The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, May 20, 2025, at 2:30 PM (with special orders at 3:00 PM). The board approved a consent calendar of routine financial and administrative items, held commendations for AAPI Heritage Month and retiring public safety leaders, conducted hearings on an appeal of a categorical exemption and conditional use authorization for a project at 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard, and adopted a report of delinquent building code enforcement charges. All votes were unanimous (11-0) unless otherwise noted. Consent Calendar - Items 1–3 (GO Bonds): Appropriated $194,000,000 in General Obligation Bond proceeds (Series 2025F) to the Departments of Public Health, Public Works, and MTA for healthcare, transportation, and street improvements; authorized issuance of up to $390,000,000 in bonds under the Healthy, Safe and Vibrant San Francisco 2024 bond; and authorized sale of up to $194,000,000 in Series 2025F bonds. Passed on first reading/adopted. - Item 4: De-appropriated and appropriated $250,000 from General City Responsibility to support District 10 safety plan, including violence prevention, safe passages, and youth services. Passed on first reading. - Item 5: Amended Administrative Code to allow accelerated procurement of fire apparatus without standard solicitation requirements. Passed on first reading. - Item 6: Accepted a retroactive $2,696,215 grant from the Department of Homeland Security/FEMA for the Regional Catastrophic Preparedness Grant Program (Oct 2024–Sep 2027). Adopted. - Items 7–8: Approved grant agreements with Glide Foundation ($14,115,847 for Free Meals Program) and San Francisco-Marin Food Bank ($12,604,048 for Food Assistance Program), both July 1, 2025–June 30, 2029. Adopted. - Item 9: Approved sale of a 46,000 sq ft portion of Parcel 21 in South San Francisco to the City of South San Francisco for $132,000. Adopted. - Item 10: Authorized acquisition of permanent and temporary construction easements from BART for $306,000 for the Regional Groundwater Storage and Recovery Project. Adopted. - Items 11–12: Approved ground lease and loan agreement for 160 Freelon Street (100% affordable housing, 85 units, including 22 units for formerly homeless and 5 for the city’s plus housing list), with a 75-year lease, $15,000 annual rent, and a loan not to exceed $22,577,900; authorized up to $76,000,000 in multifamily housing revenue notes. Adopted. - Item 13: Authorized joint grant application with Treasure Island Development Authority for up to $50,000,000 from the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program for the IC4.3 project. Adopted. - Items 14–15 (Referred without recommendation): Retroactively authorized amendments for Lavender Youth Recreation and Information Center ($300,000 for youth services and TGNC research) and Bayview Hunters Point Foundation ($18,079,996 for mental health and substance abuse services, extended through Dec 31, 2026). Adopted. - Items 16–17: Determined that liquor license transfers for El Chavo Supermercado (15 Ocean Ave) and Casa Guadalupe Supermarket 2 (3400 Cesar Chavez St) serve public convenience. Adopted. - Items 18–19: Confirmed mayoral appointments of Meghan Thurlow to the Public Utilities Commission (term ending Aug 1, 2028) and Rebecca Saroyan to the Board of Appeals (term ending July 1, 2028). Motions approved. - Items 30–33: Approved settlement with PG&E regarding FERC disputes (10-year secondary voltage service); authorized settlement of $111,500 for a trip-and-fall lawsuit; authorized solicitation of donations for fire apparatus; and declared intention to renew the Dogpatch & Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District with a public hearing set for July 2, 2025, at 3:00 PM. All adopted. - Items 36–39 (Adopted without committee reference): Proclaimed May 22, 2025 as El Farolito FC Day; celebrated Bike to Wherever Day on May 15, 2025; recognized May 24–June 1, 2025 as Queer and Transgender Asian and Pacific Islander Week; and approved Final Map 11177 for the Balboa Reservoir Mixed-Use Project. All adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General public comment included: a speaker objecting to the city’s RFP process for Juneteenth events, urging the board to recall the RFP; a speaker criticizing the board’s vote on the gift program settlement, stating that former Translatina recipients have been forced back into survival prostitution, experiencing increased abuse and mental health issues; a speaker opposing the allowance of Waymo autonomous vehicles on Market Street, citing dangers to transit, bicyclists, pedestrians, and taxi drivers; a speaker advocating for full funding of City College of San Francisco and free tuition to support the middle class; and a speaker raising concerns about the city’s lack of responsiveness and the need for artificial intelligence in government processes. Discussion Items - Commendations (Special Order 2:30 PM): The board issued multiple commendations in honor of Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month and other recognitions. Honorees included: Carol Ito (founder of PAWBAC, airport commissioner, Status of Women commissioner); Master Ho Ying Hang (40 years of tipta therapy); Dr. Paula Lee (VA director for San Francisco); Elaine Yen and Many Lai (owners of Imperial Garden in Portola); Assistant Chief of Police David Lazar (retiring after 33.5 years, with remarks from Chief Scott and multiple supervisors); six Public Works employees (Corey Jackson, Dominic Charles, Michael Lunardelli, Jackie Wilson, Henry Ramirez, Milton Navarrett) for their frontline service; Christine (executive director of All My USOs); dance groups from the Sunset District; and Cynthia “Sin” Wang (entertainment commissioner, small business advocate). - Appeals for 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard (Items 22–29, Special Order 3:00 PM): The board held consolidated hearings on an appeal of a categorical exemption from CEQA and an appeal of a conditional use authorization for a proposed 25-foot-tall, 20,000 sq ft maintenance building on the San Francisco Golf Club property. An agreement was reached between the project sponsor and appellant (Friends of St. Thomas More School). The board heard public testimony (none offered) and then voted to affirm the categorical exemption (item 23) and approve a revised conditional use authorization (item 28 as amended) with additional conditions: (1) good-faith routing of construction traffic away from St. Thomas More Way; (2) tree removal outside school hours or during summer recess; (3) watering of earth-moving areas at least three times daily; (4) compliance with health code dust control; (5) establishment of a hotline for dust complaints; (6) compliance with DBI and Fire Department requirements for fire suppression; (7) compliance with SFPUC stormwater controls; and (8) installation of an audio/visual alarm on the northern elevation for fire alerts. Items 24, 25, and 27 were tabled. - Building Code Enforcement Assessment Costs (Items 20–21, Special Order 3:00 PM): The board held a hearing on a report of delinquent charges for code enforcement violations. DBI Senior Housing Inspector Matt Luton presented the 28th annual report. After public comment (one speaker objected to lines 30–31 for 1465 Oakdale Ave, citing pending court negotiations), DBI agreed to remove several properties: 522 34th Ave (line 10, already paid), 15 Noble (lines 28–29), and 146 Vernon (lines 56–57). The board then approved the amended report and adopted the resolution. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approvals: All consent calendar items, committee reports, and for-adoption items passed 11-0. - 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard: The board affirmed the categorical exemption (item 23) and approved the conditional use as amended (items 28, 29), with specific conditions detailed above. Items 24, 25, and 27 were tabled. - Building code enforcement: The report of delinquent charges was adopted with amendments, removing several properties following payments and negotiations. - New business introduced: Supervisors introduced several items for future action, including a letter of inquiry regarding the 311 API shutdown, a performance audit of the Recreation and Parks Department, a resolution opposing proposed Medi-Cal cuts for undocumented adults, and a request for a hearing on Vision Zero 2.0. Supervisor Melgar noted that traffic crashes have cost San Francisco $2.5 billion over the last five years. - In memoriams: The meeting was adjourned in memory of former Commissioner Alan Wayne Martinez and Mr. Peter Flannery.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaOn May 19, 2025, the San Francisco Rules Committee met to consider two ordinances: one establishing the Board of Directors for the Downtown Revitalization and Economic Recovery Financing District (AB 2488) and another waiving contracting requirements for a two-year arts lease at Pier 29. The committee voted unanimously to send both items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 – Downtown Revitalization District - Mark Babson (President, Emerald Fund) expressed strong support, noting that the district is the final piece needed to enable office-to-residential conversions after addressing transfer tax and affordable housing fees. He stated that his firm studied 15–16 buildings and found that public-sector levers (transfer tax, affordable housing, property tax) are critical. - Erica McLaidis (SPUR) supported the legislation, citing research showing that conversion projects and reinvesting property tax revenues have worked in other cities to create 24/7 mixed-use neighborhoods. - Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) spoke in support, emphasizing the need for housing and stating that early estimates show the program could unlock up to 4,000 new homes, providing a stable future for residents. Item 2 – Pier 29 Arts Lease - Paul Madonna (artist, 31-year resident) expressed support, stating that the art space would have been a “refuge” for him when he started his career and that it is exactly what the city needs to maintain its creative identity. - Dave A. Keenan (CAST) stated that he spent over 1,000 hours designing the project and that a nimble build-out phase is essential for a two-year lease; he urged approval of the Chapter 6 waiver. - A letter from Mac McGur (owner/manager of Pier 23 Cafe) was read, pledging support for the residency program, noting that more opportunities on the Embarcadero benefit everyone. Five additional letters of support were submitted. Discussion Items Item 1: Ordinance Establishing the Board of Directors for the Downtown Revitalization and Economic Recovery Financing District - Supervisor Dorsey introduced the legislation, explaining that it implements AB 2488 (authored by Assemblymember Phil Ting) to create a financing district that diverts incremental property tax increases from office-to-residential conversions back to projects for up to 30 years, offsetting development costs. The district is expected to cover downtown San Francisco. - Jacob Bintliff (OEWD) presented the details: the district board will consist of 5 members (3 BOS members, 2 community members) plus an alternate, all appointed by the BOS President. The board must adopt a financing plan after public hearings. Preliminary analysis indicates about 50 commercial properties could be converted, generating approximately 4,400 housing units. - Elisa Sumara (Clerk of the Board) outlined administrative costs: the clerk’s office will provide support, estimating an annual cost of $130,000 for four meetings per year. The district can eventually reimburse these costs from incremental tax revenue, but funds may not be available for 3–5 years. A budget request will be submitted in June. Dr. Edward Diazis confirmed that the mayor’s office has been consulted but no commitment for funding has been made. - Supervisor Souter noted a new study showing the potential for 4,400 homes, 49 converted buildings, and $15.5 million in additional annual tax revenue. She expressed support and emphasized the need for funding for the clerk’s office. - Chair Walton called for clarity on the mayor’s support for the budget request before the item reaches the full board. Item 2: Ordinance Waiving Contracting Requirements for Port Lease – CAST at Large LLC at Pier 29 - Supervisor Souter introduced the item, stating that the space at Pier 29 between Fisherman’s Wharf and the Ferry Building has been underutilized and this project will add much-needed arts space in a historic pier. - Scott Lansettel (Port of San Francisco) explained that the port is leasing the dormant shed to CAST (Community Arts Stabilization Trust) for two years with an option to extend two more. CAST, in partnership with Art + Water (led by Dave Eggers and JD Beltran), will create an artist residency program for 20 emerging Bay Area artists plus 10 mentors, a daily walk-in gallery, an accessible event space, and free educational programs for SFUSD schools. The port will reimburse CAST up to $500,000 for code compliance and small improvements to enable occupancy by the end of the year. - JD Beltran and Dave Eggers described the vision: the project will provide affordable studio space, combat the loss of artist space, and create a visual arts hub similar to the Exploratorium for science. - Supervisor Dorsey expressed support, noting the importance of the project for District 3 and the city’s arts community. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Downtown Revitalization District): Motion to approve the ordinance and send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (Walton, Cheryl, Dorsey aye). The ordinance will appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda of June 3, 2025. - Item 2 (Pier 29 Arts Lease): Motion to send the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (Walton, Cheryl, Dorsey aye). - No additional items were discussed; the meeting adjourned.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, May 19, 2025, at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Chian Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmud. The committee considered two agenda items: an ordinance amending the Planning Code to eliminate retail size limits on health service uses in the Mixed Use-Office (MUO) District, and a hearing on street safety and economic recovery, sparked by a Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) report estimating $2.5 billion in traffic collision costs over five years. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: No public speakers. - Item 2: Over a dozen speakers urged the committee to adopt a new Vision Zero policy by July 30, 2025, and a detailed implementation plan by September 30, 2025. Speakers included representatives from Walk San Francisco, Kids Afoot SF, and WAC SF, as well as residents and a physician. Key points: six pedestrians (five seniors) killed in 2025; 42 traffic deaths in 2024 (highest in a decade); seniors and Black/African American travelers disproportionately affected; near misses unreported; need for automated enforcement, daylighting, no right-turn-on-red, and better sidewalk infrastructure. Some speakers criticized SFMTA for not expanding proven treatments citywide and for planning to return cars to Market Street. Discussion Items - Item 1: Planning Code Amendment (File 250099) – Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office) and Veronica Flores (Planning Department) presented the ordinance to eliminate retail use size limits for health service uses and remove retail ratio requirements in the MUO district, limited to areas east of 7th Street. The Planning Commission recommended modifications: include reproductive health clinics, remove retail ratio requirements, and apply changes only east of 7th Street. The committee adopted these amendments and continued the item to the June 2, 2025 meeting. - Item 2: Hearing on Street Safety and Economic Recovery (File 250473) – Presentations from: - Fred Brusseau (BLA): Estimated 92,799 total crashes (2018-2022), averaging 18,560 per year, with 193 fatalities (39/year). Economic costs: $2.5 billion (adjusted to 2024), including $596 million vehicle damage, $1.2 billion injuries, $310 million fatalities. City paid $61.4 million in settlements (2020-2024). Recommended annual reporting on street safety and cost-benefit analysis of safety measures. - Iris Sue (DPH): Vision Zero data: 29 fatalities/year average since 2014; pedestrians 50%+ of fatalities; seniors (65+) accounted for 38% of 2023 fatalities (up from 26% in 2022); 50% of pedestrian fatalities were seniors. Severe injuries stable. High Injury Network (HIN) covers 12% of streets but 68% of severe/fatal injuries. Black/African American travelers overrepresented (12% of fatalities vs. 5% of population). DPH does not track cost data or conduct public health campaigns. - Shannon Hayek (SFMTA): Focus on speed (1 in 5 crashes), failure to yield (15%), and red-light running (9%). Tools: quick-build projects (reduced bike crashes 25%, pedestrian crashes 33%), speed cameras (33 total, 18 active), left-turn calming (reduced speeds 15 mph by 71%), and signal improvements. Proactive traffic calming being explored. Staffing and funding constraints cited. - Captain Peter Shields (SFPD): Traffic enforcement unit has 16 officers (down from 80). Uses directed enforcement and WAVE program (2 hours/day, 2 days/week on HIN). Staffing challenges due to attrition. Richmond station issued 50% of citations due to lower call volume. Partnerships with SFMTA and DPH for data sharing. - Discussion: Supervisors questioned departments on prioritization, data sharing, cost-effectiveness, and the need for a new Vision Zero plan. Chair Melgar highlighted the need for interagency collaboration and a “Vision Zero 2.0.” Supervisor Chen asked about driver behavior and technology use. Supervisor Mahmoud inquired about charging parent companies (e.g., Uber/Lyft) for contractor violations. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to adopt amendments (as presented by the sponsor and planning commission) and continue the ordinance to the June 2, 2025 committee meeting passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Motion to hear and file the hearing passed unanimously (3-0). Chair Melgar committed to developing a new Vision Zero policy by July 30, 2025, incorporating lessons learned and community feedback, and to work with the mayor’s office, departments, and colleagues.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on May 15, 2025, at approximately 12:00 PM. The meeting covered a consent calendar, commission matters, a discretionary review hearing for a major mixed-use project on Mission Street, and several regular calendar items including a sign ordinance and a major downtown redevelopment proposal. The commission also acknowledged the departure of Planning Director Rich Hillis, who will step down in mid-July 2025 after 20 years with the city. Consent Calendar - Item 1 – 555 Grant Avenue: Unanimously approved (7-0) a conditional use authorization to add beer/wine sales and consumption on the premises (ABC Type-42) to an existing wine retail store and art gallery. - Item 3 – Draft Minutes for May 1, 2025: Unanimously adopted (7-0). Commission Matters - Director Hillis Departure: Commissioners expressed gratitude for Director Rich Hillis's 20 years of service to the city, including 12 years with the commission (7 as commissioner, 5 as director). He highlighted accomplishments including the housing element adoption, process reforms for housing and small business, and the community equity division. Hillis will remain through mid-July 2025 and plans to drive cross-country after his departure. - Commission Comments: Commissioner Sue Diamond wished everyone a happy "Bike to Work Day" and praised the city's improving bicycle infrastructure. Commissioner Braun also thanked Director Hillis for his service. General Public Comment - Georgia Shutish: Spoke about the need to adjust demolition calculations under Planning Code Section 317 to protect existing affordable housing in priority equity geographies. She cited a median home price of $1.6 million in San Francisco, requiring an income of $418,000 to buy, and argued that new housing replacing existing sound housing is rarely more affordable. Discretionary Review Calendar - Items 7A and 7B – 2588 Mission Street: The commission heard three requests for discretionary review (DR) of a proposed 10-story, 100-foot-tall mixed-use building with 181 dwelling units, 4,000 square feet of retail, 1,500 square feet of community space, and 19 affordable units (17% of base density) under state density bonus law. The project required waivers for rear yard, dwelling unit exposure, loading, height, and bulk, plus concessions for ceiling height, open space, and affordability tiers. Public Comment: Approximately 30 speakers opposed the project, citing the 2015 fire that destroyed 26 small businesses, displaced 60 residents, and caused the death of 38-year-old Mauricio Ariano. Speakers accused the owner, Hawk Liu, of gross negligence and argued that the project would accelerate gentrification and displacement of the Latino community in the Mission District (a priority equity geography). Several speakers cited the city's housing element, AB 686 (affirmatively furthering fair housing), and the commission's 2022 resolution apologizing for past discriminatory planning. One speaker, Alan R., supported the project, noting it would provide 17 very low-income units. Project Sponsor Position: Attorney Patrick Miller argued that under the Housing Accountability Act and state density bonus law, the commission must approve the project unless it finds a specific adverse impact on public health or safety, a very high bar that he said was not met. He stated that the project complies with all objective planning standards and that the owner had attempted to sell to affordable housing developers but found no takers. Commission Deliberation: The vote was preceded by a 2-month continuance (motioned by Commissioner Imperial) to explore acquisition for 100% affordable housing. Staff confirmed that the city (Mayor's Office, OEWD, MOHCD) met with the owner and two private affordable developers, but no acquisition was possible. Commissioner Imperial: Voted against approval, citing the tragic history, ongoing displacement of the Mission District (12,000 Latino residents lost since 2000), and insufficient city effort to secure funding for 100% affordable housing. He stated the city did not do enough due diligence. Commissioner Williams: Voted against approval, reading a detailed timeline of the fires and violations. He argued the project contradicts the housing element's equity provisions (Policy 1 - eliminate displacement; Policy 15 - expand affordable housing; Policy 21 - protect vulnerable populations) and the commission's own racial and social equity commitment. He said the state density bonus law is wrong and should be amended to protect low-income communities. Commissioner Moore: Voted against approval, stating the housing element obligates the commission to prioritize equity and prevent displacement. She called the project "unsettling" and said the DR is "exceptional and extraordinary." Commissioner Braun, Campbell, McGarry, and President So: Voted to approve. Commissioners Braun and McGarry acknowledged the terrible history but stated they lacked a legal basis to deny a code-compliant project under state law. President So said he reluctantly supported approval, noting the site is currently empty and unsafe, and that the new building will include community facilities. He stated that while the commission cannot change state law, he remains committed to fostering dialogue between new residents and longtime neighbors. Outcome: Motion to not take discretionary review and approve the project passed 4-3 (Campbell, McGarry, Braun, President So in favor; Williams, Imperial, Moore against). The commission also adopted the density bonus findings. Regular Calendar - Item 8 – Projecting Signs in NC and RC Districts: The commission unanimously (4-0, with absentees noted) recommended approval of an ordinance sponsored by Supervisor Stephanie to allow all corner businesses in Neighborhood Commercial and Residential-Commercial districts to have two projecting signs. The legislation originated from a commission recommendation on a prior special sign district at 2301 Chestnut Street. - Items 9A and 9B – 530 Sansome/447 Battery Street Project: The commission held an informational presentation on a major mixed-use redevelopment of a full city block at the northern edge of the Financial District, adjacent to Jackson Square. The project includes: - A new standalone 4-story Fire Station 13 (replacing the 1972 non-seismically sound station) - A 41-story, 544-foot-tall tower with approximately 345,000-390,000 square feet of Class A office space, 100-200 hotel rooms, 7,400 square feet of retail/restaurant, and 27,000 square feet of office/amenity uses - Significant public realm improvements along Merchant Street (extending the Mark Twain Place visual language) - Funding for 100% affordable housing in District 3 (Chinatown) and community benefits to be finalized in a development agreement The project requires rescission of Article 10 landmark status for the 447 Battery Street building, which will be demolished for the new fire station. Project Sponsor: Matt Witte (Related California) and Mark Schwettman (SOM) presented. They highlighted that the new fire station meets all department needs and that the office market data shows a 7% vacancy rate for "super premium" upper-floor view spaces in the top buildings north of Market, with strong tenant demand. They expect to start construction in 2027 and deliver in early 2030. Commission Support: All commissioners expressed strong support, praising the public benefits, the design sensitivity (especially regarding shadow and wind impacts), the economic stimulus for downtown, and the collaborative public-private partnership. Several noted that office and hotel uses are well-suited to this location. Outcome: The commission unanimously (7-0) voted to initiate General Plan Amendments (Urban Design Element, Downtown Area Plan, Land Use Index) and schedule a public hearing on or after July 17, 2025. The legislative package will return for a joint hearing with the Recreation and Parks Commission in mid-July. - Item 11 – 1634 Oakdale Avenue: The commission unanimously (7-0) approved a conditional use authorization to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit (UDU) on the second floor (created by splitting a flat) and restore the floor to a legal three-bedroom flat. The decision aligns with the commission's 2017 flats policy; the UDU lacked living areas and kitchen facilities. Key Outcomes - Item 7A/B – 2588 Mission Street: DR request denied; project approved (4-3). The commission adopted density bonus findings and will proceed with entitlements. - Item 8 – Projecting Signs: Recommended approval (4-0); will go to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 9 – 530 Sansome/447 Battery: Initiated General Plan Amendments (7-0); public hearing scheduled for July 17, 2025 or later. - Item 11 – 1634 Oakdale Avenue: Approved CU (7-0) with conditions. - Director Hillis Departure: Will remain through mid-July 2025; commission expressed appreciation for his service.
The San Francisco Health and Planning Commissions held a special joint meeting on May 15, 2025, to review the California Pacific Medical Center (CPMC) annual compliance statements for calendar years 2022 and 2023, marking the final hearing under the 10-year development agreement (DA). City staff presented findings that CPMC had met or exceeded all major obligations, including over $73 million in payments, workforce hiring targets, healthcare commitments, and public improvements. Commissioners expressed appreciation for CPMC's performance while noting ongoing concerns about the delayed Guerrero Plaza, the closure of labor and delivery services at Mission Bernal, and the need for continued monitoring of remaining healthcare obligations through 2028. No public testimony was offered, and staff recommended that the directors of Planning and Public Health find CPMC in compliance for the reporting period. Discussion Items - CPMC Annual Compliance Overview: Staff reviewed the DA requirements, including replacement of St. Luke's Hospital (completed in 2018/2019 with Mission Bernal and Van Ness campuses), $73 million in payments, construction of a neurological care center, and a public plaza at Mission Bernal (construction to start later in 2025). A third-party monitor will review the directors' findings. - Fee Increase Impact: Ethica Hussein, CFO of the San Francisco Health Service System, reported that CPMC rate increases are under actuarial review for 2022-2023, with all other years completed and CPMC found compliant; one small payout was made in a prior year. - Workforce Compliance: Lowell Rice of the Mayor's Office of Economic and Workforce Development reported that CPMC exceeded non-construction hiring goals (78 of 160 entry-level hires from workforce referral network in the final year, exceeding the 48% target), with a 77% retention rate (390 of 508 hires retained over 180 days). The CPMC Workforce Fund distributed $870,000 to community organizations (JVS, Self-Help for the Elderly, Success Centers, Faces SF). - Healthcare Commitments: Maxwell Garrett of the Department of Public Health detailed compliance: - Charity care/Medi-Cal patients: 30,836 in 2022 and 31,865 in 2023 (exceeding the 30,345 requirement). - Community benefits: $15 million in 2022 and $11.3 million in 2023 (exceeding $8 million). - Medi-Cal managed care: Over 43,000 beneficiaries in 2022 and 41,000+ in 2023; CPMC continues to contract with San Francisco Health Plan. - Tenderloin MSO partnership: CPMC partnered with NEMS MSO, covering 4,900 unduplicated lives in 2022 and 5,200+ in 2023. - Bed space: 30 shell beds at Van Ness remain unbuilt because Mission Bernal daily census has not reached 75%. - Labor and delivery closure at Mission Bernal: Notice given April 3, 2024; Health Commission found no detrimental impact with conditions (maintain women's clinic, transport options). - Center of Excellence in Community Health (Health First): 723 unique patients in 2022 (+10%), slight increase in 2023. - Center of Excellence in Senior Health: ACE unit saw 1,000 patients in 2022 and 1,100+ in 2023 (exceeding 600 goal). - Medical Office Building at Mission Bernal: Approved and funded, targeting 2028 opening. - Other provisions: Participation in SF HIP, partnership with Chinese Hospital renewed, compliance with national CLAS standards. - Public Improvements: Carl Hennessey (Public Works) reported that Guerrero Plaza design is near final, with a waterline design element remaining; construction permit issuance expected soon. Commissioner Braun questioned the delay and coordination with a traffic signal at 28th and Guerrero (planned for fall 2027 per SFMTA). Commissioner Braun also noted that the lower plaza at Mission Bernal was removed for construction staging of the neurosciences care complex; CPMC confirmed it will be reinstalled by 2028. - Commissioner Comments and Questions: - Vice President Moore (Planning) praised CPMC's compliance, asked about Guerrero Plaza delay, and raised concern about proposed state cuts to Medi-Cal affecting vulnerable populations. - Commissioner Braun asked about the intersection signal, lower plaza removal, and hoped for continued reduction in single-occupancy vehicle trips. - Commissioner Chow (Health) commended CPMC on CLAS standards, requested regular reporting to the Health Commission on remaining health obligations (through 2028), including subacute care, and urged DPH to keep the Commission informed on progress towards a city subacute unit. - Commissioner Guggenheim (Health) echoed support and emphasized interconnectedness of public health. - Planning Commission President (unidentified) suggested staff provide status reports in 12-18 months on Mission Bernal campus services, senior health, community health, and Guerrero Plaza completion. Key Outcomes - Staff recommended that the Directors of Planning and Public Health find CPMC in compliance for calendar years 2022 and 2023; no formal commission vote was taken. - Commissioners acknowledged that three healthcare obligations continue through 2028: maintenance of certain Mission Bernal services, operation of Centers of Excellence for Community Health and Senior Health, and annual compliance reporting. - DPH will continue to monitor these obligations and provide written updates to the Health Commission. - Commissioners requested that DPH and Planning staff provide periodic progress reports (e.g., annually or within 12-18 months) on outstanding items, including Guerrero Plaza construction, Mission Bernal campus services, the effect of labor and delivery closure conditions, subacute care development, and coordination with SFMTA on intersection improvements. - The meeting concluded with expressions of gratitude from both commissions for the collaborative process over the 10-year DA.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, chaired by Supervisor Jackie Fielder, held a regular meeting on May 15, 2025. The agenda included a hearing on the "Four Pillars Strategy" to address the city's drug crisis, alongside votes on resolutions authorizing private fundraising for new fire apparatus and renewing the Dogpatch & Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District (GBD). All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations or filed. Consent Calendar / Litigation Settlements - Items 4-8 (Settlement Approvals): The committee unanimously approved a block of five litigation settlement ordinances, including settlements for a PG&E FERC matter, an IBM lawsuit ($2,659,826.83), and individual claims from Lyudmila Maleva ($60,000), Mary Tuimavave ($26,250), and Arthur Fraser ($111,500). Items 4 and 8 were forwarded as committee reports, while items 5, 6, and 7 received positive recommendations. Regular Agenda Item 1: Behested Payment Waiver – Fire Apparatus - Presenters: Sponsor Supervisor Connie Chan and Fire Chief Dean Crispin. - Summary: The committee considered a resolution authorizing a limited number of city officials to solicit private donations for the procurement of fire apparatus. Supervisor Chan explained that manufacturing is monopolized by three companies, leading to order fulfillment times exceeding 1,000 days (over three years), and noted that some San Francisco fire trucks are still in operation from the 1970s. Chief Crispin expressed concern about the city's readiness for a major disaster like an earthquake, citing a recent fourth-alarm fire that highlighted the lack of functional apparatus. The item was unanimously forwarded to the full Board. Regular Agenda Item 2: Dogpatch & Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District Renewal - Presenters: Percy Birch (Legislative Aide to Supervisor Walton) and Donovan Lacey (Acting Executive Director of the GBD). - Summary: The committee reviewed a resolution to renew the property-based business improvement district for 15 years and expand its boundaries. Mr. Lacey stated the GBD has transformed over seven acres of open space and leveraged $5 million in assessments into over $16 million in funding. The renewal petition received overwhelming community support (280 yes petitions and 32 no petitions), and the average small property owner pays less than $300 annually. The item was unanimously forwarded to the full Board. Regular Agenda Item 3: Hearing – Four Pillars Strategy - Overview: Chair Fielder stated the hearing was timely, noting the city is on track for the second-highest rate of overdose deaths. She argued the evidence-based "Four Pillars Strategy" (Prevention, Treatment, Harm Reduction, Enforcement) used in Zurich is transferable to San Francisco's fentanyl crisis. - BLA Presentation: Fred Brousseau presented a report comparing San Francisco and Zurich. The report found Zurich has extensive interagency collaboration while San Francisco lacks a shared overarching goal. The BLA's cost-benefit analysis of a potential safe consumption site estimated a benefit-to-cost ratio of 2.0 to 4.7 (excluding the value of 15-27 estimated lives saved per year). The report noted that medication-assisted treatment uptake in Zurich is 75% compared to roughly 22% in the U.S. - Medical Expert Testimony: Dr. Opalach and Dr. Cicaroni of UCSF testified that addiction is a chronic disease, not a moral failing, and that recovery takes time and multiple attempts. They stressed that engagement requires trust, non-judgmental care, and a full toolkit of services integrating harm reduction and treatment. - Department Presentations: - DPH Director Sai: Acknowledged that "what we've done to date has not worked." He described a "new day" of collaboration, including expanded treatment beds, the "Restore" program (low-barrier housing with treatment initiation), and a 50% increase in medication for opioid use disorder (MOUD) starts. - DEM Director Carroll: Presented the Neighborhood Street Teams initiative launched March 25, 2025, which integrates DPH, HSH, SFPD, and Fire. The new "Astrid" data system tracks over 13,000 individuals. - SFPD Commander Lou: Presented the Drug Market Agency Coordination (DMAC) strategy. He reported 1,223 user-related arrests year-to-date in 2025, acknowledging that displacement is a "known symptom" of focusing resources. He noted officers had directly sheltered 178 individuals and medically transported 97 since August 2024. - Sheriff and Public Defender: Assistant Sheriff Carter described jail health services and a new CalAIM grant providing 30 days of medication upon release. Public Defender Alexandra Prey argued that the "catch-and-release" cycle for low-level drug offenses rarely leads to successful treatment engagement and increases the jail population. Public Comments & Testimony - Support for Four Pillars: A majority of public speakers expressed strong support for implementing a balanced Four Pillars strategy, emphasizing that harm reduction, treatment, and prevention must be given equal weight alongside enforcement. - Criticism of Enforcement: Several speakers stated that arrest-based strategies undermine trust, displace problems to other neighborhoods, and do not address addiction as a health issue. One speaker cited research showing overdose mortality increases near drug seizures. - Support for Safe Consumption Sites: Multiple speakers urged the city to follow the examples of New York and Providence by opening safe consumption sites, arguing they save lives and reduce public drug use. - ARF/RCFE Preservation: Numerous speakers, including residents and family members, spoke passionately against the proposed closure of the Adult Residential Facility (ARF) and Residential Care Facility for the Elderly (RCFE) at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital, calling them critical long-term homes that provide stability for people with severe mental illness and substance use disorders. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Fire Apparatus): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with positive recommendation (3-0: Sauter, Sheryl, Fielder). - Item 2 (GBD): Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3 (Four Pillars): The hearing was filed (3-0). No formal policy was adopted, but the discussion established a framework for future work. - Directives and Next Steps: Chair Fielder and Supervisor Dorsey emphasized the need for better metrics to measure success, such as reduced 911 calls, increased treatment retention, and lower overdose rates, and stressed the importance of addressing the negative effects of displacement caused by current enforcement strategies.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan with Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Rafael Mandelman, met on May 14, 2025, to consider 16 agenda items including appropriations, contracts, grants, bond issuances, and affordable housing projects. The committee forwarded most items to the full Board with recommendations, though several were amended or sent without recommendation due to concerns. Public Comments & Testimony - Fire Apparatus (Item 2): Representatives from San Francisco Firefighters Local 798 (Sam Gebbler, Cena Riahi, Alc Kauf) spoke in support, citing aging fleet with 17 of 31 aerial trucks over 20 years old and apparatus catching fire. - Lyric Grant (Item 4): Gay Lala Chavez, Executive Director of Lyric, expressed confidence in new HRC leadership and requested approval for retroactive grant to cover already-performed services. - Food Programs (Items 6 & 7): A public commenter challenged the reduced funding for SF-Marin Food Bank, stating it dropped from $20M to $3M per year over four years, and urged prioritizing food assistance. - 160 Freelon Affordable Housing (Items 11 & 12): Residents Paul Harvey and Eileen Tillman expressed concerns about lack of communication and impacts on their dead-end street. Later, Michael Manigal (SF Housing Development Corp) noted extensive outreach, including four community meetings. - SoMa Stabilization Fund (Item 13): No public speakers. Discussion Items - Item 1 - District 10 Participatory Budgeting: Ordinance transferring $250,000 for violence prevention programs. Approved with recommendation. - Item 2 - Fire Apparatus Sole Source Authority: Ordinance to allow SFFD to purchase fire apparatus without competitive bidding due to 900-day lead times. Deputy Chief Mullen reported eight engines and six trucks over 25 years old. Union noted 68% of aerial trucks over 15 years. Committee approved with recommendation; co-sponsors added. - Item 3 - Regional Catastrophic Preparedness Grant: Resolution to accept $2.7M FEMA grant for regional earthquake preparedness. Approved with recommendation. - Item 4 - Lyric Retroactive Grant: Retroactive amendment for $50,000 increase to Lyric for youth services (TGNC community). HRC CFO Samuel Thomas explained prior leadership provided verbal assurance. Committee moved to full board without recommendation due to process failure. - Item 5 - Bayview Hunters Point Foundation Contract: Amendment for mental health services. DPH proposed reducing term from 3 years to 18 months and amount from $25.7M to $18M due to high financial risk. BLA noted children's program delivered only half contracted units. Committee amended to 6-month rolling releases and sent without recommendation. - Items 6 & 7 - Glide Foundation & SF-Marin Food Bank Grants: Four-year grants for free meals ($14.1M) and food assistance ($12.6M). Approved with recommendation despite declining service levels due to inflation. - Items 8-10 - General Obligation Bonds (Healthy, Safe, Vibrant SF): Issuance of $194M (amended from $218M) for health facilities, street improvements, and public realm. Controller's office presented. Approved with recommendation. - Items 11 & 12 - 160 Freelon Affordable Housing: Ground lease and $22.6M loan for 85-unit 100% affordable housing (25% for formerly homeless). BLA noted weak cash flow in out-years. Community members raised concerns about outreach, but developers cited multiple meetings. Approved with recommendation. - Item 13 - SoMa Community Stabilization Fund: $2.4M (amended to $2.33M after removing SF Parks Alliance) for community programs. Approved with recommendation. - Items 14 & 15 - SFPUC Land Sale to South SF & Easement from BART: Sale of road parcels for $132,000 and acquisition of access easement for $306,000 for groundwater well. Approved with recommendation. - Item 16 - Treasure Island Affordable Housing Grant Application: Authorization to apply for up to $50M for 150 affordable housing units on Treasure Island. Approved with recommendation. Key Outcomes - Approved with recommendation to full board: Items 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8 (as amended), 9, 10 (as amended), 11, 12, 13 (as amended), 14 (as amended), 15, 16. - Approved without recommendation to full board: Items 4 and 5 (as amended). - Amendments: - Item 5: Term reduced to 18 months, NTE reduced to $18M, with 6-month rolling releases and reporting requirements. - Items 8-10: Bond issuance reduced from $218M to $194M. - Item 13: Removed $80,000 for SF Parks Alliance. - Item 14: Corrected short title from "from" to "to". - All votes were unanimous (3-0) on each motion.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, May 14, 2025, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included an officer recognition ceremony, a presentation of the 2024 Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) annual report, a follow-up on the Early Intervention System (EIS) rollout, a presentation on SFPD’s language access efforts, and unanimous approval of a revised Department General Order on community policing. Chief Bill Scott announced his departure, receiving tributes from commissioners and the public. The commission also voted to enter closed session and later voted not to disclose that discussion. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved (4–0) items: donation of eight pieces of art to the mounted unit (estimated value $2,000); department use of non-entity camera police quarterly report for Q4 2024; and SFPD/DPA’s SB 1421 and SB16 monthly report for April 2025. - Unanimously approved (4–0) the minutes of the meetings of April 2, 9, and 16, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Workline (public comment on general items) expressed concern about emails sent to the commission being deleted. He requested the commission and DPA be included in proper use of surveillance equipment and urged identification of unauthorized users. - David Elliott Lewis (public comment on Chief’s Report and CIT) thanked Chief Scott for his support of the CIT program, noting quarterly meetings and delivery of resources. He also spoke in favor of the co-responder model and encouraged commissioners to attend the upcoming CIT awards ceremony on May 28, 2025, at 11:00 AM at Scottish Rite Masonic Auditorium. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report – Chief Bill Scott reported crime statistics: overall crime down 27% year-to-date, property crimes down 29%, violent crimes down 16%, homicides down 27% (9 vs. 11 last year), a 45% reduction in car break-ins, 366 guns seized (41 ghost guns), and zero shootings for the week. He detailed major incidents including a homicide on Sunnydale, a stabbing, and a sideshow at Pier 32. He also noted that he is stepping down as chief to lead a new transit police agency in Los Angeles County (serving 12 million people). Commissioners and Director Henderson expressed gratitude for his eight years of service, highlighting his implementation of 272 reform recommendations, cultural change, and crime reduction. - DPA Director’s Report – Executive Director Paul Henderson announced a new language access focus group at DPA, a Distinguished Knight Award for the stop data audit, and a collaboration with Harvard Kennedy School on small business crime impacts. DPA opened 50 new cases and closed 55; top allegations were conduct unbecoming. Zero cases over 270 days and 97 sustained cases pending with the Chief’s Office. - Commission Reports – Commissioner Yee reported on SFPD’s Denim Day (April 30) in solidarity with sexual assault survivors and the Night of Remembrance (May 1) honoring 101 fallen officers. - CIT 2024 Annual Report – Lieutenant Donald Anderson presented: 72% of agency CIT-certified (unchanged from prior year); 24,510 calls for service (27% drop due to fire department taking over some wellness checks); staffing doubled from 4 to 8 officers; a co-responder clinician now works with CIT two days a week; the unit moved to a centralized location at Park Station; a new report-writing system captures mental health hold data; and the CIT unit will present at the 2025 CIT International Conference. Commissioner Clay noted the 40-hour and 10-hour training courses. The unit plans to launch a “care link” for individuals to share triggers and needs. - Early Intervention System (EIS) Update – Sergeant Darnaval reported that the transition to the Benchmark system continues to face data pipeline issues. For Q4 2024, 575 indicator points were generated, with 172 alerts for 129 members (90 members with 1 alert, 35 with 2, 4 with 3). One intervention was closed successfully; currently no active interventions. The department is piloting Benchmark’s EIS at two stations. Because of staff turnover at Benchmark, the department had to manually generate alerts, reviewing 14,000 officer records and spending 14 weeks to close a data gap. Approximately 90 support tickets have been opened with Benchmark, with resolution times averaging 28 business days. The data pipeline is expected to be complete by the end of September 2025. - Language Access Presentation – Dr. Diana Arroche (Director of Policy and Public Affairs) and Director Jorge Rivas (OCEIA) presented on SFPD’s compliance with DGOs 5.20 and 5.23. SFPD has 550 bilingual members (441 officers certified in 5 core languages). In FY 23-24, 41 members were newly certified. The department supports over 103 languages via website and 240 languages (including ASL) via Language Line. A five-year comparison of language access support was provided (2019–2023 data; 2024 report forthcoming). Key accomplishments: 19 of 40 academy graduates bilingual; a language access audit completed at all district stations; 16 neighborhood safety meetings with interpretation in Spanish, Cantonese, Tagalog, and Russian; and revision of DGO 5.20 has begun. The unit is exploring a uniform modification (name tags or pins indicating spoken languages) and enhancing data collection for hate crimes and foot patrol interactions. Commissioner Yee noted the value of such identification. The 2024 annual report is expected by mid-to-late June 2025. - Revised DGO 1.08 (Community Policing) – Sergeant Danny Lee presented the revised order, shortened from 12 to 3 pages to focus on broad guidance, with detailed procedures moved to a manual. The manual and DGO will go through the meet-and-confer process together. The commission voted unanimously (4–0) to approve the revised DGO for use in meeting and conferring with bargaining units. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar – Approved unanimously (4–0). - Minutes – Approved unanimously (4–0). - Revised DGO 1.08 – Approved unanimously (4–0) for use in meet-and-confer. - Closed Session – The commission voted unanimously (4–0) to enter closed session (Item 14) and later voted unanimously (4–0) not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - Chief’s Departure – Chief Scott announced his retirement from SFPD to become chief of a transit police agency in Los Angeles County. Commissioners, staff, and the public expressed appreciation for his eight years of service. The commission will work with the mayor to initiate a search for a new permanent chief. - Next Steps – CIT unit to present awards ceremony on May 28, 2025; EIS data pipeline completion expected by September 2025; Language Access 2024 annual report to be submitted by June 2025; DGO 5.20 revision to be completed by end of 2025. Note: The meeting was adjourned at approximately 4:30 PM. A subsequent press conference with Mayor Lurie and Chief Scott, captured in the raw transcript, was not part of the commission meeting and is not reflected in this summary.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on May 13, 2025, at 10:00 AM in City Hall. The meeting included a mayoral appearance, a public hearing on blighted property assessments, consideration of appeals for the 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard project, and adoption of numerous resolutions. Key actions included approval of an amended blighted property assessment list, continuation of the Junipero Serra appeals, and passage of a resolution supporting student journalism. Consent Calendar - Items 2 through 5 were approved as a consent calendar without objection. These included routine administrative items such as cash revolving funds, zoning map amendments, and a fee waiver. Public Comments & Testimony - Blighted Properties Hearing (Items 18-19): Over 20 property owners and tenants spoke during the public hearing. Many expressed frustration with the Department of Public Works (DPW) process, citing lack of communication, failure to receive notices, and difficulty abating graffiti on hard-to-reach areas. Several speakers claimed they had abated the graffiti but still received citations. One speaker noted that the DPW fine is $362 regardless of graffiti location. Another speaker requested notices in Chinese. A representative from the San Francisco Ballet stated they received 12 notices in 18 months. DPW staff explained the process: a 30-day notice of violation, followed by a blight notice with a fee if not abated. After the hearing, DPW staff met with property owners and waived 33 properties, amending the list. - General Public Comment: Speakers addressed various topics, including pedestrian safety (calling for action on Vision Zero), support for student journalism at Lowell High School (many students and community members spoke in favor of retaining advisor Eric Gustafson), concerns about the privatization of Kezar Stadium with a new soccer team, and allegations of mismanagement by the San Francisco Parks Alliance. One speaker also raised concerns about surveillance and health safety. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (2:00 PM): Mayor Daniel Lurie addressed the board, announcing the Breaking the Cycle Fund (a public-private initiative with $37.5 million in seed funding for behavioral health and homelessness), the "Rebuilding the Ranks" plan to address public safety staffing shortages at SFPD and the Sheriff's Office, and ongoing work on the city's $800 million budget deficit. Supervisor Melgar asked about Vision Zero; Mayor Lurie affirmed traffic safety as public safety, citing speed cameras and street redesigns. - Blighted Properties Report (Item 19): After public comment and DPW staff working with property owners, the board accepted an amended report reflecting 33 waived properties. The resolution approving the amended assessment list passed unanimously (10-0). - 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard Appeals (Items 20-27): Supervisor Melgar moved to continue these items (CEQA exemption appeal and conditional use authorization appeal) to the May 20, 2025 meeting, citing ongoing negotiations. The motion passed unanimously (10-0) after public comment from the appellant and parents of St. Thomas More School, who expressed safety concerns about a proposed maintenance building near the school. - Roll Call for Introductions: Supervisors introduced various items: Supervisor Fielder introduced a resolution for street renaming for Dr. Amos C. Brown and a permit for Golden City Football Club at Kezar Stadium. Supervisor Mahmood introduced resolutions honoring Dr. Brown. Supervisor Melgar introduced a package of legislation related to upzoning, including an enhanced infrastructure financing district, tenant protections, and a bike-to-work resolution. Supervisor Dorsey called for a hearing on recovery and overdose prevention policies. Supervisor Walton requested a hearing on the San Francisco Parks Alliance's alleged misuse of funds. - Student Journalism Resolution (Item 34): Supervisor Melgar introduced a resolution supporting student journalism and free speech, prompted by the reassignment of journalism advisor Eric Gustafson at Lowell High School. Multiple students and youth commissioners spoke in favor. The resolution passed unanimously (10-0). Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar (Items 2-5): Approved without objection. - Item 6 (Police/Sheriff Overtime Funding): Passed 8-2 (Supervisors Fielder and Walton voted no). - Items 7-17: All passed unanimously (10-0). - Item 19 (Blighted Property Assessments): Adopted as amended (10-0) after DPW waived 33 properties. - Items 20-27 (1310 Junipero Serra): Continued to May 20, 2025, meeting (10-0). - Items 30-33, 35-37 (For Adoption without Committee Reference): Passed unanimously (10-0). - Item 34 (Student Journalism): Adopted unanimously (10-0). - Mayoral Appointment (Item 16) and IHSS Appointments (Item 17): Approved. - Hearing on Recovery and Overdose Prevention Policies: Supervisor Dorsey's request for a hearing was noted for future scheduling.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, May 13, 2025, at 10:00 AM. Vice President Gail Gilman presided. Commissioners present: Gail Gilman, Willie Adams, Stephen English, and Stephen Lee. The meeting included approval of minutes, an executive session (with no disclosure), election of officers, consent calendar, a presentation on the Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefits District grant amendment, and an informational presentation on Ferry Building enhancements. The meeting adjourned at 4:32 PM. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Award of construction contract 2871 for Pier 80 mooring and berthing improvements to Manson Construction Co. in the amount of $5,518,500 with a 10% contingency ($551,850), total not to exceed $6,070,350. (Resolution 25-25) - Item 10B: Award of construction contract 2878 for Mission Bay Ferry Landing Phase 2A marine demolition and mattress to Vortex Marine Construction in the amount of $13,114,750 with a 10% contingency ($1,311,475), total not to exceed $14,426,225. (Resolution 25-26) - Item 10C: Amendment to professional services contract with Cowie OLMM Joint Venture for Mission Bay Ferry Landing Project, increasing by $1,644,848 to a total of $6,411,383. (Resolution 25-27) - Item 10D: Approval of lease L-17253 with TEC of California Inc. for 21,842 sq ft of shed space and 11,540 sq ft of paved land at Pier 80, term 3 years with three 1-year options, subject to Board of Supervisors approval. (Resolution 25-28) - Item 10E: Approval of a license for privately owned ground settlement monitoring equipment at Seawall Lot 337 (Mission Rock Project). (Resolution 25-29) All consent items were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 11A (Fisherman's Wharf CBD grant): - Taryn Hoppe (port tenant and CBD board member): Expressed strong support, stating the partnership "saved the wharf" from a negative post-COVID trajectory, praising ambassadors and cleanup of illegal vending. - Jeff Sears (CBD board member and property owner): Thanked the port for the grant, noted dramatic improvement in cleanliness and safety since 2022-23, and requested continued funding. - Todd Barby (planning consultant, client Sky Star Wheel): Supported the grant, noting the beautification of Little Embarcadero positively impacted business around the wheel, and that illegal vending had been dramatically reduced. - On Item 12A (Ferry Building enhancements): No public comments were made. - On items not on the agenda: No public comments. Discussion Items - Item 9A – Election of Officers: - President Gail Gilman was nominated and elected unanimously. - Vice President Stephen Engblom was nominated and elected unanimously (Commissioner Adams noted he declined due to small business commitments but would consider next year). - Item 9B – Executive Director’s Report: - Director Elaine Forbes reported on: May as Asian American Native Hawaiian Pacific Islander Heritage Month (23% of port workforce identifies as Asian/Pacific Islander) and Mental Health Awareness Month. - Crane Cove Park celebrated ribbon cutting for the first new YMCA in San Francisco in 30 years. - Juneteenth celebrations on the waterfront will support local Black-owned businesses. - A sculpture program is underway with Building 180; over a dozen potential sites identified, first installation expected fall 2025. - Fisherman’s Wharf Wine Walk on May 17. - Commercial salmon season closed for third consecutive year; recreational salmon season capped at 7,000 fish for summer and 7,500 after September 1. - Port participated in San Francisco Climate Week events, including augmented reality tour and Youth Summit. - Shoreline Leadership Academy graduated 16 high school students from a 15-week paid program. - PG&E will begin dredging for Beach Street Remediation (legacy sediment contamination) from June through November each year through 2030. - Commissioners commented on youth engagement, the sculpture program, and congratulated Director Forbes on being named one of the 80 most influential women in San Francisco by the Business Times. President Gilman highlighted the start of Jewish Heritage Week. - Item 11A – Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefits District Grant Amendment: - Amy Cohen (Business Generation Manager) presented the partnership since June 2023: the CBD has deployed ambassadors, removed trash and graffiti, installed hanging flower baskets, produced 41 Pier Party events (attendance grew from 17,000 in 2023 to 43,000 in 2024), installed murals, and created the Fisherman’s Wharf Promenade (8% increase in visitors since Q1 2024). - Bree (CBD staff) announced Phase 2 ground murals celebrating maritime heritage, and upcoming events: inaugural Wine Walk, Pier Parties every second and fourth Saturday, and daily activations. - The amendment requests $3,147,590 over 18 months (total grant now $6 million over 42 months). CBD landside budget is $1.8 million; grant funds waterside services. - Commissioners Adams, Lee, Engblom, and Gilman expressed support, with Commissioner Engblom requesting quantitative economic impact data for future presentations. The item was approved unanimously (Resolution 25-30). - Item 12A – Ferry Building Enhancements (Informational): - David Beaupre (Deputy Director of Planning and Environment) and Jane Connors (Ferry Building General Manager) presented proposed interior/exterior lighting, south entry gateway signage and seating, and pedestrian lights along the back plaza to improve safety and ambiance at night. - Jane Connors highlighted recent tenant additions (local entrepreneurs: Senor Sisig, Ober’s Hummus, Peach’s Patties, Lunette), facade restoration, and partnership with Foodwise for the Ferry Plaza Farmers Market. - Commissioner Lee praised the work as a model for small business and post-COVID recovery. Commissioner Adams supported the light-touch approach. Vice President Engblom suggested incorporating sea level rise education. President Gilman requested incentives for weekday evening hours and economic diversity. - No vote was taken; it was an informational item. Key Outcomes - Election of Officers: Gail Gilman elected President, Stephen Engblom elected Vice President; both unanimous. - Consent Calendar Resolutions 25-25 through 25-29: All adopted unanimously. - Resolution 25-30: Amendment to Fisherman’s Wharf CBD grant approved unanimously, increasing the not-to-exceed amount by $3,147,590 and extending the term 18 months. - Next Steps: For Ferry Building enhancements, the design team will consider sea level rise education; commissioners encouraged continued tenant engagement on hours and economic diversity. The sculpture program and Fisherman’s Wharf activations to proceed. The next commission meeting date was not announced.