The San Francisco Police Commission met on February 14, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included recognition of a Night Investigations Unit sergeant, discussion of crime trends and police policies, updates on Department General Orders (DGOs), and votes to adopt three DGOs. Consent Calendar - Received and filed: $5,000 donation to SFPD's Wilderness Program from the San Francisco Police Officers Association, Safe Streets for All 2023 Fourth Quarter report, Family Code 6228 Fourth Quarter 2023 report, and DGO 5.15 annual report regarding enforcement of immigration laws. Public Comments & Testimony - Multiple speakers opposed the commission's proposed policy to limit pretextual traffic stops, arguing it exceeds the commission's authority and conflicts with California state law (which had declined similar legislation). One speaker cited a mother who lost her son, suggesting such stops could prevent tragedies. - A mother whose son was murdered in 2006 pleaded for the commission to agendize methods to pay tipsters for information, noting that current rules bar criminals from receiving rewards despite their potential to solve cases. - Another speaker urged the commission to find ways to pay tipsters regardless of criminal history. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition: Sergeant Anthony Serke (Night Investigations Unit) was recognized for his investigative work, including a shooting case where he reviewed over 300 video items and coordinated an operation leading to an arrest. Commissioners praised his dedication and family support. - Chief's Report: Chief Scott reported a 34% decrease in overall part-one crime (13% reduction in violent crime, 36% in property crime), 40% fewer homicides (3 this year vs. 5 last year), and 93 gun recoveries with no ghost guns year-to-date. He detailed two non-fatal shootings, a federal indictment for a bicycle theft ring, two blessing scams targeting elderly Asian victims, an arson of a Waymo vehicle on February 10, and a fatal traffic collision. Vice President Carter Oberstone requested information on new automatic license plate readers (flock cameras); the commission agreed to agendize the topic for the next meeting. Commissioner Yee raised concerns about Waymo autonomous vehicles blocking traffic and creating safety hazards. - DPA Director's Report: Executive Director Paul Henderson reported 82 cases opened year-to-date (up from 79 last year), 86 closed, 308 pending, 33 investigations beyond nine months. DPA was selected to present at a national auditors conference. A survey on stop data audit objectives was distributed to commissioners. - Sparks Report (Q4 2023): Deputy Chief Peter Walsh and DPA Policy Director Janelle Kaywood presented updates on DGO development. Key discussions included DGO 7.01 (juveniles) with 55 public comments, and DGO 6.10 (missing persons), which has not been updated since 1999. Commissioners directed that DGO 6.10 be expedited rather than restarted from scratch. DPA reiterated its request for direct access to SFPD's evidence.com for body camera footage; technical and contractual issues remain. - Update on 14 DGOs: Deputy Chief Walsh provided status on 14 DGOs under revision. Commissioner Benedicto expressed frustration with slow progress and new interpretations of DGO 3.01 that lack deadlines, particularly DGO 2.07 (public review ended October 2023, not yet in concurrence). Discussion on DGO 6.14 (gravely disabled definition) and the need for physician-informed training. - Adoption of DGO 8.04 (Critical Incident Response Team): Approved unanimously (7-0) after a minor typo correction. - Adoption of DGO 3.12 (Department Training Plan): Approved unanimously (7-0) subject to labor negotiations. - Adoption of DGO 6.20 (Member-Involved Domestic Violence): Approved unanimously (7-0) after an amendment changing "should" to "shall" in Section K to mandate consideration of adjustments for member victims of domestic violence. Key Outcomes - DGO 8.04 Adopted (7-0). - DGO 3.12 Adopted (7-0) subject to labor negotiations. - DGO 6.20 Adopted (7-0) as amended. - Commission directed to agendize a presentation on flock cameras for the next meeting. - Commission directed to expedite the missing persons DGO (6.10) without restarting the process. - Closed session held on Item 14; commission voted 7-0 not to disclose any discussion except factual updates in the minutes.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, February 13, 2024, with all 11 members present. The meeting covered consent items, a mayoral appearance, multiple committee recommendations, special commendations, public hearings, and general public comment. Key actions included final passage of an ordinance restricting the Gashouse Cove project, approval of a ground lease for a 151-unit affordable senior housing project, and adoption of several resolutions. Consent Calendar - Items 1 and 2 were routine and approved unanimously without objection. - Item 3 (ordinance prohibiting recreation and park and planning departments from implementing a project to extend the West Harbor Marina by more than 150 feet) was passed on a roll call vote of 10 ayes (Supervisor Stephanie excused). - Items 4 (grant acceptance for immigrant integration, $165,978), 5 (fee waiver for Lunar New Year sidewalk sales), 6 (lease at 755-759 South Van Ness Avenue, $644,931 annual rent), 7 (multifamily housing revenue notes not to exceed $67,680,000 for Transbay Block 2 West), 8 (pest management grant agreement, $321,670), and 9 (revenue bonds for St. Ignatius College Preparatory, not to exceed $150,000,000) were all approved without objection. - Items 10 through 16 (annual reports for various community benefit and improvement districts) were adopted without objection. - Item 17 (MOU with U.S. Capitol Police for supplemental law enforcement services, retroactive 2021-2023) was adopted without objection. - Item 18 (planning code amendment to waive fees for downtown rail extension corridor) passed on first reading with 11 ayes. - Item 19 (commemorative street name "Veterans Alley" on Shannon Street) adopted unanimously (11 ayes). - Item 20 (appointments to Small Business Commission) approved without objection. - Item 23 (ordinance to waive competitive procurement for behavioral health residential care and treatment services) passed on first reading without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - During general public comment, multiple speakers urged the board to support the commemorative street naming for Sean Monterrosa (proposed by Supervisor Ronen). Speakers included Michelle Monterrosa (sister), other community members, and representatives from the Latinx Democratic Club. They described Sean Monterrosa as a community leader and activist who was killed by Vallejo police in 2020, emphasizing his legacy and the need for justice. - One speaker raised concerns about cybersecurity and improper use of a city enterprise system, requesting immediate board attention. - Another comment criticized the District Attorney's office for alleged racist comments and urged accountability. - One speaker praised the commendations for Mayor Willie Brown and expressed optimism about the city's future. Discussion Items - Mayor's Appearance (2:00 p.m.): Mayor London Breed addressed the board for up to five minutes, presenting a one-year update on the downtown revitalization plan. She cited a 23% increase in downtown visitation (2022-2023), highlighted legislative accomplishments (office-to-housing conversions, fee reductions, tax incentives), and called for tax reform, noting that pre-pandemic demand for office space no longer exists. Supervisor Mandelman expressed interest in working with the mayor on a tax reform package. - Committee Report on Item 23: Supervisor Chan explained her support for the procurement waiver for public health, noting it is narrowly tailored for services outside San Francisco, but flagged that a separate, broader waiver for homelessness services would be problematic. - Committee of the Whole (3:00 p.m.): The board convened as a committee of the whole to consider ground leases for Transbay Block 2 West, a 9-story, 151-unit affordable senior housing project at 200 Folsom Street. A presentation by Jasmine Quo (OCII) outlined the project's financing ($125 million total, including $60 million in federal tax credit equity and a $65 million OCII gap loan), and stated that the ground leases at $15,001/year (residential) and $1/year (commercial) for 75 years are below fair market value but necessary to ensure affordability. The hearing was held and filed; the accompanying resolution was adopted 10-0-1 (Supervisor Safai absent). - New Business Introductions: Several supervisors introduced legislation and resolutions: - Supervisor Safai introduced a resolution supporting AB 2359 to double the number of Type 87 liquor licenses in outer neighborhoods. - Supervisor Stephanie introduced a resolution calling for regular hearings on police recruitment/retention and requested a budget analyst report on anti-human trafficking expenditures. - Supervisor Chan introduced a resolution honoring San Francisco Ballet principal dancer Yuan Yuan Tan upon her retirement. - Supervisor Ronen introduced a resolution for a commemorative street naming "Sean Monterrosa Boulevard" at Park Street and Holly Park Circle, and legislation to extend the "First Year Free" small business fee waiver program through June 30, 2025. Key Outcomes - Final Passage of Ordinance on Gashouse Cove (Item 3): The ordinance prohibiting any extension of the West Harbor Marina beyond 150 feet was finally passed (10-0-1). - Approval of Transbay Block 2 West Ground Leases (Item 22): Resolution 240059 was adopted (10-0-1) authorizing execution of residential and commercial ground leases for the 151-unit affordable senior housing project, with construction expected to begin early March 2024. - Adoption of Consent and Regular Agenda Items: All consent items and committee reports were approved as described. - Special Commendations: The board recognized Willie L. Brown Jr. (inducted into California Hall of Fame 2024), Dee (owner of Hey Neighbor Cafe in Portola), and Danielle Hillman (ballerina, first Black Clara in San Francisco Ballet's Nutcracker). - Adoption Without Committee Reference (Items 26-29): Resolutions on Teen Dating Violence Awareness Month, condemning anti-abortion harassment, and two appointments to the Commission on the Aging Advisory Council were adopted unanimously (11 ayes) after co-sponsorship additions. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Reynaldo Timosa Novicio Jr.
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a regular meeting on February 13, 2024, at 9:45 AM. The meeting included approval of prior minutes, general public comment, a consent calendar, a major MOU with the San Francisco Unified School District, and adoption of the biennial operating budget, two-year capital budget, 10-year capital plan, and 10-year financial plan. The commission also entered closed session to discuss a settlement. All items were approved unanimously. Consent Calendar - Approved minutes of five prior meetings (January 22, 23, 26, 29, and February 2, 2024) unanimously (4-0). - Approved Consent Calendar items 6a–6d, including contract awards for engineering services for the Emergency Firefighting Water System, Sunol Valley Chemical Facility Improvements, San Francisco Zoo Recycled Water Project, and Channel Pump Station Bar Screen Replacement. Discussion on item 6a noted that only one bid was received after revising subconsultant requirements, insurance, and billing rates to attract more bidders. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment (Item 4): - Mr. DeCosta urged a hearing on replacing aging water and sewer pipes on the west side and ensuring adequate hydrant pressure to prevent fire disasters. - A speaker (Mr. Rosecrans) corrected the record regarding an MOA with the National Park Service, stating that public review was denied despite requests. - Dave Warner requested reinstatement of remote public comment (citing other commissions that allow it) and thanked SFPUC staff for storm response. - Denise Lewis (Center for Biological Diversity) urged the commission to withdraw lawsuits against the State Water Board, citing the Bay Delta ecosystem collapse and the PUC's own environmental stewardship policy. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust) highlighted discrepancies between water demand projections used for the Urban Water Management Plan and those used for the budget, and requested the long-overdue Alternative Water Supply Plan. - Liz Jackson Simpson (Success Centers) spoke in support of the SIP program, which provides workforce development and support services, noting that program dollars help with tools, union dues, and prescription goggles. - Mary Butterwick urged the commission to reduce the design drought from 8.5 to 7.5 years, apply realistic demand projections, and drop the lawsuit against the state's Bay Delta Plan. - Public Comment on Item 7 (SFUSD MOU): - Denise Lewis (California Native Plant Society) urged incorporating native plant habitats and San Francisco genetics in green infrastructure projects. - Katie Poyle (SFUSD Executive Director of Facility Services) and Kate Levitt (SFUSD Bond Program Communications Director) endorsed the MOU, highlighting its potential for student learning and play. - Public Comment on Items 8–11 (Budget, Capital Plan, Financial Plan): - Tom Francis (BOSCA) supported the budget but urged the commission to require an annual report on the Capital Planning Improvements Initiative with metrics; staff response rejected BOSCA's recommendations. - Peter Dreckmeyer questioned the 9 MGD increase in water demand projections from last year, noted that the average combined water/wastewater bill projection increased 43% over the previous plan, and urged the commission to reduce the design drought to avoid costly alternative water supply projects. - Dave Warner stressed the long-term risk of debt and the lack of flexibility once projects are committed; he noted that the 8.1% annual rate increase over 10 years is up from 6.6% last year. - Judy Irving (filmmaker and Bay swimmer) expressed concern about the 1.2 billion dollar nutrients project, urged reducing the design drought, and noted that conservation leads to higher rates (drought surcharge). - Barbara Folger (Presidio Heights resident) described the poor water quality from aging 100-year-old supply pipes and asked for coordinated replacement of water and sewer lines. - Mary Butterwick (retiree) expressed alarm that rates could triple in 15 years, urged prioritizing recycled water for nutrient reduction, and asked for analysis using a 7.5-year design drought. - Denise Lewis requested that the Emergency Firefighting Water Supply pipelines for the Richmond and Outer Sunset districts be included in the capital plan, asked for disclosure of lawsuit costs, and urged withdrawal of lawsuits. - Jacob Evans (Cycle California) warned that the 11.8 billion dollar plan relies on overestimated water demand and population growth; reducing the design drought by one year could save billions. Discussion Items - Item 7: Umbrella MOU with San Francisco Unified School District – The commission approved a 40-year framework agreement for green infrastructure projects on SFUSD properties. The MOU does not commit to specific projects but establishes a process for site agreements. Commissioners stressed the importance of data collection on performance and educational opportunities for students. - Items 8–11: Budget, Capital Plan, and Financial Plan – The commission held a public hearing on the biennial operating budget, two-year capital budget, 10-year capital plan, and 10-year financial plan. Staff presented an overview of the $1.8 billion per year capital budget (FY 2024-25 and FY 2025-26) and the $11.8 billion 10-year capital plan. Key themes included: - Climate change as a lens: $789 million for climate resiliency, $1.2 billion for Southeast Outfall Nutrient Reduction Project, $780 million for clean energy expansion. - Operating budget growth of 18% ($323 million) over two years, driven by capital costs (36%) and power purchase/distribution costs (26%). - 171 new permanent positions, including 87 conversions from temporary to permanent, to improve retention. - 10-year financial plan projects average residential water/sewer bill to reach $308/month in 10 years and $436/month in 20 years (8.1% annual increase). - Wastewater debt service is projected to rise from 24% to 58% of expenses over 10 years, with $13 billion in bonds issued. - Power enterprise: Hetch Hetchy rates remain 30% below PG&E; CleanPowerSF aims for 150 days cash on hand reserves. - Commissioners discussed risks of demand projections, affordability, and the need for cross-enterprise collaboration. Commissioner Ajami requested a sensitivity analysis on demand uncertainty and further exploration of decoupling. Key Outcomes - Approval of Minutes (numerous prior meetings) – Unanimous (4-0). - Consent Calendar (Items 6a–6d) – Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 7: MOU with SFUSD – Approved unanimously (4-0). - Item 8: Biennial Operating Budget – Adopted unanimously (4-0). - Item 9: Two-Year Capital Budget – Adopted unanimously (4-0). - Item 10: 10-Year Capital Plan – Adopted unanimously (4-0). - Item 11: 10-Year Financial Plan – Adopted unanimously (4-0). - Commissioner Initiated Items – Commissioner Ajami requested that the commission agenda for the next meeting include a discussion on reinstating remote public comment. This was noted. - Closed Session (Item 16) – Commission voted to assert attorney-client privilege (4-0) and subsequently voted not to disclose closed session discussions (4-0). The closed session concerned a proposed settlement of personal injury claims against the city (Ralph Bauer et al. v. City and County of San Francisco) for $400,000 each to plaintiffs Adian Galper and Corey Marriott, subject to Board of Supervisors approval.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 12, 2024, at 6:00 PM. Chair Hillary Ronin presided, joined by Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Supervisor Safai. The clerk, Victor Young, made announcements regarding public comment procedures. The committee considered several appointments and legislation. Discussion Items Item 4: Administrative Code Amendment – Procuring Behavioral Health and Public Health Residential Care and Treatment Services Greg Wagner from the Department of Public Health presented the ordinance, which would authorize the department to procure behavioral health and residential care beds without the usual competitive solicitation or local business enterprise requirements, citing urgent need and market undersupply. The ordinance includes a five-year sunset and reporting obligations. Supervisor Walton inquired about waiving LBE requirements; Wagner explained they are often waived anyway. Supervisor Safai raised concerns about the time to fill beds once procured, noting provider feedback about delays. Dr. Hillary Cunnins responded that the timeline varies and committed to follow up. The committee voted unanimously to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 1: Reappointment of Lydia Ely to the Redevelopment Successor Agency Oversight Board Lydia Ely, Deputy for Housing at MOHCD, presented her qualifications. Supervisor Walton asked about OCI's jurisdiction areas (Trans Bay, Mission Bay, Candlestick, Hunter's Point) and raised a concern about a former redevelopment site sold to Safeway. The committee voted to amend the motion by removing "rejecting" from the language and sent the appointment to the full board with a positive recommendation. The motion passed unanimously. Item 2: Appointments to the Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board Alex Lanceberg spoke on behalf of Edward Paralan, who was nominated. No questions or public comment. The committee voted unanimously to appoint Edward Paralan with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Appointments to the Entertainment Commission - Seat 1: Anthony Schlander, a native San Franciscan with over 20 years in live entertainment, presented his background. He emphasized bringing diverse communities together and supporting small venues. He was appointed unanimously. - Seat 2: Four applicants were considered: Asia Nicole Duncan, Benjamin McGrath, Chris Hastings (represented by Jillian), and Maria Davis. Each spoke about their experience. Public comment from Corey Hallman (Teamsters Local 856) supported Asia Nicole Duncan. After discussion, Chair Ronin recommended Maria Davis for seat 2, citing her experience as an owner and community involvement. Supervisor Safai concurred, noting the importance of recovery. The committee voted unanimously to appoint Maria Davis to seat 2. Public Comments & Testimony - Corey Hallman, representing Teamsters Local 856, spoke in support of Asia Nicole Duncan's candidacy for the Entertainment Commission, highlighting her activism and harm reduction work. Key Outcomes - Item 4 (Behavioral Health Procurement): Approved unanimously, sent to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 1 (Redevelopment Oversight Board Reappointment): Approved as amended (removing "rejecting"), sent to full board. - Item 2 (Housing Stability Fund Oversight Board): Edward Paralan appointed unanimously. - Item 3 (Entertainment Commission): Anthony Schlander (Seat 1) and Maria Davis (Seat 2) appointed unanimously. - All actions are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on February 27, 2024.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 12, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by President Aaron Peskin and Vice Chair Dean Preston. The committee considered six agenda items, including landmark designations, housing special use districts, accessory dwelling unit (ADU) regulations, and density controls. One item was passed to the full board, three were continued to future meetings, and one was amended and continued to the call of the chair. Public Comments & Testimony - Barry Threw (Executive Director, Gray Area Foundation for the Arts) spoke in support of landmarking the Grand Theater, noting the building generates 137 jobs, $7 million in local income, and $240,000 in local tax revenue, and that the organization distributes $1.8 million directly to artists annually. - Eileen Bogan urged the committee to table or oppose the Family and Senior Housing Opportunity SUD (Item 3), calling it premature and noting the Gus's Market project is not widely supported in District 4. - Chris Ward Klein deferred to the committee's judgment on Item 3. - Stan Hayes (President, Telegraph Hill Dwellers) strongly supported Item 6, citing developer proposals for 267-foot towers at 955 Sansome and 206-foot towers at 1088 Sansome in a district zoned for 65–84 feet. - Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) opposed Item 6, calling it a downzoning that would undermine housing affordability. - Jane Natoli (SF YIMBY) also opposed Item 6, arguing it would set a bad precedent for housing production. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Grand Theater Landmark Designation (231257): Anna Herrera (Supervisor Ronan's office) and Pilar Lavalle (Planning Department) presented. The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously recommended designation on November 15, 2023. The theater, built in 1940, is the last pre–World War II movie theater in San Francisco. Public comment was uniformly supportive. The committee voted 3-0 to send the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 – Sacred Heart Parish Complex Landmark Designation (231045): President Peskin requested a continuance to allow further stakeholder negotiations over draft language. The property owner and preservationists agreed. The committee voted 3-0 to continue to the February 26, 2024 meeting. - Item 3 – Family and Senior Housing Opportunity Special Use District (230808): Supervisor Engardio presented the amendments, which would allow larger buildings on corner lots in western neighborhoods. Debate centered on the ownership look-back period (five-year vs. one-year) and tenant protections. President Peskin argued for retaining the original five-year/one-year split to discourage speculation. Deputy City Attorney Pearson advised that amendments could not be finalized without further review. The committee voted 3-0 to continue to February 26, 2024. - Item 4 – State-Mandated ADU Controls (240110): President Peskin introduced amendments to limit the hybrid ADU program to two units (instead of three), add California Register eligibility, and create a 60-day approval timeline for the local program to incentivize rent-controlled ADUs. The committee voted 3-0 to adopt the amendments and then 3-0 to continue the item to the call of the chair while the Building Inspection Commission reviews the 60-day provision. - Item 5 – Density Calculation in RC, RTO, NC, and Certain NCDs (230734): President Peskin noted that form-based density decontrols could produce towers far exceeding height limits, citing a hypothetical 267-foot tower in a 65-foot zone. He proposed amendments to tie density to existing height limits and require affordability for density above base. Chair Melgar moved to continue to March 4, 2024, to allow time for amendment drafting. The committee voted 3-0 to continue. - Item 6 – Density Controls in Community Business Districts (231079): President Peskin presented amendments to reinstate numerical density limits in the Northeast Waterfront Historic District and Jackson Square Historic District, reversing unintended consequences of the downtown adaptive reuse legislation. The planning commission had recommended this approach on January 18, 2024. Chair Melgar expressed philosophical opposition, arguing it set a dangerous precedent for exempting non-equity areas from density bonuses. The committee voted 3-0 to adopt the amendments, then voted 2-1 (Chair Melgar dissenting) to send the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 passed 3-0 to the full board (February 27, 2024 agenda). - Item 2 continued 3-0 to February 26, 2024. - Item 3 continued 3-0 to February 26, 2024. - Item 4 amended and continued 3-0 to the call of the chair. - Item 5 continued 3-0 to March 4, 2024. - Item 6 amended and passed 2-1 (Melgar dissenting) to the full board.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular meeting on February 8, 2024, to consider several items including zoning amendments, a department budget, development projects, and discretionary reviews. The commission approved all items, often with modifications, and heard extensive public testimony on tobacco paraphernalia and parcel delivery regulations. Consent Calendar - Item 1b (157 Laidley Street): Conditional use authorization for a horizontal rear addition. Approved unanimously (6-0) without discussion. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish discussed concerns about roof decks and key lots at 2515 Folsom. Tomorovich (Livable City) urged the commission to develop a land use element, arguing current density controls lack coherent public purpose. - Item 7 (Tobacco Paraphernalia): Multiple speakers from the Tenderloin community, including Cheyenne White, Greg Johnson, Pratibha Techni, Kate Robinson (Tenderloin CBD), and Chris Schulman (Lower Polk CBD), strongly supported an outright ban on tobacco paraphernalia establishments, citing safety, public health, and the need to eliminate illicit activities. A petition with 81 signatures was submitted. - Item 8 (Parcel Delivery): Union representatives (Teamsters Local 2785, 350, 853, 665, Joint Council 7), Kim Cavalone (SF Labor Council), Jacob Klein (Sierra Club), and residents (Will Roscoe, Yoshisato, Celia Schumann) urged approval of Supervisor Chan’s legislation without staff modifications, citing neighborhood impacts, environmental justice, and worker protections. One cannabis industry comment expressed concern about black market impacts. - Item 10 (5425 Mission Street): Ileana opposed the project due to overcrowding, parking, and shadow impacts. - Item 13 (72 Harper Street): DR requesters David Garavioli, Brian O’Neill (attorney for Krishna Ramamurthi), Mike Lee, and Amy Bricker presented concerns about light, privacy, and scale, proposing a flat roof design to mitigate impacts. Discussion Items Tobacco Paraphernalia Establishments in North of Market SUD (Item 7) Staff recommended making tobacco paraphernalia establishments not permitted (rather than conditional use), extending controls to the lower Polk NCD, and adding a quarter-mile boundary. The commission heard strong community support for an outright ban. Commissioners supported the staff recommendations and added recommendations to examine limiting hours and shortening the abandonment period from 18 months. The ordinance was approved with modifications (6-0). Parcel Delivery Service Planning Code Amendments (Item 8) Supervisor Chan’s legislation would require conditional use authorization for parcel delivery services citywide and prohibit them as accessory uses. Staff recommended modifications to eliminate additional criteria, exempt uses under 5,000 sq ft, exclude cannabis delivery from accessory prohibitions, add technical corrections, and incorporate a temporary 60-day exemption. After extensive debate and public testimony—including strong union and community support for stricter controls—the commission voted to approve the legislation as introduced without staff modifications, but with recommendations for the supervisor to work with staff on: removing off-site signage and idling requirements, changing electrification from a condition to a criteria for smaller uses, creating a simplified CUA process for small businesses, and conducting a citywide economic analysis. Motion passed 6-0. FY2024-2026 Proposed Department Budget (Item 9) Staff presented a budget that reduces fees by $3 million, eliminates 12 vacant positions, and aligns with the mayor’s reduction instructions. Jerry Dratler questioned FTE levels and cost recovery. The commission adopted the budget (6-0). 5425 Mission Street – HOME-SF Project (Item 10) A proposal to demolish a two-story commercial building and construct a 29-unit mixed-use building with 23% on-site affordable units. Staff recommended approval with conditions. One public commenter opposed citing parking, shadows, and construction impacts. The commission approved with staff amendments (6-0). 1571 Shrader Street – Removal of Unauthorized Dwelling Unit (Item 11) Conditional use authorization to remove an unlawfully converted storage unit. Staff found legalization not financially feasible ($430,000 cost vs. $50,000 value increase) and no evidence of tenant eviction. No public comment. Approved with conditions (6-0). 72 Harper Street – Discretionary Review (Item 13) Discretionary review of a permit to add a rear addition and ADU. DR requesters argued the peaked roof would cause exceptional shadow and privacy impacts; they proposed a flat roof. Staff recommended not taking DR, noting code compliance and typical impacts. The project sponsor emphasized design compatibility and minimal shading increase. The commission voted not to take DR, noting the project was not exceptional, and acknowledged a private offer to obscure glazing. Motion passed 6-0. Key Outcomes - All items were approved on 6-0 votes. - Item 7: Approved with modifications (ban; expansion to lower Polk NCD; quarter-mile boundary; recommendations to study hours and shorter abandonment). - Item 8: Approved without staff modifications, but with multiple recommendations for further refinement (idling signage, electrification criteria, simplified CUA for small businesses, citywide economic analysis). - Item 9: Budget adopted. - Item 10: HOME-SF project approved with staff amendments. - Item 11: UDU removal approved. - Item 13: Discretionary review denied; project approved as proposed.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee held a regular meeting on Thursday, February 8, 2024, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stefani. The committee considered four agenda items: a liquor license issuance for Bruno's, a hearing on crime and violence targeting Asian-American seniors, a hearing on working conditions for women in the San Francisco Police Department, and a hearing on the 2021 Human Trafficking report. All items were acted upon with unanimous votes. Consent Calendar - No items were placed on the consent calendar. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Liquor License – Bruno's): No public comment was offered. - Item 2 (Asian-American Seniors): Numerous community members and organization representatives spoke. Carl Takay (Asian Law Caucus) expressed support for sanctuary city values and holistic safety approaches. Annette Wong (CAA) emphasized language access and community solutions. Youth speakers (Nalie Liang, Kathy Zhao, Laura Huang, and others) advocated for restorative justice programs and community-based safety. Kimberly Zito (Asian Inc.) relayed small business owners' fear. David Wu (SOMA Filipinas) read a statement calling for education and land ownership. Ken Lomba (Deputy Sheriff's Association) urged restoring law enforcement funding. Other speakers included Rodney Mitchell (CCDC), Diana Pang, So Abdo, and Demi Barroso, who shared personal experiences of violence and called for community-centered solutions. - Item 3 (Women in SFPD): Tracy McCray (POA president) thanked the committee and stressed the need for child care and lactation accommodations. Ken Lomba (Deputy Sheriffs) supported housing and wellness initiatives. Amy Hurwitz (SFPD Women's Leadership Committee) highlighted retaliation fears and called for concrete action. Captains Alexa O'Brien and Trina Wearing shared personal struggles and the need for culture change. Commissioner Deborah Walker advocated for 50% women by 2025 and housing for first responders. - Item 4 (Human Trafficking): Daniela Diaz (SF Safe House) provided statistics: 63 severe human trafficking survivors, 24% increase, 76% Black/brown, 31% LGBTQ+. Ken Lomba suggested a cyber crimes unit. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License Issuance – Bruno’s (2389 Mission Street): The committee heard from SFPD ABC liaison Officer Salmuson, who reported zero letters of protest or support, and recommended approval with conditions (noise control, loitering prevention, security guard). The applicant's representative David Villalobos noted that Bruno's was a legacy business that would have closed without a type 90 license. Chair Stefani moved to prepare a resolution finding public convenience or necessity. The motion passed unanimously (3-0). - Item 2: Hearing – Crime and Violence Targeting Asian-American Seniors: Supervisor Chan, the original sponsor, made opening remarks noting a 567% rise in hate crimes in 2021 and an 80% reduction by early 2024, but continued fear. SFPD's Commander Perra and Sergeant Hyung explained hate crime definitions and presented hate crime data: 60 API-related hate crimes in 2021, dropping to 14 in 2023, with single perpetrators responsible for a majority. They highlighted the Community Liaison Unit's language services and victim support. District Attorney Nancy Tung reported that of 21 hate crime cases presented in 2023, 12 were filed (9 felonies, 3 misdemeanors), and 41 hate crime cases are currently pending (25 based on race, 13 Asian). An audit of 2020-2021 cases resulted in no changes. The Coalition for Community Safety and Justice (CCSJ) presented: Eddie Zhang, Sarah Wan, Annie Lee, and Joyce Lamb described their victim services, restorative justice training, and cross-racial solidarity events. Statistics: 225 API victims served since 2020, 83 in 2023; $35,000 in financial assistance. Public testimony emphasized community-based solutions, language access, and funding for restorative justice. Supervisor Chan moved to continue the hearing to the call of the chair, passed unanimously. - Item 3: Hearing – Working Conditions for Women in SFPD: Chair Melgar noted SFPD's low female representation (15% sworn, while NYPD 20%, LAPD 18%). DHR's Mawuli Tugbenio outlined citywide lactation policy (96 rooms, 90 accessible to all). SFPD Deputy Chief Walsh discussed the 30x30 initiative (goal of 30% women by 2030), current demographics (280 women sworn, 37% of command staff), and recruitment challenges. Penny C (ADA coordinator) reported 24 work sites, 13 with dedicated lactation rooms, and 11 using multi-purpose spaces; modular walls received for upgrades. Director Ellis (Department on the Status of Women) recommended mandated lactation pods, expanded child care, a female recruitment task force, and annual reporting. She cited data: women use less force, fewer complaints. Public comment included Tracy McCray, Ken Lomba, Amy Hurwitz, Alexa O'Brien, Trina Wearing, and Deborah Walker, all stressing need for child care, housing, and culture change. Chair Melgar moved to file the hearing, passed unanimously. - Item 4: Hearing – Human Trafficking in San Francisco 2021 Report: Director Ellis presented key findings: one third of survivors born outside U.S., 94% women, 91% sex trafficking cases. Tony Eby (SF Safe House) noted increased capacity by 300% since 2019 but persistent wait lists, and highlighted the need for permanent housing, especially for women with children, and a new 22-unit facility at 101 Gough Street. Antonia Levine (SF Collaborative) stressed regional coordination and lack of funding for the collaborative. Public comment from Daniela Diaz (Safe House) provided stark statistics. Ken Lomba suggested a cyber crimes unit. Chair Stefani moved to file the hearing, passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Unanimous vote to recommend approval of the type 90 liquor license for Bruno's to the full Board of Supervisors (3-0). - Item 2: Unanimous vote to continue the hearing on anti-Asian hate crimes to the call of the chair (3-0). - Item 3: Unanimous vote to file the hearing on working conditions for women in SFPD (3-0). - Item 4: Unanimous vote to file the hearing on the 2021 Human Trafficking report (3-0). Chair Stefani indicated a BLA request to examine regional coordination and funding.
The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, met on February 7, 2024, to consider nine agenda items including leases, grants, bond issuances, fee waivers, contracting waivers, and budget allocations. The meeting featured extensive public testimony and debate, particularly on items related to APEC relief and homeless services contracting. Item 1: Real Property Lease – 755 and 759 South Van Ness Avenue - Proposal: Approve a lease for office and clinic space for the Department of Public Health, with $644,931 initial annual base rent (approx. $52,000/month), through December 31, 2027, with CPI increases and an extension option. - Action: Forwarded to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). Item 2: Local Immigrant Integration and Inclusion Grant - Proposal: Retroactively accept a $165,978 grant from the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development to support immigrant economic inclusion, and amend the salary ordinance to add a temporary analyst position. - Discussion: Supervisors asked about integrating housing support and suggested including resources like City College courses and the San Francisco ID in the planned economic inclusion toolkit. - Action: Forwarded to full board (3-0). Item 3: Revenue Bonds – St. Ignatius College Preparatory - Proposal: Approve issuance of up to $150 million in tax-exempt bonds for school renovations and improvements, with no city liability. - Action: Forwarded to full board (3-0) after brief discussion. No public comments. Item 4: Grant Agreement – Pesticide Regulation - Proposal: Authorize the Department of Environment to accept a $321,670 grant from the California Department of Pesticide Regulation for integrated pest management in affordable housing, including the state’s dispute resolution language. - Action: Forwarded to full board (3-0), with Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. Item 5: Multifamily Housing Revenue Notes – Transbay Block 2 West - Proposal: Authorize up to $67.68 million in conduit revenue bonds for construction of a 151-unit affordable senior housing project at 200 Folsom Street, with 150 units for households earning 15–50% of AMI, including 30 units for homeless seniors. - Action: Forwarded to full board with Vice Chair Mandelman as co-sponsor (3-0). Item 6: Waiver of Temporary Street Space Occupancy Permit Fee – Lunar New Year - Proposal: Waive fees for sidewalk sales in Chinatown from January 27 to February 10, 2024, costing the city an estimated $16,000. - Amendment: Chair Chan moved to add “retroactive” language to the title; approved unanimously. - Action: Forwarded to full board as amended (3-0). Item 7: Extending Contracting Waivers for Homeless Services - Proposal: Extend by five years provisions allowing the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) and Public Works to enter contracts without competitive bidding for homeless services and construction. - Discussion: Chair Chan proposed amendments limiting new contracts to two-year terms and bifurcating based on original procurement method. HSH opposed the amendments, citing need for flexibility and quick response to crises. Supervisors debated the balance between accountability and speed. Public comment was overwhelmingly in support of extension. - Action: Motion to continue to February 14 meeting passed (3-0) to allow further negotiation. Item 8: APEC Relief Fund and Lunar New Year Transit Supports - Proposal (as amended): De-appropriate $3.5 million from the APEC reserve: $500,000 to SFMTA for free parking at Portsmouth Square Garage (first two hours throughout February) and free Muni on parade day (excluding cable cars), plus continued ambassador services; $3 million to OEWD for a relief fund covering SOMA businesses impacted by APEC and a new Small Business Transit Impact Relief Fund for Taraval Street merchants affected by SFMTA construction. - Public Testimony: Over 20 speakers testified, many describing severe revenue losses (50–98%) during APEC and years of business decline on Taraval due to construction. Speakers urged support for both groups without pitting them against each other. - Action: Motion to amend and continue to February 14 meeting passed (3-0) for final review. Item 9: Board of Supervisors Fiscal Year 2024-2026 Budget - Proposal: Adopt a $4.8 million budget with $330,000 in cuts including reductions to legislative accounts (from $8,000 to $5,000 per district), temporary downgrades of two positions, and increased assessment appeals revenue projections ($294,000). The budget maintains hiring authority for positions hired at lower steps. - Action: Hearing filed and budget approved for transmittal to the mayor (3-0).
The San Francisco Police Commission convened on Wednesday, February 7, 2024, at 1:45 PM. The meeting included recognitions, public comment, reports, a major audit presentation on SF SAFE, a staffing analysis, budget approvals, and other operational updates. Key outcomes included approval of the SFPD FY2025-2026 budget (4-2), a request for a comprehensive audit of SF SAFE, and acceptance of most consent calendar items. Consent Calendar - Received and filed: SFPD Audit of Electronic Communication Devices for Bias (Q4 2023), Department General Order 11.02 "Secondary Employment" Annual Report 2023 (excluded pending more information on LLCs), SFPD 2022 Limited English Proficiency Report, and Semi-Annual Sexual Assault Evidence Kit Report (July–December 2023). - The Secondary Employment Annual Report was removed from consent after Commissioner Byrne requested more detail on LLCs. The remainder was unanimously approved (6-0). Public Comments & Testimony - Weekly Officer Recognition (Item 1): Michael Petrellis asked that commendations be moved to the end of meetings, calling them a "detriment to public accountability" and suggested equal time for unsolved crimes. - General Public Comment (Item 2): A speaker expressed concern about threats made by billionaire Gary Tan against Board of Supervisors members and requested removal of metal barricades at Mission Station. - General Public Comment: A mother urged action on her son's unsolved 2006 murder, providing names of alleged perpetrators. - SF SAFE Audit (Item 8): Michael Petrellis criticized the lack of remote public comment and held Mayor London Breed responsible for the lack of oversight. - Staffing (Item 9): A public commenter suggested the Commission review its own DGOs for added administrative burdens on officers. Discussion Items - Weekly Officer Recognition (Item 1): Sergeant Kira Delaney (Homicide Unit) was recognized for 12 years of service, investigating over 500 cases (lead on 100+), single parent of two, and recent academic achievements. All commissioners praised her dedication. - Chief’s Report (Item 5): Chief Scott reported that part-one crime was down 40% in January 2024 compared to January 2023 (about 1,900 fewer crimes). Homicides down 40%, shootings down 8%, property crime down 40%. Significant incidents included an assault with a deadly weapon, a stabbing on Muni, a hate crime in the Tenderloin, three stabbings, and drug market enforcement (51 arrests, 552 grams of narcotics seized, 5,243 grams of fentanyl seized YTD). - DPA Director’s Report (Item 6): Director Henderson reported 64 new cases opened YTD, 344 active cases, 7 sustained cases. 10 cases pending with the Commission, 91 pending with the Chief. He noted a 32nd month update on use-of-force audit recommendations: now only 4 of 37 remain open. - Commission Reports (Item 7): Commissioners reported on a Feather Alert hearing, stolen vehicle ticketing collaboration with MTA (18–20 recoveries), and upcoming Lunar New Year events. - Controller’s Audit of SF SAFE (Item 8): Mark De La Rosa and Amanda Sobrapenia presented the assessment (requested by SFPD in June 2023). Key findings: SFPD lacked supporting documentation for $3.8 million (72%) of $5.3 million grant (July 2018–March 2023). A sample of $910,000 in expenses revealed $36,000 for luxury gift boxes ($150 each), $12,000 in excessive expenses at a Lake Tahoe event (limousine, lodging), $21,000 in parking fees (including valet and monthly BART parking), ride-hailing from the former executive director’s home to San Francisco, and $1,300 in personal/office expenses (water delivery, Amazon Prime, Costco membership). The Controller recommended SFPD review all invoices and recover ineligible payments. Following extensive questioning, the Commission voted unanimously (6-0) to request a comprehensive audit covering the full grant period (2018–2023) and program deliverables. - Staffing and Deployment (Item 9): Deputy Chief Walsh and analyst TJ Chow presented the 2023 staffing analysis. Recommended staffing: 2,074 sworn (down 108 from 2021) and 653 civilian. Actual sworn staffing as of January 2024: 984 (down from 1,022 in June 2023), a deficit of 444 officers. Issues raised included low footbeats (5 stations with zero), traffic enforcement down 90%+, Civilianization efforts in progress (backgrounds, CSI). The Commission discussed the need for bolder action. - SFPD FY2025-2026 Budget (Item 10): Catherine McGuire presented the budget proposal, noting 87% personnel costs. After a motion to forward without recommendation failed (3-3), a motion to approve passed 4-2 (Walker, Benedicto, Byrne, Yi in favor; Overstone, Elias opposed). - DPA Budget (Item 11): Nicole Armstrong presented the DPA budget, highlighting a need for $150,000 for case management technology. Due to a 10% cut directive, proposed cuts include pausing OIS on-call pay and transcript costs, which could delay casework. This item was informational only; no action taken. - Disciplinary Review Board (Item 12): Sarah Hawkins presented Q2 2023 DRB findings. IAD found no policy failures; DPA found three, including incomplete booking searches and accident case tracking. Eight recommendations were made, including improved dog unit processes and booking manual updates. - Early Intervention System (Item 13): Sergeant Darwin Wallace presented Q2 2023 EIS data. Use-of-force alerts remained high due to new policy. 4.7% decrease in alerts from previous quarter. Two open interventions, 39 informal counseling sessions. Benchmark integration is ongoing; dashboard expected by February 2024, forms by April 2024. - Closed Session (Items 16–19): The Commission voted unanimously to hold closed session and then to not disclose discussion except as noted in minutes. Key Outcomes - Motion to request comprehensive audit of SF SAFE (Item 8): Passed unanimously (6-0). The Commission requests the Controller’s Office to audit the full 2018–2023 grant period, including financials, internal controls, and program deliverables. - SFPD FY2025-2026 Budget approved (Item 10): Passed 4-2. The budget moves to the Board of Supervisors. - Consent Calendar partly approved (Item 3): Four items accepted, one (Secondary Employment report) removed for further detail. - DPA Budget: Informational only; no vote. - Closed Session: No disclosure of details.
The Port Commission met in regular session on Tuesday, February 6, 2024, with President Kimberley Brandon presiding. Commissioners present: Brandon, Vice President Gail Gilman, Ed Harrington, and Stephen Lee. Commissioner Willie Adams was absent. The meeting included approval of minutes, an executive director's report, two major informational presentations — the San Francisco Waterfront Coastal Flood Study draft plan and the FY 2024-25/2025-26 biennial budget — and scheduling of future agenda items. Consent Calendar - Approved the January 23, 2024 commission minutes without opposition. Public Comments & Testimony - No public comments were made during the meeting. Public comment periods were opened and closed with no speakers in person or on the phone. Discussion Items Executive Director's Report - Director Forbes reported that the Port has returned to pre-pandemic revenue levels and is focusing resources on a clean and safe waterfront, including four new assistant superintendent positions in maintenance to advance race equity and career ladders. - Resilience: On January 26, 2024, the Port and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers released a draft plan to defend 7.5 miles of waterfront against sea level rise. The public comment period runs through March 29, 2024, with community meetings, walking tours, webinars, and a roadshow. - Upcoming initiatives: Trades Career Fair for high school students and transitioning youth; expansion of Pop-ups on the Plaza for Black-owned businesses (February 17, 2024); Crane Cove Park playground conceptual design 95% complete; Amador Street project to be advertised in March 2024, using the Port's first-ever federal infrastructure funds (PIDP/MIRAD grant). - Director Forbes reported an early-morning attack on Andrew Cotter near Beach and Hyde Street on February 2, 2024, and wished him a full recovery. - Commissioner Harrington suggested modeling the career fair after Bay Work, a regional water/wastewater career-path collaboration. Vice President Gilman wished Mr. Cutter well and acknowledged Lunar New Year and Black History Month. Waterfront Coastal Flood Study Draft Plan (Item 10A) - Informational presentation by Brian Harper (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers), Adam Derrett (Port planning lead), and other team members. It summarized the Draft Integrated Feasibility Report/Environmental Impact Statement released on January 26, 2024. - The plan proposes adaptations across four reaches: floodproofing buildings and adding short flood walls at Fisherman's Wharf; elevating the Embarcadero shoreline to defend against 3.5 feet of sea level rise; elevating shorelines in South Beach/Mission Bay and Islais Creek/Bayview to 1.5 feet initially, with later adaptation to 3.5 feet; adding closure structures at bridges; and incorporating nature-based features where feasible. - Estimated total cost: $13 billion, with a 65% federal cost share. The plan is not a detailed design and does not yet include design details, phasing, or inland drainage costs. - The team emphasized that non-monetary social metrics — such as community identity, health, and social vulnerability — were used in plan selection, a first for an Army Corps study. - Public comments on the draft plan are due March 29, 2024. The final feasibility report is expected by the end of 2025, with a goal of inclusion in the 2026 Water Resources Development Act. Pre-construction engineering and design would occur from 2026 to 2030, with construction beginning after 2030. - Commissioner comments raised: the need to integrate nature-based solutions throughout, avoid premature cost fixation, coordinate with the SFPUC on stormwater management, prepare for emergency scenarios, mitigate impacts on small businesses and tenants, and phase the work so partial completion still yields risk reduction. - Staff committed to report back on phasing, tenant disruption, and long-term funding strategies. FY 2024-25 and 2025-26 Biennial Operating and Capital Budget (Item 11A) - CFO Nate Cruz presented an informational overview of the proposed two-year budget. The Port has returned to pre-pandemic revenue levels ahead of schedule, led by leisure tourism and record cruise passenger volume. - Operating budget: proposed 8% increase in FY 2024-25, with inflationary labor costs accounting for about half; the second-year increase is nominal. New investments include: - In-house security model: four new Port security positions at approximately 2% cost increase. - Parking management shift to SFMTA-run multi-space pay stations and flat-fee operation contracts; expected to boost net parking revenue by about 50%. - Equity investments: four assistant superintendent positions in maintenance, a machinist helper, doubled training budget, and a 10% increase in race equity training. - Capital program: the 10-year state of good repair need is $2.25 billion, with a $1.6 billion unfunded gap. The 5-year Capital Improvement Program includes a $16.5 million Mission Rock development capital contribution, reallocation of $11.7 million in ARPA funds to capital, and resilience investments of $1.7 million in FY 2024-25 and $2.6 million in FY 2025-26. - The budget does not meet the commission's 25% capital investment-to-revenue policy (expected 14%), but it exceeds the 50% operating reserve policy (126% of annual expenses). - The Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund unpaid balance will be fully repaid to zero during this biennium. - Commissioners asked for more granular reporting on security and parking enforcement, and for a consolidated presentation of all restricted funds (resilience, beautification) with the budget. President Brandon requested a detailed plan for the use of $70 million in resilience funds. - No action was taken; an action item will return for approval at the end of February 2024. New Business (Item 12) - President Brandon recorded two future items: an update on parking program performance (if the parking model is approved) and a detailed resilience program budget at the next budget approval item, in addition to Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund details. - Vice President Gilman suggested a future joint presentation on the in-house security model and how it incorporates the Port's equity framework. Key Outcomes - Approved the minutes of January 23, 2024. - The flood study and biennial budget were informational; no formal votes were taken on those items. - Staff were directed to return at the end of February 2024 with an action item to approve the biennial budget, plus reports on parking performance, resilience budget transparency, and beautification fund balance. - The public comment period on the flood study continues through March 29, 2024. - The meeting was adjourned.