Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 711–720 ENTRIES
711
MAY 16, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - May 16, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on May 16, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC (1:15 PM local time). The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan present. The committee considered three regular agenda items: annual reports from two Community Benefit Districts, a behested payment waiver to fund a panda exhibit at the San Francisco Zoo, and closed session settlement items. Notable public comment was received regarding zoo worker conditions. Public Comments & Testimony - Corey Hallman, Teamsters Local 856 (public comment on item 3): Expressed concerns about unsafe working conditions, deliberate understaffing, and animal husbandry issues at the San Francisco Zoo under current Executive Director Tanya Peterson. Noted that workers have taken a second vote of no confidence in the director and that the Zoological Society board has hired a third party to investigate. Discussion Items - Items 1 & 2: Central Market and Civic Center Community Benefit District Annual Reports (CY2022) – Jackie Hazelwood (OEWD) and Tracy Everwine (Executive Director of both CBDs) presented. Both districts met all four OEWD benchmarks. Key statistics: Civic Center CBD had a $3.2 million budget, with 34,000 needles collected by staff. Mid-Market CBD had a $1.5 million budget. Both reports were late due to increased COVID-19 recovery demands, but the districts are now on track. Supervisor Preston noted the Civic Center CBD's field team's positive impact. Supervisor Stefani asked about needle pickup locations and proactive vs. 311 responses. Supervisor Chan raised concerns about the closure of the Fulton Gift Gallery and the displacement of vendors; the CBD is planning a vintage market starting August 2024. The items were moved to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 3: Hosting Panda Bears at the San Francisco Zoo – Behested Payment Waiver – Sean Elsbernd, Chief of Staff to the Mayor, presented the resolution to authorize the Mayor, Recreation and Park Department, OEWD, Airport, City Administrator, and Chief of Protocol to solicit donations from private entities to support a panda exhibit, targeting $25 million. Supervisor Safai expressed strong concern about prioritizing pandas over $25 million in cuts to children, youth, and family programs, and introduced a separate resolution. He questioned the zoo's readiness and deferred maintenance. Elsbernd offered to amend the resolution to include DCYF fundraising and noted the city's precedent for such waivers. Supervisor Chan asked about the zoo's readiness, referencing a Chronicle report on an internal investigation. Elsbernd detailed the multi-step process: technical agreement negotiations with China, U.S. Fish and Wildlife permit, and AZA accreditation. The committee discussed the need to list known interested parties (e.g., United Airlines) as required by the behested payment ordinance. Supervisor Stefani expressed support for the pandas as a positive for San Francisco. The committee voted 2-1 (Preston and Chan aye, Stefani no) to continue the item to the call of the chair to allow for amendments clarifying donors, narrowing department scope, specifying the beneficiary (San Francisco Zoological Society), and potentially including broader zoo capital needs. - Items 4-10: Settlements of Lawsuits and Unlitigated Claims – Seven items authorizing settlements ranging from $28,732.50 to $350,000. After public comment (none), the committee approved forwarding all items to the full board with positive recommendation without a closed session. Key Outcomes - Items 1-2: Moved to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous: 3-0). - Item 3: Continued to call of the chair (2-1: Preston and Chan aye, Stefani no). The committee expects amendments to list known interested parties, narrow the fundraising scope, clarify the beneficiary, and potentially expand to include other zoo capital needs. - Items 4-10: Moved to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous: 3-0).

PUBLIC COMMENT 22% · PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 12% · ETHICS COMMISSION 12%
712
MAY 15, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Appropriations Committee Hearing on Mayor's Proposed Budget for Selected Departments - May 15, 2024

The Budget and Appropriations Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, convened on May 15, 2024, to hear presentations on the Mayor's proposed budget for FYs 2024-2025 and 2025-2026 for 12 enterprise and non-general fund departments. The committee included Supervisors Mar, Walton, Mandelman, and President Peskin (absent). Chair Chan opened with remarks emphasizing the need to manage spending within the city's means and focus on core missions. The meeting also included public comment and concluded with a vote to continue the items to May 22. Public Comments & Testimony - Cyrus Hall (District 7 resident) spoke in support of sustainable transportation, noting that the SFMTA budget represented the best achievable within the current political context. He highlighted reduced fare increases (14% over two years instead of 20%) and a renewed focus on Vision Zero, but warned that without more funding opportunities, service cuts would begin before July 2026. He urged the committee to consider revenue measures like expanding residential parking permits and meter hours. Discussion Items - Airport (SFO): Director Ivar Satterell reported 90% passenger recovery (103% international, 85% domestic) and a proposed $1.6 billion budget (up 16%) for FY24-25, with 99 new positions (41 for an Airport Integrated Operations Center). The airport projects a $55 million annual service payment to the city's general fund, the largest ever, growing to $60 million in two years. Chair Chan thanked Satterell for his leadership and noted the airport's successful navigation of the pandemic. - Board of Appeals: Executive Director Julie Rosenberg presented a modest budget increase with proposed surcharge rate increases of $5 for DBI and Planning permits, and CPI-based adjustments for DPH and Public Works. Appeal volume is 37% below the 10-year average. The department has three full-time employees. - Child Support Services: Director Karen Roy reported that 93% of $22.4 million collected in FY2023 directly benefited families. The department operates without general fund support, relying on federal and state funds. It has 73 budgeted positions (61.5 filled, 11.5 intentionally vacant). Supervisor Melgar inquired about partnerships with the new Department of Early Childhood; Roy confirmed referral coordination and confidentiality limitations. - Department of the Environment: Director Tyronju highlighted a record $42 million in grants (45% of the budget), leveraging federal Inflation Reduction Act and Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funds. Only 3% of the budget comes from the general fund. Supervisor Melgar asked about coordination with other departments on climate adaptation; Ju noted participation in the Climate SF group and work orders with PUC, MTA, and DBI (12% of budget). - San Francisco Law Library: Assistant Director Diane Rodriguez reported a 49% lease savings (approved earlier that morning) and requested future funding for the charter-mandated head of technical services position. The library has seen a 52% decline in filing fees since 2009 and now has only three professional librarians. - San Francisco Public Library: Director Lambert presented the Vision 2030 strategic plan. Key investments include $4.8 million for a new Ocean View branch in FY26, $3.5 million for capital maintenance, $300,000 for digital collections for incarcerated individuals, and $250,000 for staff de-escalation training. The budget is funded 99% by the library preservation fund. - Port of San Francisco: Director Elaine Forbes and CFO Nate Cruz outlined three strategic pillars: economic recovery, equity, and resilience. The port has exceeded pre-pandemic revenues and is working on a $13 billion Army Corps of Engineers flood protection plan for the entire 7.5-mile waterfront. New initiatives include in-house security and promotive pathways for maintenance staff. Supervisor Walton asked about local contracting; Forbes reported that 50-80% of contracts go to local small businesses. Walton also raised concerns about flood protection for the Southeast; Forbes confirmed the plan includes that area and may expand to Yosemite Slough. - San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA): Executive Director Jeffrey Tumlin described a $214 million budget deficit in FY25-26 due to 62% lower transit revenue and 38% lower parking revenue compared to FY18-19. The budget closes a $12.7 million gap through fee indexing, including reducing a clipper discount from $0.50 to $0.25 (cash fare remains $3). Ridership increased 25% year-over-year and crime on Muni is down 48%. Tumlin emphasized a multipath strategy including SB 1031 (Senator Wiener's regional tax bill) and efficiency gains from transit-only lanes. Supervisors Chan and Melgar pressed for longer-term revenue strategies, including leverage of brand and real estate assets. Chan urged the department to pursue federal grants and cited SFO's concession approach as a model. - San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC): Deputy General Manager Ron Flynn and CFO Nancy Hamm presented a $2 billion operating budget for FY24-25, growing 20% over two years. The agency's affordability policy limits rate increases; a 10-year capital plan was trimmed by $2.7 billion. Of 170 new position requests, 87 are temporary-to-permanent conversions (budget-neutral). The capital plan includes $1.6 billion each year and a $3 billion debt authorization. Supervisor Walton expressed concern about contractors not fulfilling social impact commitments under the SSIP program; Flynn acknowledged the issue and said the agency is pressing contractors to catch up. - Rent Board: Executive Director Christina Varner reported a $13.8 million proposed budget, with the rent board fee remaining at $59 per unit. The department has grown from 35 to approximately 57 FTEs due to legislative changes. A new data analyst position will improve data modernization. Chair Chan praised the Rent Board's neutral role in helping both tenants and small property owners. - San Francisco Employees' Retirement System (SFERS): CEO Alison Romano presented a budget tied to operational excellence and technology. The system is 97% funded with $34.8 billion in assets and has exceeded benchmarks over 5, 10, and 20 years. The budget requests 11 new positions (7 previously approved for retirement services, 4 new for IT). Chair Chan questioned the growth in FTEs and its potential future general fund implications. - Department of Building Inspection (DBI): Director Patrick O'Rearden reported that the department's fees are often lower than other large California cities. A fee study proposes phased increases over three years, using reserves to bridge the gap until full cost recovery in 2027. The budget reduces attrition to maintain staffing levels. Supervisor Melgar asked about IT integration with other permitting departments; O'Rearden said collaboration with Planning and the Permit Center is ongoing. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (4-0, with President Peskin absent) to continue Items 1-3 (Hearing on Mayor's Proposed Budget, Proposed Budget and Appropriation Ordinance, and Proposed Annual Salary Ordinance) to the May 22, 2024 meeting. No final decisions on the budget were made.

BUDGET AND FINANCE 21% · PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 8% · PUBLIC LIBRARY 7% · ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 6%
713
MAY 15, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
Budget and Finance Committee Meeting: May 15, 2024 Approvals and Continuances

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, May 15, 2024, at 5:15 PM to consider a seven-item agenda. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Supervisor Mirna Melgar present and Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman arriving later. The committee unanimously approved items related to workforce grants, software procurement, affordable housing, a children's waiting room at the Hall of Justice, and police overtime funding. Two lease items were continued to the May 22 meeting due to substantive amendments. The meeting also included a period for public comment, though no members of the public spoke on any item. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was listed; all items were considered individually under the regular agenda. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comment was offered on any agenda item; the clerk reported no speakers for each item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Grant Acceptance – WIOA): OEWD's Jen Han presented a request to accept an additional $1.4 million in federal formula funds (total $5.655 million) from the California EDD for the WIOA program. The grant is retroactive because the state made adjustments after the original award. Funds support job centers and sector training, and must be spent by June 30, 2024. Supervisor Chan added herself as co-sponsor and expressed appreciation for the additional funding. - Item 2 (Software Agreement – Salesforce): DT's Hal Schiar presented a second amendment to the Carahsoft Technology Corporation agreement, increasing the not-to-exceed amount by $10.9 million to $20.625 million and extending the term by five years to June 30, 2030. Nineteen departments currently use the citywide agreement, which provides discounts over 30% and avoids seller markups. BLM's Nick Minard noted that only about a third of the estimated spending would be funded by the general fund. The committee voted to forward to the full board. - Item 3 (Housing Loan – 1005 Powell Street): MOHCD's Aliyah Gage presented a $20.9 million permanent loan for a 64-unit SRO at 1005 Powell Street, acquired by Chinatown Community Development Center (CCDC) in 2021 after years of disrepair. The loan finances acquisition and rehabilitation costs, including solar improvements and accessibility upgrades. The project includes 99-year affordability restrictions and a senior operating subsidy. Concerns were raised about long-term operating deficits and the sustainability of small sites programs. Supervisor Mandelman added himself as co-sponsor, and the item was forwarded to the full board. - Items 5 and 6 (Leases – 1145 Market Street): Real Estate Director Enrico Pinick presented two lease extensions for the Law Library (item 5) and Health Service System (item 6), both at highly competitive rates of $29.95 per square foot, saving approximately $900,000 annually in year one. The real estate division read substantive amendments into the record, including term adjustments (Law Library: 15-year term with one five-year option; HSS: 10-year term with one five-year option) and a partial market reset in year 11. Because these are substantive changes, the items were continued to the May 22 meeting. - Item 7 (Police Overtime Funding): SFPD CFO Kimmy Wu requested a transfer of $4.75 million from salaries to overtime for the airport bureau, citing vacancies and special events like APEC. Deputy Chief Daniel Perey addressed concerns about officer wellness and staffing plans. Supervisor Melgar questioned long-term overtime sustainability. The item was forwarded to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to forward to the full board passed (2-0, Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 2: Motion to forward to the full board passed (2-0, Vice Chair Mandelman absent). - Item 3: Motion to forward to the full board with Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor passed (3-0). - Item 4: Motion to forward to the full board passed (3-0). - Items 5 & 6: Motion to accept the amendments and continue both items to the May 22 committee meeting passed (3-0). - Item 7: Motion to forward to the full board passed (3-0). The meeting adjourned at approximately [time not specified].

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 30% · PUBLIC COMMENT 17% · PUBLIC WORKS 16% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11%
714
MAY 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - May 14, 2024

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on May 14, 2024, beginning at 10:15 AM. All 11 supervisors were present. The agenda included routine consent items, multiple legislative introductions, special commendations for Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month, and a lengthy committee-of-the-whole hearing on the impacts of county jail lockdowns due to overcrowding and understaffing. The meeting also featured a resolution in support of stuttering awareness and a call to restore state funding for foreclosure intervention. Consent Calendar - Items 1–6 passed unanimously without objection. These included ordinances concerning firefighter personal protective equipment containing PFAS, the Great Highway extension road closure, firearm and ammunition procurement, the Family Violence Council, surveillance technology policy for driver-safety video analytics, and agreements with government entities. Special Order 2:30 PM – Commendations - The board recognized Consul General Munkhbatar Begjav of Mongolia for his diplomatic leadership during AAPI Heritage Month. - Supervisor Mandelman commended Jenny Lamb, outgoing Board of Education member, for her 25 years of public service and championing equity in education. - Supervisor Ronan honored May Ling, gardening program manager at Recreation and Parks, for her two decades of work in urban agriculture and food security. - Supervisor Safai recognized Julius Anthony Cordero and Jason Cragasine, co-founders of the Academy Barber College, for providing barber training and second chances to underserved communities. Introductions & New Legislation - Supervisor Stefani introduced a resolution supporting AB 2913 (California Homicide Victims Families Rights Act) and adjourned in memory of Romano Marcucci. - Supervisor Walton introduced a charter amendment to elect the Director of the Department of Police Accountability, citing racial disparities in police violence and the need for independent oversight. - Supervisor Chan introduced an ordinance to expedite procurement for Vision Zero safety projects on high-injury corridors. - Supervisor Dorsey introduced legislation requiring all retail pharmacies in San Francisco to stock buprenorphine for opioid addiction, noting that only 44% of local pharmacies currently have it in stock. - Supervisor Mandelman introduced a resolution recognizing May 25–June 2 as Queer and Transgender Asian and Pacific Islander (QTAPI) Week. - Supervisor Preston introduced a resolution condemning racial terror threats against Terry Williams, a Black Fillmore resident, and calling for an FBI investigation. - Supervisor Safai introduced a resolution urging the mayor and Department of Children, Youth and Families to raise $24.8 million to restore cuts to youth programs, contrasting with a planned fundraising campaign for a panda exhibit at the zoo. Regular Agenda (Items 7–18) All items were approved on a single vote without roll call unless noted: - Item 7: Ordinance modifying the 900 Kearny Street Special Use District to allow an enclosed rooftop arts addition. - Items 8–9: Airport lease modifications with American Airlines and United Airlines, extending terms two years with rent increases ($7.24M and $5.56M annually, respectively). - Item 10: FAA grant acceptance up to $31 million for HVAC improvements at the International Terminal. - Items 11–12: Homelessness services grant amendments – Conard House ($12.8M for McAllister Hotel) and Hamilton Families ($21.9M for rapid re-housing). - Items 13–14: Designation of official city newspapers for FY2024–2025: Clinton Reilly Communications (SF Examiner) and a list of community periodicals. - Item 15: Recology refuse collection contract modification, extending term four months and increasing amount by $43.8 million. - Item 16: Retroactive cannabis equity grant acceptance of $2.04 million from the state. - Item 17: Commemorative street name “Midge Wilson Alley” on the 100 block of Elm Street. - Item 18: Reappointment of Thomas Richard Harrison to the Sanitation and Streets Commission. Special Order 3:00 PM – Committee of the Whole: Impacts of County Jail Lockdowns This hearing dominated the afternoon. Presenters included Sheriff Paul Miyamoto, Deputy Sheriff’s Association President Ken Lamba, Inspector General Terry Wiley, and Assistant Chief Attorney Angela Chan from the Public Defender’s Office. Key findings and statistics presented: - Jail population increased 36% over the past year, from 800 to 1,200 inmates (as of May 14, 2024). - Custody staff is at 78% of authorized strength; there are 195 sworn vacancies. - Assaults on deputies increased 380% from 2021 to 2023; inmate-on-inmate fights rose 45%. - 76% of inmates are released within seven days; 97% are pretrial. The jail population is 75% Black (Black residents are 6% of San Francisco). - Only 44% of surveyed pharmacies stocked buprenorphine; the same proportion of jails have limited programming. - Lockdowns occurred multiple times per week, often triggered by staffing shortages; the longest recent lockdown lasted six days (April 12–18). Key positions: - Sheriff Miyamoto attributed the crisis to increased enforcement of drug offenses, a changed inmate population (more mental health and substance use disorders), and chronic understaffing. He called for a non-carceral withdrawal management facility, additional body-worn cameras, and investment in technology to improve surveillance efficiency. - DSA President Lamba argued that the department is “running on fumes” with mandatory overtime averaging 28 hours per week (up from 16). He proposed eliminating the first step of deputy pay, freezing vacant FTEs for hiring, and creating a national recruitment campaign. - Inspector General Wiley recommended redeploying deputies from non-charter assignments (e.g., street patrol) back to jails, investing in AI-enabled cameras, and reducing reliance on overtime. - Public Defender Chan highlighted constitutional violations: denial of legal visits, delayed court transport, and lack of outdoor sunlight (a lawsuit over this is ongoing). She criticized the “war on drugs” approach and called for redirecting funds from law enforcement to community-based treatment. Mayor’s Office representative Tom Paulino was unable to answer detailed questions about the administration’s plan; supervisors expressed frustration. Public Comment (Item 19) Speakers included a mother of an incarcerated person, deputies, and community advocates. They all emphasized the need for more staffing, better programming, and alternatives to incarceration. Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 22–27) Items 24 (Stuttering Awareness Week) and 25 (Foreclosure Intervention Housing Preservation Program) were severed for individual votes. Both passed unanimously after brief discussion. Items 22, 23, 26, and 27 were adopted on a single roll call. - Item 22: Designating the Arts Commission as state-local partner with California Arts Council. - Item 23: Supporting CA Assembly Bill 1775 (Cannabis Cafes). - Item 24: Proclaiming May 13–18 as Stuttering Awareness Week. - Item 25: Resolution supporting state funding for foreclosure prevention and opposing cuts to homelessness prevention. - Item 26: Urging collaboration between CPMC and CIR-SEIU for safe working conditions. - Item 27: Urging funding for the California Employee Ownership Hub. In-Memoriam Supervisors adjourned in memory of Marilyn Patricia Driscoll, Romano Marcucci, Rebecca Scholes Winster, Barbara “Bobby” Stauffacher Solomon, and Philip C. Chin. Next Steps The hearing on jail conditions was filed. Several pieces of introduced legislation will be referred to committees for further consideration. Budget discussions on sheriff’s department funding are expected during the upcoming budget cycle.

JUSTICE AND CORRECTIONS 30% · CORRECTIONS AND REENTRY 15% · PUBLIC SAFETY 14% · PUBLIC HEALTH 8%
715
MAY 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - May 14, 2024

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on May 14, 2024, beginning at 9:30 AM. The commission approved a consent calendar, adopted new wholesale water rates (8.8% increase), approved power rate increases for Hetch Hetchy Power (12%) and CleanPowerSF (8.5%), awarded a major construction contract for the Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation project ($234.8 million), and extended several service contracts. The meeting also included a report from the Revenue Bond Oversight Committee, public comments on infrastructure issues, and closed session discussions on a settlement. Consent Calendar - Item 7 was approved unanimously (4-0). Commissioner Stacy pulled items 7C and 7G for commentary: 7C (contract to compensate for lost electrical engineers) – noted two of four engineers replaced; 7G (pre-apprenticeship training program) – reported successful hiring of program graduates by contractors. Commissioner Ajami pulled item 7D (contract increase for co-generation engine project) and questioned the 50% budget increase. Staff explained delays due to COVID and new PG&E requirements. The consent calendar included items A–H. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): Jennifer Vitaru and Ashley Westinger, both Marina residents, criticized the SFPUC for lack of response to the Pierce Street outfall closure and resulting flooding during storms on October 24, 2021, and December 31, 2022. They requested a public hearing and cited an EPA lawsuit over sewage incursions. - Item 6 (Revenue Bond Oversight Committee Report): No public comment. - Item 7 (Consent Calendar): No public comment. - Item 8 (Sunol Valley Ozonation Contract): Nicole Kula, CEO of the Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency, spoke in support of the staff recommendation. - Item 12 (Wholesale Water Rates): Two callers: a representative of wholesale customers expressed support for the rate-setting process; Peter Greckmeyer, policy director for the Tuolumne River Trust, expressed concern about rising rates and deferred maintenance, urging a review of the alternative water supply plan. - Items 13 & 14 (Power Rates): JP Rappagnani, representing Sutro Power (an employee-owned solar firm), asked about revival of the GoSolar SF program and expansion of solar incentives. No further public comment. Discussion Items - Revenue Bond Oversight Committee Annual Report (Item 6): Chair Ruben Holliber presented the report covering July 2022–June 2023. Highlights: audit of six revenue bonds ($1 billion) with two material findings and three recommendations; ongoing monitoring of bond sales; visits to Oceanside Treatment Plant and Hetch Hetchy Regional Water System. Committee is conducting its third audit (expected fall 2024) and exploring future audit topics, including technology implementation. The committee is set to sunset at the end of 2024 unless extended by the Board of Supervisors. - Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation Contract (Item 8): Project manager Brian DeSorra presented the request to award a $234,782,000 contract to J.F. Shea Construction, Inc. (lowest bidder). The engineers' estimate was $193 million; the 28% increase was attributed to a small pool of qualified contractors, material price uncertainty, and project complexity. Staff recommended against rebidding due to likely escalation costs. The contract includes social impact partnership program requirements and Buy America provisions. Approved unanimously. - CleanPowerSF Billing Contract Amendment (Item 9): Andrew Bevington requested a $2.5 million increase and 6-month extension with Calpine Energy Solutions to ensure continuity of billing and data management services while an RFP for a new contract is issued. Commissioner Ajami asked about vendor lock-in and data transferability. Approved unanimously. - VIP Power Line Corp. Contract Increase (Item 10): Danny Fung requested a $4.6 million cost contingency increase and 1,022-day duration extension for as-needed electrical distribution services. The contract supports the Power Enterprise due to a shortage of skilled workers (11 of 14 high-voltage line worker positions vacant). Approved unanimously. - Kubra Data Transfer Contract Amendment (Item 11): Deedra Andris requested a $365,000 increase and 1-year extension for electronic bill payment services, as the RFP process will not be completed by August 2024. Commissioner Ajami asked about in-house capability; staff explained the need for external vendor due to regulatory requirements. Approved unanimously. - Wholesale Water Rates for FY2024-2025 (Item 12): Rates manager Matthew Freiburg presented the proposed 8.8% volumetric rate increase (to $5.67 per CCF). Key drivers: low retail water sales, rebounding wholesale usage, a $29 million balancing account owed by wholesale customers, and increased capital spending. The monthly service charge methodology was updated for the first time since 2009–10. The rate is governed by the Water Supply Agreement. Approved 3-0 (President Paulson absent for vote). - Power Enterprise Rates: Hetch Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF (Items 13 & 14): Financial Planning Director Aaron Corvineau presented a combined hearing. CleanPowerSF: 8.5% overall revenue increase (with cost-of-service allocation varying by customer class). Hetch Hetchy Power: 12% flat increase across all rate schedules. Drivers included rising power supply costs, regulatory requirements, and the need to meet debt service coverage targets (1.1x) and reserve targets (180 days cash on hand for CleanPowerSF). Rate design changes included standardizing low-income discounts to 30% and consolidating enterprise and retail rates. Both items were approved separately: Item 13 (Hetch Hetchy) 3-0, Item 14 (CleanPowerSF) 3-0. - Commissioner-Initiated Items (Item 16): Commissioner Stacy requested a public hearing on the alternative water supply plan at the June 11, 2024 meeting or later. Commissioner Ajami requested a return of regular water supply condition updates (previously given by Mr. Ritchie) and noted unexpectedly high demand in 2024. Key Outcomes - Approved Minutes of April 23, 2024 (4-0). - Consent Calendar (Items 7A–7H) approved unanimously (4-0). - Awarded Contract WD-2897 to J.F. Shea Construction for Sunol Valley Water Treatment Plant Ozonation (4-0). - Approved Amendment No. 4 to Contract CS-247(R) with Calpine Energy Solutions, increasing amount by $2.5 million and extending duration by 6 months (4-0). - Approved cost and duration contingency increases for Contract PW-009R with VIP Power Line Corp. ($4.6 million, 1,022 days) (4-0). - Approved Amendment No. 4 to Contract CS-310 with Kubra Data Transfer, increasing amount by $365,000 and extending 1 year (4-0). - Adopted Wholesale Water Rates for FY2024-2025 (8.8% increase, effective July 1, 2024) (3-0). - Adopted Hetch Hetchy Power Rates (12% increase, effective July 1, 2024) (3-0). - Adopted CleanPowerSF Rates (8.5% overall revenue increase, effective July 1, 2024) (3-0). - Closed Session: Commission approved a settlement for an unlitigated claim from a water pipeline break (Fillmore and Green Streets, September 10, 2023) via roll call (3-0). Motion not to disclose closed session discussions passed (3-0). - Next Steps: Staff to schedule a public hearing on alternative water supply; water supply condition updates to be reinstated.

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 21% · PROCEDURAL 20% · PROCUREMENT 17% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 15%
716
MAY 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
SF Rules Committee Meeting on AI, Campaign Finance, and Housing Reports - May 13, 2024

The San Francisco Rules Committee convened on May 13, 2024, at 6:00 PM (UTC) to address a range of policy items including language access, housing needs reports, surveillance technology, artificial intelligence in elections, and campaign finance regulations. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronin, with members Supervisor Dean Preston and Supervisor Ash Safai, took actions on several ordinances and heard a presentation on AI's impact on local elections. The meeting concluded with a motion to veto two campaign finance regulations and a unanimous vote to file the AI hearing. Consent Calendar - Excusal of Supervisor Shamann Walton: Motion passed unanimously to excuse Supervisor Walton from the meeting. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made on any agenda items during the meeting. Discussion Items Item 1: Language Access Ordinance (File 230868) - Proposal: The ordinance amends the Administrative Code to clarify departments' responsibilities to provide language access services and the role of the Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs. - Amendments: On behalf of Supervisor Walton, Chair Ronin introduced two amendments: 1. Adding language ensuring that Limited English Proficient (LEP) persons may request written materials in languages not among the required languages, and that the Public Utilities Commission and Tax Collector must provide resources for understanding property tax and utility bills. 2. Revising the 'know your rights' brochure translation requirement to cover the top 20 most spoken languages with the highest language access needs. - Vote: The amendments passed unanimously. Due to fiscal implications, the item was referred to the Budget and Appropriations Committee. Item 2: Housing Needs Report Frequency (File 240281) - Proposal: The ordinance changes the frequency of the housing needs overview and assessment reports for seniors and people with disabilities, from every 3 years to every 8 years for the needs assessment, and from yearly to every other year for the production pipeline report. It also updates references to the Department of Disability and Aging Services. - Presenter: Susie Smith from HSA presented the rationale, including alignment with the housing element cycle, minor year-to-year changes, and the resource intensity of the reports (approximately one full-time staff member and a $170,000 consultant budget). - Vote: The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Surveillance Technology Policy - HSA Call Recording (File 240048) - Proposal: The ordinance approves HSA's use of call recording technology at its telephonic service centers to record and store audio calls, aiming to improve service delivery and enable telephonic signatures. - Presenter: Susie Smith from HSA detailed the technology's benefitstons, noting that COIT and its privacy board held public hearings in 2023 and recommended approval. - Vote: The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 4: Hearing on Artificial Intelligence in Local Elections (File 240029) - Purpose: This hearing, called by Supervisor Preston, examined the city's preparedness for AI-related threats to elections, including disinformation and campaign manipulation. - Presenters: - Professor David Harris (UC Berkeley, advisor to CITED) highlighted the growing risks of AI-generated disinformation, citing examples like fake images, robocalls, and the spread of misinformation. He discussed four state bills (AB 3211, AB 2655, AB 2900, and SB 1228) aimed at watermarking, deep fake labeling, and voter verification, and recommended waiting until August/September to see their outcomes before local action. - Director John Arntz (Department of Elections) detailed the department's role: it does not regulate campaign speech but maintains election integrity through secure voting systems (no internet connectivity, software reinstalled before each election, and manual audits). He described protocols for responding to misinformation and disinformation. - Patrick Ford (Executive Director, Ethics Commission) and Michael Canning (Policy Director) discussed the city's disclaimer requirements for political adsches and noted that the commission does not enforce false content laws, but is updating compliance materials. They acknowledged that enforcement of AI-generated content is currently limited. - Discussion: Supervisor Preston expressed alarm at the jurisdictional gaps, noting that no city agency currently enforces AB 730 (the state law addressing deepfakes). The committee discussed potential actions, including waiting for state legislation, exploring local enforcement, and engaging with the Brennan Center's recommendations. - Vote: The hearing was filed unanimously. Item 5: Ethics Commission Campaign Finance Regulations (File 240487) - Proposal: The Ethics Commission submitted amendments to regulations, including those impacting home/office fundraisers (Regulation 1.126-9) and other campaign finance rules. - Supervisor Concerns: Chair Ronin and Supervisor Safai expressed strong concerns that the regulations to value home/office space as an in-kind contribution would overburden grassroots campaigns, particularly affecting small donors and those in shared living situations. Supervisor Ronin also criticized the lack of increased contribution limits for over 20 years. - Ethics Commission Position: Michael Canning clarified that the regulation is narrowly targeted to prohibit city contractors and those with pending land use matters from hosting fundraisers, closing a loophole they had identified. He argued it mirrors state lobbyist rules. - Committee Discussion: Supervisors debated the breadth of the regulation, noting potential impacts on spouses, roommates, and business partners. They asked for clarification on whether the value of home space is considered a contribution (it is not under current state law, unless event costs exceed $500). - Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to veto Regulation 1.126-9 and 1.127-4, sending the veto to the full board with a recommendation. Chair Ronin indicated openness to receiving revised language from the Ethics Commission that is more narrowly tailored. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Amended ordinance referred to Budget and Appropriations Committee (unanimous). - Item 2: Sent to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Item 3: Sent to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Item 4: Hearing filed (unanimous). - Item 5: Vetoed Regulations 1.126-9 and 1.127-4, with the full board to act by June 17, 2024 (unanimous). The committee expressed willingness to work with Ethics Commission on revised regulations.

ETHICS COMMISSION 36% · ELECTIONS 12% · TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION 11% · PROCEDURAL 8%
717
MAY 13, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Meeting - May 13, 2024

The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on May 13, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Marina Melgar, alongside Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered three agenda items: a grant of non-exclusive easement for a Twin Peaks parcel, a commemorative plaque for Peter Gabel, and a hearing on the future of Union Square. Public Comments & Testimony - For item 2, Leslie Crawford spoke in support of the commemorative plaque for Peter Gabel, describing his visionary leadership in co-founding the Noe Valley Farmers Market and his transformative community impact. No public comment was offered on items 1 or 3. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Grant of Non-Exclusive Easement (Midtown Lands LLC): Director of Real Estate Andrico Penick presented a resolution to reduce an existing easement on city-owned greenbelt from 6,970 to 2,500 square feet for vehicular/pedestrian access and subsurface utilities to serve future residential development. The Recreation and Park Commission had approved the easement on July 20, 2023 (4-0). The committee noted the easement was a technical cleanup for a two-lot subdivision previously conditionally approved. - Item 2 – Commemorative Plaque for Peter Gabel: Supervisor Rafael Mandelman introduced the ordinance to designate a sidewalk area on 24th Street near the Noe Valley Farmers Market for a plaque honoring Peter Gabel, a community leader, legal activist, and co-founder of the market. Leslie Crawford read a quote from Gabel: "We together hold the key to each other's liberation." The plaque will mark the spot where Gabel greeted market visitors. - Item 3 – Hearing on the Future of Union Square: Supervisor Ahsha Safai sponsored the hearing, emphasizing Union Square's pre-pandemic role as 40% of the city's non-food-and-beverage retail sales. The hearing examined the impact of Macy's announced closure (late February 2024) and the need to diversify uses. Presentations from the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD), City Economist Ted Egan, and the Union Square Alliance outlined current conditions: Union Square retail vacancy at 19.5% (CoStar data), hotel occupancy near 60% (well below 2019's 80%), and retail employment for tourism-related sectors at only 64% of 2019 levels. OEWD reported $1.5 million in activation grants since 2022, a $4 million Powell Street improvement project (of which approximately $2.5 million remains after reallocations for activations like Winter Walk and Union Square in Bloom), and regulatory changes including flexible zoning and commercial-to-residential adaptive reuse. UFCW Local 5's Tony Vargas and Jim Araby testified that 330 union members work at Macy's, 66% with 10+ years of service and 61% San Francisco residents; they urged worker training partnerships and retention of good jobs. Union Square Alliance CEO Marissa Rodriguez stressed safety and perception challenges, citing the need for a PR campaign and continued police presence. Committee members questioned the lack of a cohesive long-term plan, equity in resource allocation (e.g., mobile command center), and the effectiveness of piecemeal incentives. The hearing was continued to allow for a more detailed vision. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The resolution was approved by a vote of 3–0 (Melgar, Preston, Peskin) and recommended to the full Board of Supervisors. - Item 2: The ordinance was approved by a vote of 3–0 and recommended to the full Board. - Item 3: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair, with Supervisor Safai indicating a desire for updates on investments and a comprehensive plan for Union Square's future.

PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT 21% · DOWNTOWN REVITALIZATION 18% · PUBLIC SAFETY 16% · PUBLIC REALM 15%
718
MAY 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting - May 9, 2024 - Stonestown Approvals and Parking Lot Extension

The San Francisco Planning Commission met on Thursday, May 9, 2024, at 20:15 UTC. The meeting covered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters (including a land acknowledgement and a commendation for retiring planner Rick Cooper), department matters, general public comment, and several regular calendar items. The main actions included approval of a five-year conditional use extension for a temporary parking lot at 469 Stevenson Street, adoption of a discretionary review settlement for 20 Paloma Avenue, and certification of the final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) along with approval of all major entitlements (General Plan amendments, shadow findings, development agreement, etc.) for the Stonestown Development Project. Consent Calendar - Items 1A/B (305 Liberty Street) and 2A/B (3901 Noriega Street) were continued to June 6, 2024. - Item 4 (680 Mission Street) was continued to May 23, 2024, at the project sponsor's request. - Items 3, 6, 7, and 8 (1828 Egbert Avenue, 3225 Fillmore Street, 2156 Chestnut Street, and 638 Rhode Island Street) were approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 5 (469 Stevenson Street) was pulled from the consent calendar and considered separately. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: One speaker requested the commission put on record whether there would be a meeting the following week (later confirmed canceled) and asked that an aging/disability housing information item be placed on the advanced calendar. - Item 5 (469 Stevenson Street): David Wu of Soma Filipinas and the South of Market Community Action Network requested a continuance, stating that before extending the parking lot for five years, a discussion should be convened with planning, MOHCD, the landowner, community stakeholders, and state legislators to explore the site's future, potentially for 100% affordable housing. He noted that the site was entitled for market-rate housing a year ago but lacks financing. - Stonestown Development Project (Items 14/15): Over 20 speakers testified, most in support. Supporters included representatives of labor unions (Operating Engineers Local 3, Carpenters Union Local 22, Laborers Local 261, Elevators Union), West Side Family Democratic Club, Housing Action Coalition, Sierra Club San Francisco Chapter, San Francisco Chamber of Commerce, YIMBY Action, merchants association, and SF State University. They emphasized the need for housing, jobs, community benefits, and climate-friendly infill development. A few speakers expressed concerns: Paul Conroy (Ingleside Terrace Homes Association) supported the project but asked for traffic studies and mitigation, particularly regarding 20th Avenue north of Eucalyptus Drive. Another resident, Dave Fullerton (sp?), stated his comments on traffic were dismissed in the EIR response. Erica Zwaig (D Forward) pushed for mandatory land grants for affordable housing in phase one and questioned the depth of affordability. Nurit Baruch requested supportive housing for very low-income individuals with mental health needs. Discussion Items - Item 5 (469 Stevenson Street): Staff recommended approval of a five-year extension of a temporary public parking lot (115 spaces and a 45 sq ft booth). Commissioners debated the merits of granting the extension given no timeline for the approved housing project. Commissioner Imperial expressed discomfort and asked planning to convene a meeting with MOHCD, the developer, and the community to explore interim uses or affordable housing. Commissioner Diamond favored approval while encouraging such conversations. Vice President Moore noted the developer had promised to build immediately when the project was upzoned but has not moved forward. The commission approved the CU with conditions and directed planning to convene a meeting with stakeholders. Vote: 7-0. - Item 16 (20 Paloma Avenue): A discretionary review settlement was reached. The project sponsor modified the design to maintain a ridge line, reduce an extension, and preserve existing windows. Staff recommended approval due to extraordinary circumstances. No public comment. The commission approved with modifications. Vote: 7-0. - Stonestown Development Project (Items 14/15): The project proposes 3,500 residential units (including 20% affordable, at least 300 on-site, 200 senior units with veteran priority), 6 acres of parks, a new child care facility (100 children), a senior center, street improvements, and a 25-year development agreement. The EIR identified significant unavoidable impacts on transit delay, noise, air quality, and wind. A revised variant added over 400 units. The Recreation and Parks Commission earlier that day recommended no adverse shadow impacts on Rolf Nickel Jr. and Gina Pera Serra playgrounds. Commissioners praised the comprehensive design, community benefits, and flexibility in the development agreement. Concerns were raised about traffic on 20th Avenue, the depth of affordability (average at 100-110% AMI), and ensuring east-west connections through the mall. Commissioner Williams urged prioritizing land dedications for deeper affordability and earlier phasing of affordable units. Commissioner Soh asked about public art requirements and local business enterprise goals. The commission certified the EIR (7-0) and then approved all related items (findings, shadow, General Plan/Planning Code/Zoning Map amendments, development agreement, design standards and guidelines) with minor amendments read into the record (corrections to square footages and shadow findings). Vote: 7-0. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Items 1A/1B, 2A/2B, and 4 continued as noted (7-0). - Consent Calendar: Items 3, 6, 7, 8 approved (7-0). - Minutes: April 25, 2024 minutes adopted (7-0). - Item 5 (469 Stevenson Street): Five-year CU extension for parking lot approved with condition that planning convene a meeting with MOHCD, developer, and community (7-0). - Item 16 (20 Paloma Avenue): Discretionary review taken and project approved with modifications (7-0). - Stonestown Final EIR: Certified (7-0). - Stonestown Entitlements: Adopted CEQA findings and statement of overriding considerations, shadow findings, General Plan amendments, Planning Code and Zoning Map amendments, development agreement, and design standards/guidelines document as amended (7-0). - Future meetings: Next week's May 16 hearing canceled due to lack of items; Stonestown will appear at RecPark Commission (May 16), SFMTA Board (May 21), SFPUC (May 28), and Board of Supervisors (early summer 2024).

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 29% · LAND USE 16% · PUBLIC COMMENT 9% · PUBLIC WORKS 6%
719
MAY 9, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety Committee Regular Meeting – May 9, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, May 9, 2024, at 6:00 PM. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stephanie presided, with Supervisor Melgar subbing for Vice Chair Joel Ongardio and Supervisor Dorsey present. The committee heard three liquor license applications, a hearing on city handling of sexual assault and harassment allegations, and a hearing on SFPD recruitment, hiring, and retention. All liquor license items were approved unanimously, the sexual assault hearing was filed with planned legislation to move the SHARP office, and the staffing hearing was continued to the call of the chair. Liquor License Approvals (Items 1–3) Item 1 – Castro Theatre (429 Castro Street) - Applicant: APE SF LLC (Another Planet Entertainment) for a Type 90 on-sale general music venue license. - Police Report: Zero letters of protest/support; high crime area; Mission Station no opposition; ABC liaison recommended approval with noise, loitering, and litter conditions. - Applicant Statement: Dan Surratt (Vice President) noted the license would replace a patchwork of temporary catering licenses, ensure RBS-certified staff, and support the theater’s restoration. He cited zero overserving incidents at APE’s other venues (Bill Graham Civic and the Independent) over 14–20 years. - Public Comment: Ralph Hibbs (Castro Community Benefit District treasurer) spoke in favor, stating the license would bring destination events, help reduce retail vacancy from 25% to 15% over 18 months, and benefit local businesses. - Supervisors: Supervisor Dorsey expressed support for the historic LGBTQ+ venue. Chair Stephanie noted District 8 Supervisor Mandelman’s support. - Vote: Motion to forward a positive recommendation to the full board passed 3–0 (Melgar, Dorsey, Stephanie ayes; Ongardio excused). Item 2 – The Lab (2948 16th Street) - Applicant: The Lab SF for a Type 64 special on-sale general theater license. - Police Report: Zero letters; high crime area; Mission Station no opposition; same recommended conditions. - Applicant Statement: Executive Director Andrew Smith explained the nonprofit lab (founded 1984) hosts 50–100 events annually and faces a rent increase from $30,000 to $190,000 per year in six months. The license would provide a revenue stream to continue arts programming. - Public Comment: None. - Supervisors: Chair Stephanie noted District 9 Supervisor Ronen’s support. - Vote: Motion passed 3–0. Item 3 – Domaine SF (2331 3rd Street) - Applicant: Domaine SF LLC for a Type 42 on-sale beer and wine license. - Police Report: Zero letters; low crime area; not high concentration; Bayview Station no opposition; same conditions. - Applicant Statement: No representative present. - Public Comment: None. - Supervisors: Chair Stephanie noted District 10 Supervisor Walton’s support. - Vote: Motion passed 3–0. Hearing on City Handling of Sexual Assault and Harassment Allegations (Item 4) Supervisor Hillary Ronen led the hearing, recalling a 2018 hearing that led to the creation of the Office of Sexual Harassment and Assault Response and Prevention (SHARP). She emphasized the need to refocus SHARP on holding city departments accountable, and announced plans to move SHARP from the Human Rights Commission to the Office of Victim and Witness Rights with stronger confidentiality and reporting requirements. SFPD Presentation (Captain Alexa O’Brien and Deputy Chief Robert O’Sullivan): - Stated that one in five women, nearly one in four men, and 81% of women/43% of men experience sexual violence in their lifetime. - SFPD Special Victims Unit receives approximately 8,700 reports per year, but only about 1,000 are sexual assault cases (forcible rape and others). Investigators dropped from 70 to 32. In 2023, 91 arrests were made (12.8% of reported cases). - Rape kit turnaround average 39 days; 154 kits in 2023, 61 resulted in foreign DNA profiles, 20 CODIS matches. - SVU participates in monthly SART meetings, Denim Day events, and has shifted to more trauma-informed questioning (e.g., not asking “what were you wearing?”). - Supervisor Ronen questioned why only 12.8% of cases result in resolution and why more public awareness campaigns aren’t done. Captain O’Brien acknowledged lack of a campaign but noted improved media engagement. SHARP Office Presentation (Director Mary Davis and Policy Director Dulce Garcia): - SHARP has two staff (Kelly Lou Dinsmore and Dulce Garcia) and focuses on prevention and community partnerships, but has not fully executed its legislative mandate to hold city departments accountable. - Since inception, SHARP received 72 direct complaints (67 complainants, 33 ongoing investigations) and 187 broadly community-informed contacts. Many complainants seek resources, not formal investigation. - Policy recommendations include a referral card system, rehousing protocols for survivors (working with HSH and DPW), and youth prevention education. - SHARP established the Gender-Based Violence Prevention Collective in February 2021, meeting monthly with over 30 organizations. - Director Davis acknowledged shortcomings in follow-up and data collection, and welcomed the planned move to OVWR. District Attorney’s Office Presentation (Chief of Staff Monifa Willis): - Filing rate for sexual assault cases rose from 31% in 2020 to 78% in 2023. - Victim Services connects with survivors within 24 hours, offers needs assessment, Cal VCB compensation, and continues services even if charges are not filed. - Advocates receive specialized training; the office promotes kit tracking and healthy relationships workshops in schools. - Recommended cross-training among agencies and earlier involvement of victim advocates. Public Comments: Eight speakers testified, including survivors, community organizers (El/La Para TransLatinas, Youth Commission, UCSF researcher, etc.), all expressing strong support for SHARP’s community-centered work and urging preservation of its survivor-led approach. Several speakers criticized law enforcement and called for abolitionist alternatives; one teacher described ongoing trauma from an unsolved assault. All emphasized that SHARP’s role is vital for marginalized communities. Supervisor Melgar: Emphasized need for systemic, measurable recommendations with regular reporting and accountability from all departments. Chair Stephanie: Supported moving SHARP to OVWR for consolidated victim services and noted the need for public awareness funding. Outcome: Motion to hear and file the item passed 3–0. Supervisor Ronen will introduce legislation to transfer SHARP and strengthen its mandate. Hearing on SFPD Recruitment, Hiring, and Retention (Item 5) Chair Stephanie stressed the critical sworn officer shortage (over 700 positions short) and the need for transparency in recruitment efforts. SFPD Presentation (Deputy Chief Peter Walsh, with DHR’s David Heepner): - As of May 1, 2024, total sworn officers: 1,583 (including airport); full-duty patrol officers in 10 district stations: 769. - Attrition outpaced hiring since 2020: in 2019 net gain of 4 officers; in 2020 net loss of 89; 2021 loss of 111; 2022 loss of 124; 2023 loss of 85. Approximately 70 officers left due to vaccine mandate. - Projected retirements: 3% at age 55/25 years; but new contract longevity pay may improve retention. - Hiring process: from application to academy graduation takes 8–9 months. Backgrounds are a bottleneck. - Recruitment improvements: contract with All-Star for modern branding/targeting; implementation of Smart Recruiter to automate communications and tracking; use of third-party medical vendors (Conscentra) to speed medical checks; training Prop F retired officers and FTOs to assist with backgrounds (35 new background investigators in pipeline); civilianization efforts: budget request for 25 non-sworn crime scene investigators, and pilot for PSAs to respond to cold property crimes. - Laterals: can be hired and in field training within a month; four laterals hired recently; recruiting at guard/reserve units and Sacramento State (majority women program). DHR Presentation (David Heepner): - Custom hiring process for Q2 (police) in Smart Recruiter will improve data and automate stages. Vendor contracts for medical exams reduce wait times. Background tracking via Smart Recruiter will increase transparency. Supervisor Questions: - Supervisor Melgar asked about demographic drop-off in hiring; Deputy Walsh noted blind application process but plans to use Smart Recruiter to identify disparities. She also highlighted 30x30 initiative (30% women by 2030) and need for a dedicated project manager. - Supervisor Dorsey expressed gratitude and hope for continued hearings. He noted confusion over sworn staffing numbers and requested consistent reporting. - Chair Stephanie emphasized focus on targeted recruitment and laterals, noting many funded vacancies (approximately 300+). She asked for legislative help; Deputy Walsh asked the board to consider the long lead time and avoid short-term cuts to recruitment funding. Public Comment: None. Outcome: Motion to continue the item to the call of the chair passed 2–0 (Melgar and Stephanie ayes; Dorsey excused, Ongardio excused). Chair Stephanie will schedule a follow-up hearing. Key Outcomes - Liquor licenses: All three approved unanimously to the full board with positive recommendations. - Sexual Assault/Harassment Hearing: Filed. Supervisor Ronen to introduce legislation transferring SHARP to Office of Victim and Witness Rights with enhanced confidentiality, reporting, and accountability. - SFPD Staffing Hearing: Continued to call of chair for future updates. Emphasis on investing in recruitment technology, laterals, and 30x30.

SEXUAL ASSAULT PREVENTION 26% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 24% · VICTIM SERVICES 13% · PUBLIC SAFETY 11%
720
MAY 8, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Regular Meeting - May 8, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee met on May 8, 2024, with Chair Connie Chan, Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman, and Supervisor Myrna Melgar present. The committee heard and voted on ten agenda items covering homelessness and supportive housing grants, a reserved-funds release for SFPUC transmission upgrades, airport grants and lease modifications, a cannabis equity grant, a Recology refuse-collection contract amendment, and FY2024-2025 official and outreach advertising designations. Every item was approved unanimously and, except for the heard-and-filed hearing, forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors, with actions expected on the Board's May 14, 2024 agenda. Discussion Items - Item 1 - Hamilton Families Rapid Re-Housing Grant Amendment: HSH's Dylan Schneider presented a second amendment extending the agreement by 72 months through June 30, 2030 and increasing the not-to-exceed amount by approximately $12.3 million, for a total not to exceed approximately $21.9 million. The program provides rapid rehousing for at least 35 families annually, with 75 families budgeted under the housing solutions program; in calendar year 2023, Hamilton served 66 households/129 unique clients. BLA reported the grant is 84% general fund, 9% HUD ESG, and 6% Prop C, and noted underspending of over $940,000 over the prior three fiscal years with an additional projected $200,000-$500,000 underspend this year. Schneider attributed the gap to roughly 19-20 families transitioning to permanent supportive housing options. Discrepancy note: BLA's oral summary said the amendment increases the NTE by $20.9 million, conflicting with the agenda/HSH figure of about $12.3 million. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation; Mandelman and Melgar added as co-sponsors. - Item 2 - Conard House / McAllister Hotel Grant Amendment: HSH presented a second amendment extending the term 24 months through June 30, 2026 and adding approximately $4.5 million, for a total NTE of approximately $12.8 million. The McAllister Hotel provides permanent supportive housing for up to 80 formerly homeless adults; in 2022-23 it served 90 households (41% over age 55, 20% LGBQ, 26% Black). BLA found Conard House generally meeting requirements and noted the grant is largely Care Not Cash funded. Discussion covered tenant satisfaction survey results (50% response; 84% satisfied among respondents) and increased resident acuity; Conard House staff described a fire's impacts, capital improvement funding, and the need for an additional staff person. Discrepancy note: BLA's oral summary said the amendment increases the NTE by $12.8 million, conflicting with the agenda/HSH figure of about $4.5 million. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation; Mandelman added as co-sponsor. - Item 3 - SFPUC Release of Reserved Funds (Transmission Lines 7/8): Margaret Hannaford requested release of approximately $2,437,812.23 in mitigation payments and interest for the Transmission Lines 7/8 Upgrade Project. Total project cost is about $35.4 million, with about $33.3 million expected in mitigation payments; SFPUC has signed agreements with 15 developers totaling about $29.1 million and reported receiving $29.9 million in payments. The project is 98% complete, with construction scheduled to finish June 5, 2024 and closeout by December 31, 2024. BLA recommended release. After no public comment, the committee approved the release and heard/filed the hearing, 3-0. - Item 4 - FAA Airport Terminal Program Grant: SFO's Deanna Volick presented a resolution to accept and expend up to $31 million in FAA grant funds for HVAC improvements at the International Terminal, with a grant period of October 1, 2023 through September 30, 2028. The airport will provide 20% matching funds totaling $7.75 million. BLA noted total project cost is $52.5 million, with remaining costs from airport revenue bonds. The committee forwarded the resolution 3-0. - Items 5 & 6 - Superbay Hangar Lease Modifications (American and United Airlines): SFO requested approval of two-year lease extensions for both airlines. American's annual rent would increase 4% to $7.24 million; United's rent would remain at $5,563,768.73 even though the fair market appraisal was 2% lower, because rents cannot decrease under the lease. Estimated total rent revenue over the new terms is about $26 million. Both resolutions were forwarded 3-0. - Item 7 - Cannabis Equity Grants Program Grant: The Office of Cannabis requested retroactive authorization to accept and expend $2,041,520.62 from Go-Biz for the Local Equity Grants Program, with a term of April 2, 2024 through October 31, 2025. The office stated it has not yet received or expended these funds. Prior grant iterations disbursed over $11 million to more than 60 equity businesses, resulting in 52 permits and a utilization rate above 95%. The current cohort includes 23 eligible grantees, each eligible for up to $59,166.26. Vice Chair Mandelman noted the existing moratorium on new permits and an expected economic report in 2025. The resolution was forwarded 3-0. - Item 8 - Recology Refuse Collection Services Contract Amendment: OCA requested a fifth amendment increasing the contract NTE by $4.2 million, for a total NTE of $43.8 million, and extending the term four months through October 31, 2024, with no rate or scope change. Recology agreed to hold current rates. OCA explained that a new solicitation had been awarded to Allied Waste in January 2023, but Allied withdrew in March 2024 after appearing before the Budget & Finance Committee, prompting negotiations with Recology. OCA expects to finalize a new contract by August 2024 and seek Board approval in October 2024. The resolution was forwarded 3-0. - Items 9 & 10 - FY2024-2025 Official Newspaper and Outreach Periodical Designations: OCA recommended the San Francisco Examiner as the official newspaper (sole responsive bidder; the Chronicle did not meet local printing requirements). For outreach advertising, OCA received 18 proposals and deemed 13 responsive, recommending periodicals including the Bay Area Reporter, Win, World Journal, Noe Valley Voice, Potrero View, San Francisco Examiner, Sing Tao Daily, and Small Business Exchange. A public commenter from the Bay Area Independent Community Media Coalition encouraged the city to use discretionary advertising to better support local/ethnic media and reach marginalized communities. Chair Chan noted the need to revisit the advertising model despite the voter-mandated system. Both resolutions were forwarded 3-0. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1: Frank Delacampa (Hamilton Families real estate manager) described a family success story and emphasized the value of landlord partnerships and workforce development in rapid rehousing. - Item 2: Sandra Davis (Conard House associate director) reported that supportive services and HSH transferred 13 residents to more appropriate housing this fiscal year and that the building's vacancy rate was under 3% last quarter. - Items 9 & 10: Maya Chupkoff (California Common Cause / Bay Area Independent Community Media Coalition) expressed support for local and ethnic media and urged the city to broaden its advertising and outreach programs, while not objecting to the official advertising resolutions. Key Outcomes - All ten agenda items passed unanimously (3-0): Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, and Supervisor Melgar voted in favor. - Items 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10 were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. - Item 3 was approved for release of reserved funds and the hearing was heard and filed. - The clerk announced that items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of May 14, 2024.

HOMELESSNESS 30% · PROCUREMENT 20% · PUBLIC UTILITIES 10% · PUBLIC COMMENT 8%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com