Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1241–1250 ENTRIES
1241
JUN 28, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 28, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on June 28, 2021, to discuss and make final decisions on the Fiscal Years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 budget and salary ordinances. The meeting was chaired by Matt Haney and included committee members President Walton, Supervisors Ronan, Safai, and Marr. The committee heard from the Department of Public Health and the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, and later recessed to reconvene at 9:00 AM on June 29, 2021. Consent Calendar - No items were listed on the consent calendar. Public comment on items 1 and 2 (budget and salary ordinances) was closed on June 25, 2021, and no further public comment was taken on those items. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment on agenda item number 3 (appropriation for rent relief and social housing) was available via phone and email. No specific public comments were recorded in the transcript for this meeting. Discussion Items - Department of Public Health (DPH): DPH presented a $150 million total spending plan for COVID-19 response, with $123 million in FY2021-2022 and $27 million in FY2022-2023. The $27 million is funded by $12.7 million in grants and $14 million in general fund. Supervisor Safai expressed concern about the $14 million general fund placeholder in year two, suggesting it should be revisited in January 2022 rather than reserved now. DPH defended the need for continued vaccination, community engagement, and operational sustainability, noting that COVID-19 will be an ongoing challenge. The committee did not take a final vote on this item during the meeting. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): HSH discussed the Safe Sleep Program, which costs $191 per tent per night. The committee questioned the high cost, noting that it is comparable to transitional housing. HSH outlined cost-saving measures, including renegotiating vendor contracts and standardizing staffing. The committee aimed to reduce the cost to approximately $145 per night, which would bring the annual program cost for 260 tents from $15 million to about $13.7 million. No final decision was made; the committee planned to continue discussions. - Other Departments: The committee later heard from the Sheriff's Office, Police Department, and Juvenile Probation Department. The Sheriff's Office reported a reduction in overtime from $25 million to $7.7 million in the current year, attributing this to the closure of County Jail 4 and attrition. The Police Department discussed recruitment goals of 100 officers per year, with academies of 30-35 recruits each, acknowledging recruitment challenges. No formal votes were taken on these items during the recessed meeting. Key Outcomes - No final votes were taken on the budget and salary ordinances (items 1 and 2) during this meeting. The committee recessed at 12:30 AM on June 29, 2021, to reconvene at 9:00 AM that same day to complete its work. - The committee indicated that further discussions would be needed to finalize the $14 million general fund allocation for DPH in FY2022-2023 and to reduce the Safe Sleep Program costs to around $145 per night.

CLIMATE ADAPTATION 10% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8% · PROCEDURAL 7% · ARTS AND CULTURE 7%
1242
JUN 25, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
2021年6月25日预算与拨款委员会休会会议 - 公众评论日

会议于2021年6月25日举行,由主席Matt Haney主持,委员会成员包括President Walton、Supervisors Ronan、Safai和Marr。本次会议的唯一议程是听取公众对2021-2022和2022-2023财年预算的意见。公众通过电话和视频提交评论,每人限时1分钟,会议持续了数小时,听取了数百位发言者的证词。 公众评论与证词 黑人社区与种族平等 - Mega Black San Francisco 要求60百万美元基线用于Dreamkeepers倡议、黑人社区组织能力建设、审计过去15年资金分配,并涵盖教育、经济、健康、住房、司法、粮食主权和艺术文化七大领域。发言者强调“不是请求,而是要求”。 - SF Block 支持总统Walton办公室提出的200万美元用于黑人社区能力建设,并呼吁更多投资。 移民与社区服务 - 菲律宾社区中心(FCC) 请求恢复Tulai项目159,000美元的削减,该中心在疫情期间服务了超过120名移民社区成员。 - SF Immigrant Legal and Education Network (SFILEN) 感谢委员会建议180万美元的追加拨款,但要求恢复快速反应热线18.2万美元的削减,确保24/7服务。 - Communities United for Health and Justice (CUHJ) 请求恢复70,171美元的削减,使预算回到135,171美元。 住房与无家可归者 - SRO家庭(通过Chinatown Community Development Center) 讲述了居住在极小单元中的困境,要求更多租金补贴和经济适用房。 - Senior and Disability Action 要求300万美元可携带租金补贴和300万美元老年人运营补贴,以帮助老年人和残障人士留在旧金山。 - Hospitality House 要求全额资助“Our City, Our Home”提案,包括灵活住房补贴、就业培训等。 - Coalition on Homelessness 支持OCOH预算提案,要求恢复200套住房补贴单元,并扩建24小时卫生间。 青少年与教育 - Youth Speaks 支持260 Fulton Street的127套经济适用房项目,整合艺术与社区。 - Parent Voices 要求保护Prop C资金,优先消除儿童保育等候名单,提高工作者薪酬,并恢复儿童保育资源与转介机构910,000美元的削减。 - Service Provider Working Group (SPWG) 要求4%的业务成本增长(针对DCYF合同)以及恢复651万美元的公平接入资金,防止约3,000个课后项目名额损失。 - City College of San Francisco (AFT 2121) 要求长期稳定资金,支持劳动力教育和恢复基金,避免课程削减和裁员。 司法与警察改革 - Causa Justa::Just Cause 要求削减警察和警长预算,资助CART(同情替代响应团队),并将关闭County Jail 4节省的2,470万美元重新投入社区服务。 - DA办公室调查助理(Local 21) 要求实现与法律助理分类的薪资平等。 - 公共辩护人办公室支持者 呼吁增加预算,因为其预算仅为警察部门的1/15。 健康与气候 - HIV Advocacy Network 要求300万美元住房补贴和30万美元心理健康服务,以支持长期生存者。 - Climate Emergency Coalition 要求至少1%的城市预算(约1.3亿美元)用于气候公平,包括建筑电气化、绿色就业、自行车基础设施等。 - Senior and Disability Action 还包括对轮椅维修试点项目的请求。 其他 - Pacific Islander社区(SALT协会) 首次提出预算请求,要求100万美元用于恢复服务。 - 家庭资源中心联盟 感谢市长500万美元提案,但要求额外250万(FY21-22)和290万(FY22-23)以满足需求增长。 - Cameo House 多方发言要求全额资助这一为司法牵连女性和儿童提供替代监禁住宿的项目,避免关闭。 - Larkin Street Youth Services 要求紧急酒店券、过渡性住房、行为健康服务等。 关键成果 - 公众评论于下午约6:00关闭。 - 委员会以5-0投票决定休会至2021年6月28日星期一上午10:00,届时将进行最终预算审议。

PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · HOMELESSNESS 15% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 9% · PUBLIC HEALTH 9%
1243
JUN 24, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Recessed Meeting – June 24, 2021: Department Budgets Reviewed

This was the June 24, 2021 Budget and Appropriations Committee meeting, chaired by Supervisor Matt Haney and including President Walton, Supervisors Ronen, Safai, and Marr. The committee reviewed proposed budgets for fiscal years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 for multiple city departments, hearing from department heads and the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA). Public comment was deferred to a dedicated day on June 25, 2021. Discussion Items Juvenile Probation Department - BLA Recommendations: $120,000 in ongoing savings for FY21-22, plus $3,607 in prior-year encumbrances closed. FY22-23: $120,000 ongoing reductions. The department agreed with the recommendations. - Discussion: President Walton raised concerns about closing juvenile hall and questioned the need for a 5.5% budget increase ($2.28 million) while closing the facility. She suggested placing funds in reserve. Chief Miller noted that state realignment funding ($795,000 in year one, $2.35 million in year two) is not intended for the hall but for a new service model. Overtime was discussed: budgeted at about $820,000 for the hall, with reductions of $325,000 from the prior year. Chief Miller explained that COVID-19 protocols require multiple units to remain open even with low populations. Adult Probation Department - BLA Recommendations: $104,811 in FY21-22 savings ($10,000 ongoing, $94,811 one-time), plus $7,650 in prior-year encumbrances. FY22-23: $10,000 ongoing reductions. Department agreed. - Discussion: Supervisor Walton questioned a $94,811 cut to a new pilot program due to a delayed start (August 1). Chief Fletcher confirmed the program would ramp up quickly, but the committee noted the dollars could be placed in reserve. Supervisor Marr asked about staffing increases: the department has 154 FTEs for 6,000 clients, with 62 case-carrying officers. Caseloads have been stable due to high-risk cases. Superior Court - BLA Recommendations: $50,000 ongoing savings each year. Department agreed. Department of Emergency Management (DEM) - BLA Recommendations: $1,036,441 in FY21-22 ($150,000 ongoing, $886,441 one-time). FY22-23: $100,000 ongoing. Department agreed. - Discussion: Supervisor Ronen confirmed that a new position to coordinate street teams (over a dozen) remains in the budget. Department of Police Accountability (DPA) - BLA Recommendations: $25,000 one-time reduction in FY21-22; no cuts in FY22-23. Department agreed. Public Defender’s Office - BLA Recommendations: $40,000 in FY21-22 ($13,000 ongoing, $27,000 one-time), plus $29,608 in prior-year encumbrances. FY22-23: $13,000 ongoing. Department agreed. District Attorney’s Office - BLA Recommendations: $26,774 one-time in FY21-22, plus $9,922 in prior-year encumbrances. No cuts in FY22-23. Department agreed. - Discussion: Supervisor Ronen jokingly asked if BLA recommended eliminating the chief of staff’s position. Sheriff’s Department - BLA Recommendations: $554,114 in FY21-22 ($462,190 ongoing, $91,924 one-time), plus $103,145 in prior-year encumbrances. FY22-23: $464,782 ongoing. Department agreed. - Discussion: Chair Haney asked about reduction in overtime from $25.1 million to $7.6 million in the current year due to CJ4 closure. CFO Kristen Holzhauser explained that FTE reductions (24 sworn positions and an overtime reduction equivalent to 84 FTEs) total 108 FTEs. The proposed budget adds $25 million largely for one-time capital costs ($11M) and COLA. Supervisor Marr inquired about 104 sworn vacancies (98 in jails, 23 elsewhere). The sheriff plans to fill 45 positions in the next fiscal year. Regarding DPH security replacement, 24 sworn positions will be reduced by March 2022, saving $1M in FY21-22 and $4M in FY22-23. Fire Department - BLA Recommendations: $560,146 in FY21-22 ($303,041 ongoing, $257,105 one-time), plus $5.8 million one-time reserves. FY22-23: $301,642 ongoing. Department agreed on technical cuts. - Discussion: The BLA outlined policy recommendations regarding new street teams (Street Wellness Response Team, Street Opioid Response Team, Street Crisis Response Team, and Community Paramedicine management). Total additional funding for these programs: $6.25 million in FY21-22, $7.07 million in FY22-23. The BLA recommended the board request an update by October 1, 2021, and consider a performance audit of all street response teams. Supervisor Safai highlighted that paramedic staffing has not increased since 2015 despite a 16% rise in calls. Fire Chief Nicholson confirmed the new teams will be overseen by Assistant Deputy Chief Simon Pang. Supervisor Ronen noted the need for a coordinated process among the many street teams, with DEM hosting a coordination role. The chief agreed to quarterly reports and an audit. Police Department - BLA Recommendations: $2.6 million in reductions for FY21-22 (0.45% of general fund) and $390,000 for FY22-23. The department did not agree. - Discussion: Chief Scott argued the cuts would harm reform efforts, hiring (goal of 100 new officers per year to offset attrition of 100), and public safety due to a 156% increase in shootings and rising crime. BLA’s Nicholas Minard stated the cuts are reasonable and won’t affect services. - Committee Members: - President Walton: Supported BLA cuts but also supported funding academies to maintain staffing. Noted the $40M baseline cut shifted to Dream Keeper initiative. - Supervisor Safai: Agreed with BLA cuts; expressed concern about overtime for side shows and demonstrations. - Supervisor Ronen: Questioned whether overtime and academy requests account for planned alternatives to policing (SCRT, wellness teams). Overtime budgeted at $15.6 million for FY21-22 and FY22-23. She noted that 51 officer FTEs respond to priority D calls and 44 to priority C calls (mental health/homelessness), arguing that as alternatives expand, these demands should decrease. - Supervisor Preston: Called for substantial cuts (10% reduction), citing Prop E allowing staffing flexibility, and suggested eliminating 5 sworn positions, cutting overtime by 50%, and disbanding the mounted unit ($1M/year). - BLA Clarification: Chair Haney asked about year-two increases; CFO Leong explained that annualization of the 100 recruits (27.5 FTEs in year one) and COLAs drive the increase. The general fund would increase from $573.8M (FY21) to about $574.5M under BLA cuts (a net increase of $0.7M). Key Outcomes - The committee expressed intent to accept the BLA’s recommendations for Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, Superior Court, DEM, DPA, Public Defender, DA, Sheriff, and Fire Department (technical recommendations). - For the Police Department, the committee accepted the BLA’s recommendations despite the chief’s opposition, but indicated further discussion would occur on June 25 and Monday. - The meeting recessed to June 25, 2021, at 10:00 a.m. for public comment and further action.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 31% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 24% · PUBLIC SAFETY 18% · PUBLIC FINANCE 7%
1244
JUN 23, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - June 23, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Haney, met on June 23, 2021 to consider the FY2021-2022 and FY2022-2023 budgets for multiple departments, as well as specific items including a retroactive agreement and the release of reserved funds. The committee accepted most departmental budgets with Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended reductions, but chose to reject a $60,000 cut for the Department on the Status of Women after the director opposed it. Public comment on the overall budget was scheduled for June 25, 2021. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (Resolution 210667): Unanimously (5-0) approved a retroactive agreement with the San Francisco Community Health Authority for a Medical Reimbursement Accounts Cash Grant Program, not to exceed $14,903,500, for a term from July 1, 2020 through December 31, 2021. Moved to full board with positive recommendation on July 13, 2021. - Item 4 (Hearing 210669): Unanimously (5-0) voted to release reserved funds of $68,099,127 to the Department of Public Health (DPH) for facilities acquisition and renovations, and $232,408,596 to the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) for housing acquisition and prevention interventions. The hearing was filed. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were received on items 3 or 4. Public comment on items 1 and 2 (budget ordinances) was scheduled for Friday, June 25, 2021 at 10 a.m. Discussion Items - Department of Public Health (DPH): Director Grant Colfax and BLA analyst Dan Gonscher presented. The BLA recommended reductions of $3,433,735 in FY21-22 (allowing a $42.2 million increase) and $1,321,352 in FY22-23. DPH accepted the recommendations. Supervisor Safai questioned $27 million for ongoing COVID-19 response in FY22-23, noting $14 million in general fund, and suggested revisiting. Supervisor Marr asked about mental health bed capacity: $10 transitional age youth residential treatment beds were funded, but no new beds for minors/children. Chair Haney noted the committee's intent to accept the budget with BLA recommendations. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): Director Abigail McSpaden and Deputy Director Gigi Whitley reported agreement with BLA recommendations of $5,708,425 in reductions in FY21-22 and $1,416,215 in prior year encumbrances (total $7,124,640 general fund savings). No reductions in FY22-23. They noted a reallocation of $34.8 million over two years to align with the Our City, Our Home committee, including hotel vouchers and navigation services. Supervisor Safai questioned the cost of safe sleeping sites ($57,000 per tent per year, $190 per night) and suggested funding only for one year. Supervisor Ronan echoed concerns about high costs. Chair Haney asked about data transparency and capital needs for permanent supportive housing. HSH noted a $3 million capital fund and plans to improve dashboarding. - Human Services Agency (HSA): Director Trent Rohr accepted BLA recommendations of $1,578,646 in reductions in FY21-22 (one-time). No reductions in FY22-23. Supervisor Melgar discussed Baby Prop C funding: $185.8 million programmed for FY21-22, $162.9 million for FY22-23, with $300 million left in reserve. She requested placing unprogrammed funds in reserve, which was noted as already in reserve. Supervisor Marr asked about staff support for the Veterans Affairs Commission; HSA proposed a commission secretary position costing $125,000 annually ($60,000-$65,000 general fund). Also discussed the Dignity Fund: of the $3 million annual increase, $1.5 million goes to cost-of-doing-business increases. Supervisor Safai asked about food programs; HSA detailed $14 million for community food hubs, $11.6 million for Great Plates (ending), and a gap for the Mission Food Hub limited to $1.4 million due to procurement caps. - Department on the Status of Women (DOSW): Director Kimberly Ellis opposed the BLA's recommended $60,000 reduction ($50,000 from city grants, $10,000 from professional services), arguing the department is under-resourced and needs the funds to address historic underspending due to understaffing. She noted that the majority of the budget increase is a $700,000 transfer from HSH for contract management without new staffing. BLA analyst Dan Gonscher justified the reduction based on historical underspending. President Walton and Chair Haney supported the director, noting new leadership and a plan to improve grant management. The committee voted to reject the BLA's $60,000 reduction but accepted the $29,622 in unencumbered funds. - Other Departments: The following departments all accepted BLA recommendations without debate: Retirement System ($374,256 reduction in FY21-22), Human Resources ($442,177 reduction in FY21-22), Public Library ($465,000 reduction in FY21-22), Asian Art Museum ($43,488 reduction in FY21-22), Fine Arts Museum (no reduction in FY21-22, $75,148 in FY22-23), Arts Commission ($100,884 reduction in FY21-22), War Memorial ($144,714 reduction in FY21-22), Recreation and Park ($710,004 reduction in FY21-22), and Department of Children, Youth and Their Families ($212,500 reduction in FY21-22). Key Outcomes - Unanimous votes: Items 3 and 4 passed 5-0. - Budget intent: The committee expressed intent to adopt the budget for DPH, HSH, HSA, Retirement, Human Resources, Public Library, Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museum, Arts Commission, War Memorial, Recreation and Park, and DCYF with BLA-recommended reductions. - DOSW exception: The committee voted to approve the DOSW budget without the BLA's $60,000 reduction, but with the $29,622 in unencumbered funds removed. This was a policy decision. - Next steps: The budget discussion continued on June 24, 2021 at 10 a.m. Public comment on items 1 and 2 occurred on June 25, 2021. - Directives: The committee requested further discussions with DPH on the $14 million general fund COVID response in FY22-23, with HSH on safe sleeping site costs and data transparency, and with HSA on food program gaps and Veterans Affairs Commission staffing. Note: The BLA report for DOSW noted that the majority of the department's budget increase is a transfer from HSH, not new grant funding. The meeting adjourned to June 24, 2021 at 10 a.m.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 38% · HOMELESSNESS 17% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · FOOD ACCESS 7%
1245
JUN 21, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting - June 21, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Haney and joined by President Walton and Supervisors Ronen, Safai, and Mar, met on June 21, 2021 to consider multiple appropriation and budget items for fiscal years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. The committee approved several items with positive recommendations to the full board, including San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) capital budget amendments, enterprise bond authorizations, supplemental appropriations for fixed-budget departments, and other financial ordinances. The bulk of the meeting focused on reviewing departmental budgets as part of the annual budget and salary ordinances (Files 210643 and 210644), with the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) presenting recommended reductions. Most departments agreed to the BLA's technical recommendations, but policy disagreements arose regarding funding for Moscone Convention Center rental incentives, additional 311 customer service positions, and two new small business permitting specialist positions at the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD). Public comment was heard on several items. Consent Calendar (The committee did not have a separate consent calendar; however, items 1–4, 7–8, 9–10, 11, 12, and 13 were approved unanimously with little or no discussion after staff presentations and BLA reports. These included routine approvals such as SFPUC bond amendments, fixed-budget department adjustments, Proposition J contract certifications, the access line tax CPI adjustment, the neighborhood beautification graffiti cleanup fund ceiling, and a certificate of participation authorization for capital projects.) Public Comments & Testimony - On Items 1-4 (SFPUC capital budget): Janice Boken, speaking on behalf of the Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods and personally, urged the committee to continue the items and hold a hearing on the PUC's $6 billion debt portfolio before the board's summer recess, citing concerns about being blindsided as with the former PUC general manager. - On Items 7-8 (Fixed-budget departments): Anita Ekinem, Chair of the SFPUC Citizens Advisory Committee, spoke in support of the budget and FTE allocations for the SFPUC, highlighting the need for positions dedicated to racial equity work. - On Items 9-10 (Prop J contract certification for DPH): Dave Canego, an employee at Curry Senior Center, advocated for the peer-based client safety services model, noting that their experience with St. Anthony's client safety services had reduced incidents, and he supported the proposal to replace sheriff deputies with community-based safety staff. - On Items 5-6 (Main budget ordinances): No public comment was taken at this meeting; it was scheduled for Friday, June 25, 2021 at 10 a.m. Discussion Items Items 1-4: SFPUC Capital Budget and Bond Authorizations - Charles Pearl, SFPUC Deputy CFO, presented four items: (1) appropriation of $19,344,824 for Hetch Hetchy power capital improvements and re-appropriations of $2,000,000 from Low Carbon Fuel Standard and $6,843,536 from Hetchy Revenue; (2) appropriation of $213,511,178 for wastewater capital improvements and re-appropriation of $42,900,587; (3) amendment to increase power revenue bond authorization from $143 million to $162,314,897; (4) amendment to increase wastewater revenue bond authorization to $563,430,430. - Key changes: $213.5 million increase in wastewater enterprise mainly due to revised schedule for the Biosolids project at the Southeast Wastewater Treatment Plant; $6 million increase for green infrastructure grants; $17.3 million increase in Hetch Hetchy enterprise mainly for Bay Corridor transmission project; offsetting reductions of approximately $40 million in wastewater and $7 million in power from other projects. - BLA (Nick Minard) recommended approval of items 1 and 3 as is, and items 2 and 4 with an amendment on item 4 to require that if refunding bonds are issued, a savings report and official statement be submitted to the Board of Supervisors. - After discussion, the committee voted 5-0 to amend item 4 with the BLA language and then 5-0 to send items 1-4 to the full board on July 13 with a positive recommendation. Items 5-6: Annual Budget and Salary Ordinances – Departmental Reviews - The committee heard from approximately 18 departments that had agreed to BLA-recommended reductions. The BLA (Dan Gonsher) presented summaries. All departments listed below were in full agreement except where noted: - Department of Building Inspection: $1,030,064 in FY21-22 ($578,064 ongoing, $425,000 one-time); $425,000 ongoing in FY22-23. - City Planning: $441,881 in FY21-22 ($291,881 ongoing, $150,000 one-time); $300,000 ongoing in FY22-23. - General City Responsibility: $400,000 one-time in FY21-22 only (correction made from draft). - City Attorney: $467,530 one-time in FY21-22. - Office of the City Administrator: Non-policy reductions of $1,003,253 in FY21-22 ($249,575 ongoing, $781,678 one-time) plus $110,000 encumbrance closeout; $355,295 ongoing in FY22-23. Policy disagreements remain on Moscone incentives and 311 positions (see below). - Department of Technology: $652,457 one-time in FY21-22 plus $27,466 encumbrance closeout and $488,107 current year savings; no FY22-23 reductions. - Department of Public Works: $751,011 in FY21-22 ($606,011 ongoing, $145,000 one-time); $621,528 ongoing in FY22-23. One position cut agreed. - Mayor's Office: $231,673 ongoing in FY21-22; $231,648 ongoing in FY22-23. - Ethics Commission: No reductions. - Department of Elections: $85,000 in FY21-22 ($10,000 ongoing, $75,000 one-time) plus $945,998 encumbrance closeout; $10,000 ongoing in FY22-23. - Department of Environment: $82,725 in FY21-22 ($20,000 ongoing, $62,725 one-time) plus $34,264 encumbrance closeout; $20,000 ongoing in FY22-23. - Human Rights Commission: $275,000 in FY21-22 ($25,000 ongoing, $250,000 one-time) plus $31,265 encumbrance closeout; $25,000 ongoing in FY22-23. - Board of Supervisors: $11,907 one-time in FY21-22 plus $1,300 encumbrance closeout; no FY22-23 reductions. - Assessor-Recorder: $197,500 in FY21-22 ($167,500 ongoing, $30,000 one-time); $167,500 ongoing in FY22-23 (revised from $250,000 after negotiation). - Treasurer & Tax Collector: $286,467 in FY21-22 ($152,879 ongoing, $133,589 one-time); $156,177 ongoing in FY22-23 (revised to include $20,000 new reduction and adjusted attrition). - Controller: $475,708 one-time in FY21-22 plus $6,225 encumbrance closeout; $119,451 one-time in FY22-23. - Policy disagreements (deferred for later decision): 1. Moscone Convention Center rental incentives (City Administrator): The BLA recommended deleting $2.6 million in FY21-22 and $2.0 million in FY22-23 for rental incentives to attract conventions. The City Administrator argued that incentives are critical for competitiveness (other cities offer 100% rent forgiveness) and that the funding is a two-year stopgap because hotel assessment revenue has collapsed. Estimated benefits: $173 million in direct convention spending and 140,000–150,000 room nights. Supervisor Safai suggested possibly funding year one and evaluating year two. 2. 311 Customer Service positions (City Administrator): Original request was 10 new positions to divert non-emergency calls from 911. BLA recommended deleting 2 (agreed) and placing remaining 8 on reserve pending an implementation plan. The department requested 3 positions be released immediately for training (6–9 months). Implementation timeline depends on a new project manager in the Mayor's Office (to be hired by October 2021) and coordination across departments. 3. OEWD Small Business Permitting Specialists: BLA recommended denying 2 new positions ($261,415 ongoing) due to insufficient justification and potential overlap with existing permit center staff (9 FTEs) and contractor services. Director Kate Sofis argued the positions are essential for providing concierge-level, end-to-end support to small businesses, especially during recovery, and would be distinct from generalists. The committee deferred a decision. - The committee expressed intent to accept all departmental budgets with BLA recommendations as presented, with policy decisions pending further discussion before the final budget vote. Items 7-8: Fixed-Budget Departments – Airport, Port, SFPUC Supplemental Appropriations - Risa Sandler (Controller's Office) explained that the supplemental appropriations are required because changes exceeded the 5% threshold for fixed-budget departments. - Item 7: Appropriation of $20,716,252 to SFPUC, and reductions of $272,379,116 at Airport and $17,664,260 at Port. - Item 8: Salary ordinance amendments for position substitutions/additions: 3 at Airport, 9 substitutions and 24 new positions at SFPUC. BLA recommended a minor amendment (delete 0.77 FTE of an 1823 position and change 0.77 FTE of 0933 to 0932), which the PUC accepted. - The committee voted 5-0 to amend item 8 per BLA, then 5-0 to send items 7-8 to the full board on July 13. Items 9-10: Proposition J Contract Certifications - Item 9: Certification for contracted security services at DPH primary care and behavioral health clinics, replacing sheriff deputies with a community-based organization providing client safety services (de-escalation, navigation, peer support). Dr. Hallie Hammer described the model as already successful at two sites (Medical Respite & Sobering Center, Curry Senior Center). - Item 10: Certification for previously approved contracted services. - No BLA report. After public comment in support, the committee voted 5-0 to send to full board on July 13. Item 11: Access Line Tax CPI Adjustment - Controller's office reported a 2.00% inflation index (measured December to December), resulting in an increase to the access line tax, which is assumed in the proposed budget. Approved 5-0. Item 12: Neighborhood Beautification and Graffiti Cleanup Fund Tax Designation Ceiling - The controller calculated the maximum percentage taxpayers can designate to this fund (Community Challenge Grant Program) to maintain a $1 million balance adjusted for inflation. Supervisor Ronen praised the program. Approved 5-0. Item 13: Certificates of Participation (COP) – Not to Exceed $67.5 Million - Kate Faust (Office of Resilience & Capital Planning) presented projects: San Francisco Wholesale Produce Market improvements, Better Market Street (5th–8th streets), new child care center at Zuckerberg SF General (recovery stimulus); and critical repairs for capital renewal projects. Luke Brewer (Controller's Office) described the structure as lease-backed COPs with an estimated annual lease payment of $5 million at 4.75% interest over 20 years. BLA noted a $2 million contingency for future grant matching, a new purpose but consistent with debt policies. Approved 5-0. Key Outcomes - Items 1-4 (SFPUC): Approved as amended (amendment on wastewater refunding bond reporting) and forwarded to full board on July 13, 2021 with a positive recommendation. - Items 5-6 (Department Budgets): The committee accepted BLA technical recommendations for all departments. Policy decisions on Moscone incentives, 311 positions, and OEWD small business specialists were deferred for further discussion before the committee's next hearing on June 23 or before the final budget vote on June 25. - Items 7-8 (Fixed-budget supplements): Approved as amended and forwarded to full board on July 13. - Items 9-10 (Prop J): Approved and forwarded to full board on July 13. - Item 11 (Access line tax): Approved and forwarded to full board on July 13. - Item 12 (Graffiti fund ceiling): Approved and forwarded to full board on July 13. - Item 13 (COPs): Approved and forwarded to full board on July 13. - The meeting recessed to Wednesday, June 23, 2021 at 10 a.m.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 45% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 8% · PROCEDURAL 7%
1246
JUN 17, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 17, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on June 17, 2021, from 6:00 PM to late evening to hear presentations from ten city departments on the proposed budget and appropriation ordinances for fiscal years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. The meeting included presentations from the Fire Department, Juvenile Probation, Adult Probation, Superior Court, Department of Emergency Management (DEM), Police Department (SFPD), Department of Police Accountability (DPA), Public Defender’s Office, District Attorney’s Office, and Sheriff’s Office. Public comment was taken at the end. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple callers urged the committee to defund the police and sheriff and reallocate funds to community-based programs and alternative response teams. Many specifically requested a reduction of at least $24 million from the sheriff’s budget, reflecting the closure of County Jail 4. - Several speakers called for fully funding the Budget Justice Coalition, the Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART), and union-represented community safety teams for hospitals and clinics. - One caller supported the fire department’s request for funding for additional hose tenders to enhance the emergency firefighting water system. - A caller from the DSA urged using the sheriff’s department more broadly, including at the airport, to supplement police. Discussion Items - Fire Department: Chief Janine Nicholson and team presented on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, community paramedicine expansion (including street wellness and overdose response teams), and the need for additional ambulance staffing. They noted that call volume has increased 16% since 2015 while staffing has remained flat, leading to concerns about response times. The department requested $5.8 million for a new training facility and funding for a five-year fleet replacement plan. - Juvenile Probation: Director Miller discussed racial equity efforts, reduced staffing (24% reduction in probation officers), and the closure of the Division of Juvenile Justice (DJJ) leading to state revenue increases. She clarified that the log cabin ranch allocation ($5.3 million) is for security and positions that were transitioned years ago, and that the ranch is not operating. Overtime is high due to pandemic-related absences and training. The department has nine vacancies. - Adult Probation: Chief Fletcher presented on a $6 million increase primarily from state realignment funds, not new positions. The department is launching a $3.6 million therapeutic residential community (TRC) for addiction recovery, contracted to a Black-led CBO. They also plan to transition from the COMPASS pretrial risk assessment tool due to bias concerns. - Superior Court: CEO Mike Yuen presented on the civil grand jury and indigent defense administration (IDA) programs. The budget is largely flat, with a $50,000 increase to cover shortfalls. No reductions were made to IDA due to workload backlog. - Department of Emergency Management (DEM): Director Mary Ellen Carroll highlighted COVID response, the closure of COVID Command by June 30, 2021, and the ongoing role of the Healthy Streets Operations Center (HSOC) in addressing encampments. She noted that police involvement in HSOC has diminished, with EMS6 and street crisis teams taking the lead. The department requested $7.9 million for continued COVID response and $12 million for a new computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system. - Police Department: Chief Scott presented on staffing shortages, with 100 recruit hires needed to maintain current levels. He noted that overtime budget is proposed at $15.6 million, up from $12.4 million, but still below 2019 levels. The department requested $1.5 million for technology to complete 16 of 19 remaining California DOJ collaborative reform initiatives. There was extensive discussion on racial disparities in stops and searches, alternative responses (e.g., street crisis response teams), and the need for foot patrols. The overall police budget shows a decrease of $6.7 million from the current year, but an increase of $5.9 million compared to the previously adopted FY22 budget. Year two includes a larger increase due to technology and annualized academy costs. - Department of Police Accountability (DPA): Director Henderson emphasized the department's transparency, independent investigations, and compliance with language access. DPA has handled over 29,000 pages of SB 1421 records. The budget is relatively flat, with a request to make 1421 positions permanent. Henderson stressed the need for technology that is compatible with SFPD’s systems to share data. - Public Defender’s Office: Public Defender Raju highlighted the systemic underfunding of the office compared to law enforcement (police budget 15 times larger). He noted a 52% increase in cases and called for expanded pre-trial release, clean slate expungement, and data capabilities. The office has 57% attorneys of color. He urged the board to prioritize equity two days before Juneteenth. - District Attorney’s Office: DA Boudin presented on the budget returning to pre-COVID levels, with almost all funding for staff and office space. He discussed a pilot restorative justice program for property crime victims in District 5 and the need for more Cantonese-speaking victim advocates. He also noted that the proposed fentanyl task force was not funded, and he advocated for a public health approach to drug use. - Sheriff’s Office: Sheriff Miyamoto and CFO Crispin Holland presented on a 40% reduction in overtime over two years, but noted challenges from COVID leave and a hiring freeze. The budget increases by $25 million, mostly due to capital spending ($11 million for fire safety and security electronics) and salary COLAs. The closure of County Jail 4 saved 90 FTEs, but those were offset by transfers and other needs. The department is reducing sworn staff at DPH locations. Key Outcomes - The committee continued items 1 and 2 (Budget and Appropriation Ordinance and Annual Salary Ordinance) to the June 21, 2021 Budget and Appropriations Committee meeting for further consideration. No vote was taken on the budget proposals themselves. - The committee received extensive public testimony and will consider the input as they deliberate on final budget decisions.

PROCEDURAL 19% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 16% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 9%
1247
JUN 16, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Meeting – June 16, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Matt Haney, met on June 16, 2021, from 18:15 to approximately 22:00, to review and take action on the Mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. The committee heard presentations from over a dozen city departments, including Public Health, Human Services, Homelessness and Supportive Housing, Libraries, Arts Commission, and others. Public comment was extensive, with callers addressing child care funding, homelessness services, Prop C allocations, and library security. The committee voted to send several items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations and continued other items for further discussion. Consent Calendar - Approved item 3 (Patient Rates for DPH) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. - Approved item 4 (Acceptance of State Grant Funds for DPH) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. - Approved item 5 (EMS Fees transfer to DEM) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. - Approved item 6 (Homelessness and Supportive Housing Fund Expenditure Plan) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. - Approved items 7 and 8 (Library Grants from Friends of SFPL) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. - Approved item 9 (Rent Board Fee Collection Ordinance) to the full board with a 5-0 vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Dozens of callers provided public comment on items 1 and 2 (the overall budget), focusing on child care funding, Prop C allocations for homelessness, library security, and the need for affordable housing. - Several callers urged the committee to fully fund the Our City, Our Home Oversight Committee's budget recommendations and respect the voter intent of Prop C and Prop I. - Library employees and advocates called for increased security staffing (BGPOs) at branch libraries. - Parents and child care advocates asked for restoration of $900,000 for child care resource and referral and adherence to Prop C funding priorities. Discussion Items - Department of Public Health (DPH): Director Grant Colfax presented a $2.8 billion budget emphasizing racial equity, behavioral health investments (including Mental Health SF implementation and overdose prevention), and ongoing COVID-19 response. Supervisors questioned the cost of overdose prevention programs, the effectiveness of sheriff reductions at Zuckerberg San Francisco General, and the need for expanded subacute care beds. - Human Services Agency (HSA): Director Trent Rhorer presented budgets for the Department of Disability and Aging Services (DOS), Office of Early Care and Education (OECE), and Department of Benefits and Family Support. Discussion included concerns about using Prop C funds for family resource centers, food security programs, and the gap in funding for the Latino Task Force food hub. - Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): Director Shireen McSpadden presented a $1 billion+ budget over two years, including 800-1,000 new PSH units, 1,500 flex housing subsidies, safe parking sites, and safe sleeping sites. Supervisors raised concerns about the high cost of safe sleeping ($57,000 per tent) and the need for geographic equity in siting services. - First 5 San Francisco: Director Teresa Zagar presented a $28 million budget focused on early childhood support, racial equity planning, and the upcoming merger with OECE. - Asian Art Museum, Fine Arts Museums, Academy of Sciences, Arts Commission, War Memorial, Recreation and Parks, Department of Children, Youth and Their Families, Child Support Services: Each department presented its budget and priorities. Significant discussions included learning loss recovery ($15 million for RISE), mental health services for middle schools, and the need for expanded security at libraries. - Item 10 (Prop I supplemental amendment): Supervisor Preston proposed amending the ordinance to allocate $128.3 million from fiscal cliff reserves to rent relief and social housing, citing unmet need from COVID-19. After debate, the committee voted to approve the amendments (5-0) and continue the item to the call of the chair for further consideration. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (5-0) to send items 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9 to the full Board of Supervisors on July 13, 2021, with positive recommendations. - Items 1 and 2 (the main budget and salary ordinances) were continued to the June 17, 2021, meeting. - Item 10 (Prop I supplemental) was amended to reflect a $128.3 million allocation from reserves for rent relief and social housing, and then continued to the call of the chair for further discussion.

PUBLIC HEALTH 18% · HOMELESSNESS 13% · PROCEDURAL 7% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 7%
1248
JUN 14, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting - June 14, 2021

The committee met on Monday, June 14, 2021, from 11:00 AM to after 9:00 PM, with a lunch recess from 12:30 PM to 1:15 PM. Chair Matt Haney presided, joined by Vice Chair Safai and Supervisors Walton, Mar, and Ronan. The committee reviewed and voted on interim budget items, heard presentations from 18 city departments, and accepted public testimony on the proposed two-year budget for fiscal years 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. Key themes included oversight, accountability, racial equity, and post-COVID recovery investments. Consent Calendar - Items 1, 2, 7, 8 (Interim budget and salary ordinances, OCI budget and bond issuance) were approved unanimously (5-0) and forwarded to the full Board for June 22, 2021, or July 13, 2021, respectively. - Items 3 and 4 (Hearings on administrative provisions) were filed without objection. - Items 9 and 10 (Official advertising and outreach newspaper designations) were approved (4-0-1, with Vice Chair Safai absent) and forwarded to the July 13, 2021 Board meeting. - Item 11 (Street artist certificate fee reduction from $849 to $0 via $80 legislative reduction and $80 rebate) was approved (4-0-1) and forwarded to July 13, 2021. - Item 12 (Cost of living adjustment for the BLA contract, an increase of $38,411) was approved (4-0-1) and forwarded to July 13, 2021. Public Comments & Testimony - Over a dozen callers provided public comment at the end of the meeting on items 5 and 6. Several speakers from community organizations (e.g., Filipino Community Center, Chinese for Affirmative Action, Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco Rising, SEIU 1021, climate advocacy groups) urged restoration of funding for immigrant rapid response, tenant counseling, workforce development, and climate equity proposals (e.g., 1% of the city budget for climate action). A few callers also supported the climate equity hub and sustainable funding roadmap. Discussion Items - Departmental Presentations (18 departments): - OEWD: Director Sofus highlighted $45M in new investments for small business relief, workforce recovery, and a city-core ambassador program ($12M). Two new permitting specialist positions added. Seventy-two percent of grants went to minority-owned businesses. Responded to questions on commercial eviction protections and equity. - DBI: Acting Director O’Reardon reported a $89.9M budget, 20 vacant positions, and technology upgrades. Addressed backlog, whistleblower reporting, and compliance with the new bad-actor legislation. - Planning: Director Hillis noted a $60M fee-revenue-driven budget, 34 vacancies, and the new Community Equity Division focused on racial and social equity. Discussed Prop H implementation, shared spaces program, and west-side planning. - Assessor-Recorder: Assessor Torres presented a $39M budget, 28 vacancies, and a $27M recovery in underpaid taxes. Emphasized technology improvements and racial equity efforts including an appraiser trainee program. - Treasurer: Treasurer Cisneros budgeted $26.1M in general fund support, 14 exempt positions, and continued fee waivers. Work on guaranteed income pilots, digital payments (33% growth), and language access improvements. - Controller: Controller Rosenfield outlined $77.4M budget, 4 new positions for public integrity and performance auditing. Updated on street cleanliness inspections restarting, cybersecurity, and contracting equity reporting. - General City Responsibility: Michelle Allersma explained this non-operational department (no staff) holds citywide revenues and baseline transfers (e.g., MTA, libraries). - City Administrator: Administrator Chu reviewed $550M budget, 950 FTE (233 vacancies). Highlights included Prop B implementation, digital equity (fiber to public housing), language access scaling, and Moscone convention incentives. - City Attorney: Attorney Herrera presented a $99M budget, 32 vacancies, and ongoing public integrity investigations (e.g., Recology settlement recovering $100M). Discussed technology upgrades and family-friendly remote work policy. - Department of Technology: Director Grewal reported $49M pass-through for hardware/software, 30 vacancies, 27 exempt positions, and digital equity initiatives (fiber to affordable housing, text-to-911, expanded language access). - Human Rights Commission: Director Davis described $4.8M investment split with OEWD, support for Dreamkeeper, reparations task force, and Office of Sharp. Noted need for more staff to manage equity plans and language access. - Public Works: Acting Director DeGraffenreid presented $350M budget, 233 vacancies (105 operational), and a $3M increase in clean corridors program. Addressed pit stop bathroom reductions (from 60 to 25 permanent) and the clean corridors SF program. - MOHCD: Director Shaw proposed $219M budget, 7 vacancies, and $10M housing innovation fund. Discussed right-to-counsel full funding, Prop I implementation, and tenant outreach needs. - Mayor’s Office: Budget Director Groffenberger presented $9.7M budget including a new Mayor’s Office of Justice Innovation (3 positions: victim rights advocate, call diversion project manager, support). - Ethics Commission: Deputy Director Takemoto requested 8 new positions (total 33) to enhance investigative capacity, ethics training, and program performance reporting. - Board of Appeals: Executive Director Rosenberg presented a flat budget with one vacancy and proposed fee surcharge increases (planning/DBI from $20 to $22.50, DPW from $7 to $9, DPH from $46 to $50.50). - Department of Elections: Director Arntz outlined $8.3M estimated cost for upcoming recall election (pending state reimbursement), 2 vacancies, and outreach to vulnerable voters. - SF Environment: Director Raphael noted no general fund support; $19M budget decrease due to expiry of multi-year grants. Advocated for funding for a climate equity hub and sustainable revenue study. - Board of Supervisors/Clerk: Clerk Calvio presented a $922K increase (5%) for fiscal year 2022, including a request to reclassify administrative assistants to legislative assistants (cost $600K) and $45K for language access after 5:30 PM. Key Outcomes - Items 1, 2, 7, 8 moved to full board with positive recommendations. - Items 3, 4 filed. - Items 9, 10, 11, 12 moved to full board with positive recommendations. - Items 5 and 6 (main budget ordinances) were continued to the June 16, 2021, committee meeting. - Multiple departments noted pending BLA reports and follow-up for next week. - The committee committed to further discussions on pit stops, language access staffing, climate equity funding, and immigrant services restoration.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 15% · PROCEDURAL 13% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 7% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 6%
1249
JUN 11, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - June 11, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 11, 2021, at 10:15 AM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Supervisors Shamann Walton and Rafael Mandelman present. Vice Chair Connie Chan was excused. The committee reviewed eight items, including employee compensation, contract amendments, and a major lease agreement. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - No separate consent calendar was designated; all items were discussed individually but approved with minimal debate. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (HealthRIGHT 360 COVID-19 contract): One caller opposed the $11.9 million increase, arguing that high vaccination rates made the expenditure unnecessary and that funds should go to other needs. A second caller supported the extension, noting that FEMA reimburses the cost and that outreach to underserved communities remains important. - No public comments were received on other agenda items. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Unrepresented Employee Compensation): Steve Ponder, Compensation Director, presented an ordinance fixing wages for unrepresented employees (mostly in the Mayor’s Office). Most employees receive a 3% increase phased in, while some (e.g., 1280 labor relations class and AB 44 attorney) receive higher amounts due to market adjustments. Discussion focused on why many lower-paid staff are unrepresented and the urgency of approving before June 30. Deputy City Attorney Brad Rossi clarified that approval after June 30 would prevent retroactive implementation. The committee voted to forward the item to the full board on June 22, not as a committee report, to allow more time for questions. - Item 2 (SEIU 1021 Nurses MOU): The second amendment allows carryover of unused tuition reimbursement funds from FY2021 to FY2022. The committee voted to recommend it as a committee report for the June 15 board meeting. - Item 3 (CalMHSA Tech Suite): Teresa Yu from DPH described a statewide mental health innovation program that funds technology-based solutions (e.g., peer chat app, Headspace mindfulness). The amendment extends the term to May 2024 and increases the amount to $10 million, but the actual budget is lower. Supervisor Mandelman questioned the use of $10 million for a texting service amid acute mental health needs. The committee recommended approval as a committee report. - Item 4 (HealthRIGHT 360 I&Q Contract): DPH’s Ms. Hiramoto requested a 1-year extension and $11.9 million increase to maintain one isolation/quarantine hotel (64 beds) due to potential variant surges. Supervisor Preston asked about wind-down triggers and interim use of rooms. BLA confirmed the contract is fully FEMA-reimbursable. The committee recommended approval as a committee report. - Items 5 & 6 (Medline Supply Contracts): Daisy Aguaio (DPH supply chain) presented two 6-year contracts for medical supplies: bulk distribution ($115 million) and low-unit-of-measure distribution ($178 million). BLA recommended reducing the not-to-exceed amounts by removing holdover budgets. The committee adopted amendments and forwarded recommendations to the full board as committee reports. - Item 7 (St. Vincent de Paul Navigation Center): Emily Cohen from HSH presented a 4-year extension and $30 million increase (total $40 million) for the Division Circle Navigation Center (186 beds, currently operating at 77 due to COVID). The committee recommended approval as a committee report. - Item 8 (AT&T Lease at SFO): Airport representatives Kathy Widener and Dee Casada described a 10-year lease where AT&T will manage a neutral-host cellular network at SFO, paying $2.4 million annual base rent plus a one-time $28.6 million reimbursement for infrastructure. AT&T will proportionally collect costs from all cellular partners. Supervisor Preston questioned the business model. The committee recommended approval as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unrepresented employee compensation ordinance forwarded to the full board on June 22, 2021 (not as a committee report). Vote: 3-0. - Item 2: SEIU 1021 MOU amendment recommended as a committee report for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0. - Item 3: CalMHSA Tech Suite amendment recommended as a committee report for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0. - Item 4: HealthRIGHT 360 contract amendment recommended as a committee report for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0. - Items 5 & 6: Medline contracts amended per BLA recommendations and recommended as committee reports for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0. - Item 7: St. Vincent de Paul grant amendment recommended as a committee report for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0. - Item 8: AT&T lease agreement recommended as a committee report for June 15, 2021. Vote: 3-0.

PUBLIC COMMENT 24% · PUBLIC HEALTH 20% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 14% · PROCEDURAL 12%
1250
JUN 10, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - June 10, 2021

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on June 10, 2021, to consider four agenda items: a resolution supporting a Compassionate Alternative Response Team (CART) for homelessness, a hearing on 24-hour public bathroom access, an ordinance to make permanent a cap on third-party food delivery fees, and a follow-up hearing on anti-Asian violence (continued). The meeting included extensive public testimony and detailed discussions on funding, coordination, and implementation. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 – CART Resolution - Over a dozen callers voiced strong support for CART, urging funding and implementation. Speakers included representatives from the San Francisco Youth Commission, Housing Rights Committee, HomeRise, Coalition on Homelessness, and other community groups. They cited the need to replace police response with compassionate, peer-led teams and highlighted the trauma caused by current systems. Several callers emphasized that CART should be funded by reallocating from the SFPD budget. - One caller (Francisco De Costa) expressed skepticism, arguing that the city must follow laws and standards and that taxpayers are not satisfied with quality of life issues. Item 2 – Public Bathroom Access - Callers overwhelmingly supported expanding 24-hour pit stops. Speakers included representatives from Glide, the Coalition on Homelessness, TNDC, and residents. They described the lack of bathrooms as a human rights issue and were shocked to learn of planned reductions. One caller (Adam) noted that a pit stop in Eastern Soma was removed without community notification. - No callers opposed bathroom access. Item 3 – Food Delivery Fee Cap - Several callers, including delivery drivers (DoorDashers) and the Latino Restaurant Association, opposed making the 15% fee cap permanent, arguing it would reduce driver earnings and increase consumer prices. Pastor Lawrence Van Hook warned it would harm African American communities. - Other callers, including restaurant owners Lori Thomas and Brian Tublin, supported the cap as necessary for restaurant survival and called for clear contract terms. The Golden Gate Restaurant Association endorsed the legislation with amendments. Discussion Items Item 1 – Resolution Supporting CART (Compassionate Alternative Response Team) - Supervisor Haney introduced the resolution, noting that police respond to 179 homelessness-related calls daily and that 45% of C-priority calls are homelessness-related. Community presenters (Gwen Westbrook, Wesley Saber, Adriana Camarena, Vinnie) detailed the proposal: a 24/7 non-police response team prioritizing peers with lived experience, costing an estimated $6.825 million annually (based on 65,000 calls, 52 staff, and 500 hours of training). - Chief Nicholson and Chief Pang from the Fire Department raised concerns about coordination, medical response, and potential delays. They noted that the existing Street Crisis Response Team (SCRT) and community paramedicine programs already handle many similar calls. Supervisor Stephanie expressed concern that CART and existing services had not fully worked out integration and questioned the $6.8 million ask. She emphasized the need for collaboration. - Supervisor Haney clarified that the resolution is a statement of support and that operational details remain to be resolved. The committee heard that a separate direct hotline and a two-pronged approach (immediate response and community capacity building) are part of the design. Item 2 – Hearing on 24-Hour Public Bathroom Access - DPW Director DeGraffenreed and Program Manager Jonathan Gumwalk presented data: the Pit Stop program grew from 24 to 60 sites during the pandemic, but as of May 2021, only 36 sites remained (25 permanent, 11 temporary). Of these, 14 sites operate 24/7. Annual costs for the current configuration are about $13 million. The proposed mayor's budget includes only $4.6 million, which would eliminate all 24-hour bathrooms and return to pre-pandemic levels (25 sites, three 24/7). - The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) reported that in May 2020, 55 pit stops (136 toilets) existed; in May 2021, 36 pit stops (123 toilets) remain. The UN standard (one toilet per 50 unsheltered persons) is met during daytime (123 toilets vs. 104 needed) but not at night (only 22 toilets). Removal of 20 temporary restrooms was attributed to funding constraints, not declining use. Supervisor Haney called the planned elimination of 24-hour bathrooms “brutally unacceptable” and committed to restoring funding through the budget process. - Public comment emphasized that bathroom access is a human right and that cuts would harm public health and dignity. Item 3 – Ordinance to Remove Sunset on Food Delivery Fee Cap - Lee Hefner (Supervisor Peskin’s office) presented the ordinance, which would make permanent the 15% cap on delivery commissions and other protections (menu price setting, no unauthorized listings). He noted ongoing amendments to allow separate contracts for non-delivery services (e.g., marketing). The Golden Gate Restaurant Association supported the legislation. Opponents (delivery platforms, drivers) argued that price caps harm restaurants, drivers, and consumers, citing examples from Oakland where consumer prices rose $2 per order. - The committee discussed timing: the sunset clause is tied to 60 days after 100% indoor dining resumes. To avoid a gap in protection, the committee agreed to duplicate the file, continue the duplicated file to call of the chair, and forward the original ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 4 – Hearing on Anti-Asian Violence - Chair Maher noted that the Human Rights Commission is still working on a comprehensive citywide plan, so the hearing was continued to the call of the chair. No public comment was received. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward the resolution supporting CART to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to file the hearing (concluding the hearing) passed unanimously (3-0). Supervisor Haney expressed intent to work on restoring funding for 24-hour bathrooms in the budget. - Item 3: Motion to duplicate the ordinance, continue the duplicated file to the call of the chair, and forward the original ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). This ensures no gap in the fee cap while amendments are finalized. - Item 4: Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed unanimously (3-0).

HOMELESSNESS 29% · PUBLIC HEALTH 18% · PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com