said it would lay off 50 from the current 250 ambassadors), a $1M cut to small business grant programs, and a $6M economic core recovery program lacking a detailed plan. Chair Ronen expressed frustration over conflicting ambassador headcount numbers and noted the budget had more than doubled in five years. The committee directed OEWD to provide detailed plans for small business grants, ambassador deployment, and economic core programming by Monday. Key Outcomes - Votes on continuances and forwarding: All consent items were forwarded to the July 12 full board or continued (Item 13 to June 27). - Department budgets: Most accepted with BLA technical recommendations. Policy recommendations for Juvenile Probation (rejected), Public Works (deferred), Sanitation and Streets (rejected), and OEWD (not accepted, further discussions ordered). - Positions retained: The committee allowed three departments (City Attorney, City Administrator, DHR) to retain position authority for government operations recovery positions, accepting salary savings but not eliminating the positions. - Future meetings: The committee recessed to June 23 at 10 a.m. to consider unfinished items (Item 2, Items 8‑9, Item 15) and to June 27 for Item 13.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 35% · PROCEDURAL 14% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 12% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 7%
1140
JUN 17, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Hears Department Budgets on June 17, 2022

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronan, held a full-day hearing on the Mayor's proposed FY 2022-2023 and FY 2023-2024 budgets. The committee reviewed budgets for multiple public safety and justice departments, heard public testimony, and voted on several items. Chair Ronan noted an unprecedented $1.3 billion in ad-back requests, reflecting deep poverty in the city. The meeting included presentations from Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, the Superior Court, the Police Department, the Department of Police Accountability, the Public Defender, the District Attorney's Office, the Sheriff's Department, and the Fire Department. Public Comment - David Pilpel (public commenter) supported the Deputy Fire Chiefs ordinance (Item 4) and urged civilianization of non‑sworn positions. He also supported the motion to continue Items 1 and 2. - One caller commented on the police vehicle theft surcharge (Item 3), stating no opposition. - Public comment was also taken on the motion to continue the budget to June 22. Discussion Items 1. Juvenile Probation (Chief Katie Miller) - Proposed budget of $36.5 million (FY23) – an increase primarily due to state funding from the closure of state youth prisons (DJJ). - Vacancies reduced to 30 (lowest in 4 years); 37 FTEs eliminated since FY 2018-19. - New responsibilities include housing young adults with long‑term commitments and developing a new facility design (requested $500,000 for design consultant). - $9.9 million increase over current year; most state funds passed to DCYF for community-based services. - Supervisor Walton asked about the transition plan for closing Juvenile Hall; Chief Miller confirmed operations continue with new state mandates. 2. Adult Probation (Chief Christel Tuac) - Proposed FY23 budget of $53.9 million, FY24 $50.7 million. - Major priorities: workforce support, preserving community partner investments, strategic racial equity plan. - 23 vacancies (14.8% vacancy rate). - TRP therapeutic community program (abstinence‑based) is one‑time funded for FY23; Mayor's budget director indicated future funding depends on effectiveness. - Supervisor Safai raised concerns about ongoing funding for programs like TRP and the Mina Project. 3. Superior Court (Executive Officer Mike U) - City funds two programs: Civil Grand Jury ($250,000) and Indigent Defense Administration (IDA) ($10.1 million). - IDA covers conflict representation for defendants when Public Defender has a conflict. - President Walton questioned the court's stance on trial delays; Mr. U cited active litigation and could not comment on a specific hearing. - Supervisor Safai expressed frustration at the court's lack of collaboration on public safety issues. 4. Police Department (Chief Bill Scott) - Proposed budget increase of $52.5 million (to $782 million). - 486 sworn vacancies; response times have increased (A-priority calls now 9 min, C-priority 99 min). - Attrition: 121 officers left since 2020; 68 lateraled to other agencies. - Budget enhancements include recruitment firm, technology, 27 new hybrid vehicles, and $26.8 million in overtime (aligned from vacancy savings). - Supervisor Walton questioned deployment priorities, arguing officers are pulled from high‑homicide districts for property crime and the Tenderloin crisis, while human life should be paramount. - Supervisor Safai emphasized the need for more officers to meet public safety demands and foot patrols. - Supervisor Chan asked about diversity metrics and civilianization; Chief Scott noted 70% of recent recruits are people of color. - Supervisor Preston proposed placing $50 million on reserve pending measurable progress on racial disparities and transparency (SB 1421 compliance). 5. Department of Police Accountability (Director Henderson) - Budget increase of $432,181; one new legal position added. - 700+ independent investigations annually; training budget increased from $4,000 to $20,000. - Hiring challenges due to police department background delays; Director urged direct access to body‑worn camera footage. - 775 allegations handled; no missed 3304 deadlines under his leadership. 6. Public Defender (Manohar Raju) - Budget of about $58 million (58% of DA's budget). - 92% of budget is salary; no new general fund positions – only grant‑funded for Clean Slate and Post‑Conviction Unit. - Vacancies: 14 positions (0 attorney vacancies; all recent). - Emphasized holistic defense model (warrior, counselor, activist) and work on racial justice, cash bail reform, and the Freedom Project. - Chair Ronan shared a story of a neighborhood crisis resolved by Public Defender and Pretrial Diversion. 7. District Attorney's Office (Chief Assistant Marshall Kine) - Proposed budget increase of 4.1% ($3.62 FTE annualization). - 130 attorneys handle 6,000 active cases; 30 victim advocates serve 8,000 victims annually. - 14% attrition rate due to leadership transition; most vacancies filled quickly (exempt positions). - Supervisor Chan noted Prop D (victim services office) may create redundancies. 8. Sheriff's Department (Sheriff Paul Miyamoto) - 176 sworn vacancies; overtime is 25% of total work hours (goal: 10%). - Hiring plan: 75 new hires per year (academy classes of 20 + lateral hires). - Criminal justice reforms include free phone calls, commissary reductions, and a pilot to provide devices to incarcerated individuals. - Cameo House transitional housing for women and children was cut from budget; Sheriff supports its restoration. - No expansion of County Jail 6; a planned annex is for COVID‑related surge capacity. 9. Fire Department (Chief Janine Nicholson) - Budget increase reflects structural adjustments and new positions: 125 new positions in FY23 (including 60 EMS from prior add‑backs). - Two new firefighter academies per year; no recruitment challenges. - Mental Health Network (MHN) program funded to support all public safety employees; additional captain position requested for behavioral health unit. - Item 4 (administrative code amendment to allow three deputy chiefs, including one for EMS) was presented and supported. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Police Vehicle Theft Crime Fund Surcharge) was amended and forwarded to the full Board on July 12, 2022, with a positive recommendation (unanimous vote). - Item 4 (Deputy Fire Chiefs ordinance) was forwarded to the full Board on July 12, 2022, with a positive recommendation (unanimous vote). - Items 1 and 2 (Budget and Salary Ordinances) were continued to the June 22, 2022 Budget and Appropriations Committee meeting (unanimous vote). - The committee heard all department presentations; public comment was taken on each item. No votes were taken on department budgets themselves; they will be reviewed further with Budget and Legislative Analyst recommendations.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · PROCEDURAL 13% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com