The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 6, 2024, at 9:00 AM local time. Chair Connie Chan presided, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar in attendance. The committee considered six agenda items: a property exchange amendment, two grant acceptances, a bond refunding authorization, and a waste services contract. All items except the waste services contract were forwarded to the full board with positive recommendations; the contract was continued to the call of the chair. Property Exchange Agreement Amendment (Item 1) - Discussion: Andrico Pinick, Director of Real Estate, presented a resolution to retroactively approve a second amendment to the conditional property exchange agreement with EQX Jackson SQ Holdco LLC, extending the anticipated closing date to December 15, 2026, due to unfavorable financing conditions. The agreement is a public-private partnership where Related Companies would build a new Fire Station 13 in exchange for city property at 530 Sansome Street. All other terms remain unchanged; any future changes would require further board approval. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Forwarded to full board with a positive recommendation (3-0 roll call). Grants from San Francisco General Hospital Foundation (Items 2 & 3) - Discussion: Carl Tanagucci, Deputy Director of Primary Care, presented Item 2: acceptance of $373,084.11 for the Children’s Health Center’s HealthySteps Program (November 1, 2023 – June 30, 2024), which provides dyadic behavioral health care for children aged 0-5 and their caregivers, serving about 3,000 patients. Retroactive authorization was needed due to late grant notification. Elizabeth Connolly, analyst at DPH, presented Item 3: acceptance of $212,500 for the Predictive Analytics AI/ML program (July 1, 2023 – June 30, 2028) from the Siegel Family Endowment, aimed at reducing racial equity gaps in heart failure readmission rates using cognitive computing and care paths. Retroactive approval was also sought. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Both resolutions forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0 roll call). General Obligation Refunding Bonds (Items 4 & 5) - Discussion: Vishald Rodhi from the Controller’s Office of Public Finance presented a resolution authorizing the issuance and sale of up to $644,675,000 in Series 2024-R1 general obligation refunding bonds to refund certain outstanding bonds issued between 2015 and 2018. The transaction aims to achieve at least 3% net present value savings per city debt policy; current market conditions have improved since November. An appropriation ordinance places the proceeds in the Controller’s Reserve for FY2023-2024. Nick Menard from the Budget and Legislative Analyst’s office recommended approval. - Public Comment: None. - Outcome: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0 roll call). Contract with Allied Waste Services (Item 6) - Discussion: The item, a resolution to authorize a contract with Allied Waste Services of North America, LLC for refuse collection and disposal services (7-year initial term, with 3-year extension, total not to exceed $119,000,000), was continued to the call of the chair at the request of the City Administrator’s office due to outstanding questions and concerns. Chair Chan noted concerns about labor harmony and the impact on union represented workers, echoing testimony from the previous week. - Public Comment: Evan Boyd, Regional Vice President of Recology San Francisco, expressed concerns about environmental impacts (adding over half a million additional truck miles to San Francisco streets annually), pricing, and labor issues (taking work from union workers in San Francisco to unrepresented workers in San Jose). He urged the committee to investigate further. - Outcome: Continued to the call of the chair on a motion by Chair Chan (3-0 roll call). Adjournment The meeting was adjourned, with Chair Chan reminding members of the afternoon Budget and Appropriation Committee meeting at 1:30 PM.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Police Commission convened on March 6, 2024, at 1:45 PM UTC (noted as evening meeting). The meeting included officer recognition, public comment, reports from the Chief and DPA Director, and votes on several Department General Orders (DGOs). Key actions included adoption of DGO 9.07 (pretext stops) for the MEA bargaining unit (4-2), and unanimous adoption of DGOs 9.05, 9.04, 5.25, and approval to send DGO 10.02 to meet and confer. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the SFPD and DPA fourth-quarter document protocol memos. No public comment was offered. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 2): Multiple speakers addressed the commission: - A speaker urged the commission to reconsider the use of autonomous vehicles and expressed concerns about "unintelligence." - Daisy Ozam reported on alleged use of synthetic telepathy and data breaches by technology systems, calling for police action. - Chris Quartklein discussed "man in the middle" attacks on police systems and asked for reduced digital surveillance to prevent overdoses. - A speaker praised an FBI plan for psychological evaluations and therapy for officers. - A speaker questioned the validity of the previous week's vote on DGO 9.07 due to a commissioner's remote participation, arguing it violated state requirements. - Alan Burradell criticized four commissioners for voting to restrict pretext stops, calling it contempt for voters. - A Latina community leader requested increased recruitment of Latinos into SFPD, citing a lack of representation. - Lethi Seth Flores asked for more accountability and questioned police reporting duties. - A speaker opposed upcharging practices in the criminal justice system. - Paulette Brown, mother of unsolved homicide victim Aubrey Abracassa, pleaded for continued attention to her son's case and others. - Comment on Item 4 (Minutes): Two speakers requested revision of the February 21, 2024 minutes to reflect that a commissioner was not present (and thus their vote void). - Comment on Item 5 (Chief's Report): A speaker discussed unsolved homicides and a proposed reward program. - No public comment on other items. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Consent Calendar: Received and filed unanimously. - Item 4 – Adoption of Minutes: Minutes from February 7, 14, and 21, 2024 were adopted unanimously after public comment. - Item 5 – Chief's Report: Chief Scott reported: - Shooting victims down 22%, total gun violence victims down 30%. - Ghost gun seizures: zero in 2024 vs. 40 by same time last year. Total gun seizures: 141 (19 fewer than last year). - Two non-fatal shootings and three stabbings (all from arguments) during the week; no arrests. - A protest on March 2, 2024, involved force (pepper spray, batons) after barricade breaches; officers were spat on and hit with objects. Body-worn camera footage contradicts initial reports of force on peaceful protesters. Two officers and at least one protester injured. - Narcotics unit seized 46 pounds of narcotics, including 10 pounds of fentanyl, with seven arrests. - Commissioner Yanez questioned the effectiveness of enforcement on overdose deaths; Chief noted disruption of daytime drug markets but acknowledged ongoing night market challenges. Discussion of CART vs. HART program funding. - Commissioner Byrne asked about release of body-worn camera footage; Chief said it would be released if it does not jeopardize an investigation, with an update in two weeks. - Commissioner Byrne inquired about staffing increases for the Tenderloin swing shift; Chief deferred to provide specifics at next meeting. - Commissioner Carter-Oberstone noted that 60% of arrests are users, not dealers, and questioned resource allocation. - Item 6 – DPA Director's Report: Director Henderson reported: - Year-to-date: 106 new cases, 110 closed, 307 open/pending (up from last year). 14 sustained, 2 mediated. 30 cases exceeding 270 days (none past 3304 deadline). - Top allegations: conduct unbecoming (22%) and neglect of duty (16%). Southern precinct had most cases. - Outreach: restocked brochures, attended Richmond Station community meeting. - Audit responses received; preparation for conference with department. - Four cases in closed session. - Item 7 – Commission Reports: - President Elias noted that Proposition E (likely passed) will be implemented with city attorney guidance; public will be kept informed. - Commissioner Benedicto reported attending Lunar New Year parade, academy graduation (19 officers), and upcoming quarterly DPA audit liaison meeting. - Commissioner Byrne asked about agendizing DGOs affected by Prop E; President Elias deferred to future discussion. - Commissioner Walker reported a ride-along at Richmond Station, meeting with patrol specials, and appreciation for retiring patrol special Alan Bayer. - Commissioner Yanez requested an update on pre-booking juvenile diversion program and a discussion on clearance rates citywide. - Item 8 – DGO 9.07 (Pretext Stops): Motion to adopt for MEA bargaining unit, with same implementation delay as POA version. After no public comment, vote was 4-2 (Commissioners Walker and Byrne opposed). - Item 9 – DGO 9.05 (Citation Control): Adopted unanimously with 45-day implementation. - Item 10 – DGO 9.04 (Seatbelt Policy): Adopted unanimously with 90-day implementation. - Item 11 – DGO 5.25 (Foot Pursuit): Adopted unanimously with 45-day implementation. Noted collaboration between DPA and training division. - Item 12 – DGO 10.02 (Equipment): Approved to send to meet and confer. Commissioner Byrne asked about applicability of Prop E's new community engagement requirements; city attorney filling in deferred to a later public answer. Vote was unanimous. - Item 13-16 – Closed Session: Commission voted to hold closed session on Item 15, and later voted unanimously not to disclose any discussion. Key Outcomes - Adopted DGO 9.07 (Pretext Stops) for MEA bargaining unit (4-2). Will take effect concurrently with the POA version after training. - Adopted DGO 9.05 (Citation Control) (unanimous). Implementation in 45 days. - Adopted DGO 9.04 (Seatbelt Policy) (unanimous). Implementation in 90 days. - Adopted DGO 5.25 (Foot Pursuit) (unanimous). Implementation in 45 days; training already underway. - Approved sending DGO 10.02 (Equipment) to meet and confer (unanimous). City attorney to address public question on Prop E applicability at next meeting. - Consent calendar and minutes approved unanimously. - Future agenda items: Update on pre-booking juvenile diversion program, discussion on clearance rates, and further DGOs affected by Prop E to be scheduled.
On March 6, 2024, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Appropriations Committee (Chair Chan, Vice Chair Mandelman, Members Melgar, Walton, and President Peskin) held a hearing to receive updates on the six-month budget status report for fiscal year 2023-2024. The Controller's Office presented an improved current-year ending balance of $35 million, reducing the projected two-year shortfall to approximately $765 million, but highlighted several major risks including FEMA reimbursement changes, assessment appeals, and excess ERAF litigation. Discussion Items - Six-Month Budget Status Report Presentation: Michelle Allersma of the Controller's Office reported a $35 million improvement in the current-year ending balance, primarily from higher-than-expected revenues at the Department of Public Health ($67 million) and departmental mid-year cuts. Citywide tax revenues showed additional weakness: property tax down $36 million (due to assessment appeals projections), business tax down $48 million (due to litigation and prior-year refunds), with modest declines in sales and hotel taxes offset partly by improved transfer tax projections. Total department net surplus reached $178 million (including previously known mid-year cuts of $96 million). - Reserves Overview: Economic stabilization reserves stood at $390 million (just over 6% of general fund revenue). Other reserves (general reserve, public health revenue management reserve, fiscal cliff reserve, federal/state emergency grant disallowance reserve) brought total reserves to roughly 12-15% of general fund revenue, though some have use restrictions and repayment requirements. - Key Risks Discussed: - FEMA Reimbursements: In October 2023, FEMA announced new rules limiting non-congregate shelter stays to 20 days and questioning pre-positioned vacant rooms. The Controller's Office has not yet reduced revenue projections pending further communication; the committee pushed for clarity before the June budget. - Assessment Appeals: The Assessment Appeals Board is still hearing 2021 cases; the Controller's Office must project outcomes for reserves. - Excess ERAF: A state dispute over charter school funding could reduce local revenue; the governor's May revise and ongoing lobbying are key. - Transfer Tax and Prop C: The current projection does not assume passage of Prop C (transfer tax exemption); transfer tax remains volatile and below historical levels. Public Comments & Testimony - One speaker noted the Irish flag raising ceremony and questioned the hotel tax rate, whether it includes Airbnb taxes, and how it relates to the health and welfare realignment. No other public comments were submitted. Key Outcomes - Motion to File: Chair Chan moved, seconded by President Peskin, to hear and file the six-month budget status report. The motion passed unanimously (5-0) with all members voting aye. - Next Steps: The Controller's Office will update the five-year forecast at the end of March 2024 and issue a nine-month report in mid-May 2024. The committee expects to receive clearer information on FEMA reimbursements and excess ERAF before the June budget debate.
The Board of Supervisors met on Tuesday, March 5, 2024, at 10:15 AM in City Hall. The meeting included roll call, approval of minutes, consent agenda, multiple legislative items, special commendations, public comment, and adjournment in memory of community members. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 7 were approved unanimously as routine. Public Comments & Testimony - A member of the public spoke about racism, technology concerns, and urged honesty. - A speaker read a passage from the Book of Jonah. - Jim McAfee raised concerns about Laguna Honda Hospital policy preventing patients from bringing durable power of attorney or domestic partner registration documents, calling them contraband. Discussion Items - Item 8 (Extend sunset of contracting waivers for homeless services) – Passed 7-4 (Chan, Dorsey, Peskin, Safai voted no). - Item 9 ($9 million settlement for Mason Masuda lawsuit) – Passed unanimously. - Item 10 (Planning code density limits in historic districts) – Passed 8-3 (Dorsey, Engardio, Melgar voted no). - Item 11 (Fleet charging conditional use authorization) – Passed unanimously. - Item 12 (Transient occupancy tax returns) – Passed unanimously on first reading. - Items 13-15 (Airport food vendor leases) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 16 (EBT agreement at Alemany Farmers Market) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 17 (Power sales revenue limit increase) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 18 (Yosemite watershed management agreement) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 19 (SFDPH participation in CalMHSA) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 20 (Grant agreement for Potrero Avenue construction) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 21 (In-kind gift acceptance) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 22 (Potrero Bus Yard predevelopment agreement) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 23 (Family and senior housing special use district) – Amended and passed on first reading; duplicated file re-referred to Land Use Committee. - Item 24 (Forgivable loan for first-time homebuyers) – Amended with consultation language; passed 10-1 (Peskin opposed); duplicated file amended and re-referred to Land Use Committee. - Item 25 (Microtrenching for fiber installation) – Passed on first reading unanimously. - Item 28 (Housing production exemptions from notice/review) – Passed on first reading unanimously. - Item 29 (Trader Joe’s liquor license transfer) – Adopted unanimously. - Item 30 (Nonprofit contract monitoring ordinance) – Passed on first reading unanimously. - Items 31-32 (Appointments to Veterans Affairs Commission and Market/Octavia Advisory Committee) – Approved unanimously. - Item 33-36 (Appeal of parcel map at 1365-1371 York Street) – Hearing held; appeal withdrawn; motion to approve decision and table disapproval motions passed. - Item 38 (Parcel delivery service ordinance) – Passed on first reading as amended. - Item 41 (Resolution urging state to retain public defenders pilot funding) – Amended and adopted unanimously. - Items 42-45 (Various resolutions and reappointment) – Adopted unanimously. Special Orders – Commendations - San Francisco-Cork Sister City 40th Anniversary: Recognized with remarks from Consul General Michal Smith, Lord Mayor Kieran McCarthy, and Supervisor Safai. - Ugo Ramirez: Honored for his work at MOHCD on eviction prevention and rental assistance programs. He spoke about his career and dedication to community development. - Castro Community on Patrol: Recognized for volunteer public safety work. Founder Gregory “Greggie” Carey accepted and noted the group’s training and national award. - Gloria Esteva: Honored during Women’s History Month for her immigrant rights organizing with Causa Justa Just Cause. She spoke about her family’s activism and thanked supporters. Key Outcomes - All consent items passed. - Several ordinances passed on first reading with specific vote splits noted. - Item 24 (forgivable loan) was amended and passed, with a duplicated file re-referred for further amendment. - The York Street parcel map appeal was resolved by withdrawal. - Commendations were presented to four individuals/organizations. - The meeting was adjourned in memory of Doris Vincent and David Johnson.
The San Francisco Rules Committee met on Monday, March 4, 2024, at 18:15 UTC. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and Member Supervisor Ahsha Safaí, reviewed two agenda items: appointments to the Immigrant Rights Commission and amendments to the Legacy Business Assistance Program. The meeting concluded with unanimous votes on both items, forwarding the legislative change to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Roll Call and Announcements: The meeting was called to order, with Clerk Victor Young announcing public comment procedures and the expected Board of Supervisors agenda date of March 12, 2024. - No consent calendar items were listed; the agenda proceeded directly to regular items. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 – Immigrant Rights Commission Appointments: - Annette Wong, overseeing Jose Ng's work at Chinese for Affirmative Action (CAA), expressed strong support for Ng, highlighting his bilingual and bicultural abilities, community ties, and advocacy work. - Vincent Pan, co-executive director of CAA, also voiced support for Ng's appointment, praising his integrity and coalition work. - Calvin Yan, representing Supervisor President Peskin, expressed support for the Legacy Business Assistance Program amendment, noting the importance of protecting legacy businesses and referencing a recent eviction case where processes were overlooked. Discussion Items - Item 1: Appointments to the Immigrant Rights Commission (File 240172) - Six appointments were considered for terms ending June 6, 2025. Candidates present included Asil Farah, Celine Kennelly, and Jose Ng; three incumbents (Lucia Obregon, Mario Paz, Sarah Sosa) were absent, with statements read by Director Jorge Rivas. - Asil Farah (new applicant): A 24-year-old Yemeni American, founder of Urgent Care for Yemen, and former youth outreach coordinator. He highlighted his work in the Tenderloin and advocacy for immigrant communities. - Celine Kennelly (incumbent): Serving since 2012 and current chair, she emphasized the commission's expanded work, including hearings on workforce development, LGBTQ+ immigrant needs, and housing. - Jose Ng (new applicant): Immigrant from Hong Kong, immigrant rights program manager at Chinese for Affirmative Action, highlighted his work on language access and voting rights. - Director Rivas read statements for Obregon and Paz, noting their contributions; Sosa was described as active in housing and workforce efforts. - The motion, amended to include a residency waiver for Mario Paz, passed unanimously.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 4, 2024, at 9:45 AM (UTC) to consider five agenda items. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Melgar with Vice Chair Preston and Member Peskin, heard public testimony, debated amendments, and voted on several ordinances related to parcel delivery services, density calculations, unauthorized unit removal, landmark designation, and accessory dwelling units. Public Comments & Testimony - Agenda Item 1 (Parcel Delivery Service): A representative from Team Service expressed continued support for the amended legislation, noting it addresses concerns from labor, environmentalists, and the local community. - Agenda Item 5 (Form-Based Density): Multiple speakers presented: - Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) and Jane Natoli (UMB Action) urged passage of the original legislation without amendments, arguing that form-based density is proven and needed to meet housing element commitments. - Kent Mercani (volunteer) asked for housing to be allowed somewhere if not at this location. - Clay (union carpenter) supported policies that include labor standards and allow more housing. - Calvin Welch (Haight Ashbury Neighborhood Council) testified in favor of Supervisor Peskin’s amendments, asserting that density alone does not create affordability and that rent control protections are necessary. - Dan Calamucci (NORCAL Carpenters Union) urged moving the legislation forward without amendments to support union construction workers. - Georgia Shudish and Lori Brooke (Cal Hollow Association, Neighborhoods United SF) argued for more discussion, warning that combining form-based density with state density bonus could lead to high-rise development and displacement of small businesses. - Agenda Item 2 (Unauthorized Unit Removal): Brian Emmiat, a West Side resident, spoke in support, saying the change would help families stay in their homes. - Agenda Item 3 (Sacred Heart Parish Landmark): Several speakers addressed the artwork of Achille D.C. and the connector bridge: - Robert Fisher urged protection of the interior paintings by including them in the landmark designation. - Robert Pritchard (Sacred Heart Preservation Commission) emphasized the importance of preserving the artwork and noted past earthquake repairs were not funded. - Jan Robinson (Committee to Save St. Bridget Church) supported maximum protection for the frescoes. - Jerry Agosta (owner of rectory/convent/school) asked that the connector bridge not be included as a character-defining feature due to seismic risks. - Agenda Item 4 (ADU Controls): No public comment was offered. Discussion Items - Item 1: Planning Code – Parcel Delivery Service (File 240169): Supervisor Chan, the sponsor, presented amendments previously discussed. President Peskin offered a friendly amendment to change the retroactivity date from March 8 to March 30, 2024, to avoid a gap in controls. The committee also duplicated the file and added further amendments (impact on educational institutions, AI/autonomous vehicles) requested by Supervisor Chan, then continued the duplicated file to the call of the chair for re-referral to the Planning Commission. - Item 5: Planning Code – Density Calculation in RC, RTO, NC, and Named NCDs (File 230734): President Peskin proposed amendments to create two pathways: one for projects not using the state density bonus (with rent control applied to units over base density) and one for those that do. He also requested a duplicate file be kept unamended. After public comment, the committee voted to duplicate the file, amend the parent file with Peskin’s amendments, and then continue both files to the call of the chair. The amended file will be re-referred to the Planning Commission. - Item 2: Planning & Administrative Codes – Conditional Use Authorization for Removal of Unauthorized Unit (File 231185): Chair Melgar introduced the ordinance, explaining it waives conditional use authorization for owner-occupied single-family homes with an unauthorized unit that has not been rented for 10 years, subject to a regulatory agreement that applies rent control. The committee adopted amendments recommended by the Planning Commission (floor‑to‑ceiling height and minimum area exemptions) and sent the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 3: Planning Code – Landmark Designation – Sacred Heart Parish Complex (File 231045): Supervisor Preston noted that substantive amendments were made the previous week. After public comment raising concerns about interior artwork and the connector bridge, the committee duplicated the file: one copy was sent to the full board as recommended, and the duplicate was continued to the call of the chair to allow further discussion on preservation of the Achille D.C. paintings and the bridge’s designation. - Item 4: Various Codes – State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit Controls (File 230310): Planning staff presented amendments from the Planning Commission, which would clarify that ADUs in historic districts trigger notification requirements under Articles 10 and 11 rather than Section 311. The committee adopted the amendments and continued the item one week to March 11, 2024. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to amend the original file (retroactivity date to March 30) passed 3-0 (Preston, Peskin, Melgar). Original file sent to full board with positive recommendation 3-0. Duplicated file amended and continued to call of chair 3-0. - Item 5: Duplicate file created (unamended). Motion to amend parent file (Peskin’s amendments) passed 3-0. Motion to continue both files to call of chair passed 3-0. - Item 2: Motion to amend (as read into record) passed 3-0. Motion to send amended ordinance to full board with positive recommendation passed 3-0. - Item 3: Motion to send original file to full board as recommended passed 3-0. Motion to continue duplicated file to call of chair passed 3-0. - Item 4: Motion to amend (as presented by Planning Department) passed 3-0. Motion to continue item one week to March 11, 2024, passed 3-0.
The San Francisco Planning Commission met on February 29, 2024, to consider consent items, an informational presentation on affordable housing, a conditional use authorization, and two discretionary review cases. The meeting also included the farewell of Commissioner Ruiz and a remembrance of Maurilio Leon, CEO of the Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation. Consent Calendar - Items 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 – Routine conditional use authorizations and planning code amendments. Approved unanimously (6-0) after recusal of President Diamond from items 5 and 9. - Item 5 (1400 Van Ness Avenue) and Item 9 (2245 Post Street) – Approved separately 5-0 after recusal. - Remaining items – Approved 6-0. Commission Matters - Land Acknowledgement – Read by staff, acknowledging the unceded ancestral homeland of the Ramaytush Ohlone. - Minutes of February 15, 2024 – Adopted 6-0. - Commission Comments – Commissioner Ruiz announced her resignation, effective after this meeting. Commissioners expressed gratitude for her service. - Tribute to Maurilio Leon – Vice President Imperial and staff honored the late CEO of TNDC. Members of TNDC spoke; the meeting was adjourned in his memory. Department Matters - Director’s Announcements – Director Hillis acknowledged the passing of Maurilio Leon and noted Macy’s closure in Union Square; planning is coordinating with OEWD on future uses. - Review of Past Events – Legislative Affairs Manager Aaron Starr reported on Board of Supervisors actions including landmark designation for Sacred Heart Parish, family housing opportunity SUD, constraints reduction ordinance, Potrero Bus Yard project, and parcel delivery/fleet charging ordinances. General Public Comment - A commenter discussed Section 317 demo calcs and urged the commission to revisit the values to preserve existing housing. Item 15 – Affordable Housing Leadership Council Recommendations (Informational Presentation) Presenters: Dan Adams (Director, MOHCD) and planning staff. Overview: The presentation covered the significant increase in affordable housing production goals (46,000 units needed, a 5‑fold increase from current production of 1,000/year). The council made recommendations focused on three themes: advocating for federal/state/regional resources, improving local processes and funding, and fostering innovation. Key Statistics: - Current production: 1,000 affordable units/year; goal is 5,800/year. - Local funds cover about one‑third of development costs; state/federal matches are critical. - Inclusionary fees are in sharp decline due to low market-rate production. - The proposed state bond (ACA1) would lower the threshold for passing bonds; a regional BAHA bond could generate $1–2 billion for San Francisco. Public Comments: - Charlie Shawma (CCHO) urged the commission to set clear benchmarks and timeline for implementation, and noted missing strategies: affordable housing budget allocation and land banking. - Joseph Smook (REAP) urged opposition to the governor’s proposed $1.2 billion cuts in state affordable housing funding. - A private citizen suggested expanding the CityBuild program to train young people and lower construction costs. Commission Discussion: - Questions focused on the affordable housing bond (March 2024), property insurance challenges, and tax increment financing. Staff noted the bond’s failure would severely impact pipeline projects. - Commissioner Koppel offered to connect staff with union funding sources. - Commissioner Imperial asked about the impact of reduced inclusionary fees and urged faster implementation of a municipal revolving loan fund. - Commissioner Braun commended the report’s detail and emphasized the need for sustainable funding sources. - Vice President Moore stressed the urgency of meeting near‑term goals despite funding uncertainties. - Recusal: Commissioner Ruiz recused herself due to her employer’s involvement; the commission voted 6-0 to accept the recusal. Item 16 – 1314 Page Street: Conditional Use Authorization Staff Recommendation: Deny; the project does not meet the 75% floor area threshold for relocated units and lacks code‑compliant exposure. Project Description: Legalization of a merger of two flats (top floors) and relocation of one unit to the ground floor (815 sq ft, 55% of original). A variance would be needed for exposure. Public Comment: - Catherine (owner, age 66, union musician) described 24 years of effort, financial strain, and compliance with prior permits. She requested approval to keep her home. - Attorney for the sponsor (Justin Zucker) requested a continuance to April 25 or May 2 to seek a variance and grow the unit closer to 75% threshold. Commission Discussion: - Commissioners were torn between policy (no mergers, protect housing) and the applicant’s circumstances. - President Diamond favored giving time to reach a larger unit; Vice President Moore and Commissioner Imperial leaned toward denial. - Architect noted technical challenges (eight‑inch shortfall in egress court width). Vote: Motion to continue to April 25, 2024 passed 4-2 (Braun, Ruiz, Koppel, Diamond in favor; Moore and Imperial against). Item 17 – 1846 Grove Street: Discretionary Review Staff Recommendation: Not take DR and approve the project (4 units, two duplexes, on a flag lot). Background: Previously approved in 2020; appealed to Board of Supervisors who limited to 2 units. Sponsor did not vest; new code now permits 4 units as‑of‑right. Variances from 2020 remain valid. Public Comment: - DR Requester (John Mark Ciketa, NOPA West Neighborhood Association) opposed citing safety: narrow 3.5‑ft access way, fire risk, lack of second egress. Presented petition with 230 signatures. - Proponents (neighbors/architects) supported the project, noting due diligence and fire department review. - Opponents cited fire safety (Lahaina analogy), lack of compromise, and destruction of trees. Commission Discussion: - Staff clarified the lot is zoned RH2/RH3; 4 units are principally permitted. - Former Fire Department Captain (Mario Ballard) testified that code‑compliant egress is achievable. - Commissioners found no exceptional circumstances; motion to not take DR and approve passed 5-0 (Ruiz absent for vote). Item 18 – 124 Fillmore Street: Discretionary Review Staff Recommendation: Not take DR and approve a two‑story garage (three cars, car lift, roof deck) in the rear yard. Variance from 2005 is valid (settlement based on disability accommodation). Public Comment: - DR Requester and neighbors opposed: excavation risk to adjacent historic buildings, noise, short‑term rental history, and out‑of‑scale nature. - Project Sponsor (David Nail) stated the garage is for himself and caregivers; plans include structural engineering reviews and compliance with codes. - Remote commenter (Lucretia Rao) worried about increased traffic and loss of quiet street character. Commission Discussion: - Staff noted excavation and structural safety are under DBI jurisdiction. - Commissioners considered the reasonable accommodation provision, but some expressed concern about precedent for stacked parking. - No exceptional circumstances found; motion to not take DR passed 6-0. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar – Approved all items (with recusals). - Affordable Housing Leadership Council – Report received; commission urged implementation with benchmarks. - 1314 Page Street – Continued to April 25, 2024 to explore unit expansion and variance. - 1846 Grove Street – Discretionary Review not taken; project approved (4 units). - 124 Fillmore Street – Discretionary Review not taken; garage project approved. - Commissioner Ruiz – Resignation accepted; farewell noted. - Maurilio Leon – Remembered; meeting adjourned in his honor.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee met on February 28, 2024, to consider 12 agenda items including tax changes, contracts, leases, and a major refuse collection agreement. The committee approved 11 items unanimously, with one item continued to the next meeting for further review of labor and environmental concerns. Consent Calendar - Item 1: Ordinance amending Transient Occupancy Tax returns to simplify filing for short-term rental hosts and require qualified website companies to collect Tourism Improvement District assessments. Approved with an amendment to strike retroactivity. - Item 2: Resolution authorizing acceptance of an in-kind gift of consulting services valued at $302,208 for the Civic Bridge program. Approved with an amendment adding "plus the coordination of related volunteer services." - Items 3 & 4: Resolutions authorizing SFDPH to continue participation in CalMHSA programs under a Joint Powers Authority (Item 3) and retroactively accept a grant agreement with Advocates for Human Potential, Inc. for $33,736,105 for an adolescent psychiatric unit at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital (Item 4). Both approved. - Items 5 & 6: Resolutions for the Public Utilities Commission: increasing the power sales revenue limit from $10 million to $20 million annually (Item 5), and approving a $40,958,727 Memorandum of Agreement with Yosemite National Park for watershed management (Item 6). Both approved. - Items 7, 8, 9: Resolutions approving three lease agreements at Harvey Milk Terminal 1: two with Tastes on the Fly San Francisco, LLC (food hall with $1.25M minimum annual guarantee, historic restaurant with $550,000 minimum annual guarantee) and one with Amoura International, Inc. (casual sit-down restaurant with $450,000 minimum annual guarantee). All approved. - Item 10: Resolution retroactively authorizing an agreement with Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. for EBT wireless payment processing services at the Alemany Farmers Market. Approved. Discussion Items - Item 11: Resolution approving a $4,350,000 continuation payment under the Potrero Bus Yard predevelopment agreement with Potrero Neighborhood Collective LLC. SFMTA presented the project, which includes a new bus yard and up to 465 housing units (affordable and workforce). Discussion focused on the importance of providing a term sheet to the board before final development agreements. The committee approved the item after adding an amendment clarifying that the board's approval covers the predevelopment agreement and continuation payment. - Item 12: Resolution approving a contract with Allied Waste Services of North America, LLC for citywide refuse collection and disposal services, with a not-to-exceed amount of $119,000,000 over 10 years. The Office of Contract Administration presented the contract, noting it was competitively procured for the first time and replaces the Recology contract. Multiple speakers raised concerns about labor harmony, potential strikes, and environmental impacts of routing. The committee voted to continue the item to the March 6, 2024 meeting for further review. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item 12: Evan Boyd, Regional Vice President of Recology San Francisco, expressed concerns about environmental impacts of collection vehicle routes and pricing. John Bouchard (Teamsters Local 350) and Mark Leeson (Teamsters Joint Council 7) raised labor concerns, including lower wages and benefits for workers outside San Francisco, history of strikes, and potential service disruptions due to picket lines. They urged the committee to evaluate the awardee's labor record. Key Outcomes - Approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors: Items 1 through 11, all by unanimous votes. - Continued: Item 12 to the next Budget and Finance Committee meeting on March 6, 2024, by a unanimous vote. - Amendments adopted: Items 1 and 2 were amended as described; Item 11 was amended to include additional recitals regarding charter section 9.118.
The San Francisco Port Commission met on Tuesday, February 27, 2024, starting at approximately 10:30 AM and adjourning at 4:28 PM. Commissioners Kimberly Brandon (President), Stephen Lee, and Ed Carrington were present; Vice President Gail Gilman and Commissioner Willie Adams were absent. The meeting included a land acknowledgment, approval of prior minutes, an executive session, public comments, an executive director’s report, consent calendar approvals, a biennial budget presentation and approval, a lease waiver for the SkyStar Wheel, and approval of a public artwork installation. Consent Calendar - Resolution 2411 (Item 10A): Retroactively authorized modification of construction contract No. 2849 for Heron’s Head Park signage to extend the substantial completion date. Approved unanimously. - Resolution 2412 (Item 10B): Awarded construction contract No. 2861 for the WRP Wharf J9 Replacement Project, Phase 1 – Float & Gangway, to Yerba Buena Engineering and Construction, Inc., in the amount of $3,557,380, plus a 10% contingency of $355,738, for a total not to exceed $3,913,118. Approved unanimously. - Resolution 2413 (Item 10C): Authorized acceptance and expenditure of a $21,582,000 grant from the Port and Freight Infrastructure Program (California State Transportation Agency) for the Maritime Eco-Industrial Complex Improvement Project, funding pier, roadway, and utility upgrades and a plan to mitigate air emissions from port trucks. Approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - Pete Sitnik (managing partner, Water Bar and Epic State, proposed tenant for Pier 33½): Expressed strong objection to a pending ordinance limiting businesses to five propane tanks (full or empty) on property, effective March 1, 2024. He stated that the restriction would hinder outdoor dining, revenue, and activation of port property, and that the 10-day notice was insufficient to plan alternatives. He requested commission review. - Anonymous caller: Requested enforcement of the street vendor code along Jefferson Street on Fisherman’s Wharf, particularly near the Cannery. Alleged that an Asian man with a street artist permit sells counterfeit items and monopolizes the area. Claimed the Arts Commission has not monitored or enforced permits for over seven years. The caller declined to give their name. - Public comment on the Executive Director’s Report: None. - Public comment on the Biennial Budget: None. - Public comment on the SkyStar Wheel Lease: None. - Public comment on the Artwork Proposal: None. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report (Item 9A) - Economic Recovery: Elaine Forbes reported on the successful Ports Day in Sacramento (held February 21, 2024), which was sold out and growing. She highlighted the state’s commitment to port investments, offshore wind partnerships, and the importance of port-aligned state partnerships. She thanked government affairs director Boris Delapine and deputy maritime director Dominic Moreno for their lobbying efforts. - Resilience: The Port’s waterfront resilience community kickoff meeting at South Beach/Mission Bay drew 75+ attendees; four people could not enter due to capacity. Outreach continues through February 29, 2024. Port and Army Corps representatives (including resilience director Brad and Chief Brian Harper) presented. - Equity: A trades career fair was held February 13, 2024, at Pier 50, with interactive demonstrations from maintenance shops to inspire careers in the trades. Other city departments will participate next year. - Personal equity story: Forbes shared a story about unknowingly making a positive impact on someone’s career, encouraging staff to persist despite challenges. Commissioners praised the report and expressed appreciation for staff. Biennial Operating and Capital Budget (Item 11A, Resolution 2414) - Presentation: Nate Cruz, Deputy Director of Finance and Administration, presented updates to the Fiscal Year 2024-25 and 2025-26 biennial budget. Key changes included: - A homeland security grant (awarded 2021, $100,000) for CCTV upgrades and security training, now being appropriated after a staff error. - Reclassification of an IT engineer position to senior level to address infrastructure complexity and create promotional pathways. - Security model shift: Moving from reliance on contractors to hiring in-house permanent port security guards (off-hours, nights/weekends) for better ownership and cost control. The commission will receive regular updates on implementation. - Parking model: Aligning with MTA practices; regular updates on financial impacts will be provided. - New attachments: Attachment 4 detailed the Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund history and allocations (including $8 million spending plan presented in January 2024 by economic recovery manager Megan Wallace). Attachment 6 provided a resilience program spending plan, breaking down the Waterfront Resilience Program (WRP) into categories and funding sources. Cruz noted that figures are based on early conceptual design and will change. - Commissioner questions: Commissioner Carrington asked about $4 million for removing red tag facilities (answered as not specific to grain silos; separate account). Commissioner Lee asked about in-house security staffing and deployment. Mike Martin, Assistant Port Director, clarified that in-house guards are for off-hours reliability, while ambassadors are used for public interaction and vending enforcement. Commissioner Lee suggested a security booth for tourist information and deterrence. - Outcome: Motion to approve the budget (Resolution 2414) passed unanimously. SkyStar Wheel Lease (Item 12A, Resolution 2415) - Presentation: Don Kavanaugh, Senior Property Manager for Fisherman’s Wharf, presented a request to waive competitive bidding and approve an 18-month lease (through October 31, 2025) with SkyStar Wheel, LLC, relocating the wheel from Golden Gate Park to Fisherman’s Wharf. The current special event license expires April 30, 2024. - Rationale for waiver: No realistic competitors exist; a new wheel would take 18 months and cost $10 million. Competitive bidding would not yield favorable responses and could cause a shutdown. - Community engagement: Favorable feedback from Fisherman’s Wharf Community Benefit District (FishWACK); one concern about traffic was routine. Lighting complaints (colored, moving lights) were addressed by requiring white lights only, with limited exceptions for festivals (e.g., Chinese New Year). Lights must turn off at 10 PM. Complaints will be handled via a dedicated email address. - Financial terms: Base rent remains similar to the special event license, with a 5% percentage rent (not over base). Operator may increase rates. Complimentary ticket policy adjusted (removed two-for-one Tuesdays/Wednesdays due to low uptake). - Statistics: In December 2023, the wheel carried 39,000 passengers (165% increase over December 2022 at Golden Gate Park). In January 2024, 28,000 passengers (120% increase over January 2023). - Commissioner comments: Commissioner Lee expressed support, noting increased foot traffic and potential for future inclusion in the Fisherman’s Wharf Revitalization plan. Commissioner Carrington stated he would vote for the lease but expressed dislike for the “carnival atmosphere” and hoped for a better long-term plan. Commissioner Lee noted the limited term due to the Revitalization exclusive negotiating agreement. - Amendment: City Attorney Michelle Sexton added environmental review findings (CEQA addendum and mitigation measures) to the resolution. The amendment was approved. - Outcome: Resolution 2415 (as amended) approved unanimously. Artwork Proposal for Cruise Terminal Plaza (Item 13A, Resolution 2416) - Presentation: Marcus Davies (Port staff) and a representative from the San Francisco Arts Commission presented the selection of artist Ana Teresa Fernández for a permanent public artwork at Pier 27’s James R. Herman Cruise Terminal Plaza. The piece, titled “Marayas” (meaning tides), is a 15-foot-high, 24-foot-wide arch made of colored polycarbonate panels framed in steel tubing, designed to capture changing light and color. - Selection process: An RFQ issued in October 2022 drew 144 applicants; 28 were advanced to a review panel, which selected three finalists (David Brooks, Ana Teresa Fernández, James Shen). All finalists received an honorarium. The review panel recommended Fernández in December 2023; the Port Northern Advisory Committee reviewed the proposal on January 17, 2024. - Budget: Total art enrichment: $330,000. Art implementation budget: $136,000 (artist fees, design, fabrication, insurance, transportation). Site work/installation: $60,600. Long-term conservation: $33,000. The artwork is expected to have a lifespan of 35 years. - Maintenance: The Arts Commission will care for the sculpture; the Port will assist with non-specialized cleaning (e.g., power washing). Vandalism abatement methods are under review. - Timeline: Artist contract in March 2024; design through September 2024; fabrication May–June 2025; installation July 2025. - Commissioner comments: Commissioner Carrington praised the artwork and asked about stipends for finalists (confirmed honorarium was paid). Commissioner Lee asked about the lifespan (35 years) and expressed appreciation. Commissioner Brandon supported the selection. - Outcome: Resolution 2416 (approving the artwork and authorizing the Executive Director to enter into an MOU with the Arts Commission) approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Minutes of February 6, 2024: Approved unanimously. - Consent Calendar (Resolutions 2411, 2412, 2413): Approved unanimously. - Biennial Budget (Resolution 2414): Approved unanimously. - SkyStar Wheel Lease Waiver and Terms (Resolution 2415): Approved unanimously, with staff directed to seek Board of Supervisors approval for the waiver of competitive bidding. - Artwork Proposal (Resolution 2416): Approved unanimously. - New Business: The Commission noted follow-up actions: (1) Research and report on the propane tank storage ordinance affecting port tenants; (2) Return with a discussion on the appropriate mix of in-house vs. contracted work for the Waterfront Resilience Program; (3) Continue to address unlicensed vending on port property. - Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 4:28 PM.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on February 27, 2024, beginning at 10:00 AM. The agenda included consent items, regular agenda items, special orders for commendations, committee reports, and public comment. Key actions included approval of a $9 million settlement, an apology to African Americans, and amendments to density controls in historic districts. The board also honored outgoing Controller Ben Rosenfield and several Black community leaders during Black History Month. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 9 were approved unanimously, except for Item 6 (settlement with Amazon.com Sales, Inc.) which was severed. Supervisors Walton and Peskin recused themselves due to conflicts of interest. The settlement of $448,119.86 was approved 9-0. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Several speakers addressed the board. One speaker criticized the memoriam for Logan Miller, arguing it was disrespectful. Another speaker advocated for reducing digital surveillance to reduce overdoses and suggested it contributed to retail closures. A speaker urged support for the Public Defender Pilot Program funding. Peter Warfield criticized the library's new strategic plan for omitting books and reading. A speaker against item 17 (apology) argued that the city must now reap what it sowed. Another speaker supported the apology but called for more action. A speaker proposed turning the vacant Macy's building into an indoor garden. One speaker complained about elevator delays in SROs due to the mayor's office holding funds. - Public Comment on Item 43 (Ben Rosenfield Day): Michael Petrellus praised Rosenfield for his compliance with public records requests, contrasting him with other officials. Discussion Items - Item 10 (APEC Fund Reappropriation): Ordinance to de-appropriate $3.5 million from General City Responsibility and reappropriate $500,000 to SFMTA for free parking and transit during Lunar New Year, and $3 million to OEWD for a relief fund for SoMa businesses affected by APEC. Supervisor Engardio thanked Supervisor Chan for securing $1 million for small businesses on Taraval Street affected by Muni track reconstruction. The ordinance passed 11-0. - Item 11 (Tax-Defaulted Property Auction): Resolution to authorize sale of tax-defaulted properties. Supervisor Safai moved to remove three occupied properties (92 Ellington Ave, 41 Sears St, 26 Stanley St) to allow owners more time to apply for mortgage relief. The amendment passed without objection, and the resolution as amended was adopted. - Item 15 (Homeless Services Contracting Waivers): Ordinance to extend sunset date for contracting waivers for homeless services through May 5, 2029. Passed 7-4, with Supervisors Chan, Dorsey, Peskin, and Safai voting no. - Item 17 (Apology to African Americans): Resolution apologizing for systemic discrimination and committing to redress. Unanimously adopted (11-0). Several supervisors spoke in support, including Supervisor Preston who emphasized the need for non-repetition of harm, and Supervisor Ronen who lamented the lost momentum from 2020 racial justice protests. - Item 22 (Density Controls in Historic Districts): Ordinance to re-impose density limits in Northeast Waterfront, Jackson Square, and Jackson Square Extension historic districts, reversing unintended consequences of prior density decontrol that allowed buildings up to 400% taller than height limits. Supervisor Melgar and Dorsey voted no, citing concerns about setting a precedent that could undermine housing production. The board also approved a duplicated file (moved by Supervisor Stephanie, seconded by Melgar) to send the issue back to committee for further work. The ordinance passed 8-3 (Dorsey, Engardio, Melgar voting no). - Special Order 2:30 PM – Commendations: - Controller Ben Rosenfield Day (Item 43): The board declared February 29, 2024 as Controller Ben Rosenfield Day. All supervisors praised his 26 years of service, including his role in maintaining AAA bond ratings, guiding the city through the pandemic, and mentoring staff. Rosenfield expressed gratitude and noted his pride in the controller's office team. The resolution was adopted unanimously. - Black History Month Commendations: Supervisor Melgar honored a team from the Department of Emergency Management (Janet Fallings, Theodores de G Rosen, Vora Hurd, Antoinette Acoff, Raquel Dawson) for their collective 132 years of service. Supervisor Preston honored Nate Ford for his 34 years of youth basketball and mentorship programs, including the SF Rebels, which has helped over 600 youth access scholarships. Supervisor Mandelman honored Dr. Tyler Termir, CEO of San Francisco AIDS Foundation, the first Black CEO in its 42-year history. Supervisor Walton honored Kyrie Howard, a first-generation law graduate who passed the bar. Supervisor Safai honored Renard Monroe, executive director of Youth First, for his community work in Lakeview. - Committee Reports (Items 33-35): - Item 33 (Fleet Charging): Amended to remove retroactive 311 notice requirement. Passed. - Item 34 (Parcel Delivery Service): Passed as amended. - Item 35 (Supporting SB 915 on Autonomous Vehicles): Adopted. - Roll Call for Introductions: Supervisors introduced various items, including an ordinance to ensure city firearms purchases only from vendors compliant with state/federal laws (Supervisor Stephanie), a resolution supporting AB 2286 requiring human safety operators in heavy autonomous vehicles, and a hearing request on SRO elevator repair delays (Supervisor Preston). Supervisor Safai called for a hearing on reimagining Union Square after Macy's closure announcement. - Closed Session: The board convened in closed session to discuss labor negotiations (Item 44). Key Outcomes - Approved Settlements: - Mason Masuda lawsuit: $9,000,000 (Item 18, passed). - Florence Kong et al.: City to receive $750,000, with debarment provisions (Item 19, passed). - Lyft, Inc. tolling agreement: $5,156,634 tax dispute (Item 20, passed). - Committee of the Whole Cancelled: Items 28-32 (delinquent property tax hearings) were cancelled because the Treasurer-Tax Collector received payment for all properties. The public hearing was opened and closed with no comment, and the items were tabled. - Adoption Without Committee Reference: Items 39-44 (minus 43) were adopted unanimously. Item 42 (supporting AB 2319 on maternal health) was also adopted. - Next Steps: The duplicated file on density controls (Item 22) will return to committee for further work. Supervisor Preston's hearing request on SRO elevator repairs will be scheduled.