The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on April 22, 2025, at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a consent agenda, new business, committee reports, roll call for introductions, a special order for commendations, and extensive public comment. Key actions included the passage of a housing element rezoning notice ordinance (8-3), approval of formula retail changes on Van Ness Avenue, adoption of multiple resolutions, and recognition of community leaders. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 5, including planning code amendments for Production, Distribution, and Repair Districts, Mission Rock public works codes, and nonprofit reporting, were approved unanimously on a single roll call vote. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers from the Citywide HUD Alliance, including residents of Alice Griffith, Plaza East, Thomas Paine Square, and other HUD-subsidized properties, testified about deplorable living conditions: mold, pests, broken elevators, structural damage, and lack of accountability from management. They called for Mayor Lurie to visit the communities and for increased oversight. Many expressed frustration with unreturned calls from supervisors. - Several speakers from the Arab Resource and Organizing Center (AROC) and community members thanked Supervisor Mahmoud for introducing the Arab American Heritage Month resolution and urged the board to stand against federal discrimination and hate violence. - Home bridge caregivers from SEIU 2015 spoke in support of additional funding for the program, citing low wages, safety risks, and the need for better training and livable wages. - Other speakers addressed unsolved homicides, surveillance technology, vacancy taxes, and the need for the city to address homelessness and addiction with harm reduction approaches. Discussion Items - Item 9 (Planning Code – Notice for Housing Element Rezoning): Ordinance requiring notice to property owners within 300 feet of rezoning sites. Debate centered on transparency versus potential alarm. Supervisor Chan, the sponsor, argued it empowers communities. Supervisors Dorsey and Melgar opposed, citing precedent and potential for unnecessary fear. The item was referred without recommendation from committee. Vote: 8-3 in favor (Chan, Chen, Engardio, Fielder, Mandelman, Sauter, Sherrill, Walton – yes; Dorsey, Mahmoud, Melgar – no). Passed on first reading. - Item 12 (Planning Code – Removing Conditional Use for Formula Retail on Van Ness): Sponsored by Supervisor Sherrill, the ordinance aims to reduce commercial vacancies on Van Ness Avenue (53% vacancy rate) by eliminating conditional use requirements for formula retail. Supported by local business associations. Passed unanimously. - Roll Call for Introductions: Supervisor Chen introduced a resolution recognizing May 10 as Transcontinental Chinese Railroad Workers’ Day. Supervisor Dorsey introduced a resolution of intent to create a downtown revitalization financing district for commercial-to-residential conversions, in partnership with Mayor Lurie and state legislation. Supervisor Mandelman introduced a resolution recognizing April 2025 as Earth Month. Supervisor Walton introduced the entitlement package for the ProLogis project at 749 Tolin Street in Bayview, which includes 2 million square feet of industrial space, $50 million in street upgrades, and community benefits. Special Order – Commendations - Supervisor Mahmoud honored Grace Horikiri, Executive Director of the Japantown Community Benefit District, for her leadership in community organizing, small business support, and cultural events. - Supervisor Dorsey honored Majors Darren and Mary Norton of the Salvation Army for their service to the homeless and addicted, particularly through The Way Out program. - Supervisor Melgar honored Her Church, a feminist Lutheran congregation, for its inclusive spiritual community and arts engagement. - President Mandelman honored Franco Stevens, founder of Curve magazine and the Curve Foundation, for her contributions to lesbian visibility and LGBTQ+ media. Key Outcomes - Item 9 (Housing element rezoning notice) passed on first reading with an 8-3 vote. - Item 10 (Content and data subscriptions ordinance) passed on first reading unanimously. - Items 11 and 12 (Special Sign District and formula retail on Van Ness) passed on first reading unanimously. - Items 15-17, 19, 20, 22-27 on the for-adoption calendar were adopted unanimously. - Item 18 (Arab American Heritage Month resolution) was adopted unanimously after being severed for a separate vote. - Item 21 (Affirming commitment to preserving BIPOC and LGBTQ+ history) was adopted unanimously after being severed. - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Otis Winfield Jr., as requested by Supervisor Walton.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on Monday, April 21, 2025, in the morning at City Hall. Chair Supervisor Shimon Walton presided, joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheryl and President Mandelman. The committee considered six agenda items: appointments to the Commission of Animal Control and Welfare, reappointments to the ABAG Executive Board, the annual surveillance report on surveillance technology, and an ordinance creating five new entertainment zones. All items were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - On the Animal Control Commission appointments, no public comments were received. - On the reappointments of Supervisors Mandelman and Dorsey to ABAG, no public comments were received. - On the annual surveillance report, no public comments were received. - On the entertainment zones ordinance, several public speakers expressed support: - Scott Roetz (Yerba Buena Partnership) spoke in full support of the Yerba Buena Lane entertainment zone, noting it already has eight small businesses and will not require a street closure permit. - Alex Sludlum (Soma West CBD) supported the Folsom Street entertainment zone, stating that the Soma Nights street fair was conceived out of merchant desperation and that City investment has been meaningful. - Jill Linwood (Yerba Buena Partnership) reiterated enthusiastic support and referenced a press conference on April 7, 2025, with the Mayor and business leaders. - Scott Gettner (President/CEO of Pier 39) supported the Pier 39 entertainment zone, stating it will create events for visitors and locals and provide relief to tourism businesses. - Chinny Amahera (Soma West CBD) expressed elation and noted that businesses are struggling and the designation recognizes their efforts. - John (John's Grill) supported the Ellis Street entertainment zone, stating that it will attract downtown businesses to promote and help revive struggling downtown. Discussion Items 1. Appointments to Commission of Animal Control and Welfare (Item 1) - Ten applicants for six seats. Each applicant gave a two-minute statement. Chair Walton thanked all and noted difficulty selecting from qualified candidates. - The committee voted to appoint: Michael Reed (Seat 1), Irina Ozernoff (Seat 2), Michaela Garfinkel (Seat 3), Nicholas Chapman (Seat 4), Dana Sherwood (Seat 5), and Michael Angelo Torres (Seat 6). Motion passed unanimously. 2. Reappointment of Supervisor Rafael Mandelman to ABAG Executive Board (Item 2) - Supervisor Mandelman recused himself. Motion to excuse passed. No public comment. Motion to forward his name with positive recommendation passed unanimously. 3. Reappointment of Supervisor Matt Dorsey to ABAG Executive Board (Item 3) - No recusal needed. No public comment. Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed unanimously. 4. Annual Surveillance Report Regarding Surveillance Technology (Item 4) - Presentation by Eddie McCaffrey (COIT Director) and Julia Cruchel (Privacy Analyst). They explained that Chapter 19B requires annual reports from departments with approved surveillance technology policies. The report covers November 1, 2023, to November 1, 2024, involving 23 departments, 11 technology categories, 46 policies for 51 technologies. Most policies saw no changes; some had shifts in authorized job titles or technology replacements. Facial recognition usage (prohibited) was reported as part of mandatory reporting. No public comment. Motion to accept resolution and forward to full board passed unanimously. 5. Entertainment Zones Ordinance (Item 5) - Ben Van Houten (Director of Nightlife Initiatives, OEWD) presented the ordinance to create five entertainment zones: Valencia Street, Pier 39, Folsom Street, Ellis Street, and Yerba Buena Lane. He described the zones as tools to activate streets and support economic recovery. He noted that the Valencia zone will support the Valencia Live night markets; Pier 39 in collaboration with the Port; Folsom Street aligns with Soma Nights; Ellis Street with John's Grill; and Yerba Buena Lane with the Yerba Buena Partnership. No questions from committee. After public comment, Chair Walton duplicated the file to allow addition of a Bayview Entertainment Zone, then moved the original file to the full board with a positive recommendation. Motion passed unanimously. The duplicated file was continued to the call of the chair. Key Outcomes - All six appointments to the Commission of Animal Control and Welfare were approved and forwarded to the full Board. - Reappointments of Supervisors Mandelman and Dorsey to ABAG were approved and forwarded. - The resolution accepting the annual surveillance report was approved and forwarded. - The ordinance creating five entertainment zones was approved and forwarded, with a duplicated file retained for potential addition of a Bayview zone. - All votes were unanimous without objection.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Monday, April 21, 2025, at 9:45 AM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood, considered seven agenda items. The meeting resulted in unanimous votes to recommend several ordinances to the full Board, continued one item, and adopted a resolution supporting the Sunset Chinese Cultural District's strategic plan. Consent Calendar (Routine Approvals) - None. All items received individual discussion and votes. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Formula Retail on Van Ness): A 40-year resident and property owner expressed 100% support for the ordinance, showing photos of his building over time and a nearby CVS. He urged supervisors to direct police to address crime to help businesses thrive. - Item 3 (Concrete Building Inventory): Sarah Atkinson (Spur) supported the legislation, calling it a crucial step for seismic resilience. She noted risks to lives, housing, business continuity, and sustainability. George Wooding supported the initial draft but urged stronger compliance requirements and disclosure laws similar to Japan. David O'Kane (structural engineer) supported, recommending a future mandatory retrofit mandate. Charlie Goss (San Francisco Apartment Association) supported, citing clarity for property owners wanting to retrofit voluntarily. Mitchell Omerberg (Affordable Housing Alliance) expressed concern about tenant displacement from retrofits and the risk of affordability loss. - Item 5 (Sunset Chinese Cultural District): Multiple speakers supported adoption of the Chess report, including Dr. Emily Murase (Japantown Cultural District), Lisa Xu (Sunset resident), Ben Wong (WAME), LeMal Leavett (consultant), Diane Chow (consultant), Angie Pettit (Sunset Mercantile), Mario Demira (Filipino Cultural Heritage District), Kimberly Zito (Asian Inc.), Gainer Ansiatanga (Pacific Islander Cultural District), and April Spears Mays (African American Arts and Cultural District). They highlighted extensive community engagement, cultural preservation, and the need for affordable housing and small business support. - Item 6 (ADU Condo Conversion): Eileen Bogan (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) criticized delays in posting amended legislation and questioned local need. Mitchell Omerberg raised concerns about tenant protections in existing ADUs and requested time to review the amendments. - Items 2, 4, and 7 had no public comments. Discussion Items - Item 1: Planning Code – Formula Retail on Van Ness Avenue - Lorenzo Rosas (Supervisor Cheryl's office) presented the ordinance to remove conditional use authorization for formula retail on Van Ness, with three amendments (two substantive) requiring a one-week continuance. The committee had received the full presentation previously. - Motion to send to full board as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 2: Planning Code – 3250 19th Avenue Special Sign District - Chair Melgar sponsored the ordinance to allow Chinese American International School to install signage on a property formerly Mercy High School. The Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval with a modification to permit indirect illumination. - Motion to amend and recommend to full board as a committee report (unanimous). - Item 3: Existing Building Code – Concrete Building Inventory Assessment - Brian Strong (Chief Resilience Officer) and Laurel Matthews (Office of Resilience) presented the ordinance to inventory seismically vulnerable concrete and tilt-up buildings and adopt voluntary retrofit standards. This followed 13 years of work since the community action plan for seismic safety. - Matthews read numerous non-substantive amendments into the record, including clarifying definitions, moving exemption language, and streamlining screening processes. - Supervisor Chen asked about outreach to mom-and-pop property owners, language access, and financial assistance. Staff responded that a FEMA grant will produce a financing guide within a year, and DBI plans extensive multilingual outreach and a mailing list. - Public comment included strong support and calls for future mandatory retrofits. - Motion to amend and recommend to full board as amended (unanimous). - Item 4: Declaration of City Property – 772 Pacific Avenue - William Wilcox (MOHCD) presented the resolution to declare 772 Pacific as exempt surplus land for 100% affordable housing (175 units for low-income seniors, 25% homeless). The property, acquired in 2017, will preserve a ground-floor banquet hall. The resolution helps compete for $32 million in state funding. - Supervisor Chen asked about future site acquisition RFPs; staff noted no current funding available after the failed regional bond. - Motion to recommend to full board (unanimous). - Item 5: Sunset Chinese Cultural District’s Cultural, History, Housing, and Economic Sustainability Strategy (CHESS) Report - Supervisor Engardio (District 4) spoke in strong support. Grace Lee (MOHCD) outlined the Cultural Districts Program and the importance of the CHESS report. Lily Wong (Sunset Chinese Cultural District) presented the six strategic areas: historic/cultural preservation, housing access/stabilization, economic/workforce development, land use, arts/culture, and cultural competency. - Community engagement statistics: over 3,000 community members, nearly 400 organizations, 150 in-person visits to small businesses, 245 visits to Chinese-owned businesses, 395 individuals contacted digitally, 2 in-person town halls, 5 community events, and interviews with community leaders. - Supervisor Chen added herself as a co-sponsor. - Motion to recommend to full board (unanimous). - Item 6: Planning, Subdivision Codes – Condominium Conversion of Accessory Dwelling Units - Supervisor Engardio presented the legislation to allow ADUs built under the state program to be titled and sold separately from the primary dwelling. He read amendments into the record, including limiting eligibility to new construction ADUs on lots with existing dwellings, moving requirements to the subdivision code, and clarifying that applications may be submitted concurrently. - Aaron Starr (Planning Department) confirmed the amendments reflected the Planning Commission’s February 13 recommendations. - Supervisor Engardio requested a one-week continuance to allow stakeholder review. - Motion to amend and continue to April 28, 2025 (unanimous). - Item 7: Planning Code – Entertainment Uses in South of Market - Supervisor Dorsey presented the ordinance to eliminate a 200-foot buffer restriction on nighttime entertainment uses in the Western SOMA Special Use District and permit entertainment at 655 Folsom. The legislation supports mixed-use neighborhoods, small businesses, and aligns with the Mayor’s entertainment zone expansion. No changes to underlying zoning. - Planning Commission recommended approval on April 10. - Motion to recommend to full board (unanimous). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Recommended to the Board of Supervisors as a committee report (vote: 3-0), to appear on April 22 agenda. - Item 2: Recommended as amended (unanimous), to appear on Board agenda April 22. - Item 3: Recommended as amended (unanimous), to appear on Board agenda April 29. - Item 4: Declared exempt surplus land; resolution recommended (unanimous), to appear on Board agenda April 29. - Item 5: CHESS report adopted; resolution recommended (unanimous), to appear on Board agenda April 29. - Item 6: Ordinance amended and continued to April 28, 2025 meeting (unanimous). - Item 7: Ordinance recommended to full board (unanimous), to appear on Board agenda April 29. Additional Notes - Committee Clerk John Carroll conducted roll call and public comment procedures. The meeting was broadcast by SFGov TV. - All CEQA determinations were affirmed per the agenda boilerplate.
Date: Thursday, April 17, 2025 This joint hearing of the San Francisco Planning Commission and Historic Preservation Commission considered four related actions for the Heritage on the Marina residential care facility at 3400 Laguna Street. The project proposes demolishing two non-contributing buildings, constructing two new four-story buildings (Bay Building and Francisco Building), renovating the historic Julia Morgan Building, and modifying the existing Planned Unit Development (PUD). The hearing included staff presentations, 10 minutes each from the project sponsor and organized opposition, and 28 individual public comments. The Planning Commission first certified the Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and adopted CEQA findings, then the Historic Preservation Commission considered a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), and finally the Planning Commission considered the Conditional Use Authorization (CUA). Public Comments & Testimony - Project Sponsor (Randy Gridley, Carolyn Kiernot, Frank Rockwood): Argued the project is essential for the financial sustainability of the 172-year-old nonprofit, which faces annual operating deficits growing from $3 million to over $8 million. They emphasized the design respects the Julia Morgan landmark and provides needed senior housing. - Organized Opposition – Save the Marina’s Heritage (Tanya Albuquerque, Christopher Verplanck, Michael Hebel, Terry Peckham, Maurice Fitzgerald): Contended the plans are incomplete (referencing a disclaimer), the new construction would overwhelm and dwarf the Julia Morgan mansion, violating Secretary of the Interior Standards (particularly standards 1, 2, 9, and 10). They also raised safety concerns about the proposed driveway on Bay Street, citing 14 injury crashes in the last 10 years on that block. - General Public – In Support (approx. 10 speakers, including residents): Spoke about the quality of care at Heritage, the need for senior housing, and the importance of the expansion to ensure the facility’s survival. One resident noted that 25% of current residents receive financial support. - General Public – In Opposition (approx. 5 speakers, including neighbors): Objected to the scale and massing, loss of open space, increased traffic, and dust during construction. One neighbor stated that the proposal looks “like a prison.” - San Francisco Heritage (Woody LaBounty, executive director): Did not oppose the project on balance, noting that preservation of the Morgan building and front garden was key, and that the organization’s mission and the recent landmark designation were important factors. Discussion Items 1. Certification of Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and CEQA Findings - Staff (Jeff Horn, Megan Calpin): Presented the EIR process: draft EIR published August 28, 2024; comment period closed October 15, 2024; 25 commenters; all impacts mitigated to less-than-significant; three alternatives analyzed (no project, rehabilitation, reduced construction). - Planning Commission Deliberation: Traffic safety on Bay Street was a major concern. Commissioner Moore described the intersection as “potentially an unsafe disaster in the making.” Staff clarified the project would move loading operations away from the intersection, provide a loading dock long enough for 40-foot vehicles, and add right-turn-only access. The project would generate 27 new peak-hour vehicle trips, well below the 300-trip threshold. The Commission certified the EIR (6-0) and adopted CEQA findings (6-0). 2. Certificate of Appropriateness (Historic Preservation Commission) - Staff (Charles Enchill): Recommended approval, finding the project complies with Secretary of the Interior Standards. Key change: demolition of two non-contributing buildings, new construction compatible in location, size, and finishes. - Commissioner Nagas Warren: Detailed analysis of Standards 1, 2, 9, 10. Criticized the west end of the south addition as too prominent, stating it needs to defer to the Morgan building via stepping back or better articulation. Also raised concerns about window replacement, seismic connection, and roof equipment. - Commissioner Baldoff: Echoed concerns about massing on the west side, lack of detailed renderings (materials not shown), and the importance of getting the design right for a landmark. Proposed sending the project to the Architectural Review Committee (ARC) rather than approving now. - Commissioner Foley: Argued for approval with condition to go to ARC for final massing and details, citing the urgent need for senior housing and the risk of the nonprofit becoming financially unsustainable. - Vote: Motion to approve COA with condition that the project return to ARC for final massing and details. Passed 5-1 (Commissioner Nagas Warren dissenting). 3. Conditional Use Authorization (Planning Commission) - Staff (Jeff Horn): Request to modify the existing PUD to allow a rear-yard exception. The project is a principle permitted use; the PUD allows modifications. The project sponsor also created a driveway loading and operations plan to mitigate Bay Street safety issues. - Planning Commission Deliberation: Several commissioners expressed discomfort with approving the CUA without seeing the final design from ARC. Commissioner Imperial raised concerns about approving the CUA before the COA details were settled. Commissioner Brown proposed a motion to continue, but later withdrew it after discussion. - Programmatic Concerns: Commissioner McGarry noted that any reduction in units or unit sizes could render the project financially nonviable; the sponsor confirmed that the project is designed to just reach break-even. Commissioner Campbell pointed out that industry average unit size in California is 1,500 sq ft, while the proposed average is 750 sq ft. - Final Motion: The Planning Commission approved the CUA (6-0) with an added finding that the ARC review must retain the programmatic viability of the project, specifically the number of units (109) and unit sizes as proposed, and that the revised plans be shared with the Planning Commission. Key Outcomes - EIR Certification: Motion passed 6-0 (Planning Commission). - CEQA Findings Adoption: Motion passed 6-0 (Planning Commission). - Certificate of Appropriateness: Motion passed 5-1 (Historic Preservation Commission) with condition to return to ARC for final massing and details. The ARC will include Commissioners Nagas Warren, Baldoff, and Baroni, plus President Matsuda as ex-officio. Target ARC meeting: May 21, 2025. - Conditional Use Authorization: Motion passed 6-0 (Planning Commission) with a finding that ARC review must maintain programmatic viability (unit count and sizes) and that final plans be provided to the Planning Commission. - Next Steps: The ARC will meet on May 21 to finalize design details (massing, materials). The project cannot proceed until the COA is finalized, which may require subsequent review by the full HPC. The Planning Commission will receive the final approved plans for informational purposes.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Jackie Fielder and including Vice Chair Sauter and Member Sherrill, convened on April 17, 2025, to discuss a resolution regarding the family shelter length of stay policy and to consider three lawsuit settlements. The main focus was the resolution urging the Mayor to rescind or drastically reform the 90-day family shelter stay limit, which sparked extensive debate and public testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Numerous families currently in shelters, many with young children, testified about the fear, stress, and confusion caused by the 90-day policy. They reported receiving eviction notices, difficulty communicating with case managers, and the trauma of facing potential homelessness. Many pleaded for the elimination of the policy and for more housing subsidies. - Advocates from Faith in Action, United Educators of San Francisco, Latino Task Force, and other organizations voiced strong support for the resolution, arguing the policy harms children and immigrant families. They called for increased permanent housing vouchers and prevention funding. - A school social worker and a pediatrician provided expert testimony on the negative impacts of housing instability on children's health and education. Discussion Items - Resolution 250237 (Family Shelter Length of Stay Policy): Chair Fielder introduced the resolution, citing constituent concerns and the policy's unintended consequences. She emphasized that families complying with rules should not face a looming deadline if no safe housing is available. - Presentation by HSH: Deputy Director Emily Cohen and Chief Deputy Director Marion Sanders presented on the reforms, citing a 39% decrease in the shelter waiting list (from over 500 families), a 72% increase in housing referrals since implementation, and that only three families had been exited due to the policy (two of whom found housing before exit). They argued the policy includes generous extension options (unlimited extensions if engaged with case management) and is needed to prioritize the most vulnerable families. - Committee Questions and Debate: Members probed details on extension criteria, case manager training, and communications. Chair Fielder questioned whether the policy is practical given insufficient housing exits and inconsistent application by case managers. She noted that the policy's success is predicated on a well-trained workforce and adequate housing supply, which are lacking. Vice Chair Sauter and Member Sherrill expressed support for continuing the discussion via a proposed ordinance rather than a non-binding resolution. - Settlement approvals: Items 2, 3, and 4 were three ordinances authorizing settlements of lawsuits: $285,000 for Chau Nancy Xiong, $75,000 for Jenny Ramirez Valdivia, and $135,000 for the San Francisco Apartment Association and Small Property Owners of San Francisco Institute. No public comment was received, and the committee voted unanimously to forward them to the full Board. Key Outcomes - Motion to Continue Resolution: Vice Chair Sauter moved to continue Item 1 (the resolution) to the call of the chair, aiming to align its discussion with Chair Fielder's forthcoming ordinance on shelter stay limits. Member Sherrill seconded. The motion passed 2-1, with Chair Fielder opposed. - Unanimous Approval of Settlements: The committee unanimously voted to forward the three settlement ordinances (Items 2-4) to the Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation.
The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on Thursday, April 17, 2025, at 10:00 AM for a full-day hearing that lasted into the evening. The agenda included consideration of planning code amendments, two draft Environmental Impact Reports (EIRs), an informational presentation on small business strategies, and a discretionary review request. Commissioners voted on several items, including a controversial amendment to allow health service uses in the Mixed-Use Office (MUO) district and a discretionary review of a rear stair project at 1150 Gilman Street. Consent Calendar - Adoption of Draft Minutes for April 3, 2025: The Commission unanimously (6-0) adopted the minutes. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 6 (Health Service Uses in MUO): No public speakers commented. - Item 7 (PG&E Power Asset Acquisition Draft EIR): Three public speakers commented. Byron Coppin (Grid Science AI) urged full city control of energy infrastructure. James Lansing (resident) asked about costs and rate impacts. Jim Warshell (resident) strongly supported the separation from PG&E, citing poor service and delays. - Item 8 (447 Battery/530 Sansome Draft EIR): Multiple speakers commented. A dental practice owner (Jahwachu) expressed concern about construction disruptions to his business. James Lansing objected to the building height and office vacancy. Several union representatives (Sprinkler Fitters, Plumbers, Electricians, Plasters, Building Trades) spoke in support of the project and deemed the draft EIR adequate. Rudy Gonzalez (Building and Construction Trades Council) praised the developer for mitigating shadow and wind impacts. - Item 9 (Small Business Strategies): Over 20 public speakers testified, mostly in favor of stronger protections for small businesses. Speakers included small business owners (Jesse Alawalia, Sean Kim, Vanessa Lawitzo, Richard Weld), community advocates (Monica Morse, Courtney Damkroger, Steven Torres), and representatives from Neighborhoods United, Race and Equity in All Planning Coalition, and Housing Action Coalition. Common themes: fear of displacement due to upzoning, need for relocation assistance, tenant consent to demolition, and preservation of neighborhood character. A few speakers (e.g., Maina Young, Joseph Smooke) urged caution about overregulation and emphasized the importance of property owner rights. - Item 10 (1150 Gilman Street DR): Maggie Yan (DR requester) and her son-in-law Matthew spoke against the proposed external staircase, citing privacy, safety, and encroachment concerns. Project sponsor Patrick Mora proposed a taller privacy wall as a compromise. Discussion Items - Item 6 – Health Service Uses in the Mixed-Use Office District (Planning Code Amendments): Staff presented a proposal to exempt health service uses (including reproductive health clinics) from retail size limits and retail ratio requirements in the MUO district. The Commission debated the scope. Commissioner Imperial expressed concern about broad applicability, especially the Mission Street corridor west of 7th Street. Commissioner Williams opposed the broadness. Commissioner Campbell supported full flexibility. After a motion to approve with staff modifications failed 3-3, a second motion passed 5-1 to adopt the recommendation with staff modifications and to examine potentially removing the MUO area west of 7th Street from the changes. Commissioner Williams voted against. - Item 7 – PG&E Power Asset Acquisition Project Draft EIR: Staff presented an overview of the draft EIR for the city’s proposed purchase of PG&E’s electrical transmission and distribution assets. The project would involve construction at the San Francisco–San Mateo County border. The draft EIR found significant unavoidable noise and air quality impacts. Four alternatives were analyzed, including a no-project alternative. Public comment period ends May 19, 2025. Commissioners expressed support for the city’s independence from PG&E and noted the complexity of the technical analysis. No formal action was taken; the hearing was for public comment only. - Item 8 – 447 Battery/530 Sansome Draft EIR: Staff and the project sponsor (Skidmore, Owings and Merrill) presented the mixed-use development (office, hotel, fire station, public realm improvements). The draft EIR found significant unavoidable impacts on historic resources (demolition of 447 Battery Street) and air quality. Four mitigation measures were identified. The Historic Preservation Commission concurred with the findings but requested clarifications and expressed opposition to de-listing the landmark. Commissioners raised concerns about the project description, shadow impacts on parks, and the lack of a prior informational hearing. The comment period ends April 28, 2025. The Commission did not vote; the hearing was for comment only. - Item 9 – Expanding Housing Choice Small Business Strategies (Informational Presentation): Small Business Forward (Justin Dolazal and Yolanda Porrata) and Planning Department staff (Lisa Chen, Sarah Richardson) presented data on small business vulnerability. Key statistics: 94,000 small businesses in San Francisco, employing 360,000 people; 5,600 registered businesses in rezoning areas; an estimated 53 businesses per year at risk of displacement. Staff proposed draft recommendations including early notification, relocation payments modeled on AB 2011, micro-retail requirements, and a new zoning district. Public comment highlighted the need for stronger protections. Commissioners praised the dialogue and emphasized the importance of connecting small business protection with housing goals. No formal action was taken. Key Outcomes - Item 6: Motion to adopt recommendation for approval with staff modifications and a study of removing the MUO west of 7th Street passed 5-1 (Commissioner Williams dissenting). - Item 10: Motion to take discretionary review and approve the project with a taller privacy wall passed 6-0. - Items 7 and 8: No votes; public comment periods remain open. - Item 9: Informational; no vote. The Commission expects continued engagement with stakeholders and refinement of protection policies. Other Actions: The Commission agreed to move the 2588 Mission Street hearing from May 1 to May 15, 2025, to avoid conflict with International Workers' Day. Next Steps: The Commission will hold a joint hearing with the Health Commission on May 15, 2025. Draft EIR comment deadlines: April 28 (447 Battery) and May 19 (PG&E). Staff will continue developing small business protection ordinances in consultation with the City Attorney's office.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on April 16, 2025, chaired by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey (in place of Chair Connie Chan, who was excused). The committee considered six items, including grants for playground improvements, a reserved fund release for the Twin Peaks Promenade, a lease for the Adante Hotel shelter, and a major lease amendment for 1455 Market Street with associated capital appropriations. The meeting featured presentations from the Recreation and Park Department, Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH), Department of Public Health (DPH), the Real Estate Division (RED), the Human Services Agency (HSA), and the Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA). Consent Calendar - Items 1 & 2 (Resolutions accepting grants): The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward both resolutions to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Item 1 authorizes acceptance of approximately $1,125,000 from Wu Yee Children’s Services for playground improvements at Tenderloin Recreation Center. Item 2 authorizes acceptance of $5,000,000 from KABOOM! for children’s playspace improvements at up to eight sites. Public Comments & Testimony - Barbara Swan (Lower Nob Hill Neighborhood Alliance board member): Expressed support for the revised Adante Hotel resolution, calling it a win for the neighborhood and the city. Thanked Supervisor Sauter, HSH, and others for engagement. - Paula Hendricks (Tenderloin resident on O'Farrell Street): Supported the one-year lease for the Adante but expressed concern about Phase 3 plans to potentially double treatment beds in the Tenderloin. Thanked the mayor for listening to the community. Discussion Items - Item 3 (Twin Peaks Promenade – Release of Reserved Funds): The committee heard from Tony Moran (Rec & Park) and Nick Minard (BLA). The grant of $1,493,692 from California State Parks will fund the Twin Peaks Promenade Project, a $5.2 million project to convert a roadway into a park with accessible trails and native plantings. The grant was retroactive to September 2024. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to release the funds and file the hearing. - Item 4 (Adante Hotel Lease – 610 Geary Street): Emily Cohen (HSH) presented a revised lease for the Adante Hotel as a non-congregate shelter, changing from a booking agreement to a lease with a one-year term and one one-year option to extend (previously four options). The revised rent includes a $100,000 final payment. Dara Papo (DPH) discussed the RESTORE program, which provides rapid treatment access for opioid use disorder, currently occupying 35 beds and planning to expand to 73 beds at the Adante. Supervisor Danny Sauter (District 3) spoke in support, emphasizing the importance of the RESTORE program and the need to manage the concentration of services in Lower Nob Hill. He noted that the Adante has a pathway to return to tourist use. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to accept the amendments as read and continue the item to the April 23 meeting. - Items 5 & 6 (1455 Market Street Lease Amendment and Appropriation): Andriko Pennick (RED) and Dan Kaplan (HSA) presented a lease amendment for 1455 Market Street, adding 225,883 rentable square feet for HSA, the County Transportation Authority (CTA), and Library IT. The amendment triggers a purchase option for the city (open until December 2027). The companion ordinance appropriates $11.8 million from revenue surplus and repurposed capital project balances to fund tenant improvements exceeding the landlord's allowance. The BLA recommended approval but noted potential savings from redesigning executive offices and using used furniture. HSA defended the costs, citing the need for a functional service center and long-term furniture durability. Supervisor Chen questioned the cost-saving recommendations. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to accept amendments (correcting the address and removing misleading general plan language) and then voted to forward Item 5 to the full Board for the April 29, 2025 meeting with a positive recommendation, and to continue Item 6 to the April 23, 2025 committee meeting. Key Outcomes - Items 1 & 2: Approved and forwarded to full Board. - Item 3: Reserved funds of $1,493,692 released; hearing filed. - Item 4: Amended (lease term reduced to one year with one-year option; retroactive to April 1, 2025; $100,000 final payment added) and continued to April 23, 2025. - Item 5: Amended (deleted misleading general plan referral language) and forwarded to the full Board for April 29, 2025, with a positive recommendation. - Item 6: Amended (corrected address from 1145 to 1455 Market Street) and continued to April 23, 2025. - All votes were 3-0 (Engardio, Chen, Dorsey).
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, April 16, 2025, at 1:30 PM. The meeting included the Chief's Report, DPA Director's Report, Commission Reports, presentations on the Disciplinary Review Board (DRB) and Firearm Discharge/In-Custody Death Review Board, and votes on two Department General Orders. The meeting also featured public testimony, discussion on large-scale enforcement actions, and recognition of Chief William Scott. Public Comments & Testimony - Several members of the public spoke during General Public Comment and on specific agenda items. One public commenter expressed full support for the large-scale enforcement operations at Market and Van Ness, citing improved conditions since the March 19 operation and urging the department to continue such actions. Another speaker, representing the Civic Center Community Benefit District, described finding individuals passed out on drugs, trash, and drug paraphernalia each morning and stated that enforcement sends a message that open-air drug use will not be tolerated. - A mother of a homicide victim (Aubrey Abercassa, murdered in 2006) urged the commission to keep unsolved case information flowing and requested that homicide inspectors maintain regular contact with families. - Several other public commenters raised concerns about organized crime, technology, and lack of police response; one speaker alleged harassment and surveillance. The commission did not respond to these comments. Discussion Items - Chief's Report (Item 2): Chief Scott reported overall part-one crimes down 30% (over 4,000 fewer crimes) compared to the same period last year, with violent crime down 15% and property crime down 32%. Shooting incidents increased 22% (28 vs. 23) and gun violence victims increased by four. Weapon seizures totaled 312 in 2025, including 41 ghost guns. The Chief provided a detailed update on the March 19 mass arrest operation at Market and Van Ness, where 41 people were arrested out of an estimated 90+ individuals engaged in drug activity. Officers confiscated 37 items of drug paraphernalia, and many arrestees had outstanding warrants from multiple jurisdictions. The Chief emphasized the operation was based on probable cause and reasonable suspicion, and he supported the officers' actions despite the District Attorney not charging many cases. He noted ongoing collaboration with the DA's office to improve evidence collection and future operations. Commissioners discussed displacement, officer fatigue, and the need for long-term strategies including lighting and environmental changes. - DPA Director's Report (Item 3): Director Paul Henderson announced a partnership with the Controller's Office to review the 2023 audit (Officer Misconduct) and reported that DPA had opened 13 new cases and closed 22 cases in the past week. The top allegation was conduct unbecoming. DPA has no cases exceeding 270 days. He updated on intern training and policy collaboration with SFPD. - Commission Reports (Item 4): President Elias and commissioners praised Chief Scott for his leadership and reform efforts, noting he received recognition from the Board of Supervisors. Commissioner Benedict discussed DGO updates (7.01, 6.16 on sexual assault), the SFPD boundary analysis, and plans to visit the new Real-Time Investigation Center. Commissioner Scott highlighted National Crime Victims' Rights Week events. Commissioner Yanes requested updates on the annual language access report (scheduled for May 7) and a pre-booking program MOU. - Disciplinary Review Board (Item 5): Lieutenant Lisa Springer (IAD) and Sharon Wu (DPA) presented findings for Q3 and Q4 2024. In Q3, the top IAD trend was conduct unbecoming (29.79%). DPA's top trend was neglect of duty. One policy failure (vehicle tows) and two training failures (body-worn camera termination, CIT training) were noted. In Q4, conduct unbecoming rose to 36.23% (25 cases). Policy failures included a sergeant working overtime over the cap (common practice) and a captain bringing a dog to work (no policy). A training failure involved an officer-involved shooting where cover/concealment training was inadequate. The department issued a department notice on swatting following a policy failure. OEI found no racial disparities. A revised DGO on vehicle tows is in concurrence. - Firearm Discharge & In-Custody Death Review Board (Item 6): Presented by Lieutenant Springer. Two OIS cases were reviewed: one found officers acted in policy except for a brief delay in body-worn camera activation; the other was an accidental off-duty discharge (no injuries). Two in-custody deaths were reviewed: one on Treasure Island (2022) where the subject died from methamphetamine/alcohol toxicity combined with physical restraint — officers found in policy; another at Park Station (2022) where the subject died from mixed drug toxicity — officers in policy. - DGO 6.14 (Psychological Evaluation of Adults) (Item 7): Adopted unanimously (7-0) with a 30-day implementation period. - DGO 11.02 (Secondary Employment) (Item 8): Approved unanimously (7-0) subject to labor relations resolution. Key Outcomes - Votes: DGO 6.14 and DGO 11.02 both passed 7-0. - Closed Session: The commission voted unanimously to hold Item 11 (Closed Session) and voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion held in closed session. - Future Agenda Items: - The full presentation on the Market and Van Ness operation and pursuit policy is scheduled for May 2025. - The annual language access report will be presented on May 7, 2025. - Homicide investigators will be invited to give an update on unsolved cases. - Directives: The Chief will coordinate with commission staff to recognize officers who received vehicle theft recovery awards. The DPA and SFPD will continue working on pre-booking program MOU and policy improvements. Meeting adjourned.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on April 15, 2025, at 10:15 AM, with all 11 members present. The meeting featured a special appearance by Mayor Daniel Lurie, who reported on his first 100 days in office, including a 35% reduction in property crime, violent crime down 15%, and car break-ins at 22-year lows. The board approved a consent agenda of six lawsuit settlements totaling $1,890,000, passed multiple ordinances and resolutions, and conducted a public hearing on an environmental appeal for a proposed six-story building at 2142 22nd Street. Numerous commendations were awarded, and legislation was introduced on public safety, housing, climate justice, and immigrant rights. Consent Calendar - Items 1–6 (lawsuit settlements) approved unanimously (10 ayes, 1 absence): Coinbase, Inc. ($1,600,000); Lester Hogan ($50,000); Ada M. Guzman ($45,000); Veronica Fulton ($40,000); Michael E. Johnson, et al. (city to receive $100,000); The Nederlander Company LLC, dba Broadway San Francisco, LLC ($55,000). - Items 40, 42–45 (for adoption without committee reference) approved unanimously: Urging Planning and MOHCD to finalize Affordable Housing Sites Strategy; supporting California SB 684 and AB 1243 (Polluters Pay Climate Superfund Act); Autism Awareness Month; Education and Sharing Day; 100th anniversary of the Great Star Theater; and a Committee of the Whole on blighted properties. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (2:00 PM): Multiple speakers addressed the board. Cheryl Shanks and others from the Mega Black coalition urged full restoration of Dreamkeeper Initiative funding, stating the allocation dropped from $60 million annually to less than $20 million. They noted a 95% approval rating for the program and demanded transparency and accountability. Cheryl Thornton (Black Employees Alliance) called for independent oversight of hiring and discipline practices for Black city workers. Several speakers supported the resolution backing the California Polluters Pay Climate Superfund Act (SB 684/AB 1243), citing the $250 billion cost of the January 2025 LA fires and the need for fossil fuel companies to pay for climate damages. One speaker opposed the Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone, calling it a "suck up to gay boarding bloc." Another speaker urged a humanitarian state of emergency in District 6 and defunding the police. - Appeal Hearing on 2142 22nd Street Project (3:00 PM): No public comment was offered in support of the appeal or in opposition. Discussion Items - Mayor’s Appearance (2:00 PM): Mayor Daniel Lurie highlighted progress on public safety, the fentanyl crisis, and economic recovery. He noted collaboration with the board and outlined upcoming priorities: family zoning, a sustainable budget, and interim housing capacity. No questions were submitted from supervisors. - Commendations (2:30 PM): The board honored: (1) The Great Star Theater on its 100th anniversary as the oldest Chinese theater in North America; (2) The City College of San Francisco men’s basketball team for winning the 2025 CCCAA state championship (32-1 season, sixth title); (3) SFPD Chief Bill Scott for his reform leadership; (4) DEM dispatchers Kathy Asorio and Nicole Workman for their service (National Public Safety Telecommunicators Week). - Appeal Hearing – 2142 22nd Street (3:00 PM): Appellants (Emily Bruff and geotechnical engineer Alan Kropp) argued that the project site has unusual circumstances—a 40% slope, location in an earthquake landslide zone, and serpentine bedrock—warranting environmental review under CEQA. They contended that only shallow soil borings (2–5 feet) were done despite a planned 30-foot excavation. Planning Department staff (Don Lewis) countered that steep slopes and serpentine bedrock are common in San Francisco (13% of city on slopes ≥25%, 39% of parcels), and that building code requirements and the construction dust control ordinance adequately address risks. Project sponsor attorney Tuya Caralano argued the appeal was driven by a dispute over property line windows, not environmental concerns, and that the project qualifies for Class 1 and 3 categorical exemptions. Supervisor Walton moved to affirm the exemption. - Legislation Introduced at Roll Call (after 3:00 PM): - Supervisor Chan: Legislation granting SOSOR contracting authority to SF Fire Dept. for fire apparatus. - Supervisor Chen: Resolution to add commemorative street name “Jerry Garcia Street” in District 11; resolution supporting AB 611 (Keep News Independent Act). - Supervisor Fielder: Resolution proclaiming April 18, 2025 as SF SPCA Day; ordinance requiring 12-month minimum shelter stays for families with children unless viable housing is found; in memoriam for Ellie Curtis. - Supervisor Mahmoud: Resolution reaffirming non-cooperation with identity-based registry (Chapter 103) and opposing federal immigration data-sharing. - Supervisor Mandelman: Resolution supporting AB 1363 (Wyland’s Law) for protective order transparency; resolution opposing the erasure of Medgar Evers from federal websites; ordinance expanding Castro LGBTQ Cultural District to include DeBose Triangle; in memoriam for Scott Nielsen. - Supervisor Melgar: Legislation to improve seismic safety of concrete buildings; resolution commemorating 110th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide (April 24). - Supervisor Sauter: Announcement of entertainment zones at PIER 39 and Union Square; in memoriam for fallen firefighter Tilo Tiape III (age 38, Station 3). - Supervisor Walton: Resolution declaring April 11–17 Black Maternal Health Week; hearing on Black maternal health. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda (Items 1–6): Approved (10-0-1). The six ordinances were finally passed. - Unfinished Business (Items 7–8): Item 7 (600 Townsend Street West SUD) and Item 8 (Castro Upper Market Entertainment Zone) all passed on final reading (same house same call). - New Business – Roll Call Votes: - Item 10 (SFPUC contract amendment with CPM/CM Pros JV, not to exceed $34 million): Adopted 11-0. - Items 11–22 and 24–29 (various contracts, leases, grants, street naming, and Mission Rock infrastructure): All passed without objection (same house same call). - Item 30 (Appointment of Supervisor Dorsey to BCDC): Approved 10-0 (Dorsey excused). - Item 31 (Appointments to Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee): Approved 11-0. - Item 32 (Appointment to Sheriff’s Oversight Board): Approved same house same call. - Item 33 (Sheriff’s Military Equipment Use Policy – 2024 Annual Report): Adopted 8-3 (Supervisors Chan, Fielder, Walton dissenting). - Appeal Hearing (Items 34–37): The board voted 11-0 to approve Item 35 (affirming categorical exemption) and table Items 36 and 37 (reversal motions). The hearing was filed. - Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 40–45): Items 40, 42–45 adopted unanimously. Item 41 (resolution supporting Polluters Pay Climate Superfund Act) adopted same house same call. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Tilo Tiape III, Ellie Curtis, and Scott Nielsen.
The San Francisco Rules Committee met on April 14, 2025, at 6:00 PM to consider a single agenda item: an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to streamline the purchase of content and data subscriptions by city departments. Chair Shimon Walton, Vice Chair Steven Sherrow, President Rafael Mandelman, and guest Supervisor Mark Mahmood were present. The committee heard a presentation from the Office of the City Administrator, discussed the narrow scope of the legislation, and voted unanimously to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Discussion Items - Ordinance 250209 - Administrative Code - Content and Data Subscriptions: The proposed ordinance would exempt certain data and content subscription purchases from standard solicitation requirements and contractor obligations, allowing city departments to more easily acquire digital tools such as business databases, legal research platforms (e.g., LexisNexis), and online reference materials. Molly Peterson of the City Administrator's Office presented the rationale, noting that current procurement rules, written in the 1990s, are ill-suited for low-risk, low-dollar digital subscriptions where vendors often refuse to negotiate custom contracts. The legislation includes a narrow definition to protect city data: it applies only when the city receives data, not when it uploads city data. Supervisor Mahmood, a co-sponsor, highlighted real-world impacts, including the public library being unable to offer digital business databases and departments like the Treasurer and Assessor facing months-long delays. Chair Walton expressed support due to the narrow scope but voiced concern about a trend of waiving procurement requirements. President Mandelman supported the measure, noting the difficulty of negotiating with vendors for essential data tools. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (Vice Chair Sheryl aye, President Mandelman aye, Chair Walton aye) to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. No public comment was received. The item is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on April 22, 2025.