The San Francisco Board of Supervisors held its regular meeting on Tuesday, February 6, 2024. The agenda included routine consent items, a major CEQA appeal hearing for a proposed 24-unit housing project at 2395 Sacramento Street, a resolution opposing state legislation that would modify the California Coastal Act zone boundaries, commendations for community leaders, and the introduction of several new policy items. Consent Calendar - Items 1 through 11, including financial settlements, grant acceptances, and various routine approvals, were adopted unanimously. Unfinished Business - Item 12 (Library Site Prioritization): The Board approved an ordinance designating the city-owned parcel at 100 Orizaba Avenue as the prioritized site for a new public library branch, subject to environmental review and approvals. The vote was 8 ayes and 3 noes (Supervisors Dorsey, Mandelman, Melgar). Discussion Items Airport Leases and City Contracts (Items 13-16): - The Board unanimously approved new 10-year lease and use agreements for various airlines at San Francisco International Airport and authorized two contract modifications for electrical supplies for city departments, totaling up to $30 million. Lithium-Ion Battery Safety (Item 18): - An ordinance amending the Fire Code to establish safety standards for the charging and storage of lithium-ion batteries in powered mobility devices and to prohibit the use of damaged or reconditioned batteries was passed on first reading. Gashouse Cove / Marina Harbor Project (Item 19): - Supervisor Safai introduced an ordinance prohibiting the Recreation and Park Department from expanding the West Harbor Marina by more than 150 feet. Safai argued the project threatened historic recreational uses (rowing, swimming, youth sailing) and called for philanthropic funding, citing the India Basin redevelopment as a model. Supervisors Dorsey and Ronan supported the measure, with Ronan expressing concerns about potential costs to the General Fund and urging the city to increase slip fees. Supervisor Stefani recused herself from the vote. The ordinance passed on first reading with 10 ayes. Opposition to California Senate Bill 951 (Item 25): - The Board debated a resolution opposing Senator Scott Wiener’s legislation to modify the California Coastal Act boundaries in San Francisco. - President Peskin (Sponsor): Argued the bill set a “horrible precedent” and was “the beginning of the end of the California Coastal Act.” - Supervisors Engardio and Melgar: Opposed the resolution, arguing it was premature given ongoing negotiations between the Senator and the Coastal Commission. Engardio also noted the proposed bill did not change the substantive protections of the Act. - Supervisors Chan, Mandelman, Ronan: Supported the resolution, expressing concern over losing local coastal protections. - Supervisor Stefani: Supported the resolution, expressing hope that the bill would be amended. - The resolution was adopted with an 8-3 vote. Voting no were Supervisors Dorsey, Engardio, and Melgar. CEQA Appeal Hearing – 2395 Sacramento Street (Items 21-24): - The Board held a public hearing on an appeal challenging the Planning Department’s determination that a 24-unit housing project (including rehabilitation of the historic Lane Medical Library landmark and new construction) was exempt from further environmental review under CEQA. The department had issued a General Plan Evaluation (GPE), tiering off of the Housing Element Environmental Impact Report (EIR). - Appellants (Richard Drury, neighbors, SF Heritage): Argued that the use of a programmatic EIR to bypass project-level review was unlawful. They highlighted “peculiar impacts” to the landmark’s interior (including Arthur Matthews murals), off-site impacts from vibration and wind, and construction-related air quality risks where experts calculated a cancer risk of 400 in a million compared to the significance threshold of 10. They argued the GPE is not a document recognized in state law. - Planning Department: Defended the GPE process, stating it provided over 150 pages of project-level analysis and required specific mitigation measures tailored from the Housing Element EIR. They argued the process was consistent with state law (CEQA 15183) and had been used for similar Community Plan Evaluations for 15 years. - Project Sponsor: Emphasized the project was a respectful adaptive reuse providing urgently needed housing (including 3 on-site BMR units). They warned that granting the appeal would add costly delays, jeopardizing the project, and noted new state law AB 1633. - Decision: Supervisor Stefani (District 2) moved to approve the GPE. She argued that the appellant failed to meet the legal burden of proof, that the debate centered on the word “peculiar,” and that the Housing Element EIR explicitly contemplated streamlined review for projects impacting cultural resources. - Outcome: The motion to affirm the exemption determination passed 10-1, with Supervisor Peskin voting in opposition. The appeal was denied. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Speakers addressed a wide range of topics, including criticism of political figures, support for unhoused residents, and a racial incident at an SFUSD school. - Preservation of 2395 Sacramento Street: Over a dozen speakers testified on the CEQA appeal, with historians, architects, and residents arguing for a full environmental review to protect the landmark, while housing advocates and neighbors urged the board to approve the project to add much-needed housing. - Youth Commissioner: Linda Yi, a Youth Commissioner, urged the board to support recognizing February as Teen Dating Violence Awareness and Prevention Month. Key Outcomes - Affirmed CEQA Exemption (2395 Sacramento Street): The Board voted 10-1 to uphold the Planning Department’s determination, clearing the way for the 24-unit housing project to proceed. - Adopted Resolution Opposing SB 951: The Board adopted a resolution opposing Senator Wiener’s bill to modify the California Coastal Act boundaries, voting 8-3. - Passed Marina Use Ordinance: An ordinance to limit the expansion of the West Harbor Marina passed on first reading (10 ayes). - Approved Consent Agenda and Resolutions: The Board approved the consent calendar and various resolutions, including supporting the UPTE-CWA optometrists’ strike, recognizing the 20th Anniversary of the Winter of Love, designating “Niners Day” (Super Bowl Sunday), and proclaiming Lunar New Year 2024. Introductions and Referrals - Supervisor Ronan: Requested a Budget and Legislative Analyst report on state and federal funding lost by the city between 2018 and 2023. - Supervisor Melgar: Called a hearing on recurrent PG&E power outages in District 7. - Supervisor Dorsey: Called a hearing on public safety and community impacts of Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) facilities in District 6. - Supervisor Stefani: Introduced a resolution condemning anti-abortion harassment and urging enforcement of Article 43; requested letters of inquiry to SFUSD regarding security bond funds and the Sandy Hook Promise reporting system. - Supervisor Walton: Introduced a resolution declaring February as Teen Dating Violence Awareness and Prevention Month. - Supervisor Preston: Provided a LAFCO update on studies related to battery storage, a municipal green bank, the future of Midtown Park Apartments, and an RFP for a municipal housing agency consultant.
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe Rules Committee convened on Monday, February 5, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronen and joined by Supervisor Safai (Vice Chair Walton excused), considered appointments to the Small Business Commission. The committee recommended three appointments to the Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - No members of the public spoke on the appointment item. Discussion Items - Appointments to the Small Business Commission: The committee heard from reapplicant Miriam Zuzunis (Seat 1, term ending January 6, 2026) and new applicant Dimitri Terry Carnett (Seat 2, term ending January 6, 2028). The third applicant, William Ortiz Cartagena (Seat 3, term ending January 6, 2028), was ill and not present; Supervisors spoke in support of his reappointment. Applicant Michael Hinckley withdrew before the meeting. - Miriam Zuzunis stated her priorities for her next term include addressing equity gaps from COVID recovery, working with the Treasurer and Tax Collector on fee cleanup, prioritizing food access and EBT‑licensed businesses, and improving infrastructure for small business workers. - Dimitri Terry Carnett, owner of Work Salon in the Mission, expressed interest in helping small businesses thrive through creative, strategic, and inclusive ideas. He identified funding, simplifying processes, and encouraging symbiotic business models as key challenges. - Supervisors Ronen and Safai praised both reapplicants for their effectiveness, community connections, and positive, solution‑oriented attitudes. Key Outcomes - Motion to recommend the reappointment of Miriam Zuzunis to Seat 1, appointment of Dimitri Terry Carnett to Seat 2, and reappointment of William Ortiz Cartagena to Seat 3 passed unanimously (Supervisor Ronen aye, Supervisor Safai aye; Vice Chair Walton excused). - The recommendation will be forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors for consideration at its February 13, 2024, meeting.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on February 5, 2024, at 9:45 AM. Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and Board President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered five agenda items, including a commemorative street naming, accessory dwelling unit (ADU) reforms, a family housing special use district, a resolution opposing state Senate Bill 951, and a fee waiver for downtown rail extension projects. Votes were taken on all items. Veterans Alley Commemorative Street Name (Item 1) - Discussion: Supervisor Preston sponsored a resolution to add the commemorative street name "Veterans Alley" to the 0 block of Shannon Street, honoring the San Francisco Veterans Mural Project founded in 2011 by Amos Gregory and the late Gilbert Lovato. Gregory described the project's origins, murals painted by veterans, and community programs including internships and block parties. He credited the Clarion Alley Mural Project and the Tenderloin National Forest for guidance. - Public Comments: Several speakers supported the designation, citing the alley's transformation, community engagement, and artistic value. Others opposed it: Richard Hack alleged lack of outreach and unauthorized painting; Rick Galliani, managing partner of 565 Geary Street, called the murals graffiti and said they hurt rentals; property manager Joe Braden cited safety concerns from painted street surfaces. Tenants and interns spoke in favor, stating the project improves the neighborhood. - Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Supervisor Preston acknowledged concerns and offered to facilitate conversations with neighbors. Family Housing Opportunity Special Use District (Item 3 – heard out of order) - Discussion: Supervisor Engardio presented amendments to Chair Melgar’s Family Housing Opportunity SUD (initially created for additional density in RH districts) to incorporate the “domicity” concept: up to six-story apartment buildings on corner lots in the Sunset and Richmond districts, with mixed-use ground floors. The goal is to provide middle-income housing (families earning 150-190% AMI) and senior housing. Planning staff noted the Planning Commission recommended modifications, including allowing RM1 zoning and lot mergers in a bounded area (Great Highway, Lincoln Way, 19th Avenue, Sloat Boulevard), but not the corner height limit increase to 65 feet (staff recommended 55 feet). President Peskin asked whether the changes affect districts beyond the SUD boundaries; staff clarified most apply citywide but corner lot and merger provisions are limited to the specified area. - Public Comments: Supporters (Housing Action Coalition, SPUR, SF YIMBY) called the plan creative and necessary for missing middle housing. Opponents raised concerns about infrastructure, parking, disruption to existing neighborhoods, and that the SUD map blue line covers most of the city (later clarified as a mapping error). One speaker urged including deed restrictions for seniors. Another noted the pending feasibility study for rezoning. - Key Outcomes: The committee adopted the amendments as read (all green and yellow highlighted changes) and continued the item to February 12, 2024, for further consideration. Motion passed 3-0. Resolution Opposing California Senate Bill 951 (Item 4) - Discussion: President Peskin introduced a resolution opposing SB 951 (Wiener), which would remove large portions of the Sunset, Richmond, and Golden Gate Park from the California Coastal Commission’s jurisdiction. Peskin argued the bill is unnecessary (only two appeals from San Francisco in 40 years, both upheld by the Commission), sets a dangerous precedent, and undermines climate adaptation and public access. He offered an amendment to change the title to “unless amended” to maintain the Commission’s geographic and appellate authority. Chair Melgar expressed reluctance to vote without seeing final negotiations between the city, Senator Wiener, and the Coastal Commission, noting potential housing opportunities on Brotherhood Way parcels. She voted no on the final motion. - Public Comments: The majority of speakers supported the resolution, citing the Coastal Act’s importance, fears of overdevelopment (e.g., a proposed 50-story tower), and the need to protect Golden Gate Park and Ocean Beach. The Housing Action Coalition and SF YIMBY opposed the resolution, arguing SB 951 would allow housing density bonus and SB 35 streamlining on underutilized parcels like the La Playa Safeway and church parking lots. - Key Outcomes: The committee adopted Peskin’s amendments (3-0) and then voted 2-1 (Melgar dissenting) to send the amended resolution as a committee report to the full Board. State-Mandated Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Ordinance (Item 2) - Discussion: This item updates the Planning Code to comply with state ADU laws. Planning staff presented four clarifying amendments (removing inaccurate findings, density limit clarity, deleting unnecessary notice of special restrictions, and expanding historic resource notification for local ADU program). President Peskin had prepared two additional amendments to steer applicants from the state ADU program (no rent control) to the local program (rent control), but he withdrew them after the state Housing and Community Development (HCD) threatened to revoke affordable housing funding. He denounced HCD’s “bullying” and intimidation. Supervisor Preston criticized the “pro-housing” designation system that conditions affordable housing money on deregulation of market-rate housing, calling it absurd. Public speakers (Housing Action Coalition, SPUR, SF YIMBY, Council of Community Housing Organizations) urged passage to secure the pro-housing designation and unlock $200 million in state funds for 472 affordable housing units and transit improvements. - Key Outcomes: To preserve the pro-housing designation deadline (March 19, 2024), the committee voted to duplicate the file. The original file was amended with the four planning amendments (green and yellow) and continued to the call of the chair pending re-referral to the Planning Commission. The duplicated file (unamended) was continued one week to February 12, 2024, to possibly incorporate Peskin’s withdrawn amendments. Both motions passed 3-0. Downtown Rail Extension Fee Waiver (Item 5) - Discussion: This ordinance allows conditional waivers or reductions of Transportation Sustainability Fees and Eastern Neighborhoods Infrastructure Impact Fees for projects along the Downtown Rail Extension (the Portal) corridor. The waiver is commensurate with the extra cost of constructing foundation types compatible with the tunnel. The Planning Commission recommended approval. Lee Lutenskate (OEWD) and Monica Jacomucci (Planning) presented the ordinance, noting it encourages early coordination and helps stalled housing projects move forward. - Public Comments: One speaker from Operating Engineers Local 3 supported the fee waiver for job creation. - Key Outcomes: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to send the ordinance to the full Board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Veterans Alley): Approved to full Board (3-0). - Item 3 (Family Housing SUD): Amendments adopted; continued to Feb. 12 (3-0). - Item 4 (SB 951 Resolution): Amended and sent as committee report (2-1, Melgar dissenting). - Item 2 (ADU Ordinance): Original file amended and continued to call of chair; duplicated file continued one week (both 3-0). - Item 5 (Fee Waiver): Approved to full Board (3-0).
The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission held a special budget hearing on February 2, 2024, to review the Power Enterprise and CleanPowerSF fiscal year 2024-25 and 2025-26 operating and capital budgets, as well as the 10-year capital plan. The meeting included a response to a prior commissioner's question on contracting out, a detailed presentation by Assistant General Manager Barbara Hale, and extensive commissioner discussion on workforce vacancies, recruitment challenges, climate adaptation, and major capital projects. Summary of Budget Hearing Questions (Item 3) - General Manager Dennis Herrera addressed Commissioner Maxwell's prior question about the correlation between contracting out and staff vacancies. He stated there is no correlation and that consultants augment staff only for specific approved reasons under a documented procedure with union notice and civil service oversight. He provided ratios: professional services contracts to PUC staff are 13% for water, 7% for wastewater, and 9% for power. Of these, only a very small fraction replace vacant positions: 9 staff in wastewater (5 in collections, 4 in planning), 4 in power (high voltage crew, not professional services), and 34 in water (6 in city distribution, 28 at Hetch Hetchy Water and Power). Commissioner Maxwell expressed appreciation for the clarification. Discussion Items – Power Enterprise & CleanPowerSF Budgets Overview and Context - Barbara Hale, Assistant General Manager for Power, introduced the organizational structure and noted that Power Enterprise operates two retail electric programs: Hetchy Power (publicly owned, serving about 6,300 accounts, mostly city departments) and CleanPowerSF (community choice aggregation, serving about 380,000 accounts). Together they serve 75% of electricity consumed in San Francisco. The Hetchy Power budget is approximately $220 million and CleanPowerSF about $370 million in the current year. - She highlighted savings to customers: Hetchy Power saved city departments over $50 million in FY2023-24 and other customers over $70 million, while CleanPowerSF saved residents and businesses more than $50 million in calendar year 2023, relative to PG&E rates. - Total proposed PUC operating budget is $2 billion (FY24-25) and $2.1 billion (FY25-26), with Power ratepayers funding $623 million and $658 million respectively (about 31% of the agency total). Budget Drivers and Position Requests - The primary cost driver is the purchase of power and delivery costs, which have increased steeply since 2020 due to higher wholesale energy prices and increased customer demand. - For Hetchy Power, the proposed operating budget grows 3% in FY24-25 and 13% in FY25-26, driven by capital needs, debt service, and increased power purchase/distribution costs. Staffing requests: 17 new positions and 9 temporary-to-permanent conversions over two years. - For CleanPowerSF, the budget grows 22% in FY24-25 (driven by power purchases) and 1% in FY25-26. Staffing requests: 5 new positions and 7 temporary-to-permanent conversions. - Commissioner Maxwell noted the current vacancy rates: 27.4% for Hetchy Power and 14.6% for CleanPowerSF as of December 2023. Hale explained recruitment challenges for specialized classifications (e.g., high-voltage line workers, utility specialists) and competition from other utilities and CCAs. Commissioner Questions on Communications and Adaptation - Commissioners urged better public communication of the PUC's services and savings, suggesting ongoing advertising rather than only during crises. Commissioner Jamy proposed dedicating budget resources to continuous communication. General Manager Herrera noted the agency is already expanding outreach but would consider the suggestion. - Commissioner Jamy also emphasized the need for intentional climate adaptation planning, noting that resilience (e.g., insurance costs, load management, workforce) affects all pillars. He encouraged cross-enterprise collaboration on adaptation and urged the power team to explicitly link budget items to adaptation efforts. Capital Projects (Hetchy Power and CleanPowerSF) - The Hetchy Power 10-year capital plan totals $1.2 billion, with major projects: - SFO Substation Improvements: Increased scope to support airport electrification and decarbonization. - Carbon Free Steam Project (Cordia): Partnering with Cordia (the district steam franchisee) to electrify steam generation. Cordia would become a Hetchy Power customer, supporting San Francisco's climate action plan. The PUC would build transmission connections. - Port of San Francisco Electrification: Over 80 megawatts of new load expected; funding for transmission to serve ferry electrification and port growth. - Redevelopment Projects: Funding for electrical duct banks serving large developments (e.g., Mission Rock, Pier 70, Parkmerced, Balboa Reservoir). - Reliability and Continuity: Improvements to Treasure Island switchyard (remote monitoring, generator connections) and Bay Corridor transmission. - Streetlight Repair and Enhancement: Covers about 25,500 streetlights, including LED conversions and pole assessments. - Public Power Expansion: Continuing efforts to acquire PG&E's San Francisco grid; funding for planning, CPUC valuation, and CEQA environmental impact report. - Municipal Solar and Energy Efficiency: $40 million for rooftop solar and efficiency at municipal facilities. - The CleanPowerSF 10-year capital plan totals $48 million, funding larger-scale renewables and battery storage, including solar on water reservoirs. Cordia Franchise and Treasure Island Updates - Commissioner Maxwell asked about the franchise agreement with Cordia. General Manager Herrera and Ron Flynn explained that the franchise is granted by the Board of Supervisors, allowing use of public rights-of-way in exchange for a share of revenues. The PUC assists the Controller's office in auditing remittances. - Commissioner Rivera requested an update on Treasure Island power reliability. Hale acknowledged ongoing outages but said connecting legacy customers to new switchgear and funding remote monitoring should improve reliability. She committed to providing a timeline in writing after consulting with TIDA. Key Outcomes - Commissioners received the budget presentations and provided substantial feedback and questions. No formal votes were taken at this special meeting; it was a workshop to inform the final budget proposal. - The next regularly scheduled meeting is in two weeks (week of February 12, 2024). General Manager Herrera noted that commissioner comments would be incorporated into the budget planning document for future consideration. - No public comments were offered.
The Planning Commission convened on Thursday, February 1, 2024, at approximately 2:15 PM for a regular hearing that extended into the evening. The agenda included a major informational presentation on the Expanding Housing Choice (Housing Element Zoning Program), certification of a Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and Conditional Use Authorization (CUA) for a Whole Foods Market at 2675 Geary Boulevard, a CUA and variance for a religious institution at 331-333 Cortland Avenue, and several other items. The commission received extensive public testimony, with over 50 neighborhood associations expressing opposition to the proposed upzoning, while YIMBY and housing advocacy groups urged expansion. The commission also discussed a potential resolution opposing state budget cuts to affordable housing. Consent Calendar - Items 1–6 (CUAs for various formula retail and other uses): Approved unanimously (6-0) as routine, with no public requests for removal. Public Comments & Testimony - Expanding Housing Choice (Item 13): Over 100 members of the public spoke, with opinions sharply divided. Opponents (representing neighborhood associations, historic preservationists, and small business advocates) argued the upzoning was too broad, threatened neighborhood character, historic resources, and existing rent-controlled housing, and did not guarantee affordable units. Supporters (from YIMBY groups, housing coalitions, and some residents) argued that the rezoning was necessary to meet state mandates, correct historic inequities, and address the housing crisis, urging even more ambitious height and density increases. Approximately 2,400 survey responses were collected during the outreach process. - Whole Foods (Items 14–15): Several union representatives and community members spoke in favor, citing job creation (200 permanent jobs, 115–140 construction jobs) and activation of a vacant space. No opposition was voiced during public comment. - Or Shalom (Item 16): Over 160 letters of support were submitted, and numerous congregation members, interfaith leaders, and neighbors testified in favor, emphasizing the synagogue’s community service and the lack of a Jewish institution in Bernal Heights. No public opposition was expressed. - Mission Street Bank (Item 18): No public comment. - Discretionary Review at 2247 31st Avenue (Item 19): The DR requesters (adjacent neighbors) testified that the proposed side addition would infringe on their privacy and sleep, citing noise concerns and prior unpermitted work by the project sponsor. The project sponsor’s architect responded that the addition complies with codes and includes a light well. Discussion Items - Expanding Housing Choice (Item 13): Staff presented the final proposed zoning map, which focuses height increases along commercial and transit corridors in the city’s western and northern neighborhoods, with a two-tiered system: a local program height (e.g., 85 feet) and a lower base height (e.g., 55 feet) for projects using state density bonus. The presentation included visualizations of potential future streetscapes. Commissioners expressed support for the overall direction but raised concerns about: protections for historic resources and small businesses; infrastructure capacity (water, sewer, schools, transit); the risk of displacement of existing tenants and businesses; and the need for a phased, neighborhood-focused implementation. Commissioner Ruiz suggested a resolution to oppose state affordable housing cuts; the commission agreed to schedule a discussion and potential vote at a later hearing (targeting February 22 or 29). Commissioners also requested a clearer map of base heights and more detail on the local program’s community benefits and waiver menu. - Whole Foods at 2675 Geary Boulevard (Items 14–15): Staff recommended certification of the Final EIR and approval of the CUA for a formula retail grocery store in a vacant former Best Buy space. The EIR identified no significant unavoidable impacts after mitigation (revised mechanical equipment noise). The commission voted unanimously to certify the EIR and approve the CUA. - Religious Institution at 331-333 Cortland Avenue (Item 16): Staff initially recommended disapproval of the CUA and variance due to the loss of a second-floor dwelling unit (illegally converted to non-residential use 14 years ago). After deliberation, the commission adopted an alternative motion that approved the project with conditions: if the institutional use ends, any future non-residential use would require a mandatory Discretionary Review. The variance for bicycle parking was also granted. The vote was 6-0. - Bank Change at 2812 Mission Street (Item 18): Staff and the project sponsor presented a simple change of operator from Bank of the West to BMO, with no physical changes beyond signage. Approved unanimously (6-0). - Discretionary Review at 2247 31st Avenue (Item 19): Staff recommended not taking DR, as the project code-complies and meets design guidelines. The commission agreed, voting 6-0 to approve the permit as submitted. Key Outcomes - Item 17 (1314 Page Street): Continued to February 29, 2024, at the request of the project sponsor, to explore options for a ground-floor unit. - Remote Public Comment (Item 10): The commission maintained its current policy (no general remote comment, but reasonable accommodation for disabilities), by a 5-2 vote (Commissioner Braun dissenting). - Resolution on State Affordable Housing Cuts: Commissioners Ruiz and Imperial proposed a resolution; the commission directed staff to schedule a discussion and potential vote in late February, in conjunction with the Affordable Housing Leadership Council’s recommendations. - Expanding Housing Choice: Commissioners directed staff to continue refining the map and code based on public and commissioner feedback, with an updated version expected for future hearings (next scheduled for February 22). - Whole Foods EIR and CUA: Certified and approved (6-0). - Or Shalom Religious Institution: Approved with conditions (6-0). - Bank CUA and Discretionary Review: Both approved (6-0).
The Government Audit and Oversight Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Thursday, February 1, 2024, at 6:15 PM. The meeting was chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, joined by Supervisor Matt Dorsey, and later by Supervisor Myrna Melgar for items 2 and 3. The committee considered a retroactive MOU with the U.S. Capitol Police, an audit of the Ocean Avenue Association, and annual reports for seven community benefit districts (CBDs) and two business improvement districts (BIDs). Public Comments & Testimony - A single member of the public spoke on item 1, placing a U.S. passport on display and referencing Arizona State University, but made no substantive comment on the agenda item. - No public comment was offered on items 4 through 9. - During items 2–3, Mary Harris, President of My Neighbors in Action, expressed support for the Ocean Avenue Association's progress, noting improved cleanliness and hanging baskets, while requesting more prominent celebration of new business openings and enhanced Small Business Week activities. Discussion Items Item 1: Retroactive MOU with U.S. Capitol Police - Diana Oliva Aroce (SFPD Director of Policy and Public Affairs) and Patrick Liang (former SFPD CFO) presented a resolution authorizing a retroactive MOU with the U.S. Capitol Police for supplemental law enforcement services (January 1, 2021 – December 31, 2023). The MOU covers off-duty officers providing security at the Pelosi residence. The originally projected reimbursement of $1 million has grown to approximately $1.8 million based on actual overtime hours. The committee expressed preference for future MOUs to be brought forward before services commence. The item was approved unanimously (2-0) and sent to the full Board of Supervisors. Items 2 & 3: Ocean Avenue Association Audit and Annual Report - The Controller's Office (Mark De La Rosa and Helen Voe) presented findings from an audit of the Ocean Avenue Association (OAA) covering FY2018-2022. Four overarching findings identified lack of internal controls, non-compliance with the management agreement, incomplete implementation of the strategic plan, and poor grant administration. Nineteen recommendations were issued, all of which OEWD concurred with. As of January 2024, 12 recommendations have been implemented; 7 remain open pending submission of the FY2022-23 annual report (expected mid-February 2024). - OEWD (Jackie Hazelwood) and OAA Executive Director Christian Martin reported on corrective actions taken: new board training, improved policies, a new CPA firm, successful leadership transition, and enhanced corridor services (e.g., cleaning, beautification, traffic calming). A missed vendor payment ($10,000) for a cancelled event (Phoenix Day) was noted; the vendor is not on the city’s debarred list but is being pursued for recovery. The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to file the hearing (item 2) and send the annual report (item 3) to the full board with a positive recommendation. Items 4–9: Annual Reports for Seven CBDs/BIDs - OEWD presented summaries of annual reports for FY2021-22 for: SoMa West CBD, Fisherman’s Wharf CBD, Lower Polk CBD, Union Square Alliance, Tourism Improvement District (TID) & Moscone Expansion District (MED), and Downtown Community Benefit District (now Downtown SF Partnership). - Most districts met all four benchmarks. SoMa West missed benchmark 2 (non-assessment revenue) and benchmark 4 (reporting error) due to its first full year of operations and COVID-19 impacts; Lower Polk met all benchmarks but submitted its report late due to vendor delays. All other districts met all benchmarks. - Key achievements highlighted: SoMa West cleaned 825,000 pounds of trash; Fisherman’s Wharf saw a 143% increase in website users; Lower Polk expanded its ambassador program; Union Square Alliance rebranded and launched new public realm projects; TID/MED reported 17 million visitors (40% below 2019) and 7 Moscone events (down from 58 pre‑pandemic); Downtown SF Partnership reported a 94% reduction in litter and launched Let’s Glow SF (67,000 attendees in 2023). Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved (2-0) to send to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. - Items 2 & 3: Hearing filed (3-0); annual report sent to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 4–9: All six resolutions approved (2-0 with one member excused) and sent to the full board with positive recommendations. - The committee excused Supervisors Chan and Stephanie from the meeting. - Supervisor Melgar was appointed as a member of the committee for items 2 and 3.
This was a special joint meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors' Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee and the San Francisco Youth Commission's Civic Engagement and Education Committee, held on February 1, 2024. The singular agenda item was a hearing to evaluate the lockdown and other safety procedures of the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD). The hearing included presentations from SFUSD leadership, questions from supervisors and youth commissioners, and public comment from students, parents, and community members. Presentation by SFUSD - SFUSD Director of Emergency Planning and Preparedness Greg Markwith and Assistant Superintendent of Student and Family Services Eric Guthertz presented an overview of the district's safety measures. - Facilities: The district reallocated $10 million in bond funds in October 2021 for safety improvements. 90% of classrooms now have secure door hardware, with completion expected by summer 2024. Remote door access with cameras is also being installed. Approximately 30 schools require PA system upgrades to meet new district standards, with an estimated additional $2-5 million needed. The November 2024 bond measure is a critical funding source; if it fails, the district will seek other funding. - Crisis communications: The district categorizes incidents as low, medium, or high impact, with corresponding notification levels. Officials noted that third-party apps like Citizen often spread misinformation, and the district prioritizes confirming facts before communicating. The Washington High School incident messaging was delayed until the district could confirm no active threat. - Law enforcement coordination: Markwith meets weekly with SFPD Captain Samuel Christ, and they maintain direct communication. Schools are encouraged to call 911 directly; central office does not intervene. - Safety planning: Every school has a comprehensive crisis plan and conducts state-mandated drills (fire, earthquake, lockdown, lockout). Lockdowns are called only when a threat is identified on campus or directed by law enforcement. - Student support: The district emphasized "sense of belonging" as a key guardrail. Coordinated care teams meet weekly at every school. Wellness centers exist at all high schools and will expand to all middle schools by next year. The district has trained over 8,000 students in the Say Something Anonymous Reporting System via Sandy Hook Promise, and has partnerships with city agencies, violence interrupters, and community organizations. Discussion Items - Youth Commissioner Barker Plummer asked about the procedure between schools and SFPD, clarifying that principals act as incident commanders and can call 911 without central office approval. They also raised concerns about crisis communication to students in real time, not just families, and the urgency of PA system funding. Plummer also asked about distribution of safe firearm storage information, suggesting hard copies sent home. - Youth Commissioner Perez asked about funding for PA systems if the bond fails; SFUSD responded that it would reallocate other projects. Perez also asked about the current state of PA systems; they exist but are not up to district standards. - Youth Commissioner Markeen asked about the crisis communication process for students; the district detailed its three-tier notification system. - Youth Commissioner Alioto Pier asked about lockdown drill policies and the emotional support available to students after drills or incidents. The district explained that drills are state-mandated twice per year, but also acknowledged staffing shortages in counselors and social workers. - Supervisor Dorsey commented on the link between bullying and school shootings, and thanked the youth for their advocacy. He also expressed frustration with Supreme Court rulings that have limited gun control. - Supervisor Stephanie highlighted that gun violence is the leading cause of death for children and teens, and praised the students' advocacy. Public Comments & Testimony - A speaker (name not given) expressed appreciation for the presentation but urged continued attention to active shooter preparedness, including door locks, PA systems, and communication with students. - Sarah Montoya, a Moms Demand Action volunteer and public school parent, stated that parents need more transparency and that students deserve better safety. She cited a teacher who feared for student safety. - Sophia, a student at Washington High School, said that lockdown drills are not conducted twice a year as required; the first in years just occurred. She also reported two bathroom fires on separate days with no parent notification. She noted wellness centers are understaffed, with wait times of up to six months for therapy, and that she had never heard of the Say Something system or seen posters. - Vincent Yi, a student at George Washington High School, echoed that Say Something was not advertised and stated that PA system upgrades have been promised for four years without delivery. He asked for accountability and a timeline for modernization. - Tom Peer, a 30-year San Francisco resident, praised the youth commission and encouraged engagement in social media regulation, referencing Senate hearings with tech CEOs. - Jen Nassakoff, a parent of a first grader, said her daughter has not had a lockdown drill, the campus is open, and there is a lack of communication. She stated the district is not prepared with technology or infrastructure. - Stephanie Falkenstein, a parent of a second grader and site council member, noted that Galileo High School's PA system failure also impacts adjacent elementary schools that evacuate there. She cited cases where principals being absent led to communication failures, and called for better oversight. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously (3 ayes) to hear and file the report, concluding the hearing without additional action. - SFUSD representatives committed to taking recommendations back to their team, including distributing hard copies of safe firearm storage information and improving communication channels. - The hearing highlighted ongoing concerns and areas for improvement, including PA system funding, student awareness of reporting systems, and mental health support resources.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Raphael Mandelman and Supervisor Myrna Melgar, met on January 31, 2024 to consider six agenda items. The primary focus was a hearing on the delayed renovation of the Richmond Senior Center, which has been largely closed since November 2022. The committee also reviewed a new lease for public health clinic space, two contract modifications for electrical supplies, and approvals for eight additional airlines to join the airport's lease and use agreement. Public Comments & Testimony - Richmond Senior Center hearing: Multiple seniors and community members testified about the hardship caused by the prolonged closure. Speakers described the center as a "second home" and noted the inconvenience of limited bathroom access, lack of programming space, and the loss of vital social connections. Kevin Casey, a five-year member, expressed disbelief that the center remained closed more than a year after the promised reopening. Amy Lee and other seniors pleaded for a concrete timeline to complete construction. Nick Letterer, Executive Director of Golden Gate Senior Services (which operates the center), provided historical context: the building was purchased in the late 1990s with assistance from former Supervisor Yaki to keep it in public use. He confirmed the center's desire to remain in the building and potentially expand to occupy the entire third floor. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Richmond Senior Center Renovation Progress: A hearing on the status of lead and asbestos remediation and construction at 6221 Geary Boulevard. The center, operated by Golden Gate Senior Services under a lease with Felton Institute, has been partially closed since November 2022. Department of Disability and Aging Services (DAS) reported that over 15,000 meals, 1,200 individual assists, and 1,500 hours of educational activities were provided in the current fiscal year before the closure, with marked reductions during the construction period. Department of Building Inspection (DBI) confirmed work began without permits, leading to a notice of violation in April 2023. A permit was issued in July 2023, but inspections were repeatedly delayed. Richmond Senior Center Director Colleta Walling detailed 14 months of communication breakdowns, unmet promises, and a second phase of work that was not disclosed until December 2022. Felton Institute CEO Al Gilbert acknowledged the building's age and scope uncertainties, including potential window replacement, but committed to retaining the property. Contractor Anthony Chu estimated 3–4 more months to complete the current scope (hallway, bathroom, emergency exit), pending inspections. - Item 2 – Real Property Lease at 755 and 759 South Van Ness Avenue: A resolution to approve a new 3-year-10-month lease for Department of Public Health outpatient mental health clinics at a starting annual base rent of approximately $626,146, with CPI-based escalations. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended a technical amendment to correct the rent amount in the resolution, increasing the stated figure. The committee continued the item for one week to allow the amendment due to the increase exceeding the title amount. - Items 3 & 4 – Contract Modifications for Electrical Supplies: Modifications to citywide contracts with Alameda Electrical Distributors ($600,000 increase, total $2.5M) and Buckles-Smith Electric Company ($2M increase, total $19.5M) to fund purchases through contract expiry dates while new solicitations are underway. Both contracts are “as-needed” with no guaranteed spending. The BLA recommended approval. - Items 5 & 6 – Airport Lease and Use Agreements: Resolution to add eight airlines (Airlingus, Flair Airlines, Hawaiian Airlines, JetBlue, Guitar Airways, TAP, and Starlux) to the 10-year airport lease and use agreement originally approved in June 2023, bringing the total to 48 signatory airlines. Projected revenues from these eight airlines over the remaining term are approximately $361 million. Key Outcomes - Item 1: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair. Supervisor Chan directed Contractor Anthony Chu to provide weekly written construction progress updates to Felton Institute, Richmond Senior Center, DAS, and her office, starting in February 2024. - Item 2: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to amend the resolution (to correct the rent amount) and continue the item to the February 7, 2024 committee meeting for final action. - Items 3 & 4: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the resolutions to the full Board with positive recommendation. - Items 5 & 6: The committee voted unanimously (3-0) to forward the resolutions to the full Board with positive recommendation.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened at 10:15 AM on Tuesday, January 30, 2024, for a regular meeting that included a 2:00 PM special appearance by Mayor London Breed, consideration of a consent agenda, several contested items, and introductions of new business. The meeting lasted into the early evening. Mayor's Appearance (2:00 PM Special Order) - Mayor London Breed delivered opening remarks highlighting a 30% decline in assaults and robberies on Mission Street following a street vending moratorium she implemented with Supervisor Hillary Ronen in November 2023, noting that 75% of businesses support continuing the moratorium. She also discussed the need to change state laws to better regulate street vending. - Supervisor Preston asked about a $10 million allocation for elevator repairs in single-room occupancy (SRO) hotels, approved in June 2022 but not yet released after 580 days. He requested the notice of funding availability (NOFA) be published by February 12, 2024. Mayor Breed declined to commit to a specific date but said she would work to expedite the process, acknowledging her department's responsibility and the urgency for residents with mobility issues. She mentioned exploring a sole-source approach due to limited contractors. Consent Calendar - Items 2 through 16 were approved unanimously via roll call (11-0). These included routine approvals such as: - Authorization of American Registry for Internet Numbers agreements. - Appropriation of $1,350,239 in tax increment revenue bond proceeds for Treasure Island infrastructure. - Acceptance of a $2,050,000 grant for organized retail theft vertical prosecution. - Several lawsuit settlements (e.g., $40,000 to Phaedra Michelle Scott, $190,000 to Alfred Coutts, $450,000 to Peyman Pakdel and Sima Chegini). - Adoption of building code and health code amendments. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment included: - A speaker urged the board to regulate cell phone warning labels regarding addictive effects. - A speaker criticized the board's response to violent rhetoric and offered to join nighttime street outreach. - A speaker alleged the mayor's office uses technology to hack social media and called for investigation of death threats. - A speaker requested help with a property dispute involving a neighbor's objections to repairs. - A speaker read a poem critical of supervisors who oppose a ceasefire in Gaza. - A speaker highlighted the fentanyl crisis and criticized Democratic leadership. - A former firefighter alleged department corruption and failure to act on attacks. - During public comment on the library item (Item 45), community members expressed support for the 100 Orizaba Avenue site, citing the need for a larger library in the underserved OMI neighborhoods. Discussion Items - Item 18 – Westwood Park Landmark Designation: Passed 10-1 (Supervisor Preston dissenting). - Item 19 – Soma Pilipinas Gateway Cultural Marker: Amended by Supervisor Dorsey to add references to public realm artworks and a bronze plaque contextualizing the Dewey Monument. Adopted unanimously as amended. - Item 20 – Overdose Prevention Initiative Grant: Passed without objection. - Item 21 – FY2023-2024 Mid-Year Budget Reductions ($48.4 million reserve): Passed without objection. - Item 31 – APEC-Related Overtime Costs ($6.5 million grant): Supervisor Chan noted the city spent approximately $20 million total on APEC, while also introducing a supplemental to support small businesses affected by the exclusion zone. - Item 32 – Pretrial Diversion Project Contract Amendment ($19.8 million): Passed 9-2 (Supervisors Stephanie and Dorsey voting no) after debate about lack of audits and financial reporting concerns. - Item 34 – Fire Code Amendment (Five-Foot Access and Sprinkler Inspection Fees): Initially faced opposition over potential conflict with state law (SB9), but after clarification from the fire marshal and city attorney, passed unanimously 11-0 on first reading. Sponsor Supervisor Chan emphasized fire safety and noted the ordinance had been vetted by the building inspection commission. - Item 45 – Library Site for Ocean View, Merced Heights, Ingleside, Lakeview (OMI) Neighborhoods: After extensive debate, Supervisor Safai offered amendments changing "shall require" to "prioritize" for the city-owned parcel at 100 Orizaba Avenue. The amendments passed 11-0, and the ordinance as amended passed 8-3 (Supervisors Dorsey, Mandelman, and Melgar dissenting). Supervisor Melgar argued the original language prohibited exploration of other sites, while Supervisor Safai and Supervisor Walton stressed the site was the only viable option after years of study and that the community deserved a new library after decades of broken promises. Key Outcomes - Consent Agenda: All items adopted unanimously. - Item 18 (Westwood Park Landmark): Passed 10-1. - Item 19 (Soma Pilipinas Marker): Adopted unanimously as amended. - Item 32 (Pretrial Diversion Contract): Passed 9-2. - Item 34 (Fire Code): Passed 11-0 on first reading. - Item 45 (OMI Library): Passed 8-3 on first reading as amended. - Items 49-51 (Adoption Without Committee Reference): Adopted unanimously. - Item 48 (Matthew Shepard Stamp): Amended and adopted unanimously. - Introductions: Supervisors introduced new items including a hearing on UCSF's acquisition of Dignity Health, a resolution opposing state affordable housing cuts, a request for a BLA report on Zurich's four-pillar drug strategy, a resolution declaring February 11 as 49er Day, and a resolution recognizing the 20th anniversary of the Winter of Love (same-sex marriage). Supervisor Peskin introduced a drafting request for campaign finance disclaimers linked to individuals making death threats. - Commendations: Recognitions were given to Coco Drake (Haight Ashbury Community Nursery School) and educators Sarah Liebert and Dr. Akiko Takahashi for their math pilot work. - Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned in memory of Lena Farrell.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee, chaired by Supervisor Hillary Ronin with Vice Chair Supervisor Walton and Supervisor Safai, met on January 29, 2024, to consider an ordinance requiring the new public library branch serving the Ocean View, Merced Heights, Ingleside, and Lakeview (OMI) neighborhoods to be built on city-owned land at 100 Orizaba Avenue. The ordinance also prohibits city funds from being used to explore alternative sites except as required by environmental review or other laws. After extensive discussion and public comment, the committee voted unanimously to recommend the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors. Public Comments & Testimony - Liz Rodriguez (Catholic Charities, OMI Community Collaborative) expressed support for a larger library to host intergenerational activities and prevent isolation for seniors. - Ann Marie Nowak (San Francisco resident) supported the new library, noting the current branch is overcrowded and that the community is growing and diverse. - Renard Monroe (Executive Director of Youth First, community resident) strongly supported the site, stating his youth programs must take shifts to use the current library and that the neighborhood deserves equity. - Mary Harris (President, All My Neighbors in Action) urged support, citing the library as a resource for children, families, and seniors and noting that the community does not want a church-nonprofit combination. - Eric (Rosetta Extension Triangle Neighborhood Association) voiced concerns about traffic safety at the proposed site (intersection of Brotherhood Way) and suggested a more pedestrian-friendly location near the M line. - Glenn Rogers opposed the greenbelt site, citing earthquake faults, organic soils, traffic dangers, and supported an alternative site at Randolph Street near the IT Bookman Center. - Andy Rice (Ocean View resident) opposed the site, arguing it would remove green space and is not accessible to many residents due to hills. - Two additional speakers opposed the project: one called the library "superfluous" and criticized spending on a green belt while the city faces a fentanyl crisis and poverty; another questioned the decision to place a library on an expressway and noted pedestrian safety hazards. Discussion Items - Supervisor Safai introduced the ordinance, providing extensive background. He stated that the current Ocean View library (9,000 sq ft) is the smallest in the city, and the community has outgrown it. He refuted Mayor Breed's December 2023 claims about lack of budget, traffic issues, and lack of consensus, citing a 2019 feasibility study that identified 100 Orizaba Avenue as the best site. He noted that $35 million from the library fund and a renewed preservation fund (passed in 2022) provide sufficient funding, with the library CFO previously calling the project "fully funded." He also referenced ongoing SFMTA traffic studies and a letter from SFMTA Director Tumlin stating that traffic improvements can proceed independently. - Andy Sohn (San Francisco Public Works architect) presented the site selection process, which evaluated five city-owned parcels on Brotherhood Way in 2019 using criteria such as neighborhood connectivity, proximity to transit (M train), and synergy with existing amenities (dog park, Tai Chi area). Option D at 100 Orizaba was the preferred site. - Supervisor Walton expressed strong support, emphasizing that libraries are essential for communities without means, providing access to technology and education. He noted that land is scarce and that resources have already been committed. - Supervisor Ronin echoed the need to move forward after five years of community process, calling libraries "neighborhood infrastructure." Key Outcomes - Motion to recommend the ordinance (File No. 240017) as a committee report to the full Board of Supervisors. - Vote: All three committee members voted aye (Vice Chair Walton, Supervisor Safai, Chair Ronin). Passed unanimously with no objections. - The ordinance is expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors' agenda on February 6, 2024. - No other items were on the agenda; the meeting was adjourned.