The Budget and Finance Committee, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan and joined by Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Asha Safayi (and later by President Aaron Peskin), met on September 20, 2023, to consider twelve agenda items. The meeting included resolutions on property tax rates, a fire training facility design contract, a hospice services contract, office leases, technology marketplace amendments, a police salary ordinance, an emergency elevator declaration, a food bank grant, and a commercial ground lease. Voting outcomes varied, with most items approved, one rejected, and one continued. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 4 (1155 Market lease): A speaker argued that the building is "worth nothing" due to homelessness in the area and urged the city to use the space for homeless services. - Item 5 (Onondaga lease): Francisco DeCosta commended Supervisor Safayi for the project but highlighted the need to address PG&E delays and costs. - Items 6-8 (tech marketplace): A speaker questioned why technology is not being used to speed up FTE hiring in city departments. - Item 9 (police command staff): Multiple speakers addressed captain turnover and command structure. Chris Romero (Municipal Executives Association) urged reconsideration, citing retention concerns. Chris Schulman (Lower Polk CBD) emphasized the negative impact of captain turnover on community trust. David Pilpel supported restructuring to reduce command staff and proposed retaining station captains for three years. - Item 10 (Portsmouth Square elevators): No public comments. - Other items: No public comments on items 1, 2, 3, 11, or 12. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Property Tax Rate (Resolution 230957): Jamie Whittaker (Controller's Office) presented the annual resolution setting the secured property tax rate at 1.17769382% (including 1% fixed rate and voter-approved bond debt service at 0.11295032%). The rate decreased by 0.17% from last year. The pass-through rate for residential tenants is approximately $0.07 per $100 of assessed value. The median assessed home increased from $683,637 to $697,310 (2% CPI increase), resulting in a $147.18 tax increase. The tax generates $2.5 billion for the General Fund. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward to the full board with a positive recommendation. - Item 2 – Fire Training Facility Design (Resolution 230939): Scott Moran (DPW) and Assistant Deputy Chief Gareth Miller (SFFD) requested approval of a $14.1 million architecture and engineering contract with RossDrulisCusenbery Architecture for the new fire training facility at 1236 Carroll Avenue (8-acre site in Bayview). The project is funded by the 2020 ESER bond. The BLA recommended reducing the not-to-exceed amount by $14,814 (to $14,085,186) due to a rounding correction. The committee approved the amendment and then forwarded the resolution to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3 – Maitri AIDS Hospice Contract (Resolution 230912): Bill Blum (DPH) presented an amendment to extend the agreement with Maitri AIDS Hospice through March 2027 and increase funding from $9.5 million to $14.1 million (an increase of $4.6 million). The facility provides hospice and mental health services for low-income HIV-positive residents. The BLA noted that mental health service targets were not met in previous years, but DPH reported that staffing has been filled. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution with a positive recommendation. - Item 4 – 1155 Market Lease (Resolution 230915): Andre Cole (Real Estate) requested approval of a retroactive five-year lease (Feb 2023 – Jan 2028) for 103,000 sq ft at $64.60/sq ft (3% annual increases), totaling $35.5 million over the term. The BLA noted the rate is above the city's appraisal ($62/sq ft) and above current market. Supervisor Safayi expressed discomfort with paying above market, and President Peskin argued the city should reject the lease to send a message to landlords. The committee voted 3-0 to forward the resolution to the full board with a recommendation of do not pass (negative recommendation). - Item 5 – Onondaga Lease Amendment (Resolution 230952): Andre Cole (Real Estate) and Supervisor Safayi presented a third amendment to increase the city's tenant improvement allowance at 35 Onondaga Avenue from $2.1 million to $2.97 million (an $850,000 increase). The space will house Clinic by the Bay (free clinic) and Artspan (artist space). The BLA noted the city's share of improvements is 2.5 times the 10-year rent, making approval a policy matter. The committee voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor. - Items 6-8 – Technology Marketplace Amendments (Resolutions 230905, 230906, 230907): Daniel Sanchez (OCA) presented amendments to increase not-to-exceed amounts for three contracts: CCT Technologies (to $66.5 million, +$3.6M), Insight Public Sector (to $43.8 million, +$3.6M), and Zones LLC (to $26.3 million, +$2.2M). The amendments allow continued spending through Dec 2023 while new contracts are developed. The BLA recommended approval. The committee voted 3-0 to forward all three with positive recommendations. - Item 9 – Police Salary Ordinance (Resolution 230865): President Peskin proposed an ordinance to delete one assistant chief and three commander positions and add 7.69 police officer positions (Q4 rank). He argued that the command staff has grown from 9 to 15 sworn positions since 2017, leading to captain turnover and increased pension liability (estimated $4M per assistant chief vs. $3M per officer over 30 years). Chief Bill Scott defended the current structure, citing reform work, span of control, and retention needs. The committee heard extensive debate. Supervisor Safayi stressed the need for captain continuity. After public comment, the committee voted 3-0 to continue the item to the October 4, 2023 meeting (though the motion referenced October 5). - Item 10 – Portsmouth Square Elevators Emergency (Resolution 230949): Stacy Bratley (RPD) requested approval of an emergency declaration for elevator repairs at Portsmouth Square garage, with a not-to-exceed amount of $2.2 million. The BLA recommended deleting the word "estimated" to limit scope. The committee agreed to the amendment and voted 3-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. Supervisor Safayi added as co-sponsor. - Item 11 – SF-Marin Food Bank Grant (Resolution 230911): Susie Smith (HSA) requested approval of a $17.8 million grant amendment (increase of $6.6 million) for the citywide grocery access program, extending the term through June 30, 2024. The budget decreases from $10.2M to $6M due to the adopted budget. The BLA recommended approval, noting no funding is budgeted for FY 2024-25. The committee voted 2-0 (Supervisor Safayi excused) to forward with a positive recommendation. - Item 12 – Florida Street Ground Lease (Resolution 230925): Omar Masry (MOHCD) presented a 75-year ground lease for two commercial parcels at 683 Florida and 2070 Bryant streets (part of the Casa Adelante affordable housing development). The lease is for $1/year to allow community-serving uses by Kana SF (nonprofit arts space). The BLA confirmed consistency with prior 2020 approvals. The committee voted 2-0 to forward with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved 3-0 to full board with positive recommendation. - Item 2: Amended to reduce not-to-exceed amount by $14,814; approved 3-0 as amended. - Item 3: Approved 3-0. - Item 4: Voted 3-0 to send to full board with recommendation of do not pass (negative recommendation). - Item 5: Approved 3-0. Supervisor Mandelman added as co-sponsor. - Items 6-8: All three approved 3-0. - Item 9: Continued 3-0 to the October 4, 2023 budget committee meeting (motion referenced October 5). - Item 10: Amended to remove "estimated" from title; approved 3-0 as amended. - Item 11: Approved 2-0 (Safayi excused). - Item 12: Approved 2-0 (Safayi excused).
Public Meetings - San Francisco, California
Public Meetings - San Francisco, CaliforniaThe San Francisco Board of Supervisors held a regular meeting on Tuesday, September 19, 2023, beginning at 2:15 PM. The meeting included a consent agenda, regular agenda items, roll call introductions, and a major special order: a Committee of the Whole hearing on the Draft San Francisco Reparations Plan and Dream Keeper Initiative updates. The board also adopted several resolutions, ordinances, and appointments, and introduced new charter amendments. Consent Calendar - Items 1 and 2 were approved unanimously (11-0). These included an ordinance regarding Guaranteed Income and a resolution authorizing certificates of participation for capital improvements up to $77,170,000. Public Comments & Testimony - Reparations Hearing (3:00 PM Special Order): Over 100 members of the public spoke in person and remotely, the vast majority expressing strong support for the reparations plan and urging immediate action. Many speakers shared personal stories of displacement, discrimination, and harm caused by city policies. A few callers opposed the plan, calling it racist or unconstitutional. Speakers included leaders from the African American Reparations Advisory Committee, clergy, educators, business owners, and allies from various communities. Several callers also criticized the board’s reduction of public comment time to one minute. - General Public Comment: A few speakers addressed other topics, including condemnation of an anti-trans conference, criticism of a proposed police staffing charter amendment, and calls for action on the drug crisis and homelessness. Discussion Items - Committee of the Whole – Reparations Plan (Item 10): The board heard presentations from: - Eric McDonnell (Chair) and Tanish Hollins (Vice Chair) of the African American Reparations Advisory Committee, who detailed the harms of urban renewal, redlining, and displacement, and presented the committee’s final report with over 100 recommendations across four areas: economic empowerment, education, health, and public policy. Key recommendations included a formal apology, creation of an Office of Reparations, and a stakeholder authority. - Dr. Cheryl Davis, Director of the Human Rights Commission, who provided an update on the Dream Keeper Initiative and outlined immediate actionable steps, including funding the Fillmore Heritage Center, supporting HBCU satellite campuses, and prioritizing certificate of preference holders. - Reverend Dr. Amos Brown and other community leaders urged the board to act without delay. - Supervisor Comments: All 11 supervisors voiced strong support for reparations. Many highlighted specific recommendations they were working on, such as public banking, affordable housing, and support for black-owned businesses. Supervisor Walton introduced a resolution to accept the final reparations plan. - Other Agenda Items: - Item 3 (1939 Market Street and 1515 South Van Ness Avenue): Declared surplus property for 100% affordable housing – adopted. - Item 4 (Produce Market lease amendment) – adopted. - Item 5 (Shared Spaces seating at Taraval and 46th) – passed on first reading. - Item 6 (Treasure Island park acceptance) – passed on first reading. - Item 7 (Interim zoning controls for parcel delivery services) – passed 9-0 after recusals by Supervisors Peskin and Walton. - Items 8-9 (Appointments to Health Authority and Reentry Council) – approved. - Items 11-14 (Liquor licenses, firefighters payroll deduction, Historic Preservation appointment) – adopted as committee reports. - Roll Call Introductions: Supervisors introduced new legislation, including: - Supervisor Safai: Charter amendments to require mayoral approval for SFMTA fare/ meter changes and to elevate the Department of Emergency Management to a charter department. - Supervisor Dorsey: Charter amendment (San Francisco Police Full Staffing Act) to set minimum staffing of 2,182 officers within five years, with a budget set-aside. - Supervisor Chan: Ordinance to reinstate the Graffiti Advisory Board. - Resolutions recognizing Annette Williams Day (September 19) and Armenian Independence Day. Key Outcomes - Reparations Plan: The board accepted the final report from the African American Reparations Advisory Committee via resolution introduced by Supervisor Walton. The board committed to establishing an Office of Reparations, with $5 million already allocated in the budget. Supervisors pledged to work on implementing specific recommendations, including a formal apology, funding for black cultural districts, and support for HBCU satellites. - Consent and Regular Agenda: All items on the consent and regular agenda were adopted as follows: - Consent items 1-2: Final passage (11-0). - Items 3-6: Adopted or passed on first reading unanimously. - Item 7: Passed 9-0 (two recusals). - Items 8-9: Appointments approved (11-0). - Items 11-14: Adopted as committee reports. - Adoption Without Committee Reference: Items 17 (Annette Williams Day) and 19 (Armenian Independence Day) were adopted unanimously (11-0). Item 18 (Inflation Reduction Act funding framework) was amended and adopted unanimously after severance. - Next Steps: The reparations hearing was heard and filed. The board will continue to work on funding and implementing the Office of Reparations and other recommendations. Supervisors pledged to bring forward legislation to advance specific proposals.
The Rules Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on Monday, September 18, 2023, at 18:15 UTC (11:15 a.m. PDT) to consider three items: a mayoral appointment to the Historic Preservation Commission, a payroll deduction addition for the Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation, and amendments to the tenant organizing ordinance (Union at Home 2.0). All three items received unanimous approval and were forwarded to the full Board of Supervisors as committee reports. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 3 (Historic Preservation Commission appointment): David Pilpel, a member of the public, noted typos in the motion (misspelling of nominee's name and incorrect reference to the previous seat holder). No other public comments were received. - Item 1 (Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation): Matt Wood, Vice President of the San Francisco Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation and representative of Firefighters Union Local 798, spoke in support. He stated that the foundation is the largest single recipient of payroll deductions through the Combined Charities program, receiving nearly $60,000 annually, and that the loss of that program necessitated this addition. He thanked the committee for its support. - Item 2 (Tenant organizing amendments): Multiple speakers testified in support: - Brad Hearn (Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco) highlighted that tenants had used the original ordinance in every supervisor district. - Lena Maibaum (Housing Rights Committee and Veritas Tenant Association member) described her experience with tenant organizing and urged passage. - Molly Goldberg (San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition) and another caller supported the amendments for clarifying good-faith negotiations. - Dave Masson (Chair of 700 Church Tenants Association) detailed how the current language allowed a landlord to avoid meaningful conferring, and that the amendments would strengthen the requirement for responsible personnel to negotiate. - Evan Arabic, a tenant, emphasized the ordinance’s role in fighting displacement and urged support. Discussion Items - Item 3 – Mayoral Appointment, Historic Preservation Commission – Hans Baldauf: - The committee took this item out of order. Nominee Hans Baldauf, a licensed architect, appeared remotely from Italy. He described his background (work on the Ferry Building, Palace of Fine Arts restoration) and his interest in the Legacy Business Program. He answered questions from Supervisor Safai about attending commission meetings and his approach to historic preservation (seeking a “win-win” between preservation and building vitality). Supervisor Safai suggested the commission work with the Planning Department to better map historic designations. - The committee identified typos in the motion (name spelling and previous seat holder). The city attorney confirmed corrections could be made without amending the motion. The committee voted unanimously to send the appointment to the full board as a committee report with a positive recommendation. - Item 1 – Administrative Code – Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation: - Sponsor President Aaron Peskin introduced the ordinance, explaining that the elimination of the Combined Charities program in the budget had removed the payroll deduction mechanism for the foundation. The ordinance adds the foundation to the list of eligible organizations for voluntary payroll deductions. The Controller’s office is aware and accepting. - Supervisor Walton, Dorsey, and Safai added themselves as co-sponsors. The committee voted unanimously to forward the item to the full board as a committee report. - Item 2 – Administrative Code – Tenant Organizing (Union at Home 2.0): - Sponsor Supervisor Connie Chan presented the amendments, which clarify the obligation of landlords to confer in good faith, require translation services to be provided with adequate notice, and make other clarifying changes. She noted that lessons learned from implementation of the original ordinance (passed in 2022) necessitated these improvements. She cited the sale of 75 buildings (over 2,000 units) by Veritas to Ballast Investments as an example of the scale of corporate landlord impact. - Supervisor Dorsey expressed support, noting his experience with tenant issues in his district. Supervisor Walton, who moved to accept the proposed amendments, stressed the importance of representation for seniors and non-English speakers. The committee voted unanimously to adopt the amendments and then to forward the amended ordinance to the full board with a positive recommendation. Key Outcomes - Item 3 (Historic Preservation Commission): Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board as a committee report. The motion will be corrected for typos. - Item 1 (Firefighters Cancer Prevention Foundation): Approved unanimously (3-0) to forward to the full board as a committee report. - Item 2 (Tenant organizing amendments): The proposed amendments were adopted unanimously (3-0), and the amended ordinance was forwarded to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). All three items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors’ agenda of September 26, 2023.
The committee convened a recessed meeting on September 18, 2023, at 5:15 PM (originally scheduled for September 14 but recessed due to technical difficulties) to consider a liquor license for ODC Theater and to continue two pending ordinances. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stephanie, Supervisor Dorsey, and Clerk Stephanie Cabrera were present. A motion to excuse Vice Chair Guardio passed unanimously. Public Comments & Testimony - On Item Continuance (Items 2 & 3): One caller commented that the meeting time (9:00 AM Monday) was difficult for public participation and questioned the Brown Act compliance regarding limiting public comment to specific items, arguing that the First Amendment allows comment on any subject. The chair closed public comment after the caller. Discussion Items - Item 1: Liquor License for ODC Theater – The committee held a hearing to determine whether issuing a Type 64 special on-sale general theater liquor license to ODC Theater at 3153 17th Street would serve public convenience or necessity. Public comment had already been satisfied at the September 14 meeting. A motion was made and approved to prepare a resolution making that determination. - Items 2 & 3: Continuance – Opioid Antagonist Requirement and Armed Guard Firearm Drawing Prohibition – Item 2 would amend the Health Code to require each retail pharmacy in the city to stock at least two boxes of an opioid antagonist (e.g., naloxone). Item 3 would amend the Police Code to prohibit armed guards from drawing or exhibiting firearms other than from a holster. After conferring with the sponsors, the chair moved to continue both items to the next meeting. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Liquor License for ODC Theater): Motion to prepare a resolution that the license serves public convenience or necessity passed unanimously (2-0). The resolution will be sent to the full Board of Supervisors as a committee report with a positive recommendation. - Items 2 and 3 (Opioid Antagonist and Armed Guard Ordinances): Motion to continue to the next regularly scheduled Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee meeting on Thursday, September 28, 2023, passed unanimously (2-0). No public comment was taken on the substance of these items. Note: Vice Chair Guardio was excused from the meeting.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee met on September 18, 2023, at 9:45 AM (the meeting began in the afternoon, per the transcript). Chair Mirna Melgar presided, joined by Vice Chair Dean Preston and President Aaron Peskin. The committee considered five items: two landmark designations, a grant of easements for affordable housing, development impact fee reductions, and a major housing constraints reduction ordinance. The meeting was also attended by Supervisors Shamann Walton, Rafael Mandelman, and Matt Dorsey at various points. Public Comments & Testimony - Item 1 (Development Impact Fee Reductions): Jake Price (Housing Action Coalition) spoke in support. A caller mistakenly referenced rent control. - Item 2 (PG&E Easements): A caller commented on Item 1 but was redirected; no public comment on Item 2 beyond a brief remark. - Item 3 (Fire Station 44 Landmark): No public comment. - Item 4 (Colombo Market Arch Landmark): Catherine Van Dyke (SF Wholesale Produce Market) spoke in support; a representative from San Francisco Architectural Heritage also spoke in favor. - Item 5 (Constraints Reduction Ordinance): Over 50 callers and in-person speakers provided extensive testimony. Opponents included the Race and Equity in All Planning (REP) coalition, San Francisco Tenants Union, Westside Tenants Association, Mission Economic Development Agency, and many individual tenants. They argued the legislation would demolish rent-controlled units, silence community input, violate fair housing obligations, and prioritize market-rate housing over affordable housing. Supporters included the Housing Action Coalition, AIA San Francisco, Spur, SF YIMB, and several architects. They emphasized the need to comply with state housing element deadlines, streamline approvals, and reduce barriers to housing production. Over 800 tenants sent letters opposing the legislation. Discussion Items Item 230855: Development Impact Fee Reductions (Ordinance) - Sponsored by Supervisor Safai. Proposed reducing inclusionary housing requirements for projects approved before November 1, 2023, and reducing fees. Chair Melgar noted prior hearings. Supervisor Preston opposed, stating the policy would reduce affordable housing without evidence of increasing production. The committee voted to send the item to the full board without recommendation (3-0). Item 230934: Grant of Easements to PG&E for 4840 Mission Street (Resolution) - Presented by Sheila Nicolopoulos (MOHCD). The project, Islais Place, is a 137-unit 100% affordable housing development (97% complete as of August 31, 2023). The city requested approval of two no-cost easements totaling 593 square feet for electrical and gas utilities to connect the building. The committee voted to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Item 230880: Initiating Landmark Designation for Fire Station No. 44 (Resolution) - Presented by Supervisor Walton. The fire station, built in 1913, is the oldest active firehouse in San Francisco. All committee members added as co-sponsors. The committee voted to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Item 230922: Landmark Designation for Colombo Market Arch (Ordinance) - Presented by President Peskin and Richard Brandy. The arch, a remnant of the 1894 Colombo Market building, was recommended for landmark status by the Historic Preservation Commission (unanimous). Public comment supported the designation. The committee voted to send the item to the full board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Item 230446: Constraints Reduction Ordinance (Ordinance) - This major legislation from Mayor Breed aims to implement the state-mandated Housing Element. Aaron Starr (Planning Department, also representing the Mayor’s Office) presented the proposal and a series of last-minute amendments. The amendments included expanding the Priority Equity Geographies Special Use District, adding tenant protections (e.g., no buyout history, replacement of rent-controlled units), and adjusting front setback rules. Discussion: Supervisor Preston opposed, citing the lack of affordable housing focus. Supervisor Mandelman expressed concerns about tenant displacement and ‘monster homes.’ Chair Melgar questioned the Mayor’s absence and the absence of affordable housing funding commitments. Supervisor Dorsey supported the legislation, warning of state intervention. After extensive public comment, President Peskin suggested continuing the item for further negotiation. Chair Melgar moved to continue to the October 2, 2023 meeting. The motion passed (3-0). Key Outcomes - Item 1 (230855): Sent to full board without recommendation (3-0). - Item 2 (230934): Sent to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 3 (230880): Sent to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 4 (230922): Sent to full board with positive recommendation (3-0). - Item 5 (230446): Continued to October 2, 2023 (3-0). The committee plans to consider amendments from Supervisors Melgar and Mandelman at that meeting.
The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 14, 2023, at 6:00 PM (Pacific) in a hybrid format. Chair Supervisor Catherine Stefani presided, with Vice Chair Supervisor Joel Engardio and Member Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The clerk was Stephanie Cabrera. The meeting addressed two liquor license items but was recessed due to technical issues before completing the second item; it was continued to September 18, 2023. Discussion Items - Item 1 – Liquor License Transfer (230729): Slake San Francisco Bottle and Sundry, 3239 Balboa Street Officer Salmanson of the SFPD Alcohol Liaison Unit reported the application for a Type 21 off-sale general license was in a low-crime area (plot 744) and low alcohol saturation (census tract 47801), with no letters of protest or support. The department recommended approval. The applicant, Daniel Levitt, stated he is a local resident seeking to open a neighborhood bottle shop in the Outer Richmond. The committee unanimously voted to direct the clerk to prepare a resolution finding that the transfer serves public convenience or necessity, and to send it to the full Board of Supervisors with a positive recommendation (vote: 3-0, with no objection). - Item 2 – Liquor License (230731): ODC Theater, 3153 17th Street Officer Salmanson reported the application for a Type 64 special on-sale theater license was in a low-crime area (plot 423) but a high alcohol saturation area (census tract 22801). The department recommended approval with a condition requiring the licensee to actively monitor adjacent property to prevent loitering. Garth Grimble, chief of staff at ODC, appeared in person and noted the organization has been in the Mission District since 1980 and operates two buildings; the license would help patrons enjoy live art consistently. Supervisor Ronen (District 9) was supportive. Before a vote could be taken, the meeting experienced intermittent internet connectivity issues. The committee recessed at approximately 6:15 PM and will reconvene on Monday, September 18, 2023, at 9:00 AM to complete consideration of this item. Key Outcomes - Item 1 (Slake): Motion passed unanimously (3-0); resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation as a committee report. - Item 2 (ODC Theater): Not voted; deferred to the continued meeting on September 18, 2023. - The remaining agenda items (230766 Health Code – requiring retail pharmacies to stock opioid antagonists, and 230708 Police Code – drawing of firearms by armed guards) were not discussed due to the recess.
The San Francisco Planning Commission held a regular hearing on Thursday, September 14, 2023, starting at approximately 1:15 PM. The meeting covered continuances, consent calendar items, commission matters, department updates, general public comment, and three major regular calendar items: Sunnydale Hope SF Design Standards amendments, an informational presentation on the Stonestown Development, and a conditional use authorization for 100 Columbus Avenue. All votes were unanimous unless noted. Consent Calendar - Items 4, 5, 6, and 7 (conditional use authorizations and a mandatory discretionary review) were approved unanimously (7-0). - Item 8 (1314 Page Street) was continued to November 16, 2023, per staff request. Public Comments & Testimony - General Public Comment: One speaker (George Ashutish) urged codification of the flat policy to preserve original configurations, citing a project at 100 Columbus Avenue as an example of prolonged vacancy. Tom Radulovich (Livable City) advocated for retail policies that prioritize walkable 15-minute neighborhoods over desperate filling of storefronts, noting high rents and speculation. - Sunnydale Hope SF: No public comments were received. - Stonestown Development: Approximately 20 speakers commented. Supporters included community working group members, a San Francisco State University representative, and union members who praised the project’s outreach and housing potential. Opponents, including affordable housing advocates and union representatives, called for significantly more deeply affordable housing, criticized Brookfield’s track record (e.g., lawsuits over taxes), and urged the city to demand a higher percentage of affordable units. Several speakers emphasized the need for family-sized units and housing for very low-income households. - 100 Columbus Avenue: Six speakers (business owners and neighborhood association representatives) expressed strong support, citing the project’s design, economic revitalization, and LoveFrom’s role as a creative anchor. Discussion Items - Item 13 – Sunnydale Hope SF Development: Staff presented 17 amendments to the Design Standards and Guidelines (DSG), including rezoning Block 7 from 40 to 50 feet to accommodate affordable housing, adding flexibility for street design, and clarifying rear yard conditions. The project sponsor (Related California) provided an update: 224 affordable units built, 170 under construction, and a community center with a gym, wellness center, and early childhood education centers. The commission unanimously approved the amendments. - Item 14 – Stonestown Development (Informational): Brookfield Properties presented plans to transform the 41-acre site into a mixed-use town center with 2,900–3,500 residential units (up to 694 affordable), 6 acres of parks, and new retail/office space. The EIR studies a variant with 3,500 units. OEWD’s Ted Conrad outlined ongoing negotiations for community benefits, including a 37% affordable housing target (above the 15% citywide requirement) and flexibility in phasing. Commissioners urged maximizing affordable housing, family units, and senior housing, and discussed lessons from past development agreements to ensure timely construction. Infrastructure coordination with DPW, PUC, and other agencies was emphasized. No action was taken; final approvals are expected later in 2023. - Item 15 – 100 Columbus Avenue: LoveFrom requested a conditional use authorization to convert a rear parking lot into a one-story office pavilion with landscaping. The project would support its existing studio at 809/831 Montgomery Street. Staff recommended approval, finding it consistent with the Jackson Square Special Use District’s intent. The commission approved unanimously. Key Outcomes - Continuances: Items 1, 2A, 2B, 3, and 8 were continued to later dates (November 9, December 7, December 14, and November 16, 2023, respectively). - Consent Calendar: Items 4, 5, 6, and 7 were approved (7-0). - Start Time Change: The commission agreed to begin future hearings at 12:00 PM (noon) instead of 1:00 PM, with a 30-day notice period. - Sunnydale DSG Amendments: Approved unanimously (7-0). - 100 Columbus Avenue CUA: Approved unanimously (7-0) with conditions. - Stonestown: No vote; the informational presentation set the stage for future EIR certification and project approvals. The commission directed staff to prioritize affordable housing, family units, and robust phasing strategies in the development agreement.
The San Francisco Police Commission met on Wednesday, September 13, 2023, at approximately 5:30 PM, with Commissioner Yi serving as Acting Chair after a unanimous vote. The meeting included officer recognition, public comment on crime and policing, reports from the Acting Chief and the Department of Police Accountability (DPA), discussion of firearm discharge incidents, and a closed session. The commission voted on consent calendar items and closed session procedures. Consent Calendar - The commission unanimously voted to receive and file the SFPD and DPA 1421 and SB16 monthly report (Item 3). Public Comments & Testimony - Karina Velasquez criticized the commission for restricting police practices, arguing that such restrictions hurt crime victims, especially people of color. She brought undocumented victims of violent crime to thank officers, and stated that the commission does not understand the urgency for safety. - Surbi described being assaulted and racially harassed at 4th and Mission on August 6, 2023, and expressed frustration with the lack of police response and follow-up, despite having evidence. She urged the city to do better. - Deepika spoke on behalf of District 3 tenants facing similar racial slurs and microcrimes, urging scalable solutions to retain high-tax-paying residents. - Deputy Public Defender Brian Cox submitted a letter on behalf of the coalition to end bias stops, asking the commission to end the meet and confer process on DGO 9.07. He cited a San Francisco Standard article about an SFPD officer who allegedly misidentified the race of those stopped in nearly half of 50 encounters reviewed by DPA. He requested an audit of SFPD traffic stop data and a working group on data integrity. Discussion Items - Chief’s Report (Acting Chief David Lazar): - Crime statistics for the week compared to the same period last year: overall crime down 3%, violent crime up 3%, property crime down 4%. Aggravated assaults down 7%, firearm incidents down 9%, burglaries down 7%, larcenies down 6%, auto burglaries down 3%. Robberies up 16% (1,908 year-to-date vs. 1,646 last year). Homicides: 38 year-to-date vs. 36 last year. Gun violence up 6% (153 incidents). - In the Tenderloin, 658 arrests for possession/sale of narcotics year-to-date, exceeding last year’s total of 500+. 89 arrests this week alone, seizing 3,297 grams of narcotics (211 pounds year-to-date). - Staffing: 1,474 full-duty officers, 72 fewer than last year, 601 below the 2021 target of 2,182. The next academy class has 6 lateral recruits graduating; a new class of 20-30 is starting in September. - Other incidents: stunt driving events (side shows) occurring in multiple locations; officers broke up gatherings with 30-100+ cars. Two traffic collisions: one motorcyclist critical, one drunk driver hit five pedestrians, one elderly woman fatally struck. - Commissioner questions: Discussion on recruitment (including laterals), use of overtime to staff stations, response times (8.5 minutes for priority A calls), and the Sojourn program (approximately 70 people total, not 70 officers). - Commissioner Carter Oberstone requested quarterly audits of stop data under Unit Order 21-01 for the next meeting. - DPA Director’s Report (Paul Henderson): - 562 new cases opened this year, 302 pending, 22 investigations past 9 months (17 tolled). 7 cases pending commission decision, 87 pending chief decision. - This week’s allegations: 29% for inappropriate behavior/speech, 14% for failure to take required actions. Central district had 3 complaints. - DPA conducted outreach and will host a mediation event on October 3, 2023. - Responding to the Standard article, Henderson stated DPA has uncovered issues with stop data accuracy, including failure to enter data, wrong race entry, and multiple race entries. DPA is considering further audits, possibly with an academic partner. - Six complaints were filed related to the Dolores Hill bombing incident. - Commission Reports: - Commissioner Walker attended an officer-involved shooting town hall and a Tenderloin community meeting, and suggested holding commission meetings in neighborhoods. She is working on a child care pilot program for officers. - Commissioner Benedicto discussed audit liaison meetings and plans to agendize a department action plan on race data misreporting. - Commissioner Yi attended the 75th annual Fire, Police, and Sheriff Mass. - Commissioner Yanes provided updates on the social media working group (extension obtained) and pre-booking diversion efforts, and requested an agenda item on the Sojourn program’s outcomes. - Commissioner Carter Oberstone announced that next week he will introduce a resolution to interpret existing policy to allow preemptive use of spike strips, which the department supports. - DPA Intern Presentation: - The summer 2023 cohort of 23 interns (50% law students, 50% undergraduate, 87% underrepresented minority) presented a policy proposal for a witness-specific Department General Order (DGO) to reduce implicit bias. Recommendations include a universal color complexion chart, pre-administration instructions for lineups, and sequential lineups. The commission and DPA expressed support and noted that previous intern proposals have been adopted. - Firearm Discharge Review Board Report (Deputy Chief Peter Walsh): - Second quarter 2023: Two incidents reviewed. - OIS 22004: A self-inflicted gunshot wound by an officer during execution of a search warrant at his residence on June 15, 2022. The FDRB recommended the discharge was not in policy. - OIS 22002: An off-duty officer in Concord fired at an assailant who was shooting at the officer’s son on April 15, 2022. The FDRB recommended the use of force was in policy. - No in-custody deaths occurred in the quarter. - A new department notice (23143) formalizes inclusion of the training division in FDRB reviews. Key Outcomes - Votes: - Unanimously elected Commissioner Yi as Acting Chair for the meeting. - Unanimously approved the consent calendar (Item 3). - Unanimously voted to hold Item 11 (Closed Session) in closed session. - Unanimously voted not to disclose any discussion from closed session (Item 12). Item 11B was taken off calendar. - Directives: - Acting Chief Lazar will follow up on the assault case reported by Surbi and provide data on drug user arrests and treatment acceptance. - The department will provide the last year of quarterly audits of stop data per Unit Order 21-01 at the next meeting. - Commissioner Carter Oberstone will introduce a resolution next week to allow preemptive spike strip use. - Several items were agendized for future meetings: race data misreporting action plan, Sojourn program outcomes, and a witness DGO based on intern recommendations.
The Budget and Finance Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors met on September 13, 2023, at 10:15 AM, chaired by Supervisor Connie Chan, with Vice Chair Rafael Mandelman and Supervisor Asha Safai. The committee reviewed four agenda items: a lease amendment for the San Francisco Wholesale Produce Market, a release of reserved funds for a small sites acquisition, spending authority for the SoMa Community Stabilization Fund, and a declaration of surplus land for affordable housing. No public comments were offered on any item. Discussion Items Item 1: Lease Amendment – San Francisco Wholesale Produce Market (File 230879) John Lau of the Office of Economic and Workforce Development (OEWD) presented the first amendment to the lease with San Francisco Market Corporation. The amendment formalizes the disbursement of $3 million in previously allocated city funds for the market’s reinvestment plan, including $1.81 million for marshalling yard improvements and $1.19 million for pre-development of the 1900 Kirkwood Avenue warehouse. The Budget and Legislative Analyst (BLA) recommended approval. The committee voted to forward the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Items 2, 3, and 4: Housing and Community Development Items (Files 230958, 230812, 230813) Sheila Nicolaopolis of the Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development (MOHCD) presented three related items. - Item 2: Release of Reserved Funds – 566 Natoma Street (File 230958): Requested release of $2.9 million from the Budget and Finance Committee Reserve (SoMa Community Stabilization Fund) to provide a small sites program loan to Mission Economic Development Agency (MEDA) for the acquisition and rehabilitation of a five-unit building at 566 Natoma Street. The BLA report noted that the per-unit subsidy of $580,000 exceeds the program’s updated guidelines, but is permissible with director approval. The project will permanently restrict rents for at least 99 years. The committee voted to file the hearing and release the funds (3-0). - Item 3: Authorizing SoMa Community Stabilization Fund Expenditures (File 230812): Originally proposed to authorize up to $3,014,800 for capacity building grants and the small sites loan. Following the release of reserves for Item 2, MOHCD requested an amendment to reduce the spending authority to $114,800 to fund only two grants: $74,800 for Cultivate Labs and $40,000 for United Players. The amendment was approved (3-0), and the resolution as amended was forwarded to the full Board. - Item 4: Declaration of Surplus Land – 1939 Market Street and 1515 South Van Ness Avenue (File 230813): MOHCD requested that the city declare these properties as exempt surplus land under state law to qualify for additional points in state affordable housing funding applications. The properties will be used for 100% affordable housing with ancillary commercial space. The committee forwarded the resolution to the full Board with a positive recommendation (3-0). Public Comments & Testimony No members of the public offered comments on any agenda item. Key Outcomes - Item 1: Approved and forwarded to the full Board (3-0). - Item 2: Hearing filed and $2.9 million in reserve funds released to MOHCD for the 566 Natoma Street small sites loan (3-0). - Item 3: Amended to reduce spending authority to $114,800, then forwarded to the full Board (3-0). - Item 4: Forwarded to the full Board (3-0). All items are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda on September 19, 2023.
The Port Commission held its regular meeting on September 12, 2023, at 10:30 AM. The commission approved minutes from August 8, 2023, held an executive session, heard public comments, and received presentations on several key items: the Executive Director’s Report (including a racial equity update), the Mission Rock Project budget and bond financing, a new lease with Recology at Pier 96, and an MOU extension with the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing (HSH) for the Embarcadero Navigation Center. The commission took action on the Mission Rock bond resolution and provided direction to staff on follow-up items. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes (August 8, 2023): Moved, seconded, and passed unanimously. - Executive Session: The commission voted unanimously to hold a closed session. Public Comments & Testimony - Daniel Conrad (resident): Requested the commission investigate Giants’ non-compliance with ground lease provisions regarding stadium lights, citing bright lights left on after night games causing nuisance. He noted he is a Giants fan but believes they should be better neighbors. - Sam Sohal (double-deck bus company owner): Asked for guidance on why his company was told they could no longer operate at Fisherman’s Wharf; requested a response and ability to work with the port. - Alice Rogers (resident): Praised the DEI report and noted the success of recent events on the waterfront showcasing Black and Filipino businesses. - Alice Rogers (also on HSH item): Supported extending the HSH MOU but requested stronger commitments on beat officer staffing and data accuracy. - Margaret Keene (neighbor in safety zone): Supported the navigation center but expressed concerns about insufficient beat officers, drug activity, and unreliable point-in-time counts; requested codified enforcement. Discussion Items - Executive Director’s Report (Item 9a): Acting Director Michael Martin reported on the September 2 fire at Islais Landing that destroyed Kayaks Unlimited’s equipment; the port will assist in rebuilding. Upcoming events: Portola Music Festival (Sept 30–Oct 1, 35,000 attendees/day), Fleet Week (Oct 2–10), Crane Cove Park market (5,000 attendees in September), Fisherman’s Wharf Pier Party. Leasing: near recommendation for former Butterfly space at Pier 33.5; broker selected for wharf vacancies. Resilience: geotechnical investigation at Ferry Building for seawall earthquake project. Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (Tony Autry): Presented the Racial Equity Action Plan (REAP) progress. Noted 2022 REAP goals: over half of 18 actions completed; increased LBE participation to 18.28% ($163.48M). Created Rising Tides internship for BIPOC youth (ages 15–25). Pop-ups on the Plaza quarterly events. For FY23-24, focus on hiring/promotion, data transparency, and psychological safety. Commissioners praised the report and suggested more regular data sharing. - Mission Rock Project – Phase One Budget and Bond Financing (Items 10a & 10b): Josh Keene (Assistant Deputy Director of Development) presented the status. Phase one includes 537 housing units (199 affordable), Visa HQ, life science building, and China Basin Park (5 acres). Construction progress: three buildings received temporary certificates of occupancy; park delivery in 2024. Budget update: total phase one completion cost now projected at $218M (up $20M), driven by city staff/consultant costs ($20M) and macroeconomic factors (inflation, interest, COVID delays, weather). Proposed solutions: (1) Port capital advance of up to $16.5M (port gets 10% return instead of developer’s 18%), (2) New bond issuance (Resolution 23-41) up to $58.335M, expected net proceeds $39.5M (current rates 5.86% vs 3.3% in 2021). Bonds will stop high-cost developer return ($500-600k/month saved). Wyatt Donnelly presented bond details: three series (development, office, shoreline special taxes). Next steps: commission approval, then Board of Supervisors, pricing by year-end. Commissioners asked about trade-offs and oversight; staff committed to quarterly reports and returned in October with final budget. - Recology Lease (Item 10c): Kimberly Beale (Acting Deputy Director) presented a new 74-month lease for Pier 96 recycling center. Current lease expired July 31, 2023. No maritime use; interim use permitted up to 10 years. Rent: $369,000/month (3% annual increases, fair market adjustment in year 5). Tenant will fund seismic/facility studies ($1M). No maritime deficiency fee; 6.5% of revenue to Southern Waterfront Beautification Fund ($1.5M first 5 years). Tenant retains community benefits (local hiring, school tours, art program). Commissioners supported the lease; discussed historical environmental reviews (2005 SEIR) and need for updated emissions data. Staff will return in October for approval. - HSH Memorandum of Understanding (Item 10d): Sandy Oberley (Senior Property Manager) and Dylan Schneider (HSH) presented a 2-year extension (with 2-year option) for the Embarcadero Navigation Center at Seawall Lot 330. Rent: $41,059.92/month (3% annual increases). The center serves 200 guests (99.5% occupancy as of Sept 1, 2023). Success story: Jonathan moved to permanent supportive housing and achieved sobriety. City partners (SFPD, DPW, HSOC) recommit to dedicated beat officers and cleaning. Community Advisory Group (eSNAG) meets quarterly. October hearing will include updated metrics on exits to housing, safety data, and interdepartmental agreement details. Commissioners expressed support but raised concerns: equity across all navigation centers, need for enforceable security commitments, and improving point-in-time data accuracy. Suggested exploring ambassador programs and controller’s office assistance. The commission expects stronger partnership and adherence to commitments. - New Business (Item 11): Vice President Adams briefed on offshore wind opportunities (future of West Coast ports). Commissioners requested more frequent updates on leasing efforts, especially for Fisherman’s Wharf vacancies (Ferry Plaza, Pier 45, Cannery) and a report on broker performance. President Brandon asked for ways to highlight historic communities at the cruise terminal. Key Outcomes - Approved: Resolution 23-41 (Mission Rock Special Tax District bond issuance) – motion passed unanimously; will go to Board of Supervisors for final approval. - Directives: Staff will follow up with Daniel Conrad regarding Giants’ light compliance and with Sam Sohal on bus operations. Staff will return in October with final Mission Rock budget increase and port capital advance request, as well as a formal commitment to quarterly budget reports. The HSH MOU will be brought back for a vote in October with additional data on exits, police coverage, and improved data collection. Staff will provide a leasing update for active vacancies and explore broker performance metrics. The Economic Recovery Report will include ideas for highlighting historic communities at Pier 27.