The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on June 11, 2025, to consider the Mayor's proposed interim and full budgets for fiscal years 2025-2026 and 2026-2027, along with related trailing legislation. The meeting opened with a special tribute to retiring Budget Analyst Harvey Rose, who served for 52 years. The committee heard presentations from the Mayor's Budget Office, the Controller, and numerous city departments, and took public testimony on budget cuts and program funding. Key votes included forwarding the interim budget to the full board and continuing several items for further discussion. Consent Calendar - Items 1-3 (Interim Budget): The committee voted 5-0 to file the hearing on the Mayor's proposed interim budget and forward the interim appropriation and salary ordinances to the full Board of Supervisors for the June 17 meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - On Trailing Legislation (Item 10 - First Year Free Program): Moses Corrett (Planning Department employee, personal capacity) expressed concern that the $2.5 million set aside for department reimbursements may be insufficient and could lead to layoffs. - On Overall Budget (Items 7-9): Numerous city workers and community members spoke against proposed cuts. Key positions: - Kristen Schumacher (Local 21) presented evidence that restoring six positions in the Assessor's office could generate $17-32 million in additional revenue, enough to avoid all layoffs. - Maggie Loush (Planning Department staff) argued that layoffs are not necessary and the premise of pain is false. - Representatives from the Tenderloin Housing Clinic, Central City SRO Collaborative, and Code Enforcement Outreach Program urged full restoration of funding, citing critical services for vulnerable tenants. - Project Open Hand's Vice President Anna Ayala noted that withholding Dignity Fund dollars would force a reduction of 100,000 meals and cut weekend services. - Workers' Rights Community Collaborative speakers (La Raza, Chinese Progressive Association) highlighted the program's role in recovering stolen wages for immigrant workers and opposed elimination in FY26-27. - Lydia Sandoval (Community Ambassador) opposed elimination of the CAP program, noting life-saving interventions. Discussion Items - Tribute to Harvey Rose: Supervisors and Controller Greg Wagner praised Rose's independence and legacy. Rose noted his office's role in providing unbiased budget analysis. - Controller's Revenue Letter (Item 4): Revenue Manager Carol Liu reported that general fund tax revenue grows by $138.8 million in FY25-26 and nearly $300 million in FY26-27, driven by business tax growth. However, the structural deficit remains at $700 million for FY27-28. Risks include federal cuts (e.g., FEMA disallowing 97% of $415 million claimed) and potential Medicaid cuts. The budget creates a $400 million federal/state uncertainty reserve. - OCII Budget (Items 5-6): Executive Director Thor Kaslofsky presented the $620 million budget for the Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure, focusing on affordable housing, parks, and infrastructure in Mission Bay, Transbay, and Hunters Point. The budget includes up to $223 million in bond issuance. The committee forwarded both items to the full board with different dates. - Department Presentations: The committee heard from the Assessor-Recorder, Treasurer, Department of Technology, Board of Appeals, City Administrator, Health Service System, Civil Service Commission, Human Resources, Department of Elections, General City Responsibility, Controller's Office, Human Services Agency, Department of Building Inspection, Planning Department, Ethics Commission, Department of Public Works, and Board of Supervisors (Clerk). Key themes included: - Assessor-Recorder: Appeals surged to over 9,000 (from 1,400 average), leading to a reassessment backlog of 14,000 items. The Assessor requested six additional positions to clear the backlog in 2.5 years instead of 5, which could generate tens of millions in revenue. - Treasurer: Jose Cisneros highlighted $7.4 billion collected annually, $212 million from audits, and the First Year Free program (over 10,500 enrollments, $5 million waived). The department faced four layoffs and 13 vacant position deletions. - City Administrator: Carmen Chu presented a $611 million budget with $14 million in general fund reductions, including elimination of 30 Community Ambassador positions (sunset) and 3 layoffs at 311. The CAP program will phase out over three years. - Human Services Agency: Trent Rhorer reported $13 million in general fund savings (25% of discretionary funds), achieved by deleting 81 vacant positions (no layoffs). Cuts include $400,000 to the Workers' Rights Community Collaborative in FY27 and $250,000 to immigrant support grants. The Dignity Fund remains flat at $3 million, causing reduced purchasing power for nutrition services. - Department of Public Works: Director Carla Short proposed $13.8 million in cuts, including closure of 10 Pit Stop locations and layoffs of two managers. The department deleted 46 positions (44 vacant). - Ethics Commission: Director Patrick Ford warned that losing four funded positions (three filled) would reduce training, compliance, and policy work. He requested restoration of two positions. - Board of Supervisors (Clerk): Angela Calvillo requested restoration of cuts and funding for three new 1406 senior clerk positions to handle the surge in assessment appeals, as well as a stipend increase for Assessment Appeals Board members from $125 to $175 per session. Key Outcomes - Items 1-3 (Interim Budget): Voted 5-0 to forward to full board (June 17). - Item 4 (Controller's Revenue Letter): Voted 5-0 to file as heard. - Items 5-6 (OCII Budget): Voted 5-0 to forward to full board (June 17 and July 8). - Item 10 (First Year Free Extension): Continued to the call of the chair (4-0, with one absent), after Chair Chan expressed concern about waiving fees while the Treasurer laid off staff. - Items 11-14 (Trailing Legislation): Voted 5-0 to forward to July 8 full board meeting. - Items 15-16 (Administrative Provisions): Voted 5-0 to file as heard. The City Attorney agreed to add a sunset date of January 20, 2029, and provide annual reports on gifts accepted under the new section 12.16. - Item 17 (Assessment Appeals Board Stipend): Voted 4-0 (one absent) to forward to June 17 full board with positive recommendation. - Meeting adjourned to June 12, 2025, at 10:00 AM.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, June 11, 2025, with six commissioners present and a quorum. The agenda included a citizen recognition award, consent calendar, the Acting Chief's crime report, the DPA Director's report, commission reports, election of officers, a presentation on new disparity benchmarks, and a vote to enter closed session. Acting Chief Paul Yep and DPA Executive Director Paul Henderson presented reports. Citizen Recognition Award - The Commission honored Carissa Cleverly-Valencia, a registered nurse at UCSF, for her actions on January 27, 2025, when she stopped her car after hearing gunshots on 9th Street and applied direct pressure to a shooting victim's wounds with her sweater until medics arrived. Sergeant Coleman and Sergeant Wells of Tenderloin Station described the scene; the treating physician said her actions "absolutely" saved the victim's life. She received a certificate from Acting Chief Yep and a Tenderloin Station sweatshirt. - Public comment: A mother of a homicide victim thanked her personally, saying she wished someone like her had been present when her son was murdered. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously (6-0) received and filed the SFPD and DPA SB 1421 and SB 16 monthly report for May 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - General public comment: Chris Ward Klein, an active-duty U.S. Marine Corps sergeant, said riots and violence were "here," asked SFPD to join a strike force to arrest six people, and made claims about signal intelligence and digital surveillance by SFPD. - A mother of homicide victim Arboria Casa (later identified by commissioners as Paulette Brown) spoke about a Board of Supervisors resolution to establish reward/tip funding for unsolved homicides, and asked the Commission to support it. - During public comment on the Chief's report, Karen Fleshman, a member of the Justice for Mario Woods coalition, named several individuals killed by SFPD—including Jessica Williams, Luis Gongora Pat, Mario Woods, Emil Carrez Lopez, and Alex Nieto—and urged that their stories remain central in the criteria for selecting the next chief. - After the officer election, public commenters thanked outgoing President Elias and congratulated the new officers; one urged the chief search process to include direct outreach to communities most impacted by policing. Discussion Items - Chief's Report: Acting Chief Paul Yep reported crime trends for June 2–8, 2025. Year-to-date crime was down 27%, with homicides down 23%, burglaries down 23%, and motor vehicle theft down 43%. There were no homicides in the reporting week; one shooting injured two people on June 6. An aggravated assault/mayhem incident involved a severed ear and a second assault; a suspect was arrested. An officer was struck by a vehicle on June 3. A pedestrian was killed in a traffic collision on June 2. The Chief discussed the department's response to First Amendment protests: 20 reported uses of force over two days (baton strikes and physical force), approximately 155 arrests on June 8 and 92 on June 9, and drone deployment on both days. The Chief read the department's statement affirming support for peaceful First Amendment activity and the city's sanctuary policy prohibiting local law enforcement from assisting federal immigration enforcement. He said the department would respond to the June 11 letter from the First Amendment Coalition and the Society of Professional Journalists of Northern California. - DPA Director's Report: Executive Director Paul Henderson reported that complaints year-to-date are significantly higher than last year; sustained cases are slightly lower; three cases are over the 270-day review threshold. DPA faces proposed cuts to four filled positions (three DPA, one Sheriff's Office) and will defend its budget at a hearing on June 13. An ongoing use-of-force audit includes surveys sent to SFPD supervisors, closing June 16. - Commission Reports: Commissioners thanked protest participants, journalists, and police; reaffirmed sanctuary city policy; recognized gun violence awareness month and Juneteenth/Pride; congratulated Paulette Brown on the Board of Supervisors resolution. Commissioner Benedicto requested a comprehensive later-summer presentation reviewing SFPD's protest response, including uses of force, arrests, drone deployment, and the FAC/SPJ letter allegations. - Election of Officers: Commissioner Clay was elected President and Commissioner Benedicto Vice President unanimously (6-0). President Clay dissolved the three-person search committee appointed May 21 by former President Elias, citing a Sunshine Ordinance violation, and said he would work with the Department of Human Resources, potentially engage a headhunter, ensure full commissioner participation, and provide regular public updates on the chief search. - Disparity Benchmark Analysis: Staff presented a new stops dashboard and three additional benchmarks beyond the traditional census benchmark. The Risk-Adjusted Disparity Index compares stops to violent crime victimization risk; results over six quarters showed Black/white contacts near parity relative to victimization risk, while Hispanic individuals were stopped less than expected. The Suspect-Adjusted Disparity Index compares stops to reported violent-crime suspects; Black and Hispanic individuals were underrepresented relative to whites based on incidents. The Traffic Analytic Layout uses not-at-fault collision data as a proxy for the driving population. Discussion noted limitations from the DPA stop-data audit; the department stated the analysis was not affected by the audit issues and that the error rate has fallen below 5%. Public commenter Karen Fleshman questioned whether the new benchmarks legitimize racial profiling; the department responded that benchmarks are multiple measures and that population benchmarks alone are flawed. Key Outcomes - Citizen Recognition Award presented to Carissa Cleverly-Valencia. - Consent calendar approved 6-0. - Commissioner Clay elected Commission President and Commissioner Benedicto Vice President (6-0). - The May 21 chief-search committee appointment was dissolved; a new search process and regular public updates were promised. - The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to enter closed session for Item 11. The available transcript ends as the Commission returned to open session for the required vote on disclosing closed-session discussion; no disclosure decision is recorded. - Commissioner Benedicto's request to agendize a comprehensive review of SFPD's protest response later in the summer was made. - The Chief agreed to provide a full response to the First Amendment Coalition/SPJ letter, with the response to be shared with the Commission and agendized.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on June 10, 2025, at 10:30 AM. The meeting included approval of minutes, consent calendar items, an executive director's report featuring a commendation for retiring engineer Uday Prasad, and a major informational presentation on the Fisherman's Wharf Forward plan, which proposes near-term improvements and long-term resilience investments. The meeting also included public comment on non-agenda items and new business discussions. Consent Calendar - Item 10A: Approved resolution 2531 authorizing a construction contract with Silverado Contractors, Inc. for Pier 90 buildings and wharf demolition, not to exceed $3,518,900 (including a 10% contingency fund of $319,900). Vote: unanimous. - Item 10B: Approved resolution 2532 for a new lease renewal with Autodesk, Inc. at Pier 9 (36-month term with one 12-month option, retroactive to February 1, 2025), subject to Board of Supervisors approval. Vote: unanimous. Public Comments & Testimony - Non-Agenda Public Comments: - A speaker (Marina, representing the Jeremiah O'Brien Foundation) reported that Metro Cruises has prohibited parking on Pier 35, impacting the ship's 45th annual memorial cruise. The speaker called this behavior "a slap in the face" to the labor on the wharf. Commissioner English directed staff to follow up with Metro Cruises and the inland boats unions. - Greg Champeau, a resident, asked for an update on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers study regarding the waterfront, noting the new administration might affect the timeline. - Executive Director's Report Public Comments: Multiple port staff members (Wendy Proctor, Erica Peterson, Brad Benson, David Beaupre, Mike Martin, Steven Real) spoke in praise of Uday Prasad, who is retiring after 23 years at the port. They highlighted his leadership, kindness, and contributions to structural assessments, sea level rise studies, and mentoring. - Fisherman's Wharf Forward Public Comments: - John Barnett (Crab Boat Owners Association) expressed strong support, but emphasized the need for security improvements, preserving historic signage, and helping historic Monterey fishing boats (feluccas) by reducing slip fees and providing a workshop space. - Frank Racino (third-generation fisherman) thanked the port for supporting fishermen, expressed excitement for the project, but raised concerns about security, parking, and trash. He stated that the current security situation is "terrible." - Sal Alioto (third-generation owner of fishing vessel Golden Gate) stressed preserving the history of Fisherman's Wharf, opposing moving the historic boats. He suggested closing Jefferson Street to pedestrians on weekends and reducing noise from musicians. - Mark Johnson (Monterey boat owner) supported the project but requested a workshop space at the wharf for boat maintenance, noting that many boatyards have closed and costs are high. - Terren Hoppe (board chair of Fisherman's Wharf CBD) expressed overwhelming support, calling the project "something the wharf desperately needs," and urged coordination with the triangle parking lot plans. - Breema (Executive Director, Fisherman's Wharf CBD) voiced support for the strategic investment, noting it builds on momentum since 2023. - Tom Escher (Red and White Fleet) congratulated staff, noting that no one objected, which is rare. - Jeff Sears (Fisherman's Wharf CBD) praised the project as a game-changer, urging design with pedestrian corridors and preserving space for events. - Mark Schwartz (fisherman) reiterated concerns about parking, security, trash in the water near the front row boats, and the need for maintenance. - Michael Racino (fourth-generation fisherman) opposed floating docks, requested new ladders, designated trash disposal, and parking. He supported keeping the historic boats visible. - Darlene Slumtree (San Francisco Maritime National Park Association) excited about the plan, emphasized preserving historic Monterey boats and the Seaman's Chapel, and suggested honoring the Alioto family with signage. - Jennifer Broca (community member and bay swimmer) praised the plan as transformative, noting the resurgence of bay swimming since the pandemic (South End Rowing Club and Dolphin Club now have over 2,000 members each). - Ben Dorfman (BCDC) stated BCDC is working with the port on a forthcoming amendment to the San Francisco Waterfront Special Area Plan to facilitate development at Fisherman's Wharf, with a public hearing on July 17, 2025. Discussion Items - Item 11: Fisherman's Wharf Forward – Executive Director Elaine Forbes and Chief Operating Officer Mike Martin presented a plan for near-term and long-term improvements at the Taylor Street and inner lagoon area. The near-term plan includes demolishing the former Alioto's restaurant to create a public plaza, improving inner lagoon berthing and lighting, and constructing a public overlook at the smokehouse site. Long-term plans involve seismic and flood resilience improvements, historic preservation of Fisherman's Grotto 9, and community engagement on design. The projected cost is $10 million, funded from Prop A bond proceeds and harbor funds. The goal is to complete the plaza by summer 2026. Commissioners expressed strong support, with suggestions to preserve history, help historic boats, improve security, and consider mobile commission meetings. President Gilman noted the overwhelming public support and directed staff to address safety and environmental concerns raised during public comment. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Resolutions 2531 and 2532 adopted unanimously. - Fisherman's Wharf Forward: The plan was presented as informational; no vote was taken. Staff will proceed with community engagement and return with further details. The commission directed staff to follow up on security and trash issues in the inner lagoon, and to explore the feasibility of mobile commission meetings at Fisherman's Wharf and Pier 70/Crane Cove. - New Business: Commissioner Lee requested a report on safety and cleanliness of the inner lagoon, and Commissioner Adams suggested exploring fee waivers for historic fishing boats. The commission also discussed the possibility of holding future meetings at the waterfront to engage the community.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, June 10, 2025, at 2:00 p.m. in City Hall. The meeting included a formal policy discussion with Mayor Daniel Lurie, adoption of consent and regular agenda items, public commendations, and public comment. Key topics included RV homelessness legislation, shelter expansion in District 10, capital investment in District 11, immigration enforcement actions, and multiple resolutions and ordinances. Consent Calendar - Items 2 through 9 were approved unanimously on a 10-0 vote. These included routine approvals such as refunding certificates of participation, appropriations, fee adjustments, lawsuit settlements, and a waiver of contracting requirements for a port lease. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public spoke on a variety of topics: - One speaker urged the board to remove 5G towers, claiming they are harmful, and issued an ultimatum for action by July 1. - A U.S. Marine veteran warned of impending violence and riots due to police not arresting the right people, and alleged signal intelligence manipulation by foreign entities. - A speaker recounted personal experiences of being strangled and abused by law enforcement, criticizing the police budget and lack of accountability. - A speaker reported witnessing ICE agents conduct what they described as a kidnapping in an unmarked van, expressing fear and anger. - Another speaker requested the board to pass legislation on rewards for unsolved homicides, displaying photos of her murdered son and other victims. - A speaker raised concerns about the narrow sidewalk on Taylor Street after construction, which they said has become a congregating area for homeless individuals. - One speaker asked about putting a measure on the ballot to restrict police access to databases, but was nervous and requested follow-up. - A final speaker honored the late musician Sly Stone and suggested turning the former Nordstrom space into a supper club. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance and Policy Discussion: Mayor Daniel Lurie appeared before the board for a formal policy discussion. He opened by addressing immigration enforcement actions occurring downtown that afternoon, stating that local law enforcement does not participate in federal immigration enforcement under long-standing city policy. He also introduced new legislation (co-sponsored by several supervisors) to limit oversized vehicle parking to two hours citywide, paired with expanded outreach and housing services to address RV homelessness, including a $90 million proposal over three years for interim housing. - Topic 1: Shelters (District 10): Supervisor Walton questioned the mayor about the Gerald Commons shelter in the Bayview, stating that the community unanimously opposes the expansion and that the mayor is making unilateral decisions in a district that already hosts multiple homeless services. Mayor Lurie defended the project, noting that Phase 1 opened in April with 60 cabins for older adults, a proposed expansion of 82 more beds, and a two-year community engagement process. He claimed no complaints have been received via the dedicated phone line. Walton pressed that no resident or business supports the expansion, and asked the mayor to pause the proposal. The mayor disagreed that support is nonexistent and stated he will continue to work with the community. - Topic 2: Capital Projects (District 11): Supervisor Chen asked what process the mayor's office uses to ensure major capital investments in historically neglected areas (e.g., Crocker Amazon renovation, Ingleside Police Station, Ocean View Library) are responsive to community needs. Mayor Lurie highlighted the city's 10-year capital plan, transparency, and equity priorities. He cited the Ingleside Police Station ($109 million, completion 2029) will include a community room, and the Ocean View Library shifted to a full rebuild ($42 million allocated) due to community feedback. Chen asked for a commitment to personally engage with District 11 constituents, which the mayor gave. - Commendations (2:30 p.m. Special Order): The board recognized four honorees for meritorious service: - Seventh and eighth graders from St. Cecilia's Church and School for a sock, shoes, and sweats donation drive that collected 1,521 pairs of socks, 49 pairs of sweatpants, and 47 pairs of shoes for St. Anthony's Foundation. - Mac Allen, a Muni transit operator known for his warmth, poetry, and care for students on the 44 O'Shaughnessy line, who also led efforts for Transit Operator Appreciation Day. - Takashi Onishi, founder of Japan Video and Media, who introduced anime and manga to the U.S. and served the Japantown community for 40 years, organizing festivals and the first anime costume parade. - Darcy Drollinger, San Francisco's first Drag Laureate, founder of Oasis nightclub and Oasis Arts, who paid over $1.6 million to performers and led initiatives like Meals on Heels during the pandemic. - Unfinished Business: - Item 10 (Fire Department ambulance appropriations) passed unanimously on final reading (two-thirds vote). - Item 11 (Downtown Revitalization and Economic Recovery Financing District board) passed on first reading. - New Business: Items 12-27 were passed on first reading or adopted, including: - Software licensing fund (Item 12) - Grant amendments and leases (Items 13-15) - Grant for Proposition 47 program (Item 16) - Brake system overhaul contract (Item 17) - Four gift/grant acceptances for DPH (Items 18-21) - Revenue obligation approval (Item 22) - Planning code amendments for reproductive health clinics (Item 23) - Two commission appointments (Items 26-27) - Committee Reports (Items 28-33): All passed unanimously, including compensation for unrepresented employees, MOU amendment for nurses, assessment ballots for community benefit districts, behested payment waiver, and an audit of Recreation and Park Department. - Roll Call Introductions: Supervisors introduced new business: - Supervisor Walton introduced a resolution supporting AB 1242 to strengthen language access laws. - Supervisor Chen introduced a resolution condemning ICE deportations and adjourned in memory of Sean O'Neill McGrew and Luisa Blue. - Supervisor Mahmood introduced a resolution affirming the right to peaceful assembly and condemning militarization of civilian response, and also introduced two letters of inquiry regarding the 311 mobile app and data accuracy. Key Outcomes - The consent agenda (Items 2-9) was approved unanimously (10-0). - All unfinished and new business items (Items 10-27) were passed or adopted with no recorded objections, mostly on same house same call. - Committee reports (Items 28-33) were adopted unanimously. - The two items for adoption without committee reference (Items 36-37: resolution urging restoration of adult acupuncture Medi-Cal benefit and findings for a conditional use authorization) were adopted unanimously (10-0). - Supervisor Fielder was excused from the meeting by motion (10-0). - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Sean O'Neill McGrew and Luisa Blue.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on Tuesday, June 10, 2025, at 9:30 AM. The Commission addressed a range of items including approval of previous meeting minutes, quarterly audit and capital improvement reports, a wildfire mitigation plan, a contract modification for the City Distribution Division campus project, and a time extension for a sewer replacement contract. All action items received unanimous approval, and the meeting included closed session discussions regarding a settlement. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the May 27, 2025 meeting unanimously (5-0). - Approved the Consent Calendar (items 6A through 6C) unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: One caller spoke on agenda item 4, criticizing the historical transfer of the Auxiliary Water Supply System (AWAS) from the Fire Department to the PUC, alleging it was done to balance the city's budget and that subsequent decisions have undermined the system's independence. The caller referenced a 2019 report that stated a single pipeline could meet goals, calling it the "beginning of the bastardization of AWAS." - No public comments were made on other agenda items. Discussion Items - Quarterly Audit and Performance Review (Item 5a): Presented by Nancy Howham, Chief Financial Officer. The SFPUC had completed 19 audits as of March 31, 2025 (14 financial, 5 performance), with 9 audits in progress and 11 scheduled. Noteworthy was a City Services Auditor public integrity assessment regarding contracts with suspended vendor Rudolph Duane Jones (RDJ); no findings were attributed to the SFPUC. There are 16 open audit recommendations across four audits. - Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program & Water System Improvement Program (Items 5b & 5c): Presented by Katie Miller. The combined 52 projects have a $4.0 billion budget, with 34% spent to date. Key updates included the emergency firefighting water system pipeline alignment evaluation with the San Francisco Fire Department, and progress on the Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozone Project facing utility conflicts. The Water System Improvement Program (52 projects, $3.8 billion) is 99% complete. Commissioners asked about delays on the Westside Recycled Water Project and Bay Division pipeline lining repair. - 2025 Wildfire Mitigation Plan (Item 7): Presented by Ethan Billigmeyer. The plan updates the 2024 version, covering assets in high fire threat districts (26% of transmission in Tier 2, 2% in Tier 3; 87% of distribution in Tier 2, 8% in Tier 3). Key accomplishments include a daily fire weather situational awareness app with live camera feeds, satellite vegetation monitoring (LIVEO), pole wrapping, and vegetation management. The plan emphasizes minimizing ignitions, grid resiliency, and continual improvement. Commissioners discussed inspection timing, the use of satellite data, and partnerships with Cal Fire and other agencies. - Contract Modification for 2000 Marin Street Project (Item 8): Presented by Shelby Campbell. Requested approval of Modification No. 1 to increase the CMGC contract with Clark Construction Group from $260 million to $305 million. The increase includes $39 million for escalation (3.5% over four years) and $6 million for work performed on behalf of other projects (BCTD duct bank, water line, and solar PV system). The project is on schedule for relocation in 2028. Commissioners noted the modification was planned, and the project team will pursue cost-cutting measures for remaining trade packages. - Duration Contingency Increase for Sewer Replacement Contract (Item 9): Presented by Aileen K. Requested and approved 365 additional calendar days for contract WW-709R (Various Locations Sewer Replacement No. 13) with M. Hernandez Construction, Inc., to allow time for completing lateral service replacements. - Closed Session (Items 12-15): The Commission voted unanimously (4-0, with Commissioner Jamdar excused) to assert attorney-client privilege, held closed session, and subsequently announced approval of a settlement recommendation to the Board of Supervisors. The Commission voted unanimously not to disclose the closed session discussion. Key Outcomes - Approved: Minutes of May 27, 2025 (5-0). - Approved: Consent Calendar (5-0). - Approved: 2025 Wildfire Mitigation Plan and authorization to file (5-0). - Approved: Modification No. 1 to Contract WD-2879R with Clark Construction Group ($305 million revised contract, not to exceed $329 million) (5-0). - Approved: 365-day duration contingency increase for Contract WW-709R with M. Hernandez Construction, Inc. (5-0). - Approved: Motion to assert attorney-client privilege (4-0, Commissioner Jamdar excused). - Approved: Motion not to disclose closed session discussion (4-0, Commissioner Jamdar excused). - The Commission also received reports on quarterly audits, capital improvement programs, and communications without requiring action.
The San Francisco Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Shimon Walton and joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheryl and Board President Rafael Mandelman, met on Monday, June 9, 2025, at 18:15 UTC. The committee considered seven agenda items: two mayoral appointments, three ordinances, and two commission appointments. All votes were unanimous, with Member Mandelman absent for the first two items. Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of June 17, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Homicide Reward Fund): Paulette Brown, mother of Aubrey Albertasa Jr. (murdered in 2006, unsolved), spoke in strong support of the ordinance. She described her son's death from 30 rounds and urged the committee to approve the reforms, stating no rewards had been paid in a decade and that many families are "suffering in silence." - Item 3 (Entertainment Zones): Richard Johnson, representing the coalition HV Safe, spoke in opposition to inclusion of Hayes Valley in the entertainment zone ordinance. He accused the legislation of being introduced in an "unethical and exclusionary manner," alleging that residents (over 9,000) were not notified, no community meeting was held, and that Supervisor Bilal had not convened a follow-up meeting after a March session with the Hayes Valley Small Business Association. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Mayoral Appointment, Historic Preservation Commission: Gayle Tsern Strang presented her qualifications as an architect with over 32 years in San Francisco, including work on adaptive reuse projects (Strand Theater, SOM projects) and personal experience restoring a Richard Neutra home. She answered a question about how her background would advance commission work. No public comment. Motion to approve passed unanimously (Walton and Cheryl aye; Mandelman absent). - Item 2 – Administrative Code: Homicide Reward Fund: A representative from Supervisor Matt Dorsey's office presented the ordinance to reform the reward fund established in 2016 but never paid a reward. Changes include allowing rewards when charges are filed (not just convictions), enabling anonymous tipsters, removing blanket criminal record bans, and barring rewards for false information. The legislation was inspired by Paulette Brown's advocacy and aligns with a unanimous Police Commission resolution. Motion to approve passed unanimously (Walton and Cheryl aye; Mandelman absent). - Item 3 – Administrative Code: Entertainment Zones: The ordinance creates entertainment zones on Valencia Street, Pier 39, Folsom Street, Ellis Street, Yosemite Avenue, and Hayes Valley, plus a downtown activation location on Yerba Buena Lane. Chair Walton expressed 100% support, noting the zones span multiple supervisorial districts. After public comment, motion to approve with positive recommendation passed unanimously (Walton, Cheryl, Mandelman aye). - Item 4 – Airport Surveillance Technology Policy: Guy Clark, IT appliance manager for the airport, presented a second amendment to the pre-security camera policy. Changes add mobile cameras for remote areas and traffic flow surveys (used once or twice yearly), and five new cameras for an integrated operations center. The four authorized use cases remain unchanged. No public comment. Motion to approve passed unanimously. - Item 5 – Neighborhood Beautification Fund: Robin Takayama, of the City Administrator’s Office, presented updates to the Community Challenge Grants program (formerly Neighborhood Beautification Grant, voter-passed in 1990). Changes: limit eligible applicants to 501(c)(3) nonprofits, remove financial match requirement, and remove unnecessary preferences. Two funding cycles have been paused during this process. President Mandelman and Supervisor Cheryl asked to be added as co-sponsors. Chair Walton expressed excitement. Motion to approve passed unanimously. - Item 6 – Appointment, Children and Families First Commission: No candidate was present. Motion to continue the item passed unanimously. - Item 7 – Appointment, In-Home Supportive Services Public Authority: Candidate Luana McAlpine (IHSS provider for 15–16 years) testified about her commitment to clients, especially elders who want to stay at home. She emphasized listening to and advocating for consumers. No other candidates were present. Motion to appoint McAlpine for seat four (term ending March 1, 2028) passed unanimously; seat nine was continued to a future meeting. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (Walton and Cheryl aye; Mandelman absent). Nomination sent to full board with recommendation. - Item 2: Approved unanimously (Walton and Cheryl aye; Mandelman absent). - Item 3: Approved unanimously (Walton, Cheryl, Mandelman aye) with positive recommendation. - Item 4: Approved unanimously. - Item 5: Approved unanimously. Co-sponsors added: President Mandelman, Supervisor Cheryl, Chair Walton. - Item 6: Continued to a future meeting (unanimous). - Item 7: Luana McAlpine appointed to seat four; seat nine continued. Approved unanimously (Walton, Cheryl, Mandelman aye). All motions carried without objection. Meeting adjourned after completing the agenda.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, June 9, 2025, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmoud. The committee considered three agenda items: approval of a street resurfacing project list funded by Senate Bill 1, an ordinance allowing two projecting signs for corner businesses, and an ordinance authorizing interim housing in hotels and motels. The meeting concluded with all consent items passed and a continued item for further review. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented; all items were discussed individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (SB 1 Road Repair Funds): No public speakers. - Item 2 (Projecting Signs): No public speakers. - Item 3 (Interim Housing): No public speakers. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Resolution Approving Project List for SB 1 Road Maintenance Funds: Ayan Schneider, Government Affairs Manager at San Francisco Public Works, presented a resolution to approve a list of 178 blocks for resurfacing in FY2025-2026, funded by the Road Maintenance and Rehabilitation Account (RMRA). These blocks are part of a larger plan to resurface over 420 blocks citywide, with other blocks funded by different sources. Supervisor Chen requested a snapshot of the prioritization criteria for his district. The committee unanimously recommended the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 2 – Ordinance Allowing Two Projecting Signs for Corner Businesses: Presented by Lorenza Rosas from Supervisor Sherrill’s office and Audrey Merlone from the Planning Department. The ordinance amends the Planning Code to allow two projecting signs for all corner businesses in neighborhood commercial and residential-commercial districts, abolishing the 2301 Chestnut Street Special Sign District. The Planning Commission approved the item unanimously on May 15, 2025. The committee voted unanimously to recommend the ordinance to the full board. - Item 3 – Ordinance for Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels: Presented by Supervisor Dorsey and Emily Cohen, Deputy Director of the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), along with Dr. Christy Soren from the Department of Public Health (DPH). The ordinance authorizes interim housing in three former hotels (Sharon Hotel, Keen, Marina Inn) for drug-free recovery programs, without abandoning their tourist use classification. Amendments were read into the record to add the three sites and make technical adjustments. The committee discussed data tracking for outcomes, including occupancy rates, demographics, and successful discharges. Supervisor Dorsey expressed strong support, noting community outreach and the need for recovery-oriented housing. The committee voted to amend the ordinance as presented and continued the item to the June 16, 2025 meeting for further review. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Passed unanimously (3-0) and sent to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 2: Passed unanimously (3-0) and sent to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Item 3: Amendments adopted unanimously (3-0); ordinance continued as amended to the June 16, 2025 meeting for reconsideration. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 10:45 AM.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held its regular hearing on Thursday, June 5, 2025, starting at approximately 1:30 PM. All seven commissioners were present (President So, Vice President Moore, Commissioners Braun, Campbell, Imperial, McGarry, Williams). The agenda included continuances, consent calendar items, informational presentations, and several conditional use authorizations and a discretionary review. Key actions included continuing the San Francisco Gateway Project and 70 Hancock Street matters, approving a formula retail use for Nordstrom Local on Fillmore Street (5-2), and denying a discretionary review for a housing project on 30th Street. Consent Calendar - Item 1 (Reproductive Health Clinics – Planning Code Amendment) and Item 2 (2258 Market Street – Conditional Use for Stretch Lab) were approved unanimously by a 7-0 vote. No public comments requested removal from consent. Public Comments & Testimony - On the continuance of the Gateway Project: Multiple residents and community advocates from the Bayview expressed strong opposition to the project, citing environmental and health impacts, and frustration with the last-minute continuance. Mark Gleason (Teamsters Joint Council 7) and Rudy Gonzalez (Building and Construction Trades Council) spoke in favor of the continuance, noting ongoing productive stakeholder discussions. - General Public Comment: George Shudish raised concerns about the city's flat policy definition, providing examples of projects he believed circumvented the intent. - On the Nordstrom Local (1919 Fillmore Street): Approximately 10 speakers opposed the project, citing traffic congestion, double parking, delays to the 22 Fillmore bus line, and insufficient neighborhood engagement. One speaker submitted a packet with a checklist of requirements. Nordstrom representatives presented their plans, including overnight deliveries, validated parking, and community partnerships. - On the Alabama Street Project: George Shudish commented that the proposed designs lacked neighborhood context and questioned affordability. - On the Folsom Street ADU project: No public comments were made. - On the 30th Street Discretionary Review: One speaker (the DR requester) argued that the third-floor addition would block views, reduce light, and harm neighborhood character. Discussion Items - Item 8 – The Portal (Downtown Rail Extension) Informational Presentation: Executive Director Adam Vanderwater of the Trans Bay Joint Powers Authority provided an update on the 1.3-mile rail extension from Fourth and King to Salesforce Transit Center. The project is 70% funded, with a $3.38 billion federal commitment, and expects 90,000 daily riders when operational. Construction could begin in 2028 with revenue service by 2035. Commissioners praised the project and discussed funding, tunneling methods, and coordination with other projects like Link 21 and the Pennsylvania Avenue Extension. - Items 9a-c – Alabama Street Housing (819, 825, 831): Project sponsors presented plans for three three-unit buildings (six primary units + three ADUs) under SB 423. Commissioners Vice President Moore, President So, and others encouraged more detailed architectural drawings, context analysis, and consideration of affordability. The presentation was informational; no vote was taken. - Item 13 – 2722-2726 Folsom Street (Conditional Use): Staff reported 21 letters of support and none in opposition. The project would merge an unauthorized dwelling unit and add a rent-controlled ADU. Commissioners praised the approach and approved unanimously 7-0. - Item 14 – 1919 Fillmore Street (Nordstrom Local Conditional Use): The department received 29 letters of support and 22 letters of opposition. Nordstrom representatives described the store as a neighborhood service hub, offering order pickup, returns, alterations, and donations. They committed to overnight delivery for store-to-store transfers, validated parking at the Annex Garage, and community engagement. Commissioners debated traffic and parking impacts. A motion to approve with conditions passed 5-2 (Commissioners Williams and Moore opposed). - Item 15 – 14-16 30th Street (Discretionary Review): The project would restore five existing units, add a third-floor vertical addition and a rear ADU. Staff recommended not taking DR, citing code compliance and consistency with design guidelines. The DR requester cited view, light, and privacy concerns. The project received 46 letters of support and none in opposition. The commission voted 7-0 to not take DR and approve the project. Key Outcomes - Continuances granted (7-0): - San Francisco Gateway Project (Items 10, 11A-E) continued to June 26, 2025. - 70 Hancock Street (Items 12A-B) continued to July 10, 2025. - Consent Calendar approved (7-0): Reproductive Health Clinics amendment and Stretch Lab conditional use. - Minutes of May 15 and May 22 meetings adopted (7-0). - Folsom Street conditional use approved (7-0). - Nordstrom Local conditional use approved (5-2) with standard conditions, including community liaison and compliance with code. - Discretionary Review on 30th Street not taken; project approved (7-0). Next Steps: The commission will reconvene on June 26, 2025, for the continued Gateway Project items.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on June 5, 2025, at 6:15 PM UTC (local morning) under Chair Jackie Fielder, joined by Vice Chair Denny Sauter, Supervisor Cheryl, and Supervisor Mahmood for certain items. The committee considered ten agenda items, including a behested payment waiver for downtown economic revitalization, a 15-year permit for Golden City Football Club at Kezar Stadium, renewal and expansion of two benefit districts, compensation ordinances for unrepresented employees and SEIU nurses, a retroactive MOU with the U.S. Capitol Police, and a hearing on fiscal mismanagement by the San Francisco Parks Alliance. The committee also approved a performance audit of the Recreation and Park Department and handled several settlement items. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Kezar Stadium Permit): Multiple speakers expressed support, including representatives from Laborers International Union (Local 261), Connect SF, youth soccer players, parents, coaches, the athletic director of Sacred Heart Cathedral, a business owner (Kezar Pub), and community members. Speakers highlighted the $10 million investment, community benefits, need for a professional soccer team in San Francisco, and positive impacts on youth and local businesses. No opposing public comment was heard. - Item 8 (Parks Alliance Hearing): Approximately 20 speakers testified, many representing community-based park stewardship groups (e.g., Stern Grove Festival, Citrous Stewards, Detroit Steps Project, Friends of Alta Plaza Park, Mount Sutro trails, Visitation Valley Greenway, Corbett Heights Neighbors, and others). Speakers expressed anger, disappointment, and urgency, describing lost bequests, halted projects, laid-off staff, and a broken trust. They called for accountability, recovery of funds, and a new fiscal sponsorship mechanism. Several speakers praised the Recreation and Park Department’s professionalism and stressed the need for systemic oversight reforms. - Item 9 (RPD Performance Audit): One speaker voiced support for the audit, linking it to the need for trustworthy agencies. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Behested Payment Waiver (Economic Revitalization): Sarah Dennis Phillips (OEWD) presented a six-month pilot to allow the Mayor’s office and OEWD to solicit donations from private entities for downtown revitalization (clean/safe efforts, small business support, cultural activations). The waiver provides transparency via board reporting. Vice Chair Sauter expressed support. Chair Fielder asked about metrics and potential expansion; Phillips noted metrics will be required and expansion could be considered after pilot. Approved unanimously. - Item 2 – Kezar Stadium Permit (Golden City FC): Supervisor Mahmood and property manager Hank Heckel presented a 15-year permit (with extension options) for Golden City Football Club to play at Kezar Stadium. The club will invest $10 million in upgrades (new turf, scoreboard, sound system, ADA improvements). Existing community uses (high school football, track, running) are preserved; adult soccer teams limited to one game/year. Chair Fielder raised concerns about impacts on other clubs (SF City, Nighthawks, El Farolito) and Boxer Stadium conditions (drainage, lights, scoreboard, mowing). Mark Rohr (co-founder) emphasized player pathway and collaboration. An amendment was adopted reallocating 38 tickets per game from “underserved communities” to “underserved youth and their families.” Approved unanimously. - Item 3 – Unrepresented Employees Compensation Ordinance: Artis Graham (DHR) presented the routine annual ordinance for 88 unrepresented employees, aligning wages with city pattern. A clerical amendment (adding “close of business”) was adopted. Approved unanimously. - Item 4 – SEIU Local 1021 Staff and Per Diem Nurses MOU: Graham explained the second amendment makes it easier for per diem nurses to transition to permanent positions while retaining seniority and shift preferences. Approved unanimously. - Item 5 – Capitol Police MOU (Retroactive): Commander Derek Jackson described continuation of 24/7 protection for Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi’s residence since January 2024. The retroactive resolution allows reimbursement from U.S. Capitol Police. Approved unanimously. - Item 6 – Dogpatch and Northwest Potrero Hill Green Benefit District Renewal/Expansion: Esther Lee (Public Works) presented the resolution authorizing the Mayor to cast affirmative assessment ballots for nine city-owned parcels ($5,983.66 annual assessment, 0.07% weighted vote). A clerical error (0.04% corrected to 4% per MTA parcels) was amended. Approved unanimously. - Item 7 – Ocean Avenue Community Benefit District Renewal/Expansion: Jackie Hazelwood (OEWD) presented similar resolution for seven parcels ($19,512.20 annual assessment, 4% weighted vote). Approved unanimously. - Item 8 – Hearing on Fiscal Mismanagement by SF Parks Alliance: Supervisor Walton led the hearing. He detailed allegations that at least $3.8 million in restricted funds intended for community park groups were misappropriated to cover operating costs. The organization has hired a liquidation firm (Jigsaw Advisors) and laid off staff. The Parks Alliance was absent. Walton called for subpoenas for three individuals (most recent CEO Robert Ogilvie, former CEO Drew Betcher, and board treasurer Rick Hutchinson) and production of documents. Chair Fielder and colleagues supported the motion. The committee voted unanimously to issue subpoenas and continue the hearing to the call of the chair. - Item 9 – Performance Audit of Recreation and Park Department: Chair Fielder introduced a motion to direct the Budget and Legislative Analyst to conduct a department-wide performance audit in FY2025-2026, noting that RPD has not undergone such an audit in over 10 years. Supervisor Walton co-sponsored. Approved unanimously. - Items 10-16 (Settlement of Lawsuits): Items 10-15 (five resolutions approving settlements totaling several million dollars) were forwarded to the full board with positive recommendation. Item 16 (Castagnola’s settlement agreement) was continued to the call of the chair on a motion by Chair Fielder. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Amended (ticket distribution to underserved youth and families) and forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Amended (clerical fix) and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 5: Forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 6: Amended (corrected percentage) and forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 7: Forwarded to full board (3-0). - Item 8: Motion passed (3-0) to direct the clerk to issue subpoenas to Robert Ogilvie, Drew Betcher, and Rick Hutchinson for testimony and documents (as per Supervisor Walton’s May 13, 2025 letter), with authority for the chair to set the date. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. - Item 9: Motion to conduct a performance audit of RPD in FY2025-2026 forwarded to full board (3-0). - Items 10-15: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 16: Continued to the call of the chair (3-0).
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joan Guardio, met on June 4, 2025, to consider 13 agenda items including contract process reforms, leases, grants, and bond authorizations. The committee voted on most items with unanimous approval, with one item continued to a later date and one amended before approval. Public Comments & Testimony - No public speakers appeared for any item on the agenda. Discussion Items - Item 1 (250192): Ordinance amending Administrative and Labor Codes on city contract processes and requirements. Supervisor Chan expressed support for streamlining but raised concerns about removing the sweatshop-free advisory group, and noted a letter from the San Francisco Labor Council. Board President Mandelman requested a continuance to July 9, 2025, which the committee approved unanimously. - Item 2 (250483): Lease with Sky Chargers, LLC for a DC fast charging hub at SFO. Airport staff presented the lease terms: 24 spaces, $190,000 minimum annual guarantee, 14-year term. The committee forwarded to full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3 (250428): Grant from San Francisco Irish Famine Memorial Committee for Lincoln Park project ($500,000). The Recreation and Park Department requested a continuance to September 24, 2025, citing administrative issues. The committee approved the continuance on that date-certain. - Item 4 (250491): Sole source contract with Wabtec for LRV4 brake system overhaul (not to exceed $15,527,933). SFMTA explained the need to maintain warranty and address defects. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended approval but urged competitive bidding for future overhauls. The committee forwarded to full board. - Item 5 (250463): Lease with 340 Jefferson Street Partners for restaurant space (10-year term, $1.51 million in revenue). The Port Commission described the Chascario concept. Committee forwarded to full board. - Item 6 (250490): Prop 47 grant for Housing Expungement and Recovery (approximately $8 million). HSH outlined the HEARTS program. BLA noted service composition still under development and recommended a letter to the board. Committee forwarded to full board, with Chair Chan requesting a hearing by October/November. - Item 7 (250549): Revenue obligations for The Sequoias San Francisco (up to $165 million). The Controller's Office explained the TEFRA process; the total issuance covers multiple counties. Committee forwarded to full board. - Item 8 (250451): Grant agreement amendment with UCSF for Community Assessment and Services Center ($17,872,321). Adult Probation requested extending the term. BLA recommended reducing the not-to-exceed amount to $17.1 million due to historical underspending. Adult Probation agreed. Committee amended and forwarded. - Item 9 (250543): Retroactive grant from CA Department of Health Care Services (CalAIM) for $265,000. DPH explained the delay in receiving notice. Committee forwarded to full board despite Chair Chan's concerns about retroactive grants. - Items 10 & 11 (250544 & 250545): Retroactive gifts from Epic Systems Corporation ($37,500 and $37,000). DPH said gifts support community resource directory and vocational rehab. Chair Chan expressed frustration with retroactivity but moved to forward. - Item 12 (250546): Retroactive gift from SF Public Health Foundation ($1,744,131) for various DPH programs. DPH described support for primary care, maternal child health, etc. Chair Chan questioned the process and asked for improvements. Committee forwarded to full board. - Item 13 (250455): Ordinance to sell licenses for legislative management system software. Clerk's office proposed an amendment to remove "category eight fund" designation. Committee amended and forwarded to full board. Key Outcomes - Continued: Item 1 to July 9, 2025; Item 3 to September 24, 2025. - Amended and Forwarded: Item 8 (reduced not-to-exceed to $17.1 million); Item 13 (stripped "category eight fund" language). - Forwarded to Full Board (positive recommendation): Items 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 12 – all unanimously approved. - No votes against any item; all motions carried 3-0.