The San Francisco Police Commission held its regular meeting on May 8, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included recognition of Officer Andrew Young, public comment, reports from Police Chief Bill Scott and DPA Executive Director Paul Henderson, a joint presentation on the city’s Homicide Reward Program, approval of the commission’s Statement of Purpose, and the quarterly Sparks Report on policy updates. The commission also voted to enter closed session and subsequently elected not to disclose the discussion with limited exceptions. Consent Calendar - Received and filed: SFPD audit on electronic communication devices, Safe Streets for All 2024 first quarter report, Family Code 6228 incident report, and SB 1421 reports from DPA and SFPD. Motion approved unanimously (5-0). - Adopted minutes from April 17, 2024, meeting unanimously (5-0). Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker questioned the mayor’s actions regarding 49 nurses and scooters on sidewalks, urging enforcement. - A speaker advocated for an elected police chief, arguing the current appointment system leads to a broken department. - A speaker alleged that elected officials illegally gave credentials to public health systems, requesting referrals for indictments. - Jake Connor B. Ortega criticized Commissioner Benedicto’s previous statements, asserting that voters passed Proposition E because the commission “failed to put policy over politics” and warned that further propositions would strip commission power. - A mother (Ms. Brown) whose son was murdered in 2006 repeatedly urged the commission to take action on unsolved homicides, referencing the upcoming presentation on the Homicide Reward Program. - During the chief’s report public comment, a speaker criticized the Mission station’s captains and alleged that a planned “hill bomb” event was used to arrest minority youth, calling for an elected chief. - During the Homicide Reward Program public comment, Ms. Brown stated the presentation contained the same information as 2022 and demanded action, noting zero rewards had been paid in a decade. Discussion Items Officer Recognition – Officer Andrew Young - Sergeant Huang presented Officer Andrew Young of the Healthy Streets Operations Center (HSOC) for his exceptional work with vulnerable populations. Officer Young received the Police Commission Recognition Award. All commissioners praised his teamwork and compassion. Chief’s Report – Crime Trends and Major Incidents - Chief Bill Scott reported overall part one crime down 30% year-to-date, property crime down 33%, violent crime down 13%, homicides down 42% (11 vs. 19), and shooting victims down 35%. Gun seizures slightly decreased to 308 (59 ghost guns). - Significant incidents included a homicide on April 29 in Bayview, a stabbing on May 5 at 7th and Market, an elder abuse battery on May 1, a carjacking at San Francisco State, and a hate incident at Sunset and Ulloa. - A pursuit on May 7 for a felony hit-and-run resulted in a 14-year-old girl being struck near Francisco Middle School; the pursuit was canceled after the injury, and the suspect was later arrested. - Vice President Carter Overstone questioned the pursuit, noting the prior policy may not have authorized it. He pressed on the department’s high collision rate and lack of progress on Star Chase technology. Chief Scott stated Star Chase has a placeholder in the budget but research continues; he does not agree with unlimited time for DGOs. - Commissioner Yi asked about Muni response times; Chief Scott said calls are high priority but response times vary. - Commissioner Yañez inquired about language access data discrepancy; Chief Scott said it may be due to record-keeping and a previous coordinator on medical leave. DPA Director’s Report - Paul Henderson reported on audit awards, participation in a conference, and upcoming audits on stop data. DPA is uploading datasets to DataSF for transparency. 119 sustained cases are pending with the chief, 13 with the commission. Commission Reports - Commissioner Benedicto described a demonstration of the “Bola Wrap” restraint device and collaboration with SFMTA on stolen vehicle recovery, resulting in over 200 recoveries. - Commissioner Yi reported attending a sexual assault awareness event and a quarterly police awards ceremony. - Commissioner Yañez reported progress on the pre-booking diversion program (expected by end of 2024) and the investigative social media DGO. Homicide Reward Program (Item 8) - Captain Noah Malinger and Lieutenant Sanders presented the current reward program: rewards up to $10,000 or more, paid only after exhaustion of leads and conviction, with only seven rewards paid since 2001 (last in 2013). A revamped website now lists 176 cases. - Jermaine Jones (DPA) compared other jurisdictions: government-run programs in LA County, Philadelphia, and DC, and third-party programs like Crime Stoppers used in NYC, LA, and San Diego. San Francisco has the highest reward amounts but strict requirements (conviction, no anonymous tips). - Vice President Carter Overstone asked about relaxing restrictions; Lieutenant Sanders had no personal concerns but noted the rules were set by the Board of Supervisors. Chief Scott highlighted the challenge of witness fear of retaliation. - Public comment: Ms. Brown reiterated that no money has been paid out and the presentation repeated past information; she demanded action. Statement of Purpose (Item 9) - Paul Allen presented a draft Statement of Purpose outlining the commission’s jurisdiction, purpose, and goals organized around public safety, professionalism, accountability, and transparency. - Vice President Carter Overstone praised the collaborative effort. - Motion to adopt passed 4-1 (Commissioner Yi voted no). Sparks Report (Item 10) - Aja Steves (SFPD) provided policy updates: DGOs 207, 513, 610, 1011 in progress. The 2024 working group list needs commission approval (slated for June). Three working groups proposed. - Jermaine Jones (DPA) reported on the crowd control working group and the social media DGO. - Vice President Carter Overstone questioned the “non-designated timeline” interpretation that allows DGOs to sit after concurrence without extension requests. Chief Scott stated he does not agree with unlimited time for DGOs. - Commissioner Yañez expressed concern that the social media DGO (209) had been postponed to 2025 without her input; Chief Scott promised a date by Friday. - The report was presented for discussion; no formal action taken. Key Outcomes - Consent calendar and minutes approved unanimously. - Statement of Purpose adopted (4-1) and to be forwarded to the Mayor and Board of Supervisors. - The commission voted unanimously to go into closed session (Item 13) and then voted (4-0, with Commissioner Yañez absent) not to disclose the session except for non-privileged factual details to be included in minutes. - The Homicide Reward Program presentation was informational; no immediate action taken, but follow-up reports requested. - Chief Scott agreed to provide a timeline for DGO 106/107 and for advancing the social media DGO (209) by Friday. - The commission acknowledged the need to revise DGO 301 to clarify post-concurrence timelines.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThis was the third and final hearing to prepare the committee for the annual budget process, focusing on community safety and the network of programs serving youth, families, immigrants, and vulnerable residents. The meeting featured presentations from four city departments and a community coalition, followed by extensive public testimony from over 100 speakers. The hearing began at 9:45 AM and lasted into the afternoon. Public Comments & Testimony - Over 100 members of the public testified, with the majority opposing proposed cuts to youth, immigrant, and community safety programs. Many speakers identified as youth or representatives of community-based organizations. - Numerous youth speakers described how after-school programs, workforce development, and LGBTQ+ youth services provided safe spaces, mentorship, and life-changing opportunities. They urged the committee to restore funding, warning that cuts would lead to increased homelessness, crime, and loss of hope. - Several speakers from the People's Budget Coalition (including Coleman Advocates, SF Latino Parity and Equity Coalition, IFPT Local 21, SEIU 1021, Lyric, and PODER) argued that true community safety requires investment in social services, not policing. They highlighted that DCYF received 414 million in proposals but only funded 92 million (22%), with severe impacts on transitional-age youth, LGBTQ+ youth, and immigrant communities. - Representative from IFPT Local 21 proposed transitioning Urban Alchemy contracted positions into city staff roles (community ambassadors and transit ambassadors) citing labor concerns and potential cost savings. - Practitioners from Urban Alchemy testified in support of their program, emphasizing their role in de-escalation, overdose reversal, and providing employment for formerly incarcerated individuals. They cited 958,000 positive engagements and 43,000 de-escalations between January 2023 and January 2024. - Parents and community members from the Immigrant Parent Voting Collaborative and various cultural organizations spoke in favor of continued funding for language access, citizenship services, and legal representation for immigrants. Discussion Items - Department of Children, Youth and Their Families (DCYF): Director Maria Sue presented the budget journey. In FY 2023-24, DCYF had $210 million total budget, with $136 million in grants. For FY 2024-25, the proposed budget drops to $182 million, including $92 million in grants. DCYF received 700 proposals requesting $414 million annually but allocated $92 million to 142 agencies for 231 programs (22% of requested dollars). Priority areas include after-school programs, youth workforce development, and justice services. The School Crisis Support Initiative was highlighted as a multidisciplinary safety approach. DCYF noted they received 130 appeals from unfunded organizations, with results expected by next week. - Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD): Director Sheila Nicolopoulos presented the San Francisco Immigrant Legal and Education Network (SFILEN) and the San Francisco Immigrant Legal Defense Collaborative (SFILDC). In FY 2022-23, SFILEN served 1,167 unduplicated clients; SFILDC served 933 clients. Current total funding is $8.5 million. MOHCD proposed no general fund decreases to these programs for FY 2024-25. - Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD): COO Chris Otano reported a base budget cut target of $4.4 million. OEWD conducted three community town halls. Proposed cuts total $650,000: $600,000 from community economic development and $50,000 from workforce development, estimated to affect 102 clients. Workforce development programming was cut $1.85 million overall. - Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs (OCIA): Director Jorge Rivas described programs including the Community Ambassador Program (35 ambassadors, on track for 250,000 interactions this year), Pathway to Citizenship (340 citizenship applications, 650 consultations), DreamSF Fellowship, and language access. To meet the 10% reduction target, OCIA proposed $695,000 in grant reductions and $380,000 from the Community Ambassador Program, totaling $1.075 million, with no service delivery impact stated. - Supervisor Remarks: - Supervisor Walton questioned DCYF on TAY funding reductions; Director Sue said no reductions were made but acknowledged shifts. Walton also noted the District 10 Safety Plan partnership. He asked MOHCD if the mayor would accept their recommendation of no cuts (they said yes). He questioned OEWD on why workforce cuts were largest; OEWD said cuts were proportionate. - Supervisor Melgar expressed concern about youth program cuts, stating that slashing youth leadership and employment programs undermines recent violence prevention efforts. She pledged to fight for restoration. - Supervisor Walton criticized attacks on organizations of color and labor, stating it was "disgusting" to balance the budget on their backs. Key Outcomes - The hearing was filed (recorded as heard and filed) by a vote of 3-0 (Supervisors Chan, Melgar, Walton in favor; Supervisors Mandelman and Peskin absent). - DCYF's RFP appeal process is ongoing, with 130 appeals under review; results expected by the week of May 13, 2024. - No formal budget decisions were made; the hearing served to gather input for the upcoming budget process starting next week with enterprise departments.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on May 7, 2024, starting at 10:15 a.m. All 11 supervisors were present. The meeting covered a consent calendar, several regular agenda items, special orders for commendations, a committee of the whole on sidewalk assessments, and public comment. Key actions included approval of settlement agreements, grant amendments, ordinances on PFAS, Great Highway closure, firearm procurement, and recognition of Affordable Housing Month. Consent Calendar - Settlement of Lawsuit - Aidan Gauper and Cory Maryott: $800,000 - Settlement of Lawsuit - Patrick Marks: $55,000 - Settlement of Lawsuit - Ralph Harris: $400,000 - Settlement of Lawsuit - Debra M. Hoisch: $157,500 - Settlement of Lawsuit - Elijah Williams: $37,500 - Landmark Designation - San Francisco Fire Station No. 44: Approved. - Administrative Code - Firefighter Personal Protective Equipment Containing PFAS: Ordinance passed on first reading, prohibiting PFAS in firefighter PPE by June 30, 2026. Supervisor Peskin noted it is a national first. - Grant Amendments - Westside Community Mental Health Center: Two resolutions approved, increasing funding to $18,336,834 and $17,308,923 respectively, with term extensions. - Accept and Expend Grant - Bay Area Young Survivors: $800,000 for renovated seating area at Conservatory East. - Grant Agreement Amendments - Compass Family Services: Flexible Housing Subsidy Pool increased to $29,151,597; Family Housing Ladder increased to $13,104,997. - Emergency Declaration - Pine Lake Park Slope: $5,000,000 for repair and restoration. - HUD Block Grants: Four resolutions approved for FY2024-2025: Community Development Block Grant ($25,638,788), Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS ($13,301,528), HOME Investment Partnership ($7,761,293), and Emergency Solutions Grants ($1,802,414). - Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program - Transbay Block 2 East: $41,011,377 award approved. - 100% Permanent Supportive Housing - 1633 Valencia Street: Loan not to exceed $41,036,048 and grant not to exceed $80,785,406 approved. - Crankstart Foundation Grant - Public Defender's Pretrial Release Unit: $150,000 retroactively accepted. Discussion Items - Item 21 - Grant Amendment - Tenderloin Housing Clinic (THC): Referred without recommendation from Budget Committee. Supervisor Chan expressed concerns about performance and contract oversight, noting a new RFP issued in 2023 with results expected June 2024. Supervisor Preston highlighted significant vacancies documented in the BLA report, but stated most have since been filled. He urged better monitoring by Adult Probation. Supervisor Safai asked about the partnership, and Chair Chan confirmed it remains with THC and Adult Probation. The resolution was adopted. - Item 22 - Park Code - Great Highway Extension Road Closure: Supervisor Melgar presented the ordinance to close a 3,317-foot segment south of Sloat Boulevard to vehicles, creating a multi-use trail and improving shoreline resilience as part of the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project. She noted rising sea levels and the need to protect the sewage treatment facility. The ordinance passed on first reading. - Item 23 - Administrative Code - Firearm and Ammunition Procurement: Supervisor Stephanie introduced an ordinance setting minimum qualifications for suppliers, citing a Brady United report that found 90 California law enforcement agencies unknowingly bought from dealers with ATF violations. She stated there are 78,000 licensed gun dealers in the U.S., more than major fast-food chains combined. The ordinance passed on first reading. - Item 24 - Administrative Code - Family Violence Council: Ordinance extending the sunset date to May 1, 2027, and allowing the mayor to select a supportive department. Passed on first reading. - Items 25-27 - Liquor Licenses: Three licenses approved for Endgames Improv (2965 Mission St.), Paname SF (523 Broadway St.), and Bi-Rite (2134-2140 Polk St.), all with conditions. - Item 35 - Planning Code - 900 Kearny Street Special Use District: Supervisor Melgar moved to strike section four regarding use size maximums in the Chinatown Community Business District, citing lack of community consultation. The amendment was adopted, and the ordinance as amended passed on first reading. - Item 36 - Appointment to Local Agency Formation Commission: Supervisor Hillary Ronen appointed, with Supervisor Ronen excused from the vote; motion passed 10-0. Special Order 2:30 p.m. - Recognition of Commendations - Margaret Thrupp: Retiring director of Tel-Hi Co-op Preschool, recognized for nearly a decade of leadership and over 40 years in early childhood education. - Police Chief William Scott: Recognized for reform efforts, achieving a 35% drop in vehicle break-ins since August 2023, and double-digit decreases in violent and property crimes in Q1 2024. - The Jelly Donut: Family-owned donut shop in the Mission District, honored for 20th anniversary of Small Business Week and community service. - Brian Lau: Special education teacher at Roosevelt Middle School, recognized for innovative programs and dedication to students with disabilities. Special Order 4:00 p.m. - Committee of the Whole: Sidewalk Inspection and Repair Program (SIRP) and Accelerated Sidewalk Abatement Program (ASAP) - The Board sat as a Committee of the Whole to hear reports on assessment costs. Department of Public Works representative Mr. Lennon reported: - SIRP: 468 invoices issued since May 2023; 95% (443) paid. Remaining 22 invoices totaling $19,513. The report for lien approval included $8,522.08 from 8 invoices. - ASAP: 46 invoices issued; 35% (16) paid. Remaining 30 invoices reduced to 15, totaling $6,260.80. After adjustments (removing one property for alignment with other enforcement), the total was $5,212 plus 12% admin fee ($5,837). - Public comment: Several property owners addressed concerns. One speaker (Eric Haverly) alleged a neighbor repeatedly filed complaints. Another (Priscilla Seriano) noted a violation sent to a wrong address, but it was resolved. Cheryl Williams raised issues with tree roots causing sidewalk uplift. After public comment, the board removed two properties (Mangles and Amber) from the list based on DPW findings. The amended ASAP report was approved. Public Comments & Testimony - General public comment included: - A speaker warned about cell phone addiction and societal harm. - Chris Workline alleged misuse of military-grade surveillance equipment and reported a near-hit by a suspect fleeing police. - John Avalos (CCHO) supported Affordable Housing Month, highlighting Prop A passage and upcoming events. - Jim McAfee raised concerns about domestic partner rights at Laguna Honda Hospital. - A homeless speaker urged faster action on livability and homelessness. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: All items passed unanimously on a single roll call (11-0). - Item 21 (THC Contract): Adopted 11-0 despite concerns. - Item 22 (Great Highway Closure): Passed on first reading. - Item 23 (Firearm Procurement): Passed on first reading. - Item 24 (Family Violence Council): Passed on first reading. - Items 25-27 (Liquor Licenses): Resolutions adopted. - Item 35 (900 Kearny SUD): Passed as amended. - Item 36 (LAFCO Appointment): Approved 10-0. - Items 39, 41, 42, 43 (Adoption Without Committee Reference): Adopted 11-0. - Item 40 (Affordable Housing Month): Resolution adopted affirming commitment to scale up affordable housing investments. - Committee of the Whole: SIRP and ASAP reports approved with amendments to remove two properties from the lien list. - Adjournment: In memory of Randy Leo Dudley, per Supervisor Ronen.
The Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronan, met on May 6, 2024, to consider appointments and proposed amendments to the Language Access Ordinance (LAO). The committee heard a presentation on the 2024 Language Access Compliance Summary Report, received extensive public testimony, and voted on several items. Public Comments & Testimony - Over 20 members of the public testified, largely in support of strengthening the LAO. Speakers included representatives from the Language Access Network of San Francisco (LAN SF), Chinese for Affirmative Action, Filipino Community Center, South of Market Community Action Network (SOMCAN), African Advocacy Network, Arab Resource Organizing Center, and the Immigrant Rights Commission. - Many speakers shared personal stories of language barriers when accessing city services, including healthcare, housing, and emergency response. Several noted that Filipino language access remains unevenly implemented despite being a threshold language since 2014. - Recommendations included: increasing bilingual staffing, lowering the LEP threshold from 10,000 to 6,000, adding Vietnamese as a required language, improving complaint processes, and adequately funding the Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs (OCEIA) to implement amendments. - One speaker noted that 22% of spot-check respondents experienced wait times of 10–20 minutes for language services, and nearly a third were never connected to a bilingual employee or interpreter. - A speaker from the Office of Racial Equity noted that the 5% threshold for emergency response translations (based on state law) would mean only Spanish and Chinese qualify citywide, potentially excluding other languages. Discussion Items - Item 2 – Appointment to Sanitation and Streets Commission: Thomas Richard Harrison, the sole applicant, was reappointed. He has 28 years of experience as a city gardener and previously served on the Breckin Park Commission. The committee voted unanimously to send the appointment to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Items 3 and 4 – Language Access Ordinance Amendments and Compliance Hearing: Supervisor Walton introduced amendments to the LAO, developed in partnership with OCEIA, the Immigrant Rights Commission, and community organizations. Key amendments include: clarifying interpretation vs. translation, adding language access for health emergencies and digital services, codifying the three required languages (Chinese, Spanish, Filipino), requiring departments to translate signage, establishing a streamlined complaint process, lowering the LEP threshold for new languages from 10,000 to 6,000 residents, and adding Vietnamese as a required language effective two years after passage. - OCEIA Director Jorge Rivas and Policy Officer Chloe Noonan presented the 2024 compliance report, showing encouraging trends in LEP interactions and translated materials, but decreases in telephonic interpretations, bilingual staffing (citywide), and language services budgets (from $20M to $15M). OCEIA requested additional resources: upgrading two positions and adding a training officer and a language specialist (e.g., for Vietnamese). - Supervisor Walton also mentioned a forthcoming resolution to further strengthen implementation. - Item 1 – Appointment to Local Agency Formation Commission: Supervisor Hillary Ronan was appointed to a term ending February 4, 2027. She was excused from voting; the motion passed without objection. Key Outcomes - Motion to accept amendments to item 3 (LAO ordinance): Approved unanimously (Chair Ronan, Vice Chair Walton, Supervisor Safai all aye). - Motion to continue item 3 to May 13, 2024 as amended: Approved unanimously. - Motion to file item 4 (hearing on compliance): Approved unanimously. - Motion to recommend item 2 (Harrison appointment) to full board with positive recommendation: Approved with Walton aye, Safai absent, Ronan aye (2 ayes, 1 absent). - Motion to recommend item 1 (Ronan appointment) as committee report: Approved with Walton and Safai aye, Ronan excused.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 6, 2024, to consider three items: a Planning Code amendment for 900 Kearney Street, a commemorative street naming for Midge Wilson Alley, and a hearing on the city's plans to finance extremely low-income (ELI) housing units. The committee unanimously advanced the first two items and filed the hearing after extensive discussion and public testimony. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (ELI Housing Hearing): Numerous members of the public testified, including representatives from Asian Law Caucus, Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation, Young Community Developers, Senior and Disability Action, Faith in Action, and individual tenants. They shared personal stories of housing insecurity, inability to afford even subsidized "affordable" units, long waitlists, and the critical need for deeper operating subsidies. Many emphasized that current affordable housing is not truly affordable for ELI households, particularly seniors on fixed incomes, people with disabilities, and families of color. They urged the city to prioritize ELI housing and expand programs like the Senior Operating Subsidy. Discussion Items - Item 1: Planning Code Amendment – 900 Kearney Street Special Use District: Supervisor Peskin introduced an ordinance to modify the existing SUD to allow an enclosed rooftop arts addition and clarify use size limits. The planning commission recommended approval with amendments. Project sponsor Alan Lowe and artist Jeremy Fish spoke in support, noting the arts component would enliven the corner of Chinatown, North Beach, and Jackson Square. The committee voted unanimously to amend and forward the item as a committee report to the full board. - Item 2: Commemorative Street Name – Midge Wilson Alley: Supervisor Preston presented a resolution to rename the 100 block of Elm Street as "Midge Wilson Alley" in honor of Midge Wilson's decades of service to Tenderloin families, including founding the Bay Area Women's and Children's Center and co-founding Tenderloin Community School. No public comment was offered. The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution with recommendation. - Item 3: Hearing on Extremely Low-Income (ELI) Housing Plans: Supervisor Peskin called the hearing to examine the city's progress and plans to meet the state-mandated goal of 13,981 ELI units over eight years (1,748 per year). Presentations were given by: - Rose Johns (Human Services Agency) who provided data on senior and disabled renter households: approximately 70,000 renter households have a senior or disabled adult; of those, 42,000 are ELI, 33,000 are renters, and 24,000 are rent-burdened. - Dan Adams (Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development) who defined ELI as households earning less than 30% of AMI (about $31,000 for a single person). He stated there are 66,000 ELI renter households citywide, with 40% being seniors on SSI. The city's current portfolio includes 14,400 units serving ELI households, but these require ongoing operating subsidies. Adams described existing subsidy programs (Local Operating Support Program - LOSP with $36M/year for 2,300 units; Senior Operating Subsidy - SOS with $52M capitalizing 200 units) and noted the need for billions in additional resources. He acknowledged that many units rely on tenant-based vouchers not included in the portfolio. Supervisors Preston and Peskin questioned the gap between need and resources, highlighting the inadequacy of current funding and the necessity of a comprehensive policy approach. Supervisor Preston specifically mentioned the Faircloth-to-RAD program and Prop M (empty homes tax) as potential additional revenue sources. The committee filed the hearing without further action, with Supervisor Peskin indicating future policy discussions. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to amend and forward as committee report (Peskin) – passed 3-0 (Preston, Peskin, Melgar aye). - Item 2: Motion to forward with recommendation (Preston) – passed 3-0. - Item 3: Motion to file the hearing (Peskin) – passed 3-0.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on May 2, 2024, to address a full agenda. Commissioners unanimously approved continuances, a consent calendar, a local coastal program amendment for a cultural center special use district, and two discretionary review items. The meeting featured extensive public comment on a proposed cannabis micro-business in the Bayview and a discussion on property billing practices. Consent Calendar - Items 4 (14 Portola Drive CUA), 5 (1300 Columbus Avenue CUA), and 6 (900 Kearny Street Special Use District PCA) were approved unanimously (6-0) as routine matters. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish from SPEAC urged the codification of the flat policy, noting high real estate prices in San Francisco. - General Public Comment (Time Accounting Billing): An 87-year-old resident of 749 27th Street protested being charged for time spent on the phone and in meetings resulting from complaints by a neighbor. Planning staff stated they would investigate the matter. Commissioners expressed interest in reviewing the billing policy for potential abuse. - Item 11 (Wawona & 45th Avenue Cultural Center SUD): Eileen Boken of SPEAC urged the commission to continue or oppose the item, claiming the project could set a precedent for the coast. - Item 13 (2330 Lane Street): Over a dozen members of the public, largely Chinese-speaking seniors from adjacent affordable housing complexes (1740 and 1780 Bancroft Avenue), spoke in opposition to the project. They cited concerns over crime, safety, health impacts, and cultural stigma relating to cannabis. A representative from Betterhousing Policies.org requested alternatives, such as removing the manufacturing and retail components, limiting hours, and requiring the project sponsor to contribute to a neighborhood watch. Discussion Items - Continuances (Items 1, 2, 3): Items were unanimously continued. Item 1 (135 Kissling Street rezoning) was moved to May 23, 2024. Items 2a/2b (1153 Guerrero Street) and Item 3 (58 Buena Vista Terrace) were moved to June 20, 2024. - Commission Matters: Commissioners commented on a trial court ruling regarding SB9. Deputy City Attorney Austin Yang noted the ruling has no precedential effect on San Francisco. Commissioner Diamond requested a downtown recovery update, which Director Rich Hillis agreed to schedule. Commissioner Imperial read the land acknowledgement. - Regular Calendar, Item 11 (Wawona Street and 45th Avenue Cultural Center SUD): Staff presented an ordinance to amend the Local Coastal Program (LCP) and Planning Code for the United Irish Cultural Center site. The amendments, requested by Coastal Commission staff, clarify the existing 100-foot height limit and define Principally Permitted Uses (PPUs) to limit coastal development appeals for code-compliant projects. The commission approved the ordinance unanimously (6-0). - Discretionary Review, Item 12 (426 Fillmore Street, Unit C): The DR requester, Lauren Simon, argued the roof deck was unpermitted, caused leaks, and created a fire safety hazard by covering a hatch. The project sponsor stated the deck had existed since 2004 and was an exclusive use granted in the condominium map. Staff recommended not taking DR. The commission concurred, finding the dispute to be a civil matter, and voted unanimously (6-0) to not take DR and approve the permit. - Discretionary Review, Item 13 (2330 Lane Street): Project sponsor Mubasher Chowdhury, a local equity applicant, proposed a 2,500 sq ft micro-business for cannabis cultivation, retail, and a consumption lounge. The Bayview project was opposed by the community group Betterhousing Policies.org. Staff recommended approval, noting the uses are permitted in the M1 district. - Positions: Community members expressed strong opposition, citing crime fears, health impacts, and oversaturation of cannabis in Bayview. The sponsor countered that the project is highly regulated, provides a safe consumption space, and benefits his own neighborhood. He cited cultural stigma as a key barrier to community acceptance. - Outcome: After a lengthy debate over the retail component's suitability off a main commercial corridor and the project's security plan, the commission voted 6-0 to not take DR and approve the project. The motion included a specific finding encouraging the project sponsor to engage in continued dialogue with the Bayview Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC). Key Outcomes - Votes: All agenda items were approved unanimously (6-0). - Approvals: The consent calendar was approved. The Wawona Street SUD and Local Coastal Program amendment was approved. The DR for 2330 Lane Street was not taken, allowing the cannabis project to proceed. - Directives & Next Steps: Item 11 will head to the Board of Supervisors and then the California Coastal Commission for certification. Staff will investigate the time accounting billing issue raised during public comment. The commission requested a downtown recovery update from staff.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 1, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, Supervisor Mirna Melgar, and Board President Aaron Peskin in attendance. The committee reviewed 15 agenda items, including a first-in-the-nation ordinance to phase out PFAS chemicals from firefighter protective gear, emergency repair funding for a water main break at Pine Lake Park, multiple housing and homeless service grants, and contract amendments for reentry housing programs. The committee forwarded most items to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation, with one item advanced without recommendation. Key Discussion Items and Votes Item 1 – Ordinance to Ban PFAS in Firefighter PPE (File 240299) - Board President Aaron Peskin introduced the ordinance, which would prohibit the Fire Department from using or providing personal protective equipment containing intentionally added PFAS by June 30, 2026. Fire Chief Janine Nicholson and Adam Wood of the San Francisco Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation testified in support, noting that cancer is the leading cause of occupational death for firefighters and that PFAS chemicals in turnout gear are a major contributor. The cost of replacing approximately 3,500 turnout sets is estimated at $10.2–$11.5 million, offset by a $2.3 million FEMA grant. The BLA report noted that the city has paid $12.3 million in cancer claims over the past decade. The committee unanimously voted to forward the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 2 – Emergency Declaration for Pine Lake Park Slope Repair (File 240343) - The SFPUC requested approval of an emergency declaration following a March 8, 2024 water main break that caused slope erosion, tree damage, and exposed utility lines. The total estimated cost is $5 million, funded by water revenue bonds. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted unanimously to forward the resolution to the full board. Item 3 – Grant from Crankstart Foundation to Public Defender’s Pretrial Release Unit (File 240380) - Retroactive authorization to accept $150,000 to fund a full-time attorney position in the Pretrial Release Unit, which provides early representation and referrals to job training and substance abuse programs for detained individuals. The committee voted unanimously to forward with recommendation. Item 4 – Grant from Bay Area Young Survivors for Golden Gate Park Seating Area (File 240303) - Authorization to accept an additional $300,000 (total $800,000) for a renovated seating area honoring young breast cancer survivors. The committee voted unanimously to forward. Item 5 – Grant Amendment to Compass Family Services – Family Housing Ladder (File 240338) - Amendment to increase funding by $7 million (total $13.1 million) and extend the term through June 2026 for a scattered-site supportive housing program serving up to 70 families annually. The BLA noted initial underperformance but recent improvement. The committee voted unanimously to forward. Item 6 – Grant Amendment to Compass Family Services – Flexible Housing Subsidy Pool (File 240337) - Amendment to increase funding by $20.2 million (total $29.2 million) and extend the term through June 2026 for rental subsidies and case management for 165 families. The BLA noted improved performance. The committee voted unanimously to forward. Item 7 – Accept Grant from CA HCD for Transbay Block 2 East Affordable Housing (File 240373) - Authorization to accept $41 million in loan and grant funding (including $28 million loan to the project) for a 184-unit affordable family housing development at 200 Folsom Street, with 40 units for families experiencing homelessness. The committee voted unanimously to forward. Item 8 – Loan and Grant for 1633 Valencia Permanent Supportive Housing (File 240374) - Approval of a $41 million loan and $80.8 million local operating subsidy grant for a 145-unit permanent supportive housing project for seniors (55+) at 1633 Valencia Street. The BLA noted the city is not retaining land ownership and that the per-unit subsidy ($372,000) is higher than typical. Discussion included lessons learned from the similar 833 Bryant project and concerns about overconcentration of high-needs tenants. Supervisor Mandelman expressed concerns, but the committee voted 2-0 (with Vice Chair Mandelman absent) to forward with recommendation. Items 9-12 – HUD Entitlement Grants (CDBG, HOPWA, HOME, ESG) - Approval to apply for and accept FY2024-2025 grants totaling $25.6 million (CDBG), $13.3 million (HOPWA), $7.8 million (HOME), and $1.8 million (ESG). The committee voted unanimously to forward all four. Item 13 – Grant Amendment to Tenderloin Housing Clinic – Justice-Involved Transitional Housing (File 240152) - Amendment to increase funding by $1.2 million (total $11.1 million) through June 30, 2024, for the Drake Hotel and Hart Hotel programs. The BLA recommended against approval, citing underperformance (high vacancies, low placements into permanent housing). Adult Probation attributed delays to staffing shortages and COVID-19. The committee voted 2-0 (with Vice Chair Mandelman absent) to forward the resolution without recommendation, with Chair Chan and Supervisor Melgar expressing concerns about accountability and urging a new RFP process. Items 14-15 – Grant Amendments to Westside Community Mental Health Center (MINA and TRP Programs) - Item 14: Amendment to the MINA program (72-bed dual diagnosis transitional housing) – increase of $10.8 million (total $18.3 million), term extended through April 2027. The BLA noted good performance but inconsistent site inspections. Funded by Prop C. The committee voted 2-0 to forward with recommendation. - Item 15: Amendment to the TRP program (65-bed sober transitional living) – increase of $7.8 million (total $17.3 million), term extended through July 2026. Funded by general fund. The committee voted 2-0 to forward with recommendation. Public Comments - Item 1: Floyd Rollins, President of Local 798, thanked the committee for unanimous support and noted the groundbreaking nature of the legislation. - Item 5: Helen Hale from the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development spoke in strong support of the housing ladder program. - No public comments were made on other items. Key Outcomes - All items except Item 13 were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 13 was forwarded without recommendation. - The committee emphasized the need for improved monitoring and performance evaluation for contracted services, especially given the city’s tight budget. - The meeting adjourned at approximately 12:10 PM, with the next Budget and Appropriation Committee meeting scheduled for 1:30 PM the same day.
On May 1, 2024, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee convened to hear the March update to the City's Five-Year Financial Plan. The hearing focused on modest changes to the projected budget deficit and key risks, including labor negotiations, state budget proposals, and economic uncertainties. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar items were on the agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No public speakers commented on the item. Discussion Items - Hearing on the March Update to the Five-Year Financial Plan: - The Controller's Office and Mayor's Budget Office presented a joint report updating the December 2023 projections. - The bottom-line change was minimal: a combined change of about $10 million across the multi-billion-dollar General Fund budget. - Revenue adjustments included decreases in property tax projections due to assessment appeals, offset by higher business and payroll tax cash receipts, partially offset by known claims. - Transfer tax projections were unchanged, and no exemptions from Proposition C (passed March 2024) were assumed within the plan period. - Expenditure adjustments included higher salary and benefit costs (health and retirement), increased caseload costs for IHSS and other entitlement programs, and cost true-ups in local operating subsidies. - The report assumed no changes in reserve use, with slight formula-based adjustments to the general and budget stabilization reserves. - Risks and Uncertainties: - Labor negotiations: The forecast assumes wage increases of about 2.5% (CPI), but any agreement above that would worsen the deficit. Health benefit costs are projected to rise 7-9% per year, significantly higher than the historical 4-5%. - Retirement investment returns: Assumed at 7.2% annually, but actual returns through February 2024 were 5.7%, and year-to-date returns have been trending below the assumption. - State budget proposals could reduce excess ERAF by over $40 million annually, a risk not yet incorporated into the forecast. - Revision of local employment data by EDD revealed net job losses, despite earlier assumptions of immediate rehiring in the tech sector. - FEMA reimbursements for COVID-19 response are assumed at prior levels; the city has received $80 million of the $123 million forecast for the current year. Key Outcomes - The committee heard and filed the report on a motion by Chair Chan, seconded by Member Walton, with a vote of 4 ayes (Chan, Melgar, Walton, Mandelman) and Member Peskin absent. - The meeting was adjourned after the hearing, with no other business. The Governor's revised state budget is expected May 14, 2024, which will be closely monitored.
The Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, April 30, 2024, starting at 10:15 AM. The meeting included a special order with Mayor London Breed for a formal policy discussion, approval of consent and regular agenda items, commendations, and public comment. Key topics included tenant right to counsel funding, the Mayor's vision for nightlife and arts, housing initiatives, and an update on the emergency nurse registry contract. Consent Calendar - Items 2 through 14 were approved unanimously on a single roll call vote (11-0), including: low-value property tax exemptions (File 240161), Treasure Island development agreement amendment (240198), several lawsuit settlements (totaling approximately $1.45 million), vending requirements (Item 15 was severed for separate consideration), and others. - Item 15 (ordinance to amend vending requirements) was severed at the request of Supervisor Safai, who successfully moved to duplicate the file and send it back to the Rules Committee. The original ordinance was then finally passed. Special Order: Mayor's Appearance and Policy Discussion (2:00 PM) - Mayor Breed’s opening remarks: She emphasized revitalizing San Francisco through arts, entertainment, and nightlife. She noted a 53% increase in entertainment permit applications in 2023 (125 permits issued in two years) and highlighted new initiatives like the SF Live Concert Series and First Thursdays. - Policy discussion – Tenant Right to Counsel: - Supervisor Preston asked Mayor Breed to commit to funding the tenant right to counsel program at the current annual level of $17.7 million. Preston cited data from the program: since 2019, nearly $68 million invested, legal representation provided to roughly 12,000 tenants; 63% of fully represented tenants stay in their homes and 92% avoid homelessness. The program is highly cost-effective, saving an estimated $10 for every $1 spent. - Mayor Breed acknowledged the program’s success but said she cannot commit to a specific funding amount due to the city’s significant deficit, though she listed right to counsel as a top priority and said she is reviewing it. - In a follow-up, Preston urged continued collaboration to maintain local rent relief funds (ERAP). Mayor Breed committed to working with the board to ensure sufficient prevention resources but noted concerns about repeat requesters and proper use of funds. - Mayor Breed then asked Supervisor Preston if he would support the budget if his priorities were included. Preston responded that he would need to see the budget, citing past opposition to large SFPD increases and refusal to allocate Prop I funds for social housing. He said he hopes to support the budget but will focus on preserving services for vulnerable residents. Commendations (Special Order 2:30 PM) - Asian Pacific American Heritage Month (May 2024): Supervisor Chan recognized the APA Heritage Foundation, especially Claudine Chang and co-chairs, for 20 years of celebrating AAPI culture. - Miguel Carrera (Coalition on Homelessness): Supervisor Preston honored Carrera for 30 years of housing justice activism. Carrera, who experienced homelessness and exploitation, spoke about the ongoing crisis, citing 400 families on the shelter waitlist and families living in hotels for decades. He called for meaningful change and criticized budget cuts. - Laborers Union Local 261: Supervisor Dorsey recognized public-sector laborers for essential city services, especially during the pandemic. Union leaders thanked supervisors for support on equity and apprenticeship programs. - Willard Harris (104 years old): Supervisor Walton honored Ms. Harris, a former nursing supervisor and community leader who secured federal grants for free clinics in the 1970s. She remains active in Delta Sigma Theta and water aerobics. Discussion Items - Item 25 (Bayview Hunters Point Foundation contract amendment): Supervisor Walton thanked the foundation for improvements and accountability. Supervisor Chan noted the contract was right-sized for a shorter term due to pandemic challenges, emphasizing the need for ongoing performance audits. - Item 34 (Tryfacta nurse registry contract, without recommendation): Supervisor Chan explained the contract grew from $5 million to over $11 million due to billing disputes and nurse staffing shortages. She noted $85 million in similar contracts citywide and 100,000 hours of overtime at Laguna Honda alone. The board adopted the resolution despite concerns. - Items 30-31 (2550 Irving Street affordable housing): The board approved acquisition and a ground lease for a 100% affordable 90-unit development for low-income households, with a loan of up to $16.96 million and a $63.8 million multifamily revenue note. - Item 33 (Piers 30-32 lease endorsement): The board found the proposed lease fiscally feasible and endorsed the term sheet. - Introductions by Supervisors (Roll Call): - Supervisor Ronan introduced a resolution supporting SB 997, which would allow students to carry naloxone and use fentanyl test strips. - Supervisor Safai introduced the Downtown University Attraction and Retention Fund (proposed $25 million) to attract public universities to SOMA, Union Square, and the Financial District, citing Phoenix’s success with Arizona State University (11,000 students, $6.5 billion in investment). - Supervisor Peskin introduced the “Housing We Need Act” to create project revenue bonds for workforce housing (up to 120% AMI) using tax-exempt financing and property tax exemptions, addressing the 70,000+ stalled pipeline units. He also introduced a resolution to develop a plan to host the Sundance Film Festival in San Francisco. Public Comments & Testimony - One speaker urged the board to allow the condominium moratorium to lapse, arguing it would stimulate housing supply and tax revenue. - Another speaker discussed propaganda in cinema and the need for beauty in education. - A speaker requested investigations into alleged illegal access to city systems and suspicious deaths at 250 Kearney Street. Key Outcomes - Consent and regular agenda approvals: Items 2-14, 16-27, 28-29, 30-31, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37 were all approved (typically on a single roll call with 11 ayes). The minutes of March 26, 2024, were also approved. - Item 15 (Vending requirements): Duplicated and sent to Rules Committee; original passed. - Items 40-49 (Adoption without committee reference): All adopted unanimously after adding co-sponsors. - Commendations: Approved for AAPI Heritage Month, Miguel Carrera, Laborers Union Local 261, and Willard Harris. - No imperative agenda items or further business. Meeting adjourned after about 3 hours.
The Port Commission held a regular meeting on Tuesday, April 30, 2024, at 10:00 AM. The meeting included unanimous approvals of consent items, an informational presentation on dredging strategy with a contract extension, and a lease amendment recommendation for the Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy at Piers 31 and 33. Public comment was received on both major agenda items.