Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 501–510 ENTRIES
501
MAR 11, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting – March 11, 2025

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on Tuesday, March 11, 2025, at 9:45 AM. Commissioners present: President Stacy, Vice President Arce, Commissioner Jamdar, and Commissioner Leveroni (quorum achieved). The meeting covered the General Manager's report, including quarterly audit and performance review, an emergency firefighting water system presentation, and the Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program. The consent calendar and seven regular calendar items were approved. No public comments were received due to a technical issue with the remote call-in code, though the commission later corrected the code and offered an opportunity for comment. Consent Calendar - The consent calendar (Items 6A–6C) was approved unanimously (4-0) with no discussion or public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided oral or written comment on any agenda item. The commission acknowledged a technical problem with the remote access code earlier in the meeting and allowed time for callers to join; no callers were in the queue. Discussion Items - Quarterly Audit and Performance Review (Item 5A): CFO Nancy Halm presented the Audit Bureau’s second-quarter report (ending Dec. 31, 2024). Highlights: 17 audits completed (14 financial, 3 performance); 7 audits in progress; 12 scheduled for Q3/Q4. A spotlighted Budget and Legislative Analyst performance audit on Chapter 6 delegated authority found 7 findings with 16 recommendations (14 SFPUC-specific). Management concurred with all recommendations and has already implemented most. 17 open audit recommendations remain. Vice President Arce and President Stacy commended the team’s professionalism and the agency’s strong internal controls. - Emergency Firefighting Water System (Item 5B): AGM Steve Ritchie presented the Auxiliary Water Supply System (AWSS), now called the Emergency Firefighting Water System (EFWS). Key facts: San Francisco has 8,552 low-pressure hydrants (potable system) and 9,887 total hydrants; 1,300 are high-pressure hydrants attached to the EFWS. The system includes 154 cisterns (70,000 gallons each), 135 miles of pipe, three reservoirs (Twin Peaks, Ashbury, Jones Street), two pump stations (using bay water), and fire boat manifolds. Since 2010, 30 new cisterns have been added (mostly on the west side). A planning study estimated at least $4 billion by 2046 for full city coverage, but the PUC is developing a dual-potable emergency system (co-funded by ratepayers and General Fund) for the west side, with $145 million in the 10-year CIP. Recent drills and a fire boat demonstration (Jan. 18, 2025) showcased readiness. Commissioners asked about pump station backup generators (have diesel/electric with backup) and coverage gaps; AGM Ritchie noted that cisterns and the existing potable system provide substantial protection, and the city’s fire station density is higher than Los Angeles. - Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program (Item 5C): Katie Miller, Director of Water Capital Programs, reported on 22 projects (14 pre-construction, 7 in construction, 1 in closeout) with $1.9 billion total budget, $404 million spent as of Dec. 31, 2024 ($65 million in Q2). Cost variances: Moccasin Powerhouse upgrade (+$15M), Moccasin Dam Reservoir improvements (+$23M due to concrete/steel escalation). The 100-day winter shutdown (Dec. 5–Mar. 10) was completed, with O’Shaughnessy Dam outlet works and tunnel repairs progressing. Mountain tunnel grouting is 50% complete; negotiations continue with contractor. A nonconformance notice was issued for a building above a shaft (requires tear-out and rebuild). Vice President Arce thanked staff and noted that investments aim to extend asset life beyond 100 years. - General Manager’s Report/EPA Litigation (part of Item 5): GM Herrera reported that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled favorably in San Francisco v. EPA, holding that Clean Water Act permits must limit discharges, not receiving water quality. President Stacy emphasized that the PUC did not seek to undermine the Clean Water Act and that the narrow ruling protects ratepayers from potentially expensive open-ended regulations. - Project Learning Partnership Grant Program (Item 7): Carmen Knighton presented proposed rule modifications to increase grant amounts (from $105,000 to $130,000 for large cohorts; from $75,000 to $95,000 for small cohorts) and add performance measures. Program has served nearly 5,000 youth since 2012; 33% of participants from southeast neighborhoods. Approved unanimously (4-0). - Water Revenue Bonds Refunding (Item 8): CFO Nancy Halm (with outside counsel) presented authorization to issue up to $1.889 billion in refunding bonds (2025 Series A, B, C) to refinance up to 30% of outstanding callable bonds, expecting net present value savings of approximately $58 million (or more). The agency’s bond ratings (Moody’s, S&P) were affirmed with stable outlook. Approved unanimously (4-0). - Contract Awards and Amendments (Items 9–12): - Item 9: Awarded Contract HH-1016 (San Joaquin Pipeline Valve Improvements Phases 2B/2C) to Ranger Pipelines Inc. for $50,296,818 (lowest of five bids; engineer estimate $57M). Duration 1,204 days. Approved (4-0). - Item 10: Approved 283-day duration increase (no cost change) for Contract WW-662R (Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant Power Feed upgrades) to 1,938 days. Construction is 84% complete. Approved (4-0). - Items 11 & 12 (presented together, voted separately): Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project. Item 11: Amendment No. 3 to design contract with Moffatt & Nichol-AGS JV (increase not specified in transcript but requested) to address California Coastal Commission-mandated changes after a unanimous CDP approval (Nov. 2024). Item 12: Increase cost contingency by $2 million and duration contingency by 1,095 days for short-term erosion mitigation contract (sandbags, sand import). Both approved (4-0 each). President Stacy noted the importance of balancing ratepayer costs with recreational benefits. Key Outcomes - The Commission voted unanimously (4-0) on all items: approval of minutes, consent calendar, all regular calendar items (7–12), and authorization to enter closed session (asserting attorney-client privilege) and later approve settlements for three claims. - The commission will receive a follow-up report on implementation of audit recommendations from the Budget and Legislative Analyst. - The Ocean Beach project will proceed with redesigned elements per Coastal Commission conditions; negotiations with partner agencies continue. - The water revenue bond refunding will go to market in early April 2025.

PROCEDURAL 37% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8% · FIRE SAFETY 8%
502
MAR 10, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Regular Meeting – March 10, 2025

The Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Walton and joined by Vice Chair Sherrill and President Mandelman, met on March 10, 2025, at 6:15 PM (UTC) to consider five items: a proposed ordinance amendment, four appointment hearings, and a continuation. Public comment was heard on each item. The committee voted to continue one item and approved the mayoral appointments for the Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee, Veterans Affairs Commission, Municipal Transportation Agency Board, and Police Commission. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Administrative Code – Personal Safety Redactions): Laura Thomas, Senior Director of HIV and Harm Reduction Policy at the San Francisco AIDS Foundation and a District 10 resident, expressed full support for the ordinance, noting that her organization is involved in a lawsuit against current administration executive orders and appreciates the potential protection for staff and board members. - Item 2 (Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee Appointments): Nineteen applicants applied for seven seats. Public comment was not offered; the committee heard two-minute statements from each applicant present. - Item 3 (Veterans Affairs Commission Appointment): Three applicants (Chester Cow Williams withdrew via written statement due to medical emergency; Joshua Wagner and Barkley Sanders spoke). John Risenweber, a Vietnam combat-disabled veteran and current commissioner, spoke in strong support of incumbent Nicholas Rusinoff, praising his work with the Veterans Court and community outreach. John Gibson, a Marine Corps veteran, spoke in support of Barkley Sanders, citing his work with homeless veterans. - Item 4 (MTA Board Appointment – Alfonso G. Felder): No public comment was offered. President Mandelman and Supervisor Sherrill praised Mr. Felder’s qualifications and service. - Item 5 (Police Commission Appointment – Mattie Scott): Multiple speakers—including Carrie Barnes (Moms Demand Action), Nancy Tung (SF Democratic Party chair), Lawrence Lee (Advancement for Asian Americans), Michael Siracusa, Dr. John Ma (general surgeon), Christine Pelosi, Carletta Jackson Lane (executive director), Dorothy Ceruda (college professor), a Stop Crime Action representative, and a mother who lost her son to homicide—spoke in favor of Ms. Scott’s appointment, citing her decades of gun violence prevention work, community advocacy, and ability to bridge police and community. No opposition was expressed. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Administrative Code – Redacting Personal Safety Info): President Mandelman moved to continue the item for two weeks to allow further discussion with the domestic violence community. The motion passed unanimously. - Item 2 (Sugary Drinks Distributor Tax Advisory Committee): The committee heard statements from 19 applicants (including incumbents, youth, health professionals, and community advocates). Chair Walton noted the difficulty of selecting from many qualified candidates. The committee voted to appoint Chester Cow Williams (Seat 1), Gabriela Castellanos Rumbo (Seat 2), continue Seat 3 to next week, reappoint Abigail Cabrera (Seat 4), Jamie Schmidt (Seat 5), and Laura Urban (Seat 16). The motion passed. - Item 3 (Veterans Affairs Commission): After hearing from two of the three applicants (Joshua Wagner and Barkley Sanders) and public comment, Chair Walton moved to appoint incumbent Nicholas Rusinoff (Seat 9), citing strong recommendations from colleagues and the Veterans Affairs Office. The motion passed. - Item 4 (MTA Board of Directors – Alfonso G. Felder): Mr. Felder described his lifelong San Francisco connection, experience as a Muni rider, and work on the ballpark and Mission Rock transportation plans. When asked about MTA’s fiscal cliff, he emphasized listening to constituents and MTA staff, evaluating options, and making tough choices consistent with city values. Supervisor Sherrill moved to amend the motion to approve (removing “rejecting”). The motion passed. - Item 5 (Police Commission – Mattie Scott): Ms. Scott shared her personal story of losing her son to gun violence in 1996 and her 50 years of violence prevention and community policing work. She emphasized accountability for both police and community, prevention, and engagement. Supervisor Sherrill moved to amend the motion to approve. The motion passed. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Continued to March 24, 2025, Rules Committee meeting unanimously. - Item 2: Appointments approved: Chester Cow Williams (Seat 1), Gabriela Castellanos Rumbo (Seat 2), Abigail Cabrera (Seat 4), Jamie Schmidt (Seat 5), Laura Urban (Seat 16); Seat 3 continued. Motion passed unanimously. - Item 3: Nicholas Rusinoff appointed to Seat 9 of the Veterans Affairs Commission. Motion passed unanimously. - Item 4: Alfonso G. Felder approved for appointment to the Municipal Transportation Agency Board of Directors (term ending March 1, 2027). Motion passed unanimously. - Item 5: Mattie Scott approved for appointment to the Police Commission (term ending April 30, 2026). Motion passed unanimously.

PUBLIC HEALTH 35% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 22% · PROCEDURAL 17% · VETERANS AFFAIRS 10%
503
MAR 10, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - March 10, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 10, 2025, at 9:45 AM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Marina Melgar and joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Bilal Mahmud, considered four agenda items. Supervisor Matt Dorsey (District 6) participated as a guest for all items. The committee voted to recommend items 1, 2, and 3 to the full Board, and continued item 4 with amendments to the next meeting on March 17, 2025. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Treasure Island Sewer Pump Stations): No public speakers. - Items 2 & 3 (Central SoMa Commercial Development Requirements): Two speakers supported the amendments. David Wu (Soma Filipinas) thanked the city for retaining key site benefits for affordable housing and community amenities, but requested more proactive community outreach before future legislation. Zach Weisenberger (Young Community Developers) expressed initial concern that the legislation would jeopardize affordable housing development at 88 Bluxom, but commended the amended guarantee of land dedication for 100% affordable housing. - Item 4 (Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels): Multiple speakers commented. Several individuals in recovery from addiction (David Murphy, Timothy Stewart, Brendan Harris, Jurony Gomez, and others from Salvation Army and Positive Directions) strongly supported the ordinance as critical for opening the sober living transitional housing program at the Civic Center Motor Inn, stating it would help prevent relapse and homelessness. Cynthia Gomez (Unite Here Local 2, Hotel Workers Union) expressed concern about a "poison pill" amendment that would allow any hotel existing after April 1, 2025 to apply for interim housing, and asked for more time to review the full text to prevent unintended harm to union jobs and benefits. Other speakers from the Salvation Army and Joseph McPhee Center also voiced strong support. Discussion Items - Item 1 (250098): Acceptance of Sanitary Sewer Pump Stations on Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island. Supervisor Dorsey introduced the item, noting that the Treasure Island development will produce up to 8,000 units (nearly 10% of the city's RHNA housing target). Public Works project manager Desmond Chan presented that four pump stations are the final infrastructure remaining for Stage 1 acceptance; 974 housing units are already built, with 1,215 more planned. The pump stations are operational but previously had punch-list work. The committee received no questions and voted unanimously to recommend to the full Board with a positive recommendation. - Items 2 & 3 (250003 and 240787): Reduction of Commercial Development Requirements in Central SoMa and Transit Center District. Supervisor Dorsey presented amendments to provide flexibility for developers to build residential or commercial projects under 600 feet, while retaining key benefits for designated key sites, including land dedication for 100% affordable housing. He read the revised long title into the record. The committee adopted the amendments and voted unanimously to send both items to the full Board with positive recommendations. - Item 4 (241067): Interim Housing in Hotels and Motels. Deputy Director Emily Cohen (Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing) explained that the ordinance is intended to incentivize hotel owners to partner with the city for interim housing by allowing them to retain their tourist hotel land-use designation. She read two sets of amendments into the record. The first set narrows the scope to the Civic Center Motor Inn for the sober living transitional housing program, adds findings about worker retention and union successorship, and includes relocation requirements for participants when interim housing ends. The second set addresses three former Shelter-in-Place (SIP) hotels (Covoy, Monarch, and Adante) that need to regain tourist status after closing; these amendments are substantive and require referral back to the Planning Commission. Supervisor Mahmud asked clarifying questions—the April 1, 2025 date ensures no retroactive applications, and the Civic Center Motor Inn currently has no union workers. Cynthia Gomez from Unite Here requested more time to review the second set of amendments. The committee voted to adopt only the first set of amendments (non-substantive) and then voted to continue the item as amended to the March 17, 2025 meeting, allowing time for review and referral of the second set to the Planning Commission. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimously recommended to the full Board (3-0). - Items 2 & 3: Amendments adopted; both items unanimously recommended to the full Board (3-0). - Item 4: First set of amendments (non-substantive) adopted unanimously (3-0); item continued to March 17, 2025 meeting. The second set of amendments (SIP hotel provisions) will be referred to the Planning Commission for review before returning to committee. - Next Scheduled Meeting: The committee is expected to continue item 4 on March 17, 2025.

HOMELESSNESS 34% · LAND USE 29% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · PROCEDURAL 6%
504
MAR 6, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission March 6, 2025: Hotel Conversion, Parking Lots, and Housing Projects

The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on Thursday, March 6, 2025, for a regular meeting, beginning with a land acknowledgement recognizing the Ramaytush Ohlone as the original inhabitants of the San Francisco Peninsula. The Commission addressed a full agenda including a settlement-driven hotel conversion, an extension for nonconforming parking lots, an informational presentation on the SFMTA’s Joint Development Program, and several Conditional Use Authorizations. The Commission unanimously passed consent items and key regular calendar items, while continuing a contested single-family demolition project with specific direction to add a second dwelling unit. Consent Calendar - Unanimously approved Items 3 (200 Rhode Island St), 4 (1375 Howard St), and 5 (225 Lee Ave) for Conditional Use Authorization without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Bridget Maley, representing Neighborhoods United SF, urged the Commission to support robust public engagement and data-driven analysis before implementing major rezoning changes, including upzoning and density decontrol. Thomas Rorick, a member of Carpenter’s Local 22, spoke on behalf of nearly 4,000 members in San Francisco, advocating for apprenticeship, fair wages, local hire, and pensions. Another speaker raised concerns about demolition calculations (“demo calcs”) for alterations leading to housing loss. - Item 10 (447 Bush Street): An unnamed speaker expressed general concern about encouraging the elimination of affordable temporary housing (SROs). Sue Hester spoke against setting a precedent for such conversions without proper legislative review. - Item 13 (237 Sanchez Street): Bill Tannenbaum, a neighbor at 46 Sharon Street, noted positive collaboration but requested a light study and licensed arborist to protect mature trees during construction. - Item 14 (788 Arkansas Street): No public comment was offered. Discussion Items Item 10: Conversion of Residential to Tourist Hotel Rooms (447 Bush Street) - Staff presented a Planning Code Amendment tied to a settlement of federal litigation. The amendment waives fees and the CUA requirement for Hotel de Arts to convert 38 of 51 units from residential to tourist use. In exchange, the buildings at 412 Hayes Street and 319 Ivy Street would become subject to the hotel conversion ordinance, resulting in 34 new residential units with minimum 30-day tenancies. - Commissioner Williams expressed strong concern about the loss of SRO housing, a critical source of deep affordability. Commissioner Imperial noted it was a unique settlement situation. Commissioner Braun stressed the legislation’s narrow scope and asserted it does not set a precedent. - Key Outcome: The Commission voted 7-0 to adopt a recommendation for approval. Item 11: Continuation of Nonconforming Parking Lots (CMUO and MUR Districts) - Staff introduced an ordinance allowing public parking lots in Central SoMa to continue operating until December 31, 2026, after which a Conditional Use Authorization could extend operations. The provision originally required these lots to cease by 1990/2013, but enforcement was overlooked. - Commissioner Moore questioned whether a targeted solution would be preferable to a district-wide policy. Madison Tam (Supervisor Dorsey’s office) argued the broader approach prevents future blight. Commissioner Campbell supported the revenue-generating aspect. Commissioner Imperial supported the legislation given its flexibility. - Key Outcome: The Commission voted 7-0 to adopt a recommendation for approval. Item 12: SFMTA Joint Development Program Goals and Policy (Informational) - Wade Wietgrefe (SFMTA) presented the program to use SFMTA-owned land (25 of 90+ properties) to generate revenue for Muni, which faces a $320 million annual structural deficit from July 2026. Goals include maximizing public good, creating inclusive communities, and building sustainable projects. The policy must comply with the Surplus Land Act (50% residential, 25% affordable at 80% AMI). - Commissioner Braun asked about portfolio-level implementation of affordability requirements. Commissioner Williams emphasized community engagement and the need for higher affordability percentages. Commissioner Imperial highlighted interest in specific sites like 5th and Mission. Vice President Moore noted the challenge of developing small sites and requested ongoing updates. - Key Outcome: Informational presentation; no action was taken. Item 13: Demolition and New Construction (237 Sanchez Street) - Staff recommended approval for a five-unit apartment building replacing a single-family home with an unauthorized unit. The project is code-compliant, provides a net gain of three units, and includes two rent-controlled units. - Neighbor Bill Tannenbaum requested a light study and tree protection. Commissioners Moore and Imperial supported a condition for an arborist study. Commissioner Campbell argued the requests exceeded standard code requirements. The neighbor and sponsor had generally good relations. - Key Outcome: The Commission voted 7-0 to approve the conditional use authorization with standard conditions. Commissioners encouraged the sponsor to voluntarily continue cooperating with the neighbor. Item 14: Demolition and New Single-Family Construction (788 Arkansas Street) - Staff recommended disapproval of the project (new 4,000 sq ft living / 5,000 sq ft gross single-family home in the Priority Equity Geography, RH-2 district), stating it does not maximize allowed density (two units) and demolishes a relatively affordable unit. - The sponsor (Aeton Frazier) argued the lot’s steep slope makes a second unit infeasible. They noted all contiguous neighbors submitted letters of support for the single-family plan and expressed frustration that the disapproval recommendation came only two weeks prior. - Commissioner Braun made a motion to continue the item to April 10, 2025, with direction to redesign for a second unit. Commissioners Imperial and Moore echoed the need for densification. Commissioner Campbell argued it is inappropriate to deny a code-compliant project based on unwritten policy goals. - Key Outcome: The item was continued to April 10, 2025 (vote 6-1, Commissioner Campbell dissenting) with direction to return with a redesigned project including a second unit. Additional Commission Matters - The Commission paused to honor the memory of former Planning Director Alan Jacobs (1967-1974). Commissioner Moore highlighted his creation of the San Francisco Urban Design Plan, Octavia Boulevard, and other community-focused projects. Director Hillis and the Commission expressed condolences. - Commissioner Imperial reported on a collaborative community survey event in the Sunset District held with Historic Preservation staff and local cultural organizations (WAM, United Irish Cultural Center).

LAND USE 21% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · TRANSPORTATION 10%
505
MAR 6, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Closed Session - March 6, 2025

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a special closed session meeting on Thursday, March 6, 2025, at 7:15 PM. The meeting included a roll call (all seven commissioners present), a vote to assert attorney-client privilege, a closed session, and a subsequent vote to keep the discussions confidential. No public comments were heard, and no other business was conducted. Discussion Items - Motion to Assert Attorney-Client Privilege: Commissioner Imperial moved to adopt a motion asserting attorney-client privilege regarding the matters listed for closed session. The motion passed unanimously (7-0). - Motion to Not Disclose Closed Session Discussions: Following the closed session, the commission reconvened in open session. A motion was made and passed unanimously (7-0) to not disclose any part of the discussions held during closed session. Key Outcomes - The commission voted 7-0 to assert attorney-client privilege and proceed into closed session. - The commission voted 7-0 to keep all closed session discussions confidential. - The meeting adjourned after the fifteen-minute break before the regular hearing.

PROCEDURAL 100%
506
MAR 6, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - March 6, 2025

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 6, 2025, at 6:15 PM UTC. Chair Jackie Fielder presided, joined by Vice Chair Sauter (referred to as "Vice Chair Slaughter" in the transcript) and Member Cheryl. The committee considered two items: a behested payment waiver for the renovation of Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park (Item 1) and a closed-session settlement of a lawsuit against the city (Item 2). Both items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Robbie Silver, President and CEO of the Downtown ESA Partnership, expressed full support for the behested payment waiver, noting his organization's role as fiscal sponsor in the public-private partnership to raise $10 million in private funds for the park renovation. He emphasized the need for city officials to assist with fundraising. - Bernadette Kim, a resident and external committee member of the Gateway Tenant Association, voiced support for the renovation project, highlighting the need for creative funding solutions due to the city's financial pressures and requesting appropriate oversight. Discussion Items - Item 1: Behested Payment Waiver for Embarcadero Plaza and Sue Bierman Park — Lisa Branson, Director of Partnerships at the Recreation and Park Department, presented a request for a six-month waiver of the behested payments ordinance to allow the Mayor's Office and Rec & Park staff to solicit donations from individuals, nonprofits, private organizations, grant makers, and foundations. The project is estimated to cost $27 million to $32 million, with $15 million to $20 million in public funding and a $10 million private fundraising goal. The plaza's infrastructure is in disrepair, and the Valencourt Fountain alone would cost an estimated $10 million to repair. The design is outdated following the removal of the Embarcadero Freeway. Visitor data showed slower usage recovery at the parks compared to the Ferry Building after COVID-19. The first community meeting was scheduled for the evening of March 6, 2025. Supervisor Cheryl asked about operational cost estimates, which were not yet available pending design development. Vice Chair Sauter introduced amendments to narrow the list of authorized parties (specifying positions in Rec & Park and the Mayor's Office) and add a reporting requirement within 60 days of the waiver's expiration. The amendments were adopted unanimously (3-0). The amended item was then moved to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 2: Settlement of Lawsuit - Hotel Des Arts, LLC — The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to convene in closed session to discuss a settlement. No public comments were received. After closed session, the committee voted to forward the settlement to the full board with a positive recommendation and unanimously (3-0) approved a motion not to disclose the closed-session discussions. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee approved amendments to narrow the authorized solicitors and add a reporting requirement. The amended resolution was sent to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (3-0). The item is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on March 18, 2025. - Item 2: The settlement of lawsuit against Hotel Des Arts, LLC was approved in closed session and forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation. The committee voted not to disclose the closed-session deliberations.

PROCEDURAL 32% · PARKS AND RECREATION 19% · PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15%
507
MAR 5, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Regular Meeting - March 5, 2025

The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and including Vice Chair Matt Dorsey and Member Joel Engardio, met on March 5, 2025, to consider a hearing on the First Year Free small business program, two tax-related ordinances, airport professional services contract modifications, a Public Utilities Commission (PUC) radio site lease amendment, an emergency declaration for a water treatment facility, Health Service System (HSS) contract amendments, and two real property leases at 1099 Sunnydale Avenue. All items were unanimously forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. No public comment was offered on any agenda item. Hearing on First Year Free Program Supervisor Steve Sherrow introduced the hearing, expressing strong support for the program as a partnership between the city and entrepreneurs. Amanda Freed (Chief of Policy and Communications, Treasurer & Tax Collector) and Katie Tang (Director, Office of Small Business) reported that since the program began in November 2021, 9,400 businesses have enrolled and nearly $5 million in fees have been waived across multiple departments, with the largest share from the Department of Building Inspection (DBI). Success stories included El Milamores ($11,000 saved) and Casa Guadalupe ($1,800 saved). Officials noted obstacles to full implementation, including interdepartmental coordination and technology integration, and emphasized that a longer authorization (e.g., 5–10 years) would enable investments in system improvements. The committee voted unanimously to hear and file the item. Voluntary Disclosure Program and Empty Homes Tax Suspension Amanda Freed presented two ordinances. The Voluntary Disclosure Agreement (VDA) program (Item 2) authorizes the tax collector to waive taxes, penalties, and interest for unregistered businesses that voluntarily come forward and pay back taxes for the prior six years. It is expected to generate $1.5 million in prior years and $1 million in ongoing revenue. The Empty Homes Tax Suspension ordinance (Item 3) suspends the tax pending resolution of a lawsuit that has prevented collection since a November 2024 court order. BLA Analyst Nick Menard noted that revenue loss is estimated at $9 million in 2024 rising to $15.4 million, but these funds are dedicated to affordable housing, not the general fund. The committee forwarded both ordinances to the full board. Airport Professional Services Contract Modifications The committee approved modifications to two project management support contracts at San Francisco International Airport. Item 4 increased the Consor PMCM, Inc. contract by $10.3 million (total not to exceed $13 million) and extended it for four years for the Cargo Building 626.1 project. Item 5 increased the Westfield Consultants (WSP/AGS) joint venture contract by $10 million (total $13 million) and extended it for four years for the Cargo Building 720.1 and GSE Building 742 projects. Both contracts resulted from competitive processes, have 20% Local Business Enterprise participation, and received positive performance evaluations. The BLA recommended approval. Both items were forwarded. PUC Radio Communication Site Lease Amendment Josh Keene (SFPUC Assistant Real Estate Director) presented a resolution to amend a lease with Communication and Control, Inc. at a radio site in Alameda County. The amendment expands the leased premises to allow the PUC to install additional equipment critical to water and power operations and emergency coordination, increasing the monthly base rent to $9,080. The lease includes options through 2040. The committee forwarded the item. Emergency Declaration for Tesla Treatment Facility Angela Chung (SFPUC Water Supply and Treatment Division Manager) presented an emergency declaration to restore the uninterruptible standby power supply system at the Tesla Treatment Facility, which failed on December 11, 2024. The PUC plans to contract with Holt of California at an estimated cost of $700,000, with completion by April 30, 2025. Chair Chan clarified that the facility name is unrelated to the Tesla corporation. The BLA recommended approval. The committee forwarded the item. Health Service System Contract Amendments Michael Visconti (HSS Contracts Administration Manager) presented two amendments. Item 8 extends the Hyland Software, Inc. contract for document management by five years, increasing the total not to exceed amount to $574,000. Item 9 extends the P&A Administrative Services, Inc. contract for administering COBRA, AB528, flexible spending, and health spending accounts by 18 months, increasing the total to $4,667,457. The BLA noted that item 9 should have been brought to the board earlier under charter thresholds and recommended an internal audit; the department confirmed no other contracts were at risk. The committee forwarded both items. Real Property Leases at 1099 Sunnydale Avenue Driko Penick (Director of Real Estate) presented two leases at the Villages community facility in Visitation Valley. Item 10 with FACES SF provides approximately 3,000 square feet for workforce development and family services, with an initial annual rent of $48,867. The lease includes a conditional 822-square-foot portion tied to grant funding; if the grant ends, rent adjusts to approximately $36,000 per year. Item 11 with Felton Institute provides approximately 1,500 square feet for aging services, with an initial annual rent of $24,216. Both leases have five-year initial terms with two five-year renewal options. The committee forwarded both items. Key Outcomes - Hearing on First Year Free Program heard and filed (unanimous, 3-0). - Voluntary Disclosure Program ordinance and Empty Homes Tax Suspension ordinance forwarded to full board (unanimous, 3-0). - Airport professional services contract modifications for Consor PMCM and Westfield Consultants forwarded (unanimous, 3-0). - PUC radio communication site lease amendment forwarded (unanimous, 3-0). - Emergency declaration for Tesla Treatment Facility power system restoration forwarded (unanimous, 3-0). - HSS contract amendments for Hyland Software and P&A Administrative Services forwarded (unanimous, 3-0). - Real property leases for FACES SF and Felton Institute at 1099 Sunnydale Avenue forwarded (unanimous, 3-0).

SMALL BUSINESS SUPPORT 28% · PROCEDURAL 25% · TAX POLICY 6% · PENDING LITIGATION 6%
508
MAR 5, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
Budget and Appropriations Committee Hearing on Six-Month Budget Status Report – March 5, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, held a hearing on the Six-Month Budget Status Report for Fiscal Year 2024–2025. The Controller’s Office presented updated revenue and expenditure projections, which showed an improved two-year projected shortfall of $840 million—a $36 million improvement from the prior forecast. Supervisors questioned the methodology behind deficit projections, the impact of federal funding uncertainties, and potential next steps to address fiscal risks. Discussion Items - Controller’s Presentation: Michelle Ellersmith from the Controller’s Office reported a $36 million reduction in the two‑year projected shortfall, bringing it to $840 million. The current year shows a net revenue shortfall of approximately $115 million from budget, largely offset by a $98 million departmental surplus (driven by expenditure constraints, a hiring freeze, and additional revenue at the Department of Public Health). Key revenue trends include: record property tax assessment appeals, a 5% projected decline in hotel tax (after an 11% drop in the first half), weakness in sales tax, and improvement in real property transfer tax and interest income. The report assumes no changes to budgeted federal revenue. - Supervisor Walton: Asked how a net surplus and improved fund balance are possible when revenue is down. The Controller explained that the prior forecast did not capture departmental savings, which are now included and total $98 million. Walton also noted that the city projects 7.6% revenue growth over five years but 29% expenditure growth, requiring corrective action. - Supervisor Ingardio: Inquired why projected deficits often do not materialize as large as forecast. The Controller clarified that the deficit reflects the cost of maintaining current service levels under existing laws and inflation assumptions; the city must take action to balance the budget (e.g., mid‑year cuts, reserve use). The deficit is the “do nothing” scenario, not a prediction of the final outcome. - Supervisor Dorsey: Raised concerns about the uncertainty of federal funding given ongoing litigation and policy changes at the federal level. He suggested a closed session or full‑board discussion to assess risks. The Deputy City Attorney noted that closed sessions require a specific legal basis under the Brown Act, such as pending litigation. Supervisor Walton suggested a public forum instead of a closed session. Chair Chan proposed further consultation with the Controller’s Office and City Attorney to determine the appropriate transparent approach. - Chair Chan: Emphasized the structural imbalance between revenue growth (7.6%) and expenditure growth (29%) over the next five years, and the need for collaborative budget decisions with the Mayor’s office. Key Outcomes - Hearing Continued: The committee voted 4‑0 (President Mandelman absent) to continue the hearing to the call of the Chair, meaning the item will be brought back at a future date for further discussion. - Future Planning: Supervisors expressed interest in a public discussion on federal funding threats and agreed to work with the Controller and City Attorney on the appropriate format (public forum vs. closed session).

BUDGET AND FINANCE 75% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · PENDING LITIGATION 6% · PROCEDURAL 5%
509
MAR 4, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting – March 4, 2025

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, March 4, 2025, at 10:15 AM in City Hall. President Rafael Mandelman presided, with 10 members present initially (Supervisor Fielder was excused for jury duty and arrived later, bringing quorum to 11). The meeting included consent calendar approvals, unfinished business, new business, special order commendations, roll call introductions, and public comment. Consent Calendar - Items 1–16 were approved unanimously without severance. These included routine approvals and numerous lawsuit settlements: Vincent Keith Bell ($825,000), Javier Grajeda ($30,000), Marvella Branner ($110,000), Matthew Gyves ($500,000), John Pugh ($60,000), Latoya Starks and Sanvada Kitcher ($2,880,000), and others. Also on consent were amendments to the Administrative Code regarding electricity purchases, Planning Code changes for the Third Street Alcohol Restricted Use District, disability access improvements, and Leland Avenue zoning. Public Comments & Testimony - Obsidian spoke against perceived divisive celebrations (Black History Month) and weather manipulation, and called for ending QR codes and digital IDs. - Leah McGeever (D6) read a poem alleging she is a political target of Supervisor Matt Dorsey, expressing feelings of war and lack of support. - Chris Hard Klein alleged a surveillance system at 250 Kearney Street caused harm to veterans, referencing multiple deaths and arsons, and called for investigations. - Richard S. D. Peterson (82) described a seven-and-a-half-year wait to build a house in Noe Valley due to bureaucratic delays, criticizing outdated compliance forms. - Jim McAfee accused the Department of Public Health of failing to report patient share-of-cost revenue from Laguna Honda Hospital. - Nick Colina (Anco Iron) spoke in support of Item 37 (LBE resolution), stating that LBEs spend over $77 million in wages in San Francisco and provide union jobs. - Daryl Davis (small business owner) urged support for the LBE program, calling it essential for equitable contracting. - Tricia Gregory (micro LBE trucking company) also supported the LBE resolution. - Samuel Adams (Baines Group) cited 30% LBE subcontract dollars and 33% local workforce on affordable housing projects. - Salah Haquea Chandler spoke about her son’s unsolved murder in the 2015 San Francisco quadruple homicide, criticizing the trial and reward process. Discussion Items - Item 17 (Unfinished Business): Ordinance to exempt downtown non-residential-to-residential conversions from development impact fees and extend the adaptive reuse program. Passed 9–1 (Supervisor Walton dissenting). - Item 18: Retroactively authorized the Public Library to accept a $1,966,000 grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation for Jail and Re-entry Services, adding three positions. Adopted unanimously. - Items 19–20: Accepted grants for Embarcadero Plaza renovations ($12.5 million from BXP) and Great Highway Promenade planning ($1 million from Coastal Conservancy). Adopted. - Item 21: Approved $24.6 million contract amendment with CDM Smith for Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant ozonation. Adopted. - Item 22: Accepted $675,000 grant from James Irvine Foundation for Northern California Apprenticeship Network. Adopted. - Item 23: Authorized $50.6 million loan for 1135-1175 Ellis Street under the Small Sites Program. Adopted. - Item 24: Authorized $8.225 million Homekey grant for 42 Otis Street permanent supportive housing, with $8.7 million in matching funds. Adopted. - Item 25: Approved $13.424 million contract for seven battery-electric buses from New Flyer. Adopted. - Item 26: Referred without recommendation from Budget Committee: Third Amendment to Brilliant Corners contract for Flexible Housing Subsidy Pool, increasing the total to $59.54 million. Supervisors Dorsey, Chan, and Sherrill expressed concerns about underperformance (140-day placement average vs. 75-day target) and unrealistic metrics, but noted a reprocurement process underway. Adopted as a resolution. - Item 27: Resolution affirming support for birthright citizenship and opposing President Trump’s executive order. Adopted. - Item 28: Resolution authorizing fundraising for immigration, LGBTQ+, environmental, reproductive rights, and racial equity services via behested payment waiver. After initially passing same-house-same-call, Supervisor Chan requested a rescission and then voted no, citing perception of conflict for Assessor Recorder Joaquin Torres. Final vote: 9–1 (Chan no). - Item 29: Resolution supporting SFMTA’s Joint Development Program to address a $321 million structural deficit. Supervisor Melgar advocated for developing underutilized agency land for housing and revenue. Adopted. - Items 30–32: Various code amendments (Form 700 filings, property tax refunds, parking tax reporting) adopted. - Items 33–34: Reappointments to Citizens Committee on Community Development (Clinton Loftman) and Early Childhood Advisory Committee (Cindy Lopez-Chastain). Approved. - Special Order – Commendations: Recognized Chef David Ho for 40 years at Sam Wo restaurant, and Rob Connolly (President, Boys & Girls Clubs of San Francisco) for 25 years of service. Speakers praised their community contributions. - Roll Call Introductions: Supervisors introduced new legislation and resolutions, including amendments to the Healthy Airport Ordinance (Mandelman/Walton), hearings on HSH contracts and the Four Pillars drug strategy, an entertainment zone on Union Street, a resolution on equitable shelter distribution, wastewater drug testing, data subscriptions modernization, and a resolution honoring Ramadan. Key Outcomes - Item 17 passed on final reading (9–1) to ease downtown residential conversions. - Item 26 (Brilliant Corners) adopted despite reservations; HSH to reprocure services with standardized metrics. - Item 28 adopted 9–1 after rescission, with Supervisor Chan opposed. - Items 37–40 (For Adoption Without Committee Reference) adopted: Item 37 reaffirms the Local Business Enterprise (LBE) program; Items 38–40 include a resolution opposing federal bureaucracy reduction, and reappointments to the Bicycle Advisory Committee and Commission on Disability and Aging Advisory Council. All passed with 11 ayes except Item 37, which was adopted without a recorded roll call. - Adjournment in memory of David Sahagan, Charles Fan (founder of The Slanted Door), and Mark Izu (musician and Japantown advocate).

PUBLIC COMMENT 29% · PROCEDURAL 15% · HOMELESSNESS 11% · PUBLIC HEALTH 9%
510
MAR 3, 2025 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - March 3, 2025

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 3, 2025, to consider two ordinances amending the Planning Code, Zoning Map, and General Plan to reduce commercial development requirements in the Central SoMa Special Use District and remove the Transit Center C-3O SD commercial special use district. The meeting included presentations from the Planning Department and the Controller's Office, public testimony, and a unanimous vote to continue the items to the March 10, 2025, meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - David Wu (Soma Pilipinas): Expressed support for the legislation as amended, noting that maintaining key site commitments for affordable housing and neighborhood amenities will ensure space for low-income and working-class families. He emphasized the importance of honoring the seven-year community engagement process. - Wes (neighborhood resident): Stated that building more market-rate housing would benefit market-rate renters like himself, and that the plan should be more ambitious given housing demand. - Zach Weisenberger (Young Community Developers): Expressed initial concern that the legislation would undermine affordable housing development rights at 88 Bluxome, but praised the inclusion of amendments that guarantee land dedication for 100% affordable housing, safeguarding community commitments. - Tommy Chan (BXP): Represented a developer owning a key site; supported the legislation as it provides flexibility to consider alternative uses (e.g., housing) given the 35% office vacancy rate. - Rudy Gonzalez (San Francisco Building and Construction Trades Council): Supported the plan revisions, noting that honoring community benefits allows full support. He highlighted that infeasibility of projects leads to joblessness among construction workers, with 700 craft workers currently out of work. - Philip Raffle (SFEMB, Noe Valley homeowner): Supported the update, stating the original plan was for a world that no longer exists after the pandemic, and the changes will revitalize SoMa and address the housing shortage. - Scott Rowitz (Yerba Buena Partnership): Supported the legislation, noting it will increase the number of residential units in the neighborhood beyond the original 1,016 units, and appreciated the collaborative effort. - Jesse Blout (Strata Investment Group): Supported the legislation as a surgical change that will unlock new housing. He noted that new office construction is far off, as his firm recently purchased a distressed office building at a quarter of replacement value. - Brianna Morales (Housing Action Coalition): Voiced support, stating the legislation removes arbitrary barriers, promotes transit-oriented mixed-use development, and aligns with housing element goals. - Raquel Redondius (Soma Pilipinas, Planning Equity Council): Supported the pivot to housing but had concerns about original lack of protections for amenities and affordable housing. She thanked the sponsors for amendments that preserve those benefits. - John Avalos (Council of Community Housing Organizations): Expressed appreciation for the amendments that restore pre-existing agreements. He stressed the need for downtown recovery to serve all residents, especially given federal funding cuts. Discussion Items - Supervisor Matt Dorsey (co-sponsor) introduced the items, explaining that they remove a requirement that large sites in Central SoMa and the Transit Center District provide two-thirds of their square footage for non-residential uses. This barrier to housing production is being updated to reflect current market conditions, where office space demand has plummeted. He noted that amendments will be prepared by March 10 to incorporate the Planning Commission's recommended modifications: limiting the exemption to projects 600 feet or lower and retaining site-specific benefits like affordable housing, open space, and complete streets. - Joshua Switsky (Planning Department) presented background on the Central SoMa Plan (2011-2018), which rezoned light industrial areas for 9,000 housing units and 32,000 jobs. The plan required large sites to have a high proportion of commercial space, but the pandemic and remote work have shifted demand. He explained that key sites were entitled with qualified amenities (e.g., 100% affordable housing land dedication, public open space) but are not moving forward, creating an opportunity to unlock housing. - Audrey Merlone (Planning Department) stated that the Planning Commission approved the ordinance with recommended modifications to retain commercial requirements but offer exceptions for projects that provide community benefits tied to impact fees. The sponsors are working with the city attorney to draft amendments, which they expect to be ready by March 10. - Asim Khan (Controller's Office of Economic Analysis) presented an economic impact report: office attendance has plateaued at <45% of pre-pandemic levels, office vacancies rose from 5.2% (Q3 2019) to 34.3% (Q4 2024), and office values dropped 40%. Removing the commercial requirement is estimated to yield 325 additional housing units over 20 years, reducing housing prices by 0.1% and generating $38 million in annual GDP and 200 jobs. He concluded the removal will have positive economic benefits. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue both items to the March 10, 2025 meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee, to allow time for the preparation of consensus amendments that incorporate the Planning Commission's recommended modifications. The motion was made by Supervisor Dorsey and seconded by the committee. - The amendments are expected to limit the exemption from non-residential requirements to projects 600 feet or lower and retain previously agreed-upon site-specific benefits (e.g., affordable housing, open space, recreational facilities) for key sites. - The committee expressed appreciation for the community engagement and the work of the Planning Department, Controller's Office, and City Attorney's Office.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 30% · LAND USE 24% · PROCEDURAL 17% · ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 15%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com