The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, February 27, 2025, starting in the afternoon. Commissioners present: President Seo, Vice President Moore, Commissioners Braun, Campbell, Imperial, McGarry, and Williams. The meeting covered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, department announcements, general public comment, and a regular calendar that included a window replacement ordinance, an informational presentation on tenant protections, and an overview of state housing laws. Consent Calendar - Item 6 (255 California Street): Approved 6-0 after Commissioner Campbell recused herself due to a conflict of interest (his firm was involved). - Items 7-10: Approved unanimously 7-0. These included conditional use authorizations at 1463 Haight Street, 401 Columbus Avenue, 2001 Van Ness Avenue, and 1530-1542 Haight Street. - Item 11 (1 La Avanzata – Sutro Tower): Removed from the consent calendar at the request of a neighborhood liaison. Heard as a separate item and approved with conditions (see Discussion Items). Public Comments & Testimony - Continuance Calendar: Sue Hester (public commenter) requested a longer continuance for items 1A and 1B (54 4th Street and 509 Minna Street), emphasizing the need for thorough consideration due to the significance of SRO conversions in the South of Market area. - Consent Calendar: Sha Lin Chen (Midtown Terrace neighborhood liaison to Sutro Tower) requested removal of Item 11 from consent, not to oppose the project itself but to object to the placement of a mandatory discretionary review on the consent calendar without prior neighborhood agreement. - General Public Comment: Bridget Maley urged extensive public outreach on the upcoming upzoning map and density decontrol, stating that most residents do not understand it. - Window Replacement Standards (Item 17): - Michael Keene (vice president of Foxtel Hill Windows and Doors) opposed deregulation, warning it would harm local wooden‑window craftsmen and lead to ill‑fitting vinyl windows. - Courtney Damkroger (former HPC member) recommended sending the ordinance to the Historic Preservation Commission for review and aligning it with objective design standards. - Garen Checkley (organizer of a support letter) spoke in favor, arguing that current standards are burdensome, costly, and erode public trust; he supported vinyl as an affordable, energy‑efficient option. - Bruce Bowen (Dolores Heights Improvement Club) supported staff modifications but questioned planning’s sudden reversal on vinyl and asked for clearer definition of exempt historic buildings. - Patrick Hoffman (resident) opposed vinyl for environmental reasons and urged referral to HPC. - George Shiddish raised concerns about vinyl longevity and appearance, and asked for clarity on “existing opening.” - Tenant Protections (Item 18): Numerous community members and coalition representatives spoke in support of strong tenant protections, sharing personal stories of displacement threats, harassment, and insufficient enforcement. Key speakers included Don Masumi, Fred Sherbin‑Zimmer, Ozzy Realman, Ramon Bonifacio, Anne Lim, Virginia Barker, Bruce Bowen, Zachary Farrell, Ann Collacchias, Aileen Mejia, Sidney Peterson, Kathy Lipscombe, Steve Leeds, John Avalos, Barbara Skinner, Reina Dale, Joseph Smook, Itran, Brianna Morales, and others. They urged the commission to adopt the solutions outlined by the REP SF coalition, including relocation specialists, one‑for‑one replacement of rent‑controlled units, and stronger enforcement. - State Housing Laws (Item 19): George Shiddish reiterated concerns about demolition definitions and DBI’s lack of a clear definition. Sue Hester requested staff outreach to community organizations about state law changes. Discussion Items - Continuances: Commissioner Imperial moved to extend the continuance of items 1A and 1B (54 4th Street and 509 Minna Street) to March 20, 2025, to allow more time for tenant history investigation and community input. Commissioners Williams and Moore supported; Commissioner Campbell and McGarry opposed. The motion passed 5‑2. All other continuances were granted as proposed (items 2, 3, 4, and 5A‑C to March 6, March 20, April 3, and April 3 respectively). - Item 11 – Sutro Tower (1 La Avanzata): Staff recommended approval of a mandatory discretionary review for replacing exterior metal panels on lower trusses. The project sponsor noted the main public concern was not the project itself but its placement on the consent calendar. Neighborhood liaison requested that future mandatory DR items not be placed on consent without prior neighborhood consent. The commission acknowledged the concern and voted unanimously (7‑0) to approve the project with standard conditions, while noting staff’s understanding not to place this item on consent in the future. - Item 17 – Window Replacement Standards: Supervisor Melgar presented a zoning code amendment to limit restrictions on replacement windows in non‑historic buildings, allowing vinyl and other materials. Staff recommended modifications to clarify the scope (only existing openings) and align definitions with the planning code. After extensive public comment, the commission deliberated. Vice President Moore opposed vinyl, urging a deeper technical review. Commissioner McGarry supported flexibility. Commissioner Imperial stressed equity and affordability. Commissioner Braun supported staff modifications. Commissioner Campbell supported vinyl as a cost‑effective option. Commissioner Williams supported staff recommendations. The motion to adopt a recommendation of approval with staff modifications passed 6‑1 (Moore dissenting). - Item 18 – Tenant Protections: Community coalitions (REP SF, SF Anti‑Displacement Coalition, CCHO) presented detailed proposals for a citywide tenant protection ordinance, including relocation specialists, one‑for‑one replacement of rent‑controlled units, mandatory pre‑application site inspections, and enhanced enforcement. Planning staff presented a parallel proposal codifying SB 330 provisions and adding local requirements (e.g., tenant notification, relocation assistance). Commissioners praised the collaboration and discussed key issues: the definition of demolition, relocation specialist funding, alignment with state law, and the need for urgency. Commissioner Williams urged a fast track, but staff cautioned that May 2025 is an aggressive target and recommended proceeding deliberately. The item was informational; no vote was taken. Staff and coalitions committed to continued collaboration. - Item 19 – State Housing Laws: Planning staff presented an overview of notable 2024 state housing legislation, including amendments to SB 423, AB 2011, SB 9, State Density Bonus Law, and the Housing Accountability Act. Staff explained changes to impact fee deferrals, entitlement extensions, and reporting requirements. Commissioners asked about the impact of HAA changes on projects over 500 units, preliminary fee estimates, and whether entitled units count toward state housing targets. Staff confirmed that entitled units are counted and that the city is working to implement new laws through planning director bulletins. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Items 1A and 1B continued to March 20, 2025 (vote 5‑2). All other continuances approved as proposed. - Consent Calendar: Items 6‑10 approved (Item 6: 6‑0 with recusal; Items 7‑10: 7‑0). - Item 11 (Sutro Tower): Approved with conditions (7‑0). Commission directed staff not to place future mandatory DR items on consent without neighborhood consultation. - Item 17 (Window Replacement): Commission voted 6‑1 to recommend approval with staff modifications. The item will proceed to the Board of Supervisors. - Item 18 (Tenant Protections): Informational. Staff will continue working with coalitions and target introduction of a draft ordinance by May 2025, alongside the housing element rezoning package. - Item 19 (State Housing Laws): Information received; no action taken.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 26, 2025, at 6:15 PM (stated meeting time) to consider 13 agenda items including loan agreements, contracts, grants, and funding approvals. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joan Guardio. Supervisor Danny Souter also attended for item 12. The meeting included presentations from city departments, public comment, and votes on all items. Consent Calendar - No separate consent calendar was used; all items were considered individually. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Normandy Ellis Loan): Chris Cummings, Director of Housing Development at Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation (TNDC), expressed strong support for the acquisition of the Normandy Apartments, noting the building's scale and condition make it a cost-effective addition to affordable housing in District 2. - Item 5 (Brilliant Corners FHSP): William Pickle, CEO of Brilliant Corners, spoke in support of the amendment, emphasizing the organization's role in developing the flexible housing subsidy pool model and commitment to reducing housing placement timelines. - Item 12 (Embarcadero Plaza): Multiple speakers expressed support: - Aaron Fenton (BXP) urged approval, highlighting the need to revitalize downtown public spaces. - Mark Leeson (Teamsters Joint Council 7) supported the project, citing good partnership with BXP and expected construction jobs. - Julia Rome (SF Travel) supported, noting the project would benefit visitors and local businesses. - Robbie Silver (Downtown Partnership) supported, calling it a once-in-a-generation opportunity for a world-class park. - Bernadette Kim (resident and Golden Gate Bird Alliance) supported but requested recognition of bird habitat protections. - Toby Levitt (San Francisco Shakespeare Festival) supported, sharing the success of their free Shakespeare performance at Sue Bierman Park and the need for better infrastructure. - A speaker from Gateway Tenants Association supported, calling the current plaza an embarrassment and urging reunification of the space. - Chris Keene (Friends of Embarcadero Bricks) supported, highlighting the community effort over three years. - Item 13 (Great Highway Promenade): Aileen Bulkin (Coalition for San Francisco neighborhoods) urged continuation, arguing the Coastal Conservancy had not finally approved the work program. Zach Lipton (Friends of Ocean Beach Park) supported acceptance, emphasizing the need for climate change and community planning studies. Discussion Items Item 1: Loan Agreement – Normandy Ellis, LP – Small Sites Program – Up to $50,600,000 - Presentation: Alia Gage (MOHCD) explained the loan would acquire and rehabilitate 1135-1175 Ellis Street (78 studios and 31 one-bedroom units). The project includes $35.8 million to repay a bridge loan, $10 million for rehabilitation (life safety, sprinklers, ADA upgrades), and 99-year affordability at 80% AMI. The per-unit cost of $266,000 is well below the program average of $364,000. - BLA Report: Nick Menard noted the total per-unit cost is about $468,000, low compared to other projects, and recommended approval. - Discussion: Chair Chan asked about cost savings; Ms. Gage cited a down market and the building's relatively good condition. The resolution was forwarded to full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Item 2: Professional Services Agreement – CDM Smith – Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation – Up to $24,600,000 - Presentation: Brian DeSore (SFPUC) detailed an amendment increasing the contract by $9.6 million (from $15M) and extending four years to 2030 due to expanded scope and construction support. The project addresses algae blooms and taste/odor issues. The total project budget is $326.3 million. - BLA Report: Recommended approval, noting the contract is funded by water revenues and bonds, no general fund impact. - Discussion: Chair Chan expressed concern about frequent contract amendments and asked about cost estimation controls. Jeremy Spitz (SFPUC) offered to brief the committee on capital program strategies. The motion passed (3-0). Item 3: Accept and Expend Grant – James Irvine Foundation – Northern California Apprenticeship Network Sustainability – $675,000 - Presentation: Orien Willis (OEWD) presented a retroactive grant to support the apprenticeship network through sub-grantees (Bay Area Council, BayVac Media). The grant runs through November 2027, targeting 30 apprentices per year and growing the network by 20% annually. - Discussion: Chair Chan noted the grant's focus on small and medium businesses and BIPOC populations. No public comment. Forwarded with recommendation (3-0). Item 4: Agreement – New Flyer of America – Battery-Electric Buses – Up to $13,424,512 - Presentation: Bob Cater (SFMTA) and Joseph Tabora presented procurement of seven battery-electric buses (four 40-foot, three 60-foot) via a Washington state cooperative purchasing agreement. This is part of MTA's transition to zero-emission fleet, with 18 total buses (others from Gillig and Solaris). Funding from FTA grants and RM3; a small funding gap will be covered by project savings. - BLA Report: Cost per bus similar to other jurisdictions, recommended approval. - Discussion: Vice Chair Dorsey asked about the cooperative agreement and Gillig's past unwillingness to work with the city due to contracting requirements (12B, indemnification) which have been resolved. The motion passed (3-0). Item 5: Grant Agreement Amendment – Brilliant Corners – Flexible Housing Subsidy Pool – Up to $59,542,690 - Presentation: Emily Cohen (HSH) presented a one-year extension (to June 2026) and $19.4 million increase to continue the scatter-site housing subsidy program serving up to 500 adults. 100% enrollment, 422 households currently subsidized. Demographics: 39% African American, 59% over 55, 17% LGBTQ. Housing retention rate 99%. Underperformance in placement timeliness (target 75 days, actual 116 days in 2024, down from 170 days) and spending due to staffing vacancies and market conditions. HSH is working with Brilliant Corners to improve and plans to adjust the target to 90 days in the next procurement. - BLA Report: Nick Menard noted persistent underperformance but improvement trend. Recommended approval but suggested considering reallocation to other providers; however, HSH noted other providers have smaller capacity and this is a large program of 500 slots. - Discussion: Vice Chair Dorsey expressed concerns about metrics but acknowledged the need for the program. The committee voted to forward the item to full board without recommendation (3-0). Item 6: Accept and Expend Grant – Homekey Round 3 – 42 Otis Street – Up to $8,225,095 - Presentation: Emily Cohen presented retroactive acceptance of $8.2 million state grant for acquisition and operation of a 24-unit permanent supportive housing site for young adults (ages 18-24). The city will provide $8.7 million in matching funds (capital and operating). The site will be operated by Five Keys, opening summer 2025. HSH proposed technical amendments to align with state terminology. - BLA Report: Recommended approval but flagged that capital costs were underestimated: $3.4 million in improvements were needed for a 2021 building, highlighting a systemic issue with due diligence. The city should better resource pre-purchase assessments. - Discussion: Chair Chan asked about partnerships with DPW for cost estimates; Ms. Cohen agreed improvements are needed. Vice Chair Dorsey noted the project is in his district and supported it. The resolution was amended and forwarded with recommendation (3-0). Item 7: Accept and Expend Grant – Andrew W. Mellon Foundation – Jail and Re-entry Services – $1,966,000 - Presentation: Jeannie Austin (SFPL) described a grant to expand information access for incarcerated people. The grant funds three project-limited positions. Achievements include updating 1992 standards for library services and growing a network from 40 to over 100 libraries. New funding supports early career librarian cohorts and digital literacy programs. - Discussion: Vice Chair Dorsey expressed interest in meeting to discuss reentry literacy programs. Chair Chan asked about retention of staff after 2027; Ms. Austin said it depends on future funding. Forwarded with recommendation (3-0). Items 8-11: Hearings – Release of Reserved Funds – Department of Public Health (Four Grants) - These items were heard as a group. Anna Volidzik (DPH) summarized each: - Item 8: State Vocational Rehabilitation Services ($791,433) – vocational services for adults with mental illness. - Item 9: STD Prevention and Control ($13,635,302) – core federal grant. - Item 10: NIDA Clinical Trials Network ($104,508) – research on cocaine use disorder treatment. - Item 11: Comprehensive Opioid and Substance Use Program ($1,600,000) – overdose fatality review. - BLA Report: Only item 8 had a report; recommended approval despite placement outcomes below targets (50-60% of targets), noting the city contributes only 20% of costs and outcomes are similar to other counties. - Discussion: Chair Chan asked about evaluating the vocational program. No public comment. The committee voted to release the funds and then to hear and file the items (both motions passed 3-0). Item 12: Accept and Expend Grant – BXP Embarcadero Plaza LP – Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park – $12,500,000 - Presentation: Supervisor Danny Souter provided context, calling the plaza the
The San Francisco Port Commission held its regular meeting on Tuesday, February 25, 2025, at 11:15 AM. President Kimberly Brandon presided, with Vice President Gail Gilman, and Commissioners Willie Adams, Stephen Englum, and Stephen Lee present. The meeting began with a land acknowledgement recognizing the unceded ancestral homeland of the Ramaytush Ohlone, followed by approval of the minutes from February 11, 2025, and procedural announcements. The agenda included the Executive Director's report, a consent calendar, a proposed lease for a Fisherman's Wharf restaurant, and new business items. Executive Director's Report - Economic Vitality: The Port successfully hosted the MBA All-Star Tournament and Lunar New Year celebrations, drawing thousands of visitors. Staff coordinated with security and SFPD to ensure a safe, clean, and vibrant waterfront. Forthcoming events include the 47th Lunar New Year Run (March 2) benefiting the Chinatown YMCA (serving 1,600 youth), and the Sail GP global sailing championship (March 22-23) featuring the Inspire Learning program (60 children per day) teaching sailing and STEM. Fisherman's Wharf progress was showcased during a February 18 tour with the Mayor's Office. The Port's 10-year capital plan was presented; Commissioner Englum provided refinements, and a final version will be brought for approval on March 11, 2025. - Equity: The Black Digital Art Collection Collective, in partnership with Hudson Properties, opened an art exhibit on the second floor of the Ferry Building, aimed at connecting diverse small businesses with contracting opportunities. - Offshore Wind: Assistant Port Director Michael Martin attended a conference in Long Beach with Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis and California Energy Commission Chair David Hochschild, reaffirming the state's goal of 25 gigawatts of floating offshore wind energy. The Port expressed interest in pursuing investments and capital upgrades to prepare marine terminals for offshore wind development. - Write-Off Policy: Pursuant to Resolution 22-11, a report summarizing three accounts recommended for write-off was provided for a 30-day review period. - Staff Updates: Director Forbes reported the passing of former Commissioner Francis X. (FX) Crowley on February 11, 2025, who served on the Port Commission from 2010-2012 and contributed to the Maritime Preservation Policy. Commissioners commented on the report: Commissioner Lee inquired about ferry connectivity to Chase Center; Commissioner Englum highlighted the $350 million economic impact of the MBA event and 10,000 attendees, urging staff to better communicate such metrics; Vice President Gilman praised equity initiatives and the Port's role as an enterprise department; President Brandon commended staff for event execution and noted the offshore wind opportunity; Commissioner Adams offered no comments. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2508 (7A): Authorization to issue a Request for Qualifications for as-needed environmental and planning services for up to three contracts, each not to exceed $6 million, with a 5-year term and creation of a 2-year pre-qualified pool. - Resolution 2509 (7B): Authorization to issue a Request for Qualifications for as-needed engineering and related services for up to four contracts, each not to exceed $5 million, with a 5-year term and creation of a 2-year pre-qualified pool. - Resolution 2510 (7C): Authorization to advertise competitive bids for Construction Contract No. 2878, Mission Bay Ferry Landing Phase 2A (marine demolition and mattress), with an anticipated contract amount of $8.5 million. - All three resolutions were approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Greg Champot (remote caller, non-agenda public comment): Requested an update on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' draft San Francisco flood study and asked about the impact of sea-level horizon planning guidelines (RSAP) issued by BCDC and the California Coastal Commission. The Commission noted the item was not on the agenda but indicated a future update would be provided. - Rebecca Groves (in-person, consent calendar public comment): A resident of Dog Patch, board member of the Green Benefit District, and active member of the Dog Patch Neighborhood Association, she expressed gratitude for the Port's new facilities (Crane Cove Park, public restrooms, YMCA, Dog Patch Paddle). However, she voiced serious concern about the planned location of the high-speed ferry terminal within 200 feet of the Agua Vista Public Fishing Pier and less than a quarter-mile from Crane Cove's on-water recreation area. She urged the Commission to consider relocation to Pier 54 (recently vacated) as a safer alternative that would avoid endangering paddlers, preserve fishing access, restore an existing Bayfill structure, and provide commercial opportunities. She requested a safety and feasibility assessment of the Pier 54 alternative before proceeding with construction. President Brandon offered to connect Ms. Groves with Planning Director David Beaupre for further discussion. Real Estate & Development: Proposed Lease with Everett & Jones BBQ Presentation: Senior Property Manager Don Kavanaugh described the competitive process for 300 Jefferson Street (formerly Lou's Crab Shack) — a two-story restaurant space of approximately 4,363 square feet. Maven Commercial issued over 2,000 email solicitations, conducted 35 tours, and received five viable letters of intent. An evaluation panel of two Port staff and an outside consultant unanimously selected Everett & Jones BBQ. Business Profile: Everett & Jones is a well-known, Black-owned barbecue restaurant with locations in Oakland (Jack London Square) and Antioch, offering live music and a community-oriented atmosphere. Lease Terms: 10 years with two 5-year renewal options; 180 days free rent; base rent of $13,000/month in year two, $14,005/month in year three, with 3% annual increases thereafter and during option periods; percentage rent of 6% of gross sales; a minimum gross sales threshold to ensure viability. Subject to Board of Supervisors approval. Owner Testimony: Dorcia White, third-generation operator, shared her family's history: the business started in 1973, operated in San Francisco until the 1989 earthquake destroyed their 3rd Street location, and now she is eager to return the legacy to the city. She will be on-site daily. Commission Support: Commissioner Adams celebrated the timing during Black History Month and praised the family legacy. Commissioner Lee stated the lease was an excellent opportunity and offered to assist with entertainment programming. Vice President Gilman highlighted the success of the Port's broker policy in attracting locally-owned businesses over chains. President Brandon noted this was the first restaurant lease on the waterfront since the pandemic and welcomed the new venture. Resolution 2511 was adopted unanimously. New Business - Flood Study Update: President Brandon noted that an update on the flood study, incorporating sea-level rise planning from BCDC, was recorded for new business but no further discussion was reported. - Commissioner Requests: Commissioner Lee requested that future staff reports include a breakdown of scoring criteria (e.g., operational strength, equity considerations) for competing proposals, not just financial terms. Vice President Gilman requested a site tour of Fisherman's Wharf to observe fishing operations and waterfront revitalization, and reminded maritime staff to schedule the tour. Key Outcomes - Votes and Approvals: - Approved the minutes of February 11, 2025. - Adopted Resolution 2508 (environmental/planning RFQ), Resolution 2509 (engineering RFQ), and Resolution 2510 (Mission Bay Ferry Landing construction bid). - Adopted Resolution 2511 (lease with Everett & Jones BBQ), forwarding it to the Board of Supervisors for final approval. - Directives: President Brandon will connect Rebecca Groves with Planning Director David Beaupre to discuss the Pier 54 alternative for the ferry terminal. Staff will incorporate Commissioner Lee's request for scoring breakdowns in future reports. Staff will schedule a Fisherman's Wharf tour as requested by Vice President Gilman. - Next Steps: The updated 10-year capital plan will be presented for final approval at the March 11, 2025 meeting. Write-off reports will be processed after the 30-day review. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of former Commissioner Francis X. Crowley.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on February 25, 2025, at 10:00 a.m. The meeting covered routine consent items, several legislative proposals, and a special order 3:00 p.m. hearing on the mayor's removal of Police Commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone. Key actions included the approval of an office-to-residential conversion fee waiver with a 7 million square foot cap, adoption of a resolution supporting regional transit funding, and a 9-2 vote to consent to the mayor's removal of Commissioner Carter-Oberstone. Consent Calendar - Items 1-2: Approved unanimously (11-0). Included appropriation for Municipal Transportation Agency ($526,000) and amendment to Airport Surveillance Technology Policy. Public Comments & Testimony - On the police commission removal: Over 50 speakers addressed the board. The majority opposed the removal, arguing Commissioner Carter-Oberstone was an independent, principled reformer who held SFPD accountable on pretext stops, DNA retention, and drone policies. Many called it a "Trump-style power grab" and noted it was Black History Month. Supporters of removal (including some from Asian American groups and Stop Crime Action) argued the commissioner's policies hindered traffic enforcement and morale, and that the mayor had the right to his own appointees. - Other public comments: Taxi medallion holders (at least 10 speakers) pleaded for relief from the failed medallion sales program, citing $250,000 loans, predatory terms, and competition from Uber/Lyft/Waymo. One speaker requested a cooperative pharmacy model. A representative from BART spoke in favor of item 27 (transit funding resolution). Several individuals spoke about unsolved homicides and the need for independent oversight. Discussion Items - Item 14 – Mid-Market/Tenderloin Community-Based Safety Program (Grant Amendment): Chair Chan spoke against, noting the city's $1 billion deficit and trade-offs. Supervisor Mahmood spoke in support, citing a 52% crime reduction and 80% drug crime reduction where ambassadors are deployed. The item passed 10-1 (Chan dissenting). - Item 15 – Office-to-Residential Conversion Impact Fee Waiver (Planning Code): Supervisor Dorsey introduced amendments with Supervisor Sauter to cap the total square footage eligible at 7 million (estimated 7,000 units). Debate included concerns from Supervisors Walton and Fielder about impacts on priority equity neighborhoods and loss of affordable housing funds. Supervisor Chen supported after trust in mayor's office. The amended ordinance passed 9-2 (Walton and Fielder voting no). - Special Order 3:00 p.m. – Removal of Police Commissioner Max Carter-Oberstone: The board sat as a Committee of the Whole. Commissioner Carter-Oberstone spoke in his own defense, emphasizing his independence and record of accountability. Supervisors then debated and voted on a motion to consent to removal. Supervisor Dorsey argued the charter allows removal without cause and that the mayor should have his own appointees. Supervisor Fielder opposed, citing the commissioner's accountability work and the lack of stated cause. Supervisor Melgar also opposed, stating that removal should be reserved for malfeasance. The motion to consent passed 9-2 (Melgar and Fielder dissenting). - Item 16 – Disability Access Improvements for Places of Public Accommodation: Passed unanimously (11-0) on first reading. - Items 17-18 – Liquor License Transfers: Approved without objection. - Items 19-20 – Appointments to Golden Gate Bridge Board and Police Commission (W.E. Wilson Leung): Approved without objection. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: All items approved unanimously. - Item 14 (Safety Program Grant Amendment): Passed 10-1. - Item 15 (Office-to-Residential Conversion Fee Waiver): Passed 9-2 on first reading, with a 7 million square foot cap (amended). - Item 16 (Disability Access): Passed 11-0 on first reading. - Police Commission Removal: The board consented to Mayor Lurie's removal of Commissioner Carter-Oberstone by a 9-2 vote. - Items 27-31 (For Adoption Without Committee Reference): Adopted unanimously, including resolutions on transit funding (affirming commitment to fiscal solutions for public transportation), Children's Dental Health Month, supporting AB 381 (forced labor), honoring Captain Jason Sawyer and Reverend Roland Gordon. - Appointments: Sabrina Hernandez, Bert Hill, Liam Devlin, Gregory Hardeman to Golden Gate Bridge Board; Wilson Leung to Police Commission. - In-Memoriam: Adjourned in memory of Betty Mae Cooks, Joe Chavez, Jean Alexander, Loretta Wiltshire, John Horton, and FX Crowley.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on February 25, 2025, at 9:30 AM. The Commission approved consent calendar items, several regular calendar contracts, and a revolving credit agreement with Wells Fargo, all part of the agency's broader financial and capital improvement efforts. Presentations covered workforce and small business outcomes, the Q2 FY 2024-25 budget status, a capital finance introduction, and agency updates. The meeting concluded with closed session and a tribute to former Commissioner FX Crowley. Consent Calendar - Approved the minutes of the February 11, 2025 meeting. - Approved the Consent Calendar Items 7A and 7C (Item 7B withdrawn). Public Comments & Testimony - Peter Dreckmeyer, Policy Director for the Tuolumne River Trust (General Public Comment): Criticized SFPUC staff for ignoring commission directives and resolutions, citing 2019 and 2020 resolutions on the Tuolumne River Voluntary Agreement. He questioned the design drought policy and risk assessment, stating the science behind fish models has been panned and that the SFPUC never responded to a peer review. He urged commissioners to act as a check on staff. Discussion Items - Item 5A - Local Community Workers and Small Businesses Report: Ben Poole (Director of Workforce and Economic Program Services) and Wendy Macy (Chief People Officer) presented outcomes for sewer and water projects. Highlights included: 34% local hiring (above city requirement) on the Sewer System Improvement Program (SSIP), 57% local resident apprentice utilization (above 50% requirement), $110 million in wages to San Francisco residents, 312 LBEs awarded 950+ contracts worth over $862 million, and project-specific achievements like the Southeast Community Facility (1550 Evans), which exceeded local hiring at 39%, apprentice utilization at 62%, and LBE participation at 31%. The presentation also covered HR recruitment efforts including 15+ career fairs by Olu Fadnipo, a San Francisco native recruiter. Commissioner Arce noted that PUC averages 41% local participation and 60% local apprentices citywide, comparing favorably to the city average of 33% and 49% respectively. - Item 5B - FY 2024-25 2nd Quarter Budget Status Report: Anna Dooning presented the Q2 report (actuals through December). Key points: Water enterprise revenues down due to lower retail volumes, offset by lower nonpersonnel costs, but overtime is over budget due to the Hetchy shutdown; wastewater revenues down, offset by lower costs; power enterprise lower retail volumes but higher wholesale sales; CleanPowerSF lower retail sales due to lower rates; all financial policy targets are being met. Commissioner Arce noted that CleanPowerSF's $40.5 million general reserve will carry over to next year. - Item 5C - Introduction to Capital Finance and Bonds: Nikolai Sklarov (Capital Finance Director) provided an educational overview on bonds, covering intergenerational equity, tax-exempt borrowing, WIFIA loans, and the importance of maintaining high credit ratings. He noted that the SFPUC has about $11 billion in debt outstanding and plans to issue $10 billion over the next 10 years, including a refinancing in March and new money in April. - Item 5D - Report on Recent SFPUC Activities: Commissioner Leveroni noted the passing of former Commissioner FX Crowley. Commissioner Arce thanked General Manager Dennis Herrera for authorizing San Francisco's first-in-the-nation mandatory local hiring policy when he was City Attorney. - Item 6 - Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) Report: Tom Francis, BAWSCA representative, praised the annual wholesale customer meeting held the prior week at the Millbury campus, with 30 representatives. Topics included emergency preparedness and the Moccasin penstocks project, which is likely to be more expensive and take longer than originally planned. - Item 8 - Revolving Credit Agreement with Wells Fargo: Approved a $200 million revolving credit agreement for two $100 million facilities (water and power enterprises). Nikolai Sklarov explained these are standby facilities to manage interim funding, with SOFR-based rates, and will not be the first choice for borrowing given the current commercial paper rates. The facilities are extendable up to nine years. - Item 9 - Cal Water Bear Gulch District Expansion: Approved the 4th Amendment to the Individual Water Sales Contract with California Water Service Company, updating the service area map to include Flood Park in San Mateo County. No other changes to service area or contract terms were made. - Item 10 - Amendments to Specialized and Technical As-Needed Services Contracts: Approved Amendments No. 1 to four contracts (Stantec/JHCE, AECOM/WRE, Lee Inc.) increasing each by an unspecified amount. Steve Ritchie explained the increases are needed to support additional capital improvement activities in the Hetch Hetchy area, including asset management and regulatory compliance. - Item 11 - Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Short-Term Improvements: Adopted the refined Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) and awarded Contract No. WD-2909 to Western Water Constructors Inc. for $44.9 million. Five bids were received; the engineer's estimate was $47.4 million. Work includes rehabilitating 1960s-70s concrete sedimentation basins, replacing sludge pumps, and installing a utility water pump station for the upcoming ozonation facility. - Item 12 - EXARO Technologies Duration Increase: Approved a 365-calendar-day increase for Cathodic Protection for Transmission Pipelines Phase 2, extending the duration contingency due to PG&E delays in providing utility power. No contract amount change. - Item 13 - Channel Force Main Intertie Increase: Approved a $2 million cost contingency increase and 350-day duration increase for Contract No. WW-723R with Anvil Builders Inc., for dewatering and utility delays. The revised contract limit is $90,375,899 and duration is 1,131 calendar days. - Item 14 - Hetchy Capital Improvement Projects Construction Management Amendments: Approved Amendments No. 1 to three contracts (AECOM/EMS, Avila, HECHE CM Partners) increasing each by $2 million for a new not-to-exceed amount of $6 million each's authority. Lucas Hoffman explained the need for additional construction management staff due to multiple active projects, technical demands, and outages requiring overtime. - Item 16 - Items Initiated by Commissioners: Commissioner Jamdar requested a briefing on the San Francisco Climate Action Plan, including Bay Area Air District zero-NOx rules. Commissioner Arce reported on Treasure Island power outages, noting five outages this year and a resolution from the Citizens Advisory Committee, and committed to working with TIDA on solutions. Key Outcomes - Approved the minutes of February 11, 2025 meeting (4-0). - Approved Consent Calendar Items 7A and 7C (4-0). - Approved Item 8 – Wells Fargo Revolving Credit Agreement (4-0). - Approved Item 9 – Cal Water Bear Gulch expansion (4-0). - Approved Item 10 – Amendments to specialized technical services contracts (4-0). - Approved Item 11 – MMRP adopted and contract awarded to Western Water Constructors for $44.9 million (4-0). - Approved Item 12 – EXARO Technologies duration increase (4-0). - Approved Item 13 – Anvil Builders Interior cost and duration increase (4-0). - Approved Item 14 – Construction Management Amendments (4-0). - Moved to not disclose closed session discussions (4-0). Closed Session - The Commission met in closed session to discuss City and County of San Francisco v. Pacific Gas and Electric Company and voted to recommend that the Board approve the settlement referenced in item 18. The Commission voted not to disclose closed session discussions.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 24, 2025, to consider several routine items including updates to the conflict of interest code, appointments to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force and other committees, and two ordinance amendments. Chair Shaman Walton presided, joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Sherril and President Supervisor Mandelman. The meeting lasted approximately one hour and included public testimony on the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force appointment. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (Sunshine Ordinance Task Force): Multiple speakers supported Cynthia Dye's appointment, citing her collaborative style, integrity, and experience on the California Citizens Redistricting Commission. Zoe Dunning (former DCCC vice chair), Lauren Gerardin (League of Women Voters of San Francisco), Leticia Miranda (research consultant), Paul Gardner (SFEDUP author), and Chris Keene (technology executive) all spoke in favor. Dylan Hirschell (2024 mayoral candidate) supported Honest Charlie Bodkin, highlighting his data journalism and technology background. One speaker criticized the recall of the school board and suggested political bias in the process. No public comments were made on other agenda items. Discussion Items - Item 1: Form 700 Conflict of Interest Code Update – Deputy City Attorney Brad Rossi confirmed that meet-and-confer obligations were concluded. The ordinance updates filing requirements for designated officials. The committee unanimously voted to recommend the item to the full Board. - Item 2: Sunshine Ordinance Task Force Appointment – Two applicants applied for Seat 10 (public member with demonstrated interest in citizen access). Honest Charlie Bodkin, a blogger and former LA Times data reporter, presented his background. Cynthia Dye, a management consultant and former member of the California Citizens Redistricting Commission, outlined her ideas for improving the task force, including proactive training, preventing abuse, and modernizing the ordinance. Chair Walton moved to appoint Cynthia Dye, citing her experience and the importance of diversity and independent voices. President Mandelman expressed disagreement with her past positions and could not support either applicant, noting additional applicants were expected. The motion to appoint Cynthia Dye failed (1-2, with Chair Walton in favor, Vice Chair Sherril and President Mandelman opposed). A subsequent motion to continue the item to the call of the chair passed unanimously. - Item 3: Citizens Committee on Community Development – Clinton Lofton, a reapplicant with over 30 years of experience in affordable housing and community development, was the sole applicant. The committee unanimously appointed him to Seat 2. - Item 4: Early Childhood Community Oversight and Advisory Committee – Cindy Lopez Chastain, the sole applicant for Seat 8, was not present but received positive remarks. The committee unanimously appointed her. - Item 5: Property Tax Refund Authorization – An ordinance to allow the tax collector to issue refunds under $10,000 without a claim, provided no property transfer occurred. No opposition. Unanimously recommended to the full Board. - Item 6: Parking Tax Reporting Requirement – Eric Mankey (Office of the Treasury Tax Collector) explained the ordinance removes the requirement for parking operators to report the ratio of unaccounted tickets, simplifying filings without affecting revenue. Unanimously recommended to the full Board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously for full Board consideration. - Item 2: Motion to appoint Cynthia Dye failed (1-2). Item continued to the call of the chair. - Item 3: Clinton Lofton appointed unanimously. - Item 4: Cindy Lopez Chastain appointed unanimously. - Item 5: Ordinance approved unanimously for full Board. - Item 6: Ordinance approved unanimously for full Board. All items acted upon are scheduled to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda of March 4, 2025, unless otherwise stated.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the Board of Supervisors met on February 24, 2025, at 9:45 AM, chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, with Vice Chair Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmud. The committee considered three items: a resolution supporting SFMTA's joint development program, a planning code amendment for alcohol uses on Third Street, and a new neighborhood commercial district on Leland Avenue. All items were recommended to the full Board of Supervisors for the March 4, 2025 agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 1, several speakers urged prioritizing affordable housing and community benefits on public land. David Wu (Soma Filipinas) and Zachary Friel (South of Market Community Action Network) argued that public land should be used for 100% affordable housing, not private profit. A speaker from the Muni Now Muni Forever campaign noted that thousands of emails were not specifically about joint development and urged using emergency funds to prevent service cuts. Another speaker cited the Hudson Yards example in New York to caution against prioritizing market-rate development. - On Item 3 (Leland Avenue NCD), multiple speakers including Kelly McCord (business owner, raised three children in Visitation Valley), Wilbur Moy (co-owner of Greenway Learning and Leland Merchant Circle), and Rebecca Miller (25-year homeowner and community group representative) expressed strong support, citing extensive community process and the need for a vibrant commercial corridor. Discussion Items Item 1: Resolution Supporting SFMTA’s Joint Development Program Goals and Policy - Chair Melgar introduced the resolution, emphasizing the need to address SFMTA’s structural deficit (projected significant near-term and long-term gaps) and generate revenue from its land holdings. She stated that MTA is an enterprise department like the Port or Airport and should prioritize financial health to maintain a world-class transit system, noting that Muni is vital for youth, seniors, low-income residents, and climate goals. - Wade Wickreff, SFMTA Joint Development Program Manager, presented. He explained that the MTA board unanimously adopted the joint development policy with three goals: (1) maximize public good through revenue, (2) create inclusive communities, and (3) build sustainable projects. The policy identifies 25 properties (out of 90+ MTA-owned parcels) for potential development, with a requirement that at least 50% of land at large sites be used for residential uses and at least 25% of units be affordable (80% area median income or below). Initial estimates for 4-12 properties suggest $12-47 million in net new annual revenue, potentially exceeding $100 million if all 25 sites are developed. - Supervisor Chen proposed amendments to add a "whereas" clause highlighting successful community-serving projects on MTA land (e.g., 1100 Ocean Avenue, 100% affordable housing for transitional age youth; Capuzol at Balboa Park, 100% affordable housing and child care; Geneva Powerhouse, community arts space) and to urge SFMTA to model a range of alternatives that maximize community development, housing affordability, and green goals. The amendment passed unanimously (3-0). - The committee then voted to recommend the amended resolution to the full board (3-0). Item 2: Planning Code – Third Street Alcohol Restricted Use District - Supervisor Walton, who introduced the item, explained that it creates an exception for distilleries, wineries, and breweries to establish on-sale liquor establishments in the Bayview Neighborhood Commercial District, subject to conditional use authorization. The goal is to draw businesses and foot traffic to the Third Street corridor. - Planning Department staff noted the Planning Commission approved the ordinance on December 5, 2024. No public comments were heard. The committee voted to send it as a committee report to the full board (3-0). Item 3: Planning Code, Zoning Map – Leland Avenue Neighborhood Commercial District - Supervisor Walton presented the item, stating it was a community-driven effort (initiated in 2023 by residents and merchants) to establish a new NCD for Leland Avenue between Bayshore Boulevard and Cora Street. The goal is to enhance foot traffic, foster a welcoming environment for small businesses, and link to the Visitation Valley Greenway. The controls were carefully chosen by the community, and the Planning Commission approved it on February 6, 2025. - Supervisor Walton noted that the community opposed including child care facilities near a cannabis shop, and the Planning Commission supported the community's vision. The committee heard public comments in support. The committee voted to recommend as a committee report (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Resolution amended and recommended to the full Board of Supervisors (3-0) for the March 4, 2025 agenda. - Item 2: Ordinance recommended as a committee report to the full Board of Supervisors (3-0) for consideration on February 25, 2025. - Item 3: Ordinance recommended as a committee report to the full Board of Supervisors (3-0) for consideration on February 25, 2025. - The meeting adjourned after all items were considered.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 20, 2025, chaired by Supervisor Jackie Fielder. The committee considered three agenda items: a resolution affirming support for birthright citizenship, a behested payment waiver for fundraising for immigrant and other legal services, and a behested payment waiver for Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park renovations. The committee also convened in closed session to discuss 12 litigation settlement items, ranging from $30,000 to $2,880,000. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Birthright Citizenship Resolution): Over a dozen speakers expressed strong support for the resolution. Speakers included retired Judge Lillian Singh, who called the executive order unconstitutional; Sophia, a DACA beneficiary from BOLD, who highlighted impacts on Latino children; representatives from Chinese for Affirmative Action, Chinatown Community Development Center, and the Japanese Cultural Community Center; and community members like Kevin Benedicto, an attorney and Police Commission member. They emphasized the historical significance of the Wong Kim Ark case, the constitutional basis of birthright citizenship, and the fear and harm caused by the Trump administration's order. Many speakers urged the committee to approve the resolution. - Item 2 (Behested Payment Waiver for Legal Services): No public speakers. - Item 3 (Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park Waiver): No public speakers on the continuance request. Discussion Items - Item 1 (250106 – Birthright Citizenship): Supervisor Connie Chan, the sponsor, presented the resolution. She detailed the history of Wong Kim Ark, a Chinese American born in San Francisco whose Supreme Court case in 1898 upheld birthright citizenship. She framed the resolution as a defense of immigrant rights and a stand against the president's executive order. Supervisor Sauter and Chair Fielder expressed support. The committee adopted an amendment correcting a date (1894 to 1895) and voted to forward the resolution to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2 (250139 – Behested Payment Waiver for Fundraising): Holly Long from the Assessor-Recorder’s Office presented the request for a six-month waiver to allow fundraising for legal services related to immigration, LGBTQ+ rights, environmental protection, reproductive rights, and racial equity. Chair Fielder introduced amendments to limit solicitation authority to four specific positions (assessor-recorder, director of policy, and two deputy assessors) and to require monthly reporting to the Board of Supervisors on solicitations and donations. The committee adopted the amendments and forwarded the item with positive recommendation. - Item 3 (250105 – Behested Payment Waiver for Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park): Lisa Branson from the Recreation and Parks Department presented the request for a waiver to solicit donations for park renovations, emphasizing the project's importance for downtown revitalization. However, due to ongoing discussions with Supervisor Chan about the scope, particularly regarding the Mayor's Office and Rec-Park involvement, Vice Chair Sauter moved to continue the item to the March 6, 2025, meeting of the committee. The motion passed unanimously. - Litigation Items (4–15): The committee entered closed session to discuss 12 litigation settlement items. After the closed session, the committee voted not to disclose the discussion content and subsequently approved forwarding the settlements to the full board with positive recommendation. The settlements ranged from $30,000 (Javier Grajeda) to $2,880,000 (Latoya Starks and Sanvada Kitcher), with others including $825,000 (Vincent Keith Bell), $110,000 (Marvella Branner), $500,000 (Matthew Gyves), $60,000 (John Pugh), $36,548.39 plus interest (Nordstrom, Inc.), $101,291.38 (Twilio Inc. and Segment.io), $35,491 (Joanna Lei), $88,000 (Peter Dumanian), $66,858 (180 Post Street, LLC), and a stipulated assessed value of $216,400,000 with a refund of $495,900 plus interest (CWI 2 San Francisco Hotel). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amendment (date correction) passed 3-0. Resolution forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (3-0). - Item 2: Amendment (narrowing solicitation authority and adding reporting) passed 3-0. Resolution forwarded to full board with positive recommendation as amended (3-0). - Item 3: Continued to March 6, 2025, meeting of the Government Audit and Oversight Committee (3-0). - Litigation (Items 4–15): Motion not to disclose closed session discussion passed 3-0. Motion to forward settlement items to full board with positive recommendation passed 3-0.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, February 19, 2025, to discuss crime trends, the DPA Director's report, and proposed changes to police district boundaries. The commission also approved a revised Department General Order (DGO) 1.06. Commissioners present: Clay, Benedicto, Yanez, Yi, and President Elias. Vice President Carter Overstone was excused. Chief Scott and Executive Director Henderson were in attendance. Consent Calendar - Approved the consent calendar with a motion to receive and file the electronic bias audit for Q3, Q4, and end-of-year 2024, and to accept a $5,000 grant from the National Association of Victims of Crime Act Administrators. The grant from the San Francisco Police Community Foundation was removed from the calendar. Motion passed unanimously (5-0). Chief’s Report - Chief Scott reported year-to-date part one crime down 34%, with violent crime down 13% and property crime down 37%. Auto break-ins down 56%, thefts down 30%. Shootings up 5% year-to-date, but homicides down to one (compared to three last year). Clearance rate at 300% due to solving older cases. - Significant events: NBA All-Star Game and Chinese New Year Parade occurred without major incidents; praised officers and city staff. Also mentioned a $250,000 donation from Charles Barkley following an op-ed by Alex Bastian. - Discussed Side Show activity: no side shows in SF; a large one on the Bay Bridge was handled by CHP, with SFPD assistance. One arrest and two cars impounded. - Discussed Sixth Street triage site: a collaborative effort with multiple city agencies; reported 270 engagements in one week, connecting people to services. Commissioners asked for a future presentation on this effort. DPA Director’s Report - Executive Director Henderson announced a new use of force audit, new interns, and that the DPA opened 18 new cases and closed 15 since last meeting. Top allegation was conduct unbecoming. 19 investigations open over 270 days (16 of those are on hold). 4 cases pending with the Police Commission, 103 pending with the Chief's office. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto acknowledged Black History Month and praised the department for the parade and All-Star Game staffing. - Commissioner Yanez raised concerns about missing community policing annual reports and requested updates on juvenile pre-booking program and DGO revisions. Chief Scott provided updates on the pre-booking program, noting ongoing collaboration with partners. Presentation and Discussion on SFPD District Boundaries - Commissioner Benedicto presented the district boundary review process, noting it was a multi-year effort. The commission considered the proposed map (page 84) and voted to forward it to the Mayor and Board of Supervisors. - Public comment included: Paul Allen (concerned about insufficient explanation for declining boundary changes), Chris Schuman (Lower Polk CBD: opposes proposed map), Alice Rogers (South Beach/Fillmore/Mission Bay Neighborhood Association: supports final map), Pratiba Tekke (Tenderloin Housing Clinic: opposes final map), Eric Rosell (Tenderloin CBD: supports patrol preferred map), and Gregory Johnson (CCSROC: urged future considerations). - Commissioner Benedicto made a motion to forward the proposal, starting a 90-day public comment period ending May 20, 2025. Motion passed unanimously (5-0). Discussion and Possible Action to Approve Dept. General Order 1.06 - Chief Scott presented DGO 1.06, 'Duties of Commissioned Officers', noting it was a collaborative effort with DPA. DPA had no objections. The DGO was last updated in 1994. Commissioner Clay moved to approve the DGO, seconded by Commissioner Yanez. Motion passed unanimously (5-0). Key Outcomes - Approved consent calendar (5-0). - Approved forwarding district boundaries proposal to Mayor and Board of Supervisors (5-0), starting a 90-day comment period. - Approved DGO 1.06 (5-0). - Closed session was removed from the agenda; meeting adjourned at 4 minutes over schedule.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, February 13, 2025, at 20:15 UTC (12:15 PM local time). The meeting covered a range of items including the FY2025-2027 departmental budget, a proposed ordinance to allow condominium conversion of accessory dwelling units (ADUs), a conditional use authorization for a maintenance building at the San Francisco Golf Club, and a conditional use authorization for a fleet charging facility. The Commission voted on all items, with some passing unanimously and others dividing the board. Consent Calendar - Item 3 (2024-009797CUA): Conditional Use Authorization to classify one dwelling unit at 2999 California Street 603 as an Intermediate Length Occupancy (ILO) unit. Approved unanimously. - Item 4 (2015-002658CUA-02): Conditional Use Authorization to extend a restaurant use at 2937 24th Street for three years. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish submitted a memorandum on the timeline of Section 317 (residential demolition) and urged the Commission to adjust demolition calcs to preserve housing in Priority Equity Geographies. Another speaker requested that the mayor's executive directive on permitting reform be distributed to the public. - Item 10 (ADU Condo Conversion): Public comment included: - Eileen Bogan (Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods) urged a continuance to May 1, 2025, citing procedural issues. - Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition) strongly supported the ordinance as a tool for homeownership and housing production. - Mitchell Omerberg (Affordable Housing Alliance / SF Tenants Union) opposed, warning of lost rent-controlled units and potential tenant displacement. - Item 11 (Golf Club Maintenance Building): Over 20 speakers, mostly parents and staff from St. Thomas More School, opposed the project, citing health and safety risks from construction dust, noise, potential chemical exposure, and fire hazards. Several speakers noted that the school's preschool and kindergarten children are especially vulnerable. The school principal, David Greenball, questioned why the club did not seriously explore alternative sites on its 163-acre property. A representative from the golf club's union (SEIU USWW) supported the project as a needed improvement for worker facilities. The club's project sponsor and architect presented revisions (increased setback, reduced height, elimination of chemical storage). - Item 12 (Fleet Charging): Two letters were received: one in support from Teamsters Local 665, one in opposition from Potrero Boosters and Dogpatch Neighborhood Associations. No public speakers appeared in person. Discussion Items - Item 9: FY2025-2027 Department Budget and Work Program - Thomas DeSanto (Director of Administration) presented a high-level summary, noting that revenue from entitlements and permits has declined 14% and 16% in the last two years. The proposed budget reduces fee revenue by $2 million, absorbs a $1 million CPI increase, and eliminates 6 vacant positions (following 17 and 20 eliminations in prior years). Total staff positions have dropped from 250 to 200. The department relies on the $7 million Pro-Housing Grant from HUD. Commissioner Moore cautioned about potential grant cancellations due to federal actions. Commissioner Williams expressed concern about future layoffs. The Commission voted unanimously to adopt the budget. - Item 10: Condominium Conversion of Accessory Dwelling Units (Planning Code Amendments) - Staff presented a detailed explanation of ADU types (local, state, hybrid programs) and rent control implications. The proposed ordinance (Supervisor Engardio) would allow certain new ADUs to become condominiums. Staff recommended modifications to limit eligibility to detached ADUs built through the state program on single-family homes or existing condominiums (4 units or less) and to new construction. This would avoid the loss of rent-controlled units and prevent tenant displacement. Supervisor Engardio spoke in support, emphasizing ADUs as a way to create generational wealth and housing options. Commissioner Williams voted against, citing concerns about affordability and the city's housing element requirements. The motion to approve with staff modifications passed 5-1. - Item 11: 1310 Junipero Serra Boulevard – San Francisco Golf Club Maintenance Building - This was a second hearing after a continuance from October 2024. The project sponsor made revisions: increased setback from 20 to 40 feet from the north property line, reduced building height from 25 to 23 feet, reduced footprint from 20,060 to 19,100 sq. ft., and reoriented the building so administrative offices are closer to the school. No chemical or fertilizer storage, no fuel filling, and no vehicle washing will occur on site. The club also offered to donate 1,800 sq. ft. of land to double the school's preschool playground. Commissioner McGarry, after a site visit, expressed concerns about fire egress, electrical transformers, and an encroaching building, but supported the project with conditions. Commissioner Williams moved to deny, citing inadequate environmental review and safety concerns; the motion failed 2-4. Commissioner Braun then moved to approve with conditions, including a review of fire safety egress at the fence line and directing staff to work with the Department of Public Health on additional dust mitigation measures during construction. The motion passed 4-2 (Commissioners Williams and Moore dissenting). The construction will be scheduled to minimize disruption during school hours, and a temporary dust barrier (12-16 ft high) will be considered. - Item 12: 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue – Fleet Charging Use - The project proposes 52 charging spaces and 6 on-site queuing spaces, replacing two surface lots now used for self-storage. One of two curb cuts on Pennsylvania Avenue will be eliminated. The project sponsor noted that the site is ideal due to its proximity to I-280 and will improve the site with landscaping, fencing, and security. The Teamsters and Electrical Workers unions expressed support after reaching agreements. Commissioner Moore asked about the lack of an identified operator; staff noted that permits often take years and an operator is likely to be secured before construction. The Commission approved the project unanimously with a condition requiring the queuing management plan to be updated once an operator is finalized. Commissioner So requested that the lighting plan be submitted to the Commission for informational review. Key Outcomes - Item 1 & 2: Continuances approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 3 & 4: Consent Calendar approved unanimously (6-0). - Item 9: FY2025-2027 Budget and Work Program adopted unanimously (6-0). - Item 10: ADU Condominium Conversion approved with staff modifications (5-1; Commissioner Williams dissenting). - Item 11: San Francisco Golf Club Maintenance Building approved with conditions (4-2; Commissioners Williams and Moore dissenting). The motion to deny failed 2-4. Conditions include: review of fire safety egress at the fence line, and staff to work with DPH on additional dust mitigation measures. - Item 12: Fleet Charging at 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue approved with conditions (6-0).