The San Francisco Police Commission met on June 4, 2025, at 2:00 PM to discuss a range of topics including a farewell to outgoing Chief William Scott, acceptance of two significant donations from the San Francisco Police Community Foundation and Ripple Labs, officer recognition, and updates on crime trends and department activities. All votes were unanimous (6-0) with Commissioners Scott, Leoung, Clay, Benedicto, Yee, and President Elias present. Consent Calendar - Item 5: Received and filed the SFPD and DPA document protocol report for Q1 2025 and the Q1 2025 audit of electronic communication devices for bias. Approved unanimously. - Item 6: Adopted the minutes from the meetings of May 14 and May 21, 2025. Approved unanimously. Officer Recognition & PAL Cadet Presentation - Item 1: Officers Edward Ochoa (soon-to-be Sergeant) and Michael Ellis from major crimes were recognized as Officers of the Week for solving a series of homicides from over 20 years ago, resulting in two arrests for four homicides. Commissioners and the public praised their work, with Commissioner Scott, a mother of a homicide victim, expressing hope for other unsolved cases. - Item 3: The San Francisco Police Activities League (PAL) presented medals to approximately 30 cadets who participated in the annual Kids' Games on May 4, 2025, serving 700 children. Commissioners thanked the program for its long-standing community engagement. Farewell to Chief William Scott - Commissioners delivered heartfelt speeches thanking Chief Scott for his nearly decade of service, noting crime reduction to historic lows, completion of reforms, and improved community relations. Chief Scott received a plaque and challenge coins, expressing gratitude to the commission, staff, and community. Public comment included praise from the Chinese Consolidated Benevolent Association, mothers of homicide victims, and others. Some speakers raised concerns about surveillance technology and accountability. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): Speakers included Chris Workline (active duty Marine), who alleged misuse of public safety systems and referenced an FBI report; a speaker opposing 5G towers; and mothers of homicide victims urging continued support for cold cases. A representative from the Chinese community thanked Chief Scott for his support. - Item 10 & 11 Public Comment: No public comment was made on the donation items. - Item 13: No public comment on closed session matters. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Item 7): Chief Scott reported that overall Part I crime is down 27% (4,200 fewer crimes) compared to last year, with property crime down 29% and violent crime down 18%. Homicides decreased 23% (from 13 to 10 year-to-date), and the clearance rate is approximately 150% due to solving cold cases. Car burglaries are down 47% from last year. The Chief also updated on unsolved homicide family meetings, noting that the cold case unit (1 sergeant, 5 investigators) now maintains better contact with families. Commissioner Scott requested biannual meetings for families. - DPA Director’s Report (Item 8): Executive Director Paul Henderson reported 50 new cases in the past two weeks, with year-to-date case input significantly higher than last year. Top allegations are conduct unbecoming. Two cases are over 270 days but under 300 days. The use-of-force audit is ongoing, and the controller’s office is following up on 31 recommendations from DPA’s 2023 audit. - Donation for Real Time Investigation Center (Item 10): The commission discussed and approved acceptance of $9,381,571 in gifts from the San Francisco Police Community Foundation ($7.3 million) and Ripple Labs ($2.1 million in-kind lease for office space) to support the Real Time Investigation Center (RTIC). Funds will purchase 12 drone docks, 12 drones, software, and services. The lease expires December 2026; the department is seeking a permanent location. The drones will expand the Drone as First Responder (DFR) program citywide, with 58 trained pilots. The department retains control of footage, which is retained for 30 days unless part of an ongoing investigation. A policy will be brought to the commission. Approved unanimously. - Donation for District Stations (Item 11): The commission approved a $866,500 donation from the San Francisco Police Community Foundation to be distributed to the 10 district stations for officer wellness and community engagement events (e.g., National Night Out, Crime Victims’ Rights Week). The foundation will disclose donors over $100. Approved unanimously. - Revised Department General Order 6.07 “Dog Complaints” (Item 12): The commission adopted the revised order. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Votes: All agenda items requiring action passed unanimously (6-0). - Next Steps: The department will proceed with the Board of Supervisors to approve the donations. The RTIC move is expected by fall 2025. The commission will hold officer elections at the next meeting (June 11, 2025). - Closed Session (Item 15): The commission voted to go into closed session and later voted not to disclose any discussion. No further details were provided.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaOn June 4, 2025, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a hearing to discuss the Controller's Nine-Month Budget Status Report for Fiscal Year 2024–2025. The committee heard a presentation from the Controller's Office detailing a net revenue shortfall, department savings, and looming risks from federal funding cuts, followed by extensive public testimony from city workers and union representatives opposing proposed layoffs and service reductions. The hearing was heard and filed on a unanimous vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Michelle Daniels (DPH health worker) opposed elimination of the Community Wellness Center program in the Southeast Quadrant, noting decades of services being withdrawn from underserved communities. - Felicia Jones (SEIU 1021) criticized the mayor's "slush funds" and alleged that the mayor is prioritizing jail over recovery, and called for fair treatment of workers. - Bianca Polavina (IFPTE Local 21 president) stated that the mayor's layoffs are a policy choice, not a necessity, and urged the board to protect public services. - Kristen Hardy (SEIU 1021 regional VP) pointed to $5 billion in outside contracts and corporate tax lawsuits (e.g., Airbnb) as a way to avoid cuts, and said the mayor has not used his influence to stop those lawsuits. - Ocean Ashworth (IBEW Local Six) argued layoffs are a choice, not a necessity, and that reductions lead to higher overtime or contractor costs. - Judy Sorrel (CityBuild program, 19-year employee) said she received a layoff notice and that cutting CityBuild would harm formerly incarcerated and underserved workers' access to construction trades. - Jennifer Asteen (DPH registered nurse, 15 years) called for making corporations like Airbnb pay their fair share, and criticized the mayor's donor relationships. - Chiara Herman (PUC, Local 21) said private contractors cost more and are less accountable than city workers. - Nicole Termany Germain (SEIU 1021 vice president, 32-year library employee) urged restoring all laid-off workers, stating "Labor is united on no layoffs." - Moses Corret (Planning Department, 25 years) noted he expects a layoff notice and that the planning department's reliance on fee revenue is short-sighted. - Lily Morales (OEWD, 13 years) said she received a layoff notice and serves underrepresented communities. - AJ Thomas (OEWD, Retirement Board president) warned that gutting the CityBuild compliance team would prevent enforcement of local hire programs. - Vincente Cordero (DPH, Local 21) argued against defunding programs while allowing corporate tax avoidance and increasing police budget. - Brenda Barros (45-year SF General employee) said the mayor's budget does not address racial discrimination and that black workers will be hit hardest. - Sarah Jarman (DPH, Trauma Informed Systems) said her program is slated for elimination, undermining DPH's commitment to a healthy workforce. - Matthew McIntyre (ARC, job coach) warned that Muni service cuts harm disabled clients and that food assistance cuts affect food insecurity. - John Thorne (DPH, Local 21) said layoffs tear apart teams, departments, and communities. - Aisha Brown (District 10 resident) opposed cutting the Community Wellness Program at Hope SF, which provides health education and mental health services in low-income communities. - Jude Dybel (Human Rights Commission, SEIU shop steward) said the mayor's cuts to HRC and Status of Women are Trump-like and will harm efforts to keep people housed. - Aaron Backis (EMS, Local 21, 19-year employee) highlighted his role in COVID-19 vaccine distribution and warned that layoffs would harm public health capacity. - Maggie Loush (Planning Department, Local 21) said the mayor asked staff to do more but then cuts colleagues. - Gabriela Casellos (Soda Tax Advisory Committee) said the mayor is ignoring the committee's recommendations and taking money from children's dental health. - Dylan Hamilton (Planning Department) said the budget will hurt low-income communities of color, and the mayor has not pressured Airbnb to drop their lawsuit. - Tammy Bryant (Human Services Agency) said layoffs increase caseloads for remaining staff and harm timely services; she opposed increasing police overtime when crime is down. - Rhett Peacock (Treasury & Tax Collector, SEIU 1021) said cutting the tax collector's office is counterproductive as it brings in revenue. - Luna Vargas (SF General ARF) said the mayor's budget threatens to displace 83 residents and called for more services for severe mental illness. - Miguel Carrera (Coalition of Homeless) said the mayor is taking money from Prop-funded homeless services, leading to more homelessness. - Ruben (social worker, SEIU 1021) asked the mayor and supervisors to have a heart and backbone. - Speaker (name not given) noted the city is hiring 500 police at $167k salary while cutting basic services. - Anna Roche (SFPUC, Local 21, 25 years) called layoffs a betrayal of progressive values and said they cost more in the long run. - Rudy Gonzalez (SF Building Trades secretary-treasurer) said the cuts to CityBuild and local hire programs will harm economic recovery and increase recidivism. - Jeff Spears (Planning Department, 12 years) urged the board not to become the new "DOGE" and to support workers. - Will McCallum (Planning Department, Local 21) said overdose deaths have increased 50% since the mayor took office, and that police overtime is a waste. - Joyce Wong (CityBuild compliance manager, 15 years) said she received a layoff notice and asked the board to remember the 1,700 people who graduated from CityBuild. - Regina East Loss (ACLU, District 1) called for no SFPD overtime, full spending of Prop I affordable housing funds, and no further Muni cuts. - Heather Samuels (Planning Department) said the mayor called the planning department a solution, but cutting staff prevents them from doing their job. - Renee Scott (SEIU 1021) opposed power washing and said the mayor's budget is wasteful. - Sylvester (PUC engineer, Local 21) said a trust fund baby bought his way into City Hall and is destroying it. - Courtney Schreiner Lee (Police Department, Local 21) said her policy analyst position is the only civilian policy writer and its loss would risk returning to fragmented policies. - Queen Vanessa (Hunters Point native) called the mayor a plutocrat and urged him to read Supervisor Walton's book. - Lorna Gainer (city employee, 11 years) said layoffs lead to people hurting themselves and living on the street. Discussion Items - Controller's Office Presentation (Michelle Ellersmith): Presented the nine-month budget status report showing a net revenue shortfall of $32.7 million (unchanged from March), a $145 million net operating surplus largely from DPH patient revenue and departmental savings. Noted weaknesses in hotel tax, sales tax, and property tax due to assessment appeals, offset by stronger business tax and transfer tax recovery. Assumes no changes to federal funding including $87 million in FEMA reimbursements. Reserves: $400 million in the mayor's proposed budget (from federal/state emergency grant disallowance reserve, fiscal cliff reserve, and abandoned accounts) to address potential federal/state funding cuts. - Supervisor Walton: Questioned the FEMA risk, noting a 90% disallowance on non-congregate shelter costs ($400 million claimed, $148 million received, potentially $140 million clawback). Asked about the remaining $260 million expected reimbursement. Requested a walk-through of reserves and general fund baselines and set-asides. Later stated that DPH's cuts to Hope SF are despicable, that layoffs are not necessary when resources exist, and that the city should not cut workers while corporations owe hundreds of millions. - Supervisor Chan: Acknowledged the difficulty of the budget process, thanked city workers, and expressed commitment to protecting workers and sanctuary values. Noted that one job loss is too many. - President Mandelman: Thanked workers and nonprofit partners, acknowledged the mayor's budget contains tough choices, and said the board will engage seriously with those choices over the next 20 days. Noted that the mayor may have already done the easy cuts, making policy choices more difficult. - Supervisor Dorsey: Shared his own history as a city employee, expressed uncertainty due to federal actions, but committed to honoring city workers' service and avoiding layoffs where possible. - Supervisor Engardio: Expressed confidence in the committee's experience, stated his philosophy that investing in city workers saves money in the long run. Key Outcomes - The committee unanimously voted (5-0) to hear and file the hearing on the Controller's Nine-Month Budget Status Report. No amendments or further actions were taken. - The hearing served as an early step in the budget process, with supervisors indicating they will work to find alternatives to the mayor's proposed layoffs and service cuts, though no specific commitments were made. - The committee acknowledged the uncertainty from federal funding cuts (especially FEMA and Medicaid) and the high volume of assessment appeals affecting property tax revenue.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on June 3, 2025, at 10:15 AM, with all 11 members present. The meeting began with a land acknowledgment, pledge of allegiance, and approval of previous meeting minutes. The agenda included consent calendar items, new business (ordinances and resolutions), committee reports, special orders (commendations), roll call for introductions, and public comment. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Consent Calendar - Items 1-8 were approved unanimously. Supervisor Cheryl added as a co-sponsor on Item 3 (purchase of fire apparatus). Items included appropriations, settlements, and administrative code changes. Special Order 2:30 PM - Recognition of Commendations - Chief Bill Scott (outgoing SFPD Chief) was honored for his eight years of service, highlighting a 42% crime drop (2017-2024), 97% compliance with DOJ recommendations, and leadership during crises. Supervisors from all districts spoke in appreciation. - Captain Liza Johansson (SFPD Mission Station) was recognized for community engagement, including installing air conditioning at the station and fostering trust in a diverse district. - Michael Wong (Community Youth Center) was commended for 30 years of victim services, co-founding the Coalition for Community Safety and Justice, and leading 165 safety workshops reaching 34,000 people in 2024. - Robert (retiring SFPL librarian) was honored for 41 years of service, including launching technology programs and a 26-year poetry reading series. - The Check-in Lounge (District 11 LGBTQ-owned business) was recognized for creating community space during the pandemic. Discussion Items - Items 9-10 (Certificates of Participation) : Authorized refunding and appropriation of $379 million for capital projects. Passed without objection. - Item 11 (Assessment Appeals Board Fees) : Increased fees. Passed without objection. - Item 12 (Farmers’ Market Fees) : Increased fees. Passed without objection. - Item 13 (Fire Department Ambulance Revenue) : Appropriated $7.9 million, with de-appropriations and overtime adjustments. Required 2/3 vote; passed without objection. - Item 14 (CalAIM Grant) : Retroactively authorized $1.5 million grant from CA Dept. of Health Care Services. Passed without objection. - Item 15 (Airport Contract) : Approved $40 million modification with T.Y. Lin International. Passed without objection. - Items 16-18 (Homelessness Dept. Agreements) : Approved amendments for Episcopal Community Services ($72.3M), Five Keys Schools ($59.2M), and assignment of 1321 Mission Street. Passed without objection. - Item 19 (Chinatown SRO Grant) : Increased grant to $6.78 million for 1005 Powell Street. Passed without objection. - Item 20 (Revenue Obligations for CIIS) : Approved $15 million for California Institute of Integral Studies. Passed without objection. - Item 21 (BLA Cost of Living Adjustment) : Approved 4.5% increase, new contract amount $3.4 million. Passed without objection. - Items 22-23 (Downtown Revitalization District) : Supervisor Dorsey introduced an amendment to Item 23 to add reimbursement language for city departments. Amendment adopted; both items passed without objection. - Item 24 (Port Lease Waiver for CAST at Large LLC) : Waived contracting requirements for Pier 29 improvements. Passed without objection. - Items 25-26 (Dr. Amos C. Brown Street Name) : Resolutions to rename Pierce Street to "Dr. Amos C. Brown Way." Roll call vote: 11-0. - Item 27 (Priority Conservation Areas) : Authorized planning department to apply for revised designations. Passed without objection. - Item 28 (Port Commission Appointment) : Ken McNeely appointment approved as amended. Passed without objection. - Item 31 (Opposing Medi-Cal Cuts) : Resolution opposing state cuts to Medi-Cal for undocumented adults. Adopted unanimously. - Item 32 (Gun Violence Awareness Day) : Resolution recognizing June 6, 2025 as National Gun Violence Awareness Day. Adopted unanimously. Roll Call for Introductions - Supervisor Mandelman : Introduced legislation and requested adjournment in memory of Steve Kellerman. - Supervisor Melgar : Introduced legislation to eliminate hard caps on storefront sizes and remove conditional use requirements for subdivided spaces. Also announced a hold on zoo funding pending audit cooperation. - Supervisor Chen : Introduced resolution urging restoration of acupuncture benefits under Medi-Cal; submitted a letter of inquiry to Planning Department for a public modeling tool for housing element rezoning. - Supervisor Dorsey : Requested adjournment in memory of Sharon Arduin, former City Attorney’s Office staff. - Supervisor Mahmoud : Requested adjournment in memory of Captain Julio Dominic DeLucci (SFFD). Fire Chief Crispin offered remarks. - Supervisor Sherrill : Introduced resolution on gun violence awareness; introduced resolution urging SFPD and DEM to classify drug activity near parks/schools as Priority A emergencies; requested adjournment in memory of William Joseph Heap. Public Comments & Testimony - Glide Center for Social Justice (multiple speakers): Urged restoration of soda tax funded programs, citing the Social Justice Academy as essential for marginalized communities. - Mission Athletic Club (multiple speakers): Opposed proposed $5/hour tennis court reservation fee, arguing it would create barriers for low-income players and that free courts foster community. - Chris Gordklein (Marine Corps): Claimed the city is eligible for $5 billion in federal funds and urged the board to rework the budget. - Solar industry representative (John Paolo Pignani): Criticized city permitting hurdles for solar and battery installations, urging investigation. - Others spoke on gun violence prevention, opposing Medi-Cal cuts, and communications with notable citizens. Key Outcomes - All consent and regular agenda items were passed, generally without objection or with unanimous roll call votes. - Commendations were presented to Chief Bill Scott, Captain Liza Johansson, Michael Wong, Robert (librarian), and The Check-in Lounge. - Legislation introduced will be referred to appropriate committees. - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Steve Kellerman, William Joseph Heap, Sharon Arduin, and Captain Julio Dominic DeLucci.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on June 2, 2025, at 6:15 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Shimon Walton, with Vice Chair Cheryl and President Mandelman. The committee considered five mayoral appointments and an ordinance to create multiple entertainment zones. Four appointments were approved for recommendation to the full board; the entertainment zone ordinance was amended to add two new zones and continued to June 9, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - A public speaker (not identified by name) criticized the entertainment zone ordinance, arguing that homeless residents are not welcome under city policies and drew historical parallels to Nazi-era laws. The speaker urged the board to avoid stereotyping homeless people, cited racial disparities in homelessness (36% of homeless are Black while 7% of the population), and called for solution-based reporting. - A representative of the Hayes Valley Neighborhood Association (name not given) expressed strong support for adding a Hayes Valley Entertainment Zone, noting that the neighborhood already hosts free events (tango, jazz, yard games) and that 14 local merchants have provided written support. He stated the zone would help events like the Hayes Valley Carnival and neighborhood wine walks. Discussion Items Appointments - Item 1 – Sunshine Ordinance Task Force: Bruce Wolfe, reapplying for a seat reserved for a person with a disability (term ending April 27, 2027). He highlighted his long tenure (since 2005), chair experience, and commitment to government transparency. No public comment. Motion to recommend to full board passed unanimously. - Item 2 – Sanitation and Streets Commission: Stuart Parmenter, nominated for a term ending July 1, 2028. He described his 26-year technology career, including as CTO at One Medical, and his desire to improve street cleanliness proactively. Public speakers (Kyle Mun Kittrick and Mark DeVito) praised his ability to trust frontline workers, analyze data, and persist. Approved unanimously. - Item 3 – Port Commission: Ken McNeely, nominated for a term ending May 1, 2029. He summarized his 33-year AT&T career, $3 billion in fiber investment, board service at Sutter Health and SF arts organizations, and focus on equity and Southern Waterfront. No public comment. Approved unanimously. - Item 4 – Historic Preservation Commission (Reappointment): Chris Foley, term ending December 31, 2028. He emphasized common sense in preservation, citing his renovation of St. Joseph’s Church. President Mandelman expressed concern that the city is not moving quickly enough to identify historic resources amid upzoning, noting the recent Sunset District survey. Foley noted staffing and budget constraints but said the commission can act quickly if resources are provided. No public comment. Approved unanimously. - Item 5 – Historic Preservation Commission (Reappointment): Diane Matsuda, term ending December 31, 2028. She highlighted the city survey, historic context statements (African American, Chinese, American Indian), and the legacy business registry. Mandelman pressed for a completion date for the city survey; Matsuda estimated two more years, citing manpower needs. She agreed that landmarking must go beyond “pretty” buildings to include cultural significance. No public comment. Approved unanimously. Ordinance – Entertainment Zones (Item 6) - Supervisor Mahmood joined to present an amendment to add a Hayes Valley Entertainment Zone to the existing ordinance (which already included Valencia, Pier 39, Folsom, Ellis, and Yerba Buena Lane). He described Hayes Valley as ideal for community events and noted support from merchants, the neighborhood association, and SFPD. Chair Walton also announced an amendment to add a Bayview Entertainment Zone (Yosemite Avenue and Lane Street). The committee voted to amend the duplicated file to include both new zones. - After public comment, the committee voted to continue the ordinance to the next Rules Committee meeting on June 9, 2025, due to the amendments. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved to recommend Bruce Wolfe to the full board (unanimous). - Item 2: Approved to recommend Stuart Parmenter (unanimous). - Item 3: Approved to recommend Ken McNeely as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 4: Approved to recommend Chris Foley’s reappointment (unanimous). - Item 5: Approved to recommend Diane Matsuda’s reappointment (unanimous). - Item 6: Amended to add Hayes Valley and Bayview Entertainment Zones; continued to June 9, 2025 (unanimous).
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 2, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmud. The committee considered three agenda items: a planning code amendment for health service uses, a resolution to apply for Priority Conservation Area designations, and two resolutions for a commemorative and permanent street name change honoring Dr. Amos C. Brown. Public Comments & Testimony - On item 2 (Priority Conservation Areas), I. Bogan (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) thanked the chair and Supervisor Goldberg for amending the legislation to include Sunset Boulevard. - On items 3 and 4 (Street renaming), multiple speakers testified in support: - Anthony Wagner, deacon at Third Baptist Church, proposed the street renaming and thanked Supervisor Mahmoud. - Rev. Devin Crawford, executive pastor, expressed full support, describing Dr. Brown's legacy. - Dr. Amos C. Brown spoke, acknowledging the honor and his commitment to justice. - Public commenters shared personal stories of Dr. Brown's impact, including one speaker who noted his role in housing a young woman and another who highlighted his work in the community. Discussion Items - Item 1: Planning Code Amendment (File 250099) – The committee previously heard and amended this ordinance to eliminate retail use size limits on health service uses and reproductive health clinics in the MUO district east of 7th Street. No further discussion; the committee voted to forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Priority Conservation Areas (File 250526) – Jeremy Shaw of the Planning Department presented the resolution to apply for new and revised PCA designations. He explained the benefits, including eligibility for regional grants, and noted that the designation does not change land use controls. The committee discussed the timeline and the need to meet the June 13 deadline. Chair Melgar proposed an amendment to include Sunset Boulevard as a new PCA, which was adopted. - Items 3 and 4: Street Name Change – Dr. Amos C. Brown Way (Files 250523 and 250524) – Supervisor Mahmoud introduced the resolutions. Item 3 is a resolution of intention to begin the permanent renaming process; Item 4 is a commemorative street name designation. Speakers from Third Baptist Church and community members testified in support. Dr. Brown addressed the committee, sharing his personal history and vision for the street. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (3 ayes). - Item 2: Motion to adopt the amendment adding Sunset Boulevard to the PCA nominations and to send the amended resolution as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors passed unanimously (3 ayes). The item is scheduled for consideration on June 3, 2025. - Items 3 and 4: Motions to send both resolutions as committee reports to the Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations passed unanimously (3 ayes). The items are scheduled for consideration on June 3, 2025.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on Tuesday, May 27, 2025, at 9:30 AM. The meeting included a disclosure training for commissioners, a quarterly budget status report, approval of a consent calendar, authorization of a major bond issuance up to $1.53 billion, approval of a contract increase for the Moccasin Powerhouse generator rehabilitation, and closed session discussions. All votes were unanimous. Consent Calendar - Item 6a: Awarded four Master As-Needed HVAC and Mechanical Services contracts (PW-012.A, B, C, D), each with a not-to-exceed amount of $4,500,000 and a five-year duration. - Item 6b: Approved Modification No. 1 to Job Order Contract No. JOC-99 with Marinship Development Interest LLC, increasing the contract amount by $2,500,000. - Item 6c: Approved Modification No. 1 to Job Order Contract No. JOC-103 with Cal State Constructors, Inc. for general engineering construction in multiple counties. - Item 6d: Approved and adopted the General Manager’s finding that ABB Medium Voltage Variable-Frequency Drives are necessary to match existing products at SFPUC Wastewater Enterprise facilities. - The consent calendar was approved unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Peter Dreckmark (Policy Director, Tuolumne River Trust) spoke during general public comment (Item 4), welcoming new Commissioner Thurlow and reporting that 100 spring-run Chinook salmon had entered the Tuolumne River. He expressed concern about the fish needing cold water through the summer and urged the SFPUC to help find a solution. - During Item 5A (disclosure training), Dreckmark stated he had heard the SFPUC is close to being maxed out on borrowing capacity, noting that debt service alone could reach $1.8 billion by 2047. He criticized the Alternative Water Supply Plan as potentially costly ($17–25 billion) and requested a commission workshop on the topic, citing past productive workshops from 2020–2022. - During Item 7 (bond issuance), Dreckmark accused SFPUC staff of spreading disinformation on demand projections and the design drought, and again requested a workshop on the Alternative Water Supply Plan. He stated that commissioners are not elected and are overly reliant on staff, which he said leads to long-term problems. Discussion Items - Item 5A – Disclosure Training for Commissioners: Presented by disclosure counsel Aaron Pham and Stephen Spitz of Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe. The training covered federal securities law obligations regarding the Preliminary Official Statement (POS) and Final Official Statement (OS) for bond offerings. Commissioners were advised to create a culture of transparency, rely on staff, and focus on material risks they personally know. Commissioner Leveroni asked about past pitfalls in disclosure; the attorneys cited cases where agencies did not acknowledge known problems. The training was followed by public comment. - Item 5B – Quarterly Budget Status Report (Q3 FY2024-25): Presented by Budget Director Anna Dunning. All enterprises (Water, Wastewater, Power, CleanPowerSF) are projecting positive operating results and exceeding financial policy targets. Key points: Water enterprise retail revenues slightly below budget due to lower volumes, offset by higher wholesale sales and interest earnings. Wastewater revenues below budget due to lower volumes and delayed stormwater surcharge collections; 8,600 accounts need to be opened, with 2,600 completed. Power enterprise and CleanPowerSF show surpluses due to lower power purchase prices and demand. The overtime budget transfer to the Board of Supervisors was approved. Commissioner Leveroni asked about the delayed billing issue; Nancy Hum reported that of 8,000 delayed bills from September, most are now resolved, with fewer than 1,000 remaining on estimated bills. The six-month accrual of $6 million from September has been collected. Commissioner Leveroni also asked about uncollected stormwater charges; staff will provide a follow-up on whether charges are retroactive. - Item 7 – Authorization of Bond Issuance: Nicolai Sklarov (Capital Finance Director) presented a request to authorize up to $1.53 billion in Water Revenue Bonds (2025 Sub-Series D and E) to fund water enterprise capital projects and retire commercial paper, plus up to $1.056 billion in Sub-Series F to refund Build America Bonds (BABs). The transaction is a risk mitigation strategy due to potential loss of tax-exempt bond status and sequestration of the 35% federal subsidy for BABs (currently at 33% after sequestration). The BAB refunding could be postponed if market conditions are unfavorable. Commissioner Leveroni asked about the team (same advisors and bond counsel, with JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs as lead underwriters). Commissioner Thurlow asked about interest rate volatility; Sklarov explained that the spread between taxable and tax-exempt rates drives savings, and that decisions on the BAB refunding will be made closer to the pricing date. Commissioner Stacy requested a follow-up report at the June 24 meeting. - Item 8 – Moccasin Powerhouse Generator Rehabilitation Contract Increase: A project manager presented a request to increase cost contingency by $1,600,000 and duration contingency by 331 calendar days for Contract DB-121R2 with General Electric Renewable Energy. The project replaces two hydro generators at the Moccasin Powerhouse (built 1969). During disassembly, a misalignment of 7 thousandths of an inch was found at the lower turbine guide bearing, requiring the collar to be machined off-site. The repaired parts are expected at the end of July 2025, with return to service in November 2025. Commissioner Leveroni noted the generators lasted 44 years (original) and now 5 years for the replacement. Commissioner Thurlow asked about the cause; the project manager attributed it to wear and tear over time. The item was approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Minutes approved: Minutes of May 13, 2025, approved unanimously. - Consent Calendar approved: Items 6a–6d passed unanimously. - Item 7 approved: Authorized the issuance of up to $1.53 billion in Water Revenue Bonds (Sub-Series D and E) and up to $1.056 billion in Sub-Series F to refund Build America Bonds, with delegation to the General Manager to appoint underwriters. The BAB refunding may proceed or be postponed depending on market conditions. A follow-up report is scheduled for the June 24, 2025 meeting. - Item 8 approved: Approved a $1,600,000 increase in cost contingency and 331 calendar days extension for the Moccasin Powerhouse generator rehabilitation contract. - Closed Session: The commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege and entered closed session. Upon returning, the commission reported recommending both settlements discussed in closed session. The commission voted not to disclose the closed session discussion. - Public comment: The commission heard public comments from Peter Dreckmark on multiple items, including requests for a workshop on the Alternative Water Supply Plan.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on May 22, 2025, to consider continuances, approve consent calendar items, hold a public hearing on the SFO Recommended Airport Development Plan (RADP) Draft Environmental Impact Report, and receive an informational presentation on a proposed housing development at 2125 Powell Street. The meeting began with a land acknowledgement and approval of minutes from May 8, 2025. Continuance Calendar - Item 1 (2258 Market Street) – Conditional Use Authorization for a formula retail use (Stretch Lab) was continued to June 5, 2025. - Item 2 (77 Broad Street) – Discretionary Review for a two-story addition was continued indefinitely. - Items 14 and 15a–e (San Francisco Gateway Project) – Certification of Final EIR, adoption of findings, and related actions were continued to June 5, 2025, at the request of the supervisor's office. Public comment: Mark Gleason (Teamsters Joint Council 7) expressed appreciation for the continuance and thanked Supervisor Walton. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (621 Sansome Street) – Conditional Use Authorization for a five-year extension of a temporary public parking lot. - Item 4 (1533 Sloat Boulevard) – Conditional Use Authorization to establish a Planet Fitness (11,842 sq ft) gym with 24-hour operation. - Item 5 (534-536 Pacific Avenue) – Conditional Use Authorization to establish an office use on the ground floor. - Item 6 (750 Gonzalez Drive) – Conditional Use Authorization for a new T-Mobile macro wireless telecommunications facility. All items were approved unanimously (5-0). Commission Matters - Land Acknowledgement – Commissioner Braun recited the acknowledgement of the Ramaytush Ohlone as original inhabitants. - Minutes – Draft minutes for May 8, 2025, were approved unanimously (5-0). Department Matters - Director’s Announcements – None. - Review of Past Events – Aaron Starr reported on the Board of Supervisors' land use committee hearing regarding Supervisor Dorsey’s ordinance on health service uses in the MUO district, and on two appeals for the project at 1310 Higuera Serra Boulevard (San Francisco Golf Course). The appeals were resolved with amendments, and the project was approved by the Board with additional conditions. General Public Comment - Georgia Shutish – Commented on the demolition calculation thresholds for major alterations, arguing that the current warning letter system is insufficient to protect sound existing housing, especially in priority equity geographies. She requested the Commission adjust the demolition calculations under Section 317. - Dave Rhodi (San Francisco policy director for Al Gore's Climate Reality Project) – Expressed frustration that the Gateway Project (Items 14/15) was continued after many people had gathered to speak on it. Regular Calendar – Item 12: SFO Recommended Airport Development Plan (RADP) Draft EIR Staff presented the draft EIR for the RADP, which includes projects such as Boarding Area H, a central hub multimodal facility, and an aircraft maintenance hangar. The draft EIR identifies significant and unavoidable operational air quality impacts. Alternatives analyzed include a no-project alternative, a reduced development alternative, and a boarding area H-only alternative. The public hearing was held to receive comments on the adequacy of the draft EIR. Written comments are accepted until June 2, 2025. Public Comments: - Liz Lopez – Stated that the expansion will induce passenger demand, increase noise and chemical pollution, and negatively impact residents. She urged the Commission not to accept the EIR as is. - Unnamed Speaker – Criticized the DEIR for using outdated standards and failing to reflect modern impacts. Noted that SFO’s noise impacts extend to Palo Alto and Santa Cruz, and that better data analysis is available. - Leo Martin (Bayview Hunters Point, Mothers/Fathers Committee) – Opposed the project, citing existing pollution burdens and high cancer rates in Bayview. He argued that the project would worsen environmental health injustices. Commissioner Comments: - Commissioner Braun acknowledged the significant and unavoidable air quality impacts and looked forward to reviewing responses. - Commissioner Imperial noted the tribal resources mitigation and requested updated traffic data (from 2019/2025) in the final EIR. - Commissioner Moore asked about international standards for noise and emissions, and suggested cumulative impacts from other projects in the area should be considered. Regular Calendar – Item 13: 2125 Powell Street Informational Presentation (SB 423) John Goldman (Goldman Architects) presented a proposal for three large family units (four-bedroom) over a commercial space, replacing an existing fencing club. The project includes a garage, a rear yard, and roof decks. The design respects the neighborhood context. Commissioners praised the project for its detail, context sensitivity, and provision of family housing in North Beach. No public comment was offered. Key Outcomes - Continuances (Items 1, 2, 14, 15a–e) – Approved unanimously (5-0). - Consent Calendar (Items 3–6) – Approved unanimously (5-0). - Minutes – Approved unanimously (5-0). - SFO RADP Draft EIR – Public hearing held; no decision made. Written comments due June 2, 2025; responses to comments expected in fall 2025, followed by certification hearing. - 2125 Powell Street – Informational presentation concluded; no action taken.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chang and joined by Supervisor Joel Engardio and Supervisor Cheyenne Chen (substituting for Vice Chair Matt Dorsey), met on May 21, 2025, to consider fifteen items. The committee heard presentations, accepted public testimony, and voted on contracts, grants, fee adjustments, a downtown revitalization district, and other fiscal matters. Most items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations; one item was continued. Public Comments & Testimony - Downtown Revitalization District (Item 6): Six speakers expressed support. Jim Chapel, a 45-year resident, urged passage, citing successful similar measures in other cities. A resident encouraged more housing to reduce costs. Mark Babson (Emerald Fund) stated the property tax incentive is the "last piece of the puzzle" for conversions. Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) highlighted potential for up to 5,000 new homes. Clerk Angela Calvio raised concerns about administrative costs and requested reimbursement language. - Homelessness and Supportive Housing Grants (Items 10-12): Lauren Hall (DISH SF) shared resident success stories. Steve Good (Five Keys) reported 242 placements into permanent housing and 51 overdose reversals. Chris Calandrillo (ECS) thanked the city and emphasized voluntary case management. Discussion Items 1. Downtown Revitalization and Economic Recovery Financing District (Item 6) Supervisor Engardio presented a resolution of intent to establish a district under AB 2488, allowing commercial-to-residential conversions in downtown, Union Square, Financial District, Civic Center, and eastern SoMa. Jacob Bentleff (OEWD) explained that the district would divert incremental property tax increases (up to 30 years) to projects. Preliminary analysis identified 49 eligible buildings that could yield 4,400 units, generating $15.2 million in annual incremental property tax. The district board must form within 90 days; a financing plan returns to the Board in fall 2025. Discussion included concerns about layering tax districts, short-term revitalization, and administrative costs. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. 2. Assessment Appeals Board Fees (Item 13) Clerk Calvio proposed increasing application filing fees from $60 to $120, doubling hearing fees, and raising written findings fees from $215/hour to $430/hour. Fees were last updated in 2010; even after increases, San Francisco’s fees remain lower than some other counties. The committee approved two amendments: adding "and hearing fees" to the use of filing fee revenue, and inserting "actual" before "expenses" for findings. The amended ordinance was forwarded. 3. Legislative Management System Software Licenses (Item 14) The clerk requested authorization to sell licenses for a new system to other government entities. The controller’s office requested a two-week continuance to finalize fund accounting. The committee voted to continue the item to the June 4, 2025 meeting. 4. Other Routine Approvals and Amendments (Items 1-5, 7-12, 15) These items were presented and approved with minimal discussion or amendments: - Item 1: Airport contract with T.Y. Lin International – increase by $32 million to $40 million, extended to 2029. - Item 2: CIIS bond issuance – up to $15 million for refinancing. - Item 3: CalAIM grant acceptance – $1.5 million for reentry planning. - Item 4: Chinatown SROS grant amendment – $6.78 million corrected to full 15.5-year term. - Item 5: Farmers’ market stall fee increase from $50 to $60 (20%). - Item 7: Overtime appropriations – Fire Department ($7.9 million from ambulance revenue), DEM ($1.5 million), PUC (reduced from $1.04 million to $500,000 as amended). Approved as amended. - Items 8-9: Refunding COPs for Moscone Center – authorization to issue up to $350 million in refunding bonds, appropriating $379 million. - Item 10: ECS grant amendment – $72.3 million for five supportive housing sites (464 units). Amended to correct a citation. - Item 11: Five Keys shelter grant – $59.2 million for Next Door Shelter (334 beds). - Item 12: DISH assignment – transfer of lease from Tides Center to DISH SF. - Item 15: BLA COLA – 4.5% increase, contract extended to 2031. Key Outcomes All votes were unanimous (3-0). The following were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations: Items 1-6, 7 (as amended), 8-9, 10 (as amended), 11, 12, 13 (as amended), and 15. Item 14 was continued to the June 4, 2025 meeting.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on May 21, 2025, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included officer recognition, public comment, a chief's report on crime trends, a DPA director's report, and commission reports. The commission also voted to enter closed session. Consent Calendar - The commission voted unanimously to receive and file the consent calendar items. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 2): - Daniel Reed alleged that the SFPD fabricated evidence used to obtain surveillance orders against him, referencing a person named Katarina connected to the late public defender Jeff Adachi. He requested a meeting with the chief. - Chantil Rose, mother of a murder victim, reported difficulty contacting lead investigator Scott Warnecke and requested updates on her son's case. President Elias offered to follow up. - A mother of an unsolved homicide victim (Arbre Arcasa, murdered August 14, 2006) urged the commission to solve the case, stating that law enforcement knows the perpetrators' names. She thanked Chief Scott for his attentiveness and expressed concern about the next chief. - A recently retired 34-year veteran of the DA's office praised the SFPD for supporting the Bombers youth program in Bayview Hunters Point. Commissioner Liang requested to agendize the program for a future meeting. - Public Comment on Officer Recognition (Item 1): - A member of the public congratulated Acting Sergeant Al Duarte, describing him as caring and supportive. - Public Comment on Chief's Report (Item 4): - The same mother of an unsolved homicide victim again pressed for progress and thanked Chief Scott. - Public Comment on Closed Session (Item 7): - No public comment was offered. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition (Item 1): - Acting Sergeant Al Duarte was honored for his behind-the-scenes work in the Chief's Office, including managing partnerships, events, and liaison duties. Chief Scott, President Elias, and Commissioners Yee, Benedicto, Clay, Leung, and Yi all praised his dedication and family sacrifices. Al Duarte thanked his family and team. - Chief's Report (Item 4): - Chief Scott reported crime trends: total Part 1 crimes down 3,883 (27% from last year), property crimes at 8,776 (down from 12,362), violent crimes at 1,508 (down 297). Homicides at 9 vs. 12 last year (25% reduction). Gun violence victims at 46 vs. 47. Firearm seizures at 377 vs. 460; ghost guns up to 41 from 40. The homicide clearance rate is 122% year-to-date. - Significant arrests included a stabbing at Trader Joe's (suspect pointed gun, arrested), a stabbing in Mission (suspect in custody), and an attempted robbery where four juveniles were arrested. Two stabbings remain under investigation. - A DUI collision on May 17 involved SFPD officer Ryan Quang, who had just graduated from the academy. Quang was arrested for DUI causing injuries and is no longer a member of the department. Chief Scott expressed condolences and affirmed accountability. - DPA Director's Report (Item 5): - Executive Director Henderson reported the use of force audit is underway (May 2024 – March 2025). DPA opened 8 new cases and closed 27. Top allegations: neglect of duty. Three cases past 270 days; two are being drafted and not sustained. 94 sustained DPA cases pending with the Chief, 2 pending with the commission. No closed session items. - Commission Reports (Item 6): - President Elias reported attending a 32-cadet police academy graduation and announced the formation of a chief search subcommittee (Elias, Benedicto, Leung) to work with DHR. The full commission will review applications and interview candidates, with public input sought. - Commissioner Benedicto visited the Real-Time Information Center (RTIC) at the Hall of Justice, noting its technology and drone operations. He also met with community groups on district boundary analysis, with maps expected for a commission vote in June. - Commissioner Yee noted AAPI Heritage Month and mental health awareness, thanking the chief for expanding Behavioral Science Unit resources. - Vote to Enter Closed Session (Item 8): - The commission voted unanimously to hold Item 9 in closed session. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Consent Calendar: Approved 5-0. - Closed Session motion: Approved 5-0. - Vote not to disclose closed session discussion (Item 10): Motion passed not to disclose except nonprivileged factual information on items 9A and 9B, which will be in the minutes. - Next Steps: - The chief search subcommittee will begin work with DHR. - District boundary analysis maps to be presented for commission vote in June. - The unsolved homicide report (Item 4 bullet) was removed from the agenda and will be reagendized. - The Bombers youth program will be agendized for a future meeting.
On Wednesday, May 21, 2025, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee held a hearing to assess the implementation of Ordinance 116-24 (language access amendments), review the 2025 Language Access Compliance Summary Report, discuss a Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) report on language access costs, and receive public feedback. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and including Supervisors Joe Ingardio, Shaman Walton, and Cheyenne Chen, heard presentations from the BLA, the Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs (OCIA), and the Language Access Network, followed by extensive public comment. Key themes included the need for increased funding ($5.8 million in new funds plus a total of $22.9 million across departments), challenges with bilingual staff recruitment and retention, and the critical importance of language access in emergency services. Presentations & Discussion - BLA Report (Fred Brusseau & Daniela Estrada): The BLA presented its April 2025 report analyzing current language access costs ($15.1 million in FY 2022-23), the projected costs of the 2024 ordinance amendments ($3.5 million one-time and $2.1 million ongoing, totaling $5.6 million in the first year), and issues with bilingual staff pay. The BLA noted that 17% of language special condition positions were vacant in 2022, and the $60-per-pay-period bilingual premium may be insufficient for attraction/retention. Recommendations included improving data consistency, creating a citywide bilingual employee registry, and urging DHR to evaluate premium pay. - OCIA Presentation (Jorge Rivas & Anna de Carolis): OCIA reported that in FY 2024, city departments recorded about 1.5 million limited English proficient (LEP) client interactions (the highest ever, 48% above the five-year average), but bilingual staff decreased by 2% compared to the prior year. Key updates: the threshold for certified languages will drop from 10,000 to 6,000 LEP individuals (effective January 2026), likely adding Vietnamese; the office is working on a "know your rights" brochure and enhanced complaint reporting; and a community language bank project is in the research phase. OCIA acknowledged it does not have enforcement authority and relies on departments’ self-reported data. - Language Access Network Presentation (Anisha Hingarani of Chinese for Affirmative Action & Munesa Wangara of African Advocacy Network): The network shared community stories of language access failures, including a traumatic incident where a monolingual Chinese neighbor died after EMTs lacked interpretation, and a healthcare appointment where an uncertified interpreter gave incorrect information. They emphasized that language access is a matter of life, safety, and dignity, especially under federal rollbacks (e.g., Trump’s executive order revoking Executive Order 13166 and declaring English the official language). They urged the committee to prioritize $5.8 million in funding ($22.9 million total) for departments and OCIA, maintain $900,000 over two years for the language access network, and require departments to present language access budgets during annual budget hearings. Public Comments & Testimony - Over a dozen community members and organizational representatives testified, many sharing personal experiences of inadequate interpretation in healthcare, emergency services, and city departments. Speakers included Sylvia Romul (CARE), Amparo Alarcon (PODER), Amy Aguilera (PODER), Sarah Souza (Immigrant Rights Commission), Teresa Dela Cruz, Semya (African Advocacy Network), Ayu (CAA), Annie (CAA), Annette Wong (reading testimony from a community member), Jose An (Immigrant Rights Commission/CAA), Nick G. (CAA), Johannes Yatbarak (African Advocacy Network), and Marty (community advocate). Common requests: fund the $5.8 million in new LAO implementation costs, maintain the $900,000 for the language access network, and ensure emergency responders activate interpretation services automatically. Key Outcomes - The committee heard and filed the hearing by a unanimous 4–0 vote (Supervisors Ingardio, Walton, Chen, and Chair Chan voting aye). - Supervisor Walton and Chair Chan committed to working during the budget process to secure funding for language access, despite the city’s fiscal deficit. - Supervisor Chan specifically raised concerns about emergency services (first responders) and pledged to follow up on improving interpretation for EMT and emergency situations. - No formal legislation was voted on; the hearing was informational and advisory for the upcoming budget cycle.