Browse by city
Date range
Search help

Search titles, summaries, topics and stored transcripts together. Keywords may match separately; put the whole query in double quotes for a phrase. Matching follows word analysis, so punctuation is not exact. Both dates are included. Documents are not searched.

SHOWING 911–920 ENTRIES
911
OCT 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · RULES COMMITTEE
Rules Committee Meeting – October 2, 2023: Appointments, Surveillance Policy, and Labor Code Updates

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Rules Committee met on Monday, October 2, 2023, at 10:00 AM (local time) under Chair Matt Dorsey, with Vice Chair Shimon Walton and Supervisor Asha Safai. The meeting began with a moment of remembrance for the late Senator Dianne Feinstein, a former San Francisco Board President and Mayor. The committee considered six agenda items: two reappointments to the Treasury Oversight Committee, one appointment to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force, adoption of a social media monitoring dashboard policy for the Department of Elections, a contractor debarment ordinance for labor law violations, and a code reorganization establishing a Labor and Employment Code. Consent Calendar - None explicitly designated, but all items were approved unanimously and moved to the full Board of Supervisors with positive recommendations. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Sunshine Ordinance Task Force): Jen Say, on behalf of the League of Women Voters of San Francisco, supported Maxine Anderson, citing her decades of active membership and commitment to government transparency. David Pilpel also supported Anderson, noting her passion and confirming that process improvements for sunshine requests are already being considered. - Item 4 (Elections Social Media Surveillance): David Pilpel expressed support, calling the department’s request a “reasonable use of technology” not mass surveillance. - Item 5 (Debarment for Labor Law Violations): Chema Hernandez Gill (SEIU Local 1021) supported the ordinance, stating it should only apply to the worst actors. Debbie Lerman (San Francisco Human Services Network) raised unresolved questions about safeguards in the debarment process, urging continued dialogue to avoid unjust pressure on employers, especially in human services. - Item 6 (Labor and Employment Code): David Pilpel questioned the need for a new code but accepted it if it was the best way to achieve the goal. Discussion Items - Items 1 & 2 – Treasury Oversight Committee Reappointments: Chair Dorsey introduced Brenda Kwee McNulty and Aimee Brown, both renominated by Treasurer Jose Cisneros. McNulty highlighted her MBA in finance and 33 years in financial services, including past service on the Citizens General Obligation Bonds committee. Brown emphasized 30 years in public finance, experience as a financial advisor to the SFPUC, and prior leadership on the Revenue Bond Oversight Committee. Both were approved without questions. - Item 3 – Sunshine Ordinance Task Force Appointment: Maxine Anderson, nominated by the League of Women Voters, spoke about her journey from voter registration to advocacy for government transparency. Chair Dorsey raised the possibility of IT improvements to streamline sunshine requests; Anderson agreed, noting funding challenges. The committee voted unanimously to recommend her appointment. - Item 4 – Department of Elections Social Media Monitoring Policy: Director John Arntz explained the proposed software (e.g., Hootsuite or Sprout) as a dashboard to unify social media accounts and schedule posts. He clarified the tool does not track individuals but aggregates engagement metrics. The policy went through the Committee on Information Technology (COIT) process starting in 2022. The committee approved unanimously. - Item 5 – Contractor Debarment for Labor Law Violations: Supervisor Connie Chan presented the ordinance to add wage theft and unfair labor practices as grounds for suspension or debarment of city contractors. She cited support from the Chinese Progressive Association and noted that debarment requires egregious violations proven through state or federal labor law. Supervisor Walton and Safai expressed strong support; Safai requested to be added as a co-sponsor, as did Chair Dorsey. Chan acknowledged Human Services Network concerns and committed to continuing discussions, possibly offering amendments on the full board floor. - Item 6 – Establishing the Labor and Employment Code: Supervisor Safai described the ordinance as a code cleanup that renumbers existing worker protection laws (19 in Division I for all employees, 9 in Division II for city contractors) and removes three expired COVID-19 laws. No substantive changes were made. The committee approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Item 1 & 2: Motion to strike “reject” from the motions and send both appointments to the full board with positive recommendations – passed 3-0. - Item 3: Motion to recommend Maxine Anderson to the Sunshine Ordinance Task Force – passed 3-0. - Item 4: Motion to send the Surveillance Technology Policy for the Department of Elections to the full board with a positive recommendation – passed 3-0. - Item 5: Motion to send the Suspension/Debarment Ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation – passed 3-0. Supervisor Chan committed to ongoing discussions with stakeholders before the October 17 board hearing. - Item 6: Motion to send the Labor and Employment Code to the full board with a positive recommendation for the October 17 board meeting – passed 3-0. All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on October 17, 2023.

LABOR RELATIONS 34% · PERSONNEL MATTERS 26% · PUBLIC COMMENT 25% · PROCEDURAL 6%
912
OCT 2, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
San Francisco Land Use Committee: Shelley Drive Promenade, Affordable Housing Leases, and Housing Production Debate - October 2, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Land Use and Transportation Committee met on October 2, 2023, to consider four items: a permanent closure of a portion of John F. Shelley Drive to vehicles in McLaren Park, delegation of authority to amend ground leases for 100% affordable housing projects, a zoning change for nighttime entertainment in the Castro, and a major housing production ordinance aimed at reducing constraints. The meeting included extensive public comment and deliberation, resulting in several votes and continuances. Item 1: Park Code – John F. Shelley Drive Road Closure Discussion: Brian Stokel (Rec & Parks) presented the proposal to permanently restrict private vehicles on a 2,100-foot segment of Shelley Drive in McLaren Park, creating a car-free promenade. The plan has been piloted since 2020 and received unanimous support at a community meeting. The ordinance is co-sponsored by Mayor Breed and Supervisor Walton. Public Comments: All speakers (Zach Lipton, Linda Stark Lightheiser, Luke Bornheimer, Amy Callender, Scott Feeney, Jake Price, Joseph Nelson, Martha Lindsay, Kate Bloomberg) expressed strong support. One speaker (David Pilpel) suggested the proposal should have been reviewed by the Park, Recreation, and Open Space Advisory Committee (PROZAC) but did not oppose. Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to forward the ordinance to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. Item 2: Administrative Code – Delegation of Authority to Amend Leases for 100% Affordable Housing Discussion: Jackie Zhou (MOHCD) presented legislation to streamline approval for amending ground leases for 12 specific affordable housing projects, making residual receipts policy consistent with current practice. Amendments were adopted to narrow the scope and clarify that only lease amendments related to residual receipts are delegated, not changes to term, rent, or other terms. Public Comments: Supporters (Sam Moss, Chris Cummings, Yelena Zilgrafane, Whitney Jones, Jana Jackson) argued the change allows nonprofits to reinvest residual receipts into capital improvements and other properties. One speaker (David Pilpel) opposed, arguing the delegation violates Charter Section 9.118. Outcome: The committee adopted two amendments by Supervisor Peskin (deleting “enter into” and adding clarifying language) and then voted unanimously to send the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Item 3: Planning Code – Nighttime Entertainment in Castro Street Neighborhood Commercial District Discussion: Supervisor Mandelman requested a two-week continuance because the planning commission’s recommended amendment was not yet prepared. Public Comments: None. Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to continue the item to October 16, 2023. Item 4: Planning Code – Housing Production (Constraints Reduction) Discussion: This large ordinance (sponsored by Mayor Breed, Supervisor Dorsey) seeks to streamline housing approvals by removing certain conditional use and notification requirements, expanding the HOME-SF program, and creating a Priority Equity Geographies (PEG) Special Use District. Chair Melgar introduced amendments to preserve protections in her Family Housing Opportunity SUD (e.g., maintaining CUs for demolitions, preserving rent control protections). The planning department’s recommended amendments (including adding the Calle 24 Cultural District to the PEG SUD) were also adopted. Supervisor Mandelman raised concerns about potential loss of board-and-care homes, monster homes, and tenant protections, and indicated he would propose further amendments. Supervisor Preston questioned whether the ordinance allows demolition of two rent-controlled units and suggested aligning with Melgar’s SUD (limit to one unit). The mayor’s office and planning director indicated openness to further changes. Public Comments: Over 50 speakers, with a majority (from the REP Coalition, Anti-Displacement Coalition, tenant groups, and labor) opposing the legislation as a giveaway to developers that undermines tenant protections and affordable housing. Supporters (Housing Action Coalition, architects, YIMBYs) urged passage to meet state housing element commitments and avoid state intervention. Outcome: The committee voted unanimously to adopt the planning department’s amendments and the Melgar amendments, then continued the item to October 16, 2023, for further discussion and potential additional amendments. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved to full board (unanimous). - Item 2: Approved to full board as amended (unanimous). - Item 3: Continued to October 16, 2023. - Item 4: Continued to October 16, 2023, after adopting two sets of amendments. The meeting adjourned at approximately 1:45 PM.

HOUSING 35% · PUBLIC COMMENT 19% · AFFORDABLE HOUSING 14% · CHARTER AMENDMENTS 7%
913
SEP 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC SAFETY AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES COMMITTEE
Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee – September 28, 2023

The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee held a hybrid meeting on September 28, 2023, chaired by Supervisor Catherine Stefani. The committee reviewed seven agenda items, including liquor license transfers, a resolution supporting gun violence victims, a police code amendment regarding armed guards, a hearing on accidental overdose deaths, and a hearing on traffic enforcement. The meeting ran from approximately 6:15 PM to late evening. Liquor License Transfers (Items 1 & 2) - Item 1 (779 Bush Street – Ad Hoc): The committee heard a proposal for a type 48 on-sale general license transfer to 790 Bush Ventures Inc. SFPD reported zero letters of protest or support, and the alcohol liaison unit recommended approval with conditions. Public comment included one caller making antisemitic remarks, which were immediately cut off. The committee voted unanimously to send a positive recommendation to the full board. - Item 2 (999 Valencia Street – Valencia Whole Foods): A type 20 off-sale beer and wine license transfer to Valencia WF Inc. was considered. SFPD reported 10 letters of protest, 3 letters of support, and 1 petition in favor. The applicant, Lana Nizal, noted the store has been in the Mission for 30 years and seeks to meet customer demand. No public comments were offered. The committee voted unanimously to recommend approval. Resolution: Urging Creation of Programming and Resources for Victims of Gun Violence (Item 4) - Presentation: Supervisor Connie Chan introduced the resolution, noting 139 shooting victims in 2022 (67% Black and Brown) and the new state law AB 1594 allowing victims to sue firearm manufacturers. DPH’s Stephanie Felder committed to developing multilingual educational materials by January 2024. Monifa Willis from the DA’s office described victim services and challenges in confidentiality. Dr. Sarah Metz from UCSF Trauma Recovery Center outlined wraparound care. Supervisor Chan offered amendments to correct clerical errors and adjust the timeline to January 2024. - Public Comment: Several callers spoke; one made racist remarks and was cut off. Another speaker, Joe Cunzler, a gun violence survivor, praised Supervisor Stefani’s leadership. - Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to approve amendments and send the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation. Ordinance: Police Code – Drawing of Firearms by Armed Guards (Item 3) - Presentation: Supervisor Dean Preston introduced the ordinance in response to the killing of Banko Brown by a security guard. The measure deletes “or property” from sections 1750.19 and 1750.20 of the Police Code, aligning local law with state standards that allow drawing a firearm only when there is an imminent threat to life. Co-sponsors include Supervisors Walton, Chan, and Peskin. - Discussion: Supervisor Dorsey noted consistency with police department general orders. Supervisor Safai expressed support and mentioned ongoing work on broader Article 25 reforms. Supervisor Stefani added herself as a co-sponsor. - Public Comment: Speakers included Jordan (“pass Banko’s Law”), Jafrea Morris (Black Women Revolt), and others. One caller made racist remarks and was cut off. - Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to recommend the ordinance to the full board. Hearing: Accidental Overdose Death Report – Departmental Responses (Item 6) - Background: Supervisor Ahsha Safai convened the hearing, noting San Francisco has the seventh-highest overdose rate among large U.S. cities. In 2023, the city is on track for its deadliest year, with fentanyl present in 81% of accidental overdose deaths. Data from the Medical Examiner shows 563 deaths in the first eight months of 2023, a 20% increase over 2022. - Presentations: - Medical Examiner: Dr. Link Ruther reported that cases have increased fourfold since 2019, with fentanyl driving the crisis. 83.5% of victims were male, 55% people of color, and 68% had a fixed address. - District Attorney Brooke Jenkins: Noted a 90% filing rate on drug cases, 1,000+ cases filed, and 248 detention motions filed but only 19 granted. She called for thorough death investigations to tie dealers to overdoses and for treating fentanyl sales as a public safety emergency. - SFPD Commander Derek Louis: Described the Drug Market Agency Coordination Center (DMAC) and reported a 58% increase in drug user arrests and 80% increase in drug trafficking arrests year-to-date. Fentanyl seizures rose 132% to 218 pounds. - DPH Director Dr. Hillary Kunins: Outlined prevention efforts, including distributing over 72,000 naloxone doses in 2023, expanding medication-assisted treatment, and launching a public data dashboard. She noted racial disparities: Black residents account for 6% of the population but 30-32% of overdose deaths. DPH operates approximately 2,500 beds, with a 5% vacancy rate. - HSH Deputy Director Emily Cohen: Reported 234 overdoses in shelter and housing programs in FY 2022-23, with 60% documented reversals. She highlighted efforts to increase naloxone access and develop clean-and-sober housing options. - Public Comment: Speakers advocated for evidence-based public health approaches and criticized enforcement measures. One caller made antisemitic remarks and was cut off. - Outcome: The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair for further follow-up on investigations and treatment capacity. Ordinance: Health Code – Requiring Retail Pharmacies to Stock Opioid Antagonists (Item 5) - Presentation: Supervisor Dorsey sponsored the ordinance, which requires retail pharmacies to stock at least two boxes of an opioid antagonist (e.g., naloxone). Dr. Jeff Hom from DPH noted that about 25% of pharmacies currently do not stock naloxone, and the legislation mirrors a successful policy in Philadelphia. Over-the-counter naloxone recently became available. - Public Comment: One caller questioned the approach, suggesting community ambassadors instead. - Outcome: The committee voted 3-0 to send the ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Hearing: Traffic Enforcement and Street Safety (Item 7) - Presentation: Supervisor Rafi Mandelman led the hearing, noting that traffic citations dropped from about 350 per day in 2014 to 10-11 per day currently, while 2022 was the deadliest year for traffic fatalities since 2007. Commander Nicole Jones of SFPD’s Special Operations Bureau presented data showing a 42% decrease in traffic fatalities in the first two quarters of 2023 compared to 2022, but overall citation numbers remain low. Factors include staffing shortages (606 officers short of baseline), increased administrative burdens from state laws (RIPA, body-worn cameras), and a shift toward directed operations and educational enforcement. The traffic division has only 46 sworn officers, down from 77 in 2014. The Vision Zero squad was disbanded in 2020. - Discussion: Supervisor Mandelman asked about the Valencia Street bike lane enforcement and use of drones for sideshows. Public comment included calls for better data transparency and focus on high-injury network. - Outcome: The committee voted to continue the hearing to the call of the chair, with Commander Jones expected to present a more detailed enforcement plan in the first quarter of 2024. Key Outcomes - Liquor License Transfers (Items 1 & 2): Both recommended to full board with positive recommendation (unanimous). - Gun Violence Resolution (Item 4): Approved amendments and recommended to full board (3-0). - Police Code Amendment (Item 3): Recommended to full board (3-0). - Overdose Hearing (Item 6): Continued to call of the chair for further follow-up. - Opioid Antagonist Ordinance (Item 5): Recommended to full board (3-0). - Traffic Enforcement Hearing (Item 7): Continued to call of the chair; enforcement plan expected by early 2024.

SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER POLICY 28% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · TRANSPORTATION SAFETY 11% · PUBLIC COMMENT 10%
914
SEP 28, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PLANNING COMMISSION
San Francisco Planning Commission Meeting Summary – September 28, 2023

The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on September 28, 2023, at 9:15 AM. The Commission acted on a consent calendar, several conditional use authorizations, a state-mandated ADU ordinance, certification of the Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR), a General Plan referral, and a discretionary review. Votes were taken on multiple items, with notable divisions on ADU controls and a residential care facility conversion. Consent Calendar - The Commission voted unanimously (7-0) to continue four items proposed for continuance (2261 Fillmore Street to Nov 2, 2023; two density/planning code amendments to Oct 26, 2023; 555 9th Street CUA withdrawn). - The Commission also approved the consent calendar (items 5, 6, 8, 9, 10) unanimously, with the exception of item 7 (725 Sanchez Street) which was continued to Oct 5, 2023. - The Commission adopted the draft minutes of September 7, 2023, unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Georgia Shutish urged codifying the residential flat policy. Eileen Vogen (Speak) questioned the city's growth strategy given projected population decline of 2.9% by 2060. - Item 16 (ADU Ordinance): Mark Hogan (OpenScope Studio) supported the ordinance but urged further alignment with state law. - Item 17-18 (Ocean Beach): Zach Lipton (Friends of Great Highway Park) supported EIR certification. Several callers raised concerns about evacuation routes, vehicle miles traveled, erosion data, and zoo access. The San Francisco Zoological Society representative noted no studies of impacts on zoo animals and called for feasible mitigation. - Item 19 (213 Upper Terrace): Jeffrey Dito, a neighbor, supported approval. - Item 20 (2214 Mission Street): Multiple speakers (Marcel Yang, Andrew, and others) supported the outdoor dining expansion. Two neighbors (Joel Becker and a caller) objected to amplified music events, citing a Sept 17 concert that violated noise conditions. Other callers defended the restaurant's community role. - Item 21 (2277 33rd Avenue): Kelly Growth (Supervisor Chan's office) requested postponement. Annie Chung (CEO, Self-Help for the Elderly) opposed conversion, stating that licensed RCFEs in San Francisco declined from 144 in 2012 to 53 in 2023, and that her nonprofit had expressed interest in acquiring the property. - Item 22 (DR – 3748 22nd Street): Mark Spencer (neighbor) supported the DR requesters' modifications. Eileen Vogen urged mapping of DRs brought before the commission. Discussion Items - Item 11: Land Acknowledgement – Commission acknowledged the Ramaytush Ohlone as original inhabitants. - Commission Comments/Questions: Commissioner Moore discussed "pod" housing; Director Hillis confirmed an enforcement case. Director Hillis reported on state bills (SB 2423 extending SB 35) and office-to-residential conversion progress. - Item 15: Review of Past Events – Aaron Starr reported on land use committee actions, including the mayor's constraints reduction ordinance continued to Oct 2, 2023. - Item 16: State-Mandated ADU Controls (2023-003061PCA) – Staff presented amendments to align local code with AB 2221 and SB 897. A new recommended modification excluded ADUs from dwelling unit mix requirements. Commissioner Moore and Diamond questioned the definition of "high quality transit corridor" and 18-foot height allowances. The Commission approved (5-2) with Imperial and Moore voting no. - Items 17-18: Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project – Staff presented the Final EIR and General Plan Referral for closing a portion of the Great Highway, constructing a buried wall, and beach nourishment. Significant unavoidable impacts were identified. The EIR was certified unanimously (7-0), and the General Plan conformity findings were adopted unanimously. - Item 19: 213 Upper Terrace CUA – Proposal to demolish a single-family home and build a two-unit building (primary unit 3,660 sq ft, secondary unit 1,333 sq ft). Commissioner Moore argued for unit equity within the Corona Heights special use district 3,000 sq ft limit. The Commission approved (5-2) with Imperial and Moore voting no. - Item 20: 2214 Mission Street CUA – Request to create an outdoor activity area and expand alcohol service for Restaurant Probetchu. Conditions prohibited amplified music outdoors. Commissioner Diamond proposed amending condition 19 to require entertainment commission permits for any outdoor music. The Commission approved unanimously (7-0) with that modification. - Item 21: 2277 33rd Avenue CUA – Conversion of a vacant residential care facility (nine bedrooms) back to a single-family home (four bedrooms). Supervisor Chan requested postponement for more data on RCFE trends. The Commission continued the item to November 2, 2023 (6-1, Diamond dissenting), citing need for additional information. - Item 22: 3748 22nd Street Discretionary Review – Neighbors sought modifications (five-foot stepback and removal of a closet) to a rear addition. The public hearing concluded; the transcript does not record the Commission's decision. Key Outcomes - ADU ordinance approved (5-2) with staff modifications. - Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project Final EIR certified and General Plan Referral adopted (both 7-0). - 213 Upper Terrace CUA approved (5-2). - 2214 Mission Street CUA approved (7-0) with added condition on outdoor music permits. - 2277 33rd Avenue CUA continued to Nov 2, 2023 (6-1). - Discretionary Review for 3748 22nd Street: hearing closed, no final decision recorded in provided transcript.

CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION 17% · PUBLIC COMMENT 16% · LAND USE 11% · PROCEDURAL 10%
915
SEP 27, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BUDGET AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
SF Budget and Finance Committee Meeting Advances Grants and Continues Housing Bond on September 27, 2023

The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Wednesday, September 27, 2023, at 18:15 (UTC) to consider a series of grant acceptances, agreements, and bond proposals. The committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Asha Safai, voted unanimously to forward most items to the full Board with positive recommendations. Two competing affordable housing bond proposals were continued to the October 25, 2023 committee meeting to allow for further discussion. The meeting included presentations from department heads and budget analyst reports. Consent Calendar - All resolutions on the regular agenda were considered as a consent calendar, with each item receiving individual discussion and a roll call vote. Public Comments & Testimony - A recurring public commenter, Mr. Phil, spoke on multiple items (1, 2, 3, 4-6, 7-9, and 10-11) repeatedly urging all officials to declare any conflicts of interest, stating that transparency is required to avoid "opacity" and achieve positive outcomes. He also expressed a general need to "slow down" on large projects, particularly the housing bond. Discussion Items Item 1: Accept Grant – National Institutes of Health (NIH) – Drug Abuse Clinical Trials (Resolution 230931) - Presenter: Philip Coffin, Director of the Center on Substance Use and Health, Department of Public Health. - Summary: This resolution retroactively authorized acceptance of an expanded grant from the NIH through Oregon Health & Science University for the Western States Node of the National Drug Abuse Treatment Clinical Trials Network. The expansion covers March 1, 2023–February 29, 2024, bringing the total grant award to approximately $109,937 for the full period of June 1, 2020–February 29, 2024. Director Coffin explained the grant supports his participation in clinical trials testing medications for substance use disorders, including the current "Curb 2" trial using two medications to treat cocaine use disorder. He noted the item was retroactive because the cumulative grant amount exceeded the $100,000 threshold requiring Board approval. - Committee Action: Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed 2-0 (Safai absent). Item 2: Maintenance Agreement with Caltrans – Southern Skyline Boulevard Ridge Trail (Resolution 230909) - Presenter: Mary Teakin, Project Manager, SFPUC; John Fournay, Water Operations Analyst, SFPUC. - Summary: This resolution approved a no-cost, project-specific maintenance agreement with Caltrans for SFPUC's ongoing maintenance of improvements at 18 locations within Caltrans right-of-way along a six-mile section of State Route 35 in San Mateo County, as part of the Southern Skyline Boulevard Ridge Trail Extension Project. The project will construct six miles of multi-use trail, a universal access loop, parking, bathrooms, a pedestrian bridge, and security fencing. The agreement is required for an encroachment permit, is for the life of the assets (more than 10 years), and assigns routine maintenance responsibilities to SFPUC while Caltrans retains vegetation management. Supervisor Safai expressed concerns about Caltrans's performance in her district but noted the PUC's positive experience on the Peninsula. - Committee Action: Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed 3-0. Item 3: Reauthorize CleanPowerSF Participation in Joint Powers Authority (Resolution 230904) - Presenter: Mike Himes, Deputy Assistant General Manager for CleanPowerSF, SFPUC; Nick Menard, Budget and Legislative Analyst. - Summary: This resolution reauthorized CleanPowerSF's participation costs in the California Community Power (CC Power) Joint Powers Authority, a consortium of community choice aggregators, with a not-to-exceed amount of approximately $4,772,710 over 25 years (January 1, 2024–December 31, 2048), including a 5% annual escalator. It would increase annual administrative payments from $50,000 to $100,000 (with escalation). The BLA recommended approval. Himes noted CC Power has nine member organizations representing over 3 million customer accounts, and CleanPowerSF benefits from joint procurement of renewable energy projects. Chair Chan asked about ongoing advocacy for labor and environmental justice principles; Himes confirmed staff will follow SFPUC Commission Resolution 23-0138 in all CC Power discussions. The committee expressed strong support for CleanPowerSF and community choice aggregation. - Committee Action: Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor. Motion to forward with positive recommendation passed 3-0. Items 4–6: District Attorney Grants and Agreements (Resolutions 230930, 230932, 230933) - Presenter: Tina Nunes (Managing Attorney, Economic Crimes Unit) for Item 4; Monifa Willis (Chief of Victim Services) for Items 5 and 6. - Summary: - Item 4 (Resolution 230930) retroactively authorized acceptance of a $1,066,724 grant from the California Department of Insurance for the Workers' Compensation Insurance Fraud Program for July 1, 2023–June 30, 2024. Nunes explained the funds support two DA investigators and partially fund three DA attorneys, plus necessary training. She called insurance fraud a "tax" on consumers and businesses and highlighted its impact on the self-insured city. - Item 5 (Resolution 230932) authorized renewal of a $75,000 revolving fund agreement with the California Victim Compensation Board to provide emergency payments to crime victims who would suffer hardship, for July 1, 2023–June 30, 2026. Willis noted the program has been held for 20 years and speeds up fund release by about two weeks; about $3,000 was paid out in the current fiscal year. - Item 6 (Resolution 230933) authorized acceptance of up to $275,391 over three annual periods (FY2023-24 through FY2025-26) for the Criminal Restitution Compact, which funds one FTE staff member dedicated to recovering restitution from offenders to reimburse Cal VCB. Willis noted the staff member has $117,000 in restitution orders in various stages of recovery in 2023. - Chair Chan noted the DA's office served nearly 10,000 victims in 2022 and indicated a future hearing on victims' compensation and restitution for gun violence victims. - Committee Action: Vice Chair Mandelman added as co-sponsor for all three items. Motion to forward all three with positive recommendation passed 3-0. Items 7–9: Probation Department Grants (Resolutions 230938, 230836, 230837) - Presenter: Taris Madison, Deputy Director of Finance and Administration, Department of Adult Probation. - Summary: These resolutions authorized the Adult Probation Department to accept multiple grants: - Items 7 and 9 (Resolutions 230937 and 230938): $100,000 each from the California Emergency Management Agency for the Probation Specialized Supervision Program, federally funded through the Violence Against Women Act. Item 9 was retroactive for October 1, 2022–September 30, 2023; Item 7 covers October 1, 2023–September 30, 2024. These funds cover about 30% of a deputy probation officer's salary for enhanced field supervision and outreach to domestic violence victims. The state now requires separate Board resolutions for these grants. - Item 8 (Resolution 230836): approximately $507,470 from the Board of State and Community Corrections for the Mobile Probation Service Centers Grant Program, funded through the Budget Act of 2022, for May 1, 2023–September 30, 2027. This new program will purchase two vans equipped as mobile probation offices to bring services to probationers, particularly those who are unhoused, in neighborhoods where they live. Chair Chan expressed enthusiasm for the mobile service approach. - Committee Action: Motion to forward all three with positive recommendation passed 3-0. Items 10–11: Affordable Housing Bond Proposals (Resolutions 230970, 230972) - Summary: Two competing resolutions proposed a $300,000,000 general obligation bond for affordable housing, to be placed on the ballot. Item 10 would fund rental affordable housing projects and a down payment assistance loan program for homeownership; Item 11 would fund only rental housing projects. Both would allow landlords to pass through 50% of the property tax increase to tenants. The proposals require independent citizen oversight and regular audits. Chair Chan announced that discussions are ongoing and that she would continue both items to the October 25, 2023 Budget and Finance Committee meeting to allow for further negotiation. - Committee Action: Motion to continue both items to October 25, 2023 passed 3-0. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (2-0, Safai absent). - Item 2: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 4–6: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 7–9: Forwarded to full Board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Items 10–11: Continued to October 25, 2023, Budget and Finance Committee meeting (3-0). The meeting adjourned after concluding all business.

PUBLIC SAFETY 23% · PUBLIC COMMENT 20% · PROCEDURAL 16% · ENGINEERING AND INFRASTRUCTURE 16%
916
SEP 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Meeting - September 26, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held its regular meeting on September 26, 2023, at 9:30 AM. The meeting covered a range of topics including the General Manager's report (recognizing retirees, introducing the new Chief Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Officer, budget update, capital project updates), a Bay Area Water Supply and Conservation Agency (BAWSCA) update, approval of consent calendar items, award of racial equity consulting contracts, amendments to the Social Impact Partnership Program rules, adoption of revised Rules of Order moving public comment earlier, and items initiated by commissioners. The commission also entered closed session to discuss litigation settlements and a performance evaluation. Consent Calendar - Items 5a–5i: Approved unanimously (4-0). Included modifications and awards of job order contracts for general engineering, HVAC energy efficiency, as-needed engineering design services, Hetchy capital improvement construction management, the Southern Skyline Boulevard Ridge Trail Extension ($20,523,445, 543 days), contingency increases for sewer replacement, correction of a previous resolution, and a sole source finding for pumps. Public Comments & Testimony - Gwen Jackson Fagan (on item 3C and item 6): Expressed hope that the $8.8 billion capital budget could be used to repair aging infrastructure at 1800 Oakdale and preserve it as a legacy. Also asked about the location of the racial equity plan and who is involved. - Peter Dreckmeyer (Tuolumne River Trust, on items 3C, 8, and 10): Supported decoupling of rates and environmental stewardship metrics such as salmon population. Expressed concern that the alternative water supply plan could lead to overinvestment and rate increases, and criticized the commission for not considering earlier runoff impacts from climate change in the design drought analysis. He thanked the commission for moving general public comment to the beginning of the agenda, calling the previous placement a way to punish the public. - Dave Warner (on items 8 and 10): Thanked the commission for moving public comment earlier and highlighted a letter comparing San Diego’s rate increases after investing in alternative water supplies to SFPUC’s own WISIP investment and cautioning against overinvestment. - Vince Courtney (Northern California Laborers, on item 7): Praised the Social Impact Partnership Program rules for their transparency and offered to engage in workforce development, pre-apprenticeship, and apprenticeship programs. Discussion Items - Report of the General Manager - 3A – Retirement Recognition: 21 retirees honored with over 25 years of service (combined decades of experience). Commissioners and staff expressed gratitude and concern about replacing such deep institutional knowledge. - 3B – Introduction of Dr. Christian Bijou: New Chief Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Officer (started July 10, 2023). Commissioners welcomed him and emphasized his role in implementing the Racial Equity Action Plan (REAP), moving from analysis to solutions, and transparent reporting. Dr. Bijou stated he has streamlined REAP from 7 to 4 priority pillars. - 3C – FY 2025-26 Biannual Budget Update: CFO Nancy Hom presented the operating and capital budget process, priorities (affordability, responsible management, investing where it matters), and the $8.8 billion 10-year capital plan. President Ajami proposed decoupling water rates from consumption and suggested hiring energy rate consultants. Commissioner Stacy noted the interrelation of priorities. Commissioner Maxwell supported a climate/environmental lens. - 3D – Hetch Hetchy Capital Improvement Program Quarterly Report: Katie Miller reported Q4 milestones: 33% overall spend ($255M), 7 projects in construction, key progress on O’Shaughnessy Dam outlet works and transmission line upgrades. Commissioner Maxwell questioned construction management cost increases; staff explained they reflect needed expert supervision for electrical projects. President Ajami urged using modern tools for early detection of pipe failures. - 3E – Wastewater Enterprise Quarterly Report: Bessie Tam reported no cost variances, awarded two construction contracts, and highlighted progress on Biosolids and Headworks projects. Addressed community concerns about paving restoration on the Womona project; staff had committed to timely repairs. - Item 4 – BAWSCA Update: CEO Nicole Sandkulla provided updates on negotiations for a new Tier 2 Drought Allocation Plan (current plan from 2009, extended yearly), a new long-term water supply strategy (Strategy 2045), and customer conservation programs. President Ajami noted increased wholesale deliveries and asked about participation statistics. - Item 6 – Award of Racial Equity Consulting Contracts (PRO.0240.A-B): Two contracts to AECOM ($9.5M) and Rosales Building Partners/G-CAP Joint Venture ($9.5M) for five years. Dr. Bijou and General Manager Herrera emphasized this is a task-order-based, internally supervised effort. Commissioners expressed initial apprehension but were assured that the PUC would retain intellectual property and build internal capacity. Approved 4-0. - Item 7 – Amendments to Social Impact Partnership Program (SIPP) Rules: Technical amendments to comply with a citywide suspension order affecting certain entities. Approved 4-0. - Item 8 – Revised Rules of Order (Move Public Comment Earlier): Changed Rule 16 to place general public comment earlier in the agenda. Approved 4-0, effective next meeting. - Item 11 – Items Initiated by Commissioners: None. - Closed Session (Items 14–16): Conference with legal counsel regarding settlement of existing litigation (Madison Collane – $40,000 settlement) and anticipated litigation (Sentinel Insurance – $100,000 settlement), both subject to Board of Supervisors approval. Public employee performance evaluation of General Manager Dennis Herrera. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved (4-0). - Item 6 (Racial Equity Consulting Contracts): Approved (4-0). Total not-to-exceed $19 million over 5 years. - Item 7 (SIPP Rules Amendments): Approved (4-0). - Item 8 (Revised Rules of Order): Approved (4-0). - Closed Session Motions: The commission voted (4-0) to assert attorney-client privilege. After closed session, the commission recommended the Board of Supervisors approve the two settlements and selected Commissioner Maxwell as the Commission's representative labor negotiator for the performance evaluation of the General Manager.

PROCEDURAL 49% · WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 11% · HUMAN RESOURCES 8% · BUDGET AND FINANCE 7%
917
SEP 26, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
San Francisco Board of Supervisors Regular Meeting - September 26, 2023

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors convened on Tuesday, September 26, 2023, at 2:15 p.m. for a regular meeting. All 11 supervisors were present. The meeting included a consent calendar, regular agenda items, a special order for a Committee of the Whole hearing on Laguna Honda Hospital, and introductions of new legislation. Key actions included the failure of a contested office lease, passage of development impact fee reductions, and adoption of the final San Francisco Reparations Plan. Consent Calendar - Items 1–3 (routine ordinances) were approved unanimously on a roll call vote of 11 ayes. - Items 4–14 (including resolutions authorizing expenditures, contract amendments, lease approvals, property tax rate setting, and emergency declarations) were adopted on same house same call without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: Multiple speakers addressed the board. Many spoke in support of bringing back eighth-grade algebra, citing equity and opportunity for STEM careers. Taxi drivers and advocates urged the city to address the decline of the taxi industry, including bailouts and fair competition with ride-share apps. Other speakers raised concerns about street conditions, fencing operations, and the need for police action on crime. One speaker criticized the city’s arts funding allocation. A parent opposed the algebra ballot measure, arguing it undermines the district’s equity-focused curriculum. Several callers made offensive remarks that were cut off by the presiding officer. - Committee of the Whole Public Comment: A few members of the public provided testimony on Laguna Honda Hospital. One speaker praised the progress but called for ongoing oversight and quarterly board hearings. A nurse criticized past management and urged the city to ensure the facility never faces decertification again. Some callers offered unrelated commentary. Discussion Items - Item 15 – Office Lease at 1155 Market Street (Recommendation: Do Not Pass): The Budget and Finance Committee recommended rejecting the lease due to unfavorable market conditions and the city’s opportunity to purchase property instead. Supervisor Chan, committee chair, urged a no vote. The board voted 11-0 to reject the resolution, effectively killing the lease. - Item 19 – Development Impact Fee Reductions (Planning Code Amendments): The ordinance reduced inclusionary housing requirements for small projects (10–24 units). Supervisor Preston opposed, citing evidence that such reductions do not spur new development and may hinder affordable housing creation. Supervisor Safai argued it would make smaller projects feasible and address the housing crisis. The vote was 10-1 (Preston voting no), and the ordinance passed on first reading. - Item 20 – Tenant Organizing Ordinance (Administrative Code Amendment): The ordinance strengthened tenant rights to be accompanied by tenant association representatives at meetings with landlords and clarified good faith obligations. It passed unanimously, 11-0. - Committee Reports (Items 22–24): Three resolutions were adopted on same house same call: a $60.8 million HUD Continuum of Care grant application, a $47.39 million loan for permanent supportive housing at 440 Geary Street, and a $14.24 million property acquisition at 42 Otis Street for homelessness services. - Committee of the Whole – Laguna Honda Hospital Recertification: The board held a public hearing on the hospital’s strategy for recertification. Roland Pickens, Director of the San Francisco Health Network, and new CEO Sandra Simon presented. Key updates: The California Department of Public Health and Department of Health Care Services recertified Laguna Honda in Medicaid (effective September 5, 2023), covering 95% of residents. An application for Medicare recertification is pending, with a full CMS survey expected at any time. New admissions will not resume until after the Medicare survey and plan of correction are completed. Former residents who were transferred will be given priority for readmission. The 120 “triplet” beds remain offline pending a CMS waiver, but the city plans to restore them. The board filed the hearing after public comment. Key Outcomes - Item 15 (1155 Market Lease): Failed (11-0). The resolution to approve the lease was rejected, directing the city to renegotiate or seek alternative space. - Item 19 (Impact Fee Reductions): Passed on first reading (10-1). Ordinance will reduce inclusionary housing requirements for projects of 10–24 units. - Item 20 (Tenant Organizing): Passed on first reading (11-0). - Item 28 (Reparations Plan): Adopted after being severed from the consent calendar by Supervisor Walton. The resolution accepts the final San Francisco Reparations Plan from the African American Reparations Advisory Committee. - New Legislation Introduced: - Supervisor Preston: Resolution urging SFMTA to implement a citywide no-turn-on-red policy; resolution supporting a green bank; hearing request on UN Plaza activation and Heart of the City Farmers Market relocation. - Supervisor Safai (with co-sponsors): Ordinance requiring each police district captain to develop a footbeat and bike beat plan. - Supervisor Engardio (with co-sponsors): Ballot measure for March 2024 urging SFUSD to offer algebra in eighth grade. - Supervisor Mandelman: Ordinance extending the deadline for small businesses to comply with the Mandatory Disability Access Improvements (ABE) program; hearing request on treatment on demand and substance use disorder services. - Supervisor Ronan: Submitted legislation without specific introduction; made lengthy remarks criticizing the mayor’s proposed drug testing for public assistance recipients. - Supervisor Chan, Supervisor Stefani, Supervisor Walton, and others submitted various items and adjournments in memory. - Laguna Honda Hearing: Filed. The board will continue to monitor recertification progress. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned in memory of Auden Schrader (on behalf of President Peskin), Reynard Hillis, and Francis Ho (both on behalf of Supervisor Walton).

PUBLIC COMMENT 28% · PUBLIC HEALTH 17% · PUBLIC EDUCATION 7% · PROCEDURAL 6%
918
SEP 21, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · GOVERNMENT AUDIT AND OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
Government Audit and Oversight Committee Hearing on Car Break-Ins and UN Plaza Farmers Market - September 21, 2023

This regular meeting of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors’ Government Audit and Oversight Committee, chaired by Supervisor Dean Preston, convened on Thursday, September 21, 2023, at 18:15 UTC (morning local time). The committee addressed two major items: a hearing on the city’s response to car break‑ins and a resolution concerning the Recreation and Park Department’s activation plan for United Nations Plaza and the forced relocation of the Heart of the City Farmers Market. The committee also approved a consent calendar of 19 settlement ordinances and resolutions. Rec Park and the District Attorney’s Office declined to send representatives, drawing sharp criticism from the chair. Consent Calendar - Items 3 through 21 (11 ordinances and 8 resolutions) authorizing lawsuit and unlitigated claim settlements were approved unanimously without discussion or public comment. Total settlement amounts ranged from $32,439.60 to $1,858,150.71. Public Comments & Testimony Item 1 – Car Break‑Ins - Several residents and business owners expressed frustration with the lack of progress. One speaker noted that over 22,000 break‑ins were reported in 2022 and that the city’s data showed a clearance rate of only 1‑2%. Speaker Andrea Carlin Michaels urged a centralized lost‑and‑found system and better collaboration among departments. Dave Jordan (Alamo Square resident) described the need for immediate messaging to tourists and suggested that bait cars should be diverse. One caller accused the committee of victim‑blaming, while others called for more foot patrols and technology like StarChase. Many praised the idea of ambassadors but underscored that enforcement and prosecution must improve. Item 2 – UN Plaza Farmers Market - Over a dozen speakers, including farmers’ market director Steve Pulliam, Tenderloin community organizers, and regular shoppers, testified in strong support of the resolution. They detailed hardships: farmers now working 18‑hour days, reduced sales (up to 75% loss for some hot‑food vendors), lack of permits, dangerous asphalt heat, and inadequate signage for seniors and disabled patrons. Multiple speakers called for a pause in construction, transparent metrics, a right‑of‑return to UN Plaza, and a direct city permit rather than control by the Civic Center Community Benefit District. Discussion Items Item 1 – Hearing on City’s Plan to Address Car Break‑Ins - Chair Preston opened by noting that over 22,000 break‑ins were reported in 2022 (likely an undercount) and that the city lacks a coordinated, multi‑departmental strategy. SFPD Commander Derek Jackson and Lieutenant Stephen Jonas presented data showing a 28% decline in auto burglaries from 2017 to 2022, but an 8% increase from 2021 to 2022. They outlined 21 plainclothes operations (Jan‑May 2023) resulting in 37 arrests and 14 firearms recovered. Q&A revealed a 1‑2% clearance rate for reported cases, attributed to officer shortages (department is 600 officers short), suspects using stolen vehicles, and rapid commission of crimes. The chair noted the lack of regular interdepartmental meetings and proposed a “reboot” of the Park Smart campaign with image‑based, multilingual signage. SFMTA representative Rob Malone confirmed that new digital messages on parking meters and the pay‑by‑phone app would begin rolling out. OEWD deputy director Chris Corgas confirmed that community benefit district ambassadors already distribute Park Smart materials in tourist areas. The hearing was continued to the call of the chair for future updates. Item 2 – Resolution on UN Plaza Activation and Farmers Market - Chair Preston authored the resolution, co‑sponsored by President Peskin and later Supervisor Chan, urging Rec Park to provide full transparency on the pilot activation plan. Preston detailed that Rec Park had refused to hold community meetings, presented the plan as a six‑month pilot but later changed it to two years, and provided no metrics for success or return of the farmers market. Steve Pulliam (director of Heart of the City Farmers Market) described the market’s forced move from UN Plaza to Fulton Plaza: it now serves 20,000+ customers weekly, operates the nation’s largest farmers’ market EBT program, and distributes $1 million annually in incentives. He cited lost truck access, reduced hours, heat‑related produce spoilage, a temporary month‑to‑month permit, and a proposed contract by the Civic Center CBD that would give the CBD control over the market. The committee expressed outrage that Rec Park failed to send a representative; Preston threatened to exercise subpoena power if necessary. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Car Break‑Ins): Committee voted unanimously (3‑0) to continue the hearing to the call of the chair for ongoing updates. No formal decisions were made, but several directives were implied: SFPD is to provide data on clearance rates and court outcomes for the 37 arrested suspects; departments are to explore a revived Park Smart campaign with visual, multilingual signs; and chair Preston will convene interdepartmental meetings to establish metrics for reducing break‑ins. - Item 2 (UN Plaza / Farmers Market): The committee voted unanimously (3‑0) to forward the resolution to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation. The resolution urges Rec Park to disclose the pilot’s duration, budget (estimated at $1‑2 million), itemized costs, metrics for evaluation, binding commitments to mitigate harm to the farmers market, and a plan for returning the market to UN Plaza if the relocation proves unsuccessful. - Consent Calendar: Items 3‑21 were approved unanimously (3‑0) and forwarded to the full board. No closed session was required.

PUBLIC SAFETY 32% · PUBLIC COMMENT 23% · FOOD ACCESS 8% · PARKS AND RECREATION 7%
919
SEP 20, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Special Meeting - September 20, 2023

The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) held a special meeting on September 20, 2023, at 4:45 PM UTC. The meeting covered the General Manager's report (including human resources, budget, bond issuances, and capital program updates), a consent calendar of routine contracts and approvals, and a regular calendar item authorizing up to $145 million in Power Revenue Bonds. The commission also entered closed session to discuss several legal matters, including proposed settlements for water main damage claims. All five commissioners were present for votes. Consent Calendar - Items 5a through 5i were approved unanimously. These included attestations for power source disclosure reports (CleanPowerSF and Hetch Hetchy Power), contract contingency increases (San Joaquin Pipeline Valve improvements, general engineering construction, Treasure Island WRRF management augmentation, water main replacement on Gold Mine Drive, acceptance of work at Southeast Community Center, sewer replacement duration contingency, and large diameter sewer cleaning contract). Public Comments & Testimony - Francisco De Costa (public speaker) criticized the HR presentation as lacking outreach and needs assessment, and urged the commission to address underutilization of the SFPUC training center and improve public engagement. He also commented on the Sewer System Improvement Project, bond transparency, and salmon protection. - Nicole Tenko (CEO of Baska) expressed appreciation for the HR discussion and encouraged continued focus on staffing challenges. - Nicole Tenko (BAWSCA CEO) thanked the commission for including the Water Enterprise CIP and WISIP quarterly reports, noting that BAWSCA member agencies pay roughly two-thirds of regional water system operating costs ($288 million in FY 2021-2022) and rely on these updates to monitor expenditures. - Francisco De Costa (during general public comment) stressed the importance of remote public comment access and advocated for greater advocate participation. Discussion Items - Human Resources Update (Item 4a): Chief People Officer Wendy Macy and CIO Jennifer Hopkins presented on HR-ITS partnership, vacancy rates (highest in infrastructure and HRS), and efforts to improve hiring through technology, data dashboards, and process efficiencies. Commissioners asked about hiring timelines, candidate communication, and job classification flexibility. The commission acknowledged the challenges of citywide hiring processes and encouraged continued innovation. - Quarterly Budget Status Report (Item 4b): Laura Bush presented fourth-quarter FY 2022-2023 results. All enterprises projected positive net operating results: Water +$12.4 million, Wastewater +$12.5 million, Power +$42.5 million, CleanPower +$32.7 million. Variances were attributed to drought recovery, weather, wholesale energy prices, and vacancy savings. - 2023 Water Revenue Bond Issuance (Item 4c): Nicolai Skarloff reported on the pricing of $450 million in new money bonds and a tender offer refinancing that achieved $85.3 million in future debt service savings ($58 million present value, 9.5% savings). The bonds received strong demand (4x subscription) and maintained high credit ratings. - Water Enterprise Capital Improvement Program Quarterly Report (Item 4d): Katie Miller reported on 36 projects with a $3.3 billion total budget, $1.1 billion expended. A $6 million forecast increase on the San Andreas Service Road project for geotechnical improvements was noted. Three projects were advertised for construction. - Water System Improvement Program Quarterly Report (Item 4e): Katie Miller reported 52 projects at 99% completion ($3.7 billion expended). The Alameda Creek Recapture Project contract termination (approved April 11) was being negotiated; equipment reuse planned. PG&E delays impacted the regional groundwater storage project. - General Manager's Report – Water Main Break Update (Item 4f): General Manager Herrera detailed the September 10-11 water main break at Green and Fillmore. As of the meeting, 50% of sewer repairs were complete; water work estimated October 2-15; PG&E work October 16-29; final restoration by November 10. Outreach included daily flyering, two updates to the supervisor's office, and a webinar. Lessons learned on expanding communication via DEM's neighbor alert system. - Power Revenue Bonds Authorization (Item 6): The commission authorized up to $145 million in 2023 Series A Power Revenue Bonds to refinance commercial paper, fund capitalized interest, and potentially fund a debt service reserve. Underwriters selected: JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley, and Siebert Williams Shank. Staff recommended delaying green bond certification due to SEC concerns about greenwashing and the need for external verification; an RFP for certification is underway. The bonds will have a 30-year maturity with deferred principal. Good faith estimate: interest rates higher but still favorable. Approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously (5-0). - Power Revenue Bonds (Item 6): Approved unanimously (5-0). - Closed Session (Items 12-19): The commission voted to recommend that the Board of Supervisors approve the settlements for water main damage claims (Items 13-19) totaling approximately $320,064.48 (individual claims: $36,000; $35,000; $50,000; $50,000; $65,000; $46,867; $37,197.48). No action was taken on Item 12 (existing litigation). The commission voted not to disclose closed session discussions. - Recusal: President Ajami recused herself from Item 12 (City and County of San Francisco v. U.S. EPA and State Water Resources Control Board) due to her previous role on the state water board. Vice President Maxwell chaired that portion.

PROCEDURAL 19% · PUBLIC COMMENT 13% · HUMAN RESOURCES 12% · PENDING LITIGATION 11%
920
SEP 20, 2023 · SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA · POLICE COMMISSION
SF Police Commission Meeting: September 20, 2023 - Tire Deflation Devices, Patrol Specials, and Stop Data Audit

The San Francisco Police Commission met on September 20, 2023 at 1:45 PM UTC. The meeting included recognition of Officer Michael Grande for video retrieval work, reports from the Chief and DPA, a resolution to permit preemptive use of tire deflation devices, a presentation on Patrol Specials, the Q2 2023 Safe Streets report, and a discussion on SFPD stop data audits. The commission voted unanimously on several items and heard extensive public comment. Consent Calendar - A weekly officer recognition certificate was presented to Officer Michael Grande (star 302, Investigations Bureau, General Work Detail) for his work in forensic video retrieval, including a case that led to a homicide arrest. Officers, commissioners, and the public praised his dedication. No public comment was made. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 2 (General Public Comment): A speaker urged the commission to stand by their constitutional rights. Jennifer J. Dub Wagner, speaking for the League of Women Voters of San Francisco, criticized the seven-month delay in finalizing DGO 9.07 (banning racially biased traffic stops) and demanded it be brought back for final approval. Another speaker argued the commission lacked authority to override failed state legislation (SB 50). One member of the public proposed guidelines for civility and requested that non-residents not speak on San Francisco matters. Another speaker expressed strong support for police, stating officers have unlimited power derived from the Second Amendment. A mother of a homicide victim thanked the police and pleaded for resources to solve unsolved murders. - Item 8 (Tire Deflation Devices): A representative from Fisherman's Wharf Community Benefit District thanked the commission for restoring spike strips, urging the chief to issue guidelines quickly. - Item 6 (Patrol Specials): A former patrol special officer (since 1977) reported historical numbers (450 patrol specials, 1,600 police officers in the past) and criticized application bottlenecks, citing a 14-year delay for one assistant. Several residents and a business district alliance president spoke in strong support of the program, calling it community policing and emphasizing the need for more officers due to current staffing shortages (600-1,000 officers short). They urged approval of three qualified candidates for the Marina Patrol. - Item 9 (Stop Data Audit): No public comment was made. Discussion Items - Item 4: DPA Director's Report – Acting Executive Director Diana Rosenstein reported that DPA case intake is up year-over-year, closure rates slightly down (543 vs. same time last year), and mediation is increasing. The top allegation was neglect of duty. DPA is planning a mediation forum on October 3, 2023. Commissioner Benedicto noted increased mediation cases and offered to attend the forum. - Item 5: Commission Reports – Commissioner Walker reported on a well-attended town hall in the Tenderloin (District 6) and thanked officers for their work. Commissioner Benedicto attended the 279th Police Academy graduation and mentioned meeting with the DPA audit team; he echoed requests for updates on DGO 9.07 and praised transparency efforts. Commissioner Yanias reported coordinating with the youth commission and juvenile probation on a pre-booking program; he expressed concern about disproportionate use of force data (25:1 ratio of African American to white in Q4 2022) and requested a future agenda item on use of force. He also questioned the investment in the Sojourn trip (36 sworn officers attending) and requested measurement of its tangible impact. - Item 8: Resolution on Tire Deflation Devices – Vice President Carter Overstone introduced a resolution interpreting DGO 5.01 to permit preemptive use of spike strips, citing 46 deployments, 82 arrests, and 31 guns recovered in 15 months before the department suspended use. The Chief expressed support but requested written guidance before full deployment to protect officers from liability. Commissioners debated whether guidance should delay implementation; the chief stated he would issue guidance within days. The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to adopt the resolution, restoring immediate preemptive use of spike strips. - Item 6: Patrol Specials Presentation – Lieutenant Patrick McCormick presented history (dating to Gold Rush) and current rules: patrol specials are private, governed by city charter, appointed by the commission, and limited to specific beats. Commissioner Walker proposed modernizing the program with oversight and data reporting, noting a 2010 Controller's audit that found systemic lack of oversight. Commissioners agreed further discussion and community outreach were needed before reviving the program. Commissioner Benedicto stressed the need for a comprehensive plan addressing liability and insurance concerns. - Item 7: Safe Streets for All Q2 2023 – Commander Nicole Jones reported 2,751 traffic citations issued in the first two quarters (50% increase over 2022, but down 80% from 2019). However, 57% of directed enforcement was focused on the "Focus on the Five" violations. Traffic fatalities decreased 42% (19 in 2022 to 11 in 2023), with pedestrians making up 7 of 11 deaths. Citations per station varied widely; Richmond station issued the most. Commissioners questioned the dramatic drop in enforcement since 2019, with Vice President Carter Overstone suggesting deployment decisions (e.g., assigning officers to arrest drug users) may be a factor. The chief and commander cited staffing, increased administrative burdens (RIPA data entry, body-worn cameras), and call volume as contributing factors, but acknowledged the department could do better. Commissioner Byrne noted that downtown stations with high fatality rates have fewer citations due to high call volume. Commissioners requested that future reports include data on stops resulting in warnings/advisements. - Item 9: SFPD Stop Data Audit (Unit Order 21-01) – Catherine McGuire explained that the current audit only checks for incomplete entries (stops started but not submitted) due to limited staffing (one sergeant). The unit order was created in response to CRI recommendation 77.2 for routine audits. Vice President Carter Overstone pointed out that the unit order explicitly requires audits to be stored, yet the department stated there is no paper trail. The discussion turned to a recent newspaper article alleging that one officer made 1,200 stops of which all but 5-6 involved white drivers. The chief cautioned against prejudging based on a newspaper article and argued that audits must have clear, fair standards. Commissioner Yanias strongly criticized the lack of proactive audit resources, saying it showed an unserious commitment to transparency. Commissioner Walker noted conflicting messaging from the commission on traffic stops. Acting DPA Director Rosenstein highlighted that CRI finding 77 stated SFPD does not conduct routine audits, and the unit order may not meet substantial compliance. The commission agreed to calendar a future action item to direct an independent audit of stop data. Key Outcomes - Resolution on Tire Deflation Devices: Approved unanimously (6-0). The resolution interprets current DGO to allow preemptive use of spike strips immediately, restoring the pre-suspension status quo. The chief indicated he would issue departmental guidance within days. - Patrol Specials Program: No vote; discussion only. Commissioners agreed to continue discussions and possibly develop a revised program with community outreach, oversight, and data reporting. The commission will consider the 2010 Controller's audit and public input. - Safe Streets Report: No action taken; the commission requested data on stops resulting in warnings rather than citations in future reports. - Stop Data Audit: No vote; the commission agreed to bring back a future action item to discuss directing DPA and an outside partner to conduct a comprehensive audit of stop data. - Closed Session: The commission voted unanimously (6-0) to enter closed session under San Francisco Administrative Code Section 67.10, asserting attorney-client privilege. No disclosure of closed session discussions was made in open session.

PROCEDURAL 39% · POLICE OVERSIGHT 20% · PUBLIC SAFETY 12% · COMMUNITY POLICING 10%
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING INDEXUPDATED DAILY · openpublica.com