Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 791–800 ENTRIES
791
FEB 27, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - February 27, 2024: Approvals, Reports, and Remote Public Comment Reinstated

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) convened on Tuesday, February 27, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting began with a land acknowledgment, approval of the February 13, 2024 minutes, and reports. The Commission addressed consent calendar items, multiple contracts and MOUs, accepted $23.3 million in federal funds for customer arrearages, approved two credit facilities, and voted to reinstate remote public comment. Voting outcomes: most items passed unanimously, with the remote public comment measure passing 3-2. Commissioner Jami arrived after the consent calendar and several regular calendar items. Consent Calendar - Approved the Consent Calendar (Item 6) in a unanimous 4-0 vote (Commissioner Jami absent). Discussion covered: modernization and capacity increase for the Moccasin Wastewater Treatment Plant; addition of contingency funding and time for the West Side Pump Station project due to $975,000 in expended contingency and unforeseen conditions; acknowledgement of OJO Technologies' acquisition by Convergent Technologies; and approval of a sole-bidder contract for a specialized groundwater project at a cost ($7M) below the engineer's estimate ($8M). Lessons learned noted about avoiding bid openings during holidays. Public Comments & Testimony - General public comment and comment on each agenda item were offered, but no members of the public appeared to speak except during the remote public comment discussion. - For Item 14 (remote public comment), Jacob Evans, a representative from Cycle California, spoke in favor, emphasizing the importance of remote access for equitable participation by elders, caregivers, and communities across the SFPUC's 2.7-million-person service area. Discussion Items Quarterly Audit and Performance Review (Item 5A) Audit Director Irella Blackwood presented the quarterly audit report as of December 31, 2023: 13 audits (41% of planned) completed, 38% in progress, 7 scheduled. Open recommendations from two audits (SSIP management contract audit and revenue lease audit of Crystal Springs Golf Partners) target closure by March 2024. The Controller's Office follow-up report validated SFPUC's implementation of seven prior recommendations. Commissioner Maxwell inquired about examples of contract management improvements. Contracts and MOUs (Items 7-10) - Item 7 (CS-109 Amendment): Increase contract amount by $1 million to $10.95 million and extend by 3 years to 16.5 years for specialized engineering services for recycled water projects. Needed due to two-year delay from critical electrical equipment failure at Westside Enhanced Water Recycling Facility. Approved 4-0. - Item 8 (Zoo Recycled Water MOU): MOU with Recreation and Park Department for 200,000 gallons per day of recycled water to the zoo (animal exhibit washdown, pool filling) and Lower Great Highway irrigation, offsetting 100% of groundwater use and freeing groundwater for potable supply. PUC constructs pipeline, owns groundwater infrastructure; Rec Park retains reservoir and pump station; PUC funds a staff position. Approved 4-0. - Item 9 (Santa Clara Intertie Amendment): Transfers operation and maintenance of the 40-MGD Milpitas Intertie to Santa Clara Valley Water District, reviewed every five years, due to SFPUC staff busy with WISIP and district proximity. Approved 4-0. - Item 10 (Treasure Island MOU): Amends and restates MOU with TIDA for utility services on Treasure Island and Yerba Buena, with initial two-year term and option to extend up to six additional years. PUC operates as contractor on outdated Navy infrastructure, reimbursed for costs. The aim is to manage risk while new utility systems are developed. Approved 4-0. Federal Arrearage Assistance (Item 11) Clarissa Wan presented acceptance of $23.3 million from the California Extended Arrearage Payment Program (ARPA-funded) to assist water and wastewater customers with arrears accrued during the COVID-19 pandemic. Applied amounts: $9.6 million for water, $13.5 million for wastewater, plus $200,000 in administrative costs. The funds will reduce water arrears from $11.8 million to $4.5 million and wastewater arrears from $15.3 million to $6.2 million. All customer types (residential, commercial, municipal) eligible; no income criteria. Remaining $10.2 million in arrears to be addressed through payment plans and outreach. Collections to resume after funds applied. Approved 4-0. Credit Facilities (Items 12 & 13) Edward Kwang presented two credit facility actions, both part of the fiscal 2024 capital financing plan. - Item 12 (Wastewater Credit Facility): $150 million five-year letter of credit from Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corporation at 30 basis points, replacing expiring facility at 32 bps, to support the Wastewater Enterprise Interim Funding Program and commercial paper issuance. Approved 5-0 (Commissioner Jami present). - Item 13 (CleanPowerSF Credit Agreement): Fourth amendment to $75 million credit agreement with JPMorgan Chase, extending term by three years to total nine years, increasing from $20 million, with lower fees (45 bps; L/C fees 1.25% vs prior 1.4-2.05%). Used for standby letters of credit for power purchase agreements, solar interconnection, and as a working capital line. Approved 5-0. Remote Public Comment Procedure (Item 14) Commissioner Jami brought a motion to reinstate remote public comment, arguing that the SFPUC's service area extends across the state and many stakeholders cannot attend in person. President Paulson opposed, citing the Mayor's directive and concerns over meeting disruptions (e.g., "Zoom bombing"), stating she would support only after the Board of Supervisors and Mayor act. Commissioner Stacy noted the estimated cost for implementing remote public comment is approximately $1,100 per meeting plus staff time, but supported remote comment for broader participation of out-of-city stakeholders. Commissioner Rivera opposed, noting in-person testimony is more compelling and remote comment is still available by phone upon request. Commissioner Maxwell strongly supported, calling it essential for democracy. After public comment by Jacob Evans, the motion passed 3-2 (Maxwell, Jami, Stacy yes; Paulson, Rivera no). Key Outcomes - Approved minutes of February 13, 2024. - Approved Consent Calendar (4-0). - Approved Item 7 (CS-109 amendment) (4-0). - Approved Item 8 (Zoo MOU) (4-0). - Approved Item 9 (Santa Clara Intertie amendment) (4-0). - Approved Item 10 (Treasure Island MOU) (4-0). - Approved Item 11 (ARPA fund acceptance) (4-0). - Approved Item 12 (Wastewater credit facility) (5-0). - Approved Item 13 (CleanPowerSF credit agreement) (5-0). - Approved remote public comment procedure (3-2).

WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 30% · PUBLIC COMMENT 22% · PROCEDURAL 13% · AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 10%
792
FEB 26, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
San Francisco Rules Committee Meeting - February 26, 2024

The Rules Committee met on Monday, February 26, 2024, at 18:00 UTC (10:00 AM PST) to consider three items: appointments to the Market and Octavia Community Advisory Committee, appointments to the Veterans Affairs Commission, and an ordinance amending the Administrative Code regarding oversight of nonprofit organizations contracting with the city. The committee was chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen, with Vice Chair Shamann Walton and Supervisor Ahsha Safai (absent for the first two items). Supervisor Dean Preston joined for item one. Public Comments & Testimony Market and Octavia CAC Appointments: No public comments were made. Veterans Affairs Commission Appointments: Twelve members of the public spoke in support of various candidates. Bill Barnacle (retired military, current commissioner) supported Jenny Perez, Jason Chittavong, and others, noting that the commission had passed three major pieces of legislation in the last three years after 40 years of inactivity. Other speakers supported James Boatman, Prince Jordan, Hanley Chan, and Daria Kutovaya, citing their work with veterans on housing, mental health, and community integration. Ordinance on Nonprofit Monitoring: Debbie Lerman from the San Francisco Human Services Network spoke in support of the legislation and its amendments, emphasizing the need for accountability measures that also include adequate funding for overhead and salaries, and elimination of duplicative burdens. Discussion Items 1. Appointments to Market and Octavia Community Advisory Committee (6 seats): Supervisor Preston introduced the item, noting the large number of applicants and the importance of the CAC in guiding development, transportation, and affordable housing commitments in the Hayes Valley area. The committee heard from eight applicants: Jesus Gien, Leah Culver (withdrew for seat 2), David Robinson, Michael Rooney, Natalie Burdick, Madeline Howie (absent), Nicholas Parker, Autumn Adam (absent), Sasha Ortega, and Andrew Signer. Supervisor Preston recommended six candidates for their progressive values and community engagement: Jesus Gien (seat 1), Natalie Burdick (seat 2), Madeline Howie (seat 3), Nicholas Parker (seat 4), Sasha Ortega (seat 5), and Andrew Signer (seat 6). The committee voted to approve. 2. Appointments to Veterans Affairs Commission (8 seats): Eleven applicants were considered, with two withdrawals (Douglas Bollard and William Barnacle). The committee heard from Jenny Perez, Daria Kutovaya, Deborah Dacumos (represented by commission secretary Mary Murphy), Jason Chittavong (represented by Mary Murphy), Tom Manchin, Hanley Chan, James Boatman, Megan Joy Maria O'Leary, Mitchell Ryan Weller, Prince Kelly Jordan, and Christopher Mark Scott. Supervisor Walton made a motion to appoint the following: Jenny Perez (seat 1), Deborah Dacumos (seat 2), John Risenweber (seat 3), Jason Chittavong (seat 4), Hanley Chan (seat 5), Prince Kelly Jordan (seat 6), James Boatman (seat 7), and Daria Kutovaya (seat 8). The motion passed. 3. Ordinance (File 230973) - Administrative Code - Monitoring of Nonprofits: Dominic O'Donovan, Chief of Staff for Supervisor Catherine Stefani, presented amendments to the ordinance. The amendments were developed after input from a coalition of small nonprofits (Asian and Pacific Islander Council, Black Wall Street, Latino Task Force, Mega Black, SALT, and SF Latino Parity and Equity Coalition). Key amendments included: requiring the controller to issue guidance on engaging contractors in performance standard development (page 3, lines 24-25); requiring the controller to engage with city departments and contractors in developing corrective action policies (page 4, lines 13-14); delaying the new auditing requirement to March 31, 2026 (page 5, lines 17-18); adding a public rulemaking process for new policies (subsection F, page 5, line 23); and requiring the controller to engage with historically underserved communities (page 6, lines 3-8). The compliance date was pushed to November 2024. Supervisor Safai and Walton expressed support for the equitable approach. Chair Ronen added herself as a co-sponsor. Key Outcomes - Market and Octavia CAC Appointments: Motion to appoint the six recommended candidates passed unanimously (2-0, with Supervisor Safai absent). - Veterans Affairs Commission Appointments: Motion to appoint the eight recommended candidates passed unanimously (2-0, with Supervisor Safai absent). - Ordinance on Nonprofit Monitoring: Motion to accept the amendments and send the amended ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation passed unanimously (3-0). The ordinance is expected to appear on the March 5, 2024 Board of Supervisors agenda.

VETERANS AFFAIRS 38% · COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 20% · AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 11% · PROCEDURAL 8%
793
FEB 26, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
Land Use and Transportation Committee Regular Meeting - 2024-02-26

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on February 26, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Myrna Melgar, with President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered ten agenda items, including housing programs, landmark designations, zoning changes, utility excavation rules, and a hearing on PG&E power outages. Several items were sent to the full board with recommendations, and one hearing was continued. Item 1: Forgivable Loan for First-Time Homebuyers (File 230864) Discussion: Supervisor Melgar presented the ordinance to establish a down-payment assistance program administered by the Human Rights Commission (HRC) for low-, moderate-, and middle-income first-time homebuyers, focusing on communities harmed by discriminatory housing policies. HRC Director Cheryl Davis stated the program aims to close wealth gaps. President Peskin raised concerns about HRC's capacity, noting the department lacks loan administration experience and suggesting a work-order with the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD). Supervisor Melgar argued HRC should retain policy control while leveraging MOHCD's technical expertise. Public Comment: One speaker opposed the program, arguing the city cannot afford new initiatives. Key Outcome: The committee voted 2-1 to recommend the ordinance to the full board (Melgar and Preston aye, Peskin nay). Supervisor Melgar requested MOHCD input before the board vote. Item 2: Landmark Designation – Sacred Heart Parish Complex (File 231045) Discussion: Planning staff presented the Historic Preservation Commission's recommendation to designate the complex as a landmark. Supervisor Preston offered amendments adding character-defining features (exterior bridge, interior elements, stained glass) and clarifying replacement-in-kind provisions. The amendments were developed with property owners and preservationists. Public Comment: Several speakers supported landmarking with strong interior protections; some lamented the roller-skating use. Property owner representatives asked to review amendments. Key Outcome: The committee unanimously approved Preston's amendments (3-0) and continued the item to March 4, 2024. Item 3: Family and Senior Housing Opportunity Special Use District (File 230808) Discussion: Supervisor Engardio presented amendments reverting to the original look-back period for lot mergers. The city attorney will prepare coastal zone language for the full board. Public Comment: Multiple speakers opposed the SUD, citing potential displacement and inappropriate density. Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to amend and recommend the ordinance to the full board. Items 5 & 6: Potrero Yard Modernization Project (Files 231256, 240047) Discussion: Supervisor Ronan expressed strong support. Planning staff and SFMTA presented plans for a rebuilt bus yard with up to 465 affordable housing units, retail, and public space. Over 150 community meetings were held. Public Comment: None. Key Outcome: The committee unanimously voted 3-0 to recommend both items to the full board. Item 4: Housing Production – Notice and Review Exemptions (File 231258) Discussion: Planning staff presented amendments clarifying planning entitlement applications and modifying 311 review criteria for large single-family alterations. President Peskin noted a future amendment on relocation assistance. Public Comment: One speaker (TODCO) supported maintaining 311 notices in priority equity geographies. Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to amend and recommend the ordinance to the full board. Item 7: Microtrenching for Fiber Optics (File 230867) Discussion: Supervisor Safai and Public Works staff presented an ordinance to codify microtrenching. Amendments removed duplicative language now covered by departmental orders. Public Comment: AT&T requested further revisions to allow direct fiber burial and trench-only restoration. Key Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to amend and recommend the ordinance to the full board. Items 8, 9 & 10: Fleet Charging (File 231080), Parcel Delivery Services (File 231223), and AV Resolution (File 240132) Discussion: Supervisor Chan presented the three items as a package to regulate fleet charging, parcel delivery, and support state legislation for local control of autonomous vehicles. President Peskin offered amendments to Item 8 (grandfathering date of Jan 11, 2024). For Item 9, amendments were adopted to simplify CU for small facilities, exclude cannabis delivery, and add a March 8 sunset; the item was then continued to March 4 for an additional amendment regarding educational institutions. Item 10 was recommended without amendment. Public Comment: Teamsters and labor groups supported all items; Chamber of Commerce opposed Item 8. Safety concerns with AVs were highlighted. Key Outcome: - Item 8: Amended and recommended as a committee report (3-0). - Item 9: Amended, duplicated, continued to March 4, and the original version recommended as a committee report (3-0). - Item 10: Recommended as a committee report (3-0). Item 11: Hearing on PG&E Power Outages (File 240119) Discussion: Supervisor Melgar convened a hearing on recurrent outages in District 7. PG&E reported 80 planned and 77 unplanned outages in January 2024, with storm-related outages peaking at 20,000 customers in San Francisco (4,692 remaining next morning). PG&E outlined restoration phases and customer programs. Supervisor Melgar pressed for better coordination with community groups and clearer communication. Public Comment: Several residents from Mount Davidson, West Portal, and other areas testified about repeated multi-day outages, aging infrastructure, and difficulty accessing assistance. They requested improved infrastructure and communication. Key Outcome: The hearing was continued to the call of the chair. PG&E agreed to provide detailed data on outage-prone areas and coordinate with the supervisor's office. Summary of Actions - Items 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 were sent to the full board with positive recommendations. - Item 2 was continued to March 4, 2024. - Items 8 and 10 were sent as committee reports to the March 5, 2024 board meeting. - Item 9 was partially continued to March 4 and also sent as a committee report. - Item 11 was continued to the call of the chair.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING 15% · PROCEDURAL 14% · PUBLIC COMMENT 14% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 13%
794
FEB 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting Summary – February 22, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular public hearing on Thursday, February 22, 2024, at 20:00 UTC. The meeting covered a consent calendar, commission and department matters, public comment, and a regular agenda of 10 items including conditional use authorizations, a citywide zoning ordinance, and a discretionary review case. Key outcomes included approval of a market-rate to rental conversion at 1546-1564 Market Street, approval of a new restaurant (Fiddle Fig Cafe) at 790 Lombard Street over legacy business concerns, and a continued hearing for a large residence at 4000 21st Street to explore adding an accessory dwelling unit. The commission also voted not to take discretionary review of a project involving earthquake shacks at 369 Valley Street, approving the project as proposed. Consent Calendar - Items 1, 2, and 4 (2022-010415CUA – 2130 Leavenworth Street 6; 2022-007099CUA – 725 Pine Street 205; 2023-005943CUA – 1401, 1499 Illinois and 700 25th Streets) were approved on consent by a unanimous 5-0 vote. Item 3 (2012.0877DNX-03 – 1546-1564 Market Street) was removed from consent by Commissioner Moore and heard separately. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Schudish requested greater scrutiny of demolition calculations (demo calcs) for projects involving exterior alterations, citing a 2009 code implementation document. Two representatives from the Northern California Carpenters Union (Christopher Siever and Brandon Phillips, Local 22) spoke in favor of including labor standards (local hiring, apprenticeships, health care) in future construction projects, noting that 26% of California construction workers lack health insurance and 50% rely on public assistance. - Item 3 (Market Street): A member of the public noted the irony that the previous tenant at the site was SF BARF (predecessor to SF YIMBY) and expressed concern about the fate of families who had made down payments on condos before the conversion to rental. - Item 10 (Citywide Commercial Expansion): No public comment offered. - Item 11 (731 Treat Avenue): A neighbor expressed concern about lack of parking and requested the building design match the historic Mission district character; she opposed the ADU and urged parking instead. - Item 12 (790 Lombard Street): Members of the public and a representative from Supervisor Peskin’s office (Sunny Angulo) detailed the displacement of Cafe Sapore, a legacy business. Angulo read a statement from the former owner, Elias Bikahi, who said his business was stolen and the new cafe opened improperly. Other speakers (Gloria Rogan, Marcela Sierzega, Tiffany Campbell) supported Fiddle Fig Cafe, citing its community contributions. A letter from a 60-year resident described the cafe’s support for a local school event. - Item 13 (4000 21st Street): Adjacent property owners Steve Bain and AJ Gard opposed the project, citing loss of light, privacy, construction risks, and the owner’s alleged coercive behavior. Georgia Schudish questioned why demolition calculations changed from 54% to 44% removal between plan versions. Jeremy Paul argued the project exceeds community-created size limits (3,000 sq ft) and undermines Supervisor Mandelman’s legislation. - Item 14 (369 Valley Street): Multiple speakers (Georgia Schudish, Catherine Petrin for San Francisco Architectural Heritage, Megan Smith for Victorian Alliance, Andrew and Tiffany Kearney, Bradley Weedmeyer) supported the discretionary review to preserve the earthquake shacks. They advocated for an alternative plan that would keep the shacks in place with minimal elevation, arguing the sponsor’s plan would render the shacks unrecognizable. Preservation architect Mike Garavaglia provided technical concerns. Discussion Items - Item 3 – 1546-1564 Market Street (Downtown Project Authorization): Staff (Rebecca Salgado) presented a request to convert 109 dwelling units from ownership to rental, including 13 affordable units (previously 90% AMI for ownership, now 55% AMI for rental). The building has been vacant since completion in 2022. Commissioner Moore questioned the treatment of parking (to be unbundled) and the status of previous down-payment holders. The project sponsor confirmed that all deposits were voluntarily returned; staff noted that of six BMR contracts, three secured other ownership, one used down payment assistance, and one is in a lottery. A public letter raised issues about an indicted inspector, but no specific problems were identified. The commission unanimously approved with conditions. - Item 10 – Citywide Expansion of Allowable Commercial, Restaurant, and Retail Uses (Planning Code Amendment): Staff (Veronica Flores) introduced the ordinance (introduced by the Mayor, duplicated from an earlier version). Director Katie Tang (Office of Small Business) summarized changes: more restrictive controls in RH/RM districts (no formula retail, conditional use for midnight hours, outdoor activity areas only at front), North Beach NCD amendments (retail professional services require CU, Polk Street NCD allows nighttime entertainment as principally permitted on ground floor). Nate Hurrell (Supervisor Peskin’s office) proposed additional amendments: reinstating change-of-use notifications (Section 311) and keeping NCD-specific controls (Sections 231C, 231D). Staff opposed the 311 notice as a step backwards. Commissioner Koppel made a motion to approve the ordinance as proposed with the yellow-highlighted changes from the land use committee, without the supervisor’s amendments. The motion passed 5-0 after a brief discussion. - Item 11 – 731 Treat Avenue (Conditional Use Authorization): Staff (Alex Westhoff) presented a proposal to demolish a fire-damaged one-story building (one legal unit, one unauthorized unit) and construct a four-story, three-unit building plus an ADU, with no parking and four class-1 bike spaces. The project received three support letters and several concerns (light, privacy, parking, view). The project sponsor explained that legalizing the existing unit would cost $550,000 but only add $150,000 in value. Commissioner Moore praised the design and density. The commission approved unanimously. - Item 12 – 790 Lombard Street (Conditional Use Authorization for Fiddle Fig Cafe): Staff (Dakota Speecher) described the request to legalize a restaurant where the prior use was Cafe Sapore, a legacy business that vacated in 2019 after the landlord terminated its lease. Planning staff initially told the new tenant no CU was needed (an error later corrected). Zoning Administrator Corey Teague explained the misinterpretation of the legacy business code. The commission received 220+ letters of support, 334 petition signatures, and no opposition letters. Commissioners expressed dismay at the displacement of the legacy business and called for stronger protections. Commissioner Moore suggested that legacy businesses should be portable and that compensation mechanisms should be explored. The commission voted unanimously to approve the CU for Fiddle Fig Cafe, with conditions. - Item 13 – 4000 21st Street (Conditional Use Authorization for Large Dwelling Unit): Staff (Michelle Taylor) presented a request to expand a 2,579 sq ft single-family home to 3,707 sq ft (vertical addition) within the Central Neighborhoods Large Residence Special Use District (requires CU above 3,000 sq ft). The project is planning-code compliant; a new city ordinance capping size takes effect in 2025 but does not yet apply. Neighbors opposed, citing loss of light and the owner’s conduct. Commissioner Moore made a motion to deny based on excessive size in RH2 zoning and the desire to add density. After discussion about adding an ADU (which would eliminate the CU requirement), Commissioner Braun proposed a continuance to allow the sponsor to explore a JDU/ADU. The motion to continue passed 5-0. - Item 14a/b – 369 Valley Street (Discretionary Review and Variance): Staff (David Winslow) described a project to relocate and raise two earthquake shacks (circa 1906), add a two-story rear addition, and increase rear yard compliance. The DR requester (Mark Norton) argued the project would destroy the shacks’ integrity; an alternative plan (keeping shacks in place with minimal raise) was supported by preservation groups and neighbors. The project sponsor argued the alternative required more excavation and risk. Commissioner Braun moved not to take DR and to approve the project as proposed, based on staff’s finding that the shacks’ form remains readable and visible from the street. The motion passed 5-0. Zoning Administrator Teague granted the variance with standard conditions. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Items 1, 2, and 4 approved 5-0. - Item 3 (Market Street): Approved 5-0 – conversion from ownership to rental, with conditions (parking unbundled, preservation of affordable units at 55% AMI). - Item 10 (Citywide Commercial Expansion): Approved 5-0 as proposed (with yellow-highlighted amendments from land use committee, without Supervisor Peskin’s additional amendments). - Item 11 (731 Treat Avenue): Approved 5-0 – demolition and construction of three residential units plus one ADU, with conditions. - Item 12 (790 Lombard Street): Approved 5-0 – conditional use authorization for Fiddle Fig Cafe; legacy business concerns noted but no further action taken. - Item 13 (4000 21st Street): Continued 5-0 to allow project sponsor to revise plans to include an ADU (or JDU) within one month. - Item 14a (369 Valley Street): Discretionary review not taken; project approved 5-0 as proposed. - Item 14b (369 Valley Street): Variance granted by Zoning Administrator with standard conditions.

CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION 25% · PROCEDURAL 16% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 14% · LEGACY BUSINESS 13%
795
FEB 22, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety Committee Meeting - February 22, 2024

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 22, 2024, at 6:15 PM. Vice Chair Joel Engardio presided, with Supervisor Dorsey present. Chair Stephanie was excused by motion. The sole agenda item was a hearing on the transfer of a Type 21 off-sale liquor license to Trader Joe’s Company for its new store at 555 Fulton Street, Suite C. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval to the full Board of Supervisors. Discussion Items - Liquor License Transfer – 555 Fulton Street (Trader Joe’s) - SFPD ABC Liaison Officer Samelson reported zero letters of protest or support. The premises are in a low-crime area (plot 551) but in a high-saturation census tract (162). Northern Station had no opposition, and the Alcoholic Beverage Control unit (ALU) recommended approval with a condition that the petitioner actively monitor the area to prevent loitering on adjacent property. - A representative of Trader Joe’s stated the store is scheduled to open in early May 2024, similar in format to other San Francisco Trader Joe’s. It will carry fresh produce, meats, fish, wellness products, and specialty items. Alcoholic beverages (beer, wine, spirits) will occupy less than 10% of display space. The applicant argued that a full liquor license would provide one-stop shopping convenience, especially given the impending closure of the Safeway on Webster and the scarcity of full-service grocery stores in the area. - No public comments were offered during the open comment period. Key Outcomes - Motion and Vote: Vice Chair Engardio moved to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that the license transfer would serve public convenience or necessity, and to send that resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation from the committee. The motion passed unanimously (2 ayes: Dorsey and Engardio; Chair Stephanie excused). - Next Step: The item is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on March 5, 2024.

LIQUOR LICENSE TRANSFER 75% · PROCEDURAL 25%
796
FEB 21, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
SF Budget & Finance Committee Hearing on Residential Treatment Beds - February 21, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on February 21, 2024, at 18:15 UTC to hear a status update on the city's Residential Treatment Bed Expansion Plan. Chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, the committee heard presentations from the Department of Public Health (DPH) and the Department of Disability and Aging Services (DAS) regarding the current inventory of behavioral health residential beds, progress on expansion goals, emerging needs, and challenges related to workforce, procurement, and data. The meeting concluded with a motion to continue the item to the call of the chair, which passed unanimously. Consent Calendar - No consent calendar was presented; the agenda contained a single hearing item. Public Comments & Testimony - Adrian Maldonado, Director of Harbor Light Center, described a dramatic increase in program utilization and staffing at his facility, crediting the 'treatment on demand' approach. He reported that Harbor Light's census grew from 30 to over 100 residents and that the program now has over 60 city-funded beds and additional beds funded by the Salvation Army. He emphasized the cost-effectiveness and success of such programs, urging the city to prioritize them. - Adam Francis, Senior Director of Advocacy and Policy for the San Francisco Marin Medical Society, highlighted the human cost of the bed shortage and the demoralizing effect on healthcare providers. He stressed that immediate workforce incentives could fill the 15-20% of beds currently unstaffed, and he encouraged creative approaches to recruitment and retention. - Andrea Ayello, Director of the Castro Community Benefit District, reported visible improvements in street conditions since late 2023 and credited the Health Street Operations Center (HSOC) for its outreach efforts. She noted that many individuals on the street have case managers and are known to the city, yet the services offered often do not match their needs, suggesting a need for more tailored options. Discussion Items - Opening Remarks and Context (Supervisor Mandelman): Supervisor Mandelman set the stage by referencing the 2020 behavioral health bed optimization analysis by Dr. Anton Nagusa Bland, which identified a gap of 50 locked subacute/skilled nursing beds. He also cited UCSF's 2023 study estimating that up to 80% of homeless individuals have mental illness. He voiced concerns about how progress is measured and noted that DPH's new analysis identifies a need for 55-95 locked subacute beds, indicating that the city may be running in place. - DPH Presentation (Dr. Hillary Kunins): Dr. Kunins presented DPH's current inventory of 2,551 residential beds, a nearly 20% increase over the baseline of 2,200. She reported that since 2020, DPH had opened nearly 400 new beds, with 44 more pending. She identified several ongoing challenges: - Workforce recruitment and retention, which at times reduces effective capacity by 15-20%. - The competitive market for 'as needed' beds, especially out-of-county facilities, which are shared with other counties. - The need for 50 additional mental health residential beds, 20-40 enhanced RCFE beds, and 20-30 SUD residential step-down beds. - DAS Presentation (Kelly Dearman): Director Dearman provided data on assisted living capacity. She noted 2,700 RCFE beds (mostly in large facilities) and 417 adult residential facility (ARF) beds. Since 2021, San Francisco lost 5% of small RCFE facilities but gained 16% in overall RCFE beds; ARFs lost 5% of facilities and beds. She also highlighted three DAS programs that subsidize assisted living for low-income seniors, with the average monthly subsidy at $4,400. - Committee Questions and Deliberation: Supervisors raised concerns about the accuracy of bed counts, the impact of staffing shortages, the lack of data on how many San Franciscans are actually using 'as needed' beds, and the adequacy of the city's approach to board-and-care homes (ARFs). Supervisors Melgar and Ronan called for a more strategic, infrastructure-based approach, including using Prop 1 funding and the Laguna Honda campus for new facilities. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair, allowing for follow-up on data reconciliation, tracking of actual bed usage by San Franciscans, and coordination on ARF needs. - DPH committed to providing follow-up information on: - The breakdown of out-of-county beds. - The methodology behind the bed need estimates. - Progress on the competitive solicitation waiver for procurement. - The impact of SB 43 and Prop 1 on bed needs and funding. - The committee will continue to work with DPH and DAS to develop a strategic plan for behavioral health residential capacity, including potential capital investments.

MENTAL HEALTH 29% · BEHAVIORAL HEALTH 27% · PUBLIC HEALTH 15% · SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 8%
797
FEB 21, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
San Francisco Police Commission Meeting - February 21, 2024: Pretext Stops Policy, ALPR Cameras, and DPA Audit Discussed

This meeting of the San Francisco Police Commission on February 21, 2024, featured discussions and actions on several key items, including a presentation on Automated License Plate Recognition (ALPR) cameras, a Department of Police Accountability (DPA) audit of SFPD's misconduct handling, and a vote on Department General Order (DGO) 9.07 restricting pretext stops. The commission also heard public comments, received the Chief's report, and the DPA Director's report, and held a closed session. Public Comments & Testimony - Charlotte (lifelong resident) criticized the commission for years of meddling that she said has undermined police enforcement, attributing the city's crime problems to commission policies and referencing Proposition E on the ballot. - Ashley Westinger and others spoke in support of the patrol special program, urging the commission to allow Alan Bard (a retiring patrol special) to stay and train replacements. Speakers expressed frustration that no community members who helped set up the program were included in the committee. - Frank Nodo (Stop Crime Action) urged the commission to take no action on topics that might be impacted by Proposition E, noting that traffic stops declined 80% from 102,000 in 2019 to about 17,000 in 2023. He said his group supports banning bias stops but opposes ending enforcement of traffic laws. - Michael Betrellis showed a video of a burglary in the Castro, questioning why the first officer did not shoot at the tires and why Supervisor Mandelman withheld the tape for four months. He called for accountability. - Jake Honor B. Ortega warned that more restrictions on SFPD would lead to Proposition E passing, and called on President Elias to resign due to an alleged conflict of interest (her husband's law firm sues SFPD). - Ms. Brown (mother of murder victim Arbor Cassa) repeatedly pleaded for a presentation on unsolved homicides and monetary rewards, stating she has been waiting for promised action. - Angela Chan (former police commissioner) urged adoption of DGO 9.07, calling delays by the POA shameful and noting that black community members continue to be harmed by pretext stops. - Carolyn Gusin (coalition to end biased stops) supported the policy, citing data that pretext stops don't increase public safety and cause generational harm. - Isabella Hutchison echoed support, noting the robust public process and that the commission has held over a dozen meetings. - Zach Dillon (Public Defender's Office) cited Chief Harold Medlock's testimony that deprioritizing pretextual stops in Fayetteville, NC, reduced racial disparities without harming traffic safety. - Several speakers opposed DGO 9.07, arguing it violates state and federal law, that the commission lacks authority to override state law, and that such stops yield guns and drugs. They pointed to the failure of SB50 in Sacramento and the decline in traffic stops. - One speaker noted that LA's policy of requiring officers to explain stops on camera has reduced bias, and urged the commission to consider that approach instead. Discussion Items 1. Chief's Report Chief Scott reported crime statistics: shooting victims down 14% year-to-date, homicides down from 7 to 3, firearm recoveries at 115, with zero ghost gun recoveries. He detailed incidents including non-fatal shootings, a carjacking, elder abuse, and a pursuit from South San Francisco. The chief also addressed questions about autonomous vehicles: SFPD does not routinely receive video from autonomous vehicle companies, and the city lacks jurisdiction to restrict them on narrow one-way roads. He noted a pro-Palestine ceasefire demonstration with an estimated 500 participants that did not result in injuries or arrests. 2. DPA Director's Report Executive Director Henderson reported 89 cases opened, 96 closed, 305 pending. 12 cases sustained, 1 mediated. 32 cases past 270-day period (22 tolled). 10 cases awaiting disposition from commission, 96 from chief's office. Allegations: 26% for conduct unbecoming an officer. Highest allegations from Southern and Mission stations. 3. Firearm Discharge Review Board (4th Quarter 2023) Lieutenant Springer presented two cases: one from 2017 where an officer-in-training fired one shot through a patrol car window, killing a suspect who ran toward the vehicle. The board found proper conduct except for seat belt violation. The second case involved an off-duty officer's accidental discharge of a firearm at home (no injuries). The board found improper conduct for unsafe firearm handling. No in-custody deaths were presented. 4. Presentation on ALPR Cameras (Item 6) Assistant Chief Lazar presented a plan to fund 400 ALPR cameras via a $15.3 million BSCC grant for organized retail theft prevention. Installation costs: $335,000; operating costs: $1.2 million/year for 3 years (total $3.935 million). Cameras will be placed at high-traffic intersections, covering about 1.5% of the city's 6,399 intersections. Usage will comply with Section 19B of the Administrative Code: only for stolen vehicles, AMBER Alerts, criminal investigations, and emergencies. No facial recognition, no traffic enforcement, no data sharing for immigration. Data retained for 1 year (5 years if evidence). Training anticipated within 60-90 days. The department hopes to launch in first half of 2024. 5. DPA Audit of SFPD's Handling of Officer Misconduct (Item 7) Audit Director Flaherty presented the final audit with 31 recommendations. Key findings: SFPD does not track key dates to ensure investigations are completed within the one-year statute of limitations; lacks consistent approach for bias-related misconduct; fails to comply with public reporting requirements (e.g., Administrative Code Chapter 96); and station captains did not follow policy to identify trends and develop prevention plans. SFPD concurred or partially concurred with 26 recommendations, did not concur with recommendations on setting time frames for chief's hearings and clarifying implicit bias handling. Commissioner Elias emphasized the need for follow-up and reporting. Commissioner Benedicto noted that permissive access for DPA to SFPD's benchmark system could address many data issues. 6. DGO 9.07 "Restricting the Use of Pretext Stops" (Item 8) Vice President Carter Oberstone moved to adopt the DGO, noting it deprioritizes nine vehicle code infractions that have no public safety benefit (e.g., license plate and registration tag stops, where arrests occur in less than 1% of cases). He stated the policy was developed through extensive public input including over a dozen town halls, a working group, and hundreds of comments. Commissioner Benedicto seconded, adding that the policy is about prioritization, not banning enforcement, and that 25% of officers' time is spent on low-value stops. Commissioner Walker expressed concerns about state preemption, the POA's threat of litigation, and whether the policy would reduce racial disparities (citing LA's camera-based approach). Commissioner Byrne requested going into closed session for legal advice. Commissioner Yee questioned why the vote was scheduled before closed session. After public comment, the commission voted 4-3 to adopt DGO 9.07 (yes: Carter Oberstone, Benedicto, Yanyez, Elias; no: Walker, Byrne, Yee). The motion included a 90-day training period (with possible 30-day extension). Key Outcomes - Adopted DGO 9.07 (4-3 vote) restricting pretext stops, with a 90-day training period (up to 120 days total). - Discussed and heard presentations on ALPR cameras and DPA audit; no votes taken on these items. - Voted to hold closed session (Item 11) and later voted not to disclose any discussion from closed session. - Commissioner Walker requested a future presentation on LA's traffic stop recording policy. - Commissioner Benedicto volunteered to serve as liaison for follow-up on DPA audit recommendations. - Commissioner Elias noted that a presentation on patrol specials is expected in March 2024. - Commissioner Yanyez committed to pushing for greater data sharing between DPA and SFPD via the benchmark system. - Update on unsolved homicides: DPA indicated a presentation on monetary rewards is anticipated in April 2024, but Ms. Brown raised concerns about exclusions for gang members and wanted the policy revised.

POLICE OVERSIGHT 38% · PROCEDURAL 25% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE 11%
798
FEB 15, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Regular Hearing - February 15, 2024

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, February 15, 2024, at approximately 2:15 PM. All five commissioners present (President Diamond, Vice President Moore, Commissioners Braun, Imperial, and Koppel; Commissioner Ruiz absent) considered continuances, a consent calendar, commission and department matters, general public comment, one regular calendar item (30 Otis Street shadow findings and conditional use), and one discretionary review (4820 Anza Street). Continuance Items - Item 1 – Citywide expansion of allowable commercial, restaurant, and retail uses (BF 231221) was continued to February 22, 2024, by a unanimous 5‑0 vote. - Item 10 – 320 Frederick Street discretionary review was continued to March 14, 2024, by the same unanimous vote. Consent Calendar - Item 3 – 2310 Fillmore Street conditional use authorization: Commissioner President Diamond recused herself due to owning Citibank bonds (formula retail). The remaining four commissioners (Braun, Imperial, Koppel, Moore) voted 4‑0 to approve. - Items 2a/b – 30 Otis Street were pulled from the consent calendar by Commissioner Imperial and heard under the regular calendar (see below). Commission Matters - Land Acknowledgement: The Commission acknowledged the unceded ancestral homeland of the Ramaytush Ohlone. - Draft Minutes from February 1, 2024: Adopted unanimously (5‑0). - Commission Comments/Questions: No comments. Department Matters - Director’s Announcements: None. - Review of Past Events at Board of Supervisors, Board of Appeals, and Historic Preservation Commission: Staff (Audrey Moroni) reported on several land use committee actions from the past week, including: - Landmarking of the Balboa Theatre (unanimous positive recommendation). - Sacred Heart Parish Complex landmarking continued to February 29 after Supervisor Peskin requested amendments. - Family Housing Opportunity SUD amendment continued to February 26 due to concerns about ownership requirements. - Supervisor Peskin’s state‑mandated ADU controls with three amendments adopted. - Form‑based density ordinance continued to March 4. - Numeric density controls in downtown/eastern waterfront C‑2 districts amended and forwarded to full board (2‑1). - Code corrections ordinance passed final read; downtown rail extension fee waiver passed first read. General Public Comment - Tom Badulovich (Liverpool City) urged the Commission to integrate land‑use and transportation planning, arguing that the city lacks a comprehensive land‑use plan and that planning for office locations should be prioritized near high‑quality transit. - Georgia Shutish discussed ongoing concerns about Section 317 demolition calculations not being updated, highlighting potential impacts on affordable housing and the misuse of alteration permits to bypass discretionary review. - A member of the public requested the Commission consider changing the meeting start time from noon to a later hour to improve remote accessibility. Regular Calendar – Items 2a/b: 30 Otis Street (Dish Wireless Facility) - Project: Installation of a new Dish wireless macro‑telecommunications facility on the rooftop of an existing 26‑story mixed‑use building (416 dwelling units, retail, arts, theater). The facility includes three antennas within two radomes (max height 42 inches) and ancillary equipment behind an 8‑foot enclosure. - Shadow Impact: The proposal would increase the shadow load on the proposed 11th and Natoma Park (under Recreation & Parks jurisdiction) by 0.003% above current levels. The shadow occurs only after 4:30 PM in winter. The Rec & Park Commission found no significant adverse impact. - Discussion: Commissioner Imperial raised concerns about future park shading. Staff noted the design had already been reduced from an original 0.01% shadow increase to 0.003%. The project sponsor confirmed alternate sites were explored but declined. - Vote: The Commission unanimously (5‑0) adopted the shadow findings and approved the conditional use authorization with conditions. Discretionary Review Calendar – Item 9: 4820 Anza Street (Two‑Story Vertical Addition) - Project: Construction of a two‑story vertical addition to an existing two‑story single‑family home (built 1924). The existing structure would triple in size to approximately 4,500 square feet. - DR Requester: Deborah Hawley, on behalf of adjacent neighbors Rita and Eugene Katz (587 39th Avenue), requested the fourth story be removed. Staff initially recommended removal of the fourth story but later accepted revisions that set back the third and fourth stories 16 feet from the rear wall and reduced the fourth‑story ceiling height. - Staff Recommendation: Take discretionary review and approve with conditions requiring the rear roof deck to be set back 5 feet from the east property line and removal of the solid parapet above the deck. - Public Comment: Two speakers opposed the project, citing scale, massing, and shadow impacts; one speaker in support praised the project sponsor’s community involvement. A letter from the immediate neighbor (4826 Anza) was read in support. - Vote: The Commission unanimously (5‑0) voted to take discretionary review and approve with staff’s modifications. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Items 1 and 10 continued (5‑0). - Consent Calendar: Item 3 approved (4‑0, Diamond recused). - Commission Matters: Land acknowledgement delivered; minutes of February 1, 2024 adopted (5‑0). - 30 Otis Street: Shadow findings adopted and conditional use authorized (5‑0). - 4820 Anza Street: Discretionary review taken and approved with conditions (5‑0).

LAND USE 21% · DISCRETIONARY REVIEW 21% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · HISTORIC PRESERVATION 8%
799
FEB 15, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Regular Meeting - February 15, 2024

The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 15, 2024, at 6:15 PM UTC, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, with Vice Chair Catherine Stefani and Member Chan excused. The committee considered four regular agenda items, including a banner fee waiver, a tourism improvement district agreement, an audit of SF SAFE contracts with the Police Department, and a resolution apologizing to African Americans. All items were advanced to the full Board of Supervisors. Consent Calendar - Items 5–12 (Settlements): The committee voted unanimously (2-0, with Member Chan excused) to recommend to the full Board of Supervisors four ordinances and four resolutions authorizing settlements of lawsuits and unlitigated claims ranging from approximately $35,000 to $9 million. The committee did not convene closed session, as Chair Preston indicated prior briefing by the City Attorney’s office was sufficient. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (SF SAFE Audit): Joanna Hernandez of the Latino Task Force expressed heartbreak over lost jobs and unpaid subcontractors, stating the organization trusted SF SAFE under the Police Department and requested accountability. Gloria Barry urged independent investigation of police contracts and criticized nonprofits that fail to deliver community benefits. No other public speakers were present. - Item 4 (Apology to African Americans): Reverend Amos Brown (President, NAACP San Francisco) said an apology is insufficient; he demanded concrete actions such as halting development in the Fillmore and allocating 40% of housing to Black residents. Gloria Barry noted disappointment that not all supervisors initially co-sponsored the resolution and challenged each to take on five action items. Salahakia Chandler criticized Black leaders for accepting paychecks without delivering reparations, threatening a revolt if no resolution in 90 days. Brian Cox (spoke on lunch break) urged policies to stop harm to Black communities and fund entities like the Public Defender’s office. Letitia Irving (former Reparations Advisory Committee member) said an apology is empty without bold actions and called for apologies from every city department. Lori Yamauchi (Japantown Task Force member) supported the resolution, citing precedents from Boston and the U.S. Civil Liberties Act. Yasmin Abdusami Oakley insisted on cash payments to descendants of enslaved Americans and distinguishing reparations from DEI. David Marquez Duncan urged direction and accountability within the Black community. Nick G. (Chinese for Affirmative Action) and Tronyan Lee expressed support and commitment to multiracial solidarity. Brother Carriott demanded a financial apology, not just verbal. Brittany Chikwata honored ancestors and thanked the committee. No other public speakers. Discussion Items - Item 1 (Banner Fee Waiver): Ordinance amending Public Works Code to waive banner and inspection fees for nonprofit organizations in specified neighborhood commercial/transit districts in District 5 through December 31, 2026. Nicholas Huff (Bureau of Street Use and Mapping, DPW) reported that between 2021–2023, 185 permits were issued; about seven per year would qualify for the waiver, with a budget impact of approximately $9,000. Chair Preston introduced technical amendments. The committee voted unanimously to adopt amendments and recommend the item to the full board. - Item 2 (Tourism Improvement District Agreement): Resolution approving a management agreement with the San Francisco Tourism Improvement District Management Corporation (SFTIDMC) for administration through December 31, 2038. Jackie Hazelwood (CBD Program Director, OEWD) explained the contract authorizes the Controller to disperse assessment funds. President Peskin highlighted Section 3.14 prohibiting use of assessment revenue for lobbying, and OEWD confirmed this language will be included in all future CBD contracts. The committee voted unanimously to recommend to the full board. - Item 3 (SF SAFE Audit Hearing): Hearing on the Controller’s assessment of invoices under a grant agreement between SFPD and SF SAFE (July 2018 – March 2023, not-to-exceed $5.3 million). Mark De La Rosa (Director of Audits, Controller’s Office) and Selina Wong presented findings: SFPD did not regularly request or review supporting documentation, resulting in $3.8 million (72%) of grant funds without adequate backup; of a sample of $910,000 from July 2022 – March 2023, $79,000 (9%) were ineligible or excessive (including $36,000 in luxury gift boxes, $21,000 in parking fees, $12,000 in excessive lodging/limousine services, $1,300 in personal expenses). SFPD concurred with the recommendation to review all invoices and recover improperly paid amounts. SFPD Director of Policy Ziana Arroche and former CFO Patrick Leong described chronic understaffing in the fiscal unit (fully staffed only 3.5 months in 4.5 years), prior attempts at monitoring that were delayed by COVID and nonprofit resistance, and an ongoing criminal investigation by the District Attorney’s office. SFPD indicated it will terminate the contract if the SF SAFE board does not respond to information requests. OEWD (Sarah Dennis Phillips) reported $3 million in total grants to SF SAFE (one closed commercial corridor safety grant, one active mission ambassador services grant) and stated they have not yet terminated but are working with the City Attorney to protect payment to subgrantees. The committee continued the item to the call of the chair (unanimous vote), with Chair Preston noting a follow-up hearing expected in late March. - Item 4 (Apology to African Americans): Resolution apologizing for systematic discrimination and committing to redress. Supervisor Walton, Director Cheryl Davis (Human Rights Commission), and AARAC Chair Eric McDonnell and Vice Chair Tanisha Hollins presented. McDonnell noted fewer than 20 local/state governments have offered such apologies; he stressed that apology must be followed by monetary repair and policy reform. Davis highlighted the ongoing trauma and the need for non-repetition. Supervisor Walton offered an amendment adding a clause urging all city departments to issue their own apologies. The committee adopted the amendment and voted unanimously to recommend to the full board. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimously adopted amendments and recommended to full board (2-0, Chan excused). - Item 2: Unanimously recommended to full board (2-0, Chan excused). - Item 3: Unanimously continued to the call of the chair (2-0, Chan excused) for a future hearing in late March. - Item 4: Unanimously adopted amendment and recommended to full board (3-0, including Walton). - Items 5–12: Unanimously recommended to full board without closed session (2-0, Chan excused). The committee adjourned at the conclusion of the meeting.

AUDIT AND COMPLIANCE 36% · RACIAL AND SOCIAL EQUITY 34% · PROCEDURAL 5% · PROCUREMENT 5%
800
FEB 14, 2024 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
San Francisco Budget and Finance Committee Meeting - February 14, 2024

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, February 14, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and including Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, considered six items: appropriations for APEC relief, a SoMa community stabilization grant, a loan amendment for affordable housing at 78 Haight Street, a lease amendment for the YMCA at Crane Cove Park, a tax-defaulted property auction, and an extension of contracting waivers for homeless services. Public comment was heard on several items. The committee voted to forward most items to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations, with one item sent without recommendation. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (APEC relief): Scott Rowitz (Executive Director, Yerba Buena Community Benefit District) thanked the committee and praised OEWD and the Office of Small Business for their outreach. Desi (Cultivate Labs) requested that the administrator of the relief fund charge minimal administrative fees (noting 10–20% is typical) to maximize direct support to businesses. - Item 2 & 3 (SoMa fund and 78 Haight loan): Chris Cummings (TNDC) spoke in support of the additional funding for 78 Haight, noting the project's delay and the need for permanent repairs to neighboring Mount Trinity Baptist Church. He mentioned TNDC is seeking up to $2 million from the Weinberg Foundation for capital costs. - Item 4 (YMCA lease): No public comment. - Item 5 (Tax auction): No public comment. - Item 6 (Homeless services waivers): One speaker urged the committee to be bold and not fear addressing homelessness. Discussion Items - Item 1: De-Appropriation and Appropriation for APEC 2023 Project ($3,500,000) – The ordinance reappropriates $3.5 million: $500,000 to SFMTA for free parking, ambassador services, and transit fares for Lunar New Year parade, and $3 million to OEWD for a relief fund for SoMa businesses and a small business transit impact relief fund. Supervisor Dorsey thanked the committee and highlighted improved interdepartmental relationships from APEC outreach. Supervisor Guardion noted that Taraval merchants reported up to 70% sales loss due to Muni track replacement and requested $1 million of the leftover APEC funds for Taraval relief. Chair Chan emphasized the need for timely distribution and future fund models. The committee voted unanimously to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Items 2 & 3: SoMa Community Stabilization Fund ($200,000) and Loan Amendment for 78 Haight Street ($35,306,233) – Item 2 authorizes a $200,000 grant from the 5M Community Benefits Agreement to the Bill Sorro Housing Program (Bishop) for anti-displacement programs in SoMa. Item 3 increases the city's loan to TNDC by $8.5 million (total not to exceed $35.3 million) for a 63-unit affordable housing development at 78 Haight Street, including 32 units for transitional-age youth experiencing homelessness. Supervisor Melgar expressed concerns about the removal of a planned childcare space due to state licensing requirements (e.g., outdoor space, proximity to parks). MOHCD and TNDC explained that Patricia's Green and other nearby parks did not meet licensing criteria, and roof redesign was cost-prohibitive. Supervisor Melgar asked about exploring a family childcare center on site. The BLA noted that the developer is investing at-risk developer fee as equity, which is an appropriate risk-sharing. The committee voted unanimously to forward both resolutions to the full board. - Item 4: Amended Lease with YMCA for Building 49 at Crane Cove Park – The port requested approval of an amended lease that reduces seismic improvements (replacing steel reinforcement with plywood and bolts, saving the YMCA about $500,000 in rent credits but costing the city an estimated $1.4 million in foregone improvements), pushes rent commencement to October 1, 2024, and requires public restrooms open by July 1, 2024. The BLA raised concerns about the port's vetting process, noting the lease was approved just months earlier. Supervisor Melgar supported the YMCA's mission, recalling the building's history of serving low-income youth through kayaking. A clerical amendment was added to clarify lease terms. The committee voted unanimously to forward the amended resolution to the full board. - Item 5: Public Auction of Tax-Defaulted Properties – The resolution authorizes the sale of 159 parcels delinquent for at least five years (some up to nine years). The Treasurer's office provided outreach including in-person visits and social services referrals. Chair Chan noted Supervisor Ronan's request to remove 3548-3550 20th Street (owned by Murphy Rauf) for one more year due to concrete payment efforts. The committee voted unanimously to remove that property and forward the amended list to the full board. - Item 6: Extending Sunset of Contracting Waivers for Homeless Services – The ordinance extends the sunset from May 5, 2024 to May 5, 2029, allowing the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) and Public Works to bypass competitive bidding for homeless services contracts. Chair Chan proposed a two-year phase-in for procurement compliance, but she remained concerned about accountability, citing recent issues with the 7-Eleven Post Street and 935 Kearny projects. She moved to send the item to the full board without recommendation. Supervisor Melgar, after receiving additional information, supported the legislation as is. Vice Chair Mandelman added himself as a co-sponsor. The committee voted 3-0 to send the ordinance without recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (3-0) to forward to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendation. - Items 2 & 3: Approved (3-0) to forward both resolutions to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 4: Approved (3-0) to amend the resolution with clerical edits and forward to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 5: Approved (3-0) to remove 3548-3550 20th Street from the parcel list and forward the amended list to the full board with positive recommendation. - Item 6: Approved (3-0) to forward the ordinance to the full board without recommendation. The meeting adjourned at approximately 7:00 PM. Items acted upon are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of February 27, 2024.

PROCEDURAL 28% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 15% · PUBLIC WORKS 11%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com