Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1231–1240 ENTRIES
1231
SEP 14, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - September 14, 2021

The Port Commission met on September 14, 2021, from 2:00 PM to 5:37 PM. The meeting included approval of minutes, a closed session (challenged by a public commenter), reports from the Executive Director, approval of a grant for Heron's Head Park, informational presentations on the Pier 70 RFP for Building 49 and the NICE building, a proposal for a lease at Pier 70 shipyard, and a new communications policy for competitive solicitations. Several items were approved unanimously, while the NICE building RFP will be brought back after further analysis. Consent Calendar - Item 10a – Resolution 2135: Retroactive authorization to modify Construction Contract No. 2813 for 19th and Georgia Street Roadway Improvements to extend the substantial completion date. - Item 10b – Resolution 2136: Approval of consent to sublease between Blue and Gold Fleet, L.P. and VP San Francisco, LLC for a month-to-month term to operate a retail shop at Pier 41. - Item 10c – Resolution 2137: Approval of Memorandum of Understanding M-16811 with the Recreation and Park Department for rent-free use of Port submerged lands beneath a dock at 502 and 504 Jefferson Street in Aquatic Park. All three items were approved unanimously by a roll call vote (President Brandon, Vice President Adams, Commissioner Wuho, Commissioner Gilman). Public Comments & Testimony - Executive Session (Item 3): One anonymous caller stated that the closed session agenda was unlawfully noticed because it did not include the required language for conference with legal counsel. The caller noted that the agenda was later amended to cite real estate negotiations but was posted less than 72 hours prior, and they urged the commission not to proceed. The commission proceeded with closed session after a motion to not disclose items. - Public Comment on Items Not on Agenda (Item 8): One speaker (unnamed) expressed full support for the Dog Patch Paddle Club and their proposal for Building 49, citing a successful paddleboarding event for youth with disabilities at Crane Cove Park. The speaker described the club as generous stewards of the land. - Item 12A – Building 49 and NICE Building RFP: Five public commenters spoke: - Charles Collins (Bayview Alliance) supported the Port's vision and the YMCA proposal for Building 49. - Sarah King, a 17-year resident of Potrero Hill, supported the YMCA/Dog Patch Paddle partnership, describing personal and family experiences with Dog Patch Paddle. - Paul Osmondson (Premier Structures) thanked the commission for the opportunity to submit a proposal for the NICE building. - Terry Heffernan (Dog Patch Studios) supported Premier Structures' proposal for the NICE building, citing their quality and ability to get things done. - J.R. Etler (Potrero Boosters Merchants Association, Friends of Dog Patch Hub) supported the YMCA proposal for Building 49 and expressed hope that the Port can create an opportunity at the NICE building that meets all needs. - Two additional callers: Jeffrey Johnson (Luster National) supported Premier Structures, emphasizing equity and community engagement; Ryan Lee (member of Premier Structures design team) supported the NICE building proposal, highlighting its integration with Crane Cove Park. One final caller, Jeff Carter (former employee of Bethlehem Shipyard), supported the YMCA proposal for Building 49 and appreciated the Port's efforts. - Item 13A – Silverado Shipyard Lease: One public commenter, Alan Jonk (co-chair of Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee), spoke in favor of the pilot program, calling it creative and exciting for maritime reuse. A second caller, Scott Clough (Silverado Contractors), thanked the commission and staff for the opportunity. - Item 14A – Competitive Selection Process Policy: One caller, Francisco de Costa, expressed skepticism about the controller's office's ability to ensure transparency, citing corruption at the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported on emergency preparedness, vaccination progress (nearly 80% of eligible San Franciscans fully vaccinated, nearly 90% of city workforce vaccinated), the November 1 vaccination deadline for city employees, a pop-up vaccination clinic on September 23, launch of racial equity training, a sidewalk vendor program workshop with 50 attendees, and the Heron's Head Park Shoreline Resilience Project. She also announced that Crane Cove Park won the 2021 American Society of Civil Engineers San Francisco Section Award. - Item 11A – Heron's Head Park Shoreline Resilience Project Grant: Carol Bach presented a request to accept $1,493,000 from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for shoreline stabilization. The project includes a living shoreline approach with a coarse sand and gravel beach and enhanced wetland habitat. The port will also seek additional funding (88% of construction costs already covered by this grant and an Ocean Protection Council grant). The project must be constructed between August and January to protect fish and wildlife. The grant requires the Port to maintain the park for habitat protection and public access. The resolution was adopted unanimously. - Item 12A – Informational Presentation on RFP for Building 49 and NICE Building: Rebecca Benassini and Jamie Hurley presented scoring results for two RFPs at Pier 70. For Building 49 (approx. 8,000 sq ft), two proposals were received: YMCA of San Francisco (partnered with Dog Patch Paddle and Daily Driver) scored 462 out of 650 points; Ted Choi (City Kayak) scored 347. The YMCA proposed a $6 million investment, human-powered watercraft center, food concession, and community programming. For the NICE building (approx. 13,500 sq ft), two proposals were received: Friends of the Dog Patch Hub (community nonprofit) scored 348 points; Premier Structures (commercial firm) scored 349 points. The close scoring (1 point difference) reflected different strengths: Premier Structures scored higher on financial feasibility and capacity to deliver; Friends of Dog Patch Hub scored higher on community benefits. The YMCA presented their vision for Building 49, emphasizing community access, equity, and partnerships. Commissioners expressed strong support for the YMCA proposal for Building 49. For the NICE building, they noted the need for more information on financial viability and execution capacity, and asked staff to consider options including reissuing the RFP. Staff will go to the Southern Advisory Committee and return to the commission in October at the earliest. - Item 13A – Informational Presentation on Silverado Shipyard Lease: Brendan Mahoney presented a proposal for a two-year lease of a 51,000 sq ft vacant area at Pier 70 shipyard to Silverado Contractors. The lease includes $400,000 in tenant improvements (debris removal, barge removal, concrete removal) with up to $309,000 in rent credits. The area is currently not generating revenue. The pilot program aims to reactivate a boat ramp for small watercraft removal and disposal. Commissioners expressed support for the creative partnership and look forward to a future action item. - Item 14A – Informational Presentation on Competitive Selection Process Communications Policy: Stephanie Tang, joined by Mark Delarosa (Controller's Office), presented a policy to prohibit communication between commissioners/staff and bidders during the quiet period (from advertisement to commission action). The policy is based on a Controller's Office report from January 2021 that found weaknesses in commission ethical standards. The policy will be implemented through agenda appendixes, RFP language, expanded conflict of interest forms, and a whistleblower program. Exemptions include normal business, pre-bid communications, public comment, and pre-qualified pools. Commissioners supported the policy and noted that the Port already informally follows a quiet period. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved: August 10, 2021 meeting minutes approved unanimously. - Closed session: Commission held closed session for real estate negotiations; voted not to disclose matters discussed. - Consent Calendar approved: Resolutions 2135, 2136, 2137 adopted unanimously. - Heron's Head Park grant approved: Resolution 2138 adopted unanimously, authorizing acceptance and expenditure of $1,493,000 from CA Department of Fish and Wildlife, pending Board of Supervisors approval. - Building 49 RFP: Staff will present recommendation to Southern Advisory Committee and return to commission for action (likely October 2021). Commissioners indicated strong support for the YMCA proposal. - NICE building RFP: Staff will consider options (including reissuing RFP) and return with a recommendation. Commissioners asked for more analysis on financial feasibility and execution ability. - Silverado shipyard lease: Staff will bring back an action item after further work. Commissioners expressed support for the pilot program. - Competitive selection policy: Staff will bring back an action item after incorporating commissioner feedback. Commissioners supported the policy direction. - Adjourned: Meeting adjourned at 5:37 PM.

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 15% · MARITIME OPERATIONS 11% · PARKS AND RECREATION 10%
1232
SEP 9, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - September 9, 2021

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, September 9, 2021, at 6:15 PM. The meeting covered liquor license approvals, a hearing on sub‑acute care, a hearing on small business startup processes and Prop H implementation, and an ordinance expanding water reuse requirements. Chair Gordon Maher presided, with Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and member Matt Haney. Supervisors Safai and Mandelman also participated for relevant items. Consent Calendar - Liquor License – Teatro Tin Tan (2519 & 2521 Mission Street): The committee approved a resolution deeming that issuance of a Type 64 special on‑sale general theater liquor license would serve public convenience and necessity. Officer Salmanson (SFPD) reported no opposition. The applicant described a nonprofit theater with limited alcohol sales. Motion carried 3‑0. - Liquor License Transfer – La Loma Produce 7 (2695 San Bruno Avenue): The committee approved a resolution for transfer of a Type 21 off‑sale license. One letter of protest was received; the applicant explained customer demand. Motion carried 3‑0. Public Comments & Testimony - Sub‑Acute Care Hearing (Item 3): Public commenters included Dr. Teresa Palmer (geriatrician), Vivian Imperiale (Mental Health Association of SF), Michael Lyon (Senior Disability Action), Gloria Rivera Simpson (family member), Patrick Monette Shaw (advocate), Suzanne Sapp (NUHW), and Benson Nadell. They expressed urgency for hospital‑based sub‑acute beds, criticized CPMC’s role, and highlighted the need for data collection and accountability. - Small Business Hearing (Item 4): Commenters Steve Martin Finto and a constituent raised concerns about public safety and crime, while Sharky Laguana (Small Business Commission) urged continued support for small business recovery. - Water Reuse Ordinance (Item 5): Multiple representatives from UA Local 38 Plumbers, Sierra Club, Housing Action Coalition, and Epic Cleantech spoke in favor, emphasizing drought resilience, job transition, and cost concerns for housing projects. Discussion Items - Sub‑Acute Care in San Francisco (Item 3): Supervisor Safai and Chair Maher sponsored the hearing. Kelly Hiramoto (DPH) reported progress: Chinese Hospital has 23 beds nearing licensure; San Francisco Healthcare and Rehab stalled due to lost inspector of record and architect. Dr. Zhang (Chinese Hospital) noted licensing approval expected imminently, but Medicare certification may take 9‑18 months. The committee discussed financial viability, partnerships with private hospitals, and the need for at least 70 in‑hospital beds. A motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed 3‑0. - Starting a Small Business & Prop H Implementation (Item 4): Supervisor Haney sponsored. Presentations from OEWD (Laurel Arvanitidis), Planning (Bridget Hicks), and Office of Small Business (Regina Dickendrizi) highlighted Prop H’s success: 150 small businesses used the streamlined process, average approval time 14 days, 100% within 30 days. 48% minority‑owned, 43% women/LGBTQ+. The committee discussed expanding Prop H zones, first‑year fee waivers, support for home‑based businesses, and collaboration with neighborhood groups. Motion to file the hearing passed 3‑0. - Alternate Water Sources Ordinance (Item 5): Jacob Bindlet (Supervisor Mandelman) presented an ordinance lowering the threshold for on‑site water reuse from 250,000 to 100,000 sq ft, requiring black water treatment in commercial buildings, and expanding mandatory uses. Amendments clarified applicability to development agreements. PUC’s John Scrapola projected water savings equivalent to 31,000 residents daily by 2040. The committee moved to accept amendments and forward to full board with positive recommendation, passing 3‑0. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2: Resolutions approved and sent to the full Board of Supervisors (September 21, 2021) with positive recommendation. - Item 3: Hearing continued to the call of the chair; DPH to accelerate licensing, collect out‑of‑county transfer data, and re‑engage hospitals. - Item 4: Hearing filed; first‑year free program to begin November 1, 2021. - Item 5: Ordinance amended and recommended to full board.

PUBLIC HEALTH 30% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 16% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 15% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 9%
1233
AUG 10, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting – August 10, 2021

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, August 10, 2021, at 3:15 PM, adjourning at 7:46 PM. Items included approval of minutes, the Executive Director's report, a Racial Equity Action Plan progress report, a resolution on the Embarcadero Enhancement Project (quick build), a Waterfront Resilience Program overview, budget increases for Mission Rock Phase 1, a licensed vending pilot program, and an informational presentation on a pop-up request for qualifications. Public comments were heard on several items. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (July 13, 2021): Motion passed unanimously. - Pledge of Allegiance and announcements were routine. Public Comments & Testimony - Items Not on Agenda: No public comments. - Executive Director's Report: No public comments. - Racial Equity Action Plan (Item 7A): No public comments. - Embarcadero Enhancement Project (Item 8A): Eight callers spoke, mostly merchants from Pier 39 and Fisherman's Wharf. They expressed strong opposition to reducing northbound traffic to one lane at Broadway, citing potential gridlock and harm to economic recovery. Some supported a protected bike lane but insisted on maintaining two lanes in each direction. One cyclist supported quick build but warned that lane reduction could increase danger. - Waterfront Resilience Program (Item 9A): No public comments. - Mission Rock Phase 1 Budget (Item 10A): No public comments. - Licensed Vending Pilot Program (Item 10B): Three callers spoke in favor, including representatives from Pier 39, Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District, and a resident. They praised the program for bringing order to vending. - Pop-Up RFQ (Item 10C): One caller, a Mission Bay resident, raised concerns about an area near Pier 30-32, asking for activation and addressing homeless encampments. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6a): Elaine Forbes reported on COVID-19 health orders, economic recovery (operating reserves of $78M vs. budgeted $56M; 30% less revenue than prior year), cable car return (free rides in August), ferry ridership increases (20-50% from COVID low), Treasure Island ferry test (August 5, 2021), and Mission Rock LEED Gold certification. Commissioners commended staff, discussed parking revenue decline (linked to COVID, ride-share trends), and expressed excitement about Treasure Island ferry for equity. - Racial Equity Action Plan – REAP (Item 7a): Tony Autry, Lavina Holmes, and Tiffany Tatum presented progress: 136 actions, 30 targeted for 2021, with 27 in progress and 3 complete. Highlights included staff demographics compiled, performance appraisal updates, micro-LBE emergency loan program (20 loans, 10 to BIPOC), outreach to 30+ ethnic organizations, and a Ramaytush Ohlone Land Acknowledgement resolution. Expenses totaled $1.1M. Challenges included pandemic, staffing, and contractor availability. Commissioners praised the work and suggested adding fun elements like potlucks to build culture. Resolution 2131 (Land Acknowledgement) passed unanimously. - Embarcadero Enhancement Project – Quick Build (Item 8a): SFMTA Director Jeff Tumlin, Casey Hildreth, and Mark Dreger presented refinements to the proposed bike lane and traffic changes between Mission and Broadway. A field test at Broadway was proposed to test two configurations: two northbound lanes with one left turn (Option A) or one northbound lane with two left turns (Option B). Extensive public comment raised concerns about traffic congestion. Commissioners added an amendment requiring SFMTA to return to the commission before any permanent change to Broadway configuration. The resolution (2132) was adopted unanimously with the amendment. - Waterfront Resilience Program (Item 9a): Brad Benson outlined a programmatic delivery process for multi-billion-dollar investments to reduce earthquake and flood risk. Three phases: planning, pre-design, final design/construction. Over 20 early projects identified. Commissioners supported the approach and requested strong LBE participation and community engagement. No vote required. - Mission Rock Phase 1 Budget Increase (Item 10a): Staff requested increasing Phase 1 budget from $145M to $184.2M (27% increase) and modifying China Basin Park sequencing (in-water portions delayed to Phase 2). The net present value to the port remained near original projections ($190M NPV) due to cost-saving measures. LBE awards reached 19% of $490M spent. Contingency increased from 7% to 10%. Commissioner Wu Ho asked for future modeling to anticipate Phase 2 costs. Resolution 2123 approved unanimously. - Licensed Vending Pilot Program (Item 10b): Mike Martin and Boris Delepine presented the program: $100 annual permit, designated locations (up to 3 vendors per site), first-come-first-served initially, enforcement tied to health/safety. Outreach partner (Mission Economic Development Agency) will provide technical assistance. Commissioners supported the program; questions addressed scalability, food safety monitoring, and enforcement. Resolution 2134 adopted unanimously. - Pop-Up Request for Qualifications (Item 10c): Chris Atanoli reported on RFQ outcomes: 22 submittals, 17 qualified (5 small, 4 medium, 8 large). Examples include Bay Area Jazz Mobile, Gumbo Social, and Craig's A La Carte. Next steps include coordinating with vending pilot, community engagement (Southern/Northern Waterfront Advisory Committees), and developing fee structures. Commissioners requested clearer guidelines on license terms, fee waivers, and programmatic continuity. No vote; informational only. Key Outcomes - Approved Unanimously: Minutes (July 13, 2021); Resolution 2131 (Ramaytush Ohlone Land Acknowledgement); Resolution 2132 (Embarcadero Quick Build with amendment requiring commission return on Broadway changes); Resolution 2123 (Mission Rock Phase 1 budget increase and park sequencing); Resolution 2134 (Licensed Vending Pilot Program). - Directives: Port staff to bring back revenue projections and a joint briefing with SFMTA (new business). For the pop-up program, staff will return with detailed guidelines on terms, fees, and program structure. For Mission Rock, staff will provide modeling for Phase 2 costs before the December 2022 deadline. - Next Steps: Embarcadero Quick Build implementation expected in early 2022; staff will report back on initial traffic data. Vending pilot launches September 2021. Pop-up RFQ activations planned for September-October 2021 with ongoing community engagement.

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 21% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 14% · STREET VENDING REGULATION 7%
1234
JUL 23, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Special Meeting - July 23, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on July 23, 2021, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Member Rafael Mandelman. The meeting addressed six agenda items, including Muni service restoration, traffic collision data sharing, a parking meter contract, Peninsula Corridor financing, and performance audits. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comments were heard on items 1 and 2 (Muni restoration). Many speakers urged full restoration of all transit lines to pre-pandemic levels, citing equity concerns, climate goals, and the needs of seniors, people with disabilities, and essential workers. Some speakers criticized SFMTA for poor communication and prioritizing capital projects over operations. A few callers also commented on items 3 and 4, supporting better data sharing and opposing the parking meter contract due to cost. Discussion Items - Items 1 and 2: Hearing on De Facto Route Abandonment and Resolution to Restore All Transit Lines – SFMTA Director Tumlin and Transit Director Kirschbaum presented, noting that 85% of service hours would be restored by winter 2021 but citing budget uncertainties and the need for a revised long-term plan. Supervisor Preston expressed concern about suspended lines and the lack of a clear restoration timeline. The committee discussed the resolution urging full restoration by December 31, 2021, with a written plan due by August 31, 2021. - Item 3: Hearing on Sharing Traffic Collision Data – SFMTA, SFPD, and other agencies presented on Vision Zero data-sharing efforts. Supervisor Chan noted that while collaboration exists, faster implementation is needed to prevent fatalities. - Item 4: Contract for Parking Meter Hardware and Support Services – SFMTA staff proposed a $70.5 million contract with McKay Meters Inc. to replace aging meters. The Budget Analyst expressed concerns about cost increases and timing. Public comment included opposition to the expense. - Item 5: Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board Financing – Staff presented a resolution authorizing up to $140 million in new bonds and up to $75 million to refund existing bonds, backed by Measure RR sales tax revenues. No public comment. - Item 6: Performance Audits of OEWD and MOHCD – The Budget Legislative Analyst would conduct audits of economic development and affordable housing programs. No public comment. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Item 2: The resolution was recommended as a committee report to the full Board (2-1, with Supervisor Mandelman dissenting). The timeline for restoration was left open for further discussion. - Item 3: The hearing was filed (unanimous). - Item 4: The contract resolution was referred without recommendation to the full Board (unanimous). - Item 5: The bond resolution was recommended as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 6: The performance audit motion was recommended as a committee report (unanimous).

PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 32% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 17% · TRANSPORTATION 10% · PUBLIC HEALTH 6%
1235
JUL 22, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety Committee: Ghost Guns, Domestic Violence Reporting, Wildfire Preparedness, Stunt Driving (July 22, 2021)

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on Thursday, July 22, 2021, with Chair Gordon Maher, Vice Chair Catherine Stefani, and Member Matt Haney. Supervisor Ahsha Safai joined as a sponsor for Item 4. The committee heard four agenda items: a ghost gun ordinance, a domestic violence data reporting ordinance, an update on wildfire preparedness, and a review of motor vehicle stunt driving response. Votes were taken by roll call, and all votes were unanimous 3-0. Discussion Items Item 1: Police Code – "Ghost Guns" - Supervisor Stefani introduced an ordinance to ban the sale, possession, transfer, and manufacturing of unserialized unfinished firearm frames and receivers, with exceptions for licensed manufacturers and importers. - Stefani stated that ghost gun seizures in San Francisco were up 350% in January–February 2021 compared to the same period two years earlier. She noted ghost guns were less than 1% of all firearm seizures in San Francisco in 2016 but rose to 16% by 2020. She also reported that shootings in San Francisco were up 62% in 2020 compared to 2019, and up over 300% in 2021 compared to the same period last year. She cited 51 gun violence victims year-to-date in 2020 versus 108 this year. - SFPD Acting Commander Carl Favreau said SFPD had seized 516 firearms in 2021 versus 485 the prior year (about a 6% increase) and reported 131 shooting victims in 2021, a 95% increase over 2020. - Sergeant Patrick Fay presented on privately manufactured firearms (PMFs), noting they lack serial numbers, allow prohibited persons to bypass background checks, and create public safety risks. - Ruth Bornstein, Brady United California policy lead, voiced support for the ordinance, saying California law currently does not effectively require serialization before assembly. She noted a 2016 state bill was vetoed and a 2019 law takes effect July 2022 but still does not require serial numbers on transferred parts. - Stephen Lindley, Brady United California program manager, demonstrated a ghost gun kit, saying assembly takes about 20–25 minutes with only a drill. He said the kit is marketed to people who cannot legally buy firearms. - Mia Treta, survivor of the Saugus High School shooting, and her mother Tiffany Treta testified. Mia said she was shot by a ghost gun and her best friend was killed. She urged the committee to classify ghost guns as guns and require serialization, permits, and background checks. - Supervisor Haney noted a 15-year-old was killed in his district a few days earlier by gun violence. - Chair Maher and Supervisor Haney added themselves as co-sponsors. - The committee sent the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Administrative Code – Domestic Violence Data Reporting - Supervisor Stefani introduced an ordinance requiring the police department and district attorney to submit monthly reports to the Board of Supervisors on domestic violence cases. - Stefani said she had seen data that in Q4 of last year, SFPD presented 131 felony domestic violence cases to the District Attorney and 113 were dismissed. She said new statistics confirmed her concern that felony domestic violence cases are not being prosecuted. - She offered an amendment aligning the reporting requirements with existing quarterly reporting requirements in the Police Code, and moved to continue the item to the call of the chair. She said there were important policy questions to resolve before the item is heard. - The amendment passed 3-0, and the item was continued to the call of the chair 3-0. No public comment was received. Item 3: Hearing – Wildfire Preparedness - Supervisor Haney requested the hearing to discuss the city’s plans for the 2021 wildfire season, including indoor wildfire refuges, smoke mitigation, and extreme fire season preparation. - Matt Wolf, DPH climate and health program manager, said climate change is among the greatest health threats. He noted San Francisco is vulnerable to extreme heat and wildfire smoke. He cited a 48% increase in EMS calls during Labor Day 2017 heat event, a 17% increase in emergency department visits, and said heat deaths are more immediately fatal than smoke exposure. - Adrian Bikelli, DEM deputy director, described the citywide response: risk-based messaging, respite locations (public locations, city weather relief centers, and community serving sites), vulnerable population outreach, and mutual aid. He said Alert SF reaches about 183,000 people, and a robocall system adds about 500,000 more. Weather relief centers are typically opened at 90°F or higher for two or more days, or when air quality is forecast in the “purple” very unhealthy range for two or more days. He acknowledged that few people use weather relief centers and the city is working on lower-barrier options. He also mentioned partnerships with PG&E for power shutoff prioritization. - Melissa Higby, Office of Resilience and Capital Planning, presented the Heat and Air Quality Resilience Project, which brings together stakeholders to develop medium- and long-term strategies. She said a NOAA grant would help map urban heat islands. - Viva Mogey, SFUSD director of policy and planning, said schools closed once in 2019 for air quality and twice during tech distribution days in 2020. She said SFUSD distributed 242 portable air cleaners and will continue installing more before August 16. She said closing schools would be an extreme last resort, and excused absences will be allowed for health reasons. - Dylan Schneider, Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, said SF homeless outreach teams distributed over 700 N95 masks in 2020 and are exploring expanding PPE distribution. She said all temporary shelters have MERV 13 filters as of 2019. - Cindy Kaufman, Department of Disability and Aging Services, described wellness check protocols for older adults and people with disabilities, including triage based on medical conditions, homebound status, and electricity-dependent medical needs. She said DAS serves about 60,000 people per year and outreach is also done through community-based organizations. - In discussion, Chair Maher asked about proactive communication. DEM said alerts are triggered by forecast heat of 85–90°F for multiple days and encouraged residents to text their zip code to 88877 to sign up for Alert SF. - The hearing was filed. Item 4: Hearing – Update on Motor Vehicle Stunt Driving Response - Supervisor Safai requested an update on the response to sideshows and stunt driving since the 2020 ordinance. He noted a Labor Day 2020 sideshow in his district resulted in one death and two injuries from gun violence. He said the ordinance strengthened vehicle seizure and aided-and-abetting enforcement. - SFPD Acting Deputy Chief Dan Perea presented. From October 2020 through June 2021, there were 70 stunt driving events. Enforcement included 7 arrests, 31 vehicle seizures, 67 citations, and 225 registered-owner vehicles identified for “pending notices.” Perea also described three “notices” categories somewhat inconsistently, including 67 notices sent and 33 notices sent in the same presentation. He said the largest portion of the pie chart was 225 pending notices. - Perea said most vehicles towed came from two recent events (11 at Delores Street and 8 at Mission/Persia), representing more than 60% of all seizures. He acknowledged early miscommunication between SFPD, SFMTA, and the City Attorney’s office regarding seizure authority. He also said all arrests to date were misdemeanor vehicle-related charges and no firearms or felony arrests were made. - Perea said participants often come from outside San Francisco (Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, Sonoma, Solano, Stanislaus, and Sacramento counties) and use social media, including online gaming platforms, to organize events. He said the pursuit policy restricts chasing misdemeanors, and officers are working with CHP, Oakland PD, and San Jose PD. - SFMTA Traffic Engineer Ricardo Olea presented engineering measures: repainting crosswalks costs $3,000–$5,000 per intersection; DPW cleanup for one incident at 22nd and Indiana was about $2,800. He described pilot measures such as ceramic dots, corner bumps, traffic circles, and median islands. He named future pilot locations: Barneveld/Loomis/McKinnon, Alemany/Geneva, 20th/Folsom, Galveston/Fairfax, and Plymouth/Sarowa. - Jeremy Spitz, DPW, said cleanup for one incident required two steam cleaners over four hours per day for three days. - In response to questions, Perea said dirt bike and ATV ride-outs are difficult to address because of the pursuit policy and difficulty identifying riders. SFMTA said speed humps on Lower Great Highway may help deter ride-outs but cannot be applied everywhere. - Supervisor Stefani asked about arrests and prosecution. Perea said no cases had been dismissed and all were still working through the courts; no felonies had been charged. - Supervisor Safai said he would investigate San Jose’s proposal to penalize organizers who use social media to promote events, but would narrow it to organizers. He also stressed that towing coordination with SFMTA’s contracted tow company must improve. - The committee continued the hearing to the call of the chair for a future update in approximately six to nine months. Public Comments & Testimony - On the ghost gun item, public commenters included Celeste Perrin (Moms Demand Action), Lorraine Meyer (Moms Demand Action), James Notton, and Ewan Balker Plummer (Students Demand Action). All supported the ordinance. - On the wildfire item, Eileen Boken (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) urged the Fire Department to finalize placing a hose tender at Station 18, seismically retrofit Sunset Reservoir’s South Basin, and consider purchasing four new hose tenders. Francisco De Costa said the city lacks commander-qualified incident managers, highlighted the wildfire risk at McLaren Park, and said senior outreach should reach more than the 60,000 people currently served. - On the stunt driving item, Francisco De Costa said Deputy Chief Perea needs more resources and suggested using YouTube and high school-based educational outreach. David Hooper from the Outer Mission thanked the board and urged Bay Area coordination, recalling a shooting at Mission and Persia. Key Outcomes - Ghost guns ordinance: recommended to the full Board of Supervisors on a 3-0 vote (Stefani, Haney, Maher in favor). - Domestic violence data reporting ordinance: amended to align with quarterly reporting and continued to the call of the chair, both on 3-0 votes. - Wildfire preparedness hearing: filed on a 3-0 vote. - Motor vehicle stunt driving hearing: continued to the call of the chair on a 3-0 vote, with the expectation of a future update. - No consent calendar was considered; no other business was taken up.

PUBLIC SAFETY 17% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 16% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12% · GUN CONTROL 11%
1236
JUL 15, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - July 15, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 15, 2021, to discuss substandard living conditions at Plaza East, litigation settlements, the repeal of the sugar-sweetened beverage warning, the Mental Health Services Act annual update, and property acquisitions. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Member Raphael Mandelman. Public Comments & Testimony - Several callers spoke on the Plaza East hearing. Dr. Cedric Jackson (FRH) commended efforts and emphasized the psychological trauma of unstable housing. Gary Banks (FRH) supported the holistic approach and new leadership. Linda Chapman highlighted the need for on-site management and regular maintenance. Nubay Brown (San Francisco Bayview National Black Newspaper) called for reparations and criticized decades of neglect. Arnold Townsman, a 54-year resident, urged unity and prioritizing community building. One caller attempted to speak on the litigation agenda but was redirected; they expressed frustration about being silenced at Plaza East. Discussion Items - Plaza East Hearing (Item 1): The committee heard updates on conditions and redevelopment plans. Presenters included MBS (Adi Nagraj), McCormick Barron Salazar (Pauline Blackwell), John Stewart Company (Will Daniels), FRH (Danielle Banks), Urban Strategies (Kevin Daniel), MOHCD (Elyse Ealy), DBI (Luis Barajona), and the Housing Authority (Dr. Laju). Key points: $2.7 million emergency grant for life safety repairs; 183 of 193 units identified for repair; 96 units touched, 27 completed; 21 active complaints with DBI; new on-site property manager starting July 20th; community engagement via safety and parking committees; no decision yet on RAD blend or other development path; focus on trust-building and immediate needs. - Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Warning Repeal (Item 7): Deputy City Attorney Ann Pearson presented legislation to repeal Article 42 of the Health Code, which required health warnings on advertisements. The item was sponsored by Supervisor Walton, who was not present. - Mental Health Services Act Annual Update (Item 8): Tracy Helton (DPH) reported that individual meetings with supervisors addressed concerns, a cover letter was added, and a state extension was obtained. The next report will include a more robust section on individual challenges. Supervisor Mandelman expressed continued concern about high-acuity unhoused individuals but supported the item. - Purchase of 888 Post Street (Item 9): Dylan Schneider (HSH) and Director Penick (Real Estate) presented a resolution to purchase the property for $29 million (plus closing costs) for a TAY Navigation Center. Appraisal confirmed fair market value. Funding from general obligation bonds. Supervisor Preston noted the city's exemption from transfer tax under Prop I, saving approximately $1.7 million. BLA recommended approval. - Lease Extension at 601 Van Ness (Item 10): Resolution to extend lease for HSH administrative offices for 5 years at $363,132 annual base rent. Space will house up to 50 staff, including temporary COVID response staff. BLA recommended approval. Supervisor Chan raised questions about city-owned property utilization and telecommuting policies. Director Penick noted a report in December on transitioning from lease to owned space. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Plaza East): Motion to continue the hearing to the call of the chair passed unanimously (3-0). - Items 2-6 (Litigation): Closed session held. The committee recommended Item 6 (settlement of unlitigated claims) without recommendation; Items 2, 3, 4, 5 recommended to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 7 (Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Warning): Motion to recommend as a committee report passed 2-0 (Vice Chair Chan excused). - Item 8 (Mental Health Services Act): Motion to recommend as a committee report passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 9 (Purchase of 888 Post Street): Motion to recommend as a committee report passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 10 (Lease Extension): Motion to recommend as a committee report passed unanimously (3-0).

PUBLIC HOUSING 30% · PROCEDURAL 28% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 10%
1237
JUL 13, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting July 13, 2021: Budget Reports, Quick-Build Traffic Plan, Vending Ordinance, and Historic Ferry Lease

The Port Commission of San Francisco met on July 13, 2021, to approve minutes, hear the executive director's report, honor retiring staff, and discuss several major items. These included an informational presentation on proposed 'quick-build' traffic and curb management changes on the Central Embarcadero, a revised budget for the Mission Rock project (Seawall Lot 337), a resolution supporting a city ordinance regulating mobile vending, an update on the Piers 38 & 40 development project, and a lease for the historic ferryboat Klamath. The commission also considered public comments on various topics, with many speakers urging approval of the Embarcadero safety improvements. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the June 8, 2021 meeting (unanimous roll call: President Brandon yes, Vice President Adams absent, Commissioner Burton absent, Commissioner Gilman yes, Commissioner Wuho yes). - Authorized advertising for a Request for Qualifications for implementation of Governmental Accounting Standards Board Statement No. 87 (Resolution 21-27). - Approved a resolution commending retiring Deputy Director of Planning & Environment Diane Oshima for 41 years of service (Resolution 21-28). Both items passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Retirement Tributes (6A): Multiple callers, including Alice Rogers, Janice Lee, Alex Bash, Chris King, Laura Schaefer, Byron Rhett, Jonathan Griffin, Katie Liddell, Jim Levine, and Ellen John, praised retiring staff Carrie Kilstrom and Diane Oshima for their decades of service, community engagement, and contributions to the waterfront. Speakers highlighted Oshima's leadership in the Waterfront Land Use Plan and Kilstrom's work on the Waterfront Resilience Program. - Embarcadero Quick-Build Project (8A): Ten callers voiced strong support for the project, citing safety concerns for pedestrians and cyclists. Luke Bornheimer (Kids Safe SF) asked the commission to move forward. Cliff Barger, Kenneth Russell, Zach Lipton, Parker Day, Brian Hoosman (Walk SF), Joanna Dudman, Evan Golden, Alice Rogers, Katie Liddell, Adina Levin, Ben, and Alec Bash all urged approval, noting the project would reduce conflicts on the promenade and improve safety. Several referenced the 2018 death of pedicab driver Kevin Manning. One caller expressed concern about the Broadway intersection but supported a field test. - Mobile Vending Ordinance (9B): Sherwin Govigger (Mission Economic Development Agency) supported the outreach program. Lee Hepner (Supervisor Peskin's office), Randall Scott (Fisherman's Wharf CBD), Taylor Sanford (Pier 39), and Darlene Plumtree (SF Maritime National Park Association) spoke in favor of the ordinance, citing public health and safety benefits. - Piers 38 & 40 (9C): Alice Rogers and Alec Bash expressed support for the project's equity and inclusion plan. - Klamath Ferry Lease (10A): Alice Rogers, Alex Bash, and Chad Mason (Water Emergency Transportation Authority) supported returning the historic ferryboat to the waterfront, emphasizing maritime heritage and public access. Discussion Items Executive Director's Report (6A) Director Elaine Forbes reported on the port's economic recovery, noting that July 1 marked the start of the fiscal year and that the port would use federal stimulus funds (instead of an interfund loan) to address pandemic revenue losses. The state allocated $250 million in American Rescue Plan Act funds for public ports, with guidelines in development. Summer/fall events included the return of the Fourth of July fireworks, the Exploratorium reopening (July 1), increased ferry service, and the return of cruise ships in September (with vaccinated passengers and crew). Forbes stated that 82% of San Franciscans age 12+ had received their first vaccine dose, with 75% fully vaccinated. She highlighted a racial equity win: a partnership providing full sailing scholarships for two young women from the Boys & Girls Club. The report concluded with commendations for retiring staff Carrie Kilstrom (community engagement) and Diane Oshima (planning). Commissioners and staff delivered heartfelt tributes, noting Oshima's 41-year career and Kilstrom's 10+ years of service. A resolution commending Oshima was adopted later in the consent calendar. Central Embarcadero Quick-Build Project (8A) Staff (Dan Hodap, Casey Hildreth, Mark, Gabe Ho) presented an informational update on proposed safety improvements for the segment between Mission Street and Broadway. The plan includes a two-way protected bikeway, road diet, and new signage to encourage wheeled vehicles off the promenade. The presentation addressed prior commission concerns: a detailed signage/wayfinding plan, traffic analysis at the Broadway intersection, and a proposed field test comparing two lane configurations (Design A with two through lanes and one left-turn lane; Design B with one through lane and two left-turn lanes). Design B was staff's recommended option based on modeling. The project survey mailed to 17,000 addresses received 1,400 responses; 81% believed the on-street bikeway would benefit pedestrians on the promenade. The commission discussed the need for a holistic strategy for the entire Embarcadero and the importance of balancing all modes. Commissioner Gilman noted that 110 letters of support had been received. No vote was taken; the item will return in August, likely on the consent calendar if all commissioner questions are resolved. Mission Rock Phase 1 Revised Budget (9A) Phil Williamson and Rebecca Benassini presented an informational update on a proposed $62 million cost increase (from $145 million to approximately $207 million) driven by unforeseen subsurface conditions, lightweight cellular concrete costs (for sea level rise), electrical utility modifications, and increased agency review costs. Three solutions were proposed: (1) sequencing China Basin Park's in-water portions (tidal shelves, food pavilion) to Phase 2, delaying $23 million in spending; (2) using a DDA provision that the first $10 million overage is repaid at a reduced return rate (approximately 4.1% vs. 18%); and (3) imposing penalties if Phase 2 is not submitted by end of 2022 ($25,000/month escalating). Staff projected port revenue (NPV) at $181 million if the park is sequenced, versus $190 million in the 2019 baseline. Commissioners questioned LBE contracting (31% awarded for horizontal work, 4% for vertical) and the Phase 2 timeline. The item was informational; further details will be brought back. Mobile Vending Ordinance (9B) Assistant Port Director Mike Martin and Boris Delapine requested approval of a resolution supporting Supervisor Peskin's ordinance to bring city vending laws into compliance with state SB 946. The ordinance would authorize the port commission to adopt time, place, and manner restrictions. Staff outlined a pilot program with 17 designated vending locations (subject to BCDC approval), a $100 annual permit fee (first year), and enforcement via citations (amounts set by state law). The port is contracting with the Mission Economic Development Agency to help vendors apply. The ordinance was passed by the board's land use committee and will go to the full board on July 20. The commission unanimously adopted the resolution (Resolution 21-29). Piers 38 & 40 Development Project (9C) David Beaupre and the San Francisco Waterfront Partners team presented an update on the historic piers project, focusing on the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) plan. The team includes a 50-50 joint venture with minority-owned firms. The DEI plan features a five-pillar system for training, jobs, and contracting (via Cornerstone Institute), a hospitality training program (via IntoAction), and a goal to exceed 25% LBE participation. Community outreach (13 meetings) has generated support for a

PROCEDURAL 26% · TRANSPORTATION 13% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 10% · STREET VENDING REGULATION 7%
1238
JUL 8, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety Committee Meeting (July 8, 2021): Paramedic 5150 Holds, Liquor License, and Continuances

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Maher, met on Thursday, July 8, 2021. The committee acted on five agenda items, including a liquor license transfer, an ordinance to allow fire department paramedics to initiate 5150 mental health holds, and continuances for three other items due to noticing errors or sponsor requests. The meeting focused heavily on expanding non-police crisis response and included detailed presentations from the San Francisco Fire Department, the Department of Public Health, and the firefighters' union. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public called in to provide comment on any agenda item during the scheduled public comment periods. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer (1600 Jackson Street – Mollie Stone’s Market) - The San Francisco Police Department Alcohol Liaison Unit reported zero letters of protest or support. The location is in a high-crime, high-saturation area, but Northern Station had no opposition. The liaison recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. - The applicant, John Devlin (representing Mollie Stone’s), stated the license is for a new full-service grocery store at the former Lombardi Sports site. He argued it would serve public convenience by being the only full grocery store with a liquor license in the census tract. - Supervisor Mar noted Supervisor Peskin’s support and moved to forward a positive recommendation to the full board. The committee voted unanimously (3–0) to approve the resolution finding the transfer serves public convenience and necessity. - Item 3 – Ordinance to Designate Fire Department Paramedics to Initiate 5150 Holds - Supervisor Ahsha Safai, the primary sponsor, presented the ordinance as part of shifting mental health crisis response away from law enforcement. He cited the Street Crisis Response Team (SCRT) data: since April 2021, SCRT responded to over 700 calls with an average response time of 15 minutes, diverting nearly 20% of mentally disturbed person calls from police dispatch. He emphasized that 37% of SCRT calls resulted in transport to hospital or behavioral providers. - Deputy Chief Simon Peng (SFFD) explained that law enforcement currently places the majority of 5150 holds—approximately 3,043 per year (8–9 per day). He argued that police presence can stigmatize and trigger people with mental illness. The fire department proposes to train community paramedics (30 FTEs in service daily by January 2022) and rescue captains to assess and place holds. He cited successful programs in Santa Barbara and San Mateo that reduced overall 5150s after paramedics took over. - Adrian Sims (Local 798, firefighters union) expressed 100% support, noting that a police uniform can be triggering for people of color and mental health crises can be handled without escalation. - Dr. Angelica Almeida (Department of Public Health) provided data: citywide, approximately 9,000 5150s were placed in FY 2019–20 (including those by clinicians and police). The health department will collaborate on training and quality improvement, with 100% review of paramedic-initiated holds in the first year. - Assistant Deputy Chief Sandy Tong (SFFD) noted a concerning rise in assaults on EMTs and paramedics, and that her department is working with the city attorney to ensure protection of personnel. - Supervisors Mar and Stephanie expressed strong support, with Mar requesting to be added as a co-sponsor. Supervisor Stephanie inquired about resources and raised the issue of 5250 holds (14-day holds) and release patterns; she requested data from SF General on releases against medical advice. - The committee voted unanimously (3–0) to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Items 2, 4, 5 – Continuances - Item 2 (Ordinance on Alternate Water Sources for Non-Potable Applications): Due to a noticing error by the clerk, the item was not eligible for hearing. The committee voted unanimously (3–0) to continue it to the call of the chair. - Item 4 (Hearing on Wildfire Preparedness): Supervisor Haney’s office requested a continuance. The committee voted unanimously (3–0) to continue to the call of the chair after no public comment. - Item 5 (Hearing on Starting a Small Business/Proposition H): The committee voted unanimously (3–0) to continue to the call of the chair after no public comment. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Liquor License): Motion to prepare a resolution finding the transfer serves public convenience and necessity and send it to the full board with positive recommendation passed 3–0 (Supervisors Mar, Safai, Stephanie in favor). - Item 3 (Paramedic 5150 Holds): Motion to recommend the ordinance to the full board passed 3–0. - Items 2, 4, 5: Each continued to the call of the chair by unanimous 3–0 votes. - Supervisor Mar added as a co-sponsor to Item 3. - Supervisor Stephanie requested a report from Department of Public Health on 5250 holds and releases against medical advice. - The committee noted the need for additional paramedic FTEs; the recently adopted budget added 10 new paramedics (increasing from 200 to 210), with further analysis promised.

MENTAL HEALTH 34% · PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14%
1239
JUL 1, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting – July 1, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met remotely on July 1, 2021, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Connie Chan and Member Rafael Mandelman. The committee reviewed seven regular agenda items, including grants, a mental health services update, and a performance audit of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, plus closed session litigation matters. Consent Calendar - Item 1 – Cannabis Tax Fund Grant: Unanimously approved an ordinance authorizing the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner to accept and expend $986,248 from the California Highway Patrol Cannabis Tax Fund Grant Program for an automated liquid handling instrument and two new positions (forensic analyst and toxicologist) for FY2021-2023. - Item 3 – Sharp Park Habitat Conservation Grant: Unanimously approved a resolution retroactively authorizing a $200,500 grant from the California Department of Parks and Recreation for the Sharp Park Habitat Conservation Project, requiring a deed restriction to protect San Francisco garter snake habitat through 2039. - Item 4 – CDC HIV Grant: Unanimously approved a resolution retroactively accepting $2,740,288 from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention for the Ending the HIV Epidemic initiative, covering August 2020 – July 2021. - Items 5 & 6 – Heron’s Head Park Shoreline Resilience Project: Unanimously approved resolutions authorizing acceptance of an in-kind donation of beach materials (estimated value $417,000) from Hanson Aggregates Mid-Pacific, Inc. and a $1,667,000 grant from the California Ocean Protection Council to construct a living shoreline to protect against erosion and sea level rise. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 2 (MHSA Update): One caller, Mr. DeCosta, criticized the department for delays in bringing the resolution and expressed frustration with the overall dysfunction of the behavioral health system. - On Item 7 (HSH Audit): Mary Kate Bacalau, co-chair of HSHLA (Homeless Services Leadership Alliance) and representing Compass Family Services, supported the audit findings, emphasized the need for collaborative program monitoring with providers, and urged focus on housing and the adult, family, and youth systems. Discussion Items - Item 2 – Mental Health Services Act (MHSA) Annual Update FY2021-2022: Tracy Helton, interim director of MHSA, presented the update. Key points: MHSA funds 87 programs serving 36,807 unduplicated clients in FY2019-20, with 51% of revenues allocated to Full Service Partnership (FSP) programs for severe mental illness. The department reported an 85% decrease in arrests and health emergencies for FSP adults and 90% for transitional youth. Supervisors Mandelman and Chan expressed deep concern that despite such spending, the city’s behavioral health crisis is worsening, with visible street suffering and rising overdose deaths. Supervisor Preston noted the report did not reference major local initiatives like Mental Health SF or state preemption. The department requested an extension from the state (original deadline June 30, 2021). The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to the July 15, 2021 meeting. - Item 7 – Hearing on Performance Audit of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH): Amanda Guma of the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) presented findings from the August 2020 audit. Key findings: - Contract underspending: 16–17% of revised budget unspent annually (FY2017–2020); updated to 14% in FY2020-21. - High vacancy rate: 26% in FY2019-20, later reduced to 8.9% but with new positions (36 temporary) pushing effective rate to 18%. - Lack of standardized program monitoring: only 9 of 20 sampled contracts had monitoring reports; no consistent metrics or corrective action processes. - Data system limitations: the “One System” had limited functionality, causing delays in housing placements. - Governance gaps: no formal oversight body; major decisions made without stakeholder input. HSH Director Shereen McSpadden responded that the department has made progress: fully staffed HR team, 12 vacancies remaining, developing monitoring policies with a workgroup (training to begin fall 2021), expanding the One System to include unit-level housing inventory (completion spring 2022), and engaging stakeholders through multiple advisory bodies. Supervisors discussed the need for clearer metrics, formal oversight, and accountability. The hearing was filed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Items 1, 3, 4, 5, 6: Recommended to the full Board of Supervisors (all 3-0 votes). - Item 2: Continued to the July 15, 2021 regular meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee (3-0). - Item 7: Hearing held and filed (3-0). - Closed Session: The committee unanimously voted to continue one litigation item to the call of the chair and recommended the remaining litigation items (settlements totaling over $5.3 million) to the Board of Supervisors for the July 13, 2021 agenda.

HOMELESSNESS 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · MENTAL HEALTH 14% · PROCEDURAL 11%
1240
JUN 29, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Recessed BOS Budget and Appropriations Committee Special Meeting – June 29, 2021

The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a special meeting on June 29, 2021, starting at 5:15 PM, to consider the city's FY2021-2022 and FY2022-2023 budget and salary ordinances, as well as a $128.3 million appropriation from the Fiscal Cliff Reserve for rent relief and social housing. The meeting was recessed multiple times throughout the day and evening, ultimately reconvening to vote on the budget package and continue the rent relief item. Discussion Items - Budget and Appropriation Ordinance (Item 1) and Annual Salary Ordinance (Item 2): Chair Matt Haney presented the final budget package, highlighting over $100 million in community investments, including $32 million in additional rent relief, funding for a guaranteed income pilot for transgender residents, support for LGBTQ+ seniors, alternative public safety response teams, and expanded mental health services. He thanked the mayor's office, budget staff, and committee members for their collaborative work. The committee received technical adjustments from the mayor's budget director. - Fiscal Cliff Reserve Appropriation (Item 3): The committee considered an ordinance to appropriate $64.15 million for rent relief and $64.15 million for social housing acquisition and operation. Supervisor Preston, the sponsor, was recognized for his leadership. The item was continued to a later date to allow for further work. Key Outcomes - Unanimous Vote to Forward Budget and Salary Ordinances: The committee voted 5-0 to amend items 1 and 2 to reflect the Board of Supervisors' spending plan, accept the mayor's technical adjustments, and forward the ordinances to the full Board of Supervisors for its July 13, 2021 meeting with a positive recommendation. - Unanimous Vote to Continue Item 3: The committee voted 5-0 to continue the Fiscal Cliff Reserve appropriation ordinance to the call of the chair. No public testimony was heard on this item. - Public Comment: There were no callers wishing to speak on item 3; public comment was closed.

ARTS AND CULTURE 31% · PROCEDURAL 22% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 5%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com