The Port Commission of the City and County of San Francisco met on Tuesday, November 12, 2019, from 2:30 PM to 5:30 PM. Commissioners Kimberly Brandon (President), Gail Gilman, Doreen Woo Ho, and Willie Adams (absent) were present. The meeting covered routine approvals, informational presentations on major development projects, contracting activity, building code updates, and a street name change. Consent Calendar - Resolution 19-44: Retroactive approval of Commission President Kimberly Brandon’s travel to Washington, D.C. (October 28-30, 2019) to advocate for a technical change to the Water Resources Development Act (WRDA). Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Damien McLeod (Spin Out Fitness) requested guidance and support for permitting a water bike fitness and touring business at Port facilities. - Jörg Schlegel (Cirque du Soleil) asked to be considered as a temporary tenant for five months per year at Pier 30-32, noting the need for structural reinforcement. - Rick Dickerson (chair of the Embarcadero Navigation Center Advisory Group) urged that the RFP for Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 include a “reality check” on economic feasibility, and encouraged residential use with neighborhood-serving retail only if viable. - Alice Rogers (South Beach Rincon Mission Bay Neighborhood Association) thanked staff for community outreach and expressed eagerness for development. - Drew Becher (CEO, San Francisco Parks Alliance) expressed excitement to partner on the Crane Cove Park fundraising campaign, noting that $500,000 had already been raised for the dog run. - Timothy Reif (Carpenters Local 22), Terry McGolabs (Swinerton Builders), Jesus Villalobos (Local 261), and James Halloran (Swinerton Builders) spoke in support of the street name change to Steuart Lane, citing union jobs and community engagement. Discussion Items - Item 11a: Informational Presentation on RFP for Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330 – Staff presented a proposed competitive solicitation allowing combined or separate bids for the two sites. Community values were identified through summer 2019 outreach (Central Waterfront Advisory Group, Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee, South Beach Rincon Mission Bay neighbors). Key values included funding and economics, urban design, transportation, sustainability, and quality of life. For Pier 30-32, support for deep-water berthing, open space, museum/arts/cultural uses. For Seawall Lot 330, interest in housing and hotel (with transportation management caveat). The RFP process would include minimum qualifications (e.g., $40 million project experience, over-water construction experience), a scoring panel (100 points written + 30 oral), and staff recommendations to the Commission. Commissioner Gilman suggested reordering scoring criteria to prioritize team diversity, LBE experience, and community engagement. Commissioner Macris urged allowing the panel to bring more than one top-scoring proposal to the Commission, not just the top. Commissioner Woo Ho recommended odd-numbered panels and adding finance and architectural expertise. Commissioner Brandon stressed that funds from Seawall Lot 330 alone should be dedicated to a clear plan for Pier 30-32. Staff noted that the Commission would have two public meetings: one informational (with executive summaries and scores) and one for action on entering exclusive negotiations or terminating the RFP. - Item 11b: MOU with San Francisco Parks Alliance for Crane Cove Park Fundraising – Authorized a memorandum of understanding to raise up to $6.4 million for a children’s playground, dog run, and historic crane restoration. The Parks Alliance would retain 11% of cash contributions for campaign costs. The MOU has a five-year term with three one-year options. Contributions over $100,000 require Commission approval. The fundraising campaign will launch in spring 2020 after the park opens. Unanimously approved (Resolution 19-45). - Item 12a: Informational Presentation on Port’s Contracting Activity FY 2018-19 – Port Contract Administrator Boris Filipov reported that 16 new contracts worth over $40 million were awarded; 63% of contracts went to LBE prime contractors, and 42% of dollars went to LBE firms. Excluding the $19 million Crane Cove Park contract (non-LBE), LBE performance rose to 58%. Of LBE contracts, four went to other business enterprises (non-minority/non-women), three to minority-owned firms ($2.4 million to an African American firm, $1 million total to two Asian American firms), and three to women-owned firms ($6.75 million total). Commissioner Brandon expressed strong concern about low minority contracting and called for an action plan. Commissioner Gilman suggested examining barriers to access. Staff agreed to return with a strategic action plan. - Item 13a: Informational Presentation on 2019 Building Code Updates – Chief Building Inspector Neil Friedman outlined proposed amendments to adopt the 2019 California codes with local amendments. Key changes: adoption of site permit process, allowance of high-strength plastic pipe (HDPE) for waste lines under piers (due to corrosion of cast iron), and fee increases (building permit review from $80/hr to $174/hr, inspection from $80/hr to $150.58/hr, administrative from $80/hr to $96/hr) to align with DBI. Green building code updates include electric vehicle charging stations and water/wastewater management. The amendment will be presented for final approval at the December 10, 2019 meeting, effective January 1, 2020. - Item 13b: Informational Presentation on Street Name Change – 200 Block of Steuart Street to Steuart Lane – Rodney Ewashta (Chief Harbor Engineer) introduced the request from 75 Howard Owner LP to rename the cul-de-sac portion of Steuart Street (within Port jurisdiction) to Steuart Lane. The renaming is intended to distinguish the dead-end and align with the new building entrance of 75 Howard, a 20-story condominium project (120 units, targeting LEED Gold, completed 2021). The project pays $8.5 million in affordable housing fees plus $6 million voluntary contribution. The item will return for action in December 2019. Key Outcomes - Approved: Resolution 19-44 (retroactive travel approval), Resolution 19-45 (Crane Cove Park MOU with Parks Alliance). - Approved: Adjournment in memory of Buck Delventhal (October 26, 2019). - Direction to Staff: - Return with a concept for third-party validation of the seawall program (as recommended by Senator Feinstein). - Calendar an item to develop an action plan to increase diversity in contracting. - For the Piers 30-32/Seawall Lot 330 RFP, refine scoring criteria to prioritize diversity and community engagement, consider odd-numbered panels with diverse expertise, and allow the Commission to consider multiple top-scoring proposals if recommended by the panel. - For the building code amendment, staff will present the final draft and fee schedule at the December 10, 2019 meeting for approval. - The street name change will return for a vote in December 2019. Meeting Adjourned: 5:30 PM in memory of Buck Delventhal.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Port Commission met on October 22, 2019, at 2:30 PM, adjourning at 5:35 PM. The meeting covered the Executive Director's report, an informational presentation on citywide resilience efforts, a request for proposals for the adaptive reuse of historic piers, and approval of a bond refunding resolution. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the September 24, 2019, meeting. - Entered executive session and reconvened; voted not to disclose the contents of that session. Public Comments & Testimony - Diane Amato, a neighbor, expressed concerns about noise from loud music bouncing off the water, double-parked buses, and lack of Uber drop-off areas affecting quality of life near Piers 38 and 40. - Alice Rogers, President of the South Beach Rincon Mission Bay Neighborhood Association, expressed support for moving forward with the RFP for the historic piers, praising the focus on values and priorities rather than specific uses. Discussion Items - Executive Director's Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported on successful Fleet Week (October 7–14, 2019), acknowledged staff contributions, and noted the appointment of Rick Dickerson and Alice Rogers as chair and vice chair of the SAFE Embarcadero Navigation Center Advisory Group, with Five Keys selected as the provider. She announced passage of State Senate Bill 451 (State Historic Tax Credit Program), which can be used with federal historic credits and has a $50 million cap (with $10 million set aside for smaller projects). Forbes also described a San Francisco Chamber of Commerce trip to Seattle (September 25–27) to learn from Seattle's seawall replacement and waterfront improvement efforts, including a special tax district for funding. She reported on the American Association of Port Authorities (AAPA) conference in Norfolk, Virginia (October 14–16), where the port received an award for the Embarcadero Seawall campaign. Finally, she announced that the Port of San Francisco and the Golden Gate Audubon Society received an award for environmental protection at Pier 94. - Citywide Resilience Efforts (Item 11A): Brian Strong (Chief Resilience Officer) provided an update on the Hazard and Climate Resilience Plan, noting that the city is developing over 70 strategies to mitigate risks from natural hazards (earthquakes, sea level rise, heat, poor air quality, etc.). The plan is required for FEMA funding eligibility. Public engagement included workshops with 50+ community organizations and a survey with 500+ responses. The plan will be submitted to FEMA in December 2019. Adam Verrit (Planning Department) presented the Sea Level Rise Vulnerability and Consequences Assessment, which examined up to 108 inches of sea level rise (including storm surge). Key findings include potential impacts on transportation, shoreline open space, new development, and joint risks from coastal and pluvial flooding. The assessment identified that all port facilities are at risk. Commissioners discussed progress compared to other cities (e.g., Seattle, San Mateo, Miami Beach), private sector engagement, and the importance of FEMA approval for accessing federal hazard mitigation grants. - Request for Proposals for Piers 38 and 40 (Item 12A): David Beaupre (Real Estate and Development) presented a request for authorization to issue an RFP for the adaptive reuse, rehabilitation, lease, and operation of the South Beach Historic Piers 38 and 40 within the Embarcadero National Register Historic District. The RFP is aligned with the Waterfront Land Use Plan, the Port's Resilience Program, and stakeholder input. Minimum qualifications include experience with a single development project of at least $40 million in committed funding. Scoring criteria allocate 100 points for written proposals (quality of design, financial strength, experience) and up to 30 additional points for oral interviews. The selection panel will include a development expert, port staff, a port advisory group member, and a citywide/regional representative. Extensive discussion by commissioners led to several amendments: revisit the 5-minute presentation time, extend the blackout period to cover panelists, and have the commission hear all proposals meeting minimum qualifications after the scoring panel completes its work (with scores public) in an informational meeting before a final recommendation. The resolution was approved with these amendments. - Bond Refunding (Item 10A): Staff presented Resolution 19-42 to authorize the issuance of Series 2020 Refunding Revenue Bonds not to exceed $27 million (expected $23.5 million) to refund the remaining outstanding balance on the 2010 Revenue Bonds. The refunding is estimated to save the Port approximately $13 million over the life of the bonds, with a net present value of $7.9 million. The maturity dates remain unchanged. The resolution was approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Resolution 19-43 (Piers 38 and 40 RFP): Approved with amendments. Staff will incorporate commissioner feedback (extended presentation time, blackout period for panelists, scoring completed before commission presentations, and a memo to commissioners on panel composition). - Resolution 19-42 (Bond Refunding): Approved unanimously. The transaction will be presented to the Board of Supervisors on October 29, 2019, and is expected to close by March 1, 2020. - The informational presentations on resilience efforts were received and discussed; no formal action was taken.
The Port Commission met on Tuesday, September 24, 2019, at 3:30 PM UTC (9:30 AM local) to consider a range of items including the Mission Rock Phase 1 budget approval, a contract amendment for the waterfront resilience program, updates to the Port Commission Rules of Order, and a proposed art installation. The meeting also featured reports on awards, fundraising for Crane Cove Park, and a proposed bond refunding. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes – The minutes from the September 10, 2019 meeting were approved unanimously. - Pledge of Allegiance – Led by the Commission. Public Comments & Testimony - Mission Rock Project (Item 7A): Several representatives of local small businesses (LBEs) expressed support and eagerness to participate in the project. Bruce Giron (GECMS/Juron Construction) highlighted his firm's experience with underground work and parks, and requested contracting opportunities. Carl Gordon (working plastering) and Tana Harris (Harris Wasting) also spoke in favor of LBE inclusion. Jacob Wallace, a community member from District 10, praised the developer's outreach to the community. Ken Nim, Director of CityBuild at OEWD, thanked the Commission for support and invited members to the upcoming CityBuild graduation on October 17, 2019. - Crane Cove Park Fundraising (Item 7B): Ever Otta Mora of Historic Pier 70/Ortun Development voiced full support for the partnership with the San Francisco Parks Alliance. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A): Executive Director Elaine Forbes announced two awards: the California Preservation Foundation selected the Pier 70 Design for Development Agreement for a 2019 preservation design award, and the Port won a 3CMA Award of Excellence for innovative communications regarding the Embarcadero Seawall program (including a partnership with Ritual Coffee and Black Hammer Brewery). She also promoted National Public Lands Day on Saturday, September 28, 2019, at Heron’s Head Eco Center. - Rules of Order Revisions (Item 6B): Amy presented two alternatives to the current two-year term limit for Commission officers: (1) eliminate term limits entirely, or (2) extend to four years. Commissioners debated the merits. Commissioner Gilman favored eliminating term limits (Alternative 1), citing flexibility. Commissioner Macris supported Alternative 1. Commissioners Adams and Wuho leaned toward Alternative 2 (four-year term). President Brandon proposed trying four years initially. A motion for Alternative 1 failed (2 ayes, 3 nays). A subsequent motion for Alternative 2 (four-year term limit) passed (3 ayes, 2 opposes). Additionally, the Commission approved updating the rules to allow the Secretary to delegate meeting attendance. - Mission Rock Phase 1 Budget & Parks Plan (Item 7A): Rebecca gave a detailed presentation on the revised Phase 1 scope, which includes 560 rental units (202 affordable, 40% below market rate), over 550,000 sq ft of office, retail, and a 5.5-acre park. The maximum horizontal expenditure is set at $145 million, with a 2-year completion target and a 5-year deadline to avoid default. Two resolutions were proposed: Resolution 1939 (approval of Phase 1 budget and parks plan) and Resolution 1940 (support for nonprofit status of the utility entity for district energy and blackwater treatment). Commissioners praised the project but stressed the need for transparent LBE reporting and workforce development. Commissioner Brandon noted the absence of LBE metrics in the staff report. The project team committed to providing regular updates. The resolutions were approved. - Crane Cove Park Fundraising (Item 7B): Chris and Drew Betcher (CEO, SF Parks Alliance) presented a partnership to raise $6.3 million in private contributions for a tot lot, riggers yard, dog run, and crane tops. The project has a total budget of approximately $36 million, with $16 million already spent. An MOU is expected in winter 2020, with park opening and campaign kickoff in spring 2020. Commissioners expressed strong support, noting the long history of the park and the Alliance's successful track record. - Seawall Program Contract Amendment (Item 8A): Brad Benson presented a $19.99 million amendment to the contract with CH2M Hill Engineers, bringing the total to $59.98 million, to support the Embarcadero Seawall Program, Army Corps flood study, and port-wide resilience work. The amendment includes $5 million for CH2M’s work, with the remainder for LBEs and workforce development. Commissioner Macris opposed, arguing the amendment circumvents the city's 12X ordinance because CH2M is now headquartered in Texas (a covered state). Staff and CH2M representatives explained that the amendment is allowed under the ordinance, and that CH2M maintains strong LGBTQ-inclusive policies. After debate, the amendment passed 4-1 (Commissioner Macris opposed). - Proposed Bond Refunding (Item 9A): CFO Katie Petruccioni reviewed a plan to refund $23.5 million of 2010 revenue bonds to save approximately $13 million over the life of the bonds (net present value $8 million). The new bonds will have a maximum interest rate of 6% (expected 3%) and maintain existing maturities. Bond counsel Russ Trice briefed the Commission on disclosure responsibilities. No action was taken; the item was informational only. - Temporary Art Installation at Pier 14 (Item 10A): Dan Hodak presented a proposal for a one-year temporary art installation titled "Quite Tower" by Sean Orlando and Tanya Seabrook. The 30-foot sculpture will feature repurposed Victorian doors and windows, painted with a gradient of colors, and interior vignettes by eight local artists addressing San Francisco’s housing crisis. The Port’s contribution is the location; no funds are provided. Commissioners welcomed the project and requested better promotion and clearer port-wide art guidelines. Key Outcomes - Rules of Order (6B): Approved amendment to extend officer term limit from two to four years consecutively (Alternative 2). Also approved delegation of secretary duties. - Mission Rock Phase 1 (7A): Approved Resolution 1939 (Phase 1 budget and parks plan) and Resolution 1940 (nonprofit utility entity support). Staff directed to provide clear LBE and workforce reports and brief the Southern Waterfront Advisory Committee quarterly. - Seawall Contract Amendment (8A): Approved Resolution 1941 (amendment with CH2M Hill) by a vote of 4-1, authorizing $19.99 million increase to $59.98 million, with a 21.2% LBE goal. Staff to report back after lightweight cellular concrete pilot project. - Bond Refunding (9A): Informational; staff will return for final approvals in October 2019. - Pier 14 Art (10A): Informational; staff to develop port-wide art guidelines and schedule ribbon-cutting in late October/early November. - New Business: Agenda items scheduled for upcoming meetings: Pier 30-32 RFP authorization (November 12), update on vacant restaurant, Pilara photography lease open session update, ethics training, and Pier 70 status.
The Port Commission met on September 10, 2019, to act on several items including a foreign trade zone agreement, a hotel/theater development, and hazardous waste contracts, as well as to receive updates on the Mission Rock project and the draft Waterfront Plan. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - Approval of minutes from August 13, 2019. - Resolution 19-34: Approval for commissioners to travel to Norfolk, VA for the American Association of Port Authorities Annual Convention (October 13–16, 2019). Public Comments & Testimony - Bruce Agate (South Beach/Rincon/Mission Bay Neighborhood Association) expressed strong support for the Mission Rock project, emphasizing the need for activated open space and 40% affordable housing, and praised the developers' community engagement. - Romula Saison Lou (Contract Monitoring Division) thanked the port for supporting Local Business Enterprises and noted the Mission Rock team's commitment to LBE participation. - Ken Nim (Office of Economic and Workforce Development) updated on workforce training programs linked to Mission Rock, including expansion of City Build Academy. - Jack Baer (San Francisco Giants) expressed gratitude for the partnership and noted that the park’s inclusion in Phase 1 was a key community goal. - Linda Richardson (resident, land use expert, Waterfront Plan advisor) supported the TZK Broadway project, citing alignment with port strategic objectives and community engagement. - Leonard Sol (Carpenter’s Union Local 22) urged approval of the TZK project to create jobs for members. - Randall Scott (Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefit District) supported removal of BCDC’s 50% rule in Fisherman’s Wharf to allow seismic upgrades without reducing pier footprints. - Alice Rogers (South Beach/Rincon/Mission Bay Neighborhood Association) commended the Waterfront Plan’s goal-based approach and requested clarifications that office use should be a financial driver, not a standalone use. - Zach Fournette (Fisherman’s Wharf Restaurant Association) supported removal of the 50% rule, citing improvements at Pier 43 and Jefferson Street. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported: - Fire Station 35 at Pier 22½ expansion: first floating facility; building permits issued, construction starts September 2019, completion April 2021. Groundbreaking tentatively January 2020. - Pier 94 Backlands Improvement Project won two awards (including Collaborative Partnering Award), to be presented September 26, 2019. - Coastal Cleanup Day: September 21, 2019, 9 a.m.–noon, at multiple port locations. Port in friendly competition with Oakland. - Foreign Trade Zone Agreement with Pacific Cycle (Item 11A): Brendan O’Mare presented. Pacific Cycle to activate two Vacaville distribution centers as FTZ subzone for 5 years with three 5-year renewal options. Port collects annual administrative fees (approximately $5,000 initial, $2,000 annual). FTZ status allows duty deferral and streamlined customs for re-exports. Commissioner Wuho noted previous FTZ operators (e.g., Chevron). Approved as Resolution 19-35. - Mission Rock Phase 1 Budget & Parks Plan (Item 12A – Informational): Rebecca Benassini and Chrisia Tano Lee presented: - Phase 1 horizontal costs: $145 million; total with entitlement costs $175 million; including developer return $265 million. - Balanced budget relies on net land revenues ($42.2 million), community facilities district bonds, and tax increment. - Cost increase of $49 million since 2018 approvals, mainly from detailed design of China Basin Park, streets, and utilities, plus site-wide soft costs. - Parks plan: 5.5 acres China Basin Park, 1 acre Mission Rock Square, 1.5 acres other spaces. Managed by single entity via management and concession agreement. Programming limits: max 100 event days per space, of which 24 may be ticketed and 18 private; paid events cannot exceed free events. - Operating budget at full build-out: $5 million, funded by CFD fees, sponsorships, and concessions. Excess revenue after reserves may go to Port Harbor Fund. - Developer return estimated at $90 million (up from $40 million at approvals due to higher costs and longer bond timing). Port’s NPV return across all phases: $190 million (down from $198 million). - Informational only; action on budget and parks plan scheduled for September 24, 2019. Staff will also seek resolution of support for nonprofit status for district energy and blackwater treatment entities. - TZK Broadway Hotel/Theater Development (Item 12B): Ricky Tidani and Jay Wallace presented: - 192-room hotel, dinner theater (Teatro Zinzani), 14,000 sq ft public open space on Seawall Lots 323/324 (59,000 sq ft total). - 50-year lease with one 16-year extension. Project cost $142 million. Developer will pay port staff and transactional costs during LDDA period. - Public benefits: bringing Teatro Zinzani back, privately funded open space, LBE and local hiring programs, new jobs, and increased port revenue. - CEQA mitigated negative declaration adopted. Commission approved Resolution 19-36 (lease disposition and development agreement, lease, schematic drawings, and CEQA findings). - Next steps: Board of Supervisors approval in September/October 2019; close of escrow by October 2020; construction 1.5–2 years, completion by end of 2022. Commissioner Gilman and Wuho urged acceleration; staff noted construction drawing and permitting timelines. - Hazardous Waste Disposal & Marine Vessel Salvage Contracts (Item 13A): Albi Udam presented. Four contracts awarded: - Clean Harbors Environmental Services, Environmental Logistics, NRC Environmental Services, Silverado Contractors. - Each contract: not to exceed $300,000, initial 4-year term with 1-year extension option. LBE subcontracting goal 5%; actual commitments averaged 7%. - Approved as Resolution 19-37. - Draft Waterfront Plan Review Process (Item 14A – Informational): Diane Oshima presented: - Summer outreach included 200+ on boat tour, multiple advisory group meetings, online survey (high agreement levels with plan goals). - Key public comments: strong support for maritime diversity, water recreation, clarifying that office use in historic pier projects is a financial driver for public benefits, and addressing transportation congestion via bike/pedestrian safety and water transit. - Plan will be refined based on comments (track changes for policy language), then CEQA environmental review starts by end of 2019. - Staff working on conforming amendments to City General Plan and Planning Code, and on BCDC special area plan amendments to remove 50% rule in Fisherman’s Wharf and update policies for resilience and sustainability. Key Outcomes - Resolutions Approved (all unanimous): - 19-34: Travel authorization. - 19-35: Pacific Cycle foreign trade zone operators agreement. - 19-36: TZK Broadway LDDA, lease, schematic drawings, and CEQA findings. - 19-37: Hazardous waste disposal and vessel salvage contracts. - New Business: Commissioner Wuho requested future informational item on park activation for the TZK project. Vice President Adams requested staff to review and bring back proposals on officer term limits and commission secretary provisions (possible action at next meeting). Staff also to research a commission rules of conduct based on port values. - Next Meetings: Mission Rock Phase 1 budget and parks plan action on September 24, 2019. Waterfront Plan refinements and CEQA initiation ongoing.
The San Francisco Port Commission convened on Tuesday, August 13, 2019, at approximately 2:00 PM. The meeting covered the approval of minutes, announcements, public comments, and several informational and action items including cruise ship fee increases, a major hotel and dinner theater development, environmental services contracts, park construction progress, and the waterfront resilience program. The commission voted on two action items and received updates on ongoing projects. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (July 9, 2019): The minutes from the July 9, 2019 meeting were approved as amended. A commissioner raised a point about recording when commissioners leave the room during votes, and it was agreed to address this protocol at a future meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - Navigation Center Advisory Group (Item 9): Toby Levine, co-chair of the Central Waterfront Advisory Committee, expressed support for the newly formed Embarcadero SAFE Navigation Center Advisory Group and emphasized the need to address the homeless crisis. The group has 12 members, including neighborhood representatives, businesses, and two formerly homeless individuals. - Teatro Zanzani Hotel Project (Item 11A): Multiple speakers voiced strong support for the proposed hotel/dinner theater development. Speakers included representatives from neighborhood associations (Bill Hannon from Gateway Tenants Association/Barbary Coast Neighborhood Association), labor unions (Carpenters Local 22, Teamsters Local 665, Unite Here Local 2), tourism (San Francisco Travel Association), and former performers (Elaine Turkot, Kristen Clayton). They highlighted the project's economic benefits, cultural value, union agreements, and community engagement. A preservation advocate (Stuart Morton) noted the developer's compliance with historic district standards. Discussion Items - Cruise Ship Passenger Fee Increase (Item 10A): Michael Nurney, Assistant Director of Maritime, presented a proposal to amend Port Tariff No. 5 to increase the bundled cruise passenger fee from $18 to $19 effective January 1, 2020, with further increases to $20 in 2021 and $20.60 in 2022. A volume discount was introduced for cruise lines exceeding 240,000 passengers per year, aiming to incentivize growth. The port expects 116 ship calls and 390,000 passengers in 2020, generating $7.2 million in revenue (including the discount). Revenue will support capital improvements at Pier 27 and Pier 35. - Teatro Zanzani Hotel and Dinner Theater (Item 11A): Staff presented a detailed informational overview of a proposed Lease Disposition and Development Agreement (LDDA) with TZK Broadway LLC for Seawall Lots 323 and 324. The project includes a 192-room hotel, a dinner theater (Teatro Zanzani), and approximately 14,000 square feet of public open space. The initial lease term is 50 years with a 16-year extension option. The port contributed no capital; the developer funds the entire project. Rent includes base rent (escalating), percentage rent (3.5%-6.5% of gross revenue), and participation in capital events. The developer requested modifications to increase the internal rate of return from 18% to 20% and adjust the capital share split from 70/30 to 80/20, in exchange for additional protections and a lower hurdle for subsequent tenants. Staff evaluated net present value projections showing significant revenue gains over the existing parking lot use. The item is scheduled for action at the September 10, 2019 commission meeting. - Environmental Services Contracts (Item 12A): The commission approved awarding three contracts for as-needed environmental and related professional services to ESA/CDIM Joint Venture, SCA Environmental, Inc., and AEW Engineering, Inc., each with a not-to-exceed value of $2 million over a 4-year term (with a 1-year extension option). The contracts cover environmental engineering, planning, permitting, stormwater management, dredging support, and climate change analysis. Staff highlighted strong LBE participation: 59% of total contract dollars will go to LBE firms (including primes and subcontractors), exceeding the 12% requirement. No protests were received. - Crane Cove Park Construction Update (Item 13A): Erica Peterson provided an update on Construction Contract No. 2812 for Crane Cove Park and the 19th Street Parking Lot. The contract amount is $17.845 million with a 24.54% LBE commitment. As of June 25, 2019, $6.9 million (39% of work) had been paid; the project is on schedule despite 10 extra rain days. Key progress includes demolition, relocation of Building 30, beach revetment installation, and parking lot construction. The beach is expected to be completed in September 2019, with substantial completion in February 2020. The port used in-house construction management to save costs. LBE participation is expected to exceed the goal; GMB mentored LBE subcontractors and used LBE truckers exclusively. - Waterfront Resilience Program & Contract Amendment (Item 13B): Brad Benson, Waterfront Resilience Director, presented the port's resilience program, which integrates the Embarcadero Seawall Program, the Army Corps Flood Study, and other initiatives. A proposed $20 million amendment to the CH2M HILL (Jacobs) contract (base contract $40 million) would fund planning, engineering, and environmental services over three years. The amendment includes $10 million for the Army Corps flood study, expanded public engagement, and port-wide adaptation planning. LBE participation is projected at 30% for the amendment (overall 23%), with targeted outreach and workforce development efforts. The program addresses seismic and flood risks across the 7.5-mile waterfront, with costs estimated at $2-5 billion. Funding sources include a state grant, city loans, a potential bond sale (subject to litigation over Proposition A), and federal/state grants. - Army Corps Flood Resiliency Study Amendment (Item 13C): Stephen Gold presented an informational report on a proposed amendment to the Feasibility Cost Sharing Agreement with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for the San Francisco Waterfront Flood Resiliency Study. The study was originally scoped at $3 million over 3 years but is now estimated at $20.3 million over 5 years due to complexity. The port's cost share is $10.05 million, mostly in-kind services. The amendment includes an accelerated funds clause allowing the port to advance funds if federal appropriations are delayed. Final approval of the revised study plan is expected in September 2019. Key Outcomes - Resolution 19-32 (Cruise Ship Fees): Approved unanimously. The tariff amendment increases passenger fees and adds a volume discount. - Environmental Services Contracts: Approved unanimously to award three contracts (ESA/CDIM JV, SCA Environmental, AEW Engineering) for as-needed services up to $2 million each. - Next Steps: The Teatro Zanzani project (Item 11A) will return for action on September 10, 2019. The Army Corps study amendment (Item 13C) will be brought for approval in September. Staff will provide updates on Pier 40 restroom concerns and the World Trade Center building as requested by commissioners.
The Port Commission convened on July 9, 2019, to address a range of real estate, engineering, and financial items. Key actions included approval of a long-term lease for Red and White Fleet, authorization to advertise for pre-construction services for the Mission Bay Ferry Landing, approval of bond issuances for park improvements, a supplemental appropriation for the Seawall Earthquake Safety Program, and an 8% salary increase for the Executive Director. Public comment was heard on several items, including strong support for the Teatro Zanzani project (though not on the agenda) and the Red and White Fleet lease. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Unanimously approved the Fiscal Year 2019-20 Monthly Rental Rate Schedule, Parking Stall Rates, and Special Events (Resolution 19-24). Public Comments & Testimony - Executive Session Public Comment: A field representative from Carpenters Local 22 expressed support for the Teatro Zanzani project, citing union labor commitments and job creation. - Item 8 (Non-Agenda Items): Multiple speakers voiced strong support for the Teatro Zanzani project: - Aaron Thornton (Letty Madeham Stacey Architects) endorsed the project. - Kevin Carroll supported the project and its activation of the area. - Bill Hannon (Gateway Tenants Association) gave wholehearted support, citing cultural and business benefits. - Laurel Fish (Unite Here Local 2) supported the hotel development, noting the developer's agreement to remain neutral on unionization and use union labor. - Bob Hare (Barbary Coast Neighborhood Association) supported the project, commending developer outreach. - Item 11A (Red and White Fleet Lease): Alan Johnk (Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee) and John William Templeton (historian) spoke in favor of the lease renewal. - Item 11B (Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330): Alice Rogers (South Beach Rincon Mission Bay Neighborhood Association) expressed general support for development but urged that Seawall Lot 330 not be delayed by the challenges of Piers 30-32. Discussion Items - Item 11A – Lease Renewal for Golden Gate Scenic Steamship (Red and White Fleet): Staff presented a 15-year lease with two 5-year options, including $4.6 million in shore-side and waterside improvements. The lease complies with the Maritime Excursion Lease Renewal Policy. Commissioner Macris opposed, arguing the lease should be put out to competitive bid. Other commissioners supported the renewal, citing good tenancy, environmental leadership (hybrid ferry), and community engagement. The motion passed 4-1. - Item 11B – Informational Presentation on Piers 30-32 and Seawall Lot 330: Staff reviewed the history and challenges, including substructure retrofit costs ($185–290 million), seawall costs ($78.6 million), and sea level rise risks. Commissioner Wuho suggested exploring demolition and replacement of the pier, and allowing RFP respondents to propose alternative configurations. Commissioners supported flexibility, interim pop-up uses, and maintaining maritime berth value. No vote was taken; staff will conduct community outreach and return with an RFP proposal. - Item 11C – Lease Amendment for Frankie’s Java House: Staff recommended approval of a lease amendment and 10-year extension for a restaurant at Pier 40½, with a new ownership structure. The new terms include a base rent increase to $4,000/month, 12% of net sales, and a $51,000 penalty for delayed capital improvements. The extension is conditional on completing all improvements. Commissioners supported the deal, noting protections against default. Approved unanimously. - Item 11D – Informational Presentation on Mission Rock Phase 1: Project team (Port, Giants, Tishman Speyer) presented Phase 1 plans: 550 residential units (202 affordable), 240,000 sq ft office, 5-acre China Basin Park, and infrastructure. The project is on track for groundbreaking by end of 2019. Commissioners praised the affordable housing component, workforce development (exceeding 10% LBE goal), and community outreach. No vote taken. - Item 12A – Authorization to Advertise for CMGC for Mission Bay Ferry Landing: Staff requested authorization to advertise for pre-construction services ($750,000) using a CMGC delivery method to meet funding and in-water work deadlines. Discussion focused on the LBE participation goal of 8% (down from an earlier 12%/6% split). Commissioner Adams wanted to hold the item due to low LBE participation, but after clarification that the 8% was a floor and staff would work on capacity building, the motion passed. Resolution 19-27 approved. - Item 13A – Fourth Bond Issuance for 2012 Parks Bond: Staff requested approval to issue $3.1 million in remaining bond funds for Agua Vista Park and Heron’s Head Park. The issuance will be combined with an affordable housing bond to save costs. Approved unanimously. - Item 13B – Supplemental Appropriation for Seawall Program: Due to litigation challenging the seawall bond (Prop A, passed with 82.7% support), staff requested a $11.5 million appropriation from Harbor Fund balance to keep the program running through June 2020. The bond sale is delayed until at least August 19. Approved unanimously. - Item 13C – Award of Construction Management Contracts to Micro LBE Firms: Staff recommended awarding two $1 million contracts to Dobri, Inc. and Joe Hill Consulting & Engineering Corporation for as-needed construction management services. The solicitation was a micro-LBE set-aside with outreach workshops. Both firms are certified LBEs, with Dobri planning 75% LBE subcontracting and Joe Hill using 100% LBEs. Approved unanimously. - Item 13D – Executive Director Salary: After a performance evaluation, the commission voted to increase Executive Director Elaine Forbes’ salary by 8% (3% COLA plus 5% additional), citing performance, equity, and comparisons with other port directors and city department heads. The salary will be $301,158 initially, with an additional 1% in December 2019. Key Outcomes - Approved: Consent calendar (Item 10A), Red and White Fleet lease (Item 11A, 4-1 vote), Frankie’s Java House lease amendment (Item 11C), authorization to advertise for Mission Bay Ferry Landing CMGC (Item 12A), parks bond issuance (Item 13A), seawall program supplemental appropriation (Item 13B), micro-LBE construction management contracts (Item 13C), and Executive Director salary increase of 8% (Item 13D). - No vote: Informational items on Piers 30-32/Seawall Lot 330 (Item 11B) and Mission Rock Phase 1 (Item 11D). Staff will return with community input and RFP proposals. - New Business: Commissioners requested a report on the Giants' LBE contracting for Mission Rock and a presentation from OEWD on the city build program to address barriers for LBEs in maritime construction.
The Port Commission convened on June 11, 2019, to hear public testimony, receive informational presentations on rental rates and the Mission Bay Ferry Landing, and approve an interim ferry landing agreement. The meeting featured extensive public support for the Teatro Zanzani project and updates on port operations and infrastructure. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers voiced strong support for the Teatro Zanzani project, a circus and theater that was displaced during the America's Cup. Speakers included representatives from the San Francisco Electrical Construction Industry, IBW Local 6, and the San Francisco Electrical Contractor Association, who highlighted union job creation during construction and operation. A working theater artist and former resident costume designer for Teatro Zanzani urged its return, noting the loss of artistic opportunities. A performer and opera singer recounted the unique experience of the Spiegel tent and the project's potential to fill a gap left by the closing of Beach Blanket Babylon. Marvin Cassoff, founder of Renew SF, cited a promise of first crack at a new location when displaced and called the project a much better use of the waterfront corner than a parking lot. Timothy Reif of Carpenters Local 22 praised the project for bringing a theater, hotel, and park. Annie Jameson of Teatro Zanzani thanked the commission and noted daily requests to bring back the show, estimating over 100 jobs (kitchen, theater, administrative). John Corso of Plumbers Local 38 supported the project for jobs. John Stewart, a neighbor and developer of 88 Broadway (178 units, including affordable housing at 30% AMI and 120% AMI), supported the project and noted cooperative utility coordination. Discussion Items - Item 10A – Informational Presentation on Primary Rental Schedule: Staff presented the annual update on parameter rents, which cover 387 tenants and 583 leases across 22.7 million square feet. Parameter rents represent 61% of base rent revenue (20% of total revenue including participation rents). In FY2019, 47 parameter leases were executed, generating $3.1 million annualized from nearly 1 million square feet. The average asking rate increased from $1.81 to $1.91/sq ft. Proposed rate increases affect 32 of 75 rates, with office rates rising to reflect low vacancy (5.8% port-wide) and market demand. A pilot fee waiver program for nonprofits with under $2 million annual revenue and San Francisco location was introduced. Commissioners asked about benchmarking against market rents (staff indicated rates are at 90th–100th percentile for Class C space due to location), and queried unchanged rates for sheds with higher vacancy. Commissioner Gilman suggested an edit requiring the nonprofit's major activities to be in San Francisco. - Item 11A – Mission Bay Ferry Landing Update: Staff presented the $45.7 million project to build a permanent two-berth ferry landing at the foot of 16th Street, designed to serve 6,000 daily passengers (1,500 commuters, up to 2,100 for events). The project includes dredging of 8 acres (2 acres with contaminated sediment requiring a cap), a translucent canopy, and sea level rise provisions. Funding sources include $38.7 million (including $8 million from OCI bonds that must be spent by August 2020) plus additional from RM3, private contributions, and the city general fund. Litigation by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association challenges the RM3 toll increase as a tax; an appeal is possible. Staff warned that delays in the in-water work window (June 1–November 30) could cost $1.2–$2 million in escalation and forfeit the OCI funds. Commissioners expressed support and asked about cost breakdown (ferry landing itself $21.5 million) and the potential for floating piers in future projects. - Item 12A – Action: Interim Ferry Landing at Pier 48½: The commission approved a memorandum of understanding with WETA and Golden Gate Ferry for a temporary ferry landing to serve Chase Center events until the permanent Mission Bay Ferry Landing opens in 2021. The interim landing will be operational by October 5, 2019 (first Warriors-Lakers game). The port will contribute staff time but no cash; rent and landing fees are waived. Construction costs will be covered by WETA with reimbursement from Golden Gate Ferry and the Golden State Warriors. The site will have a short walk (0.4 miles) to Chase Center. The lease expires when the permanent facility is operational. Commissioners noted the site is makeshift and not to permanent standards. The motion passed unanimously (Resolution 1923). Key Outcomes - Approved: Resolution 1923 authorizing the port to enter into an MOU and short-term lease with WETA and Golden Gate Ferry for the interim ferry landing at Pier 48½, with zero rent and port staff contribution. - Directive: Commissioner Macris requested a written report on management issues at Fisherman’s Wharf regarding boot trucks and permitting. - Informational: Staff will incorporate feedback on the fee waiver pilot program (nonprofit location requirement) for the July vote on rental rates. - Next Steps: For the Mission Bay Ferry Landing, staff will seek authorization to advertise for Construction Manager General Contractor (CMGC) contracting in July, continue permitting, and return for funding actions in early fall. The interim ferry landing construction bids will close June 28, 2019.
The Port Commission held a regular meeting on Tuesday, May 28, 2019, to discuss an ethics training presentation, approve a mitigated negative declaration for the Far Boat Headquarters project, consider a lease renewal for Red and White Fleet, and address other routine matters. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Adoption of the final mitigated negative declaration and mitigation/improvement measures for the Far Boat Headquarters project at Pier 22½ on Embarcadero at Harrison Street, pursuant to CEQA, and approval of the related project. The consent calendar was adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - On the Red and White Fleet lease (Item 11A): A member of the public expressed strong support for renewing the lease for Red and White Fleet, noting their long history and importance to the waterfront. The speaker also mentioned a personal connection (met spouse on their boat 28 years ago) and urged the commission to move the lease renewal forward quickly to provide security for the business. - General: No additional public comments were made on other agenda items. Discussion Items - Ethics Training Presentation (Item 9B): The City Attorney’s office delivered an informational presentation on conflict of interest rules, gift limitations, and political fundraising restrictions applicable to commissioners. Topics included recusal requirements when a commissioner's spouse or partner works for a grant-seeking nonprofit, gift scenario rules (e.g., business lunches, event tickets), prohibitions on political activity on city property, and new rules against fundraising for appointing authorities. Commissioners asked clarifying questions about informal negotiations with developers and the need for a shared commission policy on such communications. - Red and White Fleet Lease Renewal (Item 11A): Staff presented draft lease terms for a 40-year renewal for Red and White Fleet at Pier 43½, including tenant improvements tied to PG&E remediation. President Joe Bergard of Red and White Fleet expressed gratitude for staff cooperation and highlighted the project's benefits for revenue and visitor experience. Commissioner Gallman asked whether the parcel had ever gone to competitive bid; staff stated the lease had been continuously renewed for over 40 years and that the relationship had been good. No formal action was taken on the lease at this meeting. Key Outcomes - The consent calendar (Item 10A) was approved unanimously. - The ethics training presentation was received as information; no formal action required. - No vote was taken on the Red and White Fleet lease renewal; further discussion will occur at a future meeting. - The meeting adjourned at 5:50 p.m.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on May 14, 2019, at 3:00 PM. The meeting included approval of prior minutes, a closed executive session, reports from the Executive Director, consent calendar approvals, a presentation on the new Fire Boat Station 35, approval of real estate economics contracts, and an update on the Waterfront Plan amendments coupled with a dedication resolution. Consent Calendar - Item 9A: Approved amending the Port’s Harbor Traffic Code to allow parking and curb restrictions on port streets in Mission Bay east of Third Street to accommodate events at the Chase Center. Resolution 1917. - Item 9B: Approved a month-to-month consent to sublease between Blue and Gold Fleet, L.P. and Open Top Sightseeing San Francisco, LLC for a ticket booth and office at Pier 41. Resolution 1918. Public Comments & Testimony - On Executive Director’s Report: A representative from the Carpenters Union expressed support for the Teatro Zanzani project, noting the developer agreed to use a signatory union general contractor. Diana Taylor, president of the Barbary Coast Neighborhood Association, stated support for the project. Jay Wallace, project manager for TZK Broadway, reported progress and thanked staff. Cynthia Gomez of Unite Here Local 2 supported the project, citing a neutral union organizing process for the future hotel. - On Item 12A (Waterfront Plan): Alice Rogers and Ellen Jonk (co-chair of Maritime Commerce Advisory Committee) praised the staff’s work on the Waterfront Plan update and endorsed the dedication of the Pier 52 boat launch to Corinne Woods. Discussion Items - Item 10A – Informational: Fire Boat Station 35 Project and MOU: Staff presented a new 50-year memorandum of understanding between the Port and the San Francisco Fire Department for a floating fire station at Pier 22.5. The $35 million project, funded by the 2014 Earthquake Safety Bond, will replace dilapidated piers and provide a 14,500 sq. ft. station on a steel float. Rent under the MOU would be approximately $14,000 per month, with credits for improvements. Construction is expected from July 2019 to end of 2020. Commissioners expressed support; a formal action item will come at a future meeting. - Item 11A – Real Estate Economics Contracts: Staff recommended awarding four “as needed” real estate economics contracts (each up to $750,000 for four years plus one-year option) to BAE Urban Economics, Economic and Planning Systems, Kaiser Marston Associates, and CIFL Consulting. Discussion centered on the LBE subcontracting goal of 13%, down from 20% in the prior contract, due to a narrowed scope focusing on real estate economics. Commissioners Wuho and Macris questioned the lower goal and asked staff to explore increasing LBE participation. The item was approved (Resolution 1919). - Item 12A – Waterfront Plan Update & Dedication: Diane Oshima presented the draft amendments to the Waterfront Plan, which incorporates 161 working group recommendations into nine port-wide goals. The plan is expected to be released in early June 2019 for public review. A separate resolution dedicated the Pier 52 public boat launch in memory of working group member Corinne Woods. Commissioners commended the staff and working group; the resolution passed unanimously (Resolution 1920). Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 1917 and 1918 approved unanimously. - Executive Session: Held to discuss real property negotiations; no report of actions taken was made in open session. - Fire Station 35 MOU: Informational only; will return for action at a subsequent meeting. - Real Estate Economics Contracts: Approved with Resolution 1919; staff to report on LBE performance and explore increased participation. - Waterfront Plan and Dedication: Resolution 1920 approved; draft amendments to be released for public comment in June 2019. - Meeting Adjourned: At 4:45 PM.