Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1121–1130 ENTRIES
1121
SEP 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - September 13, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on September 13, 2022, at City Hall, Room 400. The meeting began at 9:45 AM and covered a wide range of items including drought updates, energy planning, capital projects, and public comments on the design drought and Tuolumne River flows. The Commission approved all consent calendar items and all regular calendar items unanimously. Consent Calendar - Item 9a: Approved attestation of veracity for CleanPowerSF’s 2021 Power Source Disclosure Reports. - Item 9b: Approved attestation for Hetch Hetchy Power’s 2021 Power Source Disclosure Reports. - Item 9c: Approved Amendment No.2 to Contract No.CS-388 for river ecosystem science support services with McBain Associates. - Item 9d: Approved an increase of 267 calendar days for as-needed water main replacement with Hernandez Engineering. - Item 9e: Approved an increase of $2,600,000 and 252 calendar days for the Alameda Creek Recapture Project. - Item 9f: Approved plans and award for Oceanside Water Pollution Control Plant slide gate system improvements. - Item 9g: Approved terms of a Facilities Easement Deed for 432-440 Natoma Street. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Eleven callers provided comments. Many speakers expressed strong disappointment with the SFPUC’s design drought, calling it arbitrary and overly conservative. Speakers urged the Commission to adopt a shorter design drought (e.g., 7.5 years) to release more water for the Tuolumne River. Speakers included representatives from the Sierra Club, Tuolumne River Trust, Golden State Salmon Association, and individual residents. They argued that the design drought ignores best available science and that demand forecasts are inflated. Some speakers also criticized the SFPUC’s pursuit of voluntary agreements instead of minimum flow standards. - Item 6 (Communications): Public comments included criticism of the August 23 meeting’s handling of public comment time and a request for more transparency. One speaker noted that the demand projections in the Urban Water Management Plan are not realistic and that staff overproject demand. - Item 7a (Drought Update): Public comments on the drought update reiterated concerns about the design drought and the SFPUC’s water storage. Speakers noted that Hetch Hetchy was at 83% capacity and that the agency had captured more water than demand in the past year. - Item 7b (CleanPowerSF IRP): One speaker thanked staff for their work on the integrated resource plan. - Item 7e (Voluntary Agreements): Two speakers opposed the voluntary agreements, calling them unenforceable and lacking public input. They urged the SFPUC to drop the lawsuit and support the Bay Delta Water Quality Control Plan. - Item 10 (COVID-19 Relief): One speaker requested restoration of in-person customer service hours and improvements to online payment receipts, noting minor wording corrections in the resolution. - Item 11 (Public Health Goal Report): One speaker claimed the presentation was misleading and urged the Commission to consider biomonitoring data. - Item 12 (Surplus Property): No public comments. - Item 13 (Google Soil Fill Agreement): One speaker supported the staff recommendation but suggested Google should also cover all staff costs; another speaker criticized the Commission for prioritizing money over community health. - Item 14 (Kennedy/Jenks Contract): No public comments. - Item 15 (Rescind Contract): No public comments. - Item 16 (Southeast Plant HVAC): No public comments. Discussion Items - Item 3: Adopted renewed findings for hybrid in-person meetings during the COVID-19 emergency, extending through June 30, 2023. Passed unanimously. - Item 4: Approved minutes of August 23, 2022, with corrections (Commissioner Moran noted his comment about “return period” was clarified). - Item 7a: Drought Conditions Update – Steve Ritchie reported that Hetch Hetchy reservoir was at 83% capacity (normal 86%), water bank at 44%. Demand reduction was about 9% year-to-date, short of the 11% target. Staff noted that four wholesale customers (Woodside, Atherton, Los Altos Hills, Hillsborough) drive peak demand. The Commission discussed the need for stricter outdoor irrigation measures in future dry years. - Item 7b: CleanPowerSF Integrated Resource Plan Update – Cheryl Taylor presented initial modeling results. The base case portfolio requires nearly 2,000 MW of capacity by 2035, including 300 MW new solar, 60 MW geothermal, and 150 MW storage. Community engagement included outreach to 600+ organizations. Staff will return in October for approval of the preferred portfolio. Commissioners discussed rooftop solar, leasing roofs, and microgrids. - Item 7c: Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program Quarterly Report – Katie Miller reported 29% overall completion ($175M spent). Major projects include Mountain Tunnel improvements, Moccasin Powerhouse transformer, and San Joaquin Pipeline valve upgrades. - Item 7d: Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report – Stephen Robinson reported 52% completion of the Sewer System Improvement Program ($3.65B phase). Key milestones: Mariposa pump station nearing completion, microtunneling finished on Wahconah stormwater project, and biosolids digester construction underway. The Commission discussed the August 2022 algae bloom in the Bay and potential treatment options. - Item 7e: Report on MOU for Voluntary Agreements – General Manager Dennis Herrera reported that negotiations with the state and irrigation districts are ongoing but no document has been finalized. Commissioner Ajami emphasized the need for strong monitoring and performance measures. - Item 7f: Report on Recent SFPUC Activities – No discussion. - Item 8: New Commission Business – Commissioner Maxwell requested a future report on algae bloom solutions. - Item 10: Authorized extension of COVID-19 relief moratorium through June 30, 2023, for residential water, wastewater, and power shutoffs. Also allowed the General Manager to resume collections for multifamily accounts with unpaid bills over $25,000 (90+ days past due). Staff will develop arrearage management strategies. - Item 11: Public Health Goal Report – Staff presented the 2022 triennial report. No contaminants exceeded regulatory limits, but three (bromate, coliform, lead) exceeded public health goals. The Commission discussed lead service line replacement, school testing, and coordination with the public health department. - Item 12: Declared surplus property in Fremont and unincorporated Alameda County for Caltrans safety improvements, authorizing sale for $11,970. - Item 13: Approved a soil fill agreement with Google LLC for work near a 45-foot-wide easement containing two pipelines. Google will pay $190,000 as compensation for future shoring costs. The Commission discussed the adequacy of the payment and long-term access. - Item 14: Approved Amendment No.6 to contract with Kennedy/Jenks Consultants, extending the contract by four years and two months (no cost increase) to support groundwater projects. - Item 15: Rescinded Resolution No. 22-0039 and terminated the design services agreement with Mark Cavagnero Associates for the CDD campus due to RFP issues (only one responsive proposal and a conflict of interest). - Item 16: Approved plans and award of $12,947,014 for the Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant HVAC and mechanical upgrades, with a 990-day duration. Key Outcomes - All consent calendar items (9a-9g) were adopted unanimously (4-0). - All regular calendar items (10-16) were approved unanimously (4-0). - Closed Session: The Commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and approved settlements for two litigation cases: (1) John LaSalle personal injury claim for $489,000, and (2) Jeanette Hudson EEO discrimination complaint for $275,000. The Commission voted not to disclose discussions. - The Commission directed staff to provide a report on algae bloom mitigation options by October 2022. - Commissioner Paulson requested a future field tour of capital projects, possibly including the Mountain Tunnel. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 22% · PROCEDURAL 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 8%
1122
SEP 7, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting: September 7, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on September 7, 2022, at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting covered crime trends, racial disparities in policing, the status of departmental general orders (DGOs), the implementation of Article 25 on private security, and quarterly data reports. Commissioners heard public testimony on quality-of-life issues, anti-blackness, pretext stops, and traffic enforcement. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously adopted the minutes from the July 6, 13, and 20, 2022, meetings. - The consent calendar (including audit of electronic communication devices, SFPD/DPA document protocol report, and acceptance of a $100 Amazon gift card to an officer) was received and filed. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple callers expressed frustration over persistent racial disparities in policing, citing data showing African Americans are 15 times more likely to experience use of force, 10 times more likely to be arrested, and 5 times more likely to be stopped compared to whites. They urged the commission to address what they termed "anti-blackness" in SFPD practices. - Several speakers criticized the DGO 9.01 (pretext stops) working group process, noting meetings held at police stations during weekday hours were intimidating and inaccessible. They requested the process be moved to community spaces and outside of standard work hours. - Callers also raised concerns about metal barricades around Mission Station on Valencia Street, stating they had been in place for over two years and created a hostile environment. They called for immediate removal. - A community organizer noted that traffic citations had dropped to approximately 10 per day in 2022, compared to 74 per day in 2019, and urged enforcement focused on the most dangerous driving behaviors ("Focus on the Five") on the High Injury Network. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report: Chief Scott reported overall Part I crime up 8% year-to-date, with violent crime up 6% and property crime up 9%. Homicides were down 6% (two fewer), but shootings remained a concern, with 122 incidents resulting in 141 victims. The department had seized 694 firearms, including 129 ghost guns. The chief addressed the Valencia Street barricades, explaining they were temporary measures to maintain sidewalk cleanliness after cleanups, and noted ongoing work with Supervisor Ronen and the community for long-term solutions. Regarding the status of 29 DGOs in revision, the chief stated progress was being made, including combining several duty-related DGOs and progressing on the disengagement DGO (5.01). - DPA Director’s Report: Director Henderson reported that in 2022, the Department of Police Accountability (DPA) had opened 465 cases, closed 501, and sustained 47 cases (up from 35 at this time in 2021). He highlighted that 90 cases were now pending at the chief’s level—a change in reporting methodology to reflect all stages of the disciplinary process, not just initial submissions. He also noted two audits in progress: one on handling of officer misconduct and one on compliance with First Amendment activity guidelines (DGO 8.10). - Commission Reports: Commissioner Benedicto provided an update on the DGO 9.01 (pretext stops) revision process, which included working group meetings, outreach to officers, and community listening sessions. He noted that over 60 emails had been received that week. The next community convening was scheduled for September 20 at the Bayview Opera House. Commissioners also reported on ride-alongs, academy visits, and a town hall in Chinatown. - Proposed Implementation of Police Code Article 25: Deanna Oliva Arroche and Lt. Steve Jonas presented a plan to implement oversight of private security firms as required by Board of Supervisors Ordinance 13-22. The proposal would require firms and guards to register with SFPD, establish a complaint process, and set up a resource/referral center. The department noted there are nearly 10,000 active guard cards in the city, and implementation would require significant staffing—an estimated 4,000–8,000 hours just for initial application processing. The next step is to submit the analysis to the Board of Supervisors and work with the Controller’s Office on a gap analysis. - Quarterly Analysis and Data Report (January–March 2022): Catherine McGuire presented data showing overall stops down 57% compared to the same quarter in 2021, but persistent racial disparities: African Americans were stopped at 5 times the rate of whites, searched at 8 times, arrested at 10 times, and subjected to use of force at 15 times. Discretionary (consent) searches totaled 79 for the quarter. Vice President Elias pressed for analysis of why searches increased among Asian and white populations (4% and 3% increases respectively) and why disparities remained high despite ongoing efforts. Commissioners debated the need for concrete actions beyond reporting numbers, with Chief Scott noting that the department is focusing on policy changes like DGO 9.01 and training to address these issues. - Collaborative Reform Initiative (CRI) Quarterly Update: Acting Captain Eric Altifer reported that of the 272 recommendations from the 2016 DOJ assessment, 245 were substantially compliant, with 27 in progress. The remaining recommendations were grouped into four projects: tracking/analyzing arrests and use of force, bias management dashboard, community policing annual plans, and accountability management tools. A standalone recommendation (1.1) on disparate use of force had a methodology plan completed, awaiting final revisions and approval for the next phase. Key Outcomes - The commission voted unanimously to hold Item 13 in closed session and to assert attorney-client privilege for specific sub-items. After closed session, the commission voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion. - The commission directed the chief and DPA to provide a breakdown of the 90 pending disciplinary cases, including how many are past the nine-month mark and approaching the 3304 deadline, for the next meeting. - The commission requested that the department present the methodology plan for addressing disparate use of force (CRI recommendation 1.1) to the commission at a future meeting. - The chief committed to reporting on the removal of the Mission Station barricades and on the status of DGO revisions at the next meeting. - The commission will continue the DGO 9.01 public outreach process, with the next community meeting on September 20, 2022.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 31% · PROCEDURAL 28% · PUBLIC SAFETY 26% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 5%
1123
AUG 23, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - August 23, 2022

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a hybrid meeting on August 23, 2022, at City Hall, Room 400, beginning just after 9:45 AM (subject to minor adjustments). The commission considered a range of items including a workshop on the agency's design drought planning, approved the consent calendar (with one item removed), authorized several contracts and agreements, and heard public testimony. All votes were unanimous (4-0) unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Item 10A (novation of Contract HH-1000R) was removed from the agenda before consideration. - The remaining consent items (10B–10J) were approved without discussion. These included awarding a job order contract for general engineering, approving contract duration increases for water main replacements and sewer improvements, and authorizing plan specifications and awards for various infrastructure projects. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 5): Four callers spoke. Francisco De Costa criticized the SFPUC for failing to learn from past federal investigations and alleged mishandling of community benefits. A caller requested a water supply update, noting it had been 49 days since the last update and system storage was just over 1 million acre-feet. Another caller urged the agency to prioritize reliability of water, sewer, and power for San Francisco residents and called for more transparent CleanPowerSF communications. John Rosa Pepe expressed disappointment that the design drought workshop was truncated and had only one-sided presentations, and urged withdrawal from the lawsuit against the Bay Delta plan. - Communications (Item 6): A caller reported a broken link on the CleanPowerSF resource plan page and stressed the need for reliable electric service on Treasure Island. Another speaker questioned public access to the Hetch Hetchy bunkhouse. - Design Drought Workshop (Item 7): Over 15 public comments were received. Environmental and fishing groups (Tuolumne River Trust, Friends of the River, California Sportfishing Protection Alliance, NRDC, and others) largely supported modifying the design drought to reflect current demand and climate science. Speakers argued the current 8.5-year design drought is an outlier with a return period of 70,000 years. The Bay Area Council (Adrian Covert) disagreed that shortening the drought would benefit housing development, instead emphasizing the need for conservatism given climate uncertainty. Bosca (Tom Francis) urged caution, noting the design drought has been the backbone of reliable water supply planning for 30 years. Alameda County Water District (Ed Stevenson) provided a real-life example of increased reliance on SFPUC supplies during droughts. Discussion Items - Item 3: Adopt Renewed Findings for Hybrid Meetings – Approved after brief public comment. - Item 4: Approval of Minutes (July 12, 2022) – Approved. - Item 7: Workshop on Planning for Drought – The SFPUC Design Drought as a Stress Test – This was the major discussion item. Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) presented data from the Long-Term Vulnerability Assessment (LTVA) showing the design drought (8.5 years) has a return period of 70,000 years, far exceeding known droughts. He argued that current demand (under 190 MGD) is much lower than planned, and that incorporating earlier runoff from climate change could create a water surplus. He requested the commission schedule an action item to reduce the design drought to 7.5 years. Steve Ritchie (Assistant GM for Water) responded that the design drought is a stress test, not a prediction, and that the consequences of running out of water are catastrophic. He emphasized the system’s junior water rights, limited alternative supplies, and the need to plan for two additional dry years after any drought. He showed operational examples from the 2012–2016 drought where the water bank dropped dangerously low. Commission President Moran noted that the design drought is a judgment based on experience and that return periods are descriptive but not predictive. Commissioner Jammy highlighted the importance of demand planning, stormwater capture, and on-site reuse. No formal action was taken, but the President indicated a future wrap-up session will synthesize all workshop findings. - Item 8: Report of the General Manager – Subitems included quarterly audit (8A), budget status (8B), water capital improvements (8C), and Water System Improvement Program (8D). Staff reported positive financial projections for power and CleanPowerSF, but operating shortfalls for water and wastewater due to drought conservation and slower economic recovery. No formal action taken. - Items 11, 12, 13: Approved as discussed below. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Adopt Renewed Hybrid Meeting Findings): Approved 4-0. - Item 4 (Approval of Minutes): Approved 4-0. - Item 10 (Consent Calendar): Adopted (excluding 10A) 4-0. - Item 11 (Joint Funding Agreement with USGS): Authorized the General Manager to execute a six-year agreement not-to-exceed $2,837,770 for data collection on reservoir elevations and releases. Approved 4-0. - Item 12 (Treasure Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Design-Build Contract): Approved the General Manager’s determination to negotiate with the sole responsive bidder (PCL Stantech) after the other bid was deemed non-responsive (188% above budget). Approved 4-0. - Item 13 (Licensing Agreement for Documentary “Time Has Many Voices”): Approved 4-0 to grant licenses to the filmmakers for nonprofit distribution, including potential PBS broadcast, for a five-year term at no cost. The film documents archaeological work at the Alameda Creek Watershed Center and the history of the Muwekma Ohlone tribe. - Closed Session: The commission met in closed session regarding litigation (water right curtailment cases). No action taken in closed session, and the commission voted not to disclose discussions.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 39% · PROCEDURAL 18% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PENDING LITIGATION 13%
1124
AUG 9, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - August 9, 2022

The Port Commission met on August 9, 2022, at 10:45 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, executive session, public comments, an executive director's report, consent calendar items, informational presentations on a micro LBE credit capacity program and the PG&E sediment remediation project, and new business items. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of July 12, 2022, unanimously. - Adopted resolutions 2240, 2241, 2242: (1) allowing remote attendance under state urgency legislation for COVID-19; (2) setting FY2022-2023 monthly rental and parking rates; (3) approving a lease amendment with Golden Gate Scenic Steamship (Red and White Fleet) for temporary rent reduction during two six-month periods (Nov-Apr) for FY2021-2022 and FY2022-2023. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment on non-agenda items: Brian Burke, representing the Inlandboatmen's Union (IBU), announced unionization efforts by workers at Hornblower/Alcatraz City Cruises and requested recognition. Also submitted a letter. Evan Mobotlin, Northern California organizer for the International Longshore and Warehouse Union (ILWU), clarified that workers are organizing with IBU and seeking an NLRB election. Commissioners expressed interest and directed staff to obtain the letter and agendize the matter for future discussion. - Public comment on Executive Director's Report: Elaine Ford (likely Director Elaine Forbes) praised Commissioner Brandon's 25 years of service and contributions to equity and resilience. - Public comment on Item 11A (micro LBE credit program): Francisco DeCosta criticized the port's outreach to small businesses, stating that many businesses, including middle-sized ones, avoid the port due to perceived issues. - Public comment on Item 12A (PG&E sediment remediation): Francisco DeCosta stated that community outreach has not been done, particularly to libraries, and expressed concerns about contamination and lack of public involvement. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Assistant Port Director Michael Martin reported on: - Welcome to new Commissioner Stephen Lee. - Economic recovery: The historic ferry boat Klamath will return to Pier 9 later in August, serving as Bay Area Council headquarters and conference center. - Port's 2022 summer internship program concluded, with interns working on projects including construction site mapping, signage database, dock maintenance, and outreach directory creation. - Resilience milestones: $5 million federal funding for US Army Corps of Engineers waterfront flood study, living seawall pilot with Smithsonian, recognition at Flood and Coastal Excellence Awards. - SFMTA Embarcadero Enhancement Program: Quick-build project includes new two-way bikeway from Folsom to Broadway, improved intersections, and education campaign. SFMTA will present full report in fall. - Recognition of Commissioner Kimberly Brandon for 25 years of service; she was praised for her leadership, equity focus, and formation of the Southern Advisory Committee. - Commissioners commented, thanking Director Forbes and staff, and expressed interest in further discussion on promenade conflicts with e-scooters and bikes. - Micro LBE Credit Capacity Program (Item 11A): Stephanie Tang and Tajal Shaw (TTX) presented a pilot program to provide $50,000 lines of credit to certified Local Business Enterprises (LBEs) with port contracts, subcontracts, or tenancies. The port will provide a $1 million guarantee to a bank, and the bank will lend. The program aims to fill a gap in short-term working capital. Key details: 12-month term, requalification for up to three years, minimum credit score 640, borrowers must maintain zero balance for 30 days annually. The RFP will be issued to banks and credit unions. The program is a proof of concept for potential citywide expansion. Commissioners expressed strong support and suggested including credit unions in the RFP. - PG&E Sediment Remediation Project (Item 12A): Catherine Purcell provided an update on the cleanup of PAH-contaminated sediments from a historic manufactured gas plant between Pier 39 and Pier 43½. The cleanup plan is required by the San Francisco Regional Water Quality Control Board. Key milestones: Final feasibility study submitted, CEQA mitigated negative declaration adopted in February 2022, cleanup and abatement order issued. The project will be constructed in phases from 2023 to 2027, with in-water work from June to November. Estimated cost is $211 million. PG&E withdrew its lease application for Pier 96 and will use a facility in Antioch for material handling. Pre-construction coordination with tenants (Red and White Fleet, Blue and Gold Fleet, Pier 39) is ongoing. Commissioners asked about potential revenue loss for tenants and duration of dredging impact; staff noted that cost agreements are being negotiated and dredging in each area will last 4-8 weeks. Key Outcomes - Approved minutes and consent calendar items unanimously. - Agendized future discussion of Hornblower/Alcatraz City Cruises unionization and SFMTA promenade deconfliction. - Supported the micro LBE credit capacity program and directed staff to include credit unions in the RFP. - Noted the PG&E sediment remediation project timeline and continuing tenant coordination. - Directed staff to provide an informational presentation on leasing opportunities and port program outreach, and to revisit wayfinding and signage strategy. - Adjourned at 4:50 PM.

PROCEDURAL 34% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 10% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 10%
1125
JUL 28, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Hearing on PES and Vision Zero - July 28, 2022

On July 28, 2022, the San Francisco Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Maher, held a hybrid meeting to discuss two items: a hearing on the conditions at the Psychiatric Emergency Services (PES) unit at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and private psychiatric emergency services, and a resolution to amend the city's Vision Zero traffic fatality protocol to include a public town hall within two weeks of a traffic fatality. The committee was joined by Supervisors Raphael Mandelman and Dean Preston (substituting for Supervisor Melgar for item two). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (PES Hearing): - Public commenters included frontline healthcare workers and advocates. Heather Bollinger (SEIU RN chapter president) described severe staffing shortages, with nurses forced to work 16-hour shifts without breaks, and cited over 50 assignment despite objection forms submitted in four months. She noted that the city offers no sign-on bonuses, unlike other institutions, and that ancillary staff shortages (no clerks, techs, or security) worsen conditions. Two emergency physicians (Scott Chang, Julie) recounted repeated assaults on staff, with patients requiring sedation and restraint, and called for more conservatorships for frequent utilizers. A community member (Patricia Boyd) highlighted the lack of transportation for non-emergency mental health services and urged restoration of the MAP program. HealthRIGHT 360’s Alex Boiter stressed pay parity issues for nonprofit workers, which exacerbate staffing shortages and limit discharge options from PES. - Item 2 (Vision Zero Resolution): - Public commenters supported the resolution. Richard Waffman cited multiple fatal pedestrian crashes with no action from SFMTA, such as at 38th and Geary and 37th and Falcon. Joaquin Kira Laguna described organizing rapid-response protests at fatality locations and noted that neighbors feel hopeless after years of unheeded safety requests. Parker Day called San Francisco’s Vision Zero efforts a failure, arguing that parking and driver convenience are prioritized over human life. Discussion Items - Item 1: Hearing on Psychiatric Emergency Services (PES) Conditions - The hearing focused on capacity, staffing, and system pressures at PES, the only dedicated psychiatric emergency service in San Francisco. Dr. Hillary Cunnins (DPH Behavioral Health Director) and Dr. Mark Leary (ZSFG) presented data: PES has been “condition red” (diverting patients to the ED) 100% of the time during the pandemic due to COVID screening, but was open 82% of the time for immediate transfer from the ED. In 2022, 65% of PES patients were discharged with outpatient referrals, 18% were admitted to acute inpatient care, and 5% each went to hummingbird respite or DOOR urgent care. 72 patients were released by court order against medical advice between August 2021 and March 2022. Dr. Cunnins highlighted new initiatives: SCRT teams (226 clients in June 2022, <15% transported to hospital), Soma Rise (330 clients served in first weeks), and progress toward 400 new beds (250 opened by end of summer 2022). Staffing: 2 RN vacancies in PES, with 23.5 RN FTEs and a 1:4 ratio, but frontline staff reported chronic understaffing, high acuity, and lack of ancillary support. Lieutenant Mario Molina (SFPD) described a decline in police 5150 detentions (from 3,426 in 2019 to 1,132 in the first two quarters of 2022), attributing it to better training and increased use of DOOR clinic and Westside Clinic, but noted that substance-induced psychosis often precludes a 5150. He called for better data-sharing and collaboration between agencies. April Sloan (SFFD Street Crisis Response) reported that five high-utilizer individuals had 1,781 ambulance transports over five years, costing $4 million, with two now deceased. UCSF’s Dr. Maria Raven noted that 485 behavioral health patients were seen in Q1 2022, with average ED length of stay of 25.7 hours, and 35% were admitted to inpatient medicine due to lack of psychiatric bed placement. Supervisor Mandelman expressed concern that despite many new facilities, the system still lacks a clear plan for severe methamphetamine users cycling through PES. - Item 2: Resolution on Vision Zero Traffic Fatality Protocol - Supervisor Preston presented the resolution, noting 19 traffic fatalities in 2022 (15 at introduction, 4 more since) and a lack of public communication after each death. Current protocols involve internal coordination (SFPD, SFMTA, DPH) but no standard public briefing. City Traffic Engineer Ricardo Olea outlined proposed improvements: a standardized public report within 30 days (including incident details, SFMTA rapid response actions, and DPH crisis response), quarterly reports to the SFMTA board, and on-site posting at fatality locations. He estimated costs for posting at $150,000 and for community outreach at $300,000 annually. Supervisor Maher emphasized the need for proactive neighborhood engagement, referencing a January 2022 fatality in his district at 46th and Lincoln where community requests for a stop sign were denied for years. Commander Walsh (SFPD) explained that some information is withheld during criminal investigations (e.g., stolen vehicle cases). The departments proposed the report and quarterly updates as alternatives to a town hall, citing concerns about logistics and the potential for misinformation. Supervisor Preston pushed for direct outreach, noting that a pilot outreach program in 2019 was discontinued due to funding, and asked for cost details and a timeline for implementation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee continued the hearing to the call of the chair. Supervisor Mandelman requested a future visit to PES and further details on the crisis diversion unit plan and its expected impact on PES demand. - Item 2: The committee continued the resolution to the call of the chair. Supervisor Preston will work with departments to finalize the standardized public report, on-site notification, and community outreach components, including securing funding for the outreach program. The item will return to committee after further negotiations.

MENTAL HEALTH 25% · PUBLIC HEALTH 25% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 17%
1126
JUL 21, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - July 21, 2022

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 21, 2022, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Supervisor Raphael Mandelman. The committee addressed several items including a Caltrain governance MOU, a hearing on the monkeypox response, a hearing on Laguna Honda Hospital's closure plan, and a response to a civil grand jury report. Public comment was heard on multiple items. Public Comments & Testimony Public comment was received on the following items: Caltrain MOU (one speaker supported approval and urged amending the JPA); monkeypox response (numerous speakers criticized the lack of urgency, communication failures, inequitable access, and called for a dashboard and appointment system); Laguna Honda Hospital (speakers urged stopping transfers due to patient deaths, calling for a pause and direct intervention from federal officials). No public comment was offered on the civil grand jury items or litigation settlements. Caltrain Governance MOU (Item 5) The committee considered a resolution approving an MOU between the Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board (JPB), Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, San Mateo County Transit District, and the City and County of San Francisco regarding JPB governance. Supervisor President Shamann Walton, the sponsor, explained the MOU resulted from a three-year process to address governance concerns, including increased oversight and independence for the Caltrain executive director. JPB Chair Steve Heminger provided historical context, noting the agreement resolves a long-standing debt from San Mateo County advancing funds for the right-of-way purchase. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Civil Grand Jury Report (Items 1-2) The committee had scheduled a hearing on the 2021-2022 Civil Grand Jury report "Shovel Ready: Best Practices and Collaboration to Improve San Francisco’s Capital Construction Program" and a board response. Chair Preston noted that the mayor's office requested a continuance to allow departments to prepare. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue items 1 and 2 to the September 15, 2022 meeting. Monkeypox Response (Item 3) Supervisor Mandelman sponsored a hearing on the city's monkeypox response. Dr. Stephanie Cohen from the Department of Public Health presented epidemiological data: as of July 19, 2022, San Francisco had 141 cases (26% of California's 266 cases). The city had received 7,743 vaccine doses and administered 3,400. The federal supply was severely limited, with only 144,000 doses distributed nationally. DPH expanded eligibility to sex workers and sexually active men who have sex with men. Dr. Tyler TerMeer from the San Francisco AIDS Foundation reported that the foundation had vaccinated 761 people, with over 5,300 on a waitlist. He noted that 65% of those vaccinated were BIPOC. Public commenters criticized DPH communication, lack of appointments, and inequitable access, urging daily data dashboards and appointment systems. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Laguna Honda Hospital (Item 4) Supervisor Myrna Melgar led a hearing on the status of Laguna Honda Hospital's closure and patient relocation plan. The hospital lost Medicare/Medicaid accreditation in April 2022, and CMS required closure by September 13, 2022. Roland Pickens, CEO of Laguna Honda, reported that the hospital had assessed all patients and made thousands of calls to find skilled nursing beds. As of the hearing, 56 patients had been transferred or discharged; four had died after transfer. The hospital proposed an 18-month closure plan, but CMS required completion in four months (with a possible two-month extension). Former Supervisor and City Attorney Louise Rennie urged CMS to pause discharges, citing patient deaths. Public commenters demanded an immediate stop to transfers, calling the situation a humanitarian crisis. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Litigation Settlements (Items 6-11) The committee considered six settlement agreements for lawsuits totaling $767,500: Morton Weisberg ($50,000), Rebecca Michaels ($280,000), Elsa Acevedo Lubguban ($175,000), Koreda Tan ($180,000), Breonna Richard ($47,500), and Kevin Lee ($35,000). Chair Preston indicated he was comfortable moving them without a closed session. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the settlements to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Caltrain MOU resolution approved and sent to full board (3-0). - Civil Grand Jury hearing continued to September 15, 2022 (3-0). - Monkeypox response hearing continued to call of chair (3-0). - Laguna Honda Hospital hearing continued to call of chair (3-0). - Litigation settlements sent to full board (3-0). - All items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of September 6, 2022, unless otherwise stated.

PUBLIC HEALTH 55% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · HEALTH SERVICES 9%
1127
JUL 20, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - July 20, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on July 20, 2022, at 1:45 PM (PDT) with all seven commissioners present. The meeting included the introduction of new Commissioner Deborah Walker, the Chief's crime report, a discussion on surveillance technology legislation, plans to increase police presence and drug enforcement in the Tenderloin, the status of the MOU between SFPD and the District Attorney, and the Department of Police Accountability's 2021 Annual Report. The Commission also approved revised Department General Order 3.07. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved (7-0) the consent calendar, which included: SFPD and DPA SB 1421/SB16 monthly reports, Family Code 6228 quarterly report, sexual assault evidence kit semi-annual report, and the police commission disciplinary actions report for Q2 2022. Public Comments & Testimony - Wesley Saver (Glide Senior Policy Manager): Stated that SFPD officers have cited program participants for possessing legal harm reduction supplies and requested the Commission clarify the law to officers to stop these actions. - Kit Hodge (Wealth and Disparities in the Black Community): Quoted Felicia Jones, calling SFPD actions "anti-blackness" regarding use of force, arrests, and racial profiling; criticized lack of urgency and requested the MOU between SFPD and DA remain in place. - Jean Bridges (WDBC volunteer): Repeated the same quote and added that black San Franciscans are 10 times as likely to be arrested, 15 times as likely to be subjected to use of force, and more than five times as likely to be subject to traffic stops; opposed expanded surveillance. - Francisco De Costa: Urged focus on mental health issues, especially in Bayview, and requested SFPD work with the health department. - Barry Toronto: Complained about lack of enforcement on illegally parked cars in bike lanes near clubs on 11th Street and issues at Walgreens at 18th and Castro. - Colin Brown: Spoke about her son's unsolved 2006 murder; pleaded for more attention to unsolved homicides and provided suspect names; called for support and media coverage. - Multiple callers during later agenda items opposed the surveillance technology policy, citing racial disparities and lack of safeguards. - Deputy Public Defender Brian Cox: Argued the surveillance policy lacks guardrails and will disproportionately target black and brown people; called for subpoena instead of live monitoring. - Susan Buckman (WDBC core team): Stated that SFPD should not be given greater surveillance power given existing disparities. - Other callers expressed support for using cameras to address theft and safety concerns. - Ms. Brown also called multiple times regarding her son's case and alleged lack of follow-up by investigators. - David Calderon: Requested his mother's homicide case be agendized due to conflicting information. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Chief William Scott): - Violent crime is up 6% year-to-date; property crimes down 25%. Gun violence homicides down 11%. Ghost guns: 116 recovered out of 564 total firearms. Two non-fatal shootings reported; no homicides. A bomb threat at SFO was resolved with an arrest. - Strategies: Deployed additional patrols to address watch robberies in Union Square, Chinatown, Northern District, and auto burglaries in Taraval area. Tourist patrols continue via voluntary overtime. - Commissioner Yee asked about community policing funding; Chief said no additional staff or funding from Supervisor Mar's ordinance. - Commissioner Benedicto asked about recent drug paraphernalia citations; Chief deferred to Tenderloin presentation. - Commissioner Walker requested a future presentation on partnerships with community groups (e.g., patrol specials, ambassadors). Commissioners agreed to agendize. - DPA Director's Report (Executive Director Paul Henderson): - Opened 358 cases year-to-date; closed 393; 227 active; 39 sustained. Mediated 13 cases. 20 cases over 9 months (16 on hold). Top complaints: neglect of duty and conduct unbecoming. - Outreach: Summer intern program continued; presented at station community meetings. - Commissioner Benedicto requested a fall presentation on the mediation program including mediators and participants. - Item 7: Status Update on Surveillance Technology Legislation (Special Project Manager Aja Steves and Chief Scott): - Explained SF Admin Code 19B process. The new STP (non-city entity surveillance cameras) is before the Board of Supervisors Rules Committee. It would allow SFPD to request video footage from private entities with captain-level approval and consent; live monitoring requires exigent circumstances or significant events. - Commissioners raised concerns about racial disparities, civil liberties, immigration consequences, and potential abuse. Chief emphasized deterrent effect and crime-solving benefits; annual reporting planned. - Commissioner Carter Oberstone noted the policy's link to DGO 8.10 (First Amendment activities) and questioned its status; Chief said an update would be provided. - Item 8: Discussion on SFPD's Plan to Increase Police Presence and Drug Enforcement in the Tenderloin: - Chief detailed the overdose crisis: 641 deaths in 2021, 297 year-to-date in 2022. Tenderloin accounts for 23% of overdoses. SFPD received a $125,000 DOJ community policing grant to disrupt open-air drug markets using engagement and enforcement (citations, arrests for warrants/stay-away orders, Narcan saves). Since July, over 150 citations and nearly 300 arrests for drug sales. - Commissioners debated: Commissioner Elias questioned why now; Chief said grant enabled strategy. Commissioner Yannis favored engagement and treatment over paraphernalia citations. Commissioner Byrne noted displacement and need for foot patrols. Commissioner Walker stressed inter-agency coordination. - Item 9: Status of MOU between SFPD and District Attorney: - Chief reported a 30-business-day extension with DA Jenkins; negotiations ongoing via mediator Judge Walker. Committed to not operating without an MOU. Commissioner Benedicto requested regular updates in Chief's report. Director Henderson offered DPA assistance but is not in mediation. - Item 10: DPA 2021 Annual Report Presentation (Sarah Muckins): - Sustained rate 11% (national avg 4%); 146 policy recommendations. Top allegations: neglect of duty, conduct unbecoming. Mediated 37 cases. New district pages with call-for-service comparison. Audit unit award-winning. Racial equity hiring: 50% exec staff women, 40% women of color. - Commissioners asked about correlation with Early Intervention System; DPA does not have access. Commissioner Yannis requested cross-reference. Commissioner Walker noted high neglect of duty cases. Assistant Chief Mosier said trainings are scheduled at stations in August to address report-taking failures. - Item 11: Approval of Revised DGO 3.07 (Collision Board of Review): - Presented by Chief; revised policy meets meet-and-confer requirement. Commissioner Yannis questioned "recommended" disciplinary language vs. "required"; Chief referenced existing disciplinary guidelines. Approved unanimously (7-0). Key Outcomes - Votes: Unanimously approved Consent Calendar (7-0). Unanimously approved DGO 3.07 (7-0). Unanimously voted to go into closed session (7-0) and later voted not to disclose closed session discussions (7-0). - Directives: - Chief to have inspector follow up with Ms. Brown on her son's unsolved homicide case. - Commission to agendize a future presentation on community partnerships (patrol specials, ambassadors). - Commission to agendize presentations on the DPA mediation program, SFPD budget increase, psychological evaluation DGOs, and community policing plans. - DPA to provide follow-up data on multiple sustained allegations per officer and cross-reference with the Early Intervention System. - SFPD to report quarterly on live surveillance requests and to share the Tenderloin grant report with the Commission. - MOU extension for 30 business days; regular updates expected in Chief's report. - DPA and IAD to conduct station visits in August to address neglect of duty complaints.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 19% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY 18% · PROCEDURAL 15%
1128
JUL 14, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - July 14, 2022

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on July 14, 2022, at approximately 11:00 AM in hybrid format. Chair Gordon Maher presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Member Myrna Melgar (later excused). Supervisor Matt Dorsey participated remotely for the SOMA Pilipinas item. The agenda included three liquor license transfers, a hearing on the economic recovery of cultural institutions and the Golden Gate Park Access and Safety Program, a hearing on senior housing continuum, and a resolution adopting the SOMA Pilipinas Cultural Heritage District’s strategy report. Liquor License Transfers (Items 1-3) - Olive (304 Clement St): Type 21 off-sale beer/wine/distilled spirits license transferred to Golden Stage Consulting LLC. SFPD reported zero protests, high crime/saturation area. Owner Ahmed Tasi described a specialty grocery store. Unanimous vote to send positive recommendation to full board. - Mili Wine Bar (110 Folsom St): Type 42 on-sale beer/wine public premise license to Unwind SF LLC. Located in low crime, high saturation area. Owner described a neighborhood wine bar. Public comment from East Cut CBD in support. Unanimous approval. - South End Rowing Club (500 Jefferson St): Type 51 nonprofit club license. Located in high crime, high saturation area. Representative Josh Sale explained the club’s need for a permanent license for member events. Supervisor Stefani recused herself but was cleared to vote. Unanimous approval. Hearing on Museum Recovery and Golden Gate Park Access (Item 4) Supervisor Stefani co-sponsored the hearing. Presentations from: - Fine Arts Museums (Tom Campbell): Pre-COVID attendance 1.5 million; current 600,000. Legion of Honor only 5% down, De Young 40-45% down. Cited loss of 270 free parking spaces on JFK as a factor. Highlighted need for increased security staffing (down from 77 to 65 FTEs), $30 million tower corrosion repair, and higher art insurance valuations (city collection valued at $6-7 billion). - California Academy of Sciences (Ike Kwan): Reduced budget 27% during pandemic. City charter requires $13M operating for Steinhart Aquarium; current allocation $7.4M. Parking and property crime listed as top visitor inconveniences. - Asian Art Museum (Jay Xu): Closed 10 months; opened 5 days a week due to frozen security positions (38 to 33). General support cut 37% since pre-pandemic. Emphasized Civic Center safety and parking barriers. - Gardens of Golden Gate Park (Stephanie Lindler): New entity combining Conservatory of Flowers, Japanese Tea Garden, Botanical Garden. Conservatory visitation at 76% of pre-pandemic; Botanical Garden record highs. Free admission for SF residents increased visitation dramatically. - Rec & Park (Sarah Madlin) and SFMTA: Reported on 40+ interventions including new ADA parking lot (20 spots near bandshell, 270% more accessible parking), improved shuttle (new low-floor buses by October), taxi stands, and plans for wayfinding signage by late 2023/early 2024. Discussions on reducing parking garage debt (ballot measure in November). - Public Comment: 13 callers and several in-person spoke. Many supporters praised car-free JFK for safety and equity; critics raised concerns about senior/disabled access and congestion. Speakers thanked Rec & Park for progress on shuttle and ADA parking. - Key Outcomes: Hearing continued to call of the chair. Committee will receive quarterly reports on progress. Hearing on Senior Housing Continuum (Item 5) Chair Maher introduced the hearing, noting follow-up from January and new budget allocations including $4M senior operating subsidy, $10M SRO elevator repairs, and a new planner position. Budget and Legislative Analyst Fred Brusseau presented the “Senior Housing Continuum” report with 39 policy options. - Demographics: 164,036 seniors (65+) in 2022, projected 243,000 by 2042 (48% growth). 25% of seniors have incomes below 150% poverty. 87,864 San Franciscans with disabilities. - Existing Programs: 16 aging-in-place programs, many small and siloed. Recommendations to expand home modifications, utility discounts, tenant-based subsidies, and flexible funding like Community Living Fund and PACE. - Affordable Housing: 5,595 deed-restricted senior units; need 2,708 more by 2042 just to maintain current ratio (135/year vs current 81/year). Need 1,718 more assisted living beds and 1,096 more skilled nursing beds. - Funding Sources: Consider increasing GO bond cap, use of certificates of participation, modular construction, collaboration with Bay Area Housing Finance Agency. - Public Comment: Speakers emphasized geographic disparities (e.g., District 4 lack of senior housing), need for portable rental subsidies, and disability operating subsidies. - Key Outcomes: Hearing continued to call of the chair. Planning department will develop integrated strategy using new planner position. SOMA Pilipinas Cultural Heritage District Strategy Report (Item 6) Presentation by Julia Sabori (Planning) and Raquel Redondiez (SOMA Pilipinas). The Chess Report (Cultural History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy) is the first such report from a cultural district. It contains 22 strategies in 6 areas: cultural preservation, tenant protections, arts & culture, economic development, land use, and cultural competency. - Key initiatives: Filipino community archives, tenant stabilization, small site acquisition, cultural gateway, mutual aid merchant association, language access barangay center, and community health report. - Public comment: Overwhelming support from over a dozen speakers representing SOMCAN, other cultural districts (Japantown, Leather & LGBTQ, Sunset Chinese, Calle 24, Transgender District), artists, and community workers. Many highlighted the need to address displacement, language barriers, and health disparities. - Key Outcomes: Unanimous vote (3-0) to send resolution to full board with positive recommendation. Note: All action items requiring roll call votes were recorded and will appear on the July 26, 2022 Board of Supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated.

PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · ARTS AND CULTURE 8% · PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 8% · CULTURAL DISTRICTS 8%
1129
JUL 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - July 13, 2022: Approval of $146.8 Million in COP for Affordable Housing

This meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronan, considered a single item: the appropriation of $146.8 million in Certificate of Participation (COP) proceeds for affordable housing, land acquisition, public housing repairs, educator housing, and related financing costs. The committee heard from supervisors, received a report from the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA), and took public testimony before approving a clarifying amendment and forwarding the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Charlie Shamus (representing Council of Community Housing Organizations) expressed strong support for the COP proposal, calling it a "bold and innovative approach" to fund affordable housing and anti-displacement strategies, and urged prioritization of Black, American Indian, immigrant, and other communities of color. He supported Supervisor Preston's clarifying amendment. - Eileen Bogan (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) spoke in opposition, arguing that COPs allow the city to issue debt without voter approval, carry higher interest rates, and add to the city's existing debt burden ($1.3 billion in outstanding COP debt and $2.5 billion in general obligation bonds). She opposed further issuance. - Anastasia Ovanopolis (Anti-Displacement Coalition) expressed support, noting that the BLA report indicated a healthy city budget and that the program should expand to include neighborhoods at risk of gentrification and displacement. She also thanked Supervisor Preston for the amendment. Discussion Items - Supervisor Dean Preston (sponsor) thanked the committee and Mayor's office for the affordable housing package, noting that the item was continued from a previous meeting due to amendments. He introduced a non-substantive clarifying amendment to correct language regarding "SIDLAC designated high need/resources areas" — changing it to "SIDLAC designated high resource areas and/or high need areas" in three places. He stated this clarification was requested by advocates and approved by the city attorney and controller. - Supervisor Connie Chan thanked Chair Ronan and Vice Chair Safai for including API community priorities in the budget, and praised Supervisor Preston for collaboration. - Budget and Legislative Analyst presented a report on the ordinance: $146.8 million appropriated from COP proceeds (including $112 million for projects and $34.8 million for financing costs). The ordinance does not authorize new debt; that would require separate board action. Total estimated debt service is $251 million. The city's COP debt service cap is 3.25% of general fund revenues, and there is currently spare capacity of about $80–$120 million, so the new projects fit within the cap. Approval is a policy matter for the board. - Supervisor Hillary Ronan (Chair) thanked Supervisor Preston and Chan for their work, noting that the COP funding was a creative solution to secure significant affordable housing resources. She emphasized the link between housing stability and issues like homelessness, workforce retention, and health. - Supervisor Ahsha Safai clarified that the current action is an appropriation, not an authorization to issue debt. He expressed hope that sites for land acquisition (especially for 100% affordable housing and API community priorities) would be brought back to the committee for public discussion before the debt authorization. - Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (via remote? Actually Supervisor Mar) thanked all parties and acknowledged community stakeholders (Housing Stability Fund Oversight Committee, API Council) for driving the process. Key Outcomes - Clarifying Amendment (moved by Chair Ronan, seconded by Supervisor Mar): Unanimously approved (4 ayes, Member Walton excused) to change the language from "SIDLAC designated high need/resources areas" to "SIDLAC designated high resource areas and/or high need areas" on pages 1, 3, and 5 of the ordinance. - Motion to Forward to Full Board with Positive Recommendation (moved by Supervisor Chan, seconded by Chair Ronan): Unanimously approved (4 ayes, Member Walton excused). The item is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on July 19, 2022.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 69% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 6% · HOMELESSNESS 4%
1130
JUL 13, 2022 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - July 13, 2022

The San Francisco Police Commission met on July 13, 2022, to review crime trends, receive reports from the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), discuss the Early Intervention System (EIS) fourth quarter 2021 and first quarter 2022 reports, address delays in updating Department General Orders (DGOs), and vote to adopt revised DGO 3.01. The meeting included public comment on unsolved homicides and policy concerns, and a closed session on personnel matters. Public Comments & Testimony - A caller criticized the proposed pretext stop policy (DGO 9.01), asking about acceptable racial disparities and comparing San Francisco's stop data to other cities. Commissioner Carter-Oberstone offered to meet to discuss the questions. - Ms. Brown called regarding her son Arve Avakasa's unsolved 2006 murder, urging the department to address the "snitch culture" and solve cold cases. She asked for safety measures for witnesses. - David Calderon called during the later discussion on pending DGOs, inquiring whether SFPD has a policy for when an investigator is found guilty of presenting perjured testimony, referencing his mother's case. Chief's Report - Chief William Scott reported crime trends for the week ending July 13, 2022: violent crime up 6% year-to-date (homicides flat at 26, robberies up 2%, assaults up 11%), property crime up 6% (burglaries down 25%, larcenies up 15%, auto burglaries up 7%). 539 guns seized (116 ghost guns). Hate crimes: 22 year-to-date, down from 113 all last year. - Major incidents included a homicide on July 9 at Dakota and 23rd Street; four shootings; the annual "Hill Bomb" event declared an unlawful assembly due to crowd hostility and vandalism; and vandalism of a new community center at 24th and Harrison. - Chief discussed the 19B surveillance camera ordinance before the Board of Supervisors, seeking authority for real-time monitoring of felony/misdemeanor activity and large events. He noted the current ordinance only permits live monitoring in exigent circumstances. - Commissioners expressed concerns about the new District Attorney Brooke Jenkins' emphasis on enforcement, particularly regarding drug users. Chief responded that the department is enforcing open-air drug use based on community complaints, but policy remains unchanged. - Commissioner Yanes urged continued focus on violent crime rather than regressive approaches; Chief agreed to agendize the topic for fuller discussion. DPA Director’s Report - Director Henderson reported DPA statistics: 346 cases opened in 2022, 367 closed, 240 pending, 38 sustained, 11 mediated. 20 cases past the nine-month investigation period (15 due to civil/criminal pending tolling). 45% of new cases involve failure to take required action (e.g., write reports); 18% involve inappropriate behavior. - Summer Law and Justice program interns met with various justice system officials; a presentation will be given at end of summer. - DPA launched a new FAQ document on their website under "Resources," explaining the complaint and investigation process in plain language. Commissioners praised the FAQ and requested it be hyperlinked from the commission website. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedetto reported on a six-hour ride-along with Mission Station officers, calling it enlightening. He also outlined community outreach for DGO 9.01 (pretext stops), including town halls and targeted meetings with Asian Pacific Islander and Latino groups starting August 2, 2022. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone requested quarterly raw stop and search data (QADR) from Chief Scott; Chief said data would be provided by Thursday, July 14. - Vice President Elias agendized a report on the expired juvenile DGO and a meeting with command staff on DGO priorities. Early Intervention System (EIS) Presentation – 4th Quarter 2021 & 1st Quarter 2022 - Commander Paul Yap presented: 3.3% of active sworn members generated EIS alerts in Q4 2021 (100 alerts from 70 members); 3.2% in Q1 2022 (89 alerts from 65 members). The most common trigger was three or more uses of force in three months (48 in Q4, 35 in Q1). - Interventions: informal counseling (61 Q4, 71 Q1); formal counseling (4 Q4, 1 Q1); performance improvement plans (2 Q4, 3 Q1). - A new EIS system with Benchmark Analytics is in development, expected production release January 2023, aiming to reduce false positives and improve predictive analytics. - Discussion: Commissioners asked about weighting of indicators (all equal), under/over-inclusivity, and whether thresholds lead to formal written plans. Chief noted that psychological counseling referrals are voluntary, not mandatory. - Commissioner Byrne raised the importance of using EIS to encourage officers to seek mental health support; Chief acknowledged but said current policy only mandates evaluation through fitness-for-duty process. Discussion on Pending Department General Orders - DPA Policy Director Janelle Kwood presented a list of 26 DGOs that have languished for unreasonable periods (e.g., Duties of Patrol Officer pending 785 days; Field Training Program pending 826 days). She noted the DOJ criticized this in 2016 and the problem persists. - Chief Scott responded that the department has been focused on CRI (Collaborative Reform Initiative) compliance, subject matter experts (SMEs) are pulled for field duties, and the written directives unit has only three staff. He announced a restructuring with new civilian positions (two for policy writing, two for community work groups) funded in the upcoming budget. - Director Henderson argued delays are systemic and go beyond staffing; DPA offered to draft policies but was told not to redline. He asked the commission to monitor DGO progress monthly. - Ms. Kwood noted that the department instructed DPA not to speak directly to SMEs, causing bottlenecks. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone expressed concern that delay undermines the commission's regulatory authority. The commission requested monthly status reports and asked Chief to present the new DGO structure in September. - Vice President Elias asked the Chief to prioritize simple DGOs for quick completion. Closed Session - The commission unanimously voted (6-0) to hold Item 9 in closed session. After closed session, they voted unanimously (6-0) not to disclose any discussion. Key Outcomes - Adopted revised DGO 3.01 (Department Written Directives) – Vote: 6-0 in favor. - Data sharing: Chief Scott agreed to provide quarterly stop and search data to the commission by Thursday, July 14. - DGO monitoring: Commission will receive monthly progress reports on pending DGOs; Chief to present new DGO development structure in September. - DGO 9.01 outreach schedule: Announced town halls on September 6, 13, and 20, plus targeted meetings with community groups starting August 2. - Closed session: No disclosure of closed session discussion.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 37% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · EARLY INTERVENTION SYSTEM 13% · POLICY AND GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS 12%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com