Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 1321–1330 ENTRIES
1321
MAY 12, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting - May 12, 2020: COVID-19 Relief, Resiliency, and Tenant Rent Deferral

The San Francisco Port Commission met on May 12, 2020, to discuss the Port's response to the COVID-19 crisis, including tenant rent relief, a food bank partnership, and the Army Corps flood resiliency study. The meeting also covered an amendment to allow an extra story in some Pier 70 residential buildings. Key actions included approval of a rent waiver for a pop-up food pantry and a consent calendar item to extend a construction contract. Consent Calendar - Item 9A: Unanimously approved (5-0) a retroactive authorization to modify Construction Contract No. 2810R for hazardous materials abatement at Building 49 and Cranes 14 and 30 at Pier 70, extending the completion date. (Resolution 2023) Public Comments & Testimony - Larry Collins (Pier 45 fish wholesale buyer) expressed appreciation for the farmers market but urged the Port to give fishermen similar consideration, noting that deferred rent is insufficient because their business has dropped 78-80%, and forgiveness is needed to keep the fleet alive. He emphasized that local fish provide food security. - Susan Karasov (San Francisco resident) supported nature-based measures for sea level rise and requested that the Port use only local native plants in mitigation strategies. Discussion Items 1. Executive Director's Report (Item 8): Michael Martin, Acting Executive Director, reported on Port COVID-19 response: - Seawall Lot 344 RV site for homeless is nearly ready for occupancy. - Pier 30-32 CityTestSF site has expanded to walk-in appointments. - 63 deployments as disaster service workers (51 individuals, about 20% of Port staff). - Ferry Plaza Farmers Market (CUESA) has implemented new health protocols, including mandatory seller rules, tripled hand-washing stations, and contactless curbside pickup. Additional space will be licensed for May 16. 2. Seawall Resiliency Program & Army Corps Flood Study (Item 10A): Brad Benson, Waterfront Resilience Director, presented an update: - The Army Corps study, originally planned as $3M/3 years, is now estimated at $20M/5 years, requiring a waiver from the Assistant Secretary of the Army. - The study covers the entire 7.5-mile Port waterfront plus Aquatic Park, analyzing flood risk 2040-2090 using five sea level rise curves. - LBE participation on the main contract has reached 18% overall (33% on recent task authorizations). - Commissioners requested a broader strategic roadmap for resilience, regular updates on federal/state infrastructure funding opportunities, and a list of LBE contractors. 3. Proposed Extended Tenant Rent Deferral Program (Item 11A): Chris Atanoli presented: - April collections: $6.1M invoiced, $3.3M paid (52% collection rate); 259 of 541 invoices paid (48% payment rate). Fisherman’s Wharf portfolio had 80% uncollected; China Basin had $1.2M uncollected. - A tenant survey (127 respondents) reported $90M+ in losses, 67% average revenue loss, and 3,500 jobs impacted. - Staff proposes an opt-in extended deferral from March 1 to December 31, 2020, with waivers of late fees if paid by year-end. Tenants must submit a statement describing COVID-19 impact, business plan, revenue projections, and proof of applying for relief programs. An opt-out mutual termination option is available for tenants who cannot recover. - Commissioner Gilman asked about stakeholder engagement on the requirements and total revenue loss projections. Commissioner Wuho emphasized the need for business plans to assess tenant viability and the importance of the opt-out process. Commissioner Macris supported broad eligibility but cautioned against overly easy early terminations. Staff will return on May 26 for authorization to extend the current deferral through July 31, and on June 9 for approval of the extended program. 4. Rent Waiver for SF-Marin Food Bank Pop-Up Pantry (Item 11B): Michael Martin presented: - The food bank currently serves 20,000 more households per week than pre-pandemic, and 90% of its 275 regular pantries have closed. - The pop-up pantry at Seawall Lot 337 (under lease to the Mission Rock project) would operate as a drive-through on Fridays, serving 300-1,200 families at no charge. - Staff recommended waiving the approximately $1,260/month in special event rent for the duration of the mayor’s emergency declaration. The item was approved unanimously (5-0). 5. Pier 70 Special Use District Design Amendment (Item 11C): Ryan Wassom presented: - The amendment, already approved by the Planning Commission, would allow residential buildings with a 90-foot height limit to have up to nine stories instead of eight by reducing floor-to-ceiling heights from 10 feet to 8 feet 8 inches (except ground floor at 15 feet). - For Parcel D, this could add about 18,000 gross square feet, increasing units from 134 to 148. Overall effect on all parcels is not yet determined. - Commissioners asked about the impact on affordable housing (20% inclusionary for rental, in-lieu fees for condos) and land value. Staff will provide a fuller analysis when the action item comes back. No action was taken; informational only. Key Outcomes - Approved (5-0): Consent calendar item 9A (contract modification). - Approved (5-0): Rent waiver for SF-Marin Food Bank pop-up pantry (Item 11B). - Directed staff: Return on May 26 to seek authorization for extending the current broad-based rent deferral through July 31, and on June 9 to approve the extended opt-in deferral program. - Requested reports: Staff will provide a strategic roadmap for waterfront resilience, a list of LBE contractors on the Army Corps study, and projections on total revenue loss from percentage rent and parking. The executive director’s future reports will include updates on all Port COVID-19 projects (Pier 30-32 testing, Seawall Lot 344, pop-up pantry) and a list of open RFPs.

PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · PUBLIC HEALTH 19% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 16% · EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S REPORT 7%
1322
APR 28, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting - April 28, 2020

The Port Commission held a virtual meeting on April 28, 2020, to discuss and act on several agenda items related to COVID-19 relief efforts, navigation center extension, construction contracts, and financial updates. All resolutions were passed unanimously. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes for March 10 and March 19, 2020: Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Public comment was taken via phone on several agenda items. Specific comments included: support for the navigation center extension from a nearby resident, concerns about equity and community engagement for the RV shelter site at Pier 94, and questions about the financial impact on port tenants. No opposition was voiced on action items. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report: Michael Martin provided an update on COVID-19 impacts to port revenue and ongoing efforts to secure federal, state, and city relief for tenants. Commissioners discussed the economic downturn and its effect on cruise ship operations and tenant hours. - 6A - Central Waterfront Navigation Center MOU Extension: Approved an amendment to extend the MOU between the port and HSH for five years, with a 3% rent increase to $6,308/month. The center has been a successful program in addressing homelessness. - 6B - Rent Deferral Policy Ratification and Extension: Approved a resolution ratifying the staff-issued rent deferral policy for tenants affected by COVID-19 and extending it through May 31, 2020. Commissioners discussed additional relief options, including potential rent forgiveness for small businesses and non-profits. - 6C - MOU with DPH for COVID-19 Testing at Pier 30-32 and Rent Waiver for C Wal 337: Approved an MOU for use of Pier 30-32 as a testing site and a rent waiver for C Wal 337 for RV staging. The motion was amended to require commission approval for any future rent waivers beyond the current scope. - 6D - MOU with HSA for RV/Trailer Shelter at C Wal Lot 344: Approved an MOU for a temporary shelter site for unhoused individuals in District 10, with amendments including a good neighbor policy, a one-year term or 60 days after the emergency declaration ends, and no holdover. Rent waiver of $520.30 per month was included. - 7A - Mission Bay Ferry Landing Dredging Contract: Awarded contract to The Dutra Group for $11,920,300 with a 10% contingency ($1,192,030), total not to exceed $13,112,330. The project is funded by OCII funds that must be spent by June 30, 2020. - 7B - Crane Cove Park 19th Street Extension and Georgia Street Contract: Awarded contract to Cazadoro Construction Inc. for $2,809,275 with a 10% contingency ($280,928), total not to exceed $3,090,203. The project supports the port's strategic plan and leverages local business participation (98% LBE). - New Business: Commissioner Wuho requested a future report breaking down port revenue impacts by business type (e.g., restaurants, cruise, maritime) to better understand financial risks. Key Outcomes - All action items (resolutions 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022) were approved unanimously by roll call votes. - The commission directed staff to provide a portfolio breakdown by business type for a future meeting. - The meeting adjourned with thanks to staff for organizing the virtual meeting.

HOMELESSNESS 21% · PUBLIC HEALTH 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 18% · INFRASTRUCTURE 9%
1323
APR 9, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - April 9, 2020

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee held a remote regular meeting on April 9, 2020, due to the COVID-19 health emergency. Chair Mandelman presided, joined by Vice Chair Stephanie and Supervisor Walton. The committee considered two liquor license applications and recommended approval of both to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items Item 1: Liquor License for The Epicurean Trader (One Ferry Building) - ALU Officer Salmonson presented the application for a Type 21/41/86 license. Zero letters of protest or support were received. ALU recommended approval with conditions requiring signage stating no alcoholic beverages beyond the tasting area and that no minors are allowed in the tasting area. The applicant, Matt Pond (owner of The Epicurean Trader), agreed to the conditions and argued that the store serves as a neighborhood necessity, especially during the pandemic, citing limited grocery access in the Financial District. No public comment was offered. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward a resolution of public convenience and necessity to the full board. Item 2: Liquor License Transfer for Kal's Neighborhood Market (1401 19th Avenue) - ALU recommended approval of a Type 20 off-sale beer and wine license transfer with conditions (sales hours 8 a.m. to 10 p.m., active monitoring to prevent loitering, and litter maintenance). The applicant’s representative, Sabrina Shagi, described the expansion of a family-owned Chevron station’s food mart into an underutilized auto repair bay, noting 37 neighbor signatures of support, 4 letters of protest, and the addition of 11 security cameras. The applicant agreed to all conditions. No public comment was received. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the resolution to the full board. Key Outcomes - Both motions passed 3-0 in favor of recommending approval to the full Board of Supervisors. - The resolutions are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on April 21, 2020.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 58% · PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · PROCEDURAL 17%
1324
MAR 19, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Special Port Commission Emergency Meeting on COVID-19 Bed Expansion - March 19, 2020

The San Francisco Port Commission held a special emergency meeting on March 19, 2020, to consider a proposed amendment to the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) to expand bed capacity at the Embarcadero Safe Navigation Center in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The meeting was held both in-person and via phone, with public comments accepted from both. Commissioners unanimously voted to approve the amendment, authorizing the executive director to modify the ramp-up schedule to allow immediate use of additional beds.

HOMELESSNESS 69% · PROCEDURAL 18% · PUBLIC HEALTH 13%
1325
MAR 12, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee Regular Meeting - March 12, 2020

Introductory paragraph: The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee met on March 12, 2020, chaired by Supervisor Raphael Mandelman, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Walton. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the city's declared local emergency, the committee asked attendees to maintain physical distance and postponed non-essential items that anticipated large public turnout. Four agenda items were considered, with two continued, one approved, and one continued after public testimony. Discussion Items - Item 1 (200075): Liquor License Issuance – 706 Mission Street – The applicant's representative noted that Supervisor Haney's office requested a continuance to allow additional time for a meeting. The committee continued the item to the March 26, 2020 regular meeting. - Item 2 (200076): Liquor License Transfer – 365-11th Street (Buzzworks) – The applicant, Vlad Cood, owner of Buzzworks and a 30-year San Francisco nightclub/restaurant operator, explained the license would allow adding craft spirits to the existing craft beer offerings. There were zero protests and support from the police department and ALU. The committee voted to forward a positive recommendation to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 3 (200141): Health Code – Adult Sex Venue Health and Safety Standards – The chair stated that, per President Yee's request, non-essential legislation with anticipated large public turnout should be postponed. The item was continued to the call of the chair, after taking public comment (no speakers). - Item 4 (200051): Hearing on Effects of On-Demand Delivery on Small Businesses – The chair similarly continued this hearing to the call of the chair after taking public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - One speaker (self-identified small business owner) expressed strong support for the hearing topic, stating that on-demand delivery services use “extortive tactics” that harm small restaurants and bars, and urged the city to regulate them. - A second speaker asked how to know in advance whether an agenda item will actually be heard, noting they rearranged their schedule to attend. The clerk and chair advised contacting the sponsor’s office or the clerk’s office (415-554-4445) ahead of time, especially during the pandemic. - Victor Escobito, owner of Papalote (two restaurants and a food truck), said the delivery services’ impact is changing San Francisco’s culinary culture and urged serious regulation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to March 26, 2020 (motion approved without objection). - Item 2: Approved with positive recommendation to the full board (motion approved without objection). - Item 3: Continued to the call of the chair (motion approved without objection). - Item 4: Continued to the call of the chair (motion approved without objection). The meeting adjourned after no further business.

PROCEDURAL 35% · PUBLIC HEALTH 27% · LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 23% · SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 15%
1326
MAR 10, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting Summary: March 10, 2020

The San Francisco Port Commission met at 10:00 a.m. on March 10, 2020. The meeting included approval of prior minutes, a closed executive session, an executive director's report focused on COVID-19 and the Grand Princess response, an ethics-law briefing, and three land/engineering actions: authorization to advertise the Mission Bay Ferry Landing dredging and site-preparation contract, a settlement/new lease with the Pilara Family Foundation for Pier 24 Annex, and a settlement/new lease with the Dolphin Swimming and Boating Club. All votes were taken by voice vote with no audible opposition. Consent Calendar - Approved the February 25, 2020 meeting minutes. - Voted to hold a closed session under attorney-client privilege and later voted not to disclose the executive session discussions. Public Comments & Testimony - Non-agenda public comment: A speaker from an LBE-certified company said Grant Construction initially described a Mission Rock material-export job of roughly 50,000 to 80,000 tons but later reduced it to about 1,000 tons. The speaker said he was told his firm would be used for LBE credit while Grant's South Bay team performed the work, and he asked the Port to address large companies using LBE-certified firms to obtain credit while funneling work elsewhere. - Executive Director's report: Vice President Adams publicly thanked Port maritime staff, relayed a call from Governor Newsom about the Grand Princess, reported that about 900 passengers had been disembarked with hopes for 1,000 more, and described the operation as a humanitarian effort. - Pier 24 item: Simon Snellgrove of Pacific Waterfront Partners called Pier 24 a world-famous cultural facility and supported the settlement; Mary Murphy, counsel to the Pilara Family Foundation, requested approval and thanked staff; artist Erica Dieman described the foundation's impact on her career; instructor Bijan Yashar read a letter from CCA professor Chris Johnson supporting the museum; and Keith Silva praised its educational value. All spoke in favor. - No public comment was offered on the executive session, the Ethics Commission presentation, or the Dolphin Club item. Executive Director's Report and COVID-19 Response - Executive Director Elaine Forbes reported that the planned Port Contract Open House and Downtown San Francisco Ferry Terminal ribbon cutting were canceled due to COVID-19. - She detailed Port involvement in the Grand Princess response: Mayor Breed had declared a local health emergency on February 25; on March 3 the Port became aware of the potential issue; by March 4 a unified command was assembled with HHS, CDC, FEMA, the Coast Guard, Cal OES, the California Department of Public Health, and Port staff. She praised the maritime team, including Andre Coleman, Joe Riley, Dominic Moreno, and Mike Nurney, and thanked the City of Oakland and labor partners. - She outlined COVID-19 precautions: telecommuting, canceling discretionary events, social distancing, staying home when sick, hand-washing, and avoiding handshakes. - Vice President Adams added operational details from Governor Newsom, noted about 900 passengers had been taken off the ship, and called the effort a humanitarian effort. Commissioners Gillman and Macris also thanked staff and emphasized vigilance. Ethics Commission Presentation - The Ethics Commission's executive director presented updates on city ethics laws and resources. Key points included: Form 700 statements of economic interest are due by April 1; annual AB 1234 ethics training is synced with the filing; a no-file, no-vote rule disqualifies non-filers from acting on matters; new behested payment reporting applies to city officers; recusal disclosure forms are public; gift limits are $500 from a single source under state law, $25 per source per year for city lobbying contacts, and $50 as a disclosure threshold; and city officers appointed by the mayor are prohibited from fundraising for the mayor or mayoral candidates. - She also described department statements of incompatible activities, reminded officials to ask for advice before acting, and noted the Ethics Commission can levy fines up to $5,000 per violation or three times unreported/unlawful amounts and refer matters to the district attorney and city attorney. - Commissioners thanked her, and Vice President Adams suggested annual or semi-annual refreshers. Mission Bay Ferry Landing Dredging and Site Preparation (Item 10A) - Shannon Cairns, manager of the Engineering Division's project management office, requested authorization to advertise Construction Contract No. 2830 for competitive low-bid dredging and site preparation. - The project is a new ferry landing across from Chase Center, with two berths accessed from a single float with a pier and gangway, plus construction of Agua Vista Park. It sits within a half mile of about 11,000 new housing units, 7 million square feet of office and commercial space, over 1 million square feet of retail space, and 70 acres of open space, and is within one block of the Muni T-Third line and near UCSF Mission Bay. - The advertisement is time-sensitive because $8.4 million in OCI funding must be used in calendar year 2020 and the in-water work window is June through November 2020. - A prior July 2019 CMGC solicitation received three bids that were significantly over Port estimates; the Port rejected them. Staff learned that bundling dredging and ferry landing construction did not yield expected efficiencies, the dredging and debris removal were more specialized than expected, and value engineering ideas were not practical. The new strategy separates dredging/site preparation from a future best-value contract for marine mattress, ferry landing construction, and landside improvements. - The estimated project budget increased from $47.1 million in July 2019 to $58.4 million currently. Increases are in construction management, inspection, monitoring, mitigation, dredging, debris removal, and cap. Funding identified includes $8.4 million OCI, $1.2 million in prior-year general fund allocation, and $3.4 million in currently appropriated Port capital, which staff hope will be reimbursed from Pier 64 cost sharing. Staff are also pursuing a $5 million general fund request and grant opportunities. - The contract value is $11.8 million, with an LBE subcontracting requirement of 11% ($1.298 million), below the 20% city standard because 82% of the contract is marine specialty work, mobilization, and allowances. LBE work includes engineering requiring an A-license and trucking. - Construction is scheduled to start June 2020 and be complete in spring 2022. Next steps include authorization for construction management services at the next meeting, an April 2020 award for this contract, a May 2020 award for construction management, and fall 2020 authorization to advertise the best-value ferry landing construction contract. - Commissioner Macris questioned the earlier bid gap, noting the lowest early-construction bid was $17.6 million against a Port estimate of $10.8 million; staff explained the gap came from specialized dredging and debris-removal costs. Vice President Adams asked about over-budget funding; staff confirmed current funds include Port capital that would need future reimbursement to complete the project. - The commission approved the authorization to advertise. Pier 24 Annex Settlement and Lease (Item 11A) - Mike Martin of Real Estate and Development presented the settlement agreement and Lease L-16653 with the Pilara Family Foundation. - Background: Pier 24 Annex was originally slated for demolition in 2007. The foundation leased the property and made improvements originally under $3 million that ultimately totaled about $14 million; Port staff verified $8.5 million in substructure, core, and shell costs. The prior lease expired in November 2017, along with $3 million in rent credits. After failed negotiations and a December 2019 30-day termination notice, the parties reached a settlement. - The settlement recognizes $5.5 million in remaining unamortized verified costs as rent credits to address rent delinquency from November 2017 to the present. The foundation will pay Port attorney's fees, and the settlement is conditioned on the new lease. - The new lease sets rent at the Port's current rate of $3.40 per square foot per month. The tenant may apply $3.21 per square foot in rent credits, leaving a monthly payment of about $5,735. The term runs until rent credits are exhausted, with an example of about four years and four months if the lease starts May 1. The tenant may propose an extension within a year by providing facility-condition information and a feasibility study on lifting the occupancy limit. The lease includes no Port termination rate, two tenant termination rights, no increase to the security deposit, Port sole discretion over transfers, increased public-access reporting, and is subject to Board of Supervisors approval. - Public speakers and the foundation's counsel supported the settlement. Commissioner Macris strongly supported it as a good deal; Commissioner Gilman supported it but urged broader day-of or walk-in access; Vice President Adams supported it but noted the history was contentious and urged a better relationship; President Brandon supported it while agreeing more public access and income are needed. - The commission approved the settlement and lease. Dolphin Swimming and Boating Club Settlement and Lease (Item 11B) - Property manager Dimitri Amaro presented the settlement agreement and Lease L-16661 with the Dolphin Swimming and Boating Club. - The Dolphin Club was founded in 1877 and has been at 520 Jefferson Street since 1927. Its lease with the Department of Recreation and Parks expires June 30, 2028. In 1993, the Port and Rec & Park determined that a 678-square-foot portion of the club's dock is on Port submerged lands, but no Port lease was ever executed. In late 2019, the Department of Building Inspection directed the club to the Port for permitting of dock repairs. - The settlement includes payment of $5,913 in back rent for the prior four years at the submerged-land perimeter rate of 19 cents per square foot, escalating 3% annually; a new market-rate submerged-land lease co-terminus with the Rec & Park lease; rent credits of up to $30,000 for dock improvements, likely leaving no rent due; waiver of the security deposit; club responsibility for pier maintenance and operation; indemnification of the Port; and an augmented building permit. The club must continue to provide and promote aquatic activities. - Port staff plan to work with Rec & Park to assign Port landlord responsibilities to Rec & Park, similar to the South End Rowing Club settlement, so the club can have a single landlord and eventually a consolidated lease. - No public comment was offered. Commissioner Gilman supported the item and noted it took 27 years to address jurisdiction; Commissioner Macris and Vice President Adams also supported it. - The commission approved the settlement and lease. Key Outcomes - Approved the February 25, 2020 meeting minutes. - Voted to hold a closed session and later voted not to disclose the discussions. - Approved authorization to advertise Construction Contract No. 2830 for Mission Bay Ferry Landing dredging and site preparation. - Approved the settlement agreement and Lease L-16653 with the Pilara Family Foundation for Pier 24 Annex. - Approved the settlement agreement and Lease L-16661 with the Dolphin Swimming and Boating Club. - No new business was introduced, and the meeting was adjourned. - All votes were voice votes with no audible opposition; no roll-call tally was recorded.

PROCEDURAL 42% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · ETHICS COMMISSION 11% · CONTRACT MANAGEMENT 8%
1327
FEB 25, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting Summary – February 25, 2020

The Port Commission met on February 25, 2020, at 10:30 AM to discuss and vote on several items, including the biennial capital budget, an informational presentation on South Beach Harbor, a 99-year ground lease for Parcel E2 at Pier 70, and approvals for the California Barrel Company mixed-use project. The meeting also included updates on the city's COVID-19 preparedness and new business scheduling. Public Comments & Testimony - Cynthia Gomez (Research Analyst, UNITE HERE Local 2) spoke in support of the California Barrel Company project, noting a signed agreement guaranteeing a fair process for hotel workers to unionize and citing benefits such as affordable healthcare and living wages. - Keith Goldstein (Chair, Eastern Neighborhoods CAC; Petro Booster's board member) expressed strong community support for the California Barrel project, highlighting 30% affordable housing, preservation of Building A, a homeless prenatal program, two childcare centers, and a 25,000-square-foot YMCA. - Bruce Huey (Dogpatch resident) also supported the project, emphasizing broad community backing. Discussion Items - Item 11: Biennial Capital Budget (FY 2020-21 and 2021-22) – Deputy Director Katie Patruccioni presented the capital budget, totaling $84.278 million over two years ($53.5M in FY2020-21 and $28.3M in FY2021-22, later revised to $54.689M and $29.589M, respectively). The budget includes an additional $2.5 million for the Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund. Commissioners questioned prior appropriations, project completion tracking, and the status of the Amador Street sewer project (which has $7 million set aside but remains in design). Staff committed to scheduling an informational item to review capital project progress and past appropriations. The resolution was approved unanimously. - Item 12: Informational Presentation on South Beach Harbor – Harbor Master Joseph Monroe reported that the 700-slip marina has achieved a net positive cash flow of $1.4 million, up from a net negative of $500,000 since the Port took over in 2012. The harbor’s bond debt has been paid off, and occupancy is at 90% (with transient slips making up the remainder). Proposed capital improvements include a $3.5 million North Guest Dock replacement and a $300,000 baffle wall repair. The Port is working with BCDC to amend permit requirements for public access, potentially reducing a $10 million obligation. Commissioners praised the harbor’s financial turnaround and discussed opportunities for larger vessels. - Item 13a: 99-Year Ground Lease for Parcel E2 at Pier 70 – Rebecca Benassini presented a request to authorize a lease below the downmarket threshold ($11.3 million) at an appraised value of $5 million. The appraisal used residual and sales comparison approaches, with the residual analysis yielding a negative value. Staff recommended tying Parcel E2 (281 rental units, 20% affordable) with Parcel A (office, appraised at $66 million) to accelerate the office closing (within 180 days) and avoid a dispute process. Commissioner Macris opposed, presenting his own analysis valuing the parcel at $28.2 million based on comparable sales. He argued the lease should be structured as a standard 30-year lease with annual payments to generate over $100 million over 99 years. Other commissioners, after hearing from peer review appraiser Tim Rundy, supported the staff recommendation, noting that the rental market is currently infeasible for such projects and that tying the parcels together provides a net benefit. The resolution passed 4 to 1. - Item 13b: California Barrel Company Mixed-Use Project – David Be presented the project on a 29-acre former power station site, including 2,600 residential units (30% affordable), 1.5 million square feet of office/life science, 240,000 square feet of hotel/residential, 100,000 square feet of retail, and 5 acres of parks. The Port’s role involves consenting to the development agreement, approving a lease for port lands (with an option to impress public trust easement), and delegating authority for MOUs. Public comment was overwhelmingly supportive. The resolution was approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 11: Capital Budget – Approved unanimously (Resolution 2021). - Item 12: South Beach Harbor – Informational; no vote required. - Item 13a: Parcel E2 Ground Lease – Approved (4-1; Commissioner Macris opposed). Staff authorized to offer Brookfield the option to transact on E2 at $5 million, contingent on expediting Parcel A. - Item 13b: California Barrel Company – Approved unanimously (Resolution 2020-2012). - New Business – Scheduled an informational item to review capital budget achievements and open projects.

PROCEDURAL 38% · REAL ESTATE AND LEASES 18% · MARINA MANAGEMENT 11% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 10%
1328
FEB 12, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
Port Commission Meeting - February 12, 2020

The San Francisco Port Commission met on February 12, 2020, to discuss a range of topics including the port's credit rating upgrade, biennial operating and capital budgets, development projects at Pier 70 and the former Potrero Power Station, a lease renewal for the Chowder Hut, a new pop-up activation program, and safety improvements along the Embarcadero. The meeting included public testimony on bicycle safety and the CBC project. Consent Calendar - Approved modification of Construction Contract No. 2809 for Pier 23 and 19 restroom upgrades with Hoi’s Construction Inc. (Resolution 2005). - Approved authorization to execute a Memorandum of Understanding with the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission for temporary electrical service at Pier 70 (Resolution 2006). Public Comments & Testimony - Embarcadero Safety (Vision Zero): Over a dozen members of the public, including representatives from the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition, teachers, parents, and residents, urged the commission to support a fully protected bike lane along the entire Embarcadero. Many shared personal stories of dangerous conditions and near-misses. Speakers called for immediate action, citing the 2019 death of cyclist Tess Rothstein and the ongoing risk to vulnerable road users. - CBC Project (Potrero Power Station): Katie Liddell (co-chair of Central Waterfront Advisory Group) expressed support for the project, noting community benefits and historic preservation. A representative from the YMCA also spoke in favor, citing the planned community center partnership. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report: Elaine Forbes announced that Moody’s upgraded the port’s credit rating from AA3 to A1, reflecting strong financial management. She also honored the late Stephanie Lazio Sincata, a long-term tenant and owner of the Alioto-Lazio Fish Company, requesting a moment of silence. - Biennial Operating Budget (FY 2020-21 & 2021-22): CFO Katie Petruccioni presented a proposed $194 million budget for FY 2020-21, with $52 million in capital investments. The budget includes 11 new permanent positions for maintenance and equity, plus 11 project-funded positions. Commissioners discussed the need for a port representative on the city’s investment committee, staffing levels, and the importance of maintaining the entire waterfront. No vote was taken; the budget will return for approval on February 25. - Biennial Capital Budget: Petruccioni outlined a $81.8 million two-year capital budget (11% increase over prior biennial), including a $25 million loan to the Mission Bay Ferry Landing project (pending RM3 litigation), $13 million for facility condition assessments (FERPA), and $6.3 million for the Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund. Commissioners requested a list of unfunded projects and a clearer five-year capital plan. No vote was taken. - CBC Mixed-Use Project (Potrero Power Station): Staff and developer Tina Chang provided an update on the 29-acre project, which includes 2,600 housing units (30% affordable), 1.2 million sq ft of commercial space, and 7 acres of parks. The project requires port approval of a lease for shoreline open space and a consent to development agreement. Commissioners expressed strong support, noting community benefits and the extension of the Blue Greenway. No action taken; item will return for approval. - Pier 70 Parcel E2 Lease: Staff proposed a 99-year ground lease for Parcel E2 at an appraised value of $5 million (down from a $11.3 million down-market threshold). The developer, Brookfield, would also exercise the option for Parcel A (office) with an accelerated 180-day closing. Commissioner Macris argued the parcel is worth $28 million and opposed the appraisal. Commissioner Wuho noted that the accelerated timeline offsets the lower value. The commission voted to continue the item to the February 25 meeting for further discussion. - Chowder Hut Lease Renewal: Staff presented a 10-year lease renewal with Boudin Bakeries for the Chowder Hut at Fisherman’s Wharf, including $800,000 in capital improvements. The tenant pays 9% of gross revenue and has strong sales. Commissioners were supportive; the item will return for formal approval. - Pop-up Activation RFQ: Staff proposed issuing a Request for Qualifications to create a pool of operators for short-term activations at five port open spaces (Pier 29, Piers 30/32, Bayfront Park, Crane Cove Park, Heron’s Head Park). Commissioners supported the concept and asked for an update on responses later in the year. - Embarcadero Safety Improvements: SFMTA planners presented Vision Zero quick-build projects, including a two-way protected bike lane from Mission to Folsom and safety improvements at Pier 35. Public comment overwhelmingly demanded a full-length protected bike lane. Commissioners expressed urgency and asked SFMTA to return within three months with a detailed plan of action, including trade-off analysis and timeline. Key Outcomes - Credit Rating Upgrade: Moody’s upgraded the port’s credit rating to A1 (from AA3), reducing borrowing costs. - Budget Approval Delayed: The February 25 meeting will include final votes on the operating and capital budgets. - Pier 70 Lease Continued: The Parcel E2 lease vote was postponed to allow further discussion of the appraisal. - Embarcadero Safety Plan Ordered: The commission directed SFMTA to return in three months with a concrete plan for a protected bike lane along the entire Embarcadero. - Future Agendas: Items scheduled include a public meeting on the World Trade Center building lease, an update on the Navigation Center, and a report on the pop-up activation RFQ results.

TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 19% · CAPITAL PLANNING 8% · APPRAISAL DISPUTE 8% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 8%
1329
JAN 14, 2020 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting Summary - January 14, 2020

The Port Commission of the City and County of San Francisco convened on Tuesday, January 14, 2020, at 10:00 AM for a full public meeting. The commission re-elected its president and vice president, honored a retiring 30-year port employee, approved a trust exchange with the California State Lands Commission, approved new street names and the schematic design for the Mission Rock development's China Basin Park, and authorized advertising for a construction contract for the Crane Cove Park roadway. The meeting adjourned at approximately 5:20 PM. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (December 10, 2019): Approved unanimously. - Executive Session: The commission voted unanimously to convene in executive session for a conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation matters. No public comment was offered on executive session items. Public Comments & Testimony - Diane Walton, President of the Dolphin Club: Walton requested the commission's help breaking a bureaucratic logjam preventing the club from repairing its dock at Aquatic Park. She explained the club's city lease (signed in the 1970s, expiring in 2028) and that the port had requested evidence of dock apron approval from the 1960s, when the site was not under port jurisdiction. The club had been working on this since September 2019 and faced an upcoming swim season. Commission leadership committed to having staff reach out and continue contact. - Bruce Agid: A 10-year Mission Bay resident and board member of the South Beach/Mission Bay Neighborhood Association, Agid expressed strong support for the Mission Rock development items, noting his eight-plus years of involvement in the community planning process and praising the project's waterfront park design. - Shelley Carroll: A 20-year South Beach resident, Carroll enthusiastically supported the China Basin Park project and commended the port and the Giants for extensive community engagement. Discussion Items Election of Port Commission Officers (Item 9A): - Commissioner Brandon was re-elected as Port Commission President by unanimous vote. - Commissioner Willie Adams was elected as Vice President by unanimous vote. - Brandon noted 22 years of service on the commission; Adams praised the commission as "the best commission in the city, pound for pound." Executive Director's Report (Item 9B): - Executive Director Elaine Forbes reported on the retirement of David Rauenbuehler, Port Plumbing Supervisor, who served more than 30 years with the port (per the commendation, June 1989 to January 2020, with 27 of those years as supervisor). Staff and commissioners praised his problem-solving, mentorship of younger staff, and photography contributions (over 80,000 photographs on his website). A commendation was presented marking his service. - Forbes announced the release of the Request for Proposals (RFP) for Piers 38 and 40, issued January 10, 2020, with a pre-bid meeting and site tour scheduled for January 24, 2020 at 1:00 PM at the South Beach Harbor Community Room. Responses are due March 4, 2020 at 4:00 PM. Trust Exchange Agreement with California State Lands Commission (Item 10A): - Staff recommended approval of a trust exchange that would remove public trust from certain Transbay streets (Fremont, Beale, and portions of Mission and Beale Streets) and impress public trust on certain Fisherman's Wharf streets (Hyde, Bay, and Beach Streets). - The exchange supports the Transbay Transit Center site consolidation and the Millennium Tower retrofit project at 301 Mission Street. - A preliminary appraisal indicated the property going into the trust (approximately 153,000 square feet) exceeds the property coming out (approximately 143,000 square feet), satisfying the state law requirement for equal or greater value. The transcript's exact phrasing of these figures was somewhat garbled. - The Planning Commission published the final mitigated negative declaration for the Millennium Tower project on December 27, 2019. - Next steps: Board of Supervisors Land Use Committee on January 27, 2020; full board on February 4, 2020; State Lands Commission in February 2020. - Commissioner Adams asked why the port owns the streets but not surrounding land; John Malamut of the City Attorney's office explained the Burton Act history regarding filled bay waterfront. - Resolution 2001 approved unanimously. Mission Rock Street Names (Item 10B): - Staff (Rebecca Benissini, Manager of Port Development Projects) presented proposed new street names "Spur Street" and "Plank Road" for the Mission Rock development at Seawall Lot 337, along with extensions of the existing street grid (Terry Francois, Longbridge Street, Bridgeville Way, and Channel Street). - Spur Street references the site's history as a rail yard (late 1800s to mid-1900s); Plank Road references the historic Mission Plank Road toll road across Yerba Buena Cove. - Benissini reported LBE (Local Business Enterprise) participation at approximately 15% of construction costs to date, working toward the committed 20% goal. She noted the number fluctuates between 14% and 19% depending on change orders. - The final map is anticipated before the Board of Supervisors in the first or second week of February 2020, a prerequisite for CFD formation, the street improvement permit, and phase one parcel leases. - Resolution 2002 approved unanimously. China Basin Park Schematic Design (Item 11A): - Dan Hodap (Port Planning and Environment Division) and Fran Weld (Senior Vice President, San Francisco Giants) presented the schematic design for the five-acre China Basin Park, the largest open space in the Mission Rock project. - Public outreach included an October 1, 2019 open house (approximately 150 attendees at Oracle Park), a Central Waterfront Advisory Committee presentation on October 16, and a joint design review with BCDC's design review board on November 18. During discussion, it was clarified that the park had been discussed at SWAC at a project level but not at this level of design detail. - Park features include: center and handshake plazas, a lifted tree grove, the Great Lawn (multi-use recreation and programming), stormwater gardens with public boardwalks, a dog run, paseos (pedestrian-only streets, Plank Road and Bridgeview Way), tidal shelves with saline-tolerant plantings and beach access, a kayak launch, and a food and beverage pavilion. - The park is designed as part of the sea level rise resilience strategy with three elevation bands from 98 to 104 feet. - Community concerns raised during outreach included encampment questions and traffic/congestion; the design team said these were addressed through transportation planning and street design. - Commissioners asked about the design review committee membership (a mix of Waterfront Design Advisory Committee members and community participants), water taxi/ferry access connections, and pedestrian safety issues such as gap hazards in grating. - Resolution 2003 approved unanimously. Construction Contract No. 2813 - 19th Street Extension and Georgia Street (Item 12A): - Erica Peterson, Port Project Manager for the Crane Cove Park Project, requested authorization to advertise for competitive bids. - Scope: approximately 950 feet of new roadway (700-foot 19th Street extension and 250-foot Georgia Street segment), sidewalk, street lights, fire hydrants, and a combined sewer, providing access to the Pier 70 shipyard and the new 19th Street parking lot. - Engineer's construction cost estimate: $4.3 million including a 10% contingency. - Funding: $1 million federal grant through Caltrans, port capital, and potentially up to $1.6 million from the port's project contingency fund. Using the contingency would wipe out the port's remaining contingency through fiscal year 2019-2020. - The DBE (Disadvantaged Business Enterprise) goal was revised by Caltrans from 28% to 18%. Federal funding prohibits LBE requirements and local hiring preferences. - The project is designed to remain functional for up to 28 inches of sea level rise. - Commissioners expressed significant concern about the cost increase over original estimates (the roadway estimate roughly doubled) and the impact on the overall Crane Cove Park budget, including the building 49 restoration scope. Vice President Adams called the project "an Achilles heel for the port." President Brandon stated, "We do not have any more money" for the park. - The commission voted to authorize advertising despite these concerns, with the understanding that bids would provide more information and the commission could reject bids if costs exceed available budget. - Resolution 2004 approved unanimously. New Business - President Brandon requested inviting WETA's new chair, Jim Wonderman, to present to the commission, as well as BCDC leadership, to coordinate on waterfront planning. - A commissioner requested a February 2020 update on the Dolphin Club's dock repair situation. - Vice President Adams requested updates on the navigation center, the shipyard, and ferry/water taxi plans. Key Outcomes - All four resolutions (2001, 2002, 2003, 2004) were approved unanimously. - Officers elected: President Brandon re-elected; Vice President Adams elected. - RFP for Piers 38/40 released; responses due March 4, 2020. - Trust exchange next steps: Board of Supervisors consideration on January 27 and February 4, 2020; State Lands Commission in February 2020. - Final map for Mission Rock expected before the Board in February 2020. - Construction contract for 19th Street Extension and Georgia Street to be advertised in March 2020, with substantial completion targeted by April 2021.

PROCEDURAL 39% · MISSION ROCK PROJECT 10% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 9% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 7%
1330
DEC 10, 2019 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - December 10, 2019

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, December 10, 2019, at 10:00 a.m. The Commission approved consent items, heard informational presentations on the Draft Waterfront Plan and PASHA operations at Pier 80, authorized an RFP for Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330, adopted the 2019 Port Building Code, and adjourned in honor of the late Mayor Ed Lee. Public comment was heard on several items. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The Commission unanimously approved the minutes of the November 12, 2019 Port Commission meeting. - Resolution 19-46: Authorized the street name change of the 200 block of Steuart Street to Steuart Lane. Public Comments & Testimony - Christopher Christiansen (ILWU Local 34) expressed gratitude to Diane Oshima and the waterfront plan working group, noting the plan contains “161 policies” (he also said “160 policies” in the same remarks). He voiced support for the plan’s completion. - Dr. Matthew Ajaque (President, San Francisco African American Chamber of Commerce) asked how stakeholders were defined for the Piers 30-32 RFP, urged inclusion of broader community voices beyond advisory groups, and asked how a museum/arts/cultural facility would address art migration and sustainability. - Alan Johnk (Co-chair, Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee) praised PASHA’s operations at Pier 80, calling the growth “thrilling” and commending the company’s local hiring and community engagement. - Christopher Christiansen also spoke on the PASHA item, noting that the local hires are now unionized with ILWU Local 6, and that ILWU fully supports PASHA. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report: Elaine Forbes reported that on November 25, 2019, Judge Shulman ruled in the city’s favor regarding the Navigation Center, determining that the Port did not need State Lands Commission approval. She announced that the city’s contracted provider had joined the advisory group. The Commission viewed a video about the Embarcadero Seawall Program’s Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment (MHRA), funded by a $425 million general obligation bond approved in November 2018. - Draft Waterfront Plan (Item 11A): Diane Oshima presented public comments received from June through October 2019, including 18 public meetings, an online survey, and letters/emails. Proposed revisions include an executive summary, clarifications on revenue-generating uses within the Embarcadero Historic District, strengthened equity language, enhanced environmental sustainability policies, recognition of Ferry Building ground leases, and additional resilience language. Staff next steps include environmental review, coordination with BCDC and State Lands, and extending design review to the full 7.5-mile waterfront. Commissioners Gilman, Adams, and Macris asked questions about equity, sub-area consistency, and community benefits. - Sea Lion Sculptures (Item 11B): Dan Hodak and Aquarium of the Bay staff presented a proposal to install 30 full-size sea lion sculptures, with 16 on Port property, for up to nine months. The fee waiver covers an approximately $1,500 license fee plus permit fees, totaling around $3,000. The project includes 3,000 mini sea lions for schoolchildren, a Guinness World Record attempt, and a STEAM education program. Commissioners expressed support; Commissioner Gilman requested community inreach to nearby neighborhoods. - PASHA Operations at Pier 80 (Item 12A): Andre Coleman reported auto volumes grew from about 4,500 in 2016 to 24,000 in 2017 and continued growing. For 2019, he stated “146 autos moved through the facility” — as transcribed, though the context suggests this may be a transcription error for 146,000. PASHA currently employs 14 full-time employees; 50% of auto processors are District 10 residents (correcting a staff report that said 29% by including manager positions). Since 2016, 28% of District 10 hires remain active and 6% were promoted. Port net terminal revenues were approximately $600k (FY16-17), $1.7M (FY17-18), $2.1M (FY18-19), and a projected $2.3M (FY19-20). PASHA representatives noted a newly negotiated 40-hour work week guarantee, an apprenticeship program, and three new community partnerships. Commissioner Brandon raised concerns that only 10 permanent jobs exist versus the original vision of up to 150, and requested a follow-up strategy for value-added work. - RFP for Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 (Item 13A): Peter Albert presented updates since the November 12, 2019 informational hearing. The RFP will allow proposals for either site or a combined project, with scoring based on a 100-point written submission plus 30 points for oral presentations. Commissioner Macris suggested keeping the oral presentation scores separate and unknown from the written scores to ensure objectivity. The timeline includes releasing the RFP in January 2020, proposals due in March 2020, scoring panel in April 2020, and Commission action in June 2020. Public comment from Dr. Ajaque asked for broader community engagement. Resolution 19-48 was approved. - 2019 Port Building Code (Item 14A): Neil Friedman presented the code adoption package, including filing local findings with the California Building Standards Commission, repealing the 2016 code, and adopting the 2019 code effective January 1, 2020. Changes include incentivizing all-electric buildings, aligning seismic upgrade triggers with the state existing building code, and increasing permit fees (e.g., a $50,000 project would increase by about $500; hourly plan review from $80 to $173; inspection from $80 to $158). No public comments were received. Commissioner Adams asked whether the code would preclude natural gas in restaurants; staff clarified it does not, but noted a pending city ordinance on electrification could have future implications. Resolution 19-49 was approved. Key Outcomes - Approved Resolutions 19-46, 19-47, 19-48, and 19-49 by unanimous voice votes. - Approved the minutes of the November 12, 2019 meeting. - Authorized the executive director to proceed with the Piers 30-32/Seawall Lot 330 RFP process. - Directed staff to: - Bring PASHA back to discuss strategies for increasing value-added auto processing work, local wage and retention data, and a full history of community outreach since 2016. - Provide an update on city legislation related to natural gas and building electrification. - Provide a report on the photography studio update (requested by Commissioner Gilman). - Invite the new SFMTA director to discuss waterfront transportation vision. - Work on clarifying sub-area geography definitions for consistency across planning and real estate. - Adjourned in honor of Mayor Edwin M. Lee on the two-year anniversary of his death, following a motion by Commissioner Gilman.

PROCEDURAL 39% · MARITIME OPERATIONS 14% · PIER DEVELOPMENT 9% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 8%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com