The Port Commission met virtually on August 11, 2020, at 3:15 PM in response to the COVID-19 emergency. The meeting focused on economic recovery, rent relief for tenants, loan programs for micro-LBEs and crab fishers, waterfront development projects including Pier 70 and Piers 38/40, and a living shoreline project at Heron’s Head Park. The Commission also honored retiring Chief Operating Officer Byron Rhett and introduced new Diversity, Equity and Opportunity Manager Toni Autry. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes – July 14, 2020: Approved unanimously (4-0). - Announcements: Members of the public were reminded of the 3-minute comment limit and instructions for remote participation. Public Comments & Testimony - Stacy Randecker (Petrero Hill resident): Urged the Commission to close the Embarcadero to vehicle traffic (at minimum from Third and King to Fisherman’s Wharf) to create safe outdoor space and support businesses during the pandemic, citing the Valencia Street model. - Justin Baker (son of Byron Rhett): Thanked the Commission for honoring his father and highlighted Byron’s passion for public space and urban development. - Herman Badgett (RDJ Enterprise): Supported the micro-LBE emergency loan program, noting the critical need for capital among small contractors. - John Barnett (President, Crab Boat Owners Association): Thanked the Commission for the crab fisher loan program and emphasized the urgency of funding. - Drew (operator of sailing school at South Beach Harbor): Reported that June and July charter revenues were down 92% and 97% respectively, and requested rent forgiveness for the months the business was forced to close. - Pete Sitnik (Managing Partner, Waterbar): Supported the proposed percentage rent forgiveness program and urged expedited action, as his restaurant’s revenues remain 65–75% below pre-COVID levels. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report Elaine Forbes provided an update on the Port’s economic reopening and recovery, noting that the city’s reopening is paused due to rising COVID-19 cases. She announced the hiring of Toni Autry as the Port’s new Diversity, Equity and Opportunity Manager, and introduced her. Autry outlined the Port’s racial equity action plan, due December 31, 2020. Forbes also reported on the summer internship program (Opportunities for All) and delivered a tribute to Byron Rhett, who is retiring after 20 years at the Port. Multiple commissioners and staff members expressed their gratitude for Rhett’s leadership and mentorship. Public comment from Justin Baker (son) was received. Item 7A: Micro-LBE Emergency Relief Loan Program ($1M from Southern Waterfront Fund) Stephanie Tang presented the program, which offers zero-interest loans up to $50,000 to micro-LBEs financially harmed by COVID-19. Key changes since the initial informational item: removed PPP as a criterion, improved administrative process with a lottery to prioritize equity, and a short inquiry application. Commissioners discussed loan amounts; President Brandon proposed amending the maximum to $25,000 to reach more businesses, with the executive director allowed to increase for hardship. Commissioner Wuho raised concerns about ensuring the loans lead to business survival. The amendment was seconded and passed unanimously. Item 7B: Crab Fisher Economic Assistance Loan Program ($1M from Capital Contingency) Boris Ellipine presented the program for crab fishers impacted by the May 23rd Pier 45 fire. Loans of 0% interest, up to five years, with a tiered formula based on trap costs. Three changes since last meeting: eliminated late fees, added hardship provisions, and required a liability release. Public comment from John Barnett (Crab Boat Owners Association) was supportive. Passed unanimously. Item 8A: Street Name Change – Channel Street to Mission Creek Rod Iwashta and Mark Slutskin (Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure) presented the proposal to rename the navigable waterway to its common name, Mission Creek, without affecting residents’ addresses. Community outreach received unanimous support from the Mission Bay Citizens Advisory Committee and Southern Waterfront Advisory Group. Passed unanimously. Item 8B: SFPD Marine Unit Dock Replacement – Authorization to Advertise for Bids Noel Aquino presented the $1.33 million FEMA-funded project to construct a new dock for the SFPD Marine Unit at Hyde Street Harbor. The project includes a 20% DBE goal. Passed unanimously. Item 9A: Exclusive Negotiating Agreement (ENA) for Piers 38 & 40 with Pacific Waterfront Partners David Beaupre presented the RFP process and recommended entering negotiations with Pacific Waterfront Partners (PWP), the highest-scoring respondent. PWP’s vision includes a public playground, maritime uses, retail, and a total investment of $383 million. Simon Snellgrove (PWP) thanked the Commission. No public comment. Passed unanimously. Item 9B: Informational – Pier 70 Mixed-Use District Project Status Christine Maher and Jack Sylvan (Brookfield) updated progress: 75% of phase one horizontal improvements complete; vertical construction delayed due to COVID-19. Brookfield declined to exercise options on parcels A and E2 due to appraised values not reflecting current market conditions; both parties are disputing appraisals with a goal of transacting early next year. The model shows developer return dropping from 19% to 17.5–18.7%. The Port and Brookfield are exploring land bonds to improve project finances. Commissioners requested regular updates. No action taken. Item 9C: Amendment to Pier 70 Special Use District Design – Allow 9 Stories in 90-ft Height Limit Ryan Walsham and Christine Maher presented the amendment, which allows an extra floor (up to 9 stories) by reducing floor-to-ceiling heights, without increasing overall maximum height or total development capacity. The Planning Commission approved it unanimously in February. Passed unanimously. Item 9D: Memorandum of Understanding for Pier 70 Infrastructure Rebecca Benissini presented the MOU that assigns responsibility for public infrastructure to various city agencies (e.g., Public Works, SFPUC, SFMTA) and retains port management for parks and unique features. An overland flow issue on 20th Street is addressed with a short-term construction restriction and a long-term solution to be developed. Passed unanimously. Item 9E: Informational – Opt-In Rent Deferral Program and Proposed Rent Forgiveness Strategy Rebecca Benissini and Chrisia Jones presented results of the opt-in rent deferral program: 73 of 505 tenants opted in; July rent collection was 52% ($3.3M). The proposed rent forgiveness targets three groups: percentage rent tenants (up to 14 months of base rent forgiveness, earlier of stabilization or 14 months), select maritime tenants (3 months of base rent forgiveness), and LBE tenants (3 months). The total maximum base rent forgiveness is estimated at $12.7 million, partially offset by percentage rent. Public comments from two tenants stressed the need for rapid action. Commissioners expressed support but asked to consider expanding maritime forgiveness to six months. They agreed to hold a special meeting before the September 8 meeting to vote on the program. Item 9F: MOU with OEWD for Use of Pier 29 for PPE Distribution Don Kavanaugh presented a 30-day MOU allowing OEWD to use Pier 29 as a central PPE distribution hub for 1.5 million masks, 600,000 face shields, and 21,000 gallons of hand sanitizer. The Port will defer the $123,750 fee and seek reimbursement from state/federal programs. Passed unanimously. Item 10A: Informational – Heron’s Head Park Living Shoreline Project Carol Bach presented the project to address erosion and restore wetlands using a nature-based shoreline. The San Francisco Bay Restoration Authority has awarded $297,000 for phase one (two years of wetland revegetation). A sole-source contract with Literacy for Environmental Justice (LEJ) is proposed for native plant propagation and youth employment. The larger shoreline stabilization ($2.46 million) is unfunded but under grant applications. Commissioners praised the equity focus and plan to bring an action item in September. Key Outcomes - Votes on Action Items: All resolutions (No. 20-33 through 20-40) passed unanimously (4-0). - Resolution 20-33 (Micro-LBE loan program) was amended to reduce the maximum loan from $50,000 to $25,000, and to allow the executive director to grant hardship increases. - Special Meeting Scheduled: The Commission directed staff to arrange a special meeting before September 8, 2020, to approve the rent forgiveness program, with consideration of extending maritime tenant relief to six months. - Pier 70 Updates: Staff will provide periodic updates on the appraisal process for parcels A and E2 and overall project status. - Dedication: The meeting was adjourned in honor of Congressman John Lewis, as requested by President Brandon.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on July 23, 2020, via video conference due to the COVID-19 emergency. Chair Raphael Mandelman presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stephanie and Supervisor Shamann Walton (transcript spells Shimon but likely Shamann). The committee considered four items: a liquor license issuance, a resolution declaring anti-Black racism a public health crisis, a hearing on the housing conservatorship program, and a hearing on COVID-19 impacts on behavioral health services for unhoused residents. Liquor License Issuance - 706 Mission Street The committee held a hearing on a Type 57 liquor license for the Four Seasons Private Residences. The item had been continued from March 12 to allow for additional community outreach. No public comments were received. The committee voted unanimously to forward a resolution finding public convenience and necessity to the full board. Resolution Declaring Anti-Black Racism as a Human Rights and Public Health Crisis Supervisor Walton presented the resolution, co-sponsored by several supervisors. Presenters from the Human Rights Commission, Department of Public Health, and the community group Mega Black SF testified that anti-Black racism drives disparities, noting that Black people comprise about 5% of the city's population but 10% of COVID-19 deaths. Supervisor Walton read amendments to update statistics and add a clause referencing the Health Commission's passage of a similar resolution. A technical issue initially prevented public comment, leading the committee to rescind its vote and reopen the comment period. Public comment included support from a nurse and a representative of taxpayers for public safety, and a suggestion to change "prioritize" to "ensure" in the resolution. The committee then voted unanimously to forward the amended resolution to the full board. Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report The committee heard an update from Angelica Almeida (Department of Public Health) and Jill Nielsen (Office of the Public Conservator) on the SB 1045 housing conservatorship program. As of the hearing, no petitions had been filed, but a few individuals were nearing the threshold of eight 5150 holds. The program aims to intervene at the fifth hold with voluntary services. Almeida noted that most individuals currently on the pathway are Caucasian, but data on racial breakdown would be provided. Public comment was extensive: supporters, including Rescue SF and neighborhood groups, urged expanded conservatorship and funding; opponents, including Senior and Disability Action and TNDC, argued the program is racially discriminatory and that voluntary services and housing are underfunded. The committee voted to continue the hearing to September 10, 2020. Impacts of COVID-19 on Behavioral Health Needs of Unhoused San Franciscans Dr. Hallie Hammer (Director of Ambulatory Care) presented DPH's plan for implementing Mental Health SF, focusing on an Office of Coordinated Care, behavioral health bed investments, street crisis response teams, and a mental health service center. Costs were discussed, including a $13 million annual cost for a 24/7 mental health service center and a $10 million investment to reduce bed wait times to zero. Public comment included support for crisis response teams and safe sleeping sites, criticism of the police response, and concerns about racial disparities. The committee filed the hearing after discussion. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded liquor license resolution to full board (3-0). - Item 2: Forwarded amended resolution to full board (3-0). - Item 3: Continued hearing to September 10, 2020 (3-0). - Item 4: Filed hearing (3-0).
The San Francisco Port Commission met virtually on July 14, 2020, to address a range of urgent issues stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and recent fires. Key actions included approving a consent item, authorizing a construction contract, and receiving informational presentations on proposed economic relief programs for local businesses, crab fishers, and port tenants. Commissioners also heard public testimony, honored retiring employees, and discussed the timeline for future decisions. Consent Calendar - Resolution No. 20-31: Unanimously approved a request to delegate vote renewal of the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District to affected tenants, consistent with past practice. Public Comments & Testimony - Pike Racino (business owner, Martin Sports Fishing) expressed full support for the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District. - Laura Schaefer (Deputy Director, Fisherman's Wharf CBD) spoke about challenges faced by the fishing vessel F/B Pioneer in finding a viable location for retail fish sales, acknowledging port staff's efforts. - Tom Creedon (Scoma's Restaurant) thanked the port for flexibility allowing outdoor dining, which brought back over half of 140 laid-off workers. - Frank Cristino (third-generation fisherman, tenant since 1908) expressed strong support for port staff and Scoma's, and urged continued assistance for the fishing industry. - John Barnett (President, Crab Boat Owners Association) thanked the port for its help after the Pier 45 fire, noting that about 30 fishermen lost everything, and stressed the need for continued aid. - James Bryant (CEO, JBR Partners) supported the proposed LBE hardship loan program, stating his company faced a 59.4% loss ratio and might not survive without assistance. - Noelle Bonner (CEO, Bonner Communications) applauded the port's proactive LBE support program, noting the disproportionate impact of COVID-19 on small businesses. - Monica Wilson (micro LBE consultant) voiced strong support, saying the program “is absolutely another tool in the LBE toolbox.” - Multiple crab fishers (John Meller, Nick Krieger, John Barnett, Eric Anklinson) testified about the devastating loss of gear in the Pier 45 Shed C fire and expressed urgent need for loan and grant programs. - Kevin Wesley (Louis' Restaurant), Pete Sitnik (Water Bar & Epic Steak), Drew Harper (Spinnaker Sailing), Mahogany Roland (Rebuilding Together San Francisco), and Peter Osborne (Mission Rock Resort) urged adoption of the rent forgiveness program, describing severe revenue declines (20–25% of pre-COVID). Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report – Elaine Forbes updated on Pier 45 fire recovery: cleaning of Sheds A, B, D complete; demolition of Shed C expected to take five weeks; insurance covers rebuilding. A separate grass fire at Heron's Head Park on July 4 burned 3 acres and a beehive but spared the Eco Center. The port is reopening Pier 50 maintenance division with COVID safety protocols. Commendations were given to retiring Deputy Director Tom Carter (15 years at port, 26 with city) and Administrative Assistant Marie Mitchell (42 years with city), both hailed as integral to the maintenance division. - 8A: Informational on LBE Support Program – Stephanie Tang presented a proposed $1 million emergency hardship loan program for micro LBEs (majority women/minority-owned), with loans up to $50,000 at 0% interest, partially forgivable. Also proposed rent forgiveness for LBE tenants ($160,000 for three months). Funding from Southern Waterfront Community Benefits and Beautification Fund. Commissioners expressed strong support. - 8B: Informational on Crab Fisher Loan Program – Boris Celapine presented a $1 million loan program for crab fishers impacted by the Pier 45 fire. Loans would have 5-year terms, 0% interest, up to $100/trap for first 200 traps, with the remainder allocated proportionally. Partnership with OEWD and Main Street Launch. Public comment noted that the program should also consider used gear and line/float purchases. - 9A: Request to Advertise Heron's Head Park Construction Contract – Erica Peterson requested authorization to advertise Contract 2795 for park improvements (ADA paths, solar panel upgrade, lighting, fencing). Funded by $1.3 million from 2012 GO bonds. 20% LBE participation goal. Unanimously approved. - 10A: Informational on Piers 38 & 40 RFP Results – David Beaupre reported two responses: Orton Development (106 points) and Pacific Waterfront Partners (PWP) (114 points). Scoring panel recommended PWP. Simon Snellgrove (PWP) presented a vision including youth sailing, public market, wetland restoration, and a community lab/career incubator. Commissioners praised the inclusion of Cornerstone and commitment to equity. - 10B: Informational on Rent Deferral and Forgiveness Strategy – Chrisia Tano Lee presented a proposal to forgive base rent for three categories: (1) 51 percentage-rent tenants (mostly restaurants) through April 2021 ($14.5 million); (2) 122 maritime tenants (fishers, processors) through May 2020 ($700,000); (3) 28 LBE tenants through May 2020 ($160,000). A fourth criteria-based category would cover other eligible tenants. Commissioners raised concerns about fiscal sustainability (port facing a projected $55 million revenue loss), the need for better data from the opt-in deferral program, and the importance of balancing tenant relief with the port's solvency. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Resolution 20-31): Approved unanimously. - Heron's Head Park Construction Contract (Resolution 20-32): Approved unanimously (4-0). - LBE and Crab Fisher Programs: Commissioners directed staff to schedule a special meeting before the August 11 regular meeting to move these items to action. - Rent Forgiveness Strategy: No action taken; staff will return with a more data-informed proposal incorporating commissioner feedback (e.g., extending maritime forgiveness, clarifying criteria for Category 4, and addressing balance sheet impacts). - Racial Equity: President Brandon requested an update on racial equity initiatives at each meeting; Executive Director Forbes committed to providing updates and introducing the new Social Responsibility Manager at the next meeting. - Future Meetings: The commission will continue meeting virtually through at least the end of 2020. A special meeting will be scheduled for late July/early August to advance LBE and crab fisher programs, with further discussion on rent forgiveness planned.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, held a remote meeting on July 9, 2020, via video conference due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The committee considered four items: a liquor license for a new wine bar, a resolution condemning racial profiling and discriminatory harassment, an ordinance to strengthen illegal dumping enforcement, and an ordinance to update health standards for adult sex venues. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (Adult Sex Venue Health Standards): Two members of the public testified in support. - Paul Aguilar, a fifth-generation native San Franciscan and member of the San Francisco AIDS Foundation’s HIV Advocacy Network, stated that the closure of bathhouses was based on fear, shame, stigma, and homophobia, and that public health policy should be based on scientific facts, especially given the availability of PrEP for HIV prevention. - Race Bannon, a longtime LGBTQ writer, activist, and organizer and San Francisco resident since 1994, expressed support, arguing that allowing privacy and personal agency leads to better sexual health and that such venues can deliver important sexual health information. Discussion Items 1. Liquor License – 620 Post Street (The Nobody Inn) - The Alcohol Licensing Unit (ALU) recommended approval with conditions (monitoring adjacent property and noise control). The applicant, Nicola Archiero, described the business as a low-key, unpretentious wine bar focusing on small-production local beer, wine, and cheese. Supervisor Mandelman noted Supervisor Peskin’s support. No public comments were received. The committee adopted a resolution finding public convenience or necessity and forwarded it to the full board with a positive recommendation. 2. Resolution Condemning Racial Profiling and Discrimination Harassment - Supervisor Shamann Walton introduced the resolution, highlighting numerous incidents of racial profiling in San Francisco and nationwide, including his own experience. He noted the introduction of the “Cairn Act” to stop false racist 911 calls and reported over 2,0120 (as stated) firsthand accounts of anti-Asian hate during the COVID-19 pandemic, with 172 incidents in San Francisco. Supervisor Mandelman and Supervisor Stefani added their names as co-sponsors. The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. 3. Illegal Dumping Enforcement Ordinance - Supervisor Walton presented the ordinance, noting over 91,000 service requests for illegal dumping last year in San Francisco, costing the city $10 million annually. Districts 9 and 10 have the highest rates. The ordinance expands the definition of illegal dumping, allows Department of Public Works employees to issue citations (previously only SFPD could), and includes amendments from the District Attorney’s office to preserve other enforcement actions. Supervisor Stefani and Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsors. The committee accepted minor amendments and forwarded the ordinance as amended to the full board. 4. Adult Sex Venue Health and Safety Standards - Supervisor Mandelman introduced the ordinance to require the Department of Public Health to adopt updated health standards for commercial adult sex venues, removing requirements for monitoring patron sexual activities and for unlocked doors. He emphasized that the closure of bathhouses during the AIDS epidemic had no remaining public health rationale given PrEP and new HIV diagnoses falling below 200 for the first time since the 1980s. The ordinance would not allow reopening before it is safe under COVID-19 orders. An amendment pushed the adoption deadline to January 1, 2021. The committee accepted the amendment and forwarded the ordinance as amended to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimous (3-0) vote to forward the resolution of public convenience and necessity for the liquor license to the full board. - Item 2: Unanimous (3-0) vote to forward the resolution condemning racial profiling to the full board. - Item 3: Unanimous (3-0) votes to accept amendments and forward the illegal dumping ordinance as amended to the full board. - Item 4: Unanimous (3-0) votes to accept the amendment (deadline extension) and forward the adult sex venue ordinance as amended to the full board. All items will appear on the Board of Supervisors meeting agenda on July 21, 2020.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, met on June 25, 2020, at 10:15 AM. The committee included Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Hillary Ronan, who replaced Supervisor Walton. The meeting featured two hearings: (1) a review of the San Francisco Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report and (2) an examination of COVID-19's impact on the city's behavioral health response to unhoused residents. The discussions highlighted significant delays in implementing the new conservatorship law, persistent gaps in mental health services, and the exacerbating effects of the pandemic. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Housing Conservatorship): Numerous callers expressed concerns. Jennifer Steen, a psych nurse and working group member, noted that the city lacks housing for conserved individuals, data on whether people with multiple 5150 holds were offered housing is missing, and black people are disproportionately affected (33% of those with 4+ 5150s). Gabby Ruiz (TNDC) highlighted racial disparities and police involvement. Several speakers, including a family doctor and representatives from the Coalition on Homelessness, argued for expanding voluntary services and housing first, opposing conservatorship as a violation of civil liberties. Others, like Carolyn Kennedy and Tom Metz, supported conservatorship for those in severe psychosis, citing public safety and the need for urgent action. - Item 2 (COVID-19 & Behavioral Health): Callers urged implementation of Mental Health SF. Javier Vermont (Treatment on Demand Coalition) called for investing in treatment and housing rather than police. Mary Kate Bacalao (Compass Family Services) noted skyrocketing demand for therapy among homeless families. Carolyn Kennedy asked for clear budget figures for beds. Molly Brown suggested buying motels for shelter and connecting with case management. Discussion Items - Housing Conservatorship Preliminary Evaluation Report (Item 1): Supervisor Mandelman expressed frustration that no one had been conserved under SB 1045 after a year. Angelica Almeida (DPH) presented data: 3,800 unique individuals placed on 5150 holds in FY 2018-19, with 117 having 4+ holds; 10 individuals currently have 8+ holds. The working group's report was delayed due to court paperwork issues, now resolved. Supervisor Mandelman pressed for a timeline and noted that the city lacks beds for the program. Jill Nielsen (DAS) explained the legal complexity. Supervisor Stefani questioned the lack of state hospital beds. The hearing was continued to July 23, 2020, for a check-in. - Impacts of COVID-19 on Behavioral Health (Item 2): Hallie Hammer (DPH) described service disruptions: 60% of visits shifted to telehealth, 85% of established clients maintained contact, but acute care demand did not increase as expected. She outlined four priorities: street response, care coordination, bed optimization, and crisis outreach. Dr. Anton Nigussie Bland presented a bed modeling study, recommending 31 new locked acute beds, 18 psychiatric nursing facility beds, 16 residential care beds, and 16 12-month residential treatment beds at an annual operating cost of $11 million. He emphasized the need for a one-to-one housing placement complement. Supervisor Ronan criticized DPH for not using Mental Health SF as the blueprint, arguing that the department's approach remains fragmented. Supervisor Mandelman questioned the lack of a crisis stabilization facility for people in psychosis and the absence of funding for expanded street outreach and care coordination. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Housing Conservatorship): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the regular meeting of July 23, 2020, to receive a progress update. - Item 2 (COVID-19 & Behavioral Health): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair, with the expectation that DPH will return with more detailed cost estimates for street crisis response, care coordination, and crisis stabilization capacity. - General: Supervisor Mandelman requested DPH provide dollar figures for meaningful progress on outreach and care coordination. Supervisor Ronan requested a follow-up meeting with DPH to align on Mental Health SF implementation.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee held a special meeting on June 19, 2020 (Juneteenth) to consider a resolution urging the Civil Service Commission to disqualify police officer and sheriff deputy applicants with prior serious misconduct. The meeting was chaired by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and included Supervisors Shamann Walton and Ahsha Safai. District Attorney Chesa Boudin joined as a co-sponsor. The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration on June 23, 2020. Public Comments & Testimony - First caller (physician and voting member): Expressed support for the resolution but cautioned that it is a small step that should not replace larger, more controversial reforms such as defunding the police. Urged the committee to pursue substantial changes alongside this measure. - Second caller (Mimi Klausner, 35-year resident): Voiced strong support for the resolution but argued it does not go far enough. Called for a "grandfather clause" to remove current SFPD officers with prior misconduct in other jurisdictions and advocated for defunding the police department. Cited the case of Officer Joshua Cabillo, who was involved in shootings after being hired by SFPD despite a prior incident. Discussion Items - Resolution (File 200592): Introduced by Supervisor Walton and co-sponsored by eight other supervisors plus Supervisor Safai (added during the meeting). The resolution urges the Civil Service Commission to adopt rules disqualifying applicants for uniformed positions in the San Francisco Police Department or Sheriff's Office if they have: - A sustained finding or two unsustained complaints of serious misconduct (including excessive force, racial bias, sexual assault, discrimination, or dishonesty) from any law enforcement agency, after investigation and appeal; or - Resigned or retired during a pending disciplinary proceeding for alleged serious misconduct. - Supervisor Walton framed the resolution as a response to systemic racism and the murder of George Floyd, noting that the officer who killed Floyd had 18 prior complaints. District Attorney Boudin highlighted the difficulty of accessing misconduct records under California law and stressed that the policy would close the loophole of officers leaving agencies under investigation. Supervisor Safai called the resolution a "no-brainer" and emphasized codifying existing best practices. - The committee acknowledged that the resolution is a first step; Supervisor Walton noted that if the Civil Service Commission does not act, a charter amendment for a future ballot may be pursued. Key Outcomes - Motion passed unanimously (3-0) to file the resolution as a committee report and forward it to the full Board of Supervisors for a vote on June 23, 2020. The motion was made by Supervisor Walton and seconded by Vice Chair Stefani; all three members (Walton, Safai, Stefani) voted aye. - The resolution now goes to the Board of Supervisors with the recommendation of the committee. No other business was conducted; the meeting was adjourned.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Rafael Mandelman, met on June 11, 2020 to consider a liquor license transfer, an ordinance authorizing overdose prevention programs, and a hearing on the Tenderloin COVID-19 plan. The meeting was held remotely due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were listed. Public Comments & Testimony - Liquor License Transfer: No public comment was received. - Overdose Prevention Programs: Twenty callers spoke overwhelmingly in support. Speakers included representatives from Drug Policy Alliance, St. Anthony's, San Francisco AIDS Foundation, Glide, HealthRIGHT 360, Tenderloin community members, and residents. Many stressed lives saved and urged inclusion of crack cocaine and smoked drugs (e.g., Del Seymour, Curtis Redford, Al Green). - Tenderloin COVID-19 Plan: Twenty callers spoke, almost all critical of the city's response. Residents described unsafe sidewalks, fires, drug activity, and lack of progress. Some called for more safe sleeping sites, spread across the city, and greater urgency. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer – 4763 Mission Street (Calabria Bros.) - The committee heard a proposal to transfer a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine license to Michael Biaggio Tufo doing business as Calabria Bros. at 4763 Mission Street. - Supervisor Ahsha Safai expressed full support, noting the business owner's long history in the community and no prior requests for a license. - Officer Samlinson from the ABC reported zero protests, low crime area, low saturation, and conditions including hours 8am-10pm and active monitoring. - The applicant stated the license would help the community by offering specialty beer and wine. - Ordinance on Overdose Prevention Programs (File 200243) - Supervisor Matt Haney (co-author with Mayor Breed) introduced an ordinance to permit overdose prevention programs (safe consumption sites) through a permitting process by DPH. - Eileen Loughran from DPH presented evidence of rising overdose deaths (330 in 2019, from 259 in 2018), 774 naloxone reversals in Q1 2020 (up from 572), and a cost savings of $3.5 million per site per year. She noted 100+ sites operate worldwide with no overdose deaths. - Supervisor Haney emphasized the need as a multipronged strategy, especially during COVID-19. - Several callers requested explicit inclusion of crack cocaine and smoked drugs. Supervisor Haney committed to work with the Mayor to clarify that the legislation allows for smoked substances. - Supervisors Mandelman and Walton expressed support and added as co-sponsors. Mandelman noted the legislation is written broadly. - Hearing on Tenderloin COVID-19 Plan (File 200536) - The committee held a hearing to evaluate the city's plan for the Tenderloin neighborhood during the pandemic. - Supervisor Haney presented opening remarks expressing outrage and disappointment at the city's failure to implement effective solutions. He cited news articles and rising encampments (tents tripled). - Mary Ellen Carroll, Director of Emergency Management, presented the plan, which includes safe sleeping sites, hotels, testing, hygiene stations, social distancing, sanitation, and food/water. - Key metrics: 350 individuals moved off streets to hotels; 180 Jones safe sleeping site opened with 16 tents/21 people; Fulton Safe Sleeping Site with 110 individuals; 1,600 tests administered; 18 community ambassadors; 5 new pit stops; 7 handwashing stations. - Supervisor Haney expressed frustration over lack of timelines, a public dashboard, and clear accountability. He noted many departments pointed to others. - Discussion: Director Carroll acknowledged failures in communication and committed to improving transparency. Emily Cohen from HSH noted an increase in need due to loss of shelter capacity and slower homeward bound program. Alaric from DPW discussed cleaning and sanitation efforts. Key Outcomes - Liquor license transfer: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward a resolution finding public convenience or necessity to the full Board with positive recommendation. - Overdose prevention ordinance: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Tenderloin COVID-19 hearing: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair (motion passed unanimously 3-0). Supervisor Mandelman was excused from the vote. - Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor on overdose prevention ordinance.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on June 9, 2020, at 11:15 AM to address critical financial and operational challenges stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and social justice issues. Key actions included approval of a drastically revised biennial budget, an opt-in rent deferral program for tenants, and updates on Vision Zero safety projects along the Embarcadero. The meeting also featured tributes to two retiring staff members, discussions on police use of port property, and statements from commissioners on racial equity. Consent Calendar - Minutes of May 26, 2020: Approved unanimously by roll call. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (executive director's report): Three callers spoke. Donald Catal raised concerns about Pier 50 being used by SFPD to process protest arrestees, calling it inappropriate use of port property. Tyler (District 6 resident) described being processed there after arrest and supported rewriting the MOU. Joe Bergard (Red and White Fleet) urged the port to advocate for reopening excursion boats as outdoor activities, noting the fleet is ready to resume operations. - Public Comment on Item 7A (Budget): None. - Public Comment on Item 8A (Vision Zero): Ronald supported the Rincon Park improvements but urged reconsideration of the Pier 35 design, arguing it prioritizes auto access over cyclist safety. - Public Comment on Item 9A (Rent Deferral): Multiple tenants spoke: David O'Malley (Coqueta) supported future rent forgiveness; Drew (Spinnaker Sailing) called the budget optimistic and warned of business failures; Kevin Wesley (Louise Fish at Fisherman's Wharf) described dire financial conditions and requested base rent abatement; Pete Sitnik (Water Bar/Epic Steak) stressed the need for rent forgiveness for the closure period; Michael Curello (Coquetta) noted high operational costs; Peter Osborne (Mission Rock Resort) supported a percentage-rent model and forgiveness. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Katie Patruccioni): - Bond Sale: On June 2, the city sold $49.7 million in Seawall GO bonds at a total interest cost of less than 2%, with interest of under $80,000. - Shared Spaces Program: Announced May 26 by Mayor Breed, effective June 12; port staff working with multiple agencies to tailor outdoor seating for tenants. - LBE Support: Two programs in development – a grant program (near-term) and a loan program (bridge funding for LBEs performing contracts). Staff will bring an information item to the Commission on July 14, with a request for grant approval in August. - Pier 45 Fire Relief: Mayor Breed, Supervisor Peskin, and commissioners toured the site. A $500,000 fundraising campaign was announced for crabbers to order pots for November season. Port staff developing a loan program with OEWD and the Crab Boat Owners Association. - Retirements: Tributes were given to Mark Lozavoy (27 years, Asst. Deputy Director for Real Estate) and Amy Quesada (26 years, Commission Secretary). Staff and commissioners expressed gratitude for their service. Mark and Amy both spoke. - Commissioner Statements on Racial Equity: Following the murder of George Floyd, all commissioners expressed support for Black Lives Matter, condemned systemic racism, and urged equity in port hiring, contracting, and leasing. President Brandon read a prepared statement. The meeting was closed in memory of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Ahmaud Arbery, and others. - Item 7A – FY2020-22 Budget Approval: Nate Cruz presented a revised biennial budget reflecting a 50% revenue loss in the first year and 25% in the second (erasing 15 years of growth). The four-part strategy includes: reducing operating expenses ($12.7M/$10M), reducing capital appropriations (deferring Mission Bay Ferry Landing and other projects), using fund balance (drawdown from $67M to a $14M reserve), and identifying $15M in prior capital defunding. A $10M Economic Recovery Project was created as a flexible fund. Commissioners expressed concern about long-term sustainability and requested clear criteria for the recovery fund. The budget was approved unanimously (Resolution 2028/2029). - Item 8A – Vision Zero Quick Build Projects: Casey Hildreth (SFMTA) presented safety improvements at three Embarcadero locations: a protected two-way bikeway between Howard and Mission (removing 13 metered parking spaces), a reconfigured loading zone at Rincon Park (with swapped bike lane and loading, plus motorcycle parking), and a protected bikeway at Pier 35 (with removable posts for 25 days of cruise/event operations). Construction begins June 2020; cost estimated at $650,000 (MTA-funded). Commissioners expressed support for the fast-track approach. - Item 9A – Opt-In Rent Deferral Program: Chrisia Tanoli presented an opt-in program extending deferral through December 31, 2020, for eligible tenants (excluding city MOUs, terminal agreements, etc.). Tenants must submit a financial impact statement, business plan, revenue projections, and information on federal/state relief applications. As of May 31, 2020, the port had received $9.9M in rent; March-April payment rate averaged 47%. The likely financial exposure is $21.4M. Staff also discussed future phases: repayment plans, sector-based forgiveness (especially restaurants and parking), and shared spaces. Commissioners pressed for more data by sector, flexibility in opt-in (partial payment), and a clear timeline for forgiveness/repayment. An amendment was added requiring staff to use collected data to inform further relief policies. The program was approved unanimously (Resolution 2030). Key Outcomes - Approved Minutes of May 26, 2020 (unanimous). - Approved FY2020-22 Biennal Operating and Capital Budget (Resolution 2028/2029) with reductions, fund balance use, and a $10M Economic Recovery Project. Commissioners directed staff to return with a framework for the recovery fund. - Approved Opt-In Rent Deferral Program through Dec 31, 2020 (Resolution 2030). The motion included an amendment directing staff to collect data and return with further tenant relief proposals. - Received Informational Report on Vision Zero Quick Build projects; construction to start June 2020. - Staff directed to rewrite the MOU with SFPD regarding use of Pier 50 as a processing center for arrestees. - Future Actions: Staff will present LBE grant/loan program details on July 14; bring percentage rent data and sector-based forgiveness proposals; and update on outdoor seating shared spaces program by June 12. Commission expressed willingness to hold special meetings or meet twice monthly to expedite relief efforts.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, May 28, 2020, at 10:15 AM via remote conferencing due to the COVID-19 health emergency. Chair Raphael Mandelman presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Shamann Walton. The committee considered four agenda items: two liquor license transfers, a resolution supporting animal rights activists facing prosecution in Sonoma County, and a hearing on suicide and domestic violence during the COVID-19 pandemic. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Liquor License Transfer – East Cut Traders, 301 Howard Street): The committee heard from ALU Officer Sammonson, who reported zero letters of protest, location in a high crime and high saturation area, but Southern Station had no opposition. ALU recommended approval with a condition to prevent loitering. The applicant, Mr. Mana, stated the business has operated since 2006 and this is their third location. The committee voted unanimously to forward a resolution finding public convenience or necessity to the full Board. - Item 2 (Liquor License Transfer – Andronico’s Community Market, 375-32nd Avenue/3132 Clement Street): ALU reported one letter of protest, location in low crime but high saturation area, Richmond Station had no opposition. ALU recommended approval with the same condition. Applicant attorney Justin Zucker stated the addition of alcohol sales would ensure long-term viability of the grocery store. The committee voted unanimously to forward a resolution finding public convenience or necessity. Chair Mandelman noted appreciation for a union grocery store returning to the space. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Resolution Supporting Activists Facing Prosecution in Sonoma County): One caller, Jordan Davis (D6 resident, activist with Direct Action Everywhere), spoke in support, arguing the activists were acting morally and under state law affirmative defense. They urged passage and further policy initiatives to end animal abuse. Discussion Items - Item 3 (Resolution Supporting Activists): Supervisor Haney’s office (Ms. McDonald) presented, noting the Animal Control and Welfare Commission passed the resolution, and a similar resolution was passed by the Berkeley City Council earlier in 2020. The resolution urges the Sonoma County District Attorney to dismiss charges against nonviolent activists who investigated factory farm conditions. No questions from committee. - Item 4 (Hearing on Suicide, Domestic Abuse, and Family Violence During the COVID-19 Pandemic): Vice Chair Stefani introduced the hearing, expressing concern about mental health, isolation, and domestic violence. Presentations included: - Lina Sheth (Interim Director, San Francisco Suicide Prevention/Felton Institute): Reported an 82,000 call volume in 2019 (up from 56,000). During COVID, call volume declined but acuity increased from 1-3 per month to 1-3 per week of callers requiring emergency intervention. 22% of callers were first-time callers. She highlighted social isolation as a risk factor and the need for expanded mental health services. - Beverly Upton (Executive Director, San Francisco Domestic Violence Consortium): Reported a 130% increase in crisis line calls in the first weeks of shelter-in-place, then leveling off. Only 14% of police-reported cases are presented to the district attorney. Noted a 44% increase in armed assailants and panic gun buying. Discussed housing insecurity and potential budget cuts of $1 million to direct services. - Emberly Cross (Cooperative Restraining Order Clinic): Described continued legal services, including in-person restraining order hearings with safety precautions. Noted archaic signature requirements and challenges for survivors sheltering with abusers. The court has remained open for restraining orders. - Committee members asked questions about risk factors, economic distress, isolation, and systemic issues. Chair Mandelman raised concerns about domestic violence, homelessness, and potential consequences of early jail releases due to COVID-19. Key Outcomes - Item 3: The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Item 4: The committee voted unanimously to file the hearing (motion by Vice Chair Stefani).
The San Francisco Port Commission met by phone on May 26, 2020, to hear recovery updates after the Pier 45 fire, authorize an expanded Army Corps flood-resilience study, approve Mission Rock infrastructure agreements, receive an informational Pier 70 update, and extend COVID-19 rent deferrals. All votes taken were unanimous, and Commissioner Macris recused himself from the Seawall Lot 337 item. Public Comments & Testimony - Non-agenda public comment: Bartolome Pantoha, an affiliate of the Building Construction Trades, expressed support for the historic Mission Rock project and urged approval. Peter Osborne, owner/operator of Mission Rock Resort, thanked the Port for deferring rents but said a balloon payment would be a cyanide tablet for businesses; he asked for new lease terms and structured financial agreements and said a coalition of waterfront tenants had submitted a letter to Port staff. - Item 8A public comment: Danny Campbell, representing Sheet Metal Workers Local 104 and a trustee of the San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council, said the Council supported the Mission Rock project and urged approval. - Item 8C public comment: Drew Harper, a 35-year Port tenant at South Beach Harbor with a sailing school and excursion company, said tenants cannot earn revenue during the shutdown and that deferral alone would force bankruptcies; he asked for rent relief and noted Pier 39 was not charging commercial marina tenants. John Valier, a 20-year non-alcoholic/beer distributor, said his business had lost more than 80% of its revenue and asked for rent forgiveness for the past two months. - No public comment was offered on the Executive Director’s Report, Item 7A, or Item 8B. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report - Acting Executive Director Katie Patricione reported that a four-alarm fire broke out at Pier 45 Shed C at about 4:15 a.m. on May 23, 2020. Shed C was a total loss, 35 tenants were directly impacted, and the Port was offering relocation assistance and working with insurers. Shed A, B, and D were not directly burned, and the Jeremiah O’Brien was saved and was being moved temporarily to Pier 35. - Patricione also announced that the Downtown Ferry Terminal project was nearing completion and would open fully within about two weeks, adding six ferry berths and a new public plaza. Item 7A – Waterfront Flood Resiliency Study Amendment - Waterfront Resilience Director Brad Benson requested approval to amend the Feasibility Cost Sharing Agreement (FCSA) with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The study budget would first increase from $3 million to $6 million, and later to $20.1 million if approved by the Board of Supervisors and the Assistant Secretary of the Army, extending the schedule from three to five years and allowing the Port to advance cash as the non-federal sponsor. - Benson noted the study covers the entire Port jurisdiction, uses a 50/50 federal/non-federal cost share, and would move to refined alternatives and environmental review before a possible 2023 recommendation to Congress. Item 8A – Seawall Lot 337 Infrastructure Plan Amendment and MOU - Rebecca Benassini, Waterfront Development Director, presented the Mission Rock infrastructure plan amendment and five-party memorandum of understanding (MOU) among the Port, Public Works, SFPUC, SFMTA, and Fire Department. Commissioner Macris recused himself because of a financial interest within 1,000 feet of the site. - The amendment adds lightweight cellular concrete and stone columns as a more cost-effective ground-improvement method for sea-level-rise protection. DPW and SFPUC had already approved it. - The MOU assigns responsibility for accepting and maintaining infrastructure; the Port will retain parks and unique features, with maintenance supported by CFD special taxes estimated at $2.8–$3 million per year at buildout. - Project sponsor Jack Bear of the Giants spoke in support, saying the items were technical but important steps before final map approval and signing of parcel leases. Item 8B – Pier 70 MOU Informational Presentation - Benassini presented an informational MOU for the Pier 70 Mixed-Use District. The project envisions about 3,000 housing units, 1.75 million square feet of office, 500,000 square feet of retail/arts/light industrial space, and 9 acres of open space. Phase one includes about 600 residential units with 30% affordable housing. - The MOU would define infrastructure acceptance among city agencies. A key issue is an overland stormwater release path required by subdivision code; the short-term solution is to avoid building on the flow path, and a long-term improvement would be designed with Brookfield and agencies. The item was informational only and will return for approval in June. Item 8C – COVID-19 Rent Deferral Extension and Tenant Relief Discussion - Port staff requested approval to extend the broad-based rent deferral through July 31, 2020. The policy waives late fees and default interest for rent due March 1 through July 31 if paid by July 31, and establishes forbearance from eviction for unpaid rent related to COVID-19. - Staff reported that, as of May 18, 2020, only 298 of 594 invoices had been paid (50%), with May payments at 33% compared with April’s 54%. The Fisherman’s Wharf portfolio had the highest share uncollected at 97%, and the China Basin portfolio had the largest dollar amount uncollected at $1.4 million. - Staff outlined future options: an opt-in extended deferral through December 31, 2020, possible repayment plans, mutual lease terminations using Resolution 0904, rent forgiveness, participation-rent restructuring, and lease extensions. Staff noted FY 2019-20 real estate revenue was originally expected to be $98 million but had been projected to fall to just over $75 million. - Commissioners supported the extension but asked for more data on the Port’s cash position, sector-by-sector relief forecasts, and a policy for treating tenants equitably before individual negotiations. Key Outcomes - Approved the minutes of the May 12, 2020 meeting unanimously. - Authorized the Item 7A amendment to the FCSA, expanding the Waterfront Flood Resiliency Study budget and schedule, in a unanimous roll-call vote. - Approved the Seawall Lot 337 Infrastructure Plan Amendment and MOU (Item 8A) unanimously; Commissioner Macris was recused. - Received the Pier 70 MOU as an informational item and directed staff to return with an update on the stormwater release-path solution and the formal MOU approval. - Extended the COVID-19 broad-based rent deferral through July 31, 2020 by adopting Resolution 2027 unanimously. - Directed staff to return on June 9, 2020 with the opt-in extended deferral program and continued discussion of rent relief, including sector-based relief and Port fiscal-impact projections.