Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 471–480 ENTRIES
471
APR 14, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - April 14, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 14, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood. The committee heard two items: an ordinance to remove the conditional use requirement for formula retail on Van Ness Avenue and an ordinance requiring notice for housing element rezoning. Both items were advanced with amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Van Ness Formula Retail): Marlene Morgan from the Van Ness Corridor Neighborhood Coalition expressed support for the legislation with the caveat that legacy eligible businesses be protected and that efforts be made to break up large spaces with fewer barriers from the Department of Building Inspection. An additional public speaker supported the initiative to increase foot traffic and reduce vacancies. - Item 2 (Housing Element Rezoning Notice): Jane Matoly, San Francisco organizing director for UMB Action, spoke in opposition, arguing the notice goes beyond what is necessary and could create undue alarm, and that the money could be better spent elsewhere during a tough budget season. Lori Brook with Neighborhoods United SF strongly supported the legislation, emphasizing that residents deserve full information about major land use changes. Tess Wellbourne from the REP Coalition supported the focus on existing residents and affordable housing needs. Multiple other speakers (Robert Ho, Lance Carnes, Jessica Vinus, Janet Monfredini, and others) supported the notice, citing lack of awareness and need for transparency. Small Business Forward also supported, noting potential displacement risks for small businesses. Discussion Items - Item 1: Removing Conditional Use for Formula Retail on Van Ness Avenue – Supervisor Stephen Sherrill introduced the ordinance, citing a 53% ground floor commercial vacancy rate on Van Ness compared to 7.7% citywide. He stated that the average permitting timeline of 7.5 months deters tenants, with some properties vacant for over five years. He proposed amendments: extending the boundary north to Chestnut Street and adding a provision to remove the requirement for a conditional use authorization (CUA) when a new formula retail operator replaces a previous one that did not have a CUA (e.g., the former Safeway on Fillmore). Supervisor Bilal Mahmood supported, noting the impact on District 5, including the 40,000-square-foot Safeway in the Fillmore, and emphasized food security. Supervisor Cheyenne Chen expressed support while underscoring the importance of formula retail restrictions for neighborhood character. Michelle Andrews, aide to Supervisor Danny Sauter, supported, noting the Van Ness 49 Muni line saw 142% ridership recovery in February 2025 (861,837 boardings). Planning Department’s Audrey Merlone presented the commission’s recommendation, including a request to replace “properties” with “lots” and a requirement for a one-year report on the corridor’s condition. - Item 2: Notice for Housing Element Rezoning – Supervisor Connie Chan introduced the ordinance, which requires the Planning Department to notify property owners, residents, and commercial lessees within 300 feet of parcels proposed for upzoning. Notification would be via postcard with a QR code linking to a website with draft proposals, sample images, and legislative process information. The planning commission recommended modifications, including urging the Board to allocate resources for costs (estimated at $200,000 for production alone, excluding staff time and translation). Supervisor Chan circulated amendments to remove minimum font size and clarify that the website needs only sample images. Planning Department’s Veronica Flores noted the estimate could rise with the final map and that staff time is not included. Deputy Director Joshua Switsky stated that direct community engagement has been more effective than mailers. Supervisor Melgar expressed concerns about the cost and noted that previous large rezonings (Eastern Neighborhoods, Central SoMa) did not include such notification. She acknowledged the need for housing for the next generation but questioned the plan’s effectiveness. The committee debated the necessity and cost, with Supervisor Chan arguing for transparency and language access. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt the amendments presented by Supervisor Sherrill (extending boundary to Chestnut Street and adding the CUA provision for former formula retail without CUA). The ordinance was then continued to the April 21, 2025 meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee (vote 3-0). Supervisor Melgar added herself as a co-sponsor. - Item 2: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to adopt Supervisor Chan’s amendments (removing minimum font size, clarifying sample images). A motion to send the amended ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors without recommendation passed 2-1, with Vice Chair Chen dissenting. The item will appear on the Board’s April 22, 2025 agenda.

LAND USE 64% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10% · PROCEDURAL 9%
472
APR 10, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - April 10, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on Thursday, April 10, 2025, beginning at 12:15 PM and concluding after 7:00 PM. The agenda included continuances, consent items, a land acknowledgement, commission comments on economic uncertainty, and three regular calendar items: a zoning amendment for entertainment uses in Western SoMa, a request to increase private event closures at a privately-owned public open space (POPOS), and an informational presentation on the city's Housing Element rezoning program. The meeting drew substantial public attendance, with over 100 speakers on the final item. Consent Calendar - Items 1-5 (Continuances): The Commission unanimously voted to continue several items as proposed: Item 1 (447 Battery/530 Sansome EIR) to April 17, 2025; Item 2 (788 Arkansas Street) withdrawn; Item 4 (2588 Mission Street DR and Density Bonus) to May 1, 2025; Item 5 (1533 Sloat Boulevard Planet Fitness) to May 22, 2025. - Items 6-7 (Consent Calendar): Item 6 (524 Howard Street – temporary parking lot extension) and Item 7 (3065 16th Street – escape room) were approved unanimously (7-0) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed neighborhood character, tourism, parking shortages, vacant units (a speaker cited 13.3% vacancy), and concerns about the Planning Department's approach. One speaker urged preserving ethnic diversity and criticized cookie-cutter development. Another speaker argued that San Francisco has a safety and affordability crisis, not a housing supply crisis. - On Item 13 (Entertainment in SoMa): No public comment was offered. - On Item 14 (1 Sansome Street): Speakers largely supported the request, including nearby business owners, the Hotel Council of San Francisco, a tenant in the building (who noted the space was key to attracting Databricks for a 150,000 sq ft lease), and a representative from Supervisor Sauter's office. Two speakers expressed caution about privatization of public space, one suggesting a sunset clause. - On Item 15 (Housing Element Rezoning): Over 100 speakers provided testimony, split roughly evenly. Supporters (including members of D9 Neighbors for Housing, SF YIMBY, and Grow the Richmond) emphasized the need to build more housing to address affordability, retain families, and support transit and small businesses. Many requested including Bernal Heights in the upzoning. Opponents (including the Race and Equity in All Planning Coalition, Senior and Disability Action, and others) argued the plan would lead to gentrification, displacement of rent-controlled housing and small businesses, and would not produce truly affordable units. They called for stronger tenant protections, dedicated affordable housing funding, and community-led planning. Several speakers questioned the state-mandated Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) numbers, citing a 13.3% vacancy rate and population decline. Discussion Items - Item 13 – Entertainment Uses in Western SoMa (Planning Code Amendment): Presented by Supervisor Dorsey's office and Planning staff. The ordinance would eliminate the 200-foot buffer for nighttime entertainment uses in the Western SoMa Special Use District (SUD) and principally permit entertainment at 655 Folsom Street. Staff explained that the buffer has been whittled away by carve-outs and is confusing. The change is supported by the Leather & LGBTQ Cultural District, SoMa West Community Benefit District, and Yerba Buena Partnership. The Commission discussed the modest impact and retained protections (entertainment commission permits, good neighbor policy). Commissioners expressed support, noting it simplifies the code and reflects the neighborhood's identity. The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to recommend approval. - Item 14 – 1 Sansome Street (POPOS Closure Increase): The applicant requested to increase full weekday closures from 12 to 36 per year for private events, with no change to partial closures. Staff confirmed that in 2024 the applicant exceeded the allowed full closures by 5 days (17 vs 12) due to recordkeeping errors, but the applicant has since implemented monthly reporting. The Commission discussed the importance of maintaining the public character of the POPOS, but many recognized the benefit of activating downtown. Commissioner Moore noted that different POPOS have different uses. The Commission approved the request with conditions, including monthly reports to the Zoning Administrator (amending the existing 6-month reporting requirement). Vote: 7-0. - Item 15 – Expanding Housing Choice (Housing Element Rezoning Program): Planning staff presented an updated draft zoning map and proposed local program to meet the city's RHNA of 82,000 new homes (shortfall of 36,000 units after accounting for pipeline). Key changes include form-based zoning (density decontrol) in residential areas off main corridors (40-foot height limit, no state density bonus allowed), transitional buffer areas up to 50 feet, mid-rise buildings (65-85 feet) on transit/commercial corridors, and high-rise zones (140+ feet) at major transit hubs. The local program is designed as an alternative to the state density bonus, offering a menu of waivers and concessions to incentivize use. Staff emphasized that demolition of tenant-occupied or rent-controlled housing is not the goal, and that tenant protection ordinances and small business strategies are being developed concurrently. Commission discussion focused on affordable housing funding, the need for on-site inclusionary housing, refining height transitions (avoiding “shark fins”), and including Bernal Heights. Commissioner Moore suggested using GIS and 3D simulation tools for better visualization. Commissioner Williams stressed that the plan is state-mandated and that affordable housing must be prioritized. No vote was taken (informational). Key Outcomes - Item 13: Approved recommendation to Board of Supervisors (7-0). - Item 14: Approved mandatory discretionary review with modified conditions (monthly reporting) (7-0). - Item 15: Informational; no vote. The Commission directed staff to continue refining the map, especially considering feedback on specific neighborhoods (e.g., Bernal Heights, Jordan Park, North Beach), and to return with additional hearings on tenant protections (April 17) and small business strategies. - Commission Comments: The Commission tasked staff with providing an analysis of federal economic uncertainty (tariffs, housing financing) and its impact on San Francisco. The Commission also noted the importance of meeting the January 2026 state deadline to avoid the builder's remedy.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 36% · LAND USE 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 12% · PROCEDURAL 6%
473
APR 9, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting – April 9, 2025

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, April 9, 2025, at approximately 11:15 AM PDT (18:15 UTC) in City Hall. Chair Connie Chan presided, joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joel Engardio. The committee considered 14 agenda items covering real estate leases, the 10-year capital plan, PUC contract amendments, Mission Rock park agreements, Sunnydale HOPE SF affordable housing financing, a shelter lease, and multiple homeless supportive housing grant amendments. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, several after amendments. Real Property Lease – Chinatown Community Children’s Center (Item 1) - The committee approved a 10-year lease (with two 10-year renewal options) at $1 per year for approximately 6,000 square feet in the City Hall basement to Chinatown Community Children’s Center (4Cs) for a child care center serving up to 36 children. The space has been vacant since 2021. - Non-substantive amendments were adopted, correcting text in the resolution to satisfy administrative code requirements for below‑market-rate leases. - The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) estimated the city forgoes about $200,000 per year in market rent and provides janitorial services ($30,000/yr) plus utilities and security. Tuition subsidies by the Department of Early Childhood could cost up to $1.2 million annually if all families receive full subsidies (starting 2027). - Public comment: Tiffany Reyes (Low Income Investment Fund) spoke in strong support, noting the center will serve city workers and the broader community with a focus on infants and toddlers. - Key Outcome: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). 10‑Year Capital Expenditure Plan FYs 2026‑2035 (Item 2) - Brian Strong, Chief Resilience Officer, presented the capital plan, now exceeding $50 billion ($52 billion over 10 years). The plan includes investments in affordable housing, infrastructure, parks, transportation, and debt management. The general fund backlog for facilities renewals stands at $1 billion; without sustained funding it could rise to $1.4 billion by 2035. - Discussion explored authorized but unused general obligation bond dollars, the city’s debt capacity constraints (capped at 0.14% of property tax ad valorum rate), and mechanisms to accelerate debt repayment or reprioritize capital projects. - Public comment: Five speakers (Joni Eisen, Elena Engel, Rosemary Jarrett, Dr. Robert Gould, Julie Lindo) urged rejection or revision of the plan to include a dedicated climate bond for greenhouse gas emission reductions. They emphasized health impacts, the need to fund the Climate Action Plan, and inclusion of the Department of Environment on the Capital Planning Committee. - Chair Chan committed to further discussions on adding Department of Environment to the Capital Planning Committee and reviewing unused bond authorizations. - Key Outcome: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). PUC Contract Amendments – East Bay Construction Management & Technical Services (Items 3 & 4) - Item 3: Approved Amendment No. 1 to a construction management contract (CPM/CM Pros JV) for the East Bay region, increasing the not‑to‑exceed amount by $25 million (from $9 million to $34 million) and extending the term two years (to June 2030). The increase is driven by scope, cost, and schedule growth on three major water projects (Alameda Creek Recapture, Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation and short‑term improvements). Construction costs rose from $85 million to $235 million for the ozonation project alone. - Item 4: Approved amendments to four specialized technical services contracts (Stantec JHCE JV, MMD JV, AECOM/WRE JV, Lee Incorporated), each increasing by $5.5 million for a new total of $13 million per contract ($52 million total). No term extension. Funds support capital planning, asset management, wildfire risk, and skill‑gap training for aging infrastructure (dams, transmission lines). - BLA noted both items are funded by utility revenues and recommended approval. Committee members praised the contextual presentation showing low percentages relative to total project costs. - No public comment. - Key Outcome: Both items forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). Mission Rock – Park Lease, Licenses, and Management Agreements (Item 5) - Approved an ordinance waiving competitive bidding to execute a park lease and loan, open space management agreements, and utility licenses with affiliates of the Mission Rock developer (Seawall Lot 337 Associates LLC). China Basin Park (completed as part of Phase 1) will be managed by the developer’s master association for a 15‑year initial term with three 5‑year renewal options. The port will provide a loan of up to $800,000 over three years to cover operating deficits. Originally Rec & Park was to fund the loan, but the port will now directly fund it. Public access hours: 6 AM–10 PM (bathrooms 8 AM–8 PM). Large events limited to 100 days per year and cannot exceed 30,000 square feet. - Licenses allow PG&E to maintain gas and electric lines, and Mission Rock Utilities to operate district energy and blackwater recycling systems (66‑year terms). - BLA noted the waiver of competitive procurement is a policy decision; committee members supported the efficiency of using the developer’s affiliate. - No public comment. - Key Outcome: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). Sunnydale HOPE SF Affordable Housing Financing – Blocks 7 and 9 (Items 6‑9) - Approved financing for two 100% affordable housing developments at the Sunnydale HOPE SF site: - Block 7 (Item 6): Multifamily housing revenue note up to $53,305,000 and loan (Item 7) up to $18,050,000. 89 units (67 replacement units for existing public housing residents at 50% AMI; 22 lottery units at 70% AMI). Total development cost $107.6 million, leveraging state ASIC funds ($18.5 million), tax credits, and private loans. Construction starts late May 2025, completion February 2027. - Block 9 (Item 8): Multifamily housing revenue bonds up to $57,075,000 and loan (Item 9) up to $30,200,000. 95 units (71 replacement at 50% AMI; 24 lottery at 80% AMI). Total development cost $113.5 million. Same construction timeline. - BLA noted city funding per unit is between $200,000 and $300,000 per unit. Committee members highlighted the importance of these reparative investments. - No public comment. - Key Outcome: Item 6 amended (deleting references to permanent lender assignment) then all four items forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). Monarch Hotel Lease – Non‑Congregate Temporary Shelter (Item 10) - Retroactively approved a one‑year lease (April 1, 2025 – March 31, 2026) with Lombard Hotel Group for the Monarch Hotel (1015 Geary Street) as a non‑congregate shelter (102 units). Annual base rent $1,597,320 plus a final payment of $100,000 upon surrender. The item had been continued from a prior meeting for substantive amendments. - No public comment. - Key Outcome: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0). Homeless Supportive Housing Grant Amendments (Items 11‑14) Four grant amendments were approved, all with extensions through June 2027 to align with a planned reprocurement of the city’s homeless housing portfolio: - Item 11 – Abode Services (Adult Rapid Rehousing): Increase by $8,511,165 (amended downward) for a total not‑to‑exceed $18,402,770. Serves up to 240 adults (expanded from 120). 97% successful housing placement and 97% retention at 12 months. Funded by homelessness gross receipts tax. - Item 12 – Episcopal Community Services (Henry Hotel PSH): Amendment reduced from 36 to 24 months; increase by $5,808,651 for a total of $20,400,596. Serves 121 units for formerly homeless adults. Rent collection rate 47% (post‑eviction moratorium issue). BLA noted legacy site costs 30‑50% less per unit than newer PSH sites. - Item 13 – Five Keys (Artmar Hotel – Transitional Aged Youth PSH): Increase by $4.9 million for a total of $13.9 million. 60 units serving young adults (33% LGBTQ). Funded by homelessness gross receipts tax. - Item 14 – Mission Action/Dolores Street Emergency Shelter: Increase by $8.5 million for a total of $18.5 million. 91 beds (expanding to 152 beds in fall 2025). Bilingual, culturally responsive shelter serving largely Latinx community; includes Jazzy’s Place (nation’s first LGBTQ shelter). Funded by general fund. - Committee discussion focused on cost disparities, rent collection challenges, and the need for tiered service models. Vice Chair Dorsey raised concerns about community relations with Abode Services at City Gardens and 1174 Folsom. - No public comment. - Key Outcome: Items 11 and 12 amended (reducing amounts/terms as presented); all four items forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3‑0).

HOMELESSNESS 16% · CAPITAL PLANNING 15% · PROCEDURAL 10% · PUBLIC WORKS 10%
474
APR 9, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting – April 9, 2025

The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, April 9, 2025, with a quorum present. The meeting covered routine recognitions, reports from the Chief of Police and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), a presentation on SPARKS reports, a review of the AB 481 annual report on military-grade equipment, and a closed session vote. Weekly Officer Recognition - Officer Raymond Ortiz (Star 4189), a 22-year veteran of the SFPD with 12 years in the Crime Scene Investigations (CSI) unit, was recognized for going above and beyond. Director Powell highlighted his dedication to the swing shift, his volunteerism for on-call duties, and his work processing a complex scene while exposed to residual tear gas, resulting in a 30-page report. Officer Ortiz expressed gratitude and pride in his work and colleagues. Consent Calendar - The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to receive and file the consent calendar, which included a luncheon donation from the California State Automotive Association valued at $9,851.84 and SFPD's and DPA's SB 1421 and SB 16 monthly report for March 2025. DPA Director’s Report - Executive Director Paul Henderson provided updates on DPA activities: - Case X Deep Dive: Henderson explained that Case X was a policy failure case over 270 days old. He noted that while the average number of cases exceeding 270 days dropped from six in 2023 to two in 2025, the fourth quarter saw a spike in late document requests from SFPD, rising to 17% (from 6.5% in the first three quarters). He emphasized that DPA tracks such delays and reports them. Commissioner Yee asked about the cause, and Chief Scott said he would look into the trend and provide an update. - Award: Steve Flaherty won the 2024 Distinguished Knight Award from the Association of Local Government Auditors for his audit of SFPD Stop Data. This was DPA's third consecutive Knighton Award and fourth in five years. Henderson and multiple commissioners praised Flaherty's work, and Commissioner Benedicto suggested inviting him to a future commission meeting. - Operational Stats: Since the last meeting, DPA opened 15 new cases and closed 9. There are currently 15 investigations open for more than 270 days, 14 of which are on hold. 93 cases are pending with the Chief's office, and two with the Commission. - Interns: The DPA intern cohort was introduced and will present their work later. Chief’s Report - Chief Scott reported that overall Part One crimes are down 30% year-to-date (about 4,000 fewer crimes), with violent crime down 16% and property crime down 32%. He credited the Real-Time Investigation Center (RTIC), which has contributed to over 500 arrests since its launch in early 2024, including 207 via Flock ALPR, 43 via drones, 166 stolen vehicle arrests, and 80 robbery arrests. - He highlighted National Crime Victims' Rights Week (April 6–12), with a ceremony held at Golden Gate Park, which included Mayor Daniel Lurie and District Attorney Brooke Jenkins. Commissioners Scott, Yi, and Leong attended. - Homicides are at 4 this year compared to 9 at this time last year; the clearance rate is 125%. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto reported that DGO 6.16 (sexual assault investigations) is now in public comment, and DGO 7.01 draft is expected by end of week. The District Boundaries Project is open for comment until May 20, 2025. SPARKS Report Presentation - Captain Chris Del Gandio (SFPD) and Director Jermaine Jones (DPA) presented the fourth quarter 2024 and first quarter 2025 SPARKS reports. Highlights included updates on DGOs under development (18 in Q4, 21 in Q1), 24 and 29 department notices respectively, and progress on working groups. DPA’s report mentioned policy failures related to conflict of interest, sexual assault warrants, and missing persons cases. AB 481 Annual Report - The department presented the AB 481 annual report on military-grade equipment. Key points included: - Community engagement: Held meetings at seven police stations; questions focused on drones, pursuits, and sideshows. - Equipment: 17 unmanned ground vehicles (used 40 times), one armored vehicle (BearCat, used 42 times, minimal annual cost), command and control vehicles, 38 flashbang deployments, 37 LRAD uses, and 63 drones (deployed 350 times). The department seeks to acquire 24 additional drones. - No complaints or violations were received regarding the use of these items. - Commissioner Clay praised the report for being posted on time and transparent. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously (6-0). - Vote to Hold Closed Session: Unanimously approved (6-0). - Vote to Not Disclose Closed Session: Unanimously approved (6-0). - Chief Scott agreed to provide a follow-up on the cause of the fourth quarter document request delays. - DGO 6.16 entered public comment; DGO 3.02 closed concurrence and will be prepared for commission submission. - The department will continue to provide quarterly updates on the Stop Data audit implementation.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 31% · PUBLIC COMMENT 21% · PUBLIC SAFETY 21% · PROCEDURAL 13%
475
APR 8, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PORT COMMISSION
San Francisco Port Commission Meeting - April 8, 2025

The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, April 8, 2025, at 10:30 AM. The meeting covered a wide range of waterfront issues including cruise operations, safety concerns raised by longshore workers, a proposed extension of the Central Waterfront Navigation Center, and updates on port projects. The commission also approved consent items and set new business items for future reports. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2518 (Item 10A): Approved a second amendment of lease L1302 granting Martin Marietta Northern California Aggregates LLC a one-time retroactive rent credit of $335,000 for delays outside their control during window work operations at Pier 94. - Resolution 2519 (Item 10B): Authorized advertising for competitive bids for a low-bid maintenance dredging project (contract 2885) with a five-year term. - Both resolutions were adopted unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Public Comment on Items Not Listed on the Agenda (Item 8): Demetrius Williams, President of ILWU Local 10, raised safety concerns about two incidents. First, on March 31, 2025, at Pier 35, the cruise ship Koeiing Dam broke loose with lines launching into the bay, causing the gangway to fall into the water and requiring a tugboat recall. He stated this created significant danger to longshoremen and passengers. Second, he described unsafe working conditions at Pier 80 on March 22–23, 2025, during sailboat launches where workers were observed without hard hats, safety vests, or shields. He read a letter from May 25, 2023, warning Metro Cruiser against allowing crew members to perform gearmen work in violation of union agreements. He urged the port to use ILWU dock workers to ensure safety. President Kimberly Brandon thanked him and asked Executive Director Elaine Forbes to update the commission on discussions with ILWU Local 10. - No public comment was offered on the Executive Director’s Report, the Consent Calendar, or the Navigation Center presentation. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A): Elaine Forbes reported that the port’s staff recognition event (“Breakfast of Champions”) was held March 21 with Mayor Lurie. April is peak cruise season: a cruise call occurs every four days in April, every other day in May, with 91 calls and an estimated 365,000 passengers booked for the year – a steady growth reflecting trends of fuller ships. The port secured an emergency dredge permit to maintain cruise operations. A sculpture “Sound Turns to Noise” was moved to New York; a new sculpture “Revolution” from Burning Man will be unveiled April 10 at Embarcadero Plaza. The BIPOC Women Makers pop-up at the Ferry Building (12 events since 2022) continues successfully. The Pier 50 career fair is scheduled for April 16. The Mission Rock development earned a partnering award; new businesses include Bakery Artist Cult and Flower Plus Water. Fisherman’s Wharf Benefits District hired Brie McLaughlin as executive director. - Commissioner Questions: - Commissioner Stephen Lee asked whether the San Francisco Visitors Bureau provides information to cruise passengers beyond Pier 39, to direct them to other businesses. Forbes agreed to look into it. - Commissioner Stephen Englum requested an updated economic impact report (last data found from 2006/2020) to better communicate cruise’s economic contribution (estimated 5% of tourism economy). He emphasized telling a powerful story about jobs and the waterfront. - Commissioner Willie Adams expressed concern about the Pier 35 incident and urged a good relationship with ILWU Local 10, 75, and 3491. He stressed safety for passengers and workers. - Vice President Gail Gilman requested an informational report on developing Pier 80 as a secondary cruise launch site, noting the trebled asset at Pier 35 may be unsuitable. She also asked for a breakdown between full-turn cruises (passengers starting/ending in SF) and intermediate port calls, as they represent different economic drivers. - President Brandon praised the staff and noted the importance of the cruise sector. - Central Waterfront Navigation Center Proposed MOU (Item 11A): Assistant Deputy Director Kimberly Beale and HSH’s Emily Cohen presented a proposed five-year MOU to continue operating the 64-bed low-barrier shelter at 625 Third Street (on a temporary street vacation site). The current MOU expires at the end of April 2025. Occupancy was 98% last month; the operator Five Keys has met or exceeded all service objectives, including 100% intake/assessment and 100% of guests offered referrals. The MOU would generate about $7,400/month in rent plus $29,000 for the Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund. The port can terminate with six months’ notice if the site is needed for a public trust purpose. - Commissioner Questions: - Commissioner Englum asked about physical facility condition (eight years old, well-maintained, no capital needs anticipated) and outcome data. Cohen highlighted the shelter’s role in reducing homelessness system-wide. - Commissioner Adams voiced strong support, citing the social conscience of the port and the reality that homelessness can happen to anyone. - Commissioner Lee asked about average length of stay (approximately six months) and noted positive community reception despite initial pushback. - Vice President Gilman emphasized prioritizing District 10 residents for placement and asked why five years instead of longer (it was always intended as temporary). Staff confirmed outreach teams focus on District 10. - President Brandon noted the unanimous letter of support from the Dogpatch Neighborhood Association and expressed support overall. However, she raised a process concern: the MOU will be signed under delegated authority but was presented as an informational item without prior input from the Southern Waterfront Advisory Committee (SAC). The SAC meeting is April 23, after the next Port Commission meeting on April 22. Staff acknowledged the oversight and will send out a notice to solicit comments. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar approved unanimously (Resolutions 2518 and 2519). - New business items added: 1. Report on Pier 80 viability for cruise operations. 2. Update on economic impact report (last from 2020, needs updating and posting on website). 3. Update on the meeting with ILWU Local 10 (per Commissioner Adams’ request). 4. Maritime projects update, including offshore wind (from a recent trip to Long Beach) and federal policy trends from the AAPA conference. - Navigation Center MOU: The informational presentation was received; staff will notify the SAC and report back at the next commission meeting if substantive comments arise. The MOU will move forward under delegated authority unless concerns warrant commission action.

PROCEDURAL 53% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · HOMELESSNESS 17% · PUBLIC WORKS 4%
476
APR 8, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - April 8, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, April 8, 2025, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, public comment, special orders for commendations and an appeal hearing, and consideration of several resolutions. Supervisor Sauter was excused due to the birth of his child. The board adopted numerous items, including resolutions on police commission purposes, leases, housing finance, and a condemnation of the Alien Enemies Act. Consent Calendar - Items 1–9 were approved unanimously (10–0). These included settlements: Coinbase, Inc. ($1,600,000); Lester Hogan ($50,000); Ada M. Guzman ($45,000); Veronica Fulton ($40,000); Michael E. Johnson, et al. (City to receive $100,000); The Nederlander Company LLC dba Broadway San Francisco, LLC ($55,000); Hanover Insurance Company ($265,909); Idemitsu Americas Holdings Corporation ($318,002.04); CSAA Insurance Exchange (City to receive $37,929.81). Public Comments & Testimony - Early Childhood Education: Multiple speakers (Quinn, Lourdes Alarcon, Alan Wong, Ashley Milbarn, Barbara Walden, and others) urged the board to protect Baby Prop C funding, expand parental choice in child care, improve educator compensation, and support Black early educators and children. One speaker noted a 60% reduction in child abuse and neglect over 20 years. - Alien Enemies Act Resolution: A dozen speakers (including Joyce Nakamura, Carl Takei, Francisco Ugarte, and representatives from Asian Law Caucus and Public Defender’s Office) expressed strong support for the resolution condemning President Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act. They shared personal and historical accounts of Japanese American incarceration and called for repeal through the Neighbors Not Enemies Act. - Other Public Comments: Several speakers addressed veterans’ issues (Anthony Garcia, Chris Ford Klein), the need for town halls in the Castro, concerns about permit delays, and a request to honor peace activist David Hartso. One speaker urged the city to replicate successful harm-reduction strategies from UN Plaza (e.g., public exercise equipment). Another speaker criticized the city’s funding cuts to transgender programs. Discussion Items - Special Order 2:30 PM – Commendations: The board recognized Mary and Edmund Wu of Petrayo Terrace Market for 65 years of community service in District 10, and Chris Duderstadt for building over 215 public benches across San Francisco through the Public Bench Project. - Appeal of Conditional Use Authorization – 4100 Third Street (Items 19–22): The appellant, Babat Brackett, withdrew her appeal after reaching an agreement with project sponsor Friends of the Children SF Bay Area to preserve historic elements and allow displaced entrepreneurs to return post-renovation. The board then voted 10–0 to approve the Conditional Use Authorization (Item 20) and table Items 21 and 22. - Roll Call for Introductions: Supervisor Mahmood introduced a resolution declaring April as Autism Awareness Month, sharing her own autism diagnosis and noting that one in 36 children nationally and a 30% increase in diagnoses in San Francisco. Supervisor Mandelman introduced resolutions recognizing Education and Sharing Day (April 9, 2025) and honoring peace activist David Hartso. Supervisor Chan introduced a resolution urging an affordable housing site strategy. Supervisor Sheryl introduced a resolution marking the 83rd anniversary of the Bataan Death March. - For Adoption Without Committee Reference: Items 26–38 were adopted unanimously except for Items 30, 31, and 35 which were severed. Item 30 (fee waivers for Detroit Steps Project) was sent to the Budget and Finance Committee. Item 31 (resolution condemning Alien Enemies Act) was amended to clarify language on page 1, line 25, then adopted unanimously. Item 35 (Week of the Young Child resolution) was adopted without objection. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda: Approved 10–0. - Regular Agenda Items 10–18 (new business): All approved without objection. These included the Police Commission statement of purpose, lease at 300 Jefferson Street, multifamily housing revenue notes for 850 Turk Street (not to exceed $64 million), loans for three affordable housing projects (Bernal Bundle, up to $11.6 million), a no-cost MOU with InnovateUS, behested payment waiver for India Basin Waterfront Park, Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone ordinance, appointment of Amerika Nachele Sanchez to Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, and appointment of Meghan Wallace to Treasury Oversight Committee. - Committee Report Item 23 (600 Townsend Street West Special Use District): Adopted without objection. - Appeal Hearing (4100 Third Street): Appellant withdrew; CU authorization approved 10–0. - Resolutions Adopted Unanimously (Items 31 and 35): Resolution condemning Alien Enemies Act (as amended); Week of the Young Child resolution. - Motions Approved Unanimously: Adjournment in memory of David Hartso.

PUBLIC COMMENT 31% · PROCEDURAL 14% · EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION 10% · PUBLIC HEALTH 9%
477
APR 8, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
SFPUC Commission Meeting, April 8, 2025: Toilet Rebates, Power Rates, Digital Equity Grant

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) met on April 8, 2025, at 9:30 a.m. The Commission approved the minutes of the March 25, 2025 meeting, adopted an ultra-high efficiency toilet rebate program, approved a 10% rate increase for Hetch Hetchy Power service (with no change to CleanPowerSF rates), amended cabin rental fees at Camp Mather, and revised the Southeast Community Center Digital Equity Operator Grant program, increasing funding and expanding services. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (March 25, 2025): Approved unanimously (4–0) without discussion or public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): One caller, referencing a 2021 open letter signed by 68 retired San Francisco Fire Department officers, criticized the SFPUC's plan to use drinking water for post-earthquake firefighting on the west side. The caller argued the plan is unreliable and could lead to destruction of neighborhoods. - Item 8 – Digital Equity Grant: Damian Posey, new Chair of the Southeast Community Facility Commission, spoke in support of the grant revisions, emphasizing the digital divide in District 10 and thanking the Commission for its support. The Southeast Community Facility Commission had unanimously recommended approval on March 26, 2025. Discussion Items Item 6 – Ultra-High Efficiency Toilet Rebate Program Julie Ortiz (Water Conservation Manager) presented the new rebate program to replace toilets using 1.6 gallons per flush (gpf) or more with premium certified ultra-high efficiency models (≤1.1 gpf or ≤0.8 gpf). Key details: - Rebate levels: Up to $100 for 1.1 gpf models; up to $200 for 0.8 gpf models. - Estimated savings: Replacing 1,500 toilets per year would save 3 million gallons annually; over 50,000 toilets replaced to date saved 6.6 billion gallons total. - Target: 40% of existing toilets are 1.6 gpf; 15% are older 3.5+ gpf. - Program launch: July 2025; administered in-house; replaces expiring direct-install program. - Commission questions: Commissioner Leveroni asked about remaining old toilets and performance of 0.8 gpf models; Commissioner Jamdar inquired about differences from previous programs. Item 7 – Power Rates and Facility Rental Fee Update Matthew Freiburg (Rates Manager) presented the rate proposal for Hetch Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF. No rate change was proposed for CleanPowerSF. For Hetch Hetchy Power: - 10% increase across all rate tariffs, effective with meter readings on or after July 1, 2025. - Three-cent per kilowatt-hour increase for legacy General Use (Goosey) and Tuolumne County customers, moving them toward cost-of-service rates. - New rate tariff (IR1T) for industrial customers receiving transmission-level voltage in Stanislaus County. - Bill comparisons: Residential Hetch Hetchy customers will pay $86/month (up $8) vs. an estimated PG&E rate of $102+; low-income discount customers will pay $60/month (up $5). - CleanPowerSF: Staff reported that lower power purchase costs allow the enterprise to achieve its 180-day cash-on-hand target without a rate increase. Residential rates remain $3/month more than PG&E due to a negative Power Choice Index Adjustment (PCIA); staff expect this to equalize within a year. - Camp Mather Cabin 2: Rental fee set at $270/night (resident rate) for the remainder of FY2025-26, increasing to $275 on July 1, 2026, to recoup upkeep costs. - Commissioner Leveroni asked about PG&E’s wildfire costs and the SFPUC’s own wildfire mitigation efforts. Vice President Arce highlighted the advantage of Hetch Hetchy rates vs. PG&E and expressed interest in long-term strategies to reduce CleanPowerSF’s dependence on market rates. Item 8 – Southeast Community Center Digital Equity Grant Revisions Elise Washington (Senior Administrative Analyst) presented revisions to the Digital Equity Operator Grant program: - Annual grant increase: From $125,000 to $200,000. - Expanded services: Job placement and workforce development, connecting residents to city apprenticeship programs, entrepreneurship workshops, and enhanced outreach. - Performance metrics: New service standards to evaluate impact and comply with Controller’s Office requirements. - Outcomes (FY2023-24): Nearly 100 individuals served; 98% received tech support or internet access. - Commissioner Leveroni noted the increase from $125k to $200k and growth in participants. Vice President Arce praised the program’s impact and the unanimous recommendation of the Southeast Community Facility Commission. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Minutes): Approved 4–0. - Item 6 (Toilet Rebate Program): Approved 4–0. - Item 7 (Power Rates & Cabin Fee): Approved 4–0. Hetch Hetchy rates increase 10% effective July 1, 2025; Camp Mather cabin fee established at $270/night (rising to $275 in FY2026-27). CleanPowerSF rates unchanged. - Item 8 (Digital Equity Grant): Approved 4–0. Annual grant increased to $200,000 with expanded services. - Closed Session: The Commission met in closed session (Item 12) to assert attorney-client privilege and discuss pending litigation. No disclosures were made upon returning to open session; the meeting adjourned.

PROCEDURAL 29% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · ENERGY MANAGEMENT 13% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 11%
478
APR 7, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - April 7, 2025: Hearings on Alice Griffith Housing, Nonprofit Reporting, Appointments, and Military Equipment Policy

The San Francisco Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Shamann Walton and joined by President Rafael Mandelman and Vice Chair Supervisor Catherine (Sherrill), held a regular meeting on April 7, 2025 at 6:15 PM UTC. The meeting addressed a hearing on mistreatment at Alice Griffith Apartments, an ordinance amending nonprofit reporting requirements, several board appointments, and the Sheriff's Office military equipment annual report. Public Comments & Testimony - Alice Griffith Hearing: Multiple residents and community advocates spoke about deplorable living conditions at Alice Griffith. Dwayne Gaines (Bayview Coordinating Council) described fire safety hazards, inoperable elevators, and allegations of developer lies. Sabrina Hall showed video of trash rooms and cited a letter expressing residents' disappointment after a March 20 DBI hearing focused on a light violation instead of broader issues. Lesonia Mansfield (Mansfield & Mansfield Construction) criticized McCormick Barron Salazar and John Stewart, citing a D rating, and called for firing both. Dennis Williams (Fillmore CDC) alleged soil contamination and that buildings should have been red-tagged. Micah Pinkston (Heart representing District 10) demanded community-led upkeep and economic inclusion under Section 3 of the HUD Act. Marie Visteau (resident since 2001) reported unmet reasonable accommodations for disabilities. Elisha Rochelle (Bayview Hunters Point Coordinating Council) spoke for two wheelchair-bound residents unable to leave their apartments due to broken elevators, and demanded enforcement of Section 3 and economic justice. - Nonprofit Reporting Item: Laura Thomas (San Francisco AIDS Foundation) expressed appreciation for protections. Debbie Lerman and Rocio Molina (San Francisco Human Services Network) praised the legislation for streamlining and protecting board members' safety. A domestic violence advocate thanked Supervisor Mandelman for addressing risks to vulnerable populations. Discussion Items - Hearing on Alice Griffith Apartments (File 250132): Chair Walton opened, stating residents face slow maintenance, pest control, trash removal, and inoperable elevators. He called on multiple entities to report. Dr. Tanya Letaju (Housing Authority CEO) reported 191 leased units out of 226, 35 vacant, utilization rate 85.5%, monthly cap $148,000, and $1.7 million in HAP loss due to abatement over three years. 62 units abated in 2024; 42 currently. She explained life-threatening conditions (e.g., gas leaks, electrical hazards) require 24-hour fix; other issues 30 days. Jennifer Wood (John Stewart Company) stated the property performed well pre-COVID, paying $5.6 million cash flow, but post-COVID faced depletion of reserves, rent arrears, subsidy confusion, and increased costs. She noted they prioritized security and pest control, restructured staffing into two management teams, and assisted residents with $1 million in rental assistance. Claudia Brody (McCormick Barron Salazar) said they funded $2.7 million in deficits, including $50,000 for elevator repairs that the company did not complete. She acknowledged struggles with limited resources. Thor Kaslofski (OCII) gave background on redevelopment dating to 2007, with 75 million from Choice Neighborhoods grant. LaShawn Walker (Five Point) described $80 million in infrastructure, and maintenance of perimeter streets and security. Director Dan Adams (MOHCD) stated their loan committee approved $500,000 on February 7 for urgent repairs, with work underway to assess capital needs. Akisha Porter (Bayview Hunters Point Multi-Senior Services) reported serving over 400 residents with case management, meal distribution, and rental assistance. Mike Martin (Port) said they have no direct role but abate nuisances in the area. Chair Walton questioned MBS and John Stewart about accountability, noting they chose to work in the community. Supervisor Sherrill asked about financial gaps and city assistance. President Mandelman called the situation shameful and noted systemic under-resourcing. - Nonprofit Reporting Ordinance (File 241209): Supervisor Mandelman presented amendments to limit reporting to organizations receiving over $1 million annually and permit redaction of information that could cause personal harm, following feedback from the City Administrator and community groups. He moved to forward with positive recommendation. - Appointments to Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee: Candidates presented for seats 3 and 15. Dr. John Ma (reappointment candidate) cited his role in the soda tax movement and health equity. Melinda Burris (current seat 3 holder) highlighted her work in Bayview and Treasure Island on nutrition and water access. Prashanti Patel (parent) emphasized school-based health and family voices. Chair Walton moved to appoint Burris and Patel, noting respect for Dr. Ma but desire to let a new member continue. - Appointments to Citizens’ General Obligation Bond Oversight Committee: Continued to call of chair per Supervisor Sherrill. - Appointments to Sheriff’s Department Oversight Board: Estella Natalie Ortiz (reappointment candidate) described her 15 years of community work and her goal to be an example. Neil Hallanan (new applicant) highlighted his 10 years as a public defender and private criminal defense practice, emphasizing the need for civilian oversight. Chair Walton moved to appoint both. - Appointment to Bay Conservation and Development Commission: Motion by Supervisor Mandelman to appoint Supervisor Matt Dorsey. - Military Equipment Use Policy (File 250017): Ronnie Singh (Sheriff's Office) presented the 2024 annual report and requested approval for a pepper ball launcher as new equipment, noting it is more targeted than previous items. She stated the investigation into the San Bruno incident is complete and settlement is pending. Chair Walton expressed philosophical concerns and moved to refer without recommendation, pending final report. Key Outcomes - Alice Griffith Hearing: Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous motion by Chair Walton, seconded by Vice Chair Sherrill, ayes all). The committee will hold periodic oversight. - Nonprofit Reporting Ordinance: Forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee: Melinda Burris appointed to seat 3 and Prashanti Patel to seat 15 (unanimous). - Citizens’ General Obligation Bond Oversight Committee: Continued to the call of the chair (unanimous). - Sheriff’s Department Oversight Board: Estella Natalie Ortiz to seat 2 and Neil Hallanan to seat 4 appointed (unanimous). - BCDC Appointment: Supervisor Matt Dorsey appointed (unanimous). - Military Equipment Use Policy: Referred to the full board without recommendation (unanimous). Chair Walton indicated he awaits the final investigation report before taking a position.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 35% · PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · PUBLIC HEALTH 9% · PROCEDURAL 7%
479
APR 7, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - April 7, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 7, 2025, at 9:45 AM (afternoon in transcript). Chair Mirna Melgar, Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen, and Member Bilal Mahmood were present. Supervisor Matt Dorsey attended for items he sponsored. The committee considered several ordinances and resolutions related to land use, zoning, and public infrastructure, primarily in Districts 6 and 8. All agenda items were approved unanimously except for one that was continued. Agenda Item 1: Planning Code – Production, Distribution, and Repair Districts (File 241196) - Discussion: The ordinance seeks to expand criteria for self-storage uses in PDR-2 districts and extend the sunset date. The item was continued from the previous meeting due to substantive amendments. No public comment was offered. - Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to recommend approval to the full Board of Supervisors. Agenda Item 2: 600 Townsend Street West Special Use District (File 250125) - Discussion: Supervisor Dorsey presented the ordinance to create a Special Use District at 600 Townsend Street to legalize long-standing office uses. The building is 94% occupied. The Planning Commission recommended approval 6-0. The ordinance waives or reduces certain requirements (bicycle parking, open space, etc.) and sets a fee structure consistent with the Eastern Neighborhoods program. A waiver from Class 2 bicycle parking was discussed; an amendment provided additional Class 1 spaces. Cecily Barclay, attorney for the property owner, expressed gratitude and support for the speedy process. - Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to send the ordinance as a committee report to the full Board for consideration on April 8, 2025. Agenda Item 8: Official Naming of Streets – Transbay Redevelopment Plan (File 250295) - Discussion: Supervisor Dorsey introduced a resolution to reserve street names East Clementina and East Tahama for new street extensions in the Transbay area. Cathal Hennessey from Public Works presented the need for addresses for planned child care and retail. The names add a cardinal direction to existing street names. Supervisor Mahmood humorously suggested more creative naming in the future. No public comment. - Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to recommend the resolution to the full Board. Agenda Items 3-6: Mission Rock Phase 1A Infrastructure and Permits (Files 250186, 250187, 250188, 250285) - Discussion: These four items were considered together. Shauna Gates from Public Works presented: - Item 3: Accept public infrastructure (streets, sidewalks) and amend Public Works Code for excavation permits in the Mission Rock Special Use District. - Item 4: Designate the Port of San Francisco as responsible for permitting minor sidewalk encroachments (tables, seating) in Mission Rock, Pier 70, and Potrero Power Station projects. - Item 5: Grant a master encroachment permit to Mission Rock Utilities Inc. for district utility systems (non-potable water, sewer, heating/cooling, fiber optic). - Item 6: Two encroachment permits: an interdepartmental master permit for the Port for non-standard improvements (public art, street furnishings), and a major encroachment permit for monitoring equipment for lightweight cellular concrete (LCC) fill used to mitigate settlement and raise the site five feet for sea level rise. The LCC monitors measure ground movement and groundwater. - Key Outcome: No public comment. Committee voted 3-0 to recommend all four items to the full Board. Agenda Item 7: Housing Plan Amendments – Mission Rock Project (File 250264) - Discussion: Chair Melgar requested continuation to allow further community conversations. The proposed amendment would reduce the per-phase inclusionary housing requirement from 30% to 20% for Phase 1 (but keep overall project requirement at 40%, per voter-approved ballot measure). The change would eliminate 150% Area Median Income (AMI) units and add 90% AMI units, described as deepening affordability. Supervisor Chen asked clarifying questions about impacts. Cynthia Gomez, a resident, requested more time for public engagement, noting the original ballot measure had extensive community input and this change had not received comparable attention. She supported the continuation. - Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to continue the item to the call of the chair. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned after completing all business.

LAND USE 27% · PUBLIC WORKS 24% · PROCEDURAL 22% · INFRASTRUCTURE 10%
480
APR 3, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting – April 3, 2025

This meeting of the San Francisco Planning Commission was held on Thursday, April 3, 2025, beginning at approximately 8:15 PM. Commissioners considered a range of items including continuances, consent calendar approvals, commission and department matters, several land use and zoning amendments, and one discretionary review. Key votes included approval of special use districts, a removal of formula retail conditional use requirements on Van Ness Avenue, a change to an inclusionary housing compliance method, and a denial of discretionary review for a new home. Consent Calendar - Items 4a, 4b (1400 John F. Kennedy Drive – AT&T wireless facility and coastal zone permit) and Item 5 (201 Mission Street – temporary parking lot extension) were approved unanimously (7-0) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: A speaker (Georgia Shutish) expressed concern about demolition calculations and the preservation of flat units, citing multiple examples of flat conversions. They urged the Commission to codify objective standards for the flat policy. - General Public Comment: Virginia Barker advocated for stronger tenant protection measures, including a one-year notice before demolition (similar to Ellis Act protections), clear city guidance for tenants, and warned against using relocation specialists. She also raised concerns about development agreement loopholes. - Item 11 (Van Ness Formula Retail): Bob Akis Vandiari, Executive Director of the San Francisco Democratic Party, expressed full support for the ordinance, noting the party unanimously passed a resolution endorsing it. He emphasized the corridor’s crisis and the need to reduce regulatory burdens. - Item 11: Kelly Hensley, a property owner on Van Ness Avenue, supported the ordinance but stressed that public safety and vandalism issues must also be addressed. She described four years of vacancy and financial losses, and urged action beyond permitting. - Item 14 (Market Street Inclusionary Housing): No public comment was offered. - Item 15 (585 Lakeview Avenue Discretionary Review): The DR requester, Ashley Klein on behalf of the Townsend family, asked for design modifications to improve light and air access for their adjacent property. The project sponsor (architect William Pearson) responded that the design was compliant and improvements were not feasible without undermining the project. Discussion Items - Item 13: 3250 19th Avenue Special Sign District – Supervisor Melgar and staff presented an ordinance to allow updated signage for the Chinese American International School (formerly Mercy High School). Staff recommended a modification to specify indirect illumination. The Commission unanimously adopted a recommendation for approval with the staff modification (7-0). - Item 12: Alexandria Theater Special Use District – Supervisor Chan presented an ordinance to redevelop the historic theater at 5400 Geary Boulevard into an 8-story, 75-unit residential building (80% family-sized, 12% affordable on-site). The project would preserve the facade, marquee, blade sign, interior murals, and chandelier. The SUD includes a 3-year deadline to obtain a building permit. Staff supported approval. Public comment from San Francisco Heritage (Woody LeBounty) endorsed the project. The Commission unanimously adopted a recommendation for approval (7-0). - Item 11: Removing Conditional Use for Formula Retail on Van Ness Avenue – Supervisor Sherrill’s office presented an ordinance to allow formula retail as principally permitted in RC4 and RC3 districts on Van Ness between Broadway and Redwood Street, citing a 50% ground-floor commercial vacancy rate (citywide average 7.7%). Staff recommended three modifications: (1) extend to RC3 parcels, (2) remove the CUA requirement when a new formula retail use replaces an existing one that lacked a CUA (e.g., prior grocery), and (3) a non-substantive wording change. The Commission discussed community engagement, legacy business protections, and design controls. A motion was made to approve with staff modifications plus a one-year report back on the RC3 extension. Motion passed unanimously (7-0). - Item 14: 1546-1564 Market Street – Inclusionary Housing Compliance Change – The project sponsor (Ryan Hong) requested to change from 13 on-site BMR units (55% AMI) to an in-lieu fee payment of approximately $6.8 million. The building (constructed in 2022) is 12 stories with 109 units, and the BMR units had not yet been marketed. Staff recommended approval. Commission debated the value of on-site vs. fee. A motion to approve carried 5-2 (Commissioners Imperial and Moore dissenting). - Item 15: 585 Lakeview Avenue – Discretionary Review – The project proposes a 3-story, 2,390 sq. ft. single-family home on a vacant lot. The DR requester (neighbor at 579 Lakeview) sought changes to improve light, articulation, and reduce excavation. Staff found the project compliant with design guidelines and recommended against taking DR. The Commission voted 7-0 to not take DR and approve the project as proposed. Key Outcomes - Items 1-3 (continuances) : Continued to May 1 and May 8, 2025 (6-0). - Consent Calendar (Items 4a, 4b, 5) : Approved 7-0. - Item 13 (3250 19th Ave SSD) : Recommendation for approval with staff modification adopted 7-0. - Item 12 (Alexandria Theater SUD) : Recommendation for approval adopted 7-0. - Item 11 (Van Ness Formula Retail) : Recommendation for approval with three staff modifications plus a one-year report back adopted 7-0. - Item 14 (1546-1564 Market Street) : Downtown Project Authorization to change inclusionary compliance to in-lieu fee approved 5-2. - Item 15 (585 Lakeview Avenue) : Discretionary Review not taken; project approved 7-0. Commission Matters & Department Updates - Land acknowledgement read. - Draft minutes for March 20, 2025 adopted 7-0. - Commissioner Moore requested a broader policy discussion on parking lot extensions; Commissioner Imperial requested a presentation on upcoming state housing legislation. - Director’s announcements: none. - Review of past events: Historic Preservation Commission approved legacy business registrations for Chile Lindo, La Victoria SF, Southern Exposure, and Winlong Hardware; expressed concern about delandmarkation at 447 Battery/530 Sansome; heard State Housing Law presentation.

HISTORIC PRESERVATION 15% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 15% · LAND USE 14% · DISCRETIONARY REVIEW 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com