Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1291–1300 ENTRIES
1291
JAN 28, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - January 28, 2021

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met remotely on Thursday, January 28, 2021, at 6:15 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Maher, with Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and Member Matt Haney. The committee considered two agenda items: a liquor license transfer for a Grocery Outlet in the Bayview and a proposed ordinance creating a right to reemployment for workers laid off due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - For Agenda Item 1 (Liquor License Transfer): No members of the public called in to comment. - For Agenda Item 2 (Right to Reemployment Ordinance): No members of the public called in to comment. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License Transfer – 355 Bayshore Boulevard (Grocery Outlet) - The San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) ABC Liaison Unit, represented by Officer Salmanson, presented the report. The applicant seeks a Type 21 off-sale general liquor license to replace the former Smart & Final, which closed in early 2019. The location is in a high-crime and high-saturation area (census tract 9809). There were no letters of protest or support. The Bayview Police Station had no opposition. The ALU recommended approval with four conditions: (1) sales permitted only between 7 a.m. and 11 p.m. daily; (2) no sale of distilled spirits in sizes smaller than 200 ml; (3) beer, malt beverages, and wine coolers in containers 16 oz or less must be sold in manufacturer-packaged multi-unit quantities; and (4) the petitioner must actively monitor the premises to prevent loitering. The applicant agreed to these conditions on December 17, 2020. - Justin Zucker and Darius Tiranchi (representing Grocery Outlet) spoke in favor, noting the store will serve a food desert and reduce the need for residents to travel for groceries. Supervisor Maher noted that Supervisor Walton (district representative) supports the transfer. - The committee voted unanimously to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding public convenience and necessity and incorporating the ALU conditions, and to send it to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Ordinance Amending Police Code – Right to Reemployment Following COVID-19 Layoff - Chair Maher introduced the ordinance, which codifies an emergency ordinance that has been reenacted three times since July 2020. It requires employers with 100 or more employees who lay off 10 or more eligible workers (employed at least 90 days) within a 30-day period to offer reemployment to those workers before hiring new employees. Offers must be made based on seniority. The ordinance exempts small businesses (fewer than 100 employees), healthcare employers, independent contractors, workers with collective bargaining agreements, and those with severance agreements. It also requires employers to notify the city of layoffs and maintain records. - Joshua Arce, Director of Workforce Development at the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD), presented data on implementation from July 3, 2020, to January 27, 2021: 124 layoff notices were received affecting 9,901 employees; 45 rehire notices were received affecting 3,489 employees; of those, 1,652 were offered reemployment, 991 accepted, and 637 declined. OEWD also received 56 emails and several dozen calls from workers seeking clarification. Arce noted that the ordinance does not provide the city with enforcement authority; that lies with private right of action. - Chair Maher questioned the discrepancy between the 3,489 employees in rehire notices and the 1,652 offered reemployment. Arce responded that not all employers who have rehired may have filed notices, and the reason for the gap is unknown without compliance authority. - Supervisor Stephanie spoke in strong opposition, arguing the ordinance harms small businesses, particularly restaurants that employ part-time workers, and could disproportionately affect women and people of color by disadvantaging those with caregiving responsibilities. She noted the Small Business Commission unanimously opposed the ordinance and that it could jeopardize unemployment benefits for workers who decline offers. - Chair Maher responded that the ordinance protects workers of color and women, who are overrepresented in the hospitality industry, and that amendments (e.g., exempting small businesses) were made based on employer feedback. - No other supervisors made remarks. Key Outcomes - Liquor License Transfer (Item 1): The committee voted 3-0 (Stephanie, Haney, Maher all ayes) to approve the resolution and send it to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration on February 9, 2021. - Right to Reemployment Ordinance (Item 2): The committee voted 2-1 (Maher and Haney ayes, Stephanie no) to recommend the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The ordinance will be placed on the Board of Supervisors agenda for February 9, 2021.

WORKER JUSTICE FUND 49% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 16% · PROCEDURAL 9%
1292
JAN 21, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - January 21, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on January 21, 2021, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston. The committee held a follow-up hearing on the 2018-2019 Civil Grand Jury report regarding the emergency firefighting water system, received public comment, and then convened in closed session to discuss litigation items. After closed session, the committee recommended all litigation items to the full Board of Supervisors and voted not to disclose closed session discussions. Public Comments & Testimony - Eileen Boken (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, speaking on her own behalf) commented on the civil grand jury report recommendations regarding the Auxiliary Water Supply System (AWAS). She stated that the recommendations were inconsistent with the first issuance of the 2020 Easter bonds, which proposed only $20 million for AWAS upgrades (two manifolds and potable water on the west side). She noted that retired firefighters strongly oppose using drinking water for catastrophic fires and believe the existing dedicated high-pressure, high-volume system is vastly superior. Discussion Items - Follow-up Hearing on Civil Grand Jury Report: "Act Now before it is too late: Aggressively expand and enhance our high pressure emergency firefighting water system" – Supervisor Gordon Maher presented the background, noting this was the third hearing on the report issued in July 2019. The first hearing was in September 2019, and the Board of Supervisors adopted a resolution responding to the report. However, several recommendations required further analysis, and the matter remained open until updated responses could be provided, expected by June 2022. In November 2019, the board adopted a resolution declaring a state of urgency to rapidly expand the system. At the July 2020 follow-up hearing, departments reported progress, but some analysis and planning steps were still outstanding. The committee discussed the need for continued monitoring. Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously recommended all litigation items (settlements) to the Board of Supervisors for consideration at the February 2, 2021 board meeting. - The committee voted 3-0 not to disclose the discussions held during closed session.

PENDING LITIGATION 28% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · FIRE SAFETY 12% · PUBLIC WORKS 6%
1293
JAN 20, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety Committee Hearing on Mass Vaccination Strategy - January 20, 2021

On January 20, 2021, the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee held a special hearing to review San Francisco's mass vaccination strategy. The meeting featured presentations from UCSF, Kaiser Permanente, Sutter Health, Dignity Health, and the Department of Public Health (DPH) / COVID Command. Key topics included vaccine supply challenges, distribution plans, equity, communication, and coordination among providers. The hearing highlighted that only 123,875 doses had been received out of an estimated 400,000 needed for Phase 1A and 1B (65+ populations), leaving a shortfall of 277,000 doses. The goal is to reach 10,000 vaccinations per day, with the first mass vaccination site at City College opening on January 22. Public Comments & Testimony - Gina Lon, Vice President of Policy at the San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium, urged the city to fully engage community clinics in vaccine planning, noting they serve 112,000 vulnerable patients, many of whom are low-income, uninsured, or non-English speaking. She emphasized that clinics are trusted providers and need vaccine supply and support. - A representative from Safe and Sound (San Francisco Family Resources Alliance) advocated for prioritizing Family Resource Center staff and early care educators, who have been providing essential in-person services throughout the pandemic. - Zach Lipton, a District 6 resident, criticized the city's vaccine notification system, comparing it unfavorably to systems in Dallas and Los Angeles. He noted that his parents received an email telling them to contact their provider but got no further assistance, and argued that the current system privileges those with internet access and resources. Discussion Items - UCSF Presentation (Dr. Josh Adler): UCSF has administered 22,873 doses (92% of first doses). They are prioritizing patients 75+ due to limited supply, with 70,000 patients in that age group. UCSF held back 8,400 doses from a Moderna lot under state quarantine. They are collaborating with Dignity Health and One Medical to open a drive-through site at City College on January 22. - Kaiser Permanente Presentation (Ron Groper): Kaiser has vaccinated 170,000 doses system-wide, with 93% distribution rate. They are prioritizing 75+ and have 240,000 members in San Francisco. Kaiser committed to sharing data with DPH and supporting mass vaccination sites. Non-members can access vaccines via a call center. - Sutter Health Presentation (Dr. Rob Nordgren): Sutter has given 7,500 employee doses and 1,000 patient doses in San Francisco. They are opening to 75+ and aim to reach 3,000 doses per day. They are working with DPH on site selection for mass vaccination. - Dignity Health Presentation (Darren Kumar): St. Francis Memorial Hospital and St. Mary's Medical Center have received 6,125 doses total, with 2,028 administered. They are focusing on Phase 1A employees and will expand to 1B as supply allows. They are partnering with DPH and other systems for mass vaccination. - DPH / COVID Command Presentation (Roland Pickens, Mary Ellen Carroll, Dr. Mary Mercer): DPH reported that San Francisco has received 123,875 doses total, but needs 400,000 to cover Phase 1A and 1B (65+). The city aims to reach 10,000 vaccinations/day. Major challenges include unpredictable supply from the federal government and state, and competition with Southern California for allocations. DPH outlined a three-pronged strategy: high-volume vaccination sites (City College, Moscone, Produce Market), mobile teams, and community-based clinics. The city launched a vaccine notification website and a data tracker. DPH acknowledged that coordination with private providers is critical and that data sharing is improving. - Equity and Access: Several supervisors raised concerns about reaching underserved communities. Supervisor Safai emphasized the role of community hubs and requested that 311 be used for scheduling. Director Carroll agreed to explore 311 integration within a week. Supervisor Haney and Chair Maher questioned how to ensure geographic coverage and access for unhoused individuals and SRO residents. DPH responded that mobile teams and street medicine teams would be deployed. - Teacher Vaccination: Supervisor Ronan proposed a proactive plan to vaccinate all SFUSD elementary school educators once the state authorizes it. DPH's Roland Pickens agreed to start planning immediately with the city's Health Service System. - Data and Communication: DPH stated that a centralized scheduling system is being developed and that all providers have committed to sharing data. The notification system will eventually allow direct appointment booking. However, public comment highlighted that the current system is confusing and inaccessible for many. Key Outcomes - The hearing was continued to the call of the chair (motion by Supervisor Haney, passed unanimously). - Vice Chair Stephanie was excused from the remainder of the meeting (motion by Chair Maher, passed). - DPH committed to integrating 311 into the vaccine scheduling system within the next week. - DPH agreed to begin planning a mass vaccination event for SFUSD elementary school educators in partnership with the city's Health Service System, contingent on state authorization. - DPH will meet with the San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium next week to better include community clinics in the rollout. - The committee emphasized the need for improved transparency, communication, and equitable access, and pledged to continue oversight.

PUBLIC HEALTH 82% · PROCEDURAL 6% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 6% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2%
1294
JAN 12, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting – January 12, 2021

The San Francisco Port Commission met virtually on January 12, 2021, to elect officers, receive updates on tenant relief and affordable housing, award contracts for youth employment, and discuss the Embarcadero Enhancement Project. The meeting began with a closed session at 1:45 PM and reconvened in open session at approximately 3:15 PM. The Commission unanimously approved routine items and heard informational presentations. Consent Calendar - Resolution 21-01 – Approved an extension to March 31, 2021, of a Memorandum of Understanding with the San Francisco Office of Economic and Workforce Development for use of Pier 29 as a central location to accept deliveries of personal protective equipment (PPE) and its distribution to nonprofits, along with deferral of rent for such use in support of the city’s COVID-19 response. Passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 11A (Youth Employment Contracts): Four callers spoke in support. Kathleen Kokatailo (Larkin Street Youth Services) strongly supported awarding the contract, citing Larkin Street’s experience and existing workforce model. DJ Brooker (Young Community Developers) urged approval, highlighting YCD’s 48‑year history in Bayview Hunters Point. Marnie Regan (Larkin Street) commended the Port’s investment. Randale Jackson (Larkin Street) noted the partnership would help homeless and at‑risk youth. No opposition was expressed. - Item 12A (Broadway Cove Affordable Housing): Bob Hare, representing the Barbary Coast Neighborhood Association, expressed pleasure with the project’s progress, its range of income levels, and the cooperative relationship with the development team. - Item 13A (Embarcadero Enhancement Project): Sunny Angulo, on behalf of Supervisor Peskin, thanked SFMTA and the Commission for their partnership and noted the project’s long history and importance for Vision Zero. Discussion Items - Election of Port Commission Officers: Kimberly Brandon was nominated and unanimously re‑elected President; Willie Adams was nominated and unanimously re‑elected Vice President. Both gave brief remarks focusing on recovery, equity, and the challenges ahead. - Executive Director’s Report & Tenant Relief Update (Item 9B): Executive Director Elaine Forbes reported on economic recovery, emphasizing shared prosperity with tenants. Acting Deputy Director Rebecca Benassini presented the status of tenant relief programs: about 50 % of eligible percentage‑rent tenants and LBE tenants had applied; only one‑third of civic‑impact tenants had applied, and maritime tenant outreach needed improvement. She noted implementation challenges—particularly the 10‑day operating requirement—and proposed solutions: applying the requirement prospectively with a 60‑day ramp‑up period and giving the Executive Director waiver discretion. The repayment program (Option A) had brought in nearly $840,000. Forbes also highlighted the Port’s Race Equity Action Plan (submitted to the Office of Racial Equity), a micro LBE hardship loan program (58 applications, 69 % minority/women‑owned, 55 % Black/brown‑owned), and the passage of the Water Resources Development Act of 2020 (WRDA), which helps fund resiliency projects and includes seismic cost considerations. Mission Rock construction is underway; the first two buildings will bring 102 affordable units and generated over $105 million in fees. - Youth Employment Program Contracts (Item 11A, Action): Contracts and Procurement Manager Stephanie Tang presented the award of two four‑year contracts (each up to $530,000) to Larkin Street Youth Services and RDJ Enterprises LLC for maintenance and beautification work at Port facilities, providing jobs and training to disadvantaged youth aged 16–24. The solicitation drew four proposals; one protest was denied. Commissioners asked about the previous contractors (San Francisco Conservation Corps and Hunters Point Family, who did not bid this time) and about the protest (lack of merit). The item was approved unanimously. - Broadway Cove Affordable Housing Update (Item 12A, Informational): Project Manager Ricky Tadani, developer Don Lusty (John Stewart Company), and Melissa Cardoza (Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development) reported that the 125‑unit family project (Broadway Cove) is 90 % complete and the 53‑unit senior project (735 Davis Street) is 98 % complete. The family project includes a restaurant, a YMCA‑operated child care center, and open space. The marketing period for family units closes January 13, 2021; as of the meeting morning, 7,736 applications had been received for 93 lottery units. Preferences include displaced tenant, neighborhood resident (District 3 or within half‑mile), and live/work in San Francisco. Commissioner Gilman asked about a homeless set‑aside; staff clarified that homeless units are in the senior building, not the family building. Commissioner Wuho inquired about unit mix (16 studios, 37 one‑bedrooms, 48 two‑bedrooms, 23 three‑bedrooms) and the child care center serving both residents and neighborhood low‑income families. - Embarcadero Enhancement Project (Item 13A, Informational): SFMTA staff Casey Hildreth and Mark Drager presented a phased plan. Phase 1A (quick‑build, 2021) would extend the two‑way bikeway from two blocks to six blocks in the central segment (Folsom to Broadway), using paint, posts, and signs to improve safety and reduce conflicts on the promenade. Phase 1B would add capital improvements (pedestrian islands, signal upgrades). The southern segment is under study; the northern segment is not currently funded but may be revisited. Parking meter impacts in Phase 1 are neutral/positive; Phase 2 may remove about 35 meters. Commissioners raised concerns about transit integration (F‑line), post‑pandemic travel patterns, bike lane usage, and revenue trade‑offs. SFMTA committed to ongoing collaboration and evaluation. No vote was taken. - New Business (Item 14): Vice President Adams suggested exploring use of Pier 32 for COVID‑19 vaccinations; Director Forbes agreed to investigate. Commissioner Gilman requested an overall update on the Port’s COVID‑19 response activities at a future meeting. Commissioner Wuho asked for a briefing on Port office space availability and marketing given changing lease patterns. Director Forbes noted follow‑up on the Italian consulate’s space interest. Key Outcomes - Elections: Kimberly Brandon re‑elected President; Willie Adams re‑elected Vice President (both unanimous). - Minutes Approved: December 8, 2020, meeting minutes passed unanimously. - Consent Calendar Adopted: Resolution 21‑01 (Pier 29 PPE/re‑grant) approved unanimously. - Youth Employment Contracts Awarded: Resolution 21‑02 awarded to Larkin Street Youth Services and RDJ Enterprises for four‑year terms, each up to $530,000 (unanimous). - No Action on Informational Items: The Commission received updates on Broadway Cove and the Embarcadero Enhancement Project; no votes were taken. - Directives and Next Steps: Staff will: Provide a COVID‑19 response update at a future commission meeting. Explore use of Pier 32 for vaccinations. Report on Port office space inventory and marketing. Follow up with the Italian consulate regarding space. Return in late spring for approval of the Embarcadero Enhancement Project Phase 1A.

PROCEDURAL 23% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 13% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 8%
1295
JAN 7, 2021 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
San Francisco Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - January 7, 2021

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on Thursday, January 7, 2021, at 10:00 AM, chaired by Supervisor Gordon Maher, with Vice Chair Aaron Peskin and member Matt Haney. The committee considered seven agenda items, including a resolution on community benefit district transparency, annual reports for three Community Benefit Districts, and three ordinances extending COVID-19 employment protections. All items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Items 2-4: Annual Reports for Civic Center, Central Market, and East Cut Community Benefit Districts – These resolutions receiving and approving annual reports for fiscal year 2018-2019 (Civic Center and East Cut) and calendar year 2018 (Central Market) were approved without opposition and recommended to the full board. Public Comments - No public comments were received on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1: Resolution Urging OEWD and Public Works to Adopt Policy on CBDs, BIDs, and GBDs Regarding Private Contributions and Surveillance Technology (File 201372) – Presented by Vice Chair Aaron Peskin, the resolution urges the Office of Economic and Workforce Development and Public Works to require disclosure of all private contributions, prohibit anonymous contributions, and require a public hearing before using surveillance technology. Supervisor Peskin noted concerns about anonymous donations and surveillance cameras potentially chilling First Amendment rights. An amendment was adopted to specify that contributions over $100 must be reported. Supervisors Maher and Haney co-sponsored the resolution. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the item as amended to the full board. - Items 2-3: Civic Center and Central Market CBD Annual Reports – Chris Corgas (OEWD) and Tracy Everwine (Executive Director of both CBDs) presented the reports. The Civic Center CBD met all four benchmarks, had a 93.59% weighted vote in favor of renewal through 2034, and reported activities including cleaning, safety, and community events. The Central Market CBD met three of four benchmarks (failed to indicate carry-forward designation), and reported challenges with illegal drug sales, encampments, and illegal vending, while collecting 29,000 needles in 2018. Supervisor Peskin inquired about the U.S. Department of Agriculture accessing surveillance footage from the Central Market CBD; Ms. Everwine agreed to provide more details. Supervisor Haney asked about tracking business storefront activity. The committee voted unanimously to recommend both items. - Item 4: East Cut CBD Annual Report (Fiscal Year 2018-2019) – Chris Corgas and Executive Director Andrew Robinson presented. The East Cut CBD met three of four benchmarks; the unmet benchmark was due to the nine-month closure of Salesforce Park (cracked structural beams), which shifted expense allocations. The CBD reported removing over 200,000 pounds of trash and 2,000 needles, and funding 80% of Salesforce Park operations. Supervisor Haney praised the partnership and neighborhood development. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the item. - Item 5: Ordinance Making Permanent COVID-19 Employment Protections (SAFER Act) – Police Code Amendment (File 201188) – Paul Mongey, legislative aide to Supervisor Ronen, presented the ordinance, which makes permanent the protections originally enacted as an emergency ordinance. It prohibits employers from firing, demoting, or discriminating against workers who test positive for COVID-19 or are quarantining. The ordinance aims to encourage testing by removing fear of job loss. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the item as a committee report to the full board for consideration on January 12, 2021. - Item 6: Reenactment of Emergency Ordinance for Grocery, Drug, Restaurant, and On-Demand Delivery Employee Protections (File 201329) – Supervisor Matt Haney presented the reenactment, extending the emergency ordinance for an additional 60 days. The ordinance provides health and scheduling protections and a complaint mechanism with the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the item as a committee report for the January 12, 2021 board meeting. - Item 7: Reenactment of Emergency Ordinance for Temporary Right to Reemployment Following Layoff Due to COVID-19 (File 201287) – Chair Maher presented the reenactment, extending the ordinance for 60 days. It requires employers to rehire laid-off workers before hiring new employees for substantially similar positions. The committee voted 2-0-1 (Vice Chair Peskin absent) to recommend the item as a committee report for the January 12, 2021 board meeting. Key Outcomes - All agenda items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Items 5, 6, and 7 were specifically requested to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda for January 12, 2021, while other items will appear on the January 26, 2021 agenda unless otherwise stated. Votes were unanimous for items 1-6; item 7 passed 2-0-1 (Peskin absent). The committee also noted that the Central Market CBD failed to meet benchmark 4 (carry-forward designation) and the East Cut CBD failed to meet benchmark 3 (budget variance) due to the Salesforce Park closure.

COMMUNITY BENEFIT DISTRICTS 47% · PROCEDURAL 21% · PUBLIC HEALTH 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
1296
DEC 15, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Meeting - December 15, 2020

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee met on Tuesday, December 15, 2020, via remote conference due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Chaired by Supervisor Gordon Mar, the committee considered two items: a reenactment of an emergency ordinance requiring public health emergency leave for large employers, and a Mills Act historical property contract for 450 Pacific Avenue. Both items were recommended as committee reports to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items Item 1: Emergency Ordinance – Public Health Emergency Leave (File 201264) Supervisor Mar introduced a reenactment of emergency ordinance 59-20, extending public health emergency leave for 60 days. The ordinance requires employers with 500 or more employees to provide two extra weeks of fully paid leave for workers impacted by COVID-19. Mar noted the ordinance had served as a model for statewide legislation and emphasized its importance amid the worst surge of the pandemic. No public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the item to the full board as a committee report. Item 2: Mills Act Historical Property Contract – 450 Pacific Avenue (File 201176) Michelle Taylor, Senior Preservation Planner at the Planning Department, presented a corrected cost estimate for the rehabilitation of 450 Pacific Avenue, a contributing building to the Jackson Square Historic District. The original November 19, 2020, presentation had incorrectly stated the rehabilitation cost as $782,655 over 10 years, omitting the ground floor storefront work. The corrected estimate is $1,280,338 over 10 years, with annual maintenance costs of $14,725. The property owner will receive an estimated property tax savings of $99,225 (a 26.46% reduction from the factored base year value). The rehabilitation plan includes storefront replacement, parapet flashing, roofing, window repairs, and brickwork. Michael Jine from the Assessor-Recorder’s Office clarified that the tax savings calculation uses a 2021 factored base year value, and the non-renewal scenario would result in different savings after 10 years. Property owner Larry Feldman expressed gratitude for the city’s commitment to historic preservation. No public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend the contract to the full board as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Public Health Emergency Leave): Unanimous vote (3-0) to recommend as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 2 (Mills Act Contract): Unanimous vote (3-0) to recommend as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors.

HISTORIC PRESERVATION 63% · PROCEDURAL 24% · PUBLIC HEALTH 9% · PUBLIC FINANCE 4%
1297
DEC 10, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting - December 10, 2020

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on December 10, 2020, at 6:15 PM. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Shamann Walton. The meeting was held remotely due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The agenda included two liquor license approvals, a hearing on the Economic Mitigation Working Group findings, a hearing on overdose death reporting and the SRO overdose prevention program, and a hearing on the Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were listed. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Economic Mitigation Working Group): David Zizunis (Med's Market) opposed the deemed approved uses fee and cigarette litter abatement fee, calling them unfair to small businesses. Miriam (Small Business Commission) supported the recommendations and urged updating the cigarette litter abatement fee. Henry Kanilowitz and other callers supported small business relief. - Item 4 (Overdose Death Reporting & SRO): Multiple callers, including Laura Thomas (San Francisco AIDS Foundation), Wesley Saver (Glide), and Andrew Reynolds (San Francisco AIDS Foundation), urged the city to open safe consumption sites, increase harm reduction services, and address racial disparities. Callers also emphasized the need for compassionate, evidence-based care and criticized over-policing. Discussion Items - Item 1 & 2: Liquor License Transfers - The committee heard from the Alcohol License Unit (ALU) and applicants. Tony Baloney's (1098 Howard) applied for a Type 21 off-sale license with no protests and two letters of support. The San Francisco Wine Society (408 Merchant) applied for a Type 42 on-sale license with no protests. Both had high-crime and high-saturation area conditions but received ALU support. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward both as committee reports to the full Board on December 15, 2020, finding public convenience or necessity. - Item 3: Economic Mitigation Working Group Findings and Recommendations - Dominica Donovan (Office of Small Business) presented 15 recommendations from a working group formed after the e-cigarette ban. Recommendations included allowing transfer of tobacco retail permits to family members, improving language access, reforming fees (e.g., point-of-sale inspection fee, cigarette litter abatement fee), expanding programs like SF Shines and Healthy Retail SF, and creating a bulk purchasing program. Supervisor Walton filed the hearing, with plans to implement recommendations. - Item 4: Overdose Death Reporting and Update on Overdose Prevention Program at SRO Hotels - Supervisor Matt Haney called the hearing to address the overdose crisis. Dr. Lick Rudder (Office of the Chief Medical Examiner) reported that from January to October 2020, 570 people died of accidental overdoses, 70% involving fentanyl. This exceeds all 2019 deaths (441) and nearly tripled 2017 deaths (222). 27% of decedents were unhoused, 41% of deaths occurred in District 6 (Tenderloin/South of Market), and Black men in SROs died at disproportionately high rates. DPH representatives Katie Burke and Eileen Lochran presented on the SRO overdose prevention program, which is currently active in only two SROs due to COVID-19 staffing and focus shifts to shelter-in-place (SIP) hotels. They noted that over 5,200 lives were saved by naloxone in 2019-2020 but that the city lacks standardized harm reduction policies across housing sites. Supervisor Haney emphasized the need for a coordinated, urgent response, including overdose prevention sites and expanded treatment access. - Item 5: San Francisco Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report - This hearing was continued to February 11, 2021, due to the COVID-19 surge, per Chair Mandelman's request (passed 2-0 after Mandelman was excused). Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2: Unanimously approved (3-0) as committee reports for the December 15, 2020 Board of Supervisors meeting. - Item 3: Hearing filed (3-0). Supervisor Walton committed to pursuing legislative and administrative implementation of the recommendations. - Item 4: Hearing filed (2-0). Supervisor Haney announced plans for further hearings and legislation, including work to open overdose prevention sites. DPH was urged to standardize harm reduction policies across all housing sites. - Item 5: Continued to February 11, 2021, by a 2-0 vote. Note: Chair Mandelman was excused from the remainder of the meeting after Item 4 due to a conflict with another committee assignment, leaving Vice Chair Stefani to preside.

SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 43% · PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 11% · TOBACCO REGULATION 7%
1298
DEC 8, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting – December 8, 2020

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, December 8, 2020, at 2:00 p.m. via video conference. President Kimberly Brandon called the meeting to order with a quorum present (Commissioners Brandon, Adams, Burton, Gilman, and Wuho). The meeting covered the Executive Director’s report, an informational presentation on the Port’s Racial Equity Action Plan, approval of two construction contracts, approval of a rent forgiveness and repayment program, approval of street names at Mission Rock, and an informational presentation on park dedication issues. Public comment was received on one item. The meeting adjourned at 6:13 p.m. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Accepted and expended a $90,500 grant from the California Department of Parks and Recreation for removal, storage, and disposal of abandoned vessels (Resolution 2051). - Item 10B: Retroactively authorized modification of Construction Contract No. 2812, Crane Cove Park Improvements and 19th St. Parking Lot, to extend the substantial and final completion date (Resolution 2052). - Both items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 13A – Civic Impact Rent Forgiveness & Tenant Repayment Program: Braxton Cahill, Controller of Aquarium of the Bay (a 501(c)(3) nonprofit at Pier 39), requested that the aquarium be included in the rent forgiveness program. He noted that the aquarium had been closed for over seven months in 2020, faced $8+ million in revenue loss, and was not eligible due to the $3 million budget threshold. He also highlighted that the aquarium pays rent to both Pier 39 and the Port. Port staff committed to following up directly. - No public comments were made on any other items. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A): Director Elaine Forbes reported on the Port’s economic recovery efforts amid the COVID-19 surge, noting that the strict stay-at-home order would impact tenants. Key updates included: - 88 Broadway: 100% affordable 120-unit project nearing completion, with applications starting by end of December. - Fireboat Station 35: Steel float delivered; landside connections to be completed over 4–5 months, with spring 2021 completion. - Embarcadero Enhancement Project: Three quick-build safety improvements (Pier 35, Ferry Building, Rincon Restaurant Zone) operational or near completion. - LBE & Crabber Loan Programs: Launched; applications being accepted. - Fisherman’s Wharf CBD: Port-side assessment district failed 45% to 55% at the Board of Supervisors on November 17, 2020; loss of funding for events like 4th of July and Fleet Week. - Port’s Equity Program & Racial Equity Action Plan (Item 11A): Staff presented the draft plan, including internal (phase one) and external (phase two) actions. Key points: - Workforce demographics: Port is more racially diverse than the city workforce overall. - Employee survey (fall 2019): 40% response rate (129 of 278 employees); 43% agreed racial disparities exist at the Port. - Listening tours identified needs for transparency in hiring, career pathways, and bias elimination training. - Proposed actions include de-identified discipline, expanded recruitment outreach, and manager training. - Commissioners emphasized the need for measurable goals, ongoing feedback, and collaboration with the Office of Racial Equity. - Contract Awards: - Item 12A (SFPD Marine Unit Dock Replacement): Awarded to Power Engineering Construction for $1,419,896 (plus $123,420 contingency, total $1,543,316). FEMA grant expires May 31, 2021; construction must start April 1, 2021. - Item 12B (Heron’s Head Park Path and Electrical Improvements): Awarded to CF Contracting, Inc. for $1,237,800 (plus $123,780 contingency, total $1,361,580). Nearly 100% LBE participation; funded by 2012 GO bonds. - Parks & Public Way Declaration (Item 13C): Informational presentation on a temporary declaration of restrictions to allow building permits for Parcel K North at Pier 70, ensuring emergency egress and fire separation across a future plaza. The permanent solution will be park dedication once the plaza is built. Key Outcomes - Votes (all unanimous): - Consent Calendar (Resolutions 2051, 2052) approved. - Construction Contract 2831, SFPD Marine Unit Dock Replacement (Resolution 2053) approved. - Construction Contract 2795, Heron’s Head Park Path and Electrical Improvements (Resolution 2054) approved. - Civic Impact Rent Forgiveness Program (Resolution 2055) and Tenant Repayment Program (Resolution 2056) approved. - Street names Maya Angelou Lane and Toni Stone Crossing at Mission Rock (Resolution 2057) approved. - No votes on informational items (9A, 11A, 13C). - Next steps: - Staff will follow up with Aquarium of the Bay regarding rent relief. - Racial Equity Action Plan to be submitted to the Office of Racial Equity by December 31, 2020; staff will return semi-annually with updates. - Declaration of restrictions for Parcel K North will be brought to the commission for approval at the next meeting. - Street naming item to be forwarded to the Board of Supervisors for approval in early 2021.

PROCEDURAL 40% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · RACIAL EQUITY 9% · PUBLIC WORKS 6%
1299
NOV 18, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget Committee Hears Economic Update and Approves Early Education Plan on November 18, 2020

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Sandra Lee Fewer, convened a special meeting on November 18, 2020, originally scheduled for 1:00 p.m. but delayed due to scheduling conflicts. The committee received an update on the city's economic and fiscal outlook for FY 2020-2021 and approved a five-year spending plan for the Early Care and Education for All Initiative (Babies and Families First Fund). Key takeaways include a projected $116 million general fund shortfall, driven largely by business tax losses due to telecommuting, and a unanimous vote to send the spending plan to the full board. Discussion Items - Economic & Financial Update (Item 1): Controller Ben Rosenfield, economist Ted Egan, and Michelle Allersman presented the first quarter report for FY 2020-2021. Key findings: a $116 million projected general fund shortfall, including $99 million from business taxes due to higher-than-expected telecommuting (100% of office workers assumed telecommuting through September, then 75% for the rest of the year). Sales tax revenue was down 43% in Q2 (April–June), the largest drop of any California county. Hotel tax revenue loss doubled from a 30% decline to 60% decline in RevPAR. The sheriff's department faced an $11.5 million overtime shortfall due to training and relocation from County Jail 4. Controller Rosenfield noted potential upside from Prop F passage (removed a major budget risk), Prop I (transfer tax increase estimated at $11 million), and possible federal stimulus. However, he cautioned about downside risks from a slower economic recovery, especially in hospitality and office sectors. The committee discussed the connection between telecommuting and the city's business tax apportionment, with Supervisor Walton and others expressing concern that Prop F did not fully address the tax base erosion from remote work. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. - Early Care & Education Spending Plan (Item 2): President Norman Yi introduced the resolution approving the Office of Early Care and Education's (OECE) five-year spending plan for the Babies and Families First Fund, funded by Prop C (stuck in court) and unlocked by Prop F. The plan prioritizes workforce compensation, subsidies for low/middle-income families, and whole-child services. OECE Deputy Director Denise Cervino highlighted extensive community engagement in 2018–2019 and noted ongoing adjustments due to the pandemic. President Yi announced the creation of an Early Care and Education Economic Recovery Grant and Loan Program to support child care providers during COVID-19. The resolution passed unanimously (4-0-1, with Supervisor Ronin absent). Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: David Pilpel commented on the telecommute mandate's impact on business taxes and asked for budget instructions timelines. He requested the staff presentation be posted to Legistar. - Item 2: A speaker asked about digital learning platforms for children during the pandemic, suggesting satellite spaces and following UN refugee camp models. June Bug, a parent leader with San Francisco Parent Voices, expressed support for the spending plan but called for transparency and specific strategies to reduce the 3,000-child waitlist, increase voucher amounts or slots, and support centers affected by the pandemic. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Hearing): Continued to the call of the chair. The committee did not take a vote on the hearing itself but will revisit after more data, including the five-year forecast and ERAF guidance expected in December. - Item 2 (Spending Plan): Approved with a positive recommendation by a vote of 4 ayes (Supervisors Walton, Mandelman, President Yi, Chair Fewer) with 1 absent (Supervisor Ronin). The resolution will appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on December 1, 2020. - Next Steps: The controller's office, mayor's budget office, and budget analyst will publish a five-year financial forecast in early December. A mid-year rebalancing proposal from the mayor is expected around the same time. The committee will receive a six-month report in early February 2021.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 54% · PUBLIC HEALTH 12% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 12% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
1300
NOV 12, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Meeting – November 12, 2020

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on November 12, 2020, chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Shamann Walton. The committee considered two items: a hearing on the SB 1045 housing conservatorship program and a proposed ordinance to prohibit smoking in multi-unit housing. Public Comments & Testimony - Housing Conservatorship Hearing (Item 1): No public comments were received. - No-Smoking Ordinance (Item 2): Over 25 public speakers voiced strong support for the ordinance. Many urged the committee to pass a comprehensive policy without an exemption for medical marijuana, arguing that secondhand cannabis smoke poses similar health risks to tobacco smoke. Several speakers shared personal experiences of suffering from drifting smoke in their apartments. A few speakers opposed the medical cannabis exemption, while one speaker (Chris Schulman) requested an exemption for his disabled wife who relies on smoked cannabis for medical relief. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Hearing on SB 1045 Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report: Chair Mandelman recounted that since June 2020 the committee had held multiple hearings on the city’s failure to file any SB 1045 conservatorship petitions. Despite repeated assurances from the Department of Public Health and the Office of Public Conservator, no petition had been filed by November 12. Mandelman moved to continue the hearing to December 10, 2020, and to require testimony from the directors of those departments. The motion passed unanimously. - Item 2 – Ordinance to Prohibit Smoking in Multi-Unit Housing Complexes: Board President Norman Yee presented an ordinance amending the Health Code to prohibit smoking in all dwelling units and common areas of multi-unit housing with three or more units, and to remove exceptions for child care facilities. The Department of Public Health (Marina Spiegel and Jennifer Callewart) presented data on secondhand smoke harms, noting that 53% of San Franciscans live in multi-unit housing and are 3.5 times more likely to report drifting smoke. Proposed amendments included: clarifying that two-unit common areas remain covered; extending the ban to child care facilities in single-family homes/duplexes; exempting medical marijuana use; and stating that violations are not grounds for eviction and do not require landlords to change existing lease terms. Chair Mandelman expressed concern about the difficulty cannabis users face finding legal places to smoke, but supported moving the amended ordinance forward. Supervisor Walton praised the tenant protections. The committee unanimously adopted the amendments, then voted 3-0 to send the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation. Key Outcomes - Housing Conservatorship Hearing: Continued to the December 10, 2020 regular meeting of the committee. Directors Colfax and Rohr are expected to testify. - No-Smoking Ordinance: Amendments were adopted (including medical marijuana exemption, child care clarification, eviction protection, and two-unit common area clarification). The amended ordinance was forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a 3-0 vote and no committee recommendation. The item will appear on the December 1, 2020 Board agenda.

PUBLIC HEALTH 51% · TOBACCO REGULATION 19% · PROCEDURAL 9% · PUBLIC COMMENT 7%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com