The San Francisco Port Commission held a regular meeting on November 10, 2020, via teleconference. The meeting covered a range of topics including the city's reopening rollback due to rising COVID-19 cases, rent relief for port tenants, a shared spaces program for outdoor dining, and a long-term waterfront resilience plan. The commission adopted resolutions on the consent calendar and on economic stabilization measures, and received an informational presentation on the Waterfront Resilience Program. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Approved unanimously (Resolution 2049) authorizing a memorandum of understanding with the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission for temporary use of up to 5.1 megawatts of power capacity supplied by the Port's shipyard at Piers 68 and 70 for up to three years. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 11A – Three members of the public offered comments. One speaker expressed support for port actions but urged that fees be refunded rather than credited, and recommended tying the program's end date to the citywide shared spaces program for consistency. Another speaker, a waterfront resident, emphasized the importance of keeping restaurants open and asked the commission to consider making the fee waiver a refund rather than a credit. The third speaker stressed the need for restaurants to have certainty, supporting the extension of the program through June 2021 but asking that the waiver be a refund rather than a credit. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report: Elaine Forbes reported on the city's decision to pause and roll back high-risk indoor activities (indoor dining, fitness centers, movie theaters) due to rapid increases in COVID-19 cases locally, regionally, and nationally. She highlighted the port's financial resilience and flexibility during the pandemic, and noted that the port received a City Partnering Award for the Pier 29 project, which was completed on budget with creative problem-solving. Commissioners commended staff for their efforts. - Item 11A – Tenant Relief and Economic Stabilization Measures: Port staff presented updates on the rent deferral program (average 274 tenants deferred $12.8 million from March to July 2020), sector-based rent forgiveness, the commercial eviction moratorium, and a proposed repayment program. The commission discussed a proposed resolution (Resolution 2050) to waive fees for use of port property for outdoor dining and retail under the Shared Spaces Program, with a termination date tied to the end of the city's public health emergency or June 30, 2021, whichever is sooner. Commissioners debated extending the end date to March or June 2021, with some expressing unease about uncertainty. Ultimately, the commission supported the staff recommendation of June 2021, with a plan to revisit the program in the first quarter of 2021. The resolution passed unanimously. - Item 12A – Waterfront Resilience Program: Staff presented an informational update on the alternatives development strategy and proposed decision framework for the Waterfront Resilience Program, which aims to adapt the port's waterfront to sea level rise and seismic risks. The presentation covered draft goal statements, planning principles, evaluation criteria, funding guidelines (including Proposition A), and the role of the Adapt Plan. Commissioners praised the structured approach and emphasized the need to include equity considerations, engage other city departments, and coordinate with historic pier rehabilitation and long-term lease extensions. No action was taken; staff will return in December 2020 for further feedback. - New Business: No new business was raised. Key Outcomes - Resolution 2049 (Consent Calendar) – Adopted unanimously: MOU with SFPUC for temporary power capacity. - Resolution 2050 – Adopted unanimously: Approval of additional economic stabilization measures, including waiver of fees for shared spaces program for outdoor dining and retail, with termination tied to the end of the public health emergency or June 30, 2021; commission to review in first quarter 2021. - Waterfront Resilience Program: Commissioners expressed support for the process and requested continued engagement; staff to return in December 2020 with further updates. - Meeting adjourned at 5:25 PM.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Port Commission met virtually on October 27, 2020, from 10:00 AM to 6:19 PM PDT, to address a range of items including approval of minutes, closed session, executive director's report, Mission Rock financing, LBE contracting, Army Corps flood study, PG&E sediment remediation, and Pier 70 shipyard update. The meeting included unanimous votes on several consent and action items. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (October 13, 2020): Moved, seconded, and passed unanimously by roll call. - Closed Session: Unanimous vote to enter closed session for public employee performance evaluation and other matters. Upon reconvening, the Commission voted unanimously not to disclose closed session discussions, except to report the appointment of Michael Morton as Assistant Port Director. Public Comments & Testimony\n- Catherine Riley (Brookfield Properties) expressed support for the Port's LBE program, noting that the Pier 70 project exceeded its 17% LBE goal with 25% participation, totaling over $48 million to LBE firms, with 33% of construction workforce local and 12% from Southeast San Francisco ZIP codes. She affirmed continued commitment to diversity. - Dwayne Jones (RDJ Enterprises) thanked the Commission for prioritizing LBE participation and highlighted work on Pier 70 and Mission Rock. - Susan Karathoff (California Native Plant Society) urged that any ecological measures in flood resilience and sediment remediation use only local native plants to meet biodiversity goals. - No other public comments were made on agenda items. Discussion Items\n- Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Director Elaine Forbes welcomed new Commissioner John Burton, reported completion of the Port's listening tour for a racial equity action plan (to be presented in December), noted San Francisco's economic reopening in the yellow tier, and announced $1 ferry fares in November ("Dollar Days") by WETA. - Mission Rock Community Facilities District Financing (Item 10A): Staff presented a resolution recommending Board of Supervisors approve CFD bond issuance not to exceed $50.1 million for Phase I infrastructure. Phase I includes 560 housing units (202 affordable), 550,000 sq ft office (Visa as anchor tenant), 65,000 sq ft retail, and a 5.5-acre park. The bond is secured by special taxes; appraisal is being updated. The resolution passed unanimously. - LBE Contract Activity and Strategic Initiatives (Item 10B): Stephanie Tang and Tiffany Tatum reported FY2019-20 contract data: $24.2M in contracts awarded, 62% to LBE primes; $30.9M in payments, 24% to LBE subs, 40% total to LBEs. Over five years, 62% to LBE primes and 40% of dollars paid to LBEs. Outlined FY2021 strategy including improved internal practices, stakeholder partnership, barrier mitigation, and integration with the racial equity plan, with deliverables in January and July 2021. - U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Flood Resiliency Study (Item 11A): Kelly Capone, Matt Wickens, and Lindy Lowe presented the study's progress. The study covers 7.5 miles of waterfront, is a 50-50 cost share with the Corps, and assesses flood damages from 2040-2090 under five sea level rise curves (up to 6 feet by 2090). The "future without project" analysis includes 2,500 buildings, 11,000 jobs, 350,000 regional commuters, and 13,000 residents (half people of color). Piers unlikely to meet federal cost-benefit criteria. Focused array alternatives include hard/soft measures, ecological enhancements, and integration with seismic measures. Commission guidance requested on non-structural measures, ecological enhancements, and phasing. - PG&E Sediment Remediation at Pier 39 to Pier 43½ (Item 12A): Catherine Purcell reported on PG&E-led remediation of PAH-contaminated sediments from a historic manufactured gas plant. A remedial action plan (FS RAP) is to be submitted; geotechnical investigation begins. Dredging and capping planned over five years (June-November windows) starting 2023, after design and permitting through 2022. Water Board will issue CEQA documents for public comment in Q1 2021. - Pier 70 Shipyard and SFPUC MOU (Item 13A): Andre Coleman presented interim use and a proposed MOU with SFPUC for temporary power. After unsuccessful RFPs for a ship repair operator, the Port achieved positive net revenue of $460,000 in FY2019-20 through interim tenants (lay berth, storage). The MOU would provide up to 5.1 MW (86% of remaining power) for 1-3 years, generating minimum $1.1 million annually, to support SFPUC's BCT line electrification. Staff seeks commission guidance on creative repurposing of shipyard assets while maintaining maritime-industrial uses. Key Outcomes\n- Resolution 2048 (Mission Rock CFD Financing) approved unanimously – recommends Board of Supervisors approve bond issuance up to $50.1 million. - Closed session actions: Commission voted unanimously not to disclose closed session discussions except to report appointment of Michael Morton as Assistant Port Director. - Staff direction: Commissioner Gilman requested an informational update at the next meeting on tenant rental relief/forgiveness for community-serving nonprofit tenants. Vice President Adams requested an earlier start time (1:30 or 1:45 PM) for future meetings that include closed session. - Next steps: LBE strategy deliverables by January and July 2021; Army Corps study to advance to final array in early 2021, with continued commission engagement; PG&E remediation design and permitting to continue through 2022; Pier 70 MOU with SFPUC to be brought as an action item at a future meeting.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met remotely on Thursday, October 22, 2020, at approximately 11:00 AM PDT. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Member Shamann Walton present. Supervisors Aaron Peskin, Hillary Ronen, and others also participated for specific items. The agenda included four liquor license transfers, an ordinance regulating third-party food delivery services, and two hearings on COVID-19 response in the Latinx community and testing protocols. Due to the pandemic, all participation was via video conference and phone. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was designated; all items were considered separately. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Swig liquor license): Michael Nolty, executive director of Alliance for a Better District 6, expressed full support for the license transfer, noting community outreach and the applicant's history. - Item 5 (Food delivery ordinance): Two callers supported the ordinance: Chubby Fani (Golden Gate Restaurant Association) thanked Supervisor Peskin for engaging stakeholders, and Michael Nolty (North and Market Business Association) supported the measure to help small restaurants and clarify pricing for customers. - Item 6 (Latinx COVID-19 response): Multiple callers testified: - Peter Corey (data scientist) urged DPH to partner with community organizations like the Latino Task Force (LTF). - John Jacobo (health committee chair, LTF) criticized DPH for failing the Latinx community, noting 170,000 tests at Embarcadero/SOMA vs. 4,000-6,000 in high-impact areas, and demanded funding. - Michael Nolty (former DPH employee) echoed frustration with bureaucratic delays. - Marco Montenegro (Excelsior Works/Excelsior Strong) highlighted that community organizations have added COVID-19 response to core services without extra funding and called for long-term plans. - Item 7 (Testing protocols): Two callers questioned transparency and favoritism in testing contracts, specifically regarding Color Genomics. Discussion Items Liquor License Transfers (Items 1-4) All four transfers were presented by ABC Officer Pat Mackie with no protests. Each applicant spoke briefly. The committee unanimously approved resolutions finding public convenience or necessity for each: - Item 1 (Swig): Type 48/47 license at 553-561 Geary St. The applicant, Brian Shee, described combining Swig (operating since 2004) with the adjacent Olympic Cafe to offer dinner service. Conditions included hours 10am-2am, no noise, no loitering, no off-sale. - Item 2 (Grab & Eat): Type 21 off-sale license at 3499 Mission St. No applicant present; committee approved with conditions (monitor area, no loitering). Supervisor Ronen supported. - Item 3 (Luke's Local): Type 20 off-sale beer/wine license at 2190 Union St. Luke’s owner described their grocery concept. Vice Chair Stefani praised the business for filling a commercial vacancy and providing jobs. Conditions included monitoring and litter cleanup. - Item 4 (Sool Bar): Type 48 license at 321-323 Grant Ave for Hotel 321. Applicant Sandy Chun requested approval to combine lodging and food/beverage. Conditions included no noise, no loitering, no off-sale. Supervisor Peskin supported. Ordinance: Third-Party Food Delivery Services (Item 5) Supervisor Peskin presented amendments to the proposed ordinance, which caps fees at 15%, prohibits delivery services from restricting restaurant pricing, allows restaurants to terminate contracts within 72 hours, and bans unauthorized delivery. Key amendments: removed the additional 3% point-of-sale fee and changed the sunset to 60 days after the health officer allows 100% indoor dining (instead of two years). Also removed administrative revision language. The committee adopted the amendments and forwarded the ordinance to the full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Hearing: Public Health Response to COVID-19 in the Latinx Community (Item 6) Supervisor Ronen convened the hearing, noting that despite a UCSF/LTF study in April showing disproportionate infection rates, the situation has not improved significantly. DPH presented through Isela Ford (Latinx COVID response lead) and Dr. Navina Baba. - Key data: 36% of DPH’s FY2021 COVID spending is estimated to serve Latinx individuals. The city announced $28.5 million for Latinx community support, but Supervisor Ronen questioned where the money is and why the Latino Task Force has not received promised funds. DPH explained that $7.3 million of that is from DPH, with $3 million for essential hubs (Mission, Excelsior, Bayview) allocated through OEWD contracts, which have been in process for about six weeks. Supervisor Ronen and Walton expressed frustration that volunteers at the Mission Hub have not been paid and that testing resources have not been prioritized in high-positivity areas. - Testing: DPH reported that 78% of tests at the Mission Hub are Latinx, but overall positivity in the Latinx community remains high (13-25% at some clinics vs. 1-3% at Embarcadero). DPH is moving the SOMA test site to Alemany (starting November 17, Monday-Friday) to better serve the southeast sector. Supervisor Ronen called for immediate fund release, reallocation of testing to hardest-hit areas, and city funding for the “Right to Recover” income support program (which ran out of funds and paused for a month). - Outcome: The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair (3-0) to allow further follow-up. Hearing: COVID-19 Testing Protocols (Item 7) Supervisor Peskin held a high-level review of DPH’s testing strategy and contracts. Dr. Baba and Deputy Finance Drew presented: - San Francisco has 31 testing sites, conducting 5,000 tests/day (50-60% city-provided). Testing budget for FY2021 is $58.9 million, with $17 million incurred since July. An RFP for continued testing services was released September 1; award expected late October. - DPH’s “adaptive test and response” strategy prioritizes hot spots, but there is a mismatch between testing volume (south of Market) and positivity (southeast quadrant). Efforts include mobile testing and partnerships with Chinese Hospital. - Supervisor Peskin raised concerns about timely payment to Chinese Hospital and overall transparency. No questions were posed due to earlier hearing overlap. - Outcome: The hearing was filed (3-0). Key Outcomes - Liquor License Transfers (Items 1-4): Approved unanimously with conditions. - Third-Party Food Delivery Ordinance (Item 5): Amended and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Latinx COVID-19 Response Hearing (Item 6): Continued to call of chair (3-0). Supervisor Ronen requested detailed accounting of the $28.5 million allocation. DPH committed to releasing hub funding through OEWD. - Testing Protocols Hearing (Item 7): Filed (3-0).
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, October 13, 2020, at 2:08 PM, adjourning at 4:46 PM. Commissioners Kimberly Brandon (President), Gail Gilman, and Doreen Wuho were present; Vice President Willie Adams was absent. The meeting covered consent items, an informational presentation on the rehabilitation of two historic buildings at Crane Cove Park, approval of a Foreign Trade Zone operations agreement with DHL, and updates on port operations, equity, economic recovery, and environmental remediation. Consent Calendar - Item 10A – Extension of MOU for Pier 29 PPE Distribution: The commission unanimously adopted Resolution 2046, approving a 60-day extension of the memorandum of understanding with the San Francisco Office of Economic and Workforce Development for use of Pier 29 as a central location for receiving and distributing personal protective equipment (PPE) to nonprofits, along with rent deferral for that use. Public Comments & Testimony - Public Comment on Items Not on the Agenda: Alex Lanceburg, a 20-year neighbor of the Port, expressed strong concern about the rendering plant at Pier 90/94 backlands, calling it a “noxious nuisance” especially during summer. He stated that promised state-of-the-art odor control and a community hotline had not been maintained, and urged the Port to enforce its lease or shut down the operation if the lessee fails to correct the issue. - Public Comment on Executive Director’s Report: - Jay Wallace (TGK Broadway LLC) thanked Port staff for their work on the Teatro Zanzani project, reaffirmed full commitment to the project, and noted that financing is currently bleak due to COVID-19 but that the market may recover toward the end of 2021. - Francisco da Costa commented on the need for clearer presentations during virtual meetings, requested more frequent updates on the Seawall project, and emphasized that the Port’s 7.5-mile jurisdiction requires broad public outreach. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes provided a comprehensive update: - Equity: The Port is in the final two weeks of its Phase 1 racial equity action plan listening tour; Stephanie Tang will replace Boris Delapine as the Port’s representative to the LBE Advisory Subcommittee; the Contract Monitoring Division is preparing an availability and utilization study of minority- and women-owned businesses. - Economic Recovery: The San Francisco Economic Recovery Task Force released 41 policy recommendations; Mayor Breed announced first steps including a permanent shared streets program, direct business funding, a pilot basic income for artists, and fee/tax waivers for closed businesses. The Port supports these efforts. - Port Reopening: Updated Pier 50 COVID-19 health and safety plans were approved by the City Administrator; 80% of maintenance staff have returned to duties, with 20% deployed as disaster service workers through end of 2020. - Hyde Street Harbor Petroleum Seepage: The U.S. Coast Guard transferred federal authority to the EPA. Over 140 gallons of oil and 1,300 gallons of oily water have been removed; the Port has committed over 3,000 personnel hours and approximately $30,000 in materials. The area of interest has expanded to 600 feet of shoreline. The EPA approved a work plan on October 2, 2020. - Teatro Zanzani (TZK): The lease disposition and development agreement (LDDA) is fully executed. TZK has invoked a force majeure extension due to COVID-19’s impact on hospitality financing. The one-year LDDA term has not yet started; staff will negotiate the force majeure duration and provide updates. - Waterfront Development Process: Mike Martin detailed the RFP process used for Piers 38-40 and Piers 30-32/Seawall Lot 330, emphasizing community engagement, an impartial scoring panel, and post-selection negotiations. The process follows the updated Waterfront Plan. - Commissioner Comments: Commissioners praised the clarity of the process, reiterated the importance of transparency, and requested quarterly informational updates on the Seawall project. On TZK, Commissioner Wuho expressed hope for the project’s cultural value and concerns about delays; staff clarified that the force majeure extension discussion is ongoing. - Item 11A – Informational Presentation on Rehabilitation of the Kneass Building and Building 49 (Crane Cove Park): Rebecca Benassini presented the proposed competitive solicitation strategy for the two historic buildings adjacent to Crane Cove Park. - Building 49: 8,000 sq ft, single story, will receive core/shell improvements including a public restroom by fall 2021; no seismic upgrade (occupancy limited to 100); listed on historic register. NICE Building: 13,500 sq ft on two levels, deteriorated, removed from public trust (flexible uses), eligible for historic listing. - Minimum RFP Goals: At least one food & beverage location, one watercraft rental/storage/sales facility, and one community-serving use. Pre-development cost estimate: $10–15 million. - Process: Staff will engage the Southern Advisory Committee and other community groups (youth, elder, at-risk populations) to define community values, then return to the Commission for approval to issue an RFP. - Commissioner Feedback: Commissioners emphasized community-serving uses, suggested site tours with historical commentary, and asked about possible office use, opening walls to the park, and historic preservation restrictions. Staff confirmed that Building 49 already has planned openings consistent with Secretary of the Interior standards, and the NICE building has large roll-up doors. - Item 12A – Operations Agreement with DHL Global Forwarding (Foreign Trade Zone No. 3): Brendan O’Mare presented the request for approval of a five-year operations agreement (with one four-year renewal option) for DHL to operate a usage-drive site at its Brisbane, California warehouse. The Port of San Francisco has been grantee of Foreign Trade Zone No. 3 since 1948. DHL, a global logistics company founded in San Francisco in 1969, has 19 active FTZ locations and has been approved by the FTZ Board and U.S. Customs. The annual fee covers administrative costs. Resolution 2047 was adopted unanimously. Key Outcomes - Adopted Resolutions: - Resolution 2046 (Consent Calendar – Pier 29 PPE extension): Unanimous. - Resolution 2047 (DHL Foreign Trade Zone operations agreement): Unanimous. - Directives and Next Steps: - The Executive Director will investigate the rendering plant complaint raised in public comment. - Staff will provide quarterly updates on the Seawall resiliency program and on Teatro Zanzani milestones. - For Item 11A, staff will engage the Southern Advisory Committee and other community groups, aiming to bring back a refined RFP proposal to the Commission in November or December 2020, with an RFP issuance expected early 2021. - The Port will respond to Teatro Zanzani’s force majeure request and establish metrics for monitoring the pandemic’s impact on financing.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met remotely on Thursday, October 8, 2020, at 6:00 PM (UTC). The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Shamann Walton present. The committee considered five agenda items, including a liquor license transfer, an ordinance prohibiting discriminatory 911 calls, amendments to regulations on third-party food delivery services, a hearing on the conditions of essential workers during the COVID-19 pandemic, and an ordinance targeting motor vehicle stunt driving (sideshows). All votes were unanimous (3-0) on actions taken. Public Comments & Testimony - Agenda Item 3 (Third-Party Food Delivery Services): Multiple callers expressed support for capping delivery fees. Brent Webcott (DoorDash policy advisor) urged clarifications to allow optional marketing programs and exclude formula retail. A representative from the Golden Gate Restaurant Association endorsed the 15% cap and two-year sunset. Ben Blyman and a District 5 resident (Peter) strongly supported the legislation, criticizing delivery app companies' practices. - Agenda Item 4 (Essential Workers Hearing): One public commenter, Francisco da Costa, criticized the city's distribution of masks and called for better logistical support from the Department of Public Health (DPH). - Agenda Item 5 (Stunt Driving Ordinance): Callers were divided. Opponents (Keegan Madrano of District 10, Peter of District 5, Michael Garcia of District 11, and Judy of District 11) argued the ordinance would over-police, criminalize, and wrongly punish without due process. Supporters (William Martin of District 11 and Theodore Randolph of Excelsior) emphasized the danger, noise, and obstruction caused by sideshows, urging passage. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License Transfer (1859 Market Street) – Officer Salmonson from the Alcohol Licensing Unit reported that the applicant signed all conditions on October 1, 2020. The applicant confirmed agreement. No public comment. The committee moved to forward a resolution finding public convenience and necessity to the full board. - Item 2: Discriminatory Reports to Law Enforcement (CAREN Act) – Supervisor Walton introduced the amended ordinance. Yurio Salvador (Legislative Aide to Assemblymember Rob Bonta) spoke in support, noting the passage of similar state legislation (AB 1775). No public comment. The committee voted to forward to the full board. - Item 3: Third-Party Food Delivery Services (Ordinance Amendment) – Lee Hefner (Legislative Aide to Supervisor Peskin) presented substantial amendments: raising the commission cap from 10% to 15%, allowing a 3% point-of-sale processing fee, requiring written consent before listing restaurants, allowing termination within 72 hours, and adding a two-year sunset. Liza Dikandrizi (Small Business Commission) supported the amendments. After public comment, the committee accepted the amendments and continued the item to October 22, 2020. - Item 4: Hearing on Essential Workers and Their Conditions During COVID-19 – Supervisor Safai convened the hearing. Presentations were made by: - Pat Mulligan (Director, Office of Labor Standards Enforcement) – Reviewed OLSE's role in enforcing labor laws, noting complaint-based enforcement and outreach during the pandemic. - Dr. Jessica Bloom (UCSF/DPH) – Described the Community Mitigation Branch's workplace response: identifying exposures, following up on outbreaks (defined as 3+ cases in 14 days), and providing guidance. She noted that construction and restaurants had the most outbreaks since July. - Terrence Hong (Principal Environmental Health Inspector, DPH) – Detailed inspections of food facilities, SROs, and distribution of masks; emphasized education and enforcement, though acknowledged challenges in verifying PPE supplies. - Labor and worker representatives: - Olga Miranda (President, SEIU Local 87, janitors) – Reported 10 member deaths; criticized building owners and contractors for inadequate PPE, gloves, and masks, and for prioritizing shirts over safety. - Jim Araby (UFCW Local 5, grocery workers) – Noted 200 local members contracted COVID-19 and 5 deaths; cited mental health issues and inconsistent enforcement of mask policies; highlighted the need for public education on sick leave benefits. - Kayla Sanborn Hum (on behalf of Fight for 15 worker Christabel Ayala) – Described unsafe conditions at Carl's Jr. (e.g., lack of PPE, intimidation of sick workers, retaliation). - Daisy MacArthur (SEIU Local 2015, in-home support worker) – Requested easier access to COVID-19 testing, cab vouchers, and strengthened protections for home care workers. - Mikila Edwards (gig driver, We Drive Progress) – Criticized Uber/Lyft for closing Green Light hubs, failing to provide cleaning supplies, and spending $180 million on Proposition 22 to deny employee status. - Supervisor Safai and Chair Mandelman questioned DPH and OLSE about enforcement of PPE requirements, sick leave compliance, and complaint processes. DPH acknowledged gaps in verifying PPE supplies but committed to improving inspections. - Item 5: Motor Vehicle Stunt Driving Ordinance – Supervisor Safai and Chief of Police William Scott presented the ordinance to combat sideshows. They described recent incidents: a September 7 sideshow in Excelsior with gunfire that killed a 21-year-old, a September 20 Bayview event with 70+ shell casings, and numerous large gatherings blocking streets and endangering residents. The ordinance would impound vehicles for at least 14 days (first offense), 15 days (second), and 29 days (third), with a maximum of 30 days. Chief Scott noted improved police response but stressed the need for stronger penalties. Supervisors Walton, Stefani, and Mandelman expressed support, emphasizing the danger to communities and rejecting claims that the ordinance was racially motivated. Public comment was divided. A clerical amendment (font correction) was adopted. The committee voted to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion passed 3-0 to forward a resolution finding public convenience and necessity to the Board of Supervisors (October 20, 2020 agenda). - Item 2: Ordinance as amended (at the September 24, 2020 meeting) was forwarded to the full board with a 3-0 vote. - Item 3: Substantive amendments were accepted (3-0), and the item was continued to the October 22, 2020 regular meeting of this committee. - Item 4: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair (3-0). Supervisor Safai's office will follow up with worker groups and DPH on complaint processes and PPE enforcement. - Item 5: A clerical amendment was adopted (3-0), then the ordinance was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0).
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, met on September 24, 2020, to consider six agenda items: three liquor license hearings, a landmark anti-discrimination ordinance (the CAREN Act), a housing conservatorship program update, and a hearing on essential frontline workers. The meeting featured extensive public testimony and discussion on the CAREN Act, as well as concerns about the slow implementation of the housing conservatorship program. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was used; each item was discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - On Agenda Item 4 (CAREN Act), Gabby Ruiz from Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation expressed full support for the legislation. One caller raised concerns about potential unintended consequences and ethnic tensions. Camille Millenni called in support. - No public comments were received on other agenda items. Discussion Items - Item 1: St. Joseph's Arts Foundation Type 99 Liquor License – Officer Samelson from the Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) reported no opposition, a high-crime and high-saturation area, but Southern Station had no opposition. The applicant presented the nonprofit's mission to bring art to underserved communities, and noted community support. The committee voted to forward a resolution with positive recommendation to the full Board. - Item 2: Golden State Food and Liquor Type 21 Transfer – Officer Samelson reported one protest letter, low crime area (error corrected), high saturation, Southern Station no opposition. Conditions included hours (8am-1am), no small distilled spirits, multi-pack sales for small containers, and loitering prevention. The applicant agreed to conditions but had not yet signed. The committee continued the item to October 8, 2020, to allow time for formal acceptance. - Item 3: Sopracasa LLC (Soda Casa) Type 20 Transfer – Officer Samelson reported no protests, high crime, high saturation, Central Station no opposition. Condition: active monitoring of loitering. Applicant's representative described the Italian-focused shop. The committee forwarded the resolution with positive recommendation. - Item 4: CAREN Act (Caution Against Racial and Exploitative Non-Emergencies) – Supervisor Walton presented the ordinance, which makes it unlawful to cause peace officer contact solely to discriminate. Co-sponsors include all 11 supervisors. Presentations were made by Angela Jenkins (San Francisco Interrupting Racial Profiling), Marty J., James Juanillo (victim of a false 911 call in Pacific Heights), and Brittany Chekuta (Human Rights Commission). The committee unanimously adopted amendments expanding protected classes to align with city code, adding a purpose clause not to deter legitimate calls, and adding specific harms. The ordinance was then continued to October 8, 2020, as required for substantial amendments. - Item 5: Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report – Dr. Angelica Almeida (Department of Public Health) reported that no petitions for housing conservatorship under SB 1045 have been filed yet. The program began serving individuals in July 2020, and about a dozen are being tracked. Some individuals have improved after receiving notices. Chair Mandelman expressed frustration with the slow pace, noting that the program has been in effect for over a year. He requested more data on 5150s and PES diversions for the next hearing. The committee continued the hearing to November 12, 2020, warning that if no petitions are filed by then, directors would be called to discuss program viability. - Item 6: Essential Frontline Workers Hearing – The committee continued this hearing to October 8, 2020, without discussion or public comment. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (St. Joseph's Arts Foundation): Motion to forward a resolution with positive recommendation to the full Board passed 3-0. - Item 2 (Golden State Food and Liquor): Motion to continue to October 8, 2020, passed 3-0. - Item 3 (Sopracasa LLC): Motion to forward a resolution with positive recommendation to the full Board passed 3-0. - Item 4 (CAREN Act): Amendments adopted unanimously, then continued to October 8, 2020, for final vote. - Item 5 (Housing Conservatorship): Continued to November 12, 2020, with a directive for more data. - Item 6 (Essential Frontline Workers): Continued to October 8, 2020.
The San Francisco Port Commission held a regular meeting on Tuesday, September 22, 2020, starting at 3:15 p.m. and adjourning at 7:26 p.m. Commissioners Kimberly Brandon (President), Willie Adams (Vice President), Gail Gilman, and Dorian Wuho were present. The meeting covered a range of topics including the Executive Director's report, consent calendar, informational presentations on Mission Rock CFD financing and the Embarcadero Seawall Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment, a proposed lease for the historic ferryboat Klamath, approval of a lease with Andre Boudin Bakeries for the Chowder Hut, and authorization to begin negotiations for an Exclusive Negotiating Agreement (ENA) with Strada Trammell Crow Company for Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330. Consent Calendar - Item 7A: The Commission unanimously approved Resolution No. 20-43, authorizing staff to advertise a Request for Qualifications for two Micro LBE Set-Aside contracts for As-Needed Public Relations, Communications, and Media Relations Services. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 9A (Seawall Risk Assessment): Three public speakers commented: Taylor Safford (Pier 39 CEO) congratulated staff on the milestone and praised proactive tenant outreach. Susan Karasov (San Francisco resident) urged inclusion of biodiversity and use of native plants. Fran Weld (San Francisco Giants SVP) commended the port's inclusive, multi-disciplinary approach. A fourth speaker, Flick McGuran (Pier 23 Cafe), expressed concern about construction impacts on the historic character of Fisherman's Wharf and Pier 39. - Item 10A (Klamath Lease): Alice Rogers, a waterfront land use plan participant, urged support for the proposal, calling it a win-win for the waterfront. - Item 11B (Piers 30-32 ENA): Seven callers provided extensive public comment. Speakers included Alice Rogers (again), John McGrath, Barbara Inaba, Mark Dragon, Carol Hart, David Horwitz, Alan Dundas, Russ McGillen, Thomas Williams, Earl G., Rick Dickerson, and John Cornwell. Key concerns raised: non-compliance with Proposition B height limits (proposed 160-180 ft towers vs. 105 ft base), excessive massing creating a "wall" on the waterfront, severe traffic congestion (especially at Beale/Bryant and Bay Bridge approaches), inadequate parking, oversaturation of high-end housing and office space, and the need for more public open space (e.g., ball fields, playgrounds) instead of a luxury floating pool. Several speakers urged the Commission to terminate the RFP process or require significant redesign and community engagement. Mark Dragon specifically noted that the Strata proposal offers a 1.5 million dollar annual land lease with an 18% IRR hurdle, while the Vornado proposal would deliver $135 million in participatory rent over 75 years. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A): Director Elaine Forbes opened with a tribute to Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, then provided an equity update on the port's internal anti-racism work, an economic reopening update (indoor dining at 25% capacity possible end of September if COVID metrics allow), a budget update ($124.8 million total, with a $10 million economic recovery reserve), and announced the opening of Crane Cove Park on September 30, 2020. The park is a 7-acre waterfront park in District 10 with direct bay access, historic interpretation, and sea level rise preparedness. - Commissioners' Report (Item 6B): Commissioners expressed excitement about Crane Cove Park and thanked staff. - Mission Rock CFD Financing (Item 8A): Phil Williamson and Wyatt Donnelly presented an informational update on the financing structure for Phase I horizontal improvements at Seawall Lot 337. The bond will fund approximately $35 million of the $265 million Phase I budget, using a Community Facilities District (CFD) with a 3-to-1 value-to-lien ratio. Commissioner Wuho asked about the number of CFD financings in the city, market conditions, and the difference between public and private financing. Port staff noted strong demand for CFD bonds statewide and no delinquencies in San Francisco. The project is on track with four leases signed and construction starting in coming months. - Embarcadero Seawall Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment (Item 9A): Brad, Stephen Real, and Lindy Lowe presented findings from the MHRA, which projects up to $30 billion in combined seismic and flood damages by 2100 if no action is taken. Earthquake risk is high north of the Bay Bridge due to deep Bay muds and liquefaction. Flood risk from sea level rise will cause significant overtopping within 30–50 years. The team presented seismic and flood mitigation measures (e.g., buttresses, deep soil mixing, raised marine structures) and a long-term planning process (Envision). Equity updates included LBE participation rates: CH2M contract at 17.1% (goal 22.9%), Civic Edge at 35.4% (goal 36%). President Brandon requested a detailed report on contracting dollars by ethnicity, highlighting concerns about low payments to African American firms. The Commission directed staff to provide a full equity and contracts report at a future meeting. - Klamath Ferryboat Lease (Item 10A): Dominic Moreno presented a proposal to lease Pier 9 South to the Bay Area Council for 15 years with two five-year options. The historic ferryboat Klamath would be rehabilitated and serve as BAC headquarters, including public museum space, event space, and subtenant offices. The proposal would reactivate a dormant berth and provide public access. Commissioners expressed support, noting the project's alignment with the Historic Vessel Policy and the strategic plan. No changes from closed session discussions were noted. - Chowder Hut Lease (Item 11A): Jay Edwards presented a 10-year lease with a 5-year option for Andre Boudin Bakeries at the Chowder Hut (Fisherman's Wharf). The lease includes a $4,000 monthly credit for janitorial services of public restrooms. The tenant plans an $800,000 glass atrium with retractable roof to expand outdoor dining. The Commission approved the lease unanimously. - Piers 30-32 & Seawall Lot 330 ENA Authorization (Item 11B): Peter Albert presented the RFP process, which resulted in Strada TCC scoring highest (109 out of 130 points). The proposal includes a rebuild of Piers 30-32 (376,000 sq ft office, 31,000 sq ft retail, 160,000 sq ft open space, a floating pool/water room) and 850 housing units on Seawall Lot 330 (643 market-rate, 57 inclusionary, 150 entirely affordable). The ENA would authorize staff to negotiate a multi-year development agreement. Extensive public comment raised concerns about height, massing, traffic, and affordability. Strada's Jesse Blout responded that the project is a starting point and they are committed to community engagement. Commissioners emphasized that this is the beginning of a long process (2-6 years) and that the ENA will include benchmarks for community input. The Commission voted unanimously to authorize negotiations. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Item 7A): Approved unanimously (Resolution 20-43). - Chowder Hut Lease (Item 11A): Approved unanimously (Resolution 20-44). - Piers 30-32 ENA Authorization (Item 11B): Approved unanimously (Resolution 20-45). - Directives: Staff directed to prepare an equity and contracts report for the resilience program and to provide regular briefings on the Embarcadero Seawall program leading up to Proposition A project selection. The Commission also requested an update on the Teatro Zinzanni project and an update on cruise ship operations. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned at 7:26 p.m. in memory of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on September 8, 2020, at 3:15 PM. The meeting covered the Executive Director's report on the Hyde Street Harbor oil sheen, COVID-19 economic recovery, a video showcasing port staff's pandemic response, an equity update, and a farewell to retiring Assistant Deputy Director Mike Nerney. The main agenda item was an informational presentation on the RFP responses for the development of Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330, featuring presentations from three teams. No formal votes were taken on the RFP. Consent Calendar - The minutes from the August 25, 2020 special port commission meeting were approved unanimously via roll call. Public Comments & Testimony - On items not listed on the agenda: No callers. - On the Executive Director's Report: Ellen Jonk, co-chair of the Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee, commended Mike Nerney for his leadership and collaboration, and expressed gratitude for his service. - On Item 7A (Piers 30-32 / Seawall Lot 330 RFP): - Russell, a District 6 resident, expressed strong support for the development, emphasizing the need for housing and urging the commission to expedite the process. - John William Chapleton, historian and co-founder of National Black Business Month, urged the port to ensure equity and diverse ownership in the project, noting the historical presence of African Americans on the waterfront. - John, a longtime waterfront-area resident, voiced concerns about the massing of the Strata proposal on Seawall Lot 330, saying it could create a wall-like effect and draw neighborhood opposition. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 6A): - Hyde Street Harbor Oil Sheen: Since spring 2020, recurring petroleum sheens were observed. On July 9, 2020, a primary source was identified near former Wharf J10. The port implemented containment measures, including 800 feet of petroleum containment boom. The U.S. Coast Guard transferred lead agency to the EPA. Investigation and cleanup continue. - Economic Reopening and COVID-19 Response: The port's shared spaces program received 17 applications, with 11 approved and six under review. Outdoor dining is sustained; indoor dining remains closed. The port supported citywide COVID-19 efforts with testing sites, food distribution, and navigation centers. - Staff Video: A video highlighted port staff's deployment to disaster service roles, including testing sites at Piers 30-32, food bank operations at Lot A, and shelter-in-place locations. Commissioners praised the video and requested broader publicity. - Equity Update: The port is developing a race equity action plan, with a listening tour launching in late September. The port hosted a contract monitoring mentor protege program. - Farewell to Mike Nerney: Commissioners, staff, and public commenters celebrated Nerney's 21-year career, praising his role in growing the cruise industry and his positive demeanor. He received a standing tribute and a letter from the Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee. - Commissioners' Report (Item 6B): No additional items. - Informational Presentation on Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 RFP (Item 7A): - Staff presented the RFP process, noting five initial responses, two deemed non-responsive, and three qualifying teams: Strata/Trammell Crow Company (Strata/TCC), Tishman Spire Worldwide (Tishman Spire), and Vornado Realty Trust. - The scoring panel (five members) evaluated proposals based on design, financial strength, capacity, and experience. Tishman Spire scored highest (89.33/130), followed by Strata (80.33) and Vornado (75.33). - Each team presented 15-minute overviews: - Strata/TCC: Proposed reducing the pier footprint by 45% (rebuilding 7.2 acres), 376,000 sq ft office, 31,000 sq ft retail, 161,000 sq ft open space, a floating public pool, 850 housing units (57 inclusionary + 150 standalone affordable), 25% affordable on-site. Underlined engineering certainty and a track record with complex waterfront projects. - Tishman Spire: Proposed retaining the full pier deck, 520,000 sq ft office, 70,000 sq ft retail/exhibition, 58,000 sq ft maker space, a 41,000 sq ft cultural building for port revenue, 460 housing units (50% affordable), 7.5 acres of public open space, and a deep berth. Emphasized experience building Mission Rock and other San Francisco projects. - Vornado: Proposed 850,000 sq ft office, 150,000 sq ft retail/community, a 12-acre green roof park (8 acres rooftop), 360 housing units (25% affordable), and self-financing without public subsidies. Highlighted financial capacity and experience with large public-private partnerships (e.g., Farley Building). - Commissioners questioned teams on infrastructure investment, public financing risks, unit mix, financial return timelines, the feasibility of the floating pool, and equity/inclusion plans. - New Business (Item 8): Commissioner Wuho requested a future update on tenant rent forgiveness and COVID-19 compliance. Vice President Adams requested an update on hiring to replace retiring staff. Key Outcomes - The minutes from August 25, 2020 were approved unanimously. - The RFP presentations were informational; no action taken. Staff will return on September 22, 2020 for a possible action item to enter exclusive negotiations with the top scorer (Tishman Spire). - Commissioners requested staff to provide technical memos (financial feasibility, engineering resilience) and to present findings from the Northern Advisory Committee meeting (scheduled for September 16). - Future commission agenda items will include updates on tenant relief, COVID-19 compliance, and staff hiring plans. - Commissioner Brandon requested the top scorer (Strata/TCC) to provide a preliminary timeline for project completion, including best, likely, and worst-case scenarios, and a detailed equity, diversity, and inclusion plan.
The Budget and Appropriations Committee met on August 26, 2020, to consider the city's two-year budget for fiscal years 2020-2021 and 2021-2022. The meeting, chaired by Supervisor Sandra Lee Fewer, included committee members Supervisors Jamana Walton, Raphael Mandelman, Hilary Ronin, and President Norman Yee. The committee recessed multiple times throughout the day, finally reconvening after midnight to pass the budget. The approved spending plan incorporates $42 million in additions over two years, focusing on restoring programs cut in the mayor's proposed budget, rental subsidies, targeted investments in Black communities, and COVID-19 response. Public Comments & Testimony - Dr. Carolyn Scott, an African American native of San Francisco, expressed support for passing $120 million for the Black community over two years, specifically for health emergency and redirecting funds from police to community-based resources. - Shorea, director of the American Indian Cultural Good Put, commented on over $200,000 in funding cuts to vital American Indian organizations, stating she had not received responses from the mayor or board of supervisors. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Suspension of Financial Policy): Controller Ben Rosenfield explained that the city's budget includes $332 million in one-time revenues but only $89 million in one-time uses, requiring suspension of the financial policy that one-time revenues match one-time uses. Supervisor Ronin clarified that the strategy is prudent given potential new revenue from ballot measures in November. The committee supported the resolution. - Fire Department: The committee agreed to accept the fire department's alternative reductions of $650,000 over two years in overtime and travel, rejecting the Budget and Legislative Analyst's (BLA) recommendation to cut funds for ladder trucks and command vehicles. President Yee expressed concern about overtime for mutual aid during wildfires but accepted the department's recommendation. - Department of Public Health (DPH): Dr. Colfax and staff reported progress on mental health SF, including funding capital costs from business tax revenue and expanding crisis teams to 6 for 24/7 coverage, with a $11.4 million deficit in year three. On black maternal health, DPH committed $600,000 in new funding, including $200,000 for doula access and $200,000 for the abundant birth project. Supervisor Fewer requested a general fund investment. Supervisor Ronin proposed $3.5 million for bi-weekly testing at community learning hubs (half reimbursable by FEMA), which DPH agreed would help but noted the science is evolving. The committee also agreed to reject the BLA's recommendation to put $36 million for Black community investments on reserve, instead requiring a spending plan and reports to the board. - Attrition Savings: The controller reported that a full analysis of department salary budget trends was not yet completed but would be provided later in the day. - Budget Passage: After midnight, the committee voted to approve the budget (items 1, 2, and 3) with amendments as outlined in the Board of Supervisors Budget Spending Plan, including technical adjustments and administrative provisions. The motion passed unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - Resolution 200917 (suspension of financial policy) approved with a positive recommendation. - Budget and Appropriation Ordinance (200567) and Annual Salary Ordinance (200568) amended to reflect the committee's spending plan, which includes $42 million in additional funding over two years for program restorations, rental subsidies, COVID-19 response, and targeted investments in Black communities. - The committee authorized the controller to make necessary adjustments and forwarded the items to the Board of Supervisors for the September 15, 2020 meeting with a positive recommendation. - The $36 million for Black community investments will not be placed on reserve; instead, the Human Rights Commission will provide a spending plan and regular expenditure reports to the board. - The committee accepted the fire department's alternative savings of $650,000 in overtime and travel cuts. - The committee supported DPH's $600,000 investment in black maternal health and agreed to consider $3.5 million for community hub testing as part of ongoing budget discussions.
The San Francisco Port Commission held a special virtual meeting at 3:15 PM on August 25, 2020, due to the COVID-19 emergency. The commission unanimously approved two action items: a Rent Forgiveness Program providing up to $13.5 million in relief for 196 tenants across three sectors, and acceptance of a $297,000 grant from the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority for wetland habitat restoration at Heron's Head Park. Consent Calendar - Minutes of the August 11, 2020 meeting were approved by a roll call vote (Commissioner Doreen Woo Ho experienced technical difficulty but later confirmed her vote). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 6A – Rent Forgiveness Program: Eleven callers spoke in support. Speakers included Jonathan (requesting clarity on sidewalk dining permits), Tyler Foster (Red and White fleet, expressing gratitude and noting the 12-passenger limit issue), Kevin Leslie (Louis Fish Jack, grateful and asking about start dates for operating days), Robert Estrada (Inland Boatman's Union, supporting the proposal and asking for equitable treatment for tour boats), Mahogany Roland (Rebuilding Together San Francisco, highlighting nonprofits not covered and requesting a future criteria-based program), Drew Colling (Spinnaker Sailing, supportive and asking about winter rent structure), Peter Osborne (Mission Rock Resort, asking about percentage rent after three months of base rent), John Barnett (Crab Boat Owners Association, thanking for consideration), Pete Sitnick (Water Bar and Epic Stake, grateful and suggesting new outdoor dining opportunities), Canton McGrath (Blue & Gold Fleet, sharing operational challenges with the 12-passenger limit and requesting port support), and Sly Hunter (Masters, Mates & Pilots, supporting the resolution and echoing concerns about inconsistent regulations). - Item 7A – Wetland Restoration: No public comments were received. Discussion Items - Item 6A – Rent Forgiveness Program (Resolution No. 20-41): Staff presented a targeted program for three sectors: (A) Percentage Rent Tenants (up to 14 months forgiveness, 48 tenants, $11.8M estimated), (B) Maritime Tenants (6 months, 121 tenants, $1.5M), and (C) Local Business Enterprise Tenants (3 months, 27 tenants, $150,000). Total forgiveness up to $13.45 million offset by percentage rent collections. Requirements include reporting government aid, maintaining operations (minimum 10 days/month, subject to health orders), and for sector A, paying percentage rent. Rent credits for startup costs and previously paid rent were detailed. Staff requested an amendment to include excursion operators in startup rent credits. The program excludes licenses; some leases require Board of Supervisors approval. Future criteria-based rent forgiveness for other tenants was discussed. Commissioners praised staff and noted the port's lack of federal stimulus. The resolution was amended as proposed and passed unanimously. - Item 7A – Wetland Habitat Restoration (Resolution No. 20-42): Carol Bach, Environmental Affairs Manager, presented a request to accept and expend a $297,000 grant from the San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority (Measure AA funds) and enter a sole-source contract with Literacy for Environmental Justice (LEJ). The grant funds two years of wetland revegetation at Heron's Head Park, including planting up to 24,000 plants across 20,000-30,000 square feet, with community engagement. The project is part of a larger living shoreline effort. The Southern Waterfront Committee was supportive. Next steps include Board of Supervisors approval. Commissioners commended staff's fundraising efforts. The resolution passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Resolution 20-41 (Rent Forgiveness Program) – Approved unanimously (4-0) as amended to include startup rent credits for excursion operators. Staff will begin lease amendments and seek Board of Supervisors approval for approximately 32 leases under charter Section 9.118. - Resolution 20-42 (Wetland Restoration Grant) – Approved unanimously (4-0). Staff will seek Board of Supervisors approval in September, then execute the grant agreement and contract with LEJ to begin work in fall 2020. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM.