The Rules Committee, chaired by Vice Chair Shiman Walton (acting for Supervisor Ronan) and joined by Supervisors Safai and Engardio, met on March 18, 2024. The committee considered three agenda items: a mayoral appointment to the Entertainment Commission, an ordinance to codify the Homeward Bound program, and a hearing on UCSF's proposed acquisition of Dignity Health's St. Mary's and St. Francis hospitals. Key decisions included approving the appointment, amending and forwarding the Homeward Bound ordinance, and filing the hearing. Consent Calendar - Motion to excuse Supervisor Ronan passed unanimously (3-0). Discussion Items 1. Mayoral Appointment to Entertainment Commission Lieutenant Leonard Poggio, a 22-year SFPD veteran, presented his qualifications for the law enforcement representative seat. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about nightclub violence and asked about safety enforcement. Poggio emphasized a measured approach and plans to improve coordination between SFPD and the commission. Public comment from three speakers (including a fellow lieutenant and a childhood friend) strongly endorsed Poggio's integrity and experience. The committee voted 3-0 to approve the appointment and send it to the full Board with a positive recommendation. 2. Permanent Homeward Bound Program (Ordinance 231226) Deputy Director Emily Cohen (HSH) presented the program, which has served over 11,000 households since 2005. The ordinance would codify relocation assistance for homeless or at-risk individuals. Discussion focused on the eligibility reuse period: originally set at five years. Supervisor Safai moved to amend it to two years after feedback from the Human Services Agency, and the amendment passed without objection (3-0). Public comment included one speaker who opposed including permanent supportive housing tenants and expressed concerns about coercion and lack of safeguards for LGBTQ+ individuals. The committee then voted 3-0 to send the amended ordinance as a committee report to the full Board. 3. UCSF Acquisition of Dignity Health Hospitals (Hearing 240099) UCSF Vice President Shay Strawn outlined plans to acquire St. Mary's Medical Center and St. Francis Memorial Hospital, committing to maintain all services, retain staff, invest $75–100 million in deferred maintenance, and honor collective bargaining agreements. She noted the hospitals lose over $10 million monthly and are at risk of closure without the acquisition. Claire Altman (DPH) reported that the Health Commission found the acquisition would not be detrimental if UCSF meets its commitments, and will require six-month updates through 2027. Nurses and CNA representatives (Albina Guerrero, Amy Preble, Matt Jones, Mike Rayburn) testified about critical services: 27% of unhoused patient care, 50% of psychiatric discharges, 42% of rehab discharges, and the only burn center. They criticized UCSF's lack of transparency and cited concerns from the Children's Hospital Oakland acquisition. Public comment was mixed: some supported the acquisition for expanding reproductive health access, others demanded stronger commitments and oversight. Supervisor Safai queried UCSF about ownership structure, staffing, and charity care commitments. The committee voted 3-0 to file the hearing. Key Outcomes - Motion to excuse Supervisor Ronan: passed. - Appointment of Lieutenant Leonard Poggio to the Entertainment Commission: approved and recommended to full Board. - Homeward Bound ordinance (231226): amended (reuse period changed from 5 to 2 years) and sent to full Board as committee report with positive recommendation. - UCSF acquisition hearing: filed.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaAt its regular meeting on March 14, 2024, the San Francisco Planning Commission addressed a consent calendar of continuances, adopted minutes, heard a major informational presentation on the Waterfront Resilience Program, and ruled on a discretionary review and variance request for a residential project at 1336 Shotwell Street. The meeting also included land acknowledgement, commission comments, department matters, and general public comment. Consent Calendar - The Commission unanimously voted to continue five items: Item 1 (4000 21st Street - conditional use) to April 11, 2024; Item 2 (320 Frederick Street - discretionary review) to April 11, 2024; Item 3 (58 Buena Vista Terrace - conditional use) to April 11, 2024; Item 4 (426 Fillmore Street, Unit C - discretionary review) to May 2, 2024; and Item 5 (900 Kearny Street Special Use District - planning code amendment) indefinitely. - The Commission adopted the draft minutes for February 29, 2024, as amended to include a public commenter's request, with a unanimous vote of 6-0. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish discussed the importance of demolition calculations (demo calcs) in the context of a project at 4000 21st Street, arguing that extreme remodels create market instability. She urged the Commission to uphold Section 317 of the Planning Code. Nitsu Hash requested a future presentation on changes to the planning process due to state mandates and RHNA, emphasizing that the Commission's scope of work is being reduced. - Waterfront Resilience Program: During the informational item, public commenters raised concerns about contamination at Hunters Point (Georgia Shutish) and the need for a presentation on sea level rise impacts on the western side of the city (Nitsu Hash). - 1336 Shotwell Street DR: The DR requester (neighbor) argued that the project sponsor had not followed the Commission's direction to move the stair off the property line and presented an alternative internal stair option. The project sponsor (architect Mason Kirby) explained that the stair location is necessary given the geometry and that reducing the deck to 125 square feet addressed the variance concern. Additional public comment from Georgia Shutish questioned whether the project triggered Section 317 demo calcs. Discussion Items - Waterfront Resilience Program Informational Presentation (Item 11): Adam Barrett from the Port of San Francisco presented the draft San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study, a collaboration with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The study covers 7.5 miles of the eastern waterfront and proposes a $13.5 billion plan to elevate shorelines, floodproof piers, and improve drainage to protect against up to 3.5 feet of sea level rise by 2140. The draft plan is in a 60-day public comment period ending March 29, 2024. Commissioners praised the presentation and raised questions about federal funding feasibility, cost escalation, design flexibility, local share, phasing priorities, equity considerations, contamination remediation, and coordination with other city projects. Commissioner Moore emphasized the need to maintain waterfront connections and view corridors. Commissioner Braun noted the importance of a "build once" strategy. Commissioner Williams asked about local community benefits and racial equity. The item was informational only; no vote was taken. - Commission Comments: The Commission discussed supporting a Board of Supervisors resolution (24-2) urging the state to restore cuts to affordable housing programs. All commissioners expressed support, and the Commission agreed to agendize an endorsement item for the next meeting. The Commission also welcomed new Commissioner Williams. - Department Matters: Director's announcements welcomed Commissioner Williams. The legislative affairs manager reported on recent Board of Supervisors actions, including passage of the ADU controls ordinance and the OOPS ordinance. The Zoning Administrator reported that the Board of Appeals denied rehearing requests for the Great Highway Pilot Program, finalizing the coastal permit approval. Key Outcomes - Consent Continuances and Minutes: All continuances and the minutes adoption were approved unanimously (6-0). - Endorsement of Affordable Housing Resolution: The Commission agreed to place an item on the next agenda to formally endorse Board of Supervisors Resolution 24-2, urging the state to protect affordable housing funding. - Discretionary Review and Variance at 1336 Shotwell Street: The Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to take discretionary review and approve the project as amended in plans dated March 11, 2024. The approved design reduces the roof deck to 125 square feet, eliminates the rear yard expansion, and retains the stair location on the property line. The Commission also closed the public hearing on the variance and granted it pursuant to the revised plans. The motion included a recommendation for neighborly communication regarding noise.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on March 13, 2024, at 6:00 PM UTC to consider six agenda items. All items were approved and forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for the March 19, 2024 agenda. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar. Public Comments & Testimony - Items 2 & 3 (Power Station EIFD): Two speakers supported the EIFD. Jude Deckenbach, a neighborhood resident and advocate, highlighted the project’s creation of seven acres of open space and waterfront access, noting the developer’s commitment to privately fund park maintenance in perpetuity. John Doherty, Business Manager of IBEW Local 6 and Vice President of the San Francisco Building Trades Council, expressed support for the project’s thousands of jobs, career opportunities, and apprenticeship slots. - Item 6 (Port Economic Recovery): John Doherty also spoke in favor of releasing the $10 million reserve, emphasizing the importance of supporting commercial fishermen and maintaining the historic port town character of San Francisco. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Self-Help for the Elderly Grant Amendment: The Department of Disability and Aging Services (DOS) requested a $1.9 million increase (total not to exceed $11,515,405) to fund an additional 82,500 home-delivered meals for older adults through fiscal year 2024-2025. Self-Help for the Elderly delivered 246,000 meals to 1,100+ clients in 2023, a 3.5-fold increase from 71,000 meals to 400 clients in FY 2018-2019. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) noted no compliance issues and recommended approval. The committee unanimously approved the resolution. - Items 2 & 3 – Power Station Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD) and Development Agreement Amendment: The Controller’s Office of Public Finance and the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) presented the Infrastructure Financing Plan (IFP) for the Power Station EIFD, the city’s first use of this tool. The EIFD will divert 50% of the city’s property tax increment (58.3% of the city’s share of the 1% tax rate) to fund up to $548 million in public infrastructure, including affordable housing, parks, streets, and utilities. The project includes 2,600 residential units (30% affordable), 1.6 million square feet of commercial space, and seven acres of open space. The base year assessed value is $138.9 million; total allocated tax revenue over 45 years is not to exceed $3.29 billion, with conditional tax revenue up to $2.36 billion. The city’s annual net fiscal benefit at build-out is estimated at $15.1 million. Supervisor Shamann Walton (District 10) noted that the first building, named after former Supervisor Sophie Maxwell, will contain 105 affordable units. The BLA reported that the original development agreement did not contemplate using property taxes for infrastructure, but OEWD clarified that the developer bears upfront costs and is reimbursed only from incremental tax revenue. The committee expressed support for the EIFD as a tool to invest in underserved neighborhoods and meet housing goals. The resolutions were approved unanimously. - Items 4 & 5 – Motorola Solutions and CentralSquare Technologies Contract Amendments: The Department of Emergency Management (DEM) requested approval of two contracts for the Computer Aided Dispatch (CAD) system. Item 4: Amendment with Motorola Solutions for a new CAD system, increasing the not-to-exceed amount from $9.6 million to $44,845,036 and extending the term to November 30, 2038 (11 years). Annual maintenance costs are $1.8 million, $1.4 million more than the current system. Item 5: Amendment with CentralSquare Technologies to extend maintenance for the current CAD system through November 30, 2027 (3 years) at $8,364,557 total, to ensure overlap during transition. The BLA noted that the new system’s cost will require new general fund money starting FY 2026-27. DEM confirmed the contract includes training and organizational change management. The committee approved both items unanimously. - Item 6 – Hearing to Release Reserved Funds for Port Economic Recovery Project: The Port of San Francisco requested release of $10 million from the Budget and Finance Committee Reserve (Ordinance 165-20) to fund economic recovery initiatives. The funds are part of a larger $64.4 million plan. Of the $10 million, $7.3 million is allocated to Fisherman’s Wharf for activation, tenant attraction, and support for commercial fishing. The BLA noted that operating revenues are recovering unevenly, and the port is investing in historical assets. The committee approved the release and the hearing was filed. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board with recommendation. - Items 2 & 3: Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board with recommendation. Supervisors Mandelman and Melgar added as co-sponsors. - Items 4 & 5: Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board with recommendation. - Item 6: Approved unanimously (3-0) to release the $10 million reserve and file the hearing.
The Port Commission met on Tuesday, March 12, 2024, at 11:15 a.m. and adjourned at 5:12 p.m. The meeting included an executive director’s report, an informational presentation on Mission Rock Phase 1 land rights, and two informational reports on local business enterprise (LBE) participation and workforce development. No formal votes were taken on informational items; the Commission unanimously approved the February 27, 2024 meeting minutes. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (February 27, 2024): Moved, seconded, and approved unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were offered on items not listed on the agenda, the Executive Director’s Report, the Mission Rock presentation, or the LBE and Waterfront Resilience Program reports. No remote callers commented on any item. Discussion Items Executive Director’s Report (Item 6A) - Assistant Director Michael Martin presented the report for Executive Director Elaine Forbes, who was out of the office. He highlighted Women’s History Month initiatives, including a staff waterfront walk highlighting women changemakers and a pop-up event celebrating Black women makers planned for Saturday, March 30 at the Downtown Ferry Terminal Plaza. - Waterfront Resilience Program outreach: since the January draft plan release, the Port and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers hosted four community workshops with nearly 300 attendees, two port tenant webinars, a dozen community-based organization presentations, two public webinars, and four walking tours. Nearly 3,000 people viewed the online story map. The draft plan is on display at the Center for Architecture and Design through the public comment period, which closes March 29, 2024. Two in-language workshops (Spanish and Cantonese) were scheduled later in the week. - Construction on the Roundhouse 2 office building is underway, with completion scheduled for March 2025. The project is managed by a woman project manager. - Port staff provided a report on nine accounts recommended for write-off under Resolution 22-11; commissioners have 30 days to raise concerns. - Commissioners praised the outreach efforts and expressed interest in the waterfront walk and pop-up events. Mission Rock Phase 1 – Land Rights Agreements (Item 7A) - Phil Williamson (Port project manager) and Josh Keene (assistant deputy director of development) presented. The project includes 537 rental apartments, 550,000 sq ft of office space (including Visa’s future global headquarters), 52,000 sq ft of retail, a District Energy System, and a recycled water facility. China Basin Park is expected to open to the public in April 2024. - Retail leasing progress: five leases executed (Ike’s Love and Sandwiches, AeroScale Bakery, Proper Foods, Quick Dog, and Back Home Hospitality) plus a fitness facility (Lux Fit). Approximately 18.57% of project dollars have been awarded to LBE firms, and 102 of 415 vendors (24.5%) are LBE firms. The project’s LBE goal is 20%. - Horizontal project budget: $218 million, on budget, with about $72,000 of cushion on the city cost portion. - Acceptance process: developer to submit SOP compliance in May; Port Commission acceptance anticipated as early as July 2024; Board of Supervisors approval required for some agreements. A series of land rights agreements (parks lease, paseos, utility agreements for PG&E and MRU, etc.) will be negotiated through the summer and into the fall. - Park events: BCDC guidelines limit closures to 18 times per year in defined areas; most events will be public and open. Parking: no dedicated parking in buildings; Lot A and Pier 48 provide about 1,900 spaces on non-game days; a future garage is entitled for 3,100 spaces but likely fewer. Residential occupancy at The Canyon (Parcel A) is just above 60%. - Commissioner Adams expressed strong support, calling the project “good medicine” for the neighborhood and city. Commissioner Harrington raised questions about management agreements and event closures. Vice President Gilman asked about residential leasing and park opening. Commissioner Lee asked about park amenities and parking availability. Local Business Enterprise and Workforce Development Report (Item 8A) - Elizabeth Alexander Toots (contracts and procurement manager) and Tiffany Tatum (senior community development specialist) presented. In FY 2022-23 (July 1, 2022 – June 30, 2023), the Port awarded 19 contracts totaling $29.5 million, doubling the number of contracts from the prior year. 68% of new contracts went to LBE primes or LBE joint ventures, exceeding the Port Commission’s 20% goal; over $10 million of new contract dollars went to LBEs. - Of 67 active contracts, LBE primes received $2.6 million (12%) and LBE primes paid $6.2 million to LBE subcontractors; total payments to LBE contractors were $8.8 million, representing 40% of total payments. (Percentages as reported by staff.) - Workforce data showed very low participation of women, African Americans, Asian/Pacific Islanders, and Native Americans on Port public works projects. Commissioner Adams called the disparity “glaring” and said the Port must “raise the bar.” Commissioner Lee asked whether the low numbers reflect the available applicant pool. Vice President Gilman urged conversations with OEWD and the Building Trades Council and suggested collaborating with other city departments. President Brandon requested an ethnicity breakdown of LBE firms and asked what initiatives exist to improve workforce and contracting diversity. - Tiffany Tatum highlighted the Rising Tides maritime youth internship program: seven juniors from Burton High School completed a week at Cal Maritime and five weeks at the Port; one student was accepted to Cal Maritime. The Port’s annual contract open house is in its seventh year and expects 250 attendees. Waterfront Resilience Program LBE and Equity Actions (Item 8B) - Carlos (first name only in transcript) presented an update on the Waterfront Resilience Program’s (WRP) LBE participation and equity actions. Under the CH2M contract, LBE participation through December 2023 was 27.7%, exceeding the 19% target; 28.4% of total payments went to LBEs. The required LBE amount was $12.7 million (21.19% of the $59.9 million contract). Ethnicity data showed White-owned firms at 12.1%, MBEs at 8.2%, and smaller shares for African American (6%), Asian (4%), and Latino (1.2%) owned firms. Carlos noted that some minority women-owned businesses choose WBE rather than MBE designation, and some minority-owned firms are not San Francisco LBEs, accounting for differences. - Next steps: CH2M contract capacity expected to be exhausted by the end of summer; final LBE participation values will be reported. A future report will include Pier 50 and Wharf J9 float construction LBE numbers. Equity work includes an equity working group, roadmap to equity, and workforce development and LBE support guides. - Commissioner Harrington asked whether data exists on who actually works for the contracting firms; staff said such information is not collected. Commissioner Lee noted the low African American and Asian percentages. Commissioner Adams asked if the Port is succeeding; President Brandon replied, “If we were succeeding, we wouldn’t be having these conversations.” Key Outcomes - Unanimously approved the February 27, 2024 meeting minutes. - No formal votes were taken on informational items. - Port staff committed to: - Provide an ethnicity breakdown of LBE firms and workforce data in future reports. - Provide an annual diversity report on Port staff by division. - Pursue conversations with OEWD, the Building Trades Council, and possibly other city departments to improve workforce and LBE pipelines. - Continue Mission Rock acceptance and land rights work; report back in April with lease-up and affordable housing data. - The public comment period for the Waterfront Resilience Program draft plan closes March 29, 2024.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, March 12, 2024, beginning with roll call, approval of previous minutes, and a consent agenda. Mayor London Breed appeared for a special order policy discussion on family homelessness. The board then considered and voted on numerous ordinances, resolutions, and motions, including housing policy, bond refunding, land use, and committee reports. Several supervisors introduced new business, and public comment was heard on a variety of topics. The meeting also featured commendations for the Cuban chargé d'affaires and a Treasure Island community organization, and adjourned in memory of Maurilio Leon. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 5 were approved unanimously without objection as routine business. Public Comments & Testimony - Chris Ward Klein raised concerns about unauthorized access controls in the city's "Sherlock" data system used by human service agencies, urging the board to correct access control issues. - Jordan Pranan spoke against Proposition F, arguing it would harm homeless individuals and force queer recipients into religious treatment programs. - Jim McPhee addressed public corruption and fraud in city services. - Megan Smith requested that the ceiling be protected as part of the Sacred Heart Parish Complex landmark designation. - Beverly Epton, representing the San Francisco Domestic Violence Consortium, expressed support for item 28 (Supporting California Assembly Bill 1956 on victim services funding), noting the importance of federal VOCA funds. - Other speakers discussed education reform, technology, and quality-of-life issues. Discussion Items - Mayor London Breed's Special Order (2:00 p.m.): Mayor Breed stated the city faces a growing number of families experiencing homelessness. She noted that San Francisco currently provides 337 units of family shelter and transitional housing and over 2,300 units of family housing in the homeless response system. She emphasized the need to balance newcomer demand with existing needs, highlighted increased case management, asylum legal support, and a pilot hosted housing program, and called for collaboration. - Item 7 – Forgivable Loan for First-Time Homebuyers Program: Ordinance establishing a loan program for low-, moderate-, and middle-income first-time homebuyers. The measure passed 9-1, with Supervisor Peskin voting no. - Items 8 & 9 – Potrero Bus Yard Project: Two ordinances to amend the General Plan and create the Potrero Yard Special Use District. Both passed unanimously (10 ayes). - Items 10 & 11 – Refunding General Obligation Bonds: Authorized approximately $645 million in refunding bonds. Approved without objection. - Items 12–14 – Grants and Property Exchange: Resolutions to accept grants (HealthySteps, Predictive Analytics) and amend a property exchange agreement for a fire station. Approved without objection. - Item 15 – Sacred Heart Parish Complex Landmark: Ordinance designating the complex as a landmark. Passed on first reading. - Item 16 – Conditional Use Waiver for Unauthorized Units: Ordinance waiving conditional use authorization for removal of unauthorized units under certain criteria. Passed on first reading. - Item 17 – Legacy Business Assistance Program: Ordinance creating the program. Passed on first reading. - Item 18 – Appointments to Immigrant Rights Commission: Motion to appoint six members, approved without objection. - Item 19 – Tolling Agreement with Chevron: Committee report on a retroactive tolling agreement for oil well plugging and remediation. Approved. - Item 20 – Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Ordinance: State-mandated ADU controls were amended to conform to state law. Supervisor Peskin expressed frustration that state law prevents rent control on ADUs created through the state program. The measure passed without objection after discussion. - Item 21 – Planning Commission Appointment: Motion to approve Gilbert Williams to the Planning Commission, term ending July 1, 2026. Approved. - New Business Introductions: - Supervisor Dorsey: Hearing request on SFPD staffing to reach full deployment in three years. - Supervisor Engardio: Resolution to prioritize municipal issues over non-local resolutions. - Supervisor Mandelman: Hearing on implementation of the "Place for All" homelessness strategy, citing a 37% reduction in tents but a steady unsheltered population (4,189 in 2023 vs. 4,144 in 2022). - Supervisor Peskin: Resolution urging the CPUC to deny AT&T's request to be relieved of carrier-of-last-obligation; also adjourned meeting in memory of Maurilio Leon, former CEO of Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation. - Supervisor Safai: Resolution urging the Department of Homeless Supportive Housing to prioritize families with children on the streets and create a transparent dashboard. Key Outcomes - Item 7 (Forgivable Loan Program) passed 9-1 (Peskin opposed). - Items 8-9 (Potrero Yard) passed 10-0. - Item 10-11 (Bond refunding) approved without objection. - Item 15 (Sacred Heart landmark) passed on first reading. - Item 16 (Unauthorized unit waiver) passed on first reading. - Item 17 (Legacy Business Assistance) passed on first reading. - Item 18 (Immigrant Rights Commission appointments) approved. - Item 20 (ADU ordinance) approved as a committee report without objection. - Item 21 (Gilbert Williams to Planning Commission) approved. - Items 24, 25, 27, and 28 (resolutions on Equal Pay Day, ethnic journalism, wastewater drug testing, and victim services funding) adopted 10-0 after Supervisor Melgar severed item 26 for separate consideration. - Item 26 (Lucille Cuttler Day resolution) adopted without objection after brief remarks. - New business introductions were submitted for committee referral or future action.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on March 12, 2024, from approximately 9:30 AM to 12:30 PM. The commission approved a $407 million amendment to the biosolids digester facilities contract, heard updates on the waterfront flood study and power enterprise customer programs, and received the FY 2022-23 audited financial statements with unmodified opinions. Public comment addressed community benefits, power outages, customer assistance program barriers, and the alternative water supply plan. Consent Calendar - 6a: Approved a 684‑calendar‑day extension to Contract No. DB‑130 (Bay Corridor Transmission and Distribution) with no change to the contract amount, due to contractor delays including equipment malfunctions, water intrusion, and protection relay system issues. A third‑party consultant is reviewing testing. - 6b: Approved closeout of Contract No. HH‑1004.C (Master As‑Needed Tree Services‑Hetch Hetchy) with Capax Group, Inc. and authorized final payment of $17,175. The contractor elected to shut down after one task order; three other contractors remain. - 6c–6f: Approved modifications and awards for contracts related to general engineering construction, HVAC maintenance, sewer replacement, and pipe and plant solutions. All items were approved unanimously (3‑0). Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Francisco de Costa urged the commission to fully utilize the community contracting center (currently open Tuesday–Thursday) and called for an audit of the 5% community benefits set‑aside (targeting $300 million on the first $6 billion in projects). - Peter Dreckmeyer, policy director for the Tuolumne River Trust, requested a workshop on the alternative water supply plan, noting that full buildout could cost $16–$25 billion and double the SFPUC’s budget. He stated that the plan’s demand projections rely on an “outside envelope” and that actual water use in 2023 was 178 MGD versus a 2020 projection of 216 MGD. - A caller speaking for her parents reported that the Customer Assistance Program (CAP) required additional income verification for low‑income immigrant applicants, that a letter was sent only in English (not Spanish as the application was submitted), and that months of delay had occurred without a discount. - Barkley Sanders, a resident of Treasure Island and member of the citizen advisory board, stated that the island has experienced over 487 power outages in 25 years (with outages lasting 2–3 weeks) and called for an emergency authorization to upgrade the grid for current residents. - On Item 7 (Biosolids Amendment): Two community members criticized the pace of the social impact partnership commitment. One speaker, Attorney Jafferia Morris, urged the commission to delay the vote until Commissioner Sophie Maxwell could attend and demanded increased community benefits, noting that the Black population in District 10 had dropped from 40% to 18%. Another speaker, Francisco de Costa, said his nonprofit had received no funds and called for the contracting center to be open Monday–Friday. Discussion Items - 5a. FY 2022‑23 Audited Financial Statements: Nancy Hom, CFO, and Annie Lewey from MGO LLP presented the three audited enterprise statements (water, wastewater, Hetch Hetchy Power, CleanPowerSF). The audits received unmodified opinions with no material misstatements and no internal control deficiencies. One uncorrected misstatement (damage claims liabilities) was noted but deemed immaterial. The annual comprehensive financial report and popular annual financial report were also issued, and the SFPUC has received Government Finance Officers Association awards annually since 2009/2010. Commissioner Stacy commended the transparency and clarity of the reports. - 5b. San Francisco Waterfront Flood Study Draft Report: Adam Verrett (Port of San Francisco) and Sarah Minick (SFPUC Wastewater) presented the draft plan. The study covers 7.5 miles of waterfront, with a preliminary cost estimate of $13.5 billion. Congress would fund up to 65%. The draft plan proposes a phased approach: non‑structural floodproofing at Fisherman’s Wharf; raising the shoreline to 3.5 feet of sea‑level rise along the Embarcadero; elevated shoreline and vegetated berms in South Beach/Mission Bay; and flood walls, closure structures, and nature‑based features in the southern reaches. The 60‑day public comment period is underway. Commissioners emphasized the need for interagency coordination, public safety (including firefighting water access), and collaboration with national and international experts. - 5c. Update on Power Enterprise Customer Programs: Daniel Young presented two new programs. The All‑Electric Multifamily program (started Nov. 2023) offers site assessments for affordable housing buildings served by Hetch Hetchy Power; two assessments have been completed. The Electrify My Ride e‑bike program (started Feb. 2024) provides a $1,000 point‑of‑sale discount at local bike shops, limited to customers enrolled in energy assistance programs and living in equity priority communities. The $1 million incentive budget is 50% reserved, with 70+ coupons redeemed in the first month. The first round expires at the end of April 2024. Both programs are revenue‑funded. - 7. Approve Amendment No. 6 to Contract No. WW‑647R (Biosolids Digester Facilities): Project manager Carolyn Chu requested a $407 million increase (to a total of $2.2 billion) and a 111‑day extension (60 days for additional foundation work, 51 days contingency). All 105 construction packages have been bid out, with procurement occurring during and after COVID. The increase is offset by $107 million in savings from other project elements (e.g., terminated lease, contingency for biogas P3). The overall project completion date remains unchanged. Local hire participation is at 34% (exceeding 30% goal), apprenticeship hours at 61% (exceeding 50%), and LBE participation at 17% (94 firms, $318 million awarded, of which $214 million is from District 10). The social impact partnership commitment of $16 million is not keeping pace, partially attributed to a prior contract pause. The commission approved the amendment unanimously. - 8. Award Contract No. WW‑750 (Southeast Plant SEP‑7 Operations, Engineering, and Maintenance Buildings): Project manager Shelby Campbell presented the award to Clark Construction for $97 million, with a duration of just under five years. The project will consolidate end‑of‑life facilities, provide direct connection to the biosolids project, and create a neighborhood‑friendly campus edge. The contract is a two‑step CMGC: the commission approved the design/pre‑construction phase; construction approval will return after environmental review completion (approximately one year). Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Votes: Consent calendar (6a–6f) approved 3‑0. Item 7 (Biosolids amendment) approved 3‑0. Item 8 (WW‑750 contract award) approved 3‑0. Closed session settlements (Item 13: $58,986 to Matthias Sally; Item 14: eight claimants from Fillmore/Green Street water main break) were approved. - Directives: Commissioners directed staff to provide periodic updates on the waterfront flood study and to continue working with the contractor on the biosolids social impact partnership. The commission will receive a workshop on the alternative water supply plan at a future date. - Next Steps: The public comment period for the waterfront flood study draft plan is open; a joint city comment letter will be submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The power enterprise programs will be evaluated at the end of April for potential expansion. The biosolids project is expected to reach peak construction in fall 2024.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee convened on Monday, March 11, 2024. Acting Chair Supervisor Walton presided, joined by committee members Supervisors Safai and Preston (substituting for Chair Ronan). The committee reviewed the presidential appointment of Gilbert Williams to the Planning Commission and legislation to codify the city's Homeward Bound program for individuals experiencing homelessness. Public Comments & Testimony - Appointment of Gilbert Williams (Planning Commission): Multiple community leaders and organizations spoke in strong support of the nomination. - Tere (Poder) voiced support, highlighting Williams' community-centered problem-solving approach. - Matias Mormina (Chinatown CDC) endorsed him as a strategic listener and thinker who values diverse experiences. - Raina Teyo (Poder) emphasized his commitment to building the leadership of others. - Charlie Shamus (Council of Community Housing Organizations) offered his highest recommendation, praising Williams' integrity, principled advocacy for working-class and BIPOC communities, and work on equitable development. - Timothy Reif (Carpenters Local 22) noted that Williams' hands-on experience as a trained carpenter is an asset for achieving the city's housing goals. - A former Supervisor underscored Williams' role in ensuring that the voices of working-class communities in the southern neighborhoods are represented in planning. - Gabriel Medina (La Raza Community Resource Center) highlighted Williams' firsthand experience with foreclosure and his long track record of fighting displacement. - Homeward Bound Program (Administrative Code): No members of the public provided testimony on this item. Discussion Items - Presidential Appointment of Gilbert Williams to the Planning Commission (File 240171): Nominee Gilbert Williams presented his background. Born and raised in San Francisco, he is a union carpenter who lost his home to foreclosure in 2010, an experience that led him to become a community leader advocating for affordable housing and against displacement. He has worked on the first 100% affordable housing projects in District 11 in 20 years and participated in the Excelsior Outer Mission Neighborhood Strategy. Supervisor Preston praised his longtime advocacy. Supervisor Safai questioned Williams on the city's Housing Element goals of 82,000 units, including 46,000 affordable units. Williams identified the need for state and federal funding as critical, expressed caution regarding the impacts of upzoning on small businesses and existing residents, and committed to listening to community voices in his decision-making. - Homeward Bound Program Legislation (File 231226): Supervisor Safai, the legislation's sponsor, presented an ordinance to establish a permanent Homeward Bound program in the Administrative Code. The program, launched in 2004-2005, served over 11,000 people through 2018-2019 before its utilization declined significantly. It reunites unhoused individuals with family or support networks in destinations elsewhere, typically costing less than $200 per person. The legislation aims to restore the program's prominence, add oversight and accountability, and expand eligibility to include individuals at risk of homelessness or those in permanent supportive housing. Safai introduced amendments to enact this expansion. Key Outcomes - Planning Commission Appointment: The committee unanimously voted to approve the nomination of Gilbert Williams for the Planning Commission seat vacated by Commissioner Gabriela Ruiz. The appointment will be sent to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report for the March 19, 2024, meeting. (Vote: 3-0, Preston, Safai, Walton). - Homeward Bound Program: The committee unanimously approved Supervisor Safai's amendments to expand the program's eligibility. Following the amendment, the committee voted to continue the item to the March 18, 2024, Rules Committee meeting to allow for further review of program statistics by the Human Services Agency (HSA) and the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH). (Vote: 3-0).
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, March 11, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Mirna Melgar, joined by Board President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered two ordinances: one clarifying ministerial approval for accessory dwelling units (ADUs) and another amending the Planning Code to correct errors and extend certain programs. Both items were forwarded to the full Board with positive recommendations. Discussion Items Item 1: Ordinance on State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit Controls (File 230310) - Proposed clarification of ministerial approval process for ADUs in single-family and multifamily buildings. Planning Department representative Aaron Starr noted that amendments from the previous week had been incorporated. No public comment was received. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the ordinance as a committee report to the Board of Supervisors. Item 2: Planning Code Amendments – Exceptions and Extensions for Existing Uses (File 240070) - Audrey Merlone of the Planning Department explained the ordinance addresses four specific items: modifying height offset requirements in the Bernal Heights Special Use District, permitting large movie theater signage in the Japantown neighborhood commercial district, allowing medical cannabis dispensaries to continue as temporary cannabis retail uses until December 31, 2024, clarifying eligibility for inclusionary housing reductions, and correcting a zoning control table error. The ordinance resolves permitting errors for two specific projects that built non-compliant elements following approved permits, and extends two temporary programs. - Supervisor Melgar noted she had checked with Supervisor Ronan's office regarding the Bernal Heights height limits, confirming no issues. - No public comment was received. - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the ordinance with a positive recommendation to the full Board. Key Outcomes - Both items were forwarded to the Board of Supervisors for the March 18, 2024 meeting with unanimous recommendations. - No public testimony was provided on either item. - The meeting adjourned after completing the agenda. Note: Not all items on the printed agenda (e.g., item under 30-day rule) were discussed.
The San Francisco Planning Commission convened on Thursday, March 7, 2024, to act on continuances, consent calendar items, and a contested discretionary review and variance for a property at 1336 Shotwell Street. All five commissioners were present: President Diamond, Vice President Moore, and Commissioners Braun, Imperial, and Coppel. The meeting included public comment, a consent calendar, and a lengthy deliberation over the Shotwell Street project. Continuance Calendar - Item 1 (638 Rhode Island Street, DR) was continued to March 21, 2024 (from March 14). - Item 2 (1701 Fillmore Street, CUA) and Item 3 (807-809 Vermont Street, CUA) were continued indefinitely. - Public comment was closed with no speakers. The motion to continue as proposed passed unanimously 5-0. Consent Calendar - Item 4 (2675 Geary Boulevard): The Commission rescinded its February 1, 2024, Conditional Use Authorization for a Whole Foods Market due to an omitted CEQA findings agenda item. Public comment none. Passed unanimously 5-0. - Item 5a/5b (2675 Geary Boulevard): The Commission adopted CEQA findings and approved the Conditional Use Authorization for the formula retail grocery store. Passed unanimously 5-0 as part of the consent calendar. - Item 6 (3233 22nd Street): Request for Conditional Use Authorization to change from Limited Restaurant to Restaurant. Passed unanimously 5-0 as part of the consent calendar. Commission Matters - Commissioner Imperial read the land acknowledgement acknowledging the Ramaytush Ohlone as the original inhabitants of the San Francisco Peninsula. - The draft minutes for February 22, 2024, were adopted unanimously 5-0. - No commission comments were made. Department Matters - Director's announcements: None. - Legislative Affairs Manager Aaron Starr reported on recent actions at the Board of Supervisors, Board of Appeals, and Historic Preservation Commission. Items included a parcel delivery ordinance, an ordinance amending conditional use requirements for removing unauthorized dwelling units, a landmark designation for Sacred Heart Church, an ADU ordinance, form-based density legislation, and several other planning-related items. General Public Comment - Georgia Shutish spoke about Section 317 demolition calculation requirements, referencing the Terhalian v. City and County of San Francisco case. She argued that demo calcs should be required for projects with horizontal and vertical expansions, especially near Priority Equity Geographies, and provided written comments. Regular Calendar - Item 12 (65-67 Noe Street): Request for Conditional Use Authorization to remove an unauthorized dwelling unit. Staff reported the unit is approximately 368 square feet, has been vacant since April 2017, and is uninhabitable. No public comment was made. The Commission approved the request with conditions unanimously 5-0. Discretionary Review Calendar - Items 13a/13b (1336 Shotwell Street): The Commission considered a public request for discretionary review of a building permit to legalize an accessory dwelling unit, construct a horizontal front addition, and add a roof deck. A variance was also required due to the property's substandard lot and a 1991 variance condition. - Staff recommended not taking discretionary review, finding no extraordinary circumstances. The department received 4 letters in opposition and 33 letters in support. - The DR requester, Carlina Hansen, and her attorney Brian O'Neill opposed the vertical and horizontal expansion and the roof deck, citing privacy, light, noise, and the 1991 variance conditions. They proposed alternative rear yard access via an external or internal stair. They expressed support for legalizing the ADU. - Project sponsor Andy Greenwood, his wife Jess, and architect Mason Kirby supported the project, emphasizing the need to legalize the ADU, provide open space, and build community. They stated they studied alternative stair locations and found them problematic. - Public comment was divided. Direct neighbors (Mike Bowton, Curry McLaughlin, Karen Kircher) and architect Alex Garcia opposed, while tenants, friends, and community members supported the project, citing housing needs and the sponsors' good neighborliness. - During deliberations, concerns were raised about the portion of the roof expansion extending into the required rear yard and the size of the roof deck. Vice President Moore proposed shrinking the deck to the minimum 125 square feet and working with neighbors. Commissioner Braun moved to continue the item for one week to allow revised plans addressing the commission's comments. - The zoning administrator also continued the variance to the same date. Key Outcomes - Unanimous approval (5-0) of continuances, consent calendar items, minutes, and the 65-67 Noe Street CUA. - The 1336 Shotwell Street discretionary review and variance were continued to March 14, 2024, with a motion passed 4-1. President Diamond voted against the continuance, preferring more limited direction. The item will return with revised plans from the project sponsor.
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Thursday, March 7, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Chair Dean Preston presided, joined by Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Supervisor Connie Chan. The committee considered several items related to community benefit districts (CBDs) and a tolling agreement with Chevron. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public provided testimony on any agenda item. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Excelsior Community Benefit District Management Agreement): Jeff Buckley (legislative aide to Supervisor Safai) and Jackie Hazelwood (OEWD CBD Program Director) presented a resolution to approve a management agreement with the Excelsior Action Group (EAG) as the owners' association for the newly established Excelsior CBD. The district was created in July 2023 with a 10-year term starting January 1, 2024. The contract template was updated to prohibit use of assessment revenue for lobbying. EAG Executive Director Maribel Ramirez expressed excitement about bringing funds to the struggling commercial corridor. The item was unanimously recommended to the full board. - Items 2–5 (CBD Annual Reports for FY 2021–2022): Jackie Hazelwood presented an overview of the four CBDs: Yerba Buena (met all benchmarks), Japantown (missed benchmark 1 due to a categorization error), The East Cut (met all benchmarks), and North of Market/Tenderloin (missed benchmark 4 due to missing carry-forward reporting). Each CBD director presented highlights: - Yerba Buena CBD (Scott Rowitz): 513,000 lbs of trash removed, 10,000 graffiti tags removed, 3,278 steam cleanings, 3,780 human waste removals, 1,571 311 calls responded to. Community guides on streets 365 days/year, a 10B SFPD officer hired. Budget spent 36% on cleaning/streetscaping, 34% on safety/security, 16% management, 14% branding. - Japantown CBD (Grace Horikurie): Focused on COVID recovery, small business support, cleaning (6 city blocks), safety alerts, and community partnerships. Over 15,000 people attended a Naked Inc. immersive art exhibit. Budget error resulted in over-budgeting environmental enhancements and under-budgeting economic enhancements; corrected in FY22-23. - The East Cut CBD (Angie Robinson): Covers 4,907 parcels, with 15,000 residents and 20M sq ft of office space. Services include 24/7 cleaning and security; 2,000 graffiti tags, 800 needles, 120,000 lbs of trash removed. Maintains Salesforce Park (funds 80% of programming and maintenance), Emerald Park, Guy Place Mini Park, and a community garden. Highlighted two 100% affordable housing projects delivering 300+ units. - North of Market/Tenderloin CBD (Kate Robinson): Densely residential, low-income neighborhood with median income $38,000, 68% immigrants. Camera network expanded from 10% to 60% coverage. Safe Passage program transitioned to hourly employees; park stewards employed 20 Tenderloin residents. Budget exceeded assessment by $5M due to frontline pandemic work. Staff grew from 4 to 70, with 50 residents employed. - OEWD Role Discussion: Chair Preston inquired about OEWD's neutrality in recommending vendors or surveillance technology. Chris Corgus (OEWD Deputy Director) stated the department does not provide contractor recommendations but acts as a thought partner, referring CBDs to each other for peer advice. CBD directors confirmed they rely on each other for vendor information. - Item 6 (Chevron Tolling Agreement): Resolution to retroactively approve a tolling agreement extending the statute of limitations for litigation regarding Kern County oil wells from November 30, 2023 to May 31, 2024. Chair Preston noted it was straightforward and no closed session was needed. Unanimously recommended to the full board as a committee report. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Motion to send to full board with positive recommendation passed unanimously (3 ayes). - Items 2–5: Motion to recommend to full board passed unanimously (3 ayes). - Item 6: Motion to forward to full board as committee report passed unanimously (3 ayes). - No action was taken on closed session items; the committee did not convene in closed session.